Minutes
City of Orangeburg · Orangeburg County · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Orangeburg
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
A RESOLUTION TO SUPPORT THE MUNICIPAL ASSOCIATION
2018 LEGISLATIVE ADVOCACY INITIATIVES
BE IT RESOLVED, cities and towns in South Carolina are the government closest to the
people providing the core services residents and businesses demand for
an exceptional quality of life; and,
WHEREAS,
WHEREAS,
WHEREAS,
WHEREAS,
WHEREAS,
WHEREAS,
WHEREAS,
WHEREAS,
WHEREAS,
hundreds of municipal officials from across the state collaborated to
identify challenges at the municipal level; and,
these challenges can be addressed through a 'comprehensive approach
that includes changes to state law, training from experts, research and
collaboration with stakeholders; and,
the Municipal Association identified five advocacy initiatives based on the
feedback from local officials including encouraging business growth and
development, providing quality municipal services, increasing funding for
law enforcement, expanding funding sources for infrastructure and
reducing blight; and,
implementing business licensing practices that save businesses time and
supports local economic growth; and,
cities and towns need dependable and consistent revenue sources to
support the efficient and effective delivery of municipal services; and,
supporting reliable funding for the Criminal Justice Academy in order to
make more training opportunities available to law enforcement officers,
increasing funding for body-worn cameras and equipping cities with the
tools to meet challenges created by the opioid epidemic. Increased
funding for quality training will result in safer streets and communities;
and,
repairing and maintaining existing roads and infrastructure is about
encouraging and supporting statewide economic development with
infrastructure that cari accommodate new industry and support existing
industry; and,
dilapidated structures pose a public safety threat in municipalities of all
sizes; and,
the City of Orangeburg supports the agenda set forth by the Municipal
Association of South Carolina Board of Directors for city and town
councils to govern effectively and efficiently.
BE IT, THEREFORE, RESOLVED that the Council of the City of Orangeburg affirm on this 16th
day of January 2018, its support for the Municipal Association's 2018 advocacy initiatives for the
state's 270 cities and towns.
DONE AND RATIFIED THIS 16th DAY OF JANUARY 2018: . . : ~
Jf.tri--w./1 c-
· .... ii::::=..
~EST:
I vciv. f.
··2686
City Council Minutes
January 16, 2018
Orangeburg City Council held its regularly scheduled City Council Meeting on Tuesday, January
16, 2018, at 7 :00 P .M., in Council Chambers with Mayor Butler presiding.
PRESENT:
Michael C. Butler, Mayor
Bernard Haire
Jerry Hannah
Charles W. Jernigan
L. Zimmerman Keitt
Sandra P. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
Mayor Butler acknowledged that Mr. Jeff Ruth, Hillcrest Golf Course Manager, has resigned to
accept another position. The City wishes him well.
A motion was made by Councilmember Stroman, seconded by Councihnember Haire, to approve
the December 19, 2017, City Council Minutes, as distributed. This motion was unanimously
approved.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, seconded by Councihnember Knotts, to approve
the January 9, 2018, Special City Council Minutes, as distributed. This motion was unanimously
approved.
Department of Public Safety Director Mike Adams accepted the Character Trait Proclamation for
the month of January, 2018, "Cheerfulness".
A motion was made by Councihnember Haire, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, to approve a
Resolution to support the Municipal Association 2018 Legislative Advocacy Initiatives. This
motion was unanimously approved.
City Administrator John Yow overviewed the Appointments to Boards and Commission. He
stated, "Council has the prerogative to make nominations tonight, if prepared, or we can put this
item on the February 6, 2018, Agenda."
Councilmember Hannah (District #3) made a motion, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, to
appoint Ms. Phyllis Pelzer to the Aviation Commission for a four ( 4) year term expiring January,
2022.
Councihnember Jernigan asked Councilmember Hannah, "What is her background."
Councihnember Hannah replied, "She is an engineer that teaches in the public schools and is an
adjunct professor at South Carolina State University and now she is at South Carolina
Department of Transportation."
This was a 5-1-1 vote, as Councilmembers Jernigan opposed and Councilmember Stroman
abstained.
Mayor Pro Tern Keitt (District #5) made a motion, seconded by Councilmember Jernig~,_to
reappoint Mr. Kevin Bell to the Aviation Commission for another four ( 4) year term expmng
January, 2022. This motion was unanimously approved.
Page2
2687
Mayor Butler (At Large) made a motion to reappoint Colonel Richard Leonard to the Aviation
Commission for another four ( 4) year term expiring January, 2022. This motion was
unanimously approved.
Councilmember Stroman (District # 1) made a motion, seconded by Councilmember Haire, to
reappoint Mr. George Buck to the Board of Zoning Appeals for another four ( 4) year term
expiring January, 2022.
Councilmember Hannah (District #3) made a motion, seconded by Councilmember Haire, to
appoint Ms. Elaine Wright to the Board of Zoning Appeals for a four ( 4) year term expiring
January, 2022. Councilmember Jernigan asked Councilmember Hannah, "What is her
background?"
Councilmember Hannah replied, "She is a community activist that is retired from the public
schools."
This motion was unanimously approved.
Mayor Pro Tern Keitt (District #5) made a motion, seconded by Councilmember Haire, to
reappoint Willie Brown to the Board of Zoning Appeals for another four ( 4) year term expiring
January, 2022. This motion was unanimously approved.
Mayor Butler (At Large) made a motion, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, to reappoint Mr.
LaNard Huggins to the Board of Zoning Appeals for another four ( 4) year term expiring January,
2022. This motion was unanimously approved.
Councilmember Stroman (District # l) made a motion, seconded by Councilmember Haire, to
reappoint Mr. Guy Best to the Planning Commission for another four ( 4) year term expiring
January, 2022. This motion was unanimously approved.
Councihnember Hannah (District #3) made a motion, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, to
appoint Ms. Paula Payton to the Planning Commission for a four ( 4) year term expiring January,
2022. This motion was unanimously approved.
Mayor Pro Tern Keitt (District #5) made a motion, seconded by Councilmember Haire, to
reappoint Mr. Bill Barrett to the Planning Commission for another four ( 4) year term expiring
January, 2022. This motion was unanimously approved.
Mayor Butler (At Large) made a motion, seconded by Councihnember Haire, to reappoint Dr.
Shirlan Moseley-Jenkins to the Planning Commission for another four ( 4) year term expiring
January, 2022. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Stroman, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, to
reappoint Mr. G. W. Berry and Mr. Louis Boone, to the Building Board of Appeals for another
four ( 4) year term expiring January, 2022. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, seconded by Councihnember Knotts, to reappoint
Mr. Linton Davis and Mr. Michael Stroman, as alternates, to the Building Board of Appeals for
another four ( 4) year term expiring January, 2022. This motion was unanimously approved.
There were no Department of Public Utilities matters brought before Council.
Page 3
2688
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Counci lmember Knotts, to enter into
an Executive Session for (1) Legal Matters, concerning (a) Intergovernmental Agreement
Municipal Court/Orangeburg County and (b) Ground Lease for Hangar Construction-
Orangeburg Municipal Airport and (2) Sale of Real Property, (a) Old City Gym at 1420
Broughton Street.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Knotts , to return to
Open Session. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Councilmember Hannah, to approve
the First Reading of an Ordinance to lease real property at the Orangeburg Municipal Airport to
Green Mountain Boys, LLC. This will be a Ground Lease for thirty (30) years and a 10,000
square foot hangar will be constructed to house two planes. This motion was unanimously
approved.
No action was taken on Item 10, Approval Intergovernmental Agreement - Municipal
Court/Orangeburg County.
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, to adjourn.
This motion was unanimously approved.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
/pfb
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
February 6, 2018
2689
Orangeburg City Council held its regularly scheduled City Council Meeting on Tuesday,
February 6, 2018, at 7:00 P.M., in Council Chambers with Mayor Butler presiding.
PRESENT:
Michael C. Butler, Mayor
Bernard Haire
Jerry Hannah
Charles W. Jernigan
SandraP. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
ABSENT:
L. Zimmerman Keitt
A motion was made by Councilmember Stroman, seconded by Councilmember Knotts, to
approve the January 16, 2018, City Council Minutes as distributed. This motion was
unanimously approved.
Mayor Butler, Department of Public Utilities Manager Warren Harley and Director ofDPU
Electric Division Wade Holmes, presented John H. Fields a Retiree Resolution and gold watch
for bis thirty-four years, one month and twenty-two days of service to the Department of Public
Utilities.
Ms. Candice Roberson, Executive Director with Downtown Orangeburg Revitalization
Association (DORA) addressed Council. She stated, "There were many successes in 2017, there
were eight (8) free events held Downtown. Twelve (12) businesses participated in these events.
There was a first Farm to Table Dinner held in downtown Orangeburg. Overall, there were
1,000 volunteer hours to coordinate these events. Tea Thyme had. a new addition of a courtyard.
Memberships have increased and we have had an increase in pedestrian activity. In 2018, we
have developed a work plan for the community that will be unveiled at our annual meeting in
conjunction with Business Ailer Hours on February 27th. There will be a car show on April 1,
2018, and we will be working on a small grant program in 2018. We received a parcel of land in
2017, and we will be building a pavilion to house our Farmer's Market. I would like to request
that at our next event, which is the St. Patrick's Day Festival, to be held on Friday, March 16,
2018, that we allow the sale of alcoholic beverages on City property."
A motion was made by Councilmember Stroman, seconded by Councilmember Haire, to allow
for the sale of alcoholic beverages on City property at the St. Patrick's Day Festival on Friday,
March 16, 2018. This motion was unanimously approved.
Concerning Second Reading of an Ordinance, City Administrator John Yow stated, "This is a
Second Reading of an Ordinance to Lease Real Property at the Orangeburg Municipal Airport to
Green Mountain Boys, LLC. It is a grounds lease for constructing a hangar that is 10,000 square
feet. It is for a thirty (30) year term and rent adjustments are made at ten (10) year interval.s.
This has been sent to the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) for approval and we hope to
have an answer back from them before the Third Reading."
A motion was made by Councilmember Jernigan, seconded by Council~ember Haire, to approve
the Second Reading of an Ordinance to Lease Real Property at the Orangeburg Municipal
Airport to Green Mountain Boys, LLC. This motion was unanimously approved.
Ms. Evelyn Disher, Executive Director for the Community of Character, accepted the Character
Trait Proclamation for February, 2018, "Honesty".
Page2
2690
City Administrator John Yow overviewed the Recreation Complex. He stated, "As you know,
we have approved a contract to construct the new Recreation Complex. We will have an
official groundbreaking on February 15th . The lighting was a separate contract and the bids are
shown and the low bid is Tecbline at $1,181,510 with a ten (10) year warranty. We opted for the
ten year warranty instead of the twenty-five year warranty because of how quickly technology
changes and we can also extend an additional fifteen years. Tecbline has installed lighting at high
school, municipal, collegiate, and professional levels. They want this to be the flagship for
municipal governments in South Carolina. This lighting system is LED and this also gives us
flexibility to control lights remotely and to adjust them as necessary. I am confident to proceed
with this company. We will be bringing back a revenue bond for Council's approval."
A motion was made by Councilmember Stroman, seconded by Councilmember Hannah, to
approve giving authorization to City Administrator John Yow to purchase a LED lighting
system for the Recreation Complex in the amount of$1,181,510 from Tecbline Sports Lighting.
This motion was unanimously approved.
City Administrator Yow stated, "I will also note that the LED lighting will cut our lighting load
about 50% and we will need a reduced number of poles and fixtures that will also reduce the
wind load. We want to build this right the first time."
Councilmember Stroman stated, "I noticed that this is about $150,000 less th~ was projected in
the budget and you should be commended for that."
There were no utility matters brought before Council.
A motion was made by Councilmember Stroman, seconded by Councilmember Haire, to
adjourn. This motion was unanirnol,lsly approved.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
/p±b
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
February 20, 2018
2691
Orangeburg City Council held its regularly scheduled City Council Meeting on Tuesday,
February 20, 2018, at 7:00 P.M., in Council Chambers with Mayor Butler presiding.
PRESENT:
Michael C. Butler, Mayor
Bernard Haire
Jerry Hannah
Charles W. Jernigan
L. Zimmerman Keitt
SandraP. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
A motion was made by Councilmember Stroman, seconded by Councilmember Haire, to approve
the February 6, 2018, City Council Minutes as distributed. This was a 6-0-1 vote, as Mayor Pro
Tern Keitt was not present at the last meeting.
Ms. Jeanne Gue and Ms. Jeanna Reynolds made an appearance before Council concerning a
Downton Project.
Ms. Jeanne Gue of 270 Mason Drive addressed Council. She stated, "As I travel to Charleston, I
take back roads and as I did last year around July 4'\ I noticed all the small towns had American
Flags in their downtowns. I know last year there were small flags in the square which was great.
What I am asking tonight is permission from the City to have flags hung from Russell Street and
the square from the week after the Rose Festival throughout June and July donated by members
of the Community. These members have a vested interest and these flags can be hung in honor
or memory of someone. I have spoken to the Times and Democrat and they will do an article on
this before the event. However, the light poles are hard to hang anything on so I called Parks &
Recreation and they referred me to the Department of Public Utilities. DPU has rods to hang
from the poles and we are asking permission to move forward with this. The flags will be made
locally at Carolina Visuals, a flag plant in Smoaks, SC. Once we get the design of the flag, we
will bring it back to you for approval. The cost of the flags will be approximately $30 to $35
each."
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "Where can we sign up for a flag?"
Ms. Gue replied, "I will send you a form."
Councilmember Hannah stated, "This is a well thought out plan. My vehicle has American flags
on it. Is this for beautification or patriotism?"
Ms. Gue replied, "Both."
A motion was made by Councilmember Stroman, seconded by Councilmember Hannah, to
approve the request to hang flags from Russell Street and the Town Square from the week after
the Rose Festival throughout June and July. Flags to be donated by members of the Community.
This motion was unanimously approved.
Ms. Melinda Jackson, President of the Orangeburg County Chamber of Commerce, made an
appearance before Council concerning the Soft Skills Program. She stated, "My appearance
tonight is two-fold. First of all, I would like permission from City Council to allow the Chamber
to sell alcohol, (no liquor) as we did last year, during the Rose Festival on May 5th from 2:00
until 6:00 P.M. We had no issues last year and we will have two bands performing."
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Haire, to approve
the sale of alcohol during th.e Rose Festival on May 5th. This motion was unanimously approved.
Ms. Jackson asked if this could be approved from here on out and City Attorney Walsh replied
that it would have to be done by Resolution.
Page2
Ms. ~(ij]assed out information to Mayor and Council regarding workforce initiatives. She
has been working in local high schools and will be moving this to middle and elementary school
levels.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Haire, to approve
the Third Reading of an Ordinance to Lease Real Property at the Orangeburg Municipal Airport
to Green Mountain Boys, LLC. This motion was unanimously approved.
There were no utility matters brought before Council.
A motion was made by Councilmember Stroman, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, to enter
into an Executive Session for (1) Economic Development, (a) Project Recycle, (b) Project Halo,
(c) State Infrastructure Bank/Site Readiness, (d) Project Oz and (e) Project Global, (2) Legal
Matter (a) GKN Contractual Matter, (3) Purchase of Real Property, (a) Discussion on purchase
of real property- YMCA Tract, and (4) Personnel Matter, (a) Municipal Court Judge Hiring
Process Position.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
/pfb
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
MARCH 6, 2018
2693
Orangeburg City Council held its regularly scheduled City Council Meeting on Tuesday, March
6, 2018, at 7 :00 P .M. in Council Chambers with Mayor Butler presiding.
PRESENT:
Michael C. Butler, Mayor
Bernard Haire
Jerry Hannah
Charles W. Jernigan
L. Zi=ennan Keitt
Sandra P. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Stroman, to approve
the February 20, 2018, City Council Minutes as distributed. This motion was unanimously
approved.
Chief Adams addressed Council in regards to the SC Overdose Prevention Act. He stated,
"LEON stands for Law Enforcement Officer Narcan. LEON's goal is to provide comprehensive
training to law enforcement agencies across South Carolina that focuses on the identification, the
treatment and the reporting of drug overdoses attributed to opiates/opioids, such as heroin and
narcotic pharmaceutical drugs. The program was created pursuant to the 2015 passing of the
South Carolina Overdose Prevention Act (SC Code Section 44-130-60). The Act seeks to grant
i=unity from both civil and criminal prosecution, to doctors, pharmacists, caregivers and first
responders who are engaged in the prescription, dispensation and administration of Naloxone
(Narcan) in an opioid-overdose suspected case. Drug overdose is currently the leading cause of
accidental death in the United States with 62,497 lethal drug overdoses in 2016, or an average of
one life every eight and one-half minutes. In 2016, there were 5 .2 million opioid prescriptions
dispensed in South Carolina (Population 4,961,119). In 2016, there were 366 murders in South
Carolina but 616 opioid deaths, so this is 616 opioid related deaths versus 366 murders. Narcan
usage is on the rise with 4,197 incidents in 2014 versus 7,278 incidents in 2017. Thi.sis a 48%
increase since 2013 in EMS administration ofNarcan. For many reasons, EMS is usually not the
first emergency responder to the scene of medical emergencies. The average current response
time for EMS to all 911 calls in South Carolina is 11.9 minutes. The average response time for
fire departments running medical first response is 6.41 minutes and the average law enforcement
response time is usually 3-5 minutes, depending on the setting (rural/urban/suburban). To date,
LEON has trained over 4,300 officers in 140 agencies in thirty-five counties with 217
deployments and 196 lives saved. The program offers for free the training, the online reporting
portal, access to DHEC pharmacies, statewide standing orders by a physician to carry and
administer the Narcan. LEON was awarded a Federal SAMHSA Grant to continue the program
and to purchase Narcan for the program. Unless a LEON agency chooses another Narcan product
from the one we provide, there is no other cost. LEON program emphasizes tactics and safety.
There may be situations where it may not be safe to use Narcan. It is 100% up to the individual
officer's discretion. Because of the high potency of the illicit fentanyl and opioid analogues, we
reco=end officers to carry N arcan to save fellow officers who inadvertently come in contact or
inhale the powdered forms. The dosage and route given by LEON is enough to keep an
overdosed person breathing and alive. None of the 217 deployments to date have resulted in a
problem and data from other states concur. Narcan can also save a canine officer's life.
Powdered opioids like fentanyl and carfentanil can be inhaled by them as well as it can be
absorbed through the pads on their feet. A first responder may administer an Opioid antidote in
an emergency if the first responder believes in good faith that the person is experiencing an
Opioid overdose. The first responder must comply with all applicable requirements for
possession, administration and disposal of the opioid antidote and administration device. The
Department (DHEC) may promulgate regulations to implement this section, including
Page2
appr~aining for first responders who carry or have access to an opioid antidote. A first
responder who administers an opioid antidote in accordance with the provisions of this section to
a person whom the first responder believes in good faith is experiencing an opioid overdose is
not by an act or omission subject to civil or criminal liability or to professional disciplinary
action.
Councilmember Haire asked, "How many officers are trained to administer this?"
Chief Adams replied, "We have two certified instructors now and we will get all of our officers
trained. It is a container that is put in the nostril and squeezed to release the Narcan and EMS is
called to follow up."
Mayor Pro Tern Keitt asked, "You stated, you :cu-e seeing an increase?"
Chief Adams replied, "Yes, the serious problems in the past have been cocaine and it is now
shifting to heroin, fentanyl, and opioids. People may start out with a prescription and get
addicted and then go outside for these drugs."
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "What ages do you see in this abuse?"
Chief Adams responded, "Generally, ages 16-35 and all walks oflife."
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "Are you working with SC State University and Claflin
University on this since it is right in that age group?"
Chief Adams responded, "Not yet, but we will try to get them to come to our training."
Councilmember Haire asked, "I hope you will reach out to the infirmaries on the campuses also."
Chief Adams replied, "Any first responders are eligible to get this training and product;
however, it is best to call Law Enforcement whenever something may happen on campus as we
will get there quicker."
Deputy Director of Public Safety, Ed Conner addressed Council in regards to the Orangeburg
Safe Communities Initiative. Director Conner stated, "The Orangeburg Safe Communities is a
unified, proactive police and community collaboration that engages, educates and empowers
repeat serious offenders ( on probation) to obtain assistance, change behavior, make healthy life
choices or suffer consequences of unified police/prosecutorial focus and priority. This focused
deterrence model creates an appropriate mix of legal and ethical pressure to change offender
behavior, reduce recidivism, severity and reduce victimization. Orangeburg Safe Communities
Focused Deterrent addresses crime violence through research-based problem solving strategies
and partnerships among local, state and federal law enforcements, local governments and a
variety of community organizations and partners. It identifies individuals to participate in the
program through established criteria. Offenders will be selected by a Board made up of
members of the law enforcement community and civilians. A lot of the agencies involved are
SLED; Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Fire Arms and Explosives; US Justice Department Drug
Enforcement Administration; SC Department of Probation, Parole and Pardons Services; SC
Department of Corrections; Orangeburg Department of Public Safety; Department of Justice US
Marshall; South Carolina Highway Patrol; Department of Justice Bureau of Investigations;
Orangeburg County Sheriffs Office; Holly Hill Police Department; North Police Department
Santee Police Department and the Eutawville Police Department. The Call-In is selected
offenders that are · informed by both the law enforcement community and the citizens of the
community that they must change their behavior in order to remain in the community. Through
the network of community organizations they are offered help in job training, housing, religious
guidance, counseling, etc. The final step and most important, is to follow through with the
services and promises made at the call-in. A civilian coordinator (working with Probation, Parole
and Pardon) ensures that each offender receives the assistance they need by referring them to the
community organization best equipped to meet their individual needs. We are partnering with
many agencies such as: CASA Family Systems; CPM Federal Credit Union; Family Solutions of
the Low Country; SC Regional Housing Authority; Palmetto Goodwill; OC Tech, South
Page3
Carolina Department of Probation; Parole and Pardons Services; National Fatherhol~~ve;
SC Works; NewVision; the Dawn Center; Vocational Rehabilitation and the SC Department of
Corrections. Our first call-in is March 14, 2018, at 6:00 P.M. in the City Council Building, 633
Middleton Street, Orangeburg, SC.''
Ms. Evelyn Disher, Community of Character Executive Director, accepted the Community
Character Trait Proclamation for the month of March, 2018, "Perseverance".
There were no utility matters brought before Council.
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, to enter into
an Executive Session for (1) Legal Matter ~Luther Batiste III, Opioid Ligation, (2) Discussion of
proposed contractual arrangements, purchase of real property and legal matters TMP# 0184-00-
01-040.000 (US Hwy 21), (3) Proposed location, expansion and provision of services for
industries -- Tri-County Co-Op Property (US Hwy 601) and (4) Legal Matter-Public Service
Commission Intervention (SCANA-Dominion Energy).
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
Res ectfully submitted,
2696
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
MARCH 20, 2018
Orangeburg City Council held its regularly scheduled City Council Meeting on Tuesday, March
20, 2018, at 7 :00 P .M., in Council Chambers with Mayor Butler presiding.
PRESENT:
Michael C. Butler, Mayor
Bernard Haire
Jerry Hannah
Charles W. Jernigan
Sandra P. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
ABSENT:
L. Zimmerman Keitt
A motion was made by Councihnember Stroman, seconded by Councilmember Knotts, to
approve the March 6, 2018, City Council Minutes as distributed. This was a 6-0 vote as Mayor
Pro Tern Keitt was not present.
Mr. Stanley Montgomery of 1168 Douglas McArthur Street addressed Council requesting
construction of a skating park. He stated, "I would like to ask for a proposal for a skate park.
(All supporters stood up.) There are many that are not here that want this to happen. This is a
community effort and there are reasons and purposes for this proposal. (1) A skate park reduces
illicit behavior for juveniles and negative behavior. There are not many activities or programs
available for my age. (2) A skate park provides a safe place to skate. Common injuries are
collisions with motor vehicles, falls or trips. (3) A skate park reduces destruction to private
property. Most people do not want people to skate near their homes. (4) A skate park promotes
physical activity and more physical exercise. ( 5) A skate park would provide different exposure.
If you are not into baseball, soccer or football, this is another option. There are many types of
obstacles that are needed for a skate park. We would need ledges, flat bars, half pikes and some
other flat surfaces."
Councihnember Haire asked, "Have you run this by Parks & Recreation?"
Mr. Montgomery replied, "Yes;they stated I need to come to Council."
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "Where do you want to build it?"
Mr. Montgomery replied, "There is a location at 897 Russell Street that is abandoned and has
gravel areas."
Councihnember Jernigan asked, "You want the City to build it? How much would this cost?"
Mr. Montgomery replied, "Yes, and it would probably be about $10K for new concrete, ramps
and ledges."
Councihnember Hannah asked, "Do you skateboard around SC State University?"
Mr. Montgomery replied, "No, we skate near the bus station."
Councilmember Hannah replied, "You are on point with what you are saying and I agree this
will give kids another option as a project. I represent District 3 and I am delighted that you
came before us and to allow another opportunity."
Mayor Butler responded, "Thank you and we will take this under advisement."
City Administrator John Yow overviewed the City's FY 2018-19 Budget Calendar which was
given to Council as information only at this time. Councilmembers were requested to review
their respective calendars and notify City Administrator Yow of any conflicts prior to the next
Council meeting. Consideration for approval of the Budget Calendar will be on the April 3,
2018, City Council Agenda.
Page3
Counc~ Jernigan replied, "We did vote, 5-1."
Councilmember Knotts asked, "Is it possible to review the Section of the Ordinance that we have
now?"
City Administrator Yow replied, "Come by the office and we will be glad to provide that section
of the code."
City Administrator Yow stated, "We do not allow smoking at our facilities now."
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "What precipitated this Ordinance?"
City AdministratorYow stated, "Mayor Pro Tern Keitt addressed Council at a prior meeting."
Councilmember Hannah replied, "It is mainly for health reasons."
Councilmember Knotts asked, 'There are already "No Smoking" signs currently?"
City Administrator Yow replied, "There is, and it is currently not enforceable with a fine. In the
City facilities, it is State Law you cannot smoke."
City Administrator Yow addressed Council in regards to an Ordinance providing for the issuance
of a not exceeding $5,000,000 Accommodations and Hospitality Tax Revenue Bond of the City
of Orangeburg, SC and other matters relating thereto. He stated, "This is part of our overall
budget for the new Recreation Complex. We have slightly under $18 million budget and a $5
million revenue bond that is part of this budget. We have funding from the 1 % County Capital
Project Sales Tax and the Local Accommodations and Hospitality Tax. For your information,
Charlton deSaussure, who has served the City for many years, is the bond counsel on this.
Letters will be going out accepting bids until Tuesday, April 12th at 12:00 noon. We will have
the bids at the April 17th City Council Meeting and the Third Reading. We will have the First
Reading tonight and Second Reading on April 3rd and the final reading and bids on April 17th.
The reason we are doing it this way is because if we put something out for that amount of
money, they may pad the rates forty-five days out. We are trying to keep the rates as low as we
can. This will also refinance existing debt with a balance of a little over $600,000 leaving us
with only one debt in that fund. The original issue was $3 .5 million. Revenue from the
Hospitality and Accommodations Tax is what is pledged and therefore does not affect your
property taxes as it is not a General Obligation Bond, it is a Revenue Bond. I have a couple of
things to talk over with our bond counsel prior to the next meeting. If you look at Article I,
Section 4, it states, we are constructing a 90 acre recreation complex. As Council knows, we
own more property than that and we could spend any additional amounts on the existing
property, more than the 90 acres in that property."
Councilmember Hannah asked, "Is it a savings to the City to refinance the $600,000 or is it a
convenience?"
City Administrator Yow replied, "It is both, I cannot tell you what the rates will be. We are
currently at 4.1 % and we are anticipating 3.6°3.7%. Don't hold me to that, but that would be a
significant savings to the City. If the rates come in higher, we would not refinance or look at the
best overall option."
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Councilmember Knotts,
to approve First Reading of an Ordinance providing for the fasuance of a not exceeding
$5,000,000 Accommodations and Hospitality Tax Revenue Bond of the City of Orangeburg, SC
and other matters relating thereto. This motion was unanimously approved.
There were no utility matters brought before Council.
A motion was made by Councilmember Stroman, seconded by Councilmember Haire, to enter
into an Executive Session for (1) Purchase of Real Property-- Purchase of real properties located
on Boulevard at Railroad Comer, (2) Legal Matter -- Discussion on possible Opioid Litigation,
and (3) Personnel Matter -- Municipal Court Judge Process Position.
_ _J
i __ j
Page2
Mayor Butler recognized Dr. Jerome Fitch, Director of Athletics at Claflin Universl)(j9'Jfr.
Ricky Jackson, Head Men's Basketball Coach. Mayor Butler presented the Team with a
Proclamation for their success this basketball season.
City Administrator Yow addressed Council in regards to a First Reading of an Ordinance
amending Chapter 5 of the Code of Ordinances of the City of Orangeburg, titled "Police
Regulations" by adding a new Section 5-28 titled, "Smoking in Public Places", Prohibiting the
smoking in public places.
He stated, "At the November 21, 2017, City Council meeting, Mayor Pro Tern Keitt proposed a
possible No Smoking Ordinance. For review tonight is an Ordinance for that purpose and it is up
for discussion. I know that Ms. Keitt has spoken to some of you already about this. This is our
first attempt. What we hlve before you tonight is an Ordinance that would prohibit smoking at
I
our Parks and Recreation Facilities including parks. I would like to mention that Section 5-28.9
on page 3 should be omitted from this Ordinance. As you can see from the listing of all parks,
I
Hillcrest Golf Course war purposely omitted from the list as it is a wide area and there are
foursomes that regularly play together. Again, that is up to Council. I would like to go on
record to say that we haye signs in our facilities now for no smoking and we do not allow
smoking in the recreation areas. This is up for Council's discussion to see if you still want to do
this and see what areas of ~e Ordinance you like or don't like."
i
Councilmember Haire stated, "I have a concern. I had a brother who was a chain smoker who
has passed away and I triJd talking to him, but it was very difficult for him to give up smoking.
In this Ordinance, it stat+ that you must be within 10 foot of a recreation facility. Does that
inc. lu. de sidewalks? I thi] the Department of Public Safety has .more to do than issuing smoking
tickets."
City Administrator Yow eplied, "You would like to insert in the Ordinance, unless on a public
sidewalk?"
Councilmember Haire re~lied, "I would like to see us (I thought Ms. Keitt would be here) carry
this over until we have had an opportunity to review this Ordinance. I move that we postpone
this Ordinance. Counbiimember Kuotts, seconded the motion. This was a 5-1 as
Councilmember Jernigan bpposed.
Councilmember Jernigan ltated, "I am opposed at postponing this, it is just delaying it. We can
make changes on the Secdnd and Third Readings. Why postpone it for one person? Also, I have
some questions that I arli not clear on. In Centennial Park, it states you cannot smoke in
Centennial Park. Does thlt mean an individual cannot smoke if they are there by themselves?"
City Attorney Walsh replibd, "Yes."
Councilmember Jernigan stated, "The Ordinance states that it has to be a group of people, isn't
that contradictory?"
City Administrator Yow eplied, "I read it that way as well. Under State Law you cannot smoke
in buildings under any , ondition. But in Section 5-28.4, it states a gathering of the public
regardless of the number. I read that as if one person is there alone, they could smoke. This is
our first attempt at this so it may take some time."
Councilmember Stroman. stated, "I have a problem creating new laws on the books. I know
smoking is not good. I think DPS has more to do than to write a $25 ticket for someone
smoking. I have not had ny complaints from people smoking."
Councilmember Haire stlted, "I would like to address Councilmember Jernigan's statement
about one person, we do
I
ot know that until we vote."
Page4
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned. 2699
/pfb
2700
City Council Minutes
April 3, 2018
Orangeburg City Council held a Public Hearing on Tuesday, April 3, 2018, at 7:00 P.M., in
Council Chambers with Mayor Butler presiding. The purpose of the Public Hearing was for the
following:
(1) Comments on adoption of an Ordinance providing for issuance of not exceeding
$5,000,000 Accommodations and Hospitality Tax Revenue Bond.
(2) Consideration of a Zoning Map District change from A-1 Single-Unit Residential District
to 0-I Office-Institutional-Residential District for property belonging to Unity Mortgage
of SC, LLC, located at 1705 Carolina Avenue, TMP# 0173-05-25-007.000.
Public Hearing #1 received no comments and was closed.
Public Hearing #2, Consideration of a Zoning Map District change from A-1 Single-Unit
Residential District to 0-I Office-Institutional-Residential District for property belonging to
Unity Mortgage of SC, LLC, located at 1705 Carolina Avenue, TMP# 0173-05-25-007.000, Mr.
Leon Felder of Unity Mortgage addressed Council. He stated, "I am the property owner and
when we started this process I asked the surrounding neighbors if they had a problem with this
business being there, no one objected. There will be two people working there. I would like to
thank the City, Mr. John Singh and Mr. David Epting since this is a process and they helped me
with the application." Mr. Felder also recognized supporters that were present.
Hearing no other comments on Public Hearing #2, a motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt,
seconded by Councilmember Hannah, to close the Public Hearing. This motion was
unanimously approved.
Council entered into the regularly scheduled City Council meeting.
PRESENT:
Michael C. Butler, Mayor
Bernard Haire
Jerry Hannah
Charles W. Jernigan
L. Zimmerman Keitt
Sandra P. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Councilmember Knotts, to approve
the March 20, 2018, City Council Minutes as distributed. This was a 6-0-1 vote, as Mayor Pro
Tern Keitt was not present at the last meeting.
Mayor Butler and City Administrator Yow presented Allen Robinson with a Retiree Resolution
and gold watch for his thirty years and twenty-five days of service to City of Orangeburg's
Hillcrest Municipal Golf Course.
Mr. Shawn Taylor, Recreation Superintendent of the Parks and Recreation Department,
presented Mr. Jerry Ellis the South Carolina Recreation and Parks Association (SCRPA)
"Champion of Our Community Award" for his achievements as a baseball and football coach for
over twenty-five years of service to the Orangeburg community .. A video was shown from the
SC Recreation and Parks Association about the award. Mr. Ellis received a standing ovation
from the audience.
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, to approve
the Fiscal Year 2018-19 Budget Calendar, which also cancels the July 3
rd
meeting and July 17
th
meeting. This motion was unanim,ously approved.
Page2
Mayor Pro Tern Keitt addressed Council in regards to the proposed Smoking in pJ1';ZOilces
Ordinance. She stated, "This started with a no smoking grant for Project LifePositeen located at
349 Summers Avenue. I asked Council to consider a smoking ban originally on four places, two
being Centennial Park and the Recreation Complex on North Road. City Administrator Yow and
I discussed putting all parks on the Qrdinance with the exception of Hillcrest Golf Course. I
would love to see us entertain this for non-smoking. People shouldn't have to inhale someone
else's smoke. I am asking Council to consider this or what you would like to go with or take out
of the Ordinance."
City Administrator Yow reminded Council, "It is against state law to smoke in public buildings
currently."
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "What about the Downton Plaza?"
City Administrator Yow stated, "The Plaza is in the list of public places and if you want to
smoke, you would have to go to the sidewalk."
Councilmember Jernigan stated, "I think the Plaza is too restricted. We have events on the
Plaza, the car show this weekend, bands, and other events and we allow them to sell alcohol and
I think if someone wanted to smoke there, preventing them from doing so at these events would
be too restrictive and I have misgivings on that."
Councilmember Stroman stated, "As I said last time, I have had no complaints on smoking from
anyone. A police officer has more to do than write smoking tickets; I can't go along with it."
Councilmember Haire stated, "I spoke with the author of this Ordinance and I thought that there
were only four areas of non-smoking, I think this is too invasive. I know the four were
Centennial Park, the workshop at DPU, the Complex on North Road and I am not sure what
else."
Councilmember Knotts asked City Attorney Walsh, "In Section 5-28-8, how is this enforced?"
City Attorney Walsh replied, "It would be on a uniform traffic ticket or an Ordinance summons
and they would go before Municipal Court."
Mayor Pro Tern Keitt stated, "There were four places originally and one was the North Road
Recreation Center, is that listed?"
City Attorney Walsh stated, "That is not in the City, we would have to amend the Ordinance
once it is in the City."
City Administrator Yow suggested that Council discuss this and decide what they want to
include or exclude in the Ordinance. Staff is just bringing it up for consideration and discussion.
This item was tabled until a later meeting.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Haire, to approve
the Second Reading of an Ordinance providing for the issuance of a not exceeding $5,000,000
Accommodations and Hospitality Tax Revenue Bond of the City of Orangeburg, SC and other
matters relating thereto. This motion was unanimously approved.
Mayor Butler read the Fair Housing Resolution declaring April 2018, as Fair Housing Month in
the City of Orangeburg.
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, to approve a
Resolution declaring April 2018, Fair Housing Month in the City. This motion was unanimously
approved.
Ms. Evelyn Discher, Executive Director of the Community of Character, accepted the Character
Trait Proclamation for April 2018, "Humility".
Page3
CiJ 1Jitlistrator Yow overviewed the Contingent Fee Retainer Agreement for Opioid Related
Litigation.
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "If we do this and the City is sued over an opioid case, would
they be the City's lawyers?"
City Administrator Yow and City Attorney Walsh stated," No."
Councilrnember Jernigan asked, "So what does this actually do?"
City Administrator Yow replied, "We are entering an agreement that the attorneys would
represent us in litigation to recover City costs related from opioid manufacturers and others.
Councilmember Haire stated, "On Page 1, the bottom is #2 and the next page goes to #6. I think
there are pages missing and I would like to have the original Ordinance voted on that we
received originally."
A motion was made by C01,p1ci!rnember Haire, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, to approve
the Contingent Fee Retainer Agreement for Opioid related Litigation (original copy) giving City
Administrator Yow authorization to execute the documents. This wai; a 6-1 vote, as
Councilrnember Jernigan opposed.
Counci!rnember Hannali asked Council to Keep Orangeburg Beautiful. He passed out to Council
a flyer about litter and the three ways litter comes to our neighborhoods through cars, walking
and the homeowners. He stated, "The homeowners do not clean up their home areas. We have to
talk to these people about keeping their areas and neighborhoods clean and welcoming."
Councilrnember Hannali asked Reverend Hil!on L. Simmons to speak. He mentioned a homeless
shelter he helped organize and the litter is troublesome.
City Administrator Yow stated, "We support you in your efforts and be assured the City enforces
the Litter Ordinance. We, as City, employees, also pick up litter and will be organizing another
litter pick up again in May."
Councilrnember Stroman replied, "I see the Service Department picking up litter all the time and
we appreciate it."
Mayor Pro Tern Keitt,replied, "It is a great idea and we can do better."
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, to approve
the First Reading ofan Ordinance to amend Section 24-4.1, District Boundaries and Maps of the
Code of Ordinances and the Zoning Map change of the City of Orangeburg, property belonging
to Unity Mortgage of SC, LLC, located at 1705 Carolina Avenue, TMP# 0173-05-25-007.000.
This motion was unanimously approved.
There were no utility matters brought before Council.
City Administrator Yow introduced the new Public Works Director, Mr. Dean Felkel.
Mayor Pro Tern Keitt told DPS Director Adams that his staff was doing a wonderful job.
A motion was made by Councilrnember Haire, seconded by Councilrnember Knotts, to adjourn.
This motion was unanimously approved.
There being no further business, the p:ieeting was adjourned.
;y~spectfully submi
YarneW.J
City Clerk
/ptb
--,
'
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
April 17, 2018
2703
Orangeburg City Coun~il held it_s regularly scheduled City Council Meeting on Tuesday, April
17, 2018, at 7:00 P.M. m Council Chambers with Mayor Butler presiding.
PRESENT:
Michael C. Butler, Mayor
Bernard Haire
Jerry Hannah
Charles W. Jernigan
L. Zillllllerman Keitt
Sandra P. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Councilmember Knotts, to approve
the April 3, 2018, City Council Minutes as distributed. Tbis motion was unanimously approved.
Mayor Butler and DPU Manager Warren Harley presented Mr. Burnie Martin, Jr., with a Retiree
Resolution and gold watch for his thirty-three years, five months and two days of service to t!Je
Department of Public Utilities.
Mr. Stanley Montgomery of 1168 Douglas McArt!Jur Street addressed Council. He stated, "I am
here to follow up on any concerns for the Skate Park proposal?"
Mayor Butler replied, "We are taking tlris under advisement and will be discussing it in our
planning session in June."
Mr. Montgomery stated, "I also want to start a Youth Council for the teens to express their
concerns in Orangeburg. Teens should get involved in politics and be involved in changes in t!Je
collllllunity. A Youth Council would be beneficial in many ways to the City and to the
collllllunity."
Mayor Butler asked, "How are you going to bring tlris about?"
Mr. Montgomery explained, "There would be two yout!Js per district."
Mayor Butler asked, "Is tlris more of an advisory capacity?"
Mr. Montgomery stated, "Yes, bringing ideas to the forefront."
Mayor Butler explained, "We will take tlris idea into our planning session as well in June."
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "Do you know Willie Johnson, he would be a good person to
talk to about fomJing this Council."
Mayor Pro Tern Keitt gave Mr. Montgomery her business card.
Councilmember Hannah stated, "I stood where you stand before and I applaud you and please
understand that everyone here will have to agree to this."
Ms. Candice Roberson of DORA addressed Council. She stated, "I wanted to bring to you what
has been going on with DORA this last quarter. There are two new businesses in t!Je 1100 block
of Russell Street. One business is "Addicted", a women's boutique and the oilier is "Prime Time
Nutrition" that serves smootlries and nutritional drinks. There is an increase in building
improvements in downtown and also effects of the City's Facade Grant where "Tea Thyme" has
new sigus and "Jenn Affairs" is remodeling. We have a quarterly merchant training and this
quarter was Window Displays, which was beneficial to t!Je merchants. We plan to have an event
each mont!J in downtown. In March, we had a successful St. Patrick's Day celebration and t!Je
car show scheduled for April has been rescheduled for May 5th due to inclement weather. We
Page2
contacted the Rose Festival Committee about holding this in conjunction with the Rose Festival.
The n).ll7&ftre will be our street dance where the Mighty Kicks will be performing on the
square. Tlie ~owntown Fanner's Market will be starting May 15tl
1
through August 28
th
on
Tuesdays from 3 :30 p.m. until 6:00 p.m. Our Fann to Table Dinner will be June 7
th
with tickets
going on sale May 1st. We are partnering with Blue Bird Theatre this surmner to bring a movie
series one day a week at 10:00 a.m. We plan to market this to stay at home moms, daycares, and
schools to bring pedestrian traffic downtown. None of these events can happen without your
continued support from the City employees and City Council and your help is most appreciated.
I am requesting permission to sell beer and wine at the Street Dance on May 4th and also be able
to serve beer and wine at the Fann to Table Dinner on June 7th. It will be a part of your ticket
price."
A motion was made by Councihnember Jernigan, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, giving
approval to DORA to be able to sell beer and wine at the Street Dance on May 4th and serve beer
and wine at the Fann to Table Dinner on June 7th. This motion was unanimously approved.
Councilmember Jernigan stated, "I commend what you do with such a limited staff and only
volunteers."
City Administrator Yow overviewed for Council the bidding on the Revenue Bond (15 year
term) to assist in the funding of the Recreational Complex. He stated, "As Council knows we
have had two readings previously on the Revenue Bond. We had a bid opening on April 12
th
and in your packet is the bid tabulation of the responses. I am happy to report that we received a
favorable rate of2.957% from a local bank and the second bid of3.35%, which was also a good
bid. South State Bank has done a lot of business with us over the years. Going back to a
previous question, we are paying off 4.1 % money with 2.957% money, so we are saving money
paying off the previous debt which is also included in the memo."
Councihnember Hannah asked, "On the first page under requirements from South State Bank,
what is bond counsel, does that replace the City Attorney?"
City Administrator Yow replied, "No, we actually employ a bond counsel and also have the City
Attorney review any type of General Obligation Bond or Revenue Bond, but also we employ a
separate bond counsel which is Haynesworth, Sinkler & Boyd, which is Mr. Charlton deSaussure
who we have used for many years."
A motion was made by Councihnember Haire, seconded by Councihnember Knotts, to approve
giving authorization.to the City Administrator Yow to accept the bid from South State Bank in
the amount of2.957% APR for $5,000,000 Revenue Bond. This motion was unanimously
approved.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, seconded by Councihnember Haire, to approve
the Third Reading of an Ordinance providing for the issuance of a not exceeding $5,000,000
Accommodations and Hospitality Tax Revenue Bond of the City of Orangeburg, SC, and other
matters relating thereto. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Councihnember Knotts, to approve
the Second Reading of an Ordinance to amend Section 24.4.1, District Boundaries and-Maps of
the Code of Ordinances and the Zoning Map change of the City of Orangeburg, property
belonging to Unity Mortgage of SC, LLC, located at 1705 Carolina Avenue, TMP# Ol 73-05-25-
007.000.
City Administrator Yow addressed Council in regards to a lighting contract for the Recreational
Complex. He stated, "As Council knows at the February 6, 2018, meeting, City Council granted
me the authorization to award contract to Techline, Inc., in the amount of$1,181,510 for LED
Lighting at the new Recreation Complex. However, this contract was not awarded to Techline.
In our due diligence, it was brought to our attention that Techline did not have the applicable
state contractor's license in place at the time of their bid submittal. They have since
obtained their license; however, I asked Attorney Walsh to review the matter in its entirety.
Page3
According to state code, it was not proper for Techline to submit a bid nor would it be proper for
the City to award contract to them. At this time, we have opted to reject all bids. Fo~17"'f)'5
we are able to negotiate directly with MUSCO Sports Lighting, LLC, who has a standmg
contract with National Joint Powers Alliance of which we are a member. We have negotiated
base price of$1,161,500 for a complete installed LED sports lighting system. This
amount is $20,010 lower than the previously presented contract authorization request and
$151,575 lower than MUSCO's earlier offered bid. There is no reduction in the LED lighting
system being provided. MUSCO is the largest sports lighting provider in South Carolina and
have a proven track record across South Carolina. We are also considering adding the control
link and monitoring system with a twenty-five (25) year warranty for an additional, $15,400.
It is my recommendation that Council grant authorization to proceed with the award of contract
to MUSCO Sports Lighting, LLC, for the total amount of$1,l 76,900.
Councilmember Haire asked, "How were we going to monitor the system with Techline?"
City Administrator Yow replied, "I don't think they could do that at present."
Councilmember Haire asked, "Would we have to do the monitoring ourselves ifwe went with
them?"
City Administrator Yow replied, "Yes, and they would have had a local company from Irmo, SC,
do the maintenance."
Mayor Pro Tern Keitt stated, "I am glad you found out in time about the license."
City Administrator Yow replied, "I think this is the first time we have had this happen, This
company was trying to get into the South Carolina market and be aggressive with the pricing and
some states do not require such a license but South Carolina does."
Councilmember Hannah stated, "We are getting more for less?"
City Administrator Yow replied, "We are getting more and it is slightly lower in price than
Techline, but significantly lower than MUSCO's original bid."
A motion was made by Councilmember Jernigan, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, to
authorize for City Administrator Yow to purchase a LED lighting system for the Recreation
Complex in the amount of$1,l 76,900 from MUSCO Lighting System, LLC. This motion was
unanimously approved.
Assistant City Administrator Singh addressed Council. He stated, "I am pleased to bring you an
additional item for our tool box for downtown, which is the Bailey Bill. This is a histori.c tax
credit for an entity or individual that may want to renovate a historic building downtown over a
period of time. The Bailey Bill works with an entity by freezing the taxable assessed value of a
property up to twenty (20) years based on building value. Typically, many entiti.es have used
20% for this threshold. The Bill is a tax savings incentive by freezing the building's value at the
rate prior to the improvements. The tax assessment savings is based on the amount of restoration
to the building. Two examples are provided. The first example is a twenty year period and the
second example is a ten year period. This Ordinance provides a scale as to the amount of
restoration to tax savings. The County needs to provide the same incentive on the County level
to increase this credit."
Councilmember Haire asked, "Will this Ordinance squeeze the people out due to financial
constraints or resources putting pressure on them to maintain their structures in certain
decorum?"
City Administrator Yow and Assistant City Administrator Singh replied, "Only, if they use the
Bailey Bill."
Assistant City Administrator Singh stated, "It is the same with our Fa9ade Grant, they need to
maintain the improvements."
Page4
City 4~ator Yow replied, "In the past in residential districts, it has become somewhat
burd8':s6Amn some with windows and some sort of things with historical houses and we have
not done that."
Councilmember Hanuah asked, "Are all the buildings historic?"
Assistant City Administrator Singh replied, 'The threshold is 1950 or earlier.".
Councilmember Hanuah asked, "On page 7 of 8, Item H, who is the agent that handles that?"
Assistant City Administrator Singh stated, "We will be giving you that information based on the
process. The answer to that will probably be our staff and Public Works and we have to have a
Board to evaluate the applications. We are working on that and it is in process."
City Administrator Yow stated, "We need input from Council on that to start the process."
A motion was made by Councilmember Jernigan, seconded by Councilmember Stroman, to
approve the First Reading of an Ordinance adopting the "Bailey Bill" providing for special
property tax assessment for rehabilitated historic properties; and other matters related thereto.
This was a 6-0-1 vote, as Councilmember Haire abstained.
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, to approve
the Fiscal Year 2018-2019 Department of Public Utilities Budget Calendar. This motion was
unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, to enter into
an Executive Session for a (1) Legal/Economic Development matter concerning inclusion in a
Multi-County Industrial Park of certain tracts ofland owned by Zeus Industrial Products and (2)
a Personnel Matter concerning Municipal Court Judge position hiring process.
Council will not return to Open Session.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
\
/pfb
A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE CANCELLATION OF REVERSIONARY
CLAUSE OF THE CITY IN PROPERTY OWNED BY PALMETTO DEVELOPMENT
GROUP
WHEREAS, by deed dated September 26, 2016 the below described property
was conveyed to Palmetto Development Group with the City of Orangeburg retaining a
reversionary interest therein, and
WHEREAS, Palmetto Development Group has or is in the process of applying for __ .
grant funds from the United States Department of Commerce, Economic Development
Administration and a condition of said application is that the grant be awarded to
Palmetto Development and a co-applicant consisting of a governmental agency, and
WHEREAS, the City has been advised that said deed reversionary clause has
prevented Palmetto Development Group and its co-applicant from obtaining grant funds
for its corporate purposes as described in City Ordinance No. 2016-5, and
WHEREAS, the City wishes to assist Palmetto Development Group in its
creation of a business incubator at said site which will contribute to the general welfare
of the citizens of the City and its surrounding areas.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY CITY COUNCIL DULY
ASSEMBLED, that John H. Yow, City Administrator is hereby directed and authorized
to execute a termination of the reversionary clause of the City in the below described
property and contained in the above deed in recordable form and deliver said
termination to Palmetto Development Group for recording purposes on either of the
following conditions:
1. The below described property shall be conveyed by Palmetto Development
Group to a political subdivision of the State of South Carolina, an agency of
said subdivision or to a public educational institution of the State of South
Carolina.
2. Article XI of the Articles of Incorporation of Palmetto Development Group be
amended and after amendments shall need as follows:
Article XI-Dissolution:
"In the event of the dissolution of Palmetto Development Group (PDG), all
assets, including real property, shall be distributed for a public purpose to
the State of South Carolina, an agency of said State, a South Carolina
local government or a South Carolina public educational institution. Any
personal property not so disposed of shall be disposed by the court of
competent jurisdiction of the county in which the principal office of the
corporation is then located, exclusively for such purposes or to such
organization or organizations, as said court shall determine, which are
organized and operated exclusively for such purposes."
Description of property:
All that certain piece, parcel or lot of land, with buildings and all
improvements thereon, situate, lying and being on the South side of Russell
Street, in the City and County of Orangeburg, State of South Carolina,
fronting on said Russell Street, forty-three (43) feet, eleven (11) inches, and
running back and measuring on the respective sidelines, one hundred
seventy-eight (178) feet, eight (8) inches, and measuring on the rear line
forty-three (43) feet, five (5) inches, and bounded as follows: On the North
by Russell Street; on the East by property now or formerly of Mrs. Emma C.
Dantzler; on the South by property now or formerly of Willi.am W.
Wannamaker (Orange Cotton Mills); and on the West by property of J.W.
Smoak.
AND IT IS SO RESOLVED.
Done in meeting duly assembled this /$}- day of~· 2018.
MEMBERS OF COUNCIL
STATE OF SOUTH CAROLINA )
) RESOLUTION NO. ----
CITY OF ORANGEBURG )
RESOLUTION OF THE CITY OF ORANGEBURG, SOUTH CAROLINA
AUTHORIZING THE INCLUSION IN A MULTI-COUNTY INDUSTRIAL PARK
OF CERTAIN TRACTS OF LAND OWNED BY ZEUS INDUSTRIAL
PRODUCTS, INC. LOCATED WITHIN THE CITY LIMITS OF THE CITY OF
ORANGEBURG PURSUANT TO SECTION 4-1-170 OF THE SOUTH
CAROLINA CODE.
WHEREAS, Zeus Industrial Products, Inc. (the "Company") is investing
additional capital in Orangeburg County (the "County") thereby maintaining existing jobs
and creating additional job opportunities for the citizens of the City of Orangeburg (the
"City"); and
WHEREAS, in connection therewith, the Company and the County desire to
include certain tracts owned by the Company including those more particularly described
on Exhibit A attached hereto (the "Company Tracts") in an existing multi-county
industrial park created pursuant to an agreement between the County and Dorchester
County (the "Park") in order to continue to provide certain incentives to the Company;
and
WHEREAS, the Company Tracts are located in the City, such that the consent of
the City is required in order to include these properties in the Park; and
WHEREAS, as an incentive to encourage the Company to continue to invest in
the County and to encourage the retention of jobs and the creation of additional jobs, the
City desires to consent to the inclusion of the Company Tracts in the Park.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, by the City Council of the City of
Orangeburg, South Carolina, in meeting duly assembled:
1. The inclusion in the Park of the Company Tracts is hereby consented to by
the City, pursuant to all requirements of South Carolina law, including
Section 4-1-170 of the South Carolina Code of Laws and on the conp,tions
that "Revenue" as defined in County Ordinance No~4?-o5""·o7wi\:b. the
effective date of S-?-1'2 shall be calculated and paid to the City in
accordance with said County Ordinance.
2. The City agrees to execute any other documents necessary to evidence this
consent.
3. This Resolution shall become effective innnediately and shall be
prospective only.
4. All orders, resolutions, and parts thereof in conflict herewith are, to the
extent of the conflict, hereby repealed.
(Signature Page Follows)
Done in . meetmg dul ,
1
y assembled this /:r,;. / __ day of ~ ~,----- ,2018
/1/_/ ch«/( /?.dA
Mayor ?
AITES
1.
EXHIBIT A
Champlain Property - Manufacturing Property - Mill Building 1 (located in the
City of Orangeburg)
(Mill Street and Boulevard)
Tax Map# 0173-18-19-001.000
All that certain piece, parcel or lot of land, with improvements thereon (including a four
story brick building, a one story office building and a two story warehouse), situate, lying
and being in School District No. 5, City of Orangeburg, County of Orangeburg, State of ·
South Carolina, being on the South side of Mill Street, at the comer of Boulevard, S. E.
and Mill Street, containing one and fifty-four hundredths (1.54) acres, and being more
particularly shown and delineated on a Plat of 1.54 Acres, prepared by Edisto Surveyors
& Associates, approved by A.R. Parler, Jr., RLS dated July 29, 1981, and recorded in the
office of the Clerk of Court for Orangeburg County in Plat Book 51, at page 92, and
bounded and measuring as follows: On the North by Mill Street, measuring thereon two
hundred nineteen and forty-hundredths (219.40) feet; on the Northeast by the right-of
way of the Atlantic Coastline Railroad Company, measuring along a curved line, one
hundred sixty-four and sixty-one hundredths (164.61) feet; on the Southeast by property
of the grantor herein, measuring thereon one hundred sixty-four and fifteen-hundredths
(164.15) feet; on the South by property of the grantor herein measuring thereon two
hundred fourteen and sixty-one hundredths (214.61) feet; and on the West by South
Boulevard Street, measuring thereon two hundred fifty and seventy-hundredths (250.70)
feet. Said property having such courses, distances, boundaries and measurements as
more particularly set forth and shown on the aforesaid plat, which is incorporated herein
and for a more complete and accurate description reference is craved thereto. Being a
portion of the same property conveyed to Management and Investment Corporation by
South Carolina Cotton Mills, Inc., by deed dated January 21, 1980, and recorded in the
aforesaid office on January 21, 1980, in Deed Book 459, at page 209.
2. Warehouse Property (located in the City of Orangeburg)
(Moseley Street)
Tax Map #'s 0173-18-06-001.000, 0173-18-07-002.000, and 0173-18-07-003.000
All that certain pieces, parcels or lots of land containing 2.97 acres situate, lying and
being in the City of Orangeburg, School District #5, Orangeburg County, State of South
Carolina shown as Parcels A, B, & C on a plat surveyed for O.L. Hughes & Son, Inc. by
Edisto Engineers & Surveyors, Inc. dated May 1, 2007 and recorded in the Office of the
Register of Deeds for Orangeburg County in Plat Book D74, at Page 10, and having all
metes, bounds, courses, distances, directions and measurements as are shown on said
plat, are incorporated herein and made a part hereof by reference.
This is the same property conveyed to O.L. Hughes & Son, Inc. by O.L. Hughes, Sr. &
O.L. Hughes, Jr. dated and recorded January 9, 1975 and recorded in the O±lice of the
Regi.ster of Deeds for Orangeburg County in Deed Book 406, at Page 159; also conveyed
to O.L. Hughes & Son, Inc. by Deed of Florence W. Henry and Frances Henry Scott
dated and recorded December 6, 1994 and recorded in the Office of the Register of Deeds
for Orangeburg County in Deed Book 610, at Page 995.
All that certain piece, parcel or lot of land, with all improvements thereon, situate, lying
and being in the City and County of Orangeburg, State of South Carolina containing
sixty-one hundredths (0.61) of an acre and being more fully set forth and shown on a Plat
for Zeus Industrial Products, Inc., prepared by Edisto Engineers & Surveyors, Inc.,
approved by Richard L. Stroman, RLS, dated September 18, 2006 and recorded in the
office of the Register of Deeds for Orangeburg County in Plat Book 49, at page 6 and
bounded as follows: On the West by the right-of-way of Magnolia Street; on the North
by property of O.L. Hughes & Son, Inc.; on the East by property of O.L. Hughes & Son,
Inc.; and on the South by the right-of-way of Mill Street.
Said property having such size, shape, courses, distances, boundaries and measurements
as more fully set forth on the aforesaid plat which is incorporated herein by reference.
Being the same property conveyed to G and G Investments by deed of Harry B. Rahner,
III, et al., recorded in the office of the Register of Deeds for Orangeburg County on July
3, 1980 in Deed Book 462 at page 795 and a portion of property conveyed to G & G
Rental Co., Inc. by deed of G & G Investments, a SC General Partnership, by deed
recorded in the aforesaid office in Deed Book 565, page 1055.
3. Manufacturing Property - Mill Building 2 (located in the City of Orangeburg)
Tax Map# 0173-18-19-002.001
All that certain piece, parcel or lot of land, with the buildings and improvements thereon,
situate, lying and being at the Southwest comer of the intersection of Mill Street
(formerly Duke Street), and an unnamed street, 50-feet in width, in the City and County
or Orangeburg, State of South Carolina, being triangular in shape and measuring on the
northern side ninety-seven feet, six inches (97'6"); on its eastern side one hundred
nin.eteen feet, ten inches (119'10"), and bounded now or formerly as follows: On the
North by right-of-way of said Mill Street (formerly Duke Street); on the East by the right
of-way of th.e said unnamed street (now Wheeler Street) above mentioned; and on the
South and West by the right-of-way of the Southern Railway Company's connecting
track, the eastern ends of cross ties of said track being the line; said said (sic) and its
boundaries being more fully shown and delineated by the Plat thereof made by Samuel
Dibble, Jr., Surveyor, in December 1896.
Being a portion of the same property conveyed to O.L. Hughes & Son, Inc., by deed of
O.L. Hughes, Sr., et al., etc., recorded in th.e office of the RMC for Orangeburg County in
Deed Book 406 at page 159.
,-ef/4841-9508-5662 v.1-
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
May 1,2018 2707
Orangeburg City Council held its regularly scheduled City Council Meeting on Tuesday, May 1,
2018, at 7:00 P.M. in Council Chambers with Mayor Butler presiding.
PRESENT:
Michael C. Butler, Mayor
Bernard Haire
Jerry Hannah
Charles W. Jernigan
L. Zimmerman Keitt
Sandra P. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Knotts, to approve
the April 17, 2018, City Council Minutes as distributed. This motion was unanimously
approved.
Mayor Butler and DPU Manager Warren Harley presented Mr. Michel G. Sells with a Retiree
Resolution and gold watch for his thirty-six years, four months and twenty-one days of service to
the Department of Public Utilities.
DPS Director Mike Adams presented to Council a certificate, for CALEA Meritorious Advanced
Law Enforcement Accreditation, which was awarded to the Department of Public Safety. Chief
Adams stated, "This is the sixth accreditation and being accredited is difficult and resources are
provided by Council and taxpayers. I would also like to give an update on PSO Cody Miles who
was injured on the job. He is to have surgery later this week."
City Administrator Yow introduced the new Hillcrest Golf Course Manager to Council, Mr.
Gregg Funderburk. Mr. Funderburk is a PGA Professional with nearly thirty (30) years
experience.
Mr. Rasheed Ali appeared before Council to show appreciation for four ( 4) DPS officers. He
stated, "I am a news correspondent and I see a lot of violence and Chief Adams has a great
department and there are no protests here in Orangeburg. The City has officers with good
restraint. First, I would like to show appreciation to Sergeant Arney Lucas. He's a role model
and many of our youth have been touched by him. He goes the extra mile to get the job done.
His goal is to steer youth from criminal activity. Thank you for not abusing the badge. I would
also like to show appreciation to Corporal Justin Daff, Corporal Jimmy Jones and Sergeant Jason
Sturkie. Sometimes interaction with white officers is unpleasant. These three wise men are
lurking among the ranks and they are assets to the Departm.ent of Public Safety. White guys
matter in the form of these officers. Orangeburg County has not been on the evening news
because of these professional officers. Blue lives matter. These officers are role models. Police
Departments in America would be better off if everyone possessed the traits of these officers."
Mr. Ali presented plaques to Sergeant Lucas, Corporal Daff, Corporal Jones and Sergeant
Sturkie.
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Councilmember Knotts, to approve
the Third Reading of an Ordinance to amend Section 24-4.1, District Boundaries and Maps of
the Code of Ordinances and the Zoning Map change of the City of Orangeburg, property
belonging to Unity Mortgage of SC, LLC, located at 1705 Carolina Avenue, TMP# 0173-05-25-
007.000. This motion was unanimously approved.
Assistant City Administrator Singh presented the First Reading of the Bailey Bill Ordinance. He
stated, "This is an incentive package. There are a few changes that I've noted in the memo.
Before Third Reading of this Ordinance, we will have the Board confirmed."
Page2
Mal>'?~r asked, "What are the districts?"
Assistant City Administrator Singh replied, "Russell Street Corridor, downtown."
City Administrator Yow asked, "W mtld you like to involve other areas?"
Assistant City Administrator Singh asked, "Would the same areas as the Fa9ade Grant be good?"
Mayor Butler stated, "Yes."
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, to approve
the Second Reading of an Ordinance adopting the "Bailey Bill" providing for special property
tax assessment for rehabilitated historic properties; and other matters related thereto. This
motion was unanimously approved.
City Administrator Yow stated, "I have placed the First Reading of an Ordinance amending
Chapter Five of the Code of Ordinances of the City of Orangeburg, "Police Regulations",· by
adding a new Section 5-28, titled, "Smoking in Public Places", prohibiting the smoking in public
places on the Agenda at the request of Mayor Pro Tern Keitt.
Councilmember Haire stated, "Maxcy Street Playground needs a name change to Rosa Parks
Playground."
The four places for non-smoking in the City are as follows:
(I) Centennial Park
(2) Chapel of Hope
(3) Duncan Street Playground
( 4) Rosa Parks Playground
Councilmember Stroman stated, "I have had no complaints on smoking. There are enough laws
on the books now. I'm against this Ordinance."
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Haire, to approve
the First Reading of an Ordinance amending Chapter Five of the Code of Ordinances of the City
of Orangeburg, "Police Regulations", by adding a new Section 5-28, titled, "Smoking in Public
Places", prohibiting the smoking in public places. This was a 5-2-0 vote, as Councilmember
Stroman and Councilmember Jernigan opposed.
Ms. Evelyn Disher, Community of Character Executive Director, accepted the Community of
Character Trait Proclamation for the month of May, "Self-Control".
Concerning Item #9 on the Agenda, Discussion on Community Policing, Councilmember
Hannah stated, "I am asking for a little to achieve greatness. We have a great staff at the
Department of Public Safety. If officers would take three or four minutes during their tour of
duty on each shift to interact with someone during that period, it could be a street corner, park or
business. Interact with citizens in the City. Interaction will pay off, the officer will gain a friend
and the citizens will have faith and this will help our City maintain excellence. There are
persons who have never had any interaction with the police. This is what I'm suggesting to the
great City of Orangeburg"
Mayor Pro Tern Keitt stated, "It is happening and we need to encourage what they do. They are
everywhere."
Chief Adams stated, "Community Policing emphasizes interaction. We have a program. Signal
25, which is to visit people and businesses .. It is documented, logged and included in our
quarterly reports. In 2017, we had 4,375 interactions with people (not calls). In 2018, the first
quarter, we had 1,354 Signal 25-interactions. We have reached 1,700 kids on gang initiatives.
We raise money to host programs. In 2017, there was 216 community events supervised by the
Department of Public Safety. This is commitment to our community. Kudos to Colonel Conner
for Orangeburg Safe Communities where we take away reasons for those to reoffend."
----,
Page3
Councilmember Hannah stated, "There is no question about your contacts. Can we geV7@9
chart, numbers can be misleading?"
Councilmember Stroman stated, "We have very good officers, I have no problems."
Mayor Butler stated, "We have spent weeks and much time on the matter of the appointment of a
Municipal Judge and we are ready to make a recommendation. We recommend Attorney Virgin
Johnson for the City's Municipal Judge position for a two year term."
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Haire, to approve
the recommendation of Attorney Virgin Johnson for Municipal Judge."
Councilmember Stroman stated, "I did not like the way this was handled. It was not fair to all
the candidates. Some Councilmembers were at the interviews and some were not. We have had
no discussion at all. I have nothing against Mr. Johnson, I just did not like the process."
Councilmember Jernigan stated, "I agree with Mr. Stroman. There were some exceptionally
good candidates that were passed over that were more qualified than Mr. Johnson. There was no
discussion on it and in fact, it eliminated the discussion altogether."
Mayor Butler stated, "We had a process and the Human Resources Officer assisted with that
process. We were to grade the candidates first, second and third. That system was interrupted
and we voted for first only. We graded according to the system given to us. We all had one
vote. This is a two year term."
Councilmember Haire cal.led for a vote on the motion. This was 5-2-0 vote, as Councilmembers
Jernigan and Stroman opposed.
Mayor Pro Tern Keitt gave thanks to Human Resource Officer, Theresa Williams, for her help
and assistance in the hiring process for a Municipal Judge.
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, to enter into
an Executive Session for (1) Legal and Real Property Matters, (a) Palmetto Development
Corporation at 1170 Russell Street and (b) Multi-County Industrial Park-Zeus Industrial
Products, Inc. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, to return to
Open Session.
Council returned to Open Session.
City Attorney Walsh addressed Council. He stated. "The City conveyed the Old First National
Bank building to Palmetto Development Group in 2016. In that deed, we had a Reversionary
Clause that if they failed to operate a business incubator in that location, the property would
revert back to the City. Palmetto Development Group has had some difficulty in obtaining
grants because of that clause. The Resolution before you authorizes the City to terminate the
Reversionary Clause. After research, I recommend that the Resolution be amended giving
Palmetto Development Group two choices. Option 1 - when they apply for grants, they would
have to have a co-applicant, which has to be a state agency. The title would then be conveyed to
that agency and they would be required to use that property for public purpose. Option 2 -
Palmetto Development Group would have to amend their Articles of Incorporation, which again
would require upon dissolution that the title of the property would be transferred to a County or
State Political Subdivision and they would be required to use that property for public purpose."
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Knotts, to approve the
Resolution authorizing the cancellation of the Reversionary Clause of the City in property owned
by Palmetto Development Group. This was a 5-2-0 vote, as Councilmembers Jernigan and
Stroman opposed.
Page4
City lJrl~alsh stated, "A Resolution that the County has requested of the City that the
property owned by Zeus located in the City, which is three tracts ofland, that this property be
included in a Multi-County Industrial Park which consists of the County of Orangeburg and
Dorchester County. Zeus has committed to invest $15,000,000 and create twenty (20) full time
jobs in the next five years to make that investment. Included, is a fee in lieu agreement where
the property will be assessed at 6% instead of I 0.5% and the millage rate of 94 ntills will be
locked in. The County by Ordinance has agreed to distribute the fee in lieu with 1 % going to
Dorchester County and then a 25% infrastructure credit will be given to Zeus and 20% of the
revenue will then come to the City and the remainder will go to the County. We all know Zeus
is a major industry in our community and it is my recommendation that you approve this
Resolution."
Councilmember Haire made a motion, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, to approve a
Resolution authorizing the inclusion in a Multi-County Industrial Park of certain tracts ofland
owned by Zeus Industrial Products, Inc., located within the city limits of the City of Orangeburg
pursuant to Section 4-1-170 of the South Carolina Code and giving authorization to the City
Administrator to execute. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Stroman, seconded by Councilmember Jernigan, to
adjourn. This motion was unanimously approved.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
/bpf
City Council Minutes
May 15, 2018
Orangeburg City Council held its regularly scheduled City Council Meeting on T~Z!,~ay
15, 2018, at 7:00 P.M. in Council Chambers with Mayor Butler presiding.
PRESENT:
Michael C. Butler, Mayor
Bernard Haire
Charles W. Jernigan
L. Zinunerman Keitt (Attended Late)
Sandra P. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
Absent:
Jerry Harmah
A motion was made by Councilmember Stroman, seconded by Councilmember Knotts, to
approve the May 1, 2018, City Council Minutes as distributed. This motion was unanimously
approved.
Mayor Butler and DPS Director Mike Adams presented Mr. Donnell Shuler with a Retiree
Resolution and watch for his twenty-five years of service to the Department of Public Safety.
Director Adams also mentioned Shuler's twenty years of service with the National Guard that
ran concurrently with his year's with DPS. Councilmembers congratulated Mr. Shuler and
thanked him for his service.
The Honorable Willie Robinson, Magistrate for Orangeburg County, administered the Oath of
Office to the newly selected Municipal Court Judge, Mr. Virgin Johnson.
City Administrator John Yow reviewed the changes in an Ordinance amending Chapter Five of
the Code of Ordinances related to Smoking in Public Places. He stated, "One amendment had
been made since the First Reading as requested on Page 2 Section 5-28.3 replacing the name of
Maxcy Street Park with that of Rosa Parks Playground."
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Councilmember Knott, to accept the
Second Reading of an Ordinance amending Chapter Five of the Code of Ordinances of the City
of Orangeburg, titled, "Police Regulations", by adding a new Section 5-28, titled, Smoking in
Public Places, prohibiting the smoking in public places. This was a 3-2 vote, as Councilmembers
Stroman and Jernigan opposed.
City Administrator John Yow brought forward the nomination of Mr. Harry Holman of the
Public Works Department to fill the vacancy on the City Grievance Committee for a three-year
term. Mr. Holman had previously served on the Committee and City Administrator Yow agreed
with his nomination.
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Councilmember Knotts, to postpone
this item until the next meeting. This was a 3-2 vote, as Councilmembers Stroman and Jernigan
opposed.
Department of Public Utilities Manager Warren Harley presented a Resolution regarding the
waiver of water and wastewater tap fees for the County of Orangeburg, Detention Facility.
Mayor Pro Tern Keitt was present at this time. DPU Manager Harley reviewed the previously
provided figures and calculations of the impact of the request that would total $147,445.13 based
upon current estimates. He also mentioned his concern with this request as DPU has recently
experienced the loss of a dryer for wastewater processing and will be adding roughly $30,000 in
additional expenses each month to handle wastewater until this dryer can be replaced. Funds for
this replacement are to be included in the next fiscal year's budget request. Due to these
Page2
unex@~l!1ditional expenses, Manager Harley is recommending denial of this waiver at this
time. However, in lieu of total denial, he would recommend waiving water only as tap fees
would require an immediate expense to purchase the necessary equipment.
Councilmember Jernigan made a motion to deny the waiver, seconded by Councilmember
Stroman.
Councilmember Haire then made a substitute motion to grant to the request as he recommended
that working on better relations with the County is essential. Prior to voting on the motions,
additional discussion took place.
Councilmember Knotts asked, "Is there a deadline for this request?"
DPU Manager Harley stated, "No, as they have already paid the $147,445.13 and would be given
a credit or refund, if the measure was approved.
Mayor Pro Tern Keitt inquired on any additional timing for the item.
DPU Manager Harley indicated that they would be working at the Council's pleasure.
Mayor Pro Tern Keitt also asked, "What type of funds do we have that would allow, or not
allow, us to do this?"
DPU Manager Harley revisited the detailed spreadsheets provided and reviewed those figures
and breakouts.
Councilmember Knotts stated, "Does the City fund the County Detention Center and does the
City reimburse them for City residents?"
City Administrator Yow stated, "It is totally operated by the County and residency doesn't
impact funding as City residents are also county residents."
Mayor Butler stated, "All seventeen municipalities in Orangeburg County use the Detention
Center in the same manner."
Based upon the discussion, Councilmember Haire rescinded his earlier substitute motion and
made a new substitute motion to table this item to allow Councilmembers time to discuss and
gather additional information as needed. Mayor Pro Tern Keitt seconded the motion. This was a
4-2 vote, as Councilmembers Jernigan and Stroman opposed.
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, to enter into
an Executive Session for (1) Legal and Contractual Matter ( a) Railroad Development - Piedmont
Company and (2) Legal Matter (a) Mediation Department of Public Safety - Related Lawsuit.
This motion was unanimously approved.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
Respectively submitted,
c?YGYo~
Tricia Phillips
Finance Coordinator
/pfb
-
City Council Minutes
June 5, 2018
2713
Orangeburg City Council held its regularly scheduled City Council Meeting on Tuesday, June 5,
2018, at 7:00 P.M., in Council Chambers with Mayor Butler presiding.
PRESENT:
Michael C. Butler, Mayor
Bernard Haire
Jerry Hannah
Charles W. Jernigan
L. Zimmerman Keitt
Sandra P. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
A motion was made by Counci!member Haire, seconded by Councilmember Stroman, to approve
the May 15, 2018, City Council Minutes as distributed. This was a 6-0-1 vote, as
Councilmember Hannah was not present at the last meeting.
Mayor Butler, City Administrator John Yow, Public Works Director Dean Felkel and former
Public Works Director Durwood Bowden, presented Ms. Brenda Ballard with a Retiree
Resolution for her twenty-eight years and eighteen days of service to the Public Works
Department.
Councilmember Hannah asked for special privilege and stated, "I have been working since I was
fifteen years old on a paper route and I had many customers such as doctors, lawyers, dentists,
preachers and this was in the 1960's. I was elected to Council in 2017, and to have my women
and children treated by Council the way they have been treated is terrible and I am out."
Councilmember Hannah left the meeting.
Concerning the Smoking in Public Places Ordinance, Councilmember Stroman stated, "I do not
see adding new laws on the books for Public safety and I cannot vote for it."
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern, Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Haire, to accept the
Third Reading of an Ordinance amending Chapter Five of the Code of Ordinances of the City of
Orangeburg, titled, "Police Regulations", by adding a new Section 5-28, titled, Smoking in
Public Places, prohibiting the smoking in public places. This was a 4-2 vote. Councilmembers
Jernigan and Stroman opposed.
Mayor Pro Tern Keitt stated, "Thank you to all Councilmembers that voted for this. I have had
calls from many churches thanking us for this and I thank you also those that did not vote."
Concerning the Bailey Bill Ordinance, Councilmember Jernigan asked, "How are the properties
declared historical? Is there a list?"
Assistant City Administrator Singh replied, "It is on the age of the building, it must be fifty (50)
years old. The age of the building must be verified prior to the application. If the building is
already a historical property there may be additional requirements in its restoration. There is al.so
language in the Ordinance that gives Council leeway in regards to determining if you feel a
property is historic. The SC Archives and History can do historic reviews before a committee is
established."
A motion as made by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, seconded by CouncilmemberJemigan, to approve
the Third Reading of an Ordinance adopting the "Bailey Bill" providing for special property tax
assessment for rehabilitated historic properties and other matters related thereto. This motion
was unanimously approved.
Page2
Con~,tie Grievance Committee reappointment, Councilmember Haire asked, "Didn't we
do ~gs differently in the past, we had a slate of names to choose from and then Council could
determine who would be appointed to the Co=ittee. If one name is submitted, it seems we are
only rubber stamping this process and we have no input on this."
City Administrator Yow stated, "There are some years where you have alternates and other
· appointments and may have more than one to vote on."
Mayor Pro Tern Keitt stated, "Mr. Holman is willing to serve and served previously."
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Stroman, to
reappoint Harry Hallman from the Public Works Department to the City Grievance Committee
for a three year term expiring June, 2021. This motion was unanimously approved.
Mayor Butler presented to Ms. Evelyn Disher, Executive Director for the Co=unity of
Character, the Character Trait Proclamation for June 2018, "Prudence".
DPU Manager Warren Harley addressed Council in regards to a Resolution authorizing the
waiver of water and wastewater taps for the County of Orangeburg Detention Facility. He
stated, "Based on projects that DPU has coming up, we carmot absorb these fees and I would
reco=end that you do not grant the waiver based on other projects that we need to get done."
A motion was made by Councilmember Stroman, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, not to
approve the Resolution authorizing th.e Waiver of Water and Wastewater Tap and Impact Fees
for the County of Orangeburg Detention Facility. This was a 5-0-1, vote as Councilmember
Haire abstained.
A motion was made by Councilmember Stroman, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, to enter
into an Executive Session for (1) Personnel Matter concerning Municipal Court-Associate
Judge (s) and (2) Legal Matter concerning Northwood Estates. This motion was unanimously
approved.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
Respectively submitted,
~tf/~£Y~
Carrie Johnson U
City Clerk
/pfb
City Council Minutes
June 5, 2018
2713
Orangeburg City Council held its regularly scheduled City Council Meeting on Tuesday, June 5,
2018, at 7:00 P.M., in Council Chambers with Mayor Butler presiding.
PRESENT:
Michael C. Butler, Mayor
Bernard Haire
Jerry Hannah
Charles W. Jernigan
L. Zimmerman Keitt
Sandra P. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
A motion was made by Counci!member Haire, seconded by Councilmember Stroman, to approve
the May 15, 2018, City Council Minutes as distributed. This was a 6-0-1 vote, as
Councilmember Hannah was not present at the last meeting.
Mayor Butler, City Administrator John Yow, Public Works Director Dean Felkel and former
Public Works Director Durwood Bowden, presented Ms. Brenda Ballard with a Retiree
Resolution for her twenty-eight years and eighteen days of service to the Public Works
Department.
Councilmember Hannah asked for special privilege and stated, "I have been working since I was
fifteen years old on a paper route and I had many customers such as doctors, lawyers, dentists,
preachers and this was in the 1960's. I was elected to Council in 2017, and to have my women
and children treated by Council the way they have been treated is terrible and I am out."
Councilmember Hannah left the meeting.
Concerning the Smoking in Public Places Ordinance, Councilmember Stroman stated, "I do not
see adding new laws on the books for Public safety and I cannot vote for it."
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern, Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Haire, to accept the
Third Reading of an Ordinance amending Chapter Five of the Code of Ordinances of the City of
Orangeburg, titled, "Police Regulations", by adding a new Section 5-28, titled, Smoking in
Public Places, prohibiting the smoking in public places. This was a 4-2 vote. Councilmembers
Jernigan and Stroman opposed.
Mayor Pro Tern Keitt stated, "Thank you to all Councilmembers that voted for this. I have had
calls from many churches thanking us for this and I thank you also those that did not vote."
Concerning the Bailey Bill Ordinance, Councilmember Jernigan asked, "How are the properties
declared historical? Is there a list?"
Assistant City Administrator Singh replied, "It is on the age of the building, it must be fifty (50)
years old. The age of the building must be verified prior to the application. If the building is
already a historical property there may be additional requirements in its restoration. There is al.so
language in the Ordinance that gives Council leeway in regards to determining if you feel a
property is historic. The SC Archives and History can do historic reviews before a committee is
established."
A motion as made by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, seconded by CouncilmemberJemigan, to approve
the Third Reading of an Ordinance adopting the "Bailey Bill" providing for special property tax
assessment for rehabilitated historic properties and other matters related thereto. This motion
was unanimously approved.
Page2
Con~,tie Grievance Committee reappointment, Councilmember Haire asked, "Didn't we
do ~gs differently in the past, we had a slate of names to choose from and then Council could
determine who would be appointed to the Co=ittee. If one name is submitted, it seems we are
only rubber stamping this process and we have no input on this."
City Administrator Yow stated, "There are some years where you have alternates and other
· appointments and may have more than one to vote on."
Mayor Pro Tern Keitt stated, "Mr. Holman is willing to serve and served previously."
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Stroman, to
reappoint Harry Hallman from the Public Works Department to the City Grievance Committee
for a three year term expiring June, 2021. This motion was unanimously approved.
Mayor Butler presented to Ms. Evelyn Disher, Executive Director for the Co=unity of
Character, the Character Trait Proclamation for June 2018, "Prudence".
DPU Manager Warren Harley addressed Council in regards to a Resolution authorizing the
waiver of water and wastewater taps for the County of Orangeburg Detention Facility. He
stated, "Based on projects that DPU has coming up, we carmot absorb these fees and I would
reco=end that you do not grant the waiver based on other projects that we need to get done."
A motion was made by Councilmember Stroman, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, not to
approve the Resolution authorizing th.e Waiver of Water and Wastewater Tap and Impact Fees
for the County of Orangeburg Detention Facility. This was a 5-0-1, vote as Councilmember
Haire abstained.
A motion was made by Councilmember Stroman, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, to enter
into an Executive Session for (1) Personnel Matter concerning Municipal Court-Associate
Judge (s) and (2) Legal Matter concerning Northwood Estates. This motion was unanimously
approved.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
Respectively submitted,
~tf/~£Y~
Carrie Johnson U
City Clerk
/pfb
City Council Minutes
August 21, 2018 2753
Orangeburg City Council held a Public Hearing on Tuesday, August 21, 2018, at 7:00 P.M., in
Council Chambers with Mayor Michael C. Butler presiding. The purpose of the Public Hearing
was for the following:
1. Public Hearing: Consideration of an Ordinance to Raise Revenue and Adopt a Budget
for the City of Orangeburg, SC, for the Fiscal Year beginning October 1, 2018 and
ending September 30, 2019
2. Public Hearing: Consideration of an Ordinance to (1) Adopt a Budget for the
Operation of the Department of Public Utilities of the City of Orangeburg, SC,
for the Fiscal Year beginning October 1, 2018 and ending September 30, 2019
and (2) Adopt Amended Gas Rates effective October 1, 2018
Public Hearing #1
Mr. Gene Gartman Jr., of Park Street addressed Council. He stated, "I am here to represent the
citizens of the City, we just built a new Recreation Center on Broughton Street that you have to
pay or rent it. We have parks and all of you have walked those streets to get re-elected. I ran un
successfully for City Council and I promised to keep taxes down and I have no desire to run
again. I want to get behind you to look out for the interests of the citizens in Orangeburg. How
can we make young people go to the new Recreation Complex when we have a lot of other
facilities here? My concern is we are going to have to do with what we have. We have elected
officials and others that work for the City. It is your job as holders ofOrangeburg's trust for our
well-being. We have people on fixed incomes. Four years from now, you will raise the taxes
again. We need to look out for people. The new recreation complex will probably be annexed
and bring in money. I urge you to look at your budget and don't spend fruitlessly."
Mayor Butler responded, "We have to provide quality of services in a timely manner. We are on
point with our fire services, trash pickup and other services. We needed to do this to continue to
be able to maintain the quality of services."
Hearing no other public comments, the Public Hearing was closed.
Public Hearing #2
Mr. Gene Gartman Jr., of Park Street addressed Council. He stated, "We have a new
consolidated school district that has the potential of tax increases. I would ask that you re-look at
your plans and look out for the public's interest."
A motion was made by Councilmember Stroman, seconded by Councilmember Haire, to enter
into the regular scheduled City Council meeting. This motion was unanimously approved.
Council entered into the regularly scheduled meeting.
PRESENT:
Michael C. Butler, Mayor
Bernard Haire
Jerry Hannah
Charles W. Jernigan
L. Zimmerman Keitt
Sandra P. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Mayor P~o Tern Keitt, to approve
the August 7, 2018, City Council Minutes, as distributed. This motion was unanimously
approved.
Page2
Ms.llS~, Director of Communications for the Center for Heirs' Property Preservation
made an appearance before Council.
She stated, 'The Center is a non-profit organization that provides legal services and education to
heirs' property owners. The project was started under the Coastal Community Foundation in
2005. Heirs' property is land that has been passed down without a will and keeps getting passed
down without a clear title. These families cannot get a loan, mortgage or any financial assistance
because of not having a clear title. It is more of a liability than an asset. There is a legacy and a
history behind the land. We help provide legal services to provide a clear title. In the seven
counties we began working with has 47,000 acres in 2012. We are determining what exists
across the state. In 2013, now that families have of Heirs' Property clear title, what can they do?
· We were funded by the U. S. Endowment for Forestiers' and the United States Department of
Agriculture (USDA) to launch sustainable forestry and African American land retention
program. This has provided families with forest education and forest land management,
technical assistance, connection to professional foresters and a connection to programs to
manage their land for timber and also receive assistance financially to do so. Timber is a 21
billion dollar industry and people are taken advantage of as to what their timber may be worth.
We are happy to report that we are expanding our service to fifteen (15) counties moving inland
towards I-95. We are going to open an office in Orangeburg in a few months. We will have an
open house and all are welcome and we ask that you become messengers in what we are doing.
We will be working with families to maintain their legacy and create an asset. In the past, a lot
of heirs' property was lost and there is an enormous distrust and fear to come forward and talk
about it. We always come into a community and work with civic leaders, pastors, churches and
councils to work with you to open doors for us in the community. We will come back and speak
where we are invited so we can share this information in order for families to keep their land.
We have three buckets of work which are the following:
(I) Prevention, which is preventing growth of heirs' property through education, wills and
probating estates.
(2) Resolutions, which are direct legal services for a clear title to their land as well as family
presentation tools.
(3) Land Utilization, which is an opportunity to create forest land management solutions.
We look forward to working with Orangeburg and on September 15th, we will be at the
Agricultural Center on Henley Street where we have had seminars. Please spread the word."
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "Are you non-profit?"
Ms. Lynn responded," Yes, we are funded through foundations, SC Bar Foundation,
Corporations, and donors as well as US Department of Agriculture (USDA)."
Councihnember Jernigan asked, "Are your services free to the public?"
Ms. Lynn stated, "The direct legal services are free. Sometimes there may be a cost for a survey
or a title search. You can call anytime to see if you may or may not own heirs' property."
Councihnember Jernigan asked, "Where is the office going to be?"
Ms. Lynn stated, "It is on St. Paul Street and we will have an attorney, a paralegal and hoping to
have a full-time forester."
Councilmember Jernigan stated, "Thank you for coming. Orangeburg has a need for this
service. I appreciate you coming and look forward to the opening of the new office."
Mayor Pro Tern Keitt stated, "I am glad you are here so we will know where to send people."
Page3
Reverend Henry Smith made an appearance before Council regarding the purchase ofli'iffio
Creamery.
He stated," As I travel north on Highway 301 at the fork of Russell Street and 301, that comer
tells a story for who we are as a people. I had a thought that this would make a great Welcome
Center for the Edisto Memorial Gardens. My prayer is that the proposal I give to you will
become a reality. As you can see from the proposal, you will get a better understanding."
Mayor Butler responded, "We will take this under advisement and we will read it and go over it
and get back to you."
A motion as made by Councilmember Stroman, seconded by Councihnember Jernigan, to
reappoint Mr. Francis Faulling to the Hillcrest Golf Course Commission for a term of three (3)
years expiring July, 2021. This motion was unanimously approved
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Haire, to reappoint
Mr. Joseph Keitt to the Hillcrest Golf Course Commission for a term of three (3) years expiring
July, 2021. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Stroman, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, to
reappoint Mr. West Sunllliers to the Board of Adjustments and Appeals for a four (4) year term
expiring July, 2022. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Couneihnember Haire, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, to reappoint
Mr. Willie Hubbard to the Board of Adjustments and Appeals for a four ( 4) year term. expiring
July, 2022. This motion was unanimously approved.
Concerning the Second Reading of an Ordinance amending the Budget for th.e City of
Orangeburg, SC, for the Fiscal Year beginning October 1, 2017 and ending September 30, 2018,
City Administrator Yow stated, "I went over in detaiI in the Budget Meeting and the prior
Council meeting, the details are reflected in the minutes. Nothing has changed. The Airport
final expenditures may be lower due to the bids that recently came in on the water and sewer
project for the new hangar, but that does not affect the General Fund Budget totals."
A motion was made by Councilmember Jernigan, seconded by Councihnember Haire, to approve
the Second Reading of an Ordinance amending the Budget for the City of Orangeburg, SC, for
tl1e Fiscal Year beginning October 1, 2017 and ending September 30, 2018. This motion was
unanimously approved.
Concerning the Second Reading of an Ordinance to Raise Revenue and Adopt a Budget
for the City of Orangeburg, SC, for the Fiscal Year beginning October 1, 2018 and ending
September 30, 2019, City Administrator Yow stated, "We just had the Public Hearing on this
and the details were also covered in the Planning Session and the prior meeting and are reflected
in both meetings minutes. I would like to thank staff and City Council for your support.
Therefore, we will be continuing our current level of services including a nationally accredited
Department of Public Safety with a current ISO Rating of2 and providing great sanitation
services and also recreation programs for our youth and adults. This will allow us to continue
the services that our citizens expect in this community."
Public Works Director Dean Felkel addressed Council regarding an Agreement with G. H. Smith
Construction, Inc., in the amount of $96,991.00 for the extension of water and sewer utilities at
the Orangeburg Municipal Airport.
He stated, 'This project is to provide water and sewer to the new hangar at the Airport as well as
for future hangars and infrastructure. DPU will be providing power for the new hangar and
future hangars. We will have water, sewer and electrical, not only for the new hangar, but for
future expansions. DPU has been a great help. There were six bids from $96,991.00 to
$210,276.00. The good news is that the low bid was substantially lower than what we had
estimated. The estimated costs were $242,000.00. Out of that, $196,000.00 was designated for
this construction. G. H. Smith Construction is from Columbia and they have worked with DPU
and I would recommend that we award the bid to G. H. Smith Construction, Inc."
Page4
Coi2c1'.ii6.ber Stroman asked, "Is the $2,000 for the seed? The only concern that I had was that
they know what kind of seed to put down because they didn't put the right seed down ten years
ago."
Director Felkel replied, "There are specifications and construction guidelines that he has to abide ·
by, we will make sure that gets done."
Councilmember Hannah asked, "Since there is a disparity in the bids between the high and low,
is the City getting every element you asked for in the low bid?"
Director Felkel replied, "Everyone bid on the same specifications and drawings. I know G. H.
Smith Construction has done a lot of work in the past with DPU and everyone bids item to item."
City Administrator Yow replied, "When we have a contract of this nature, we generally have
retainage we keep until we have signed off on the project and we are satisfied with the final
results and the retainage would not be released until after we have approved the job."
Councilmember Hannah stated, "The reason why I ask is because Pepsi and Coke are both a
soda, but there is a difference between the two. When we spend this money, I just want to be
sure when we ask for Pepsi, we get Pepsi and when we ask for Coke, we get Coke."
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Councilmember Knotts, to approve
authorization for City Administrator Yow to enter Agreement with G. H. Smith Construction,
Inc., in the amount of$96,991.00 for extension of water and sewer utilities at the Orangeburg
Municipal Airport. This was a 6-0-1 vote, as Councilmember Stroman abstained.
DPU Manager Warren Harley presented the Second Reading of an Ordinance to adopt an
Amended Budget for the Operation of the Department of Public Utilities of the City of
Orangeburg, SC, for the Fiscal Year October 1, 2017 through September 30, 2018.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Haire, to approve
the Second Reading of an Ordinance to adopt an Amended Budget for the Operation of the
Department of Public Utilities of the City of Orangeburg, SC, for the Fiscal Year October 1,
2017 through September 30, 2018. This motion was unanimously approved.
DPU Director Harley stated, "The budget remains the same as we discussed in the work sessions
and the budget proposed is maintaining a safe and reliable system whereas the customers are
getting the best service for the best price with a reasonable return on investment. Also included,
is a gas increase on our core residential gas customers for just under $5.00 per month for a
typical bill. This does not include any rate increases on industrial customers."
Councilmember Stroman stated. "I don't like to raise taxes or fees; it is just something we have
to do. It costs a lot of money to operate."
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Councilmember Knotts, to approve
the Second Reading of an Ordinance to adopt a Budget for the Operation of the Department of
Public Utilities of the City of Orangeburg, SC, for the Fiscal Year October 1, 2018 through
September 30, 2019. This motion was unanimously approved.
Mr. Eric Odom, Division Director of the Water Division ofDPU addressed Council. He stated,
"The Lease Agreement currently is for a cell phone tower on our tank at 615 Dantzler Street.
This amendment is to allow them to install a permanent generator which is not uncommon
during storms for cell phone towers. Our current Lease Agreement allows for a portable
generator and when approached about the possibility of a permanent generator, we felt this was a
better way to set the specifications for noise control and location."
PageS
2757
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Jernigan, to approve
a Resolution to amend the Lease Agreement between the City of Orangeburg Department of
Public Utilities and SunCom Wireless Property Company, LLC, dated March 26, 2001. This
motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Jernigan, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, to enter
into an Executive Session for a (I) Personnel Matter concerning City Attorney Compensation.
This motion was unanimously approved.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
Respectfully submitted,
. Johnson
City Clerk
/pfb
/
), ..._
/
)'
·-,
DPU PLANNING WORKSHOP
SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES - JUNE 14, 2018
Orangeburg City Council and the Department of Public Utilities held a ~eJary
Planning Workshop Meeting on Thursday, June 14, 2018 at 9:00 a.m. in the"'A's~mbly
Room of the DPU, 1016 Russell Street with Mayor Michael C. Butler presiding.
Mayor Butler opened the meeting by welcoming everyone to the DPU Planning
Workshop Meeting at the Department of Public Utilities.
Mayor Butler gave an invocation.
PRESENT: Michael C. Butler, Mayor
L. Zimmerman Keitt, Mayor Pro Tern
Bernard Haire
Jerry Hannah
Charles W. Jernigan
Sandra P. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
The meeting was then turned over to Mr. Warren Harley, Manager of the Department of
Public Utilities.
Manager Harley welcomed everyone to the meeting. He informed the Mayor and
Members of Council that he will start with a brief overview. The Directors will inform you
about the projects and plans they have projected for the upcoming year. There is a
focus like last year on safety, workforce development and reliability. We hired a Safety
Superintendent which is Wes Connelly. ·He is doing a great job for us. Because of
Wes' dedication to safety to look deeper into issues, we are finding things that we need
to do more intently to be safe. We are training more; we have scheduled training
process throughout the year and being safe starts with that culture of safety. We are
able to find areas of weakness and we will be spending a little more money in those
areas. We don't have exact figures now but Wes has worked on a budget that we will
bring to you during the budget process. We see that we need the biggest of those items
as we go into the process of a comprehensive safety manual. We have one but it is not
in an up-to-date comprehensive way that covers all of the utilities that we have so Wes
is working with a couple of groups to get some quotes so that we can get that done.
Also, pertaining to workforce development we have started in January the DPU
Leadership Institute where we have managers and supervisors attend. We have done
about six sessions which are monthly training where they are exposed to conflict
resolution, communication training, how to deal with a diverse workforce, how to deal
with a multi-generational workforce. There are five generational workforces here at the
same time and we want to make sure we are equipping our leadership to deal with
those people in the workforce, deal with each other so that they can communicate and
understand how we get work done at a more efficiently, more productive level. We
have exposed them to conflict resolution, how you resolve things in a proper
environment. DPU needs to make sure that wherever we are and we are seen we are
handling ourselves as professionals. No matter if you are on a backhoe or in the office,
we are all still professionals. We are focusing on liability. DPU has been around for
100 years and some of our infrastructure is almost that old and we are in a situation
where we necessarily need to start a comprehensive focus on bringing those utilities
and their infrastructure into the 21 st century and make sure that the reliability that we
have maintained over the years is still there. Since I came on board we have had at
least two catastrophic failures in our Electric Division with transformers at substations
where we have lost power to as many as 2,000 people in one case. We need to make
sure that we have a plan going forward on making sure we can replace those things in a
timely manner so they don't happen and force us to do something at the last minute that
would cost us more money than if we were planning it out in a methodical process.
Having said all that, we will start with Josh Nexsen.
Director Josh Nexsen informed the Mayor and City Council that he was going to go over
the goals and objectives of DPU and those are always to provide quality, reliable utility
services safely at the lowest reasonable costs. Through the past year our overall
electric usage is up slightly. One area of a week spot in the Electric Division is that the
industrial load is down a bit and that is due to a number of large industrial customers
have,;atJeJJ~ome lines down and a couple have actually closed. Natural Gas usage is
up al1!'.Hfr'f ~/o over the past year due to industrial load. Water and Wastewater usage
are up a bit; we are starting to see more development/growth in the area. Department
wide we are seeing a slight up-tick. There is a demand for labor which means people
can go get jobs other places so we need to keep benefits up to keep them here.
Manager Harley stated that as you know, we are in the middle of a compensation study
on DPU and the City side and that is ongoing. We've gotten some preliminary numbers
on that and our goals are to make sure that we are being fair and competitively
compensating our employees. Based on what we have seen in the preliminary number
we do not anticipate a big cost impact on DPU. There are certainly some positions and
groups that are a little behind but we think from a financial aspect that we will be able to
manage the cost pretty well and we will keep you up to date. Director Nexsen stated
some overview operational points. In the Electric Division the usage between the two
groups overall usage is up slightly but the primary industrial load is down a bit. Power
supply and distribution costs are increasing; infrastructure replacement costs are
increasing. In Gas we have some significant needs in that division to replace some
aging infrastructure. Water and Wastewater have alw;3ys historically operated at kind of
a break-even point. If you look at the amount of assets tied up in Water and
Wastewater and the net income we get off those two divisions, it is generally in the 1-
2% rate of return. What you are seeing is a preliminary high-level estimate on
revenues, cost of sales operating income for the upcoming year. DPU is in pretty good
shape, but in the next 5 to 15 years some of the costs are going to be significantly
higher; in some case it will be double what they have been in prior years on the capital
side. We have a lot of transformers and substations that we got from the SC Electric
and Gas Company that were basically gifted over to us that we will be replacing over
the next 10-20 years. The budget estimates that the transfer to the City will be the
same; we will work with the City regarding this. The DPU has around $20 million cash
provided by operating activities. In the upcoming years, out of that $20 million, $5.4
million will go to the City for the transfer and that leaves around $15 million left. DPU
will probably in the current year be budgeting to spend around $15 million in capital
improvements. We are going to draw down cash around $866,000. DPU has around
$24 million cash right now. We would estimate at the end of the FY 2019 to remain in
that same range. DPU does have $30 million in an investment account. All those
investments are invested in U.S. Treasuries and agencies in the U.S Government.
None of these investments are in duration of more than 5 years and none of them are in
buckets of more than one year. Manager Harley stated that one of the things Director
Nexsen said was that our fund balance, reserve is pretty healthy at this point.
Sometime people might give you a little flack about having healthy reserves but you are
a utility and everything you do costs a lot of money with respect to infrastructure and the
contractors that you have to get on board to do the work. In the event of a hurricane
which is always looming this time of year for our area and any other things that can go
bad in one of the divisions. Director Labrador had one that went bad this year, so in
terms of being able to respond to those it's important that we have a healthy amount of
cash and then keep in mind that we get a lot of our revenue from the industrial
customers so if one of those closes down, there is a big exposure for us in that regard.
Councilmember Keitt said that it was stated that in 1 to 2 years from now prices will go
up; what will we do to camouflage that kind of thing. Director Nexsen stated that we are
just saying that in general prices are going up. We look at what we buy; we look at what
the price per unit is the last 3 or 4 times we bought it. Those things usually go up about
2 ½ - 3% every month. Manager Harley stated that we have been in a recession for the
last decade and as we start to come out of that and things start to improve, we are
going to start competing with people on buying materials and labor; this is generally
when the price starts to go up on things. Director Durgin has seen this in a couple of his
most recent contracts where we had an estimated project and the bids have come in a
little higher than what we had expected. Director Nexsen stated that he wish he had a
really good answer to how to deal with the rising prices but he doesn't. We always try to
be as fiscally conservative as we can; we try to cut cost where we can. That is really
your number one way to do it which is to control what you can control on that side of
things.
2
Capital Projects
Administrative - Director Josh Nexsen 2729
Project #1: Replacement of Administration Software - Continuing Project - Director
Nexsen stated that this was originally planned to be a 40 month project. The financial
piece took about 18 months; we went live in July 2015 and then the customer
information side which basically is everything that affects our bills going out and what
customers see was done December 1, 2017. The bills looked different, the payment
options were different, the website to pay on was different. It was definitely a big
learning curve for our folks that we trained from 12-18 months. It still takes 6 months for
you to know how to do your job on the new system. There are some things we could
not test until we went live; they have worked its way out. We have seen our call volume
go back to a normal level. We had very long hold times and that has resolved itself.
We went about three or four months without doing any disconnections; we wanted to
make sure that our customer base was familiar with the new bills, payments were being
posted correctly. Manager Harley stated that with any software change you lose a level
of productivity for about six months to a year because you are learning the new system
and you have continuous ongoing training of employees but he feels we will have a
better product in the long run. DPU has weekly meetings with our people to help to deal
with and understand the new software. Our employees have participated in some
statewide user groups as well. We are taking every measure to make sure we get a
proficient system as soon as possifile. Director Nexsen stated that DPU has some
great employees who were very dedicated through that process; they worked through a
lot of challenges; they worked with the customers. We came in about $2 million under
budget on that project. Manager Harley also informed City Council that the DPU
website is being updated. It is not ready for rollout yet. As with anything new, there will
be some learning curves for some people navigating the new website but it will look
better and be easier to manage. Director Nexsen stated that this project is in the
closeout phase and by the end of September of this year it should be completed.
Project #2: Economic Development Building Located in OCCIP - Director Nexsen
stated that the DPU proposed in the past an economic development building two budget
cycles ago. It was approved by City Council to go into the planning stages and when
that happened there were several very large industrial economic development projects
that came along and took precedence over it. We bring this back to say this is an option
for us to continue to participate in economic development. Manager Harley stated that
we want Council to really think about this project. Whether we should put this project
back into the budget again for the FY 18-19 is your decision; especially in light of some
of the things we will have to deal with going forward. It's good in that the goal you
invest in a building you get that return back; it is not like you are sinking money into
something that will not pay you back. Even in our conversations with the County as we
talk through how we can partner together they have said to go after these types of
projects because there is a quicker turnaround. We would need a quicker turnaround
on our money if we are going to invest given the things that we've got to deal with going
forward. Please keep that in mind and we will talk about this a little later.
Project #3: 1036 Russell Street/ DPU Main Office Complex - Previously Approved
Project - Director Nexsen stated that Project #3 was the corner of Russell and Cuttino
Streets; and Cuttino and Oliver Streets as well. We had an original budget of $400,000
and the total project ended up being around $440,000. During that time there were a
couple of change orders put in for Cuttino Street and Oliver Street regarding paving
them. The City has both of those streets on its list of things to do in the upcoming year
or two so we were able to get these streets paved at the same time that they had all the
asphalt torn up and got it all paved and it will be no cost to the City. If you take those
streets out we actually came about $40,000 under budget for the project. We think it
has improved the traffic flow on busy days. We definitely have seen fewer backing
accidents.
Project #4: Operations Center Crew Quarters - Previously Approved Project - Director
Nexsen stated this project is an Operations Center improvement to the Crew Quarters.
3
When the original Operations Center was built, the warehouse and crew quarters were
integrated into one building. The warehouse with the crew quarters along the front of
the building was built in 1967, more than 50 years ago when the DPU was about a third
of it:O,<o¥fflt size. Those Crew Quarters have become very cramped for the number of
staff'memlkrs we have. Over the past year we have taken some steps to do some
programming. Programming is where an architect firm comes in and talks to the
employees and supervisors; they look at the kinds of work you do, your head counts and
they try to come up with a plan for the next 50 years. There is a fair amount of work to
do because with the plan to build a new building it requires moving the existing laydown
yard and other issues we have to deal with like the railroad right-of-way. Manager
Harley stated that if we stay with the current design of the building we could use it to
house out of town utility personnel when they are here to help with disasters and there
are no more hotels available. Most of you have seen the current facility and it is not a
jewel in our facilities treasures so we need to address this and get something that fits
the time and the way we operate and do business as it currently stands. Director
Nexsen said we think this will be a generational project; it will be a 50-60 year project;
this isn't a 10-15 year project. For 20 years DPU has been growing at a pretty good
rate; Orangeburg hasn't grown for about 10 years but it is not going to be like that
forever. The challenges on this project is that you are reworking the current 6 acre site
where all your inventory is. You have to move all that, build a building on it, redo all the
storm water and build several big buildings subdividing the parcels out between the land
that was purchased in 2004. You are revising a lot of the_ traffic patterns. Right now
there are no clear traffic lanes and construction of the new Crew Quarters, Assembly
Building and Storage Building in that project.
Project #5 - 400 kW Backup Generator for the Main Office - Previously Approved
Project - Director Nexsen stated that during the loss of commercial power which hasn't
happened a lot but when it does happen it can be real bad. Everything at DPU 20 years
ago would be in a room .like we are in putting pins in a cork board and writing down
outages. Literally everything at the DPU is electronic now. There is a nerve center here
that is fed by an air conditioner but it's not on a backup generator. Server rooms are
kept really cold because if they get over a certain temperature they will shut themselves
down so they don't have any damage done to them. Our current server supports our
SCADA system, the outage system, the customer service system, the dispatching
system which is all electronic now and it is not on backup. The computers are on a
backup generator but the air conditioner that cools them is not. If we have an outage
like we had in 2016 we are crossing our fingers hoping that it doesn't get too hot in there
to shut down the server. This project should be done in the current fiscal year by the
end of September; it may take a month or so longer than that but we are trying to get it
done as soon as possible. This project was slated to be about $600,000 and we think
we are going to come in a little lower than that. The backup generator will serve the
entire building.
Director Nexsen stated that this is a summary of all the projects. Project #1 again no
expenditures in the upcoming year planned. Project #2 is dependent on City Council to
give DPU direction. Project #3 - no more expenditures for the upcoming year. Project
#4 will be a multi-year project which will take about 2 years/24 months to complete.
Right now all we have spent is about $150,000 on programming and planning. If DPU
got authority to proceed with that project we would go ahead and have the dart speck
and the design speck and create a request for proposal that goes out to contractors. It
would be a competitive bid process that would not be done until after October 1
st
if we
are given approval. Project #5 we hope to have completed by the end of this fiscal year
so there would be no expenditures in the upcoming fiscal year for this project. Manager
Harley asked if there were any questions. The Operations Center was one of the things
he sent to Council ahead of time because it was a significant project and Manager
Harley wanted to make sure Council had a chance to look through it if case they had
any questions.
Electric Division - Director Wade Holmes
Director Holmes informed the Mayor and City Council that the Electric Division has eight
capital improvement projects for FY 2018-2019.
4
Project #1 - 115 KV Transrnission Line Extension to Highway 601 Substation #10
Previously Approved Project - This project will provide more reliability to thisM9"tion
and will cost around $1.90 million.
Project #2 - Rebuild - Highway 601 Substation #10 - Previously Approved Project -
This substation serves the Highway 601 area which is one of the fastest growing areas
on our system. We will be placing that substation on the 115 KV system. This is
important because from SCE&G we have seven delivery points, four at 115,000 volts
and three at 46 KV volts. With the future of SCE&G up in the air, we don't know if they
will be able to provide that 46 KV voltage to us or if we went to another transmission
owner service provider whether they will have that 46 KV voltage. The 46 KV voltage is
old and antiquated; most transmission owners operate at 115,000 or 230,000 volts. We
at DPU have·to redesign our thought patterns when we are building substations to
create a more self-sufficient 46 KV system if we keep those substations.
Project #3 - Rebuild - Goff Avenue/Claflin/SCSU Substation #17 Upgrade - Previously
Approved Project (On-Hold) - This project is on hold right now; we are still going to
rebuild that substation but we need to do some re-engineering of how that station is
going to be fed; it is a 46 KV system.
Project #4 - Peak Shaving / Wastewater Plant Generator - Rowesville Road Substation
#20 - Previously Approved Project On-Hold) - This is a 2 megawatt generator that we
were going to put at Substation #20. That project was going to give us cost benefits
through the end of our contract with SCE&G. If that contract got renewed we would get
a credit for having it. At this time we are going to cancel putting that 2 megawatt
generator at Substation #20 because we don't know what the future holds for SCE&G.
Project #5 - City of Orangeburg Street Lights Upgrade LED Lighting - Previously
Approved Project - This is our street light project which provide LED lighting. These
lights have a longer life cycle. This project will be completed by the early November
2018 timeframe.
Project #6 - Rebuild - Substation #18 (SI Group) - Previously Approved Project- This
project is a rebuild of Substation #18 on Cannon Bridge Road. This is the feed point of
our largest industrial customer the SI Group. This substation is roughly 40 years old
and is on our 46 KV system. We want to take it off that 46 KV system and put it on the
115 KV system which will make it a lot more reliable and have that added capacity for
when the SI Group starts to expand.
Project #7 - Rebuild - Substation #1 (Bull Street) - Proposed Project - This is a new
project for Substation #1 on Bull Street. This substation is 50 years old and it is past its
life cycle. This substation feeds to the Water Treatment Plant which is a critical asset
for the Water Division. Back in August of 2017 the transformer at that substation
experienced a catastrophic failure which was due to age because the material inside the
transformer started to break down which caused one of the insulators to blow out. This
substation feeds roughly 2,000 customers and as well as the Water Treatment Plant.
Manager Harley stated that we currently have no spare transformers and we were trying
to find one. Director Nexsen said that there was not one transformer in the eastern
United States to replace it with. Manager Harley said what we had on the yard wasn't a
perfect fit and Director Holmes will explain what was done. Director Holmes stated and
showed on a slide where they had to do some creative engineering to actually make
that spare transformer to work. The fix is not technically ideal but it works. The new
transformers for Substation #1 and Substation #12 were ordered right after this failure
and they will be in and on sight in July of this year.
Manager Harley stated that this highlights the issues that we are going to see regarding
as this system continues to age. These substations run 24 hours a day, seven days a
week and sometimes in extreme weather.
5
Project #8 - Rebuild - Substation #12 (Berry Street) Proposed Project - This
Substation is behind BB&T Bank on Berry Street. This substation also has that unique
connection that you do not find anywhere in the world anymore. When they built the
sys~"7Ul was the thirig to do but now any transformer that DPU purchases we will
ma~ stir$' that it is more of a standardized unit so that we can plug and play at any
substation that we have. Manager Harley stated that because of the age of the units at
Substation 1 and Substation 12 they don't make parts for them anymore and you would
have to get them fashioned. Director Holmes stated the transformer has shown through
testing that this transformer is worse than the one at Substation 1. It is not a matter of if
it is going to fail but when it is going to fail. We are on a rush timeline to get it changed
before that happens.
Gas Division - Director Dave Durgin
Director Durgin stated that the Gas Division has two major priorities; the first is safety
our number one priority to our employees, customers and to the general public and the
second is reliability. Customers expect service 24!7 whenever they need it and
wherever they need it with minimal interruption. One of the challenges the Gas Division
has is if Director Holmes has an electric outage he can flip a switch and reconnect
customers but for the Gas Division to reconnect 25 people we have to turn every one of
those folks off. We have a procedure that takes several hours and then we have to
reconnect each customer individually which can take up to a day to complete so we try
really hard to provide reliable service because in the end that is the most cost efficient
way operating.
Director Durgin stated that for 2019 they have identified a number of areas of concern
on our existing system that we feel need to be addressed to help us provide that reliable
service. To help pay for that, we also continue to seek new opportunities for growth and
the good news is that we are in talks with several large users about extending usage to
those facilities. The DPU gas system started in 1954 which makes us 64 years old.
When the system was originally installed it was an all steel system. One of the ways
that we protect steel natural gas pipe is with a methodic protection system which is a
fancy way of saying that we put an electrical current on it that prevents it from corroding.
Unfortunately that wasn't a common industry practice until the mid-1970s so from a third
of its life the pipe was underground and unprotected. That means that any corrosion
that occurred at that time wasn't reversed; whatever damage was done, was done. We
are now beginning to see the effects of some of that now. Our steel pipes that were
installed in the 50s and 60s in high concentrated areas of people and commercial
activities. We are meeting all pipeline· safety regulations and have passed all our
inspections but we must find ways to deal with our infrastructure in a cost-efficient
manner. We have identified characteristics to prioritize our replacement program.
Obviously pipes with a leak history, pipes further from our methodic protection system -
the further you get away from the sourcing of the protection system the less protection
you have .. The pipes closest to the source have the most protection. Councilmember
Haire asked with what we see happening regarding explosions around the world, are we
looking at that kind of situation with our aging system. Director Durgin stated that it is
not impossible but a lot of those situations that have occurred are leaks on the customer
side of the meter. One of the threats that would involve what you are discussing would
be what we call a cross-four type situation which is when a gas line happens to be
installed inside a wastewater line and it causes an issue where a plumber may come
and clean out a wastewater line and it causes gas to fill up a house. We have not had
that situation and in our construction practices that we do and we try to mitigate any of
those situations. Manager Harley stated that one of the reasons we sent you
information regarding our 25 year planning is so that we don't get to a point where that
kind of stuff is happening on our side of the ledger. · As he has met with all the
department directors over the last year and a half, Director Durgin has stated gas is an
optional utility. In other words, people can decide not to use gas but the other three
utilities they have to use. What causes people to opt out of using gas is if they feel like
it is unsafe and we need to do everything on our side to make sure that we are able to
deliver it in a safe manner. If our system starts to degrade where we can't keep up with
it we would probably lose a generation of customers. We are at a point now with the
age of the system we won't be able to stay ahead of the need to repair and replace and
6
the cost will be more if we continue to patch instead of doing some of the wholesale
improvements that is needed. Councilmember Jernigan asked if more customers are
changing to gas or going gas when they build a house. Director Durgin stated that
typically we have gotten 95% of new construction but we also have not had ~~1lftlew
construction in the area recently. Mostly we see water heaters, fireplaces antr'f6r'nates.
Stoves are probably about 30% of new construction, dryers are about 20%. Manager
Harley stated that one idea that we have discussed but have not brought to you yet is
that some utility companies have encouraged in a more aggressive way people
changing over to gas. Director Durgin stated that we actually have a rebate program
available to our core customers in Orangeburg. He stated that we talked about our
steel pipe is at risk but the good news is that our high pressure loop that goes around
the City has shown to be in very good condition. It is really our low pressure distribution
system that has more issues. We have come up with a five-year plan to address our
most critical concerns. We are proposing investing a million plus dollars a year in
upgrading the gas system; this is a 20-25 year plan. At the end of it we are still looking
at having pipe in the system that is 90 years old but we are going to address the most
risky pipes that have the most potential of causing us issues. For the following fiscal
year we are looking at addressing pieces of Russell Street and Belleville Road and after
that along Riverbank Drive and other low pressure areas. Councilmember Haire asked
about the Elloree project. Director Durgin stated that the Elloree Project is completed.
We are currently hooking up customers; we have 4 that are fully connected at this time,
we have another seven services that are being run this week. We have a goal of
getting 100 services within the first three years; we are 11 % to our goal with three
months into the connection period. Manager Harley stated that one of the challenges
Director Durgin has run into is plumbers. Director Durgin said that DPU is a utility
distribution company and we are all dependent on contractors, electricians, plumbers to
do the customer-side of the work to be able to take our utility. With Elloree being a new
area there is not a native group of plumbers doing gas work and so that group of
plumbers is being identified now. Manager Harley stated that will help to speed up the
process. Councilmember Stroman asked how many new customers from the Oaks to
Santee. Director Durgin said the DPU has only picked up two or three; we are
expecting more of a commercial development to occur near 1-95 to the intersection with
it and the County has also contacted us about their future plans for the Jafza Park.
Water Division - Director Eric Odom
Project #1 - 1 O" Water Main Replacement along Shillings Bridge Road - Previously
Approved Project - This particular section of water main we have had 12 breaks on
record, 7 in the past six years. It has become a problem area for us because it can
significantly increase the likelihood of contamination to the system every time we have a
break. There are no street lights in this area, but also in this particular area the water
main is almost underneath the roadway and traffic along this road tends to go very fast
so it is a safety concern for our employees at night so we do the best we can with it
now. This project has somewhat evolved since we started the design process; we are
still projecting to get this project completed this fiscal year. We ran into some wetlands
issues and had to hire an engineer to go out and do some mitigation for us. The good
news is that once he did all his work we found out we are not going to have to go into
the wetlands so it is going to save us time and money. We are planning on bidding this
project and will receive bids July 11th.
Project #2 1954 High Service Pump Station, Engine Driven Pump Station and
Chlorine Scrubber at the Water Treatment Plant - Previously Approved Project - This is
a previously approved project. The good thing is that the pumps were probably built
better than you could buy anything today so our plans are to reutilize those existing
pumps and have them rebuilt. We will send them off to a factory that specializes in this
type of repair and they will be rebuilt back to the 1950's standard that you cannot buy
today. This project has evolved overtime; we had planned on rehabbing the entire 1954
Pump Station, we have looked into that building extensively since Council approved us
to get started with this project last year and we have decided to move some of these
pumps. One will be moved to a newer building and add the other one on our Clear Well
which will get us up to our 30 million gallon a day permitted capacity by DHEC and
improve our finished water pumping capacity for the next 20 years. The Chlorine Gas
7
Scrubber was put in the year 1999. Chlorine Gas is not conducive; it will corrode. We
will be replacing this Chlorine Scrubber as part of this project also and it will hopefully
give us another 20 years of life. .
WasiJJJ Division - Director Richard Labrador
Project #1 - Biosolids Dryer Replacement - Director Labrador stated that our sludge
dryer will need to be replaced. The original dryer was purchased in 1997 and it was
then replaced in 2004. There were issues with the first one and it never really met the
design requirements so the 2004 purchase was kind of a trade in finance. Fast forward
and several months ago the dryer finally quit working. It had a 10 year design life; we
got Closer to 13 ½ years out of it. The idea all along was either to purchase another
dryer or wait for it to fail because we were not happy with its performance and then
purchase another but in the meanwhile go to the landfill. We are now going to the
landfill and are looking at replacing the dryer right now. It will eliminate the landfill
hauling and the disposal costs that we are paying right now. The hauling and landfill
disposal is costing around $30,000 a month. Manager Harley said that Director
Labrador told him the problem with landfill costs is you are subject to their will and they
can either tell you not to come anymore or push the price up even more. Director
Labrador said the landfill is owned by Waste Management; the County landfill cannot
take sludge from the plants. The plants that have sludge that go to landfills are
scheduled D landfills that are lined and they protect the ground water, etc.; they handle
scavenger type waste and household waste. We will continue to dry with newer
technology and a more reliable machine. What we have been looking at will produce
the volume and increase the quality of our solids and the drying produces that Class A
Biosolids that we can sell or give away as soil amendment. Before the dryer quit on us,
we were selling the Biosolids to a local farmer. We have a contract where they come
and pick it up. We charge them a modest fee for selling them the Biosolids. The best
thing about the newer machine is that we will keep a smaller footprint that allows in the
future to get a second machine if we ever need to expand and get a larger machine we
will have a second one for reliability. The building that we have was originally built to
handle two machines and we will not have to build a new building. We also will keep
our tracking down in the plant because right now we have the trucks from Waste
Management taking three loads a day and that is why it cost so much because we
generate a lot of stuff and we have to pick up the containers that we fill up and then haul
off to the landfill so that is where the cost comes in. We have already started
preliminary engineering and will have some more details regarding what we have to do.
Director Labrador stated that he feels we will be able to reuse most of the equipment
that we already have and may need to make some modifications but not too many. The
main cost will be in the engineering and the machine itself. Manager Harley said that
we will know more specifically after the PDR is done but in lieu of being hostage to the
landfill and that price going up we need to be able control our own destiny in how we
manage this and we have talked through it and the best option at this time is for us is to
replace the dryer.
Manager Harley asked if there were any questions. He then invited Consultant Tom
Sullivan to give his presentation. His presentation will be about our rates and where we
are and in light of some of the things we have to do going forward.
Consultant Presentation
Consultant Sullivan gave background information regarding what has happened in the
recent past. Electric base rates where changed in October 2015; the bulk of the electric
revenue is the power supply cost and we change that twice a year based on what our
supplier costs are. The gas rates, the residential commercial rates where last changed
in 2009; the industrial rates which really only affected about a dozen biggest customers
where changed in 2013. We had originally included a residential commercial rate at
that time. He stated that we did make some modifications to the transportation rates a
little over a year ago and that was primarily in response to our larger industrial
customers and also to have rates available for some of the larger projects that were
going to come in with potentially really high volumes. This time last year he had
recommended and it was approved by City Council the third of the three-part phase of
8
water and wastewater rates that had started back in 2014 which went into effect in the
beginning of the fiscal year that we you are currently in. Overall, Electric usage is up
3% and that is primarily because this past winter was colder than the prior winter. The
winter before this past winter was one of the warmest winters we have ~~ in
Orangeburg. A large part of that weather benefit was offset by the fa~ (h'll'.r-'our
industrial sales have been down; they have been down virtually every month this fiscal
year and a lot of that is due to retooling and shutting down of some lines which hopefully
are temporary. Potentially what is happening with industrial customers is when they
change out equipment the equipment they put in is technically more efficient. When SI
Group switched their boilers we thought we were going to get a big uptake in load but
we didn't get a lot and some of it was because they replaced the boilers with a much
more efficient system and even though they were using more gas and energy there
were some ups and downs as far as electricity goes. Gas usage was up quite a bit
because of that colder winter and also there were two large industrial customers who
added loads in the last year. Water usage is up and revenues are up 11 % primarily due
to the rates increase that was approved last year. Wastewater usage has been flat;
wastewater revenues are really dependent upon surcharges and those get reevaluated
on a regular basis. The 8% increase in revenues is attributable to the rate increase that
was approved last year. Consultant Sullivan stated that he was mostly going to focus
on the gas and electric divisions. Over that last 15 years most of the large projects that
have been done have really been on water and wastewater. Because of the cash flow
generated by the gas and electric divisions we were able to finance a lot of that;
especially the water work just from internal funds. We were anticipating starting to use
the gas and electric cash flows on the gas and electric systems and that was a large
input to why we borrowed money from the SC Water Quality Revolving Fund Authority
to fund the Wastewater Plant. We have done some internal analyses looking at the
aging facilities on both the gas and electric systems and have done some estimates of
what to replace those facilities would cost. The substation upgrades in the electric
division that Director Holmes talked about will eventually include poles, conductors and
feeds that are also 50-60 years old. Over the next 10 years we are talking about $130
million. We also have the gas extension projects, the special projects and those
customers pay a higher rate. These projects are designed to have the customers that
are served off of those systems pay for those systems within a 10-15 year period. The
existing older system is not subsidizing those systems and those systems really aren't
subsidizing the current system; but once they pay for the system they will have paid for
everything and the customers will be contributing positively to the rest of the system.
The infrastructure that Dave was talking about was really on the old, not on the special
project systems or the outlying areas but really on the old core original system. As
Director Durgin discussed, they need to replace the old steel mains and there is also
service lines that are connected to those mains so when you replace the mains you also
replace the service lines. The estimate on that is probably in the neighborhood of
around $35-40 million over a longer period of time. As Director Holmes stated, the
issue with the substations is probably a little bit more severe because all of the
substations we got from SCE&G are all of the same era which makes it a higher sense
of urgency to replace them. With Director Durgin, he was able to identify the worse stuff
and they are able to prioritize it; he can do that in a more systematic way. Historically
the Electric Division has been the primary source of the cash finance projects for not
only the electric but the water and wastewater divisions. They account for 75% of the
transfer, 75% of the revenues, probably 80-90% of the profits. Consultant Sullivan said
that they met yesterday to begin the initial phases to determine what is the most optimal
way to pay for these improvements. Our existing rates cannot support $170 million of
capital projects. What we are looking at is ways to potentially finance those projects
over a longer period of time. We are looking at finding the optimal mix of using internal
funds and maybe some debt financing in order to mitigate the rate impact. The plan is
to more fully develop that plan over the next 12 months to give you an idea of the longer
term financing and the rates that potentially will be needed to support that next year.
This year the rate discussion is really to discuss the gas rate that we have been kicking
the can down the road for the last five years. Manager Harley stated that the first part is
just identifying what the needs are and costs. Now we have a pretty good handle on
what Director Holmes and Director Durgin need in terms of what needs to be done. The
next phase is sitting down with the group and figuring out what the recommendation will
be to you how we proceed. One thing he wants everyone to keep in mind is we need to
9
have a really healthy reserve because of what we are exposed to so theoretically you
can spend a lot of cash to do some of this stuff but it would not be the wise thing to do
based on how we are exposed to storms or the failure of our equipment and the costs to
repl~-Q.l}Q repair. We want to make sure we do a mix where it keeps our cash on
han<r'p'relt}'healthy and manage to keep Council from doing gigantic rate increases; we
need to balance that out across the board. Consultant Sullivan stated that for the last
10 years the Gas Division's projects the DPU has not really been growing; adding
facilities. It has really been kind of a maintenance mode and when we shift into more of
a renewal and replacement mode you are likely to see that staffing needs will need to
be changed in order to manage all of the work and operate the facilities. You need to
be able to keep your existing customers happy, you need to maintain the system, you
need to do renewals and replacements, and you need to be responsive to growth.
Councilmember Keitt stated that· she is glad to see more emphasis placed on
maintenance. Consultant Sullivan said that when we put stuff in the ground it is brand
new and you don't really have to do much. · If the methodic protection wasn't done in the
60s the gas pipes would have been gone 25 years ago. There are things that have
been done but some of the construction practices that were used that were thought to .
be able to last forever weren't tested years back and come to find out they aren't as
good as everyone thought they were. When it gets to be real bad we rather replace the
whole thing than continuously patch different areas. Manager Harley said that DPU is
no different than any organization that when you go through lean times like the last 10
years from the recession to tend to try to hold· on in a different way and most local
government agencies don't want to raise rates or taxes so they try to go into a mode to
sustain and kicking the can down the road. It is a reaction that may not have served a
lot of organizations well because probably the best time to start doing some of this work
is during those lean times but it is hard to do. Consultant Sullivan said the DPU has
historically been very conservative from the standpoint of borrowing money and
sometimes if you are just trying to do projects based on the cash you are generating
that limits your scope. The water improvements that were done several years ago for
$20-25 million used up a lot of cash that basically deferred some the stuff that Director
Holmes and Director Durgin were talking about. We are talking about something that is
on a fairly large scale that will take a long time so it makes more sense to do a more
reasonable balance of cash and debt financing. When we look at the revenue number
for the DPU it is $100 million; $70 million of that is electric and 75% of that electric is
money to be paid primarily to SCE&G to buy electricity which is just a straight pass
through. Our revenue number tends to be a little bit inflated because we are not
producing the electricity and the gas; we are paying third parties to provide it. We
manage this on both gas and electric very closely. We monitor this every month and we
adjust the rates on gas every month and electric we do it every six months to make sure
that we are collecting our power costs. We don't try to over-collect and we certainly
don't want to get into a position where we are under-collecting because a lot of this is
driven because the Nuclear Plant is not being built. If Natural Gas prices goes up this
goes up. Fortunately gas prices have been very stable but we have history in the past
where prices were much higher and much more volatile so we always have to be really
recognizant and monitor and work with that closely. On the Electric Division right now
because we just had the rate increase three years ago we are not proposing any rate
increase; we think we can cover this year but as we prepare this plan over the next year
there i~ probably going to be some mix of rates and debt that we are going need to look
at on electric in the coming years. We are expecting the infrastructure on gas to be
about $30-40 million over the next 20-25 years. The existing rates are insufficient to
support these and the increasing costs. The special project rates have a surcharge.
Those bustomer pay a much higher rate for 10-15 years to pay for their system and
once their system is paid for the surcharge goes away and they revert back to the
systemi Those projects and the feasibility of those projects whether we do them or not
are based on whether we connect enough customers to pay for them. If we can't
connect enough customers we project to pay for them we don't do the project; these are
basically self-paying projects. The Gas Division, after the transfer, generally averaged
just under $1 million a year in net income and a little bit more than that in cash: The
audit he just got from Director Nexsen is half that and that Is Just the erosion of
increasing costs, increasing transfers is a part of that, benefit costs, material costs; all of
that has just eroded that down and he is projecting that it wil_l continu_e to erode and
once those capital projects start kicking in the numbers will obviously, without increases
10
in rates, we will not be able to afford the capital projects. Consultant Sullivan said the
last major rate increase on gas was 2013 and that particular recommendation that was
made at that time was $325,000 a year for residential and $290,000 for industrial. The
industrial rate was approved but the residential was not Our core residentia1-,,:t11ryers
are not covering costs and are not generating enough cash flow to replat'e tl"i'e old
system. An average residential customer if you take out gas costs contributes about
$176 a year in margin. The actual cost of that is almost double that, it's like $350, so in
order to make up that gap you have to actually to increase rates by $14 a month. He is
not going to suggest that The industrial rates are recovering the costs. The other
concerns we have on industrial rates are that they are much more of a competitive
market In some cases they can burn a different fuel, in some cases they can actually
direct connect into the pipeline and just eliminate service from the DPU altogether if we
charge too much. Most of the companies here have plants in other locations and so
they are always looking at what we are charging versus what is being charged at those
plants and occasionally we have started to get some feedback that our rates on
industrial are bumping up against the maximum that we can charge. Director Durgin
stated that those companies that have multiple plants internal projects are competitive
within the plants that they own and we have received feedback that the Orangeburg
plants may not be as competitive as some other their other plants located elsewhere.
Consultant Sullivan said we have become really sensitive; some of the response
regarding the change to the transportation rate earlier was to recognize that the rate we
had in place was probably impediment to customers adding incremental capacity to
their plants so we put an incentive in the rate where if they use more than they have
historically used they can use at a lower rate and that has worked for one customer.
The problem we have is that we have a pretty big infrastructure that is really being
supported by our industrial customers primarily and more of that load is going to need to
be picked up by our residential and commercial customers. In order to meet that deficit
he has developed some rates to demonstrate what source of rate increase would be
needed to meet the deficit For the core residential customers in the City their annual
usage is 400 therms and that translates into an average monthly bill of about $34.31.
The rates that would be needed to meet that deficiency would be raised to $39; that
would be about $4.69 a month increase. The core commercial customers are closer to
$11. Even though we are talking about a lot of infrastructure replacement and it is
expensive and an increase in rates, the good news is we are starting from such a low
comparable level that even with the increase we have and potentially increases down
the road, we are still going to be highly competitive and among the lowest in North
Carolina and South Carolina. Manager Harley said that one of the things is you never
want to be in a situation where we have the amount of infrastructure replacement
needed to be done and at that higher level; that would have meant you had not used
your money wisely. Over the last 15-20 years DPU has maintained lower rates,
maintained quality service, done a great job but it also means we have room now to
tackle the problems at hand. Consultant Sullivan stated that we want to have a plan in
place to do it and also having a plan in place to pay for it Ultimately part of that is
paying for it through higher charges. In reviewing the infrastructure plan we are not only
looking at gas and electric; we also need to be cognizant of what the needs are on
infrastructure in water and wastewater. Manager Harley stated that we would propose
that we do a rate increase on gas. We are not ready to give you a number on electric
yet; we want to be on point so that as Council talks to customers and citizens you can
rightly defend whatever you decide to do as a Council. We are comfortable where we
are and what we need to do starting now on gas to give you that projection. As we
develop the plan further we will be able to come back and tell you where we need to go
from there. Consultant Sullivan said this is the increase we asked for in 2013 and it just
goes up every year; this is almost a catch-up to get us where we thought we should
have been five years ago. Manager Harley stated that Council has been careful and
considerate of the customers and that is why we only bring this to you when we've dug
into it and it is really at this point that the best option for us is to propose raising gas
rates; we will do only what you tell us to do. Councilmember Stroman asked if they
could go back to discussing building a spec building in the Orangeburg County City
Industrial Park. He said the he feels we should move forward with the project Manager
Harley stated that he really wanted Council's feedback on this project as well as the
rates. We thought for the last two years this is something that we felt is doable and a
wise decision that made sense to do. It is probably still in his opinion over giving cash
11
to deals, over seeding projects with cash; it's probably the most doable and sensible
step forward for us because we will be able to turn that quicker than anything else we
would do other than building a new project for a company that has already decided to -
com,7~tllse keep that in mind when you think through all of this or you can put it on
the 1i'aclt'l¾rner and say we want to hold off because I have reached out to the County
on several occasions to try to get their feedback on what they think they are going to be
looking to do going forward. Manager Harley said he has not received feedback from
the County; it really would be helpful if they shared what they are going to do. He said
that he is a planner and likes to know what is next as much as possible because he
doesn't like to bring Council any surprises. Sometimes things are unavoidable but he
has been talking to the County to see what their next steps are and what type of help
they want from us. Councilmember Jernigan asked where DPU is looking to build a
spec building - in the OCCIP or at the airport. Manager Harley said he has spoken to
the County about their view of this and we have talked internally and with the City, Mr.
John Yow, what he thinks; either one of the areas works for us in terms of the services
we provide - we get a return on all of them. We wouldn't want to put a spec building
anywhere we don't have electric and gas at the top of the list. We just need from the
two governmental sides what makes sense. Councilmember Jernigan asked if DPU
has infrastructure at the airport. Manager Harley said we have everything at the airport
as well as at the OCCIP. Director Labrador said the only thing that is different is that
one area is in the City and one area is in the County. There will be more of a return on
the area in the City. Manager Harley said that if you do the airport, that is a tax base for
the City and revenue for DPU as well. The County is still working through their budget
which is a July to June budget so hopefully they'll get their things ironed out and then
they will sit down with us and talk through what they may be expecting us to do going
forward.
Manager Harley informed Council that what he sent to them earlier was a request for
them to consider in lieu of a City vehicle for the manager to allow him to receive a car
allowance. That would mean he would not receive a car directly from the City. All the
gas, all the responsibility, maintenance of that vehicle would be on the Manager and not
the City; it would be in lieu of what we currently have in the budget to spend this year for
a City vehicle which is around $43,000; it is basically a replacement of the current
vehicle that he is driving. He simply asks that if Council be inclined to do a car
allowance in lieu of that so you would not make that car purchase. Manager Harley
stated that it is a great deal what he has now but he wishes to forego some of those
benefits and receive the car allowance. Councilmember Stroman made a motion to
accept the request of Manager Harley to receive a car allowance of $750 a month,
second by Councilmember Keitt, approved unanimously.
Manager Harley informed Council that they do not have to vote on a gas rate increase
now and he will not bring it to them at the Special Council Meeting if they are not
inclined to consider it.
Mayor Butler thanked everyone for the direction that the DPU is going in. As Mayor, he
sees cohesiveness between the Manager, Directors and Administrative team. He likes
that everything that was requested for the various areas is in order to improve the
services of DPU and to give our customers better quality services. He stated that he is
really impressed and hopes that Council will be able to meet most of the needs. Mayor
Butler said he appreciates what DPU does and the leadership. Manager Harley stated
that all five of the Directors do a great job; they try to shoulder the burden to make sure
everything goes right in their areas and they own it. Each and every one of them takes
it as a personal responsibility to do a good job; they are not to be taken for granted.
Councilmember Haire asked when will we deal with the rates. Manager Harley said
DPU will bring the rates up in the budget. He was waiting on a clear indication or
consensus one way or the other and what he takes from what he hears is that most of
you are in line with considering that further so it will be in the _budget. Councilmember
Keitt thanked DPU; she really appreciated the updates regarding infrastructure and the
foresight of what is needed and what has to be done. It is a blessing to us to see you
putting a plan together to address these issues. Councilmember Stroman thanked DPU
for what they do; it is very professional and you do a good job. I am proud of you; I
complain about rates because people complain to me.
12
Councilmember Haire made a motion to adjourn the meeting, second by
Councilmember Keitt, approved unanimously. The meeting was adjourned.
Respectfully submitted,
Carol E. Franklin
Executive Administrative Assistant to the Manager
Department of Public Utilities
13
2739
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING AUGUST 14, 2018
Oran~!fiCity Council held a Special Meeting on Tuesday, August 14, 2018 at 5:30
p.m. ffl t~'Assembly Room of the Department of Public Utilities, 1016 Russell Street
with Mayor Michael C. Butler presiding.
May~r Butler opened the meeting by welcoming everyone to the Special City Council
Meeting at the Department of Public Utilities.
Manager Warren T. Harley gave an invocation.
PRESENT: Michael C. Butler, Mayor
L. Zimmerman Keitt, Mayor Pro Tern
Bernard Haire
Jerry Hannah
Charles W. Jernigan
Sandra P. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
The meeting was then turned over to Warren T. Harley, Manager of the Department of
Public Utilities.
Budget Presentations
Manager Warren Harley to Mayor and Council
Manager Harley proceeded by thanking the Mayor and Members of Council for taking
time to attend the Special Meeting. He informed City Council that the proposed 2018-
2019 budget is designed to meet all the needs for our upcoming year in terms of
providing resources to maintain reliability, maintain safety standards throughout the
entire department and all divisions. We also have provided resources that might
provide a little increase to employees which we will go into with a little more detail
shortly. Also, if you look at the very back of your notebooks we have "Department
Wide" which is all of the equipment and other items that are routine throughout the
department; we can go into as much detail in that as you would like. Most of the
presentation today will be those big ticket items and capital expenditures in each
department. We also will discuss a rate increase for the Gas Division. We will go into
that in a little more detail after the divisions have given their presentations and we will
talk through the impact of that rate increase and what it would mean to the department
going forward. Manager Harley said we will start with Director Nexsen; he will give you
a brief overview of the financials and then move directly into his Administrative Division
discussion. Manager Harley asked if there were any questions.
************************************************************
ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION - OPERATIONAL AND CASH FLOW BUDGET
JOSH NEXSEN - DIRECTOR
Director Nexsen welcomed the Mayor and Council. He said that as always, DPU is
pleased to present to City Council it's operational and capital budgets for the upcoming
year. The operational budget details all the changes in DPU's net position for the year.
The details of those changes are in your binder on the first few pages and are broken
down by division and the department wide total. Operating revenues are projected to
be down just slightly; the offset is in purchased gas and electric. Offsetting the decline
in sales we don't project those to be very large, just around 1 %. Total expenses are
projected only to increase slightly over the upcoming year, around 1-2%; the primary
being depreciation which has about a 12-13% increase in the upcoming year and that is
primarily due to the fact that DPU has spent a lot more on capital improvements than it
has historically. Once those things start depreciating, you realize your expense once
that starts happening. The total revenue for the budget is $104,939,000; this is in the
Public Notice. This is operating revenues, non-operating income and the capital
contribution, which are reimbursements for outlays of capitals that we buy from other
parties. In this case it is a utility extension which we will go into later in the meeting.
Also things like the Penny Project show as capital contributions. Total expenses of the
budget will be $91,489,000 which is the total costs of sales, operating eXPJJ'l1lai-land
general fund transfers to the City of Orangeburg. Income before transfers flhfl ta'):>ital
contributions are budgeted to be $13,449,980. The DPU also included in your budget
documents two amendments we generally do every year on the 2016-2017 operational
cash flow budgets. Those are the versions that were presented to Council in the August
7, 2018 minutes by our auditor. This is just to amend the budget to final for the actual
outcome of the year and there is also an ordinance in your budget materials to amend
the 2017-2018 budget to more closely and accurately portray the outcome of the current
years cash flow statement. The cash flow statement for the upcoming fiscal year is
probably a better representation of what cash comes into the company and how it is
used. Capital improvement costs have significantly increased primarily in electric and
gas and the Operations Center. The upcoming year does budget a drawdown on cash
of around $5,400,000. The total cash provided by operations is $20,681,000; that is
right where it has been historically. Cash used for transfer to the City of Orangeburg
General Fund is $5,600,000. Cash used for capital and financing activities, this is
projects for economic development or special perk projects, payments on long-term
debt tap and impact fees and contributions. The net of that number is $20,960,000 and
then total cash provided by investing activities is budgeted to be $472,000. Cash
reserves are projected to be $25, 635,130 at the end of fiscal year 2018-2019. The
American Public Power Association Best Practice Guide indicates our utility maintain a
cash reserve of approximately $36,000,000. When investments are taken into account
the DPU meets this reserve requirement. DPU currently has approximately
$30,000,000 in investments. Those are investments held in 1-5 years Treasury and
U.S. Agency bonds. Manager Harley said Director Nexsen is making a distinction
between cash and cash we have in investments. Totally we meet that threshold. The
budget does place reserves on DPU's cash and equivalence by ordinance, $2 million for
bond repayment, $4.5 million for customer deposits, $2 million for various other
liabilities. The budget also places reserves on these investments by ordinance of $15
million for a capital reserve account and $15 million for a contingency reserve account.
Basically this is a reserve to fund depreciation which the ordinance requires. When we
enter into projects it has an out clause for us - if you cancel a project, generally projects
have a 60-90 day window where you have to give written notice to the contractor before
you stop doing the project. Not that we are going stop doing a project but if something
came up and we needed to stop a project we could but there could be some run out on
the project and that is why we reserve a contingency account. We enter into long-term
capital projects to build substations, to build waterlines, to redo gas lines, build buildings
and if you had to drawdown those projects you would have to spend some money to
close them out. Manager Harley asked Council if everyone was clear on the financials.
It is important to note that by ordinance we designate all of those restrictions. That is
why anytime going forward Council decides to change direction we have to bring it back
to you because if it impacts any of those numbers in a different way we have to get your
approval to do it because you have done it by ordinance. Director Nexsen stated that
he feels this is a sound and reasonable budget proposal that asks for a 1 % cost of living
adjustment for our employees and allows for an increase in capital spending to better
serve our customers in the Orangeburg community. The proposed budget will provide
the DPU with the resources necessary to continue to meet our obligations of providing
our customers with the best possible service at the lowest reasonable rates while
providing a reasonable rate on return for the City of Orangeburg. Councilmember
Jernigan asked what contributes to the decrease in sales - are customers just not using
as much or are we losing customers. Director Nexsen said that generally in their
planning sessions they have talked with Consultant Tom Sullivan about what would
cause some decreases in usage. The primary areas we see are efficiency. Even if you
have your total number of customers increase, if appliances use 10-20% less energy,
light bulbs are all going LED now, it draws down the total amount of electricity, gas or
water we sell. Councilmember Jernigan replied that apparently we have not increased
our customers enough to offset this. Are we addressing that to the point where we need
to try to increase our customers more; is this in the plan? Manager Harley said a lot of
that will be a part of economic development and whether people are landing on our
system and people moving to the community. If we don't see that type of growth you
2
will see people continue to put those efficiency measures in place that will decrease
water usage, decrease how much power they burn but the goal is hopefully that on the
economic development side and the community growth side that we will see businesses
and~i~e,ices start to grow. Councilmember Jernigan said that annexation will be a
big fclc'to?';"'tf we can annex some other areas. Manager Harley said to keep in mind in
our situation they are already customers most likely and in wastewater and water you
will see a decrease in revenue because they get that immediate break when they get
annexed. We would have to work really closely with Mr. John Yow to time that
annexation because it is going to be an impact to those two divisions in a negative way
in terms of revenue. Water and wastewater will take the biggest hit on any annexation
of current customers. If it is a new housing start that is different but with any existing
customer we will lose some ground on those revenues. Director Odom said territory
wise, electric and water are pretty much maxed out on the territory we can grow out
into. Gas is probably the only utility that is able to extend further out and grab some of
the newer areas out towards Santee like they have done in the last few years. Manager
Harley said that in regards to growing the footprint that you currently have developing
that customer base, we do have some ideas on how we might be able to do that going
forward. We are not ready to roll those out to you yet; we are certainly concerned that
we are able to pull and attract customers to our system and that is the important part.
Moving forward everybody is looking at whether it is homeowners, businesses or
commercial industries, they are looking at ways to be more efficient in the resources
they use so we have to make sure that we are adjusting to that way of doing business.
Director Nexsen said now we will discuss the capital projects. The capital projects are
the large majority of what the DPU spends its money on outside of payroll and
purchasing power and electricity.
************************************************************
ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION PROJECTS
JOSH NEXSEN - DIRECTOR
Director Nexsen informed the Mayor and Council that the Administrative Division has
two previously approved capital projects for the upcoming fiscal year 2018-2019. The
first capital project is the Operations Center Crew Quarters.
Project #1 - 350 Sprinkle Avenue / DPU Operations Center Improvements
Cont'd.
Total Project Cost: $ 7,500,000
Expenditures to Date: $ 200,000
Estimated 2018-2019 Cost: $ 300,000
Director Nexsen stated that the original warehouse and crew quarters were constructed
in 1967 when DPU was approximately 1/3 of its current size. These facilities have
exceeded their useful life. The project has gone through planning and programming to
identify the long terms of continued use of DPU. The first phase of the project allows for
additional space for crew and work areas and training areas. The initial phase also
addresses a re-combination of several adjacent parcels, wetlands mitigation, clearing
and macerating of the site. improvements to traffic flow as well as improvements to the
storm/water retention infrastructure on this site. This is going to be pretty big project
that will have pretty much the entire company involved over the next year and a half.
Manager Harley pointed out that DPU will propose that we borrow money for this
project. We have it broken into phases so in the first phase as Director Nexsen
mentioned we actually would want to do both the assembly portion and the crew
quarters and that would give us a better meeting place for training that would be open to
not just to DPU employees but City employees as well and things that Council would
like to do also. We want to make sure that it meets the needs for the next generation of
DPU employees. As we work through the rest of the project we want to make sure that
we are finding opportunities to be efficient and save money at every turn. Manager
Harley said he has never been a part of a project with this many engineers; they all
have a way of finding a way to make efficient decisions about what we ought to do. _He
feels they will be able to bring a really good project to fruition after they get everything
3
lined up. The key point he mentioned is that DPU will be asking Council to allow us to
borrow money on this project. We will bring this back to you, probably in the middle of
the spring because ideally they would like to do some of the ground work this time of the
year next year when the ground is right. 2 7 43
Project #2 -1016 Russell Street/ Main Office Backup Generator- Cont'd.
Total Project Cost: $ 600,000
Expenditures to Date: $ 100,000
Estimated 2018-2019 Cost: $ 500,000
Director Nexsen stated that the second project for the Administrative Division is also a
previously approved project. It is the replacement of the current standby backup
generator to the DPU main office. The current generator is a 1 00kw unit which is
approximately 20 years old. The DPU's critical command and control systems run
almost entirely by computers now. That is the SCADA (Supervisory Control And Data
Acquisition) outage management, telephone system, etc. In the event of a loss of
commercial power standby electric generators are a critical component to the
restoration of utility services. The plan is to install a 400kw generator to allow the DPU
to run entirely on standby power in the event of the loss of commercial power. This
project was originally planned to be completed during the current year but it was
delayed due to a delay in production of the manufacturer. There is a certain unit that we
want that is already EPA certified where we won't have to have air quality testing done
on it. Manager Harley said that as you remember, we had an issue with one of our
other generators and talked to you individually about it but this would eliminate that
problem going forward. Director Nexsen said that part of the project will be to build a
wall around it that matches the building where it is not going to stick out so bad because
it is a rather large generator.
The total cost for both projects for the upcoming year is $800,000; $300,000 is going to
be to finish the planning engineering design of the building and site work and the
remaining $500,000 will be spent to acquire the generator and install it and build the
retaining area.
************************************************************
ELETRIC DIVISION PROJECTS
WADE HOLMES - DIRECTOR
Director Wade Holmes informed the Mayor and Council that the DPU Electric Division
has six capital improvement projects we will be presenting this evening. Four of those
projects are previously approved and two are new projects. All of the projects that he
will be presenting tonight will be a part of our overall plan to update some aging
infrastructure. Right now the Electric Division has roughly ten substations that are 45+
years old and most of those are at the end of their life cycle. With that type of project
load we have to get accomplished we are going to try to do this over the next 8-10
years.
Project #1 -115 KV Transmission Line
Extension to Highway 601 Substation #10 - Cont'd.
Total Project Cost: $ 1,892,000
Expenditures to Date: $ 1. 170,000
Estimated 2018-2019 Cost: $ 722,000
Director Holmes stated that Project #1 is the transmission line to Substation #10. This
project consists of extending out transmission loop to Substation #10 so that it will be
part of our bi-directional feed substations. This project includes the installation of 13
transmission poles; 9 of those poles are being engineered poles and the other 4 are
being direct bearing. All the poles that we have installed along Hwy 601 is a part of our
new extension to .Substation #10. Those poles are designed to be able to withstand
125 mph hurricane force winds and carry conductors. Should there be an ice storm
those conductors can hold the weight of ice 1" or less. The poles range from 70' to 120'
4
in front of the substation. This project itself is 95% completed and we expect to have
the rest of it completed by the end of this calendar year. Manager Harley said that
when we get it to a nice place out there where it is cleaned up if you would like we will
givey~irst on the ground look at it. It is pretty impressive and it will give you an
oppm'1:6nlty'"to see where you spend your money. .
Project #2 ~ Highway 601 Substation #10 Rebuild - Cont'd.
Total Project Cost:
Expenditures to Date:
Estimated 2018-2019 Cost:
$ 7.428,000
$ 6,918,000
$ 510,000
Director Holmes said that Project #2 is our Substation #1 0 rebuild. This substation was
a 50 year old substation that we rebuilt to put on our 115 KV Transmission Line. Now
that substation has the capabilities of being fed from two different directions. If any part
of that 115 KV group drops out, this substation will stay on line. This substation will be
able to handle the future growth along Hwy 601 and also this substation will provide
backup power to Substations #3 and #6 which are along Russell Street, Substation #19
which is on Old Elloree Road near Husqvarna and Substation #16 which is on North
Road up pass Walmart. This substation went from being able to carry Koyo, the
hospital, the industrial park up Hwy 601 and roughly 500 customers to being able to
carry that location plus an additional 4,000 customers. The rebuild on the substation is
95% complete and we expect to have it completed by the end of this calendar year.
Councilmember Jernigan asked if this will be the biggest substation we have. Director
Holmes said close, this is tied with Substations #16 and #19 which both of these are 50
megawatt substations.
Project #3 - City of Orangeburg Department
Of Public Utilities Street Lighting Upgrade (Phase 1) - Cont'd.
Total Project Cost: $ 230,000
Expenditures to Date: $ 210,000
Estimated 2018-2019 Cost: $ 20,000
Director Holmes said Project #3 is our LED upgrade lighting project. This project
extends along Hwy 301 South from the river all the way up to Five Chop Road. It
consists of 100 lights and we changed over from high pressure sodium to LED. These
lights can be controlled through our AMI system as well as these lights are 40% more
energy efficient than the high pressure sodium lights we had. Also with the replacement
of the lights we replaced the poles that the lights sit on. These poles meet SCOOT
regulations for lighting poles and have the breakaway base at the bottom. This project
is also 95% complete and we expect to have it completed by the end of this calendar
year.
Project #4 Substation #18 (SI Group) Rebuild - Cont'd.
Total Proiect Cost: $ 6,200,000
Expenditures to Date: $ 155,000
Estimated 2018-2019 Cost: $ 950,000
Director Holmes said that Project #4 is our Substation #18 rebuild. That substation is
located on Cannon Bridge Road and feeds one of our largest industrial customers. That.
substation is almost 40 years old and during the peak season it is running around 80-
85% capacity which is the natural threshold for a substation. The rebuilt substation will
be put on the 115 KV Transmission Line that runs along the front of the property and. a
bi-directional feed so once again if one section on 115 KV that goes down it will not take
the substation down and it will provide additional growth for a new industrial customer
that comes in the corridor or for the industrial customer that it is feeding today. Director
Holmes said that they have already done the substation transformer drawings that has
been approved and placed for manufacture. Because there is a backlog with all
substation manufacturers we are looking at a 46-50 week delay before this transformer
will be delivered so we are looking at some time around this time next year that we will
be able to have the transformer there and have that project in construction phase.
5
Project #5 - Substation #1 {Bull Street) Rebuild
Total Project Cost
Expenditures to Date:
Estimated 2018-2019 Cost
$ 2,900,000
$ 407,000
$ 1,200.000 2745
Director Holmes said that Project #5 is a new project which is for Substation #1 which is
on the corner of Bull Street and Windsor Street. This substation itself is 50 years old
and supplies power to our Water Division and is a critical asset to our Water Treatment
Plant. This substation feeds roughly 2.000 customers. Manager Harley said that
substation impacts Councilmembers Stroman, Hannah and Haire's districts. If you
recall when we had the mass outage in that particular substation it impacted all of your
areas. This project would go a long way at addressing those needs that feeds those
districts. Director Holmes said that a year ago this time that substation's transformer
experienced a catastrophic failure. The root cause analysis showed that the internal
cord of the transformer had a fault because the material inside the unit started to
breakdown which in layman's term is the transformer was wearing down on the inside
from being online so long. We are talking 50 years, 7 days a week. 365 days a year, 24
hours a day. Power was lost to the affected areas for about 1 ½ hours. We went ahead
and ordered a replacement transformer for the substation back in September and that
transformer arrived on site in July (last month). If you go by Substation #1 you will see
that construction has started to pick up and we look to have that station rebuilt in a
year·s time.
Project #6 - Substation #12 {Berry Street) Rebuild
Total Project Cost $ 2,900.000
Expenditures to Date: $ 345,000
Estimated 2018-2019 Cost $ - 0 -
Director Holmes said that Project #6 is a new project which is a substation rebuild for
Substation #12 which is located at Berry Street and Holly Street right behind BB&T.
Substation #1 provides backup for Substation #12 and vice versa. When we rebuild
these two substations we have to build one first and then the other one. We can't have
these substations rebuild coincide with each other so Substation #12 will be done when
we finish Substation #1. This substation like Substation #1 is 50 years old and during
our peak time we actually have used it as backup. Substation #12 is running at 95%
load capacity which is something we should never do with a substation but unfortunately
we had to do for 3 or 4 days until we could get the spare that we put at Substation #1
online. Quarterly inspections on Substation #12 indicate that the internal components of
this substation transformer core is starting to deteriorate also so it is just a matter of
time and that is why we are racing on the clock to try and get this substation rebuilt and
back online. Once again, this substation provides the service area around Berry Street
and Boulevard. Manager Harley said that would be Councilmembers Stroman, Hannah
and Haire's districts. We know that Council gets questions about these things so we
want you to be informed as much as possible. You can always send them to Director
Holmes but we know that when they see things going on in your districts they want to
ask you and we want to keep you informed.
Director Holmes said this concludes our six projects for the Electric Division. In the
upcoming fiscal year we look to spend $3.4 million for the capital improvements projects
we have discussed. Councilmember Hannah asked how do we compare to other
utilities having substations that are antiquated. Director Holmes said that is
unfortunately par for the course. Most utilities try to get every last kilowatt out of their
substations and transformers before they take them offline. What we are finding out
now is that when we are ordering substations and transformers from vendors and
manufacturers Southern Power, Duke Energy, and others are ordering also; it is around
that same cycle - 40-50 year mark. Manager Harley said that one of the reasons why it
is like that in the industry. I'm talking about the public utilities, is that in the last ten years
we have been in an economic downturn and you push things as far as you can push
them and as things go you can only get so much out of a piece of equipment and now it
is coming home that we have to do something different. It is good that things
nationwide are starting and may pick up; hopefully that will continue and show up in
Orangeburg as well. Councilmember Keitt said that most of what we have done is
6
getting better than what it was and it really makes an impression on us. Manager
Harley said over the next 5-10 years we are going to be continuing that push to improve
our infrastructure. Again, you point to what DPU has already done with the wastewater
impr0)'erpfj.[tS and you just have to continue that as best you can. That is part of the
reasdri w?\tre putting together the plan that you heard about in the planning session.
We will need to address across the board infrastructure needs; you can't continue to
push those things down the road and still get good results. At this point we would like to
believe that we still are able to maintain reliability and safe operation but if you continue
to push that down the road then that will put us in jeopardy.
Councilmember Haire asked about the difference in the fiber optic rental amounts for FY
2016-2017 and FY 2017-2018. Director Nexsen said that the reason the amount
decreased so much is because there is a pole attachment agreement that is recorded in
that fiber optic rental agreement and he believes it is paid once over a five year period
and he thinks the years that the amount is much larger is the years that the five year
payment is due. Director Nexsen said he is pretty sure that is the reason but he will
look into it and give Councilmember Haire more information regarding it. There are
three basic rental streams; DPU gets pne. For years we cost shared the fiber optics
network that we built with SCE&G - a company called Scana Communications. They
were sold to a company called Spirit and if you notice Spirit is boring in Orangeburg and
they will probably end up not renting fiber optics with us in the next year or so. The
second stream is the pole attachment agreement from Spectrum, AT&T, etc. Those are
normally paid in a lump sum every 3-5 years. The third stream is where Director Odom
rents space on water towers to cellphone companies. He thinks Director Holmes may
have one as well.
Councilmember Haire asked about bad debt expenses. Director Nexsen said that in FY
2016-2017 there was a 3-4 month period when we did not do any disconnections for
non-payment. Unfortunately, there are some customers who don't pay if you don't cut
them off. In FY 2017-2018 and FY 2018-2019 we expect a fairly substantial increase in
bad debt from the cutoff from the former system to the upcoming system. We did not
convert but about two years of history on that system so if someone left us with a bad
debt some of that didn't get converted over. There are some statutes and laws about
what you can collect and how far back you can collect. We made some business
decisions not to risk not following the law and probably also lost some of the ability to
find out who the customer was, where they were, if they left us with a bad debt and if we
were able to collect it. These are budgeted numbers and our Comptroller Lauren Privett
may be able to speak to it a little bit better. Director Nexsen does not know if they have
increased three-fold but he does know that they have gone up significantly. They have
probably doubled what they were the same time last year. Historically DPU has had a
very low bad debt ratio; almost none. In fact some years it has been a. positive number
where someone you wrote off came back and paid back their debts where you had a
positive number. We have also had some of our commercial and industrial customers
sign an irrevocable letter of credit, gotten surety bonds or required a commercial
deposit. He told Councilmember Haire that he can get him additional information
regarding this if he wants it. Manager Harley said if he is correct the law states you can
go back three years and we use the setoff debt program to collect those debts which is
pretty good. He said he will take the blame; he and Director Nexsen talked through it
when we did the changeover and we did not want to run afoul of cutting someone off
inadvertently during the switchover. We had a lot going on in terms of the changeover
in software so we wanted to make sure we were spot on so we erred on the side of
caution so we will pay a little bit of a premium on the decision we made. We extended a
little more courtesy during that time. Director Nexsen said that when we got towards the
end of the software project and we were significantly under budget by almost $2 million,
at some point you kind of make some business decisions like if it cost me $50,000,
$60,000 or $70,000 not to cut someone off mistakenly I am coming in so far under
budget on this project that it may be a give or take situation.
************************************************************
7
-· ~ ..
GAS DIVISION PROJECTS
DAVE DURGIN - DIRECTOR
Director Dave Durgin informed the Mayor and Council that the Gas DivisiCJ"l'114~0
previously approved projects that will help us to improve the safety and reliatfil(ty of the
gas system as part of our Distribution and Integrity Management Program or "DIMP"
Program.
Project #1 - Natural Gas Service along Hwy 33 - Cont'd.
Total Project Cost: $ 590,000
Expenditures to Date: $ - 0 -
Estimated 2018-2019 Cost: $ 590,000
Director Durgin said that Project #1 is a previously approved project that will replace
approximately 10,500 feet of gas pipe along Hwy 33 starting at Old Cameron Road.
This area has seen an increase in maintenance costs and it has been identified as part
of our DIMP Program to address the aging infrastructure of the gas system. This
project has been awarded and construction has recently begun.
Project #2 - Improvements to Natural Gas Service along Russell Street- Cont'd.
Total Project Cost: $ 540,000
Expenditures to Date: $ - 0 -
Estimated 2018-2019 Cost: $ 540,000
Director Durgin said Project #2 is a previously approved project that will replace
approximately 7,500 feet of gas pipe along Russell Street starting at Pinkney Street and
extending just pass the By-Pass. This area was identified as part of our DIMP Program
to address the aging infrastructure and due to increased maintenance costs as well.
The total amount budgeted for both project is $1.13 million which we plan on spending
in the upcoming fiscal year. Councilmember Hannah asked if these projects will
interfere with the gas service. Director Durgin said that when we do projects like this we
actually build a new line and then do transfers one by one so the amount of interruption
is minimum; at least we try for that.
*****************************************************'lrl<*****
WATER DIVISION PROJECTS
ERIC ODOM - DIRECTOR
Director Odom said that the Water Division has two previously approved projects for the
upcoming fiscal year.
Project #1 1 O" Water Main Replacement along Shillings Bridge Road - Cont'd.
Total Project Cost: $ 800,000
Expenditures to Date: $ 36,000
Estimated 2018-2019 Cost: $ 764,000
Director Odom said that Project #1 is a previously approved project which consists of
approximately 10,000 feet of 1 O" PVC water main that is going to be basically from the
intersection of Hwy 4 all the way underneath the Edisto River to Lake Edisto Road. This
has been a failure prone area for our system for the past few years and is in need of
upgrading. We had originally planned to have this project completed this fiscal year; to
date we have completed the design, permitting and also received bids on this project
with the anticipation of starting construction in September. During the design phase of
this project we ran into some potential wetlands issues that caused us to get a wetlands
delineation. The fortunate thing is that it saved us probably 10% because it gave us
another route to proceed that is a lot cheaper. The plan is to begin construction
hopefully in September with the completion of this project in December.
8
Project #2 - Upgrading of the 1954 High Service
Pump, Engine Driven Pump Station and Chlorine
Scrubber at the Water Treatment Plant- Cont'd.
Tot-t Cost: . $ 2.116.000
Exp I s to Date: $ 96.000
Estimated 2018-2019 Cost: $ 2.020.000
Director Odom said that Project #2 is a previously approved project which is an upgrade
to our 1954 High Service Pump Station as well as an upgrade to our 1973 Diesel
Engine Driving Pumps and the replacement of our 1991 Chlorine Scrubber. Basically
this project consists of two major components at our Water Treatment Plant. The first is
upgrading and improving the overall reliable finished water pumping capacity at our
Water Treatment Plant. The 1973 diesel pumps as well as the 1954 pumps while some
of them are still operational some of them are not. Our plans are to rebuild four of those
pumps, put in all new electrical components and get rid of the diesel engines. We will
also have to replace check valves. some piping and other things like that to make it
more efficient. Also during the design phase of this project we think we have identified
some cost saving measures that will hopefully keep us well under budget on this
project. The second component to this project is the replacement of our Chlorine Gas
Scrubber. Chlorine Gas is what we use at our Water Treatment Plant to treat water and
disinfect it; by law we have to have this and it is a very important piece of equipment
that has become somewhat of a very costly piece of equipment to maintain. The new
piece of equipment that we are looking to install is much less expensive to maintain and
much more reliable and hopefully will last us the next twenty years. Safety wise it is
important for the citizens of Orangeburg for us to have this as well as our employees
who operate the Water Treatment Plant. To date we have completed about 50% of the
design work; our plans are to bid this project early in October with an anticipated
completion of this project in the upcoming fiscal year. The total budgeted expenses for
the upcoming fiscal year are $2.784.000 to complete both of these projects.
Councilmember Knotts asked what happens to the lead joint pipes once you remove
them and where do they go. Director Odom said that our environmental engineer will
write in our specs and it will be the responsibility of the contractor to dispose of those
pipes in an environmentally manner but currently we do not move any water through
that section of our Plant, it is valved off.
************************************************************
WASTEWATER DIVISION PROJECTS
RICHARD LABRADOR - DIRECTOR
Director Labrador informed the Mayor and Councilmembers that the Wastewater
Division has one new project for the upcoming fiscal year which is the Biosolids Dryer
Replacement.
Project #1 - Biosolids Dryer Replacement
Total Proiect Cost:
Expenditures to Date:
Estimated 2018-2019 Cost:
$ 5,200,000
$ -0-
$ 5,200,000
Director Labrador said Project #1 is a new proposed project that replaces the existing
dryer which has been in operation since 2005. The dryer has exceeded its useful life
and is no longer operational. The replacement of the dryer will allow us to continue to
see substantial reduction in landfill hauling and disposal costs. We will also continue to
produce a Class A exceptional quality Biosolids that can be sold or given away as soil
amendment. This project will consist of removal of the existing dryer and installation of
a modern indirect thermal dryer and all necessary appurtenances. Major new
components will include a feed pump, instrumentation and controls and modifications to
the existing Biosolids Hopper. The total project cost is approximately $5,200,000, all of
which we anticipate will be spent during the upcoming fiscal year. Manager Harley tol_d
Council that DPU had alerted them to the issue relating to this earlier this year. At this
point it is a substantial cost to have the waste go to the landfill which we have no control
9
--·-,
,-
over the cost. Councilmember Jernigan asked when do we anticipate the new dryer
being operational. Director Labrador said there is a lead time on the dryer itself and he
anticipates most of the upfront work will done in anticipation of receiving the completed
machine when it comes so it will be late in the fiscal year before we actuall~J11ijlQ:he
machine. If all goes well we will be churning away before the end of the upcoming fiscal
year. Mayor Butler asked how many dryer do we need. Director Labrador said that we
have one and we use the landfill as the backup; we don't have to have two for
redundancy or reliability like pumps and critical components because our
backup/redundant plan is to go to the landfill which is what we are doing now. This will
be the third dryer; the first dryer when he first came to DPU over 20 years ago was not
very successful and they had to negotiate a replacement for the second one which was
a little bit better but nothing to write home about. At any time we could have purchased
a second machine; we were never confident in any of the first two machines that we
would pull the trigger on a third. We have room in that building for a second machine
and when the time comes and if we need a second machine we can always do that
when we expand the capacity of the Wastewater Treatment Plant. We would only do so
if we had confidence in the machine; both times the manufacturer went out of business
and no longer supported the product. We did our homework and we are looking at a
manufacturer that has a 75 year track record in the industry; they are not going
anywhere and their machines have a good track record also. We feel good about this
one and we feel we don't have to purchase a second dryer; we can stay with the first
and hopefully it will last us in excess of 20-25 years.
************************************************************
Manager Harley said the goal always is to maintained reliability and safety. We want to
make sure that when your citizens see you on the street that you can tell them that you
are always able to provide what they need at their homes, businesses and industries;
that is what counts and also that the prices is fair for the service that we provide. With
that being said we will move to the next items on the agenda which is a proposed
amendment to the gas rates.
Manager Harley said that he wanted to give Council and second opportunity to discuss
this. The ordinance contains the actual amendment for the rates of the Gas Division.
He gave Council a copy of the impacted areas; the core residential and commercial and
then the special project residential and special project commercial. The difference for
the core residential customers is $4.87 and for the core commercial customers the
amount is $11 a month. The amount for the special projects is $4.64 and $21.12 and
that is on an average annual use for all of those customers. We feel this is an impact
that is something fair but also gets us where we need to be. Manager Harley said he
knows that previously this was discussed and did not get granted. He asks that Council
strongly consider granting this increase at this point. Considering the things that the
Gas Division has ahead of it in terms of infrastructure improvements and replacements
this is an important step in getting those things back to where they need to be. He
asked if Council had any questions on the gas rate increase. Councilmember Keitt said
that we know that a lot of our customers are on a fixed income and she knows that we
are going to need to raise the rates and asked are we setting up ways for fixed income
people to pay their bills in a way that it will not be totally burdensome on them.
Manager Harley said that since he has been on board, staff and customer service
representatives do a great job working with customers on trying to find a way to pay
their bills. Our desire is never to cut anyone off and sometimes although it comes to
that we are working diligently with the customer to try to find a way to ease the burden.
Generally it's during those peak times when we see that but we do everything we can to
work with customers to try to find a way to help them continue to have service while at
the same time collecting what we have to from them. He knows that Council is
concerned about that so we do our best to work with each customer and we know that
everyone is different, every situation is different but we certainly do our best to work with
them to try to help them maintain services. Manager Harley said we have partners in
the community that we are able to refer them to for assistance as well; whether it is
OCAB or CCMO, we do our best to help them find opportunities to find assistance.
10
Councilmember Keitt said she thinks more churches are helping now more than usual.
Councilmember Stroman asked if there are any flat rates if people don't use any gas.
Manager Harley said everybody has a service charge. He has had this conversation
anct:?~S<,ar although we had it in the budget we didn't chronicle it like we are doing
here s'howing every group that would be impacted. We tried to make sure this year that
this is only on commercial and residential customers not industrial customers.
Councilmember Stroman said Council talked about raising the City taxes by 4 mills and
then raising this is just tough on the people. He said he cannot make himself vote for
this; he is sorry. Councilmember Jernigan said that it looks to him like everything they
do in the City affects our citizens. When we raise something it affects people but we still
have to provide all of our services. We have services that we provide to every citizen
and the costs for providing that is going up and if the citizens can't see that the costs
are going up he is sorry. We have got to keep up with the increase with our costs of
providing service and the only way we do it is to raise our rates from time to time.
Councilmember Jernigan said the he doesn't think we raise our rates unnecessarily.
Manager Harley said that even with this increase DPU still remains one of the lowest
around. Councilmember Stroman said the citizens of the City of Orangeburg own the
DPU and we represent the citizens and their dividend is lower rates. Mayor Butler said
he does agree with Councilmember Jernigan because if we are going to provide
efficient and effect service and they expect us to do that; they expect to be warm, they
expect to be cold and if it takes a little raise in rates he feels Council should provide this
increase so that we can continue to be efficient and effective. Councilmember Jernigan
said that we are not raising rates just for the sake of making more money, that is not the
reason to raise rates. The reason we raise rates is so we can continue to provide the
service. Councilmember Keitt said that it is not that much. If you look at it you are
taking about a little over $4.00. She thinks that our constituents are going to have to
realize that in order for us to have good service we are going to have to keep changing
the infrastructure that we have. In order to do that there is no other way than to
increase the rates. Mayor Butler said that DPU has been so effective in making
presentations here tonight and he feels they have done their homework and have
studied what needs to be done to continue to perfect their departments. He really likes
that and that is why he really wants to support the presentations. Manager Harley said
that if you have any questions that you didn't ask tonight, he and Director Durgin will be
glad to sit down and talk more in-depth with Council about them and show Council any
numbers they would like to see going forward. Councilmember Hannah said that some
of his neighbors, friends and associates have had situations. with DPU and some have
had their services disrupted and one thing they told him that resonated well is that DPU
worked with them. That is a plus because they said DPU went the extra mile to help;
people feel good about what is happening at DPU. Rates do go up and that is just a
fact of life; salaries will go up, we will get over it; everything goes up. Councilmember
Stroman said he just feels like we are operating like years ago - waiting for people to
come in; he feels we just need to have a way of going out and sell the gas. Manager
Harley said that DPU is formulating a plan that we will share with Council in the next few
weeks. It is a marketing plan, kind of like the next phase. DPU has done a good bit of
work already but we are going to do more in the coming weeks. Mr. Randy Etters,
Director Durgin and I have met several times with some potential partners to try and
market gas on a different level to make sure we get the kind of penetration that we feel
is possible; we certainly have something coming forward. Manager Harley asked if
there were any other questions. There were no more questions so they moved to the
next item on the agenda.
Mayor Butler read an Ordinance to Adopt an Amended Budget for the Department of
Public Utilities of the City of Orangeburg, State of South Carolina for the Fiscal Year
October 1, 2017 through September 30, 2018. Manager Harley told Council that as you
are familiar with the process at the City Mr. Yow always amends his current year budget
to kind of more accurately project the closing numbers and that is exactly what we are
proposing to do here. As the City has done we have put into place an ordina_nce that
will amend our current year budget to more accurately reflect what we believe the
closing numbers will be. A motion was made by Councilmember Jernigan to adopt the
ordinance to amend the budget, second by Councilmember Keitt, motion was
unanimously approved.
11
Mayor Butler re an Ordinance to (1) Adopt a Budget for the Operation of the Department
of Public Utilities of the City of Orangeburg, State of South Carolina for the Fiscal Year
October 1, 2018 through September 30, 2019 and (2) Adopt Amended Gas Rates
effective October 1, 2018. A motion was made by Councilmember Haire tei,a,CIP'I the
ordinance for the budget and amended gas rates, second by Councilmem~f ~Eld, 6
approved, Councilmember Stror11an opposed.
Manager Harley informed Council that is all DPU has in terms of ordinances. The
Second Reading of the Ordinances and the Public Hearing will coincide with the City's
Public Hearing. The only other item on the agenda is a quick executive session.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
Respectfully submitted,
Carol E. Franklin
Executive Administrative Assistant to the Manager
Department of Public Utilities
12
2758
City Council Minutes
September 4, 2018
Orangeburg City Council held a Public Hearing on Tuesday, September 4, 2018, at 7:00 P.M., in
Council Chambers with Mayor Michael C. Butler presiding. The purpose of the Public Hearing
was for the following:
Public Hearing: Consideration of a Zoning District Map change from A2 Residential, Multi-Unit
District to 0-I Office-Institutional-Residential District for property belonging to Paragon, Inc., of
South Carolina, LLC, located at 795 Whitman Street, Orangeburg, SC TMP# 0173-14-07-
010.000
Hearing no public comments, the Public Hearing was closed.
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, to enter into
the regularly scheduled City Council Meeting. This motion was unanimously approved.
Council entered into the regularly scheduled meeting.
PRESENT:
Michael C. Butler, Mayor
Bernard Haire
Jerry Hannah
Charles W. Jernigan
L. Zimmerman Keitt
Sandra P. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Knotts, to approve
the June 14, 2018, Department of Public Utilities Planning Workshop Minutes, as distributed.
1bis motion was unanirnously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Stroman, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, to approve
the August 14, 2018, Special City Council Minutes, as distributed. This motion was
unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Knotts, seconded by Councilmember Haire, to approve
the August 21, 2018, City Council Minutes, as distributed. This motion was unanimously
approved.
Mr. John Shuler, Vice President of the Orangeburg County Fair Association, addressed Council.
He was also accompanied by Dr. Eugene Atkinson of the Board of Directors. Mr. Shuler stated,
"We have no paid Board Members or a paid Manager of the fair. We have had some financial
difficulties in the past with a former employee who embezzled funds and is an embarrassment to
the Board and the community. We are in a rebuilding situation. The Board is doing everything
to rebuild the trust and provide transparency to the Board and shareholders. The President of the
Board, Matt Stokes, acts as CEO. The officers handle the management and all activities of the
fair. We cannot continue to borrow money to have a fair. We have the potential to continue to
have a fair like we used to have here in Orangeburg and we do not have the funds to do a fair.
We borrowed money last year as well. We have got to build on a five-year plan. We knew we
had to have marketing help and we brought in a marketing firm to compete for entertainment for
the community. It takes planning fairs two years out. That firm presented a new logo, a new
mascot and a float advertising the fair throughout the year. We are not charging for parking.
The admission rates are $6 and $3. The physical plant we have will be painted in fall colors. We
have volunteers who have been painting and we have hired a local contractor to assist in painting
the bigger buildings. We are working with local people, not from other counties. (Sketches
were shown of the new logo, mascot and the older buildings in need ofrepair.) We are asking
for help for the refurbishing of these buildings as you can see in your packet." (Slides were also
shown of the fairgrounds and buildings that are being painted).
----·---······· .. ----
,..----
,_
Page2
Dr. Atkinson explained the slides and the buildings that are in disrepair.
Mr. Shuler further explained, "The fairgrounds are used by SC State University Polil i~g,
Orangeburg County Sheriff's Office for training, Boy Scouts, Emergency Service Training,
Junior Service League and our biggest lessee is the Grand American Coon.Hunt. We used to
host SC State University Homecoming events, but lately found out that we were in violation of
the law. We cannot do big parties and can only have forty-nine (49) people without any fire
suppression systems. We are looking into up fitting the buildings for this, but right now, we
cannot allow any big parties for rentals.
Councilmember Haire asked, "Who is renting it for Homecoming?"
Mr. Shuler replied, "They are private parties and alunmi events."
Councilmember Hannah asked, "What has the attendance been like and the profits?"
Mr. Shuler replied, "We had good weather in 2017; however, with the indictment we have had
substantial losses. We have been struggling from year to year. Some fairs within fifty ( 50)
miles ofus, have $250,000 in the bank. We should be that way. I do not have an answer on the
attendance, but we have been struggling and borrowing money to run the fair."
Councilmember Haire asked, "Have you approached the County for funding?"
Mr. Shuler stated, "Yes, we have approached the Accommodations Tax Committee for funding
of our advertising and we are also reaching out for other funding."
Mayor Pro Tern Keitt asked, "We gave funds a few years back, what was that for?"
Dr. Atkinson replied, "Those funds were used to upgrade and paint the restrooms."
Councilmember Jernigan stated, "We need to take this under advisement and discuss the amount
and bring this back to Council at the next meeting;" All of Council was in agreement.
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, to approve
the Third Reading of an Ordinance amending the Budget for the City of Orangeburg, SC, for the
Fiscal Year beginning October 1, 2017, and ending September 30, 2018. This motion was
unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Knotts, seconded by Councilmember Haire, to approve
the Third Reading of an Ordinance to raise Revenue and adopt a Budget for the City of
Orangeburg, SC, for the Fiscal. Year begiuning October l, 2018 and ending September 30, 2019.
This motion was unanimously approved.
Department of Public Safety Director Michael Adams addressed Council in regards to an update
on the Forensics Lab and the presentation was turned over to Dr. Fitts.
Dr. Matthew Fitts addressed Council. He stated, "These slides are the steps that were taken as a
time line for the Forensic Lab Accreditation. These steps have to be done sequentially in order to
obtain accreditation. If something may hold us up in the early steps, we cannot move forward.
These were the issues last time to address: Personnel, validation, equipment calibration and
maintenance and the proficiency testing. In the personnel issue, we now have two full time
employees hired by the lab. Our newest member is Mr. Krishna Addanki who was hired in June
to work full-time. His Visa application is being reviewed by the US Immigration Services. The
process took longer than we thought due to paperwork."
Mayor Pro Tern Keitt asked, "He is not cleared by Immigration? What does that mean?"
Mr. Addanki stated, "I was employed with Claflin University for ten (10) years in the same
position, but once I switch employers, a new application has to be done with Immigration. The
application has been submitted and I am eligible to work. It may take four to six months to be
finally approved, but I have sent in extra money myself to speed up the process."
Page3
Dr. Fitts stated, "The next item was facilities. There were minor lab renovations in February,
2018'),-'6{)trument calibrations and maintenance were completed in February, 2018, and the
building mamtenance is ongoing. This summer we have had HV AC issues and those are being
addressed now. We have instruments that cannot be in high temperatures. In addition, there are
headwinds that are slowing us down. Our LIMS System Company was bought out and we are
now working with the new company and we have had some issues with services with the new
company, as well as proper training. The validation process has been done and new kits were
obtained by CO DIS and final reports were issued in June. AV alidation Teach Back is scheduled
for the week of September 17th to generate the validation data to complete the testing. In this, we
have proficiency testing we have to complete twice a year. The next time will be in November.
This has slowed us down, but has not stopped us. We anticipate accreditation next year. I have
had conversations with Major Todd Hughey in regards to funding of the lab in the next round of
funding with SLED. This is for a grant given by the State and provides a minimum of$150,000
per lab. The next application will involve our lab."
Mayor Butler asked, "With hiring of the new personnel, will this get us closer to accreditation?"
Dr. Fitts replied, "Absolutely. I anticipate the process to begin speeding up."
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "Is there a problem with the grant?"
Dr. Fitts stated, "There is no problem, I am trying to make sure we are included to apply for
funds the next fiscal year. The funds would be available in 2020."
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "What are you doing now in the lab."
Dr. Fitts replied, "Internal documentation for the accreditation and other case work. We are
continuing to do fingerprint analysis, drug analysis, crime scene investigations and evidence."
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "Have you gotten into nationwide databases?"
Officer Shultz replied, "We do analysis with AEFIS, IAEFIS and other databases for finger
printing."
Mayor Pro Tern Keitt asked, "Are other cities coming to join you?"
Dr. Fitts replied, "Not at this time."
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "Are other entities being contacted to do business with us?"
Dr. Fitts explained, "It would be great to have another county partner with us and hire their own
DNA Analysts so that they can do their own casework and assist in paying overhead. If we get
inundated by other cases, we cannot keep up with the City's needs."
Councilmember Hannah asked, "What is the time schedule in 2019?"
Dr. Fitts stated, "I anticipate six to eight months from now to apply for accreditation. We have
to operate three months before inspection."
Councilmembcr Hannah asked, "What can we do to expedite this?"
Dr. Fitts explained, "I think you have already done that with the budgets, the personnel and we
have to do the internal work now."
City Administrator Yow stated, "Some of the software maintenance is annual recurring costs for
the lab aud Council was made aware of that in the budget meetings."
Ms. Evelyn Disher, Community of Character Executive Director, accepted the Character Trait
Proclamation for September, 2018, "Fairness".
Page4
Assistant City Administrator Singh updated Council in regards to the First Reading of an
Ordinance for a Zoning Map Change from A-2 Residential Multi-Unit District to O-I ~,f;.1
Institutional Residential District for property belonging to Paragon, Inc., of SC, LLC, locatAf tt
795 Whitman Street, TMS# 0173-14-07-0 I 0. He stated, "As you can see from the slides, the
map is showing the property in question on Whitman Street located next door to a nursing home,
Pruitt Health, which is an institutional setting. A-2 Residential allows up to three non-related
people who can live there. This is a different set up and this is by definition, a dormitory. It is
not a Multi-Family unit. This has a common area and an example is shown on Dorchester Street.
It actually looks like a townhouse. This is what is being proposed. Land use needs to be
institutional, which is also at Claflin University and SC State University. The Planning
Commission approved this. Our goal is to preserve residential neighborhoods; however, we are
seeing more Multi-Family. This area is a transitional area."
Councihnember Jernigan asked, "This is a dorm?"
Assistant City Administrator Singh replied, "Yes, it is not the old school college dorms, it is an
outside setting."
Councihnember Jernigan asked, "Have you had any opposition from the house next door or any
comments?''
Assistant City Administrator Singh replied, "No objections and none at the Planning
Conunission Meeting."
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "Have you thought about rezoning more of this area?"
Assistant City Administrator Singh replied, "It could be done, it is up to Council."
Councihnember Hannah asked, "ls that the specs or plans?"
Assistant City Administrator Singh replied, "That is the exact plans and I also have the parking
plans. There are two floors, with the baths, rooms and common areas. Each dorm has two
bedrooms."
Councihnember Jernigan asked, "Is this just for students?
Assistant City Administrator Singh replied, "It could be for anyone, but it is primarily for
students."
Councilmember Stroman asked, "Where is the parking?"
Assistant City Administrator Singh replied, "It is around the building and it does meet our
parking specs."
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, seconded by Councihnember Hannah, to approve
the First Reading of an Ordinance for a Zoning Map Change from A-2 Residential Multi-Unit
District to O-I Office Institutional Residential District for property belonging to Paragon, Inc., of
SC, LLC, located at 795 Whitman Street, TMS# 0173-14-07-0lO. The motion was unanimously
approved.
Councilmember Haire addressed Council in regards to concerns of illegal dumping of yard
debris in the City. He stated, "I have a concern of non-residents dumping yard debris on City
Streets. Recently, I was coming into Orangeburg from I-26 and a truck passed me full of yard
debris. I followed the truck because I had a concern that this person may dump in the City. I
followed the truck into the City to Glover Street, but didn't see any unloading of the debris.
Often, I observe debris being cut and in different locations in the City being piled up. That to me
is litter and I think we need to improve our Ordinance as it relates to littering so that these people
think twice about dumping in the City. The citizens of Orangeburg shouldn't have to pay for
those who illegally dump. Some of the streets that I have noticed cuttings being placed are on
Amelia Street and Ellis A venue and a few others. If the Ordinance is made to be punitive, these
Pages
individuals won't consider dumping in the City, ifwe increase the fines. I think we should go
bacJ.i,,pl!jbition, where if you made and transported illegal whiskey, you confiscate the
vehi~e. i¼utd like to make a motion that we ask the City Administrator and the City Attorney
what can.be done for illegal dumping to increase the fines for yard debris and other com1nercial
debris."
City Administrator Yow stated, "This happens every week and if they have a business license,
maybe we revoke it with proper amendments to the Ordinance .. We need to consider all
commercial materials as well."
Councilmember Hannah seconded Councilmember Haire's motion to improve our City
Ordinance as it relates to littering. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, to approve
the Third Reading of an Ordinance to adopt an Amended Budget for the Operation of the
Department of Public Utilities ofthe!City of Orangeburg, SC, for the Fiscal year October 1,
2017, through September 30, 2018. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, to approve
the Department of Public Utilities of the City of Orangeburg SC; for the Fiscal year beginning
October 1_, 2018, and ending September 30, 2019 and (2) Adopt Amended Gas Rates effective
October I, 2018. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Stroman, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, to enter
into an Executive Session for a Personnel Matter concerning the Associate Judge Compensation.
This motion was unanimously approved.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
Respectfully submitted,
Carrie W. Jo
City Clerk
/ptb
-~
!
j
WHEREAS,
WHEREAS,
WHEREAS,
WHEREAS,
WHEREAS,
RESOLUTION
this Resolution is made in regard to the submission of an application for
Hometown Economic Development Grant funds to the Municipal
Association of South Carolina on or before October 12, 2018; and,
the City of Orangeburg hereby commits to provide a local cash/in-kind
match of at least $3,750; and,
which is the minimum 15-percent local match required by the Municipal
Association of South Carolina; and,
to support the City of Orangeburg application for a $25,000 Hometown
Economic Development Grant; and,
these grant aud local matching funds will be used for a partnership with
the Downtown Orangeburg Revitalization Association (DORA) to develop
an open air market/downtown. pavilion and commercial kitchen.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, that the Mayor and City Council of the
City of Orangeburg, South Carolina, in Council assembled on this 2nd day of October 2018
committing the City of Orangeburg to providing a local match for a Municipal Association of
South Carolina Hometown Economic Development Grant.
Passed by the City Council of the City of Orangeburg, State of South Carolina, this 2nd day of
October 2018.
MEMBERS OF COUNCIL
CITY COUNC MINUTES
September 20, 2018 2763
Orangeburg City Council held a City Council meeting on Thursday, September 20, 2018, at
12:00 Noon in Council Chambers with Mayor Butler presiding. This change in meeting date was
scheduled after the regularly scheduled meeting for September 18, 2018, was canceled due to
Hurricane Florence.
PRESENT:
Michael C. Butler, Mayor
L. Zimmerman Keitt
Jerry Hannah
Bernard Haire
Charles W. Jernigan
Richard F. Stroman
ABSENT:
Sandra P. Knotts
Mayor Butler recognized Mr. Gerrod Maddox, Intern from South Carolina State College.
A motion was made by Councilmember Stroman, seconded by Councilmember Haire, to approve
the September 4, 2018, City Council Minutes as distributed. This motion was unanimously
approved.
City Administrator Yow addressed Council in regards to a funding request from the Orangeburg
County Fair Association. He stated, "At the September 4, 2018, meeting, Mr. John Shuler and
Dr. Eugene Atkinson appeared before Council requesting financial assistance with the Fair.
Council took no action but instructed this matter be placed on tonight's agenda."
Councilmember Haire stated, "I have gone by the Fair property and the plans the Fair has will go
a long way to make our City more attractive. I would like to make a motion that we fund one
half of the requested amount for this project and it be coupled with a proviso that if the Fair
Association disbands before two years that the City be reimbursed."
The motion received no second.
Mayor Pro Tern Keitt stated, "This Fair brings people from all over the connnunity and I think
the Association is doing an excellent job. I make a motion that we give the Fair Association
$10,000 so our citizens wi11 have a place to go. Ifwe help support what we have, we don't have
to reinvent the wheel."
Mayor Pro Tern Keitt's motion was seconded by Councilmember Stroman.
Counciimember Stroman stated, "I don't think it is fair to put stipulations on the money. I
suggest these funds come from the Hospitality Acconnnodations Tax Fund."
Councilmember Haire stated, "I have an uureadiness and the reason for my stipulation is if they
sell the property, I think the citizens should not have to pay for this and we should be able to
recoup the money."
The vote was 4-1- l, with Couneilmember Hannah abstaining and Councilmember Haire
opposing.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, seconded by Councilmembcr Stroman, to approve
the Second Reading of an Ordinance for a Zoning District Map change from A-2 Residential,
Multi-Unit District to 0-1 Office-Institutional-Residential District for property belonging to the
Paragon, Inc., of South Carolina, LLC, located at 795 Whitman Street, Orangeburg, SC TMP#
0173-14-07-010.000. This motion was unanimously approved.
Page2
2764
Department of Public Safety Director Michael Adams addressed Council in regards to a FEMA
Fire Prevention and Safety Grant. He stated, "The City has been awarded a Resident Fire
Inspection Safety Grant through FEMA in the amount of $12,477.00 with a $623.00 match. This
Grant brings awareness through fire safety inspections with an emphasis on the at risk population
and we will be able to install fire alarms and possibly stove auto extinguishers. We will be
using social media as well as our co=unity groups to get the word out. Of the frre calls we
have, 87% are residential."
Councilmember Hannah stated, 'This is a good thing, how many fire calls did you have last
week?"
DPS Director Adams stated, "There were twenty-six (26) calls last week for service, we have
about 1,500 calls per year."
Councilmember Hannah stated, "How are you going to get the word out on this? You can ride
by someone's house and see they need help."
DPS Director Adams replied, "We will be using social media, our co=unity.groups and crime
watch meetings."
A motion was made by Councilmember Stroman, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, to approve
the FEMA Fire Prevention and Safety Grant in the amount of$12,477.00 and the local match of
$623.00. This motion was unanimously approved.
There were no utility matters brought before Council.
A motion was made by Councilmember Hannah, seconded by Councilmember Haire, to enter
into an Executive Session for a Legal Matter and Discussion of Claim Assertion of
Demetrius Jamison. This motion was unanimously approved.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
submitted,
'---lc;a'.lc11·e W. Johnson
City Clerk
/pfu
7
.. J
-- .J
City Council Minutes
October 2, 2018
Orangeburg City Council held a Public Hearing on Tuesday, October 2, 2018, at 7:0o@q.65
Council Chambers. with Mayor Michael C. Butler presiding. The purpose of the Public Hearing
was for the following:
Public Hearing: To consider an application for annexation into the City of Orangeburg, SC,
property belonging to W-3 Holdings, LLC, 950 Chestnut Streeet, TMP# 0174-18-05-001.000
Hearing no public comments, the Public Hearing was closed.
Council entered into the regularly scheduled meeting.
PRESENT:
Michael C. Butler, Mayor
Bernard Haire
Jerry Hannah
Charles W. Jernigan
L. Zimmerman Keitt
Sandra P. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
Two students from Edisto High School were recognized as attending the meeting.
A motion was made by Councilmember Stroman, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, to approve
the September 20, 2018, City Council Minutes, as distributed. This motion was unanimously
approved.
Mayor Butler and DPU Manager Warren Harley presented a Retiree Resolution and gold watch
to Mr. Donald Brett Yongue for his thirty years, two months and twenty-one days of service to
the Department of Public Utilities.
Mr. Shawn Taylor, Parks and Recreation Superintendent of Recreation and Marketing,
recognized the All-Star Baseball Champions players and their parents.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Knotts, to approve
the Third Reading of an Ordinance for a Zoning District Map Change from A-2 Residential,
Multi-Unit District to 0-1 Office-Institutional-Residential District for property belonging to
Paragon, Inc., of South Carolina, LLC, located at 795 Whitman Street, Orangeburg, SC, TMP#
0174-18-05-001.000. This motion was unanimously approved.
Ms. Evelyn Discher, Community of Character Executive Director, accepted the Character Trait
Proclamation for October, 2018, "Courage".
Ms. Shaniqua Simmons, Parks and Recreation Director, addressed Council in regards to an
update on Parks and Recreation Programs. A power point presentation was presented. Ms.
Simmons overviewed the Parks and Recreation organizational chart that also included a Division
for FY 2018-19, to include the new North Road Recreational Complex.
She stated, "We have 14 playgrounds, 11 fields, 2 community centers, shelters and two
cemeteries. During our busy season, we have up to 17 6 volunteers. These volunteers are mainly
coaches. We rely on our volunteers heavily. We have sixty three (63) paid staff that includes
referees and scorekeepers. At the Orangeburg City Gym in FY 2017-18 we have had 93 events
with over 19,000 visits. We have open play and our rentals have increased with tournaments.
The revenue collected at the gym. is $19,209 for the fiscal year. Our leisure or recre<ftional
services include day camps, summer camps and rentals. The Spray Park i doing well with a 6%
increase this fiscal year in attendance. We have had 210 rentals in FY 20 7-18 which could be
shelters, gazebos or the Spray Park. 1n athletics, we had 167 volunteers i FY 2017-18. An
average volunteer pay rate for the State of SC is $22.22. We had 8,016 vo unteer hours in FY
2017-18 which equates to $178,000 in savings. The bulk of our volunteer are coaches, which is
an extension of our staff. We have hosted state tournaments here and hop to do more at the
Recreational Complex. The most sponsorship comes from baseball and e least participants are
Page2
in football. This is mainly due to parents being cautious about concussions; however, soccer is
incre~(J4Jirticipants. We have collected in revenues for FY 2017-18, $71,608 for athletics.
Our maintenance staff takes care of the gardens and keeps the organization running and they also
offer support to DORA and other agencies. We have special events throughout the year from
Spring Camps, Sunmier Camps, Senior Games, Dance Classes and we have Senior Day at the
Gym on Wednesday that includes bingo and line dancing. What's next? The North Road
Recreational Complex. Soon we will be advertising for staff. Our facility will be new and great
· and we will have new lights that will bring the people and tournaments to Orangeburg."
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "How many jobs will this bring.to Orangeburg?"
Ms. Simmons replied, "There are six budgeted, four full-time staff and two part-time staff."
Councihnember Jernigan asked, "Will you have volunteers also?"
Ms. Simmons replied, "Yes, that is essential to recreation. The issue is finding good volunteers."
Mayor Pro Tern Keitt stated, "The only issue I have is that the Spray Park is not open long
enough."
Ms. Simmons replied, "We may need to try something different."
City Yow stated, "There was some questions before as to activities in the City Gym. Some
citizens came before Council to state that there is no activities going on there. As you can see
from the numbers and the events, it is being utilized."
Ms. Simmons replied, "We try to tell our visitors to go to the gym to park in the back by
Mirmow Field, so if you are riding down Broughton Street, you do not see the cars in the back."
A motion was made by Councilmember Stroman, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, approving
the application for Hometown Economic Development Grant Funds to the Municipal
Association of South Carolina for a $25,000.00 grant with a local match of $3,750.00 for an open
air market pavilion. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councihnember Haire, seconded by Councihnember Knotts, to approve
the First Reading ofan Ordinance for annexation into the City of Orangeburg, SC, property
belonging to W-3 Holdings, LLC, 950 Chestnut Street, TMP# 0174-18-05-001.000. This motion
was unanimously approved.
Carrie Johnson, Finance Director stated, "Tonight we are requesting approval to move forward in
signing the final contract to begin the AS/400 Conversion with New World/Tyler Technologies.
The project began in 2009 with an Information Technology Committee discussing future IT
related needs. As you can see in your packet, I've outlined our steps since 2009. We
demonstarted various software packages to enhance our City's IT infrastructure with solicitations
requested from eight vendors (InCode, Southern Software, Tyler New World, CSI, American
Data Corp, QSI and AVG). Only three (BS&A, New World and Tyler) responded via RFP
process. Bids were enclosed in your packet. Demos and visits were made to other locations,
including Fairfield County, Goose Creek, North Augusta and Sumter priorto the Committee's
selection. The contract amount of $278,660, which includes the base module, training and Esuite
applications of which $200,000 is budgeted in FY 2017-18 with the possible addition ofroughly
$100,000 over the next three years to include variance with contract and possible additional
hardware and licenses as needed. The Project Plan outlines all task through a three phase
implementation-reference document provided to them with such tasks ad Data Prep, Gap
Analysis, Validation of Conversation Data, Testing and Training. This is the first and largest
phase as implementation date of November 1, 2019. Last phase will be implemented December
31, 2020. We will be providing quarterly status updates to Council as we progress. Due to
limited staff we will be assisted by our consultant who has been with us since the beginning of
this effort and also has significant experience with
Page3
his product due to his other work with the Sumter implementation. I would recommei fA! 1, authorize the City Administrator to enter into this contract extension with New World/Tyler Technologies."
Mayor Butler asked, "This technology is for what?"
Finance Director Johnson replied, "It is for all facets of Finance and also modules pertaining to Public Works that includes accounts payable, accounts receivable, revenue accounting, taxes,
business licenses and a community development module. This module will be map interfaced
where you can go to a location and see what is due or applicable to that address such as work
orders, taxes or a business license. The AS400 is an archaic technology and we are going to a more server based environment, it will be a three year process. A lot of our programs are home grown from the 1980's and we will be going to a more user friendly and windows based
environment. This would be an extension of our current contract,"
Mayor Pro Tern Keitt asked, "How many companies were involved in this?"
Director Johnson stated, "There were eight companies and we received three bids. The bid
process was done on a grading process."
Councilmember Hannah asked, "Who is our consultant?"
Director Johnson stated, "Mr. Karl McCollester from UDHHA, who was recommended to us from MASC."
Councilmember Hannah asked, "On your pages where it states you visited Fairfield County in 2012 and Goose Creek in 2013, that Technology is outdated?"
Director Johnson replied, "We started thi.s project back in 2009, these cities use the same product as to what we are trying to implement now and their software has been updated yearly. Goose
Creek is mainly with Tyler and their software will be updated each year. We get upgrades each year on our current software."
Councilmember Knotts asked, "Are these upgrades automatic?"
Director Johnson stated, "Yes, upgrades are automatic each year."
Mayor Pro Tem Keitt asked, "Who would be trained on this?"
Director Johnson stated, "We will train those applicable to that module. We will train departments that need to do deposits in revenue accounting and Public Works will be trained in community development, as an example. I believe in cross training. Someone else should know
what to do if someone else is out."
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Councilmember Knotts, to approve
an authorization to enter into a contract extension with New World/Tyler Technologies for the AS/400 system conversion in the amount of$227,015.00. This motion was unanimously
approved.
There were no utility matters pertaining to the Department of Public Utilities.
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Mayor Pro Tem Keitt, to enter into an Executive Session for (1) Legal Matter concerning Opioid Litigation and (2) Personnel Matter
regarding City Attorney Compensation.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
/
(
/
<
A RESOLUTION TO ACCEPT A GIFT OF PROPERTY LOCATED ON
AMELIA, RUSSELL AND WINDSOR STREETS IN THE CITY OF
ORANGEBURG, STATE OF SOUTH CAROLINA, FROM R. MICHAEL
JOHNSON AND GREG B. CAMPBELL
WHEREAS, R. Michael Johnson and Greg B. Campbell have offered to donate
the below described property to the City of Orangeburg, and
WHEREAS, the City finds that it is in the best interest and that of its citizens to
accept said gift.
NOW THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED BY CITY COUNCIL DULY
ASSEMBLED this d:z-+/,, day of November, 2018 that the City of Orangeburg does
hereby accept the offer of R. Michael Johnson and Greg B. Campbell to convey the
below described property to the City as a gift and donation.
Description of property:
All that certain piece, parcel or tract of land, with any improvements thereon, situate,
lying and being in the City of Orangeburg, School District 5, County of Orangeburg,
State of South Carolina, being shown as Parcel "A" and Parcel "B" on a Plat for Luther
Adden, prepared by W. F. Stokes, RLS, dated January 5, 1981, and revised on January
7, 1981 and recorded in the office of the Register of Deeds for Orangeburg County in
Plat Book 50 at Page 85 and bounded and measuring as follows: On the Northeast by
the right-of-way of Broughton Street, measuring thereon three hundred one and three
tenths (301.3) feet; on the Southeast by property now or formerly of First Citizens Bank
and Trust Company of South Carolina, measuring thereon two hundred thirty-one and
nine-tenths (231.9) feet; again on the Northeast by property nor or formerly of First
Citizens Bank and Trust Company of South Carolina, measuring thereon one hundred
twenty-nine and four-tenths (129.4) feet; again on the Southeast by the right-of-way of
Russell Street, measuring thereon three hundred twenty-four and nine-tenths (324.9)
feet; on the Southwest by the right-of-way of Windsor Street, measuring thereon four
hundred thirty-three and three-tenths (433.3) feet; and on the Northwest by the right-of
way of Amelia Street, measuring thereon five hundred fifty and nine-tenths (550.9) feet;
all measurements being more or less. LESS AND EXCEPT: Two and eighty-seven
hundredths (2.87) acres, more or less, shown on a Plat for Kimbrell's Investment Co.,
Inc., dated April 2, 1999 and recorded in the aforesaid office in Deed Book C-125 at
Page 10.
TMS #: 0173-17-03-001
AND IT IS SO RESOLVED.
Members of Council
A RESOLUTION TO ACCEPT A GIFT OF PROPERTY LOCATED ON LANGSTON,
MAPLE AND HAMPTON STREETS IN THE CITY OF ORANGEBURG, STATE OF
SOUTH CAROLINA, FROM J. LEONARD SANFORD AND SANFORD
INVESTMENTS II, LLC
WHEREAS, J. Leonard Sanford and Sanford Investments II, LLC have offered to
donate the below described properties to the City of Orangeburg, and
WHEREAS, the City finds that it is in the· best interest and that of its citizens to
accept said gift.
NOW THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED BY CITY COUNCIL DULY ASSEMBLED
this l,W day of November, 2018 that the City of Orangeburg does hereby accept the
offer of J. Leonard Sanford and Sanford Investments 11, LLC to convey the below
described properties to the City as a gift and donation.
Description of properties:
From J. Leonard Sanford
All that certain piece, parcel or lot of land, with any improvements thereon, situate, lying ·
and being in School District 5, City and County of Orangeburg, State of South Carolina,
and being set forth and shown as property of R. T. Ashley on a Plat of 2.18 Acres,
prepared for Leonard Sanford, by Edisto Surveyo~s Inc., approved by A. R. Parler, Jr.,
RLS, dated August .6, 2002 and recorded in the office of the Register of Deeds for
Orangeburg County in Plat Book D-140 at Page 5 and bounded and measuring as follows:
On the Northwest by the right-of-way of Langston Street, measuring thereon fifty (50')
feet; on the Northeast by property formerly of J. G. Houser, now of J. Leonard Sanford,
measuring thereon one hundred fifty-one and forty-one hundredths (151.41 ') feet; on the
Southeast by property of J. Leonard Sanford, measuring thereon fifty (50') feet; and on
the Southwest by property of J. Leonard Sanford, measuring thereon one hundred fifty
one and forty-one hundredths (151.41 ') feet; all measurements being more or less.
From Sanford Investments 11, LLC
All that certain piece, parcel or lot of land, with any improvements thereon, situate, lying
and being in the City and County of Orangeburg, State of South Carolina, and being
shown as property of J. G. Houser on a Plat for Leonard Sanford, prepared by Edisto
Surveyors , Inc., approved by A. R. Parler, Jt., RLS, dated August 6, 2002 and recorded
in the office of the Register of Deeds for Orangeburg County in Plat Book D-140 at Page
5, and bounded as follows: On the Northeast by the right-of-way of Maple Street,
measuring thereon one hundred fifty-one and forty-one hundredths (151.41 ') feet; on the
Southeast by property of Leonard Sanford, measuring thereon fifty (50') feet; on the
Southwest by property now or formerly ofR. T. Ashley, measuring thereon one hundred
one hundred fifty-one and forty-one hundredths (151.41 ') feet; and on the Northwest by
the right-of-way of Langston Street, measuring thereon fifty (50') feet; all measurements
being more or less.
AND
'
All that certain piece, parcel or tract of land, with all! improvements thereon, situate, lying
and being in School District 5, City and County of Orangeburg, State of South Carolina,
containing two and eighteen hundredths (2.18) acres, more or less, and being more fully
set forth and shown on a plat for Leonard Sanford, prepared by Edisto Surveyors, Inc.
approved by A. R. Parler, Jr., RLS dated August 6, 2002 and recorded in the Office of the
Register of Deeds for Orangeburg County in Plat Book C271 at Page 2.
AND IT IS SO RESOLVED.
Members of Council
2768
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
October 16, 2018
Orangeburg City Council held its regularly scheduled meeting on Tuesday, October 16, 2018, at
7:00 P.M., in Council Chambers with Mayor Michael C. Butler presiding.
PRESENT:
Michael C. Butler, Mayor
Bernard Haire
Jerry Hannah
Charles W. Jernigan
L. Zimmerman Keitt
Sandra P. Knotts (attended late)
Richard F. Stroman
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Stroman, to approve
the October 2, 2018, City Council Minutes, as distributed. This motion was unanimously
approved. Councilmember Knotts not present at time of voting, but was present for the rest of
Othe meeting.
Mr. William Green of 1048 Doyle Street addressed Council. He stated, "I am here tonight to
discuss a project I am working on to bring more attention to Downtown Orangeburg for
Christmas. Since it doesn't snow here, I would like to see businesses dress their windows with
white lights for Christmas. Also, the light poles only have about ten lights on them. I Would like
to see an increase in the number oflights that are on a pole to 100 to 150 lights. I think it would
be great to add red bows to the top of each light pole from here to the Gardens and the
surrounding streets to make downtown look like a Christmas village."
Mayor Butler stated, "You must have a plan behind your suggestion."
Mr. Green replied, "I have asked business owners with poles in front of their business to consider
purchasing the bows and the ones I have talked to verbally agreed."
Mayor Butler asked, "Do you have a list of business owners that will put bows on top of the
poles? We are here to provide safety to the citizens and beautification, there must be a plan in
place."
Mr. Green stated, "I have talked with two florists who would do the bows for the poles."
Mayor Butler asked, "Have you talked to City officials to be sure that th.e bows can be put on the
poles?
Mr. Green stated, "No, I have not."
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "Have you talked to Downtown. Orangeburg Revitalization
Association (DORA)?"
Mr. Green replied, "I did talk to someone from DORA last year."
Councilmember Jernigan stated, "I think you need to be working with. them on this."
Mr. Green replied, "This is something I am working on and I will be sure to put it all in writing."
Mayor Pro Tern Keitt stated, "I think it is a good idea and you need to have a plan in place."
Councilmember Haire asked, "How many businesses seem to be interested?"
Mr. Green replied, "Let me get all ~f that in writing."
Page2
Councilmember Haire asked, "How many poles are there?" 2769
Mr. Green replied, "I didn't really count the ones not in front of a business, so let me get that
number to you."
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Haire, to approve
the Second Reading of an Ordinance for annexation into the City of Orangeburg, SC, property
belonging to W-3 Holdings, LLC, 950 Chestnut Street, TMP# 01074-18-05-001.000. This
motion was unanimously approved.
City Administrator Yow stated, "There is no new business; however, I want to say that we are
thankful that we were spared from another storm by the storm again and I want to thank City
Council and the employees for their storm preparedness."
There were no utility matters brought before Council.
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Councilmember Knotts, to enter into
an Executive Session for the following:
( 1) Legal Matter and Discussion of Claim Assertion of Demetrius Jamison
(2) Legal and Contractual Matters
A. Memorandum of Understanding with Tri-County Electric Cooperative
B. Midlands Utility/Northwood Estates
(3) Contractual Matter
A. Purchase of Property - Orangeburg County Parcel TMP# 0173-17-03-001.000; 1003,
1007, 1009, 1013 and 1015 Russell Street, Orangeburg, SC
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
/pfb
2770
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
November 6, 2018
Orangeburg City Council held its regularly scheduled meeting on Tuesday, November 6, 2018, at
7 :00 P .M., in Council Chambers with Mayor Michael C. Butler presiding.
PRESENT:
Michael C. Butler, Mayor
Bernard Haire
Jerry Hannah
Charles W. Jernigan
L. Zimmerman Keitt
Sandra P. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
ABSENT:
I. Zimmerman Keitt
A motion was made by Councilmember Stroman, seconded by Councilmember Haire, to approve
the October 16, 2018, City Council Minutes, as distributed. This motion was unanimously
approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Councilmember Knotts, to approve
the Third Reading of an Ordinance for annexation into the City of Orangeburg, SC, property
belonging to W-3 Holdings, LLC, 950 Chestnut Street, TMP# 0174- I 8-05-001.000. This motion
was unanimously approved.
Ms. Evelyn Disher, Community of Character Executive Director, accepted the Character Trait
Proclamation for November, 2018, "Empathy".
Mr. Jim Battigaglia addressed Council in regards to the Classification and Compensation Study
that has been ongoing for the City and the Department of Public Utilities.
He stated, "The Archer Company has thirty (30) years of experience and is headquartered in
Rock Hill, South Carolina, with additional offices in Chicago, Columbus, Atlanta, Raleigh and
California. Our primary focus is developing classification plans and compensation plans for
public organizations.
First, I am going to summarize the mechanics of the study and an introduction to the work we
completed with more details in Executive Session.
We have worked with 1,500 organizations in fifteen (15) states. We are working on this as two
different studies, one for the City and one for DPU.
Our goals were to create an objective classification and compensation plan, balance internal
equity and external competitiveness results in fair compensation, collect, compare and assess
major fringe benefits. This can be maintained efficiently and effectively as jobs change.
During this time, we completed a job analysis where employees completed a comprehensive
position questionnaire (CPQ). The supervisors and directors reviewed the CPQ's and reviewed
them. We then interviewed the Department Directors after we categorized the CPQ's. These
interviews allowed the discussions of department services, employee classification issues and
recruitment issues, including turnover.
Our next step was job evaluations where we evaluated the jobs and compared them in the public
sector and each job had a numerical score. We established a classification structure consistent
with the client's preference. The classifications were evaluated by the Archer Job Evaluation
System to establish internal equity. The client then reviewed classifications and pay grade
--
Page2
assignments. We then responded to any issues. I would like to point out that the City jig'~{
hundred (100) job titles and DPU has one-hundred and twenty (120) job titles.
During our market analysis phase, we discussed external equity objectives and compared salary
survey data comparing to target employers and identifying benchmark jobs. We then compiled
the survey salary ranges and average pay and then analyzed the survey results and compared
results to our client's data.
During the statistical analysis phase, we had market estimates that were graphed by job
evaluation points. The higher the job, the greater the worth and the higher of pay. There is a line
. .
of best fit and correlations calculated and pay policy was developed from these results to match
the market. We also looked at the major fringe benefits and we are still in process of doing this.
We are looking at paid time off and comparison to holidays, vacation days, sick days and
retirement.
Some of our salary survey participants were Aiken County, Lexington County, Orangeburg
County, Sumter County, City of Goose Creek, City of North Charleston, City of Santee, City of
Summerville, Santee Cooper, Greenville Water, North Charleston Water, A WW A Salary Survey
and the Economic Research Institute.
The benchmark jobs we used and job titles and job :fumilies were DPU Administration Director,
Public Safety Director, Public Works Director, Finance Director, City Attorney, Human
Resources Administrator, all Superintendent, Building Official, Public Safety Officer V,
Network Engineer, Sanitation Supervisor 1 Public Safety Officer IV, Accountant, Building
Inspector, Water Operation IV, Public Safety Officer I, Executive Administrative Assistant,
Mechanic, Motor Equipment Operator III, Wastewater Operator II, Water Operator II, Accounts
Payable Clerk, Administrative Specialist I, Motor Equipment Operator I, Data Entry Specialist,
Maintenance Worker II, Custodian II and Receptionist. The regression analysis on page 12 of
yollt-handout shows the benchmarked jobs and those below the line are below the minimum pay
grade.
The City Pay Plan recommendations are to develop a pay plan at 100% of the market with
twenty-one (21) pay grades. Each pay grade has a 50% spread from minimum to maximum. We
also assigneed employees to classifications and pay grades and increase salaries so that all
employees are within pay grade minimum salary ranges.
Department of Public Utilities pay plan recommendations are to develop a pay plan at 105% of
the market with twenty-one pay grades. Each pay grade has a 50% spread from Minimum to
maximum. Assign employees to classifications and pay grades, increase salaries so that all
employees are within pay grade salary ranges and providing revised descriptions and benefits
analysis.
That is the overview and there will be more details in closed session."
Mayor Butler stated, "I understand this overview very well and it will be beneficial to
employees."
Councilmember Stroman asked, "On page 9, there is nothing noted on health and dental
insurance, shouldn't that be there?"
Mr. Battigaglia stated, "Insurance is volatile and can. change from one year to th.e next. One
government can pay 100%, others 20% or 40%."
City Administrator Yow stated, "We pay 100% of the employee's coverage and a lot of
organizations do not do that and I think it is an important benefit."
Councilmember Hannah stated, "I also had insurance down as a benefit On page 11, is that
sequential?" Also, when you talked to the directors, was it individually?"
Page3
Mr.~& replied, "There is no order to that page and yes we did interviews individually."
Councilmember Haire asked, "I have a concern of those employees that are on the lower end of
the scale. Garbage collectors, do you treat them any different since they work outside? Where
did you get the comparison data?
Mr. Battigaglia stated, "We use the Economic Research Institute and evaluate jobs. The
employees that work outside get a higher score under environmental factors compared to
someone who works inside such as an Administrative Clerk."
A motion was made by Councilmember Stroman, seconded by Councilmember Haire, giving
Department of Public Utilities Manager, Warren Harley, authorization to sign a Memorandum of
Understanding with Tri-County Electric Cooperative. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Councilmember Knotts, to enter into
an Executive Session for the following:
1. Discussion of Employee( s) Compensation
2. Legal Matter and Discussion of Claim Assertion of Demetrius Jamison
3. Legal Matter -- South Carolina Electric and Gas Company Demand
4. Contractual Matters
A. Gift of Property-Orangeburg County Parcel TMP# 0173-17-03-001.000,
Orangeburg, SC
B. Gift of Property- Orangeburg County Parcel TMP#'s 0173-17.31-001.000, 0173-17-31-
002.000, 0173-17-31-003.000, 0173-17-31-004.000 and 0173-17-31-006.000,
Orangeburg, SC
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Councilmember Knotts, to return to
Open Session.
Council returned to Open Session.
A motion was made by Councilmember Stroman, seconded by Coun.cilmember Haire, to approve
a Resolution to accept a gift of property located on Amelia, Russell and Windsor Streets in the
City of Orangeburg, SC, from R. Michael Johnson and Greg B. Campbell, which is located
directly across from DPU. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Stroman, seconded by Councilmember Haire, to approve
a Resolution to accept a gift of property located on Langston, Maple and Hampton Streets in the
City of Orangeburg, SC, from J. Leonard Sanford and Sanford Investments II, LLC.
This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Stroman, seconded by Councilmember Haire, to
adjourn. This motion was unanimously approved.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourn.ed.
Ca · . Johnson
City Clerk
/pfb
RESOLUTION
TO AUTHORIZE THE MUNICIPAL ASSOCIATION OF SOUTH CAROLINA TO ACT AS
CLAIMANT AGENCY FOR THE COLLECTION OF DEBT ON BEHALF OF THE CITY OF
ORANGEBURG IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE SETOFF DEBT COLLECTION ACT.
WHEREAS, the Setoff Debt Collection Act (S.C. Code Ann. §12-56-10) allows the South
Carolina Department of Revenue to render assistance in the collection of debt owed to political
subdivisions of the State; and
WHEREAS, the Municipal Association of South Carolina will act as a claimant agency as
provided by S.C. Code Ann. §12-56-10 for political subdivisions in South Carolina; and
WHEREAS, the City of Orangeburg desires to participate in the Setoff Debt Collection
Program of the Municipal Association;
Now, Therefore, Be It RESOLVED, that the City of Orangeburg authorizes the City
Administrator to enter into an agreement with the Municipal Association of South Carolina for
the collection of debt owed to the City of Orangeburg.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that the City of Orangeburg indemnifies the Municipal
Association of South Carolina to the extent permitted by law against any injuries, actions,
liabUO~ oc proceed;ags aO.ag from perlumaag 1_~ the '"'.;'.' debt p~;'.;oas. ✓
Resolved by the City of Orangeburg this day of J)t' £ c)y._pp)(2o_f.
-"-,,,,··✓
Ci Clerk
City Council Minutes
November 20, 2018
2773
Orangeburg City Council held its regularly scheduled meeting on Tuesday, November 20, 2018,
at 7:00 P.M., with Mayor Michael C. Butler presiding.
PRESENT:
Michael C. Butler, Mayor
Bernard Haire
Jerry Hannah
Charles W. Jernigan
L. Zimmerman Keitt
Sandra P. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
A motion was made by Councilmember Stroman, seconded by Councilmember Knotts, to
approve the November 6, 2018, City Council Minutes, as distributed. This was a 6-0-1 vote as . '
Mayor Pro Tem Keitt abstained, as she was not present at the meeting.
Ms. Doris Greene, SC Partnership Specialist with the US Census Bureau addressed Council. She
stated, "We are ready for the 2020 Census. This is mandated by the United States Constitution
that we have a Census every ten years to count every person in the United States. Our goal is to
count every breathing person. The Census determines representatives for Congress and
determines money in our state. There are sixteen (16) programs impacted by the Census that are
federaliy funded. In 2000, South Carolina received $1,499.00 per person per year and in a ten
(10) year period, which is $15,000 for each person in South Carolina. Federal Funding includes
Head Start, Medicaid, schools and hospitals. Cemus Day is April 1, 2019. Students are counted
differently. Each household needs to be counted and children are at risk of not being counted.
Many connnunities are impacted by the census ofunacconnted children with school
overcrowding. I am here to help with churches, organizations and enlighten people about the
Census. It also starts with you in assisting with getting the word out. There are hundreds of jobs
available for 12-18 months starting a $15-18 per hour. We are recruiting now."
Councilmcmber Jernigan asked, "The jobs are paid?"
Ms. Greene replied, "Yes, and it is up to forty hours per week with paid mileage."
Council.member I-Iarmah asked, "I see where smaller counties scored very low in 2000, but
increased in 2010, what can you attribute to that?"
Ms. Greene replied, "Of course, it was me and the Partnership Program and we got one more
person in Congress because of that."
Ms. Cheryl Lynch, Department of Public Utilities Human Resource Officer and Ms. Theresa
Williams, City Human Resource Officer, overviewed the Current Classification and Comp
Study. Details are as follows:
l. Discuss and determine pay plan placement beyond the pay grade minimums.
2. Discuss and determine timing of implementation plans for minimum and beyond.
3. Fringe Benefits - Holidays, Leave - Paid Time Ofl: Retirement, City Retiree Health Care,
City Health Care and Auxiliary Benefits.
4. Holidays-Ten (10) paid annually which are New Year's Day, Martin Luther King, Jr., Day,
Good Friday, Memorial Day, Independence Day, Labor Day, Thanksgiving Day, Friday after
Thanksgiving, Christmas Eve and Chri.stmas Day.
Page2
Length of Service
0-6Months
Days Per Month Days Per Year
6 end of probation (48 Hrs.) 6
6 Months - 5 Years
5 Years-15 Years
15 Years-25 Years
25 Years+
1 ¼ (10 Hrs.) 15
1 ½ (12 Hrs.) 18
1 ¾ (14 Hrs.) 21
2 (16 Hrs.) 24
6. South Carolina Retirement Plan-City Contribution on Employee Compensation
YEAR YEAR YEAR YEAR
2018-19 2019-20 2020-21 2021-22
YEAR
2022-23
SC RETIREMENT 14.56% 15.56% 16.56% 17.56% 18.56%
PORS 17.04% 18.04% 19.04% 20.04% 21.04%
(Employer contributed scheduled 1 % increase per year as mandated by the State)
7. City Retiree Health Benefits (Between the ages. of 60 - 65)
Last hired prior to June 1, 1993
15 yrs. service / over age 65
20 yrs. service / over age 60
25 yrs. service
28 yrs. service with SC Retirement with 15 yrs. service with City
25 yrs. service with SC Police Retirement with 15 yrs. service with City
Last hired after June 1, 1993 -January 1, 2010
25 yrs. service
(Value approximately $8,112 per year for 5 years)
8. City Health Benefits-Medical BCBS (PPO) Plan Annual Value $8,112.00
HDHP Plan/includes Health Savings Acct. Annual Value $7,584.00
Dental BCBS Plan Annual Value $ 420.00
9. Auxiliary Benefits -- Social Security and Medicare Tax (.0765%)
Workers Compensation Insurance
Long Term Disability (premium value $200.00 per year)
Companion $15,000 Life Insurance (premium value $35.00 per year)
Jury Duty
Military Duty
Bereavement (2 days)
Educational Assistance (70%)
Uniforms
Steel Toe Shoes (only DPU)
Ms. Theresa Williams, City HR Officer, overviewed the 2016/2018 Compensation Statements.
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "Can you give me an average pay rate of one position as are
currently provided to employees?"
Ms. Williams replied, "We can work on that for you because it would depend on the
classification of employees."
Councilmember Jernigan stated, "Just an average for a person working for the City of the 200
employees."
Councilmember Hannah asked, "Did I hear you right, that the $15,000 life insurance policy is
$35.00 per year?"
Ms. Lynch replied, "Yes, that is right, we have a group term policy and those are the current
rates based on 400 employees."
Councilmember Knotts asked, "For bereavement, is that two days?
Page3
Ms. Lynch replied, "Yes" 2775
Councilmember Knotts asked, "What happens when someone has to travel over a period of
days?"
Ms. Lynch replied, "They would have to take annual leave or do not get paid for it."
Councilmember Stroman asked, "Do we owe anyone overtime?"
Ms. Williams stated, "Overtime is paid as it is accrued with the exception of DPS employees
who have to work a number of hours before they are paid overtime."
City Administrator Yow stated, "Overtime is paid and someone could accrue overtime today, but
not get paid until next pay period.
A motion was made by Councilmember Stroman, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, to approve
the 2018-19 Fac,ade Grant Awards. This motion as unanimously approved.
There were no Department of Public Utility matters brought before Council.
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, to enter into
an Executive Session for a ( 1) Contractual Matter (A) Proposed: Contract with the Buxton
Company and a (2) Legal Matter (A) Ownersbip/Reversionary Clause Palmetto Development
Group -- 1170 Russell Street, Orangeburg, SC.
Council did not return to Open Session.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
/pfb
A RESOLUTION TO AUTHORIZE THE MUNICIPAL ASSOCIATION OF SOUTH
CAROLINA TO ACT AS CLAIMANT AGENCY FOR THE COLLECTION OF DEBT ON
BEHALF OF THE CITY OF ORANGEBURG DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC UTILITIES IN
ACCORDANCE WITH THE SETOFF DEBT COLLECTION ACT
WHEREAS, the Setoff Debt Collection Act (S.C. Code Ann. §12-56-10) allows
the South Carolina Department of Revenue to render assistance in the collection of debt
owed to political subdivisions of the State; and
WHEREAS, the Municipal Association of South Carolina will act as a claimant
agency as provided by S.C. Code Ann. §12-56-10 for political subdivisions in South
Carolina; and
WHEREAS, the City of Orangeburg Department of Public Utilities desires to
participate in the Setoff Debt Collection Program of the Municipal Association;
NOW THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED BY CITY COUNCIL DULY
ASSEMBLED this '1""- day of December, 2018 to authorize the Manager of the City of
Orangeburg Department of Public Utilities to enter into an agreement with the Municipal
Association of South Carolina for the collection of debt owed the City of Orangeburg
Department of Public Utilities.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that the City of Orangeburg Department of Public
Utilities indemnifies the Municipal Association of South Carolina to the extent permitted
by law against any injuries, actions, liabilities or proceedings arising from performance
under the setoff debt provisions.
AND IT IS SO RESOLVED.
City Council Minutes
December 4, 2018 2777
Orangeburg City Council held it regularly scheduled meeting on Tuesday, December 4, 2018, at
7:00 P.M., with Mayor Butler presiding.
PRESENT:
Michael C. Butler, Mayor
Bernard Haire
Jerry Hannah
Chares w. Jernigan
L. Zimmerman Keitt
Sandra P. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
Mr. George Dean addressed Council. He stated, "On behalf of my family, my wife and my
business family, we had an unexpected fire on November 9th. I want to acknowledge what a
great job the first responders did. Chief Adams and staff, the Dean's Limited Family thanks you
and your personnel for a great job. As a small business in Orangeburg, the City of Orangeburg
has done a great job in revitalizing downtown to be pedestrian friendly; however, we need more
pedestrians. As a business owner for over forty-eight ( 48) years and having a history in this
community, we need your help and we are asking that you incentivize small businesses. The tax
burden is greater for small businesses and we employ over 85% of the workforce. We need you
to help us help ourselves. I want to encourage everyone to buy locally and remember where
you spend your money. For those of you that believe in Hanukkah, Happy Hanukkah and for the
rest, Happy Holidays.
Councilmember Stroman stated, "I was there the next morning and I want to thank the Service
Department for cleaning the streets the next morning and I am sorry for your loss."
Mr. William Green spoke to Council in regards to downtown buildings. He stated, "I spoke with
someone two weeks ago that the County was going to tear down a landmark in the City of
Orangeburg. I would like to ask if there is a listing of historical buildings in the City, since there
are very few art deco buildings in Orangeburg and can a building like that be saved? This is the
building at the comer near the old Piggly Wiggly. I asked the County Administrator if this could
be incorporated into the new library as a gift shop and I was told that the building had to come
down. I just think the building should be preserved."
Mayor Pro Keitt stated, "We will talk to County Council about this and see what their plans are."
City Administrator Yow overviewed information concerning the removal of the Reversionary
Clause from the deed to Palmetto Development Group at 1170 Russell Street. He stated, "In
May of this year, Palmetto Development Group was given options to achieve the cancellation of
the Reversionary Clause. Last Friday, we received a letter that their by-laws are being amended
and in the event of dissolution, all assets would be distributed to SC State University. This is for
information only and docs require action of Council."
Councilmember Haire asked, "Where are we at, as it relates to their request?"
City Attorney Walsh stated, "The cancellation was sent to Mr. Kelly, their attorney today."
Concerning Classification Compensation Plan/Benefits Comparison, Mr. Jim Battigaglia from
The Archer Company addressed Council with comparisons to other organizations. He stated,
"The final list of survey participants and published surveys are the City of Anderson, City of
Rock IIill, City of Edisto Beach, Town of Batesburg-Leesville, City of Chester, City of
Georgetown, Beaufort-Jasper Water and Sewer Authority, Orangeburg County, Kaiser Family
Foundation, Society for Human Resource Management, World at Work and International
Page2
F oun~7iJ~Employee Benefits. There were a high level summary of Benefits Survey
Findings such as Healthcare Plans, Healthcare Premiums monthly, Deductibles monthly, Out-of
Pocket Expenses maximum, Paid Time Off, Accruals and Paid Holidays. The majority of South
Carolina respondents offer Preferred Provider Organization (PPO) and high deductible (HDHP)
health coverage through the South Carolina Public Employee Benefit Authority (PEBA). The
City of Orangeburg emphasizes 100% of employee-only premiums with smaller percentages for
dependents and family. The City's PPO deductibles are less than the South Carolina
organizations surveyed but the City ofOrangeburg's out-of-pocket maximum is greater. The
City uses a combined PTO Bank Plan and the City's PTO is conservative compared to surveyed
organizations. The City's paid holidays are conservative compared to surveyed organizations.
Benefits Survey recommendations are to consider increasing annual leave accruals as the City is
somewhat conservative, consider providing annual sick leave as Orangeburg is much more
conservative and consider increasing the number of paid holidays."
Ms. Theresa Williams, HR Officer for the City and Ms. Cheryl Lynch, HR Officer for the
Department of Public Utilities addressed Council on discussing and determining pay plan
placements (pay grade minimums and beyond), to discuss and determine timing of
implementation, discuss and µetermine increasing annual leave, discuss and determine a new
annual sick leave policy and discuss and determine increasing number of paid holidays. This
information will be taken into consideration and a recommendation will be made to Council.
Councilmember Haire asked, "Once the. pay plan is presented and the increases and
recommendations, then you can implement?"
Ms. Williams replied, "We will have to bring the recommendations back to you for approval."
Councilmember Haire asked, "When will this process be completed?"
Ms. Williams replied, "In December, we should bring you back recommendations and present
for funding and timing to bring to conclusion."
Ms. Evelyn Disher, Community of Character Executive Director, accepted the Community
Character Trait "Kindness" for the month of December, 2018.
City Administrator Yow presented the First Reading of an Ordinance relating to the Recovery of
Collection Costs as part of Delinquent Debts collected pursuant to the Setoff Debt Collection
Act. A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Councilmember Knotts, to
approve the First Reading of this Ordinance. This motion was unanimously approved.
City Administrator Yow presented a Resolution to authorize the Municipal Association of South
Carolina to act as the claimant agency for the collection debt on behalf of the City of Orangeburg
in accordance with the SetoffDebt Collection Act. A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern
Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Haire, to approve this Resolution. This motion was
unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, to cancel the
City Council meeting scheduled for Tuesday, January l, 2019. This was a 6-0-1 vote as
Councilmember Hannah abstained.
DPU Administrative Director Josh Nexsen presented a Resolution to authorize the Municipal
Association of South Carolina to act as the claimant agency for the collection debt on behalf of
the City of Orangeburg Department of Public Utilities in accordance with the Setoff Debt
Collection Act. A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, seconded by Councilmember
Haire, to approve this Resolution. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Councilmember Knotts, to enter into
an Executive Session for (1) Contractual Matter concerning Contracts for Health, Dental
Insurance and Stop Loss Insurance.
7 i
··--.,J
i _,_1
--,
I
___ j
Page3
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Stroman,!'11'J1
to Open Session.
Council returned to Open Session.
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Councilmember Knotts, g1vmg
authorization to City Administrator Yow to enter into a Contract with Optum for Specific and
Aggregate Insurance. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Stroman, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, to adjourn.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
/ptb
RESOLUTION
A RESOLUTION TO ADOPT HEALTH INSURANCE BENEFITS FOR
THE EMPLOYEES OF THE CITY OF ORANGEBURG EFFECTIVE
JANUARY 1, 2019 AND REPEALING ANY CONFLICTING RESOLUTION
OR ORDINANCE
WHEREAS, by Resolution of the Orangeburg City Council dated December 19, 2017 certain
retirement and health insurance benefits of City employees were adopted; and
WHEREAS, the City by said Resolution retained and reserved the right to review, amend or
change said benefits, with or without cause; and
WHEREAS, City Council has reviewed its present benefits and finds that for financial reasons it is
now necessary to amend and change the present health insurance benefits provided its employees
and retirees.
NOW THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED, by City Council duly assembled this it th day of
December, 2018, that subject to the City's right in its discretion to amend, change, discontinue or
abolish in whole or in part, the conditions, qualifications and requirements of all past, present and
future employees of the City of Orangeburg, including retired and disabled employees of said City
(hereinafter referred to as "employees") as of January I, 2019 to obtain health insurance benefits
from the City are set forth and shown on Exhibit A attached hereto and made a part hereof by
reference. The amended rates, benefits and conditions of eligibility as referenced therein shall be
prospective and not retroactive. Said health insurance benefits shall be continuously reviewed and
may be amended, changed, discontinued or abolished after each review.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that regardless of any prior review the health insurance benefits
of employees shall be defined, revised, reviewed, established and adopted annually by resolution of
the City of Orangeburg and its Departruent of Public Utilities.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that any amendment, change, discontinuation or abolishment
shall be effective upon adoption by City Council and notice of same after adoption shall be
provided to employees within forty-five (45) days after adoption.
The City of Orangeburg is committed to reviewing its personnel policies and procedures and its
health insurance benefits as needed. Accordingly, the policies and benefits of employees are subject
to review, amendment, change or abolishment at any time, at the discretion of City Council; thus
benefits may be increased, decreased or abolished at any time, with or without cause.
Any term, condition or limitation contained in any existing ordinance or resolution in conflict with
this Resolution is repealed in its entirety.
RESOLVED BY City Council duly assembled this{ih day of December, 2018.
ATTEST:
~~at~~ !CLERK ~
THIS IS NOT A CONTRACT
HEALTH INSURANCE BENEFITS
CALENDAR YEAR 2019
Exhibit A
The within benefits may be increased, decreased or abolished at any time, with or
without cause.
Definitions:
"Dental, Vision and Term Life", collectively and individually, is defined as the insurance benefits
provided by the City of Orangeburg and administered by BlueCross BlueShield (BCBS) of South
Carolina and Companion Life.
"Employees" are defined as all City of Orangeburg employees, including employees of the Department
of Public Utilities.
"Dependent" is defined as an individual who is an employee's spouse: Is a lawful spouse or; a former
spouse who is required to be covered by a divorce decree. Dependent is also defined as an employee's
child: Is a child under the age of 26 which includes a natural child, adopted child, foster child,
stepchild, or child for whom an employee has custody or legal guardianship unless child has other
federal or state insurance coverage. The t= "child" also includes an incapacitated dependent, a child
who is on a medically necessary leave of absence, a child of a divorced or divorcing employee who,
under a qualified medical child support order, has a right to enroll under the employer's group health
plan. The term "child" does not include the spouse of an eligible child. Under the Patient Protection
and Affordable Care Act and the Health Coverage and the Education Reconciliation Act, a child does
not include an individual who is eligible for other employer sponsored coverage if the group health
plan is grandfathered plan beginning for plan years before January 1, 2015.
"Health Insurance Benefits" are defined as medical, hospitalization and prescription drug benefits
available to active full-time employees of the City and provided by the City of Orangeburg and
administered by insurance providers under contract with the City.
"1500 HSA" plan is the 2018 Preferred Blue Plan-HDHP administered by BlueCross BlueShield of
South Carolina.
"500 PPO" plan is the 2018 Preferred Blue Plan administered by BlueCross BlueShield of South
Carolina.
"TERI" is defined as the Teacher and Employee Incentive Program administered by th.e South Carolina
Retirement System.
Active Employees
Active Full Time Employees
The City of Orangeburg (hereinafter referred to as "City'') will provide medical, hospitalization,
prescription drug, dental and vision insurance and ($15,000) t= life insurance to active full-time
employees (as defined within the Personnel Handbook) with 100% of the premiums paid by the City.
The insurance is offered through providers chosen by the City. New full time employees are eligible to
be covered at the beginning of the month following 30 days of continuous employment. Terrniuated
employees are only covered until their last day of employment. Councihnembers, City Administrator,
Manager of the Department of Public Utilities, and the City Attorney are considered active full-time
employees for purposes of qualifying for health insurance benefits.
D()!)endents of Active Full Time Employees
Dependents, as defined by th.e insurance providers, are eligible for dependent Health Insurance
Benefits, with the City contributing up to the following dollar amounts towards the premium costs and
the employee paying all additional costs and premiums, including any future increases:
$ 276.93 per month for spouse coverage for the BCBS 500 PPO plan
$ 241.00 per month for spouse coverage for the BCBS 1500 HSA plan
$ 191.81 per month for children coverage for the BCBS 500 PPO plan
$ 166.90 per month for children coverage for the BCBS 1500 HSA plan
$ 383.02 per month for family coverage for the BCBS 500 PPO plan
$ 333.26 per month for family coverage for the BCBS 1500 HSA plan
I
The above City contributions to the dependent portion of the premium are capped as of January 1,
2013.
Dependent Dental, Vision and Companion Term Life ($5,000) insurance may be obtained with the
employee paying 100% of the premium cost. Dependents of new employees are eligible to be covered
at the beginning of the month following 30 days of continuous employment of the employee. Dental ·
and Vision for dependents of terminated employees are only covered until their last day of
employment of the employee. Dependent premiums for Dental, Vision and Companion Term Life
Insurance ($5,000) are as follows:
Dental:
$ 35.00 per month for spouse coverage for the Dental plan
$ 45.00 per month for children coverage for the Dental plan
$ 81.00 per month for family coverage for the Dental plan
Vision:
$ 3.00 per month for spouse coverage for the Vision plan
$ 4.00 per month for children coverage for the Vision plan
$ 7.00 per month for family coverage for the Vision plan
Companion Term Life Insurance ($5,000):
$ 1.00 per month for any number of dependents covered under the Companion Term Life Insurance
Dependents of current active full-time employees are eligible to be added or dropped during the City's
annual enrollment period or as defined by law. All dependent coverage will be subject to the then
terms and conditions of the City's benefit package being offered to dependents and the terms and
conditions of the insurance policy or policies of the then insurance provider.
Employees who select medical coverage under the BlueCross BlueShield 1500 HSA plan will forfeit
all other benefits referred to herein, but will receive the following amounts deposited quarterly into
their Health Saving Account (hereinafter referred to as "RSA" account).
$150 per month for active full-time employee coverage only
$180 per month for active full-time employee and spouse coverage
$175 per month for active full-time employee and children coverage
$185 per month for active full-time employee and family coverage
Spouses of active full-time employees who are eligible for Health Insurance Benefits and/or Dental,
Vision and Term Life with their employer(s), regardless of coverage limits or conditions., must select
and obtain. coverage under their employer's plan or plans before they can become eligible for coverage
under any City plan which, if selected, will be secondary insurance.
Effective January 1, 2016, all employees and dependents over the age of 2 years which are covered by
one the City's Health Insurance Benefits Plans will be entitled to use the employee clinic (if
operational). All covered members who elect to use the clinic must conduct an initial health risk
assessment. There is no charge for members covered by the BCBS 500 PPO Plan. There is a required
co-pay for members covered by the BCBS 1500 HSA Plan for non-preventative services as required by
law.
Effective January 1, 2016 and thereafter; employees or any dependent of an employee covered by the
City's Health Insurance Benefits who uses tobacco products shall be subject to a surcharge of $50 per
employee per month. An employee will be subject to this surcharge for the full calendar year if they or
their dependent is a tobacco user during any part of the year. The employee is subject to repay the
employer for this surcharge if they willfully disregard this rule or fail to properly notify employer.
Effective January 1, 2017 and thereafter; plan participants over the age of 18 and covered by the City's
Health Insurance Benefits shall be required to participate in the City's wellness plan which requires the
participant to undergo an annual Health Risk Assessment administered by a provider with whom the
City contracts or the equivalent of same by participant's primary care provider, within the plan year.
Plan participants over the age of 18 who fail to undergo a Health Risk Assessment shall be charged a
$20 per month surcharge in addition to the plan premium.
Effective January 1, 2017 and thereafter; active full-time employees covered by the City's Health
Insurance Benefits shall be eligible for a City paid subsidy of $5 per month for individual monthly
dues and $10 per month for family dues participation at the Orangeburg YMCA. Employees must
agree to pay the YMCA dues through payroll deduction at the time of open enrollment and must
maintain membership for the full calendar year.
2
--
--~··
Eligibility for Post-Employment Benefits
Present Active Full Time Employees last hired prior to June 1. 1993
These employees may be eligible for the continuation of Health Insurance Benefits and Dental and
Vision insurance coverage if they meet one of the following:
a. The employee has 15 years employment with the City and is over age 65.
b. The employee has 20 years employment with the City and is ov
Text truncated. Open the original for the full document.
Source: City of Orangeburg website. First collected Oct 13, 2026.