Minutes
City of Orangeburg · Orangeburg County · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Orangeburg
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
WHEREAS,
WHEREAS,
WHEREAS,
RESOLUTION
Franklin D. Haigler faithfully served the City of Orangeburg"s
Department of Public Works for twenty-eight years with a
retirement date of November 23, 2015; and,
he, through his long and faithful service , contributed greatly to the
successful operation of the City of Orangeburg' s Department of
Public Works; and,
the City Council, in recognition of the fine contribution rendered the
City of Orangeburg, wants to inscribe on the records its
appreciation.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the Mayor and Members of Council.
in Council assembled, do officially recognize the faithful service rendered to the City of
Orangeburg in the capacities in which he served the City and we take pride in commending him for
a job well done.
-BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that a copy of this Resolution, in appreciation for his
devotion of duty to the City of Orangeburg, be placed in the Minute Book of the City and a copy
furnished to Mr. Haigler in recognition of his services.
PASSED BY the City Council of the City of Orangeburg, State of South Carolina , this
ninetieth day of January, 2016.
_,., ~
C);/?~ -
~,._ 6?. 4?~1frl
/ ,,,/
~~ <. _,.
-2, ,<X\'-~z_ \- ~ ~-m~-
\_ MEMBERS OF COUNCIL
2492
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
January 5, 2016
Orangeburg City Council held its regularly scheduled meeting on Tuesday, January 5, 2016, at
7:00 P.M., in Council Chambers with Mayor Butler presiding.
PRESENT:
Michael C. Butler, Mayor
Charles B. Barnwell
Charles W. Jernigan
Bernard Haire
L. Zimmerman Keitt
Sandra P. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell , seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, to approve
the December 8, 2015, City Council Minutes as distributed. This motion was unanimously
approved. The December 15, 2015, City Council meeting was canceled.
Ms. Evelyn Disher accepted the Character Trait Proclamation for January 2016, "Wisdom".
City Administrator Yow addressed Council in regards to the body cameras for the Public Safety
Department. He stated, "As you know we went over this in budget sessions and determined
there was a need for body cameras and it was adopted in this year's budget."
Chief Adams addressed Council. He stated, "We have a public confidence crisis and using body
cameras can restore faith. Our employees at DPS are enthusiastic about the cameras and this will
aid in the prosecution of cases. We went through a testing and evaluation phase and the Taser
International Cameras are top of the line. They are rugged, very good resolution , good night
vision as well as sound and offer three mounts. We looked at another camera that was cheaper
and was within budget but we later determined that there were software problems and corruption
in the software. We feel the Taser camera is a better product . These cameras are state of the art
and can be worn on the lapel, glasses or collar. This system has a replacement policy as well,
where we get equipped with new cameras in 2.5 years and in 5 years. The video is downloaded
at the end of each shift and Taser stores the data in the Cloud . With the replacement of these
cameras, we can stay ahead of the technology curve. I feel this is the best system for us and I
will answer any questions ."
Councilmember Haire asked, "Are the cameras different and is there a standard recommendation
as to where the cameras should be placed on the officer?"
Chief Adams replied, "We are in the process of developing our policy that will be Commission
on Accreditation for Law Enforcement Association (CALEA) as well as approved by the Law
Enforcement Training Council. The camera is the same and there are three different mounts. I
think it would depend on the officer as to which mount he/she will use depending on the
visibility. Most will probably use the glasses mount that comes with Oakley ballistic glasses.
Any of the mounts will be able to catch all video."
Councilmember Barnwell asked , "Will these cameras be running all the time?"
Chief Adams replied, "All cameras have an on and off switch and they will be running when in
contact with the public, traffic stops , etc."
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "Do these work like the in car video cameras?"
Chief Adams stated, "They work very similar to the in car video cameras and we will continue to
have redundancy. They will not automatically download like the in-car video cameras, they will
have to be docked in order to download and the retention period will be 60 days."
Councilmember Jernigan asked , "Who will have access to the videos?"
Page 2
. 2493
Chief Adams replied. "The Director, Deputy Director , Command Staff and the Evidence
Custodian only. This is in acco rdanc e to CALEA standards and the in-car video is the same.''
Councilm ember Jernigan asked, "Wha t about FOIA as it relates to the video s, like we sometimes
see on television? ''
Chief Adams replied , "I wi ll be attending some training as it relates to body cameras and J am
sure this will be covered, but I believe some areas of the video are not subject to FOIA. "
Councilmember Jerniga n state d, "l believe that this is state mandat ed when we attended some
sessions at the MASC Annual Meeting ."
Chief Adams stated, "There is a Law Enforcement Body Camera Fund and we can apply for
reimbursement. I do not know what formula they are using or if we will get any mone y back,
but we will do the paperwork along with the City Admini strator and Assistant City Administrator
to get this starte d. As of right now , no one has gotten any funds."
Counci lmember Jernigan stat ed, "At our meetings, the repr esentatives there stated all you had to
do is ask for it."
Councilmember Haire asked, "If the cameras are not runn ing all the time, do you project saving
money toward s the data cost? Also, if you have vacancies, how does this relate to the num ber of
cameras?' '
Chief Adams replied, "We are ordering 80 cameras and we have 79 sworn position s. We have
some vacancies, but I am optimi stic that we will have some good candidates comi ng in. The
storage is more than adequate and we shou ld not have a problem with storage. If we need
additional storage, it is readily available. We have three terabytes per year and each year
thereafter. We can also review older footage and purge that if needed ."
Chief Adams stated, "We are looking at this as a sole source becau se when you look at this
packa ge, Taser can provide us with the upgrades , repairs and replacement polic y, no one else
compares. The IT Division agree s with the DPS staff that this is the best camera system for us.'·
Councilmember Barnwell asked, "This is lease purchase? "
Chief Adams stated, " Yes and at 2.5 years, we get new cameras and at 5 years, we get new
cameras .''
City Administrator Yow stated, "We would be examining our options for the future in year 4.''
Councilm ember Jernigan made a motion authorizing the City Administrator to purch ase body
cameras for the Public Safety Departm ent in the amount of $103,135.82, seconded by
Co uncilmernber Barnwell. This motion was unanimously approved.
Assistant City Administrator John Singh addressed Council. He overviewed the current
Downtown Facade Grants and the process. He stated, "Th e Committee met mid -December and
we had $90,000 .00 in requests in our latest round and the Committee had a little over
$50,000 .00. Out of the total in grants we are lookin g at, there will be $209,000.00 in private
monies going toward these projec ts. We are leveraging gran t money and having private money
coming in. We are meeting with the awardee s on Thursda y. We wanted to let you know it is
very successful. We would like to increase this budget to $100,000.00. There are many people
who want to apply. The Facade Grant last year made some good improvem ents to buildings.' '
Mayor Butler replied, "I was downtown today and I was very impressed and a lot of owners were
talking about the grant and how they benefited from it. I think it is a good thing."
Page3
City Asl[npHt~tor Yow stated, "If Council would approve this, we would bring you back an
amend~'llri~t like we usually do to amend the current year budget."
Councilmember Stroman asked, "Where is this money coming from?"
City Administrator Yow stated, "From the fund balance in the 2% Fund. This is budgeted in the
2% Fund. It is not in the General Fund.,'
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "What is the average of businesses participating in this grant?"
Assistant City Administrator Singh replied , "I would say about 35 to 40%. We have had positive
feedback that it is not complicated and invoices are sent in and we generally turn the money back
around in about 10 days."
City Administrator Yow stated , "One person that participated last time thought ahead that he
may get another Facade Grant and purchased another building in anticipation of getting another
grant."
Assistant City Administrator Singh stated, "If you look down Russell Street toward Palmetto
Office Supply, the buildings look great."
A motion was made by Councilmember Stroman, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, to approve
amending the Facade Grant budget to $100,000.00. This motion was unanimously approved.
DPU Manager Tommy Miller brought to Council, as information, regarding the weather in
December and the reduction of rates. He stated, " We have had the warmest December on record
since 1954. This has affected our bottom line and we would like to also announce a second rate
reduction in the last year to reflect lower power supply costs. The Orangeburg Department of
Public Utilities will implement a rate reduction to reflect lower projected fuel costs from its
principal electricity supplier , South Carolina Electric and Gas Company. The reduction will
equal approximately $4.0 million over the next twelve months. This is the second power supply
cost reduction in the last twelve months due to lower fuel costs; rates were reduced $4.4 million
in June, 2015. DPU's rates automatically adjust to reflect changes in its power supply costs. The
pass through of this cost reduction will be reflected in a reduction in energy charges for all the
DPU's customers . A typical residential customer's monthly bill will decline $4.52 or $54.00,
over the next 12 months. The changes will be reflected in bills dated after January 1, 2016.
DPU Manger Tommy Miller states, "Natural gas prices have dropped below $2 per million BTU;
the last time prices for natural gas was this low was over fifteen years ago. Lower customer
demands due to a mild winter and historically high levels of domestic natural gas production
have contributed to these prices. As a part of DPU 's long term power supply agreement entered
into with SCE&G on January 19, 2011 , SCE&G forecasts its fuel costs each year. SCE&G
changes the rate it charges DPU for fuel costs once a year in May based on this forecast. DPU lowered
power supp ly rates in June 2015, based on this forecast. DPU Manager Miller indicated that based on the
current market and other information available from SCE&G , we anticipate a further reduction by
SCE&G when it performs its next forecast and rather than wait, DPU is lowering the prices now to reflect
the current lower fuel prices . A second component of the price that DPU pays for its electricity related to
the cost of SCE&G ' s generating facilities . This component has been fixed under the terms of the power
supply agreement since January I, 2013, and will not change until SCE&G ' s V.C. Summer Unit #2 goes
online some time in 2919 ."
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Haire, to adjourn . This
motion was unanimously approved.
There being no further busine ss, the meeting was adjourned .
A RESOLUTION TO SUPPORT THE MUNICIPAL ASSOCIATION
2016 LEGISLATIVE ADVOCACY INITIATIVES
BE IT RESOLVED,
WHEREAS,
WHEREAS,
WHEREAS ,
WHEREAS ,
WHEREAS,
WHEREAS,
WHEREAS,
WHEREAS,
WHEREAS,
cities and towns in South Carolina are the government closest to the
people providing the core services residents and businesses demand
for an exceptional quality of life; and,
hundreds of municipal officials from across the state collaborated to
identify challenges at the municipal level; and,
these challenges can be addressed through a comprehensive approach
that includes changes to state law, training from experts , research and
collaboration with stakeholders; and,
the Municipal Association identified five advocacy initiatives based on
the feedback from local officials including streamline business license
processes , fund services , embrace the sharing economy , fix roads and
clear blight; and,
looking at and continuing innovative and efficient business licensing
practices that support local economic growth ; and,
cities and towns need dependable and consistent revenue sources to
support the efficient and effective delivery of municipal services that
residents and businesses demand for a positive quality of life and
econom ic prosperity ; and,
new business models are changing the way consume rs and businesses
connect and interact on a daily basis; and,
repairing and maintaining existing roads and infrastructure is about
encouraging and supporting statewide economic development with
infrastructure that can accommodate new industry and support existing
industry ; and,
dilapidated structures pose a public safety threat in municipalities of all
sizes; and,
the City of Orangeburg supports the agenda set forth by the Municipal
Association of South Carolina Board of Directors for city and town
councils to govern effectively and efficiently ;
BE IT, THEREFORE, RESOLVED that the Council of the City of Orangeburg affirms on this 19th
day of January , 2016, its support for the Municipal Association 's 2016 advocacy initiatives for the
state's 270 cities and towns.
DONE AND RATIFIED THIS 19th DAY OF JANUARY, 2016.
fflchlc.J:JL
~ MAYOR'
MEMBERS OF COUNCIL
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
January 19, 2016
2495
Orangeburg City Council held its regularly scheduled meeting on Tuesday, January 19, 2016, at
7:00 P.M., in Council Chambers with Mayor Butler presiding.
PRESENT:
Michael C. Butler, Mayor
Charles B. Barnwell
Charles W. Jernigan
L. Zimmerman Keitt
Sandra P. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
ABSENT:
Bernard Haire
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to approve
the January 5, 2016, minutes as distributed. This motion was unanimously approved.
Public Works Director Durwood Bowden and Mayor Butler presented Mr. Franklin D. Haigler a
Resolution and watch for his twenty-eight (28) years of service to the City. Director Bowden
read a list of all the items that Mr. Haigler worked on during his tenure with the City.
Mr. Andrew Silver of Piedmont Companies Inc., addressed Council in regards to funding of
utilities extension at the Orangeburg Charter School for Health and Science Professions on
Magnolia Street. He presented a slide show on the project.
He stated, "I would like to go over our vision, reality, location, benefits, and development cost
and a request for assistance."
He introduced Ms. Angel Malone, Director of the Charter School. She stated, "I do want to say
the Mission of the High School for Health Professions is to improve student achievement
through rigorous academic instruction supplemented by innovative teaching, interactive learning
and professional mentoring to give students a competitive edge throughout their high school,
college and professional years. That is our mission statement that our kids know . We started in
2011 with a vision and a dream and there were local citizens, who along with Orangeburg
Consolidated School District 5, performed a work force study for jobs of what would be the
competitive jobs in the local area and one of them was health professions. This was the vision
and this would feed into the pipeline and we partnered with Orangeburg Calhoun Technical
College to make this happen. Through this vision, we now have a school with the first
graduating class this year . We are at 89% capacity. I can say we have a waiting list for 9th
through 11
1
h grades. With people that have been supportive, we have been able to form
partnerships with the Medical University of South Carolina, Charleston Southern University,
Cornell University, South Carolina State University, Claflin University, and Orangeburg
Calhoun Technical College. The instructional staff is there and we are busting out the seams, so
it is time for us to move ."
Mr. Silver stated, "Piedmont decided to assist with this Charter School and we did look at
locations. We wanted to come into the City, but there was just no available property. It is my
passion to re-generate the City. We then looked at various locations and chose a site on
Magnolia Street of thirty-four 34 acres. Since this was coming off of I-26 and could open up a
pathway to the City center, we felt like this would bring you past the traffic lights. This location
is by the Regional Medical Center, Orangeburg Calhoun Technical College and various other
institutions and restaurants. We have a vision that the schools will create an educational campus
on both sides of the road. The benefits of this location would be a new destination with
commercial retail and offices. The daytime population is expected to be 1,000 people. The job
creation would be 100 jobs. This will generate retail businesses because we do not want people
to go to Columbia; we want them to stay here. The development is on both sides of the road.
Pagc2
On?~ide is 25.89 acres which would be the Health Professions Charter School (8 acres),
Felton Lab"Charter School (10 acres) and Commercial and Retail (7.89 acres). On the west side,
there is 8.37 acres which would be commercial and retail. The Health Professions Charter
School construction cost is $6 million , Felton Lab Charter School construction cost is $7 million
and the Retail and Commercial construction cost is $8-$ IO million and the land was just over a
million dollars. As you can see, Piedmont is investing over 25 million in this area. The O'Cain
Construction Company , a local contractor, is currently doing the site prep work. We have come
to you to request assistance on the infrastructure on the site. As you can see, the estimated
construction cost of water and wastewater is $138,747.50 . We would like to partner with the
City of Orangeburg for assista nce in this infrastructure. Can you help us please with the initial
infrastructure? Time is of the essence and we need to move forward ."
Councilmember Barnwe ll asked, "Wha t student s are there?"
Mr. Silver replied , "N inth through twelfth grades."
Councilmemb er Barnwell stated, "I have a problem with this, this is a Charter School. We
already have two and every student that goes out of the district , the state fund s are decreased and
the taxes have to increa se which is the last thing we need. One thing that I do not want is to
charge our taxpayers more money when we take students out of the publ ic school s. I spoke with
the Superintendent of School District 5 today."
Ms. Malone replied, "I would like to respond. We are a public charter school that is sponsored
by the local school district so the money remain s in the district. The only thin g we offer is, if
they want a specific career in health profes sions. It is a public school and it is for any child that
wants to come. The money stays in the district and it is governed by School District 5."
Councilm ember Barnwell stated, "Acc ording to the superintendent , they will lose money."
Ms. Malone stated, "It depends on how the school is set up. If you are funded as a state charter
school district , then the money will follow the child as in any school transfer. But, when you are
sponsored by the local school district , it stays within the local school district. "
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "Is this going to be a new school?"
Ms. Malone replied , "No, our school would relocate there and expand. The curriculum would be
the same."
Counci lmember Jernigan asked, "Whe re does your funding come from?"
Ms. Malone replied , "Mos t of our funding is generated through state local funds within the
district."
Counc ilmemb er Jernig an asked, "These student s are selected how?
Ms. Malone replied, "They are not selected. We have open enrollment and there is an appl ication
process. Every child in School District 5 is eligible to apply. We take 100 students per grade, up
to 400 for the school.''
Counc ilmember Jernigan asked, "Are the stude nts enro lled in the Charter School or are they
enrolled in Orangeburg-Wi lkinson or another school?"
Ms. Malone replied , "They are our students in the Charter School."
Counci lmcmber Jernigan asked, "Your curricu lum is desig ned to help with health professions?
What docs that have to do with their genera l education?"
Page3
. 2497 Ms. Malone replied, "They do take the regular general education classes and the health
professions are electives. Some of them even take college classes during their last two years in
high school."
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "Would this in any way take students away from Orangeburg
Calhoun Technical College"
Ms. Malone replied, "No , actually we have some students who have transitioned to Orangeburg
Calhoun Technical College. We have some students who have finished up their courses and are
enrolling in the nursing program without having to wait."
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "Does it cost any more for a student to go to the Charter School
than Orangeburg-Wilkinson School."
Ms. Malone replied , "No, it is free."
Mr. Silver stated, "I am asking for the City to assist with the infrastructure, it will be new people
and jobs. I hear your concerns, but we have got to look at the big picture. We anticipate
spending over $25,000,000 in the next three years. I don't think we need to isolate the negatives
and focus on the future benefit."
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "You are asking the Department of Public Utilities to do this
infrastructure at the cost shown and we are to absorb that cost through them? Mr. Miller, can
DPU legally do this?"
DPU Director Miller replied, "In the DPU General Terms and Conditions, it states that it has to
be paid for by the customer both direct and indirect. We will pay for the gas and electric; he is
asking for water and wastewater .''
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "This would go to our DPU customers as a pass through?"
DPU Director Miller stated, "Yes ."
Mayor Butler stated, "We appreciate you coming and we are going to take this under
advisement."
City Administrator Yow addressed Council in regards to the endorsement of the Municipal
Association of South Carolina Legislative Agenda through a Resolution. He stated, "Each year
the MASC issues advocacy issues that represents the best interests for the cities. I want to
briefly touch on those issues. One of them is funding services. They are asking for the
Legislature to fully fund local government as set by statute. Also, a change in the State Budget
Proviso is recommended to take out the municipal funding of Indigent Defense. MASC is asking
for support of legislation promoting the sharing economy. Another initiative is the repairing
and maintenance of existing roads and support legislation that municipalities have a direct voice
in how local "C" Funds are distributed. Another initiative is to support the passage of the
Dilapidated Structures Act as well as simplifying the process of collecting liens in code
enforcement cases. Another is to streamline business license processes. As you know,
Representative Quinn introduced over a year ago, proposed legislation that would hinder a cities
ability to deliver vital services. There have been discussions on a portal where persons across
the state could take out licenses only on renewals. Please convey to our local Delegation that we
appreciate the support that they give cities. We would prefer no proposed Bills to interfere with
Home Rule."
Councilmember Barnwell asked, "What did you say about the Indigent Defense?"
Page 4
City ~Sra tor Yow replied, "If you remember, last year there was a budget proviso that
made municipalities contract with the Public Defender's Office for services. We know that
ticket fines go to Indigent Defense and County taxes also pay for indigent Defense. Our
residents pay a percentage of county taxes as well. This is asking for the Budget Proviso to be
removed."
Councilmember Jernigan stated, "I think MASC does an excellent job in their work with the
Legislature and it does concern me at times when the state wants to get involved in municipal
business . The Legislature is the one that passed Home Rule and then they pass Bills that
interfere with Home Rule . Fortunately, we have the MASC, which is a good voice to get that
across."
City Administrator Yow replied, "An example is where Council already decided to purchase
body cameras and now we will have to come up with $40,000 annual recurring costs. But, the
State Legislature passed legislation requiring cities to have body cameras, which is an unfunded
mandate.
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell , seconded by Councilmember Stroman, to
approve the endorsement of the Municipal Association of South Carolina Legislative Agenda.
This motion was unanimously approved.
City Administrator Yow addressed Council in regards to an appointment to the Planning
Commission. He stated, "As you know Mr. Don Tribble, a long standing member of the
Planning Commission has resigned. It is necessary to appoint someone for the remainder of his
unexpired term ending January, 2018. This is an "at large" nomination that is generally
nominated by the Mayor."
Mayor Butler stated, "I nominate Shirlan Jenkins for this position." The vote was unanimous.
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "Will she also have to go through training?" Assistant City
Administrator Singh stated, "Yes ."
Parks & Recreation Director Shaniqua Simmons addressed Council in regards to vaca ncies on
the Accommodations Tax Committee. She stated, "We have had some vacancies since 2014 that
have not been filled . I have contacted several people to see if they would serve on the
Committee; the only one that I have gotten a response from is Ms. Beth Thomas of the Fine Arts
Center. She has agreed to serve in the "cultural sector", and this will give us five out of seven
position s. We will be having a meeting soon and this should give us a quorum. We currently
have requests in."
City Adminis trator Yow stated, "We do have to submit a report to the State, so we need to get
this vacancy filled so that the Committee can meet."
A motion was made by Councilmember Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to
approve the appointment of Ms. Beth Thomas to the Accommodations Tax Advisory Committee
for a four(4) year term ending March 2018. This motion was unanimously approved.
City Administrator Yow addressed Council concerning vacancies in various Commissions whose
terms have expired. He stated , "There is no action to be taken tonight and, if you wish for us to
contact any of these persons in your district to see if they are interested in serving again, please
let Ms. Blackwell know in my office. If not , we will be prepared for nominations for the first
meeting in February."
DPU Manager Miller addressed Council. He stated, "The terms of three (3) members of the
Grievance Committee will expire and all employees have agreed to be reappointed.
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Knotts, to
reappoint Ms. Tara Rivers to the DPU Grievance Committee. This motion was unanimou sly
approved.
Page 5
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Knotts, tcg,499it
Mr. Willy Wearing to the DPU Grievance Committee. This motion was unanimously.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to
reappoint Ms. Dawn Collins to the DPU Grievance Committee . This motion was unanimously
approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Stroman, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, to enter
into an Executive Session concerning the purchase of real property at the corner of Henley and
Gibson Streets. Council will not be returning to open session; therefore, the meeting was
adjourned.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
/pfb
A R ESOLU TION TO DECLARE FEBRUARY 2016
AS "CITIES MEAN BUSINE SS" MONTH
WHEREAS,
WHEREAS ,
WHEREAS,
WHEREAS,
WHEREAS,
cities and towns are the economic engines of South Carolina ; and,
the partnership between local officials and business leaders is critical
to the new knowledge economy and future of regional workforce
development ; and,
cities and towns offer a positive quality of life that attracts business,
industry and new jobs to the region; and,
success of the state relies upon the economic success and prosperity
of hometowns; and,
"Cities Mean Business" month celebrates that cities and towns are
committed to a strong and positive relationship with local business
leaders.
NOW, THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED that the Mayor and City Council of the City of
Orangeburg , South Carolina, affirms on this day, February 2, 2016 , its dedication to
businesses that operate in this hometown and its commitment to the economic success
and competitiveness of South Carolina and is proud to declare February 2016 as,
"Cities Mean Business Month"
in the City of Orangeburg.
PASSED BY the City Council of the City of Orangeburg , State of South Carolina , this 2nd
day of February 2016.
Members of Council
2500
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
February 2, 2016
Orangeburg City Council held its regularly scheduled meeting on Tuesday, February 2, 2016, at
7:00 P.M., in Council Chambers with Mayor Butler presiding.
PRESENT:
Michael C. Butler
Charles B. Barnwell
Charles W. Jernigan
L. Zimmerman Keitt
Sandra P. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
ABSENT:
Bernard Haire
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, to approve
the February 2, 2016, Minutes as distributed. This motion was unanimously approved.
Ms. Evelyn Disher accepted the Character Trait Proclamation for February 2016, "Courage".
A motion was Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Stroman, to approve the
Resolution for" Cities Mean Business". This motion as unanimously approved.
Parks and Recreation Director Shaniqua Simmons addressed Council in regards to the
recommendations from the Accommodations Tax Advisory Committee. She stated, "The
Committee met on January 281h and received $13,500.00 in requests. We only have $5,400.00 to
disburse, so the recommendations are as follows:
The Committee recommended that the Chamber of Commerce be designated Lead Agency.
Orangeburg County Chamber of Commerce requested $6,000.00 for tourism and promotional
items and the Committee recommended $1,500.00. Orangeburg County Chamber of Commerce
for the Festival of Roses requested $5,000.00 for promotion of the Festival and the Committee
recommended $2,400.00. Orangeburg County Fine Arts Center requested $1,500.00 for
promoting the Festival and Showcase Orangeburg and the Committee recommended $ I ,000.00.
Parks and Recreation Department requested$ I ,000.00 for the promotion of music and dance for
the Rose Festival and the Committee recommended $500.00."
Councilmember Barnwell asked "Where is this money coming from?"
City Administrator Yow replied, "It comes from the State Accommodations Tax monies."
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, to approve
the recommendations of the Accommodations Advisory Tax Committee. This motion was
unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Jernigan, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, approving
the reappointments of Carroll Joye (District #I), John Smith (District #2), Lamar Tisdale
(District #4) and Tonzel Shuler (District #6) to the Aviation Commission to serve another four
(4) year term ending January , 2020. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Knotts, approving
the reappointments of Jesse Eargle (District 3), William R. Evans, Jr., (District #4) and John H.
Wolfe (District #6) to the Planning Commission to serve another four (4) year term ending
January, 2020. This motion was unanimously approved.
Page2
2501
A motion was made by Councilmember Knotts, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt. approving
the reappointments of Tom Salley (District #2), Desiree Chavis (District #4) and Johnny Byrd
(District #6) to the Board of Zoning Appeals to serve another four ( 4) year term ending January,
2020. This motion was unanimously approved.
Department of Public Utilities Manager Miller addressed Council in regards to a first Reading of
an Ordinance for the adoption of proposed new and amended water and wastewater rates
effective April L 2016.
He stated, "We are proposing to increase water and wastewater rates for all customer classes. As
you will recall. all of our rates were discussed with you in all of our budget workshops and
budget approval meetings. We probably spend more time discussing water and wastewater rates
than any of the others. The last time water and wastewater rates were increased was in April
2014, which was two years ago. We did not propose a change in them last year. So, I am
appearing before you this evening requesting your approval of a first reading of an Ordinance to
increase water and wastewater rates. I am proposing to increase water rates by about nine
percent (9%) across the board. Inside City water rates will go $13.00 to $14.00 per month. The
South Carolina average for 2015 is $26.00. Even after the proposed DPU increase, residents of
Orangeburg will still only be about half of what residents of other cities in South Carolina pay
for water service on a monthly basis in 2015. Outside City water will go from $25.00 to $27.00
a month. The South Carolina average is $40.00. Rural residential rates are $31.00 to $34.00 per
month , still well below the state average for outside city customers. We are proposing to
increase wastewater rates by about fifteen (15%). Most of this increase is related to the
wastewater treatment plant upgrade that will be completed October, 2016. Inside City
wastewater rates will go from $17.50 to $20.00 a month . The South Carolina average is about
$39.00. Just like the water rates, even after the proposed DPU increase, residents of Orangeburg
will still only be paying about half what residents of other cities in South Carolina pay for
wastewater service on a monthly basis. Outside City Wastewater rates will go from $32.00 to
$37 .00 per month. The South Carolina average is $59.00. While we never like to raise rates,
these increases are needed to cover our increasing costs and the capital improvements that will
allow us to continue to offer our customers quality service. The rates we are proposing are still
among the lowest in the State of South Carolina."
Council member Barnwell asked, "Didn 't we just give back to the citizens money on Electric?"
DPU Manager Miller replied, "Yes , In June, 2015 and in January, 2016, we gave back over
$8,000 ,000.00 which averaged $8.50 per month decrease."
Councilmember Stroman stated, "I have no problem with a rate increase, but I hear from people
every day that are on a fixed income and I feel for these people."
DPU Director Miller stated , "It is the cost of doing busin ess and to meet regulations and our
chemical costs have doubled due to rain. It is supposed to rain one inch tomorrow and I feel sure
the chemicals will go up tomorrow due to the rain. It is an expensive operation."
Mayor Butler stated, "As it relates to what is going on in Flint, Michigan, we need to keep our
water purified and clean."
DPU Director Miller stated, "We arc very fortunate to have a clean water source here.''
Mayor Pro Tem Keitt stated , "I hate to raise rates, but it is needed in order to keep the City
running."
Councilmember Stroman stated, "We raised electric rates this year, taxes and fire contracts, we
have had three increases."
DPU Director stated, "We incr eased the electric, but we decreased it twice."
~502
Councilmember Barnwell asked, "It is my understanding that the wastewater and water will be in
the red in September if we do not have these increases in place, is that right?"
DPU Director Miller replied, "Yes, our projections show we will be losing money by
September."
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, to appr0ve
the First Reading of an Ordinance for the adoption of proposed new and amended water and
wastewater rates for DPU effective April 1, 2016 . This was a 5-1 vote as Councilmember
Stroman opposed .
A motion as made by Counc ilmemb er Stroman, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to enter
into an Executive Session. This motion was unanimously approved.
Council will not return to Open Session .
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
Respectfully submitted,
Q&~\ , ~u~
Carrie W. Jo
City Clerk
/pfb
A RESOLUTION AMENDING PAGE 9 OF THE CITY OF ORANGEBURG
PERSONNEL HANDBOOK DATED MARCH 1, 2007, TITLED HIRING OF
RELATIVES.
WHEREAS, the previous Personnel Handbook of the City of Orangeburg had an
effective date of September 6, 1988 with revision dates of November 15, 1988, May 2,
1989, December 5, 1989, January 16, 1990, April 3, 1990, and May 15, 1990, and
WHEREAS, the existing personnel policy and handbook of the City of
Orangeburg was adopted by Resolution dated March 1, 2007, and
WHEREAS, in the process of revising the personnel policy in 2007 "son-in-law"
and "daughter-in-law" were inadvertently omitted from the definition of "immediate
family" and City Council now wishes to correct said error.
NOW THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED BY THE CITY COUNCIL DULY
ASSEMBLED, this 16th day of February, 2016, page 9 of the Personne l Handbook of
the City of Orangeburg dated March 1, 2007, titled "Hiring of Relatives" is hereby
amended and after amendment shall read as follows:
"Persons in the same immediate family may not be employed
or continue to be employed in the same department or division if one
directly or indirectly supervises the other or interacts with the other in the
handling of money , compensation or personnel records. Immediate
family is defined as spouse, parent, child, grandparent, grandchild , brother
or sister, parent-in-law , grandparent-in-law , brotl1er-in-law, sister-in-law,
son-in-law and daughter-in-law . The immediate family is also considered to
include step-parents , step-children , step-brothers and step-sisters when
the employee and the step-relat ive have lived together regularly in the same
household. Unrelated employees residing together or otherwise engaged in
an apparently romantic relationship (such as domest ic partner, co-habitant
or significant other) are treated as being within the immediate family of each
other for the purposes of this nepotism policy. Members of the immediate
family of elected officials of the City are not eligible for City emp loyment.
If employees become related by marriage and create a situation
prohibited by this policy, one of the employees may be asked to give up his
position. If the employees cannot choose which of them it will be, the
employee having the lower budgeted annual compensation may be removed.
The removed employee may be considered for other positions within the
City for which he is qualified .
Situations not specifically addressed in this policy which , in the City's
opinion, create a conflict of interest or give the appearance of a conflict of
interest, will be handled in the City's discretion ."
AND IT IS SO RESOLVED.
Members of Council
C:\Documents and Setlings\ J mes F. Wa lsh.MAIN\Desktop\Beth's Documents\City or O'burg\Reso lutions\Personnel Hiring of Family
2 5.16.wpd
A RESOLUTION TO APPOINT MEMBERS TO THE 2016 CAPITAL PROJECT SALES
AND USE TAX COMMISSION CREATED BY THE COUNTY OF ORANGEBURG
WHEREAS, S.C. Code Ann. §4-10-300, et. seq. (Capital Project Sales Tax Act)
authorizes the imposition of a one (1 %) percent sales and use tax, subject to a
referendum, for the purpose of funding capital projects within the County of
Orangeburg ; and
WHEREAS, S.C. Code Ann. §4-10-320 authorizes the creation of a
Capital Project Sales and Use Tax Commission; and
WHEREAS, the City of Orangeburg is entitled to the appointment of two (2)
members to said Commission.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ~SOLVED BY ORANGEBURG CITY COUNCIL
DULY ASSEMBLED , on this the "/L day of February , 2016 that the City of
Orangeburg hereby appoints John H. Yow, City Administrator and John D. Singh,
Assistant City Administrator to the Orangeburg County 2016 Capital Project Sales and
Use Tax Commission pursuant to the above §4-10-320 .
AND IT IS SO RESOLVED.
. \
RESOLUTION
A RESOLUTION FOR THE CITY OF ORANGEBURG, DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC
UTILITIES TO ACCEPT THE LOW RESPONSIVE, RESPONSIBLE BID BY
UTILITY SERVICE COMPANY, INC. OF PERRY, GEORGIA IN THE AMOUNT OF
$448,200.00 FOR THE REPAIR AND REPAINTING OF THE BOLENTOWN AND
LIMESTONE ELEVATED WATER TANKS
WHEREAS, the Department of Public Utilities of the City of Orangeburg, South Carolina,
received bids on February 4, 2016 for the repair and repainting of the Bolentown and
Limestone Elevated Water Tanks; and
WHEREAS, the low responsive, responsible bid for this work was submitted by Utility
Service Company, Inc. of Perry, Georgia in the amount of $448,200 .00; and
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, by the Mayor and Members of Council of the
City of Orangeburg, in Council assembled, and by authority of the same, that the low
responsive, responsible bid of Utility Service Company, Inc., in the amount of $448,200 .00
be accepted; and
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED , that 0. Thomas Miller, Manager of the Department of
Public Utilities, be authorized and he is hereby directed to accept said bid and execute the
contract documents on behalf of the Department of Public Utilities of the City of Orangeburg.
RESOLVED BY City Council duly assembled this K day of March , 2016.
2 " L-~'-J(__ ~ ~~~
MEMBERS OF COUNCIL
RESOLUTION
A RESOLUTION ESTABLISHING AND AGREEING TO PARTICIPATE IN
THE LOWER SA VANNAH REGIONAL HOME CONSORTIUM
WHEREAS, the Congress of the United States has enacted the Cranston-Gonzales National Affordable
Housing Act of 1990 (hereinafter the "Act'') which created the Home Investment
Partnerships Program (hereinafter the "Home Program") to provide funds to states and local
governments for affordable housing assistance with the flexibility to decide what kind of
housing assistance or mix of housing assistance is most appropriate for local needs: and,
WHEREAS, the City of Orangeburg has affordable housing needs; and,
WHEREAS, the City of Orangeburg desires to increase affordable housing opportunities for its present and future
residents, particularly for very low-income persons; and,
WHEREAS, the City of Orangeburg desires to enter into affordable housing development activities which arc
directed toward the above general purposes, and for those reasons, wishes to seek such federal
funding as may be available to it pursuant to the Act; and,
WHEREAS, the City of Orangeburg desires to enter into the affordab le housing activities and has determined that
joint action with other units of local governments that choose to participate in accordance with the
"Inter-Governmental Agreement Establishing the Lower Savannah Regional Home Consortium'' the
terms of which are incorporated by reference and such relevant HUD regulations and requirements
as may now or hereafter be in effect would benefit the City of Orangeburg.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED , that the Mayor and City Council, in Council duly assembled, authorize John H.
Yow, City Administra tor of the City of Orangeburg to sign the "Inter-Governmental Agreement Establishing the
Lower Savannah Regional Home Consortium FY 2017-2019" on behalfofthe City of Orangeburg, as \vcll as all other
documents necessary to f01m the Consortium and to carry out and fulfill its purposes for FY 2017-2019.
ADOPTED BY the City Council of the City of Orangeburg, State of South Carolina, this 1st day of March 2016.
Members of Council
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
February 16, 2016
2503
Orangeburg City Council held a Public Hearing on Tuesday, February 16, 2016, at 7:00 P.M., in
Council Chambers with Mayor Butler presiding.
The purpose of the Public Hearing was to adopt new and amended water and wastewater rates
for the Department of Public Utilities.
Ms. Nellie Mae Dunning of 160 Tucker Street addressed Council. She stated, "I am on a fixed
income and I cannot afford these increases in water rates."
Mayor Pro Tern Keitt stated, "It is hard on everyone, but there is a need for increasing. We
know that there are a lot of people on fixed incomes and it is hard for them to get their
medicines. When it comes to a need for the City, and that includes everybody , we know a lot of
people are talking about it and we don't want to do it, but we have to. This is a need from the
Department of Public Utilities. Remember, we are giving back on the electric side, so we are not
really increasing the water and wastewater."
Ms. Dunning asked, "Why did you go up again?"
Councilmember Barnwell stated, "It was two years ago."
Mayor Pro Tern Keitt stated, "We are not having the growth that we need."
Ms. Dunning asked, "Why is the trash $12.00 per month?"
Mayor Butler stated, "We have to stay on the topic of water and wastewater rates, but if you call
Public Works, they can assist you."
Department of Public Utilities Director Miller stated, "The rates are going up $1.00 per month,
which is $12.00 per year, which is a small increase compared to other areas. I wish we didn't
have to do it, but it is a need. Our chemical costs are increasing each day with the rain. Our cost
to operate our water system is very expensive. I promise you, I hate to ask for an increase."
Mayor Butler stated, "The City is obligated to keep clean drinking water for our citizens. We do
not want what is happening in Flint, Michigan to happen here."
Hearing no other comments, the Public Hearing was closed.
Council entered into the regular scheduled City Council meeting.
PRESENT:
Michael C. Butler
Charles B. Barnwell
Bernard Haire
Charles W. Jernigan
L. Zimmerman Keitt
Sandra P. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to approve
the February 2, 2016, City Council minutes as distributed. This was a 6-0-1 vote.
Councilmember Haire abstained, as he was not present at the last meeting.
Chief Adams stated that there are two individuals present to speak to Council in regards to the
wrecker rotation rates.
Mr. Mike Pooser of 455 Kings Ridge Drive addressed Council. He stated, "I own Pooser's
Service Center and have been in business since 1974. I have been told that the rates have not
been increased in eleven ( 11) years for those on wrecker rotation. Right now the present rate is a
maximum charge of $75.00. We are asking Council to increase that rate to a maximum of
$150.00 . The SC Highway Patrol rates are up to $200.00 and $30.00 per day storage.
Page2
2504
Orangeburg County Sheriffs Department rates are up to $175.00 and a $30 .00 per day storage.
We are proposing that the City rates be increased to up to $150.00 plus $30.00 per day storage.
Disabled cars would not fall under this rate , this is only for wrecks or late night calls. If I am
going to continue on the rotation list, I pay our employees that come out at night Y2 of that call.
Presently, $37.50 will not get an employee out of the bed at night at 3 o'clock in the morning.
The first rollback I bought was $19,000.00. I checked in December and they range from
$95,000.00 to $125,000.00. The last time I purchased a rollback , I bought two of them totaling
$130,000.00 for two. Now, that is the price for one. I am asking Mayor and Cou ncil to adjust
the rates."
Mayor Pro Tern Keitt asked, "How many of you are on the wrecker rotation list?"
Department of Public Safety Director Adams stated, "I have been contacted by these wrecker
companies and we looked at the rates . We had a meeting at DPS and all the wrecker serv ice
companies attended and we came up with a rate that they could all agree to. For mechanical
breakdowns, the maximum is $120.00. So this is just for wrecks or after hour 's calls. These are
maximum fees, I can tell you that Mr. Pooser does not really charge the maximum amount if he
can help it."
City Administrator Yow stated, "We will get you a list of all of those on the wrecker rotation. "
Council member Jernig an asked, "How many calls per complete rotation?"
DPS Director Adams stated, " We investigate twelve to seventeen traffic accidents in a week. It
takes about two weeks to go through a complete rotation. Then the wrecker goes to the back of
the list."
Councilmember Jernigan asked, " What determines who is on each agency's rotation list?"
DPS Director Adams replied, "Each agency has their own wrecker rotation. If an individual
requests a certain wrecker, then we call that company."
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "What other kinds of calls do you get?"
Mr. Pooser stated, "We get disabled calls and a Class A during regular business hours is $45.00 .
What we are referring to is wrecks , overturned vehicles or a vehicle in an embankment."
Councilmember Haire asked, " Have you checked with other cities to see what their rates are?"
DPS Director Adams replied, "We went to the local market and SC Highway Patrol, Troop 7
covers many counties. A comparable City would be Waterboro and we can check with them. "
Mayor Butler asked, "If you have a disabled car and it needs to go to Columbia, what do you
charge?"
Mr. Pooser replied, "If it is during regular business hours, we charge per mile . If it is after hours,
it is a different rate. We pay the employee more after hours."
Councilmember Jernigan stated, "These guys are investing in their businesses and investing in
the City and are providing a service to the citizens. These rates need adjusting and they need to
be increased and I am in favor of that.
Mr. Mack Stillinger of Stillinger· s Inc., on 301 South addressed Council. He state d, "We handle
heavy duty wrecks where a truck may be over-tuned, this is what we specia lize in. The Heavy
Duty wreckers cost about $350.000.00 to $500 ,000.00 . We are asking for an increase to
Page3
$350.00 per hour, the State charges $400 per hour with a $50.00 per day storage . W~
tractor trailers are over-turned , we have to respond quickly in order to get the roads back open.
There are only two or three big wreckers on this list."
Councilmember Haire asked, "What are you charging now?"
Mr. Stillinger stated, "It depends on the truck, an average is $3,500 .00 - $5,000.00 and a
container is $1 ,250.00 to $1,500.00. If the product is on the ground, we have to clean it up by
hand."
Councilmember Haire asked, "How does our Ordinance address these types of calls now?"
DPS Director Adams replied, "$150.00 per hour."
City Administrator Yow asked, "If there are any other questions, please give them to me, we will
make sure we have all that information for you."
City Administrator Yow stated, "I am handing you what our current Personnel Handbook states
in reference to this Resolution amending the handbook. I was asked to put this before Council to
amend this policy. Attorney Walsh has prepared a new Resolution to address what should be in
the policy that must have been left out in the last revision in 2007. It does not have under the
hiring ofrelatives, daughter-in-law and son-in-law in the current language. This is for your
consideration ."
Councilmember Barnwell asked, "Mr. Walsh, is this retroactive from a constitutional
standpoint?"
Attorney Walsh replied, "That would be up to Council. If you see the last paragraph in our
present policy, it states - Situations not specifically addressed in this policy which, in the City's
opinion, create a conflict of interest or give the appearance of a conflict of interest, will be
handled in the City's discretion- that is kind of open."
Councilmember Barnwell stated, "I talked to Steve Savitz and he said it could not be
retroactive ."
City Administrator Yow stated, "This Resolution does not address retroactive."
Councilmember Jernigan asked, ''Would this cause anyone in the City to lose their job?"
City Administrator Yow stated, "I can't answer a legal question, I can only tell you how I would
interpret the Ordinance."
City Attorney Walsh stated, "It does not say it is retroactive."
Councilmember Jernigan stated, "So, you can't go down your list and say this is his brother-in
law and now he is out?"
City Administrator Yow replied, "No, not in my opinion, but that is a legal question."
City Attorney Walsh stated, "What I am trying to say is that it is Council's decision, Council can
tell us what to put in there, effective as of a certain date."
Councilmember Jernigan stated, "I would like to make a substitute motion to put a specific date
on the Resolution when it will go into effect." This motion was seconded by Councilmember
Page 4
Barn~Q-{,e vote was 3-4. Councilmembers Knotts, Haire and Mayor Pro Tern Keitt and
Mayor Butler opposed. The substitute motion did not pass.
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, on the
Resolution amending Page 9 of the City of Orangeburg Personnel Handbook dated March 1,
2007, titled hiring of relatives. The vote was 4-3. Councilmembers Barnwell, Jernigan and
Stroman opposing. The motion passed.
City Attorney Walsh stated, "As far as from a legal standpoint, there is some implication here
between the City Administrator and the Manager of DPU as far as an effective date."
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "What is wrong with having an effective date on it? Why can' t
we put a date on it?"
Mayor Pro Tern Keitt stated, "We are just voting on the Resolution. "
Mayor Butler asked, "Do we have to put an effective date on it?"
City Attorney Walsh stated, "It is normai that it is effective the date it passes."
Mayor Butler stated, "We said it was not retroactive."
Councilmember Haire stated, "If there is more tweaking to be done, then we will address it"
Councilmember Stroman asked, "What are we doing again and why is it coming about?"
City Administrator Yow replied, "I was asked by a Councilmember to put this on the agenda
because this was left out in the revisions from 2007 ."
Councilmember Barnwell asked, "This means that it is effective tonight going forward?"
City Administrator Yow replied, "It is my understanding it is effective tonight. We apply this
going forward."
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Stroman, to approve
a Resolution to appoint members to the 2016 Capital Project Sales and Use Tax Commission
created by the County of Orangeburg. This motion was unanimously approved. City
Administrator John H. Yow and Assistant City Administrator John D. Singh will serve as
members on the Commission.
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Councilmember Knotts, to approve
for City Administrator Yow to enter into an Agreement for Victims of Crime Act Program Grant
No. 1 V14134. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, to approve
the Second Reading of an Ordinance for the adoption of proposed new and amended water and
wastewater rates for the Department of Public Utilities effective April 1, 2016. The vote was 6-1
with Councilmember Stroman opposing.
Department of Public Utilities Director Miller addressed Council. He stated, "I was asked by a
Councilmember to ask for an amendment to Section C, Water (1,2,4) and Section D, Wastewater
(1,2) of the General Terms and Conditions. This would authorize a waiver of water and
wastewater taps, impact fees and fire service taps for the County of Orangeburg and
municipalities within the County of Orangeburg."
Councilmember Barnwell made a motion to table this Ordinance to give DPU time to come up
with expenses so we will know what type of money is being talking about. He stated, "I think we
need to discuss." This motion was seconded by Councilmember Stroman.
Page S
DPU Director Miller stated, "That number would not be the same in every situation . 12S{J7
on the size of the tap and other factors."
Councilmember Barnwell stated, "Could you give us some figures or examples?"
DPU Director Miller stated, "Sure, I can do that."
Councilmember Stroman asked, "Is that legal?"
City Attorne y Walsh stated, "Yes , if the Terms and Conditions are changed."
Councilmember Haire stated, "There is a motion on the floor and I would like to speak to that
motion. I am somewhat concerned and I asked for this to be put on the agenda as well that we
are trying to form a relationship with the County. It is my understanding that there is an
opportunity to have some fees waived and right now this is not a way to do this . You mentioned
Mr. Miller about the fees?"
Councilmember Haire stated, "My thought was to have the fees waived for governmental
entities ."
DPU Director Miller stated, "It states that all fees, water, wastewater and fire service taps for
County of Orangeburg and municipalities ."
Councilmember Haire stated, "In my talking, this will form a better relationship with the Count y
and I think at times we need to work better with the County. At this time I will make a motion to
accept the First Reading of an Ordinance amending Section IV, Department installations, Section
C. Water (1.), (2.), and (4.) and Section D., Wastewater (1.) and (2.) of the General Terms and
conditions of the Department of Public Utilities as presented . This motion was seconded by
Councilmember Knotts .
A vote was taken on the motion made by Councilmember Barnwell , seconded by
Councilmember Stroman, to table this item until further information can be given to Council
from DPU on costs. The vote was 3-4, with Councilmembers Knotts , Haire, Mayor Pro Tern
Keitt and Mayor Butler opposing.
Councilmember Jernigan asked , "Does this change, what does it do? An entity wants a fee
waived, does it come before Council to waive or not? So, it is not automatic? "
Mayor Butler stated , "Ye s."
Mayor Pro Tern Keitt stated , "I am glad to see this , we need to move fast and move forward."
Councilmember Barnwell stated, "My reason for tabling this is if this costs the City $500,000,
where is the money going to come from? The taxpayers are going to have to pay for it. That is
not right just to accommodate the City or County . We need to have figures brought before us
and we are here to make money for the City and not to keep increasing taxes. I don't know what
the problem would be to have Mr. Miller advise us on the costs. Why should we jump into
something without due consideration of the costs?"
Councilmember Haire replied, "The Ordinance says "May" and not "Will", and you can't
determine the costs because you don't know what the impact fees are."
Councilmember Barnwell replied, "ls that correct , Mr. Miller ?"
Director Miller stated, "Yes, there is a lot that goes into it."
City Administrator Yow stated, "On each request, we will bring it to you for discussion."
Page 6
Mayl,$08eitt stated, "It will give us the opportunity . when you get them, to bring them to us
and we can decide. We can't let anyone do anything."
A vote was taken on the motion by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Councilmember Knotts ,
on the original First Reading of an Ordinance amending Section IV, Department installations,
Section C. Water (1.), (2.), and (4.) and Section D., Wastewater ( 1.) and (2.) of the General
Terms and Conditions of the Department of Public Utilities. The vote was 5-2 with
Councilmembers Jernigan and Barnwell opposing.
A motion was made by Councilmember Stroman, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to
enter into an Executive Session for a (1) Legal Matter concerning property Maintenance Code -
orders to demolish property of Kenneth Middleton, Earl Brooks, Mural Properties, LLC , (2) a
Personnel Matter concerning an Employee Grievance - Department of Public Utilities,
Wastewater Division. This motion was unanimously approved.
Council did not return to Open Session.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
/pfb
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
March 1, 2016
Orangeburg City Council held its regularly scheduled City Council Meeting on March 1, 20~,StQ~o P.M., in
Council Chambers with Mayor Butler presiding .
PRESENT:
Michael C. Butler, Mayor
__ Charles B. Barnwell
Bernard Haire
Charles W. Jernigan
L. Zimmerman Keitt
Sandra P. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Keitt, to approve the March I,
2016, City Council Minutes as amended. This motion was unanimously approved.
Mr. Tommy Miller, Manager of the Department of Public Utilities, Mr. Wade Holmes, Director of the Electrical
Division and Mr. Mike Bombard, Supervisor in the Electrical Division, presented Laura Nichols with a
Resolution and a gold watch for her twenty-two years, nine months and three days service with the City.
Ms. Evelyn Disher accepted the Character Trait Proclamation for the month of March, 2016, "Endurance ."
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Keitt, to approve a Resolution
establishing and agreeing to participate in the Lower Savannah Regional Home Consortium . This motion was
unanimously approved. Two duplexes will be built on Peasley Street.
Department of Public Safety Director , Mike Adams addressed Council. He stated , "I appreciate you looking
at the Ordinance to adjust wrecker rates in the City of Orangeburg. We expect these wreckers to be available
24/7, have reliable equipment , be insured and have a large liability policy and we also require them to respond
in a timely manner. They should be on call and ready to respond. We demand a lot from these wreckers. The
rates have not been increased for over eleven years. We have looked at various other agencies including the
City of Walterboro and we are equal to or considerably less than these agencies. I ask that you give this due
consideration ."
City Administrator Yow stated, "Anyone who is in a wreck has the right to ask for a wrecker of their choice."
DPS Director Adams stated, "That is correct, it can be the owner 's request."
Councilmember Barnwell asked, "If they do not follow the rules and regulations or do not respond, do you
remove them from the list?"
DPS Director Adams stated, "Absolutely . If we call you and you do not respond , we can do so. Each company
is inspected by the Special Operations Division and if they do not pass the inspection, they are not allowed on
the wrecker rotation list."
Mayor Pro Tern Keitt asked, "Do you have people who want to call someone else?"
Department of Public Safety Director Adams replied, "Yes, we do."
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "Are they responsible for the clean-up of the scene?"
DPS Director Adams stated, "Yes, they have to clean up glass, parts and anything else on the scene."
Mayor Butler stated, "It was an eye opener to me that the driver gets one-half the fee at night."
Councilmember Stroman asked, "According to the original Ordinance, after eight hours you start charging for
storage. I see the City of Walterboro is after twenty-four hours. I see that the rates are higher for storage
though . It doesn't address the hours; it only states $30.00 per day."
Page 2
City Admt~fij Yow stated, "Cou ncil can make that change if you want it."
Co uncilmember Stroman state d, "I recommend it."
DPS Director stated, "I think that i s fair."
Councilmem ber Stroman stated , "A lot of people lose their car due to high storage."
DPS Director Adams stated , "We have cars towed and the wreckers have a liab ility incurr ed, you are
responsible . Ther e have been cars broken into at the wrecker lots."
Mayor Butler stated, "If it is your car, it is your responsibility . The $30.00 storage fee is good compared to
other places."
Councilme mber Barnwell stated, "I thin k you should give them twenty-four hours, someone may be hurt and
can' t get to their car."
City Administrator Yow stated, "There is no time set for storage, Council can direct the time whe n the storage
begins, eight hours, twenty-four hours or something else. You can make that ame ndment. "
Councilmembe r Keitt amend ed the First Reading of an Ordinance amending Section 9-15.4, 9- 15.6, 9-15.7,
9-15.8 and 9-15.10 titled R otation Eligibility, Wrecker Rotation Operating Procedures, Wrecker Service
Responsibilities, towing and storage charges and indemnification, respectively, for storage fees to begin after
twenty-four hours, seconded by Counc ilmemb er Barn well and unanimou sly approve d.
Counci lmember Haire nominated Mr. Michael Stroman for an alternate vacancy on the Buildin g Board of
Appeals. This was seconded by Councilmember Knott s.
Counc ilmembe r Barnwell asked, "What are his qualific ations?"
Councilmember Haire stated, "He is a contractor, married and has three children. He graduated from South
Carolina State University in 1981 in Industrial Education and has been a contractor for fourtee n years." The
vote was unanimou s.
DPU Director Miller addre ssed Cou ncil. He stated, "I ask for third and final readi ng tonight of an Ordinance on
the amendment of water and wastewater rates for all customer classes. The last time we ame nded our water
rates were two years ago. Water w ill be a 9% increase for all classes and wastewater will be a 15% increase for
all classes. A typical residenti al customer will see about a $ 1.00 increase per month ."
Counc il member Jernigan asked, " Is it not true that one of the reasons for the increa se is because water and
wastewa ter haven't been showi ng a profit and we are losing customers? "
DPU Director Miller stated, Yes, we are projected to lose money by September. The revenues are down and
the cost of chemicals and operations are increasing trem endously."
Councilmemb er Stroman asked , "If you are selling less water, aren't you treating less water?"
DPU Director Miller stated, "The problem with that is we have a thirty million gallon plant and it costs to
maintain and operate whether you sell one gallon or ten million gallons. It is fixed costs."
Councilmember Barnwell stated, "Let's not forget we had the rebate on electric."
DPU Director Miller stated, "We reduced the electric $4.4 million last Jun e and $4 million in January, whic h
resulted in about $8.50 decrease per month."
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell , seconded by Counc ilmemb er Keitt, to approve the Third
Read ing of an Ordinance for the adoption of proposed new and amended water and wastewater rates for DPU
effec tive April 1, 2016. This was a 6-1 vote as Council member Stroman oppo sed.
DPU Director Miller addressed Council on the Secon d Reading of an Ordinance amending Section IV ..
Department Installations, Section Water (1.), (2.) and (4.) and Section 0., Wastewater (1.) and (2.) of the
General Term s and Condi tions of the Dep artment of Public Utiliti es.
Page3
Councilmember Jernigan stated, "I am against this Ordinance, we just increased water and w~tl rates and
we have lower revenue in these divisions. This Ordinance is giving away revenue when we are waiving a tap
fee. I think that is counterproductive. It is hard enough on the citizens in Orangeburg when we raise rates.
This is making it harder for the citizens of Orangeburg because we are giving away revenue at DPU. If my
understanding is right, a water tap could cost as much as $25,000, is that correct?"
DPU Director Miller stated, "Yes, for a fire service tap."
Councilmember Jernigan stated, "That is in this Ordinance that we can waive that fee, that is one example. I
think that is putting a burden on taxpayers in the City. This puts us in a position that we have to raise taxes. 1
am not in favor of this at all."
Councilmember Barnwell stated, "I feel the same way. We are taking money from us. The County has given
us nothing. We are giving up actual money. We raise rates and then we are taking away from DPU. DPU will
end up hurting and then cannot transfer money to the City."
Councilmember Haire asked , "Mr. Miller, do the tipping fees and impact fees have anything to do with rates?"
DPU Manager Miller replied, "Tipping fees have nothing to do with water."
Councilmember Haire asked, "Does it have anything to do with City taxes?"
DPU Manager Miller replied, "No."
Councilmember Haire stated, "Why are we trying to muddy up this? I see nothing wrong with trying to work
with municipalities and the County. I see nothing wrong with better relations . If the County has to pay for it,
we still have to pay for it in taxes. We shouldn't be narrow-minded to say, the Count y can tax, but we
;houldn't. I believe that it allows us an opportunity, it doesn't say we will, it says we may."
- -Nlayor Pro Tern Keitt stated, "I am for this to see us grow. It is going to take this type of opportunity to bring in
new industries. If we are able to give them a waiver to get jobs in here, I am for it. We have to be more liberal
with working with other municipalities. This can open up roads and opportunities. We are not growing, we are
staying stagnant."
Councilmember Barnwell asked, "What has the County done to help the City?"
Councilmember Haire stated, "The County decreased the tax on airplanes at the Airport."
Councilmember Stroman stated, "The County did decrease the tax rate on airplanes and they are working with
us on a fire tax district . I think we need to move forward with this. There are too many houses for sale and too
many businesses closing."
Councilmember Jernigan stated, "The lowering of the taxes on the airplanes is not revenue for the City anyway.
The County was getting all of that revenue to begin with. It didn't affect the City. If you happen to live in the
City, it would. I am glad to see the County does that, as far as it affected us financially, it didn't help. This
Ordinance will actually take money from the Department of Public Utilities and the water and wastewater
divisions . I don't feel like Mr. Haire, that I am muddying up the water. I know you feel that way about it, but
that is getting kind of personal and I don't like to get my personal feelings involved in Council. I resent the fact
~hat you would say something like that and direct it to Council."
t\ motion was made by Councilmember Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Knotts , to approve the Second
Reading ofan Ordinance amending Section IV., Department Installations, Section Water (1.), (2.) and (4.) and
Section D., Wastewater (1.) and (2.) of the General Terms and Conditions of the Department of Public Utilities .
This was a 5-2 vote as Councilmembers Jernigan and Barnwell Opposed
Councilmember Haire asked DPU Manager Miller, "When a business moves in or out, are fees charged to the
new business for taps?"
DPU Manager Miller stated,"Not if they are already paid ."
Page 4
A motion w~~y Councilmember Haire, seconded by Councilmember Keitt, to approve a Resolution to
accept the lo~re~sive, responsible bid by Utility Service Company, Inc., of Perry, Georgia, in the amount of
$448.200.100 for the repair and repainting of the Bolentown and Limestone elevated water tanks. This motion
was unanimously approved . This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Stroman, seconded by Councilmember Keitt, to enter into an Executive
Session for a Legal Matter concerning property of Kenneth Middleton, Earl Brooks, Mural Properties, LLC. and
a Personnel Matter concerning an Employee Grievance with the Department of Public Utilities. This motion
was unanimously approved .
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell , seconded by Councilmember Keitt, for Council to return to
Open Session.
Council returned to Open Session.
A motion was made by Councilmember Keitt that the decision of the Grievance Committee upholding the
termination of the employee be reversed. The employee shall be reinstated to employment in his previous
position in the Wastewater Division of the Department of Public Utilities as of the date of his termination with
back pay calculated from said date. This motion is based upon the fact that the insubordination of the employee
was caused by the confusion created when the meter readers transferred to other positions were required to sign
an agreement duplicating portions of his or her job description. This implied that the signing of the agreement
was required before same was enforceable. All jobs of the Department of Public Utilities and job descriptions
require an employee to perform any and all tasks required by members of management regardless of division or
position. Failure to comply with any such directive is insubordination and grounds for termination. This motion
was seconded by Councilmember Barnwell. This was a 6-1 vote as Councilmember Jernigan opposed.
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell to adjourn.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
Respectfully submitted,
WHEREAS,
WHEREAS,
WHEREAS,
RESOLUTION
Lavern Davis faithfully served the City of Orange burg's Parks and
Recreation Department for forty-three years, five months and
sixteen days with a retirement date of March 16, 2016; and,
he, through his long and faithful service, contributed greatly to the
successful operation of the City of Orangeburg's Parks and
Recreation Department; and,
the City Council, in recognition of the fine contribution rendered
the City of Orangeburg, wants to inscribe on the records its
appreciation.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the Mayor and Members of
Council, in Council assembled, do officially recognize the faithful service rendered to the City of
Orangeburg, as a Maintenance Worker 11 for the Parks and Recreation Department, in which he
served the City and we take pride in commending him for a job well done.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that a copy of this Resolution, in appreciation for his
devotion of duty to the City of Orangeburg , be placed in the Minute Book of the City and a copy
furnished to Mr. Davis in recognition of his services .
PASS ED BY the City Council of the City of Orangeburg, State of South Carolina, this
191h day of April 2016.
o§~~
~ ,- 1, ""'-~L ~ ~~- -
MEMBERS OF COUNCIL
WHEREAS,
WHEREAS,
WHEREAS,
WHEREAS,
RESOLUTION FOR FAIR HOUSING
the City of Orangeburg desires that all its citizens be afforded the
opportunity to attain a decent, safe, and sound living environment; and,
the City of Orangeburg rejects discrimination on the basis of race,
religion, color, sex, national origin, disability and/or familial status in the
sale, rental or provision of other housing services; and,
the State of South Carolina enacted the South Carolina Fair Housing Law
in 1989: and,
April is recognized nationally as Fair Housing Month.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, that the Mayor and City Council of the
City of Orangeburg, South Carolina, in Council assembled, do officially recognize April as
"Fair Housing Month"
Passed By the City Council of the City of Orangeburg, State of South Carolina, this 5111 day of
April 2016.
ATJEST:
(!_~,__~ &~c/~
~ ,, \'\;.,-\_ '- ~~----
MEMBERSOCO
A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE EXECUTION AND DELIVERY OF A LEASE
AGREEMENT WITH ATTACHED PAYMENT SCHEDULE, PROJECT FUND
AGREEMENT AND RELATED INSTRUMENTS, AND DETERMINING OTHER
MATTERS IN CONNECTION THEREWITH.
BE IT RESOLVED by the governing body of the City of Orangeburg (the ·'Lessee"). at a duly called
meeting of the governing body held on the 5th day of April, 2016. the following resolution was
introduced and adopted:
RESOLVED, whereas the governing body of Lessee has determined that a true and very real need exists
for the acquisition of Equipment as described in the Request for Proposal and Exhibit "A'' attached
hereto, in the amount of $1,557,792.00 at an annual interest rate of 0.98% for four (4) years , by entering
into an Lease Agreement with South State Bank as Lessor and the City of Orangeburg as Lessee (the
'·Agreement") according to the terms set fmth in the Bid Proposal from South State (Exhibit " B''). The
Equipment will be used by the Lessee for the following purpose : To provide new and cost efficient
equipment for the operation of City government.
RESOLVED , whereas the governing body of Lessee has taken the necessary steps, including any legal
bidding requirements, under applicable law to an-ange for the acquisition of such equipment.
RESOLVED, whereas the governing body hereby directs its legal counsel to review the Agreement and
negotiate appropriate modifications to said Agreement so as to assure compliance with state law and local
statutory law prior to execution of the Agreement by those persons so authorized by the governing body
for such purpose.
BE IT RESOLVED, by the governing body of the Lessee that the terms of said Agreement are in the
best interests of Lessee for the acquisition of such equipment and the governing body of Lessee
designates and confirn1s the following person(s) to execute and deliver, and to attest, respectively, the
Agreement and any related documents necessary to the consummation of the translations contemplated by
the Agreement.
Name and Title of Person(s) to Execute and Attest Agreement:
John H. Yow, Citv Administrator and Carrie W. Johnson, Citv Clerk
RESOLVED , the Lessee covenants that it will perform all acts within its power which are or may be
necessary to insure that the interest portion of the rental payments coming due under the Agreement will
at all times remain exempt from federal income taxation under the laws and regulations of the United
States of America as presently enacted and construed or as hereafter amended. The Lessee hereby
certifies that it has not issued or effected the issuance of, and reasonably anticipates that it shall not issue
or effect the issuance of more that ten million dollars (10,000,000.00) of tax-exempt obligations during
the calendar year, and hereby designates the Agreement as a "qualified tax exempt obligation'', as defined
by Section 265 (b) (3) of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986, as amended.
Passed by the City Council of the City of Orangeburg, South Carolina this 5th
day of April, 2016.
fl 6 rj=.J I fl#-, r ichael C. Butler
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
March 15, 2016
2513
Orangeburg City Council held its regularly scheduled City Council meeting on March 15, 2016,
at 7:00 P.M., in Council Chambers with Mayor Butler presiding .
PRESENT:
Michael C. Butler, Mayor
Charles B. Barnwell
Bernard Haire
Charles W. Jernigan
L. Zimmerman Keitt
Sandra P. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
City Administrator Yow introduced the new Hillcrest Manager, Mr. Jeff Ruth to City Council.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to approve
the March 1, 2016, City Council Minutes as distributed. This motion was unanimousl y
approved.
Mr. Charles Way, South Carolina State University Chairman of the Board of Trustees addressed
Council. He stated, "I am from Orangeburg and I am coming before you tonight and you know
the history of South Carolina State University. I have been in this job since May of last year.
The Legislature appointed a new Board last year and I was elected Chairman. SCSU did not
tend to their business in 2007 -2009 as other Colleges and Universities did with the economic
downturn with cutting programs and services that were not needed, SCSU did not. We have a lot
of debt and a lot of deferred maintenance. We are trying to move forward, but are holding on
with our thumbs trying to get the ox out of the ditch. SCSU owes a great deal of money; we
have whittled that down substantially. We owe the State $18 million dollars . I appeared before
the House Subcommittee on Higher Education and they did a proviso to help us erase those
debts. On Thursday, I am appearing before the Senate Subcommittee on Higher Education and
hopefully they will help us also. There was a joint proviso in the Legislature to help SCSU; we
are a state agency just like the Department of Health and Environmental Control and the South
Carolina Department of Transportation . The State, we hope, is going to help us. We have other
needs. We have a fourteen (14) story building , the tallest building in Orangeburg County with
four-hundred ( 400) beds that we cannot use due to health concerns. It needs a $5 million dollar
renovation. We have many items like that. We have a balanced budget and a surplus which is
unheard of, but we have all of these past debts and deferred maintenance . We need help. I am
asking help from the City and the County this month with our streets and sidewalks. It will cost
about $1 million dollars to repair these streets and sidewalks. (Mr. Way handed out pictures of
potholes, barricaded areas and road issues) As you can see, they are pretty deplorable . What I
am asking is that if you can please help us, I would request along with the County for help. If
City Council can help us and allow the County and City Administrator to see what you can come
up with in cash, labor or materials. The SACS accreditation is coming up and five professors are
coming to our campus on April 12-14. We have to prove to a five member visitation team that
we have our problems under control. There were nine (9) deficiencies and four (4) were
academic and five (5) were financial. SCSU has been on probation for two years and we could
lose our accreditation and then have to close down because we would lose our financial aid. We
have to prove to SACS that we have a good financial situation . The new Board inherited this."
Councilmember Haire asked, "These pictures, are they a result of steam under the road?"
Mr. Way referred the question to Mr. Ken Davis, Consulting Engineer , and he stated that those
pictures are due to heavy rains and storm drainage.
Page 2
Cout2S1ti2fer Barnwell stated , "Mr. Way, I am not sure that a municipality can give money to
a state ownectinstitution. I will have to get our attorney to check on that."
Mr. Way stated, ''There are 512 employees that work in the City and it must be a way."
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "Is SCSU totally responsible for their streets and maintenance?"
Mr. Way replied, "Yes , SCSU is a closed campus due to safety and we are responsible."
Mayor Butler asked, "As a point of information , if the State wipes your debt you owe, the last
thing that would be left is this maintenance?"
Mr. Way replied, "No, we have a ton of deferred maintenance totaling about $30 million dollars.
Truth Hall is $5 million dollars . We are trying to get money for this and that. It is a tough job
and we can't cure it all, we need help. We did not create this problem."
Councilmember Haire asked Attorney Walsh, "Can we research Mr. Barnwell ' s question, I
would like to see about that before we take action .
Mayor Butler stated, "The City supports SCSU and would like to help it maintain its presence in
the City and its employees and students and we will take this under advisement."
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "Financially, are you meeting your obligations?"
Mr. Way stated, "Yes, and we are trying to tackle our past obligations as well and we are trying
as hard as possible. You have a good Board."
DPS Deputy Director Ed Conner addressed Council concerning the Second Reading of an
Ordinance amending Section 9-15.4, 9-15.6, 9-15.7, 9-15.8 and 9-15 .10 of the Code of
Ordinances for the City of Orangeburg titled Rotation Eligibility , wrecker rotation operating
procedures, wrecker service responsibilities, towing and storage charges and indemnification,
respectively .
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to
approve the Second Reading of an Ordinance amending Section 9-15.4, 9-15.6 , 9-15. 7, 9-15.8
and 9-15 .10 of the Code of Ordinances for the City of Orangeburg titled Rotation Eligibility,
wrecker rotation operating procedures, wrecker service responsibilities, towing and storage
charges and indemnification, respectively. This motion was unanimously approved.
Council received, as information , the preliminary Fiscal Year 2016-2017 City Budget Calendar.
Public Works Director Durwood Bowden addressed Council in regards to a contract for the
demolition of the old Emart building at 215 Courthouse Square .
Mr. Bowden stated, "In your packet is a cover letter to City Administrator. Yow and a tabulation
sheet concerning submittals for the demolition of 215 Courthouse Square. It is a three story
building with a basement. Most of the roof on the top two floors has collapsed. The building
contains a small amount of asbestos; therefore, we have to do asbestos abatement during
demolition . All the debris will have to be treated. There will have to be a work area and access
will be limited. Middleton Street and Courthouse Square will be blocked. Debris will have to be
loaded and wrapped with plastic and completely enclosed. There will be air monitoring
equipment at the site at all times. After the demolition, the City is supplying the dirt and the
contractor will have to haul and grade the site. We advertised for submittals on February 5,
2016, and a mandatory pre-submittal meeting was held on February 17, 2016, and nine
contractors attended with only four submitting proposals ranging from $89,875.00 to
$229,000.00 . The low bid was submitted $89,875.00 with the demolition of $76,675 .00 and a
backfill price of$1 l.OO per cubic yard to haul the dirt to the site to backfill totaling $13,200.00.
There is a good bit of difference between their price and the next lowest price. We were
concerned about the price and we have checked their references, talked to them and verified
Page3
what they have done with other cities. They have a good reputation and everyone we have talked
to have continued to use them and they had initial concerns as well. We are convinced they are a
good company with experience and I recommend that you allow the City Administrator to
engage in a contract with 4 Seasons Site and Demo Inc., with permission to adjust the final
balance due to the actual cubic yards for backfill."
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "Are those seven days realistic ?"
Director Bowden replied, "Yes, as you know the building by the County Courthouse was taken
down in about a week. It will take a few extra days to haul the dirt. Good weather days, but rain
actually helps with keeping the dust down."
Councilmember Haire asked, "Have you checked their references for tall structures?"
Director Bowden stated, "Yes, they have taken down hotels and other tall structures."
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Haire, to approve
authorization to 4 Seasons Site and Demo , Inc., in the amount of $89,875.00 for the demolition
of the old Emart building at 215 Courthouse Square. This motion was unanimously approved.
Department of Public Utilities Director Miller addressed Council in regards to the Third Reading
of an Ordinance amending Section IV, Department Installations, Section, Water (1.), (2.) and (4.)
and Section D (1.) Wastewater (1.) and (2.) of the General Terms and conditions of the
Department of Public Utilities.
Councilmember Haire stated, "I asked last time about tipping fees and you replied; however, I
meant tap fees , is the answer the same?'
Councilmember Haire asked again, "Does tap fees have anything to do with rates?"
DPU Director Miller, "Maybe not, because tap fees would be an expense, if we spend more
money, we would have to collect more money."
Councilmember Haire asked, "Do we use tap fees to supplement rates? Aren't fees set aside for
future improvements to the system?"
DPU Director Miller asked, "That would be impact fees, we use tap fees to supplement costs.
Tap fees impact costs."
Councilmember Jernigan stated, "I am still not in favor of this Ordinance because it is taking
revenue away from DPU. Maybe it doesn 't directly affect the rate, but it will indirectly. If we
waive one, it will be less revenue. It would affect revenue which affects rates."
Councilmember Barnwell stated, "I agree completely ."
Councilmember Stroman stated, "I feel we should work with the County, they lowered the
airplane tax, but we get fuel sales and hangar rent. I saw the County repairing a road for the
Police Camp and I haven't seen a bill. We got the bridge built; we need to keep it open. We are
working with them on fire contracts."
Mayor Pro Tern Keitt stated, "If an industry comes in and we waive a fee and they bring in jobs
for our people, then those people are going to work and pay their light bill on time. We have to
make things happen in Orangeburg because if we don 't do this kind of thing in order for us to
make things happen here ."
Councilmember Barnwell stated, "The County dropped the taxes that helped them not us."
Page 4
Councilmember Haire stated, "When the County lowered the taxes that was so we could get
additional airplanes to come to our airport and this was the reason for that. It doesn 't have to be
a direct benefit. If more planes are housed at the Airport, there are more fuel sales. The
lowering of taxes, does not help them."
A motion was made by Councilmember Keitt , seconded by Councilmember Haire, to approve
the Third Reading of an Ordinance amending Section IV, Department Installations, Section ,
Water (1.), (2.) and (4.) and Section D ( 1.) Wastewater (1.) and (2.) of the General Term s and
conditions of the Department of Public Utilit ies.
This was a 5-2 vote as Councilmembers Barnwell and Jernigan opposed.
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to enter
into an Executive Session for a legal matter concerning properties of Kenneth Middleton, Earl
Brooks and David Pickett.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned .
Carrie W. Johnson
City Clerk
/pfb
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
April 5, 2016 2517
Orangeburg City Council held its regularly scheduled City Council meeting on April 5, 2016, at
7:00 P.M., in Council Chambers with Mayor Butler presid ing.
PRESENT:
Michael C Butler, Mayor
Charles B. Barnwell
Bernard Haire
Charles W. Jernigan
L. Zimmerman Keitt
Sandra P. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
A motion was made by Councilmember Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to
approve the March 15, 2016, minutes as distributed . This motion was unanimously approved.
Mr. Fred Johnson with F.A. Johnson Consulting Group and Mr. Jim Pagett with Palmstar Global
addressed Council.
Mr. Johnson discussed Pre-Development (Pre-Construction) Due Diligence , Action Plan
Considerations, Action Plan Activities, creating the Action Plan, recommendations of Catalyst
Project(s) and/or Phased Development , Retail Tenant Identification, Establishment of Feasibility
Rent and Development Strategy and lastly financing the project. (This was shown via a power
point presentation concerning the redevelopment of the Railroad corner.)
Mr. Jernigan asked, "Mr. Johnson, in reference to your acquisition, what kind of percentage do
you have to acquire before you can start Phase 1 ?"
Mr. Johnson replied , "It will really depend on how properties are clustered? There are a few that
are clustered very tightly and to what location they are in?"
Councilmember Jernigan stated , "I know that in the past we found that some of the owners are
out of town. Do you anticipate any problems with that?"
Mr. Johnson stated, "With any municipal project with subsidies, people think the City has
pocketbooks that are wide open and I have to come in and say no and be the bad guy. Last time,
we had appraisals and there are some unreasonable requests with owners and we have to be
careful in that process. There are some that will move on and there are some that think they can
retire."
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "We are working to bring businesses downtown, how do you
feel that this project would enhance our downtown?"
Mr. Johnson stated, "It will enhance the downtown and I commend that you have taken a
consistent approach and you can see the difference and the reinvestment. We now have the
bookend here and that is the front door to downtown. It will just show the work you have done."
Councilmember Jernigan stated, "Our citizens want to bring it back to the old days where you
can walk and shop downtown. If you can conceive of this and what we are trying to do, it would
be accepted a lot more ."
Mayor Pro Tern Keitt stated, "Where are we right now?"
Mr. Johnson stated, "We are back to ground zero, we want to start and move forward ."
Page 2
Mayo~1i8tated , "It is the gateway to the City and I like your ideas and we welcome you."
Mr. Pagett stated, "It is important that with the acquis ition, we don't take a negative approach to
things ."
Mayor Butler stated , "Mr. Johnson has sent an Agreement down already to City Administrator
Yow for approval so he can start, if it so pleases Council."
Mr. Howard Jackson, a concerned citizen, addressed Council. He stated, "I am a concerned
citizen and I have some questions for you on City finances. Are there any Ordinances or
Resolutions in place for giving funding to SC South University and Claflin or other Universities?
Mayor Butler replied, "Not that we all know of."
Mr. Jackson asked, "Without written policies or procedures, how are requests handled for
funding?"
Mayor Butler replied, "If we receive a request , Council discusses it along with the budget in our
Planning Sessions."
Mr. Jackson asked, "According to the Times and Democrat, Attorney Walsh was to research
whether or not it was legal to allow contributions from the City to another state agency. what was
the outcome?"
Mayor Butler and City Attorney Walsh replied , "That is on the agenda later."
Mr. Jackson asked, "Have you made any contributions to any College or University?"
Mayor Butler replied, "Not that we know of."
Mr. Jackson asked. "Who makes the list of items for the Penny Sales Tax?"
Mayor Butler replied, "We come together as a Council and discuss what is needed and prepare a
list in our Planning Sessions."
Mr. Jackson asked, "Since 1998, have there been any projects from the Penny Sales Tax funded
for SC State University?" Mayor Butler and other Council replied, "No."
Mr. Jackson asked, "Who oversees the Sales Tax Projects?"
Mayor Butler replied, "City Council gives guidance, but the City Administrator oversees the
projects."
Mr. Jackson asked , "In the third penny, there was $7,250,000 budgeted for North Road projects
and projects at Edisto Gardens and Hillcrest Recreational Facility? Have the projects at Edisto
Gardens and Hillcrest been completed?"
Mayor Butler stated, "We had to finish the Gym Project first and then we will begin the others.
We have done work at the Recreational Facility on North Road."
Mayor Butler and Councilmember Barnwell stated, "We maintain 1-lillcrest, we do not own it."
Mr. Jackson asked again, "What projects have been done at Hillcrest and at Edisto Gardens.''
Page3
Mayor Butler replied, "None yet, we will be working on them soon."
2519
Mr. Jackson asked, "Do you have a timeline when these projects will be started?"
Mayor Butler replied, "No , not yet, but we will be moving forward soon and discussing it further
in our planning."
Mr. Jackson asked, "Have you received all the third round penny money from the County."
Mayor Butler and others stated, "No."
Mr. Jackson had no more questions.
Ms. Evelyn Disher received the Character Trait Proclamation for April 2016, "Creativity" .
Received as information , discussions on Downtown Business Incentives.
Assistant City Administrator Singh addressed Council about downtown incentives. He stated, "I
know that several members of Council and the City have been looking at several incentives and
programs for Downtown. Mr. Johnson stated, we have worked hard for Downtown and we will
continue to do so. We are looking at more ways to get businesses downtown. One of those
items is some type of an incentive program dealing with business licenses. We just wanted to get
this out in front of you to talk about different ways with a waiver or with a rebate where the
business would pay and get a rebate at a later date. I have given you a couple of options for you
to look at and we will come back at a later date."
Councilmember Jernigan stated, "I think this parallels other project incentives for Orangeburg.
We need to bring in businesses to this area and enhance the business area. I think that Mr. Willie
Johnson is working with us on some other loan programs with other agencies. I think this is a
great incentive ."
City Administrator Yow stated, "We would like you to give us feedback before next meeting ."
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, to approve
a Resolution for Fair Housing Month . This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Councilmember Stroman , to approve
a Resolution to authorize City Administrator Yow to execute a Financial Lease Purchase
Agreement for $1 ,557,792.00 to South State Bank. This was unanimously approved .
Councilmember Barnwell asked, "Is this budgeted?"
Assistant City Administrator Singh replied , "Yes."
City Admini strator Yow gave Council an overview concerning a Resolution addressing a matter
pertaining to giving funds to SC State University for the repair of roads and sidewalks. He sated,
"As you know, Mr. Charlie Way, Chairman of the Board of Trustees for SC State University,
came before Council at the last meeting and asked for help in addressing some of their needs in
the repair of roads and sidewalks. At that time, City Council did not take any action but asked
for this to be placed on the Agenda for future consideration. Also, Councilmember Barnwell
asked for a legal opinion on the City giving money to the University. Council has before you a
Resolution , should you give funding to SC State University. I will turn it over to City Council
for discussion and any legal questions can be answered by Attorney Walsh."
Councilmember Jernigan stated, "Back a good while ago, we were working with Claflin
University on a project where they were building dorms and they needed some help on the
streets. We worked with them on a good level. I said at that time, Orangeburg is a University
town and Orangeburg depends on their Universities. Whether a lot of people want to believe it
or not, SC State University is an economical engine to Orangeburg and they bring a lot of money
Page 4
to thiAcS.lOd a lot of people. It is just one of the things to help Orangeburg go forward. Mr.
Charlie Way came to the last meeting and made a request for help. I think that because of the
fact that SC State University is part of Orangeburg, and is a main part of Orangeburg, that I
would certainly hate to see them lose their Accreditation because of financial problems . When
someone comes to this Council and asks for help, I think we should do anything possible to
answer that call to help them. Based on that, I would make a motion that we amend the
Resolution from $200,000 to $1,000,000 to SC State University for this project."
Councilmember Jernigan made a motion to approve the Resolution granting monetary assistance
to SC State University for road and street repairs, seconded by Mayor Pro Keitt. This was a 6- 1
vote as Councilmember Barnwell opposed.
Councilmember Jernigan stated, "I think this Council is looking toward the future, we need to
get SC State University back on the right path and I think with the new Board they have, they are
going to make a wise decision on their new President and I don' t think it will be anything but SC
State University moving forward."
City Attorney Walsh stated, "My research indicates that this is a proper use of municipal funds;
however, the Resolution is subject to an opinion of the Attorney General's Office."
Councilmember Jernigan stated, "It would have to be. If that's what it is going to take to get this
University accredited, let's move forward. I would hate for the citizens of Orangeburg to look at
us and say why we didn't you help?"
City Attorney Walsh stated . "I would highly recommend that Council adopt the Resolution.
as presented and not just the amount. There are various things in there for the Attorney
General ."
Councilmember Jernigan stated, "I think I did that to amend the amount and everything else was
the same."
City Attorney Walsh asked that the Resolution be read by title with the new amount.
Mayor Butler read the Resolution by title. He stated , "A Resolution authorizing the contribution
not to exceed $1,000 .000.00 , to South Carolina State University for the purpose of road and
street improvements.''
A motion was made by Councilmember Jernigan, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt to approve
the Resolution at $1,000,000 .00.
Councilmember Barnwell stated, "I thank Mr. Charlie Way and the Board for the job they have
done balancing the budget for the year. SC State University got into bad shape due to theft and
fraud and a lot of things. In my opinion , the money will have to be replaced. It's been increased
from $200,000.00 to $1,000,000.00 and that comes out of capital improvements and that is
allowed for emergencies, such as new fire trucks and new garbage trucks. In order to put the
money back, it would have to, in my opinion, ultimately end up as a tax increase, which would
cost the citizens of Orangeburg. Also, can the $1,000,000 .00 be legally transferred from the City
to a state agency and South Carolina State University is owned by the State of South Carolina . I
want to sec SC State University reaccrcdited, but I can't see using taxpayer's money to do it.''
Councilmember Jernigan stated, "I appreciate Mr. Barnwell's position to a certain extent and we
do have money in our fund balance and DPU has money in some of theirs. This would be a good
use for the money and would not hurt the taxpayers of Orangeburg and it would not necessarily
affect the taxes. It would not require that we raise taxes. If we go like we normally do, we put
money back in our fund balance every year. The City staff and employees work hard and I don't
think it would cost the taxpayers a dollar."
PageS
Mayor Pro Tern Keitt stated, "We are here to assist in whatever endeavor we are able j~]i
This money does not belong to the Councilmembers; it belongs to the City of Orangeburg. SC
State University has much to give to the City of Orangeburg, so it' s the City's time to give back
to them. We have the funds that can be assisted with and we're going to do that."
Councilmember Barnwell stated, "This money does not belong to the City, it belongs to the
taxpayers. "
Department of Public Utilities Director Tommy Miller addressed Council in regards to a
Resolution authorizing the investment of funds held by DPU with First Citizens Investment
Services Inc. He asked, if Council would take this under advisement and take no action and he
would bring it back to the next meeting.
A motion was made by Councilmember Stroman, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, to take no
action on the Resolution at this time . This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Stroman, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, to enter
into an Executive Session for Contractual Matters , ( 1) Sale of real property - 1099 Russell Street,
and (2) Review for purcha se of real propertie s - 990 Russell Street and a Legal matter
concerning (1) South Carolina Human Affairs Commission (SCHAC ) Employment Audit. This
was unanimously approved.
Council will not be returning to Open Session.
There being no further busines s, the meeting was adjourned .
R pectfu
(IA , / .
rrie W. John on
/p c,._-~
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
APRIL 19, 2016
ora.rUZl::ity Council held a Public Hearing on Tuesday, April 19, 2016, at 7:00 P.M., in
Council Chambers with Mayor Butler presiding .
The purpose of the Public Hearing concerning Ordinance No. 2016-2, amending the Code of
Ordinances titled Rotation, Eligibility, Wrecker Rotation Operating Procedures, Wrecker Service
Responsibilities, Towing and Storage Charges and Indemnification, Respectively .
The Public Hearing was for opened for comments.
Hearing no comments, the Public Hearing was closed.
Council entered into the regularly scheduled City Council meeting.
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Keitt, to
approve the April 5, 2016, City Council Minutes as distributed . This motion was unanimously
approved.
J.W. Hunt and Compan y presented the FY 2014-15 audits for the City of Orangeburg and the
Department of Public Utilities. Ms. Anne Ross presented the City. She stated , "I want to start off
by thanking the staff for their help. You have an unqualified or clean audit. The opinions are in
the back with the Federal Fund Compliance. The Management's Discussion and Analysis starts
on page 4 and we don't audit that section, just the numbers . The big elephant in the room is
GASB 68 where you have to book your SC Retirement Systems liability . It is a big number, net
pension for the City was $13 million and net pension for the other enterprise funds, including
DPU is approximatel y $20 million. This is only on the government wide statements and the
enterprise fund statements. On page 20, the unrestricted net position decreased due to the
recording of the GASB68 liability for pensions. The General Fund does not apply with the
Governmental Balance Sheets so there is a positive change in the unassigned fund balance on
page 22. On page 24, other government funds, $4.3 million was used to build the gym. You
have paid down a lot of debt also. In the proprietary funds, there are two new categories which
are deferred inflows and deferred outflows , which is part of GASB 68. That starts on page 40
and the notes that relate to it are on pages 52-58. There is $18 million dollars in long term debt
which includes pension and the annual leave. The golf course and airport start on page 81 . The
Golf Course had a $240,000 loss with depreciation of $71,000.00. The Airport had a $733,000
loss with $691,000 of that being depreciation. Your Federal reports are in the back."
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "In the Budget Analysis, there is a reference to indigent defense,
local government revenue decreasing and changes in business license rates that may affect
revenue, what is that?"
Ms. Ross stated, "That is in the Management Discussion and Analysis and that is the City's take
on the year."
City Administrator Yow answered, "The Indigent Defense was a budget proviso in the State
budget and we entered into a contract for $24,000 per year with the Public Defender's office so
that is currently in place. The last Legislative update, the budget proviso was in most of the
committee reports for next year. The local government fund shortfall is in the neighborhood of
$90,000.00 . The proposed legislative business license change is an unknown number and we
don't know that number yet. Hopefully, it will have a neutral effect."
Councilmember Jernigan stated, "It is getting harder and harder for municipalities around the
state to meet these mandates and do what we need to do."
Councilmember Barnwell asked the City Administrator, "Didn't we find out that the State is also
funding the indigent defense?"
Page 2
City Administrator Yow replied, ''The State funds, the Public Defender's office throuJSrlB
government taxes and through the surcharges assessed on local fines. What we are saying is that
we fund indigent defense through property taxes and fines. Also, we contribute to indigent
defense through property taxes and fine assessments and now directly as well"
Mr. John Creech , of J. W. Hunt & Company addressed Council regarding the FY 2014-15 audit
for the Department of Public Utilities. He stated, ·'J want to thank DPU for helping us in our job,
it was a critical year this year due to the new software. On pages 12-15, is the Management' s
Discussion and Analysis for DPU and on pages 26-31 are the basic financial statements and total
assets for DPU increased $3 million due to investment , plant, etc. On page 27, the total net
position decreased by $14.2 million dollars which most of it was due to the pension liability of
$19 million dollars. On page 28 are the income statements which revenue decreased $3 .2
million and a corresponding reduction in cost of goods sold evened out. On page 29 is the
statement of cash flows, page 46 is the breakdown of property, plant and equipment. On page
47, is the breakdown of debt for DPU and shows future requirements."
Councilmember Haire asked, "What did you mean by your opening remarks regarding the
software being an issue?"
Mr. Creech replied , "It was the first year of the new software and it was a change from the old
system so it was a learning curve for both DPU and our staff."
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, to accept the
audit for the City of Orangeburg and the Department of Public Utilities for FY 2014-15. This
motion was unanimously approved .
Concerning the Ordinance amending the Code of Ordinances titled Rotation, Eligibility, Wrecker
Rotation Operating Procedures, Wrecker Service Responsibilities, Towing and Storage Charges
and Indemnification, City Administrator Yow stated, "There are no changes to the Ordinance
with the exception of the storage fees after twenty-four hours ."
Director Mike Adams stated , "I will be happy to answer any questions you may have."
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell , seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt to approve
the Third Reading of an Ordinance amending the Code of Ordinances titled Rotation , Eligibility ,
Wrecker Rotation Operating Procedures, Wrecker Service Responsibilities , Towing and Storage
Charges and Indemnification, Respectively . This motion was unanimously approved .
There were no utility matters brought before Council.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Haire, to enter into
an Executive Session for legal matters (1) Property of Earl Brooks, former Emart Building at 215
Comihouse Square, (2) Sale of Real Property at 1099 Russell Street and (3) Monetary
contributions to SC State University . This motion was unanimously approved.
Council will not be returning to Open Session.
There being no further business , the meeting was adjourned .
/pfb
A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE SALE OF APPROXIMATELY 11.86 ACRES,
TAX MAP NUMBER 0235-00-01-021, TO THE MURDOCH FAMILY LIMITED
PARTNERSHIP FOR THE AMOUNT OF $150,000.00 AND PROVIDING FOR THE
REFUND OF THE PURCHASE PRICE IF THE PURCHASER CREATES AT LEAST
FIVE (5) FULL TIME-NEW JOBS AND MAKES A CAPITAL INVESTMENT OF AT
LEAST $3,500,000.00 WITHIN FIVE YEARS OF THE PURCHASE CLOSING DATE
WHEREAS, the City of Orangeburg (hereinafter referred to as "City") entered
into a Development Agreement with the County of Orangeburg (hereinafter referred to
as "County") for the purpose of developing an industrial park located at the intersection
of U.S. Interstate 26 and U.S. Highway 301, and
WHEREAS, the City and County agreed that title to the industrial park real
property would be vested in the Orangeburg County/City Industrial Park Commission
(hereinafter referred to as "Commission") , and
WHEREAS , any proceeds from the sale of property within the park are to be
shared equally between the County and City, and
WHEREAS, the Commission has entered into a Purchase and Sale Agreement
dated April 27, 2016 with the Murdoch Family Limited Partnership for the sale of
approximately 11 .86 acres, Tax Map Number 0235-00-01-021, for the consideration of
$150,000.00, and
WHEREAS, the Commission agreed that the purchase price of $150,000.00
would be refunded to the Murdoch Family Limited Partnership if in the development of
the property Murdoch created five (5) full time-new jobs and made a capital investment
of $3,500,000 .00 within 5 years of the purchase closing date, and
WHEREAS, in accordance with the Development Agreement between the City
and County it is necessary that the City agree to the refund provisions of the Purchase
and Sale Agreement.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY ORANGEBURG CITY COUNCIL
DULY ASSEMBLED , on this the 11th day of May, 2016 that:
(A) The sale and development of the property is anticipated to benefit the
general welfare of the City and the County and City Industrial Park;
(8) The purposes to be accomplished by the sale and development of the
property are proper governmental and public purposes and the inducement of the
location of industrial development is of paramount importance and the benefits received
from the sale and development of the property to the public are greater than the
anticipated refund; and
City Council has evaluated the proposed development considering all relevant
and required factors but not limited to the anticipated dollar amount and nature of the
investment to be made and the benefits to the County and City and finds that it is the
best interest of the citizens of the City of Orangeburg that the Purchase and Sale
Agreement between the Orangeburg County/City Industrial Park Commission and
Murdoch Family Limited Partnership dated April 27, 2016 be approved , including the
refund provisions of the purchase price as set forth in Section 8 of said Agreement.
AND IT IS SO RESOLVED.
ATTEST {ta4f!!t_Q_
City Clerk
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
May 3, 2016 2525
Orangeburg City Council held its regularly scheduled City Council meeting on May 3, 20 I 6, at
7:00 P.M., in Council Chambers with Mayor Butler presiding.
PRESENT:
Michael C Butler, Mayor
Charles B. Barnwell
Bernard Haire
Charles W. Jernigan
L. Zimmerman Keitt
Sandra P. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Knotts , to approve
the April 19, 2016, minutes as distributed. This motion was unanimously approved.
Ms. Evelyn Disher, Community of Character Director, accepted the May Character Trait
Proclamation, "Patience".
Assistant City Administrator Singh addressed Council, he stated, "We have talked about some
type of incentives for business licenses and we are working on finishing the details with a rough
Ordinance and you have some details with some recommendations from Ms. Johnson on tying
down some details. When we are talking about the rebate and the waiver and with talking to
City Administrator Yow, the recommendation would be to start with the waiver as doing as an
incentive to get us started. If it works well , we may come back to you in increasing the
incentives or a rebate. We are looking to present to you at the next meeting, a waiver of the first
year license and that will be it, and it is only in the downtown area. Included in your packet, is a
map that is shaded for the area that is defined for the waiver. The concept is to promote the
downtown area."
Mayor Prtlem Keitt asked, "Are we looking at that the business is presenting and not focusing
on what they are bringing?"
Assistant City Administrator Singh stated, "What we have here is a basic incentive, we are really
not focusing on what they may be bringing. With staff, if you have a business come in with a
very detailed business plan and with a good deal of backing that may be a different type of
incentive. Almost like an industrial incentive. Florence has put out a lot of incentives to their
downtown. You as Council would make the decision."
City Administrator Yow stated, "This is not limited, this is more for the small businesses . It is
very basic."
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "It is restricted to the map that is shown here for downtown?"
Assistant City Administrator Singh stated, "That is the proposal by staff."
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "Does that include the old E-Mart building?"
Assistant City Administrator Singh stated, "Yes, it does by street line, we need to make it more
shaded."
City Administrator Yow stated, "You can go down Amelia to Doyle, that is up to Council."
Councilmember Jernigan stated, "That would be a good area for someone to come in there ."
Mayor Butler stated, "It is a good idea, it is needed."
Page 2
2526
Assistant City Administrator Singh stated, "We will have some more examples in the Planning
Session."
Councilmember Jernigan stated, "There is a group that is planning on presenting some ideas to
Council soon as well ."
Councilmember Haire asked, "Ms. Keitt, what were your thoughts on your comments in
duplication of businesses."
Mayor Pro Tern Keitt replied, "No t necessarily, I think it would be according to what they bring
to the table, we need to set up some criteria."
Councilmember Haire asked, "We need to set up criteria to prevent duplication of the same
thing."
Council received this as information.
Concerning the discussion of an Ordinance of prohibiting the sale and on premise consumption
of alcoholic beverages in commercial establishments during certain hours, Department of Public
Safety PSO Warrington addressed Council concerning crime trends of three bars in the City
limits, Locals Pub, The Palms and Agora/Faces. He stated, "We have gathered statistics since
January 1, 2014 through April 28, 2016. One hundred and eighteen crimes occurred at only
three club locations. If these locations would have been required to close at 2:00 AM, this would
have eliminated 49% of these crimes. At Locals, we have had 66 incidents, at the club and
within one block of the location, we have had 218 incidents. Between 2:00 AM and 6:00 AM,
there were 41 incidents of the 66. At Agora, there were 34 incidents and 203 within one block.
Between 2:00 AM and 6:00 PM, there were 12 incidents. At the Palms, there were 18 incidents
and 209 within one block of the location, five being between 2:00 AM and 6:00 AM. Crimes
within one block are reflective of the location's crimes; these crimes are more frequent in the
surrounding area. Crimes are occurring at higher rates in 2016 than in 2014 and 2015 with
reports taken in only four months of nearly the previous year totals."
Director Mike Adams stated, "We have had six incidents since this presentation was completed
from April 28th. One was of a high and aggravated assault at Locals and we were not notified of
the crime until they arrived at the hospital to seek treatment and the hospital called us. As the
Director, I am concerned about this."
Mayor Pro Tern Keitt asked, "Why do we not have a time for these places to close?"
Director Adams stated, "That is what we are trying to do now. The City of Charleston and
Columbia close at 2:00 AM. What we are advocating is some open and frank discussion on this
concerning a time these businesses should close. If you look at the number of offenses that occur
after 2:00 AM, it is a large number . If you get there at 9:00 PM and drink all night until 2:00
AM, that is a long time. You have some establishments that will close a long time before 2:00
AM.
Councilmember Haire asked DPS Director Adams, "Do you find any correlation between what
the County has done as it relates to shutting down these facilities at 2:00 AM and increasing in
the City.
DPS Director Adams stated, "Yes, sir, I do believe there is a direct correlation between the two.
An Ordinance was passed by the County on Nov 15, 2015, and as PSO Warrington pointed out,
the correlation is that we have seen an increase in the number of offenses so far this year based
upon the time of the study. In the first four months we are up 75% from all oflast year, so I do
believe that is a correlation. We have a club that is going to open on US 301 and we just did
Page3
final inspection and they were approved. We have information that another club is gol~2 7
relocate in the City."
Councilmember Haire asked if the club was going to locate next to the old Holiday Inn across
from the old KFC."
Chief Adams state, "That is correct."
Councilmember Jernigan asked Chief Adams, "Don't you think that from 2:00 AM to 6:00 PM
would be adequate to prohibit sale and consumption of alcohol."
Chief Adams answered, "I do think it would be adequate and fair that from 2:00 AM to 6:00 AM
the sale and consumption of alcohol would be prohibited and the owner would be prohibited
from selling and the patron would be prohibited from buying and at 2:30 AM everyone would
have to be out of the establishment and the consumption of alcohol would cease at 2:00 AM."
Councilmember Stroman asked, Can you sell alcohol on Saturday after 12:00 AM, which is
Sunday"
Chief Adams stated, "In a private club you can. Time restri~tions are different in private clubs
than public clubs".
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "Does this Ordinance relates to public and private?"
Chief Adams Stated, "Yes. "
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "This would regulate both."
Chief Adams stated, "Yes sir, all licensed establishments."
Councilmember Stroman asked, "Everybody in the City."
Chief Adams answered , "Yes Sir."
Mayor Pro Tern Keitt stated that it is imp011ant that the clubs close at 2:00 AM and I thought this
was when they were closing."
Chief Adams stated, "We are a college town and there is a lot of young kids and establishment s
that are staying open after 2:00 AM and this is not good as i~ is about protecting the kids."
Mayor Butler stated, "I thought individuals would be home at such a time at night and I would
like to know what time Five Points close."
Chef Adams stated, "They close at 2:00 AM, similar to what we are proposing. "
Councilmember Knotts stated , "The businesses around these three clubs that you are talking
about. What have they said as it relates to the traffic and incidents that have occurred."
Chief Adan1s stated, "That is a good question . Like Club Agora. POS Warrington discus sed the
issues of Henry Travel Plaza and the Dodges store right next door. I am not aware of employees
at the store addressing Club Agora but I can tell you what we see from our experiences. We see
that it takes a lot of time to get in the club as they are trying to be thorough when they get people
in there as they are concerned about weapons, etc. You will have folks parking at Henry' s
Travel Plaza and there are issues that go along with that. This also happens at the Dodges store
and I will tell you that the owners of the club are trying to keep up with what is going on with the
people. We get calls from the locals stating that can' t sleep at night."
Mayor Butler asked, "What time does the Country Club closes?"
Chief Adams stated, "Way before 2:00 AM."
City Administrator Yow stated , "We are proposing to bring this Ordinance back to you at the
next meeting for first reading , so please review it thoroughly."
Chief Adams asks if there were any more questions that he would be happy to answer them.
Page 4
Coli~ber Haire asked, "What about the County's Orcinance on this and do you see any
problems with it."
Chief Adams stated, "Their Ordinance is similar to the one that we have. Closing times are the
same."
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "Is there a state law governing serving alcohol at certain times."
Chief Adams stated, "It depends on the day and the establishment s; and like I said, private club
times are totally different."
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Stroman, to appoint
Clayton Bozard (Finar.ce Dept. , IT) to the Grievance Committee to fill an unexpired term. He
will also serve as the Chairman and Lt. Jennifer Haig to serve on the Committee as an alternate
from the Department of Public Safety. This motion was unanimously approved. At the May l ih
City Council meeting more additional vacancies will need to be nominated to the Committee.
The Fiscal Year 2016-17 Budget Calendar will be placed on the May 17, 2016, agenda for
approval due to scheduling conflicts.
There were no utility matters brought before Council.
A motion was 1mtde by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, to enter into
an Executive Session for legal matters (1) Monetary Assistance to SC State University, (2) Sale
of property at 1099 Russell Street.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
Respectfully submitted ,
SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
May 11, 2016
Orangeburg City Council held a Special City Council meeting on Wednesday, May I f,~~t
I 0:00 A.M., in Council Chambers with Mayor Butler presiding.
PRESENT:
Michael C. Butler, Mayor
Charles B. Barnwell
Bernard Haire
Charles W. Jernigan
L. Zimmerman Keitt
Sandra P. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, to enter
into an Executive Session for Economic Development - Project Bulldog- sale of real property .
Council will return to Open Session .
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, second by Councilmember Barnwell, to return to
Open Session . This motion was unanimously approved .
Council returned to Open Session .
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire , seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, to approve a
Resolution for Project Bulldog, sale ofreal property. This motion was unanimously approved .
City Administrator Yow stated , "We have met and I have given you an outline while we work on
the 2016 1 % sales tax list. The Mayor has talked with the County that we are meeting today
developing a list. The list will be on the agenda next week."
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "When will the 8.2 million be available to use? "
City Administrator Yow stated, "It will be voted on in November. The y will borrow money after
the Referendum. I asked the County what is the projected total dollar amount countywide, and
they stated $64,500,000 which would be split between the County & seventeen municipalities .
There will be issuance cost of bonds and administrative fees."
Councilmember Haire asked, "If we nominate a project for 1 million and we deem it no longer
viable, where does the dollars go?"
City Administrator Yow stated, "You do not have to expend exact amounts, costs are unknown,
some under and some over, you may remember a project some years ago went back to County."
Councilmember Knotts, "Can we see the total list from County prior to voting in November?"
City Administrator Yow stated , "Yes, the meeting will be open to review the list."
Councilmember Jernigan asked , "Will the list be on the ballot? "
City Administrator Yow stated, "Yes, the priorities are as Council directs and the list is a draft
based on input from you. Councilmember Keitt wants to do a Bayne Street sidewalk . I've
received some feedback on a parking lot at the Arts Center and some Department Heads have
mentioned section of ditches on Middleton and Broughton and building a culvert or pipe for
ditches."
Assistant City Administrator Singh stated, "Pedestrian Bicycle Improvement Project to
implement some part of it."
Page 2
Counc~~ijr Haire asked, "Didn't we talk about culvert on Sunnyside Canal? Residents are a
great advocate of completing the canal, started at the end and not where it starts . People were
promis ed it would be completed. If we can do culverts, we can complete that project. "
City Administrator Yow stated, "All of that was before our time. Would you like it on the list?"
Councilmember Haire stated, "If we never start, we are never going to complete it."
City Administrator Yow stated, "We may need to add money for a study, engineering and costs
to know what it entails."
Council went through the Capital Projects List.
Item #1 Library
Councilmember Stroman stated, "As long as County builds the library and not a private citizen."
City Administrator Yow suggested, "The County owned library ."
Item #2 City Airport'
City Administrator Yow stated, "We have received letters for large Corporate hangers for large
planes. Some Councilmembers expressed interest."
Councilmember Barnwell asked , "Do we have commitments?"
Councilmember Jernigan stated , "I agree, there needs to be a list so we will be able to find them.
We need to have money set aside. Can we list improvements? Better time, use of money to
improve it."
City Administrator Yow stated, "We have used money for fuel tanks, Council has to have a grant
match money for project s. You can use this to match several grants."
Councilmember Stroman stated, "When we increased the tax, Sumter needed to move a jet, and
Orangeburg had nowhere to put it."
Councilmember Haire stated , "List under improvements ."
City Administrator Yow stated, "This will assist with Economic Development and will increase
our fuel sales for operations."
Councilmember Jernigan stated, "At the Municipal Association they often get asked about
communities with Airports, industries want to know if you have an Airport. I do think th e
Airport is an asset of the City for development."
Item #3 Improvements of City owned streets
City Administrator Yow stated , "The City owns roads in Pinc Top subdivision, roads are in need
of repair, we did not accept the dam. This was before my time . We will address roads at some
time. Repairs to Pine Top are less than $600,000 .00. Other roads, the City owns are a small
section of Rowe Street that the State did not accept, Executive Court , Mosely Street and Blair
Street. Councilmember Stroman thinks it is private ."
Item #4 Mirmow Field
Resurface parking lot, walk under bleachers, all of that needs updating .
Councilmember Haire stated, "Birds roost there."
City Administrator Yow stated, "Large fans are needed to keep cool and possibly a need for
electrical upgrades ."
2S3 l
Page3
Item #5 Railroad Corner
City Administrator Yow stated, "Mayor Butler has indicated that Railroad Corner is a priority .
We are trying to get an environmental assessment done. Budget was 5 million a few years back.
If you use all the money there, you won't have enough."
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "Are we duplicating services or money? Isn't the developer
talking about developing the area as a private development? Are we subsidizing a private
developer?"
City Administrator Yow stated, "City Council has not said you are doing anything with a private
developer."
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "Are we willing to develop property ourselves? Do we want to
spend money or whether a private developer is going to develop?"
Councilmember Haire asked, "What about streets , parking, and drainages? That's not something
a private developer will address."
City Administrator Yow stated, "Some may want some incentives such as streetscape and
lighting."
Councilmember Jernigan stated, "That's a lot of money in a project."
City Administrator Yow stated, "We have projected it at 3 million ."
Item #6 Expand City Hall and Stevenson
City Administrator Yow stated, "We need to expand the Finance Department, a place is needed
at Stevenson to hold a reception, we need to move street over, Market Street to St. John Street,
estimated at $1,000,000 .00.
Item #7 Edisto Garden Improvements and Riverfront Development
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "Revisit RV Park or not?"
Mayor Butler stated, "We need to develop near the water."
Councilmember Haire asked, "Didn't we discuss with Senator Matthews about cleaning the river
and development?"
City Administrator Yow stated , "Yes."
Mayor Butler, "Build a fishing deck. We could do a RV park if we develop the riverfront."
Council decided to included $571,948 .00 for Riverfront Development
Item #8 North Road/Recreation Complex
City Administrator Yow stated, "North Road project is not finalized . We need to include money
in the next round to carry project over. We are trying to get the encroachment permit and enter
into a Memorandum of Understanding with SCDOT. This may warrant a traffic signal. The
City is responsible for that and the Legislation Delegation will help us."
Councilmember Haire asked, "When did they start requiring that? I thought they were all about
safety and welfare?"
9. Parking beside City Gym
All Councilmembers have agreed to spend $150,000.00 for this project.
Page 4
10. Other Items Discussed
Councilmember Jernigan, "What about the Gardens and Boardwalk money City Administrator
Yow stated, "We are getting money from FEMA on that we hope. Parking at Arts Center? We
can come back to address." Councilmember Jernigan stated, "Since the money is received over
seven years, we can't do all these projects on the list."
City Administrator Yow stated, "It takes us years to get the money. We can fund small projects
with cash flow. We can' t do three big projects at one time."
Sidewalks for $100,000.00 were also added.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to
adjourn .
There being no further business , the meeting was adjourned.
RESOLUTION
A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE INVESTMENT OF FUNDS HELD BY THE
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC UTILITIES OF THE CITY OF ORANGEBURG WITH WEAL TH
MANAGEMENT GROUP OF FIRST-CITIZENS BANK & TRUST COMPANY IN
ACCORDANCE WITH SECTION 6-5-10 OF THE CODE OF LAWS FOR THE STATE OF
SOUTH CAROLINA
WHEREAS, the Department of Public Utilities of the City of Orangeburg has for many
years used the investment services of South State Bank and First Citizens Bank of South
Carolina, and
WHEREAS, First Citizens Bank & Trust Company, Inc. of South Carolina and First
Citizens Bank of North Carolina have now merged and an investment division of the surviving
company is Wealth Management Group of First-Citizens Bank & Trust Company, and
WHEREAS, Wealth Management Group of First-Citizens Bank & Trust Company has
requested authorization to invest the funds of the Department of Public Utilities.
NOW, THEREFO,RE, BE IT RESOLVED BY ORANGEBURG CITY COUNCIL DULY
ASSEMBLED , this ~ day of May, 2016 that 0 . Thomas Miller, Jr., Manager, Department of
Public Utilities, is authorized to execute any and all documents necessary to utilize the
investment services of Wealth Management Group of First-Citizens Bank & Trust Company,
including without limitation, the authorization of employees Joshua Nexsen, John W. Beeks,
and 0 . Thomas Miller, Jr. to access and view the online investment accounts of the Department
of Public Utilities and to authorize investments , deposits , withdrawals and internal transactio ns
in accordance with Section 6-5-10 of the Code of Laws for the State of South Carolina.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that 0. Thomas Miller, Jr. shall authorize Janice Price to
access and view the online investment accounts of the Department of Public Utilities.
AND IT IS SO RESOLVED .
z I
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
May 17, 2016 2533
Orangeburg City Council held its regularly scheduled City Com,cil meeting an May 17, 20 i 6, at
7:00 P.M., in Council Chambers with Mayor Butler presiding.
PRESENT:
Michael C Butler, Mayor
Charles B. Barnwell
Bernard Haire
Charles W. Jernigan
L. Zimmerman Keitt
Sandra P. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Haire , to approve
the May 3, 2016, City Council minut es as distributed. This motion was w1animously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Councilmember Knotts, to approve
the May 11 , 2016, Special City Council minute s as distributed . This motion was unanimou sly
approved.
Dr. Jerome Fitts of Claflin University and the Baseball SIAC Conference Champions thanked
City Council for their acknowledgements . Coach James Randall stated, " We are headed to
Tampa , Florida , of the NCAA Regionals and we are sche duled to play Thursday at 3:00 P.M ., as
a ih Seed and we thank you for your support ."
City Administrator Yow presented the City's FY 2016-17 Budget Calendar.
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire , seco nded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, to approve
the adoption of the City ' s FY 2016-17 Budget Calendar and to cancel the Jul y 5th and July 191\
2016, City Council regularl y schedu led meeting s.
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt , to approve
the reappointment of Ms. Anna Bloome from Parks and Recreation Departm ent and LeAndrae
Felder from the Service Department to the City's Grievance Committee. This is a three year
term expiring June 4, 2019. This motion was unanimou sly approved.
Assistant City Administrator John Singh presented the First Reading of an Ordinance amending
Chapter VII of the Code of Ordinances of the City of Orangeburg by adding a new Section 7-8,
Titled Busine ss License Incentive Program for New Businesses. He stated, "This is an incentive
for businesses in the downtown area. We will be bringing back a cleaner map for second readin g
and we have added the area City Council wanted down Amelia Street. A $1 ,000.00 maximwn
waiver limitation was also added."
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Haire, to approve
the First Reading of an Ordinance amending Chapter VII of the Code of Ordinanc es of the City
of Orangeburg by adding a new Section 7-8, Titled Business License Incentive Program for New
Business es. This motion was unanimously approved .
DPS Director Mike Adams brought before Council the First Reading of ijn Ordinance prohibiting
the sale and on premi se consumption of alcoholic beverages in commercial establishments
during certain hours. Director Adam s stated, "This is the same as we discussed earlier with a
closing time of 2:00 A. M. and a must stop serving and premises cleared by 2:30 AM."
Councilmember Haire asked, "How many establishments are we talking about. "
Chief Adams stated, "Six."
MayMS4em Keitt asked for a list of these places.
Councilmember Knotts asked, "What days do this refer to?"
Director Adams stated, "Eve ryday, they can sell on Sunday in private clubs."
Mayor Butler stated, " With the number of crimes out there this is the reason why we are doing
this"
Director Adams stated, "Between 2:00 A.M. and 5:30 A.M. is when you have the largest number
of offenses at these establis hments and within a one block area."
A motion was made by Councilmember Stroman, seconded by Councilmember Knotts , to
approve the First Reading of an Ordinance prohibiting the sale and on premise consumption of
alcoholic beverages in commercial establishments during certain hours . This motion was
unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Stroman, to approve
the adoption of the 2016 Capital Project Sales Tax List as follows:
2016 Capital Project Sales Tax List
Library-City portion of total funding
for County owned library in downtown
Airport improvements & upgrades
Improvemen ts of City owned streets
including Pine Top Subdivision
Mirmow Field improvements
Railroad Corner Redevelopment
Expand City Ha11 & Stevenson Auditorium
street realignment and construction
Edist o Gardens improvements
& riverfront deve lopment
North Road Rec. Complex,
traffic Control
Parking beside City Gym
City Sidewalks
Total
* Amount projected to be received by City
This motion was unanimously approved.
$1,000 ,000.00
$1 ,000,000.00
$ 600,000.00
$ 400,000.00
$3,000,000.00
$1,200,000.00
$ 571,948 .00
$ 200,000.00
$ 150,000.00
$ 100,000.00
$8,221,948.00
$8,221,948.00
DPS Director Adams stated, "On April 5th, we demostrated 0ur newer patrol vehicles that
included a nimbler siren that overcomes radios and they work very well and we are installing
them in our standard packages. Councilmember Haire asked that this be brought up for
discussion and has requested some information about it. We have twenty-seven (27) patrol
vehicles and eleven (11) fire apparatu s and each rumbler costs $426. 93 and including installation
would be approximately $29,883.43."
Page3
Council member Haire stated, ''I asked for this information after the demonstration ~%nd I
immediately saw a need for the additional safety of personnel. We should go ahead and invest to
see if we can get them installed. I feel that if we can save a life, it is a worthwhile investment. I
wanted to bring this up before Council to share your opinions."
Director Adams stated, "I had intended to include this as a budget item, as this upgrade we are
speaking about stands out above the rest. We have over 1,000 fire calls a year and a new truck is
over $500. 00.00 and if we wreck one, we are behind the 8 ball."
Mayor Pro Tern Keitt asked, "Do we have the money?"
City Administrator Yow stated, "We will be amending the current year budget and it is not
uncommon for us to fund things in the year-end with good budgeting and management. We will
see if we can work it in the year-end budget."
Council received this as information.
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Councilmember Knotts, to approve a
Resolution authorizing the investment of funds held by the Department of Public Utilities with
First Citizens Investment Services, Inc., in accordance with Section 6-5-10 of the Code of Laws
for the State of South Carolina. This motion was unanimou<ily approved.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Haire, to enter into
an Executive Session for a legal matter for sale of property at 1099 Russell Street. This motion
was unanimously approved.
Council will not return to Open Session.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
/pfb
RESOLUTION
A RESOLUTIO ' FOR THE CITY OF ORANGEBURG, DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC
UTILJTJES TO ACCEPT THE LOW RESPONSIVE, RESPONSIBLE BID BY
FOREMOST PIPELINE CONSTRUCTION CO., INC. OF GASTON, SOUTH
CAROLINA IN THE AMOUNT OF $1,831,187.47 FOR THE CONSTRUCTION OF
APPROXIMATELY 8 MILES OF 6" STEEL GAS MAIN ON U.S HIGHWAY 176
SOUTH.
WHEREAS, the Department of Public Utilities of the City of Orangeburg, South Carolina,
received bids on May 18, 2016 for the construction of approximately 8 miles of 6" steel gas main
on U.S. Highway 176 South; and
WHEREAS, the low responsive, responsible bid for this work was submitled by Foremost
Pipe::lirie Construction Co., Inc. of Gaston, South Carolina in the amount of$1,831,187.47 ; and
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, by the Mayor and Members of Council of the City
of Orangeburg, in Council assembled, and by authority of the- same, that the low responsive,
responsible bid shown above be accepted; and_
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that 0 . Thomas Miller, Jr. , Manager of the Department of
Public Utilities, be authorized and he is hereby directed to execute the contract documents on
beh<.1 lfofthe Department of Public Utilities of the City of Orangeburg.
RESOLVED BY City Council duly assembled this f7~ day of June, 20 16.
MEMBERS OF COUNC IL
~ES~1
ORDINANCE NO. 2016- S-
AN ORDINANCE AMENDING CHAPTER VII OF THE CODE OF ORDINANCES
FOR THE CITY OF ORANGEBURG BY ADDING A NEW SECTION 7-8,
TITLED BUSINESS LICENSE INCENTIVE PROGRAM FOR NEW
BUSINESSESS
WHEREAS, the City Council finds that the development of its business tax base
requires a business license incentive program for new businesses ("incentive program"),
and determines that a reduction in the business license taxes for qualifying new
businesses will foster and encourage business development in the downtown core area.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED, by City Council duly assembled , that Chapter
VII of the Code of Ordinances for the City of Orangeburg is amended by adding a new
Section 7-8, titled Business License Incentive Program for New Businesses which shall
read as follows:
7-8- BUSINESS LICENSE INCENTIVE PROGRAM FOR NEW BUSINESSES.
Section 7-8.1 Purpose and Intent
The City Council finds that the development of its business tax base requires a business
license incentive program for new businesses ("incentive program") , and determines
that a reduction in the business license taxes for qualifying new businesses will foster
and encourage business development in the downtown core area.
Section. 7-8.2. Definitions
For purposes of this article, the following words shall have the meanings ascribed to
them in this section:
Acquisition shall mean the combination of two (2) or more existing businesses where
one (1) business acquires the ownership of the other business .
Business license year shall mean April 1st through March 31st of each calendar year.
Change in business form shall mean a change in the organization of an existing
business. A change in business form occurs whether such rhange is voluntary or
involuntary, recognized by the South Carolina Secretary of State or not recognized by
the South Carolina Secretary of State.
Merger shall mean the combination of two (2) or more existing businesses to establish a
new business.
Name change shall mean the change in the name upon which a business trades. A
name change occurs whether or not the business registers such name or change of
name with the South Carolina Secretary of State.
Similar business combination shall mean any transaction that is of the same nature as a
merger or an acquisition.
Section 7-8.3. Business license tax incentive created.
There shall be a business license tax category of "new business qualifying for
incentives". Rates otherwise applicable under the City's classification for business
license tax purposes, as from time to time amended , shall be abated for new
businesses qualifying for the category as provided in Section 7-8.5.
Section 7-8 .4 License tax abatement schedule.
(a) Business which meet the requirements of "new business qualifying for incentives" as
provided in Section 7-8.5 shall have their business license taxes abated one hundred
percent for the first taxable year of operation or any portion thereof , but not to exceed a
maximum tax abatement of $1,000.00.
(b) Any business which meets the requirements of Section 7-8.5 and which is issued a
business license permit for less than a six month period in its first taxable year of
operation may elect to extend its 100 percent abatement to the second taxable year for
the remaining unused abatement in order to obtain a total taxable year abatement.
(c) No business and no successor or affiliated business entity having one or more of
the same principals and substantially the same business activity may cease business
operations in the name of one business and then resume business operations in
another name if the effect of such resumption is to circumvent this section or to prolong
the incentives provided beyond one total taxable year.
Section 7-8.5 - Qualifying Requirements.
Qualifying business shall mean a business that locates for the first time in the following
described, designated area of the City after the effective date of this article. A business
shall not be deemed to locate in the City for the first time based on a merger,
acquisition , similar business combination, name change , or a change in business form.
A business shall not be deemed to locate in the City for the first time if there is an
existing business in the City trading under the same or substantially similar business
name, the businesses conduct similar business activities, and the businesses are
related either by a shared ownership structure or a contractual relationship such as a
franchisor/franchisee relationship . A qualifying business shall not include peddlers and
itinerant merchants . A qualifying business shall not include contractors required to
obtain a business license under the License Schedule , Section 7-2.4 of this Code.
When applying for any benefit afforded under this article, the applicant shall have the
burden of proving qualification as a qualifying business .
Description of Area: Any new business fronting on either side of Russell Street
beginning at the intersection of Russell Street and Riverside Drive and continuing from
said point in a northeastern direction to the intersection of Russell Street and Boulevard
Street, any new business located in the area marked with hatched lines on Exhibit "A"
attached to this Ordinance and described generally as having the following boundaries;
Northwest by Amelia Street, Northeast by Doyle Street and Middleton Street, Southeast
by St. John Street and Fischer Street and Southwest by Broughton Street ; and any new
business fronting and located on either side of said streets .
Section 7-8.6 -Application and Appeal.
(a) Any business seeking to qualify as a qualifying business shall complete an
application in writing. The application shall be on forms developed by the City Finance
Director.
(b) Any determination of qualification or of non-qualification as a qualifying business
shall be in writing by the City Finance Director.
(c) The appeal of a determination of non-qualification shall be filed and decided by the
City Administrator.
Section 7-8.7 - Obligations of a Qualifying Business.
(a) Nothing in this article shall be construed to repeal any requirement of businesses
within the City to maintain records or comply with an audit by the City Finance Director.
(b) A qualifying business shall report its gross receipts to the City Finance Director, at
such times and in such manner as required by law and the failure to timely report shall
result in the forfeiture of any entitlement to the license tax abatement provided herein.
Section 7-8.8 - Effective Date.
This article shall be effective July 1, 2016 and the incentive may be granted to qualifying
businesses for a period of three (3) years thereafter ; expiring on June 30, 2019 unless
extended by Resolut ion of City Council.
DONE AND RATIFIED by City Council for,~ City of rangeburg , State of South
Carolina, in Council duly assembled this c)/ day of , 2016.
I I
-------
2536
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
June 7, 2016
Orangeburg City Council held its regularly scheduled City Council meeting on June 7, 2016, at
7:00 P.M., in Council Chambers with Mayor Butler presiding.
PRESENT:
Michael C Butler, Mayor
Charles B. Barnwell
Bernard Haire
Charles W. Jernigan
Sandra P. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
ABSENT:
L. Zimmerman Keitt
A motion was made by Councilmember Stroman, seconded by Councilmember Haire, to approve
the May 17, 2016, City Council minutes as distributed. This motion was unanimously approved.
Mayor Michael Butler and Tommy Miller, Department of Public Utilities Manager, presented a
Retiree Resolution and gold watch to Mr. Charlie Williams , Jr., from DPU for his twenty-four
years, ten months and seventeen days of service to the Department of Public Utilities.
Mr. Gene Gartman and Cheryl Dalton from the Dalton House for Veterans and Non Veterans
made Council aware of their facilities and that they have twenty (20) beds available and they are
now one-half full. They stated that would like to receive $30,000.00 from the City of
Orangeburg for their next year's operation. Council took this presentation under advertisement
and took no action.
Regarding the Ordinance prohibiting the sale and on premise consumption of alcoholic
beverages in commercial establishments during certain hours the following individuals made an
appearances before Council.
Mr. Eric Clark from the Local's Pub spoke. He stated," Local's Pub is a licensed tax paying
business in Orangeburg and one of the most businesses that is being discriminated against. The
Local Pub constantly reaches out to local law enforcement agencies about extra security
measures and constantly being ignored. How can we have a safe environment if we can't have
our Public Service that is paid to protect us and ignore the citizen's needs? I feel there is a
disconnection between Orangeburg County and Public Safety. Public Safety does not interact
with the Orangeburg County Sherriff. I reached out to both the County and Public Safety.
Community policing is very important between Public Safety and Orangeburg County. How is
the disconnection? Police officers don't interact with the community they just mainly patrol the
streets. Crime statistics are very questionable. The Local's Pub is becoming a scape goat for
crimes that are in the community. We are constantly being blamed for crimes that are not even
in the vicinity of the Local Pub. The Local's Pub hires licensed , bonded security companies with
armed and unarmed sled certified officers. On various occasions we try to hire law enforcement
officers and have been denied. Several times the requests have been denied. What else can a
business do for security and we don't have the support oflocal law enforcement. Local' s Pub is
one of the few establishments that actually gives back to the community and most of the hotels
and businesses that benefits from the clubs and bars. During graduation and homecoming
weekends, tow truck companies take advantage of visitors and citizens and they are also the
ones that do absolutely nothing for the community of Orangeburg. Why are we being restricted
on what is going on in Orangeburg". Mr. Clark made mention of several local charities and
organizations that he has assisted or is affiliated with.
Mayor Butler asked, "Why do you want to stay open?"
Page2
Mr. Clark replied, "Because I cater to the plants such as A VP and Kayo that get off or0.~<3t17
shift. They get off around 11 :30 -12:00 midnight and they go home and get dressed a~ they
come out 1 :00 A. M. which would only give them an hour. Also , 40% of my sales are between
the hours of 1 :00 A.M . and 4:00 AM."
Mayor Butler asked, "What time do you normally close ?"
Mr. Clark replied, "It varies between 4:00 - 5 :00 AM. I have a staff of 25 people to include 10
bouncers. There are individua ls certified by SLED in the parking lots also. By closing at 2:00
AM will limit the taxes that I will be paying the City. I will be losing $9,000 - $10,000 a month
by closing at 2:00 AM."
Ms. Simone Clark, of Local's Pub, 1510 Wingate Street Spoke. She stated "Good Evening. I
just wanted to touch on some points. Who we cater to as our customers and why we are
concerned with the early closing . We aim to please all our customers by opening early in the
evening and closing as late as 4:00 AM. We are trying to be suitable for all our customers to
meet everyone's social needs. A large part of our service is between the hours of 2:00 -4:00
AM as we cater to the grave yard shift at Koyo, Zeus, Sunbeam Bakery, gas stations and
restaurants . We host upcoming artist talent for local young people to show their craft which
happens between 11 :30 - 2:00 AM. We try our best to provide a safe environment for college
students to enjoy. Some of our customers are not social drinkers ; they just come to interact with
their peers. Even if we have to close at 2:00 A.M. The Locals Pub, as well as other local
businesses , within the community will continue to become more dedicated and sophisticated in
dealing with the well-being of our City and our citizens ."
Ms. Shondra Bender, of Local' s Pub spoke. "The Local ' s Pub has monthly meetings once or
twice a month to make sure our employees are happy and discuss what we can do to make our
bar number one and safe for our employees and customers. We have armed security and
bouncers on the inside. Customers must have ID to enter and must be at least 21 years of age.
All customers are searched before entering. If a person is intoxicated when entering they are
turned around. If someone becomes intoxicated while in the bar, we will no longer serve them .
We try to find out who they are with to make sure they get home safely or we ourselves have
taken them home. We do not allow any gang related clothing or signs. We want to stay open
because we have so many men and women that depend on us to make a living and take care of
their families."
Ms. Eva Baltzegar from The Palms Social Club spoke against the Ordinance for bars closing at
2:00 A.M. She provided a handout for Council of her comments , which is attached to the
minutes and spoke from this handout..
Mr. Aaron Gillespie, Cloud Nine, 1664 Russell Street, stated "Today we are coming in with not a
particular time we want to stay open; I'm speaking as a business, not as a club. There are no
other businesses in Orangeburg that are required to close their businesses, none. If I go to any
other establishment and ifI am intoxicated , I'm responsible, So why is it when someone comes
to my establishment, I the business owner is responsible. Look at us as businesses. It took us 18
months to get our liquor license. We want the opportunity to operate our business in the confines
of the law. We opened this business with our money in 2011. This is how we feed our families.
When we went for licenses no one said we had to close at a certain time. Anything can be
accomplished if we sit down at a table and speak together and come to an agreement. And I
think that's how things should be handled, instead of saying this is what it is. I thank you for
your time ."
Mayor Butler asked," What is Cloud Nine? Is it a restaurant?"
Mr. Gillespie answered , "Yes, it a Hookah Lounge and Bistro."
Mayor Butler asked, "Where is it located?"
Page 3
Mr. ~$,,iff;tated, " It is located at 1664 Russell Street next to Freddie Ford's across the street
from the old Piggly Wiggly. We're open Monday through Saturday and we open at 6:00 A.M.
We offer all type s of foods."
Councilm ember Jernigan asked, " What time do you normally close?"
Mr. Gillespie stated , " On the weekends, on an average, it is anywhere between 3 :00 and 4:00
A.M . Durin g the weekend s our hours are longer since people don ' t have to work the next day.
If they can spend their money here, we would prefer them to spend it here as opposed to going to
Columbia or Charleston . It is beneficial for everybody. I thank you for your time."
Mr. William Green, a concerned citizen spoke. He stated, "Good evening . I am here as a
citizen . My address is I 048 Doyle Street, Orangeburg, SC. I have been running around
Orangeburg working on several committees and organi zations trying to bring Orangeburg back
from where it is now . If this Ordinance, which I call it a curfew for adults, is passed , we' re in
big trouble. There are people looking at Orangeburg. There are several committees and
organizations in the City of Orangeburg and outside investors that are thinking about opening up
businesses within the City limits and downtown Orangeburg, such as a supper club. There is an
individual that is looking at two separate locations. I have lived in Atlanta and Baltimor e and
other places in Europe . A supper club basically starts around 12:30 A. M. or 12:00 A. M. is
when people begin coming in. They serve supper and they serve breakfast. If this is passed, this
will not take place . A supper club provides live entertainment , jazz, anythin g from the arts scene
to theatrical. All of this is provided once you are dining and having your meal. I also feel that
Orangeburg needs to move forward into the 21st Century . Orangeburg is 40 years behind places
like Aiken , Sumter, Spartanburg and Summerville. We are 40 years behind these places. If this
Ord inance is passed , it will throw 20 or 30 more years to Orangeburg. So how do we plan to
grow as a community? We have taxpayers here. These club and bar owners that are sitting here
tonight cannot afford to pay their workers if they have to have a limit on what time they have to
close which means cuttin g their staff down or perhaps even closing their busines s and if this
Ordinance is passed to clo se at 2:00 A.M . who's to say next year it will be 1 :00 A.M. We have
to look forward to the future of the City of Orangeburg . When we look at the Councilm ember s
sitting here, basically all the Councilmembers are from the same generation. We do not hav e a
Council that represents the citizens of Orangeburg . We don ' t have any young people on the
Council. So how can the decision be a fair decision, if you ' re not open-minded? Thank you."
Mayor Butl er stated, "We thank Mr. Green for his comments and all of you for your comments .
We are listening to you and will take it under advisement. Do any Councilmembers have any
question s?"
Councilmember Jernigan stated, I appreciate everyone that was here tonight to speak. 1
appr eciate you coming and I appreciate you voicing your opinion. That's why we have a
Council meeting so that the public can come and voice their opinion when this happens. We all
have to consider the fact also that our Department of Public Safety is tasked with the job of
prot ectin g the citizens of Orangeburg. They are tasked also with keepin g the peace and makin g
s11rc that crimes stay as lo"'-' as possi ble in the City of Ornngcbu rg. When fJur crime statist ics in
the City of Ora ngeburg st<1rt increas ing it concerns DPS. They do st1.tdies and they kno w when
they arc called out and ,vhcn they have to go to rl c1 ccs and tl1c place ::; they have to go to. When
they come to Citv Counci l and ask that ,Ne do a n O rdinance to hel p the m to <:ontro l crim e in the
Cit)' of Orangc b;trg, I fee l it is Counci l's obli gation to clo tbat. I rc::ili7c th;,t you may feel like
th;:i.t we're makin g a decision 1h;1t is detrim ental to yo•.ir bu sin,:;ss. but T rc:ill; would like to know
what yo u really thi nk abou t th at. \Vhcthcr or n0t closing 8t 2:00 AJvi. i11 the morni ng, how much
business are you cictually go ing to Jose if you close at 2 :00 /\.M . mid we we igh that agai nst how
much crime we arc going to prevent by closing es tablishm ents at 2:00 A.M. t11at have a
pretcnt ion for crime . We ,van t to be proactive on crime as much as we can in the City. \Ve wan1
t0 tr:: to kee p this ;:i sar: tnwn. \Vhocvc r it w;-, o: 1h3t ~poke c1 lwt1t the pc01+ : co111ing in ;)Jld
]t:,nking ci t (_)i;111gchurg awl lwving s0111rth ing to d(': they 1\::0 co mr: :ind lo<'k ~1 1hc cri111c r;itc in
OrnnQc b11r12:. If thcv Jrv,k ;it it mid sec ;, crime: r;:it,: 11':it is i11•:1':;1 ~ing or sec :i hig r,i n 11' i;, tc. t]v :, ·
<:;iy ,,':°],;11 y~11 ZllT rl ~in r: in th is 5i1q:iti0 n. \\ ·, r('ly n11 l )T'~ <' '1 \\ lii,·h i11 111 , ·
Page 4
opinion, does a good job in preventing crime in Orangeburg. I can't see where this Or~~
going to be detrimental to the businesses in Orangeburg. B&sed on that, I'm going to support the
Ordinance and I haven't heard anything tonight that would convince me anything different in
why I wouldn't support it. The statistics that we have seen, I have them here in front of me, and
I've looked at them again and I don't see any reason why we shouldn't pass this Ordinance.
Thank you."
Mayor Butler asked, "Do any other Councilmembers have comments or questions?"
Mr. Aaron Gillespie from Cloud Nine stated, "Mr. Jernigan, my response to that is there is a lot
of violence at McDonald's. People get shot at the Bojangles all the time. We know for sure
every year during Black Friday at Walmart there will be a fight. Security is provided to them.
All I'm saying is don't require us to shut our businesses down. You 're saying that you don't see
how that can affect our businesses, right? We're saying it can. If you want to go further into it,
we're more than willing to help you come along to that. But to sit here today and say, okay I'm
going to agree with this based on limited knowledge of the situation, then I think that it is unfair
to us. I can tell you right now and Chief Adams is here. I don't think it is right for anyone to
get into fights and be shot at any establishments, but if we're going there how many people have
been shot and killed in these communities compared to how many people have been shot and
killed at these establishments. So we can't put all the violence on these places . At least with us,
you can say that at Cloud 9. If someone gets shot right now in one of these neighborhoods , on
Chestnut or John C. Calhoun, who do you go to?"
Councilmember Jernigan answered, "DPS is there to protect us."
Mr. Gillespie stated, "And who do they go to?"
Councilmember Jernigan stated, "I guess they go to the people that did the shooting."
Mr. Gillespie stated, "I guarantee if something happens at my establishment , they come to me.
There's no guessing. They will come to me. We can work together to figure it out. I'm not
saying that nothing is definitive . I'm saying it has to be some room for us as adults, business
owners and Councilmembers. I shouldn't feel like you all are against me. You all are here to
help me."
Mayor Butler stated, "Our purpose as Council is we want to hear you and once we hear you, we
can take what you say under consideration. That's why we ask for the hours. We can take what
you say under consideration, this entire Council, we can discuss it and come back with a
decision, but our main thing is that we're looking at it and we don't have enough man power to
get around to everyone at these clubs if something goes wrong . We are required to keep the City
safe because we have people that don't go to clubs that are at risk. That ' s one thing that we have
to do. But we want to hear you; we hear what you're saying. And we can consider what you
said and discuss among ourselves and take it under consideration and get back with you. But we
hear you; we hear what you're saying. I'm listening, but we have to consider the whole
spectrum because we have people that send their children here to Claflin and State. They depend
on us to keep their children safe. We have old people that depend on us to keep them safe in
every neighborhood under the jurisdiction of DPS."
Mr. Gillespie stated, "I'm just saying to everyone go home at 2:00 A.M., That's all I'm saying.
We should be able to sit down and talk this out."
Mayor Butler stated, "It's not our intention to stop new business or to stop you from having
income. We hear you and we want to give you consideration. We are listening to you."
Ms. Baltzegar stated, "Orangeburg has had so many businesses to close in the last two or three
years. It is a statistical fact when unemployment increases, crime increases. Most people that
are going to do crime, are going to do it at night and in the wee hours of the morning. They are
not going to do it in the middle of the day. My second question to Council, which I have not
even heard discussed, if someone is in noncompliance of this Ordinance, if it is passed, what will
Page 5
the ri-S:4Jlf they do not comply? What is the penalty goii1g to be? Has that even been
discussed or considered? Thank you."
Mr. William Green stated , "In reaction to what I just heard, what do you do when you close
down a business at 2:00 A.M . in the morning; preplanned to that since everyone knows we have
to close at 2:00 A.M .? There are people that are planning house parties in several communities
around Orangeburg and in the Orangeburg City limits. How do you control that? If they remain
at a club or sports bar, you know where they are. If Public Safety is getting several calls from all
parts of the City of Orangeburg becau se there is a party here that something happened or a party
there that something happened. How do you know where to get to? If you have to go to a club,
you know where to club is located? You don't know where these houses are located. So how do
you control that? There are already people starting to hav e house parties in communities . If this
Ordinance is passed, there will be even more house parties in the communities. How do you
control that? How many office rs do you have to send to these different areas where all of these
parties are located? And some of the streets, you may not know the name of them. So how do
you find them? If they are at one of these pubs , you can find them because these pubs have a
name . I feel, like I said before, the Councilmembers that are sitting up here, if this Ordinance is
passed, it really shows how unattached you all are with the citizens of Orangeburg . There is a
big age difference between the people that are sitting on this Council and the people that are
trying to have a good time and enjoy them in the City."
Mayor Butler stated, "We have heard everyone and we are going to take what everyone said
under advisement and we will get back with you."
A motion was made by Councilmember Stroman, seconded by Councilmember Haire, to approve
the Second Reading of an Ordinance amending Chapter VII of the Code of Ordinances of the
City of Orangeburg by adding a new Section 7-8, Titled Business License Incenti ve Program for
New Businesses. This motion was unanimousl y approved.
A motion was made by Mayor Butler , seconded by Councilmember Stroman, to table the Second
Reading of an Ordinance prohibiting the sale and on premise consumption of alcoholic
beverages in commercial establishments during certain hours. This was a 4-2 vote as
Counci lmembers Jernigan and Haire opposed.
Ms. Evelyn Disher, Commu nity of Character Director, accepted the June 20 16, Proclamation
"Sincerity''.
DPU Manager Tommy Miller stated, "The Orangeburg Department of Public Utilities will
implement a rate reduction to reflect lower projected fuel costs from its principal electricity
supplier, South Carolina Electric and Gas Company. The reduction will equal approximately
$4.5 million over the next twelve months. The DPU's rates automatically adjust to reflect
changes in its power supp ly costs. The pass-through of this cost reduction will be reflected in a
reduction in energy charges for all the DPU's customers. A typical residential customer's
monthly bill will decline approximately $6.50 or $78.00 over the next twelve months . The
changes will be reflected in the bills dated after June 1, 2016. As a part of the DPU's long term
power supp ly agreement entered into with SCE&G on January 19, 2011, SCE&G forecasts its
fuel costs each yea r. SCE&G changes the rate it charges DPU for fuel costs once a year based on
this forecast. A second component of the price that DPU pays for its electricity is related to the
cost of power supply agreement since January 1, 2013 and will not change until SCE&G's V.C.
Summer Unit #2 goes online some time in 2019. Based on the reduction in SCE&G's fuel costs.
our rates allow us to directly pass the decrease on to our customers. The lower costs that
SCE&G pays for the natural gas used in its generating units have resulted in a significant decline
in their fuel costs. This is the third power supply cost decrease that we have passed on to our
customers over the last two years."
DPU Manager Miller presented a Resolution for the City of Orangeburg, Department of Public
Utilities to accept the low responsive, responsible bid by Foremost Pipeline Construction
Company, Inc., of Gaston, SC, in the amount of$1,831 ,187.47 for the construction of
approximately eight miles (approximately 42,000 ft.) of 6" steel gas main on US Highway 176
Page 6
2541
South . He stated that construction begins this summer and will take approximately ten (10)
months to complete and the bid was under the budget amount.
Councilmember Barnwell stated, "Where is this going?"
DPU Manager Miller stated, "Near Interstate 95, the County ran water there years ago and this is
a pipeline for the future as there is a medium plant there as well as a few agriculture customers. "
Councilmember Stroman stated , "Is this the same company as the one that worked in Santee?"
DUP Manager Miller stated, "Yes."
Councilmember Jernigan stated, "Are we providing gas to Matthews Park?
DPU Manager Miller stated, "Ye s, we already have it there. This will enable us to double feed
the park."
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to
approve a Resolution for the City of Orangeburg, Department of Public Utilities to accept the
low responsive , responsible bid by Foremost Pipeline Construction Company, Inc., of Gaston,
SC, in the amount of $1,831,187.47 for the construction of approximately eight miles
(approximately 42,000 ft.) of 6" steel gas main on US Highway I 76 South. The motion was
unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Haire, to enter
into an Executive Session for Contractual arrangements and proposed sale of property, ( 1)
Orangeburg County /Piedmont Company Proposed Agreement, (2) Sale of property at 1099
Russell Street, and a Personnel Matter concerning (1) Department of Public Safety - City
Grievance Committee Findings.
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Jernigan , to
return to Open Session. This motion was unanimousl y approved .
Council returned to Open Session .
A motion was made by Councilmember Jernigan , seconded by Councilmember Haire, to accept
the recommendations of the Grievance Committee. This was a 5 -1 vote as Councilmember
Stroman opposed.
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Councilmember Knotts, to adjourn.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
/pfb
2S4~
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
June 21, 2016
Orangeburg City Council held its regularly scheduled City Council meeting on June 21 , 2016, at
7:00 P.M., in Council Chambers with Mayor Butler presiding.
PRESENT:
Michael C Butler, Mayor
Charles B. Barnwell
Bernard Haire
Charles W. Jernigan
L. Zimmerman Keitt
Sandra P. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
A motion was made by Councilmember Stroman, seconded by Councilmember Haire, to approve
the June 7, 2016, City Council minutes as distributed . This motion was unanimously approved .
Regarding the Ordinance prohibiting the sale and on premise consumption of alcoholic
beverages in commercial establishments during certain hours, the following individuals made an
appearance .
Mr. Michael Payne with Delta 4 Security, LLC spoke. He stated, "I am the owner of Delta 4
Security, Barnwell , SC and we have the same power of arrest as local Jaw enforcement. I work at
the Local's Pub. People are now getting the picture that we are not just a local security team, we
are enforcing the law and we are armed. I have informed my team to raise the bar. While we
work hard to prevent crime, we realize that not all crime naturally comes to an end at a club,
movie theater, shopping mall, etc. At any given time you can turn on the news and see the
violence in America and that the need for local security is needed now more than ever as our
local enforcement cannot be everywhere as there simply is not enough. While we would like to
have more officers with the local cities , counties and states, trying to balance budgets , it is just
not reachable at this time . This is where our security comes in and fills in the gap. Businesses
hire us at their own expense, not costing the county or city, and still keeping the crimes down.
The presence of armed security officers can keep some crime down from happening with local
law enforcement working. I say that because private security cannot transport according to state
law, but we do have the power of arrest and we can have the suspects ready after calling in to
dispatch to have law enforcement transport them to the county jail. "
Mayor Butler ask, "Do you work at the Local Pub."
Mr. Payne stated, "Yes."
Mayor Butler asks, "How long have you been there."
Mr. Payne answered , "Four or five months ."
Councilmember Jernigan asks, "Since you are a security person and work for the Local Pub, how
do you explain that our DPS department has designated and given us a report that it a high crime
area? What is your respon se to that?"
Mr. Payne answered, "Well, sir, according to state law enforcement we do not have the numbers.
As security officers, we make the call into dispatch and we do not get credit for that. Your local
law enforcement does."
Councilmember Jernigan stated , "You are not answering my question . How do you figure if you
are supposed to be containing this crime and preventing it, why is it that our DPS department
said it is high crime area there?"
Page2
Mr. Payne stated, "Well sir, I am not aware of what happened before our arrival but a!54t,
arrival we have brought everything down to a bare minimum. Now, if law enforcement considers
this to be a high crime area, where are those crimes? At that particular area there are reports that
these particular crimes happe ned at this particular area while security was there. I would have to
review those files and then determine if this is in fact a high crime area."
Councilmember Jernigan state d, "Our Public Safety is tasked with pre venting crimes in
Orangeburg and keeping our citizens safe. Do you feel like closing from 2:00 A.M. to 6:00 A.M.
would?"
Mr. Payne stated, "Sir , I don't think it is going to prevent crime . Crime is something that is
going to happen just like the sunrise in the morning ."
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "Do you think it will help?"
Mr. Payne answered, "No , I don 't think it is going to help. It is just going to spread. I will give
a scenario. In my hometown , when authorities came in to shut down a local club , downtown ,
the crowd was at one particular area and what they did not reali ze was that crimes spread
throughout the neighborhood making it more difficult for law enforceme nt to response quicker.
At least if there is crime in a certain area, we can contain it.
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "Why does crime spread?"
Mr. Payne answered ," If you stop people from going to local clubs, they just go to someone's
back yard where there is no security and more feasible for crime."
Councilmember Jernigan stated, "I don't totally agree with you and I have to go along with our
Public Safety Department as that is their job and they know where they are having to go to the
most in Orangeburg and what is creating the problem for them. They have come to us for a
solution ."
Mr. Payne asks if he could be provided with some document ation of the crimes.
Councilmember Jernigan stated that he did not have the information, but Chief Mike Adams
could provide him with it.
Mr. William Green spoke "As I mentioned at the last meeting, this is the lady who is supposed to
be opening up a supper club in a downtown area in City of Orangeburg. I want to know from
Council why you are wanting to shut these businesses down."
Mayor Pro Tern Keitt state d, "We are not shutting the doors, we said closing at 2:00 A. M., but
that is not shutting the doors, the doors are open from whatever time they open in the day until
2:00 AM., by 2:30 A.M . everyone should be out of the place."
Mr. Green stated, " These business owners clearly state that between the hours of 1 :00 A.M. and
4:00 A.M. is when they make their revenue as they are getting people in that work a second shift
in plants in Orangeburg County. If they have to close at 2:00 A.M. that means they are losing
fifteen or twenty people and they will have to cut their staff in half because they cannot afford to
pay them, pay their light bill, or their rent, if they do not own their building , so that is shutting
their doors. If they have to close at 2:00 A.M . and they make their money between l :00 A.M.
and 4:00 A.M ., then you are forcing them to shut their business down. Any questions?"
Councilmember Jernigan stated, "You mean to tell me that they don 't make enough money from
between 6:00 A.M. in the morning and 2:00 A.M. to be open?"
Mr. Green stated, "That ' s not how they make their money. They make their money by their
customers coming , in other words they are coming when get off from a grave yard shift. That's
when they make the majority of their money, so if they have to close at 2:00 A.M. you are
forcing them to basicall y have to close their doors. That was state d at the last meeting or was
Page3
anybody paying attention or just relaxing back and reclining in their chairs. You need to take
not~12tgl, what people are saying about their businesses. I see people sitting back and
rec~ifig'i11<e they are at home watching television. You all need to sit up and pay attention
because this is going to destroy Orangeburg. People already do not want to come here. I have
an aunt from DC that comes here with her two kids and once they are here two days, they are
ready to leave as there is nothing to do here. How can you expect things to grow if you are
hindering the growth? I do not understand ."
Councilmembe r Barnwell stated, "Every town around us closes their bars at 2:00 A. M.,
Columbia included."
Mr. Green stated, "No they do not. I have heard this from law enforcement. The City of
Charleston and Columbi a, closes at 2:00 A.M., but outside the city closes at 4:00 A.M. or 5:00
A.M. in the morning , because I have been there, but in Orangeburg, the City and County want to
close at 2:00 A.M .. The only thing you are going to do is create more crime as people want
something to do."
Councilmember Jernigan stated. "We do not have anything to do with the County."'
Mr. Green stated, "I am just bringing it up, that's all. It was brought up last time. I brought it
up to show an example. In Orangeburg , you want the City and County to close at 2:00 A.M."
Councilmember Jernigan stated, "I do not care what the County does . I am thinking about the
City and that 's all I'm thinking about and that's all this Ordinance references."
Mayor Butler stated, "Mr. Green, we have your message, you want to stay open past 2:00 A.M."
Ms. Adaline Yon spoke, she stated, "I am a licensed master social worker and I am also an
entrepreneur and I am going to be honest. I am shocked. I have known Ms. Keitt since I was 18
years old just coming out of high school and she introduced to me the importance of
participating in different activities in the county. Ms. Keitt took care of my generation, all three
of my children and one is an aspiring doctor, a musician and a journalist. When my son came
home from Chicago, he came here to do the graduation speech for Howard Middle School. He
told me that he was ready to leave as there was not anything to do in Orangeburg. My question
is, do you all believe in passing the torch? I am a senior citizen and I always felt like getting
involved in things to get the City to grow and we have to do something to encourage these young
people and I don't see any young people here. I mean, people, what's going on? How many
more years do you all think we have to live, what's going to happen to Orangeburg and it breaks
my heart. I can remember in the 1970' s, when I was a teenager, that we had a lot of stuff going
on, wonderful things. You don 't even see the college students walking down the street anymore
and no jobs . It broke my heart about the Samaritan House. Orangeburg has a lot of probl ems."
Mr. Samuel Glover spoke. He stated, "As noted on your agenda , I am here for a particular
reason, the Samaritan House. I appeared before County Council last night. I started with the
Samaritan house one year ago in May as I wanted to do something for the County and the
homeless. I had no idea that one year later that I would be the Chairman of the Samaritan
House. I want to thank Counci lmember Jernigan's wife for starting the Samaritan House and it is
certainly needed in this three county area, Orangeburg, Calhoun and Bamberg. The next nearest
place for the homeless is Columbia, which is quite some distance and I think all of you are aware
that we have quite a few homeless people in Orangeburg. One year ago , at the Samaritan House
we had seven (7) board members and now we have twelve (12) very professional board
members . I think we know how to run the Samaritan House , all except the part that is most
important, as someone needing to be the director of the Samaritan House and someone to run
that place on a day to day basis. What really happened, there were some things in the paper and I
wrote an editoria l. The Samaritan House opened in 2002 and was operating off of a shoe string
budget, in 2004 we received a HUD grant for $226,000.00 with matching funds . For the first
three years the City supported us and Orangeburg County has continued to support us. On the
211d of May, we got a notice that the Samaritan House would not be receiving any additional
funds as of the 31st of May and that was not enough time for us to get funding to continue to
Page 4
operate. We were getting by on a shoe string budget with what we were getting from HlJQ. cpi;L
some other places, the County and some churches allowing us to get by. When I beca~M~
Chairman, we started meet ing on a monthly basis and we started to see things that needed
improving and one of them was funding . The director at that time said she was going to retire
and that really was not good for us and in addition to that we only had two people, the night
person and on weekends a part time cook. We had fourteen (14) persons in the house at that
time, the 2°d of May, and when it got to the 31st, we only had two (2) people in the house. One
went to the Dalton House and the other one had a problem with his social security card and once
we got that taken care of, he will have a job. We want that facility to return and it is going to take
approximately $125,000 to $130,000 a year for that facility to stay open and that is operating
with the bare minimum and that is starting with five people to help them to be productive
citizens."
Mayor Butler asks, "What kind of fund raisers have you done?"
Mr. Glover stated , "We have only done one and we closed down on the 31st and at that time
HUD required us to do certain things and get reports back to them . There was not a whole lot of
time to do anything else ."
Councilmember Barnwell asked, "Why did HUD cut off part of your funding?
Mr. Glover stated, "We have no idea, but it happened throughout the United States ."
Mayor Butler stated . "They do not want to work with temporary shelters; they want to work
with permanent shelters throughout the United States."
Councilmember Barnwell asks, "You are not a permanent shelter? "
Mr. Glover stated, "We are a transitional facility in that we have a certain period of time to get
folks ready to go to work and that is why we need skilled workers."
Councilmember Haire stated, "I thought I heard you say that you were still getting things ready
for HUD which leads me to believe there is still a possibility of getting HUD assistance ."
Mr. Glover stated, "There is no possibility, as all across the United States transitional facilities
are being closed."
Mr. Haire asks, "What is it that the other counties are doing as it relates to the Samaritan
House?"
Mr. Glover answered, "We are giving them the same presentation as we are giving to you all."
Councilmember Haire asks, Have they in the past, to your knowledge, contributed anything to
the Samaritan House in the past? "
Mr. Glover states, "Yes, Calhoun County has and with my limited knowledge and searching
around the house without a director, I could not find anything of what has happened in the past."
Councilmember Jernigan asks, "Have you determined who owns the building now?"
Mr. Glover stated, "That is a good question The Federal Home Bank owns that building now
and there is a $150,000.00 note on the building. If we occupy the building until 2024, then the
county, city or Samaritan House will own that building, but it has to be occupied."
Councilmember Jernigan asks, "Has there been any payments on the building?
Mr. Glover stated, "It is a forgivable loan."
Mayor Pro Tern Keitt asks, "What plans do you have now, other than asking for help ."
Pages
Mr. 2"5'41(jtated, "We have no plans. "
Councilmemb er Jernigan asks, "Have you put any kind of budget together? I will actually need
to see an operating budget , what's your plan?"
Mayor Pro Tern Keitt asks, "Put together a budget where we can see what you have itemized."
Mayor Butler stated, "We are very passionate about the Samaritan House and we want to see it
open and that is the consensus of the Council. If we get a budget, we will definitel y vote on it
because if we have a homeless problem that will affect everybody ."
Councilmember Barnwell asks, "What funds did you get from the County, Calhoun and
Bamberg?"
Mr. Glover stated, "We ll, I have not been to Bamberg or Calhoun yet. I will say when the article
came out we got a lot of calls and now the calls have just went away."
Mayor Pro Tern Keitt stated, "Present the budget to our City Administrator and he will get it to
us."
Mr. Willie Johnson made a presentation to Council. He stated, "About three years ago we had
a company out of Columbia as a consultant in revitalizing the downtown with a lot of pictures
and drawings and nothing ever materialized. So over this year, I became a concerned citizen. I
meet with Mr. Adolphus Johnson of New America, Mr. Jim Johnson with the small business
government of SCSU and an associate, Mr. Gary Robinson . We had meeting s with pros and
cons but the one common element we all had is a City tax plan that will help spark small
businesses in the downtown. There were five commons ones. There were (I) revolving loan
companies, (2) the City will waive the business license fee for the first year, (3)downtown fai;:ade
grant money that is available, (4) city parking, that we already have, and (5)
free wi-fi."
Mr. Gary Robinson stated, "I am coming as a citizen and business owner. First, I want to thank
you for working with the County on the Orangeburg County Library. A number of individu als
have been turned down for bank loans for new businesses. So having some type of program to
help businesses is needed in order to build more businesses downtown ."
Councilmember Jernigan stated, "I have met with these fellows on several occasions and these
guys have worked hard to see that Orangeburg progresses. They have done it without any pay or
recognition. I would like them to know that City Administrator Yow is on top of everything that
you are talking about. We are having a third reading of the Busine ss License Incentive Program
tonight. He is definitely on top of the rest of these items. It' s citizens, like you, that will make a
difference in Orangeburg ."
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Haire, to approve
the Third Reading of an Ordinance amending Chapter VII of the Code of Ordinance s of the City
of Orangeburg by adding a new Section 7-8, Titled Business License Incentive Program for new
businesses with first taxabl e year of operation not to exceed a maximum tax abatement of
$1,000.00. This motion was unanimousl y approved.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Haire, to approve
the Second Reading of an Ordinance prohibiting the sale and on premise consumption of
alcoholic beverages in commercial establishments during certain hours. This motion was
unanimously approved.
There were no utility matters brought before Council.
Page 6
A motion was made by Councilmember Stroman, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to
enter into an Executive Session for (I) contractual arrangements and proposed sale of j<54t7
regarding the Orangeburg County/Piedmont Company Proposed Revenue Sharing Agreement
and Option for sale of property at 1099 Russel Street and (2) Personnel Matter regarding the
Department of Public Utilities Administrative Division.
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, for Council to
return to Open Session. This motion was unanimously approved.
Council returned to Open Session.
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Councilmember Knotts, to accept
the findings of DPU's Grievance Committee. This was a 5-2 vote as Councilmembers Barnwell
and Jernigan opposed.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Haire, to authorize
City Administrator Yow to enter into option with Piedmont Company for purchase of property at
1099 Russell Street. This was a 6-1 vote as Councilmember Barnwell , opposed.
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, to adjourn.
This motion was unanimously approved.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
Respectfully submitte
crrie U--"Ollll ,
/pfb
BUDGET WORKSHOP MINUTES
July 11, 2016
5:30 P.M. 2549
Orangeburg City Council held a Budget Workshop Meeting on Monday, July 11, 2016,
at 5:30 P.M., in the City Council Building.
PRESENT:
Michael C. Butler, Mayor
Charles B. Barnwell
Bernard Haire
Charles W. Jernigan
L. Zimmerman Keitt
Sandra P. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
John H. Yow, City Administrator
John D. Singh, Assistant City Administrator
Carrie W. Johnson, Finance Director/City Clerk
City Administrator Yow overviewed the current FY 2015-16 Budget year-end
projections and the summary sheet for the proposed FY 2016-17 Budget.
TOTAL GENERAL FUND
Revenues
Expenditures
$ 19,360,458
$ 19,360,458
*Includes all General Fund operations and capital expenditures; does not include 2%
Hospitality or 1 % County CPST. General Fund does include $62,300 in anticipated
grants and Federal/State reimbursments. City Administrator Yow stated that the General
Fund Budget proposed is a balanced budget.
REVENUE HIGHLIGHTS
No property tax increase
No business license rate increase; Council did implement Downtown business
license incentive for new businesses up to $1,000
No commercial sanitation rate increase unless we are notified of increase in tipping
fee
$1.00 per month increase in residential sanitation; from $12.00 monthly to $13.00
monthly. Last increase was FY 2012-13 (about $55,000 annually)
No increase proposed in DPU transfer
No increase in fire contracts; Fire Response Recovery Ordinance will be proposed
within next several months
Still working with County on Fire Tax District
Recreation fees review; we do anticipate $30,000 through new gym
tournaments, rental and camps; Parks & Recreation reviewing registration and
sponsorship fees
$650,000.00 cash reserve budgeted
Interest income up slightly; still way down from years past
Building permits steady; not growing
No change in Franchise Fees (AT&T , Time Warner)
No proposed changes in Hillcrest fees at this time
Hospitality Fund steady; helps take load off General Fund with certain
departmental requests; $256,000 transferred to 2% for FY 2016-17
No major Airport Grant this year; no plans to spend $150,000 FAA Entitlement
Fund in FY 2016-17 - Will be carried over to future projects; fueling island
FY 2015-16
Page 2
Forensics lab fees being developed by command staff at DPS
~~ water management fee proposed as new costs
No proposed change in Stevenson Auditorium rates, was raised in FY 2015-16;
needs more promoting
EXPENDITURE HIGHLIGHTS
Continue all existing services; including glass recycling, which some cities have
ceased as glass recycling costs City between $1,000-$2,000
2.5 % COLA $83,000 equals 1 % with benefits ; for all full time employees= $208,750
Merit totaling $50,000 City-wide; $65,000 pays adjustments for DPS, command staff to
decide for DPS
City Administrator Yow stated, "We are looking to the Department of Public Safety staff
to allocate the $65,000 to personnel, even with the possibility of signing bonuses ."
Councilmember Haire asked , "What about signing bonuses?"
City Administrator Yow stated, "The Class Compensation Study needs to be revisited ."
Councilmember Barnwell stated, "I think we need to do a study ."
Council member Haire stated, "If it is City wide, what is the time line for this?"
City Administrator Yow stated, "Four to five month at least."
Councilmember Haire stated. "If there was money in the budget for a study, when it is
complete, we won't know how much this will be."
City Administrator Yow stated, "Yes."
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "Can we see the internal study?"
City Administrator Yow answered, "Sure."
Councilmember Knotts stated, "At least this sends a message that we are making an
effort."
City Administrator Yow stated, "You will have to come up with the money to increase
salaries from here on. We need to do it, but do it right. We need someone from outside,
no vested interest , to do the study, compensation and classification with bottom and top
levels. Some may top out. Cost unknown about $50,000 for City and DPU."
Councilmember Jernigan stated, "I would hate to see it get more top heavy with
$65,000."
Councilmember Haire asked, "Can we agree to get this study done?"
City Administrator Yow stated, "Please go over this with DPU and have DPU fund it.
There will be a number Council will have to address."
Councilmember Haire stated, "It is our desire to have a City wide Classification
/Compensation study done ."
After extensive conversation, all City Council was in agreement to the study.
Councilmember Haire stated, "If adjustments need to be made, let us know."
Page3
City Administrator Yow stated, "We will need to address different revenue sources2~1
the road to find funds to compensate employees.
Councilmember Jernigan stated, "We are trying to protect our citizens and citizens need
to pay their fair share. DPS is approximately 45% of our budget, we really have no
increases."
Two (2) new personnel for Gardens/Parks in P&R; approximately $55,000
Increase again in employee state retirement rates from 10.91 % to 11.56% on
SCRS general employees and PORS from 13.34% to 14.24% as of 7-1-16
$60,000 budgeted from medical and dental insurance increases ; dependent
amount picked up by employee; City is self-insured
$1,465,500 for capital expenses in FY 2016-17 to be done on three (3) year lease
purchase; major items include fire truck, $550,000; sanitation truck, $285,000;
miscellaneous mowers , tractors, vehicles (see lease purchase list)
Councilmember Barnwell stated, "Who decides if we need a new fire truck?"
City Administrator Yow stated , "DPS command staff. Trucks have to be inspected each
year and ISO has a say on this. The amount of $176 ,000 was brought forward from Fire
Equipment Reserve as revenue to assist with the purchase of a new truck."
There was discussion on an aerial platform fire truck.
$179,225 equipment costs budgeted in year-end FY 2015-16 to help defray
equipment costs for FY 2016-17 (see attached list)
$100,000 for continued building demolition and code enforcement
$256,900 of department requests moved to 2% Fund (list provided), others covered
in next CPST or Cemetery Funds or Narcotics Fund
No funds budgeted in General Fund for Railroad Corner Redevelopment;
$3,000,000 in next round of CPST; 4th Penny
Retiree supplemental insurance continues to be capped at $100 monthly; we will bring
back a Resolution of employee benefits
Fuel and tire costs stabilized for now. Again, have held most operational line
items
$176,000 brought forward from Fire Equipment Reserve as revenue to assist with
purchase of new truck; helps defray cost of fire truck
New DPS radio system (PAL 800) expense annually $43,000 CJIS Compliance
$67,500 , new expenses
Also, review what we can continue to provide in terms of barricades,
bleachers, PA systems, other equipment ; costs to the City, won't affect budget but we
need a policy to vote on these items . Delivery of equipment is a direct cost to the City.
No funds currently budgeted for new recently submitted outside agency requests ; no
direction given by Council at this time.
Councilmember Barnwell stated, "On the Samaritan House, we need more detail on the
budget."
City Administrator Yow stated, "Council needs to decide and give me direction ."
Councilmember Keitt stated, "The Samaritan House budget was not detailed enough, we
need more information; we need information from other counties giving funds to them
also."
Page 4
T~$~g no further business , the meeting was adjourned.
Respectfully submitted,
Lease Purchase FY 16- 17
70/20
70/20
70/40
70/40
70/40
40/01
40/65
10/30
60/20
60/25
60/25
60/30
Walker Mower
Kubota L47TB Bucket & Tractor
1'2 Ton Pickup
Kubota Tractor MC5200F
Kubota ZD1010 52' Deck Mower
Vehicle
Garbage Truck
Software
Three Vehicles & Eqmt
Firetruck
Two Vehicles
Vehicle
Total Other Financing
3 years approximately $488,500 Principle
$14,000
$55,000
$19,000
$19,500
$15,000
$30,000
$285,000
$250,000
$114,000
$550,000
$76,000
$38,000
$1,465,500
Added to Projections FY 2015-16 from Requests of FY 2016-17
(City Administrator Recommendations)
90/10 Weed Trimmers Misc Eqmt
Vehicle Capital
10/30 Battery Backup Sm Cap
Core Switch Cap
Computer ReplacementSm Cap
Laptop Replacement Sm Cap
20/10 Vehicle Capital
Copier Capital
40/01 Laptop Sm Cap
40/30 Painting Garage Fae Maint
Pressure Washer Cap
Roof for Garage Fae Maint
70/10 Copier Capital
70/40 Blades Misc Eqmt
70/40 Trailer Misc Eqmt
60/10 Microsoft License Comp Operations
60/20 Rumblers Traffic Contro l 460-028
60/25 Scott Packs Cap
Vent Saws Cap
Cooling Vests Cap
Metal Detector Cap
Battery Backup Cap
Saw Blades Materials & Supplies
60/30 Victim Ser Tablet Sm Cap
Moved to Cemetery Funds
70/40 Finishing Mower
Weedeaters/Hedge Trimmers
Total
Moved to Drug Fund
60/30 Binoculars
Revised 7/18/2016
$1,125
$22,000
$6,000
$10,000
$2,000
$2,000
$35,000
$10,000
$2,000
$8,500
$7,000
$10,000
$10,000
$2,400
$1,700
$2,500
$30,000
$4,000
$6,000
$4,000
$6,000
$4,500
$1,500
$1,000
$189,225
$3,200
$2,400
$5,600
$960
City Council Meeting
Special Minutes
July 21, 2016 2553
Orangeburg City Council held a Special City Council Meeting on Thursday , July 21,
2016, at 10:00 A.M. in Council Chambers with Mayor Butler !?residing.
PRESENT:
Michael C. Butler , Mayor
Bernard Haire
Charles W. Jernigan
L. Zimmerman Keitt
Sandra P. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
ABSENT:
Charles B. Barnwell
The purpose of the meeting was for the First Reading of an Ordinance (2016-6) to convey
property located at 1170 Russell Street, City of Orangeburg, SC, to Palmetto
Development Group .
Attorney James Walsh updated Council. He stated, "This is the first reading of this
Ordinance and we will update it further on the second and third readings. There will be
updates to the Ordinance because of grant applications. The second grant will be for
equipment and third grant to be applied for renovations and the possibility of a reverter,
property will revert back to the City upon conditions.
Councilmember Stroman stated, "Reverter , what does that mean?"
Attorney Walsh stated, "The grant applications may not permit a reverter, which means
the property will revert back to the City upon conditions, until we get the grant
application, I cannot say. The third grant is for renovations, $100 ,000 is what I've been
told."
Councilmember Stroman stated , "We should postpone this until we know what is being
done."
Councilmember Jernigan stated , "Why was this such a rush?"
Mayor Butler stated, "To assist this organization in furthering the City and getting loans
to get the grants in."
Mayor Pro Tern Keitt stated, "They need this to know for grants being applied for, you
cannot get grants unless you own the building . There are two more readings so we can
adjust as we go or start over, this is just first reading ."
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, to
approve the First Reading of an Ordinance (2016-6) to convey property located at 11 70
Russell Street, City of Orangeburg, SC, to Palmetto Development Group. This was a 5-1
vote as Councilmember Jernigan opposed .
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Haire, to
adjourn . This motion as unanimously approved.
Respectfully submitted,
Carrie W. Johnson
City Clerk
/pfb
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
August 2, 2016
Orang25Mr Council held its regularly scheduled City Council meeting on August 2, 2016,
at 7:00 P.M., in Council Chambers with Mayor Butler presiding.
PRESENT:
Charles B. Barnwell
Bernard Haire
Charles W. Jernigan
L. Zimmerman Keitt
Sandra P. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
ABSENT:
Michael C Butler, Mayor
A motion was made by Councilmember Stroman, seconded by Councilmember Haire, to approve
the June 21, 2016, City Council Minutes as distributed. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Councilmember Knotts, to approve
the July 11, 2016, Budget Workshop Minutes. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Stroman, seconded by Councilmember Haire, to approve
the July 21, 2016, Special City Council Minutes. This was a 6-0-1, vote as Councilmember
Barnwell abstained.
Ms. Shaniqua Simmons, Director of Parks and Recreation, introduced all coaches for the Dixie
All-Star Machine Pitch Baseball Team. They are Shane Burroughs, Chad McCutcheon, Fred
Riley and Jarrett Hill. Coach Shane Burroughs introduced the members of the team. A banner
was presented to the team and they had their picture made with Council.
Ms. Aaron Gillespie of Cloud 9 Bistro addressed Council concerning the Ordinance prohibiting
the sale and on premise consumption of alcoholic beverages in commercial establishments
during certain hours.
He stated, "Have penalties been discussed? I know you said this is about stopping the violence
after 2 A.M. I went in and got the records from my establishment from when it opened and in
three years, there has only been one case. My business should be exempt because of that and I
shouldn't be subject td this."
Mayor Pro Terri Keitt replied, 'Thank you and we will take this matter under consideration and
we will have to deal with your issue individually."
City Attorney Walsh stated, "For the record, penalties are $500 per offense or thirty (30) days in
jail."
A motion was made by Councilmember Jernigan, seconded by Council.member Haire, to approve
the Third Reading of an Ordinance prohibiting the sale and on premise consumption of alcoholic
beverages in commercial establishments during certain hours. This motion was unanimously
approved.
Ms. Evelyn Disher, Community of Character Director, accepted the July Character Trait
Proclamation, "Determination" and the August Character Trait Proclamation, "C:ooperation."
City Administrator Yow addressed Council. He stated, "The General Fund 2015-16 fiscal year
end budget is different from the last time it was presented by $10,000. That is due to an
oversight of the roof for the garage that was excluded originally. It has been added to the year
end which makes the difference added to the fund balance of$585,255. Otherwise, there are no
changes to projections.
Page2
A m~tion was _made by Co~cilmember ~aire, seconded by Coun.cilmember Strom~t~ ~:e!ove
the Frrst Reading of an Ordmance amending the Budget for the City of Orangeburg, ~e
fiscal year beginning October 1, 2015, and ending September 30, 2016. This motion was
unanimously approved.
City Administrator Yow addressed Council concerning the budget for FY 2016-17. He stated,
"The General Fund vis a balanced budget in accordance with Revenues and Expenses of
$19,360,458. This does not include Enterprise Funds, Hospitality Funds, or the County Capital
Project Sales Tax Fund. I would like to go over some of the highlights of the budget for the
audience."
City Administrator. Yow stated, "Revenue Highlights are as follows:
No property tax increase
No business license rate increase; however Council did implement a Downton Business License
incentive for new businesses up to $1,000
No commercial sanitation rate increase unless we are notified of increase in tipping fee
$1.00 per month increase in residential sanitation; from $12.00 monthly to $13.00 monthly. Last
increase was FY 20112-13
No increase proposed in DPU transfer
No increase in frre contracts; budgeted $30,000 new revenues for gym; anticipate $5.00 -$10.00
increase in registration fees
Recreation fees reviewed
$650,000 cash reserve budgeted, which is down from last year of$ 950,000. We did not use any
of the $950,000
No Airport Grants but $150,000 entitlement money will be transferred top future projects
No change in Stevenson Auditorium. rates
No storm water fees budgeted
City Administrator Yow stated, "Expenditure Highlights are as follows:
Continue all existing services; including glass recycling, which some cities have ceased
2.5% COLA for all employees, $65,000 pay adjustments for Department of Public Safety
Two new personnel for Gardens/Parks Division with Parks and Recreation Department
Increase again in employee state retirement rates
$60,000 budgeted from medical and dental insurance increases
$1,465,500 for capital expenses in FY 2016-17
$179,225 equipment costs budgeted in year-end FY 2015-16 to help defray equipment costs for
FY 2016-17
$265,900 of department requests moved to 2% Fund
$176,000 bought forward from Fire Equipment Reserve, as revenue, to assist with purchase of
new truck, which is budgeted at $550.000.
New DPS radio system expense annually $43,000. ens Compliance $67,500, Sanitation
Truck $285,000; $100,000 for Code Enforcement
Councilmember Jernigan stated, "Without you and the staff and employees this would not be a
great place to live, work and play. We have good people working for us. The budget is balanced
and I appreciate it. I thank Councilmembers and it is a team effort.
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Haire, to
approve the First Reading of an Ordinance to raise revenue and adopt a budget for the City of
Orangeburg, SC, for the fiscal year beginning October 1, 2016, and ending September 3 0, 2017.
This is a General Fund balance of$19,360,458. This motion was unanimously approved.
There were no DPU utility matters brought before Council.
Councilmember Haire made a motion, seconded by Councilmember Knotts, to postpone the
Executive Session for contractual matters and proposed conveyance of property at 1170 Russell
Street, in the City of Orangeburg, SC, to Palmetto Development Group and then Return to Open
Page3
Ses2$ f;6he Second Reading of an Ordinance to convey property located at 1170 Russell
Street in the City of Orangeburg, SC, to Palmetto Development Group.
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "Why are we doing this?"
Councilmember Haire stated, "I haven't gotten all the information I want gathered."
This was a 3-3 vote and the motion did not carry with Councilmembers Jernigan, Stroman and
Barnwell opposing.
A motion was made by Councilmember Jernigan, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to
enter into Executive Session for contractual matters and proposed conveyance of property at
1170 Russell Street, in the City of Orangeburg, SC, to Palmetto Development Group and the
Return to Open Session for the Second Reading of an Ordinance to convey property located at
1170 Russell Street in the City of Orangeburg, SC, to Palmetto Development Group. The vote
was 3-3 and the motion did not carry with Councilmembers Knotts, Haire and Mayor Pro
Tern Keitt opposing.
Councilmember Stroman thanked the City for removing debris and fallen trees from the river in
the Gardens.
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Councilmember Knotts, to adjourn.
This motion was unanimously approved.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
/pfb
-,
'
'
~
'
1 ---~
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING -AUGUST 91 2016
Orangeburg City Council held a Special Meeting on Tuesday, August 9, 20~e,30
p.m. in the Assembly Room of the Department of Public Utilities, 1016 Ru~'Stfeet
with Mayor Michael C. Butler presiding.
Mayor Butler opened the meeting by welcoming everyone to the Special City Council
Meeting at the Department of Public Utilities.
Mayor Butler gave an invocation.
PRESENT: Michael C. Butler, Mayor
L. Zimmerman Keitt, Mayor Pro Tern
Charles B. Barnwell
Bernard Haire
Charles W. Jernigan
Sandra P. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
The meeting was then turned over to 0. Thomas (Tommy) Miller, Jr., Manager of the
Department of Public Utilities.
Budget Presentations
Manager Tommy Miller to Mayor and Council
Manager Miller proceeded by thanking the Mayor and Members of Council for taking
time to attend the Special Meeting and allowing DPU to present its proposed budget for
their consideration.
Next, he thanked the Directors and their staff for the amount of work that they put into
this budget. This is a team effort; there are a lot of people working in the background.
Accounting people, cost analysis people compiling the data that this budget was
developed from. I would be remised if I did not thank Ms. Carol Franklin; this is her first
budget meeting with us and she has been a tremendous help to me, she prepared the
booklets and checked to make sure everything was accurate.
The purpose of our budget is to meet the future goals and obligations of the Department
of Public Utilities and to ensure that it remains one of the most respected utilities in
South Carolina. This budget allows us to continue to provide quality utility services to
our customers at just and reasonable rates and lays the foundation for the future so with
that, I am pleased to present to you a proposed budget for the City of Orangeburg's
Department of Public Utilities for fiscal year 2016 - 2017. This proposed budget has an
income of $94,704,380, almost $100,000,000. With expenses of $78,832,41 O with a net
profit before the transfer of $15,871,970 and this represents a return on equity for the
citizens of the City of Orangeburg of 6.8%. Two of the large components of the
Department of Public Utilities budget of course is the energy charges that we purchase,
that would be the electric power that we buy and of course the natural gas that we
purchase. This budget does take into account electric supply costs that are based on
our contract with SCE&G. It does not anticipate the unpredictable cost for electric
generation. If you remember back on January 1 we reduced power supply costs by $4
million annually and then again on June 1, six months later, we reduced power supply
costs by an additional $4.5 million. This was due to the cost of fuel going down for the
generators primarily due to the low cost of natural gas which is what they are using
today to produce electric power and we anticipate those costs to remain stable at least
until SCE&G's nuclear units go online sometime in 2019 or 2020. These power supply
costs are directly passed on to our customers and have no effect on DPU. It is a net
zero for us but the good news is that because our supply costs have been going down,
the cost of electricity to our customers have been going down and I think that is good
news for our customers. This budget also forecasts that the cost of natural gas as I
mentioned a few minutes ago to remain relatively stable; that is due to the shale
production so we expect the cost of gas to remain relatively low through 2017.
However, the cost of providing water and wastewater services continues to increase.
The cost of many of our commodities and government regulations and labor are
expected to rise and add to the cost of doing business. I am now going to talk a little bit
ab~S51) division.
In the Electric Division, we predict that overall sales for the next fiscal year will remain
approximately equal to this year's sales. This year so far, residential customers served
are down about 17 customers compared to last year but commercial customers are up
29 customers over the same period so the total customers are up slightly which I think is
good news and we believe that trend will continue. So far this year, large industrial
sales are down. If you remember, we lost one large industrial customer this year. That
particular customer was downsizing over the last several four or five years and finally
this year they shut that operation completely down. That and a warm winter contributed
to our loss of sales there. The good news in the Electric Division is that I do not
recommend a change in any of our electric rates at this time.
In the Natural Gas Division, we are predicting that sales will increase in 2017 due to
increases in industrial transportation and the addition of customers in special projects.
The Gas Division has one particular customer that I think began around January,
required a large increase in gas consumption and it's our understanding that number
will increase even some more in 2017 so we are actually really excited about that. The
Gas Division served twenty more customers, primarily small commercial customers this
year as compared to last year. The West System cost recovery is on schedule and as I
have said earlier, we anticipate the market cost of natural gas to remain relatively stable
due to the continued production of shale gas. We are very fortunate to have lower
natural gas costs and what it allows us to do is to be the low cost gas provider
compared to other gas systems. We are constantly looking at marketing efforts so that
we can increase our gas sales and our gas usage throughout the county and you will
see that in some of the proposed projects that Dave Durgin will present in a few
minutes. As in the Electric Division, we do not recommend or anticipate any change in
any natural gas rates at this time.
In the Water Division, we are predicting that sales and revenues will stabilize in fiscal
year 2017. Sales in fiscal year 2016 in the Water Division have been declining, partially
offsetting the 2016 rate increase that you approved back on April 1. We do show a 3%
increase in revenues that is attributable to that rate increase but in reality it probably
should be more than that. The decline in sales offsets about half of that increase. I
remember back in November which was the lowest water sales month that we ever had.
The good news is that with the hot summer that has turned around and water sales
have increased somewhat. As we have reported many times, the cost of operating and
maintaining our water system continues to rise, rapidly increasing costs primarily due to
increases in chemical costs, depreciation costs and increased distribution flushing due
to regulatory requirements. The rate increase in April that you approved obviously has
been very beneficial but we are continuing to study our water rates to determine if any
future increases will be necessary. The good news is today, at this time, we do not
anticipate any changes in our water rates.
In the Wastewater Division, it sort of parallels towards the Water Division. The sales
are up slightly, only 1 % in 2016. We are predicting that sales and revenues will stabilize
in fiscal year 2017 and pretty much remain the same as they are today. There is a 9%
increase in revenues in the Wastewater Division and again that was due to the April 1
-
rate increase; the same increase that we had in the Water Division. The flat sales in .......,
wastewater has offset some of that rate increase but not has had as much effect on the
Wastewater Division as it has the Water Division. As with the water operations, the cost
of wastewater continues to increase and these costs will increase significantly as we
continue to operate and maintain the Wastewater Treatment Plant and the gaining
distribution system. The increase in our wastewater rates in April have been beneficial
but we will continue to study our wastewater rates to determine if there will be any need
for future increases but again, I am happy to report that we do not anticipate or
recommend any change in our wastewater rates at this time.
2
Proposed spending on capital projects fiscal year 2016-2017 is $13,824,100. In a few
minutes the Directors will present their proposed projects in their respective divisions
and give you some more details on them. There are 13 capital projects, six of those
project are carry-over capital projects previously approved and seven are nev,~ed
capital projects. As always, we feel that this is a sound and responslJ!e-'~get
proposal and I will say it one more time, does not include an increase in any of our rates
that this time. It does allow for a 2.5% cost of living increase for employees and it
allows for the transfer to the City to remain the same. This proposed budget will also
allow us to continue with the previously approved capital projects and with your
approval, allow us to get started on the new proposed projects that we will present to
you in a few minutes. I don't know that DPU has or ever had a mission statement but if
I had to say what our mission is: "Our mission is to provide our customers with the
safest and best service at the lowest possible rates. Our mission is to provide a
reasonable return on investment for the City of Orangeburg. Our mission is to continue
to maintain and invest in our utility infrastructure to meet the needs and challenges of
the future." We are confident that we can continue to meet these obligations with this
proposed budget.
Mr. Mayor and Council, this concludes my portion of the budget presentations. I will be
happy to try and answer any questions that you may have. Councilmember Keitt said
no questions but she is glad to see no recommendations for any rate increases.
Manager Miller expressed that this concluded his portion of the budget presentation.
The meeting was then turned over to the Directors to present their capital projects.
************************************************************
ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION PROJECTS
JOSH NEXSEN - DIRECTOR
Director Nexsen informed the Mayor and Council that the Administrative Division has
three projects in the proposed 2016-2017 budget for consideration. The first project is a
continuing previously approved project, the Enterprise Software.
Project #1 - Replacement of Administrative Software
(Previously Approved - Continuing Project)
Total Project Cost: $11.600.000
Expenditures to Date: $ 5.888.260
Estimated 2016-2017 Cost: $ 2,539.600
We are currently in the second phase; this was a two phase project. The first phase
went live in July 2015 and was the internal work management and financial systems.
The second phase is the customer service and billing component. This is the larger
undertaking of this whole project. We are currently under budget and currently on time
and with a proposed go live date of spring 2017. The key benefits of this project are it
updates our current GIS software which is nearly 25 years old at this point and the
operating system that it is running on its end of life; the IBM system is no longer
supported. There will be less reliance on manual processes. We will be able to take
advantage of our AMI / GIS capabilities with this system. We will have better access to
information from management, employees, customers and vendors. There will be
better reporting analytical tools and more integration with these systems. The total
budget for this project is $11,600,000; we are in our fourth year of this project and we
plan to spend $2,539,600 in the upcoming fiscal year. Director Nexsen asked if there
were any questions.
3
Project #2 - Economic Development Building
Orangeburg County I City Industrial Park
Tota-Cost:
Expertrs to Date:
$ 2,600,000
$ -0-
Estimated 2016-2017 Cost: $ 2,600,000
The next project on the Administrative Division's budget coming to you is an Economic
Development Building. We plan to construct, with the City Council's approval an
Economic Development Building in the Orangeburg County/ City Industrial Park located
at 1-26 and US Hwy 301. Similar to the building that was built several years ago that
GKN Aerospace is now in. The project overview is expected to take somewhere
between 12 and 15 months with the goal to attract industrial prospects into the DPU
service territory, increasing economic development activity and jobs in the area. 100%
of the funds we plan to use on this project we plan to recoup from the sale of the asset
so whatever we put into the project we plan to just break even. We are not looking to
mark it up; we are trying to cut all the cost out of it as much as possible and give it for
the price we can get. The key benefit of this area is that it has a good strategic location
for Volvo and Boeing suppliers. It is in the close proximity to 1-95, 1-26 and US Hwy
301, the Global Logistics Triangle. It has all four utilities readily available in that park
and it eases entry for any suppliers to some of the bigger names that are closer to
Charleston to locate. The graphic is a proposed site location. The primary building will
be 56,000 square feet with an additional 56,000 square feet build-out should the
prospect desire to do so. Director Nexsen asked if there were any questions.
Councilmember Haire asked in the OCCIP which we jointly own are there any monies
we need to pay the County for the use of that space? Manager Miller stated that DPU
has not actually discussed the plan with the County yet but what we would like to think
that the County would give their half of the ownership to us and allow us to build that
building. We would like to get the project approved before making that next step.
Director Nexsen stated that DPU has allocated about $150,000 in the budget for any
land development needed. This is a win-win for the County as well because if we build
this and it gets sold to an industrial prospect they bring jobs and investment, the County
gets tax revenue from the property taxes and industrial property taxes. Manager Miller
said if the property is approved that will be the first order of business to ensure that we
have the property.
Councilmember Haire asked to back-up to the software project. He stated that Director
Nexsen said that DPU currently spent $5,888,000 as it relates to software. You project
to spend $2,539,000 and we are scheduled to go online in 2017. If you are going online
then is there additional expenditures you are anticipating. Director Nexsen said that
only recurring support and maintenance; we would hopefully be significantly under
budget. Councilmember Haire asked are we looking at expenses around another
$1,000,000 to $3,000,000 and Director Nexsen answered yes sir. Director Nexsen
stated that he wanted to make sure DPU went live before he gave Council the good
news; your math is correct. We are significantly under the original budget. If you recall,
we looked at approximately 25 different vendors and we got numbers back from some
in the mid $20,000,000 range and we got some that were unbelievable in the
$2,000,000 range. He thinks the original contract was $7,000,000 or $8,000,000.
Director Nexsen asked if there were any other questions on any of the two projects that
were discussed.
Project #3 -1036 Russell Street I DPU Main Office
Total Project Cost: $ 400,000
Expenditures to Date: $ - O -
Estimated 2016-2017 Cost: $ 400.000
Director Nexsen stated that the third project is a proposed project that will be the
construction of a customer parking area located at 1036 Russell Street. This project is
estimated to take 12 - 15 months. The goal is to improve the DPU Main Office
customer parking area which will improve traffic and storm water management as well
as beautification of the area in the downtown street scape fashion. The key benefits are
the removal of an unsightly building and deteriorated parking area. It will improve
4
-,
-
pedestrian and automobile traffic on high traffic days and it consolidates the DPU
campus between Russell, Windsor, Cuttino and US Hwy 301. What you see is a
rendering of what the site would look like after construction. If includes resurfacing
completely of Cuttino Street down to the entrance of the drive-thru parking lot'JW~ as
well as the complete resurfacing back to the corner of Oliver Street by thEf"~~~ion
Army. He has spoken to Durwood Bowden and John Yow and this is on their budget in
the upcoming year or the year after to resurface Oliver Street with some penny tax
funds. We will do a cut in this area where they will be able to tie back into. This project
also includes some curb and gutter work along the sidewalk to improve some of the
drainage issues that we have. The budget for this project is $400,000 and is all planned
to be spent in this upcoming fiscal year. Director Nexsen asked if there were any
questions. Councilmember Keitt asked if the project would start this year in October
and Director Nexsen said yes. Director Nexsen said that we have done the site layout
and we would do a bid package for demolition and construction of putting it up. Mayor
Butler stated it would be a good look for downtown. Director Nexsen said that one of
the big things is if you look out there now there is head-in parking here and there is also
head-in parking there and on busy days the SCOOT doesn't like that you have to back
out on each side of the street so that is one issue it would solve and the other issue is
the walkway. Before the City owned this piece of property, our customers would park all
over it. Mayor Butler asked is we would take down the Cherry Feed and Seed building
and Director Nexsen stated yes sir that is the plan.
Director Nexsen said a summary of the projects are as follows: the total expenditures to
date for the software project is $5,888,260 and hopefully this will be the last year for this
project and he will give an update in the next upcoming fiscal year for any unused
balance. The Economic Development Building has a $2,600,000 budget and the 1036
Russell Street project has $400,000 budget, which both plan to be expended in the
upcoming fiscal year. Director Nexsen asked if there were any other questions. He
thanked the Mayor and Council for their time.
************************************************************
ELETRIC DIVISION PROJECTS
WADE HOLMES - DIRECTOR
Director Wade Holmes informed the Mayor and Council that the DPU Electric Division
has five capital improvement projects for the upcoming fiscal year. Two of these
projects are previously approved projects and three are new projects. All the capital
improvement projects I will present will serve to enhance our DPU Electric Division
distribution system.
Project #1 - 115 KV Transmission Line
Extension to Koyo I Highway 601
Substation #10 - Cont'd.
Total Project Cost:
Expenditures to Date:
Estimated 2016-2017 Cost:
$ 1.000,000
$ 120.000
$ 500,000
Director Holmes stated that Project #1 is our 115 KV Transmission Line Extension
Project. This project will basically provide transmission lines along US Hwy 601 in front
of Koyo. The key benefits of this project are that it will help reduce our already taxed 46
KV Transmission System and will alleviate some of the burden off that system as well
as to build the lines on the existing right of way along US Hwy 601. This project will
coincide with the rebuild of Substation #1 O providing power to that substation. This is a
$1,000,000 project of which we spent $120,000 thus far and are asking to spend
another $500,000 for the upcoming fiscal year for the purchase of materials such as the
poles and the conductors. He asked Council if they had any questions.
5
Project #2 - Koyo / Highway 601
Substation #10 Rebuild - Cont'd.
Tot · ct Cost: 5 700 000
Ex es to Date:
Estimated 2016-2017 Cost:
1560000
$ 1.000.000
Director Holmes stated that Project #2 is our Substation #10 Rebuild Project that is
Substation #10 along US Hwy 601 and Koyo. US Hwy 601 is one of the fastest growing
areas in our DPU electric territory. It is essential that we rebuild this substation to
accommodate any future growth along US Hwy 601. The key benefits of this project are
that it will allow us to get rid of all the antiquated equipment at Substation #1 O and will
replace it with a much better system and it is also a part of our overall five year system
improvement plan. We have identified and evaluated various substations and this is
one of the older substations we have that we have provided plans as to how we will
upgrade or rebuild over the next five to ten years. It is essential that we rebuild this
substation because it provides electric services to Carolina Regional Parkway,
International Boulevard Parkway, Koyo and The Regional Medical Center. This projects
total cost will be $5,700,000 of which we have already spent $1,560,000 which was for
the purchase of the substation transformers. We are asking to spend another
$1,000,000 on this project in the upcoming year for the other substation equipment such
as the structures, the foundation, poles and other equipment. Councilmember Keitt
asked when was the last time this substation was upgraded? Director Holmes replied
this substation was built in 1971 and probably in 1983 some of the breakers and
substation controls were upgraded. Right now the substation is running at a little over
80% capacity during peak time which is usually at the limit at which you want to put a
substation. Anything more you would be in duress and would probably start seeing
failures. Councilmember Keitt said that it really is due an upgrade. Councilmember
Haire asked where is there a comparable substation that is going to look like what you
are going to do at that site? Director Holmes said that Substation #19 near Husqvarna
is comparable. Councilmember Knotts asked that when you are doing that rebuilding of
that substation will there be any interruptions in service? Director Holmes stated no
maam; there will be no interruptions in service to any of the industrial parks or The
Regional Medical Center. We have a system that when we take the substation down
we can feed it from nearby substations. Director Holmes asked if there were any other
questions.
Project #3 - Goff Avenue/ Claflin University/
SC State University Substation #17 Rebuild
Total Project Cost: $
Expenditures to Date: $
Estimated 2016-2017 Cost: $
800,000
- 0 -
300,000
Director Holmes said that Project #3 is a new project for the Electric Division. It is
Substation #17 Rebuild. This substation serves Golf Avenue, Claflin University and SC
State University. This substation was built and designed in 1979 and most of the
equipment at this substation is at the end of it life cycle status. It is no longer viable to
replace it because we cannot find the parts. The key benefit in rebuilding this
substation is it will help us to eliminate the underground enclosures that you see here in
that substation. That is important because those enclosures represent circuit feeds and
if they ever go down, we can only take one at a time down so any worker would have to
be very much impaired with any of the other equipment while they are trying to work on
any of those enclosures; it is a major safety hazard to actually have it the way it is. Our
desire is to rebuild the substation and bring everything above ground. Councilmember
Haire stated that in essence, the substation was built from an esthetic point of view and
the new substation will be more practical. Director Holmes said yes, the new substation
won't be as pretty but will be a lot more functional and a lot safer to work on. The
present enclosures actually open up and the worker would have to get inside or use
some live-line tools to actually work on it. When they are working on the current
substation they are actually exposed to other energized parts. This project is once
again part of that overall five year system improvement plan. The project total cost is
$800,000 and we are asking to spend $300,000 for the purchase of substation
6
.. J
breakers, equipment and structures. Director Holmes asked if there were any other
questions in reference to Project #3.
Project #4 - Peak Shaving / Wastewater Plant Generation
Rowesville Road Substation #20 2563
Total Project Cost: $ 2.125.000
Expenditures to Date: $ -0-
Estimated 2016-2017 Cost: $ 1,700,000
Director Holmes said that Project #4 is also a new project for the Electric Division. This
is Substation #20, the Rowesville Road Generation Station. This project will add an
additional 2 megawatts of generation to the DPU Electric Division distribution system.
The key benefit of this project is that it will add peak shaving capacity to the Electric
Division. This project will pay for itself over the first ten years of service. This project
will also allow us a backup feed to the Wastewater Treatment Plant so that if there is
ever a power outage, they will be able to run totally offline without losing power. The
total cost of this project is $2,125,000 and we are asking to spend $1,700,000 in the
upcoming fiscal year for the purchase of the generator itself. Director Holmes asked if
there were any questions.
Project #5 - City of Orangeburg Department
Of Public Utilities Street Lighting Upgrade (Phase 1)
Total Project Cost: $ 200,000
Expenditures to Date: $ - 0 -
Estimated 2016-2017 Cost: $ 100.000
Director Holmes said Project #5 is also a new project for the DPU Electric Division. This
is a street light upgrade to LED lighting. Presently we have over 1500 street lights
throughout its territory that DPU maintains. The first part of this project will be to
replace the street lights along US Hwy 301 South to Five Chop Road. We figure this is
one of the main arteries into the City of Orangeburg and it would be aesthetically
pleasing to have newer lights and poles. The lights will be LED lighting and will coincide
with the other work that is being done by streetscape. One of the major benefits of this
project is it will tie into our already existing AMI system and we will have remote control
functionality with the lights to dim or brighten them through our dispatch center. Also,
the lights will actually report back to our dispatch center if there is something wrong with
the light (whether the light is out, the light is cycling or if there is a problem). That
information will be broadcast from the light itself to our dispatch center. With the new
LED type lighting, the lights will actually be more energy efficient and will definitely
reduce our maintenance cost. The total cost for the first phase of this project is
$200,000 and we asking to spend $100,000 in the next fiscal year for the purchase of
the lights and the poles. Director Holmes asked if there were any questions.
Councilmember Haire asked is the five projects would be operating simultaneously or in
phases. Director Holmes said that the Substation #10 Rebuild will be the longest of two
projects. Substation #17 will be operating in conjunction with Substation #10 because
with Substation #17 we actually have enough space there to rebuild that substation
without having to interfere with the existing equipment there. Those two projects will
probably be going on at the same time. Councilmember Haire asked how much of the
work will be contracted out? Director Holmes stated that for Substation #1 O most of the
groundwork for the ground grid will be contracted out. We actually rebuilt Substation
#19 so we have experience there to rebuild ourselves. Substation #10 is the same
thing, we will do most of the work ourselves. The lighting project we will probably have
to contract out because that is going to require breakaway setting the breakaway poles
and putting in new raceways to those lights. Right now along John C. Calhoun Drive
the pipe in the raceways are particularly old so it is probably easier to hire a contractor
to boar the raceways to the light locations. Councilmember Keitt asked if the manpower
is suitable enough now to handle the work. Director Holmes said yes, we do utilize
Sumter Utilities to help us with our maintenance work so that when we do have times
we have to shift crews for the capital projects we cover our other work. Director Holmes
asked if there were any other questions.
7
Director Holmes said that to summarize the projects, the Electric Division spent
$1,680,000 on the two previously approved projects and in the next upcoming fiscal
year, if approved, we plan to spend $3,600,000 on all five projects. He thanked the
MCZ<56Jf Council for their time and consideration.
************************************************************
GAS DIVISION PROJECTS
DAVE DURGIN- DIRECTOR
Director Dave Durgin informed the Mayor and Council that the Gas Division has two
previously approved projects and one new project for the upcoming fiscal year for their
approval. These projects represent an important investment in DPU and the future of
Orangeburg.
Project #1 - Natural Gas to the Town of Elloree/
Cleveland Street (Special Project) - Cont'd.
Total Project Cost: $ 1,576,250
Expenditures to Date: $ 100,000
Estimated 2016-2017 Cost: $ 1.476.250
Director Durgin said that Project #1 for 2016 is a previously approved project to extend
Natural Gas Service along Cleveland Street in the town of Elloree. This project consists
of installation of over 76,000 feet of plastic gas main pipe. Since project approval last
year, we have had discussions with the Elloree Town Council and secured an exclusive
franchise to provide gas to that town. This project is currently out for bid and we expect
to complete the project in the upcoming fiscal year. We recommend classifying this as
a special project for 15 years. The estimated cost is $1,576,250. Director Durgin asked
if there were any questions. Councilmember Haire said this is a special project for 15
years; are we going in the hole as it relates to our return. Director Durgin said that
whenever we approach doing a special project or are considering something to be a
special project, we enlist some outside help with our rate consultants and they help us
evaluate the validity of the project. We have reached out to several of the larger
customers in Elloree and have also conducted a survey of the population there and
received really good survey results from folks who are interested in getting gas service
from us. Director Durgin asked is if there were any other questions.
Project #2 - Natural Gas Service Along
Highway 176 (Old State Road) (Special Project) - Cont'd.
Total Project Cost: $ 1.958.250
Expenditures to Date: $ 300.000
Estimated 2016-2017 Cost: $ 1.658.250
Director Durgin said Project #2 for 2016 is a previously approved project to extend
natural gas service from US Hwy 301 along US Hwy 176 towards 1-95. This project
consists of the installation of a 6" steel gas main pipe and will allow DPU to serve a very
large area of the Global Logistic Triangle. We recommend classifying this as a special
project for 15 years. This project has an approved winning bid of $1,831,187 and
should take six months to construct. He added that this amount is below our projected
budget. Director Durgin asked if there were any questions. Councilmember Haire
asked for clarification of when you say a special project for 15 years, after 15 years, for
the record, do we have to renegotiate with someone as it relates to our ability to provide
the services for that area? Director Durgin stated no sir, the special project enables us
to put a construction adder to the customers in those areas that allows us to help
financially justify this project. Our ability to serve has never been challenged. It allows
us to extend natural gas service to areas that would normally be more difficult to serve.
Because our rates are so low, we generally don't have that type of inability to contract.
Director Durgin asked if there were any other questions.
8
Project #3 - Natural Gas Service Along
Highway 178 (Charleston Highway) (Special Project)
Total Project Cost: $ 590,000
Expenditures to Date: $ - O - 2565
Estimated 2016-2017 Cost: $ 590.000
Director Durgin said Project #3 for 2016 is a new project to extend natural gas service
along US Hwy 178 along Charleston Highway. This project consists of the installation
of 18,500 feet of 6" high pressure natural gas main pipe to Bethel Forest Road. This
project will help support commercial and industrial growth along the 1-26 corridor and
should take six months to construct. We expect to complete it in the upcoming fiscal
year. We recommend classifying this to as a special project for 15 years. The
estimated cost of this project is $590,000. Director Durgin asked if there were any
questions.
Director Durgin said in summary, that the Gas Division have spent $400,000 this year
on our previously approved projects and we expect to spend $3,724,500 in the
upcoming fiscal year for all projects to be completed in the upcoming fiscal year.
Director Durgin asked if there were any further questions. He thanked the Mayor and
Council for their time.
************************************************************
WATER DIVISION PROJECTS
ERIC ODOM - DIRECTOR
Director Odom said that the Water Division has two projects for your consideration for
the upcoming fiscal year.
Project #1 - Advanced Meter
Infrastructure (AMI) - Cont'd.
Total Project Cost:
Expenditures to Date:
Estimated 2016-2017 Cost:
$ 7,450,000
$ 290,000
$ 710,000
Director Odom said that Project #1 is the Advanced Metering Infrastructure Project
(AMI). This project is a continuing project that has been previously approved. The
purpose of this project is to build on our already existing Advanced Metering
Infrastructure that is in place at DPU. By replacing and retrofitting our water meters with
new automated meters that will be capable of being read remotely which is very similar
to what the Electric and Gas Divisions currently have. Today we have completed the
installation on our AMI System of the radio network infrastructure. We have also
completed the meter data management software installation; it is all up and running and
100% of the electric and gas meters are currently converting to AMI. Water is the only
division we haven't done yet. Once again, what Director Holmes just deluded to earlier,
he is starting to look into street lighting capability that utilizes the AMI technology as
well. The plan for the 2016-2017 fiscal year is to change out for retrofit all of our
existing commercial and industrial accounts with new automated meters. Once the
installation of all of our C&I meters have been competed, we plan to move towards our
residential meters. We are trying to basically get more bang for our buck by putting our
money into the larger user customers by going with the commercial and the industrial
accounts. We plan to change out approximately 4,000 - 5,000 meters a year until we
are complete so we anticipate this to take probably 4 - 5 years before we will have all of
them converted; that is commercial, industrial and residential. This is actually a good
thing for us because on the water meter side unlike electric which has basically an
unlimited power supply to it, water meters are out there standalone by themselves and
they have a battery so that by spacing the project out over multiple years once the
battery starts to die on the meters it will allow us to have a phased approach to get the
batteries replaced. The total cost of this project is $7.450,000. This past fiscal year we
spent approximately $290,000 purchasing the water meters for the C&I customers. We
9
anticipate spending an additional $710,000 in order to finish the installation and
conversion of those meters to AMI for the upcoming fiscal year. Director Odom asked if
there were any questions.
Pro~'1Ji Ellis Avenue Booster Pump
Station Standby Generator Replacement
Total Project Cost:
Expenditures to Date:
Estimated 2016-2017 Cost:
$
$
$
250.000
- 0 -
250.000
Director Odom said that the second project that we have for you this year is our Ellis
Avenue Booster Pump Station Generator Replacement. This is a new project for your
consideration this year. The purpose of this project is to replace the existing backup
generator at our Ellis Avenue Pump Station. The current generator, I call this my WWII
generator, was installed at our Water Treatment Plant in 1973. It stayed there until
1993 when we did a plant upgrade and we took this generator and moved it to our Ellis
Avenue Pump Station where it sits today. The pumping station which it sits at on Ellis
Avenue currently serves our St. Matthews Road system. That St. Matthews Road
pressure zone is the St. Matthews Road area, the US Hwy 601 to the interstate, The
Regional Medical Center is on it as well as approximately 3,500 residents, commercial
and other medical facilities that are out there so that is a very important area for us to
maintain at least a backup power source so we can continue to pump water bearing an
outage. The plan for us on this project is to replace this existing diesel generator with a
new natural gas fire generator. We also plan to upgrade the switch gear; there is
currently a manual switch gear which requires us during a storm or power outage to
dispatch someone to manually throw the switch so we plan to change it out with a new
automatic switch gear that will automatically transfer it in a loss of power. This will save
manpower and time on restoring the pump station to be able to pump water. The total
cost of this project is approximately $250,000 and we do anticipate spending all of that
in the upcoming fiscal year. Director Odom asked if there were any questions.
Director Odom said in summary to date, the Water Division have spent $290,000 on an
advanced metering project that is basically for the purchase of meters. The upcoming
fiscal year, we plan to spend approximately $960,000 in capital projects. Director Odom
asked if there were any questions. He thanked the Mayor and Council for their time.
************************************************************
WASTEWATER DIVISION PROJECTS
RICHARD LABRADOR - DIRECTOR
Director Labrador said the Wastewater Division proposes no new projects for the
upcoming fiscal year. The Wastewater Treatment Plant Upgrade Project is on schedule
and budget and will be completed next month. Unfortunately, the bond payment and
associated interest expense as well as the plant appreciation expense will begin this
upcoming fiscal year. He asked if there were any questions.
Manager Miller invited the Mayor and Council at a later date to tour the Wastewater
Treatment Plant. It is a very nice facility; they did a super job out there. Right now they
are in the cleanup phase plus it is 90 degrees outside so maybe in the fall of this year
when it gets a little cooler we will have you out and show you what $27,000,000 looks
like.
************************************************************
Manager Miller said Mr. Mayor and Council, this concludes our proposed capital
budgets and projects and budget presentations. He said he would be happy to answer
any questions. Councilmember Haire said he knows we are going to modern
technology with the software. Is there any kind of feel that you have for hacking and
people getting control of your systems. He is just wondering what kind of safeguards
10
,-,
-.
you have against hacking. Manager Miller stated that we have talked about this many,
many times and it is a great concern of ours as would anybody who has a database that
contains customers' information. Manager Miller knows that Director Nexsen has done
some work on that. He said he is not going to say that the system is 100~ c~tly
safe because he doesn't know if there is such a thing anymore but we have ~r¥s6me
measures. Director Nexsen said there are directives for the divisions. Director Homes
said that for the electric utility we get messages from FERC which is the Federal Energy
Regulatory Commission. They send out alerts monthly that we have to check for
malware. About two months ago they sent us a red alert to contact our IT Department
to make sure our system is capable of detecting malware and cyber intrusion. Director
Nexsen said we also have protected passwords. You have to have a 15 digit password
that has to be changed often. We recently bought a firewall between us and the outside
world. We have done some network upgrades recently that keeps a log of basically
every transaction that happens on all networks and blocks traffic from certain locations.
There are a lot of big areas in the world that we call blacklists such as China, Russia,
Iran and Africa which have IP addresses and we are not expecting information from
them so we do not accept any traffic from these sites. Manager Miller said that he read
something just the other day about a Quantum computer that is in the process of being
developed, it is still a couple of years away, and this article said that once it is
developed all the protection processes will be vulnerable to it. It will be able to get into
any computer system. Our federal government and defense system are working now to
get ahead of that. It is a real fear, there is no doubt about that; we are all very
vulnerable to that.
Mayor Butler thanked the Manager and all the department heads for the presentations
that were presented tonight. We are all working for the betterment of the citizens here
in Orangeburg and we really appreciate it. Councilmember Keitt said she certainly
wanted to thank Manager Miller, department heads and other staff members for a job
well done; we thank you.
Mayor Butler asked if there were any other questions regarding the budget and if not
they will have the First Reading to Adopt A Budget for the Operation of the Department
of Public Utilities for the Fiscal Year October 1, 2016 through September 30, 2017.
A motion was made by Councilmember Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell to
accept the First Reading of this Ordinance. The motion was approved unanimously.
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Councilmember Knotts to
adjourn. The motion was unanimous.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
Respectfully submitted,
(:.,~ {...9-~
Carol E. Franklin
Executive Administrative Assistant to the Manager
Department of Public Utilities
11
RESOLUTION
A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE ACCEPTANCE OF A NATURAL GAS
FRANCHISE AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE CITY OF ORANGEBURG AND THE
TOWN OF ELLOREE
WHEREAS , the Town of Elloree by Ordinance dated June 2 1, 20 16 agreed to grant the City of
Orangeb urg, State of South Carolina a Natura l Gas Franch ise Agreement for a period of sixty
(60) years and subject to the terms and conditions as contained therein; and
WHEREAS , by Resolution of the Town of Ellore e dated September 12, 20 16 the timeline to
accept said Franchise Grant was extended ; and
WHEREAS, the Manager of the Department of Public Utilities has advised Council that it is in
the best interest of his department that said Franch ise be accepted.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED , by the Mayor and Members of Council of the C ity
of Orangeburg , in Counci l assemb led, and by authority of the same, that 0. Thomas Miller , Jr.,
Manager of the Department of Public Utilities is hereby author ized to accept the grant of the
Natura l Gas Franchise of the Town of Elloree dated June 2 1, 2016.
AND IT IS SO RESOLVED BY City Council duly assembled this lQ ..}h day of September ,
2016.
RESOLUTION
A RESOLUTION FOR THE CITY OF ORANGEBURG, DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC
UTILITIES TO ACCEPT THE LOW RESPONSIVE, RESPONSIBLE BID BY PIKE
ELECTRIC, LLC OF MOUNT AIRY, NORTH CAROLINA IN THE AMOUNT OF
$1,097,962.40 FOR THE CONSTRUCTION OF APPROXIMATELY 14.5 MILES OF
PLASTIC GAS MAIN OF VARIOUS SIZES TO THE TOWN OF ELLOREE
WHEREAS , the Departm ent of Public Utilities of the City of Orangeburg, South Carolina,
rece ived bid s on August 25, 2016 for the construction of approximately 14.5 miles of plastic gas
main of various sizes to the Town of Elloree; and
WHEREAS , the low responsi ve, responsibl e bid for this work was submitted by Pike Electric ,
LLC of Mount Airy , North Carolina in the amount of$I ,097,962.40.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED , by the Mayor and Members of Council of the City
of Orangeburg , in Council assembled, and by authority of the same, that the low responsive,
responsibl e bid of Pike Electric, LLC of Mount Airy, North Carolina in the amount of
$ 1,097,962.4 0 is accepted; and
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that 0. Thomas Miller , Jr., Manager of the Department of
Public Utilities , is authorized and he is hereby directed to accept said bid and execute the contract
docum ents on behalf of the Department of Public Utilities of the City of Orangeburg .
. ~
RESOLVED BY City Council duly assembled this I,,D day of September , 2016 .
MAYOR
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
September 6, 2016
Orangeburg City Council held its regularly scheduled City Council meeting on SeptJ:Sik~
2016, at 7:00 P.M., in Council Chambers with Mayor Pro Tern Keitt presiding.
PRESENT:
Charles B. Barnwell
Bernard Haire
L. Zimmerman Keitt
Sandra P. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
ABSENT:
Michael C Butler, Mayor
Charles W. Jernigan
A motion was made by Councilmember Stroman, seconded by Councilmember Knotts, to
approve the August 9, 2016, Special City Council Minutes as distributed. This motion was
unanimously approved. Councilmember Barnwell was not present at time of voting.
A motion was made by Councilmember Stroman, seconded by Councilmember Haire, to approve
the August 16, 2016, City Council Minutes as distributed. This motion was unanimously
approved. Councilmember Barnwell was not present at time of voting.
Mrs. Barbara Johnson Williams and Mr. Cecil Williams,1843 Lake Drive, Orangeburg, SC,
addressed Council.
Mrs. Williams stated, "For over 10 years, we have been asking for help and assistance with the
extraordinary high sewer cost in our neighborhood, which is Northwood Estates. We have been
pretty much tossed aside or overlooked. We pay a charge for city water with our DPU bill. We
also pay a service charge for sewer as well as a treatment fee from Midland Utility, which is the
sewer company. We pay approximately $53 to DPU. The treatment fee is $31.31 and a $21.66
service fee. We cannot see what benefits we are getting for these service charges. Why are we
paying these services outside the city limits? We are being told that ground water is going into
our system and the system is costing us more per unit. The capacity charge went from $1.90 to
$2.30. The commodity charge decreased from $.33 to $.31. It is my understanding that we are
being charged $3.00 per 100 cubic feet which is about 740 gallons. The way the system is setup,
it doesn't matter about the seepage into the system, we are still going to have a high cost. The
little research I've done it seems people in newer subdivisions use approximately 200-300
gallons of water/sewer. We, as a neighborhood, are a little overwhelmed and are coming before
you this evening to ask for your assistance."
Councilmember Haire asked, "Have you met with anyone at DPU about your concerns?"
Mrs. Williams answered, "We had a meeting some months ago. We met with the Mayor and I
think several DPU persons were in that meeting. And these were some of the things we talked
about like the high cost of our sewer and the amounts we are paying. It seems as the sewer
company is blaming DPU and DPU is blaming the sewer company.
Mayor Pro Tern Keitt asked if there were any other questions.
Councilmember Haire asked, "Since your meeting, you have not heard anything back from
DPU?"
Mrs. Williams answered, "No, because we also talked about the possibility of them taking it on
provided the system was brought up to par and we also talked about annexation. Those were the
two things that came up."
Councilmember Haire asked, "The Company owns the system, right?"
Page2
Mrs.l$I'iJo answered, "They manage the system. We have been told Northwood Estates
owns the system. I'm not sure as I'm new to the area. Some years back this company got
involved with the sewer system at Northwood Estates."
Mr. Cecil Williams answered, "I have been there longer than she has, probably 28 years. The
system does not belong to us. They probably would like it to be known that we own the system,
but ifwe owned the system, we would not be paying the ridiculous rates we are paying. So we
have no control."
Councilmember Haire asked Director Labrador, "I suspect you were involved in this meeting
withDPU?"
Mr. Williams answered, "Yes."
Councilmember Haire asked, "What needs to be done as it relates to upgrading that system?"
DPU Director of Wastewater Richard Labrador stated, "First of all, I have had experience with
Midlands Utilities. We do not own it. Midlands Utilities owns the system. Homeowners pay
Midlands utilities. They have a wholesale contract just like the County and the Oaks. These are
standard rates, D PU has a fair rate structure and they bill by gallons used through the meter.
Councilmember Haire asked, "So there is nothing that the Department has done or figured out
what needs to be done in order to bring the system up to standard?"
Director Labrador stated, "If you have a problem with Midlands Utilities you go to the Public
Service Commission. It is not up to standards. Someone is doing a study to bring it up to
standards. We have assisted Midlands at our expense. It's an old system and it needs work.
Councilmember Haire asked, "If the system is brought up to standard, is Midlands willing to turn
it over to DPU?"
Director Labrador stated, " I have no firsthand .knowledge of that. The County is involved in
doing a study."
City Administrator Yow stated, "If I could interject something here, the water that they are
talking about is the water coming through the water meter. And I think what you're talking
about Mr. Labrador is the wastewater that is coming through the master meter. There is a
difference in that."
Mrs. Williams stated, "I thought that was what I was talking about too. The same water is what
they are saying we are being billed for. Whether is comes through that meter from Midlands or
whatever. It doesn't seem like we are being charged based on that. It seems like they just take
the total cost and divide it among everyone in the neighborhood because we were told that there
were persons that were not paying for sewer."
Mayor Pro-Tern Keitt stated, "We are going to have two more questions and then we are going to
cut it off."
Councilmember Haire asked, "The way I understand and maybe I misunderstood. At my house,
I am billed based on the water that I use that comes through the water meter. Are you telling me
that this is based on the water that goes through the meter?
Director Labrador stated, "It is liquid waste that goes through the meter."
Councilmember Barnwell asked, "Where is Midlands located?"
Director Richard Labrador stated, "I believe they are in Lexington."
Page3
Mr. Cecil Williams stated, "I appreciate this great opportunity to address you. I have ii 17
resident there for 28 years and a lifelong resident of Orangeburg. Northwood Estates is a
residential community with approximately 100 homes which approximately 99% are African
American. We've come to you because we need your assistance. We are located four miles
from Interstate 26. Approximately 68% of the residents are retirement age, fixed income with an
average of2.6 persons per household. Even though I'm a member of the Northwood Estates
Neighborhood Association (my wife is the President), I wish to speak to you from the
prospective of an individual. My wife spoke with you as the President of the Association. We
want to bring some attention to matters I feel greatly impact myself and others in the subdivision
economically and health wise. With extraordinary patience, for more than 10 consecutive years,
the Northwood Estates Association has tried to resolve the sewer issue. We have bounced from
the County to the City, to Midlands and back and forth. Everybody is talking about a lot of
things but nobody has stepped forward to help us resolve the problem. We pay our taxes. We are
good citizens. We obey the law. We love this community. We try to do things for this
community, but it's not being reciprocal to us in this Neighborhood Association. We are here to
ask for your help and I'm stepping forward here publically because in most cases I've seen my
wife year after year in retirement struggle with an issue and get bounced back and forth and
nothing really happens. In fact, my wife and the Organization have devoted 10 years. They have
held meetings, conferred, sought advice, lobbied City, County, corporate entities and
Commissions who after listening, talking and promising say wait or they pass the buck each and
every time blaming someone else promising change which never comes. At least, it hasn't come
yet. I'm only here tonight because apparently these methods did not work. Whatever we tried
did not work. Now we realize that we are at the City meeting, we just left the County. We are
not located in the City, we're in the County. We are charged unmetered for the discharge of
sewer. For example, my sister went out of town recently and she was gone for nearly a month.
When she got back, even though she did not use any sewer whatsoever, her bill was the same as
mine, so it doesn't matter if you use the sewer or not. We had about six inches of rain in
Orangeburg County last week, so guess what; our bill next month will be even more. So we're
impacted by both the City and the County. So let me graphically depict what we pay for sewage
services. This is a disgrace the amounts we are paying and there not be a resolution. Residents
of Northwood Estates pay the highest sewer rates in the Southeastern United States and 27th in
the entire United States of America. (Mr. Williams showed Council various posters.)
Representatives we have talked with, City, DPU and County and others are well aware of sewer
problems arriving from an old decaying system that allows waste water and storm water to
uncontrollably enter the system. That's why I showed you the pictures. You see compounded
with DPU and Midlands Utility charges on three different charges. Three charges we have. So
you take a retired 85-year-old person in our neighborhood on a fixed income is paying almost
$1,000 a year on sewer. This should not exist in our County. This is shameful. The health
concerns are a major issue to me. There have been a lot of deaths in our neighborhood.
Unrelated, I don't know. What I'm saying is, I don't drink the water. We feel for a long time
these problems have gone unaddressed. We are here tonight to really ask for your assistance to
solve these problems. We are vulnerable and we need some assistance. We just left the County
and they said "Blah, Blah, and Blah" as they have done many times in the past. We asked them
a question, okay, so you have no answers for us. We can go back in our community and tell the
home owners. Regardless, where the problem is and where the solution lies, all we need is some
help. Do we have to become the Flint, Michigan of Orangeburg, SC? But it's not lead we're
talking about, it's something else I don't want to mention. I want to thank you very much for
listening to me and I want to thank you again for your efforts in trying to help the tax paying
citizens of Northwood Estates in Orangeburg solve these problems."
Mayor Pro Tern Keitt stated, "Thank you Mr. and Mrs.Williams and your neighbors in the
Northwood Estates. As of right now, we have heard there is a study being done. We're hoping
that the City of Orangeburg, the County and Midlands will get together. Something needs to be
done. There is a study that is being done by the County and we're hoping that it is the County
that needs to do this."
Mr. Williams stated, "Do you know when this situation accelerated and the interest coming to
our community started? After I did the research on this. So we have heard this for years but
Page4
there hjS5f'8en any earnest. Can they do assessment as to why they are charging people who
cannot afford it?"
Mayor Pro Tern Keitt stated, "We are very much concerned with the problems you have. As of
tonight, we are going to take it under advisement, but you will hear from us in a few days. I
promise you that because I really don't think anyone should go through what you all are going
through; however, the County, the City and Midlands have to get together. This is what has to
happen. The Mayor will be back in town by Thursday and we're going to work on this. We feel
your pain."
Councilmember Haire stated, "I have a request. I would like DPU to provide me a report on
wastewater, water, and sewer leakage in this area"
Director Richard Labrador stated, "We have given the Home Owner's Association a report in the
past and we will update it and get it to you."
Mayor Pro Tern Keitt stated, "We ask that DPU look at this and provide a report to us as soon as
possible so that we can do something. We will definitely work to see what can be done."
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Knotts, to
approve the Third Reading of an Ordinance amending the Budget for the City of Orangeburg,
SC, for the Fiscal Year beginning October 1, 2015 and ending September 30, 2016. This motion
was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Councihnember Barnwell, to
approve the Third Reading of an Ordinance to raise revenue and adopt a Budget for Orangeburg,
SC, for the Fiscal Year beginning October 1, 2016 and ending September 30, 2017. This motion
was unanimously approved.
Ms. Evelyn Disher, Executive Director of the Community of Character, accepted the Character
Trait Proclamation for the month of September 2016, "Respect".
A motion was made by Councihnember Barnwell, seconded by Councihnember Stroman, to
approve the appointment of Mr. Ron Kohler, Airport Manager, to the City Grievance Committee,
as an alternate, to fill an unexpired term which expires 6-4-17. This motion was unanimously
approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Councihnember Barnwell, to grant
authorization to the County of Orangeburg for a highway right-of-way as they are planning to
pave Ambrose Street which runs parallel to the left side of the City's old C&D Landfill located
at the end of Pitt Road off of Cannon Bridge Road. The City's fence is currently located 12Yz feet
from the centerline of Ambrose Street right-of-way and the County is requesting the additional
12 Yz feet making the edge of the right-of-way 25 feet from the centerline of Ambrose Street.
The County will replace the old fence. This motion was unanimously approved.
Regarding matters pertaining to the Department of Public Utilities, DPU Manager Tommy Miller
stated, "On August 9, 2016, at the DPU Administration Building, you were presented with and
approved the First Reading of an Ordinance for the proposed budget for DPU for Fiscal Year
2016-17 and then on August 1611\ you approved the Second Reading of the Ordinance budget.
This proposed budget has an income of $94,704,380 with expenses of $78,832,410 for a net
profit before the transfer of$15,871,970. This represents a return on equity for the citizens of
the City of Orangeburg of6.8%. We anticipate sales in the Electric, Water and Wastewater
Divisions to remain stable, as well as an increase in sales in the Gas Division. This proposed
Budget does not include an increase in any of our rates at this time. Proposed spending on
capital projects in Fiscal Year 2016-17 is $13,824,100. There are a total of thirteen (13) capital
projects proposed in this Budget. The majority of the projects are six (6) carryover capital .
projects and seven (7) new proposed capital projects. This propose~ budget allows ~s to co~tmue
to provide safe and quality utility service to our customers and contmues to lay the foundat10n to
meet the needs and challenges of the future. I would ask that you please consider the Third
J
Page5
Reading of the DPU Budget Ordinance and the proposed rate changes as presented for ~,?cJ 9
Year 2016-17.
Councilmember Barnwell made a motion seconded by Councilmember Knotts, to approve the
Third Reading of an Ordinance to adopt a Budget for the Operation of the Department of Public
Utilities for the Fiscal Year October 1, 2016 through September 30, 2017. This motion was
unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Knotts, to enter
into an Executive Session for ( 1) Legal Matter concerning demolition of a structure at 1916
Centre Street and (2) Contractual matter and proposed conveyance of property at 1170 Russell
Street in the City of Orangeburg, SC, to Palmetto Development Group. This motion was
unanimously approved.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
Respectfully submitted,
/pfb
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
September 20, 2016
OraniM(tty Council held its regularly scheduled City Council meeting on September 20,
2016, at 7:00 P.M., in Council Chambers with Mayor Butler presiding.
PRESENT:
Michael C Butler, Mayor
Charles B. Barnwell
Bernard Haire
Charles W. Jernigan
L. Zimmerman Keitt
Sandra P. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
A motion was made by Councilmember Stroman, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to
approve the September 6, 2016, City Council Minutes, as corrected. This was a 6-0-2 vote, as
Mayor Butler and Councilmember Jernigan abstained, as they were not present at the meeting.
Ms. Michelle A. Mapp, Executive Director of the South Carolina Community Loan Fund made a
presentation to Council. She stated, "Thank you for the opportunity to be here tonight. The SC
Community Loan Fund was founded in 2005. We are a non-profit lender certified by the US
Treasury and the SC Department of Commerce as a community development financial institution
making loans for community facilities, housing, health food enterprises and community based
businesses. Over the last eleven years we have made 311 kians ranging from $10,000 to $6.2
million dollars. We loan to local governments, non-profits and for profit entities. We are
focused on financing real estate assets generating income in low income or moderate income
communities. In Orangeburg, we have worked with New America Corporation and it has been
one of our borrowers and has worked with redeveloping main street and we have made loans in
twenty-one ( 21) of forty-six (46) counties. We get our capital by borrowing capital from
financial institutions and foundations and we pool that capital with fundings with local
governments and apply to the United States Treasury for matching funds. We leverage local
dollars, twelve to one, that we relend for community development projects. In our packets, you
will find our annual report and other information of who we have helped. There is a wide variety
of connnunity based projects and we arc here to help and they look to us. We do not see
ourselves as a competitor but as a partner to make a deal happen."
City Administrator Yow will meet with Ms. Mapp in the future to further explore opportunities
and to have a presence in Orangeburg.
Mr. Fred Jolmson with F .A Johnson Consulting Group, Inc., gave Council an update on Railroad
Comer. He stated, "On April 13, 2016, we received a notice to proceed and have been engaged
in project launch meetings. There are a completed number of apprai.sals and several proposed
contracts and 82 % of property owners engaged. I have ordered sixteen appraisals and three
parcels to submit for City Administrator Yow' s consideration. There is some federal and state
option funding."
Councilmember Keitt asked, "Have we bought any property?"
Mr. Johnson stated, "There arc three contracts for your review tonight and three property owners
have agreed to the terms."
Mr. William Green of 1048 Doyle Street spoke to Council. He stated, "I have worked with
DORA and brought up the idea of the Farmers Market having crafts for sale, but was told it
would be $100.00 to sell crafts, why is this?"
City Administrator Yow stated, "The City doesn't put on the Farmers Market, this is a DORA
project. They work with farmers who sell their own produce that they grow. They do not have a
business license and not required to have one per state law."
Mr. Green stated, "I think the City needs a permanent Farmers Market, one that is in and out. Is
there any talk of this? I know Elizabethtown, NC, has one downtown.
Page2
. 2581
A mot10n was made by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Haire, to approve a
Resolution committing the City of Orangeburg with a local match for a Municipal Association of
South Carolina Hometown Economic Development Grant for the Airport. This will be used as
an Economic Development Grant for the Airport. This is a $25,000 grant with a $5,000 match.
This motion was unanimously approved.
Mr. Dave Durgan, DPU Gas Division Director stated, "On June 21, 2016, the Town of Elloree
signed for gas service. We now need to counter sign the Agreement to start the process. We
recommend passing this Resolution and allow the Department of Public Utilities Manager to
execute this Franchise Agreement."
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "How long will this project take?"
Director Durgin stated, "Eight to nine months."
Councilmember Haire stated, "Hasn't this item come up before?"
DPU Division Director Durgin stated, "Yes, it was addressed in budget meetings."
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "What is the return on investment based on the number of
people in Elloree."
Director Durgin stated, "Less than fifteen (15) years to recover the money."
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "How many gas customers are there in Elloree?"
Director Durgin stated, "100."
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "Are they using propane?
Director Durgin stated, "Yes."
A motion was made by Councilmember Stroman, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, to approve
a Resolution authorizing the acceptance of a Natural Gas Franchise Agreement between the City
of Orangeburg and the Town of Elloree. This motion was unanimously approved.
Director Durgin stated, "I would now like to present to you a Resolution for the City of
Orangeburg Department of Public Utilities to accept the low, responsible bid from Pike Electric
LLC in the an1ount of $1,097,962.40 for the construction of approximately 4.5 miles to the Town
of Elloree. This bid is below budget and Pike has a number of crews in North Carolina and
South Carolina and we suggest that you allow the DPU Manager to execute the contract."
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to
approve a Resolution for the City of Orangeburg, Department of Public Utilities, to accept the
low responsive responsible bid by Pike Electric, LLC of Mount Airy, North Carolina, in the
amount of $1,097,962.40 for the construction of approximately _14.5 miles of plastic gas main of
various sizes to the Town of Elloree. This motion was unanimously approved.
Cmmcilmember Haire spoke regarding DPU Electric Division. He stated, "On July 28, 2016,
City Council met at DPU to talk to the Electrical Division. This was done to let them know of
our support to them. The Electrical Division provided a list of their concerns. On August 15'1\
we met with DPU Management and gave them a copy of the concerns and asked that they let us
know which concerns they could honor. Two weeks passed without a resporue, not even a yes
or no. After a period of time, I called. I was inforn1ed they are working on answers and a
response. I then informed Management as to whether or not it could be done, yes or no. Later
we received a more detailed answer from the Department that I feel was evasive and not to the
point. I have come to the conclusion that it seems there was some foot dragging going on as it
took too long of a period to receive an answer or a narrative. We have men who are employed to
Page3
prol6Si;!e City utilities. There is a war between Management and the Division. We are not
taking these items seriously. There are things you hear in the street and you can't believe it all.
There seems to be some type ofresistance to provide relief to these men. The City needs to look
closely at these items and they feel that the response is one that brings us closer to Management
and employees. We need to go back and meet with Management as we need answers and this
needs not to be done in Open Session. Men who are here tonight in the Electrical Division, there
is an environment that seems to say, take it or leave it. I don't want to lose these men who put
their lives on the line and I do not take it lightly. They work storms, etc., and are called out at
night. We canuot expect these men to continue to work for us in this climate. We, as a Council,
need to sit down with Management and go through this list. IfI rated this episode from a 1 to 10,
the rating would be a 2, due to response time. This has lasted too long, two months and I want us
to bring a halt to it. Is there a feeling of intimidation, if so, we need to get it behind us. If you
see any value in what I'm asking, can we get together to address these concerns."
Mayor Pro Tern Keitt stated, "We are in agreement with Councilmember Haire to get this
moving. We need to work with them to help keep them safe."
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to enter
into an Executive Session for (I) Proposed Purchase of Property - Appraisals of properties in
Railroad Comer Redevelopment area, (2) Legal Matter-Northwood Estates Wastewater System,
(3) Contractual Matter- Update on access road for Recreation Complex off of North Road and
( 4) Contractual and Legal Matter - Proposed conveyance of property at 1170 Russell Street in
the City of Orangeburg, SC, to Palmetto Development Group. This motion was unanimously
approved. ·
Council entered into Executive Session.
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, to return to
Open Session. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councihnember Haire, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, to approve
the Third Reading of m1 Ordinance to convey property located at 1170 Russell Street, City of
Orangeburg, SC, to Palmetto Development Group. Councilmember Barnwell stated, I am
opposed. "They have lied the whole time." The vote was 4-2-1, with Councihnembers Barnwell,
and Jernigan opposing. Councilmember Stroman abstained.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Haire, to approve
authorization for City Administrator Yow to enter into a contract with R&T Grading, Inc., in the
amount of $611,476.76 for construction of an access road to the planued Recreation Complex
area. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern, Keitt, to adjourn.
This motion was unanimously approved.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
Respectfully submitted,
Carrie W. Jo
City Cle
/ptb
City Council Minutes
November 1, 2016 2585
Orangeburg City Council held its regularly scheduled City Council meeting on November 1,
2016, at 7:00 P.M., in Council Chambers with Mayor Butler presiding.
PRESENT:
Michael C. Butler, Mayor
Charles B. Barnwell
Bernard Haire
Charles W. Jernigan
L. Zimmerman Keitt
Sandra P. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
Mayor Butler asked that all the Federal Emergency Management Agency and other County, State
Disaster Assistance related groups, please stand and state what agency they represented.
A motion was made by Councilmember Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to
approve the October 4, 2016, City Council Minutes as distributed. This was a 6-0-1 vote as
Councilmember Haire abstained as he was not present at the meeting.
Ms. Elisa Roper, Intergovernmental Affairs Specialist for FEMA from Atlanta, Georgia spoke.
"I do work for the State of South Carolina. Basically, I want to tell you that we are in here as
you can see in force and we have abilities and skills to take care of things and if there are any
questious about these programs, we will have people outside to talk with you. Individual
assistance needs to file for disaster assistance. You can go online for the application or call and
there are disaster recovery centers in Orangeburg County. You need to file your claims for
assistance, if you do have insurance apply and if you don't apply. Even if you are denied you
have the ability to file for a Small Business Administration (SBA) loan. Just because it is a loan
it tends to make people uneasy as they don't want to ask for a loan. One of the big things was
that if you apply for a loan and you are approved, you don't actually have to take the loan, you
can stop it. If you are not approved it goes back to FEMA and there is a second chance for you
to get some assistance. Ms. Clara King is present tonight with the SBA and Mr. Rob Burton is
here from South Carolina. They can talk about the hazard mitigation program and also other
people with FEMA that can talk about filling out applications. I have some handouts for you if
you have any additional questions.
Mayor Butler asked, "Our Councilmembers represent districts. Are you having any trouble with
going into the neighborhoods and people not answering the door. They are not sure if it is
actually FEMA representatives."
Ms. Roper replied, "Looking at the numbers, we are leaving a lot of flyers and having a lot of
interaction also. I cannot tell you the number of people not answering the door but we have had
over 3,500 interactious of which have left flyers on the doors. As of yesterday, I was showing
right at 149 new registrations we had put in coming through the City. A couple of incidents that
had to be handled, but most people were very receptive to us but, if they feel uncomfortable with
us we do offer the website and an 800 number."
Mr. Yow stated, "Ms. Roper, you mentioned you do have centers for people to get assistance.
Can you tell Council where the centers are located."
A FEMA representative replied, "There is one at the YMCA and one in Holly Hill.."
Ms. Roper stated, "You don't have to go to one in your County. There are ten centers now and
you can go to whichever is closer to you. Also, in regard to people knocking on the door, we all
have badges and they are official badges."
Ms. LaShandra Morgan with the Department of Health and Environment Control spoke, "I am
the Lowcountry Healthy Eating Active Living Coordinator working with DHEC and I work with
Orangeburg, Allendale, Bamberg and Calhoun Counties. I am under a CDC Grant called the SC
Prevention and Health Across Systems Grant. One of the programs is pedestrian planning. I
wanted to do this in the City of Orangeburg because currently according to CDC data the obesity
rate here is 41 % and that is pretty significant. I wanted to make you aware of this. This year two
of the four regions will be selected for this grant. If you are not selected this year, you could be
selected next year for this pedestrian planning. Also, I am working with open co=unity youths
where schools open their outdoor facilities to children for open COillillunity use."
Ms. Beth Thomas, Executive Director of the Orangeburg County Fine Arts Center addressed
Council, "I would like to thank you for the support you have given us for our renovations. We
are making progress and steadily moving along and we are not quite as far along as we had
hoped but getting close. We did find out that we cannot be under construction during the
election because we are a polling site and could not in any way hinder any potential voters. Mr.
Cliff Emery has spearheaded this program from the start and he has prepared reports throughout.
We did submit a report and we do have an update that we can pass out to you. Mr. Emery will
go over this with you."
Mr. Cliff Emery spoke. He stated, "Thank you for inviting us to give you an update on the
Center. A year and a half ago we were here telling you what our plans were. Since that time a
lot has happened and we have been raising funds. We have done engineering drawings, and an
asbestos survey was done, hired an architect and an interior design furn. We have worked with a
set of professionals all the way through this process. We have done fund raising in several
phases. The first was the city, state and county phase which all stepped forward and gave us a
significant amount of money to go forward. A second phase was foundations throughout the
region. It has taken longer than expected and it has not really developed the dollars we had
hoped for. We got $25,000 through the Home Foundation. This morning we found out that the
Central Carolina Foundation is now open for another set of fund raising and we will submit a
letter of intent for that. We have been working with local businesses and individuals on raising
funds. A major potential donor is coming to the area and we are meeting with them the first of
December. We are not where we wanted to be at this time. Most of the construction elements are
set to go and we are getting closer and closer every day. Early next year, we will have a
renovated Art Center."
Ms. Evelyn Disher, Executive Director of the Community of Character, accepted the November
2016 Proclamation, "Responsibility".
Concerning discussion of Rental Property Regulation Ordinance, Mr. Haire stated, "I asked that
this item be placed on the agenda. 1 was going through parts of my district and I was appalled of
the conditions in parts of the district. There were places where water was coming in from the
ceilings into their beds and on Gibson Street there was an elderly lady who fell at her house and
because of the fracture she had, she was out of the house. The daughter had to have someone
come in and scrape the ceiling because of the particles, etc. coming from her ceiling. On Fair
Street there was a lady that informed me that she had notified her landlord on numerous
occasions, sending emails and communicated with him as it related to a problem with mol_d in
the children's bedroom, so all of them had to live in one bedroom. I have provided Council with
information as it relates to an Ordinance and I would like for this Council to go on record to
adopt an Ordinance wherein there are conditions, that are just horrendous with some rental .
property. The Ordinance I have given you is a copy from the City of Columbia. I am n_ot saymg
that we have to adopt this Ordinance but that we should go on record as to domg an Ordmancc
where in in these kinds of conditions that I saw in the last few weeks, cannot be continued here
in the City. The landlords are getting income from these dwellings and the tenants need to be
living in decent conditions. We need to go on record to ask our attorney to put together an
Ordinance that would address what I have expressed here in the City of Orangeburg."
-
Page3
2587
City Administrator Yow stated, "Mr. Haire and I have discussed this and also briefly in our
planning session but we really did not address it as a rental housing regulation. We talked about
some of the issues we have with code enforcement and as I see it, this is just another tool in the
toolbox. To address some of the things you mentioned, could be addressed through the building
codes that are already in place. In reviewing the Ordinance that Mr. Haire provided it really
gives you a way to register the rental properties and issue pennits. If you read through it, it talks
about accessing points for violation and it gives people a chance to get the points taken off their
record. We need to give Council a chance to review this and give us some feedback. We can't
just assume that you will like all parts of it. I do think it is a step in the right direction that will
show that Council is on record that they want rental property maintained. It will be then
incumbent upon us as how we are going to manage it as staff. We will need to meet on this and
discuss."
Councihnember Keitt stated, "What I like about this Ordinance, is that it makes the landlord be
more responsible for these houses."
Councihnember Jernigan asked, "The majority of the things you are talking about, isn't it code
enforcement or code issues as opposed as to trying to get an Ordinance. Could we do it under
our Code Ordinance?"
City Administrator Yow stated, "It does more than that and it makes people register to have a
pennit and they could lose that pennit to have rental property."
Councihnember Jernigan stated. "I am thinking about the enforcement of an Ordinance to do
this. If we are having a problem enforcing the codes, wouldn't we have problems enforcing this
Ordinance since it has some of th.e same areas."
City Administrator Yow stated, "We are always going to have issues enforcing codes and Mr.
Haire and I have talked about this. Since the City of Columbia has adopted this they have
already identified some issues. We need to put another tool in the toolbox to have a way to
enforce these codes. Quite frankly, after we are in it for another year, we may need another staff
person to do this, but that would be wortb it if the rental property is maintained."
Councilmember Jernigan stated, "I think initially while we are trying to come up with an
Ordinance that we should put extra emphasis on the problems about the rental houses. We need
to put more emphasis on our code enforcement for these areas.
Mr. Yow stated, "For instance we would not know that water is coming into the house. Now that
we know, we can address that. It is a process that the landlord has certified that he has already
addressed these issues. We would not knock on people's doors to see if there is any mold."
Councilmember Jernigan stated, "This person talked to Mr. Haire and if Mr. Haire comes and
talks to you, then we need to send code enforcement people around to check it."
City administrator Yow stated, "We do that all the time."
Councihnember Haire asked, "Let me understand where we are at with this. We are going to
wait for feedback from each Councihnember at this time, right."
City Administrator Yow stated, "Yes sir. We really are interested in this and l would like for
you to read it and we may not know the answers to your questions. There are only a couple of
cities we know of in South Carolina that have done this."
Mr. Tommy Miller, DPU Manager, spoke regarding matters pertaining to the Department of
Public Utilities. He stated, "Mr. Mayor and Council, good evening. DPU has been blessed over
the years of having the privilege in serving several. towns within our service territory. These
Pa~~88
towns are Rowesville, Cordova, Cameron and Cope. We have franchise agreements with these
towns that range 40 to 60 years and we are presently in the process of renewing one of those
agreements, actually an agreement that includes three utilities with one of the towns. There is
another town that expires in February 2017 and we are in the process of addressing that as well. ---,
Presently, our general terms and conditions do not address franchise fees. So in anticipation of
future franchise fees, we are proposing to amend the General Terms and Conditions to add a
paragraph to Section 7. Section 7 is entitled; Billing and Payment Terms and that paragraph will
be number 18 and read as follows: all electric, natural gas, water and wastewater customers in
addition to applicable rates shall be billed their prorated share of any sales tax, franchise fee or
business license tax imposed or accessed by any state, franchise or other government taxing
authority on services received. So this evening, I am requesting first reading approval on
Ordnance 2016-10 that will amend the General Terms and Conditions as presented. I will be glad
to answer any questions."
Councilmember Haire stated, "In this particular addition, paragraph 18, are you saying those
areas for instance. Let me back up, will all citizens have to pay these fees. Say we are going to
run gas to Elloree and there is a franchise fee that has been added. Are you saying all gas
customers are going to pay this as it relates to this."
DPU Manager Miller stated, "If you would allow me to use Elloree as an example, we do have a
franchise agreement with Elloree. There is a moratorium on the franchise fee for the first seven
years so there will be no fees for the first seven years. After that, just a fee on the gas bill and
that applies to all customers in that town. "
Councihnember Keitt asked, "Approximately how much are we talking about?"
DPU Manager Miller answered, "Generally, and I did a little bit of research, and it appears to be
about 5% of the bill."
Councihnember Haire asked, "The way I look at it now is that everybody could possibly be
charged."
DPU Manager Miller stated, "This is the statement that is accepted by the Public Service
Co mission."
City Attorney Walsh stated, "If you look at your telephone bill or cable bill there is always a
charge for a franchise fee. All utilities have gotten a tariff from the Public Service Commission
which permits that. So this is what DPU is trying to do. If a franchise fee is going to be charged,
they just want to pass that through to the customer."
Councilmember Haire stated, "The affected customer ?"
Attorney Walsh stated, "That's right, only the customer that is receiving service in that franchise
area."
City Administrator Yow stated, "So, it should read to all affected customers within the
jurisdiction of the franchise."
City Attorney Walsh stated, "It does not have to say that. The language only said charge for the
services received, so if you don't receive services under a franchise, you don't have to pay a
franchise fee. It also has included business license taxes and sales taxes.
Text truncated. Open the original for the full document.
Source: City of Orangeburg website. First collected Oct 13, 2026.