October 24, 2017
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · meeting of Oct 24, 2017 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
WAYS and MEANS COMMITTEE
Tuesday, October 24, 2017
The regular meeting of the Ways and Means Committee was called to order at 5:00 p.m.,
Tuesday, October 24, 2017 in Council Chambers of City Hall, 1207 Palm Boulevard, Isle of Palms,
South Carolina. Attending the meeting were Councilmembers Bergwerf, Bettelli, Carroll, Ferencz,
Kinghorn, Rice and Ward, Mayor ProT em Harrington, Mayor Cronin, Administrator Tucker,
Assistant Administrator Fragoso and City Clerk Copeland; a quorum was present to conduct
business.
1. Mayor Cronin called the meeting to order and acknowledged that the press and public had
been duly notified of the meeting in accordance with the Freedom of Information Act.
2. Approval of Previous Meeting’s Minutes
MOTION: Councilmember Carroll moved to approve the minutes of the regular
meeting of September 19, 2017 as submitted; Councilmember Bergwerf seconded
and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
3. Citizens’ Comments
Arnold Karig, 5102 Palm Boulevard, stated that, in recent wee ks, he has heard residents talking
about the marina, stormwater and sewers; he said that he also has heard compliments about
Public Works that picks up the garbage on time and keeps the beach clean. He expressed the
opinion that Director Pitts does “a fab ulous job,” but, since Council will begin budget talks soon,
he asked that consideration be given to increasing the staff in the Public Works Department
because he has also heard complaints that the beach access paths are not being kept up.
4. Financial Statements – Treasurer Debbie Suggs
In an update on the conversion to the new financial software, the Treasurer reported that a BS&A
representative is in City offices this week training a large number of employees who have not yet
been involved, but, will be entering requisitions, purchase orders and invoices. Certain procedural
changes will occur with the new software that will give more control to the department heads while
keeping a good separation of duties. Cash receipts training will take place later in the week, and
the new software will go live on Monday, October 30 th. She indicated that she expects the next
couple of months to be somewhat chaotic, and, although she anticipates many more options in
financial reporting, she does not know how November’s financial statements will look. Treasurer
Suggs said that BS&A representatives will be on -site for the next two (2) weeks to assist in the
transition.
Responding to Councilmember Ward, the Treasurer said that the changeover “has not been as
painful as [she] thought it would be” because BS&A has done a lot of work on the front -end with
converting the data. Although staff will not have the detail that it now has in descriptions, ten (10)
years’ data will be available in the new system. They appear confident that the conversion will
continue smoothly and successfully.
Treasurer Suggs explained that data will be stored on the City’s server since the new system is
not cloud-based and that automatic backups will take place every night.
Ways and Means Committee
October 24, 2017
Page 2 of 6
A. Financial Statements
From the financial data through September 30, the City is one-fourth (¼) of the way through FY18;
therefore the target for revenue and expenditures is twenty -five percent (25%). Typically, at this
time of year, revenues are low, and General Fund Revenues are eleven percent (11%) of budget
or eighty-eight percent (88%) of last year for the same period. Building Department revenues are
short about twenty-thousand dollars ($20,000) due to a timing difference on a late deposit; another
big swing in revenue is attributed to a one-time FEMA grant received last September for the flood
situation of 2015. General Fund Expenditures for all departments are at twenty -three percent
(23%) of budget; all departments are at or below budget with the exception of Public Works, which
is likely due to storm -related work. General Fund cash on -hand is at two point seven million
dollars ($2,700,000); the majority of those funds are in the LGIP receiving one point zero eight
percent (1.08%) interest. Total cash is at twenty-two point four million dollars ($22,400,000) that
includes four point eight million dollars ($4,800,000) of stakeholder funds for the beach restoration
project.
At the request of a Councilmember, Treasurer Suggs expanded the tourism graphs back to 2005
for this meeting.
B. Tourism Schedules
Treasurer Suggs reported that the City has not received State ATAX funds or funds from the
Charleston County Pass -through in this fiscal year. Hospitality Taxes received were fifty -one
thousand eight hundred dollars ($51,800), which is low, but it related to the timing issue with a
deposit of twenty-nine thousand dollars ($29,000). With that deposit added in, September was a
good month for Hosp itality Taxes with collections of approximately eighty -one thousand dollars
($81,000) from thirty-one (31) taxpayers. The Beach Preservation Fee mirrors Municipal ATAX
showing an increase of three percent (3%) over the same period in FY17.
C. Projects Worksheets
The Vehicle Wash-down Project continues to proceed slowly; recent expenditures included two
(2) pay applications to Hitt Construction and a special inspection; also listed are two (2) invoices
from Thomas & Hutton for engineering oversight tha t have not been paid. For this project, the
City has expended six hundred four thousand dollars ($604,000) of a seven hundred seventy
thousand dollar ($770,000) budget; fifty-one thousand dollars ($51,000) remains in the project ’s
contingency.
Expenditures from the Beach Restoration Project were to Coastal Science and Engineering and
for legal fees.
Mayor Cronin was pleased to announce that the City received the grant from SC Parks Recreation
and Tourism for the beach renourishment project of approxi mately two point nine million dollars
($2,900,000) in advance of the project; the Mayor commented that the receipt of the check not
only confirms their participation in the project, but will also help with cash flow as the project
begins.
Ways and Means Committee
October 24, 2017
Page 3 of 6
Small expenses for engineering and design were paid to Civil Site Environmental (CSE) on the
Phase II Drainage Project. Since the bids for the project came i n considerably higher than
anticipated, the City will use the June 30, 2017 reserve balance in General Drainage and Roads
and has received an additional grant from Charleston County TST funds to partially cover the
shortfall in the project funding . The re maining short fall is considerably less than the available
contingency on the project.
Based on community discourse about the City’s debt limit as it relates to the five and a half million
dollar ($5,500,000) marina revitalization, Treasurer Suggs has p repared a schedule that shows
how the City’s debt limit is calculated according to state statutes and the City’s current debt. (A
copy is attached to the historical record of the meeting.) At the end of FY17, the City’s debt limit
exceeded fifteen million nine hundred thousand dollars ($15,900,000) with current debt principal
of approximately eight million one hundred thousand dollars ($8,100,000). Based on this
schedule, borrowing the funds for the marina revitalization would not cause the City to exceed its
state mandated debt limit.
Administrator Tucker noted that this information is included in the “Questions and Answers”
section of the marina revitalization portion of the City’s website.
D. Report on Status of ATM contracts and expenses related to Marina Plan
Treasurer Suggs reported that, going back to 2015 when the relationship with ATM began,
Council has approved payments to them of one hundred seventy-six thousand dollars ($176,000);
additionally, the City spent twelve thousand seven hundred forty-four dollars ($12,744) for the
mailings and postage and visual aids and models for the two (2) community meetings.
After learning that Treasurer Suggs has been with the City since 1996, Councilmember Kinghorn
asked her whether she has seen the City ’s financial position improve or worsen over the past
eight (8) years, and she answered that it has improved. Assuming that the City continues to
manage its finances as it has, he then asked her if she could see any reason why improvement
would not contin ue. The Treasurer responded that a natural disaster would cause a “blip,” but
she thought the City would recover quickly. Councilmember Kinghorn then inquired that, barring
such a circumstance, did the Treasurer see any reason why the City’s financial position would not
continue to improve, to which she said that she did not.
5. Old Business – None
6. New Business
A. Consideration of an award of a sole source contract to Civil Site
Environmental (CSE) in the amount of $13,200 for an evaluation of drainage
issues at 32 Thirty -second Avenue (One qualified source documentation
attached.)
MOTION: Mayor Cronin moved to award a sole source contract to CSE as
detailed above; Councilmember Kinghorn seconded.
Ways and Means Committee
October 24, 2017
Page 4 of 6
Mayor Cronin commented that this proposal and the underlying issues associated with it
generated lengthy discussion at the Public Works Committee meeting; until the City has an
engineering evaluation, it cannot move forward.
Councilmember Bergwerf asked if this evaluation was for one (1) property or for the entire block.
Administrator Tucker referred Council to the areas marked on the maps included in the meeting
packet. She stated that this ditch runs on the side of one (1) property, then behind several
properties toward the outfall via Waterway Boulevard to the backside of the island. The evaluation
will look at the water that is coming from elsewhere into the ditch as well as look at the tidal aspect.
The property owner has reported that, when the ditch is serviced and when the island receives
heavy rains, the ditch is eroding and resulting in loss of his yard; he came before the Committee
to get the City’ s approval to allow his landscaper to pipe the ditch. His proposal lacked any
engineering evaluation as to what impact his actions would have on the watershed in that area.
She said that the CSE proposal was not for one (1) property but an attempt to le arn what could
be done to improve the situation in that area.
Councilmember Ferencz added that the City requires an engineering evaluation before any
changes are made to the island’s drainage system.
Administrator Tucker explained that, in the case of an SCDOT ditch, a property owner deals
directly with SCDOT, not the City; if SCDOT agrees with the technical aspect to pipe a ditch, it
might proceed. The City is only responsible for seeing that all of SCDOT’s requirements are met.
VOTE: The motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
B. Consideration of an amendment to the Thomas & Hutton contract for con -
struction oversight on the NPDES vehicle wash facility in an amount not to
exceed $10,000
Mayor Cronin commented that funds would come from the Drainage Contingency Fund that has
a current balance of fifty-one thousand dollars ($51,000).
MOTION: Mayor Cronin moved to approve an amendment to the Thomas &
Hutton contract in an amount not to exceed $10,000; Councilmember Ferencz
seconded.
Mayor Cronin explained that, since this project has taken much more time than expected, Thomas
and Hutton have incurred much engineering oversight than projected.
VOTE: The motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
C. Consideration of amending the Eadie’s contract to increase the frequency of
ditch maintenance
The Mayor noted that this subject has been the object of much discussion since the flooding from
Hurricane Irma.
Ways and Means Committee
October 24, 2017
Page 5 of 6
Administrator Tucker recounted that the City has a five-year (5 yr.) drainage maintenance contract
with Eadie’ s Construction, and the City ’s relationship with Eadie’s extends back ten to fifteen
years (10-15 yrs.); the City is currently in the third year of the existing five-year (5 yr.) contract. In
this contract, Eadie’s cleans and restructures the island’s ditches and cleans out some pipes, but
it has become increasingly apparent that the frequency of that work is inadequate for the amount
of water the ditches and pipes carry, plus the vegetation grows back very quickly. Another factor
is the demand from citizens that the ditches be kept clean and free -flowing. Based on
recommendation from the Public Works Committee, staff asked Eadie’s for a proposal for cleaning
the island’s ditches more frequently; also addressed in the proposal are the addition of cleaning
the drainage system from 53 rd to 57th Avenues (Phase I Drainage Project) as well as the cost of
hauling the debris collected off the island and taking it to a proper disposal site since they can no
longer discharge the water collected through Carmen R . Bunch Park; t he increase proposed is
unbudgeted for the current fiscal year and would be budgeted for FY19 and FY20.
Councilmember Ferencz stated that the total five -year (5 yr.) contract cost will inc rease from
approximtely four hundred thirty-eight thousand two hundred dollars ($438,200) to seven hundred
fifty-one thousand four hundred fourteen dollars ($751,414), but she emphasized that amending
the Eadie’s contract for more frequent ditch cleaning i s something that can be done for the
residents now while the Planning Commission is studying the drainage on the entire island.
MOTION: Councilmember Ferencz moved to amend the 5 -year drainage main-
tenance contract with Eadie’s Construction by increasing Year 3 (FY18) from
$88,150 to $198,288, by increasing Year 4 from $80,100 to $187,038 and Year 5 from
$88,400 to $184, 538; Mayor Cronin seconded.
Councilmember Rice asked if the amended contract would i nclude the area in the Phase II
Drainage Project.
According to the Administrator, those ditches should not need maintenance until Year 4, and the
City would enter into a new contract. She also assured Councilmember Rice that Eadie’s has
sufficient manpower and equipment to do the job as stated in the amendment.
Councilmember Bettelli asked specifically what the City would be getting fo r the increase in the
contract, and Administrator Tucker replied that the ditches on the island would be cleaned three
(3) times a year rather than once a year – as they are now, add the ditches between 53rd and 57th
Avenues and pay to haul and dispose of the debris collected off the island.
Responding to Councilmember Kinghorn’s concern, Administrator Tucker stated that Eadie’s has
recommended that the ditches be cleaned in March, July and October each year. And, when he
asked the source of funding for FY18, the Administrator stated that staff’s recommendation was
for the additio nal contract cost be an unbudgeted expenditure from the Capital Projects fund
balance that is projected to be one million point one million dollars ($1,100,000) at June 30, 2018.
Councilmember Kinghorn asked whether the City could be reimbursed from FEMA for Eadie’s
work in preparation for Hurricane Irma.
Ways and Means Committee
October 24, 2017
Page 6 of 6
Mayor Cronin stated that grants are available for hazard mitigation whereby the local government
reduces the likelihood of subsequent damage; these grants are a fifty-fifty match.
Councilmember Kinghorn saw these grants as a two -fold opportunity for the City; the first being
for the work done prior to Irma and the second being for preparations for future storms.
In the Mayor’s opinion, a large part of preparation was planning, noting that large parts of the
island have no drainage infrastructure and to install the needed infrastructure is a very costly
project, and he pointed to the project underway for 45th to 52nd Avenues.
VOTE: The motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
D. Consideration of a retroactive engagement of McCay, Kiddy & Associates,
LLC in the amount of $23,000 for the audit for the year ending June 30, 2017
and approval of engagement through FY19
When staff looked back at the minutes when the award was made, it was found that the motion
covered only one (1) year although the proposal quoted four (4) years; this action is a matter of
housekeeping since the audit for June 30, 2017 has just been completed and prepares for the
FY18 and FY19 audits. The numbers quoted for FY18 and FY19 are twenty-three thousand six
hundred dollars ($23,600) and twenty -six thousand two hundred fifty dollars ($26,250),
respectively; they also provided numbers for a single audit that would be necessary if the City
exceeds a certain amount of federal funds.
MOTION: Councilmember Ward moved to approve the engagement as stated;
Councilmember Bettelli seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
7. Miscellaneous Business – None
Next Meeting Date: 5:00 p.m., November 28, 2017 in Council Chambers
8. Executive Session – not needed
9. Adjournment
MOTION: Mayor ProTem Harrington moved to adjourn the meeting at 5:43 p.m.;
Councilmember Bergwerf seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Respectfully submitted:
Marie Copeland
City Clerk
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Oct 13, 2026.