Emergency Meeting - May 8, 2020
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · meeting of May 8, 2020 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
SPECIAL CIT
Y COUNCIL MEETING
2:00pm, Friday, May 8, 2020
Virtual Meeting via Zoom call due to COVID-19 Pandemic:
Broadcasted live on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/user/cityofisleofpalms
MINUTES
1. Call to order
Present: Council members Popson, Streetman, Moye, Ward, Buckhannon, Bell,
Pounds, and Smith, and Mayor Carroll
Staff Present: Administrator Fragoso, Attorney Copeland, various department
heads, Sandy Stone of the Short-Term Rental Task Force
MOTION: Council Member Ward made a motion to suspend the rules of order and
add a discussion of the “keep it moving” requirement in Ordinance 2020-03 to the
agenda. Council Member Streetman seconded the motion. The motion passed
unanimously.
Council Member Smith abstained from voting on the motion as she said the ordinance
affects her family business.
2. Discussion of Ordinance 2020-03
MOTION: Council Member Ward made a motion to rescind the requirement that
those on the beach be in constant movement and eliminate the regulation that the
beach is open for exercise only effective immediately. Council Member Streetman
second the motion.
Post motion, Council Member Ward noted for the record a statement that this
amendment is due to the exigent circumstances of public health measures and the
inability to enforce the current ordinance.
Chief Cornett shared that most beach goers have been successfully practicing social
distancing and sees no issue with rescinding that requirement. Chief Cornett also noted
that the wording of the Governor’s Executive Order makes enforcing group size at
restaurants very difficult, but he can still enforce the limitation of group size on the
beach to three or less unless they are from the same family and live in the same
household.
VOTE: The motion was passed unanimously. Council Member Smith did not vote.
Special City Council Minutes, 5/8/2020
2
Council Member Ward expressed concern about enforcing the groups of three or less
on the beach but not in the restaurants.
3. Presentation and consideration of the recommendations developed by the
Short-Term Rental and Hotel Phased Re-Opening Task Force
Council Member Buckhannon recused himself from the discussion and any votes
regarding short-term rentals.
Director Kerr reviewed the creation and makeup of the Short-Term Rental and Hotel
Phased Re-Opening Task Force. He then shared the considerations and their final
recommendations as provided in a document to City Council. He said the
recommendations are to be effective immediately and in place for the next 61 days.
Council members thanked the members of the Task Force for their service. Mr. Stone
said that rental managers are not asking for waivers be signed by renters. Council
members Streetman and Ward noted that the rental managers have more at stake for
not following the guidelines.
When asked about a requirement for cleaners to wear PPE, Director Kerr indicated that
rental property managers have no control over the cleaning companies and what they
do.
Dr. Edward O’Bryan of MUSC said the guidelines were “very good” as presented. He
shared that MUSC is developing a program through their Public Health Team to help
any business or municipality to do walk-throughs and help them develop a playbook for
implementing the guidelines provided by Federal, state, and local governments. Council
Member Ward encouraged Administrator Fragoso to follow up on that program with Dr.
O’Bryan.
Director Kerr said that all of the Task Force recommendations will be sent to rental
property owners and will include information about the MUSC program described by Dr.
O’Bryan.
Administrator Fragoso noted that a requirement for cleaning employees to wear face
masks and gloves when available needs to be added to §B(3). She also said that
reservations can be taken for check-ins on or after May 13, 2020.
MOTION: Council Member Pounds made a motion to accept the sanitation and
hygiene recommendations as presented by the Short-Term Rental and Hotel
Phased Re-Opening Task Force. Council Member Streetman seconded the
motion.
The effective date for these measures would be May 13, 2020 following the expiration of
the short-term rental ban on May 12, 2020.
Special City Council Minutes, 5/8/2020
3
VOTE: A vote was taken with all in favor. Council Member Buckhannon did not
vote.
3. Adjournment
Council Member Pounds made a motion to adjourn, and Council Member Bell seconded
the motion. The meeting was adjourned at 3:12pm.
Respectfully submitted,
Nicole DeNeane
City Clerk
Public Comment For City Meetings
Name
James King
Address
2705 Cameron Blvd, Isle of Palms, South Carolina 29451
Comments for Council Meeting
Thank you for scheduling this special City Council Meeting to discuss the planned palm tree removals by
Dominion Energy and soliciting questions from IOP residents.
Overall, I am interested in seeing a process that effectively BALANCES the needs of the residents with the
needs of DE.
My questions:
1. What specific data points were presented by DE that justify the removal of 97 palm trees from the
island? Specifically, over the past year, 5, and 10 years, how many palm trees caused downing or outages
of island power lines on IOP? What is the documented risk of power grid compromise?
2. Was there any involvement of an arborist (independent/not by paid by DE), representing the interests of
IOP residents, in the palm tree risk assessment process? If not, should/could there be?
3. Is there an opportunity to establish “one palm out, one palm in” policy to ensure palm tree replacements
and maintenance of the IOP natural island environment? Will the City Council take on a proactive
approach island tree preservation, on behalf of the IOP residents?
Longer term, it would be great to understand the possibilities for putting the power lines underground for
grid preservation and tree preservation. There are several sections of IOP where the power lines are
underground already and making this an island wide standard would be ideal.
Thank you.
Sincerely,
Jim King
Meeting This Comment is Intended For:
City Council
Public Comment For City Meetings
Name
Mr Frank W Barnes
Address
Ocean point, Iop, South Carolina 29451
Comments for Council Meeting
Thank you for all of your hard during this difficult time .
I own three properties in wild dunes which I rent two of them through wild dunes rental management.
I am more concerned with keeping the residents safe and
healthy than I am about renting my homes.
Please continue to stay strong on your convictions regarding the safety of the people you have agreed to
look out for on isle of palms . We are counting are you to go slowly as we open the island and keep the
the curve flat . Remember the hospitals are prepared however we do not have a large hospital system
here which means we could get overwhelmed very quickly in Charleston. Keep safety first money second .
Without healthy what good is money
Data is important to understand.
Again many thanks
Stay well
Frank W Barnes
Meeting This Comment is Intended For:
City Council
Public Comment For City Meetings
Name
Ms. Monica Kubican
Address
1300 Ford Hampton Rd, Winchester, Kentucky 40391
Comments for Council Meeting
Why is there an exercise only restriction on the beach? People can sit together at a restaurant but not on
the beach? Hilton Head beaches are open with no beach restrictions.
Meeting This Comment is Intended For:
City Council
Public Comment For City Meetings
Name
Mr Paul J Stress
Address
9002 Palmetto Drive, Isle of Palms, South Carolina 29451
Comments for Council Meeting
Based on what I was hearing in your video meeting concerning beach access (i.e. primary concern social
distancing with keep moving as a means to enforce it), I would respectfully suggest modifying Ordinance
2020-03 to read: "Access to the beach will be for recreational activities consistent with social distancing.
Loitering and congregations of people greater than the governor's order are prohibited."
The above modification would save public safety resources by eliminating the need for police officers to
request responsible "socially distanced" people to keep moving. It would also lead to more consistent
enforcement. I think that this modification would also go a long way to reduce existing tensions within the
local communities and encourage vacationers to support IOP businesses again.
Meeting This Comment is Intended For:
City Council
Public Comment For City Meetings
Name
Brittany L
Address
1800 Indigo Market Drive, Mt Pleasant, South Carolina 29464
Comments for Council Meeting
Thank you for working to keep the public safe. Could you explain the logic behind the keep in moving
policy? What is the difference between a couple or family who lives together sitting on the beach versus
running on the beach?
Thank you.
Meeting This Comment is Intended For:
City Council
Public Comment For City Meetings
Name
Michael Ramsey
Address
7600 Palmetto Drive, 429D, Isle of Palms, South Carolina 29451
Comments for Council Meeting
I am a full time resident of Isle of Palms and the owner of a short term rental condo. I hope that the
purpose of the short term rental task force is to find the best way to get back to allowing renters to return
and not how do we keep them away as long as possible. Like it or not our community is based on tourism
and many peoples income including the town comes from short term rental activities. It is time to stop
hiding behind we have to keep our residence safe. People that want to stay sheltered in their homes are
more than welcome to but the rest of us are moving on with or lives the best we can. Whoever came up
with the "keep it moving" rule should be ashamed. It has nothing to do with safety because there is no way
you can justify that a person sitting in a chair or on a blanket alone or with people they live with is harmful
to them or anyone else on the beach. One of the safest places you can be is outside. I looks to me that the
town council does not like the fact that the beach should be open to everyone and is trying to make it as
unattractive as possible. If you want to enforce gatherings over 10 then that at least has some merit. We
just lost a week rental because the people cannot be sure that by the time they wanted to come they could
sit and enjoy the beach. Maybe that is what the city council was hoping for, but if this goes on we as
owners will have to look at legal options. We have already lost 2 months of income from our unit and it is
reaching a boiling point. Please revisit the "keep it moving" rule now!!
Meeting This Comment is Intended For:
City Council
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Oct 13, 2026.