October 11, 2017
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · meeting of Oct 11, 2017 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
MINUTES OF THE ISLE OF PALMS
PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING
October 11, 2017
The Isle of Palms Planning Commission met in the City Hall conference room, 1207
Palm Boulevard on October 11, 2017 at 4:30 p.m. Members attending included Ron
Denton, Vince DiGangi, Richard Ferencz, Lewis Gregory, Bill Mills and Lisa Safford; the
Director of Planning Douglas Kerr was present as well. The press had been notified of
the meeting and the agenda for the meeting was posted in City Hall and the Building
Department to comply with the Freedom of Information Act.
PUBLIC COMMENTS
Ms. Donna Hart, #17- 20th Avenue, asked what the criteria was to have a flapper valve
installed on a drainage outfall. Mr. Kerr answered that there is no criteria per se, but the
ones that have been installed on the island were specified by the civil engineers working
on the particular project. He explained that he believed the one installed near Breech
Inlet was done by SCDOT when they made drainage modifications for the construction
of the new bridge. He stated that there was no set conditions when flappers were
installed, but he was aware that they require a lot of maintenance because growth can
cause them to malfunction.
APPROVAL OF MINUTES
With no more public comments, Mr. Ferencz explained that the next item on the agenda
was the approval of the September 20th, 2017 minutes. Mr. Gregory stated that his
name showed up as “Mr. Lewis” instead of “Mr. Gregory.” Mr. Denton made a motion to
approve the minutes with the proposed amendments and Mr. Ferencz seconded the
motion. The vote was unanimous in favor of the motion.
DISCUSSION OF FUTURE HOTEL WITH WILD DUNES
Mr. Kerr explained that Mr. DiGangi had requested that this item be put on the agenda
and the Wild Dunes staff was present to discuss the future development of a hotel. Mr.
Gregory asked what role the Planning Commission would have with the project. Mr.
Kerr answered that the Planning Commission would not be involved with the approval of
the hotel, but as he understood what was being requested, the Commission would look
at the impact of traffic outside of the Wild Dunes gate to determine if some changes
needed to be made outside of Wild Dunes. He explained that the original Wild Dunes
planned development agreements gave the resort the right to develop a certain number
of hotel rooms and this development would be allowed under that agreement.
Mr. Dan Battista with Wild Dunes introduced the design team and asked that the resort
manager, Frank Fredericks, walk the Commission through the concept of the
Planning Commission minutes
October 11, 2017
Page 2
development and he would talk about the details. Mr. Fredericks explained that at the
location of the existing Wild Dunes administration building, at 57th and Palm Boulevard,
the existing building would be demolished and in its place there would be a new 153
room hotel with a spa, a roof top entertaining area, an outside restaurant and an
expanded pool area. He stated that the plan also included changing the configuration of
the rear gate to add new lanes and move the guard house to better handle the guests
coming to stay within the resort’s properties.
Mr. Denton asked what the parking requirement would be. Mr. Battista answered that
the parking for the new hotel would be underneath the hotel and it would be controlled
by a valet service and it would be in compliance with the Wild Dunes PDD (Planned
Development District) requirements. He added that all of the guests of the resort would
be directed to the newly configured gate and because of all of the additional queuing
area, they believe the backups on Palm Boulevard would be greatly reduced, if not
eliminated.
Mr. Ferencz asked how guests will know which gate to go to. Mr. Fredericks answered
that the resort is in contact with all of their guests numerous times before their trip and
directions include a video, signage and GPS coordinates to ensure that they go to the
correct gate.
Mr. Denton asked what the resort expected the difference to be between the current
traffic counts and the expected new counts. Mr. Battista explained that the existing
administration building will be moving off the island and over 80 employees that are
currently reporting to work every day on the island will be going elsewhere, which will
help minimize the impact. The traffic engineer working on the project, Ms. Jennifer Bihl
with Bihl Engineering, explained that according to their analysis, at the very peak hours
of the summer they expect an additional 100-150 trips per hour over what is currently
happening. She explained that this is about two additional cars per minute, which the
new configuration of the rear gate is designed to accommodate.
Mr. Mills asked what the capacity of the new conference room would be. Mr. Fredericks
answered about 250 people. Mr. Mills asked if these people would be in addition to the
guests staying at the hotel. Mr. Fredericks answered no, it would always be their intent
to have the people using the conference room to be guests of the hotel. He explained
that they have this condition now with the Boardwalk Inn and the people using
conference space are always guests of the hotel.
Planning Commission minutes
October 11, 2017
Page 3
Mr. Kerr stated that early in discussions, he heard talk about adding an additional lane
to Palm Boulevard just prior to getting to the rear gate and he asked if the resort was
still considering this. Mr. Battista explained that they had discussed this and been
advised that with the newly configured rear gate lanes there would be no reason to
change Palm Boulevard.
With no other questions, the Commission thanked the Wild Dunes team for attending
the meeting and answering questions.
DISCUSS STORMWATER ASSIGNMENT
Mr. Kerr explained that at the last meeting, the Commission discussed options for
assisting the City Council with planning for the stormwater system on the island. He
explained that a few members of the Commission were not present and the group
agreed to discuss the idea further before beginning work on the project.
He explained that it was his thought that the Planning Commission could be useful to
the Council in establishing a list of priorities for the Council to consider. He explained
that for many years, the City has been setting aside funding for phase one and two of
the stormwater expansions for the avenues between 57th and 45th Avenues. He stated
that phase two of this project should be completed this winter, so there could be new
priorities established for future projects. He explained the packets included a datasheet
with some of the top priorities identified by the staff and he stated that he thought that
the Commission could gather data about the cost and the severity of each of these
priorities and establish an order of priorities.
Mr. Ferencz stated that he felt like it would be useful for the Commission to create a
standardized process for dealing with drainage issues. Mr. Kerr stated that he
envisioned calls regarding maintenance issues to be handled by the Public Works
Department the same way they are currently handled. He asked if Mr. Ferencz was
talking about creating a process for dealing with routine maintenance calls. Mr. Ferencz
answered yes.
Mr. Gregory stated that he felt that to be involved with how each call is handled would
be too granular for the Planning Commission and he felt that this type work should be
handled by the Public Works Department and their committee.
Mr. DiGangi asked if the Commission could discuss how these issues are being
handled with the Public Works staff. Mr. Kerr answered yes, he could ask Director Pitts
to attend the next Planning Commission meeting.
Planning Commission minutes
October 11, 2017
Page 4
Mr. Ferencz stated that he felt that having the assistance of an engineer would be
important for the Commission’s work on the issue and he asked if Charleston County or
SCDOT had an engineer that could help. Mr. Kerr answered that the Public Works
division of Charleston County handled the administration of the City’s NPDES (National
Pollution Discharge Elimination System) and he could ask if they could help. He added
that the County’s focus for the City was more water quality over handling water
quantities, so they are two slightly different issues, but he was sure they could help.
Mr. Ferencz asked if they could be present at the next meeting. Mr. Kerr answered that
he could ask, but if the Public Works staff is already coming, did the Commission also
want to have Charleston County present. The Commission agreed to have the City’s
Public Works staff at the November meeting and the County’s engineer at the
December meeting.
Mr. Ferencz made a motion to review a draft of a standardized process for dealing with
drainage issues at the next meeting. The motion died without a second.
The Commission generally agreed to progress as discussed and have discussions with
the Public Works staff at their next meeting.
DISCUSS IMPERVIOUS SURFACE REQUIREMENTS
Mr. Kerr explained that at the last meeting the Commission discussed options for
reducing impervious surface requirements including reducing the allowable lot
coverage, creating a minimum standard for area to be left vegetative, requiring all
paving materials to be pervious, and modifying the lot fill requirements.
Mr. Ferencz asked if the City currently had minimum standards for areas to be left
vegetative. Mr. Kerr answered no, that an owner could cover their entire yard in
pervious paving.
Mr. Denton explained that in almost every community he worked in they have a 40% lot
coverage limit, like the Isle of Palms, and he felt that it was primarily an aesthetic
consideration. He added that he doubted that the limit was based on much analysis.
He stated that he worried that adjusting this number without any scientific basis may be
more of a feel-good approach than a problem-solving approach.
The group agreed to consider a minimum percent of the lot to be left vegetative, adding
standards for pervious materials and considering amending the lot filling provisions.
Planning Commission minutes
October 11, 2017
Page 5
UPDATE ON EXPANSION OF PUBLIC SEWER ORDINANCES
Mr. Kerr explained that at the last meeting, the Commission had passed on a series of
recommendations for Council to consider regarding the expansion of public sewer. He
stated that because of the lack of time between the Commission meeting and the
Council meeting, the recommendations did not make it onto the Council agenda, but
they would be on their next agenda for consideration.
He stated that the Water and Sewer Commission staff had had made him aware that
they had reservations about the provision that would reduce the allowable lot coverage
and house size for lots served by septic systems. The Sewer Commission staff
believed that this provision might have the effect of driving more people to the grinder
system program, which may cause the Sewer Commission problems in the future.
ADJOURNMENT
With there being no further business, the meeting was adjourned at 6:10 p.m.
Respectfully submitted, Richard Ferencz, Chairman
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Oct 13, 2026.