November 6, 2017
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · meeting of Nov 6, 2017 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
REAL PROPERTY COMMITTEE
9:30 a.m., Monday, November 6, 2017
The regular meeting of the Real Property Committee was held at 9:30 a.m., Monday, November
6, 2017 in the City Hall Conference Room, 1207 Palm Boulevard, Isle of Palms, South Carolina.
Attending the meeting were Councilmember Rice, Mayor ProTem Harrington, Chair Bergw erf,
Administrator Tucker, Assistant Administrator Fragoso and City Clerk Copeland; a quorum was
present to conduct business.
1. Chair Bergwerf called the meeting to order and acknowledged that the press and public
were duly notified of the meeting in accordance with the Freedom of Information Act.
2. Approval of Previous Meeting’s Minutes
MOTION: Mayor ProTem Harrington moved to approve the minutes of the
regular meeting of October 9, 2017 as submitted; Councilmember Rice seconded
and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
3. Citizens’ Comments
Presentation about dredging Hamlin Creek at Breach Inlet – Steve Halleck
Steve Halleck of 104 Palm Boulevard attended the meeting as a representative of a group of
homeowners and business owners on the south end of the island, from the Boathouse toward the
Exchange Club, with property on Hamlin Creek. He stated that, over the past few years, a mud
bank has been building up underneath their docks , and it is now interfering with navigation; he
added that, at low tide, the docks are resting on the mud. This common problem brought the
residents together to investigate dredging the creek, and, since a public boat ramp is there that is
inaccessible at low tide, the group thought that the City might be interested in a dredging project
as well. His expressed purpose in attending today was to learn if the City had any interest in
participating and if the City would support acquiring a permit for a project “in the public purpose”
that would assist in the permitting process and allow for a closer spoil site, thereby, reducing the
cost. He stated that the group has had conversations with Marcol Dredging about the permitting
process, but they currently have no timeframe and no estimate of the cost.
Administrator Tucker reported that the City has had experience with similar projects, and she
recalled a partnership for dredging of Morgan Cove; she explained that , in such situations, a
group, homeowners association, etc. enters into an agreement with the City stating that the City
will be the permittee and incur no expenses related to the project; the expense for the project
would fall to the other party. She commented that the group of residents involved might have to
form some type of association to enter i nto an agreement. The group gets the public purpose
making the project less expensive but the City incurs no expense and gets its area dredged as
well.
When Mr. Halleck asked for the Committee’s perspective on his proposal, Councilmember Rice
responded that the group should form some type of association and engage an attorney to draw
up an agreement with the City stating that the City would be the permittee and the property owners
would pay all of the costs for dredging that would include the City’s boat ramp.
The Administrator told Mr. Halleck she would send him a copy of Morgan Cove’s agreement.
Real Property Committee
November 6, 2017
Page 2 of 6
Chris Crolley of Coastal Expeditions stated that his comments would add very little substance to
his comments at the October meeting; he said that, driving home from the October Council
meeting, he recalled his time working with the federal government and his experienc e having a
business at the marina. He commented that the government’s expenses today w ould much be
less today if they had not gotten fifteen (15) years behind in the maintenance responsibilities; his
conclusion was to be careful what one buys because the maintenance is an ongoing expense
over time. He looked at the marina from that viewpoi nt and stated that the marina needs
maintenance; he stated that, as a business owner, he has established an escrow account where
he deposits money regularly knowing that, at the end of five (5) years, it will be spent and he will
have to start all over again.
4. Comments from Marina Tenants
Per the terms of the Marina Outpost lease, Marina Manager Brian Berrigan informed the
Committee that he plans to close the store the day after Martin Luther King Day, January 16th, for
a period of three (3) days when he will replace air conditioners, replace the siding on the store
and do some things in the attic, like add insulation.
5. Old Business
A. Results of RFB 2017 -04 Rebid for Front Beach Restrooms and Boardwalk
Renovations
Administrator Tucker reported that the City received two (2) bids for this project , i.e. a bid from
IPW Construction and a bid from Phillip Smith, General Contractor; the bid tabulation was
included in the meeting packet. She was confident that the Committee coul d take an action on
the project at this meeting.
Director Kerr stated that the IPW bid was for five hundred thirteen thousand dollars ($513,000)
and the Phillip Smith bid was for four hundred eighty -nine thousand dollars ($489,000); the bids
were within budget. He reported that he and Mr. Smith were working on the bid amount for the
public restroom renovation because, as presented, the bid amount exceeds the value of the fifty
percent (50%) rule for the restrooms although by only a small amount. He has spoken with Mr.
Smith relative to ways to get the cost under the fifty percent (50%) value; he explained that certain
items would not count toward the fifty percent (50%) rule, such as demolition, administrative costs
and lay-down and mobilization costs. In a meeting with Mr . Smith in a few days, the Director is
confident that he and Mr. Smith will arrive at an acceptable figure; therefore, staff’s recommend-
dation is to proceed with the entire project with the low bidder Phillip Smith, GC, LLC.
MOTION: Mayor ProTem Harringt on moved to recommend to the Ways and
Means Committee the award of a contract to Phillip Smith, GC, LLC, the low bidder,
in the amount of $489,622 for the public restroom renovation and boar dwalk
contingent upon t he restroom renovations cost not exceed ing the 50% rule;
Councilmember Rice seconded.
Director Kerr stated that currently the costs exceed the fifty percent (50%) rule by thirty thousand
dollars ($30,000).
Real Property Committee
November 6, 2017
Page 3 of 6
Councilmember Rice asked when Mr. Smith planned to start the project in order to complete it for
the start of the 2018 tourist season.
The Director said that he did not know when Mr. Smith would start, but a completion date was
specified in the RFB. When the Councilmember asked about the permit for the boardwalk, the
Director replied that the City has had a permit for a couple of years and, since it is good for five
(5) years, time remains on it.
VOTE: The motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
B. Update on Beach Renourishment Project
Administrator Tucker announced that the emergency berm project has been completed, and the
plan is to start the project on the north end at the end of December or beginning of January. The
project is to be complete before the start o f turtle nesting seaso n, and the Administrator noted
that the project will moved quickly once it is started.
C. Update on underground storage tank replacements RFB
The Administrator told that Committee that getting the RFB ready for advertising has taken much
longer than staff contemplated; she stated that getting the bid document into shape to advertise
has been a struggle. Today it is eight to eight-five percent (80-85%) ready.
D. Consideration of an amendment to ATM contract
The Administrator noted that the Committee received a proposal from ATM in the meeting packet
for the engineering associated with the preparation of construction documents, plans and
permitting for the upland areas of the IOP Marina – the logical next step in the Marina Enhance-
ment and Community Red evelopment Project. ATM has recommended that the landside
improvements be made before those on the waterside. Since she received the proposal late on
Friday, she has unanswered questions, but she voiced hope that the Committee would take action
on it as long as all questions and/ or concerns were answered in time for the Ways and Means
Committee meeting on November 28th.
At this point, Kirby Marshall, Joe Mina, Site Civil Engineer for ATM, and Aaron Temple of Epic
Engineering, who has been a member of the assessment team, joined the discussion.
Administrator Tucker stated that one (1) of her concerns was that this proposal might contain
items that were in a previous proposal, so a reconcil iation is necessary to determine that. Her
second issue was that the total engineering cost for the project per ATM’s calculations was four
hundred twenty-two thousand seven hundred twenty-three dollars ($422,723), and then, looking
at this proposal, the engineering costs are not proportionate between the landside and the
waterside.
Mr. Marshall stated that currently the computations have been done and ATM is ninety percent
(90%) certain that all of the components will fit on the site; this proposal deals with the actual
Real Property Committee
November 6, 2017
Page 4 of 6
engineering and design of systems, i.e. grading and the specific elevations for specific instructions
for the site work contractor, utilities in terms of a totally new distribution system with piping, levels
of piping and slopes, calculations of volumes, sewer and the demolition of the existing pump
station, etc. This work will create a set of construction level documents that will allow a contractor
to bid on the project and give the City a reliable number to go to construction. Exclusions are the
traffic and wayfinding signs, no iconic entrance sign, all improvements to the waterside, the
restrooms and the stand-up paddleboard building, the parking meter system and associated IT,
marina permitting and permitting fees, and construction oversight, which the Administrator stated
should be added back.
The Administrator asked Mr. Kirby to get with Director Kerr to find out whether the City Code will
require the City to hire a firm to perform special inspections on this project, like the vehicle wash-
down project.
Mr. Temple commented that special inspections will be needed for the fuel dispensing.
Councilmember Rice asked what the permit costs were for the upland improvements.
Mr. Mina explained that Task 1 is the design of the plans for the permit, the documents, the
backup, and the calculations; Task 3 is completing the paperwork, conversations with the
agencies for the process itself. He noted that the cost is a time and materials cost with a not-to-
exceed number. He also stated that the design plans from Task 1 will be the permit plans as well.
Councilmember Rice then asked if there was a way for the biddable plans to be the construction
plans, and Mr. Marshall answered that, in this case, he understood that the City wanted to bid this
out relatively soon which will require ATM to do a “tremendous” amount of work in a short period
of time to come up with plans that will enable contractors to come back with a reliable bid to the
City. Due to the short timeframe, it is anticipated that contractors and/or permitting agencies may
have comments about the plans that would require modifications, corrections or adjustments to
the plans. Based on the timeframe in this case, ATM will come up with set of bid documents to
enable contractors to co me up with a price for the City, but things come out during the bidding
process that initiate addenda or perhaps plan revisions to further help the contractor to provide a
number. For this project, ATM thinks the process will continue post the awar d of a construction
contract; issues could arise in the permitting process that would require modifications before the
finalization of the plans resulting in a second round of construction plans.
Administrator Tucker explained that the assignment to ATM was that, if the City wanted to have
the land-side improvements under construction expeditiously, what would ATM charge to amend
their contract to assist in doing that. Bidding would likely be done with permits applied for but
pending.
Chair Bergwerf pointed out that the year was nearly over and that this work could not be done in
the boating season.
Councilmember Rice asked how long the construction would take; Mr. Marshall responded that,
if the work could begin by the first of the year, the improvements could be completed before
Memorial Day. He added that the project would be done in phases to avoid shutting down the
Real Property Committee
November 6, 2017
Page 5 of 6
entire site; the goal would be to accomplish the work over the winter months and to be open prior
the Memorial Day weekend.
On the electrical infrastructure, Administrator Tucker commented that it had developed over time
and that, as a result, the desired level of shore power could not be taken to the Intracoastal
Waterway side of the marina because of what is underground there now. She told Mr. Marshall
that the City wants to have full service for the entire site.
Mr. Temple assured the Administrator that the situation would be rectified.
When Chair Bergwerf expressed concern about the amount included in the FY18 budget, the
Administrator replied that, if the contract were to be awarded in the amount quoted, which likely
will go up or down based on discussions at this meeting, the budget is sixty thousand dol lars
($60,000) short of the needed amount.
MOTION: Councilmember Rice moved to recommend to Ways and Means the
award of the contract to ATM to proceed with the next phase of work for the purpose
of moving forward with the landside improvements; Mayor Pr oTem Harrington
seconded.
Referring to the sixty thousand dollar ($60,000) number, Administrator Tucker explained that staff
took the contracts to-date that the City is paying and what was paid in the past out of the budgeted
amount, then applied this con tract that is short because it does not include cons truction
administration and that some of the time and materials task s may be less than projected; the
result of the calculation is that the budgeted amount is sixty thousand dollars ($60,000) short to
be able to fund it from the FY18 budget. She stated that the total amount budgeted for design
and permitting of the upland portion of the Marina Enhancement Project in the FY18 budget was
two hundred thirty-two thousand seven hundred fifteen dollars ($232,715).
VOTE: The motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
E. Update on new beach access paths signage
Assistant Fragoso reported that the City has paid the deposit to the contractor for the new signs;
they will be placed on the beach access paths at 5 th, 8th, 9th, 21st, 25th, 28th and 42nd Avenues, at
the Sea Cabins and at the public restrooms. The designer also worked on the City’s wayfinding
signs, so he is fully knowledgeable of the color pallet and style. Once the design is approved, the
manufacture should take four to five (4 -5) weeks. The sign material will be durable , capable of
withstanding the salt air environment and require little in the way of upkeep.
Councilmember Rice recalled that these new signs will consolidate several signs into one (1) sign.
Administrator Tucker announced that the City has found someone who will repaint the existing
wayfinding signs since some are quite faded.
6. New Business – None
Real Property Committee
November 6, 2017
Page 6 of 6
7. Miscellaneous Business
Tenant Rents Report – Administrator Tucker stated that she would provide the
information at the Ways and Means Committee meeting.
Next Meeting Date: 9:30 a.m., Tuesday, January 9, 2018 in the Conference Room
8. Executive Session – not needed
9. Adjournment
MOTION: Mayor ProTem Harrington moved to adjourn the meeting at 10:28
a.m.; Councilmember Harrington seconded and the motion PASSED
UNANIMOUSLY.
Respectfully submitted:
Marie Copeland
City Clerk
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Oct 13, 2026.