RecordWell Data

Agenda

City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · meeting of Apr 21, 2026 · Agenda packets

Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

Beach Preservation Committee 9:00 a.m., Tuesday, April 21, 2026 1207 Palm Boulevard City Hall Council Chambers Public Comment: All citizens who wish to speak during the meeting must email their first and last name, address and topic to Nicole DeNeane, City Clerk, at nicoled@iop.net no later than 3:00 p.m. the day before the meeting. Citizens may also provide written public comment here: https://www.iop.net/public-comment-form A genda 1. Call to order and acknowledgment that the press and the public have been duly notified of the meeting in accordance with the Freedom of Information Act. 2. Citizens’ comments- All comments have a time limit of three (3) minutes. 3. New Business- Applying the Beach Committee’s new definition of a “healthy beach” at the 3 trouble spots and calculating required sand volumes for the upcoming renourishment project. 4. Miscellaneous Business- Next meeting: Thursday, May 7, 2026 at 9am 5. Adjournment Recommendation to IOP City Council 1. Adopt new “healthy beach” definition • 200 feet of dry sand at highest tide • Measured from 2018 SCDES baseline or structure line (houses and pools), whichever is most seaward • Using the most recent 5-year erosion rates 2. Increase the planned renourishment project volume to 3MM cubic yards • Applying that new definition to the 3 critical IOP beach hot spots requires 546,000 more cubic yards than the 2.5MM permit max. • Sand will never be as inexpensive as now • This will cost the city/Wild Dunes an extra $4.1MM Healthy Beach Goals Feature Current Method (cy structure to closure) New Method (200 feet of beach) Primary Goal Protect the house foundation Protect the entire beach and property line Tourism Risk of Decline High; leads to “beach-less’ shores. Loss of tourism revenue Low; maintains wide, attractive beaches Risk of Property Values Erosion leads to property value decline and flood insurance issues Protects entire island residential property valued at $6.5 billion Storm Buffer Fails under extreme pressure Minimize structural damage Private Assets Pools and yards often lost Homes, pools, and land are shielded Emergency Funds ~$4MM+ spending on emergency measures Reduced emergency spending Minimize damage in a level 3 hurricane; ensure a recreational beach at all tides and seasons, and protect private property and structures. Healthy Beach – Defined in terms we understand and can ‘see’ • Beachline: SCDES 2018 baseline or structure line (houses and pools), whichever is most seaward • Healthy Beach Definition: 200 feet from Beachline to Mean Highest High Water Line (MHHW)* • Renourishment Placement : Sand placement will focus on areas of need, defined as those areas where: • There is a sand volume deficit currently, using Healthy Beach Definition, or • Where the protective healthy beach width is proposed to be less than 200 feet at the end of the project life • And the MWWH line* is experiencing erosion * Consider Arial photography method to overlay the wet line, taken in November and April at higher tide period, similar to Hilton Head practice. Renourishment Volumes • Renourishment Volume = [Current Deficit] + [Advanced Fill] – [Current Excess] • Current Deficit: cubic yards of sanded needed to establish 200 feet between Beachline and MHHW line. • Advanced Fill: forecast erosion rate (using last 5 years) * project life (currently using 8 years) • Current Excess: Excess between current MHHW line and MHHW line if only 200’ from Beachline Renourishment Volume Recommendation • Minimum: use permit max for each of the 3 permitted reaches • Recommended: additional 546,000 cubic yards (+$4.1MM) using new healthy beach definition: • South end: +352,000 cy ($2.6MM) • Larger deficit using new definition • 5 year erosion rate thru Feb 2025 (89k cy/yr) • North end: + 194,000 cy ($1.5 MM) • Larger deficit using new definition • 2018-2026 rate for advance fill numbers (150k cy/ft) • Smooth out / extend Beachwood East area renourishment to 53 rd Ave to create usable beach. • Any future changes to volume or locations require town council approval Permit Vs. Healthy Beach, cubic yards Permit Maximum Case Recommended Using Healthy Beach Definition Comments Wild Dunes 1,700,000 1,894,000 +194,000 ($1.5 MM) Smooth out placement thru to 53rd Ave. South End 800,000 1,152,000 +352,000 ($2.6MM) Total 2,500,000 3,047,000 +546,000 ($4.1MM) Smooth out Beachwood East Reach Renourishment Recommend extending renourishment to limit line to 53rd Ave. Was erosional from shoal attachment Establishes usable beach in interim until sand from north attaches. Risk Analysis • If south end high recent erosion continues (2022 -2024 period), an additional 376,000 cubic yards ($2.8MM) would be needed over recommended volumes • 136k/yr erosion versus 89k/year 5 year rate assumed • If only max permit is placed and high erosion case occurs, the 800,000 cubic yards would erode in 5 1/2 years • Start groin analysis ASAP • Army Corp beneficial use volume of 300,000 is fine and known to erode faster. Recommend sand quality testing to inform erosion rate. • Shoal attachment doesn’t occur • Renourishment volume at far end near breach inlet may erode quickly • Spread out healthy beach volume consistent with bid drawing vs. add more sand on the end • Start groin analysis ASAP Future monitoring: MHHW – mean highest high water; the higher of the two tides in a day • Measure in November and April • Allow immediate feedback on hurricane season losses • Capture MHHW ‘wet line’ on a ~5.5 foot tide day via arial photography* • Memo: October 2025 severe erosion had tide of 6.8 feet *Seek expert second opinion on monitoring methodology Pre-read Materials 150 cy/ft reflects 2018- 2026 rate (Source: CSE) South End Erosion Long term erosion less relevant as future trend of sand loss expected, per second opinions Erosion Rates: 30k/year: Long term erosion 56k/year: Since 2018 70k/year: Permit assumption by CSE 89k/year: 5 year erosion rate (thru 2/25) 136k/year: High erosion period recently (2022-2024) Advanced fill ranges: 240,000 (30k/yr) 448,000 (56k/yr) 560,000 (70k/yr) 712,000 (89k/yr) 1,088,000 (136k/yr) Healthy Beach Deficits using higher of SCDES Baseline or Structure Line Healthy Beach = 200’ from “BCM” Red Dash Healthy Beach = 200’ from “BCM” Red Dash Healthy Beach = 200’ from “BCM” Red Dash or Blue Structure, whichever is most seaward Recommendation: Structure to include houses and pools Healthy Beach = 200’ from “BCM” Red Dash or Blue Structure, whichever is most seaward Recommendation: Structure to include houses and pools South Beach measurements March 21 (5.8’ tide) Location Beach: T oe of Dune to Wet Line Beach if put dune back Comments 104 Ocean Zero Zero Will lose property at higher tide 100’s (Sand bag area) Almost zero Zero Need dunes re-established. Keep sand bags for 6’ tides in April 2nd Ave 46 feet 26 feet No dunes. Sandbags. Have lost private property 3rd Ave 83 feet 63 feet Insufficient dunes. 6th Ave * 50 feet 35 feet Insufficient dunes 7th Ave. * 70 feet 50 feet Insufficient dunes Grand Pavillion (March 14) Over 200’ but can see it has eroded recently Wild Dunes hot spots Zero Zero Ocean club; Beachwood east * One month later, there is erosion. 6th and 7th Avenues have same dry beach distance but on a LOWER tide day of 4.6 ft (vs 5.8 ft tide above). Emergency cost avoidance ~ $4MM+ • Source is Completed Beach Projects section on IOP town website Cost - $ Comment 300,000 Beachwood east sand scraping 250,000 Sandbags for south end unknown Collins Engineering dune restoration, 100 -314 Ocean Blvd 1,250,000 Sand scraping south end 322,000 CSE emergency management oversight 200,000 Sandbags Beachwood East 800,000 Shoal management, Ocean Club, Seascape, Beachwood East Unknown Private resident spend: extra sand bagging, dune restoration due to Army Corp delays (~10 families), pool repair costs, vegetation install $3,122,000-4,000,000 T otal

Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Oct 13, 2026.