Special Town Council Meeting — Minutes
Town of Hilton Head Island · Beaufort County · General · meeting of Jul 9, 2026 · Minutes
Open the original document More from Town of Hilton Head Island
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council
Meeting Minutes
7/9/2026 Page 1 of 9
Town of Hilton Head Island
TOWN COUNCIL MEETING
Thursday, July 9, 2026, 10:00 AM
Minutes
Call to Order
Mayor Perry called the meeting to order at 10:00 a.m.
Council Members present: Alan Perry, Mayor; Alex Brown, Ward 1, Mayor Pro-Tempore; Patsy
Brison, Ward 2; Steve DeSimone, Ward 3; Tammy Becker, Ward 4; Steve Alfred, Ward 5;
Melinda Tunner, Ward 6
Others Present: Marc Orlando, Town Manager; Brittany Ward, Town Attorney; Kim Gammon,
Town Clerk
Pledge to the Flag
Adoption of the Agenda
Mr. Alfred moved to approve. Ms. Becker seconded. Motion carried 7-0.
New Business
Discussion of Public Safety Matters Related to Law Enforcement Services
Mayor Perry began the meeting by reminding everyone of Hilton Head Island’s ongoing
commitment to community safety in light of recent incidents at public spaces, including a tragic
event on July 4th. The Mayor acknowledged the victims, their families, and the broad network
of responders who supported the community during and after the incident. The Mayor
emphasized that public safety is the foremost responsibility of local leadership and is a shared
duty across the community and that Hilton Head Island's longstanding reputation for safety is
the result of sustained effort, but changing visitor patterns and increased use of public spaces
and evolving expectations require the Town to continually adapt its approach to safety. Mayor
Perry then introduced the Town Manager, Marc Orlando.
Marc Orlando, Town Manager, stated that the Town of Hilton Head Island’s Public Safety
Program focuses on readiness, prevention, and coordinated support across multiple
departments. Public safety is a core strategic priority, guided by ongoing feasibility studies and
investments that strengthen situational awareness and enhance community safety and that the
Town advances public safety through two major areas: capital investments—such as public
realm improvements, safety cameras, and license-plate reader technology—and daily
operational activities led primarily by Fire Rescue and the municipal Public Safety Department.
Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council
Meeting Minutes
7/9/2026 Page 2 of 9
Fire Rescue is a large, well-established department of 154 employees overseeing fire services,
EMS, emergency management, and building safety. The Public Safety Department, with 11
employees and a $2.4 million budget, focuses on municipal code compliance, beach and park
safety, short-term rental oversight, event support, and coordination on waterways. The Town
provides visibility, observation, and coordination but does not serve as sworn law enforcement.
Instead, it complements the statutory responsibilities of the Beaufort County Sheriff’s Office,
maintaining a strong and collaborative partnership with the Sheriff and other agencies such as
SC Department of Natural Resources and private community security teams and that this
collaboration ensures aligned efforts during routine operations, special events, and emergency
situations. Mr. Orlando stated that public safety represents a major investment, with more than
42% of the Town’s $68 million general fund and 54% of Town personnel dedicated to safety
functions and that overall, the program delivers critical support for resident and visitor safety,
community quality of life, and the smooth coordination of local and regional safety partners.
Mayor Perry highlighted the Town of Hilton Head Island’s continued and growing financial
commitment to public safety and noted that the Town has made significant capital and
operational investments and will continue prioritizing them. He relayed that, in addition to Town
funding, residents contribute nearly $7 million in FY 2027 through the Beaufort County Sheriff’s
Office HHI Police Fee, which has risen substantially over the past five years and, altogether,
the community will invest more than $9.4 million in public safety in the upcoming fiscal year.
The Mayor expressed that the central question raised is not whether the Town is investing
enough, but whether current strategies, resource allocations, and partnerships are aligned with
today’s operational needs—and whether new or revised approaches may be necessary
moving forward. Mayor Perry invited Sheriff Tanner to provide an overview of law enforcement
operations and current resources.
Sheriff Tanner pointed out that he believes there is an additional tax that is paid directly
through Beaufort County and related to a countywide portion of the Sheriff Department's efforts
across every municipality and requested that someone provide the figure representing what
the Town contributes to Beaufort County for coverage.
Sheriff Tanner then introduced a video showing some events that transpired on Hilton Head
Island during the July 4, 2026 weekend. This video is part of the BCTV recording of the
meeting and can be viewed as part of the meeting via this link: Jul 09, 2026 Hilton Head
Special Town Council Meeting - Beaufort County, SC
Sheriff Tanner focused on current public safety realities, the changing environment in Hilton
Head Island, and the extensive efforts by the Beaufort County Sheriff’s Office to manage
increasing activity, especially in high-traffic beach areas like Coligny. He explained that the
video shown to Council was intended to give residents and officials an unfiltered view of the
nighttime activity officers deal with regularly. He highlighted the Sheriff’s Office’s continuous
24/7 operations across Beaufort County and noted how Hilton Head Island has evolved
culturally and demographically over decades. The Sheriff discussed recurring conversations
about whether Hilton Head Island should form its own police department, emphasizing that
while he has never opposed the idea, it is a major undertaking often underestimated by the
public. He referenced recent events, including the July 4th shooting where deputies arrived
Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council
Meeting Minutes
7/9/2026 Page 3 of 9
within 17 seconds, to demonstrate the capability and rapid response of the Sheriff’s Office,
supported by coordinated efforts with multiple agencies. He shared detailed call-for-service
and crime-rate data, noting significant reductions in calls over the past two years. He explained
that Hilton Head Island’s status as a destination brings heavy seasonal activity, requiring
vigilant resource allocation based on real-time information from deputies. The Sheriff also
outlined recommendations made in 2025 to improve the Coligny area—such as lighting,
landscaping changes, and camera expansion—and updated Council on progress, including the
establishment of a new substation in Coligny Plaza at a symbolic lease rate of one dollar per
year. The Sheriff finished by acknowledging partner agencies, noting ongoing investigative
progress with the July 4th cases, and reinforcing that some operational tactics must remain
confidential. Overall, his message stressed the need for continued adaptation, enhanced
infrastructure at key hotspots, and strong collaboration between the Town and law
enforcement. Sheriff Tanner then introduced Daniel Gourley, II, general counsel for the
Beaufort County Sheriff's Office.
Mr. Gourley outlined the Sheriff’s Office’s key recommendation to the Town Council:
implementing a juvenile curfew to address recurring late-night issues involving minors on
Hilton Head Island. He explained that other cities in South Carolina—such as Charleston,
Myrtle Beach, Columbia, and Greenville—already use curfews effectively, giving law
enforcement the authority to stop, identify, and direct juveniles home when encountered after
certain hours. He stressed that enforcement should extend to parents who knowingly allow
their children to be out late. Based on patterns observed by deputies, he recommended an
8:00 p.m. curfew for unaccompanied minors in known hotspot areas, with reasonable
exceptions for emergencies, work, or travel home. He noted that juvenile behavior shown in
the video highlights a lack of respect for law enforcement and the absence of legal tools to
intervene, since current laws—like disorderly conduct—no longer apply to minors. The curfew,
he argues, is a lawful, tested solution that would give officers the tools needed to reduce
disruptive juvenile activity and improve public safety.
Sheriff Tanner then expanded on earlier recommendations by urging the town to enhance its
overall community-based safety structure, in addition to considering a juvenile curfew. He
suggested creating community resource positions within the Town—built out from the existing
Code Enforcement team—to function similarly to community policing. These staff members
would gather information directly from non-gated neighborhoods, address quality-of-life
concerns beyond crime, and work more closely with residents. He noted that Code
Enforcement already interacts with the community through issues like short-term rentals,
parking, and business licensing, making it a strong foundation for a broadened role. He
emphasized that this approach does not require sworn law-enforcement officers; the Town can
build it in-house with leadership from its experienced public safety director. He reiterated
support for the juvenile curfew, highlighting that the Town can tailor it by season, age, or
specific hours, and stressed the importance of public education, so residents understand the
new rules. He concluded by noting that shaping an environment where poor behavior leads to
a loss of opportunity is an effective corrective approach for young people, reinforcing the need
for these measures to address recurring issues in hotspot areas.
Mayor Perry thanked Sheriff Tanner and Mr. Gourley and asked Council about enhancing the
Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council
Meeting Minutes
7/9/2026 Page 4 of 9
Town's Code Enforcement. He asked the Town Manager to work on obtaining this information,
including funding needs, so it could be brought to Council for consideration. The Mayor then
asked Council for comments and questions.
Council discussion centered on recent public safety concerns on Hilton Head Island,
particularly incidents involving teenagers on the beach, including the July 4th shooting at
Coligny Beach. Council members, the Mayor, and the Sheriff debated responsibilities, needed
changes, and next steps.
Key points included:
1. Long-standing public safety issues on the beaches. Several council members emphasized
that problems involving large teenage gatherings, fights, and drug use have been occurring for
years, mostly unnoticed by non-beach-goers. There was consensus that the time has come for
meaningful action.
2. Insufficient “boots on the beach”. Multiple council members expressed concern that deputy
sheriffs are rarely present on the beaches unless a major event is anticipated. The Sheriff
disputed this to a degree, saying deployment is based on intelligence and need, and that
teams are dispatched when necessary. He stated 28 officers were deployed on July 4th,
mainly on the South End.
3. Town vs. Sheriff responsibility. A key theme was whether the Town of Hilton Head Island
must create and operate its own police department or significantly expand code enforcement.
The Sheriff reiterated that his office is obligated to serve the entire county and cannot contract
with municipalities, though Memorandums of Understanding (MOUs) can be used to authorize
enforcement of town ordinances.
4. Potential creation of a Town of Hilton Head Island Police Department. Several council
members referenced a long-standing discussion about establishing a local police department.
The Sheriff provided estimates:
• Startup cost: $26–$30 million for the first year
• Full implementation timeline: 3–5 years
• He said he would fully support the Town if it chooses this path.
5. Enhancing Code Enforcement. There was agreement that code enforcement could be
expanded with additional officers equipped with radios and body cameras. The Sheriff
supported better integration between deputies and code enforcement, especially on the beach.
6. Role of technology (cameras, drones, Flock system). The Sheriff stressed that technology is
essential. Cameras provided critical evidence in the July 4th incident. He strongly encouraged
the Town to expand beach cameras and adopt a drone program for overhead surveillance.
7. Curfew discussions. Several members discussed establishing a teen curfew in certain
areas. Concerns were raised that curfews may simply shift gatherings elsewhere and must be
paired with broader community mitigation and youth support.
8. Coordination with the incoming Sheriff. Because Sheriff Tanner is leaving office in about six
months, some council members stressed that this meeting should help shape expectations for
the next Sheriff.
9. Community concerns and resource offers. The Lowcountry Alliance for Healthy Youth
Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council
Meeting Minutes
7/9/2026 Page 5 of 9
offered funding ($15–$20k) to help cover armed officers on weekends.
Council members described additional issues:
• Drugs and marijuana use on beaches
• A series of teen gatherings and parties at Gumtree, Sea Pines, and other locations
• At least one incident where a 911 caller was told no officers were available to respond
• Need for monitoring social media flyers promoting teen beach meetups
Next steps identified
Council members expressed interest in:
• Proceeding with a study on expanded code enforcement or creating a police
department
• Drafting a new Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) with the incoming Sheriff
• Ensuring better communication and expectation-setting
• Improving beach safety through surveillance, staffing, youth programs, and possible
curfews
• Hearing public comments before forming final action items
Council Member Brison had the following suggested timeline for action:
Within 30 days
• Adopt a curfew ordinance.
• Create a system for additional beach patrols at Coligny and other areas where crowds may
shift.
• Get a recommendation from the Town Attorney on how to manage and disperse large
crowds, via ordinance or state statute.
• Issue a press release to the community and vacation rental companies explaining how they
will receive safety alerts or shelter-in-place notices (perhaps via Nixle if appropriate and
efficient).
Within 90 days
• Investigate the use of drones for public safety.
• Begin analyzing options for an interim or intermediate law enforcement force, including cost
and service analysis, and the potential path toward a full police department.
After the election / with the new Sheriff
• Establish an agreement with the incoming Sheriff, reviewing past services and prior
contracts.
• Explore youth programs and interventions.
• Evaluate drug intervention programs for the community.
• Discuss the law enforcement fee with the County and assess possible changes or reductions
until the Town establishes its own police force.
Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council
Meeting Minutes
7/9/2026 Page 6 of 9
• Consider charging for parking at Coligny.
Additional recommendation
• Add this topic to the July 14 council agenda for continued discussion and sequencing of
immediate, secondary, and long-term actions.
• Evaluate possible youth/juvenile programs and whose duty it would be.
• Evaluate drug intervention programs and whose duty it would be.
Council Member Becker relayed that she has scheduled a meeting, open to the public, to be
held at the Hilton Head Island Branch Library that evening, where the public could come and
continue the dialogue or if unable to attend the Town Council meeting, would be able to
participate at the library meeting. Ms. Becker also expressed support for the recommendations
from a report that landscaping changes be addressed as soon as possible and parking fees at
Coligny need to be discussed and addressed. She also gave assurance that growth
management/capacity for the Island is being addressed and requested that Town Council give
authority to the Town Manager and Town Attorney to begin working with the Sheriff's
Department to implement ordinances to begin the work needed to be done. Additionally, Ms.
Becker questioned the amount and the use of the County's Police Fee. Ms. Becker also
relayed that the Lowcountry Alliance for Healthy Youth may have available funds from the
opioid lawsuits to assist Hilton Head Island for services to help with addiction and it could be
possible for Fire Rescue to work with that nonprofit to bring those dollars to the Island.
Mayor Perry asked Mr. Orlando for his thoughts and summary of expectations as to how to
provide the best safety and security for Hilton Head Island, its residents, businesses and
guests, in consideration of the fact that Beaufort County, which provides Hilton Head Island's
policing, will have a new Sheriff in place in approximately six months.
Mr. Orlando responded to offer an explanation with regard to the Coligny area study that was
mentioned several times during the meeting. The study contains security-related
recommendations and was in the planning process when it was requested by several council
members. Because it was in the planning process and remained an active study in the
Beaufort County Sheriff's Office, it was advised that the study not be released at that time. The
study does recommend landscape improvements, additional lighting and camera expansion.
Landscaping was cut back, additional lighting was added and there is a contract underway for
additional cameras.
Mr. Orlando then outlined ongoing efforts, challenges, and proposed next steps related to
public safety, beach operations, and cooperation with the Beaufort County Sheriff’s Office. He
emphasized that Hilton Head Island has already invested heavily in public-realm
improvements—including cameras, the Coligny quadrant, and beach infrastructure—and that
planning for the Beach Operations Center is well underway. He clarified prior comments
regarding golf carts on the beach, explaining the intent was to ensure law enforcement and
Town staff have adequate equipment (ATVs, vehicles, cooled units) due to overwhelming
beach conditions, and he relayed that there may be unspent funds of approximately $20,000 in
the Beaufort County Law Enforcement Fee which could be used toward essential items. Mr.
Orlando relayed that the Town Attorney would work on a proposed curfew ordinance for
Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council
Meeting Minutes
7/9/2026 Page 7 of 9
Council's review, and discussed the Town’s Community Resource Officer (CRO) model, noting
the Town of Hilton Head Island already employs 11 CROs and that their role is
municipal-code-focused, not law enforcement. Mr. Orlando acknowledged the ongoing theme
of redefining the Town–Sheriff partnership and highlighted the need for a clearly structured
MOU that specifies service expectations, measurable results, and accountability, especially
given the law enforcement fee (approximately $6.9M and rising) placed on taxpayers. He
stressed that the ordinance defining this fee requires services “above and beyond” base
County law enforcement levels, prompting a need for renewed clarity via a Memorandum of
Understanding. He suggested, moving forward, four possible service-delivery models:
• Status quo
• Strengthened Memorandum of Understanding with measurable outcomes and
accountability
• Hybrid model with deputized officers assigned to Town needs
• Formation of the Town’s own police department
Council Member Becker requested a timeline for the Town Manager's recommendations.
Mr. Orlando requested time to produce key deliverables, including a curfew ordinance (within
30 days) and a full public-safety assessment, and he underscored the need to collaborate with
Sheriff Tanner now and with the incoming sheriff beginning January 4th. In closing, Mr.
Orlando asked Council for direction and reaffirm the shared responsibility—town, sheriff, and
community—to set service levels, understand current gaps, establish expectations in writing,
and ensure taxpayer dollars are tied to clearly defined public-safety outcomes.
Mayor Perry closed the discussion by thanking everyone for their time and stated that they
should use the knowledge gained from this experience and continue to work together to keep
the Town of Hilton Head Island as one of the safest communities in South Carolina.
Mayor Perry asked for public comment:
John Davidson: addressed Council regarding real property values, the lawsuit regarding the
dredging project, the ability to look ahead, that the time allotted for public comment is
ineffective.
Richard Bisi: addressed Council regarding shootings at Coligny Beach and measures that
could be taken to prevent such incidents, including monitoring of social media.
Teresa Duncan: addressed Council to relay that the gathering was planned on social media,
the Sheriff's Department and officers did a great job, and suggested beach markets should
have their own security.
Skip Hoagland: addressed Council to state that more police presence is needed in hotspot
areas, the level of law enforcement needs to be expanded in connection with community
growth and that Hilton Head Island should establish its own police department with the
Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council
Meeting Minutes
7/9/2026 Page 8 of 9
possibility of a tourism fee to help offset costs.
Pamela Ovens: addressed Council to commend officers on their response and handling of the
shooting incident, which shows that the current system is working, and thanked the Sheriff's
Department.
Krista Flanders: addressed Council to request an increase in law enforcement presence on
beaches and to strengthen the Town's partnership with Beaufort County Sheriff's Office
through education, prevention and community outreach and suggested investment in addiction
treatment and recovery resources.
Mark Piekarski: addressed Council to suggest that the Town expand service with the Sheriff's
Department to enhance security in order to immediately address safety.
Rick Gillette: addressed Council to express concern regarding the unintended consequences
of free parking at Coligny Beach and perhaps the free parking should be re-evaluated to
reduce over-crowding and improve safety.
Lynn Greeley: addressed Council to express the need for Hilton Head island to have its own
police force with increased police presence, especially in consideration of the expanded
airport, which brings increased visitors, and suggested using tourism revenue to offset costs.
Kris Reitz: addressed Council regarding the need for law enforcement and patrolling to
prevent the disruptive and dangerous late-night negative activities that have been occurring on
the Island.
Dave Ferguson: addressed Council to express that Town Council's first responsibility is public
safety and action should have been taken sooner to prevent the shooting tragedy, instead of
reacting after the fact.
Philip Smith: addressed Council regarding the need for more sheriffs, traffic enforcement and
canines, as well as a lockup facility, all of which may be used to deter criminal behavior.
Paige Cope: addressed Council regarding concern about the history of shootings on the Island
and the change in community and feels the residents are taking a back seat to visitors, tourism
and development and many residents no longer feel safe and requested that Council become
more proactive.
Chuck Dowd: addressed Council and commended the Sheriff and the Sheriff's Department,
stated that changes in the community require serious consideration of having a police
department on the Island so it would be dedicated to the issues that affect the Island and noted
that if such department heads are ineffective, they could be replaced.
Dominique Binins: addressed Council and expressed that he moved to Hilton Head Island to
feel more safe, but juveniles on the Island are out of control because they understand the
limitations of law enforcement and additional measures are needed to manage their actions
Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council
Meeting Minutes
7/9/2026 Page 9 of 9
and behavior before another tragedy occurs.
Niwar Davis: addressed Council regarding the need for there to be immediate accountability
for juveniles in order to avert catastrophic effects on the community and suggests that the
community and Council need to work together more often to solve issues.
Laurie Yingling: addressed Council to share that her son-in-law and grandson were present
on the beach at the time of the shooting, and they felt that something bad was going to happen
based on the atmosphere.
Alexandra Ascencion: suggested outreach programs for youth in the community.
Public Comment - Non Agenda Items
Richard Bisi: addressed Council regarding concern that the scheduled time for the meeting
disenfranchises working people who cannot attend meetings during working hours; and
thought that the juvenile curfew would be a good idea.
Dave Ferguson: addressed Council regarding thoughts on ways to handle public safety such
as putting more of the funding from the budget towards public safety, conversion of the Wild
Wing Cafe building on Pope Avenue into a substation for law enforcement to include a holding
cell, to show a strong police and civil community presence.
Skip Hoagland: addressed Council regarding the use of AI technology in place of a lawyer,
forensic audits and financial oversight.
Brenda Armstrong: addressed Council regarding concern over the Island's growth, support of
the curfew for juveniles and a request for additional educational assistance for the Island's
most affected children and expressed concern for the Island's children who lack activities
during the hottest months of the summer.
Adjournment
At 2:23 p.m., Mr. Alfred moved to adjourn. Ms. Becker seconded. Motion carried 7-0.
__________________________
Alan R. Perry, Mayor
____________________________
Kimberly Gammon, Town Clerk
The full recording and a transcript of this meeting can be found on the Town’s website
at www.hiltonheadislandsc.gov
Source: Town of Hilton Head Island website. First collected Oct 13, 2026.