Board of Zoning Appeals — Minutes
Town of Hilton Head Island · Beaufort County · Board of Zoning Appeals · meeting of Jun 22, 2026 · Minutes
Open the original document More from Town of Hilton Head Island
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
Town of Hilton Head Island Board of Zoning Appeals
Meeting Minutes
6/22/2026 Page | 1
Town of Hilton Head Island
BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS MEETING
Monday, June 22, 2026, 2:30 PM
Minutes
1. Call to Order
Vice Chair Bayless called the meeting to order at 2:30 p.m. In attendance were: Vice-Chair
Bayless, Jeffery Greene, Peter Kristian, Michael Sackheim and Amy Fee. Absent were:
Chairman Fingerhut and Dale Strecker.
2. Welcome and Introduction to Board Procedures
Vice Chair Bayless welcomed all in attendance and introduced the Board's procedures for
conducting the meeting.
3. Adoption of the Agenda
Mr. Kristian moved to approve the agenda as presented. Mr. Sackheim seconded. The motion
passed unanimously.
4. Approval of the Minutes
a. Regular Meeting Minutes of April 27, 2026
Mr. Greene moved to approve the minutes of April 27, 2026. Mr. Kristian seconded. The
motion passed unanimously.
5. Unfinished Business
a. Public Hearing
VAR-000251-2026 - Request from Daniel Kirchberg, owner of 14 Pelican Street, also
identified as Beaufort County Tax Map Parcel R550 015 00A 0467 0000, for a
variance from LMO Section 16-6-104.F.2.a, General Requirements, to remove a
specimen tree that is located on a single-family lot.
Vice Chair Bayless advised the Board that they would pick up where we left off on this
item from the April 27, 2026 meeting. All members of the Board were present for the last
Hearing. Brian Eber, Principal Planner, advised the Town had received an Aborist Report
from Mr. Richard V. McDevitt, Certified Aborist from Abor Nature as requested. Mr. Eber
responded to several questions from the Board. Vice Chair Bayless then invited
comments from the applicant, Daniel Kirchberg had nothing to add to Mr. Eber's
comments. Following discussion, Mr. Greene moved to grant the applicant's request to
remove the specimen tree. There being no second, the motion died for lack of a second.
Mr. Kristian moved to deny the applicant's request due to the following:
Findings of Fact
Town of Hilton Head Island Board of Zoning Appeals
Meeting Minutes
6/22/2026 Page | 2
1. The subject property contains a specimen tree which the applicant states is
approximately 36" in diameter.
2. The subject property is approximately 0.27 acres in size and contains 4 specimen
live oaks and one significant 28" live oak tree.
3. The subject property is a single family residential lot, located at 14 Pelican Street,
within the RSF-District and subject the Forest Beach Character Overlay (FB-NC-
O.) The subject parcel borders single-family residential uses to the north and south
while fronting Pelican Street.
4. The property owner requests a variance to allow removal of the 36" live oak tree
located immediately adjacent to the rear of the house so a new swimming pool and
pool deck can be constructed.
5. The Forest Beach Owners Association Inc. has approved the construction plans
but has neither approved nor disapproved the removal of the 36" live oak tree.
Instead, the Association relies solely upon the provisions of the Town of Hilton
Head's Land Management Ordinance for the determination of removal of
significant trees.
6. The risk associated with 36" live oak has been professionally evaluated. On March
19, 2026, Arborist Clay Jones, with Jones Brothers Tree Service, called Town staff
member Brian Eber. The property owner had requested that Mr. Jones give his
opinion of the tree and Mr. Jones stated that the tree was healthy.
7. A second opinion was obtained by the owner by Abor Nature. By letter of May 1,
2026, Mr. Richard V. McDevitt, Certified Aborist, opined that the tree presented a
"moderate risk" with a "possible" likelihood of failure. A "moderate failure" means
that the tree may be mitigated and/or retained and monitored. A "possible"
likelihood of failure means that failure could occur but is unlikely during normal
weather conditions.
8. The proposed accessory use of a 350 square foot swimming pool with a 417
square foot permeable paver deck is the sole reason for the proposed removal of
the 36" live oak tree.
9. Both the property owner and the contractor for the owner have acknowledged that
a smaller pool can be built upon the property at a different location.
Conclusions of Law
1. The purpose of the Residential Single-Family (RSF-5) District is to primarily
accommodate neighborhoods of single-family dwellings at densities ranging up to
five units per acre. It is intended to discourage any use that would substantially
interfere with the development of single-family dwellings or would be detrimental to
the quiet residential nature of single-family neighborhoods. The district also
accommodates agricultural uses and parks as permitted uses.
2. Section 16-6-104.F.2a of the Town's Land Management Ordinance (LMO) reads
"No specimen tree may be removed except in accordance with the paragraph
below. In addition, all specimen trees shall have the following protections, whether
located on public or private land."
3. A variance from this section of the LMO may be allowed in an individual case of
Town of Hilton Head Island Board of Zoning Appeals
Meeting Minutes
6/22/2026 Page | 3
unnecessary hardship if the Board of Zoning Appeals determines that all the
following four criteria are met. Those criteria are: a) There are extraordinary and
exceptional conditions pertaining to the particular piece of property. b) These
conditions do not generally apply to other properties in the vicinity, c) Because of
these conditions, the application of the ordinance to the particular piece of property
would effectively prohibit or unreasonably restrict utilization of the property, d) The
authorization of the variance will not be substantial detriment to adjacent property
or the public good, and the character of the zoning district where the property is
located will not be harmed by the granting of the variance.
4. Based upon the report of a Certified Arborist, the BZA concludes that the 36" live
oak tree on this particular piece of property does not present an imminent danger
requiring removal at this time. Furthermore, the tree does not "effectively prohibit
or unreasonably restrict the utilization of the property." Both the owner and the
contractor have acknowledged that there is an alternate location on the property
on which a pool and deck can be constructed.
5. Therefore, the request for a variance is hereby denied.
Mr. Sackheim seconded. The motion to deny the application passed with a vote of 4-1. Mr
Greene was opposed.
6. New Business
a. Public Hearing
VAR-000528-2026 - Request from Judd Carstens, on behalf of MACH XVII, LLC,
owners of 1010 William Hilton Parkway, also identified on Beaufort County Tax Map
as parcel number R552 015 000 289A 0000, for a variance from LMO Section 16-4-
102.B.5.b., Use Specific Conditions, to allow an Outdoor Commercial Recreation
Use Other Than a Water Park to not have the required direct vehicular access to a
minor arterial street.
Mr. Brian Eber presented the staff report, as included in the agenda packet, regarding a
variance request submitted by Judd Carstens, on behalf of MACH XVII, LLC, owners of
1010 William Hilton Parkway, also identified on Beaufort County Tax Map as parcel
number R552 015 000 289A 0000, for a variance from LMO Section 16-4-102.B.5.b., Use
Specific Conditions, to allow an Outdoor Commercial Recreation Use Other than a Water
Park to proceed without the required direct vehicular access to a minor arterial street.
Staff recommends the Board of Zoning Appeals find the request to be consistent with the
Town's Our Plan and serves to carry out the purposes of the LMO, based on those
Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law as determined by the LMO Official. Staff
recommends that the Board of Zoning Appeals approve the application, with the following
conditions to mitigate the potential impacts on nearby residential uses:
The outdoor use shall not be permitted between the hours of 10:01 pm and 6:59 am.
1. There shall not be any speakers or amplified music or sound outside of any
enclosed building or directed from inside any enclosed building to the outside.
Town of Hilton Head Island Board of Zoning Appeals
Meeting Minutes
6/22/2026 Page | 4
2. A landscaping plan must be approved by the Design Review Board (DRB) and
must include additional landscaping and a sound dampening fence or wall
generally along the Dunnagans Alley property line and/or the existing Santee
Cooper powerline easement running parallel to Dunnagans Alley, at a minimum.
3. An exterior lighting plan showing all exterior buildings and site lighting must be
approved by the DRB.
Mr. Eber concluded his presentation and responded to questions from the Board
concerning the impact of traffic on 278E and Dunnagans Alley, whether it is in the interest
of Hilton Head to have an additional mini-golf course in the middle of the road, and
concern about tree removal.
Vice Chair Bayless then invited comments from the applicant. Mr. Judd Carstens on
behalf of the applicant. Mr. Carstens stated within light commercial, you are allowed a lot
of uses. Outdoor recreation just ends up having that extra level of scrutiny. What we are
trying to do with our development here is to utilize the existing open lot, which was the old
car wash, while trying to lightly impact the state of trees on the backside without the
removal of any significant trees and, of course, providing sufficient parking per the LMO.
The variance just sought in relief to the point regarding the minor arterial, the access to a
light situation of roadways. The south end of 278 is a very active area. It is surrounded by
light commercial properties, including the RV Resort which is designated light
commercial. Mr. Carstens said he appreciates the conditions that staff has laid out. From
a use standpoint, we find it appropriate being within this district surrounded by
restaurants, accessible to both our residents and our guests. Mr. Carstens mentioned
Alan Wolf of Serge Group is here, as well as Tim Probst of Architecture Group if you have
any questions.
Mr. Carstens answered several questions and concerns from the Board regarding
whether adding another mini-golf course in that location and restaurant adds to the
attractiveness of Hilton Head or does that make Hilton Head more like Myrtle Beach and
making sure there is no removal of significant trees.
After discussion, Mr. Kristian moved that based on the staff report and the Findings of
Fact and Conclusions of Law that the Board of Zoning Appeals finds this consistent with
the Town's Our Plan and serves to carry out the purpose of the LMO and recommends
that the request for the variance should be approved based on the conditions listed
above. Mr. Greene seconded. The motion to approve the application passed
unanimously.
7. Public Comment - Non Agenda Items
Chester Williams, Esquire introduced Ms. Lola Campbell to the Board. Ms. Campbell is a
native Island Gullah, went to University of Georgia and Howard University Law School, has
worked for Wells Fargo as a Senior Derivatives Counsel. Ms. Campbell is learning about
zoning and land use laws and is a member of the Town's LMO Task Force. The Board
welcomed Ms. Campbell.
Town of Hilton Head Island Board of Zoning Appeals
Meeting Minutes
6/22/2026 Page | 5
8. Staff Reports
There were no staff reports.
9. Adjournment
The meeting was adjourned at 3:24 pm
Source: Town of Hilton Head Island website. First collected Oct 13, 2026.