Minutes
City of Orangeburg · Orangeburg County · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Orangeburg
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
RESOLUTION
A RESOLUTION TO ADOPT HEALTH INSURANCE BENEFITS FOR
THE EMPLOYEES OF THE CITY OF ORANGEBURG EFFECTIVE
JANUARY 1, 2017 AND REPEALING ANY CONFLICTING RESOLUTION
OR ORDINANCE
WHEREAS, by Resolution of Orangeburg City Council dated November 17, 2015 certain
retirement and health insurance benefits of City employees were adopted; and
WHEREAS, the City by said Resolution retained and reserved the right to review, amend or
change said benefits, with or without cause; and
WHEREAS, City Council has reviewed its present benefits and finds that for financial reasons it is
now necessary to amend and change the present health insurance benefits provided its employees
and retirees.
NOW THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED, by City Council duly assembled this 20th day of
December , 2016, that subject to the City's right in its discretion to amend, change, discontinue or
abolish in whole or in part, the conditions, qualifications and requirements of all past, present and
future employees of the City of Orangeburg, including retired and disabled employees of said City
(hereinafter referred to as "employees") as of January 1, 2017 to obtain health insurance benefits
from the City are set forth and shown on Exhibit A attached hereto and made a part hereof by
reference . The amended rates, benefits and conditions of eligibility as referenced therein shall be
prospective and not retroactive . Said health insurance benefits shall be continuously reviewed and
may be amended, changed, discontinued or abolished after each review.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that regardless of any prior review the health insurance benefits
of employees shall be defined, revised, reviewed, established and adopted annually by resolution of
the City of Orangeburg and its Department of Public Utilities.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that any amendment, change, discontinuation or abolishment
shall be effective upon adoption by City Council and notice of same after adoption shall be
provided to employees within forty-five (45) days after adoption.
The City of Orangeburg is committed to reviewing its personnel policies and procedures and its
health insurance benefits as needed. Accordingly, the policies and benefits of employees are subject
to review, amendment, change or abolishment at any time, at the discretion of City Council; thus
benefits may be increased, decreased or abolished at any time, with or without cause.
Any tenn , condition or limitation contained in any existing ordinance or resolution in conflict with
this Resolution is repealed in its entirety.
RESOLVED BY City Council duly assembled this 20th day of December, 2016.
MEMBERS OF COUNCIL
TIDS IS NOT A CONTRACT
HEAL TH INSURANCE BENEFITS
CALENDAR YEAR 2017
Exhibit A
The within benefits may be increased, decreased or abolished at any time, with or
without cause.
Definitions:
"Dental, Vision and Term Life", collectively and individually, is defined as the insurance benefits
provided by the City of Orangeburg and administered by BlueCross BlueShield (BCBS) of South
Carolina and Companion Life.
"Employees" are defined as all City of Orangeburg employees, including employees of the Department
of Public Utilities.
"Dependent" is defined as an individual who is an employee's spouse: Is a lawful spouse or; a former
spouse who is required to be covered by a divorce decree. Dependent is also defined as an employee's
child: Is a child under the age of 26 which includes a natural child, adopted child, foster child,
stepchild, or child for whom an employee has custody or legal guardianship unless child has other
federal or state insurance coverage. The t= "child" also includes an incapacitated dependent, a child
who is on a medically necessary leave of absence, a child of a divorced or divorcing employee who,
under a qualified medical child support order, has a right to enroll under the employer's group health
plan. The t= "child" does not include the spouse of an eligible child. Under the Patient Protection
and Affordable Care Act and the Health Coverage and the Education Reconciliation Act, a child does
not include an individual who is eligible for other employer sponsored coverage if the group health
plan is grandfathered plan beginning for plan years before January 1, 2015.
"Health Insurance Benefits" are defined as medical, vision, hospitalization and prescription drug
benefits available to active full-time employees of the City and provided by the City of Orangeburg
and administered by insurance providers under contract with the City.
"1500 HSA" plan is the 2017 Preferred Blue Plan-HDHP administered by BlueCross BlueShield of
South Carolina.
"500 PPO" plan is the 2017 Preferred Blue Plan administered by BlueCross BlueShield of South
Carolina.
"TERI" is defined as the Teacher and Employee Incentive Program administered by the South Carolina
Retirement System.
Active Employees
Active Full Time Employees
The City of Orangeburg (hereinafter referred to as "City") will provide medical, hospitalization,
prescription drug, dental and vision insurance and ($15,000) term life insurance to active full-time
employees with 100% of the premiums paid by the City. The insurance is offered through providers
chosen by the City. New employees are eligible to be covered at the beginning of the month following
30 days of continuous employment. Terminated employees are only covered until their last day of
employment. Councilmembers, City Administrator, Manager of the Department of Public Utilities,
and the City Attorney are considered active full-time employees for purposes of qualifying for health
insurance benefits.
Dependents of Active Full Time Employees
Dependents, as defined by the insurance providers, are eligible for dependent Health Insurance
Benefits, with the City contributing up to the following dollar amounts towards the premium costs and
the employee paying all additional costs and premiums, including any future increases:
$ 277.00 per month for spouse coverage for the BCBS 500 PPO plan
$ 241.00 per month for spouse coverage for the BCBS 1500 HSA plan
$ 192.00 per month for children coverage for the BCBS 500 PPO plan
$ 167.00 per month for children coverage for the BCBS 1500 HSA plan
$ 383.00 per month for family coverage for the BCBS 500 PPO plan
$ 333.00 per month for family coverage for the BCBS 1500 HSA plan
1
The above City contributions to the dependent portion of the premium are capped as of January 1,
2013.
Dependent Dental, Vision and Companion Term Life ($5,000) insurance may be obtained with the
employee paying 100% of the premium cost. Dependents of new employees are eligible to be covered
at the beginning of the month following 30 days of continuous employment of the employee. Dental
and Vision for dependents of terminated employees are only covered until their last day of
employment of the employee. Dependent premiums for Dental, Vision and Companion Term Life
Insurance ($5,000) are as follows:
Dental:
$ 29.64 per month for spouse coverage for the Dental plan
$ 3 7 .96 per month for children coverage for the Dental plan
$ 70.24 per month for family coverage for the Dental plan
Vision:
$ 3.00 per month for spouse coverage for the Vision plan
$ 4.00 per month for children coverage for the Vision plan
$ 7.00 per month for family coverage for the Vision plan
Companion Term Life Insurance ($5,000):
$ 1.00 per month for any number of dependents covered under the Companion Term Life Insurance
Dependents of current active full-time employees are eligible to be added or dropped during the City's
annual enrollment period or as defined by law. All dependent coverage will be subject to the then
terms and conditions of the City's benefit package being offered to dependents and the terms and
conditions of the insurance policy or policies of the then insurance provider.
Employees who select medical coverage under the BlueCross BlueShield 1500 HSA plan will forfeit
all other benefits referred to herein, but will receive the following amounts deposited quarterly into
their Health Saving Account (hereinafter referred to as "HSA" account).
$150 per month for active full-time employee coverage only
$180 per month for active full-time employee and spouse coverage
$175 per month for active full-time employee and children coverage
$185 per month for active full-time employee and family coverage
Spouses of active full-time employees who are eligible for Health Insurance Benefits and/or Dental,
Vision and Term Life with their employer(s), regardless of coverage limits or conditions, must select
and obtain coverage under their employer's plan or plans before they can become eligible for coverage
under any City plan which, if selected, will be secondary insurance.
Effective January 1, 2016, all employees and dependents over the age of 2 years which are covered by
one the City's Health Insurance Benefits Plans will be entitled to use the employee clinic operated by
HealthStat, Inc. All covered members who elect to use the clinic must conduct an initial health risk
assessment. There is no charge for members covered by the BCBS 500 PPO Plan. There is required
co-'pay for members covered by the BCBS 1500 HSA Plan.
Effective January l, 2016 and thereafter; employees or any dependent of an employee covered by the
City's Health Insurance Benefits who uses tobacco products shall be subject to a surcharge of $50 per
employee per month. Employee will be subject to this surcharge for th.e full calendar year if they or
their dependent is a tobacco user during any part of the year. The employee is subject to repay the
employer for this surcharge if they willfully disregard rule or fail to properly notify employer.
Effective January 1, 2017 and thereafter; Adult plan participants covered by the City's Health
Insurance Benefits shall be required to participate in the City's wellness plan which requires th.e
participant to undergo an. annual Health Risk Assessment administered by HealthStat, Inc. or the
equivalent of same by participant's primary care provider, within the first three months of the plan year
(January - March). Adult plan participants who fail to undergo this Health Risk Assessment shall be
charged a $20 per month surcharge in addition to the plan premium.
Effective January 1, 2017 and thereafter; active full-time employees covered by the City's Health
Insurance Benefits shall be eligible for a City paid subsidy of $5 per month for individual monthly
dues and $1 O per month for family dues participation at the Orangeburg YMCA. Employees must
agree to pay the YMCA dues through payroll deduction at the time of open enrollment and must
maintain membership for the full calendar year.
2
Eligibility for Post Employment Benefits
Present Active Full Time Employees last hired prior to June 1, 1993
These employees may be eligible for the continuation of Health Insurance Benefits and Dental and
Vision insurance coverage if they meet one of the following:
a. The employee has 15 years employment with the City and is over age 65.
b. The employee has 20 years employment with the City and is over age 60.
c. The employee has 25 years employment with the City.
d. The employee has 25 years employment with the City Department of Public Safety. ·
e. The employee has 28 years of service under the SC Retirement System; with at least 15
years of continuous employment with the City.
£ The employee has 25 years of service under the SC Police Retirement System; with at least
15 years of continuous employment with the City.
Present Active Full Time Employees last hired on or after June I, 1993 and before January 1, 201 O
These employees may retire with the City and be eligible for continuation of Health Insurance Benefits
and Dental and Vision if an employee meets the following condition.
a. The employee works 25 years for the City.
State of South Carolina TERI Retirement Program
Years of employment with the City while participating in the TERI program are included in employee
tenure calculation for Post Employment Benefits eligibility.
Active Full Time Employees Retired under the SC Retirement System or SC Police Retirement System
Total years of City employment of an active full-time employee who has retired under either the SC
Retirement System or the SC Police Retirement System are included in employee tenure calculation
for Post-Employment Benefits eligibility.
Retirees with Post Employment Benefits
Retiree Insurance
The City will pay the entire cost of a retired employee's Health Insurance Benefits being provided
active full-time employees of the City once the retired employee reaches the age of 60 and until the
employee reaches the age of 65. Prior to reaching the age of 60, the employee must pay th.e full
premium and cost of his or her Health Insurance Benefits being provided as an active full-time
employee of the City. Retirees of the City will be allowed to participate in Dental and Vision insurance
of the City if permitted by the insurance provider and provided the retired employee pays the full
premium. and cost of coverage.
Retirees over the age of 65 and/or their spouses over the age of 65 are eligible to receive any enhanced
medicare or medicare supplemental plan being provided by the City. The City will pay up to $100" per
month towards an HRA for the retiree to be used for insurance coverage and/or for HRA approved
medical expenses for the Retiree and /or spouse. The above City contributions are capped as of January
1, 2013. The City contribution of $100 per month ends upon the death of the retired employee,
however, the spouse may elect to remain on the enhanced Medicare or Medicare supplemental plan
being provided by the City with the spouse responsible for paying the entire cost thereof.
The Retirees under the age of 65 are also elii,rible for the continuation of Health Insurance Benefits and
Dental and Vision for dependents. The retiree will be responsible for the entire cost of the Health
Insurance Benefits dependent coverage and the entire cost of the Dental and Vision retiree and
dependent coverage. Once the retiree attains the age of 65 years, the retiree may continue Dental and
Vision coverage for both the retiree and dependents, but must pay the entire cost of any such coverage.
A Retiree must elect coverage at the time of retirement. Failure to make an election for available
retiree, spouse or dependent coverage upon retirement shall constitute a waiver and forfeiture of all
retiree Health Insurance Benefits, including Dental and Vision insurance provided by the City.
Retirees ( excluding TERI employees) returning to full time employment with the City will be required
to pay fifty (50) percent of premiums for employee coverage of medical, dental and vision insurance
regardless of age of employee or other terms previously expressed in this paragraph.
3
Spouses of Deceased Retirees
Spouses of deceased retirees, who are receiving Group PPO Health Insurance Benefits from the City at
the death of a retiree, may continue the insurance coverage then in existence, and shall continue up to
the age of 65 and shall pay the required premium while covered.
Retirees with No Post Employments Benefits
Employees hired on or after January 1, 2010
These employees upon retirement or termination will not be provided and may not continue any
benefits referred to herein, including without limitation, Health Insurance Benefits, and Dental, Vision
and Term Life.
Election to HSA Plans
Current active full-time employees who elect to be covered under a City's HSA medical insurance
coverage waive any future rights to be eligible for any benefits referred to herein, including without
limitation, Health Insurance Benefits and Dental, Vision and Tenn Life upon termination of or
retirement from employment. However, an employee may return to coverage under the standard 500
PPO plan, however all post employment benefits remain forfeited and shall not be reinstated.
Spouse & Dependents, over 65, of Active Full Time Employees, Who Would Qualify as a Dependent
Spouse and Dependents, over the age of 65, of active full-time employees are eligible for the standard
dependent 500 PPO insurance plan or the Medicare Advantage Plus plan. Spouses and dependents
shall be subject to the same restriction for spouse eligibility referred to above if coverage is available at
their place of work.
Active Full Time Employees on FMLA Leave or Long Term Disability
The City will continue to pay the monthly health and dental insurance cost of an employee who is
placed on long-term disability or Family Medical Leave for a period of three (3) months following the
last month worked. Upon expiration of three (3) month the employee has the option of continuing
health and/or dental coverage (COBRA) at his own expense for a period of 18 months or up to 29
months (if totally disabled as defined by the Social Security Administration). COBRA coverage
ceases once the employee becomes eligible for Medicare or Medicaid.
Dependent medical, dental, vision and life insurance shall remain in force on dependents for a period
of up to three (3) months starting with the month following the last month worked by the employee.
The City will continue to pay the same portion of the dependent coverage in effect while the employee
was an active full-time employee of the City. The employee will continue to pay his portion of the
premium for dependent coverage. Dependents will have the same option as an employee of continuing
coverage under COBRA after this three-month period.
The employee or dependent must make arrangements for the payment of the employee's portion of the
health insurance benefits premiums for the three-month period to be paid weekly, semi-monthly, or
monthly.
If COBRA is elected after this three-month period, employee will make full premium payments the
first of each month, payable to the City.
4
A RESOLUTION TO SUPPORT THE MUNICIPAL ASSOCIATION
2017 LEGJSLA TIVE ADVOCACY INITIATIVES
BE IT RESOLVED 1
WHEREAS,
WHEREAS,
WHEREAS,
WHEREAS,
WHEREAS,
WHEREAS,
WHEREAS,
WHEREAS,
WHEREAS,
cities and towns in South Carolina are the government closest to the
people providing the core services residents and businesses demand for
an exceptional quality of life; and,
hundreds of municipal officials from across the state collaborated to
identify challenges at the municipal level; and,
these challenges can be addressed through a comprehensive approach
that includes changes to state law, training from experts, research and
collaboration with stakeholders; and,
the Municipal Association identified five advocacy initiatives based on the
feedback from local officials including encouraging business growth and
development, providing quality services, increasing law enforcement
training, repairing roads and reducing blight and,
implementing standardized business licensing practices saves
businesses time and supports local economic growth; and,
cities and towns need dependable and consistent revenue sources to
support the efficient and effective delivery of municipal services; and,
supporting reliable funding for the Criminal Justice Academy in order to
make more training opportunities available to law enforcement officers
and increasing funding for body-worn cameras. Increased funding for
quality training will result in safer streets and communities; and,
repairing and maintaining existing roads and infrastructure is about
encouraging and supporting statewide economic development with
infrastructure that can accommodate new industry and support existing
industry; and,
dilapidated structures pose a public safety threat in municipalities of all
sizes; and,
the City of Orangeburg supports the agenda set forth by the Municipal
Association of South Carolina Board of Directors for city and town
councils to govern effectively and efficiently.
BE IT, THEREFORE, RESOLVED that the Council of the City of Orangeburg affirms on this 17th
day of January 2017, its support for the Municipal Association's 2017 advocacy initiatives for the
state's 270 cities and towns.
DONE AND RATIFIED THIS 17th DAY OF JANUARY 2017.
/J1ihfc.13fo·
1 . MAYOR .
MEMBERS OF COUNCIL
City Council Minutes
January 17, 2017
2597
Orangeburg City Council held a Public Hearing on January 17, 2017, at 7:00 P.M., in Council
Chambers with Mayor Butler presiding. The purpose of the Public Hearing was adoption of
amended Electric and Gas Rates for the Department of Public Utilities.
Mr. Wade Holmes, Electric Division and Mr. Dave Durgin, Gas Division, addressed Council.
Mr. Holm.es spoke in regards to credits on solar customers for electric and Mr. Dave Durgin
presented rates in transportation for gas utility charges. It was noted that this would not affect
any households.
Hearing no further comments, the Public Hearing was closed.
PRESENT:
Michael C. Butler, Mayor
Charles B. Barnwell
Bernard Haire
Charles W. Jernigan
Sandra P. Knotts
Richard "F. Stroman
ABSENT:
L. Zimmerman Keitt
Council entered into the regularly scheduled City Council meeting.
A motion was made by Councilmernber Stroman, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to
approve the December 20, 2016, City Council Minutes as distributed. This motion was
unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Stroman, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to
approve the December 28, 2016, Special City Council Minutes as distributed. This motion was
unanimously approved.
Mr. Jim Johnson, Scout Master and members of Boy Scout Troop #45, and Pack 90 were present
at Council. Their attendance was for citizenship in local government and it was mentioned that
a lot of their Eagle Scout projects were in the City.
Mr. William Green, 1048 Doyle Street, Orangeburg, SC addressed Council. He had several
ideas that he wanted to pass along to Council. He would like to work with the Rose Festival
Committee for a parade and to have an International Festival on the Square for all cultures. In
December he would like a Christmas Festival Downtown or in Centennial Park. Mr. Green
stated, "He has spoken with Chamber of Commerce and DORA on events."
City Administrator Yow stated "I have talked with Mr. Green and advised him to work with the
Chamber of Commerce and DORA on events."
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Councilmember Knotts, to approve a
Third Reading of an Ordinance amending Section 2-5.3 Purchasing Procedures sections f., n., s.,
and x. of the Code of Ordinances of the City of Orangeburg, SC. This motion was unanimously
approved.
Ms. Evelyn Discher, Executive Director of the Community of Character, accepted the January
2017, Character Trait Proclamation, "Enthusiasm".
2598
Page2
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Councilmember Knotts, to approve a
Resolution to support the Municipal Association 2017 Legislative Advocacy Initiatives. This
motion was unanimously approved.
There was discussion on rescheduling the time of City Council Meetings. Mayor Butler asked to
table or not, since Mayor Pro Tern Keitt was not present. Councilmember Jernigan made a
motion for City Council Meetings to remain at 7:00 P.M. and the motion received a second from
Councilmember Haire. This was a 4-2 vote as Mayor Butler and Councilmember Knotts
opposed.
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to
approve the Second Reading of an Ordinance adopting amended Electric and Gas Rates for the
Department of Public Utilities effective on March 1, 2017. This motion was unanimously
approved.
There will be a Special City Council meeting on Tuesday, January 24, 2016, at 4:00 P.M.
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to enter
into an Executive Session for a Contractual Matter concerning the Department of Public Utilities
Manager. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councihnember Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Haire, to return
to Open Session.
Council returned to Open Session.
A motion was made by Councilmember Jernigan, seconded by Councilmember Haire, to
authorize Mayor Butler to execute a contract with Warren Harley, Interim Manager for the
Department of Public Utilities. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Knotts, to
adjourn.
There being no further business the meeting was adjourned.
/p.tb
Special City Council Minutes
January 24, 2017
2599
Orangeburg City Council held a Special City Council meeting on January 24, 2017, at 4:00 P.M.,
in Council Chambers with Mayor Butler presiding.
PRESENT:
Michael C. Butler, Mayor
Charles B. Barnwell
Bernard Haire
Charles W. Jernigan
L. Zimmerman Keitt
Sandra P. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, seconded by Councilmernber Stroman, to enter
into an Executive Session for the following:
Industrial Development concerning location, expansion and provision of services to encourage
industry. A. Project Pillar, B. Project Columbus, C. Global Logistics Road Enhancements for
Orangeburg, and D. Spec Building--City/County Industrial Park. This motion was unanimously
approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Mayor Pro T em Keitt, for
Council to return to Open Session. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, seconded by Councilrnember Haire, to adjourn.
Tilis motion was unanimously approved.
TI1ere being no further business the meeting was adjourned.
Carrie W. John n
City Clerk
/ptb
A RESOLUTION TO ADOPT THE UPDATE OF ORANGEBURG
COUNTY'S NATURAL HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN FOR 2016
WHEREAS,
WHEREAS,
WHEREAS,
Lower Savannah Council of Governments, in conjunction with the
South Carolina Emergency Management Division and FEMA Region
IV, has prepared an updated Natural Hazard Mitigation Plan for
Orangeburg County; and,
an adopted and updated Natural Hazard Mitigation Plan is required in
order for Orangeburg County and its participating municipalities to be
eligible to receive Pre-Disaster Mitigation funding providing for pre
disaster mitigation planning and implementation of cost-effective
mitigation projects prior to a disaster event; and,
FEMA has approved the updated Orangeburg County Hazard
Mitigation Plan with final approval being subject to adoption by the
County and the affected communities within the County along with a
final Public Hearing;
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the Mayor and Members of City Council of
the City of Orangeburg , South Carolina, hereby adopt this updated Orangeburg County
Hazard Mitigation Plan.
PASSED BY the City Council of the City of Orangeburg, State of South Carolina, this 7th
day of February 2017.
12&-r/iJC-R4/:=
Mayor r-
•
City Council Minutes
March 7, 2017
2607
Orangeburg City Council held its regularly scheduled City Council meeting on Tuesday, March
7, 2017, at 7:00 P.M., in Council Chambers with Mayor Butler presiding.
PRESENT:
Michael C. Butler
Charles B. Barnwell
Bernard Haire
Charles W . .Jernigan
L. Zimmerman Keitt
Sandra P. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
A motion was made by Councilmember Stroman, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, to approve
the February 21, 2017, City Council Minutes as distributed. This motion was unanimously
approved.
Ms. Elaine Wright, Sunnyside Association, made an appearance before Council. She stated,
"The deadline for streets to be repaired has passed and no results have been seen."
Mayor Butler stated, "The City has done their part for matching funds and the South Carolina
Department of Transportation (SCDOT) is doing the project. Project has not progressed yet."
City Administrator Yow stated, "SCDOT is attending the March 21, 2017, City Council
Meeting. We are meeting with them tomorrow, Wednesday, March 8th• Concerning ditches, the
ones across from Malibu Apartments are theirs. If ditches are tying together state drainage, it is
their responsibility. The City cleans Sunnyside Canal.
Mr. and Mrs. Darby of Salley Street mentioned to the Mayor that the same thing applies to
sidewalks on his street also and you are welcomed to come to the meeting at 11 :00 A.M. on
Wednesday.
Mr. Harvey Elwood, 676 Buckley Street appeared before Council. He stated, "Revitalization of
Railroad Comer area has been neglected. When there is no restoration or development, we as a
community have to turn to the government. People have a role and responsibility to move these
projects forward, people have to be more concerned. The staff at my studio is young.
City needs to find young people to be on sub committees. There should be a young person to
lead the government We have to replace blighted buildings now
to make progress happen in
Orangeburg. I believe I have come back to Orangeburg to make a difference. I want to get
involved in government and if we want to see something done, we have to work together. I just
want to Railroad Comer developed. Updates are needed to provide to the public.
Councilmember Stroman stated, "I've spent forty-five years on the comer, we have plans in
place with the penny tax and we are well aware of it."
Mayor Butler stated appraisals and environmental assessments have been done on several of the
properties and that there is a process.
Ms. Evelyn Discher, Community of Character Director, accepted the March 2017, Character
Trait Proclamation, "Initiative".
Assistant City Administrator John Singh presented an overview of the Bailey Bill that can be
used toward property tax incentives for restoration of historic downtown buildings. Mr. Singh
stated this could be another tool in the toolbox, along with our business license'incentives and
2608
Page2
fai;ade grants. City Administrator Yow pointed out that the Bailey Bill tax incentive can
possibly be layered with other State and Federal incentive programs. City Staff also plans to
research the possibility of other downtown incentives for new construction or restoration of
existing buildings.
Concerning the City Election Commission, Councilmember Haire asked about the terms of the
Election Commission. He stated Council's terms are for four years and should the Election
Commission be four year terms instead of six years.
City Attorney Walsh stated, "The length of time of the terms on the Election Commission is
determined by State Statute, I believe, is six years, but will check to verify."
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to appoint
Ms. Tara Williamson to the Election Commission for a six year term expiring March 31, 2023.
There were no matters pertaining to the Department of Public Utilities.
A motion as made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Councilmember Knotts, to enter into
an Executive Session for (I) Economic Development concerning Project Pillar and Project
Columbus. This motion was unanimously approved.
There being no further business the meeting was adjourned.
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
March 21, 2017
2609
Orangeburg City Council held its regularly scheduled meeting on Tuesday, March 21, 2017, at
7 :00 P .M., in Council Chambers with Mayor Butler presiding.
PRESENT:
Michael C. Butler
Charles B. Barnwell
Bernard Haire
Charles W. Jernigan
L. Zimmerman Keitt
Sandra P. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
A motion was made by Councilmember Stroman, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, to approve
the March 7, 2017, Minutes as distributed. This motion was unanimously approved.
Mr. Berry Mattox, P. E. SCOOT, Program Manager presented an update on a TAP Grant for
Sunnyside and Salley Streets. He stated, "A TAP Grant is a Trans Alternatives Program. It is a
Federal Grant with 20% match by the City. Projects are behind. They were scoped projects last
spring. We requested surveys to be done and then Hurricane Matthew delayed it as several
forces went to that area. We are still surveying. The designer ready to go for sidewalks on
Salley and Sunnyside streets. The benches on Goff have plans for early fall then R-O-W phase
and hopeful R-O-W impacts will be minimal with construction for next fall 2018, possible early
2018 ifno R-O-W problems. We are short staffed."
Mayor Butler stated, "Please explain the process when we apply for a TAP Grant."
Mr. Mattox stated, "Unfortunately it is Federal money with more loopholes. We are tied down.
The money is available from the TAP program. Projects with available funds are 80% Federal
money and 20% City. We have to determine viability of the project to have pedestrians.
Application was awarded last year. We scoped the project last spring, developed project to move
to R-O-W and then move into construction process."
Council Member HS;ire asked, "What are some of the requirements of Federal vs State?"
Mr. Mattox answered, ''NEPA, Federal funding on a project. We have to look at social
economic impact, endangered species to be sure the impact is minirnalized and weigh
alternatives that it is a fair project and all constituents are impacted equally."
Council Member Haire asked, "Hasn't the City met its obligations as of July 2016? How long
does that take once the go-ahead is given?"
Mr. Mattox answered, ''Pretty simple, several phases, survey and R-O-W. There is a lot of
processes to go thru just like a large road process. Six month period of survey and design, then
R-O-W phase with estimates and it is unknown right now."
Council Member Haire asked, "The project will not be starting until September or October?"
Mr. Mattox answered, "Yes, R-O-W is usually one year, and ifwe have to close on any property
it could take longer."
Council Member Haire asked, "Project was slowed by Hurricane Matthew? Where are we on
Hurricane Recovery?"
Mr. Mattox answered, ''Pretty good shape, 80%, 20% claim issues."
Page2
col.QJ.ltber Haire asked, "Wouldn't we use less personnel in that area and free up more
personnel?"
Mr. Mattox answered, "We only have so many survey crews. Then our design guys will be
ready."
Councilmember Haire asked, "Is 601 and 126 still ongoing?"
Mr. Mattox answered, "Yes, that is not my project, but I can check."
Mayor Pro-Tern Keitt asked, "Are you short on employees?"
Mr. Mattox answered, "We have had a lot of turnover. Also, we have more work and
construction with the same staff."
Councilmember Barnwell asked, "Have you surveyed Sunnyside?"
Mr.Mattox answered, "Yes, we should be receiving it any day now."
Councilmember Barnwell stated, "This is frustrating because we thought we would have been
done by last September."
Councilmember Knotts asked, "The existing timeline is now not 2017, but 2018?"
Mr. Mattox answered, "Yes, hopefully we will speed it up."
Councilmember Knotts asked, "If you explore in R-O-W and no problems are found. Will that
expedite the project?"
Mr. Mattox answered, "Yes, we can finalize construction quicker."
Mayor Pro-Tern Keitt asked, "Is there a deadline on the funds?"
Mr. Mattox answered, ''No, the funds will rollover."
Mayor Butler asked, "Is there anyone from Sunnyside or Salley Street neighborhoods that would
like to speak?"
Ms. Elaine Wright with Sunnyside Community asked, "On Sunnyside, what is scheduled to be
completed?"
Mayor Butler answered, "Sidewalks and lighting with DPU."
Mr. Mattox replied, "It is a pedestrian project, there is no intent of road repair."
Ms. Wright stated, "We are tired of patchwork. It is a state owned road."
City Administrator Yow stated, "We can get the local DOT office number for you. You can
inquire and check with the District office since it is a state owned road."
Ms. Wright asked, "Is a copy of the Grant available? The road is causing damage. The drainage
has not been addressed."
Councilmember Haire stated, "The community prioritizes roads at the local level then they go to
the Columbia office."
Mr. Yow asked, "Mr. Mattox, are there any available funds in CTC for street not on the list."
Page3
A member from the community stated, "At the intersection of Ellis and Gibson, can a~/il 1
bump be installed or a caution light? It is very dangerous."
Mr. Yow stated, "It has to be approved by DOT then the City can approve. State streets have to
be approved by DOT.
A member of the community asked about dilapidated houses.
Mayor Butler explained that the City takes this seriously, and we have tom down houses. He
stated that you can contact the Public Works Department to see ifwe are already in contact with
these homeowners.
Orangeburg Department of Public Safety Chief Michael Adams addressed Council with an
overview of the ISO Public Protection Classification Survey. Chief Adams stated, "ISO provides
the information through the Public Protection Classification (PPC) program. Class 1 generally
represents superior property fire protection, and Class 10 indicates that the area's fire
suppression program doesn't meet ISO's minimum criteria. There were 1,345,500 total fires
reported during2015 in the U.S. which was up 3.7% from 2014. ThePPC evaluation process
has four key parts to include Emergency Communications Systems, Fire Department, Water
Supply and Community Risk Reduction. Toe report received from ISO states the OOPS and
Orangeburg County 911 Center has improved in its capabilities and exceeded the previous
standard. Effective June l, 2017, ODPS will move from an ISO Class 3 to an ISO Class 2 fire
department. The efforts of the OOPS and DPU, and 911 Center show a continued determination
and commitment to the citizens of Orangeburg to provide the fire protection they deserve. There
are 46,042 fire protection areas in the United States. Orangeburg ranks in the top 3%. There are
579 fire protection areas in South Carolina. Orangeburg ranks in the top 1 7%. The benefits for
Orangeburg are as follows: 1. Insurance companies use PPC information to help establish fair
premiums for fire insurance - generally offering lower premiums in communities with better
protection. 2. Statistical data on insurance losses bears out the relationship between excellent
fire protection - as measured by the PPC program - and low fire losses. 3. PPC helps
communities prepare to fight fires effectively. In summary, the benefits of ISO Classification 2
for citizens of Orangeburg are improved capabilities of Orangeburg Public Safety to mitigate fire
hazards, proven effort of the DPS, DPU and 911 Center to the citizens of Orangeburg, improved
classification rating for property insurers, and lower insurance premiums for business owners
and homeowners."
Mayor Pro Tern Keitt stated, "On behalf of the Mayor and Council, we appreciate all you and
your staff at ODPS continue to do for us."
Chief Adams reiterated ODPS's commitment to our community.
Councilmember J emigan asked, "Do all of your officers respond, not just fire?"
Chief Adams answered, "Yes, Fire Engineers and Public Safety Officers. Sworn officers
generally get there first. We had two fires today and all officers hit the street. We also have
mutual aid agreements with the County. There are several areas we are working on now as well,
'donut areas'."
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "Was it a team effort that contributed to Class 2?"
Chief Adams answered, ''Yes."
Councilmember Haire asked, "How is this communicated to the insurance industry?"
Chief Adams answered, "By fire district maps. Everyone can take advantage of the rate. ISO
enters it into the National Database."
Councilmember Haire asked, "Inside the City is the same rating?"
Chief Adams answered, ''Yes, within a 5 mile radius. Beyond 5 miles, it is a split rating 2X
which is more than 5 miles."
Department of Public Utilities Interim Manager Warren Harley addressed Council in regards to a
First Reading of an Ordinance for the adoption of new Electric Rate-Code 2J-Contract
Transmission Service for the Department of Public Utilities Effective July 1, 2017. He stated
this is an incentive rate for large industrial customers with a 20 megawatt load to perhaps locate
in the area. There are no current customers that meet the criteria. A motion was made by
Councilmember Barnwell to approve the First Reading of the Ordinance, seconded by
Councilmember Haire. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Stroman, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to
enter into an Executive Session. This motion was unanimously approved.
Council will not return to Open Session.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
/lrm
City Council Minutes
April 4, 2017
2613
Orangeburg City Council held its regularly scheduled City Council meeting on Tuesday, April 4,
2017, at 7:00 P .M., in Council Chambers with Mayor Butler presiding.
PRESENT:
Michael C. Butler
Charles B. Barnwell
Bernard Haire
Charles W. Jernigan
L. Zimmerman Keitt
Sandra P. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
A motion was made by Councilmember Stroman, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, to approve
the March 21, 2017, City Council Minutes as distributed. This motion was unanimously
approved.
Ms. Candice Roberson, DORA Executive Director, made an appearance before Council. She
presented Council DORA's 1st Quarter report and overviewed the following:
She stated "DORA is a part of Main Street South Carolina which is a non-profit organization.
A. Organization
1. 6 new Board members to serve a 3 year term starting January 2017
2. Board Workshop ·
3. Membership is up 25% compared to 2016
4. Private sector funding is up compared to 2016
B. Promotions
1. 1 ST Festival-St. Patrick's Day Festival included food vendors and live music
92 email addresses were collected.
2. 5th Annual Classic Car Show on the Square was held on April 1, 2017 11 am - 3 pm.
The presenting sponsor was Ford Tire. There were 75 participants and over 500
attended.
3. Bunny Hop Scavenger Hunt-April 3 - 12, 2017
C. Economic Development
1. Ali Weathers· is the 2017 Market Manager for the Downtown Orangeburg Farmer's
Market. The market will open May 9th at 3:30 pm in front of First Baptist Church.
2. Downtown registry includes vacant buildings.
3. 2nd Endeavor project
a. Identified building
b. Applied for Grant for funding for renovation project
D. Design - Welcome to Downtown Mural on Ford Tire building
E. Upcoming events
1. Free Street Dance on the Square Friday, May 5 6-10 PM with the band Riptide
performing. Request to approve sale of alcoholic beverages for this event.
2. Taste of the Market on June 8th to spotlight and raise funds for the Farmer's Market.
Three course meal to include alcohol if City Council approves."
Mayor Pro-Tern Keitt asked, "Do you have the price on tickets yet?"
Ms. Roberson answered, "The price point is $50."
Cowicilmember Stroman stated, "Thank you for what you are doing."
A motion was made by Councilmember Jernigan and seconded by Councilmember Keitt to allow
DORA to serve alcohol at these two events. This motion was unanimously approved.
2614
Page2
Mr. William Green, 1018 Doyle Street, Orangeburg, SC made an appearance before Council.
Mr. Green stated, "I've done some research on the internet. The character of structures being
renovated in Downtown is not being maintained. There are companies that sell at a discount for
historical purposes not modern doors and windows. I also want to update you on plans for the
International Festival for different cultures for food, talents, etc so individuals can experience
other cultures. Vendors will pay to participate and the money will be used to beautify
Orangeburg. Four other cities are to participate with artwork, food and entertainment. Claflin
University has responded that they will help."
Mayor Butler stated, "We are happy that these buildings are being renovated in downtown."
Mayor Pro-Tern Keitt stated, "Please get us the details so we will kn~w what's going on."
Ms. Evelyn Disher stated, 'We all need to talk and work together as we are working on the same
thing."
Ms. Evelyn Disher, Executive Director of Community of Character, accepted the April 2017,
Character Trait Proclamation "Virtue".
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell and seconded by Councilmember Knotts to
approve a Resolution for Fair Housing Month. This motion was unanimously approved.
Lieutenant Carl Shultz with Orangeburg Department of Public Safety overviewed the Latent
Print Technology for Council. He stated, "The Automated Finger Print Identification System
(AFIS) was purchased in 2009. A major upgrade to the system was made in November 2016.
Latents in evidence cases from 2000 to 2015 were 775 latent cards, 347 latents cards re
examined and/or searched, ODPS idents on cases 2000 to 2015 were 67, outside agency case
identified were 9. Latents examined from 2016 to 2017 cases were 255 total cases, 26 ODPS
total cases identified, 5 outside agency cases identified and North PD, SCDNR and Beaufort PD.
CODIS identifications from past 4 months were 6 identifications on cases as old as 2003. In
summary, the upgraded system has increased efficacy, 107 latent identifications and older cases
and latents to review."
A motion was made by Mayor Pro-Tern Keitt and seconded by Councilmerriber Barnwell to
enter into an Executive Session for Economic Development concerning Projects Halo and
Columbus and State Infrastructure Bank. This motion was unanimously approved.
Council will not return to Open Session.
There being no further business the meeting was adjourned.
WHEREAS,
WHEREAS,
WHEREAS,
WHEREAS,
RESOLUTION FOR FAIR HOUSING
the City of Orangeburg desires that all its citizens be afforded the
opportunity to attain a decent, safe, and sound living environment; and,
the City of Orangeburg rejects discrimination on the basis of race,
religion, color, sex, national origin, disability and/or familial status in the
sale, rental or provision of other housing services; and,
the State of South Carolina enacted the South Carolina Fair Housing Law
in 1989; and,
April is recognized nationally as Fair Housing Month.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, that the Mayor and City Council of the
City of Orangeburg, South Carolina, in Council assembled, do officially recognize April as
"Fair Housing Month"
Passed By the City Council of the City of Orangeburg, State of South Carolina, this 4th day of
April 2017.
MEMBERS OF COUNCIL
WHEREAS,
WHEREAS,
WHEREAS,
RESOLUTION
Wesley 0. Huff, faithfully served the Department of Public
Utilities of the City of Orangeburg for thirty-one years, three
months and two days with a retirement date of March 31, 2017;
and
he, through his long and faithful service contributed greatly to
the successful operation of the City of Orangeburg; and
the City Council, in recognition of the fine contribution
rendered to the City of Orangeburg, wants to inscribe on the
records its appreciation.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the Mayor and Members of
Council, in Council assembled; do officially recognize the faithful service
rendered to the City of Orangeburg in the capacities in which he served and we
take pride in commending him for a job well done.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that a copy of this Resolution, in appreciation
for his devotion of duty to the City of Orangeburg, be placed in the Minute Book
of the City in recognition of his services.
PASSED BY the City Council of the City of Orangeburg, State of South
Carolina, this 18th day of April 2017.
'',_ .. ~--, ;"
i ·--..
'·
-
, _, ................. -~-··"\.._ _.. ,,_, ,, __ _.:-·• ...... }
Members of Council
City Council Minutes
April 18, 2017
2615
Orangeburg City Council held a Public Hearing on Tuesday, April 18, 2017, at 7:00 P .M., in
Council Chambers with Mayor Butler presiding. The purpose of the Public Hearing was
consideration of an Ordinance to Adopt a New Electric Rate-Code 2J---Contract Transmission
Service for the Department of Public Utilities Effective July 1, 2017. No Comments from public
were made, and the Public Hearing was closed.
PRESENT:
Michael C. Butler, Mayor
Charles B. Barnwell
Bernard Haire
Charles W. Jernigan
L. Zimmerman Keitt
Sandra P. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
Council entered into the regularly scheduled City Council meeting.
A motion was made by Councilmember Strom~ seconded by Mayor Pro-Tern Keitt, to approve
the April 4, 2017, City Council Minutes as distributed. This motion was unanimously approved.
Mr. Wesley 0. Huff was presented a Retiree Resolution and watch by Mayor Butler, Warren
Harley, Interim DPU Manager and Joshua Nexsen, DPU Director of Administration.
Ms. Sandy Price, Marketing Director, Orangeburg County Chamber of Commerce addressed
Council to request to have a beer garden venue at the 2017 Festival of Roses. The beer garden
would be offered on Saturday, May 6th only in a select spot near the Chamber and would be
accompanied by a solo upcoming Country Western artist
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Councihnember Barnwell to
approve the request from the Orangeburg County Chamber of Commerce to have a designated
beer garden for Saturday. This motion was unanimously approved.
Councilmember Jernigan made a motion to nominate Mr. Christopher (Chris) Worley to the
vacancy on the Planning Commission expiring January, 2020, seconded by Councihnember
Stroman. The motion was unanimously approved.
Chief Michael Adams presented Council with a new two-year mutual aid agreement between
ODPS and the City of Myrtle Beach Police Department. Chief Adams explained that this is a
strong relationship where ODPS assists Myrtle Beach with Bike Week and they assist
Orangeburg with SCSU Homecoming.
Councilmember Stroman made a motion to authorize City Administrator Yow to sign the new
two-year agreement, seconded by Mayor Pro-Tern Keitt. The motion was unanimously
approved.
Mayor Butler read the Lineman Appreciation Day Proclamation and presented it to the DPU
linemen present at the meeting.
Councilmember Barnwell made a motion to approve the second reading of an Ordinance
Adopting New Electric Rate-Code 2J-Contract Transmission Service for the Department of
Public Utilities Effective on July 1, 2017, seconded by Councihnember Haire. The motion was
unanimously approved.
Page 2
2616
A motion was made by Mayor Pro-Tern Keitt , seconded by Councilmember Barnwell to enter
into an Executive Session for Economic Development concerning Project Halo and Project
Columbus, a Contractual -Legal Matter-Fire District , Legal Matter-Manager Division DPU and
Personnel Matter- DPU Manager's Position. This motion was unanimously approved.
Council will not return to open session .
There being no further business the meeting was adjourned.
Respectfully submitted ,
d filTie
/lrm
2620
City Council Minutes
May 16, 2017
Orangeburg City Council held its regularly scheduled City Council meeting on Tuesday, May
16, 2017, at 7:00 P.M., in Council Chambers with Mayor Butler presiding.
PRESENT:
Michael C. Butler
Charles B. Barnwell
Bernard Haire
Charles W. Jernigan
L. Zimmerman Keitt
Sandra P. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Stroman, to approve
the May 2, 2017, City Council Minutes as distributed. This was a 5-0-2 vote as Mayor Butler
and Councilmember Haire abstained.
Mr. Gene Gartman and Ms. Joy Roberts with the Dalton Home for Veterans, Non-Veterans, and
In-Home Care for Everyone yielded speaking at this meeting. They did not state any reason for
not speaking except that it was due to circumstances beyond their control.
Mr. Aaron Gillespie of 1664 Russell Street, Orangeburg made an appearance before Council. He
stated, "I would like Council to re-evaluate the Ordinance regarding closing businesses at 2:00
A.M. as to how it is working. My business is my life and I want to leave it to my kids. We are
in the City and are required to sell food. We cannot sell food and beer after a certain time. I have
to watch people leave and go somewhere else to get the food. How do we get everyone out in
thirty minutes? The Ordinance should be used as a tool, not a law. Over the last few weeks,
officers come by because of the Ordinance. I went to court last week for a ticket that was written
at 2.22 A.M. I want you to revisit the Ordinance. We cannot tell people what to do. Please take
my words into consideration."
Mayor Butler asked, "Do you understand that you are to close and have everyone out of your
business by 2:30 A.M.?"
Mr. Gillespie stated, "If I have family there, should I tell them to leave?"
Mayor Butler asked Chief Adams, "Does the Ordinance say who has to be out?"
Chief Adams stated, "It states stop serving at 2:00 AM and everyone has to be out of the
business by 2:30 A.M."
Mayor Butler stated, "We have to abide by the rules and we appreciate your business in the
City."
Mr. Gillespie stated, "It has not been a year yet and one business has already closed."
Mayor Butler stated, "This is for safety reasons."
Mr. Gillespie stated, "Five or six cop cars are always at my business every Friday and Saturday
night."
Mayor Pro Tern Keitt stated, "What were the hours before?"
Mr. Gillespie stated, "Stop serving liquor at 2:00 A.M and beer and wine at 3 :00 A.M."
-
L
I , __
2621
Page2
Mayor Butler stated, "Council will take this under advisement."
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, to
approve the Second Reading of a Zoning District Map Change from A-2 Residential Multi-Unit
District to O-I Office Institutional Residential District for six properties belonging to Claflin
University, located on Clark Street, TMP# 0173-10-07-001,0173-11-01-001 0173-11-01-002 . , ,
0173-11-01-003, 0173-11-01-005 and 0173-11-01-007. This motion was unanimously approved.
Mr. Harvey Elwood updated Council on the Orangeburg County Music Festival. He stated,
"This music festival will include white musicians as well for all aspects of the co=unity and
we reached out to the white media as well. We invested a lot of money and we are not a profit
organization. In December, 2016, I decided to reach out for a concert, another good Christian
event. I was able to obtain a copy of a memorandum from the Municipal Association of South
Carolina that I would like to go over four points with you. (1) Benefit to the public must be
primary or direct and not merely incidental. I am disabled and I don't .secure a dime from this
organization. (2) It is not sufficient that an undertaking bring about a remote or indirect public
benefit to categorize it as a project within the sphere of 'Public Purpose'. There will be no
charge and no admission. (3) A four part test in the analysis of whether the public purpose
doctrine is violated consists of the following determinations: (a) What is the intended ultimate
goal or benefit to the public? It is entertaimnent. (b) Are public parties or private parties the
primary beneficiaries? ( c) Is the benefit to the public speculative? ( d) What is the probability
that the public interest will be ultimately served and to what degree? I've been a good
Ambassador to the the City."
Mayor Butler stated, "We need our City to come together anytime we can and it would be a
wonderful thing"
Mayor Pro Tern Keitt stated, "I ask that we vote on an amount to be given to New Perspectives
Media Association.''
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "Have you solicited funds from other agencies?"
Mr. Elwood stated, "Orangeburg County gave $7,000.00, that's all. I have faith that we will
raise the money."
Councilmember Jernigan stated, "Why do you say you'll be fine if $7,000.00 is all you received?
What do you mean close enough? What will you cut if you don't raise enough money?"
Mr. Elwood responded, "Advertisement and entertaimnent. The Regional Medical Center has
donated $1,500.00 also."
Councilmember Stroman stated, "I support you, but there is a problem with spending tax payer's
money. DORA and the Chamber raise money for concerts, etc."
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Haire to check with
the City Administrator to see how much money can be d?nated to New Perspec~ives Media
Association. This was a 5-2 vote with Councilmembers Jermgan and Stroman opposmg.
City Attorney Walsh stated, "City Council has to decide if the event purpose is a public endeavor
and has to adopt by a motion."
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, to recognize
this event as a public purpose. This motion was unanimously approved.
2622
Page3
Councilmember Haire made a motion, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, to poll City Council
for a figure amount for the event. Tbis motion was unanimously approved. City Attorney
Walsh stated that polling Council for an amount is inappropriate, have
to be notified.
City Administrator Yow stated, "Public money will be ratified at the next meeting, which will be
June 6, 2017."
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, to hold a
Special City Council meeting on Tuesday, May 23, 2017, at 10:00 A.M. to finalize a money
amount for the event. This was a 6-1 vote with Councilmember Jernigan opposing.
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, to read the
National Public Works Week Proclamation at the Public Works breakfast being held for
employees on May 22, 2016.
There were no utility matters brought before Council.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to enter
into an Executive Session for a (1) Contractual Matter concerning Compensation Classification
Survey and (2) Economic Development conceding Project Halo and Project Columbus. This
motion was unanimously approved.
There being no further business the meeting was adjourned.
,---·./ -,/·
,-.. , ---~ --
/
/lptb
Special City Council Minutes
May 23, 2017
2623
Orangeburg City Council held a Special City Council meeting on Tuesday, May 23, 2017, at
10:00 A.M., in Council Chambers with Mayor Butler presiding.
PRESENT:
Michael C. Butler
Bernard Haire
L. Zimmerman Keitt
Sandra P. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
ABSENT:
Charles B. Barnwell
Charles W. Jernigan
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt to donate $3,500.00 for funding to New
Perspectives Media Association for the Orangeburg County Music Festival scheduled for June 3,
2017. There was no second for this motion.
A substitute motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Councilmember Stroman,
to donate $3,000.00 for funding to New Perspectives Media Association for the Orangeburg
County Music Festival scheduled for June 3, 2017. This amount will come from the 2% Fund.
This was a unanimous vote, 5-0 as Councilmembers Jernigan and Barnwell were not present at
the meeting.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Knotts, to adjourn.
This motion was unanimously approved.
There being no further business the meeting was adjourned.
City Council Minutes
June 20, 2017
2627
Orangeburg City Council held its regularly scheduled City Council meeting on Tuesday, June
20, 2017, at 7:00 P.M., in Council Chambers with Mayor Butler presiding.
PRESENT:
Michael C. Butler
Charles B. Barnwell
Bernard Haire
Charles W. Jernigan
L. Zimmerman Keitt
Sandra P. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Stroman, to
approve the June 6, 2017, City Council Minutes as distributed. This motion was unanimously
approved.
Slide shows were shown from the Department of Public Safety and the Parks and Recreation
Department on summer youth programs in the City.
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, to approve
the following appointments to the City Grievance Committee. This is a three (3) year term
expiring June, 2020. This motion was unanimously approved.
Clayton Bozard
Clatus Griddle
Albert Black
Latoya Walker
Finance
Hillcrest
Department of Public Safety (Alternate)
Public Works (Alternate)
Appointments to Hillcrest Golf Course Commission were postponed to the next City Council
Meeting.
There were no utility matters brought before Council.
City Attorney Walsh addressed Council to amend the Executive Session Agenda to add item #8
as a Legal Matter concerning the Department of Public Utilities former manager and to amend to
Return to Open Session to address a Legal Matter concerning Department of Public Utilities
former Manager. A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by
Councilmember Haire to amend the Executive Session Agenda. The motion was unanimously
approved.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to enter
into an Executive Session for Contractual Matters, (1) Option on bank building located at 1170
Russell Street, (2) Sale of real property-Old City Gym and Legal Matter concerning former
Department of Public Utilities Manager.
A motion was made by Councilrnember Jernigan, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, to return to
Open Session. This motion was unanimously approved.
City Attorney Walsh addressed Council, He stated, "As Council is aware, we are in the final
stages of negotiating a settlement with the former DPU Manager and once we reach an
Agreement, I would like for Council to authorize Mr. Harley to execute the finalized
Agreement."
2628
Page2
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell for Council to authorize Mr. Harley to execute
the final Agreement with the former DPU Maoager, seconded by Councilmember Knotts. This
motion was unaoimously approved.
Councilmember Haire made a motion that the City of Orangeburg hire Warren Harley, Interim
DPU Manager, as the DPU Manager effective immediately. This motion was seconded by
Councilmember Jernigao and unanimously approved.
Councilmember Barnwell stated, "I am disappointed that the four ( 4) individuals that were to be
interviewed did not return for a second interview. This is a Council form of government aod not
a Mayor form of government, even though I am in full support of Mr. Harley. I am disappointed
in the process."
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, to adjourn.
This motion was unaoimously approved.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
!!/~!full~ rubmht d,
Carrie W. o
City Clerk
/pfb
_j
7
BUDGET WORKSHOP MINUTES
July 12, 2017
5:00 P.M. 2629
Orangeburg City Council held a Budget Workshop Meeting on Wednesday, July 12, 2017
at 5:00 P.M., in the City Council Building.
PRESENT:
Michael C. Butler, Mayor
Charles B. Barnwell
Bernard Haire
Charles W. Jernigan
L. Zinunerrnan Keitt
Sandra P. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
John H. Yow, City Administrator
John D. Singh, Assistant City Administrator
Carrie W. Johnson, Finance Director/City Clerk
City Administrator Yow overviewed the current year budget with projection figures and
pointed out that the City would be using $1,389.245 in cash reserves to balance the
budget for Fiscal Year 2016-17. The amount of $1,000,000 of this is for SCSU
infrastructure repairs as well as storm damage repairs from Hurricane Matthew. The City
has not been reimbursed for approximately $100,000 from the hurricane and the City
would be spending $239,000 more than we would be taking in for the year.
City Administrator Yow overviewed the Enterprise Funds stating that the City will cash
flow the Airport approximately $100,000 and Hillcrest approximately $120,000. He then
overviewed the Executive Summary of the recommended budget for Fiscal Year 2017-
18. He mentioned first that after the last budget was passed, Council approved $300,000
in Department of Public Safety raises plus fringe benefits, which was approximately
$400,000 and that the City absorbed a $200,000 health insurance increase the first of the
year.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
OF
RECOMMENDED BUDGET
FISCAL YEAR2017-18
TOTAL GENERAL FUND
Revenues
Expenditures
$19,552,212
$19,552,212
*Includes all General Fund operations and capital expenditures; does not
include 2% Hospitality or 1 % County CPST.
REVENUE HIGHLIGHTS
No property tax increase; also no tax increase last two year
No business license rate increase; reconunend continuing Council implemented
Downtown business license incentive for new businesses
No conunercial sanitation rate increases unless City is notified of increase in tipping fee.
A discussion wa~ held on increasing rates possibly. This continues to be a cost effective
benefit for businesses in the City.
Page2
~ jn,Gf~Se in residential sanitation fee-will remain $13.00 monthly; this remains a
~ervice for an affordable rate $300,000 increase in DPU transfer; there was no
increase in transfer in
FY2016-17
Anticipate $400,000 increase in Fire Protection Fund either through more
equitable funding via Fire Tax District or enforced collection of contracts and penalties
(The City cannot continuing supplementing fire service outside the City ) Many persons
and businesses are taking improper advantage of the ISO Rating of 2.
$835,000 in cash reserve budgeted
$10,000 income for Forensics Lab-DPS studying options for funding. City
Administrator Yow stated the Department of Public Safety will give a presentation on the
lab and DNA certification.
Building permit fees steady
Interest income has increased slightly
Still not fully funded under Local Government Fund, approximately $100,000
underfunded
No change in Franchise Fees
Are planning increases in Parks and Recreation fees (list attached) Also, agreed to
increase intertnnent fees at cemeteries.
Also, incremental
changes in fees at Hillcrest Golf Course which does not affect
General Fund Revenues; a $1.00 increase in carts and green fees and 5% increase in
memberships. ( (List Attached)
No major Airport Grant Projects this year-are reviewing options for Entitlement
Funds carry over for next year; will still try to build road.
No storm water management fees-still not required under Federal Permit Process
(Council still wants to hold off on this item.)
Stevenson Auditorium rates remain the same
Do anticipate FEMA/State reimbursements for Hurricane Matthew--<lid not
budget as revenue line item as it will not be recurring revenue for future years
EXPENDITURE IDGHLIGHTS •
-~
Continue all existing services; recycling truck this Fiscal Year costs $160,000 tff continue
2% COLA - full time employees $170,000; 1
% equals $85,000;
-
Additional l % for Retirement System from 11.56% to 13.56% on SCRS and
14.24% to 16.24% on PORS--Goes up 2%, state is funding l % of increase; nothing built
in budget for Comp and Class Study.
Total for this increase in State Retirement is $74,000 and will continue for next several
years.
No new positions; four ( 4) positions were requested.
_ _j
7
.. ___ J
___ _j
Page3
$180,000 increase budgeted for medical and dental insurance; City remains
self-insured
2631
$670,700 for capital expense for Fiscal Year 2017-18; to be financed on three (3)
year Lease Purchase-major items include recycling truck $160,000, six (6) police
vehicles, $228,000, mowers, tractors and trucks
PAL Radio System $45,000 annually, CJIS Compliance $70,000; body cameras
maintenance $43,000
Software for Finance Department $200,000
Other operational line items held to current amounts
Building Code Enforcement continued, $100,000 for demolitions and cleanups
$53,000 Department requests moved to appropriate fund, i.e., 2% Hospitality Fund,
Cemetery Fund or Narcotics Fund
Fuel costs and tire costs stabilized
Retiree Supplemental Insurance capped at $100 monthly
$40,000 for Accommodation Tax Advisory Committee from Hospitality/
Accommodations Tax Fund; persons or groups requesting money would
apply to this group
A discussion was held on this as to how this would be handled and City Administrator
Yow stated that City Attorney Walsh would need to approve and the Committee would
bring recommendations to City Council. Funding of outside groups would follow current
state statute on Aecommodators Tax. He also stated that Keep America Beautiful was
requesting funds as well and would bring this back to Council.
City Council unanimously agreed to move forward with the budget as presented and that
the Department of Public Utilities needs to share 50/50 in the costs of SC State
University infrastructure.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
Respectfully submitted,
City of Orangeburg Parks and Recreation Fee Increase
City Resident $ 20 $ 25
Non - City Resident $ 45 $ 50
Chapel of Hope $ 10 $ 50
Centennial Park $ 100 $ 200
Cemetery Plot $ 500 $ 750
Opening and Closing
8:00am - 3:00pm Weekdays $ 320 $ 420
After 3:00pm $ 350 $ 450
Weekends/Holidays $ 400 $ 500
Weekends/Holidays (opened and closed on same day) $ 450 $ 550
Cremains $ 50 $ 150
Francis F. Fau!ling Chairman
Joseph Keitt
Lee W. Harter
Leon E. Myers
- Marion Moore
Randy Shuler
Lynnette Rhoad
Paul Bryant
Oliver W. Pough, Ill
Commission Members
City of Orangeburg
South Carolina
HILLCREST GOLF COURSE
803-S33-6030
To: John Yow, City Administrator
From:' Jeff Ruth, General Manager
Date: July 13, 2017
Mr. Yow,
Jeff Ruth, PGA
Genera! Manager
Here are the current rates and proposed rate increases for next year. The memberships
have not been raised in years and a very small increase of3% is very justifiable. I also
believe that a $1 increase in cart fees is justifiable if we are getting new carts. Greens
Fee rates have been low since 2009 and a $1 increase per 9 holes is justifiable based on
the improved conditions. ·
Student
Senior
Single
Family
Green fee 9 holes
Green fee 18 holes
Cart 9 holes
Carts 18 holes
2017
$215.00
$325.00
$490.00
$610.00
$8.00
$16.00
$8.00
$16.00
GF/Cart Mon.-Thur. $24.00
GF/Cart Fri. -Sun. $27.00
Membership
Rates
2018
$220.00
$335.00
$505.00
$630.00
$9.00
$18.00
$9.00
$18.00
$27.00
$30.00
2632
City Council Minutes
August 1, 2017
Orangeburg City Council held its regularly scheduled City Council meeting on Tuesday, August
1, 2017, at 7:00 P.M., in Council Chambers with Mayor Butler presiding.
PRESENT:
Michael C. Butler
Charles B. Barnwell
Bernard Haire
Charles W. Jernigan
L. Zimmerman Keitt
Sandra P. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to
approve the June 20, 2017, City Council Minutes, as distributed. This motion was unanimously
approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Stroman, seconded by Councilmember Knotts, to
approve the July 12, 2017, Budget Workshop Minutes, as distributed. This motion was
unanimously approved.
City Administrator Yow presented the Amended Budget Ordinance for the City of Orangeburg,
SC, for Fiscal Year beginning October 1, 2016, and ending September 30, 2017.
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to
approve the First Reading of an Ordinance amending the Budget for the City of Orangeburg, SC,
for the Fiscal Year beginning October 1, 2016, and ending September 30, 2017. This motion
was unanimously approved.
City Administrator Yow reviewed the projected use of fund balance and outlined as follows:
He stated "The City is projecting to spend $1,389,000 from the cash reserve. A million dollars
of that is for the infrastructure repairs at South Carolina State University. As Council directed,
we are sharing this expense with the Department of Public Utilities, bringing the cash reserve
down that the City would be spending in this fiscal year to $889,000. Out of the $889,000,
$500,000 of that amount would be the City's share to go towards South Carolina State
University. So it's understood that we are not spending that much of our fund balance for
operations, brining that total down to $389,000 that we will be spending outside of the assistance
to the University. The amount of $100,000 is storm recovery money from Burri.cane Matthew,
not yet collected from FEMA or the State's share. From an operational standpoint, we are
projecting to spend $289,000 of our fund balance. If we collect the balance of about $400,000
that's still outstanding from FEMA and the State relating to Hurricane Matthew, we will not
spend any money for operations. If the funds are received within sixty (60) days in the new
budget year, it can still be recorded as this year's money."
City Administrator Yow presented the Budget Ordinance for the City of Orangeburg, SC, for
Fiscal Year beginning October 1, 2017, and ending September 30, 2018.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Haire, to approve
the First Reading of an Ordinance to Raise Revenue and Adopt a Budget for the City of
Orangeburg, SC, for tl1e Fiscal Year beginning October 1, 2017, and ending September 30, 2018.
This motion was unanimously approved. (An outline of Budget Highlights is attached.)
City Administrator Yow mentioned that the City would continue to provide all current services
including residential recycling services to the citizens even though many residents are not
participating.
Page2 2633
Councilmember Haire stated, "ls there a way we could get more residents aware and increase
participation."
Mayor Pro Tern Keitt addressed Council and others letting them know that the South Carolina
State University Alumni met in Greenville, SC, this past weekend. While there the Alumni
thanked the City of Orangeburg for all of its efforts in giving to the University and help funding
various projects.
City Administrator Yow stated, "The City has not raised property taxes in three consecutive
years. Also, the City has not increased business license fees since the 1960's."
Councilmember Jernigan thanked City Administrator Yow for a job well done, but stated he felt
that taxes should have been raised for the upcoming fiscal year to stay ahead of rising costs.
Director of Public Safety Michael Adams accepted the July, 2017, Character Trait Proclamation,
"Integrity" as well as the August 2017, Character Trait Proclamation, "Curiosity."
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, to postpone
appointments to Hillcrest Golf Commission. This motion was unanimously approved.
Public Utilities Manager Warren Harley reported that there were no utility matters to bring
before Council.
Councilrnember Barnwell asked, "Mr. Yow, concerning a handout, "Moving Towards a More
Walkable Orangeburg" for Stonewall Jackson Road, Glover Road and Bayne Street. What
exactly is this?"
City Administrator Yow answered, "Mr. Barnwell, this is a Department of Environmental
Control (DHEC) funded grant. As you recall, a representative from DHEC spoke to Council and
announced that she had some funding for various local governments around the state for
pedestrian planning and healthy living. They have engaged a group, Alta Planning, to do studies
and planning in various communities across the state. That group will be in town on this day
along with representatives from DHEC, SCDOT and Lower Savannah Council of Goverrnnents
to do planning sessions. This is not a City contract. The City is not paying for this. This is
through the DHEC Grant, but it is there to receive public input from City Council."
Councilrnember Barnwell asked, "Can we amend it to include Suunyside?"
City administrator Yow answered, "You can certainly come to that meeting as that is what it is
for, public input."
Assistant City Adrni.nistrator Singh stated, "Mr. Barnwell, we wanted to let Council know of the
meetings. There will be meetings all week. We have asked different areas to have
representation. The two meetings listed on the handout are actually for public input where
something like an area of Sunnyside or 0th.er areas of concern around the City would be brought
up. Suunyside is being addressed through SCOOT with sidewalks and the enhancement
programs. This is a separate project. This will be an extension of the planning that Lower
Savannah Council of Governments did three or four years ago of a Citywide bike/pedestrian
program. This is going to "piggy back" on top of that to continue expanding. Certainly, we can
bring those issues up during this public meeting."
Councilmember Barnwell asked, "Where do we stand now?"
2634
Page3
City Assistant Yow answered, "As we discussed in the planning meetings, SCDOT is actually
coming to the next City Council meeting to bring us an update on various projects, Magnolia,
Zan Crossing, 301 Edisto Bridge. We can certainly ask them to bring an update on two sidewalk
projects."
Councilmember Knotts asked, "What are the dates of the meetings? We have received emails
from Rochelle Williams of different dates and times."
Assistant City Singh answered, "Tuesday is the 8th . There are different meetings and times
scheduled for three days next week. The 6:00 pm meetings are designated for public input."
Councihnember Jernigan asked, "Is this going to conflict with DPU's budget meeting?"
DPU Manager Harley answered, 'The DPU meeting begins at 5:30 P.M. and should not take
long."
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, seconded by Councihnember Barnwell, to enter
into an Executive Session for a Legal Matter concerning a Settlement Agreement with former
Department of Public Utilities Manager. This motion was unanimously approved.
ectfully submitted,
Connie McMicheal
Assistant City Clerk
/pfb
-
7
DPU BUDGETARY PLANNING MEETING MINUTES
SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING - JUNE 15, 2017
Orangeburg C_ity Council held a Special Department of Public Utilities 11~~ry
Planning Meeting on Thursday, June 15, 2017 at 9:00 a.m. in the Assemblyr{oo1'fi of
the DPU, 1016 Russell Street with Mayor Michael C. Butler presiding.
Mayor Butler opened the meeting by welcoming everyone to the Special City Council
Meeting at the Department of Public Utilities.
Mayor Butler gave an invocation.
PRESENT: Michael C. Butler, Mayor
L. Zimmerman Keitt, Mayor Pro Tern
Charles B. Barnwell
Bernard Haire
Charles W. Jernigan
Sandra P. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
The meeting was then turned over to Mr. Warren Harley, Manager of the Department of
Public Utilities.
Manager Harley welcomed everyone to the meeting. He informed the Mayor and
Members of Council that he will start with a brief overview. The Directors will inform you
about the projects and plans they have projected for the upcoming year. Nothing is
etched in stone. They cover several strategic areas; safety for both our employees and
citizens; efficiency and reliability. We will lead with our staff presentations and then
follow with a presentation from our consultant, Tom Sullivan. He will give you a
historical perspective on our rates and where we are and what we. can expect going
forward. The goal of this meeting is for you to hear the information; not to make any
decisions at this time. We really want you to hear the information and context in which
the DPU is currently operating, all the issues that we are dealing with and the
challenges that we will be working on to resolve as we go into the budget session in
August. Our goal is to have you give us your feedback on some of the things that we
are to discuss; if not today, if you think of things later please do not hesitate to call us or
send us an email. We can talk to you individually or as a group again.
Director Josh Nexsen gave a year to date update. The year to date overall sales is up
by 6% due to the rate increases over the past 2-3 years in water and wastewater. The
overall quantities of sales in electric are actually down due to losing some industrial
customers over the past few years. Operating and administrative expenses are slightly
up. From the administrative expenses that have gone up, primarily the health insurance
and pension expenses have increased. Our cash position is right about where we
thought it would be. We haven't overspent on any projects. The SC Retirement System
through the prior year there was some changes in regulations that made the system
accrue the entire pension deficit. The employer contribution as well as the employee
contribution has increased. Our balance sheets are right where we thought they would
be this time last year. Our largest expenses are cost of sales for purchasing power and
gas. We see those costs being relatively flat; maybe a slight increase in gas. Tom
Sullivan will talk about the SCE&G forecast going forward but we don't see it increasing
greatly. In the last few years we have actually reduced the net cost of purchasing
power to our end result customers. The biggest increases we have right now are
employee benefits, cost of labor, cost of health insurance and cost of pension.
DPU makes 100 % of its revenue through utility sale and usage. We are now going to
go through a five year analysis. This consists of the quantities we've sold over the last
five years, the rates and the number of customers and trends.
Director Wade Holmes stated that the electric division usage trends have been slightly
down over the last couple of years. The numbers of electric customers have been flat
due to seasonal customers (college students); not much change.
Director Dave Durgin stated that the gas usage is always weather dependent but we are
up this year due to our increase in our industrial distribution. We had one new customer
anOffllq-~ustomers added loads. We are coming out of one of one of the warmest
wintt!Min'6ver sixty years. We are projected to have the largest usage in the past ten
years this year. The billing margins have remained stable. Our customer trend has
remained flat. We are hoping to see an increase with the turning on of Elloree this
coming year. We are seeing more of an increase in our commercial customers than our
residential customers.
Mr. Hank Rutland stated that the water usage goes up and down. Revenues have
increased slightly due to increases in 2014 and 2016. The number of water customers
has been flat.
Director Richard Labrador stated that the wastewater trends have been relatively flat for
the last five years. As a result of our rate increases we have been able to increase the
revenues.
Director Nexsen said to sum it up the numbers across the department is relatively flat.
Mr. Nexsen stated that to give you an overview of our budget, we project our sales to be
similar to our prior year's budget. Manager Harley said that there is a possibility of a
need for seven new positions of which one is a safety coordinator. He stated that our
projections look at cost of living increases and competitive salaries for the workforce.
We have to stay ahead of the curve or we will continue to lose good people. As you
know, we are having a compensation study done. When the study comes back and if
you were able to budget a portion of it, we may be able to use that to begin
implementation of whatever recommendations comes out of the compensation study.
You might say instead of doing the 2% cost of living and merit increase we may use the
amount that has been set aside for the implementation of the compensation plan
instead.
Manager Harley stated that department wide we are looking at replacing company
trucks so we don't have inefficient vehicles that are costly to maintain and are not
equipped with the most up to date safety mechanisms.
Director Nexsen sated the SC State Infrastructure Bank contribution we discussed with
City Council is $1,000,000; there are two economic development projects which add up
together close to $19,000,000. These projects may happen and they may not happen.
The City Recreation Complex costs between water and wastewater is approximately
$600,000.
Capital Projects
Administrative - Director Josh Nexsen
Project #1: Replacement of Administration Software - Continuing Project - Director
Nexsen stated that we are looking to complete the project by August 2017. We are
hoping to implement prepaid billing, kiosks, etc.
Project #2: Economic Development Building Located in OCCIP - Canceled - This
project was canceled due to some other priorities that came up.
Project #3: 1036 Russell Street / DPU Main Office Complex - Previously Approved
Project ..:.. Bids were taken on June 1, 2017 and came back at $400,000. This project
will fix storm water issues and add additional parking. Mayor Butler asked if the building
(old Cherry Feed and Seed) was on the list for renovation. Dire_ctor Nexsen said that
that after inspection we were told the building was beyond repair so we are having 1t
torn down and additional parking will be provided.
Project #4: Operations Center Crew Quarters - The Operations building is a metal roof
building with no break room areas, two restrooms, and no training rooms. There Is a
10-15 year plan for the completion of a new building. Manager Harley stated that a
2
group came in to do some planning of the facility. We felt the most important area right
now is the crew quarters.
Electric Division - Director Wade Holmes 2637
Project #1 - 115 KV Transmission Line Extension to Highway 601 Substation #1 O
Previously Approved Project - The upgrade will make the system more reliable.
Project #2 - Rebuild - Highway 601 Substation #10 - Previously Approved Project -
This substation was built in 1968. An upgrade is needed because any future growth in
that area would be beyond the capabilities of this substation. This rebuild should be
completed by February 2018.
Project #3 - Rebuild - Goff Avenue/Claflin/SCSU Substation #17 Upgrade - Previously
Approved Project - This substation was built in 1979. It is near the end of its life cycle.
This project was put on hold but will start up again probably in March 2018.
Project #4 - Peak Shaving / Wastewater Plant Generator - Rowesville Road Substation
#20 - Previously Approved Project - This project is to add another generator for peak
shaving and as a backup for the WWTP. This project was placed on hold because of
Hurricane Matthew. We plan to start this project in March 2018. Ms. Knotts asked that
when you have to put a project on hold when you do start it will additional funds be
needed. Director Holmes answered no, just the time frame changed.
Project #5 - City of Orangeburg Street Lights Upgrade LED Lighting - Previously
Approved Project - This project will help us to upgrade our street lights along John C.
Calhoun Drive and 301 South. Those lights are roughly thirty years old. With the LED
lighting we will integrate those lights into our AMI system. We already have the lights
set up in our parking lot across the street with the automatic dimmers. Using the AMI
system it will let us know the power the light is using, what type of voltage it is running
at, and if there is a light is out.
Project #6 - Rebuild - Substation #18 (SI Group) - This substation was built in 1977-
1978. This substation is capacity prone and with the upgrade, SI Group will be able to
increase their capacity if the need arises. Mr. Jernigan asked what caused the North
Road outage two weeks ago. Director Holmes had an insulator fail on our 46K system.
Mr. Jernigan said that years ago we talked about a loop around our service area that if
one service station goes out it automatically switches everything over to another station.
Director Holmes stated that this is on our 115KV system; the 46KV system does not .
have that function but we are in the process of upgrading it so we can have that same
type of flexibility. Manager Harley stated that we have someone internally that can fly a
drone to do internal imaging so we can find out beforehand problem areas. This person
has recently become certified to perform this task. Mr. Jernigan asked when our
contract with SCE&G up? Manager Harley said in about four or five year. Mr. Jernigan
asked is we are going to consider alternate sources of energy; number one being a
different supplier than SCE&G? Consultant Tom Sullivan stated that the contract we
have with SCE&G has fixed rates. When these contracts come up for renewal we will
start negotiating with SCE&G and other parties. Mr. Jernigan said he has noticed that
on the news SCE&G said they were going solar; will this have an effect us? Director
Holmes stated that if we have a supplier that has green power credits it should not have
an effect us. Consultant Tom Sullivan said that we make money on distributing power,
not making power.
Gas Division - Director Dave Durgin
Project #1 Natural Gas Service - Town of Elloree (Special Project) - Previously
Approved Project - Director Durgin stated that this project came under budget and has
remained under budget. The project is progressing very well; we have laid about
45,000 feet of the 70,000 feet required to complete the project. We began construction
in December of last year and we do plan on being able to provide gas service this fall to
those customers.
3
Project #2 - Natural Gas Service US Highway 176 {Old State Road) {Special Project)
- Previously Approved Project - The bid came in below budget. Construction began
this past February and is on track to be completed this fiscal year.
ProjJAJ8_ Natural Gas Service - US Highway 178 iCharleston Highway) {Special
Project) - Previously Approved Project - This project is on hold because of pending
Department of Transportation projects.
Project #4 - Improvements to Natural Gas Service along Russell Street - This is a new
project We are planning. to upgrade the piping within the City by the Universities
toward Cameron. The existing pipes are old and need to be replaced. This would be a
DIMP project.
Project #5 - Improvements to Natural Gas Service along Highway 33 - This is a new
project. This project is to upgrade 10,500 feet of pipe from the 1960's era piping which
has a coating that is being phased out in the gas system.
Consultant Sullivan stated that Gas projects 1, 2 and 3 are all Special Projects that will
be paid for by customers; they are not adding costs that customers would have to pay
through rate increases; once the Special Projects are completed the surcharges to
those customers will expire. Once Projects 4 and 5 are completed the DIMP
surcharges will expire.
Water Division - Mr. Hank Rutland
Project # 1 - Advanced Metering Infrastructure AMI - Water - Previously Approved
Project - We are in the process of retrofitting a portion of our larger 1 ½ inch and above
meters and replacing our meters 1 inch and lower with AMI registers and
communication units to allow us to remotely begin reading our meters. We are now
concentrating on the most remote routes and time consuming routes for our meter
readers. This portion of the project should be completed by the end of this fiscal year.
Project #2 Ellis Avenue Booster Pump Station - Emergency Standby Generator
Replacement - Previously Approved Project - This project involved the replacement of
a 1973 vintage diesel generator being replaced with a new Natural Gas Generator. The
new generator will be delivered in the next few weeks and installed. This project will be
completed on time.
Project #3 - 1 O" Water Main Replacement along Shillings Bridge Road - This is a new
project. This project will vastly improve the distribution reliability in the Bolentown
pressure zone. It will also make it safer for our work crews by greatly reducing the
number of calls responding to water main breaks in this area. The pipe that is currently
in this area is at the end of its life cycle and does not meet the PVC piping standards of
today.
Project #4 - Upgrade of the 1954 High Service Pump Station, Engine Driven Pump
Station and Chlorine Scrubber at the Water Treatment Plant - This is a new project.
The purpose of this project is to improve and restore the reliable capacity of the finished
water pumps and be prepared for future growth. We would upgrade and rehabilitate the
1954 Station and replace the diesel driver pumps. The Scrubber we now have is at the
end of its user life. The new Scrubber will be a dry one and easier to maintain. It will
also cost half as much to main than the unit we have now.
Wastewater Division - Director Richard Labrador
Director Labrador informed the Mayor and Council that the Wastewater Division has no
new projected project for Fiscal Year 2017-2018.
Director Nexsen stated that all Capital Projects are under budget or at budget.
Manager Harley asked if there were any questions. He then invited Consultant Tom
Sullivan to give his presentation.
4
-,
Consultant Presentation
Consultant Sullivan stated that a lot of what he will be talking about will loo~fR1'.ior to
what you have seen before. We changed the electric base rate in October ~'l-lr;'it7was
a $4 million base rate increase. We had proposed increasing industrial and residential
gas rates in 2013 but that was deferred; last time we raised rates was in 2009. We
made modifications to the 3G Rate to allow for large transportation customers. Water
and Wastewater rates were changed in April of 2016. Electric usage is down this year.
Gas Usage is up because our largest customer has increased its volume. Water and
Wastewater usage is up from a fairly low level.
Consultant Sullivan would really like to focus on infrastructure. We have some
substations that were built in the 1950s and 60s that need to be upgraded; parts are not
even made for them anymore. We need to look at what the investment would be to
replace or eliminate them. The estimate we have right now for over the next ten years
is over $100 million. The past several years we spent a lot of money on water and
wastewater and not so much on electric and now we really need to focus more on
funneling more cash for replacing the aging infrastructure on the electric system.
Because of the additional projects across the divisions, we probably will need to look
into raising additional cash flow and/or possibly borrowing money. Manager Harley
sated that we wanted Council to know where we are. He knows that Council has been
very conscious about rate increases and how you deal with them. You have been very
careful not to overburden your constituents and the customers that we serve. This
demonstrates your responsible management of the utility but we wanted to give you the
full picture.
The Mayor and Council thanked the DPU for their presentations.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
Respectfully submitted:
C ~ {. 8-,11..g , t--1_, · 1
Carol E. Franklin
Executive Administrative Assistant to the Manager
Department of Public Utilities
5
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING AUGUST 8, 2017
Or~i;Jf.nJ City Council held a Special Meeting on Tuesday, August 8, 2017 at 5:30
p.m"'il"l'1M{ Assembly Room of the Department of Public Utilities, 1016 Russell Street
with Mayor Michael C. Butler presiding.
May~r Butler opened the meeting by welcoming everyone to the Special City Council
Meeting at the Department of Public Utilities.
Mayor Butler gave an invocation.
PRESENT: Michael C. Butler, Mayor
L. Zimmerman Keitt, Mayor Pro Tern
Charles B. Barnwell
Bernard Haire
Charles W. Jernigan
Sandra P. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
The meeting was then turned over to Warren T. Harley, Manager of the Department of
Public Utilities.
Budget Presentations
Manager Warren Harley to Mayor and Council
Manager Harley proceeded by thanking the Mayor and Members of Council for taking
time to attend the Special Meeting and allowing DPU to present its proposed budget for
their consideration. He said he would not say much at this point but will allow the team
to gi_ve their presentations. They will walk you through each division step-by-step and at
the end I will come back and we can have a final discussion on what we are proposing.
The meeting was then turned over to the Directors to present their capital projects.
************************************************************
ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION- OPERATIONAL AND CASH FLOW BUDGET
JOSH NEXSEN - DIRECTOR
Director Nexsen welcomed the Mayor and Council. He stated that we would start off
with the operational and cash flow budget presentation. The goals of this are to make
sure that we are continued to be one of the most respected utilities in South Carolina
and allow us to keep providing the high quality of service to our customers with just and
reasonable rates and lay a strong foundation for the future. We look at our trend
analysis; the usage, the revenues from those units charged, the rate time actually billed
and a summary of our customers. Other facts that affect those trends are weather, the
economy and economic development. We went into more of these details in our budget
workshop; these are just overviews of the trends and analysis. Electric usage is down
slight over the prior year (about 1 %). Natural Gas usage is up slightly from the prior
year primarily due to industrial customers. Water and Wastewater usage and the
number of services are flat. Department wide we are not seeing a lot of growth now.
The primary factors that are influencing our operations are increasing regulations and
demands put on our system from aging infrastructure. Some of the bright spots are
there have been several industrial projects that we have been talking to you about over
the past year or so. We look at the trend database on these sales and we get with our
rate experts and look at what our revenues are projected to do in the upcoming years.
We also take a deeper dive in some of the recurring costs in our operational budget
such as labor. We are budgeting a few additional personnel to meet the demands we
have in front of us. It also has increases for operation and maintenance. Some for
health insurance, SC Retirement System as you know, the State has increased the
amount on both the employee and employer. This also takes into account transfer to
the City and debt service costs on our debt we have currently. Purchase power which is
the main part of our budget which is our Natural Gas and Electricity is about 60-65% of
our total budget under $100,000,000 that DPU takes in each year is flat to decreasing.
This is a great point because that is a direct pass through to the customer. Natural Gas
is flat to increasing. It continues to get lower due to tracking. Treatment costs,'52fltter
and Wastewater as well as materials for all the divisions continue to increai'e slr9'ltly
more. Labor and benefits are probably the largest area we see where we could have
some room for increases. The City transfer is budgeted to increase in the incoming
year. The Electric usage is flat and decreasing. Gas is really the only area in the
company that we can expand profitably. We are landlocked with Electric and it is not
probable to expand Water and Wastewater services; they are kind of a breakeven
proposition. I do want to note that the Water and Wastewater divisions will run deficits
(a net loss) for the year without a review of the rates. Manager Harley stated that at the
end of the presentations we will talk more about that in detail and give you more options
about this. This is a summary of the Department Wide totals and is not the division
totals that are in your handout. It has total revenues of about $95,000,000; costs of
sales is the cost to purchase Natural Gas and electricity - $50,585,000; operating
expenses (all the salaries, software and maintenance supplies) - $29,251,000; other
peripheral items, interest income, gains and losses when we dispose of things, before
the transfer the net profit is about $15,500,000. Capital Contribution is FEMA
reimbursements from the 2016 Hurricane Matthew. We budgeted those in FY 2017-
2018 and may get some of that in the end of the current year or it may all fall into the
next year; we really don't know until the State begins disbursing those funds. The
transfer to the City is budgeted to increase about $300,000 per Manager Harley and Mr.
John Yow. Transfers for economic development, there are two parts to the economic
development. There are Capital Expenditures the Department and City will own after
those funds are disbursed. There are funds that are grants and partnerships with the
County and other organizations that will be discussed in the upcoming slides. In your
budget packet is a projected statement of cash flows. The first part is a summary of
operating activities of our sales and is projected to bring about $97,000,000 in total
receipts from customers. Payments to suppliers are project at $65,000,000. Payments
to employees (salaries, merit, overtime, all-in budget including the retirement system
payments which is about 13% increase) are budgeted to be $12,700,000. The net cash
provided by our operations will be right under $19,000,000. Out of that $19,000,000 for
Non-Capital Financing is the $5,400,000 transfer to the City General Fund and
$6,000,000 to be transferred to the City to be dispersed per the inter-governmental
agreements that Council executes with those partnering organizations. Capital and
Financing Activities: the capital projects for the upcoming year budgeted will be
$10,278,000; routine capital expenditures - these are things like trucks, computers,
desks and renewals and replacements for each utility. We don't know how many line
drops we are going to do or how many homes are going to be built; some of that we
base on average. We replace a number of services every year that are fully
depreciated out or need to be rebuilt. That is in that number that we can provide details
which are in your packet and broken down by type and division. Economic
Development - we plan to spend $7,700,000 on projects in the upcoming year. DPU
currently is budgeted to at the end of the current fiscal year to have approximately
$29,000,000 in cash. We do plan to draw down that cash reserve by about
$15,500,000 in the upcoming fiscal year. That should still leave us with $13 - 14 million
in cash. In the past, it would not be uncommon for the DPU to draw down cash for $2, 3
or 4 million each year in any given year depending on timing of projects and timing of
rate increases. The primary draw this year is going to be some of the capital and
transfer projects that we are going to do on the economic development front which we
could not have historically done in the past. We will still have approximately
$30,000,000 in reserve in addition to the $13,500,000 of cash in investments.
************************************************************
2
ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION PROJECTS
. JOSH NEXSEN - DIRECTOR
Dirmlf. r;exsen informed the Mayor and Council that the Administrative Division has
fivtf'Mp'fffl'I projects; three are previously approved; one of which has been cancelled
and two proposed. The first project is the Administrative Software project.
Project #1 - Replacement of Administrative Software
(Previously Approved - Continuing Project)
Total Project Cost: $11,600.000
Expenditures to Date: $ 7,620,340
Estimated 2017-2018 Cost: $ 988,000
The first phase was completed in July of 2015, the second phase was planned to go live
in the spring of 2017 but we had to add some time to that budget. It is an extremely
complicated project and we want to make sure we get it right. I want to emphasize that
it is currently under budget. We have a fixed price contract so adding time to the project
doesn't necessarily add any cost to the project. We have delayed the payments that did
not occur in FY 2016-2017 and they will occur in FY 2017-2018. The go live date is fall,
the September or October timeframe. There will be less reliance on manual processes
and it will add some new features to customers that we haven't been able to do in the
past.
Project #2 - Economic Development Building -
Orangeburg County I City Industrial Park
Total Project Cost: $ 2,600,000
Expenditures to Date: $ -0-
Estimated 2017-2018 Cost: $ - 0 -
The second project was an economic development project that was budgeted for
$2,600,000 and was planned to be in the Orangeburg County City Industrial Park has
been cancelled and we plan to reappropriate these funds to some other economic
development projects which are included in that $13,000,000 number. We thought it
would be more prudent pursue the other projects at this time.
Project #3 1036 Russell Street I DPU Main Office
Total Project Cost: $ 400,000
Expenditures to Date: $ 400,000
Estimated 2017-2018 Cost: $ - 0-
Director Nexsen stated that the third project is a proposed project that will be the
construction of a customer parking area located at 1036 Russell Street. This project
began July 17, 2017 and is making progress. They have demolished the building, have
graded the site and are starting curb work now. We were able to repave pretty much all
of Oliver Street from the City parking facility on Broughton Street back around to Cuttino
Street. Within the budget, this project saved the City about $75,000. It was a necessity
to pave Oliver Street because we are diverting a lot of traffic to turn into that parking lot.
SCOOT did not want to have head in parking because there have been numerous
backing accidents in that parking lot between the DPU property and the old Cherry's
property. This project should be completed in the next sixty (60) days. It is not going to
be a very long project by the end of this fiscal year. This project also addresses some
of the storm issues we have when it rains hard.
Project #4 350 Sprinkle Avenue/ DPU Operations Center Improvements
Total Project Cost: $ 6,000.000
Expenditures to Date: $ - O -
Estimated 2017-2018 Cost: $ 150,000
Director Nexsen stated that the fourth project is a proposed project, the planning of
construction of an Operations Crew Quarters. Current Crew Quarters our divisions are
housed in where they do all their training, where they plan all their work for the day, was
constructed in 1967 when DPU was about a third of the size it currently is. Some of the
3
divisions still have some space but there are several divisions that are packed in there
pretty tight. We have contracted with a company that has worked with SCE&G, several
of the co-ops and several other municipal utilities to do a master plan of what the site
could look like five to ten years from now. This is not necessarily in the Ol)rAl}i'l'ear
budget. The current budget does call for design and plan of a crew quarter~~~! as
some engineering and architectural work. It would have a full training room big enough
to accommodate the entire company for company meetings. It will have a kitchen that
we can serve food out of when operating during storm conditions which is a huge
challenge for us now trying to feed 150 - 250 employees plus 100 additional linemen
that are working to restore the power during storms. What you are seeing today is a
conceptual drawing, this is not the plan. It will very likely change somewhat between
now and when it gets designed.
Project #5 -1016 Russell Street/ Main Office Backup Generator
Total Project Cost: $ 600,000
Expenditures to Date: $ -0-
Estimated 2017-2018 Cost: $ 600.000
Director Nexsen stated that the fifth project is a proposed project. It is the
implementation of a 400Kw Backup Generator for the Main Office. DPU operates its
entire command and control from this building during a storm. During Hurricane
Matthew we lost commercial for 1 ½ days due to situations beyond our control; our
supplier had a large tree in an inaccessible part of the transmission line take out the
transmission line which took down the building. We were able to run off the 100 KW
Generator. All our commanding control systems are in a server room which requires a
cool temperature and the air conditioning system in there would outstrip the demands of
what the current generator can supply. The new generator could supply the entire
building during any kind of event. The new generator would be Natural Gas fired.
The summary of the total cost expenditures to date and future year expenditures is
$21,200,000 and to date we have spent $7,660,000 and in the upcoming year we have
budgeted to spend $1,738,000.
Director Nexsen asked if there were any questions. Councilmember Keitt referred to
Project #1 - the time schedule is eight month overschedule?. Director Nexsen said we
are overschedule by eight months. There are pieces that have to fall into place, one of
which is data conversion. We are trying to convert a lot of the data from the current
Orcom system and make it show up the exact same way in the Cayenta system; the two
systems are very different. Director Nexsen stated that we have a fixed price contract
so other than it taking us additional time it does not add any price of vendor charges.
************************************************************
ELETRIC DIVISION PROJECTS
WADE HOLMES - DIRECTOR
Director Wade Holmes informed the Mayor and Council that the DPU Electric Division
has six capital improvement projects we will be presenting this evening. Five have been
previously approved and one is a proposed project. All of the projects that we are
presenting are part of our overall system improvement plan. What that means is that
we are going back and doing assessments on our infrastructure and rebuilding,
replacing or upgrading aging infrastructure accordingly.
Project #1 - 115 KV Transmission Line
Extension to Koyo I Highway 601
Substation #10 - Cont'd.
Total Project Cost:
Expenditures to Date:
Estimated 2017-2018 Cost:
4
$ 1,000,000
$ 150,000
$ 850,000
Director Holmes stated that the first previously approved project is the Substation #1 0
Transmission Line upgrade which is along Highway 601 in front of Koyo. The
engineered transmission poles will be placed on the existing Right of Way. This project
will ~2(>fJ1Pleted by December 2017. He asked if there were any questions.
Cou~Mi~n,'ber Keitt asked if it an old system and if it is like putting in a new one.
Director Holmes said yes. This Substation #10 which we will talk about in the next
project is fed off the original 46Kv system which right now is almost at overload so we
will have to start moving our substation to the 115 KV Transmission Line.
Project #2 - Koyo / Highway 601
Substation #10 Rebuild - Cont'd.
Total Project Cost
Expenditures to Date:
Estimated 2017-2018 Cost:
$ 5,700,000
$ 2,900,000
$ 2,200,000
Director Holmes said that Project #2 is the actual rebuild of Substation #10 to add to the
115 KV Transmission Line project is once again part of that overall system improvement
plan. That substation itself during the winter and summer months are at 85% capacity.
· Any future growth in that 601 area would cause that substation to be overloaded and as
we know, Highway 601 is one of our fastest growing areas in the electric division
territory. The rebuild on that substation will actually provide a more reliable power
system and more capacity for future growth in that area. This substation will be
completed in March 2018. This will be put on the 115 KV system and relieve some of
the stress off of the 46 KV system. Director Holmes asked if there were any questions.
Councilmember Jernigan stated that a couple of years back we talked about the way
things were going to be set up is if a substation goes down it switches over the load to
the next one. He asked if this was part of this system. Director Holmes said yes; we
don't do it from a substation level; it is already built into our SCADA system so that we
have prebuilt switching orders already in our outage management system so that when
we do have an outage it actually starts that process of closing switches, opening
switches, isolating the down area and restoring power as fast as can be. We have that
on manual right now because of the fact that it requires a lot of coordination and with us
still rebuilding the system and improving it we do not want it to do without any human
intervention right now. With this being a 115 KV substation it goes from a 30 megawatt
up to a 50 megawatt station. We looked at the trending growth in that area and tried to
predict what it would be in another ten to fifteen years so we can still handle that. We
have the ability as we rebuild these stations to leave basing in case we ever have to
expand it for even more capacity. -
Project #3 - Goff Avenue/ Claflin University/
SC State University Substation #17 Rebuild
Total Project Cost: $
Expenditures to Date: $
Estimated 2017-2018 Cost $
800,000
- 0 -
300,000
Director Holmes said that Project #3 is also a previously approved project and is the
rebuild of Substation #17 which is on Goff Avenue near SC State University and Claflin
University. This project was put on hold because of the delays that were created
because of Hurricane Matthew. We plan to start this project around February 2018.This
project is helping to replace an old and aging infrastructure. This station was built in
1979 and it is probably near the end of its life cycle. As we rebuild the substation we
will try to utilize the same design when it was first built to make sure it is a low profile
substation and there is not too many vertical structures so that it can fit in with the
aesthetics of the campus and the surrounding area. Director Holmes asked if there
were any questions.
Project #4 Peak Shaving/ Wastewater Plant Generation
Rowesville Road Substation #20
Total Project Cost $ 2,125,000
Expenditures to Date: $ -0-
Estimated 2017-2018 Cost: $ 1,700.000
5
Director Holmes said that Project #4 is a previously approved project and is a two
megawatt substation generator for Substation #20. We have already had a two
megawatt generator there and with the addition of another two megawatts we will be
able to run the Wastewater Treatment Plant totally offline; if we lose power,f,qJJAt,at
substation the Wastewater Treatment Plant will continue to operate without atfri~'tl'es.
This project also with the four megawatts of generation saves DPU an estimated
$3,500,000 over a ten year period; SCE&G actually gives us credit for those generation
capabilities. Director Holmes asked if there were any questions.
Project #5 - City of Orangeburg Department
Of Public Utilities Street Lighting Upgrade (Phase 1)
Total Project Cost: $ 200,000
Expenditures to Date: $ 3,500
Estimated 2017-2018 Cost: $ 100,000
Director Holmes said Project #5 is also a previously approved project. With this project
we look to upgrade our high pressure sodium street lights to a more energy efficient
LED lights and structures. Also along with the LED lights we will be able to tie those
lights into our AMI infrastructure so that we will be able to remotely control those lights,
dim them, interrogate them to get data from them to see whether it is working and the
lights will be able to do some self-recording - they will be able to call in to say they are
not working, that it is cycling. Hopefully that will eliminate a lot of calls from customers
or City Council about a street light not working or a street light is dim. With this new and
improved technology we will be able to have all that data at our hands. We actually
have a pilot program actually set up for the street lights in the parking lot behind the
building and from that we can actually see the type of light, whether the light is on or off,
and actual location. That data also gives us what we call telemetry on alarms whether it
is cycling, it's a lamp failure, low current, there's a relay issue or a communication
issues. We will start at the river and travel all the way up to Five Chop Road; that is
probably 80-85 lights that will have that new LED, new poles, new structure and new
technology. The system overall street lights that we have on our system is
approximately 1,500; once we finish this first phase we estimate it will take another five
to six years to replace all the street lights. Director Holmes asked if there were any
other questions.
Project #6 - Substation #18 (SI Group) Rebuild
Total Project Cost $ 6,200,000
Expenditures to Date: $ - O -
Estimated 2017-2018 Cost: $ 200,000
Director Holmes said that Project #6 is a proposed project that once again goes along
the line of updating some aging infrastructure. This is Substation #18 that is on Cannon
Bridge Road. This substation was built in 1977 and is 40 years old. This substation
feeds one of our largest industrial loads in the Orangeburg system and is also on the 46
KV line. We would like to rebuild that substation and have it tie into the 115 KV lines
that run directly in front of it plus give the substation itself and the customers more
capacity and improved reliability. This will allow us to have the capabilities of having
redundant feed so that if it goes down we can refeed it from another location.
Director Holmes stated that the Electric Division has five previously approved projects
and one proposed project all totaling a little over $16,000,000 in total cost.
Expenditures to date are a little over $3,500,000 and in the next fiscal year we look to
spend about $5,300.000 on all six projects. He asked if there were any questions.
Director Holmes thanked the Mayor and Council for their time.
************************************************************
6
GAS DIVISION PROJECTS
DAVE DURGIN - DIRECTOR
Dira,t~,,p~e Durgin informed the Mayor and Council that the.Gas Division has three
prev,o\J~pproved projects and two new project for the upcoming fiscal year for their
approval that will help improve the safety and reliability of the gas system.
Project #1 - Natural Gas to the Town of Elloree/
Cleveland Street (Special Project) Cont'd.
Total Project Cost: $ 1,606,250
Expenditures to Date:
Estimated 2017-2018 Cost:
$ 1,166,250
$ 440,000
Director Durgin said that Project #1 is the extension to serve the town of Elloree and is a
previously approved project. Work is progressing well on this project and we expect to
be able to provide gas service this winter to the town.
Project #2 - Natural Gas Service Along
Highway 176 (Old State Road) (Special Project) Cont'd.
Total Project Cost: $ 1,958,250
Expenditures to Date: $ 1,488,250
Estimated 2017-2018 Cost: $ 470,000
Director Durgin said Project #2 is the extension of six inch steel pipe along Old State
Road to 1-95 and is a previously approved project. Work is progressing well on this
project and is expected to be completed this winter.
Project #3 - Natural Gas Service Along
Highway 178 (Charleston Highway) (Special Project) - Cont'd.
Total Project Cost: $ 590,000
Expenditures to Date: $ - O -
Estimated 2017-2018 Cost: $ - 0-
Director Durgin said Project #3 is an extension along US Hwy 178 towards Bowman
and is a previously approved project. This project has been placed on hold due to
possible SCOOT work that would conflict with the proposed design. We plan on
revisiting this project in the future.
Project #4 - Improvements to Natural Gas Service along Russell Street
Total Project Cost: $ ,500,000
Expenditures to Date: $ - 0 -
Estimated 2017-2018 Cost: $ 500,000
Director Durgin said Project #4 is a new proposed project that would replace
approximately 7,500 feet of gas pipe along Russell Street starting at Pinkney near the
University. This area has seen an increase in O&M calls and now is the time to fix it
before those costs continue to escalate. This area is part of our Distribution Integrity
Management Program ("DIMP") to address the aging infrastructure of the gas system.
Project #5 - Natural Gas Service along Hwy 33
Total Project Cost: $ 640,000
Expenditures to Date: $ - 0 -
Estimated 2017-2018 Cost: $ 640,000
Director Durgin said Project #5 is a new proposed project that will replace approximately
10,500 feet of gas pipe along Hwy 33 starting at Old Cameron Road and progressing
past the Interstate. This area too has seen in O&M calls and has been identified as part
of our Distribution Integrity Management Program ("DIMP") and we plan to address the
aging infrastructure of the gas system with this project.
Director Durgin said in summary, that the total amount budgeted for all the projects is
$5.3 million. We have spent approximately $2.65 million to date. We plan to spend
7
approximately$2.1 million in the next fiscal year with carryover amounts on the Elloree
and Old State Road projects representing retention payments to contractors. The
balance of $1.1 million for the new DIMP projects along Russell Street and Hwy 33 will
improve the safety and reliability of our gas system. Director Durgin asked if"Jw"ll. 'Vere
any questions. Councilmember Haire said that he we recently travelling tovhr-~~I6ree
and saw were pipes were being laid; there is not that much space between the actual
road and the side of the road where a car can pull off. Are they packing that as they lay
the pipe; he was wondering if a car had to go off the road would they get bogged down
in the trench that is there. Director Durgin said that pipe location is actually a very
common placement for pipes of gas, water, wastewater and telephone. Yes we do pack
the trench as we go along. We do monitor those ditch lines for settling over a period of
time and the advantage of having a contractor in the area for a long period of time is
that they can address those settling issues quickly. Councilmember Jernigan asked
what kind of commitments do we have from Elloree? Director Durgin said that we have
had a lot of interest, we've had several sign-ups, we were waiting until we got closer to
a go live date before we begin a concerted marketing effort. We expect to go live
sometime mid-November. He thanked the Mayor and Council for their time.
************************************************************
WATER DIVISION PROJECTS
ERIC ODOM - DIRECTOR
Director Odom said that the Water Division has two previously approved projects and
two proposed projects for your consideration for the upcoming fiscal year.
Project #1 - Advanced Meter
Infrastructure (AMI) - Cont'd.
Total Project Cost:
Expenditures to Date:
Estimated 2017-2018 Cost:
$ 7,450,000
$ 652,550
$ 400,000
Director Odom said that Project #1 is our Advanced Metering Infrastructure Project
(AMI). This project has somewhat evolved over time with the Water Division. To date
we have converted approximately 1,100 water meters to AMI, primarily large meters -
commercial and industrial accounts. Our intention is after this fiscal year is to
significantly scale back the installs of these AMI meters. They are very expensive for
water. The goal for the upcoming fiscal year is to replace approximately 2,600 water
meters to AMI. These meters that we are looking replace are going to be located in the
routes that are currently difficult for our meter readers to timely read and difficult for
them to get to because of some locations. By replacing the routes that we are going to
replace in the upcoming fiscal year it will streamline our meter readers or at least make
them more efficient in the meter reading routes. Once we complete this fiscal year and
change out the approximately 2,600 meters we would replace old meters as we have
done in the past routinely; those meters will be converted to AMI as we change them
out. There are several benefits to this. With the water meters they have a battery in it
and the batteries don't last forever so if we change out all of our water meters in one
year the likelihood of all of them failing in one year is a possibility. By scaling back and
changing out 1,000 or so a year as a routine part of our O&M we will be able to stay on
top of it and all of our meters won't be failing at the same time. That is the plan for this
project going forward. Director Odom asked if there were any questions.
Councilmember Knotts asked what percentage of the water meters have already been
converted to AMI. Director Odom said about five percent; it's not a lot but primarily they
are our large industrial customers; it helps us track our large customer users.
Councilmember Keitt asked when you do finish up the manual meter reading what
happens to those individuals that are reading the meters; will they be moved to some
other place? Director Odom said yes, there is no intention of getting rid of anybody -
their role will change. He stated that as Director Holmes has seen since he has
changed all the electric meters to AMI, there are different needs for technicians to go
out and troubleshoot. While these meters are a lot more efficient and streamline, meter
reading and billing are problems that do come up so we will still need people who can
8
go out and troubleshoot them. Councilmember Barnwell asked have we seen any
problems with large farms. Director Odom said we haven't, particularly here in
Orangeburg. We are fortunate that we have not been in a drought situation recently
ancl)t~~r level_ has been up due to all the rain events. There has been issued that
he 1i'as 15een hearing on well water; the levels 1n wells have been dropping due to the
large farms that are primarily over in Aiken County. The two wells that we have at the
Water Treatment Plant we have even seen some seasonal drop in it, about 50 feet
which was significant this year. There is a lot of wells going in for farming and irrigation
right now but from his understanding he does not think it is 100 percent yet but DHEC
and the State government is looking to make this area what they call a capacity use
area which will basically highly regulate ground water. It is already heavy regulated
along the coast and those regulations will migrate here now. Councilmember Jernigan
asked if the Edisto River is still our primary water source. Director Odom said yes, the
North Fork Edisto River. Councilmember Jernigan said that he knows there is talk
about cleaning it out, have you heard any talk about cleaning it out. Director Odom said
he has not heard anything; trees and things like that would not be an issue if someone
goes in and starts trying to do any dredging or something like that. Councilmember
Jernigan asked if there was anything upstream that he heard about that would create a
problem for us. Director Odom said no, Batesburg-Leesville has a wastewater plant
upstream from us and the town of Norway discharges upstream from us but they are
very low discharge numbers and their significantly far upstream. We monitor the water
quality in the river regularly and haven't seen any problems but as for the other things
that have been in the news like pesticides our sampling has indicated that we have not
found any. Mayor Butler said the County is doing a five-year study on cleaning the river
out, removing trees.
Project #2 - Ellis Avenue Booster Pump
Station Standby Generator Replacement - Completed
Total Project Cost: $ 250,000
Expenditures to Date: $ 250,000
Estimated 2017-2018 Cost: $ - 0 -
Director Odom said that Project #2 is a previously approved project. This was the old
1973 generator that was still running. It was removed and the new generator has been
installed and we are schedule to test it this week. We are waiting on the manufacturer
and the contractor to get together and give us a time. Once it passes all of our test
requirements then this project will be significantly completed. We should be online by
the end of the week. Councilmember Jernigan asked what will become of the old
generator. Director Odom said the old generator is stored in our warehouse and will
probably be cannibalized for parts for somewhere else.
Project #3 10" Water Main Replacement along Shillings Bridge Road
Total Project Cost: $ 615,000
Expenditures to Date: $ - O -
Estimated 2017-2018 Cost: $ 615,000
Director Odom said that Project #3 is a new proposed project for the upcoming fiscal
year. This is the 1 O" water main replacement along Shillings Bridge Road. Currently
there is about a two mile stretch of 10" PVC pipe that has been in the ground since
1981; it is a problem area for us. Since we started keeping records on water main
failures we have had twelve water main breaks in this two mile section alone; seven of
those b
0
reaks have occurred in the last five years. The plan is to parallel this pipe with a
new 1 O" water main that is built to today's standards. One of the primary reason for
doing this is to improve our system reliability and water quality in th_is area; we_ don't
want any contamination due to water main breaks. The other part 1s a safety issue.
Shillings Bridge Road where it crosses the North Fork Edisto River and if a_ny of you
-have been down that road there is virtually no shoulder to pull off on the side. of the
road; it is very limited when we have equipment and manpower in that area. There is a
lot of traffic on this road and it is a big safety concern. We have dealt with it for years,
we are good at traffic control but it is time to replace this line. It is a problem line that is
not going to go away and would like to get this project approv~d so _we can replace this
line and improve the safety of our employees as well. This proJect we do plan on
9
- ___ I
designing bidding and constructing in this upcoming fiscal year and hopefully have it
completed the early part of 2018.
Project #4- Upgrading of the 1954 High Service
Pump, Engine Driven Pump Station and Chlorine
Scrubber at the Water Treatment Plant
Total Project Cost: $ 2.116.000
Expenditures to Date: $ - 0 -
Estimated 2017-2018 Cost: $ 125.000
2649
Director Odom said that Project #4 is a new project for your consideration. This is the
upgrade of our 1954 High Service Pump Station, the upgrade of our diesel driven
pumps and the replacement of our chlorine gas scrubber at the Water Treatment Plant.
Our 1954 High Service Pump Station is currently not in service. These pumps have had
several changes over the years and it is time for an overhaul. There is some significant
need for having this; there are smaller pumps that we currently do not have operational
at the plant. This will improve our energy use and energy efficiency by being able to run
some smaller pumps during lower flows as opposed to running a big pump and cutting
in on and off. By running a smaller pump continuously saves a lot on our electric bills.
Some of the piping we have now is lead joint so we will be replacing it, we will be
replacing all the valves. The only thing we plan on saving is the old pumps; the old
pumps are very good pumps and we are going to send them off and have the rebuilt to
factory specifications. This will save us money. The second phase of this project is to
replace the diesel engines on our diesel engine driven pumps. The pumps also will be
sent off and rebuilt. We will replace these diesel engines will electric motors that will be
tied to our backup generator so we will still have the ability to run these in the event of
outages. It will piggyback on some of the electrical work that will have to be done to
improve the 1954 Pump Station. The last part of this project that I am presenting today
is the chlorine gas scrubber in our Water Treatment Plant. This is primarily a safety
thing, it still works fine. We are going to replace it with what they call a new dry
scrubber. It is a lot less operational cost, maintenance cost, a lot less moving parts in it
and much safer for our employees to operate as well. The primary purpose of this
which we hope is never used is if there was a chlorine gas leak at the Water Treatment
Plant this is a way to contain it, mitigate it and clean that chlorine gas out of the room so
that it is a safe environment for employees to get back into. This is definitely an
important piece of equipment we have in the plant. Director Odom asked if there were
any questions on this three-part project.
Director Odom said in summary the total expenditures for 2017-2018 fiscal year are
$1,140,000 for the Water Division. Director Odom asked if there were any questions.
He thanked the Mayor and Council for their time.
************************************************************
WASTEWATER DIVISION PROJECTS
RICHARD LABRADOR - DIRECTOR
Director Labrador informed the Mayor and Councilmembers that the Wastewater
Division has no new projects for the upcoming 2017-2018 fiscal year.
Manager Harley said that Director Labrador had brought that Wastewater Treatment
Plant project well under budget; it was initially budgeted for $27,000,000 and he came in
at $25,000,000. The Wastewater Treatment Plant has been completed.
************************************************************
Manager Harley pointed out the fact that is you look at what we have gone over and
what the team has presented there are several things to keep in mind. The team was
mindful of the costs and we took every opportunity to make sure that we were asking for
what we felt was an important need for DPU. We kept efficiency in mind; we kept safety
10
in mind; and we kept reliability in mind. If you notice, that is what we've talked about so
that is what we focused our efforts on in terms of the budget. To go to a question earlier
that the Mayor asked about positions, traditionally DPU has had on the books 205
posit~~.C:f'think it has been a strategy that as I've talked with staff to not always fund
those"'p'6~1Hons fully unless they are needed. This has been a strategy in the past and
we have not parted very much from that tradition. We have included in the budget
seven positions that were already on the book except one to be funded this upcoming
year. Two of these positions.that weren't named positions are a locator position and the
safety coordinator position. These are strategic positions; we have one locator for the
utility and with the size of Orangeburg that is a tremendous amount of work for one
locator to try and manage. The number we heard is 8,500 - 10,000 locates a year that
one person has been doing and the departments from time to time have to assist on
that when he is out or on the weekend. After talking with staff and we have been
reviewing that process to make it better we felt like it is a need to have at least one
more locator. Secondly, the other new position is the safety position that we feel is
important for DPU because of all the things that we do, the very different divisions that
we have we need someone who is on point coordinating that on a daily basis for our
staff. We do have again funding included for one lineman, one electric crew leader, two
gas operators, and one water mechanic are also part of that number. There.are again a
total of 205 on the books; we are not going to fund the other eight positions. If we ever
feel like in the upcoming year that we need to come back and address one of those
positions based on the department needs we would come back to you for that funding.
Councilmember Jernigan asked if DPU is going to possible hire how many new people
this coming year. Manager Harley said seven and that is in the funding number in your
budget notebooks. That is a safety position, locator, lineman, electric crew leader, two
gas operators and one water mechanic. Councilmember Jernigan asked if these will be
new positions. Manager Harley said the locator and the safety administrative position
are the only two new positions; the other ones are positions that are on the books but
not funded. Some communities have a tradition of either holding onto a position and not
funding it in a particular budget year and some communities do the same thing by
funding the position but putting a freeze on the hiring. It all accomplishes the same
thing; you get more money somewhere else in the budget.
The other thing that Manager Harley pointed out that Director Nexsen earlier pointed out
that the Water and Wastewater divisions will have deficits in the upcoming budget year
as the budget is currently proposed. We have been evaluating this and talking about
this on a daily basis trying to find a strategy to make sure that we give Council an option
that is keeping in mind how you have always been really conscious of how you handle
rates with your customers. You have been very responsible, you have not asked or put
on rates when they were not needed and so we kept that in mind and we wanted to
make sure that we gave you an option if you decided to do this that would be in keeping
with that thought process so what we have proposed if you want to solve the deficit
problem in the Water and Wastewater Divisions that there would be a rate increase that
would essentially amount to $1 a month for water residents in the City and also in the
Wastewater Division it would amount to $2.75 a month for City residents. Those
numbers come on the average typical bill usage for City residents. That is the total
amount you would be looking at is just a little over $3.75. That's both water and
wastewater. Councilmember Jernigan asked if that is going to completely fund the
deficit. Manager Harley said yes, that will get us out of the negative situation; it does
not put us far over it. It just helps resolve the tension in the deficit. Again, on a
combined basis we would still be among the lowest utility cost in the State. It also, if
you look back at the numbers the staff has provided for me, the numbers over the last
four years, even if you include this rate increase in your budget, you would still as a
customer be paying lower rates now than you did four years ago. This is important to
keep in mind. Again that goes to the mindful strategy you as Council has instituted in
terms of dealing with the rates increases here at DPU and I think you ought to be
applauded for that. As a staff we want to make sure that we don't bring you anything
that gets away from what you have traditionally done. This is a modest increase that
again has a customer on a total DPU bill paying lower today that what they would have
paid four years ago. Councilmember Jernigan asked when DPU anticipates the rate
increases would be in effect. Manager Harley said DPU proposes that they can be
effective either October 1, 2017 or approve it in the current budget and have it start at
11
-,
__ j
some other time in the budget such as January 2018. It would be up to you but in order
to address the deficit we have it starting October 1, 2017. Mayor Butler said we would
have an increase of $1 for City resident, what about the County residents. Manager
Harley said for the County which is outside residents it would be a $2 increas,/{~ter
and a $5 increase on wastewater; that would be just over $7 per month bas~-~~ in
mind that we do have a cost differential on In City Resident versus Outside City
Residents. Councilmember Jernigan asked if the Public Service Commission gets
involved. Manager Harley said no. He wants Council to keep in mind that even with
those increases we still remain among the lowest for rates. None of these increases
gets our utility water or wastewater to the average in the State. The Budget Control
Board puts out numbers on where we stand and we are still either at the bottom or we
moved just up above ourselves in most categories which puts us as the bottom. We are
still in most categories either the lowest or right near the lowest in all four utilities. There
is a tremendous gap between us and what the average is. Councilmember Keitt said
we think about those persons that have been eliminated from their jobs in the
Jenkinsville area that is going to have an impact on them but I know we cannot help that
but we want to really think about that. Councilmember Haire said that he looked at the
budget he is concerned about the deficit that we are having in water and wastewater
and we are going to have to address them. In order to delay it until January would be
irresponsible; we need to make each area self-supported. Councilmember Jernigan
said he thinks our citizens have always had the best quality service and the best quality
water that they can get anywhere in the State of South Carolina. We cannot jeopardize
that so he is in favor of doing what DPU is suggesting. Councilmember Stroman said
the budget notebook information stated "no rate increase" in water and wastewater.
Manager Harley said that is correct and that he should have started by saying that the
proposed budget in your notebooks does not have a proposed rate increase included.
He wanted to give you an option, it will easy for us to amend the budget by the second
reading to include the rate increase but he wanted to have the plain budget so Council
could see what the budget without a rate increase would look like and give Council an
opportunity the hear the implications of not doing rate increases. Again, we wanted to
make sure it didn't overburden our citizens and customers what we are asking for. It is
just simply to bring water and wastewater out of the deficit situation. Manager Harley
asked Council to keep in mind that Director Labrador and his team have just put on line
the new Wastewater Treatment Plant and we borrowed money for that so it is important
that we would be able to show that we were able to cover those costs. Councilmember
Stroman said that people outside the City about fifteen miles have to get their parents or
their children to sign to get water and we are losing customers. Manager Harley said
there are a couple of situations where we have had trouble signing up people.
Councilmember Stroman said that he doesn't know how we are going to do it but we
need to look at this. Manager Harley said that is a discussion we will have to discuss
with the City Attorney, Mr. Walsh. Councilmember Stroman said he is always against
rate increases. Mayor Butler and Councilmember Keitt said that we do not want to
jeopardize ourselves. Mayor Butler said we are the custodians of DPU and it shows
good management on our part. Manager Harley said DPU will do what Council
suggests. Councilmember Jernigan asked if Council would need to make a motion
regarding the rate increases. Manager Harley said that what Council would need to do
is amend the ordinance to include the rate increases for water and wastewater. We
would have it included on the second reading. Manager Harley pointed out in the
budget that if you read through the budget, the second page includes a $5.4 million
transfer to the City, a $5 million Economic Development for Project Halo, $1 million for
the SC State Infrastructure Bank projects and $500,000 for SC State Infrastructure
Improvements which the City is going to cover half of that amount per a conversation
that he and Mr. Yow had last week. Manager Harley asked if there were any questions.
He said the only thing Council would need to do is to amend the budget ordinance with
the rate increases for water and wastewater. Councilmember Haire made a motion that
Council to accept the recommendation from the DPU to amend the budget as it relates
to the rate increases for water and wastewater effective October 1, 2017 which was
second by Councilmember Knotts and unanimously approved by Council.
Councilmember Keitt made a motion to approve the first reading and adopt the
amended budget of DPU which was second by Councilmember Barnwell and
unanimously approved by Council.
12
Mayor Butler thanked the Manager and all the staff for all the hard work they have done
and explaining the budget to Council. We appreciate your due diligence to DPU and all
that you are doing to make it better for our citizens. Manager Harley said that DPU
app"9~ all that Council does and all the support that you give us which makes it
easffbt-e~ryone in this room to do their jobs; thank you very much.
A motion was made by Councilmember Keitt, second by Councilmember Knotts to
adjourn. The motion was unanimous.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
Respectfully submitted,
Carol E. Franklin
Executive Administrative Assistant to the Manager
Department of Public Utilities
13
TOTAL GENERAL FUND
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
OF
RECOMMENDED BUDGET
FISCAL YEAR2017-18
Revenues
Expenditures
$19,552,212
$19,552,212
*Includes all General Fund operations and capital expenditures; does not
include 2% Hospitality or 1 % County CPST.
REVENUE IDGHLIGHTS
No property tax increase; also no tax increase last two years
No business license rate increase; recommend continuing Council implemented
Downtown business license incentive for new businesses
No commercial sanitation rate increases unless City is notified of increase in tipping fee. A
discussion was held on increasing rates possibly. This continues to be a cost effective benefit for
businesses in the City.
No increase in residential sanitation fee-will remain$ 13.00 monthly; this remains a premium
service for an affordable rate
$300,000 increase in DPU transfer; there was no increase in transfer in
FY 2016-17
Anticipate $400,000 increase in Fire Protection Fund either through more
equitable funding via Fire Tax District or enforced collection of contracts and penalties
(The City cannot continuing supplementing fire service outside the City ) Many persons and
businesses are taking improper advantage of the ISO Rating of 2.
$835,000 in cash reserve budgeted
$10,000 income for Forensics Lab---DPS studying options for funding. City Administrator Yow
stated the Department of Public Safety will give a presentation on the lab and DNA certification.
Building permit fees steady
Interest income has increased slightly
Page2
Still not fully funded under Local Government Fund, approximately $100,000
underfunded
No change in Franchise Fees
Are planning increases in Parks and Recreation fees (list attached) Also, agreed to increase
internment fees at cemeteries.
Also, incremental changes in fees at Hillcrest Golf Course which does not affect
General Fund Revenues; a$ 1.00 increase in carts and green fees and 5% increase in
memberships. (List Attached)
No major Airport Grant Projects this year-are reviewing options for Entitlement
Funds carry over for next year; will still try to build road.
No storm water management fees-still not required under Federal Permit Process
(Council still wants to hold off on this item.)
Stevenson Auditorium rates remain the same
Do anticipate FEMA/State reimbursements for Hurricane Matthew----d:id not
budget as revenue line item as it will not be recurringrevenue for future years
EXPENDITURE HIGHLIGHTS
Continue all existing services; recycling truck this Fiscal Year costs $160,000 to continue
2% COLA- full time employees $170,000; 1 % equals $85,000;
Additional 1 % for Retirement System from 11.56% to 13 .56% on SCRS and
14.24% to 16.24% on PORS--Goes up 2%, state is funding 1 % of increase; nothing built in
budget for Comp and Class Study.
Total for this increase in State Retirement is $74,000 and will continue for next several years.
No new positions; four (4) positions were requested.
$180,000 increase budgeted for medical and dental insurance; City remains
self-insured
Page3
$670,700 for capital expense for Fiscal Year 2017-18; to be financed on three (3)
year Lease Purchase-major items include recycling truck $160,000, six (6) police
vehicles, $228,000, mowers, tractors and trucks
PAL Radio System $45,000 annually, CJIS Compliance $70,000; body cameras
maintenance $43,000
Software for Finance Department $200,000
Other operational line items held to current amounts
Building Code Enforcement continued, $100,000 for demolitions and cleanups
$53,000 Department requests moved to appropriate fund, i.e., 2% Hospitality Fund, Cemetery
Fund or Narcotics Fund
Fuel costs and tire costs stabilized
Retiree Supplemental Insurance capped at $100 monthly
$40,000 for Accommodation Tax Advisory Committee from Hospitality/
Accommodations Tax Fund; persons or groups requesting money would
apply to this group
A discussion was held on this as to how this would be handled and City Administrator Yow
stated that City Attorney Walsh would need to approve and the Committee would bring
recommendations to City Council. Funding of outside groups would follow current state statute
on Accommodators Tax. He also stated that Keep America Beautiful was requesting funds as
well and would bring this back to Council.
City of Orangeburg Parks and Recreation Fee Increase
City Resident $ 20 $ 25
Non • City Resident $ 45 $ 50
Chapel of Hope $ 10 $ 50
Cenntinial Park $ 100 $ 200
Cementary Plot $ 500 $ 750
Opeaning and Closing
8:00am - 3:00pm Weekdays $ 320 $ 420
After 3:00pm $ 350 $ 450 ·
Weekends/Holidays $ 400 $ 500
Weekends/Holidays (opened and closed on same day) $ 450 $ 550
Cremains $ 50 $ 150
Francis F, Faulling Chairman
Joseph Keitt
Lee W. Harter
Leon E Myers
Marton Moore
Randy Shuler
Lynnette Rhoad
Paul Bryant
Oliver W. Pough, !JJ
Commission Members
City of Orangeburg
South Carolina
HILLCREST GOLF COURSE
803-533-6030
To: John Yow, City Administrator
From: Jeff Ruth, General Manager
Date: July 13, 2017
Mr. Yow,
Jeff Ruth, PGA
General Manager
Here are the current rates and propos,ed rate increases for next year. The memberships
have not been raised in years and a very small increase of 3 % is very justifiable. I also
believe that a $1 increase in cart fees is justifiable if we are getting new carts. Greens
Fee rates have been low since 2009 and a $1 increase per 9 holes is ju~tifiable based on
the improved conditions.
Student
Senior
Single
Family
Green fee 9 holes
Green fee 18 holes
Cart 9 holes
Carts I 8 holes
2017
$215.00
$325.00
$490.00
$610.00
$8.00
$16.00
$8.00
$16.00
GF/Cart Mon.-Thur. $24.00
GF/Cart Fri. ~Sun. $27.00
Membership
Rates
2018
$220.00
$335.00
$505.00
$630.00
$9.00
$18.00
$9.00
$18.00
$27.00
$30.00
City Council Minutes
August 15, 2017
2653
Orangeburg City Council held a Public Hearing on Tuesday, August 15,2017, at 7:00 P.M., in
Council Chambers with Mayor Butler presiding. The purpose of the Hearing was consideration
of an Ordinance to Raise Revenue and Adopt a Budget for the City of Orangeburg, SC, for the
Fiscal Year beginning October 1, 2017 and ending September 30, 2018.
Hearing no comments, the Public Hearing was closed.
PRESENT:
Michael C. Butler
Charles B. Barnwell
Bernard Haire
L. Zimmerman Keitt
Sandra P. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
ABSENT:
Charles W. Jernigan
Council entered into the regularly scheduled City Council Meeting.
City Attorney Walsh added item number IO to the Agenda, Executive Session for a Legal Matter
concerning former Department of Public Utilities Manager.
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Haire, to amend
the Agenda to include an Executive Session for a Legal Matter concerning the former
Department of Public Utilities Manager. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Ilaire, to approve
the August !, 2017, City Council Minutes as distributed. This motion was unanimously
approved.
Mayor Butler and City Administrator Yow presented Durwood Bowden a Retiree Resolution and
gold watch for his twenty years, eight months and sixteen days of service as the Public Works
Director.
Mr. Adam Humphries of the South Carolina Department of Transportation (SCDOT) addressed
Council on the Project updates in and around Orangeburg.
Mr. Humphries overviewed project updates in the area. He stated the US 310/SC 33 (John
Calhoun Blvd./Russell Street) Intersection project is currently in the preliminary Engineering
Phase of project development. SCDOT has secured the services of Parrish and Partners to do the
bridge design and environmental docun1entation for the project. Proposed redesign will
eliminate realignment of SC 33 and add a free-flow right turn movement onto US 301 as an
acceleration lane extending across the bridge. Redesign will also include replacing the US 301
bridge over North Edisto River and the overflow bridge. The current schedule is Right-of-Way
Phase Quarter 4, 2019 and Construction Phase Quarter 4, 2020.
City Administrator Yow asked that the City be included in this project for pedestrian connections
under the Edisto River Bridge to connect both sides of the Gardens and SCDOT agreed.
PaJp54
Mr. Humphries addressed the US 601/S-199 (Magnolia Street/Zan Street) Intersection and
Railroad Realignment at Claflin University. Intersection realignment across Norfolk Southern
Railway is to improve the safety and operational capacity of the roadway/railway network at
multiple intersections and railroad.crossings for vehicular and pedestrian ,traffic. The Right-of
Way Phase is currently finalizing, with eleven of twenty-two tracts secured. SCDOT anticipates
all the right of way secured by September, 2017. There will be twelve to eighteen months of
construction. City of Orangeburg TAP Project includes pedestrian improvements along the
following routes. Sunnyside Street is to be resurfaced from Cemetery Street to Gibson Street as
a part of a resurfacing project. Also, there will be drainage .and sidewalk improvements in the
area of the canal and repairs. From Salley Street to Glover Street to Fletcher Street, we recently
received additional surveys to investigate connecting sidewalks to the nearby park OI) Fletcher
Streeet. This schedule is currently being finalized based on an expanded scope. On Goff
A venue, we are finalizing bench locations with the City to proceed with an Improvement Plan. A
future project is US 21/US 178 Bypass (Chestnut Street) Corridor Project, from US 21
Business/US 601 (Magnolia Street) to SC 33 (Russell Street). Pedestrian improvements will
include the following: (1) Installing/Rehabbing sidewalk along corridor from Magnolia Street to
Russell Street, (2) Retrofitting stairs to the south-west column of the SC State University
pedestrian bridge, (3) Installing planted medians and decorative barrier fencing along the
corridor. Another future project is SC 33 (Russell Street) Corridor Project from US 21/US 178
Bypass (Chestnut Street) to S-1849 (Sylvan Avenue, NE) to include the following: (1) provide
bicycle/pedestrian accommodations along corridor to include possible restriping of curb and
gutter to include bike lanes, (2) include four foot paved shoulders to Sylvan Avenue, (3) scope
currently being finalized and (4) the current schedule is Right of Way .in Fiscal Year 2019 and
construction in Fiscal Year 2020.
Ms. Candice Roberson, DORA Executive Director updated Council on DORA's activities oflast
quarter. She overviewed the following activities, which took place downtown or were hosted by
DORA:
l. May 2017, Festival of Roses Street Dance, band was Riptide, two downtown food vendors,
and attended by a large crowd
2. May 9, 2017, Farmers Market started on Tuesdays of each week
3. June 2017, Taste of Market, Farm to Table Dinner, 170 people attended
4. Obtained 2017 Main Street Accreditation
5. Tea Thyme at 1122 Church Street opened a courtyard
6. DORA assisting with an Eclipse Party on August 2lstfrom 11:00 A.M. to 4:00 P.M. at SCSU
7. September 30, 2017, Upcoming Garden City Music Festival to include food vendors and
food trucks
8. October 22, 2017, Taste of Orangeburg as well as Talent of Orangeburg and the youth
will be performing
9. DORA will highlight a Shop Local Campaign at Christmas and sponsor the Christmas
Program at Stevenson and The Messiah at Stevenson Auditorium
Ms. Roberson asked Council for permission to sell alcoholic beverages at the Garden City Music
Festival on Saturday, September 30, 2017.
Councilmember Haire made a motion, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, to allow DORA to sell
alcohol beverages on the Square for the Garden City Music Festival. This motion was
unanimously approved.
-
Page3 2655
Ms. Martha Ford of 506 Azalea Drive and Mr. and Mrs. Edward (Carrie) Lewis of 494 Azalea
Drive addressed Council concerning drainage and erosion issues on their property on Azalea
Street.
Mr. Edward Lewis spoke. "We have had problems with this ditch for quite some time." (He
passed out pictures to Council) He began to go through the pictures and explain where trees
were and were not and sewage pipes exposed and what happens when it rains. Also, on page 14
of the handout, Mr. G.W. Berry installed a pipe that helped, but did not fix the problem."
Mayor Butler stated, "We have begun to pull the necessary people together and the SCDOT
Commissioner and we will do what we can to help resolve this problem".
Councilmembcr Barnwell stated, "I asked Mr. Kevin Gantt of the SC Department of
Transportation to meet me there today and he did not show."
Mr. Roger Brant, Service Department Director, addressed Council and stated "I called Michelle
Lambright with SCDOT and she has tried to call Mr. Edward Lewis. The number she was given
is wrong and she had been trying to reach him in reference to this issue. Mr. Yow asked me to
check on this a few weeks ago and I know that they are working on it."
Councilmember Haire made a motion, seconded by Councilmember Knotts, to approve the
Second reading of an Ordinance amending the Budget for the City of Orangeburg, SC, for the
Fiscal Year beginning October 1, 2016, and ending September 30, 2017. This motion was
unanimously approved.
A motion as made by Mayor Pro T em Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Haire, to approve the
Second Reading of an Ordinance to Raise Revenue and adopt a Budget for the City of
Orangeburg, SC, for the Fiscal Year beginning October 1, 2017, and ending September 30. 2018.
This motion was unanimously approved.
Concerning tl1e Hillcrest Golf Commission Members, Councilmcmber Haire made a motion to
vote on each nominee separately, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt. This motion was
unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, to approve
Randy Shuler to serve another three year term on the Hillcrest Golf Commission, expiring July
2020. This motion was mianimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, to approve
Lee Harter to serve another three year term on the Hillcrest Golf Commission, expiring July
2020. This motion was 1mmlimously approved.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tem Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Haire, to approve
Lynette Rhoad to serve anotlier three year term on tlie Hillcrest Golf Commission, expiring July
2020. This motion was mianimously approved.
Councilmember Haire nominated Lamont Green of 1198 Schley Street to serve on tlie Hillcrest
golf Comnussion. He is an SCSU graduate and played football and is in the pharmaceutical
field.
Page1656
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, to approve
Lamont Green to serve a three year term on the Hillcrest Golf Commission, expiring July 2020.
This motion was unanimously approved.
Mayor Pro Tern Keitt withdrew her nomination of Rodney Hudson to serve on the Hillcrest Golf.
Commission.
There were no new business items brought before Council.
There were no Department of Public Utilities matters brought before Council.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to enter
into an Executive Session for a Legal Matter concerning Settlement Agreement with former
Department of Public Utilities Manager.
There being no further business the meeting was adjourned.
/pfb
J
WHEREAS,
WHEREAS,
WHEREAS,
WHEREAS,
WHEREAS,
RESOLUTION
this Resolution is made in regard to the submission of an application for
Hometown Economic Development Grant funds to the Municipal
Association of South Carolina on or before September 29, 2017; and,
the City of Orangeburg hereby commits to provide a local cash/in-kind
match of at least $3,750; and,
which is the minimnm 15-percent local match required by the Municipal
Association of South Carolina; and, ·
to support the City of Orangeburg application for a $25,000 Hometown
Economic Development Grant; and,
these grant and local matching funds will be used for a partnership
Endeavor Project with the Downtown Orangeburg Revitalization
Association (DORA) to improve a downtown building space for a new
business.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, that the Mayor and City Council of the
City of Orangeburg, South Carolina, in Council assembled on this 19th day of September 2017
committing the City of Orangeburg to providing a local match for a Municipal Association of
South Carolina Hometown Economic Development Grant.
Passed by the City Council of the City of Orangeburg, State of South Carolina, this 19th day of
September 2017.
MEMBERS OF COUNCIL
City Council Minutes
September 5, 2017
2657
Orangeburg City Council held a Public Hearing on Tuesday, September 5, 2017, at 7:00 P.M., in
Council Chambers with Mayor Butler presiding. The purpose of the Hearing was consideration
of an Ordinance to Adopt a Budget for the Operation of the Department of Public Utilities of the
City of Orangeburg, SC, for the Fiscal Year beginning October 1, 2017, and ending September
30, 2018, and Adopt Amended Water and Wastewater Rates effective October 1, 2017.
Mayor Butler asked for comments from the public. Hearing no comments, a motion was rnade
by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Haire, to close the Public Hearing. The
motion was unanimously approved ..
PRESENT:
Michael C. Butler
Charles B. Barnwell
Bernard Haire
Charles W. Jernigan
L. Zimmerman Keitt
Sandra P. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
Council entered into the regularly scheduled City Council Meeting.
A motion was rnade by Councilrnember Stroman, seconded by Councilmernber Haire, to approve
the June 15, 2017, Department of Public Utilities Budgetary Planning Meeting-Special City
Council Minutes. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was rnadc by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, seconded by Councilmembcr Barnwell, to approve
the August 8, 2017, Special City Council Minutes. This motion as unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmernber Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Knotts, to
approve the August 15, 2017, City Council Minutes. This was a 6-0-1 vote as Councilmembcr
Jernigan abstained, as he was not present at the meeting.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Knotts, to approve
the Third Reading of an Ordinance amending the Budget for the City of Orangeburg, SC, for the
Fiscal Year beginning October I, 2016, and ending September 30, 2017. This motion was
unanimously approved.
A motion as made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Haire, to approve
the Third Reading of an Ordinance to Raise Revenue and Adopt a Budget for the City of
Orangeburg, SC, for the Fiscal Year beginning October 1, 2017, and ending September 30. 2018.
111is motion was unanimously approved.
Ms. Evelyn Disher, Executive Director of Community of Character, accepted the Character Trait
Proclamation for September 2017, 'Trustworthiness".
Department of Public Utilities Manager Harley ovcrviewed the major points of the Budget. He
stated, "The total revenue projected for FY 2017-2018 is $96,676,730; total expenses projected
arc $70,000,836 which includes profits before transfers totaling $16,840,730 with a $5.4 million
transfer to the City. The return on assets are 5%. Included is a 2% COLA for employees and
$ I 4.6 million budgeted for capital projects and infrastructure projects.
2658
Page2
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to
approve the Second Reading of an Ordinance to Adopt a Budget for the Operation of the
Department of Public Utilities of the City of Orangeburg, SC, for the Fiscal Year beginning
October 1, 2017, and ending September 30, 2018, and Adopt Amended Water and Wastewater
Rates effective October 1, 2017. This motion was unanimously approved.
Mayor Pro Tern Keitt asked DPU Manager Harley, "Have you heard anything from the citizens
on the rate increases?"
DPU Manager Harley stated, "I have not heard of any concerns and I have visited several civic
organizations and even with this modest rate increase, DPU is still one of the lowest utilities in
the state that provides services like ours."
Mayor Pro Tern Keitt stated, "On behalf of Council, we appreciate all you have done and we are
hearing good things on the street about your staff and helping the citizens."
Councilmember Stroman stated, "I echo that as well. The City is doing a great job on the budget
with no tax increase."
A motion was made by Councihnember Stroman, seconded by Councilmember BarnweU, to
amend the DPU Budget Ordinance to include the language regarding the Fire Service to read as
follows: Customers who are billed on this rate for fire protection service will not be required to
pay for water actually used to fight a fire on the property for which this meter provides service.
The customer must provide the Department a Fire Incident Report. from the applicable Fire
Department and for those properties located in the City of Orangeburg Fire District, a City Fire
Contract, dated previous to the fire incident, in order for this provision to apply. This language
will be a part of the Ordinance at Third Reading. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Haire, to
approve a Resolution Adopting the Department of Public Utilities Safety Policy Statement. This
motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councihnember Jernigan, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, to enter
into an Executive Session for a Legal Matter concerning the Settlement Agreement with former
Department of Public Utilities Manager.
There being no further business the meeting was adjourned.
itted,
/pfb
-!
7
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
September 19, 2017 2659
Orangeburg City Council held its regularly scheduled meeting on Tuesday, September 19, 2017,
at 7 :00 P .M., in Council Chambers with Mayor Butler presiding.
PRESENT:
Michael C. Butler, Mayor
Charles B. Barnwell
Bernard Haire
Charles W. Jernigan
Sandra P. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
ABSENT:
L. Zimmerman Keitt
Moment of Personal Privilege from Councilmember Barnwell.
Councilmember Barnwell stated, "I want to thank all the representatives over the last sixteen
years for their support. A certain segment of the community didn't get out and vote and that was
beyond my control. I want to thank Shaniqua Simmons, P&R Director, for helping me in the
Sunnyside area, a lot was accomplished. I want to also thank Warren Harley, DPU Manager, for
everything you have done and also to Mr. John Yow, City Administrator. If you search the State
of South Carolina, you will not find a more competent City Administrator. A lot of you may not
know this, but when Mr. Yow came to the City, it was broke. We had to borrow money from
DPU to make payroll. He came in and has built up our capital reserves to over eleven million
dollars. I have enjoyed working with him for many years and City Council should compliment
him on thi.s because if you searched the United States, you would not find a more trustworthy,
diligent, competent City Administrator."
A motion was made by Councilmember Stroman, seconded by Councilmember Haire, to approve
the September 5, 2017, City Council Minutes as distributed. This motion was unanimously
approved.
Department of Public Utilities Administration Manager Josh Nexsen addressed Council in
regards to the bids received for audit services for Fiscal Years 2017-2020. He stated, "Pursuant
to SC Code of Laws Section 5-7-240 - Councils are required to provide for independent annual
audit of financial records and transactions of municipality and agencies funded by municipal
funds. Requests for audit proposals for the City of Orangeburg and the Department of Public
Utilities were submitted to fourteen qualified firms on June 30, 2017. The audit request for
proposal and the listing of firms contacted is attached. Responses were due back by August 11,
2017, at 5:00 P.M. Of the fourteen frrms contacted, seven firms provided no response, two firms
notified us that they would not be able to propose due to prior engagements and five frrms
submitted qualified proposals. After careful review and evaluation of the qualified proposals by
the City and DPU staff, Mauldin and Jenkins, LLC, from Macon, Georgia, was the lowest
qualified respondent over the four year period under the proposal. Mauldin and Jenkins, LLC,
provided very strong references and qualifications. It is our recommendation that City Council
enter into a four year contract with Mauldin and Jenkins, LLC, to provide audit and attestation
services in the amount of$144,700."
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "Do they specialize in Utilities?"
Mr. Nexsen replied, "They have a long list of utility and government references."
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Councilmember Jernigan, to award
the Financial Statement Audit Contract to Mauldin and Jenkins, LLC, from Macon, Georgia, in
the amount of$144,700 .. This motion was unanimously approved.
Pag2660
Assistant City Admini strator John Singh addressed Counci l i , refer ence to an MASC Hometown
Economic Development Grant. He stated, "Staff would like o apply for this grant and has
looked into partnerin g with DORA in the redevelopment of downtown space. This grant is a
matching grant. The maximum award is $25,00 0 and the 15~ match would be $3,750.00.
DORA and other financial partners will also be providing fu9ding with the proj ect ranging
$35,000 to $60,000.
A motion was made by Councilmember Jernigan, seconded ~y Councilm ember Barnwell , to
approve a Resolution committing the City of Orangeburg to prov iding a local match for a
Municipa l Assoc iation of South Carolina Hometown Econorhic Development Grant. This
moti on was unanim ously appro ved. /
A motion was made by Councilm ember Haire, seconded by ~ ouncilmember Knotts , to approve
the Third Reading of an Ordinance to (1) Adopt a Budget for the Operation of the Department of
Public Utilities of the City of Orangeburg , SC, for the FiscallYear beginning October 1, 2017 ,
and ending September 30, 2018, and (2) Adopt Amended Water and Wastewater Rates effectiv e
October 1, 20 17. This motion was unanim ously approved . I
Councilmember Jernigan asked for a moment of Personal p, ·vilege.
Councilm ember Jernigan stated, "I wish to thank Budd y for is service of sixteen years, you
have done a good job on Council and I wish you the best in he future."
Councilmember Stroman stated, "I have known Buddy sinc(e 1968, I sold him a Mercury and he
used to come eat with us before he was married. Thank you or being a friend and for your
service."
Counci lmember Knotts stated, "I echo the sentiment s, it ha1 been a pleasure for you being my
seat mate, you have served the City well and the best is yet to come ."
Mayor But ler stated, "I have certainly enjoyed working witrl you and may God bl ess you in all
you do."
Councilmember Haire stated, "I may be the longest person erving and I have enjoyed being on
Council with you, we have had some honest differences, bJt we worked them out."
A motion was made by Counc ilmember Haire, seco?de d b) Counc il~ember_ Barn~ell , to enter
into and Executive Session and would not be returnm g to Open Sess10n. This motion was
unanimousl y approved.
Counc il entered in to Exec utive Sess ion for the following:
1. Legal Matter -Appeal of City Zoning Board of Appea l d ecision - properties of Thoma s S.
Daras and Debra C. Daras and Rivers Bridge Camp #8r Sons of Confede rate Veterans
2. Contractual Matter - Propos ed Ground Lease for Hangar Construction at Orangeb urg
Municipal Airport.
There being no further business, the meetin g was adjournecl.
Respectfully submitt ed,
/pfb
City Council Minutes
October 17, 2017
Orangeburg City Council held its regularly scheduled meeting on Tuesday, October 17, 2017, at
7:00 P.M. in Council Chambers with Mayor Butler presiding. 2665
PRESENT:
Michael C. Butler, Mayor
Jerry Hannah
Charles W. Jernigan
L. Zimmerman Keitt
Sandra P. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
ABSENT:
Bernard Haire
A motion was made by Councilmember Keitt and seconded by Councilmember Knotts, to approve
the October 3, 2017, City Council Minutes. This motion was unanimously approved.
Mayor Butler asked that Regina "Tina" Dantzler and Roy Givens to step forward as well as their
supervisors. Mayor Butler read the Retiree Resolution, and Chief Adams, Lieutenant Colonel
Connor, and City Administrator Yow added their comments and appreciation to both Tina and Roy
for their work for the City. Each retiree was presented with a Resolution and watch as appreciation
for their service. Ms. Dantzler years of service to the City was thirty-three years and eight months
and Mr. Givens years of service to the City was forty years and two months.
Assistant City Administrator Singh presented an outline of the Comprehensive Plan for the City of
Orangeburg, SC. He stated, "I want to give you a brief outline of th.e plan and will be glad to
answer any questions that you may have. The planning process consisted of four public meetings
that were held here with the Planning Commission. At one meeting we did not have a forum, but
was probably one of our biggest dialogue sessions that we had. Section 1.4 specifies the use of
Character Areas. Character Areas and planning knowledge is the visual and functional differences
between different portions of the community and allows for more intentional guidance of future
development through adequate and specific planning and implementation initiatives. You can often
find places that have unique perspective characteristics that allow us to look forward."
City Administrator Yow added, "These areas do not have legal zoning issues that would require
changes in usage or require additional action if zoning amendments are requested."
Assistant City Administrator Singh continued with comments related to the Population Chapter
stating, "Most of the data from that is drawn from the US Census, so it's basically boilerplate
information. The one thing that I'll point out is that it does point out a key in our census data. As
we go along further in the years, our population indicates a small decrease, actually which again
that is a guide or giving us an idea. But, where we also talk about economic development and also
the development of other neighborhoods and so forth, we have the opportunity to grow. One of the
big components of having good planning is the ability to annex. The next item is a Housing
Component. Again, we talk about the different components of housing around the City of
Orangeburg. We have a couple of subdivisions right now that are beginning to develop that we are
excited about and increased population as we continue to look at industries that will help us.
Several examples were provided from Habitat for Humanity Housing to the Boswell Project."
Mayor Butler commented, "Condominiums or apartments would be a good thing. A lot of people
ask about nice condominiums. Of course, swimming pools are not absolutely necessary."
Assistant City Administrator Singh replied, "And those are things that are addressed by the planners
and are promoted in the Plan and we'll talk a little bit further at the end. Economic Development
through partnership, such as with Orangeburg County, and there is a little liaison effect of
Orangeburg Development Commission. Under the Natural Resources Section, again, we discuss
the areas of natural resources that we have in our communities, the Edisto River specifically. With
the maps, this version will be larger and would be brought to the next council meeting. These maps
also include the flood plains. It was interesting to look at how Orangeburg has developed and how
Page2
the flood plains tie into it. For the Cultural Historical Resources and Community Facilities no . ,
maJor changes are noted in those sections. Under Transportation are some of the big things, just
pointij6'(j 6ain, that we have this going on now with the bike and pedestrian programs. We are
looking at current bike trails and improvements and bus service. Bus service is something very
important to communities and is something that we need to highlight. Another integral part is we
have a lot of things going on at our airport and those will be things that we will be looking at.
Chapter nine is the Priority Investment which we will have for you at the Second Reading. The
Priority Investment is a new section required by state law. This is going to be kind of a road map or
like the plans we do with you at our Council Planning Sessions."
City Administrator Yow stated, "The 1 % Capital Projects Sales Tax outlines some of the priority
investments set by City Council that are required by the Planning Enabling Act and this can be
reviewed at the Second Reading. "
Councilmember Knotts inquired, "I am looking at your meeting minutes in relation to public
comments, are the strengths and weaknesses from this meeting going to be addressed?"
Assistant City Administrator Singh stated "These were more informational and would be
incorporated, but some of the comments did not quite hit the mark or the input was a bit off. We
had a very diverse group of people which was great and we are happy to have the input."
Councilmember Knotts further stated, "The reason I was asking is that I was personally looking at
the weaknesses where you're talking about branding. Are we a college town, or are we a retirement
town or whatever the case may be?"
Assistant City Administrator Singh replied, "I want to touch on that a little bit and that kind of goes
right back over to DORA a little bit, if you remember. We did a presentation not too long ago, the
right to address branding, it's an issue that comes up."
Councilmember Hannah inquired about a ratio of homes versus apartments, versus low income
housing in the census data.
Assistant City Administrator Singh replied, "It is pretty much a square box way, which is not what
we necessarily wanted and that is going to address those issues. The statistics that are available in
terms of the Census Bureau and so forth, where we get into discussing the Plan and where you're
coming from on that is again where we are. It will ask what kind of sustainable housing we have.
Those are things that have been brought up. The census tells us how many housing units we have in
terms of Single Family, Multi-Family and so forth. It gives us a road map so when you look at the
Plan, we need more single family housing, good quality housing and multi-family apartments."
Councilmember Hannah inquired, "Does the data include comparisons to other cities of similar size
and/or other college towns?"
Assistant City Administrator Singh stated, "Greenwood, North Augusta, and Lexington were used
in the Plan for comparison purposes."
Upon no further questions, a motion was made by Councilmember Keitt and seconded by
Councilmember Hannah, to approve and adopt the First Reading of the Ordinance related to the
Comprehensive Plan for the City of Orangeburg. The motion was unanimously approved.
City Administrator Yow reviewed with Council regarding the FY 2015-16 Audit: He stated "This
item was tabled at the last meeting due to pending questions from various Counc1lmembers. He
reminded Council that we did receive a clean, unqualified opinion and the report at some point
needs to be accepted, as information, into the record."
Mayor Pro Tern Keitt stated," My outstanding questions have been answered."
Councilmember Hannah inquired as to the findings listed in the audit related to internal controls.
Mayor Butler stated, "This was due to a staffing/turnover issue ~at has_no~ been ad?Iessed and
resolved, and City Administrator Yow concurred and added that m the mtenm the City also asked
Page3
the accounting firm completing the audit to provide one of their staff munbers to come in and fill in
on an interim basis. Unfortunately, that person left the company, which we had no control over and
it did take a couple of months to get it worked out." 2667
As no further questions were given, Mayor Pro Tern Keitt made a motion with a second from
Councilmember Knotts, to accept the FY 2015-16 Audit, as information. The motion was
unanimously approved.
City Administrator Yow discussed the vacant seat on the Fireman's Inspection and Insurance
Fund/Supervisory Board that was previously filled by Councilmember Barnwell. He stated,
"Council needs to make a replacement appointment for this seat."
Councilmember Knotts nominated Councilmember Haire, and the motion was seconded by Mayor
Pro Tern Keitt. The motion was unanimously approved.
Eric Odom, Director of the Water Division from the Department of Public Utilities (DPU) provided
Council with details on the South Carolina Water and Wastewater Agency Response Network
(SCW ARN). He stated, "SCW ARN consists of approximately ninety water and wastewater
member utilities across the state. By way of this Agreement, it's very similar to our electrical needs
Mutual Aid Agreement. It is an Agreement to provide manpower and materials of any kind in the
event of a natural disaster or some other form of emergency where we would need assistance or
bring our water or wastewater utility back online or into compliance. A recent event that would
have activated this Agreement, if you remember, the floods in October 2015, in Columbia and the
effort that went into the City of Colombia's water system getting back online. They are members of
this Agreement and they utilized it that time. Without SCW ARN it would have been a much larger
undertaking for them to be able to get back online. So basically, at this time, we're just seeking
your approval to allow the Manager to enter into this Mutual Aid Agreement."
A motion was made by Councilmember Stroman and seconded by Councilmember Knotts, to
approve and accept the Mutual Aid Agreement into record. The motion was unanimously
approved.
Mayor Pro Tern Keitt made a motion, seconded by Councilmember Hannah to enter into an
Executive Session for Legal Matters concerning (1) Sunnyside Cemetery and Orangeburg Cemetery
and (2) Intergovernmental Agreement with the County of Orangeburg, SC. This motion was
unanimously approved.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
Respectfully submitted,
~~&C-~&Gl
Patricia Phillips ¥
Assistant City Clerk
2668 City Council Minutes
November 7, 2017
Orangeburg City Council held a Public Hearing on Tuesday, November 7, 2017, at 7:00 P.M in
Council Chambers with Mayor Butler presiding. The purpose of the meeting was for
consideration of proposed, updated changes to the Comprehensive Plan 2006-2016 and Land Use
Plan of the City of Orangeburg, South Carolina.
Mayor Butler asked for comments from the public. Hearing no comments, the Public Hearing
was closed.
PRESENT:
Michael C. Butler, Mayor
Bernard Haire
Jerry Hannah
Charles W. Jernigan
L. Zimmerman Keitt
Sandra P. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
Council entered into the regularly scheduled City Council Meeting.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Knotts, to approve
the October 17, 2017, City Council Minutes. This was a 6-0-1 vote. Councilmember Haire
abstained as he was not present at the meeting.
Mayor Butler and Public Safety Director Mike Adams presented Bobby Rivers with a Retiree
Resolution and a gold watch for his twenty-six years and twenty-six days of service with the
Public Safety Department. He will continue to work part-time with the Department of Public
Safety.
Assistant City Administrator John Singh presented the Comprehensive Plan for the City of
Orangeburg and introduced Mr. Bobby Ford, author of the Plan with Robert and Company.
Mr. Ford stated, "Mayor and Council, thank you for the opportunity that you provide. As an
engineering and architectural planning firm, we enjoy working with local governments and we
have enjoyed working with the City of Orangeburg. As part of the Plan., I need to mention that
this is the Land Use Plan. It updates the land use category slightly, although it is very much
rooted in the previous Plan .. It does not affect zoning by itself and that would come with the
Zoning Ordinance update. It does not affect anything as far as properties outside of the City
limits currently, although it does identify some potential outside of the City because what
happens immediately outside of the City may also have an impact inside the City itself. We try
to identity Character Areas. A character area is a place-making approach and helps to use a
community's assets to identify what the potential, inspiration and opportunities are within
various places within the City. It is definitely a process and I believe it provides strength to the
Plan itself. We did continue much of the connection identified with the previous Plan. The
compliance index is still in the Plan, which helps you identify what should be appropriate. Per
John Singh' s suggestion, we relocated a couple of the chapters from what we initially provided.
By relocating the chapters they are aligned with the planning guide the Municipal Association
puts out for local government. Two new elements are added to this Plan that was not in the 2006
Plan. They were added in 2007 by arnendment at the State Legislature and called amendments to
the State Planning Enabling Act and as part of that, the Plan will include the transportation
section and priority investment section. The adopted Plan will include notification of planning
: proposal which is part of the suggested best practices of the Municipal Association of South
· Carolina
Page2
The County, SC Department of Transportation and other major agencies have a lot to do with
implementing development within the City. If you have any questions, I will be pleased to
answer them. This was a great experience working with the City of Orangeburg."
Councilmember Hannah asked, "Does this Plan go out to more than City Council?"
Mr. Ford stated, "The Plan will be adopted by City Council and becomes public information and
· will be published as a document that the City can use in the future to help provide decision
making."
Councilmember Hannah stated, "The reason I ask the question is that on page 3, it stated Claflin
University, 1899."
Mr. Ford stated, "I think that is an error, it is 1869. Thank you for pointing that out and we will
go back and edit that."
Councilmember Hannah stated, "The other is on page 4.3., Sumter Air Force Base twenty miles
to the north and North Auxiliary Landing Field in North, ten miles is something you may need to
look at."
Mayor Butler stated, "We just want to be clear that this Plan does not affect future annexations in
the City."
Mr. Ford stated, "That's a decision to be made in an annexation action. All the Plan does is it
looks at whole communities including areas that are just outside the City, but it has no legal
effort to identify what's outside the City, but I think it's important for the City to make
assumptions for what's happening immediately outside of the City. I did get a great opportunity
with Orangeburg County which just adopted their Plan and I tried to use as much of their
information as I could outside of the City."
: City Administrator John Yow stated, "Mr. Mayor, you are correct, State Law requires the
· properties to be annexed as Residential A-1, unless otherwise requested. So it does not affect
.. that."
Assistant City Administrator John Singh stated, "Mr. Hannah, in regards to what you asked, the
process is actually one that went through the Planning Commissions and we had three public
meetings with people in attendance with a lot of good feedback and interaction and then again
we bring it to you for final approval after the recommendation of the Planning Commission."
Mayor Butler stated, "We want to make the necessary correction in adopting this, is that
correct?"
Attorney Walsh stated, "Just adopt the Plan subject to the changes."
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Haire, to approve
the Second Reading of an Ordinance adopting a Comprehensive Plan with the necessary
corrections to be made for the City of Orangeburg, SC, as amended. This motion was
unanimously approved.
Ms. Evelyn Disher, Executive Director of the Community of Character, accepted the Character
Trait, "Gratitude" for the month of November, 2017.
Mr. Jeff Ruth, Hillcrest Golf Course Manager addressed Council. He stated, "Hillcrest Golf
Club was approved for sixty (60) new golf cars in 2017-18 fiscal year for a price of $205,000.
• Three companies bid on the golf cars, Yamaha, EZ Go and Club Car. Yamaha is our current
vendor and we have had excellent service and our members/customers like the comfort and
additional room that the Yamaha's provide over the EZ Go and Club Car. We have had a demo
Page3
..2i>'7 0
. golf car from all three companies over the past month and the Yamaha golf car has been the golf
car of choice from the Golf Commission and from over 90% of our members and regular
customers. I recommend, along with the Commission, we stay with Yamaha based on the
following reasons. Their service over the past four and one half years has been excellent. If a
golf car has a problem, they respond within 24-48 hours and have the golf car back up and
running. The EZ Go service contract is that they visit your golf course once a week to make
repairs. This is a huge advantage to have with Yamaha to have golf cars up and running within
days. Yamaha golf cars are two inches higher then either Club Car or EZ Go and our
members/customers have grown to like this additional height. Many members make the
comment when they go play at Orangeburg Country Club they hit their heads on the lower EZ
Go roofs. The Yamaha dashboard is the most user friendly of all three dashboards. Yamaha is
the only company that has designed the dashboard to accommodate the player's cell phones and
have a designated dual range finder holder. Yamaha has the largest golf bag well to
accommodate the larger golf bags these days. Yamaha also has the largest storage basket and the
largest seating area for both golfers. Yamaha's bid comes in at $12,987.66 higher than the EZ
Go bid. The golf car is the most comfortable of the three according to our members/customers
and the additional room in all the areas of the golf car along with the player friendly dashboard
· and the excellent service makes Yamaha a great choice for Hillcrest. The total price is
$174,354.36 for sixty (60) golf cars and comes in at $30,645.64 under the approved $205,000
budget. In my opinion, Yamaha is the highest quality golf car on the market and provides the
best service. I feel very confident in making this recommendation as I have had the opportunity
to work with all three companies in my twenty years as being a golf professional and I have a
great relationship with all three companies"
Councihnember Haire asked, "Did you present specs to the various companies to bid on?"
· Manager Ruth replied, "Yes, we sent a listing to all three companies to bid on the exact same
thing. For example, with two of the companies, the USB ports come standard and one company
~ ' \
· had to add th.e USB ports."
Councihnember Haire asked, "Can I get a copy of those specs?"
Manager Ruth replied, "Yes."
Councihnember Haire asked, "In regards to the response for service, Yamaha can respond within
24 to 48 hours, the other company only comes once a week. What is the frequency of the
breakdowns? We are talking about a difference of over $12,000 higher than EZ GO."
· Manager Ruth replied, "When they are brand new, the frequency is very low because they are
new. It is very hard to predict, if someone were to run it into a tree or run into the pond that is
when we would have to call them. Once the cars get older, and the cars we have now are 4.5
years old, they break down quite a bit. The warranties run out at vari.ous times as you can see
from the attached pages."
Councilmember Haire stated, "I am trying to see why this one is $12,000 more. You are saying
that the height of the top is an issue, do we have problems with height now?"
Manager Ruth stated, "Yes, if you talk to various people, people over 6 feet, their heads hit the
top and the steering wheel hits them."
Councilmember Hannah asked, "What is the total cost per car?
-Manager Ruth replied, "The cost per car is $2,900."
The bids that were taken for 60 cars are as follows including tax: Yamaha $174,354.36 with
trade-ins, Club Car $178,904.00 with trade-ins and EZ-GO $161,366.70 with trade-ins.
~-;
'"'· ..
-,
I
i
- .)
7
'
I
__ J
______ :::..,
Page4
2671
A motion was made by Councilmember Stroman, seconded by Councilmember Jernigan, to
approve a contract to Yamaha Golf-Car Company in the amount of$174,354.36 for sixty (60)
golf cars. This was a 6-0-1, as Councilmember Haire abstained.
City Administrator Yow presented information on the Recreational Complex. He stated, "I am
pleased to present for Council's consideration an exciting project that will have a positive and
lasting impact on our community. Council has seen most of this but for the public; I would like
to go through this. We are talking about the Recreational Complex which is located off of the
North Road right outside of the City. The layout of the project is baseball and softball fields with
a total of nine (9) fields. Two are 250 feet and the others are 300 feet which will accommodate
little league baseball, ladies softball, college softball and youth baseball up to about a 13-15 year
age group. There will also be green space for picnics and walking trails. We have a
maintenance building for equipment and four restrooms throughout the site. Several parking
areas designated throughout the site for a total of slightly over 500 parking spaces. Two
buildings located in the center of the ball fields serve as press boxes and concession stands. The
City opened bids on October 23, 2017, and received five bids and the low responsive bidder is
Edcon Construction from Peak, SC. We have done background checks on them and so far the
references have been very good. We asked each company to submit the number of days that they
think it will take to complete the project and Edcon is 390 days. This is the base bid for the ball
fields and does not include the lights. We will bring this back to you in a future meeting. We are
looking at LED Lights and we have gotten prices from three different companies that we are
evaluating. They are estimated at $1.4 million and we will have other costs such as project
management and miscellaneous equipment, such as security cameras, trash containers, portable
fences, bleachers, benches and computers. Also, we will need to do an intersection upgrade as
well as legal and financial costs. We have monies in the 1 % Capital Project Sales Tax Fund and
in our City Hospitality Fund. These funds are on hand and we will need to borrow $4 million to
complete this project. We suggest refinancing an existing revenue bond. I want to thank City
Council for participating in the planning sessions for this, Ms. Simmons and her staff for their
input, Attorney Walsh's input and especially DPU, which will be providing all utilities to this
Complex."
Mayor Pro Tern Keitt asked, "What's the beginning date."
City Administrator Yow stated, "If Council awards this tonight, we will notify architects and
engineers and we will notify the contractor, Edcon. We will issue a Notice of Award and hold a
Pre-Construction Conference. They have to secure their performance bond and we have to
review it and then we give them the order to get on the site. I am hoping in about thirty days but
I can't guarantee that.
Councilmember Hannah stated, "You stated it did not include bleachers."
City Administrator Yow stated, "Other equipment, bleachers, trash cans, etc."
Councilmembcr Hannah asked, "It includes 500 parking spaces, is that paved parking?"
City Administrator Yow stated, "Roads and walking spaces are paved throughout."
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "Have you started working on a fee structure for playing out
there."
City Administrator Yow stated, "Ms. Simmons is working on that."
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "Will there be a positive revenue stream once this gets going."
'
PageS
2672
City Administrator Yow stated, "We never said that there will be a direct positive revenue
stream. This is for the quality of life for our co=unity, but we certainly hope to generate
revenue and hope to spur economic development, which will give us indirect revenue. "
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Councilmember Hannah, to approve
a bid for construction of the Recreational Complex to Edcon Construction, Inc., in the amount of
$15,103,300.00. This motion was unanimously approved.
'
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Councilmember Knotts, to approve
the following Department of Public Utilities Grievance Committee appointments as follows:
Corey Adicks
Dyna Wactor
Tannerk Garrick
Jim Hill
Gas Division
Water Division
Alternate
Alternate
Tius motion was unanimously approved.
November 2017 - January 2020
November 2017 - January 2020
January2018 - January2021
January 2018 - January 2021
Mr. Wade Holmes addressed Council, he stated, "DPU would like to take a moment and update
you on the acceptance of bids on transformers for substations # I and # 12. Substation # 1 is
located on Bull and Windsor and Substation #12 is located on Holly and Berry Streets. Both of
these substations are fairly old, roughly fifty years old and at the end of their lifecycle. As you
may remember at the end of August, we had a catastrophic failure for substation #1 and we used
a spare that was on our yard which is what we are currently using right now. We need to replace
that substation. Substation #12 is a mirror image of Substation #1 so we need to replace that one
as well. The Electric Division sent out RFQ's and we received three (3) accepted bids from
manufacturers of transformers as you can see from the memo. We evaluated the bids and after
this process, SPX Waukesha scored higher based on the calculated evaluation cost. This
transformer is a more expensive transformer, but they met all the specs, while the other two did
not. We would like to send an award letter to SPX Waukesha in the next few days."
. Councilmember Hannah asked, "Are there any other areas that need updating that are older as
•· well?"
· Mr. Holmes replied, "We have a ten year plan that we need to rebuild about six substations."
DPU Manager Harley replied, "We will be bringing a full plan in the next budget for you to
. consider."
Councilmember Stroman asked, "Will DPU be installing this or someone else?"
Mr. Holmes replied, "With the amount of work this is, we will be hiring most ofit out."
Councilmember Stroman asked, "How much does that cost?"
Mr. Holmes stated, "With the layout and design, we don't really have a number yet, with the
other substations, it is generally a million to a million and a half for full build out."
Councilmember Stroman asked, "Is this in the budget?"
Mr. Holmes replied, "Yes."
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Haire, to approve
the acceptance of a bid for Transformer Purchases from SPX Waukesha for $579,587 per
transformer for Substation #1 and Substation #12. 11,is motion was unanimously approved .
.
7
-I
I
__!
7
I
i -"
Page6
2673
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Stroman, to enter
into an Executive Session for a Legal matter concerning a Building Permit Revocation and Stop
Work Order - Mr. Tommy Daras and a Contractual Matter concerning the discussion of Power
Supply Agreement. This motion was unanimously approved.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
. Respectfully submitted,
City Clerk
/p±b
City Council Minutes
November 21, 2017
2674 Orangeburg City Council held its regularly scheduled City Council Meeting on Tuesday,
November 21, 2017, at 7:00 P.M., in Council Chambers with Mayor Butler presiding.
PRESENT:
Michael C. Butler, Mayor
Bernard Haire
Jerry Hannah
Charles W. Jernigan
L. Zimmerman Keitt
Sandra P. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
A motion was made by Councihnember Stroman, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, to approve
the November 7, 2017, City Council Minutes, as amended. This motion was unanimously
approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Knotts, seconded by Councihnember Haire, to approve
the Third Reading of an Ordinance adopting a Comprehensive Plan for the_ City of Orangeburg,
SC, as amended.
Mayor Pro Tern Keitt asked, "Will Council receive a new copy of the Plan."
Assistant City Administrator Singh replied, "Yes."
Department of Public Safety Lt. Carl Shultz addressed Council and presented part one of a
presentation of the operation of the Forensic Services Unit.
Lt. Shultz stated, "The Orangeburg Department of Public Safety Forensic Services Unit is under
the Department of Public Safety with the Drug Analysis and DNA Sections housed on the
campus of Claflin University. The Unit handles drug/chemical analysis, crime scenes, latent
prints/AFIS, property and evidence and DNA analysis."
He further explained the rooms at ODPS and at Claflin University, which is the lab.
Lt. Shultz stated, "We do testing for our agency and fourteen 0th.er agencies within the First
Judicial Circuit We provide expert testimony in these areas in court and we provide real time
crime scene assistance. We also provide assistance to small agencies. In forensics, we have won
two awards, the 2010 Augusta Vollmer Award for Excellence in Forensic Services and the 2014
South Carolina Municipal Association Achievement Award in Public Safety. Currently, in
Evidence, we have over 14,335 pieces of evidence. All 723 DNA samples are at Claflin. The
chemist is at Claflin and he has processed over 295 cases to date this year. It is a substantial
workload. I came here in 2007 and I have worked over 719 crime scenes since 2007. We search
other databases as well and we have had four identifications this week. We have had SLED
contact us to process some evidence on 222 cases and we have taken some of those back."
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "How long do you have to keep this evidence?"
Lt. Shultz replied, "It depends upon the case, generally thirty days after a municipal court case.
If it is a State case, then that involves violent crimes and those may have to be kept indefinitely."
Councihnember Jernigan asked, "How is this evidence disposed of?"
Lt. Shultz replied, "We have an incinerator and we can melt guns or use extrication equipment to
dispose of guns."
Mayor Pro Tern Keitt asked, "At this time, is there a charge for these other agencies?"
Lt. Shultz replied, "Not at this time."
Page2
City Administrator Yow replied, "That is what part two of their presentation will be, !W,5
their Business Plan, not only these agencies mentioned, but other agencies outside of our area."
Councilmember Haire asked, "Does SLED charge for their services?"
Lt. Shultz replied, "They do not."
Councilmember Hannah asked, "Of the fourteen cities, what percent is county or cities?"
Lt. Shultz replied, "I do not have that exact figure, but the majority is ours, Calhoun County and
Orangeburg County, which is in the First Judicial Circuit."
City Administrator Yow stated, "We are going to have to separate our costs from the other cities
or counties to determine what the City's exact costs are. I think the Department is also looking
at some other areas outside of Orangeburg and it may take budget sessions to work all of this
out."
Councilmember Hannah asked, "Are Claflin students coming?"
Lt. Shultz stated, "No, they were not on the program."
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "Cities of our size, what others have a facility in comparison to
ours?"
DPS Director Adams stated, "No one."
Ms. Theresa Williams, City Human Resources Manager and Ms. Cheryl Lynch, Human
Resources Supervisor at DPU addressed Council in regards to the update on salary
compensation, employee benefits and job classification studies.
Ms. Williams stated, "Good evening Mayor and Council. I am Theresa Williams, HR Officer
with the City of Orangeburg and joining me is Cheryl Lynch, HR Supervisor with the
Department of Public Utilities. As Human Resources Managers for both the City of Orangeburg
and the Department of Public Utilities, we are here this evening to provide an update to the
Compensation, Benefits and Job Classification Study that Council approved in December, 2016.
A copy of tonight's presentation is included in your packet. For the benefit of Mr. Hannah, who
was not on Council when this study was first discussed and approved, as well as to benefit full
Council, we want to start by doing a brief recap. I am certain that Cheryl will agree that finding
a good employee is tough. Both the City and DPU have been impacted by the need to find good
employees to fill job openings. Wbile finding a good employee is tough, keeping a good
employee is tougher. Therefore, the purpose of the study is to professionally evaluate the City's
and DPU's pay plans to determine if our pay structures, our benefits and our policies are
effective enough to attract a diversified workforce as well as to retain our best employees. We
asked our chosen consultant to focus on eight specific areas for the evaluation. Job
Classifications - where job duties, tasks and levels of authority for each job are accurately
defined. Job Grades - this is where a collection of jobs that may have the same value should
therefore be structured and paid the same. Salary Ranges - to analyze the span between
minimum, mid-point and maximum pay bands for each job category. Comparative Market
Analysis - this will determine how we compare to similar size municipalities, other utilities and
even some private entities. A side benefit of this study will be updated job descriptions. We've
learned that over the years many of our job descriptions have become outdated compared to
duties and tasks that are now required of our employees. Updated job descriptions will address
this issue. Pay and Equity is another concern and the study will ensure that employees are paid
equally for equal work done. While we feel as a City that we offer a good benefits package, we
want to know how we compare with others and if our benefits can be improved. For example,
the number of paid holidays compared to other governmental agencies, separate vacation days
Page3
verstlo:Z61eave days, etc. Finally, Policy and Procedures and we've asked 1he consultant to
reco=end any policy, procedure and practice changes which may result from any pay practices
disparities. We have also asked that any reco=endations must include documented costs or
savings associated wi1h implementing."
Ms. Lynch stated, "Regarding the time line of the study, Council initially approved the study in
December 2016, after which we, as HR Managers, met to discuss 1he criteria for 1he RFP. We
identified four (4) potential consultants and asked them to submit a proposal. We reviewed each
proposal in March 2017, and made a selection in April. The Archer Group was selected based
on cost, their knowledge and work done in the industry wi1h other municipalities and utility
organizations. In May, we reviewed our decision with Council before co=unicating the
decision to our employees. Some employees were notified in writing with letters, others were
notified verbally through their Department Heads. In July, the Archer Consultant met with each
manager to do an overview ofwhat'this process will entail. This also allowed each manager to
ask questions for clarification purposes. In September, each employee was asked to complete an
employee questionnaire stating their job duties and responsibilities. At the end of this month,
November, the Archer Group will be on-site at the City on the 29th and at DPU on the 30th• The
purpose of this meeting is to give each department manager an opportunity to discuss any issues
within their departments, such as hard to fill positions, structure of departments, etc. In
December, we anticipate the Market Survey to begin. This is where, as a City and Public
Utilities organization, we are measured against others of similar size and structure. In January,
the job evaluation and structure process will begin followed by the survey analysis in February.
In March, we should have a preliminary draft of the Plan, which will be reviewed in April before
a final report is presented to Council in May. We anticipate the implementation steps could take
up to three years because of costs, plan integration, new job descriptions, training and support.
Are there any questions?"
Mayor Butler asked, "If employees could not write to complete the questionnaire, how was that
handled?"
Ms. Williams and Ms. Lynch both stated that employees were encouraged to meet in groups and
Human Resources also assisted."
Mayor Pro Tern Keitt addressed Council in regards to Smoking Cessation.
She stated, "We are Project Life Positeen, Inc., working with a Grant from 1he SC Collaborative
Training. We work with students and adults. People exposed to second hand smoke are dying
faster. Employees with the City of Orangeburg who are going to the Clinic and do not smoke,
your insurance is cheaper to advocate non-smoking. I have with us tonight, Mr.,Tavian Hardy a
senior intern at Orangeburg Wilkinson. He will be assisting Project Life Positeen throughout
this grant process. If you smoke, within a year, you can see the amount of tar in your lungs from
our display. I would like to ask Council to consider no smoking on City grounds and other cities
have this. City Administrator Yow gave us some information pertaining to this. Secondhand
smoke still kills and I want you to think about it and work with us."
Mayor Butler stated this will be taken under advisement.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Stroman, to enter
into an Executive Session for (1) Economi.c Development - Update on Project Recycle, (2)
Contractual Matter -- Contracts for Health, Dental Insurance and Reinsurance and (3) Legal
Matter- Property of Palmetto Development Group, 1170 Russell Street (Old First National Bank
Building).
Page4
2677
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
/pfb
RESOLUTION
A RESOLUTION TO ADOPT HEALTH INSURANCE BENEFITS FOR
THE EMPLOYEES OF THE CITY OF ORANGEBURG EFFECTIVE
JANUARY 1, 2018 AND REPEALING ANY CONFLICTING RESOLUTION
OR IORDINANCE
WHEREAS, by Resolution of the Orangeburg City Council dated December 20, 2016 certain
retirement and health insurance benefits of City employees were adopted; and
WHEREAS, the City by said Resolution retained and reserved the right to review, amend or
change said benefits, with or without cause; and
WHEREAS, City Council has reviewed its present benefits and finds that for financial reasons it is
no:w necessary to amend and change the present health insurance benefits provided its employees
and retirees:
NOW THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED, by City Council duly assembled this 19th day of
December, 2017, that subject to the City's right in its discretion to amend, change, discontinue or
' . abolish in whole or in part, the conditions, qualifications and requirements of all past, present and
'
futur¢ employees of the City of Orangeburg, including retired and disabled employees of said City
(hereinafter referred to as "employees") as of January 1, 2018 to obtain health insurance benefits
from ,the City are set forth and shown on Exhibit A attached hereto and made a part hereof by
reference. The amended rates, benefits and conditions of eligibility as referenced therein shall be
prospective and not retroactive, Said health insurance benefits shall be continuously reviewed and
may be amended, changed, discontinued or abolished after each review.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that regardless of any prior review the health insurance benefits
of employees shall be defined, revised, reviewed, established and adopted annually by resolution of
the City of Orangeburg and its Department of Public Utilities.
BE IT .FURTHER RESOLVED, that any amendment, change, discontinuation or abolishment
shall be effective upon adoption by City Council and notice of same after adoption shall be
provided to employees within forty-five ( 45) days after adoption.
The City of Orangeburg is committed to reviewing its personnel policies and procedures and its
health insurance benefits as needed. Accordingly, the policies and benefits of employees are subject
to review, amendment, chan~e or abolishment at any time, at the discretion of City Council; thus
benefits may be increased, de.creased or abolished at any time, with or without cause.
Any t=, condition or limitation contained in any existing ordinance or resolution in conflict with
this Resolution is repealed in its entirety.
RESOLVED BY City Council duly assembled this 19th day of December, 2017 .
•
TIDS IS NOT A CONTRACT
HEAL TH INSURANCE BENEFITS
CALENDAR YEAR 2018
Exhibit A
The within benefits may be increased, decreased or abolished at any time, with or
without cause.
Definitions:
"Dental, Vision and Term Life", collectively and individually, is defined as the insurance benefits
provided by the City of Orangeburg and administered by BlueCross BlueShield (BCBS) of South
Carolina and Companion Life.
"Employees" are defined as all City of Orangeburg employees, including employees of the Department
of Public Utilities.
"Dependent" is defined as an individual who is an employee's spouse: Is a lawful spouse or; a former
spouse who is required to be covered by a divorce decree. Dependent is also defined as an employee's
child: Is a child under the age of 26 which includes a natural child, adopted child, foster child,
stepchild, or child for whom an employee has custody or legal guardianship unless child has other
federal or state insurance coverage. The term "child" also includes an incapacitated dependent, a child
who is on a medically necessary leave of absence, a child of a divorced or divorcing employee who,
under a qualified medical child support order, has a right to emoll under the employer's group health
plan. The t= "child" does not include the spouse of an eligible child. Under the Patient Protection
and Affordable Care Act and the Health Coverage and the Education Reconciliation Act, a child does
not include an individual who is eligible for other employer sponsored coverage if the group health
plan is grandfathered plan beginning for plan years before January 1, 2015.
"Health Insurance Benefits" are defined as medical, hospitalization and prescription drug benefits
available to active full-time employees of the City and provided by th.e City of Orangeburg and
administered by insurance providers under contract with the City.
"1500 HSA" plan is the 2018 Preferred Blue Plan-HDHP administered by BlueCross BlueShield of
South Carolina.
"500 PPO" plan is the 2018 Preferred Blue Plan administered by BlueCross BlueShield of South
Carolina.
"TERI" is defined as the Teacher and Employee Incentive Program administered by the South Carolina
Retirement System.
Active Employees
Active Full Time Employees
The City of Orangeburg (hereinafter referred to as "City") will provide medical, hospitalization,
prescription drug, dental and vision insuran.ce and ($15,000) term life insurance to active full-time
employees (as defined within the Personnel Handbook) with 100% of the premiums paid by the City.
The insurance is offered through providers chosen by the City. New full time employees are eligible to
be covered at the begiuuing of the month following 30 days of continuous employment. Terminated
employees are only covered until their last day of employment. Councilmembers, City Administrator,
Manager of the Department of Public Utilities, and the City Attorney are considered active full-time
employees for purposes of qualifying for health insurance benefits.
Dependents of Active Full Time Employees
Dependents, as defined by the insurance providers, are eligible for dependent Health Insurance
Benefits, with the City contributing up to the following dollar amounts towards the premium costs and
the employee paying all additional costs and premiums, including any future increases:
$ 276.93 per month for spouse coverage for the BCBS 500 PPO plan
$ 241.00 per month for spouse coverage for the BCBS 1500 HSAplan
$ 191.81 per month for children coverage for the BCBS 500 PPO plan
$ 166.90 per month for children coverage for the BCBS 1500 HSAplan
$ 383.02 per month for family coverage for the BCBS 500 PPO plan
$ 333.26 per month for family coverage for the BCBS 1500 HSA plan
I
The above City contributions to the dependent portion of the premium are capped as of January 1,
2013.
Dependent Dental, Vision and Companion T= Life ($5,000) insurance may be obtained with the
employee paying 100% of the premium cost. Dependents of new employees are eligible to be covered
at the beginning of the month following 30 days of continuous employment of the employee. Dental
and Vision for dependents of terminated employees are only covered until their last day of
employment of the employee. Dependent premiums for Dental, Vision and Companion T= Life
Insurance ($5,000) are as follows:
Dental:
$ 35.00 per month for spouse coverage for the Dental plan
$ 45.00 per month for children coverage for the Dental plan
$ 81.00 per month for family coverage for the Dental plan
Vision:
$ 3.00 per month for spouse coverage for the Vision plan
$ 4.00 per month for children coverage for the Vision plan
$ 7.00 per month for family coverage for the Vision plan
Companion Term Life Insurance ($5,000):
$ 1.00 per month for any number of dependents covered under the Companion Term Life Insurance
Dependents of current active full-time employees are eligible to be added or dropped during the City's
annual emollment period or as defined by law. All dependent coverage will be subject to the then
t=s and conditions of the City's benefit package being offered to dependents and the terms and
conditions of the insurance policy or policies of the then insurance provider.
Employees who select medical coverage under the BlueCross BlueShield 1500 RSA plan will forfeit
all other benefits referred to herein, but will receive the following amounts deposited quarterly into
their Health Saving Account (hereinafter referred to as "RSA" account).
$150 per month for active full-time employee coverage only
$180 per month for active full-time employee and spouse coverage
$175 per month for active full-time employee and children coverage
$185 per month for active full-time employee and family coverage
Spouses of active full-time employees who are eligible for Health Insurance Benefits and/or Dental,
Vision and Term Life with their employer(s), regardless of coverage limits or conditions, must select
and obtain coverage under their employer's plan or plans before they can become eligible for coverage
under any City plan which, if selected, will be secondary insurance.
Effective January I, 2016, all employees and dependents over the age of2 years which are covered by
one the City's Health Insurance Benefits Plans will be entitled to use the employee clinic operated by
HealthStat, Inc. All covered members who elect to use the clinic must conduct an initial health risk
assessment. There is no charge for members covered by the BCBS 500 PPO Plan .. There is a required
co-pay for members covered by the BCBS 1500 RSA Plan.
Effective January 1, 2016 and thereafter; employees or any dependent of an employee covered by the
City's Health Insurance Benefits who uses tobacco products shall be subject to a surcharge of $50 per
employee per month. An employee will be subject to this surcharge for the full calendar year if they or
their dependent is a tobacco user during any part of the year. The employee is subject to repay the
employer for this surcharge if they willfully disregard this rule or fail to properly notify employer.
Effective January 1, 2017 and thereafter; plan participants over the age of 18 and covered by the City's
Health Insurance Benefits shall be required to participate in the City's wellness plan which requires the
participant to undergo an annual Health Risk Assessment administered by HealthStat, Inc. or the
equivalent of same by participant's primary care provider, within the plan year. Plan participants over
the age of 18 who fail to undergo this Health Risk Assessment shall be charged a $20 per month
surcharge in addition to ·the plan premium.
Effective January 1, 2017 and thereafter; active full-time employees covered by the City's Health
Insurance Benefits shall be eligible for a City paid subsidy of $5 per month for individual monthly
dues and $10 per month for family dues participation at the Orangeburg YMCA. Employees must
agree to pay the YMCA dues through payroll deduction at the time of open emollment and must
maintain membership for the full calendar year.
2
Eligibility for Post Employment Benefits
Present Active Full Time Employees last hired prior to June 1. 1993
These employees may be eligible for the continuation of Health Insurance Benefits and Dental and
Vision insurance coverage if they meet one of the following:
a. The employee has 15 years employment with the City and is over age 65.
b. The employee has 20 years employment with the City and is over age 60.
c. The employee has 25 years employment with the City.
d. The employee has 25 years employment with the City Department of Public Safety.
e. The employee has 28 years of service under the SC Retirement System; with at least 15
years of continuous employment with the City.
f. The employee has 25 years of service under the SC Police Retirement System; with at least
15 years of continuous employment with the City.
Present Active Full Time Employees last hired on or after June 1. 1993 and before January 1. 2010
These employees may retire with the City and be eligible for continuation of Health Insurance Benefits
and Dental and Vision if an employee meets the following condition.
a. The employee works 25 years for the City.
State of South Carolina TERI Retirement Program
Years of employment with the City while participating in the TERI program are included in employee
tenure calculation for Post Employment Benefits eligibility.
Active Full Time Employees Retired under the SC Retirement System or SC Police Retirement System
Total years of City employment of an active full-time employee who has retired under either the SC
Retirement System or the SC Police Retirement System are included in employee tenure calculation
for Post-Employment Benefits eligibility.
Retirees with Post Employment Benefits
Retiree Insurance
The following benefits are not available to retirees who during employment with the City, ever made
an election to the 1500 HSA Plan. The City will pay the entire cost of a retired employee's Health
Insurance Benefits being provided active full-time employees of the City once the retired employee
reaches the age of 60 and until th.e employee reaches the age of 65. Prior to reaching the age of 60, the
employee must pay the full premium and cost of his or her Health Insurance Benefits being provided
as an active full-time employee of the City. Retirees of the City will be allowed to participate in Dental
and Vision insurance of the City if permitted by the insurance provider and provided the retired
employee pays the full premium and cost of coverage.
Retirees over the.age of 65 and/or their spouses over the age of 65 are eligible to receive any enhanced
Medicare or Medicare supplemental plan being provided by the City. The City will pay up to $100 per
month towards an HRA for the retiree to be used for insurance coverage and/or for HRA approved
medical expenses for the Retiree and /or spouse. The above City contributions are capped as of January
1, 2013. The City contribution of $100 per month ends upon th.e death of the retired employee,
however, the spouse may elect to remain on the enhanced Medicare or Medicare supplemental plan
being provided by the City with the spouse responsible for paying the entire cost thereof.
The Retirees under the age of 65 are also eligible for the continuation of Health Insurance Benefits and
Dental and Vision for dependents. The retiree will be responsible for the entire cost of the Health
Insurance Benefits dependent coverage and the entire cost of the Dental and Vision retiree and
dependent coverage. Once the retiree attains the age of 65 years, the retiree may continue Dental and
Vision coverage for both the retiree and dependents, but must pay the entire cost of any such coverage.
A Retiree must elect coverage at the time of retirement. Failure to make an election for available
retiree, spouse or dependent coverage upon retirement shall constitute a waiver and forfeiture of all
retiree Health. Insurance Benefits, including Dental and Vision insurance provided by the City.
Retirees ( excluding TERI employees) returning to full time employment with the City will be required
to pay fifty (50) percent of premiums for employee coverage of Health Insurance Benefits, dental and
vision insurance regardless of age of employee or other terms previously expressed in this paragraph.
3
Spouses of Deceased Retirees
Spouses of deceased retirees, who are receiving Group PPO Health Insurance Benefits from the City at
the death of a retiree, may continue the insurance coverage then in existence, and shall continue up to
the age of 65 and shall pay the required premium while covered.
Retirees with No Post Employments Benefits
Employees hired on or after January 1, 2010
These employees upon retirement or termination will not be provided and may not continue any
benefits referred to herein, including without limitation, Health Insurance Benefits, and Dental, Vision
and Term Life.
Election to HSA Plans
Current active full-time employees who elect to be covered under a City's HSA medical insurance
coverage waive any future rights to be eligible for any benefits referred to herein, including without
limitation, Health Insurance Benefits and Dental, Vision and Term Life upon tennination of or
retirement from employment. However, an employee may return to coverage under the standard 500
PPO plan, however all post employment benefits remain forfeited and shall not be reinstated.
Spouse & Dependents, over 65, of Active Full Time Employees, Who Would Qualify as a Dependent
Spouse and Dependents, over the age of 65, of active full-time employees are eligible for the standard
dependent 500 PPO insurance plan or the Medicare Advantage Plus plan. Spouses and dependents
shall be subject to the same restriction for spouse eligibility referred to above if coverage is available at
their place of work.
Active Full Time Employees on FMLA Leave or Long Term Disability
The City will continue to pay the monthly health and dental insurance cost of an employee who is
placed on long-t= disability or Family Medical Leave for a period of three (3) months following the
last month worked. Upon expiration of three (3) month the employee has the option of continuing
health and/or dental coverage (COBRA) at his own expense for a period of 18 months or up to 29
months (if totally disabled as defined by the Social Security Administration). COBRA coverage
ceases once the employee becomes eligible for Medicare or Medicaid.
Dependent medical, dental, vision and life insurance shall remain in force on dependents for a period
of up to three (3) months starting with the month following the last month worked by the employee.
The City will continue to pay the same portion of the dependent coverage in effect while the employee
was an active full-time employee of the City. The employee will continue to pay his porti.on of the
premium for dependent coverage. Dependents will have the same option as an employee of continuing
coverage under COBRA after this three-month period.
The employee or dependent must make arrangements for the payment of the ·employee's portion of the
health insurance benefits premiums for the three-month period to be paid weekly, semi-monthly, or
monthly.
• If COBRA is elected after this three-month period, employee will make full premium payments
the first of each month, payable to the City.
4
City Council Minutes
December 5, 2017
Orangeburg City Council held its regularly scheduled City Council Meeting on Tuesday,
December 5, 2017, at 7:00 P.M., in Council Chambers with Mayor Butler presiding.
PRESENT:
Michael C. Butler, Mayor
Bernard Haire
Jerry Hannah
Charles W. Jernigan
L. Zimm=an Keitt
SandraP. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
A motion was made by Councilmember Stroman, seconded by Councilmember Knotts, to
approve the November 21, 2017, City Council Minutes, as corrected. This motion was
unanimously approved
Ms. Vicki King , Fine Arts Center Director appeared before City Council to provide an update on
the Arts Center Renovations and presented a flyer to Council on what has been happening the
last ten (10) months at the Arts Center.
Ms. King stated, "As you can see from the pictures, we have had the outside of the Arts Center
painted and we will begin renovations on December 18, 2017. Carbra Construction and Design,
Inc., was the low bidder in the amount of $222,444.00. We are in the process of moving out and
we are having a rummage sale currently. We will have a POD onsite for storage during this
time. We hope to have all renovations completed before May, 2018. We will be storing some
items upstairs and we will be putting a new hanging systems upstairs. I came here to, not only
thank City Council, but to provide an update concerning our funds that we have received from
many avenues such as from City Council, County Council, Senator John Matthews and a Grant
from Central Carolina Community Foundation, as well as businesses and local community
members. We would like to thank you for your continued support for the Arts. This has been
about a three year venture and it has begun."
Councilmember Hannah asked, "Will the opening coincide with the Rose Festival?"
Ms. King replied, "We have until June to finish, but she is going to do her best to actually finish
by the Rose Festival. I think that will be a good time to reopen."
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "How many classrooms do you have?"
Ms. King replied, "We have two and a Board Room and we are actually extending the kitchen
for possible receptions and we have used the upstairs for many classes this year as well. All of
the rooms have been utilized."
DPS Director Mike Adams addressed Council concerning the Forensic Services Unit and the
percentage of cases we are processing for the City and other agencies.
He stated, "Of the Latent/ AEFIS cases, 29 .11 % came from outside agencies and of the DNA
cases, 36.28% came from outside agencies."
Dr. Matthew Fitts of the Orangeburg Department of Public Safety addressed Council in regards
to Part II of the Forensic Services Unit at Claflin University. (A PowerPoint presentation was
given.)
Page2
Dr. Matthew Fitts stated, "I know that City Council has seen the budget requests grow for the
Forensic Lab. Some of the standards mandated by the FBI are also where we incur costs. I want
to go over the standards that are mandated and the costs and mention the capabilities of the lab
and at the final end of this presentation, present some ideas for possible revenues for the lab and
the Department of Public Safety.
1bis is a timeline that shows the process to obtain accreditation of the lab. The DNA Act of
1994 established the DNA database called CODIS. There are standards for anyone who wants to
participate in the database from the FBI. The Act requires the following: The Laboratory shall
establish, follow and maintain a documented quality system that is appropriate to the testing
activities and is equivalent to, or more stringent than what is required by these standards. 1bis
system shall be documented in a manual that includes or references elements and we have not
met the elements of, Personnel, Validation, Equipment Calibration and Maintenance and
Proficiency Testing. We have to be compliant in order to be accredited and we also have to be
accredited by an outside agency, which is another set of criteria that we have to be compliant
with. We also have to undergo external audits every two years. Once we are accredited, we will
probably participate in external audits with other agencies. Law Enforcement agencies have to
have a lab with the City's oversight instead of Claflin. Th.e organization and management
requirement is that you have to have two full-time employees who are qualified DNA Analysts.
I am a DNA Analyst and I run a case, all of my work has to be reviewed by another DNA
Analyst, which is a requirement and we have to have at least two qualified DNA analysts and
have to be employed by the local law enforcement agency. In order to participate in the
National DNA database, there are thirteen LOCI that we were participating in the DNA testing
labs and now the FBI have mandated that additional LOCI be added, so the kits had to be
changed so that the interfaces could interact and be mandated. We have to determine if the kits
are reliable and this is part of the budget that we have to validate the kits for the FBI. Both
Analysts have to participate in proficiency testing twice a year, which is again just an added
component to the budget. The facilities when transferring the oversight, we need to determine
whether Claflin has access to the building or who is in charge of the maintenance. Is the City or
Claflin going to be in charge? We need some type of clarification as to who is running the
facility, whether it is a MOU or some type of understanding. On this timeline that I have, we
have just purchased the supplies we need for the validation studies and once we do our
validation, we can start casework. We can then start working on the backlog of cases. We have
to sign up for proficiency testing, have the audit and submit manuals and then apply for the
CODIS eligibility. We have body fluid evidence from crime scenes and we have trace evidence,
touch DNA evidence from the transfer of skin cells and of course known standards from DNA
Profiles. We have our own local DNA database set up and a lot of these crimes are committed
by the same people, so we can start linking those together. There are approximately over 600
cases of backlog we can start on in the lab."
He further explained the costs that are involved in processing DNA Profiles from $42.13 to
$86.14.
Dr. Matthew Fitts explained, "To help us with our costs, I have talked to the head of the SLED
DNA Lab and she stated there are a lot of agencies that want DNA capability. There is no need
for everyone to build a lab. Ours is one of the best in the area according to SLED. Our facility
has the room to acco=odate additional analysts. We can approach other agencies to help fund
the Lab and personnel and maintenance of the Lab. Other agencies could hire an Analyst for our
lab. It is a win-win for everyone and reduces the burden of the City by having them participate.
Once we are accredited, we can get access to $150,000 per year to the DNA backlog reduction
funds. By law, each agency gets these funds."
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "Do you have to be accredited to gain access of these funds?"
Page3
Dr. Fitts replied, ''You do, and on our timeline we are looking to apply in July, 2018, for the
agency to be audited and accredited."
City Administrator Yow stated, "There are a couple other key dates which are validation and the
studies to be completed by the end of March. I would like for the Lab to do quarterly updates as
we go into budget planning sessions."
Mayor Pro Tern Keitt asked, "How long have you been in this position?"
Dr. Fitts replied, "Five years total, four with Claflin and one year at ODPS."
Mayor Pro Tern Keitt asked, ''What is it going to take to get the accreditation done?"
Dr. Fitts replied, "We are not accredited now, I was with SLED for fifteen years and not wanting
to cast stones, I think it was a situation where the costs were not known going in. Grant funds
that we initially had is now gone. Claflin was reimbursed for the building originally."
Mayor Pro Tern Keitt asked, "Do you have the personnel that you need?
Dr. Fitts replie~ "We do not. We need the second DNA Analyst to get this to accreditation."
Mayor Pro Tern Keitt asked, "Do you or do you not, have the employee now?"
Dr. Fitts explained, 'We do not have the employee now., we have someone who is employed by
Claflin part-time and he has other duties at Claflin. I do not have someone full-time."
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "Do you have to be certified to have other Departments send
you evidence?"
.Dr. Fitts stated, "They can send it and we can test it, but it cannot go into the Database and it
cannot be used in court. The agencies are not going to send us any samples unless we are
accredited and the evidence has to be defended in court by an accredited lab instead of an un
accredited lab."
City Administrator Yow stat~ "There was a position requested in their budget and I think it has
been posted. We will need to move some funds to cover it."
Human Resources Director Williams stated that it was posted and there are fifty-one (51)
applications.
Councilmember Haire asked, "Of the six-hundred (600) cas,es, how long will it take to catch up
the back log of evidence?"
Dr. Fitts replied, "Each case would be different. On property crimes, it is an easier process where
we could do more than 10 cases per month. At SLED, we could do 10 cases per month. Ifwe
have paying people, we may have to do their DNA as well."
Councilmember Haire asked, ''What areas are you getting information from that want DNA
evidence tested?"
Dr. Fitts replied, "Charleston wants to build a Lab and that is one agency to approach as well as
the regional and local ones here."
Councilmember Haire asked, "For smaller agencies, wouldn't this be cost prohibitive?"
City Administrator Yow stated, "I think what I envision is a menu of charges for other agencies
that may want evidence tested periodically and I think there are other labs that have this
information. I think we need for them to come back with a progress report in reference to the
budget and costs. The backlog is what is happening at SLED's lab now."
Councilmember Jernigan asked about the qualifications of the DNA Analyst.
Page4
Ms. Williams stated, "They have to be certified in the areas of Biology and Chemistry and have
experience."
Councihnember Jernigan stated, "It must be a real specialized job and I hope you will be able to
find a good candidate."
Mayor Butler stated, "Clafin and Orangeburg Calhoun Teclmical College teach these subjects."
Councihnember Knotts asked, "You asked about clarification on who will run the Lab, what do
you mean by that?"
Dr. Fitts replied, "The City and ODPS will run the facility. It is just the maintenance and who is
responsible for what in the details as far as maintaining the heating and air, etc., and who can
have access to the Lab."
Mayor Pro Tern Keitt asked, "Didn't we do an MOU in the set-up?"
City Administrator Yow replied, "We have done several and several drafts, but we are getting to
a key point on whether we are going into a long-term MOU with Claflin. Council has to be on
board with this and be comfortable in the continuation of the Lab and the business model. We
are trying to get to your answers from the Planning Session about the continuation of the Lab and
the costs. We are going to have to make a decision on the revenues and the business model and
if City Council is willing to continue to fund this Lab. We can do other lab items such as
fingerprints, but we are talking about the DNA Lab."
Mayor Pro Tern Keitt replied, "I am concerned because we are not moving where we should be
with the backlog of cases, when are we going to get to them?"
Dr. Fitts explained, "HopefullybyMarchof2018."
Chief Adams stated, "The six-hundred (600) cases are cases SLED will not process. Property
crimes SLED will not process. Most of these are our cases and unless we do them ourselves,
they are not going to get done. Some of the other agencies are not doing this at all. We are at
crime scenes doing DBA work up and those cases came from our processes instead of not doing
it at all."
Councihnember Jernigan stated, "I personally think the DNA Lab is something we need to get
behind and get it certified as quickly as possible. We are the only City this size that has
anything comparable. I think we need, as a Council, to get behind this."
Ms. Evelyn Disher, Co=unity of Character Director, accepted the Character Trait Proclamation
for December 2017, "Generosity''.
City Administrator Yow explained that Assistant City Administrator Singh will be overviewing a
draft Ordinance for the Bailey Bill which was discussed in Planning Sessions.
City Administrator Yow stated, "I think it is a good draft and I think we can talk about this in the
next couple of weeks."
Assistant City Administrator Singh stated, "The Bailey Bill was passed by the State in 1992 and
its main goal was to provide tax credits for revitalizing old buildings in Downtowns. We have
talked about this before and what we would like to do is bring this to you in January for First
Reading of an Ordinance. We added a sample Ordinance to see what it looks like. Different
cities in the state have this and this is an Ordinance from Hartsville, just as an example. We are
going to have to come up with a matrix on how far we want the tax credits to go and we have to
look at how we need to set it up. The Bill itself allows the property value to be frozen before
renovations and the Bill will allow the property owner to only pay taxes on the pre-value up to
25%. Ideally, we need to pass this along with County Council. It is a great item and we will be
Page5
working toward something in January crafted for Orangeburg."
City Administrator Yow replied, "It can be possibly layered with the Federal and State Historic
tax credits as well."
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Hannah, to approve
the 2017 Facade Grant Awards. This motion was unanimously approved. The Fayade Grant
Awards are as follows:
1. Tea Thyme
2. MartyRae's
3. Sulit-Jennifer Chapman
4. Kenneth E. Middleton
5. Limehouse and Walsh
$ 4,291.92
$10,000.00
$10,000.00
$10,000.00
$6,500.00
Councilmember Hannah asked that we also acknowledge other events other than Christmas. He
passed out a list
of other cultures and their holidays to Council.
There were no utility matters brought before Council.
A motion was made by Mayor Butler, seconded by Councilmember Knotts, to adjourn. This
motion was unanimously approved.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
City Clerk
/p±b
City Council Minutes
December 19, 2017
Orangeburg City Council held its regularly scheduled City Council Meeting on Tuesday,
December 19, 2017, at 7:00 P.M., in Council Chambers with Mayor Butler presiding.
PRESENT:
Michael C. Butler, Mayor
Bernard Haire
Jerry Hannah
. Charles W. Jernigan
L. Zimmerman Keitt
Sandra P. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tem Keitt, seconded by Councilrnember Haire, to approve the
December 5, 2017, City Council Minutes, as distributed. This motion was unanimously
approved.
Mr. Josh Nexsen, Department of Public Utilities Administrative Director, presented a Resolution
to adopt insurance benefits for City Employees for 2018. He stated, "There were no changes in
the Resolution and attachment and the only change is on Page 2 with dental insurance coverage."
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Councilmember Knotts, to approve a
Resolution to adopt insurance benefits for City Employees for 2018. This motion was
unanimously approved.
Mayor Butler read a Proclamation for Observance of National Mentoring Month.
·city Administrator Yow overviewed with Council the vacancies on the Boards and
Commissions. He stated, "This concerns members whose terms are expiring next month and it is
not necessary for Council to take action tonight. You will note the different Commissions and
Boards based on your district for those whose terms are expiring. The ones expiring "At Large"
are usually nominated by the Mayor. Council needs to look at their respective districts and if
you want to re-appoint that person, you can contact them or you can let us know to contact
them .. "
Mayor Pro Tern Keitt asked, "Has anyone been asked to be removed?"
City Administrator Yow responded, "Not that we know of, no one has asked to be taken off.
Some of these Boards have been pretty active this year. I just wanted to bring this to Council's
attention to give you time to look at it and ask any questions."
Mr. Fred Broughton, Chairman of the Accommodations Tax Committee, addressed Council in
. regards to the Accommodations Tax Advisory Committee Recommendations. He stated, "The
· Committee met on Monday, December 1, 2017 with $37,700.00 to be allocated. We received
requests from four agencies. Among them, the Chamber was designated as lead agency. They
are as follows:
Orangeburg County Fine Arts Center - Signage and Showcase Promotions
Orangeburg County Chamber of Commerce -- Tourism/Promotional Items
Hillcrest Golf Course - Promotion and advertising of the Golf Course
Parks and Recreation - Promotion of vocal, musical and dance, Arts Festival
Total
$10,000
$ 6,950
$ 3,000
$ 1,000
$20,950
Everyone was funded their requested amounts and the remaining funds will be carried over until
next year."
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "What happens with the leftover money?"
Mr. Broughton replied, "It will be carried over until next year's requests."
Councilmember Hannah asked, "How much is left over, $7,000?"
Mr. Broughton stated, "Approximately $17,000."
City Administrator Yow stated, "It is possible that Council could ask the Committee to reopen
. the process for other requests later in the year."
·iA motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Hannah, to approve
the recommendations from the Accommodations Advisory Tax Committee. This motion was
unanimously approved.
City Administrator Yow asked Council, "Due to the next Council meeting being on January 2,
2018, which is the day after New Year's and people may be traveling out of town, we would
like to ask Council to consider canceling the January 2, 2018, meeting. Due to timing of other
possible events, it may be necessary to call a special meeting on January 9, 2018."
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Councilmember Knotts, to cancel
the Tuesday, January 2, 2018, City Council Meeting. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Stroman, second by Councilmember Haire, to enter into
-.
an Executive Session for (I) Legal Matter -- GKN Contractual Matter, (2) Contractual Matter -- __ _;
Former First Citizens Bank Building - temporary use of 1099 Russell Street and (3) Economic
Development Matter -- Project Recycle.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
Respectfully sub
a
Carn
City
/pfb
_ _J
City Council Meeting
Special Minutes
January 9, 2018 2685
Orangeburg City Council held a Special City Council Meeting on Tuesday, January 9,
2018, at 12:00 Noon in Council Chambers with Mayor Butler presiding.
PRESENT:
Michael C. Butler, Mayor
Bernard Haire
Jerry Hannah
Charles W. Jernigan
L. Zimmerman Keitt
Sandra P. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
A motion was made by Councilmember Stroman, seconded by Councihnember Haire to
enter into an Executive Session concerning:
Legal Matters:
A. GKN Contractual Matter
B. Intergovernmental Agreement
Municipal Court/Orangeburg County
This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councihnember Haire and seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt to
return to Open Session. This motion was unanimously approved.
Mayor Pro Tern Keitt made a motion to give Mayor Butler authorization to appoint a
temporary Municipal Court Judge. This motion was seconded by Councilmember Haire
and was unanimously approved.
A motion to adjourn was made by Councihnember Haire and seconded by
Councihnember Knotts. This motion was unanimously approved.
/Inn )
> >
-, \_,....."'-. .. ·,.:... .. ._.1
·,/\/,~ '--....'''J
Source: City of Orangeburg website. First collected Oct 13, 2026.