Regular Meeting - February 3, 2020
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · meeting of Feb 3, 2020 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
City Council Meeting
6:00pm, Tuesday, February 25, 2020
Council Chambers
1207 Palm Boulevard, Isle of Palms, SC
MINUTES
1. Call to order
Present: Council Members Popson, Stre etman, Moye, Ward, Buckhannon, Bell,
Smith, Pounds, and Mayor Carroll
Staff Present: Administrator Fragoso, Asst . Administrator Hanna, Attorney Copeland,
various department heads
2. Reading of the Journals of the Previous Meetings
Council Member Buckahnnon made a motion to approve the minutes of the January 28, 2020
meeting, and Council Member Moye seconded the motion. The minutes passed unanimously.
3. Citizens’ Comments
Susan Stabine, 20 22nd Avenue, President of the Wild Dunes Swim Team, spoke in favor of a
community pool. She also shared the issues the swim team is having as a result of not having
their own pool in which to conduct swim meets.
Chris Crowley, owner of Coastal Expeditions, asked the Council to consider making the marina
dock more accessible for the public to enjoy the water in self-powered watercraft. He asked them
to consider “purpose and service instead of financial gain” when thinking about future plans for
the marina.
Krista Swindle, 2704 Cameron Boulevard, spoke in favor of an all-pedestrian crossing at the IOP
Connector and Palm Boulevard intersection.
MOTION: Council Member Ward made a motion to change the order of the agenda to
allow for the discussion of the Swimming Pool Citizen Advisory Board to occur prior to the
Reports from Standing Committees. Council Member Bell seconded the motion. The
motion passed unanimously.
4. Miscellaneous Business
Further discussion and possible action regarding the Swimming Pool Citizen Advisory
Board
City Council Minutes, 2/25/2020
2
Mayor Carroll asked Ways & Means Committee Chairman Pounds to highlight the large projects
City Council is considering in FY21. Council Member Pounds stated that City Council is
looking to include funding for Phase III of the drainage project as well as two projects at the
marina in the FY21 budget. Council Member Ward asked if a community pool is in the
Comprehensive Plan and if the Planning Commission has looked into it. Administrator Fragoso
said that a pool was previously in the 10-year capital plan, but it is not there at the moment.
Several Council members spoke to the need for a Strategic Plan. Council members Smith, Moye,
Streetman, and Buckhannon encouraged City Council to allow those citizens interested in being
on the Citizen Advisory Board to conduct the study to determine community interest in the pool.
Council Member Pounds said, “I think having the conversation is a great idea… We decided to
put about $7 million dollars’ worth of projects in our budget for Fiscal 21. This is probably not a
’21 issue anyway regardless of what we like tonight or not. But if we are going to kick off this
advisory committee, I think it is more about managing expectations than anything else. Yes, we
want the input. Yes, we need some due diligence done. Yes, we need to see if it is even feasible.”
He added the input may be put aside for a few years.
Mayor Carroll said that he placed this item on the agenda because “after our budgeting workshop
it became very apparent that we are reacting to everything instead of being proactive. We are
reacting to drainage. We are reacting to a marina that has been neglected. We are reacting to a
Public Safety Building that was poorly built. So we have got a lot of things on our platter, and
City Staff has got a lot on their platter, but at the same time when this was approached to us, it
was let us do a Citizens Advisory Board, no cost to the City. Let’s go forward with this. I am
good with that, but as long as there is not a realistic reason to think that we are going to react to it
or do something knowing that our financial house of cards right now isn’t that solid. We have to
take care of the things that we need to take care. Our needs versus our wants.”
5. Reports from Standing Committees
A. Ways and Means Committee
Council Member Pounds briefly reviewed the minutes of the February 12 Budget Workshop and
the February 18 Ways & Means Committee meeting.
i. A ward of a contract to Munnerlyn Pyrotechnics in the amount of $25,000 for
the July 4, 2020 fireworks show [FY20 Budget, State ATAX Fund, General Government,
Programs/Sponsorships - $85,000, p. 22, ln. 20]
MOTION: Council Member Streetman made a motion to approve, and Council Member
Pounds seconded the motion.
Council Member Smith said that while she enjoys the fireworks show, it creates a lot of trash
going into the ocean. She encouraged the Public Safety Committee to consider the environmental
impact of fireworks in the future and to see if the trash could be mitigated in some way. Council
Member Buckhannon said that may be more a concern of the Public Works Committee, adding
that staff cleans up the beach immediately following the show and a beach cleanup is always
scheduled for July 5.
City Council Minutes, 2/25/2020
3
VOTE: The motion passed unanimously.
ii. Approval of a five (5) year extension of the JLG Enterprise contract for
beach garbage and recycling collection services [FY20 budget, Muni ATAX, Front Beach
and Parking Management, Contracted Services - $11,800, p. 19, ln. 80 and State ATAX Front Beach
and Parking Management, Contracted Services - $150,000, p. 23, ln. 66]
MOTION: Council Member Buckhannon made a motion to approve, and Council
Member Ward seconded the motion.
Council Member Moye asked the City Administrator to speak to the consistent use of the
procurement process as it related to selecting this contract. Administrator Fragoso said, “The
only difference with this contract is when City Council approved the assignment to the new
owner, it had six years left in the current contract. So what the City did was authorize that with
the caveat that we would have a one-year trial period and upon successful termination or
completion of that trial period the City would honor the remainder of the contract that it had
originally approved as part of the assignment. Once this contract is completed after the five
years, we would be in a position to bid it out again.”
Council members Pounds and Streetman both reported receiving positive citizen feedback about
JLG Enterprise and the work they do.
VOTE: The motion passed unanimously.
iii. Approval of expenditure in the amount of $2,000 for the purchase of reusable
bags for tourism promotion and to encourage beach cleanup when visiting the beach
[FY20 Budget, State ATAX Fund, General Government, Programs/Sponsorships - $85,000, pg. 22,
ln. 20]
MOTION: Council Member Moye made a motion to approve and Council Member
Streetman seconded the motion.
Administrator Fragoso asked the motion be amended to $2,200 because bulk pricing would allow
the purchase of 1,250 bags for that amount. She believed that the City could secure business
sponsorships to pay for the next purchase of bags.
MOTION: Council Member Moye made a motion to amend the amount of the purchase to
be $2,200. Council Member Buckhannon seconded the motion. The motion passed
unanimously.
VOTE: A vote was taken on the motion as amended. The motion passed unanimously.
iv. Approval of expenditure in the amount of $4,000 for advertising new beach
rules in SIP magazine and Island Eye News paper
[FY20 Budget, State ATAX Fund,
General Government, Programs/Sponsorships - $85,000, pg. 22, ln. 20]
MOTION: Council Member Moy made a motion to approve, and Council Member Bell
seconded the motion.
Council Member Smith recused herself from the discussion and vote on this matter.
City Council Minutes, 2/25/2020
4
Administrator Fragoso said these funds will go to purchase one advertisement in SIP magazine
and 11 ads in the Island Eye News.
VOTE: The motion passed unanimously.
v. Award of a contract to Trident Construction in the amount of $5,256,159 for
the construction of the repairs to the Public Safety Building [FY20 Budget, Capital
Projects, Muni ATAX, State ATAX, Police and Fire Departments]
MOTION: Council Member Buckhannon made a motion to approve, and Council
Member Bell seconded the motion.
Administrator Fragoso said, “This is the third phase of the contract. As you all know, City
Council went through a competitive bid process to engage the services of a design build team.
City hired Trident Construction and Coast Architects. They conducted an investigative report,
and then presented sort of the needs of the building. What needs to be repaired. What needs to be
removed. What could stay. That report became part of what Council approved as the project
budget. We were looking at $6.2 million. That number includes a 10% contractor’s contingency
and a 15% contingency to the City. After working on the design and drawings and engineering,
conducting some specific tests, they came back to us with some refined numbers of the actual
work. And those numbers came back a little bit different. During the Ways & Means meeting it
was presented to Council a couple of options of how to stay within budget, and Council made the
decision to, I guess, move forward with a simplified entrance design that would put the project at
roughly $620 under budget. And then the decision was made that the contractor is going to notify
the City as to when we would need to make a final decision on the design for the building, and
we would look at our contingency funds and make a decision at that point. So you all are
approving the total budget for the project, knowing that on top of that we are a building in a 15%
contingency that the City is carrying. That 5.2 number includes a 10% contractor’s contingency
that we will get if it is not used.”
Council Member Popson expressed concern that the four hours per week allotted to Insight as the
owner’s representative will not be enough time. Council members Popson, Bell, and Ward said
their oversight is crucial to the long-term success of the project. Administrator Fragoso said the
four hours was used as a benchmark by which to compare bids, but there is money in the budget
for increased hours as needed.
VOTE: The motion passed unanimously.
vi. Approval of renew of agreement with The Palms Hotel for use of the
municipal parking lot and include provisions for automatic renewal and to adjust rates as
determined by Council
MOTION: Council Member Ward made a motion to approve, and Council Member Bell
seconded the motion. The motion passed unanimously.
vii. Approval of an amount not to exceed $15,000 for the installation of a
pervious patio area behind the public restrooms on Front Beach
[FY20 Budget,
Hospitality Tax Fund, Public Works, Maintenance & Service Contracts - $193,800, pg. 20, ln. 32]
City Council Minutes, 2/25/2020
5
MOTION: Council Member Buckhannon made a motion to approve, and Council
Member Ward seconded the motion.
Council Member Buckhannon noted there is more to this beautification project than the new
patio, adding that chairs and tables will be added to the space. Administrator Fragoso said front
beach businesses will be informed of the plans when they have been finalized.
VOTE: The motion passed unanimously.
The next regular meeting of the Ways & Means Committee will be Tuesday, March 17, 2020 at
5:00pm,
B. Public Safety Committee
Council Member Buckhannon reviewed the minutes of the February 3, 2020 Committee meeting.
i. Consideration of establishing an all-pedestrian crossing at the IOP
Connector and Palm Boulevard intersection
Council Member Buckhannon said he did not think Council members have had time to research
the concern about the all-pedestrian crossing as of this meeting. Administrator Fragoso said that
SCDOT needs a letter from City Council “authorizing us to move forward. So we did not feel
like that was a call that the Chief and I could make, and they requested a letter and action from
Council. So we brought it up to Public Safety and ultimately, it will be up to Council to make
that decision.”
Mayor Carroll made a motion to write a letter to SCDOT asking for a study. Council Member
Buckhannon encouraged Council members to sit at the intersection to understand what a 41-
second traffic delay would feel like. Mayor Carroll withdrew his motion until Council members
have had a chance to further study the issue.
Council Member Moye wondered if there are other solutions SCDOT could provide, and Chief
Cornett reported this was their solution. He expressed concern that even with a 41-second stop in
all directions, there would still be a green right-turn allowed coming off the Connector. He will
look into the possibility of additional signage but believes it may be lost in all the other signage
in the area. He reported that crosswalk rules and safety was going to be addressed in a series of
videos the Public Safety department would be making for social media. Council members
briefly discussed this proposal as being part of the larger traffic issues to be addressed in hopes
of making the community at large safer.
ii. Consideration of exemption from the noise ordinance during the Veterans
and First Responder Blessing Ceremony on November 7, 2020
Administrator Fragoso said the salute will consist of three officers shooting seven blanks each.
MOTION: Council Member Ward made a motion to approve, and Council Member Bell
seconded the motion. The motion passed unanimously.
The next meeting of the Public Safety Committee will be Monday, March 2, 2020 at 9am.
City Council Minutes, 2/25/2020
6
C. Public Works Committee
Council Member Pounds reviewed the minutes of the February 6, 2020 meeting.
The next meeting o
f the Public Works Committee will be Thursday, March 5, 2020 at 8am.
D. Recreation Committee
Council Member Smith reviewed the minutes of the February 10, 2020 Recreation Committee
meeting. She reminded the public that the last day to apply to be on the Swimming Pool Citizens
Advisory Board is Friday, February 28, 2020.
Council Member Sweetman noted an error in the approval of the Recreation Committee meeting
minutes.
The next meeting of the Recreation Committee will be on Monday, March 2, 2020 at 5pm.
E. Personnel Committee
Council Member Moye reviewed the minutes of the February 12, 2020 Personnel Committee
meeting.
The next meeting of the Personnel Committee will be on Tuesday, March 3, 2020 at 9am.
F. Real Property Committee
Council Member Buckhannon reviewed the minutes of the February 13, 2020 Real Property
Committee meeting. Administrator Fragoso reported that a contractor has been hired to grind
down some of tripping hazards to make it safer on Waterway Boulevard while continuing to
pursue County funding to rework the entire path.
The next meeting of the Real Property Committee will be on Wednesday, March 4 at 5pm.
5. Reports from City Officers, Boards, and Commissions
A. Accommodations Tax Advisory Committee
B. Board of Zoning Appeals
C. Planning Commission
6. Reports from Special or Joint Committees – none
7. Petitions Received, Referred or Disposed of – none
8. Bills Already in Possession of Council – none
9. Introduction of New Bills, Resolutions, Proclamations
A. First Reading by Title Only of Ordinance 2020-01 – An ordinance that makes it
unlawful to flee from a public safety officer under certain conditions
MOTION: Council Member Ward made a motion to approve, and Council Member
Popson seconded the motion. The motion passed unanimously.
City Council Minutes, 2/25/2020
7
B. Resolution 2020-01 – A resolution authorizing the consumption of beer and wine only at
the Front Beach Fest on March 7, 2020
MOTION: Council Member Moye made a motion to approve, and Council Member Streetman
seconded the motion. The motion passed unanimously.
10. Miscellaneo
us Business
The next meeting of the City Council will be on Tuesday, March 24, 2020 at 6:00pm.
11. Executive Session
MOTION: Council Member Bell made a motion to move into Executive Session in accordance
with §30-4-70(a)(2) to discuss negotiations incident to proposed contractual arrangements related
to the marina restaurant lease. Council Member Pounds seconded the motion. The motion
passed unanimously.
Council members entered Executive Session at 7:36pm. City Council returned from Executive
Session at 8:06pm. Mayor Carroll reported no decisions were made.
MOTION: Council Member Ward made a motion to extend exclusive negotiations with
the IOP Families for thirty (30) days effective March 10, 2020. Council Member Bell
seconded the motion. The motion passed unanimously.
12. Adjournment
Council Member Buckhannon made a motion to adjourn, and Council Member Moye seconded
the motion. The meeting was adjourned at 8:07pm.
Respectfully submitted,
Nicole DeNeane
City Clerk
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Oct 13, 2026.