Regular City Council, 6:00 p.m. August 22, 2017
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · meeting of Aug 22, 2017 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
CITY COUNCIL
6:00 p.m., Tuesday, August 22, 2017
The regular meeting of City Council was called to order at 6:03 p.m. on Tuesday, August 22, 2017
in Council Chambers of City Council, 1207 Palm Boulevard, Isle of Palms, South Carolina.
Attending the meeting were Councilmembers Bergwerf, Bettelli, Carroll, Ferencz, Kinghorn, Rice
and Ward, Mayor ProTem Harrington, Mayor Cronin, Administrator Tucker, Attorney Halversen,
Assistant Administrator Fragoso and City Clerk Copeland; a quorum was present to conduct
business.
1. Mayor Cronin called the meeting to order and acknowledged that the press and public
were duly notified of the meeting in accordance with the Freedom of Information Act. Following
a brief invocation and the Pledge of Allegiance, Clerk Copeland called the roll.
2. Reading of the Journals of Previous Meetings
MOTION: Councilmember Bettelli moved to approve the minutes of the regular
meeting of July 19, 2017 and the Special Meetings of July 18 and August 7, 2017 as
submitted; Councilmember Bergwerf seconded and the motion PASSED
UNANIMOUSLY.
3. Appointment and Administration of Oath to New Employee
MOTION: Councilmember Bettelli moved to accept William “Tony” Sease as an
employee of the City; Councilmember Bergwerf seconded and the motion PASSED
UNANIMOUSLY.
After administering the oath, the Mayor welcomed Mr. Sease to the Isle of Palms family.
4. Citizens’ Comments
Randy Bell, 22 – 41st Avenue, stated that, some members of the community might think that he
is “vehemently opposed” to the marina revitalization, but, in fact, h e was opposed to assumi ng
debt without understanding what that debt means. He reported that he sent a FOIA request to
the City asking who was using the marina; he assumed that it was primarily off -islanders. He
indicated that he asked for that information on a daily basis and also about slip rentals, i.e. resident
versus non-resident, that he thought would be readily available since the wait list consists of sixty
(60) boaters. He stated that the responses from the City were that the City does not collect that
type of data and that the marina manager was not required to provide that data. In his opinion, it
was the responsibility of Council, because the information was vital to the understanding the
marina for residents; he stated that he did not want to vote for something he did not understand.
Mr. Bell opined that the statistical data he wanted should be readily available via a point of sale
report on a monthly basis and that it was simple data to collect and should be made available to
the public “to see where the marina is headed.” If the referendum passes, he did not believe that
anyone thought that the revitalization would reduce “the parking issues or the conflicts within the
marina property , construction traffic, etc.” He requested the statistical data once again and
commented that he did not think it should be his responsibility to go to the marina manager to get
the requested information, but he did think Council should ask for information that was relevant
to a public vote. He suggested raising the launch fees for off-islanders, adding that the marina
City Council
August 22, 2017
Page 2 of 13
manager would earn the same amount of money with half the people; he voiced the opinion that
to increase the fees would impact traffic volumes over the island. Another question posed by Mr.
Bell was how the manager could suspend the sale of annual launch passes? The response he
received from the City was that the language of the lease did not state that he could not suspend
the sale of passes. He concluded stating that he wanted Council to be consistent in handling
matters and to start addressing the residents’ concerns. In his opinion, the only thing he got from
the City was “a bill for one hundred twelve dollars ($112) for research and not an answer to a
single question,” he added that he did not think he “should be charged for information that should
be readily available.”
5. Reports from Standing Committees
A. Ways and Means Committee
From the meeting of August 15 th, Mayor Cronin reported that the Treasurer had computed
preliminary and unaudited year -end results for FY17 that indicate the City’s budget will have a
positive net result of approximately eight hundred ninety -seven thousand two hundred fifty -four
dollars ($897,254). One (1) category where revenues were significantly greater than budget was
Court Revenues, and the City received approximately one hundred fifty two thousand dollars
($152,000) in g rants that was not budgeted for that was reimbursement for personnel and
equipment operating costs related to Hurricane Matthew . Two (2) categories ended the year
significantly under budget, and they w ere salaries where the Police Department operated much
of the year understaffed and legal services that are influenced by outside and unpredictable
catalysts. The auditors will be on -site soon to make the final tweaks needed to close out FY17,
and City Council will decide how to best use the year’s positive net result. The Treasurer reported
that the conversion to the financial software has begun and the ir schedule is “very ambitious.”
They will be on the island at the end of the month on a discovery mis sion; they plan to convert
ten (10) years of data and to train members of staff in October and the “go-live” date is scheduled
for mid-November. Through one (1) month of the new fiscal year, expenditures in the General
Fund were at six percent (6%) of budget, and, as usual, revenues were low because much reflects
activity prior to June 30, 2017. Because Municipal Accommodations Tax collections were lower
than the same period in FY16, the Treasurer will perform forensics on the report to determine if a
major tax payer(s) was delinquent. State Accommodations Taxes for FY17 were three and a half
percent (3.5%) higher than FY16 at approximately one million one hundred seventy thousand
dollars ($1,170,000). As has been reported previously, the Charleston Count y Accommodations
Tax Pass-through was paid to the City in a lump sum and was seven percent greater than FY16.
The City ended FY17 with very strong months for Hospitality Tax Collections, and the year ended
with an eight percent (8%) increase over FY16. Reflecting Municipal Accommodations Taxes,
Beach Preservation Fees saw only a negligible increase over FY16. Mayor Cronin noted that the
Vehicle Wash -down project continues, and a completion date has yet to be announced. For
Phase II Drainage, the Mayor noted that the bids came in more than was budgeted, and to bridge
the funding gap, the City applied for addition al TST funding from Charleston C ounty that was
awarded last week in the amount of one hundred ninety -three thousand dollars ($193,000) and
change. With the money in-hand for the project, the contract can be awarded. The decision was
also made to re-bid the Front Beach restrooms and boardwalk since the bids came in one hundred
thousand dollars ($100,000) more than budgeted. The need for a wider and as much sturdier
City Council
August 22, 2017
Page 3 of 13
boardwalk than usual has driven the costs up; therefore, City staff has gone back to the design
engineers asking for modifications that would reduce the price yet meet the needs of the City –
the boardwalk must be strong enough to support two (2) ATVs. The City is also considering
dividing the project into two (2), execute one (1) and consider how to fund the second.
1. Award of a contract to Vic Bailey Ford for one F -150 pickup in the amount
of $31,834, state contract pricing (State ATAX Fund, p g. 29, ln. 299 –
Recreation Department, Capital Outlay - $32,000)
MOTION: Mayor Cronin moved to award a contract to Vic Bailey Ford for one F-
150 pickup in the amount of $31,834; Councilmember Bergwerf seconded and the
motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
2. Award of a contract to Hunter Powersports LLC for 2 Kawasaki Mules Pro-
FX EPS LE (ATVs) in the amount of $26,434.96, including sales taxes,
registration fee, accessories, assembly, delivery and 3 -year warranty
(Hospitality Tax Fund, ps. 27, ln. 188, Fire Department Capital Outlay, $34,000)
MOTION: Mayor Cronin moved to award a contract for $26,434.96 for two ATVs
as described above; Councilmember Bettelli seconded and the motion PASSED
UNANIMOUSLY.
3. Award of a contract to Great Lakes Dredge & Dock for beach renourish -
ment in the amount of $11,875,000 (pg. 30, ln 341 – Beach Restoration Fund,
Beach Renourishment - $15,004,000)
MOTION: Mayor Cronin moved to award the contract for Beach Restoration to
Great Lakes Dredge & Dock Co. in the amount of $11,875,000; Councilmember
Carroll seconded.
The Mayor recalled that the City received three (3) bids from competent bidders; one (1) bidder
indicated that they would not be available to begin work until 2018, which took them out of
consideration, and Weeks Marine was the contractor for the 2008 project. He commented that
Weeks and Great Lakes were the two (2) biggest dredging companies in the country. Included in
the meeting packet was a recommend ation from Coastal Science and Engineering (CSE) to
award the contract to Great Lakes Dredge and Dock for the low bid of eleven million eight hundred
seventy-five dollars ($11,875,000); CSE reports that they have worked with Great Lakes in the
past at Edisto and Kiawah. The Mayor explained that, although the City received a favorable bid,
funding for the project has many pieces , and the FEMA grant and funds from Parks, Recreation
and Tourism (PRT) contain stipulations relative to the project, such as the a mount of sand and
where it is placed. In addition, the PRT grant will not pay for engineering leading up to the project;
therefore, that expense has to be eliminated from the calculations when they determine what they
will pay. One stipulation of the contract is that, if the project is stopped for any reason by the City
leaving the equipment idle, the City must pay Great Lakes one hundred thousand twenty -one
thousand dollars ($121,000) per day; the Mayor added that the City did not stop the work on the
2008 project. In the Mayor’s opinion, the City was in a good position to award the contract and
he looks forward to a successful project.
City Council
August 22, 2017
Page 4 of 13
Administrator Tucker repeated that the project has multiple funding compon ents and the City is
planning to spend grant funds first since they have time tables associated with them. She also
reminded Council that the FEMA and PRT grants have match requirements as well; she noted
that this project has a lot of unknowns that the City did not face in the 2008 project. Coordinating
the grants and ensuring that the City complies with the requirements of each will demand paying
close attention to all facets of the project, and cash flow will be tight throughout the project. The
Administrator explained that the PRT grant requires that the City pay back fifty percent (50%) of
any federal money expended for the project and has stated that they will only fund forty -eight
point eight percent (48.8%) of fifty percent (50%) of the eligible costs.
According to the Mayor, the contract to be awarded generates one million four hundred thousand
cubic yards (1,400,000 cu. yds.) of sand unlike original discussions of one million cubic yards
(1,000,000) of sand; the City stretched the permit limits to be able to put the one point four million
cubic yards (1,400,000 cu. yds.) of sand on the beach. He continued that, if the City were to
realize a funding shortfall, it could suspend the project at a lesser amount of sand; he stated that
each one hundred thousand cubic yards (100,000 cu. yds.) of sand reduces the project cost by
six hundred thousand dollars ($600,000), meaning that the City will have a degree of flexibility in
executing the project.
On the subject of cash flow, Mayor Cronin recalled a conference call with representatives of Edisto
Beach to understand how they had managed their project which had some of the same funding
sources. In the course of the conversation, the Mayor an d Administrator learned tha t Edisto
requested that FEMA and PRT provide the funding up front rather than the City expending its
funds and having to wait for reimbursement. The City has reached out to these agencies and
asked for the same consideration to avoid issues with cash flow during the project; the Mayor
noted that he expects the request to be honored since FEMA and PRT have already set the
precedent.
The Administrator commented that she and the Treasurer had generated a “worst case” financial
scenario and found that the City could execute the project by using nine hundred thousand dollars
($900,000) of the project contingency. She added that, if the scope of the project was reduced,
the amount of grant funds would also be reduced.
Repeating his question from the Ways and Means Committee meeting, Councilmember Ward
asked for confirmation that the City was not going to borrow money for the renourishment project
which was the impression Council was given at that meeting.
Mayor Cronin answered that the budget for the project calls for the City to borrow one million two
hundred thousand dollars ($1,200,000) and that, “with all of the moving parts,” he could not
commit to not borrowing some amount of money to fund the project. He added t hat the City has
committed to contribute one point two million dollars ($1,200,000) to the project, but a funding
source has not yet been identified.
Administrator Tucker stated that the FY18 budget was approved including the borrowing of this
amount of money for the project and that the City’s money would be spent last in hopes of avoiding
the need to borrow. Although she thought the financial picture for the project looked promising,
City Council
August 22, 2017
Page 5 of 13
she was not comfortabl e saying, at this point in time , that the City would not borrow money to
complete the project.
Councilmember Ferencz stated that the stakeholders contributed approximately five million
dollars ($5,000,000), or about one third (⅓), toward a fifteen million dollar ($15,000,000)
renourishment project, but, now that the project will be approximately eleven million nine hundred
thousand dollars ($11,900,000), she asked whether the same percentages applied.
The Mayor explained that Councilmember Ferencz’ numbers did not include the engineering and
permitting costs necessary for the project. The contract of eleven plus million dollars
($11,000,000+) only covers mobilization and demobilization of equipment and dredging sand, but
also included in the total project cost are eight hundred thousand dollars ($800,000) for
engineering and project management and post project monitoring. Mayor Cronin stated that the
total project cost was approximately fourteen million two hundred thousand dollars ($14,200,000).
For the City’s commitment of one point six million dollars ($1,600,000), the Mayor recalled that
the City planned to use a portion of the Beach Preservation Fee Fund , but now that fund has
another year’s collections of approximately one million dollars ($1,000,000). Council must decide
how much of that amount the City will expend for the renourishment project; additionally the post-
project monitoring will be spread over a couple of years. At the time of the monitoring, the City
can decide if those costs were fundable with future revenue in the Beach Preservation Fee Fund.
Councilmember Ferencz urged the Mayor to state that the City was going to have to borrow one
point two million dollars ($1,200,000) for this project, but the Mayor repeated that the amount of
money the City might have to borrow could be less than that figure. In the Councilmember’s
opinion, not doing so would mean that the City was not being financially transparent.
Administrator Tucker stated that the City’s plan was to borrow one point two million dollars
($1,200,000) and, as currently budgeted, the need to borrow the money is still a reality. But, as
the project and cash flow progress, she stated that she would like to bring news to Council that
the City did not have to borrow the money as originally thought.
VOTE: The motion PASSED on a vote of 7 to 2 with Councilmembers Ferencz and
Ward casting dissenting votes.
4. Report in accordance with Chapter 20, Purchasing, Section 1-10-3(c) less
than $25,000 and in the budget
• Award of a contract to Charleston Power Sports in the amount of $12,500
for 1 – 2017 Sea Doo GTI 155 jet ski (State ATAX Fund, pg. 29, ln. 286 – Fire
Department Capital Outlay, $13,000)
Mayor Cronin reported that, during the conversation with Edisto Beach , he had inquired about
how they were impacted financially by Hurricane Matthew and was told that, considering what
they have and expect to receive from FEMA and the Department of Transportation and others,
the total full recovery cost to the City was in a pproximately two hundred fifty thousand dollars
($250,000). In addition, they also saw a reduction in accommodations taxes for a period of about
six (6) weeks; they said that only a couple of residences remain in disrepair. Their
City Council
August 22, 2017
Page 6 of 13
accommodations taxes are stronger this year than in prior years despite the effects of Hurricane
Matthew.
As Vice Chair of the Ways and Means Committee, Councilmember Kinghorn thanked his fellow
Council members in their efforts over the past year to reduce the number of committee meetings
and tightening up of agendas; he stated that there is a real cost in staff time – he took note of the
fact that, in addition to the nine (9) members of Council present at this meeting, at least nine (9 )
staff members were also present. In his opinion, there was also the lost opportunity cost for
department managers in their attendance at Committee meetings that precluded their doing other
things. He also said that, after reviewing committee agendas, h e saw a lot of oversight and less
policy-making. The Councilmember then reads a statement about meetings that concluded by
the writer asking “Have you ever seen a monument erected to the memory of a committee?”
B. Public Safety Committee
From the meeting of August 7 th, Councilmember Bettelli reported that the first item of business
was the request by Cosmic Pictures to film from the beach an IMAX video of the eclipse as it exits
the country as a City-sponsored event; the Committee approved the request. An island resident
spoke to the Committee about encroachments in the right -of-way and his opinion that
enforcement should begin in the construction phase. Chief Buckhannon reported that all of the
overgrown lots originally identified have been cleared and that letters have been sent to property
owners on Cameron and Wills Way. Also discussed were the banning of balloons from the beach
and parking at the Rec Center that will be a part of the after -action discussions at the end of the
season. Councilmember Bettelli praised the staff for their excellent planning and execution of the
event held around the eclipse on Monday; he described the activities as “an excellent family
event.” From the Fire Department report, he stated that the Dep artment responde d to two
hundred (200) calls in July; this was the highest call volume on record. For the Police Department,
officers responded to a call for the discharge of a gun in a local establishment; the subject was
arrested by Mount Pleasant police after barricad ing himself in his vehicle. Officers Molina and
Hardy attended the I OP Recreation Department’s Local Heroes Week at summer camp.
Communication Specialists responded to six thousand five hundred thirty -three (6,533) calls in
July; of that number, five tho usand seventy-nine (5,079) were for the IOP Police Department.
Traffic stops totaled three hundred ninety -eight (398) , and eighty -two (82) of them received
tickets. Fifteen (15) noise complaints were lodged in the month; Three (3) received citations, four
(4) received warnings and eight (8) were determined to be unfounded. Councilmember Bettelli
commended the Police Department on the “Family Night Out” held in conjunction with the
Recreation Department; it was another family-friendly event.
The Public Safety Committee will hold its next meeting at 2:00 p.m., Monday, September 11 th in
the Conference Room.
Referring to the parking problems at the Rec Center, Councilmember Ferencz asked if “NO
PARKING OVERNIGHT” signs could be installed as Councilmember Bergwerf suggested before
the end of the season; she stated that the one (1) piece of heavy equipment parked there has not
moved all summer.
City Council
August 22, 2017
Page 7 of 13
Administrator Tucker stated that her understanding was that no one knew the identity of the heavy
equipment owner, and the equipment had no identifying markings and was not licensed.
C. Public Works Committee
From the regular meeting of August 2 nd, Councilmember Ferencz reported that Jim Burke
presented his case for piping the ditch at the rear of his property, and he ultimately convinced the
Committee that something must be done. The Administrator was authorized to request that David
Stevens provide the Committee with his recommendation and a proposal for piping the ditch. For
the time of year, Public Works monthly report indicated what one would expect, i.e. beach
cleanups were numerous, garbage collections were high and trash collections were l ower. The
Committee continued its discussions about the City’s compactor located behind The Dinghy
relative to short and long-term solutions to the problems cited at the July meeting; Councilmember
Ferencz thanked Directors Kerr and Pitts and the City Administrator for taking action immediately
and for the time necessary to develop the solutions. Councilmember Ward told the Committee
that Brett Jones, owner of The Dinghy, had emailed his thanks to the Committee and the City for
their work in handling the problems associated with the compactor. According to Mr. Jones,
Director Kerr was looking into adding tracks to guide the truck and insure that it is always put in
the proper location when it is returned to the island; Councilmember Ward said that one (1) thing
that needed to be done as soon as possible was to replace the wall around the compactor since
the existing fence is falling apart. The Committee was told that once the final piece of funding for
the Phase II drainage project is in place, the City w ill award the contract; awarding the contract
will start a ten-day period for public comments. Bill Schupp of Schupp Enterprises informed the
Committee that , after seventeen years, he was interested in selling his busines s with the
equipment and that he h as found a buyer. The Administrator stated that an assignment of the
contract must be approved by City Council, and the C ommittee asked that Mr. Schupp bring the
potential buyer to the September meeting to insure that he is fully aware of the City’s expectations
and challenges in keeping the beach clean. Additionally, the Committee looked at the impact of
beach chairs being left in the dunes; they were told that this problem comes up every year.
Typically when the City receives a complaint, Director Kerr contacts the chair rental company and
reports the situation to them; they then work with their employees to stop any reoccurrences.
Unless the issue becomes chronic, the Committee agreed that staff should continue handling the
incidents as they occur in the same manner. The Committee approved a proposal from Bucky
Buckhannon’s company to do a cleanup of the Breach Inlet parking area and beach path.
Undergrowth around the sign at the Carmen R. Bunch Park was discussed as it creates a blind
spot for drive rs of golf cart drivers as they travel from 20 th Avenue toward Harris Teeter and
maneuver around the sign. Administrator Tucker assured the Committee that she would look into
the situation; she also reported that a picnic table and benches have been added to the park.
Councilmember Ward added that the undergrowth continues to create a safety hazard
The next Public Works Committee meeting will be at 11:00 a.m., Wednesday, September 6 th in
the Conference Room.
When the Mayor asked how much garbage had been removed from the beach after the eclipse
event on Monday, Director Pitts stated that Mr. Schupp finished garbage removal at 5:00 a.m.
Councilmember Ferencz noted that Mr. Schupp has been amazingly responsive.
City Council
August 22, 2017
Page 8 of 13
Councilmember Carroll commented that Mr. Schupp has done a “fabulous job” for the City over
the years.
Councilmember Ferencz stated that Mr. Schupp, as an island resident, has been always
accessible and “amazingly responsive,” and she thought it was unlikely that the City would be as
fortunate in the future. The same time, the Committee is being gi ven the opportunity to look into
the future to consider what the City’s need s will be in ten (10) years; she added that the Isle of
Palms is one of few beach communities who have trash receptacles on the beach.
D. Recreation Committee
Councilmember Rice stated that Susan Smith attended the August 2 nd meeting and voiced her
concern over beach cleanup after the eclipse event; therefore, she has organized The Wild Dunes
swim team and their parents to do a beach sweep. Having seen pictures of them at work, she
stated that they removed a large quantity of trash from the beach; Councilmember Rice thanked
them profusely. In the monthly report, Director P age stated that the summer camp season had
been very successful and that staff has been particularly busy with their demanding summer
schedules combined with special events planning and execution, like the eclipse event and 19 th
Annual Halfrubber Tournament, and planning for upcoming events, like the Wellness Fair, Ghostly
Tide Tales, the Halloween carnival and the Holiday Street Festival. In addition, the Committee
reviewed the recommendation from the Recreation Director naming Robert Asero and Ricky
Daugherty as Employees of the Month; Director Page acknowledged the many services they had
performed for the City over and above their regular job responsibilities. Under Old Business the
Committee reviewed and made some recommendations about the architectural renderings of the
proposed fitness room. They also discussed the estimated costs and conserva-tive estimates of
potential revenue from charging for memberships and use by visitors. She noted that the eclipse
event had been “amazing” one for all who attended; she was very proud – she described it as “a
feel-good, wonderful, powerful event.” She noted that the City had received positive exposur e
from CNN and Channel 2; she stated that she could not say “Good job!” enough to the entire City
staff. Parking at the Rec was also a topic of discussion, and the decision was to address it in the
after-action discussions in the fall. Councilmember Rice reported that the City has not been
successful in locating the owner of the backhoe that has been parked at the Rec all summer.
The Recreation Committ ee will meet again at 9:00 a.m. on Wednesday, October 4 th in the
Conference Room.
Mayor Cronin added his voice to those singing the praises of the Recreation Department that took
the lead in organizing the eclipse event; h e noted that the various news agencies on the island
for the eclipse were impressed with the care they were shown while here . He described the
eclipse as “an amazing, once-in-a-lifetime experience.”
Councilmember Ferencz expressed the opinion that the ca lculations of revenue to be generated
by a fitness room were incorrect and over -estimated revenues from memberships. The
calculations were based on the responses to a survey the Recreation Department generated to
determine the interest of the community in having a fitness room on the island, and Director Page
had use the number of responses in each category against a possible charge to develop the
estimated revenue. Councilmember Ferencz stated that each category was counted as one
City Council
August 22, 2017
Page 9 of 13
hundred percent (100%); she contended that responses to the categories of “likely” and “sort of
likely” should not be counted at one hundred percent (100%), but a more realistic percentage.
Councilmember Kinghorn stated that not only do the revenue figures need to be studied, but the
cost of day -to-day expenses was absent; he noted that staff was working on a more
comprehensive budget for the proposed space.
Councilmember Ferencz also asked if the Director had compared the income a nd the cost of a
cardio-fitness space to the cost of a pool, which could provide cardio as well as other healthy
activities and serve a much larger portion of constituents than a fitness room.
E. Personnel Committee
Mayor ProTem Harrington remarked th at the activities surrounding the eclipse were a great
example of coordination and cooperation of City employees; he noted that the City was blessed
with a remarkable staff. He also noted that the Personnel Committee was pleased to support
Director Page’ s recognition of Robert Asero, Parks and Maintenance Supervisor, and Ricky
Daugherty, Parks and Facilities Specialist, for their outstanding work over the entire island and
for assisting other Departments over the summer season. Based on negative comments on social
media posted by residents and Councilmembers, Mayor ProTem Harrington introduced a Code
of Contact for elected and appointed officials; the need and purpose were debated by Committee
member. The City Attorney is drafting a Code of Conduct for IOP councilmembers and appointed
officials that is to include repercussions for those who do not follow the code; Mayor ProTem
Harrington plans to introduce the document to City Council at its September meeting. The only
unfilled position in the City was a p art-time Animal Control Officer for the Police Department.
Safety Sweepstakes winners for July were Amy Lee of the Courts Department, Kenneth Carroll
of the Fire Department, Sgt. Kraig Thompson of the Police Department and John (Rob) Graham
of the Public Works Department.
The next meeting of the Personnel Committee will be at 3:00 p.m., Wednesday, September 6th in
the Conference Room.
Councilmember Ward asked why Mayor ProTem Harrington felt that a Code of Conduct was
needed.
Mayor ProTem Harring ton responded that he believed that members of City Council should be
held to a higher standard and that inappropriate comments made by Councilmembers on social
media have prodded him to investigate a Code of Conduct.
Councilmember Carroll asked the Mayor ProTem Harrington to research such comments and that
he forward these “inappropriate” comments to him; he said that he has not seen anything that
would be in that category. He added that he would be interested to see who was sending such
messages.
Councilmember Kinghorn thought that a Code of Conduct could also serve as a preventative
measure.
City Council
August 22, 2017
Page 10 of 13
Councilmember Ward stated that he would like to see “just one” posting by any Councilmember
that would constitute a violation of a Code of Conduct. He added that City Council could not
control what residents are posting and that politics was a very hot topic on the island currently.
Councilmember Bettelli said that the Personnel Committee was referring to derogatory comments
against other people, and, since he does not engage in such behavior, he has no issues with
signing a Code of Conduct.
Mayor Cronin urged Councilmembers to withhold judgment until they see what the document
says.
Councilmember Ward stated that would have preferred that this subject had been discussed by
Council before incurring legal expenses.
Councilmember Carroll commented that Council talks about saving money and at the same time
is spending money on this kind of research.
Councilmember Kinghorn asked Councilmember Carroll if he was against a Code of Conduct for
social media; he stated that both he and the Mayor suggested that it could be a preventative
measure for things that have or have not happened.
F. Real Property Committee
Reporting on the meeting of August 3 rd, Councilmember Bergwerf reported that Administrator
Tucker announced that the City had a consultant under contract to write the bid specifications;
currently he was studying the City’s procurement code in anticipation of bidding the removal and
replacement of the underground storage tanks. On the subject of the marina bond referendum,
the Committee discussed the need for public education; she commented that staff has looked
back on the information provided to citizens fo r the original referendum as a guide to preparing
information for the funding of the marina revitalization project. Current plans include a mailing to
island citizens with the relevant factual information and two (2) public meetings, one (1) at the
marina and one (1) at the Rec Center. Two (2) pieces of information important for residents to
understand are the benefits to the residents of the marina improvements and that the bonds will
be paid without using property tax revenue paid by the citizens. Residents should also understand
that the City must maintain its asset in the best way possible; some of the docks are thirty (30)
years old and must be replaced. Councilmember Bergwerf reported that the only bidder on the
project for public restroom renovati ons and replacement of the boardwalk came in one hundred
thousand dollars ($100,000) over budget. Consideration of separating the bid into separate
pieces for the restrooms and the boardwalk and making design modifications to the boardwalk to
make them mo re affordable. With the maintenance and improvements made to the restrooms
before the season, the renovations to the building could be postponed for a year if necessary.
The Committee agreed that the painter of the restroom floors needs to come back to r e-do the
job since the paint is peeling and to combine two (2) stalls into one (1) on each side to
accommodate a parent and small child. Under New Business, Assistant Fragoso informed the
Committee of a MASC Hometown Economic Development grant to be used for downtown revita-
lization; staff was suggesting that the City apply for a grant to revitalize Leola Hanbury Park since
it is the gateway to the City. The Committee also discussed that the residential neighbor of Tidal
City Council
August 22, 2017
Page 11 of 13
Wave Watersports has asked the City for years to relocate the business farther from his property;
one (1) possible solution would be for Tidal Wave Watersports move to the Morgan Cre ek Grill
docks and vice versa for next season to give the resid ent relief. A permanent solution will be a
part of the marina revitalization that is several years in the future, and the Committee will continue
to look for the best location. While the Committee was in Executive Session, Dr. Jim Smiley
suggested to Marina Manager Berrigan that plans for the marina revitalization should include a
storage facility for paddleboards and kayaks belonging to island resid ents; Mr. Berrigan and the
Committee endorsed the concept.
The Real Property Committee will meet again at 9:30 a.m., Thursday, September 7 th in the
Conference Room.
Discussion related to future of marina leases
Mayor Cronin stated that he understood that there was an open issue with the Morgan Creek Grill
lease; he asked that staff open a dialogue with Morgan Creek Grill to understand their intentions
based on the condition of the lease as it stands today. After the discussion has started, he
suggested that staff return to Committee to determine if any changes to the lease are warranted
at this time.
MOTION: Mayor Cronin moved for staff to compose a letter to Morgan Creek
Grill concerning the condition of the lease and action in that regard;
Councilmember Bettelli seconded.
Councilmember Rice asked if the subject of the docks could also be introduced in the letter and
that parking be included in future discussions.
VOTE: The motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Councilmember Bergwerf commented that th e Committee also discussed the TidalWave
Watersports lease that expires in 2020 . She stated that they have been the recipient of some
bad press recently and that Council should make a decision and notify them; if the decision is not
to renew because they have outgrown the IOP Marina, the Committee agreed that Council should
also notify them as soon as possible allowing them three (3) years to make other arrangements.
Administrator Tucker noted that the Committee and Council have heard concerns expressed
about the business from the adjacent residential neighbor, and they have heard from others in
the community who are concerned that the business has outgrown that location, as well as
whether that type of business should remain at the marina. Having heard those comments, she
believes that, if Council does not plan to renew the lease, the best course of action would be to
inform the business now, giving them the maximum amount of notice to find an alternate location.
Councilmember Kinghorn suggested having additional dialogue with them to determine what their
plans are and to temporarily relocate them and see how that evolves; he suggested that they may
be willing to reduce their footprint at the marina or make other compromises.
City Council
August 22, 2017
Page 12 of 13
Councilmember Bergwerf explained that, in her opinion, this decision should be made by full
Council and not by the Committee, but she did want to know Council’s positions. She said that
the City is looking at a whole revitalization project with an intent of making it more resident-friendly,
which she interpreted to mean more dock space for residents on a limited footprint.
When the discussion went to the use of the dock space assuming the lease was not renewed and
to traffic and parking, Councilmember Bettelli called “point of order” that the discussion had
digressed from the subject of marina leases.
MOTION: Mayor Cronin moved to notify TidalWave Watersports that the City
does not intend to renew their lease; Councilmember Carroll seconded.
Councilmember Carroll opined that the City has “a marina that has outgrown itself” in that it now
has so many businesses that the parking is overflowing into the neighborhoods.
Councilmember Kinghorn asked if the City has any economic impact data regarding what the
business brings to the island. He pointed out that people come to the island to enjoy activities
provided by TidalWave and might go into the other businesses or they might go to Front Beach
to enjoy a meal. He des cribed Tidal Wave as an economic driver and that, if the City was
considering terminating their lease and creating an opportunity for another business to come in,
it should know what economic impact it will have on the City.
Councilmember Rice said that f ound this to be a “painful” discussion because TidalWave has
been such a good tenant and have provided an opportunity for residents and visitors alike to
experience parasailing and jet skiing, but at the same time, she agreed that they have outgrown
the marina. She expressed confidence that, in three (3) years, they would be able to find another
location where they would be as successful as they have been at the IOP Marina. The
Councilmember suggested that the City reach out to them to determine if they would be interested
in operating a scaled-down version of their current business.
Based on the Council discussion, the Mayor withdrew his motion to allow for further discussion
between the tenant and City staff. Councilmember Carroll also withdrew his second.
Councilmember Carroll stated that contact information for Councilmembers is on the City’s
website and, with one (1) click, someone can contact all of Council.
5. Reports from City Officers, Boards and Commissions
A. Accommodations Tax Advisory Committee – no meeting in August
B. Board of Zoning Appeals – minutes attached
C. Planning Commission – minutes attached
6. Reports from Special or Joint Committees – None
7. Petitions Received, Referred or Disposed of – None
8. Bills Already in Possession of Council – None
City Council
August 22, 2017
Page 13 of 13
9. Introduction of New Bills, Resolutions and Proclamations
Resolution to Support and Approve CARTA FY18 Budget
MOTION: Councilmember Bettelli moved to approve the Resolution to Support
and Approve the CARTA FY18 Budget; Councilmember Rice seconded.
Councilmember Ferencz asked if Council was satisfied with the CARTA service on the island ,
and Councilmember Bettelli recalled that, about three (3) years ago, CARTA t ested a route from
Mount Pleasant to the Isle of Palms and then to Sullivan’s Island. The ridership was very low,
less than five (5) people, and CARTA determined that the ridership was insufficient to support the
route. Councilmember Bettelli informed Council that seventy percent (70%) of the CARTA budget
came from the federal government and th at ridership only contributed thirty percent (30%) . He
reported that CARTA was in the process of acquiring land in North Charleston for parking that
would create t he first park -and-ride for the area; he also noted that the groundbreaking for the
Intermodal Terminal would be on Thursday, August 27th and the public was invited.
VOTE: The motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
10. Miscellaneous Business
Mayor Cronin reminded everyone that the first IOP Farmer’s Market would take place t the County
Park from 4:00 p.m. until 7:00 p.m. on Thursday, August 31st.
Next Meeting Date: 6:00 p.m., Tuesday, September 26, 2017
11. Executive Session
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Oct 13, 2026.