September 19, 2017
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · meeting of Sep 19, 2017 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
WAYS and MEANS COMMITTEE
5:00 p.m., Tuesday, September 19, 2017
The regular meeting of the Ways and Means Committee was called to order at 5:00 p.m.,
Tuesday, September 19, 2017 in Council Chambers of City Hall, 1207 Palm Boulevard, Isle of
Palms, South Carolina. Attending the meeting were Councilmembers Bettelli, Carroll, Ferencz,
Kinghorn, Rice and Ward, Mayor ProTem Harrington, Mayor Cronin, Administrator Tucker,
Assistant Administrator Fragoso and Clerk Copeland. A quorum was present to conduct
business. Councilmember Bergwerf was absent.
1. Mayor Cronin called the meeting to order and acknowledged that the press and public
were duly notified of the meeting in accordance with the Freedom of Information Act.
2. Approval of Previous Meeting’s Minutes
MOTION: Councilmember Bettelli moved to approve the minutes of the regular
meeting of August 15, 2017 as submitted; Councilmember Rice seconded and the
motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
3. Citizens’ Comments
John Moye, 6 Nineteenth Avenue, stated that he would like to see the City’s FY17 departmental
“surpluses” returned to the tourism funds that were budgeted to support certain General Fund
expenditures, and that, if that is not done, to consider increasing the Disaster Recovery Fund.
4. Financial Statements – Treasurer Suggs
A. Financial Statements
Being only two (2) months into FY18, the target for revenue and expenditures was seventeen
percent (17%). She stated that there was little to report for revenues since the bulk of revenue
received in August actually relates to June, 2017. General Fund revenues were seven hundred
ninety-eight thousand dollars ($798,000), coming primarily from Residential Rental Licenses and
Parking, and represent eight percent (8%) of the General Fund budget. Expenditures through
August were at fifteen percent (15%) of budget, which is slightly ahead of FY17 for the same
period. She reminded the Committee that the Mayor/Council expenditures were greater than the
target due to the payment to MeduCare Air for the premium, which was a budgeted expenditure;
the percentage will come in line as the year progresses. The City continues to have a strong cash
position, which is inflated by the four point eight million dollars ($4,800,000) of stakeholder funds
the City is holding in anticipation of the Beach Renourishment Project and the new revenue stream
from the Beach Preservation Fee Fund is one million dollars ($1,000,000) higher than last year at
this time. The interest rate at the LGIP has dropped slightly to one point zero six four six percent
(1.0646%), but overall the City is recognizing more interest as the rates are beginning to trend
upward.
B. Tourism Schedules
The City had a very good August and Municipal Accommodations Taxes reached a new high at
two hundred thirty-five thousand dollars ($235,000); the fund is up seven percent (7%) from the
same period in FY17. The City has received no collections from State Accommodations Taxes
Ways and Means Committee
September 19, 2017
Page 2 of 11
or the Charleston County Pass-through. August was also a record month for Hospitality Taxes
with collections of approximately nine -nine thousand dollars ($99,000); year -to-date, collections
are six percent (6%) higher than the same period in FY17. Collections of Beach Preservation
Fees mirror Municipal ATAX and are up seven percent (7%).
Councilmember Carroll again cautioned the Committee that the City should not count on tourism
fees increasing year after year.
C. Projects Worksheets
For the Phase II Drainage Project, expenses related to the bid opening and legal fees were paid
in August. On page 2 is the most recent analysis of the City’s funding for the project based on
the bid received; it shows that, when matching up the project funding including the contingency
with the estimated spending, the project funding is approximately five hundred eighty thousand
dollars ($580,000) short. After applying the existing reserve for General Drainage and Roads and
the approved TST funding request from Charleston County, the short fall is reduced to sixty-three
thousand dollars ($63,000), which is well below the substantial contingency for the project.
Pursuant to Councilmember Ferencz’ que stions, it was determined that the Committee did not
have the revised schedule in the meeting packet. Treasurer Suggs explained that the difference
was an increase the fund balance in General Drainage and Roads by one hundred thirty thousand
dollars ($130,000) as a result of audit entries to three hundred twenty -three thousand dollars
($323,000); this reduces the remaining shortfall to sixty-three thousand dollars ($63,000).
Mayor Cronin added that the project has been contracted, and, according to the Administrator,
some survey work has begun in the area of the outfall.
Looking at the second page of the Beach Restoration Project worksheet, the expenses incurred
in August are shown; the Treasurer stated that she continues to refine the FEMA and Parks,
Recreation and Tourism (PRT) amounts. She recalled that the PRT agreement contains a
provision stipulating that, if the City receives FEMA funds, it will reimburse PRT fifty-percent (50%)
of the value of the FEMA reimbursement in the project area; Coastal Science and Engineering
has provided the data to calculate that payback amount, and it is included calculations. Also
included in the full twenty -five percent (25%) of the South Carolina match to the FEMA grant.
With the bids received, this project is fully funded and has a surplus of fifty-eight thousand dollars
($58,000) after a healthy construction contingency.
Administrator Tucker noted that the pre-construction conference on this project will be tomorrow
morning, Wednesday, September 20th.
The worksheet for the Public Works Vehicle Wash -down project shows expenditures in August
for special inspections of the project; approximately five hundred thousand dollars ($500,000)
remains to be paid on the project.
Treasurer Suggs responded to Councilm ember Ward’s question that the total project cost is at
eight hundred sixty-six thousand dollars ($866,000) including the contingency.
Ways and Means Committee
September 19, 2017
Page 3 of 11
In clarifying the column headed “Net cost to City,” the Treasurer recalled that the City received
four hundred seventy -one thousand dollars ($471,000) from Charleston County in stormwater
fees it had collected for the City, making the net cost to the City of three hundred ninety -five
thousand dollars ($395,000) . The City’s portion is being paid with a combination of Capital
Projects and Municipal ATAX funds.
Administrator Tucker reported that the City had signed a no-cost change order for rain days based
on the bad weather experienced recently; thereby granting Hitt an extension for the rain days lost.
D. Report on Millage
The Treasurer remarked that the IOP Schedule of Assessed Values from the Charleston County
Auditor’s Office was included in meeting packet, containing historical data since 2013 for
comparison. Treasurer Suggs has added the property taxes received from the County for the tax
year 2017, which will be the City’s fiscal year 2018; as anticipated, the City has seen some growth
in assessments. Directing attention to the sections “Collectible ,” which is based on calculations
that the Treasurer finds “somewhat strange.” When the Treasurer computes the total anticipated
Property Tax collections and compares it to the budget, the City has a shortfall of one hundred
forty-two thousand dollars ($142,000). She noted that the City frequently shows a shortfall when
using the County’s numbers, and, after reviewing this data with the Mayor and City Administrator,
the decision was that the millage does not need to increase for FY18. Treasurer Suggs expressed
confidence that the City could meet the budget estimate without increasing the millage or the
Local Options Sales Tax credit.
MOTION: Mayor Cronin moved that the operating millage to stay at 21. 3 mills
and that the debt service millage remain at 3.4 mills for a total of 2.4.7 mills; Mayor
ProTem Harrington seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
E. Consideration of Distribution of FY17 Year-end Positive Net Result
Attention was now directed at the Fund Balance Roll-forward Schedules included in the meeting
packet that show the preliminary net revenue for FY17 in red. The audit is currently underway,
meaning that the numbers represented could change, but the Treasurer was confident that these
were a good indication of how the City would end the year. At this meeting, she was looking for
direction from Council as how FY17 positive net results of eight hundred twenty -two thousand
thirty dollars ($882,030) should be distributed. The Treasurer’s suggestion was to allow some
amount, possibly one hundred to one hundred fifty thousand dollars ($100,000 – 150,000), to
remain in the Unassigned General Fund Account because the City has a target to maintain twenty-
percent (20%) of total General Fund expenditures in the account. With this addition, the General
Fund would have close to twenty -five percent (25%) of General Fund expenditures, giving the
City a “comfortable cushion.” Going to the second page of the schedule, Treasurer Suggs pointed
out that the preliminary FY17 ending balance in the Capital Projects fund is approximately one
million seven hundred thousand dollars ($1,700,000), but with the aggressive FY18 budget, the
projected FY18 year -end balance drops to approximately five hundred fifty thousand dollars
($550,000). She, therefore, would like to see five or six hundred thousand dollars ($500,000 –
600,000) transferred to the Capital Projects fund in order to keep that fund balance at a healthy
level.
Ways and Means Committee
September 19, 2017
Page 4 of 11
Mayor Cronin noted that the City collected more from FEMA than the actual costs the City paid
out in certain categories. Of those extra FEMA funds, the Mayor recommended that fifty thousand
dollars ($50,000) be put into the Disaster Recover Fund and the balance of one hundred to one
hundred twenty thousand dollars ($100,000 – 120,000) remain in Unassigned Funds in the
General Fund.
MOTION: Mayor Cronin moved to distribute the FY17 positive net result as
follows: $50,000 to Disaster Recovery Fund, $600,000 to the Capital Projects Fund
and $232,000 in the Unassigned Funds in the General Fund; Councilmember
Kinghorn seconded.
Councilmember Ferencz offered a different scenario for the distribution of the positive net result.
From an earlier year -end projection, Treasurer Suggs had s hown that two hundred thousand
dollars ($200,000) of it could be attributed to wages in the Police Department that operated for a
portion of the year under-staffed. Based on the FY17 budget, Municipal Accommodations Taxes,
Hospitality Tax and State ATAX in excess of four hundred seventy thousand dollars ($470,000)
to the Police Department for personnel expenses; therefore, Councilmember Ferencz proposes
returning two hundred thousand dollars ($200,000), proportionately, to the respective tourism
fund. Since the City has done the same thing for the FY18 budget, she believes that the tourism
funds are paying twice for the same wages. Additionally, she sug gests that approximately one
hundred fifty -two thousand three hundred dollars ($152,300) received from FEMA go to the
Disaster Recovery Fund because she assumed that money spent during and in recovering from
a disaster would be paid from that fund.
Treasurer Suggs noted that money for wages and vehicle usage would all be paid from the
General Fund, and she reported that the FEMA reimbursements were credited back to the funds
that paid the disaster-related expenses.
Her final suggestion was to add a minimum of one hundred thousand dollars ($100,000) to
increase the Disaster Recovery Fund. In her calculations, the amount remaining of the FY17
positive net result, or four hundred forty-five thousand dollars ($445,000), would be available for
the Capital Projects Fund.
The Treasurer informed Councilmember Ward that the disaster declaration has no t yet been
made for non-Category B expenditures.
Since the City has no experienced damages from three (3) near-misses in the past two (2) years,
Councilmember Ward opined that “it would behoove [the City] to let the resident know that [the
City] is adding to that fund.” He voiced the opinion that in previous years, the City has either put
“a pittance into to [the Disaster Recovery Fund] or ignored it.”
Mayor Cronin noted that the Isle of Palms was the only community with a Disaster Recovery Fund;
he added that other communities consider it unassigned funds to be used for a disaster or any
other purpose. He reported that the City has made it a habit not to dr aw from the unassigned
funds; he said that the City has three and a half million dollars ($3,500,000) in unassigned and
two million dollars ($2,000,000) in the Disaster Recovery Fund.
Ways and Means Committee
September 19, 2017
Page 5 of 11
According to Councilmember Ward, the addition of funds to the Disaster Recovery Fund was a
psychological issue, a reassurance matter, with residents more than it was a money issue. The
Councilmember expressed the opinion that “[the City] could never have too much mone y in the
bank especially when a hurricane is coming in.”
Councilmember Rice said that she wanted to be assured that the City will have the sixty -three
thousand dollars ($63,000) to complete the drainage project because it will help with the flooding
issues on the island.
When Councilmember Ferencz asked if the reluctance to put money into the Disaster Recovery
Fund was the fact that the fund was assigned.
The Mayor reminded the Committee that funds could be unassigned by an act of Council, and
that the level of unassigned funds, as a percent of budget, was set by ordinance.
Councilmember Ferencz continued her argument that, by not reimbursing the tourism funds for
police wages that were not spent, the tourism funds were paying for the same thing tw ice; she
also questioned that the City could put tourism funds into the Capital Projects Fund.
Treasurer Suggs stated that Councilmember Ferencz was assuming that the tourism funds were
what was saved, when it could just as easily be money from the Genera l Fund that was saved.
The Treasurer stated that the link between tourism funds and the City’s need for police officers
was clear and that she has no qualms in saying that the tourism funds come in first to fund these
expenditures – otherwise, the expense falls to the taxpayers. The Treasurer added that she
thought that spending the tourism funds in the manner that the City does was the responsible
action for Council to take.
Mayor Cronin contended that keeping the money where it is or moving it to Capital Projects saved
Council for doing anything with property taxes in the future.
AMENDMENT: Mayor Cronin amended the original motion to put $100,000 in the
Disaster Recovery Fund, $600,000 in the Capital Projects Funds and to leave the
balance of $18 2,030 in the Unassigned General Fund; Councilmember Ward
seconded.
Councilmember Carrol; voiced the opinion that five million dollars ($5,000,000) would never be
enough if the City were hit with another hurricane like Hugo because tourism on the island would
end for several years.
VOTE on AMENDMENT: The amendment PASSED on a vote of 7 to 1 with
Councilmember Ferencz casting the dissenting vote.
VOTE on AMENDED MOTION: The amended motion PASSED on a vote of 7 to
1 with Councilmember Ferencz casting the dissenting vote.
As part of the BS&A discovery process, BS&A convinced Treasurer S uggs that pooling cash,
rather than having multiple checking accounts was a viable option for the City; in thinking through
Ways and Means Committee
September 129, 2017
Page 6 of 11
the process, the Treasurer identified nineteen (19) different checking a ccounts that are used by
the City. She explained that the separate funds would continue to exist for the General Ledger ;
cash balances would be consolidated for the purpose of the bank accounts only. The Treasurer
has decided that the City would need to retain only five (5) accounts, not nineteen (19); t he
expenditures from the individual funds would be accomplished through journal entries. Treasurer
Suggs stated that she has resisted the concept in the past when recommended by one (1) of the
City’s auditors, but the process will be much simpler and more exact with the new software. She
has decided to make this change after consulting with prior and current auditors, the Mayor and
Administrator and Councilmember Ward. She added that doing this would have a positive impact
on both her and Laura McLellan, the Accounts Payable Clerk.
The Administrator commented that the reporting Council receives would remain the basically the
same.
5. Old Business
Drainage – Report from Public Works Director Pitts
As the Director walked to the podium, he indicated that his comments were directed more to any
type of weather-related event that hits the island, not just drainage.
The Director explained that the City has a protocol for every event that includes a chec k-list for
every department; when operating conditions change, the Administrator calls a meeting of
department heads to review what they have completed on their checklist.
Four (4) questions were posed to the Public Works Director, and the first was to review the
strengths of the Department before, during and after flooding conditions. Before the storm, Public
Works took the appropriate steps in accordance with each operating condition as defined by the
City before, during and after the storm. The four (4) pumps the City owns were serviced and
ready for deployment to the areas of the island that typically flood the most; in addition, Director
Pitts rented four (4) additional pumps for deployment to flood-prone areas. Additionally, the fuel
storage tanks were filled, and a generator was ready in event of a power outage to insure that the
gas pumps were operational for City vehicles. The Department was fully -staffed from the
beginning to the end of the weather event. Duri ng the storm, Public Works was i n constant
communication with the Police Department to receive real -time information about areas of the
island that were flooding and needed attention. Public Works personnel were deployed quickly
after the storm to begin debris removal, to keep the pumps operational, to clear streets, and to
clean the beach before the emergency berm restoration; Director Pitts coordinated with Eadie’s
for emergency ditch restructuring. On the subject of needs for immediate future events, the
Director noted that 45 th through 52nd Avenues are the most flood-prone areas of the island, and
the problems in that area are being addressed with the Phase II Drainage Project scheduled to
begin in October. In addition, the City needs to update the comprehensive drainage plan for the
entire City, identifying existing drainage/flooding areas and finding ways to avoid new problems.
Although this would be a major expense and have a significant impact on the City’s budget, the
Director opined that the frequency of Eadie’s stormwater maintenance should be redefined from
a five year (5 yr.) plan to an annual plan. Needs for the long -term include focusing on improve-
ments to the drainage system, having additional temporary labor to assist in debris removal and
Ways and Means Committee
September 19, 2017
Page 7 of 11
the revision of the Eadie’s contract as noted above. The Director’s final recommendation for long-
term needs was a restructuring of the of the Public Works Department into three (3) areas of
responsibility, i.e. garbage collection and debris removal, drainage and general maintenance of
City properties. The final question, the financial commitment needed, was left unanswered.
Councilmember Ferencz voiced the opinion that the Eadies’ contract should be revised ”very
quickly;” she recalled that they completed Year 3 of the five -year (5 yr.) contract at the end of
June 2017. She acknowledged that to do this would be quite expensive, but she thought it was
a serious need for the City.
Mayor Cronin commented that the water tabl e on the island has risen significantly across the
island and has not fallen much in the past couple of months. Director Pitts added that, in low -
lying areas where water was still standing, it is there because the water level is the level of the
water table.
Mayor Cronin stated that the drainage is part of a complex issue that would bring in grinder pumps
and septic tanks as well as stormwater issues.
Responding to Councilmember Rice’s question, the Director said that the City needed a civil
engineer to study the island’s drainage system and it needed open ditches everywhere on the
island. He explained that open ditches provide storage, and currently the City has no storage,
the City also needs more land mass to create dry ponds to store the water, esp ecially at high
tides.
Councilmember Ferencz commented that, on the Public Works agenda for September was an
item to consider giving the task of developing a comprehensive drainage plan since they have
been working on issues related to septic tanks grinde r pumps and sewer to the Planning
Commission. She said that the Administrator told her that the City had a comprehensive plan in
1995 developed by E.M. Seabrook; that plan has been the basis for drainage projects Phase I
and Phase II; the Councilmember thought it could also serve as a starting point for the Planning
Commission.
Councilmember Carroll asked if requiring that driveways, sidewalks and pool surrounds have
pervious surfaces would help the flooding problems.
Councilmember Kinghorn asked the Director if he could have cost estimates ready for the
December budget planning meeting, and the Mayor was confident that he could.
When Councilmember Ferencz asked what percentage of the surface would be permeable in the
revitalization plan for the marin a because covering the site with asphalt would only exacerbate
the flooding problems in that area . Mayor Cronin did not have the statistics, but noted that the
engineering includes a stormwater plan.
Administrator Tucker indicated that Kirby Marshall of ATM would have the percentages at the
Council meeting.
(Councilmember Harrington left the meeting due to medical issues.)
Ways and Means Committee
September 19, 20187
Page 8 of 11
6. New Business
A. Report on Emergency Contracts Awarded
1. Robert Collins Co., Inc. - $246,200, construct replacement dunes
2. Coastal Science and Engineering - $30,000, project oversight and
post-project monitoring
The Administrator explained that the Robert Collins contract was originally awarded for two
hundred twelve thousand dollars ($212,000), but additional equipment was needed that increased
the contract to two hundred forty-six thousand two hundred dollars ($246,200). Like the City did
immediately after Hurricane Matthew, the City contracted with CSE to supervi se the emergency
dune restoration to survey the entire seven (7) miles of coastline to determine if the island had
any sand losses attributable to Hurricane Irma.
In addition, the City needed some emergency drainage work that has added fifty thousand dollars
($50,000) to the preliminary damage assessment report; the figure is based on rates Eadies’
provided prior to the storm.
Also included in the preliminary damage assessment will be overtime incurred by the Public
Works Department and the Fire and Police Departments, plus damages to City buildings – some
of which will be covered by insurance and others fall under insurance deductibles, and damage
to vehicles that are still be assessed. Some of the City’s constructed dune walkovers were
damaged and will need restoration; estimates are still being gathered. Losses to date, not
including sand losses or data still being gathered, total, approximately half a million dollars
($500,000).
Responding to Councilmember Ferencz’ question about the source of f unds to cover these
expenses, the Administrator explained that overtime expense and certain others will be paid from
the General Fund while the emergency contracts will be paid from the Disaster Recovery Fund.
Administrator Tucker reminded the Committee th at the expenses were subject to insurance
reimbursement as well as reimbursement through FEMA Category B.
Councilmember Carroll recounted that Council had received an email from Administrator Tucker
discussing the berm restoration from Breach Inlet to 10th Avenue; then a second email was sent
with diagrams of the beach that showed gaps in that area. He asked if the emergency berms
were being constructed from Breach to 10 th or if the berms were only being restored in specific
places between Breach Inlet and 10th Avenue.
Administrator Tucker stated that the original target area was Breach Inlet to 10th Avenue, but the
City then received clarification from OCRM as to which areas within that area they determined
needed emergency work and which did not. One (1) of the determining factors was the distance
between a structure and the high tide line; the second email to Council took into consideration
OCRM’s interpretation of the regulations. City staff continues to be in conversation with OCRM
about mechanisms that would allow the City to meet the original goal. Today, discussions
concerned ways to get the job done under the City’s existing permit that encompasses Breach
Inlet to 14th Avenue; since all of the regulatory agencies have commented on that permit, the City
hopes to eliminate the gaps.
Ways and Means Committee
September 19, 2017
Page 9 of 11
The Mayor said that, in his mind, OCRM has changed the rules and the City is trying to find a way
to work within their rules and get the job the City wants done.
Since the City has a contractor mobilized, the fact that the City had the storm and that another
storm is sitting in the Atlantic, OCRM appears to be motivated to help the City; the Administrator
expressed the opinion that OCRM was trying to work with the City in every way within the confines
of their regulations.
B. Consideration of an award of a contract to Master Craft in the amount of
$34,500 for the installation of retractable basketball goals in the Recreation
Center
MOTION: Mayor Cronin moved to award the contract for retractable basketball
goals to Master Craft in the amount of $34,500; Councilmember Kinghorn seconded.
Acknowledging that this expense was included in the FY18 budget, Councilmember Carroll
opined that awarding this contract at this time sends the wrong message right now for the City to
be spending money on basketball goals.
Councilmember Bettelli suggested that this action sends the “correct message to the residents
that [IOP] is a viable island that is going to look out for residents and, in particular, the youth of
the island.”
VOTE: The motion was DEFEATED on a tie vote with Councilmembers Carrol l,
Ferencz and Ward casting dissenting votes.
MOTION: Mayor Cronin moved to reconsider the award of a contract to Master
Craft for the installation of retractable basketball goals; Councilmember Rice
seconded and the motion PASSED on a vote of 4 to 3 with Councilmembers Carroll,
Ferencz and Ward casting dissenting votes.
MOTION: Mayor Cronin moved to award the contract for retractable basketball
goals to Master Craft in the amount of $34,500; Councilmember Rice seconded.
Councilmember Ferencz reiterated the opinion that the City is spending money on a want rather
than a need. Looking at the flooding around the Rec Center after Irma, she suggested that now
may not be the time for this purchase and that the City should wait since it is not an emergency.
Councilmember Bettelli countered that Council was doing what it had told the citizens it would do
in the budgeting process.
VOTE: The motion PASSED on a vote of 4 to 3 with Councilmembers Carroll,
Ferencz and Ward casting dissenting votes.
C. Consideration of an award of a contract to Technology Solutions of
Charleston in the amount of $29,896.81, state contract pricing, for Access
Ways and Means Committee
September 19, 2017
Page 10 of 11
Control Upgrade to the Police Department (Pg. 43, ln. 38 – Capital Projects, Police
Department, $30,000)
D. Consideration of an aware of a contract to Technology Solutions of
Charleston in the amount of $33,197.90, state contract pricing, for Access
Control Upgrade to the Fire Department (Pg. 44, ln. 68 – Capital Projects, Fire
Department, $30,000)
MOTION: Mayor Cronin moved to award contracts to Technology Solutions of
Charleston as detailed above; Councilmember Ward seconded.
Councilmember Ferencz asked what this was, and the Mayor explained that it was the security
on the doors in the PSB.
VOTE: The motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
The Administrator informed the Committee that the total of the two (2) contracts was over budget
by approximately three thousand dollars ($3,000).
F. Authorization for up to $25,000 for unexpected repairs to the 95 foot ladder
truck
MOTION: Mayor Cronin moved to authorize the repair expense in an amount up
to $25,000; Councilmember Bettelli seconded.
Responding to Councilmember Ward’s inquiry, the Administrator stated that this expense was not
included in the FY18 budget.
Chief Graham stated that the truck has outriggers that extend to stabilize it; one (1) of them has
so much movement in it that it must be repaired. The truck is fourteen years old, and, in her
opinion, it was not reasonable to fix one without fixing all four (4). The truck must be taken to
Georgetown where a factory representative will perform the repairs; she commented that the truck
was usable, but the crew must use extreme caution.
When Councilmember Ward asked about the existence of a Repairs and Maintenance line in the
budget, Chief Graham noted that this repair would exhaust half of the year’s budget designated
for repairs and maintenance.
The Treasurer asked whether the expense should be charged to the Capital Projects Fund or the
General Fund; she also stated that, typically, she would charge something out of the ordinary like
this repair to the Capital Projects Fund.
Treasurer Suggs indicated that this truck was due to be replaced in FY20.
The Chief commented that she tries to get seventeen to twenty years (17-20 yrs.) use out of the
trucks, therefore the crews take excellent care of them, but this is one (1) of the trucks that as
subject to the elements for two years (2 yrs.).
Ways and Means Committee
September 19, 2017
Page 11 of 11
When asked the name of the company making the repairs, the Chief responded that the FireLine
representative will do the work in the First Vehicle shop in Georgetown. If the work goes well, the
truck will be in the shop for approximately a week.
VOTE: The motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
7. Miscellaneous Business – None
Next Meeting Date: 5:00 p.m., Tuesday, October 24, 2017
Administrator Tucker reminded those present about the Farmers’ Market on Thursday, the
Wellness Fair on Friday and Wacky Golf on Thursday, September 28th.
8. Executive Session – not needed
9. Adjournment
MOTION: Councilmember Kinghorn moved to adjourn the meeting at 6:23 p.m.:
Councilmember Bettelli seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Respectfully submitted:
Marie Copeland
City Clerk
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Oct 13, 2026.