September 20, 2017
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · meeting of Sep 20, 2017 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
MINUTES OF THE ISLE OF PALMS
PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING
September 20, 2017
The Isle of Palms Planning Commission met in the City Hall conference room, 1207
Palm Boulevard on September 20, 2017 at 4:30 p.m. Members attending included Ron
Denton, Richard Ferencz, Lewis Gregory and Lisa Safford; the Director of Planning
Douglas Kerr was present as well. Vince DiGangi and Bill Mills were absent. The press
had been notified of the meeting and the agenda for the meeting was posted in City Hall
and the Building Department to comply with the Freedom of Information Act.
APPROVAL OF MINUTES
With no public comments, Mr. Ferencz explained that the next item on the agenda was
the approval of the August 9th, 2017 minutes. Mr. Denton made a motion to approve the
minutes and Ms. Safford seconded the motion. The vote was unanimous in favor of the
motion.
DISCUSSION OF EXPANDING PUBLIC SEWER SERVICE
Mr. Kerr explained that at the workshop with City Council, five action items were
identified and he had circulated draft ordinance amendments for consideration. He
explained that he knew the drafts still had some corrections to be made and he that he
would like the Planning Commission to review the distance required for new
construction to tie into sewer. He stated that the current draft set the distance requiring
tying into sewer at 150 feet, but he had the impression that at least some people at the
workshop indicated that they felt this distance was too short.
Mr. Ferencz stated that the Commission agreed on recommending 150 feet as a
starting point with the understanding that after some time had passed and the
Commission had some examples of how the provision would work, they would consider
recommending that the distance be extended. Mr. Denton added that currently the
Commission does not have any data on how many properties this provision would
impact in a year and how much it could cost an owner to comply with the prevision, but
after some time they would have some useful data on these issues to consider. The
Commission generally agreed with this rationale and agreed to leave the
recommendation at 150 feet.
Mr. Kerr explained that another item to consider was that the reduction in lot coverage
and floor to area ratio (FAR) for properties tying into a septic system did not have a floor
or ceiling. He explained that the existing lot coverage and FAR requirements establish
limits that correlate to the minimum lot size for the SR1 and SR2 zoning districts. The
limit for how large a house can be built, regardless of lot size is set at 40% of 17,500
square feet, which is the minimum lot size for SR1. Therefore, the largest house that
can be built is 7,000 square feet of living area and 7,000 square feet of lot coverage.
Planning Commission minutes
September 20, 2017
Page 2
The provision also establishes a minimum standard for how restrictive the provision will
be for small lots at 40% of 8,000 square feet, which is the minimum lot size for SR2.
Therefore, no matter how small a lot may be an owner could still build a house with
3,200 square feet of living area and 3,200 square feet of lot coverage.
He explained that to follow this logic through to the new 30% limits for houses tying into
septic systems, the maximum size house that could be tied into a septic system would
be 5,250 square feet, but the requirement would never limit an owner to a house smaller
than 2,400 square feet.
The Commission members discussed the idea of establish some maximum and
minimum requirements for the size and coverage of houses tying into septic and agreed
to follow the same logic of the existing provisions and recommended that the limits be
set at 5,250 for the FAR and lot coverage and set a limit that a house would be allowed
to have a FAR and lot coverage of 2,400, regardless of lot size.
Mr. Kerr stated that he would report back to the City Attorney on the changes that the
Commission has asked for and have the ordinances put on the next available City
Council agenda.
DISCUSS STORMWATER ASSIGNMENT
Mr. Kerr explained that the Council has requested assistance with planning for the
stormwater system on the island. He explained that he thought that the Planning
Commission could be useful to the Council in establishing a list of priorities for the
Council to consider. He explained that for many years, the City has been setting aside
funding for phase one and two of the stormwater expansions for the avenues between
57th and 45th Avenues. He stated that phase two of this project should be completed
this winter, so there could be new priorities established for future projects.
He explained that in the packets he included a datasheet with some of the top priorities
identified by the staff. He stated that he thought that the Commission could gather data
about the cost and the severity of each of these priorities and establish an order of
priorities. He stated that the method he saw for establishing would include ranking
projects in terms of impact on property, impact on roadways, impact on stormwater
quality for properties served by septic systems and the cost of each project. At the end
of the Commission’s effort, they could forward on a list of top priorities that include
conceptual ideas for repairs, costs and a ranking of the impact of each problem.
Mr. Ferencz stated that he felt like it would be impractical for the Commission to try to
create budgets and solutions for all the problems. Mr. Kerr stated that he believed
Planning Commission minutes
September 20, 2017
Page 3
that the Commission would have to rely on engineers and contractors to provide
concepts of how to fix drainage problems and create budgets, but he thought the
Commission could be useful in ranking all of the various problems in terms of their
severity and cost.
Mr. Gregory stated that he thought it would be challenging for each Commission
member to understand the drainage outside of their personal neighborhoods and asked
if there was some documentation that could be reviewed. Administrator Tucker was
present and explained that there was an aerial video taken after Irma’s flooding. Mr.
Kerr stated that he would try to distribute the video.
Mr. Kerr explained that the group had discussed one way of working on the drainage
issue, but he thought it would be good for the group to give the issue some thought and
they could discuss the matter at a future meeting with all members present.
REVIEW OF IMPERVIOUS SURFACE REQUIREMENT
Mr. Ferencz stated that he had been asked by a member of City Council to discuss the
City’s policies on impervious surfacing requirement and how they are impacting the
drainage systems on the island. He stated that in Europe communities require that
driveways be done out of materials that are completely pervious and he knew that it
would be challenging to require this on existing developments, but this could be made a
requirement for new construction.
Mr. Kerr explained that currently the City set a limit of how much impervious surface can
cover a property at 40% and he thought the rationale for not having a hard rule on
driveway materials to give property owners a choice of how to comply. Also, it might be
punitive to require an owner building a small house to install a more expensive driveway
even though they are covering less than a neighboring house.
Mr. Kerr stated that some areas that he thought could use some work on lot coverage
are: considering specifications for pervious surfaces, consider a minimum percent of the
lot to be left vegetated and considering improving the lot filling provisions to ensure that
newly developed properties are not running water onto their neighbors.
The Commission generally discussed lot coverage and agreed that it would be
beneficial to investigate further.
ADJOURNMENT
With there being no further business, the meeting was adjourned at 6:15 p.m.
Respectfully submitted, Richard Ferencz, Chairman
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Oct 13, 2026.