August 15, 2017
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · meeting of Aug 15, 2017 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
WAYS and MEANS COMMITTEE
5:00 p.m., Tuesday, August 15, 2017
The regular meeting of the Ways and Means Committee was called to order at 5:24 p.m.,
Tuesday, August 15, 2017 in Council Chambers of City Hall, 1207 Palm Boulevard, Isle of Palms,
South Carolina. Attending the meeting were Councilmembers Bergwerf, Bettelli, Carroll, Ferencz,
Kinghorn, and Ward, Mayor ProTem Harrington, Mayor Cronin, City Administrator Tucker,
Assistant Administrator Fragoso and Clerk Copeland; a quorum was present to conduct business.
Councilmember Rice was absent.
1. Mayor Cronin cal led the meeting to order and acknowledged that the press and public
were duly notified of the meeting in accordance with the Freedom of Information Act.
2. Approval of Previous Meeting’s Minutes
MOTION: Councilmember Carroll moved to approve the minutes of the regular
meeting of July 18, 2017 as submitted; Councilmember Bettelli seconded and the
motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
3. Citizens’ Comments – None
4. Financial Statements – Treasurer Suggs
A. Financial Statement
Update on Year-end FY17
The Treasurer noted that the first page of the financial reports was a preliminary and unaudited
picture of the state of the City’s finances at the end of FY17; she stated that the General Fund
and other funds of the City were in good shape and cash balances were high as they need to be
to address the very ambitious budget for FY18. She then reviewed the schedule prepared today
that explain the components of the FY17 positive net result in the General Fund of approximately
eight hundred ninety -seven thousa nd three hundred fifty -four dollars ($897,354). The City
received revenues in excess of budget in Property Taxes, Insurance Licenses, Building Permits
and Court Revenues; she noted that Court Revenue includes parking ticket revenue which had a
new contributor as a result of parking violations in the automated municipal parking lots. The
revenue received from grants was not budgeted for; approximately twenty -five hundred dollars
($2,500) was from a PARD grant for the Recreation Department, and the balance was FEMA
reimbursement related to personnel and equipment usage for Hurricane Matthew. The standard
rate for equipment usage includes the type of equipment, the hours of usage for addressing the
damage, fuel and depreciation on the equipment; therefore their reimbursement for equipment is
a very generous amount that more than addresses the City’s actual expenses. The final line of
revenues shows that the parking lots and meters did not meet the amount budgeted; FY17 was
the first full year for the parking lots and staff over -estimated the revenue . Areas where the
expenditures were less than budget were Salaries and Fringes, attributable to the Police
Department operating understaffed for much of the year, vehicle fuel, vehicle maintenance,
utilities, and professional services, attributable primarily to legal fees that were lower than
estimated. In addition to these contributors to the positive net result, the City has yet to receive
the last Local Option Sales Tax collection for FY17; it is expected to be approximately seventy-
five thousand dollars ($75,000).
Ways and Means Committee
August 15, 2017
Page 2 of
Referring to the legal expenses, Administrator Tucker explained that this category includes the
City prosecutor, the bond attorneys, and possibly others in addition to the City Attorney.
Treasurer Suggs stated that auditors would have additional journal entries to make when they do
their field work in mid -September, but she does not anticipate any significantly impacting the
numbers.
As one would expect, the financial statement for the first month of the fiscal year does not include
anything of materi ality because much o f the revenue received in July is for FY17. The City did
collect three hundred fifty -one thousand dollars in revenue from rental licenses and parking l ots
and meters in the General Fund. The target for expenditures was eight percent (8%), and, overall,
the Departments were at six percent (6%); the Treasurer explained that the reason the Mayor and
Council budget was twenty -two percent (22%) expended is that the premium for MeduCare Air
was charged to Citizen and Employee Services in that budget. Cash remained very healthy
through July, again in anticipation of the ambitious FY18 budget.
The Treasurer noted that BS&A, the City’s new financial software vendor, has an ambitious
conversion planned for the City. The initial conference calls have taken place; they will be on-site
at the end of August for discovery-type meetings; they plan to convert ten years of the City’s data
in September. Training will take place in October, and the plan is to go live in November.
The Mayor urged Council to be patient with City staff as it goes through this process , especially
in October when training is occurring.
B. Tourism Schedules
The July collections of Municipal Accommodations Taxes were lower than the same month in
2016 and lower than expected; after review the Treasurer found that one (1) major taxpayer was
missing from the detail and she will do additional follow-up to see if it is a timing issue. The final
quarter of state ATAX was up significantly from FY16, resulting in a three and a h alf percent
(3.5%) increase from last year. The City has strong months in June and July that resulted in the
year ending with an increase of eight percent (8%) over FY16. Like Municipal Accommodations
Taxes, the Beach Preservation Fee fund ended the year flat.
C. Project Worksheets
At the request of the Administrator, discussion of the Beach Restoration worksheet will take place
later in the meeting in coordination with the project bid opening.
On the Public Works Vehicle Wash-down project, two (2) June invoices were paid in July, and the
worksheet has been updated to reflect the change orders approved last month.
When the Mayor inquired of an estimated completion date, the Administrator said that she has
not been given a revised completion date. Although the project is fully funded, the amount of
expense for FY18 will be greater than the amount budgeted.
Ways and Means Committee
August 15, 2017
Page 3 of
On the worksheet for Phase II Drainage, Administrator Tucker recalled that, at the last meeting,
Council authorized award of a contract to the bidder of the project once the City had sufficient
funding; she then directed Council to page 2 of the project worksheet where the shortfall is shown
as five hundred seventy -nine thousand eight hundred ninety-four dollars ($579,894) which is
larger than previously shown. She stated that the City has one hundred ninety-two thousand nine
hundred sixty-eight dollars ($192,968) in reserves in General Drainage and Roads that could be
used; in addition, Char leston County Council will meet on Thursday night and will vote on the
City’s application for an additional one hundred ninety -three thousand dollars ($193,000) in
Transportation Sales Tax (TST) funds. Assuming the County awards those funds, the remaining
shortfall would be one hundred ninety-three thousand nine hundred twenty-six dollars ($193,926).
The Administrator also repeated that the Public Works Committee had instructed staff not to go
into the project without a contingency, and the worksheet contains a contingency of fifteen percent
(15%). After being reminded by the project engineer that Phase I drainage was done without a
contingency, Administrator Tucker suggested that the shortfall be filled with a portion of the
contingency, thereby reducing the contingency for the project to seven percent (7%).
The Administrator stated that she has been reassured by the City’s representative to County
Council that, if the contingency is depleted, the City could go back to County Council with an
application for additional funding.
She reminded Council that Charleston County had followed and provided substantial funding for
the Phase I project, and they have followed and contributed toward Phase II. Administrator Tucker
noted that County Council recogn izes that the City has saved money over time in order to do
these projects and has successfully executed them.
Mayor Cronin stated that the underlying point is that the City asks so little from the County that
they are willing to assist with a worthwhile, quality project.
MOTION: Mayor Cronin moved to authorize staff to proceed with the award of
contract assuming Charleston County awards the TST funds request;
Councilmember Kinghorn seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
5. Old Business – None
6. New Business
A. Update on the Bid for Renovations to the Front Beach Restrooms and
Boardwalk
Administrator Tucker informed the Committee that staff has chosen not to accept the bid and to
re-bid the project. After meeting with the architects, the decision was made to work on the design
elements of the walkover. Since the boardwalk at the public restrooms is designated an
emergency access, it must support the weight of multiple ATVs and must, therefore, be
significantly more structurally sound than a typical dune walkover and those elements drove the
cost up in the bid received. The goal is to alter some of the design elements to reduce the cost
Ways and Means Committee
August 15, 2017
Page 4 of
of construction. Staff will also seek to determine if there is merit in splitting the pro ject into two
(2) separate bids, one (1) each for the restrooms and the boardwalk.
The Administrator commented that, with the work that has been done over recent months, the
public restrooms were in the best conditi on they have been for a long while and, if properly
maintained, the remaining renovations could wait for another year. On the other hand, the
boardwalk is in “terrible shape and definitely needs to be replaced.”
Administrator Tucker reiterated that sta ff hopes that, with design modifications, rebidding the
project will result in a cost that is within the budget established.
Mayor Cronin recalled that, at times, OCRM has one million dollars ($1,000,000) to fund improved
beach accesses, and the Administrator noted that the City has been a recipient of these funds in
the past. The Administrator added that, the last time the City applied for one (1) of these grants,
the process was painful, and the City lost a year’s time. Additionally, staff has found that OCRM
prefers to use the money to fund a traditional access path, wooden and six feet (6 ft.) wide; they
do not tend to fund anything that is out of the ordinary, for instance, the path at 42nd Avenue. The
Administrator suggested this would be a good source of funds for one (1) of the beach accesses
that is flooded currently.
B. Recommendation from the Recreation Committee for award of a contract to
Vic Bailey Ford for one F -150 pickup truck in the amount of $31,834, state
contract pricing
MOTION: Councilmember Ward moved to award a contract to Vic Bailey Ford
as detailed above; Councilmember Bettelli seconded and the motion PASSED
UNANIMOUSLY.
C. Consideration of a contract award to Hunter Powersports LLC for 2 Kawasaki
Mule Pro-FX EPS LE (ATVs) i n the amount of $26,434.96 (cost increased to cover
sales taxes and registration), including accessories, assembly, installation, delivery
and 3-year warranty
Mayor Cronin stated that budget for the ATVs was thirty-four thousand dollars ($34,000).
MOTION: Mayor Cronin moved to award a contract to Hunter Powersports LLC
in the amount of $26,434.96 for the purchase of 2 Kawasaki ATVs as stated above;
Councilmember Ward seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
D. Report on RFB 2017-05 – Beach Renourishment Bid Opening
Administrator Tucker indicated that she had sent Council emails of the bid tabulation and a revised
project schedule that includes the bid numbers from the lowest bidder. Looking at the revised
worksheet, the Administrator recalled that the project was estimated to cost approximately fifteen
million dollars ($15,000,000), which included
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Oct 13, 2026.