July 17, 2017
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · meeting of Jul 17, 2017 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
PUBLIC WORKS COMMITTEE
11:00 a.m., Monday, July 17, 2017
The regular meeting of the Public Works Committee was held at 11:00 a.m., Monday, July 17,
2017 in the City Hall Conference Room, 1207 Palm Boulevard, Isle of Palms, South Carolina.
Attending the meeting were Councilmembers Kinghorn and Ward, Cahir Ferencz, Administrator
Tucker, Assistant Administrator Fragoso, Public Works Director Pitts and Clerk Copeland; a
quorum was present to conduct business.
1. Chair Ferencz cal led the meeting to order and acknowledged that the press and public
were duly notified of the meeting in accordance with the Freedom of Information Act.
2. Approval of Previous Meeting’s Minutes
MOTION: Councilmember Ward moved to approve the minutes of the regular
meeting of June 9, 2017 as submitted; Councilmember Ward seconded and the
motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
3. Citizens’ Comments – None
4. Departmental Reports for June 2017 – Director Pitts
The focus for the month of June was clearing the beach of debr is; Eadies completed the year’s
maintenance plan with ditch restructuring on June 30, 2017. The collections of yard debris were
down slightly from June 2016 due to the department being short a truck for a couple of days, and
household garbage was down a small amount from June 2016. The Director stated that debris
collection was behind and that he planned to run a shift on Saturday. The Director was pleased
to announce that the Department had completed the year under budget in the category of vehicle
maintenance.
5. Old Business
A. Update on NPDES Project
Mark Yodice of Thomas and Hutton was present to inform the Committee on the status of the
project and to review the most recent change order from Hitt C onstruction. The project is
progressing, but is behind schedule; Hitt is now estimating a completion date of July 28
th, but Mr.
Yodice does not believe they will make that date.
According to Mr. Yodice, Change Order #5 from Hitt in the amount of twenty -one thousand four
hundred one dollars ($21,401) is a compilation of several small change orders along with a
request for six (6) additional days due to adverse weather. The components of the change order
are as follows:
• The disposal of unforeseen debris $11,858.00
• Required foundation modification 5,175.00
• Remove and replace soil under footers 2,473.00
• Addition of electric meter (SCE&G) 1,895.00
$21,401.00
Public Works Committee
July 17 2017
Page 2 of 6
If the Committee agrees with the Change Order, it will reduce the contingency to approximately
sixty-one thousand five hundred dollars ($61,500).
Mr. Yodice stated that several credits have been issued by Hitt on the project and they total seven
thousand two hundred eighty dollars ($7,280). He recommended that the galvanized members
not be painted; if this were to be agreed to, it would result in a savings of five thousand seven
hundred fifty dollars ($5,750).
When asked about future change orders, Mr. Yodice stated that Hitt has now asked for extended
overhead based on lengthening the contract forty -nine (49) days in the amount of thirty -two
thousand dollars ($32,000).
Councilmember Kinghorn suggested that the City not approve any additional change orders until
the project was completed.
Administrator Tucker reminded the Committee that the City was paying Thomas and Hutton to
supervise the contract and that, before any change order is presented to the Committee, it has
been thoroughly vetted by Thomas and Hutton.
Responding to Councilmember Kinghorn’s suggestion about withholding payment on change
orders until the project was complete, the Administrator stated it would be counter to the terms of
the contract with Hitt.
When asked about the level of satisfaction with the contractor’s work, both Mr. Yodice and Director
Kerr indicated that they were very satisfied.
MOTION: Councilmember Ward moved to recommend approving Change Order
#5 to the Ways and Means Committee; Councilmember Kinghorn seconded and the
motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY,
B. Update on City compactor
At Councilmember Ward’s request, Brett Jones, owner of The Dinghy, was allowed to join this
discussion since his business operates in close proximity of the compactor.
Chair Ferencz and Councilmember Ward stated that among the items left at the compactor were
a fifty -inch (50 in.) television, mattresses, tires, paint cans, shelving and other miscellaneous
trash. Included in the meeting packet were two (2) drawings showing the compactor moved to
the center of the parking lot behind The Dinghy. Mr. Jones stated that the compactor draws rats
and flies and is a breeding area for mosquitoes and rats and, then there is the odor the materials
in the compactor produce. To offset the cost of relocati ng the compactor, Mr. Jones offered to
lease the current space from the City if the City did not want it for additional parking; the net gain
in parking spaces was seven (7). To reposition the compactor as suggested, people would not
have the opportunity to drop-off the miscellaneous debr is because parking spaces would exist
around it.
Public Works Committee
July 17, 2017
Page 3 of 6
Director Pitts reported that three (3) recycle bins were in the parking lot as well as a grease trap;
he stated that he has contacted the County about moving them closer to the businesses in hopes
that they will be used more. Currently the employees who take the waste to the compactor are
comingling it with recyclables and dumping it all in the compactor because it is clo ser than the
recycling bins.
Councilmember Kinghorn suggested that a comprehensive maintenance plan should be initiated
for both the compactor and the area surrounding it before any actions were taken to relocate the
compactor. He asked if the City could do more and do it better in an effort to rid Mr. Jones of the
problems.
Councilmember Ward reported that the enclosure for the compactor was too large, allowing
people to dump these large items there; he indicate that the enclosure for the compactor should
be made of concrete blocks and only large enough for the compactor.
Administrator Tucker opined that, in order to get the compactor and surrounding area acceptable,
an attendant must be on duty from 7:30 a.m. to clean up what was left the night before and to
remain there throughout the day. Without an attendant, maintenance would be done when the
Public Works Director has managed to “manufacture time” or to deal with a problem when it
happens.
Responding to the Chair, Administrator Tucker stated that, to move the compactor would involve
a survey of the site, check for permitting requirements , construction of a new pad and fencing,
removal and disposal of the existi ng pad and fencing and the rehabilitation of the existing site.
She added that this was a task that the City should plan for and include in the next budget cycle;
she asked that the Committee consider moving the compactor to the middle of the parking lot
since doing so would inhibit a future change in use. In the interim, the City could construct a
concrete wall, add camera surveillance and arrange to keep the area clean.
MOTION: Councilmember Ward moved to authorize staff to explore
improvement(s) to the compactor and its location; Councilmember Kinghorn
seconded.
Councilmember Ward stated that the compactor and the surrounding area create a public health
hazard as they are today.
AMENDMENT: Councilmember Kinghorn amended the motion to include
exploration of a comprehensive plan for maintenance at the existing location;
Councilmember Ward seconded.
Chair Ferencz commented that staff seemed to come up with money for other items not included
in the budget and she thought they could find the money for this project as well.
According to Director Pitts, the new landscaper’s area of responsibility ends at the recycling
dumpsters, but he thought the compactor area could be added to their responsibilities to get
weekly attention and not to be dependent on Public Works.
Public Works Committee
July 17, 2017
Page 4 of 6
Mr. Jones stated that something must be done about the compactor because the fencing is falling
down and the gate no longer closes. He expressed the opinion to make those corrections in the
current location will not eliminate his problems.
VOTE on AMENDMENT: The amendment PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
VOTE on AMENDED MOTION: The amended motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
MOTION: Councilmember Kinghorn moved for Director Pitts and staff to come
to the next meeting with a plan to improve the current situation; Councilmember
Ward seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
C. Results of RFB 2017-03 – Phase II Drainage and update on project
Administrator Tucker stated that the City received four (4) bids on this project, and the bids ranged
from two million three hundred eighty -one thousand dollars ($2,381,000) to three million six
hundred seventeen thousand dollars ( $3,617,000) – all of which were over -budget. The City’s
project engineer, Civil Site Environmental (CSE), is currently vetting the low bidder as well as
meeting with them. Included in meeting packets were the project worksheet which shows the
construction budget to be one million eight hundred seventy thousand seven hundred thirty dollars
($1,870,730) without a contingency. If that amount were to be compared to either the low or
second low bid, the City needs to find either five hundred ten thousand dollars ($510,000) or five
hundred ninety-seven thousand dollars ($597,000). If the contingency were added in, the gap is
a little less concerning at two hundred twenty -two thousand dollars ($222,000) when looking at
the lowest bid. A portion of that difference can come out of fund balance in this year’s budget in
the line “General Drainage for Roads and Assigned Fund Balance.” In addition, the Administrator
spoke with the person managing CTC and TST funds for Charleston County who suggested that
the City submit an amended request adding the drainage project. They will present the request
for TST funds to County Council in August; they have one hundred ninety-three thousand dollars
($193,000) available. If the City is awarded those funds, the balance of the gap can come from
the fund balance in the line item identified previously; the Administrator reiterated that taking these
actions leaves no contingency for the project. She also pointed out that the timing of this project
is critical since the construction of the outfall will require that a section of the gol f course in Wild
Dunes be closed for a period of time, and the five hundred thousand dollar ($500,000) Rural
Infrastructure Grant has a time limit on its use.
The project is expected to take six or seven months (6-7 mos.) with starting in August and
completing in February or March 2018. Director Pitts said that the project should have an
indefinite life span with proper maintenance.
The Administrator was not looking for the Committee to take action today since the engineer is
still vetting the bids.
The Committee was adamant that the City should not enter into this project with no contingency.
D. Drainage issues on Hartnett Boulevard between 29
th and 30th Avenues
Public Works Committee
July 17, 2017
Page 5 of 6
The Administrator stated that they do not want the ditch re-opened; for them, that is not a viable
alternative. The Administrator, therefore, thought an engineer should evaluate the problem,
design the solution and estimate the cost for the solution; maybe this could be the next drainage
project. Beyond that, she thought the City has done all it can at this time.
MOTION: Chair Ferencz moved to add an item to the Agenda relative to the
parking of Eadies’ trucks; Councilmember Kinghorn seconded and the m otion
PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Director Pitts reported that Eadies parks its vac trucks in the SCDOT right-of- way on the
Connector side of the Harris Teeter parking lot; he stated that he got a complaint last week from
the manager of the shopping center with the Beach Company that the trucks were parked too
close to the picnic tables Harris Teeter has for its employees. He had Eadies move the trucks
closer to the Connector and well inside the SCDOT right-of-way. When she called again today,
the Director infor med her that the trucks were in SCDOT right-of-way, not on Beach Company
property, but he has decided to relocate them. He plans to park the trucks in the back area of the
municipal parking lot during the week and behind the Rec Center over the weekends in an attempt
to work with the Beach Company.
Councilmember Kinghorn stated that, as elected officials, their role was to provide oversight and
to set policy, he has observed that the Committee’s agendas tend to lean more toward oversight.
He opined that there were longer term policy decisions they could focus on and not take up as
much staff time; therefore, he would prefer to see future agendas dealing with more policy issues.
He stated that such policy issues could be pathways could be constructed connecting the beach
access paths, dealing with stormwater issues, etc.
7. Miscellaneous Business
Discussion of future representation at IOP Water and Sewer Commission meetings
Chair Ferencz recalled that this subject came up at a City Council meeting and that
Councilmember Bettelli mentioned that, when he was Chair of the Public Works Committee, he
attended IOP Water and Sewer Committee meetings. She stated that, personally, she did not
think a member of City Council should be present at their board meetings unless they were going
to discuss or consider an issue of import to the entire City . She was concerned that the
Commissioners would interpret the Councilmember’s attendance as a voice representing the City
and ask him/her questions he could not answer since he was not representing the opinion of City
Council. She then asked Councilmember Kinghorn what his reasoning was for making the
request.
Councilmember Kinghorn expressed the opinion that Council should be engaged, and more
importantly be informed about what they were doing; he thought the lack of attendance sen t a
message of indifference to the Commis sion. Since they set policy regarding a major part of the
City’s infrastructure, he stated that he wanted more information and what could be done to build
a relationship with them. The Councilmember stated that Council was acting in a vacuum; he
wants an information flow.
Public Works Committee
July 17, 2017
Page 6 of 6
MOTION: Councilmember Kinghorn moved for someone from the Public Works
Committee attend all IOP Water and Sewer Commission meetings; Councilmember
Ward seconded and the motion FAILED on a vote of 1 to 2 with Councilmember
Ward and Chair Ferencz casting dissenting votes.
Next Meeting Date: 11:00 a.m., Wednesday, August 2, 2017
8. Adjournment
MOTION: Councilmember Ward moved to adjourn the meeting at 12:35 p.m.;
Councilmember Kinghorn seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Respectfully submitted:
Marie Copeland
City Clerk
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Oct 13, 2026.