Minutes
City of Orangeburg · Orangeburg County · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Orangeburg
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE EXECUTION AND DELIVERY OF A MASTER
LEASE AGREEMENT, EQUIPMENT SCHEDULE, AND ESCROW AGREEMENT,
AND RELATED INSTRUMENTS, AND DETERMINING OTHER MATTERS IN
CONNECTION THEREWITH.
BE IT RESOLVED by the governing body of the City of Orangeburg (the "Lessee"), at a duly called
meeting of the governing body held on the 15111 day of January, 2013, the following resolution was
introduced and adopted:
RESOLVED , whereas the governing body of Lessee has determined that a true and very real need exists
for the acquisition of Various Equipm ent as described in the Request for Proposal and Exhibit "A"
attached hereto, in the amount of $551,275.00 at 1.08% APR for three (3) years, by entering into an Lease
Purchase Agreement with First Citizens Bank as Lessor and the City of Orangeburg as Lessee (the
"Agreement") according to the terms set forth in the Bid Prop osa l from First Citizens Bank the
Equipment will be used by the Lessee for the following purpose : To provide new and cost efficient
equipment for the operation of City government.
RESOLVED , whereas the governing body of Lessee has taken the necessary steps including any legal
bidding requirements, under applicable law to arrange for the acquisition of such equipment.
RESOLVED, wherea s the governing body hereby directs its legal counsel to review the Agreement and
negotiate appropriate modifications to said Agreement so as to assure compliance with state law and local
statutory law, prior to execution of the Agreement by those person s so authorized by the governing body
for such purpose .
BE IT RESOLVED, by the governing body of the lessee that:
The terms of said Agreement are in the best interests of Lessee for the acquisition of such equipment and
the governing body of Lessee designates and confirms the following person(s) to execute and deliver , and
to witness (or attest), respectively , the Agreement and any related documents necessary to the
consummation of the translations contemplated by the Agreement.
Name and Title ofPerson(s) to Execute Agreement:
John H. Yow, City Administrator
RESOLVED, the Lessee covenants that it will perform all acts within its power which are or may be
necessary to insure that the interest portion of the Rental Payments coming due under the Agreement will
at all times remain exempt from Federal income taxation under the laws and regulation s of the United
States of America as presently enacted and construed or as hereafter amended . The Lessee hereby
certifies that it has not issued or effected the issuance of, and reasonably anticipate s that it shall not issue
or effect the issuance of more than ten million dollars ($1 0,000,000.00) of tax-exempt obligations during
the calendar year, and hereby designates the Agreement as a "qualified tax exempt obligation", as defined
by Section 265 (b) (3) of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986, as amended.
Passed by the City Council of the City of Orangeburg, South Carolina this
15th day of January, 2013.
>
Paul A. Miller, Mayor
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
January 15, 2013 2235
Orangeburg City Council held its regularly scheduled meeting on Tuesday, January 15, 2013, at
7:00P.M., in the Council Chamber Building with Mayor Miller presiding.
PRESENT:
Paul A. Miller, Mayor
Bernard Haire
Charles B. Barnwell, Jr.
Charles W. Jernigan
L. Zimmerman Keitt
Sandra P. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
A motion was made Councilmember Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to approve
the December 18, 2012, City Council Minutes as distributed. This motion was unanimously
approved.
Mr. Bobby Bowers, Director of SC Office of Research and Statistics, made a presentation before
Council on the redistricting process for the 2010 Census. He stated the following criteria for
City Council redistricting plan ..
I . Adhere to the court ordered constitutional requirement of one person, one vote,
a. County Councils must adhere to a state law of population variance under 10%
(under Home Rule); does not necessarily apply to City but is advised to follow.
2. Adherence to the 1965 Voting Rights Act as amended and by controlling court decisions.
3. Ensure that parts of the districts are contiguous
4. Respect Communities of Interest
5. Attempt to maintain constituent consistency
6. A void splitting voting precincts
7. Solicit public input
He stated, "If Council wants to change the plan, don't change deviation and retrogression. The
City Attorney has to make the submission. Council should take this under advisement as the
Justice Department has sixty (60) days to approve the plan."
Councilmember Barnwell asked, "Is there any requirement to be done this year?
Mr. Bowers stated, "No, but Council needs to adopt the criteria accepting the plan.
Councilmember Jernigan asked "Are the figures taking into consideration annexations after
2010?"
Mr. Bowers stated, " No, they are out of date already."
Mayor Miller stated "So what you are saying is to adopt the criteria and get comfortable with the
plan. Council will take this information under advisement."
Ms. Bernice Tribble made an appearance before Council thanking the City for their twenty years
of support to DORA. She stated she has been the Executive Director of DORA seventeen years
of the twenty. Ms. Tribble introduced Ms. Jennifer Hoesing who will be taking over the position
of Executive Director due to her retirement.
Ms. Bernice Tribble introduced Ms. Kristina Thomas who will be the Director of the Community
of Character program due to Mr. Don Tribble's retirement.
Mr. Marion Moore of the Century 21 Moore Group made an appearance before Council. He
addressed Council in regards to United Developers , Inc., for a housing project in Orangeburg."
Page 2
Mr. BjH,~n addressed Council in regards to his company building the apartments in North
CaroM~~ South Carolina. He stated, "A first development in South Carolina was in
Hartsville in 1981. In 1997, focus was changed to a Federal tax credit program adopted by South
Carolina State Housing and Financing Authority. Developers requested an application for tax
credit award. We have received twenty (26) tax credit awards. In 2012, we received an award
for best rental design in North Carolina. We have been interested in Orangeburg for some time.
The last time an award was made in Orangeburg County was in 2006 on St. Matthews Road. We
will be targeting incomes of up to 60% of county median income. Tenants go through criminal,
credit and background checks. Applications are competitive and points are given to where
services are. We found a site on Columbia Road , adjacent to Glenfield Apartments , which is
currently zoned A-2. This plan shows a site layout which is a proposed eight unit building of
brick and hardi-plank. Development would be fifty-six units of which eight are one-bedroom,
thirty-two are two-bedroom and sixteen are three-bedroom units. The units will have energy
saving appliances. The tax credit program must be controlled . We must maintain an operating
fund, a replacement fund, and we will have an annual compliance review and quarterly unit
inspections. A local manager reports to a regional manager. We as developers , compete for
awards. In 2012, eighty-two apartments were submitted and only sixteen were awarded . I am
here tonight to ask for positive support for a proposed development to accompany our
application. If we receive an award in August, we would close on propert y and begin
construction in 2014 . The budget is $6,600,000."
Councilmember Keitt stated "What are your prices?
Mr. Owen stated, "Rent calculation is still in the application process and the rent will be
competitive for the market?"
Mayor Pro Tern Haire asked, "In each of the cities you named, are they still owned and managed
by you?"
Mr. Owen stated, "Yes ."
Mayor Pro Tern Haire asked, "Can you give me names and addresses of sites you own ."
Mr. Owen stated , "Yes, I can give you that information."
Mayor Pro Tern Haire asked , "Are you asking for support tonight because I would like to see
your track record ."
Mr. Owen stated, "Application is due March 1, 2013."
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "What are the security plans for the residents? "
Mr. Owen stated, "On staff will be a retired deputy sheriff that visits and corrects problems as
needed."
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "Is the Manager full time employee?"
Mr. Owen stated, "Not always, usually four days a week."
Councilmember Keitt asked, "I would like a listing of security complaints and to which site they
are from."
Councilmember J emigan asked, "Are you aware that sewer would have to be extended to this
area and you would have to pay for it?"
Mr. Owen stated, "I am aware of it and we are prepared and have it in our budget."
Mayor Miller asked, "What is the project cost, $6.6 million?"
Page 3
Mr. Owen stated, "Yes." 2237
Councilmember Stroman asked, "Where will you get materials?"
Mr. Owen stated, "We will buy locally and have items shipped in due to standards by SCDHA."
Councilmember Stroman asked, "Is the laundromat being operated by a third vendor , is that
legal?
City Administrator Yow stated, "We will check on that?"
Mayor ProTem Haire asked, "Will there be washer and dryer hook-ups in each unit?"
Mr. Owen stated, "Yes."
Councilmember Keitt asked , "Do you seek minority construction workers?"
Mr. Owen stated, "We have to provide information on this each month."
Mayor Pro Tern Haire stated, You are aware of City infrastructure as it relates to roads and
sidewalks."
Mr. Owen stated, "Yes ."
Mayor Miller stated that Council will take this information under advisement tonight and this
item will be placed back on a future City Council Meeting agenda.
Ms. Kristina Thomas, Community of Character Director, accepted the January 2013 Character
Trait Proclamation, "Patriotism".
A motion was made by Councilmember Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Stroman , to approve
a Resolution authorizing the execution and delivery of a Master Lease Agreement, Equipment
Schedule and Escrow Agreement and related instruments and determining other matters in
connection with First Citizens Bank at 1.08% Annual Percentage Rate. This motion was
unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, seconded by Councilrnember Stroman, to approve
a Resolution to authorize the granting for a meter and regulating easement to Carolina Gas
Transmission Corporation for waste distribution system. This motion was unanimously
approved.
Mayor Pro Tern Haire stated, "Can you give us an update on this project ?
DPU Manager Miller stated, "The project is 51% complete, tap has been made and completion
date is the end of march. Gas will be available to farmers at this time.
A motion was made by Councilrnem ber Stroman, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, to enter
into an Executive Session for a legal matter concerning Hospitality and Accommodations Tax
Sodexo. This motion was unaJilmously approved.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
RESOLUTION TO AUTHORIZE THE GRANTING OF A METER AND REGULATING
EASEMENT TO CAROLINA GAS TRANSMISSION CORPORATION
WHEREAS, the City of Orangeburg purchased property on Bonnette Road in the County of
Orangeburg, State of South Carolina for the purpose of constructing thereon a gas distribution
station in conjunction with its West Gas Distribution System extension; and
WHEREAS, Carolina Gas Transmission Corporation agreed to construct at its expense on said
property its meter and regulation station for the purpose of providing natural gas to the
Department of Public Utilitie s of the City of Orangeburg, and
WHEREAS , it is necessary that the City grant to Carolina Gas Transmission Corporation a
Meter & Regulating Easement for the construction and operation of its facilities.
NOW, THEREFORE, ~»)RESOLVED BY ORANGEBURG CITY COUNCIL DULY
ASSEMBLED on the~ day oflanuary , 2013, that 0. Thomas Miller, Jr., Manager ofthe
Department of Public Utilities of the City of Orangeburg , State of South Carolina is hereby
authorized to execute the a ttached Meter & Regulating Easement granting said easement to
Carolina Gas Transmission Corporation its successors and assigns; said agreement being attached
hereto and made a part hereof by reference as Exhibit "A".
AND IT IS SO RESOLVED .
2013 Cities Mean Business and Legislative Priorities
WHEREAS, cities and towns in South Carolina are the government closest to the people providing the core
services residents and businesses demand for a high quality of life; and,
WHEREAS, residents and businesses want their local city and town councils to have the flexibility to make
decisions that are best for their communities while also being held accountable by their residents
to spend wisely and govern locally; and,
WHEREAS, cities and towns support increasing the economic strength of the state to enable job creation for
residents and encourage business development and success; and,
WHEREAS, the partnership between local officials and business leaders is critical to the new knowledge
economy and future of regional workforce development; and,
WHEREAS, cities and towns offer a positive quality of life that attracts business, industry and new jobs to the
region; and,
WHEREAS, the Municipal Association Board of Directors approved the 2013 legislative priorities that
supports local elected leaders making decisions based on local needs and priorities; and,
WHEREAS, the three legislative priorities are based around creating places and delivering services that
support a healthy local economy and offer a positive quality of life; and,
WHEREAS, finding solutions to dilapidated structures, securing a dependable revenue source and providing
quality transportation and infrastructure maintenance are the three major legislative issues that
local elected leaders determined can have the greatest impact on their hometowns; and,
WHEREAS, the priorities focus on fiscal stability, economic development and infrastructure that are important
to cities and towns of all sizes and in all parts of the state; and,
WHEREAS, success of the state relies upon the economic success and prosperity of hometowns; and,
WHEREAS, the City of Orangeburg fully supports the legislative priorities set forth by cities and towns to
govern locally for residents.
BE IT, THEREFORE, RESOLVED that the Council of the City of Orangeburg, South Carolina, affirms on this day,
February 19, 2013, its support for the "Municipal Association's 2013 Legislative Priorities" to encourage local
decision making by the local elected officials that govern the state's 270 cities and towns.
BE IT, THEREFORE, FURTHER RESOLVED that the Council of the City of Orangeburg declares February as
"Cities Mean Business Month" to emphasize the importance of local businesses and their contribution to the
local economy.
DONE AND RATIFIED THIS FEBRUARY 19,2013.
Members of Council
2238
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
February 5, 2013
Orangeburg City Council held its regularly scheduled meeting on Tuesday, February 5,
2013, at 7:00P.M., in the Council Chamber Building with Mayor Miller presiding.
PRESENT:
Paul A. Miller, Mayor
Bernard Haire
Charles B. Barnwell, Jr.
Charles W. Jernigan
L. Zimmerman Keitt
Sandra P. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
A motion was made by Councilmember Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to
approve the January 15, 2013, Minutes as distributed. This motion was unanimously
approved.
Ms. Kristina Thomas, Community of Character Trait Director, accepted the February
2013, Character Trait Proclamation, "Sincerity".
Mayor Pro Tern Haire addressed Council. He stated, "When I received a letter from
Time Warner, once again, I had heart burn due to rates increasing . I know here in
America we have the free enterprise system. I am troubled with the fact that there are
individuals that are wage earners who cannot pay these prices as their salaries are not
going up. Every year we get the same information about these rates going up. I know the
power we have had to have some influence has been taken away by the state legislature.
I am here as a citizen who cares about the average wage earner as to being put across the
barrel as it relates to these rates. I noticed that we have had spikes in the cost of gasoline
and it just seems to me that those companies don't have the same cost structure. With
service stations, one with one price, all have the same price. These companies have no
concern in being good cooperative citizens. They are just being greedy. The average
citizen is just being squeezed to death."
Councilmember Barnwell stated, "Most of the time, I don't look at my bill, I did in
January. I saw where Time Warner was charging us $3.95 for a lease for a modem. I
called and I was told that Time Warner sent out postcards to every customer. They in
turn sent me the language that I sent to City Administrator Yow. For years and years,
they have been paying the lease in the overall charge. Not only is Time Warner going up
on the rates, they are also charging us for a modem . We can pay for our own modem, but
with technology changing, it may be more. I agree with Bernard, rates keep going up and
up and people can't afford this. I don't think there is anything we can do with the price
increase."
Mayor Miller stated, "If you would like, Mr. Yow stated that Time Warner agreed to
come down and answer any questions and address Council 's concerns at our next
meeting and let us voice our opinions. I know that several citizens called Mr. Yow when
they saw it was on the agenda."
City Administrator Yow stated, "I want to add that one other time, you addressed concern
about publishing phone numbers and about not getting through to Time Warner and I had
a phone call today from a lady about that as well. She cannot get through. I will also
convey that to them. I will also let them know and place it on the agenda."
Council agreed to request a Time Warner representative attend a future meeting.
Page 2
Councilmember Keitt stated, "This is not the first time they have been increasing the
bills. Why not stop sending them your money? That is the best way to stop sending
them a bill each year. Delete them."
A motion was made by Mayor Pro tern Haire, seconded by Councilmember Stroman , to
accept a P.A.R.D . Grant in the amount of$5,000.00 for repaving the parking lot at the
City Landing in the Gardens. This motion was unanimously approved.
City Attorny Walsh gave Council a handout on election guidelines for the upcoming
election as well as the redistricting schedule. The upcoming election is scheduled for
September 10, 2013. The proposed redistricting schedule was presented by City Attorney
Walsh.
Mayor Pro Tern Haire asked, "These dates, the February 251h date or final date to submit
plans, is that the final date? Is there no play in there?
City Attorney Wash replied, "That is a date that fits in within this proposal."
Councilmember Barnwell asked, "After that date, no one can submit plans?"
City Attorney Walsh replied, "We have in the past, plans have been submitted after the
date, but Council has submitted those plans to the Justice Department but with the
understanding that they were not submitted in a timely manner."
Mayor Pro Tern Haire asked , "Instead of February 25
1
h, I know we have a first reading on
March 51\ I just have a little problem that we are in February now and the 25th is the final
day for submission. I know that there are individuals looking that would like to submit
plans for redistricting and I don't know if that would give them enough time, which is
only twenty days from today."
City Attorney Walsh stated, "I have not looked at the calendar , but it could be very easy
to move the first meeting up to March 19th, but I don't know the calendar. We may have
to have a special meeting. We would just move everything up."
Mayor Miller asked, "What kind of time frame is adequate?"
Mayor Pro Tern Haire stated, "Another two weeks or so, maybe March 11th for the date
to submit plans."
A motion by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, seconded by Councilmember Keitt, to approve the
redistricting schedule, including changing the date to March 11th for submitting final
plans for redistricting and to change other dates as necessitated by the changen . This
motion was unanimously approved .
A motion was made by Councilmember Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to
approve a Resolution adopting criteria for Municipal Council Redistricting as requi red by
the 2010 Census. This was a 6-0-1 vote, as Mayor Pro Tern Haire abstained.
Page3
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, to
approve the following appointments to the DPU Grievance Committee . This motion was
unanimously approved.
Linda Blanks (Chair)
Wade Holmes
Brittany Garrick
Michael Owens
Dawn Collins
Beverly Thomas
Janice Price
Adm. Division
Elec. Division
Gas Division
Water Division
Wastewater Division
Alternate
Alternate
January 2013- January 2016
January 2013 - January 2016
January 2011 - January 2014
January 2011 - January 2014
January 2013 - January 2016
January 2012- January 2015
January 2012 - January 2015
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Knotts ,
to enter into an Executive Session for (1) a legal and contractual matter concerning the
lease of the old former First National Bank Building/Palmetto Development Group and
(2) a contractual matter concerning sale of real property, First Citizens Bank Building.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
/pfb
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
February 19, 2013 2241
Orangeburg City Council held its regularly scheduled meeting on Tuesday, February 19,
2013, at 7:00P.M., in the Council Cham ber Building with Mayor Miller presiding.
PRESENT:
Paul A. Miller, Mayor
Bernard Haire
Charles B. Barnwell, Jr.
Charles W. Jernigan
L. Zimmerman Keitt
Sandra P. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, to
approve the February 5, 2013, City Council Minutes as distributed. This motion was
unanimously approved.
Mr. Tom Dandridge, Administrator of The Regional Medical Center (TRMC), addressed
Council, concerning Medicaid Expansion in South Carolina.
He stated, "Healthcare premiums are increasing and with the President's Affordable
Care Act with getting everyone insured with two mass majorities in the House and Senate
and it failed in his first te1m.
This has happened since the presidency of Lyndon Johnson. The first step is to get
everyone insured. The way the President was going to do that is to have the states to
expand their Medicaid Program up to 138% of the Federal poverty guidelines. After
138%, if your employer does not provide it for you, you get a subsidy, the more well off
you are, the smaller the subsidy, to go out and buy your own insurance on an exchange or
website. So then approximately 98% of the population should be insured . Twenty six
states filed suit claiming the Federal Government could not force you to buy anything.
The Supreme Court ruled that it was constitutional, not because of the commerce clause,
but because the penalty you pay if you don't buy it. The Supreme Court says it is a tax, if
you don't buy it, the Federal Government can tax you. The Supreme Court also ruled
that states cannot be forced to expand Medicaid. Immediately, a number of Governors
said they were not going to expand, our state being one of those. Once, President Obama
became re-elected, a number of those states have changed their minds. South Carolina
has the fourth greatest benefit from the Medicaid expansion, if we expand. For the first
three years of the expansion, states put up no money. After the first seven years, the
Federal Government gives the state $11.24 billion dollars and the state has to give $442
million dollars. For every $1 the state puts up, the Federal Government puts up $9. This
expansion was given to the Darla Moore School of Business and in their analysis by
2020, this expansion will create 44,000 new jobs. The tax revenue would more than pay
for the $442 million dollars and add another $9 million to it. No matter what the decision
the state makes on Medicaid expansion, our state will see a reduction in Medicare
reimbursement from 2014 to 2020 of over $2 billion dollars. Hospitals will also see over
$735 million in reductions in Medicaid DSH funds from 2014 to 2020 with or without
Medicaid expansion. If Medicaid is expanded, hospitals get $11.7 billion dollars. The
cuts will happen regardless. The Regional Medical Center will take the following cuts
from 2014 to 2020 in Medicaid and Medicare reimbursements in the amount of$72
million dollars. If Medicaid were expanded, the Regional Medical Center would receive
$94 million dollars . Small rural hospitals will be bankrupt if Medicaid is not expanded .
Medical University of South Carolina will get hit with a $400 million dollar cut which
the state has to find the money to cover because it is a state supported hospital. I would
be more than happy to answer any questions."
~42
Mayor Pro Tern Haire asked, "People who don't have insurance and they have to go to
website to get insurance , what is going to prevent them from getting scammed ?
Mr. Dandridge replied, "The government is already putting out warnings on this, states
can do an exchange or the Federal Government can do an exchange for the state. The
websites must have certain characteristics for it to be on the exchange ."
Councilmember Keitt asked , "What can we do?"
Mr. Dandridge replied , "You should consider writing your Governor, House and Senate
to reconsider the Medicaid expansion position in the State."
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "What kind of statistics have been done on who will not
have insurance?"
Mr. Dandridge replied, "If we don't expand, those people making $11,000 or less will not
have insurance which is over 200,000 people, which is who cannot afford it and will not
get a subsidy. The more educated or richer, the more apt they will go to the exchange.
There is still going to be a lot of people that will be uninsured. We cannot continue to be
these people ' s primary care doctor's, these patients go the emergency room when they
are sick."
Mayor Miller asked, "If this does not pass in South Carolina, what are the chances ofthe
Regional Medical Center staying open and how can it service the area?
Mr. Dandridge replied, "First we take the service line and say what Mission Critical is, a
few years ago we closed our Hospice , we were the first in town and now there are five, so
the population is still being served. The waits in the emergency room will be longer
because of the decrease in staff. We will weather this, but there will be several hospitals
that won't make it and some may say that is just business."
Mayor Miller replied, "We cannot afford to be without a hospital in Orangeburg. TRMC
is just as important for economic development as we got going."
Mayor Pro Tern Haire asked, "Has our Chamber taken a position on this?"
Mr. Dandridge replied, "No, I have spoken to several."
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "Does Doctor's Care take the pressure off of you?"
Mr. Dandridge replied, "Yes, and the Family Health Center takes a lot of pressure off of
us, but there you pay on a sliding scale and at the hospital it is free."
Councilmember Barnwell asked, "Where do the jobs come in?"
Mr. Dandridge stated, "Many will be in healthcare , insurance will be able to use the
system for healthcare, going to the doctor. The multiplier effect comes into play when
the money is put into the local economy."
Mayor Pro Tern Haire made a motion that the City encourage the Governor and the State
Legislature to support Medicaid Expansion in the State and a support letter be sent,
seconded by Councilmember Keitt. This motion was unanimously approved .
J.W. Hunt and Company presented the annual City of Orangeburg and the Department of
Public Utilities Audits for Fiscal Year ending 2012. Mrs. Anne Ross overviewed the
City's audit. She reported the City received a clean unqualified opinion . She stated, "As
Page3
your MD&A stated, originally you budgeted $600,000 to spend in fund balance anf~13
only spent $22,000 so someone did a good job with the budget. Hospitality tax came in
better than usual."
She overviewed the financial statements and noted cash in other funds and noted property
tax collections, debt and post retirement benefits . She also overviewed the Enterprise
Funds on page 76 for Hillcrest and the Airport. She also noted that a single audit had to
be completed for grants which were on page 84.
The required communication letter was overviewed with Council by Mrs . Ross.
Councilmember Barnwell asked, "On page 5, expend limited fund balance, do you
anticipate that?"
Mrs. Ross replied, "This part is written by your staff, I talked about that, you budgeted
$600,000 that you thought you may have to use, but you only used $22,000 in the year
we audited . They are putting you on notice that may be your option if your expected
revenues don't come in, you came real close this year."
City Administrator Yow stated, "We do an Amended Budget Ordinance and we always
strive not to use fund balance . In fact, in the amended budget presented to Council we
projected using $200,000 of the Fund Balance. That is a proper use of fund balance to
maintain your level of services ."
Mr. Creech addressed Council in regards to the Department of Public Utilities . He stated,
"The audit is unqualified which is the best you can possibly get. On the balance sheet, the
total current assets went up about $8.8 million dollars, the total assets increased about 9
million dollars and primarily the increase was in cash, unbilled receivables and
investments. As far as liabilities , these increased about$ 7.5 million dollars and the
operating expenses also went down by about $7.7 million dollars. Operating income
went up about $100 ,000. The change in the net assets this year is about $500,000 less
than it was last year ."
City Administrator Yow addressed Council in regards to information in their packet in
regards to a multi-family housing project for United Developers , Inc. at 2574 Columbia
Road. It was now Council's decision whether to endorse this project via a letter to the
State Housing and Finance Authority for a Tax Credit Project. At a prior meeting,
Council asked for various information and data and Council was provided this as
requested. City Administrator Yow also recognized Mr. Bill Owen of United Developers
who was present to answer Council 's questions.
Councilmember Barnwell asked, "Is this a tax credit?"
Mr. Owen replied, "The state will receive $10 million dollars in tax credits and
developers apply for these, it is a vehicle to help fund a development. If awarded, they
are passed to a financial institution."
Councilmember Barnwell asked, "Are tenants rent subsidized?"
Mr. Owen replied, "That is confidential because it is in the packet. If you look I have
included it and it is based on income."
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "Can you tell us more about the contingency fund?"
Mr. Owen replied, "This program is highly controlled, more than if you just went out and
did a commercial project on your own. You have to maintain an operating fund and a
p~244
maintenance fund monthly . The operating fund is in case, if units are not filled and to
make sure it is operating. The maintenance fund is used for roofs , etc. There has not
been a tax credit project in Orangeburg since 2006 and it is on St. Matthews Road."
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "What would a buyer be required to do if you decided in
two years to sell this project? "
Mr. Owen replied, "We have built sixty (60) developments since 1979 and we have never
sold one and we do not intend on selling any, we make a thirty year commitment and we
get additional points if we make a thirty-five year commitment."
Mayor Pro Tern Haire made a motion to endorse the proposal from United Developers ,
seconded by Councilmember Keitt. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Knotts, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, to
approve a Cities Mean Business Resolution. This motion was unanimously approved .
City Administrator Yow presented an Ordinance to approve the First Reading of an
Ordinanc e authori zing the lease of property at 1170 Russell Street to Palmetto
Development Group . A motion was made by Councilmember Keitt, seconded by
Councilmember Knotts. This was a 6-1 vote as Councilmember Barnwell opposed.
There were no utility matters brought before Council.
A motion was made by Councilmember Stroman, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Haire , to
enter into an Executive session for a contractual matter concerning discussion on
purchase of real property on Middleton Street. This motion was unanimously approved.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
/pfb
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
March 5, 2013
2245
Orangeburg City Council held its regularly scheduled meeting on Tuesday, March 5,
2013, at 7:00P.M ., in the Council Chamber Building with Mayor Miller presiding.
PRESENT:
Paul A. Miller, Mayor
Bernard Haire
Charles B. Barnwell, Jr.
Charles W. Jernigan
L. Zimmerman Keitt
Sandra P. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Keitt, to
approve the February 19, 2013, City Council Minutes as distributed. This motion was
unanimously approved.
City Administrator Yow presented an Ordinance to approve the Second Reading of an
Ordinance authorizing the lease of property at 1170 Russell Street (Old First National
Bank Buidling) to Palmetto Development Group.
Councilmember Barnwell asked, "What will they do?"
City Administrator Yow stated, "They are an organization that would serve as a business
incubator and are provided technical assistance to upstart businesses .. "
Councilmember Stroman stated, "Have you checked these people out? This building
needs a lot ofwork. If you told me I could have it, I wouldn't take it."
City Administrator Yow stated, "Yes, I have and they will have to do repairs and they
will take bids. Once the repairs are done, the City will reimburse for repairs for Phase I.''
Councilmember Keitt stated, "I certainly hope this will come to fruition because we need
businesses to come downtown ."
Councilmember Jernigan stated, "Small businesses provide income and jobs and these
people are going to assist in that and are they going to be in conjunction with South
Carolina State University?
City Administrator Yow replied, "Yes, their board chair stated that in the Times and
Democrat article that one of the reasons they wanted to locate in Orangeburg was the
presence of a Small Business Development Group at South Carolina State University .
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, seconded by Councilmember Knotts, to
approve the Second Reading of an Ordinance authorizing the lease of property at 1170
Russell Street to Palmetto Development Group. This was a 6-1 vote as Councilmernber
Barnwell opposed .
Ms. Catherine Thomas, Executive Director of the Community of Character, accepted the
March 2013, Character Trait Proclamation "Cooperation" .
City Administrator Yow presented information to Council on the building next door to
City Hall (formerly Fast Phones). He stated, "As you know, we received a donation of
property from DORA that goes from the parking lot drive up to this property so obtaining
this property will give us all the way to the comer and will immediately give us nine (9)
additional parking spaces which are already being used by city staff and by Stevenson
Auditorium patrons. The negotiated amount for the purchase of this property is $63,600
and with the City paying the closing costs of several hundred dollars".
A motion was made by Councilmember Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Stroman, to
approve a Resolution to purchase property at 1009 Middleton Street. This motion was
unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Mayor Miller, seconded by Councilmember Stroman, to approve
the nomination of Mr. Don Tribble to fill the unexpired term (January, 2014) on the
Planning Commission due to Mr. Randy Snell's resignation. This motion was
unanimously approved .
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, seconded by Counci lmember Keitt, to
approve the reappointment of Ms. Ellen Robinson Ricoma to the Election Commission.
This is a six (6) year term ending March , 2019. This motion was unanimously approved.
There were no utility matters brought before Council.
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Keitt, to
enter into an Executive Session for (1) Economic Development concerning discussion of
matters relating to proposed location of industry update on proposed prospects , (2) Legal
Matter concerning Hospitality and Accommodations Tax/Sodexo and (3) Contractual
Matter concernin g sale of real property/First Citizens Bank Building .
There being no further business , the meeting was adjourned.
Respectfully submitted ,
/pfb
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
March 19, 2013
2247
Orangeburg City C?uncil held its regularly scheduled meeting on Tuesday, March 19,
2013, at 7:00P .M., m the Council Chamber Building with Mayor Miller presiding.
PRESENT:
Paul A. Miller, Mayor
Bernard Haire
Charles B. Barnwell, Jr.
Charles W. Jernigan
L. Zimmerman Keitt
Sandra P. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Keitt, to
enter into an Executive Session for a legal matter concerning Council Redistricting.
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Stroman,
for Council to return to Open Session.
Council returned to Open Session .
A motion was made by Councilmember Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to
approve the March 5, 2013, City Council Minutes as distributed . This motion was
unanimously approved .
An appearance was made by Orangeburg Wilkinson Bruinettes Basketball Team,
Superintendent of District 5 Cynthia Wilson and Coach Joshua Staley. Mayor Miller
presented the team with a Proclamation for an eighteen game winning streak (regular
season and playoffs) with a 27-2 overall record, 23-1 regular-season record and 10-0 in
conference play.
Time Warner Vice President Dan Jones and Vice President Charlene Keys addressed
Council in regards to comments and concerns Council had at previous meetings
concerning service with Time Warner Cable.
Mr. Dan Jones stated, "We try to work together with franchise holders and we are here to
address any concerns."
Mayor Pro Tern Haire stated, "I have had problems with my picture freezing and I cannot
get the problem resolved and I have to tum the program to a different channel and it is
fine. I am concerned about rates increasing each year. The rationale that is given is that
there is better service given and better programming given. A lot of the programs that I
get presently are re-runs and programs that I have no interest in and programs I do not
need. The public has no kind of opportunity to voice their concern on changes and it
troubles me. Each year the rates go up and the quality isn't getting any better. A
situation where I was getting channel 30 and all of a sudden I wasn't getting it, so I went
to the local office and was informed that I needed a modem. To me, you are creating
more problems than you are solving and I am concerned about those things and also there
is the problem of making contact with someone locally. There are numbers listed in the
local directory and we cannot reach anyone at those numbers. I think we should be able
to contact someone when we have a problem ."
Councilmember Keitt addressed Council, "My concern is for my constituents. Every
year with the bill going up is not good especially with the economy the way it is. I don't
see why you send it out because your programs are not that great.
"Councilmember Barnwell stated, "My one concern is that I got a bill that had a fee for a
modem for $3.95 and I called and was told we just started charging for that and I was told
that I could buy my own. The phone number was on the bill and that was the only way I
could get in touch with you. To me, that makes no sense or justification to charge for it
when you weren't charging before."
Councilmember Jernigan stated, "The only concern that I have heard from my
constituents is that the ones that have Time Warner TV service and the phone service is
that their name is not listed in the telephone book with their telephone number. In fact,
one time I had all three services and my name was not listed when I had telephone
service with Time Warner."
Councilmember Knotts stated, "The concern that I have is that whenever there is an
interruption in service, do customers ever see credits, iftheir cable is out? If you go and
pay your bill, they do not remember when their cable may have been out to ask for a
credit."
Councilm ember Stroman stated, "I have a bill here and a bill from my neighbor and we
have the exact same service , why is his bill less than mine? I think people should be
treated fair and all rates should be the same."
Mayor Miller stated, "You are always sending out bundling packages, but when you are
with your company, there is no direct savings. I think everyone should be treated fairly,
why would you charge two rates?"
City Administrator Yow stated, "The complaints I have been getting are from fixed
incom e subscribers that are on the basic tier, these rates are always increasing and they
are least able to afford it. I have a concern for those on the basic tier."
Councilmember Keitt stated, "I hope one day you will have better competition ."
Mayor Miller stated, "I changed and saved over $100 a month ."
Vice President Charlene Keys addressed Council ' s concerns. She stated, "Thank you for
allowing us to be here and address your concerns one at a time."
She stated, " Let me address the issue of credits, if your service is interrupted. If you call,
we will oblige and give you credit, we will believe you and offer you a credit. There are
some instances where your cable goes out due to a power outage and creates a situation
for us and we don't know whose services have gone out, we will take your word for it
and give you a credit. We do not have a system in place where we look at everyone and
see where the system is down, house #1234 is out and was out for two minutes and we
need to offer a credit. Maybe we can think about looking forward to putting systems in
place, but right now that is not where we are. Today, we advise our customers that if you
advise us, we will make adjustments to your bills."
Mayor Pro Tern Haire asked, "How have you made that known to your customers ; is
there something in writing that they have been provided as it relates to that policy?"
Ms. Keys replied, "I am going to go back and confirm, but one thing that we offer is our
customer bill of rights and I think that is also included in our bill of rights. I will go back
and check that the information is in there.
My entire career has been in Telecom, I relocated to Columbia to launch their telephone
services in the State of South Carolina. I absolutely know that your numbers can be
Page 3
listed and should be listed in the telephone directory. The company made a deci~l49
listings would include a fee so at the point of ordering your services you could include
your listing. In the Bell days, the Bell companies owned the telephone book and you
actually paid not to be listed. You have the right to be listed. If you have specific
examples of those who wanted their numbers in the phone book who do not have their
numbers listed for some reason, I will give you my personal information and if you get
me that information we will run it down and make sure those numbers are listed in the
next publishing of those books. As far as the Internet, that cannot be changed, we have
researched this; those should be listed and changed. The information that is loaded
digitally is almost like a scanned document and cannot be changed, but if you have
examples, there is no reason that those numbers are not listed ."
Mayor Miller stated, "But, they are not. It is all of them. I keep an old phone book
around to look up phone numbers who used to be listed. So, I think that every Time
Warner telephone customer you have, is not in the phone book."
Ms. Keys replied, "That should not be the case. I am going to accept your feedback that
you have offered us and we are going to go back and follow up on those who have Time
Warner phone service and who has asked who have had their numbers published and do
some research."
Councilmember Jernigan stated, "One concern I have is ifl was on the other side of the
fence, is that how many customers have gone away from Time Warner because they
couldn't get their phone number listed in the telephone book."
Ms. Keys replied, "One of the things we look at on a daily basis is the number of
customers who leave Time Warner and the reason why they left. I will be honest and say
I never see a reason that they left Time Warner because their number was not published
in the phone book. They may say they left because they found a better rate. We don't
have any data today to support that, but I am going to go back and look and report back to
Mr. Yow or we can come back."
Councilmember Jernigan stated, "I changed from Time Warner to a local internet
provider, NTI Net, they provide internet and phone service and my phone number is still
not in the phone book."
Ms. Keys stated, "In reference to the annual rates, which is what I anticipated most, one
of the things we do is figure how much the rates go up over the last eight years. We
purchase programming , we are not programmers. We deliver this to customers' homes,
we deliver it by satellite through cable to a customer's home. The rate we have to pay to
programmers has increased 30%, the rates we have increased to our customers have only
increased 15% over the last eight years. I think you have seen over the past four years
where Time W amer is fighting back with programmers and customers are concerned.
The economy has been in a downward spiral and people are on a fixed income and
customers do not want to have a rate increase. Networks that people don't watch, we are
dropping from our channel lineup. We are trying to be smart about this. We are trying to
think about what matters to the consumer. One of the questions Mr. Haire asked was
why can't I pick the channels I want? One ofthe things we do, you can choose the
premium channels. We get push back from the programmers that say we are not ready
for you to offer customers to pick eight, ten, fifteen channels they want. We are looking
at ways to do this, but as you and I both know, both broadcast providers and cable
television providers make their money through advertising and they limit what we can do
through ala carte offerings. We push back at rate increase time. You will see broadcast
commercials from Time Warner Cable and in newspapers where we have to go through a
retransmission consent. Every New Years, I am on the phone talking about rate
increases, talking to our lawyers. What we have been very successful at and what you
can share with your constituents is that we are not increasing their rates at the rates at
Page4
!2:§t)r rates are increasing ."
Vice President Dan Jones stated, "We also have to pay the local stations to broadcast.
There was a time where they were begging us to include their stations , but now we have
to buy them."
Ms. Keys stated, "We talked about picture quality , we have done a lot to upgrade our
network. If you had that conversation with me eighteen months ago about pixilation , I
would have said let me tell you what we are doing. I want to get some specifics about
where you live Mr. Haire to follow up on that. We just have not had those kinds of
service issues as it relates to quality of our picture that we had because we have been
building our network so that we can provide a better level of service to our customers .
Every now and then, there may be problems. Today, we have qualm sharing throughout
our network, both standard video service and video on demand services . So the quality
of picture that you get should be better than anything you have ever gotten with Time
Warner, so if something is specifically happening in your environment, I want to get to
the bottom of it. I will personally get back in touch with you."
"Let 's talk about getting in touch with Time Warner Cable. In June oflast year, as a
company, we made some decisions that we would aggregate some of our call centers and
we would create virtual call centers to make the most of our resources that we had. Prior
to that, we had individual call centers that served individual areas . South Carolina was a
division where you called and spoke to someone at our Platt Springs Road location and
they dealt with your issues. Our new call structure has your calls routed around the
Carolinas . Today, we have four call centers in Raleigh, Charlotte, Greensboro and in
West Columbia . They share calls . We also made a decision to size this. That caused
some decreases in our service levels and today we have opened up our head counts so the
centers are staffed properly. Last year, the service levels decreased significantly, nothing
that we are proud of. Today, we have service levels like we did several years ago where
we could answer 80% of our calls and we are doing that today . It keeps us competitive .
We are competitive and we fight for every customer we have and we value every
customer we have . You have an 800 number and a number on your bill, ther e is access
on the internet and there are live chats on the internet. I think Dan said the numbers are
not listed in the telephone book. As a service provider, we have interconnection
agreements and our numbers should be provided in those books."
Mr. Jones stated, "The white pages is where business don't pay and the yellow pages is
where businesses pay, so I think if you look in the yellow pages, you will find our
numbers there. The white pages we cannot control and the numbers are incorrect, if you
call one of them, you get no answer. Phone books are a lot different than they used to be.
We are going to look into the phone number issues and get them corrected ."
Mayor Miller stated, "That is one of the things that people call me about and I have called
and I have experienced the same thing. I think it validates what I said earlier that all of
your customers are not in the phone book."
Mr. Jones replied, "All service providers are supposed to be listed in the front and we
aren't listed also . We are going to have to address that as well."
Ms. Keys stated, "On modem fees, you have the option to lease your modem from Time
Warner Cable in reference to Mr. Barnwell 's question. That was just a business decision .
If you think of all the modems we go through and all of the modem expense in managing
them, it makes business sense to add a modem fee. I will tell you it is something that all
other cable companies do as well. Whether or not customers are happy with it, it is a
decision the company has made ."
Mayor Miller asked, "How do you justify the 15% increase where your increase was
30%, that doesn't make good business sense, how do you not go broke?"
Page 5
2251
Ms. Keys replied, "The justification is that the company makes that decision and if you
track the rate increases and the rates increases are 15% to the customers and 30% from
the programmers to us. We are operating more efficiently than before . When your
revenues grow and you need to have a certain margin, what we find ourselves doing is
managing our expenses more aggressively ."
Ms. Keys stated, "As far as bills being different, rates are different as when you
subscribed and I would have to look at the bills. You see specials on television and there
is a lot print advertising on promotions and if you call into the call center and ask about
discounts , the reps are trained to look at the products to possibly migrate you into a new
offering . There are a lot of things that could be going on; your neighbor could be on a
different campaign. Digital services are different. There is a phone number on your bill
you can call."
Councilmember Jernigan stated, "I had the same problem as Mr. Haire but I was told that
my problem was because I was at the end of the street.
Ms. Keys stated, "We have a top rate team down here and if we have some technical
problems down here, I am positive they can straighten it out. We are going to look at
your bill, Mr. Stroman, and give you some options. There is a product offering called TV
Everywhere that is suitable for families on a fixed income. We have gone through a lot
and I think what a lot of you want is what can we give to customers on a fixed income.
We give you information on what you want to do. I want to thank you for the
opportunity to address you and hear your concerns and you always have the opportunity
to call on us and we will do everything we can and we are very proud to serve
Orangeburg and the community and we value the relationship we have with our
customers. "
Mayor Miller replied , "We thank you for coming and giving you our concerns that we
hear on a daily basis.
Mr. Paul Cullen of 458 Murray Road addressed Council in regards to Time Warner
Cable. He stated, "I am very impressed with the presentation and I am thrilled that all of
you have similar concerns . I feel that I need to add a little comment to this because my
situation is a little unique. My service has been exceptionally good. I have the lowest
basic tier available . Each year, it has increased, more so than other packages . I have the
statistics and I have been bringing them to the Mayor ' s office every year. The rate has
increased from last year 16%, the other rates for the other services were more like 5%
and 6%. So the others that are getting more expensive packages have less of an increase,
but those of us with the basic tier have the largest percentage of increase . Over the last
few years, the percentage of increases on the basic tiers were 11%, 13%, 9%, 1%, 18%,
and 14.5% in 2006. So, that is a large increase on my particular service. I wish there was
some smaller packages. I don't need twelve channels. I need news channels and an
education channel. Of course , you have a monopoly on cable, for those of us who cannot
afford a higher rate, there should be some smaller package that would keep us informed.
We can only afford a small amount for our communication and so I think it would be
good to have a smaller package and this is my concern and I think I am not alone .
Someone mentioned advertising, why can't they share the brunt of these increases. I
know that is not easy to do. Is there some way to convince them that everyone needs
some information? Thank you and thank the Board for taking up this issue."
A motion was made by Councilmember Keitt, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, to
approve the Third Reading of an Ordinance authorizing the lease of property at 1170
Russell Street to Palmetto Development Group for six (6) months with a renewal of six
(6) months to operate a small business incubator program. This was a 6-0-1 vote as
Councilmember Barnwell opposed .
Page 6
2252
City Administrator Yow addressed Council, "As Council knows, there was a 2010
Census and it is incumbent upon Council to look at redistricting. As you know, Mr.
Bobby Bowers with the State Office of Research and Statistics, came down and
addressed Council in regards to redistricting and presented Council with an overview of a
redistricting process and at the next meeting Council adopted the criteria for redistricting
and a schedule. Mr. Bowers presented a Benchmark Plan which is the existing Plan with
new populations and demographics showing the breakout with deviations and a Plan 1.
In adopting your schedule, you adopted a timeframe in which alternate plans could be
submitted by March 11th. A plan was presented as I covered in a memo to you. For the
public's information, Plan 1 is the Plan Mr. Bobby Bowers from the State presented and
Plan 2 is the Alternative Plan that was submitted by the minority members of Council, so
those are the questions you have before you. You will need to proceed in adopting a
plan . You have one Ordinance that adopts Plan 1 and one that adopts the Alternative
Plan."
Councilmember Barnwell asked, "What is the purpose of the Second Plan?''
Mayor Pro Tern Haire stated, "It better reflects the population breakdown ."
"Councilmember Barnwell asked, "You don't consider this gerrymandering?"
Mayor Pro Tern Haire replied, "No, I don't."
Councilmember Barnwell stated, "That plan, my district #3 runs from the By-pass to
Riverside and it basically shifts me out of my district except my house . I don't know
who prepared the Plan , but I cannot make heads or tails of it."
Mayor Pro Tern Haire made a motion to adopt the Alternate Plan (#2), seconded by
Councilmember Keitt. This was a 3-4 vote as Councilmembers Jernigan, Stroman,
Barnwell and Mayor Miller opposed, The motion did not carry.
Councilmemqer Barnwell made a motion to adopt Plan 1 from the State, seconded by
Councilmember Jernigan. This was a 4-3vote as Mayor Pro Tern Haire, Councilmembers
Keitt and Knotts opposed.
Councilmember Jernigan asked if there was anything that was going to be presented on
the Alternative Plan if a better map could be done, it could not be read.
There were no utility matters brought before Council.
A motion was made by Councilmember Stroman seconded Councilmember Keitt, to
enter into an Executive Session for a personnel and legal matter regarding the
Department of Public Utilities Administration Division.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
Respectfully submitted,
(!d)r}aj ;II ~
Carrie W. Johnson
City Clerk
/pfb
City Council Minutes
Special Meeting
March 26, 2013
2253
Orangeburg City Council held a Public Hearing on Tuesday , March 26, 2013, at 7:00P.M. , in the
Council Chamber Building with Mayor Miller presiding.
The purpose of the Public Hearing was for discussion on redistricting of the City of Orang eburg six (6)
Single-Member Council Districts.
The Mayor asked for public comments.
Hearing none, the Public Hearing was closed.
PRESENT:
Paul A. Miller, Mayor
Bernard Haire
Charles B. Barnwell, Jr.
Charles W. Jernigan
L. Zimmerman Keitt
Sandra P. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
Council entered into the regularly scheduled City Council meeting.
A motion was made by Councilmember Jernigan , seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to approve
the Second reading of an Ordinance to amend Section 2-3.1, Chapter II, of the Code of Ordinances for
the City of Orangebur g for the purpose of establishing six (6) Municipal Council Districts pertaining to
Plan 1. Mayor Pro Tern Haire and Councilmembers Keitt and Knotts opposed.
DPU Director Tommy Miller addressed Council in reference to the First Reading of an Ordinance
amending industrial gas rates for the Department ofPublic Utilities of the City of Orangeburg, deleting
gas rate code 3F Propane Peaking Service and correcting a typographical error in the existing Gas Rate
Code 3N. He stated, "This proposal would be effective June 1, 2013, which would increase the
industrial gas rates from .80 per dekatherm to .95 per dekatherm . This proposed rate change has no
effect whatsoever on any residential or commercial gas customers. The last time natural gas rates
increased was in 2009. Since the price of natural gas has declined since peaking in 2007, the customer
total bills will be less than they paid in 2002."
Councilmember Keitt asked, "What would happen if we did not increase?"
Director Miller replied, "Our regulatory compliance costs would increase and our operations costs
would increase and it has been three and a half years since we have had an increase and we are still the
lowest in the Carolinas."
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to approve the
First Reading of an Ordinance adopting amended Industrial Gas Rates for the Department ofPublic
Utilities of the City of Orangeburg , SC, deleting Gas Rate Code 3F Propane Peaking Service and
correcting a typographi cal error in existing Gas Rate Code 3N. This motion was unanimously
approved.
Councilmember Keitt asked for a moment of privilege .
She stated, "I would like to ask everyone's help in keeping the City and County cle~ . We need to
make our areas clean, keep our houses up, even if it is just raking our yard or cutting the grass. I ride
around and am just displeased at the way we have our areas. We have to keep our areas clean to bring
people in and get jobs here. On Bleakle y Street, a lady was cleaning out a ditch and I stopped to thank
her. It is a team effort."
Page 2
2254
Councilmember Barnwell stated, "We have to pick up old sofas and stoves to keep the streets clean."
Councilmember Keitt stated, "The sanitation guys do a wonderful job and I would like to thank the
police too, but we can do better."
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
Respectfully submitted,
(!WiJf!~
Carrie W. Johnson
City Clerk
/pfb
WHEREAS,
WHEREAS,
WHEREAS,
WHEREAS,
I
\
RESOLUTION FOR FAIR HOUSING
the City of Orangeburg desires that all its citizens be afforded the
opportw1ity to attain a decent, safe, and sound living environment; and,
the City of Orangeburg rejects discrimination on the basis of race ,
religion, color , sex, national origin , disability and/or familial status in the
sale, rental or provision of other housing services; and,
the State of South Carolina enacted the South Carolina Fair Housing Law
in 1989; and,
April is recognized nationally as Fair Housing Month.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, that the Mayor and City Council of the
City of Orangeburg, South Carolina, in Council assembled, do officially recognize April as:
"Fair Housing Month"
Passed By the City Council of the City of Orangeburg , State of South Carolina , this 2nd day of
April 2013.
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
April 2, 2013
2255
Orangeburg City Council held its regularly scheduled meeting on Tuesday, April2, 2013, at 7:00
P.M., in the Council Chamber Building with Mayor Miller presiding.
PRESENT:
Paul A. Miller, Mayor
Bernard Haire
Charles B. Barnwell, Jr.
Charles W. Jernigan
L. Zimmerman Keitt
Sandra P. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
Mayor Miller welcomed everyone. He asked that everyone take a moment of silence in honor of
the passing ofMr. Yow's mother and Gregg Robinson 's mother.
Mayor Miller opened the Public Hearing for comments.
Hearing no public comments, the Public Hearing was closed.
A motion was made by Councilmember Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to
approve the March 19, 2013, City Council Minutes as distributed. This motion was
unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Knotts, to
approve the March 26, 2013, Special City Council Minutes . This motion was unanimously
approved .
Mayor Miller and DPU Manager Tommy Miller presented Ms. Linda Reid with a Retiree
Resolution and a gold watch for her thirty-three years and two months of service to the
Department of Public Utilities. Mayor Miller wished her enjoyment in her retirement. Ms. Reid
thanked DPU and Council.
City Attorney Walsh presented Council with the Ordinance to amend for redistricting in
accordance with Plan 1. Attorney Walsh stated that the plan would be submitted on Thursday of
this week and that would follow the timeline to have it approved in time to have the normal City
election on September 13, 2013.
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember J emigan, to
approve the Third Reading of an Ordinance to amend Section 2-3.1, Chapter II, of the Code of
Ordinances for the City of Orangeburg for the purpose of establishing six (6) Municipal Council
Districts. This was a 4-3 vote with Mayor Pro Tern Haire, Councilmembers Keitt and Knotts
voting against the Ordinance.
Mayor Miller presented Mr. Don Tribble the Character Trait Proclamation for April 2013,
"Integrity".
Assistant City Administrator Singh addressed Council on a Resolution for April2013, as Fair
Housing Month. He stated, "It is important in two ways, the first is just the fact of recognizing
the need for safe and fair housing with rentals and purchasing within our City and the second, is
the need with the CDBG Grant program. This is a requirement that also must be met."
A motion was made by Councilmember Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell. to
approve the Resolution for Fair Housing Month for April , 2013. This motion was unanimously
approved.
Page 2
Mr. ~1t§ 9mith addressed Council on the acceptance of a $10,000 Heritage Corridor Grant.
He stated, "The grant will be used to establish an interpreter counter and exhibit in the Gardens.
It will display the value of the wetlands on our environment and the history of the North leg of
the Edisto River. The City has been notified by PRT that the grant has been approved . The
$10,000 grant will be coupled with a $10,000 private donation and a $10,000 match from the
City's 2% Fund, for a total of a $30,000 project.
Mayor Pro Tern Haire asked, "Are there funds out there to assist with cleaning of the Edisto
River from down trees ."
Mr. Smith stated, "It has been inquired about, but the maintenance of the river systems in South
Carolina are controlled by the Corp of Engineers and they state they have no funds for that."
Councilmember Barnwell asked, "Exactly, where will the corridor run."
Mr. Smith stated, "The South Carolina National Heritage Corridor runs from the upstate down to
Charleston , South Carolina, basically parallel with the Savannah River, it includes seventeen or
eighteen counties. Orangebu rg has an active Heritage Corridor Committee ."
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "Would the Corp of Engineers object to a private group
cleaning out the river from the water plant to the boat landing."
Mr. Smith stated, "My opinion would be that they would not object but would have to have
some approval on the process ."
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, seconded by Councilmember Stroman, to approve
the acceptance of a South Carolina National Heritage corridor Grant in the amount of $10,000.
This motion was unanimously approved.
DPU Manger Tommy Miller presented Councilmember Sandra P. Knotts with her twenty year
service pin from the Department of Public Utilities.
DPU Manger Tommy Miller addressed Council on the Second reading of an Ordinance to amend
Industrial Gas Rates. The proposal would increase the industrial gas rate from .80 per dekatherrn
to .95 dekatherm. It would be effective on June 1, 2013. This proposed rate change has no
affect whatsoever on any residential or commercial gas customers . The last time gas rates were
increased was in 2009.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell , to
approve the Second Reading of an Ordinance adopting amended Industrial Gas Rates for the
Department ofPublic Utilities ofthe City of Orangeburg , SC, Deleting Gas Rate Code- 3F
Propane Peaking Service and correcting a typographical error in existing Gas Rate Code -3N.
This motion was unanimously approved
A motion was made by Councilmember Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell , to
adjourn . This motion was unanimously approved.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
J]::llysu
Duane. Tarrant
Assistant City Clerk
\pfb
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
April16, 2013
2257
Orangeburg City Council held a Public Hearing on Tuesday, April 16, 2013, at 7:00P .M., in the
Council Chamber Building with Mayor Pro Tern Haire presiding.
The purpose of the Public Hearing was for adoption of Proposed Gas Rate Changes for the
Department ofPublic Utilities.
Hearing no public comments, the meeting was closed.
PRESENT:
Bernard Haire
Charles B. Barnwell, Jr. (arrived late)
Charles W. Jernigan
L. Zimmerman Keitt
Sandra P. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
ABSENT:
Paul A. Miller, Mayor
A motion was made by Councilmember Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Stroman, to approve
the April 16, 2013, City Cmmcil Minutes as distributed. This motion was unanimously
approved. Councilmember Barnwell not present at Voting.
Ms. Claudia Brooks, representative of United Way ofthe Midlands, made an appearance before
Council. She stated, "The United Way of the Midlands is not only supported with donations,
but they also write grants. We wrote a Housing Urban Development (HUD) Grant for the
Samaritan House for $100,000. United Way of the Midlands gave $250,000 back to the
Orangeburg community last year. An amount of $11,418 was raised by the City of Orangeburg
with 62% participation and was awarded the Bronze Award. The City is one of the great
supporters of the United Way and has been for years."
A motion was made by Councilmember Jernigan, seconded by Councilmember Keitt, to approve
First Reading of an Ordinance to amend Section 2-1.2, Chapter II, of the Code of Ordinances for
the City of Orangeburg, for the purpose of providing for the election procedure for Mayor and
Council Members in compliance with State Statutory Law.
Mayor Pro Tern Haire asked, "Can we to start our petition drive six (6) months before the
period?"
Attorney Walsh answered, "Certification, is as of a certain date of registered voters, but I will be
happy to look into the matter."
The motion to approve the First Reading of an Ordinance to amend Section 2-1.2, Chapter II, of
the Code of Ordinances for the City of Orangeburg, for the purpose of providing for the election
procedure for Mayor and Council Members in compliance with State Statutory Law was
unanimously approved.
For information, Fiscal Year 2013-14 Budget Calendar was provided to Council. It will be on
the next Council meeting for adoption. Council was asked to review key dates with their
personal calendar.
2258
Page2
A motion was made by Councilmember Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to
approve the Third Reading of an Ordinance adopting amended Industrial Gas Rates for the
Department of Public Utilities of the City of Orangeburg, SC, Deleting Gas Rate Code- 3F
Propane Peaking Service and correcting a typographical error in existing Gas Rate Code -3N.
This motion was unanimously approved .
A motion was made by Councilmember Stroman, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to
enter into an Executive Session for a legal matter concerning an annexation covenant. This
motion was unanimously approved.
Council did not return to Open Session .
There being no further business , the meeting was adjourned .
Respectfully submitted,
.VWJ]YL)
\pfb
--
RESOLUTION
A RESOLUTION FOR THE CITY OF ORANGEBURG, DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC
UTILITIES TO ACCEPT THE LOW RESPONSIVE BID BY MCCLAM &
ASSOCIATES, INC. OF LITTLE MOUNTAIN, SOUTH CAROLINA IN THE AMOUNT
OF $480,297.00 FOR THE RIVERSIDE PUMP STATION UPGRADE
WHEREAS, the Department of Public Utilities of the City of Orangeburg , South Carolina,
received bids on January 23,2013 for the Riverside Pump Station Upgrade; and
WHEREAS, the low responsive bid for this work was submitted by McClam & Associates, Inc.
of Little Mountain, South Carolina in the amount of $480,297.00.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED , by the Mayor and Membe rs of Counci l of the City
of Orangeburg, in Council assemb led, and by authority of the same, that the low responsive bid
of McClam & Associates , Inc., in the amount of$480,297 .00 be accepted; and
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that 0. Thomas Miller, Jr., Manager of the Department of
Public Utilities, be authorized and he is hereby directed to execute the contract documents on
behalf of the Department of Public Utilities of the Ci ty of Orangeburg.
RESOLVED BY City Counci l duly assembled this £/&f day of May, 2013.
~~
/
A RESOLUTION
AUTHORIZING THE EXECUTION OF A SERVICE AGREEMENT
FOR RATE SCHEDULE FT WITH
CAROLINA GAS TRANSMISSION CORPORATION
FOR A PERIOD OF BEGINNING
JUNE 1, 2013 AND EXPIRING ON OCTOBER 31,2016
WHEREAS, the Department of Public Utilities of the City of Orangeburg obtains
natural gas from Carolina Gas Transmission Corporation and presently has a pipeline
capacity of 9,400 Maximum Daily Receipt Quantity (MDRQ), and
WHEREAS, the said Department of Public Utilities has been offered additional
capacity of 1,000 MDRQ (Dts), and
WHEREAS, the City of Orangeburg and its Department of Public Utilities are of the
opinion that they should accept said offer for the purpose of future expansion of its
natural gas system.
NOW THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED BY ORANGEBURG CITY COUNCIL DULY
ASSEMBLED, that O.Thomas Miller, Jr., Manager of the Department of Public
Utilities of the City of Orangeburg is hereby directed and authorized to enter into a
Service Agreement For Rate Schedule FT with Carolina Gas Transmission
Corporation for the purpose of increasing the Department of Public Utilities pipeline
capacity in an amount of 1,000 MDRQ (Dts) for a period beginning June 1, 2013 and
expiring on October 31 , 2016.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that the said Manager is hereby authorized to execute
Exhibits A, B, C, D and E attached to the said Service Agreement and take any all
other actions as may be necessary to accomplish the purposes as stated herein.
AND IT IS SO RESOLVED.
Members of Council
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
May 21,2013 2261
Orangeburg City Council held a Public Hearing on Tuesday, May 21, 2013, at 7:00P.M., in the
Council Chamber Building with Mayor Miller presiding. Mayor Miller asked for a moment of
silence for the tragedy in Moore, Oklahoma.
The purpose of the Public Hearing was to amend an Ordinance for Zoning Code Chapter XXIV
for revision to Section 24-6.4 Design Overlay District and Section C. (Permitted Uses) to allow
existing pawn shops to relocate in the Design Overlay District.
Hearing no comments, the Public Hearing was closed.
PRESENT:
Paul A. Miller, Mayor
Bernard Haire
Charles B. Barnwell, Jr.
Charles W. Jernigan
L. Zimmerman Keitt (arrived late)
Sandra P. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Knotts, to
approve the May 7, 2013, City Council Minutes. This motion was unanimously approved
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Jernigan, to
approve the Third Reading of an Ordinance to amend Section 2-1.2 Chapter II, of the Code of
Ordinances for the City, for the purpose of providing for the Election Procedure for Mayor and
Council Members in compliance with State Statutory Law. This motion was unanimously
approved.
City Attorney Walsh stated that he confirmed with the State Ethics Commission that you can
start getting signatures for a petition anytime after an election, but you increase the risk of
obtaining signatures that may not be valid. Attorney Walsh also informed Council that he
provided the County with the new Council Districts prior to hearing from the Justice Department
to start their process.
Mayor Pro Tern Haire stated, "Since the Director of Voter Registration at the County has
resigned, will this cause a problem?
Assistant City Administrator Singh stated, "He will be there another two weeks, but he indicated
it shouldn't be a problem."
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Stroman, to
approve the Second Reading of an Ordinance to amend the Zoning Code, Chapter XXIV for
revision to Section 24-6.4 Design Overlay District and Section C (Permitted Uses) to allow
existing pawns shops to relocate in the Overlay District. This motion was unanimously
approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Stroman, to approve
the reappointments to the City Grievance Committee as follows:
Jacque Fogle
LeAndrea Felder
Parks and Recreation
Service Department
This motion was unanimously approved.
3 year term ending June 2016
3 year term ending June 2016
Page 2
2262
DPU Manger Miller presented a Resolution for acceptance of the Low Bid-Upgrade-Riverside
Pump Station, McClam and Associates, Inc., of Little Mountain, South Carolina, in the amount
of $480,297.00 to Council. He stated, "The County of Orangeburg has committed to pay its
portion of $359,751.00 as previously agreed upon and DPU's cost will be $120,546.00 . The
County will give DPU ownership of the system."
Mayor Pro Tern Haire asked, "What are your plans for the old pump station?"
DPU Manager Miller stated, "We have those same pumps elsewhere and we will be able to use
those for spare parts.
A motion was made by Councilmember Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Stroman, to approve
a Resolution for acceptance of the Low Bid-Upgrade-Riverside Pump Station, McClam and
Associates, Inc., of Little Mountain, South Carolina. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to enter into an
Executive Session for Legal Matters concerning (1) Substandard Building and (2)Hospitality
and Accommodations Tax (Sodexo) and a Contractual Matter concerning the Department of
Public Utilities regarding gas line capacity.
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Keitt, to return
to Open Session. This motion as unanimously approved.
DPU Manager Miller presented a Resolution to Council authorizing the execution of a Service
Agreement for Rate Schedule FT with Carolina Gas Transmission Corporation for a period
beginning June 1, 2013 and expiring October 31,2016.
Councilmember Knotts stated, "Did you say you would be asking for an increase in rates again,
passing it on to customers and then do this increase again. I'm not at peace with this. It is
already a hardship on some people . I'm not opposed to what you are doing, I'm thinking about
the average customer."
Mayor Miller stated, "I'm not comfortable with it at this time."
A motion was made by Councilmember Jernigan, seconded by Councilmember Keitt, to approve
a Resolution authorizing the execution of a Service Agreement for Rate Schedule FT with
Carolina Gas Transmission Corporation for a period beginning June 1, 2013, and expiring
October 31, 2016. This was a 4-3 vote as Councilmembers Barnwell, Knotts and Mayor Miller
opposed.
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, to
adjourn.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
\
\pfb
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
June 4, 2013
2263
Orangeburg City Council held its regularly scheduled City Council Meeting on Tuesday, June 4,
2013, at 7:00P.M., in the Council Chamber Building with Mayor Miller presiding
PRESENT:
Paul A. Miller, Mayor
Bernard Haire
Charles B. Barnwell, Jr.
Charles W. Jernigan
L. Zimmerman Keitt
Sandra P. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
A motion was made by Councilmember Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to
approve the May 21, 2013, City Council Minutes. This motion was unanimously approved.
Mr. Jim Johnson from Eat Smart, Move More and Dr. Linda Payne from Ways to Wellness
addressed Council.
Mr. Johnson stated, "Eat Smart, Move More, is a collation of sixteen (16) wellness minded
agencies in Orangeburg County founded in 2010 that is a 501 c3 organization. We have three
workgroups as follows:
The Community Workgroup focusing on safe walking and bicycling routes. I am the leader of
this group.
The Farmer's Market Group is currently working with the Family Health Center. Dr. Edith
Anadu is the leader of this group.
The School Workgroup partnered with Mellichamp Elementary School setting up wellness
activities at the school. Ms .. Rosa Kennerly Dance is the leader ofthis group."
Mr. Johnson further discussed the Comprehensive Plan of the Lower Savannah region and stated
that now the City has a Plan and referenced a map. He stated walking audits were done to note
where ramps were not at the end of sidewalks or if sidewalks were in disrepair or if there were
no sidewalks at all to develop an inventory where people can walk or ride their bikes. The map
from Lower Savannah Council of Governments Regional Bicycle and Pedestrian Study was
passed out to Council, as information, with proposed bicycle and pedestrian facilities.
Dr. Linda Payne addressed Council from Ways to Wellness. She stated, "Ways to Wellness is
founded by Orangeburg Calhoun Technical College, The Regional Medical Center, Four Winds
Empowerment Group and Midlands Society for Human Resource Management and we have
been working since the beginning of2012. For 2013-14, we are focusing on three (3) major
areas which is improving access to healthy foods, active community environments and faith
based tobacco initiatives." Flyers and information were given to Council.
A motion as made by Councilmember Barnwell , seconded by Councilmember Stroman, to
approve the Third Reading of an Ordinance to amend the Zoning Code, Chapter XXIV for
revision to Section 24-6.4 Design Overlay District and Section C (Permitted Uses) to allow
existing pawns shops to relocate in the Overlay District.
Ms. Knotts asked Mr. Chan Holman, "What's going to be in the store?"
Mr. Holman answered, "I am carrying on my current business and expanding other retail items
as well."
~4
Councilmember Stroman stated, "It is great to have something in the Old Winn Dixie store."
Councilmember Barnwell stated, "It is good to have you in that area of town,"
The motion and second was unanimously approved for the Third Reading of an Ordinance to
amend the Zoning Code, Chapter XXIV for revision to Section 24-6.4 Design Overlay District
and Section C (Permitted Uses) to allow existing pawns shops to relocate in the Overlay District.
City Administrator Yow reported that Redistricting Plan 1 submitted by Council was approved
as submitted in the allotted period. We have sent copies to our Election Commission, County
Election Commission, State Election Commission and the State, Mr. Bobby Bowers. Some
persons from the public have request ed copies and they are available for the public. We have
time to adhere to the deadline.
Mrs . Kristina Thomas , Community of Character Director , accepted the June Character Trait
Proclamation, "Cheerfulness".
A motion was made by Councilmember Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to
approve the First Reading of an Ordinance to amend Section 24-4.1, District Boundaries and
Maps of the Code of Ordinances of the City of Orangeburg and the Zoning Map of the City of
Orangeburg, property belonging to Claflin Univers ity, #0 173-10-1 4-001.000. The Planning
Commission approved the change to 0-1, Office Institutional. This was a 6-0-1 vote as
Councilm ember Knotts recused herself from voting. (See Attached Recusal Statement ).
There were no utility matters brought before Council.
A motion was made by Counc ilmember Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Stroman, to adjourn.
There being no further business , the meeting was adjourned.
\pfb
RESOLUTION
BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF ORANGEBURG, SOUTH CAROLINA
MAKING DECLARATION OF INTENT PURSUANT TO UNITED STATES
TREASURY DEPARTMENT, INTERNAL REVENUE SERVICE,
REGULATION 1.150-2
WHEREAS, the City Council of the City of Orangeburg, South Carolina ("City Council")
intends to issue bonds to defray the cost of certain capital improvements contained in
the Capital Improvement Program (the "Project") for the City of Orangeburg
Department of Public Utilities ("Department"); and,
WHEREAS, City Council expects that funds for the Project will be advanced from the
General Revenue Fund of the Department and it is the expectation that the proceeds
of the bonds received as reimbursement will be deposited to the General Revenue
Fund of the Department to replenish this account; and
WHEREAS, City Council is mindful of the fact that, in order for the use of federally tax
exempt obligation proceeds to be considered "expended" for purposes of United
States Treasury Department Internal Revenue Service Regulation 1.150-2 ("Reg.
1.150-2") when used to reimburse the Department for expenditures made prior to the
issuance of the obligations, certain conditions including the making of a declaration of
intent to reimburse such expenditures must be met; and
WHEREAS, with the intent of supplementing, but not to supersede, any prior
declarations of intent of City Council with respect to the Project, City Council desires to
make such declaration of intent;
NOW THEREFORE, BE IT. RESOLVE
ASSEMBLED on the J~ day of , 2013, that the declaration of
intent to reimburse expenditures on th Project with the proceeds of federally tax
exempt obligations not exceeding $10,0 0,000.00 pursuant to Reg. 1.150-2 is hereby
made, and that the Clerk of City Council is hereby directed to maintain a copy of this
declaration in the files and records of City Council.
AND IT IS SO RESOLVED.
I • ~"'"' - "t~tt"IL' ~
Members of Council
RESOLUTION
WHEREAS, the South Carolina Water Quality Revolving Fund Authority (the "State
Authority") provides low-interest loan financing for the construction of publicly owned
wastewater treatment facilities from the Water Pollution Control Revolving Fund (the
"Fund") pursuant to the Federal Clean Water Act and Title 48, Chapter 5, Code of Laws of
South Carolina , 1976, as amended ; and
WHEREAS, the City of Orangeburg is a legally constituted municipality in the State of
South Carolina and is authorized to incur revenue debt pursuant to Title 6, Chapter 21 ,
Code of Laws of South Carolina , 1976, as amended ; and
WHEREAS, the City of Orangeburg has determined that it is in the best interests of the
City to apply to the State Authority for a loan from the Fund;
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the City Council of the City of Orangeburg ,
South Carolina (the "Council") , in a meeting duly assembled :
1. That the Council hereby authorizes 0 . Thomas Miller, Jr., Manager of the Department
of Public Utilities to comp lete, and Paul A. Miller, Mayor of the City of Orangeburg,
South Carolina to execute and submit an application to the State Authority for a loan
from the Fund in the amount of approximately $20.3 million dollars to finance the costs
of constructing improvements to the City's Wastewater Treatment Plant. The Manager
of the Department of Public Utilities is authorized to take such actions as may be
necessary or convenient to comp lete the application process .
2. That the City will grant to the State Authority a pledge of, and lien on, all revenues of
the City's Combined Utility System for repayment of the loan.
3. That the final terms and conditions of the loan and the loan documents shall be subject
to the approval of this Council.
P~D BY the cr Council of the City of Orangeburg , State of South Carolina, this
~day of _LJfU ) , 2013 .
Members of Council
, .. ""-- ~ ..,- . r . ' «»< ~
RESOLUTION
A RESOLUTION CONTINUING PARTICIPATION IN THE
LOWER SAVANNAH REGIONAL HOME CONSORTIUM
WHEREAS , the Congress of the United States has enacted the Cransto n-Gonzale s National Affordab le
Housing Act of 1990 (herein after the "Act") which created the Home Investment Partne rships
Program (hereinafter the "Home Program") to prov ide funds to state s and loca l governments for
affo rdable housing assistan ce with the flexibility to decid e wk-;! kind of hou sing assista nce or mix
of housing assistance is most appropriate for local needs; and,
WHEREAS, the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (hereinafter "HUD") subseque ntly
issued regulat ions set forth in 24 CFR Part 92 allowing units of general local government to enter
into mutua l cooperat ion agreement s to form consort ia for the purpose of obtaining funding from
the Home Program; and,
WHEREAS, the City of Orangeburg has affordable housing needs; and,
WHEREAS, the City of Orangeburg desir es to increase affordabl e housing o pportun ities for its present and
future residents, particularly for very low-income persons; and,
WHEREAS, the City of Orangeburg desires to enter into affordable housing development activitie s which are
directed toward the above genera l purposes, and for those reasons , wishes to seek such federal
fu nding as may be available to it pursuant to the Act; and,
WHEREAS, the City of Orangeburg desires to enter into the affordable housing a ctivities and has determined
that joint action with other units of loca l gove rnment s that choose to participate in accordance
with the "Inter-Governmental Agreement Establishing the Lowe r Savannah Regional Home
Consortium FY 2014-2017," the terms of which are incorporated by reference and suc h relevant
HUD regulations and requirement s as may now or hereafter be in effect wou ld benefit the City of
Orangeburg.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED , that the Mayor and City Council, in Council duly assemb led, author ize John H.
Yow, City Administrator of the City of Orangeburg to sign the "Inter -Governme ntal Agree ment Establ ish ing the
Lower Savan nah Regional Home Consortium FY 2014 -20 17 ," on behal f of the City of Orangeburg, as well as all
other document s necessary to form the Consortium and to carry out and fulfi ll its purposes.
PASSED BY the City Council ofthe City of Orangeburg, State of South Carolina, this 6111 day of August 2013.
l..p
~~
" I ";--x'f .. /
ci ~~~?~~
',' ~p
~-
Membe rs of Council
ATTEST: ~------ ------r---r------
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
August 20, 2013
2287
Orangeburg City Council held two (2) Public Hearings on Tuesday, August 20, 2013, at 5:30
P.M., in Council Chambers with Mayor Miller presiding.
The purpose of the Public Hearing #1 was to raise revenue and adopt a Budget for the City of
Orangeburg, SC, for the Fiscal Year beginning October 1, 2013, and ending September 30, 2014.
Mr. Abe Salama of 1495 Hillsboro Road, Orangeburg, SC, addressed Council. He stated, "The
topic of my discussion is that I have had a change of heart and I thank you and commend you for
coming up with a budget that doesn't require an increase in property taxes. All of you should be
commended. But, for the record, the only member who during the original discussion and who
was against the increase in property taxes was Ms. Liz Keitt. She was the only one among all of
you to reject the increase. The question becomes what was the real motive for the changing of
the heart. There are many people in the City of Orangeburg that think the motive is that some of
the members are looking for re-election. Of course, there is a way to prove that we are wrong.
You have a chance now to vote and freeze the property taxes for next year. Your position has
nothing to do with being re-elected. Thank you for hearing about the economic suffering today."
City Attorney Walsh stated, "From a legal standpoint, City Council cannot take up tax issues for
the upcoming year. The present City Council cannot bind future Councils."
Hearing no further comments, Public Hearing #1, was closed.
The purpose of Public Hearing #2 was to adopt a Budget for the operation of the Department of
Public Utilities for the City of Orangeburg, SC, for Fiscal Year beginning October 1, 2013, and
ending September 30, 2014.
Hearing no comments, Public Hearing #2 was closed.
Council entered into the regular scheduled City Council meeting.
PRESENT:
Paul A. Miller, Mayor
Charles B. Barnwell, Jr.
Bernard Haire
Charles W. Jernigan
L. Zimmerman Keitt
Sandra P. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
A motion was made by Councilmember Stroman, seconded by Councilmember Keitt, to approve
the August 6, 2013, City Council Minutes as distributed. This was a 6-0-1 vote as
Councilmember J emigan abstained, as he was not present at the meeting.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, seconded by Counci1member Barnwell, to
approve the Second Reading of an Ordinance amending the Budget for the City of Orangeburg,
SC, for FY beginning October 1, 2012, and ending September 30, 2013. This motion was
unanimously approved.
City Administrator Yow stated, "We anticipate finishing the year in the black with $117,748 in
revenues over expenditures."
A motion was made by Councilmember Stroman, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, to approve
the Second Reading of an Ordinance to raise revenue and adopt a Budget for the City of
Orangeburg, SC, for FY beginning October 1, 2013, and ending September 30, 2014. This was a
6-0-1 vote, as Councilmember Keitt abstained.
~288
City Administrator Yow stated, "It is a balanced budget with revenues and expenditures totaling
$17,479.750. For the record, the proposed budget has never included a proposed property tax
increase."
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, seconded by Councilmember Stroman , giving
City Administrator Yow authority to execute a General Aviation Administration Grant (FAA) in
the amount of $92,202 for the design of relocating fuel farm.
Councilmember Stroman stated, "This should have been done a long time ago."
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "What will happen to the old tanks?"
Public Works Director Bowden replied, "We can either dig them up or fill them with flowable
fill, which would be the most cost effective."
Mayor Pro Tern Haire ask, "Is this an above ground operation and will we be at risk for
tampering or sabotage?"
Director Bowman stated, "It is self contained for leaks, but I will have to find out more on the
tampering ."
City Administrator Yow stated , "There is nothing full proof, this project is tentatively approved
by the FAA and there are gates and full perim eter fencing and security cameras at the airport."
This motion was unanimously approved .
A motion was made by Councilmember Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Knotts, to approve
the Second Reading of an Ordinance to adopt a Budget for the Department of Public Utilities for
the City of Orangeburg, SC, for Fiscal Year beginning October 1, 2013, and ending September
30,2014. This motion was unanimously approved .
Councilmember Barnwell asked, "Severa l students at the University of South Carolina found that
meters could be hacked. I found out that theirs is not licensed and ours is, can you explain that?"
DPU Manager Miller stated, "We have looked to be sure it could not be hacked, our system is a
licensed frequency and the one in Columbia is not. The electronic data is encrypted also. I
cannot tell you it is 101% safe, but we should be fine and we are monitoring it all the time."
Mayor Pro Tern Haire asked, "Who is it licensed by?"
DPU Manager Miller stated , "The FCC."
A motion as made by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, seconded by Councilmember Knotts, to adjourn.
This motion was unanimously approved.
There being no further business , the meeting was adjourned.
\pfb
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
SPECIAL SESSION- AUGUST 13,2013
Orangeburg City Council held a Special Session Meeting on Tuesday , Augu~ ~13,
at 5:30P .M. in the Assembly Room of the Department of Public Utilities, 1~~Fi~sell
Street with Mayor Paul A. Miller presiding.
Mayor Miller opened the meeting by welcoming everyone to the Special City Council
Meeting at the Department of Public Utilities.
Mike Sells gave an invocation.
PRESENT: Paul A. Miller, Mayor
ABSENT:
Bernard Haire, Mayor Pro T em
Charles B. Barnwell
L. Zimmerman Keitt
Richard F. Stroman
Charles W. Jernigan
Sandra P. Knotts
The meeting was then turned over to 0 . Thomas (Tommy) Miller, Manager of the
Department of Public Utilities.
Budget Presentation
Manager Tommy Miller to Mayor and Council
Manager Miller proceeded by thanking the Mayor and Members of Council for taking
their time to attend the Special Meeting and allowing DPU to present its proposed
budget for their consideration.
Next, he thanked the Directors and their staff for the many hours of work in putting this
budget together. He went on to state "this is a team effort". He explained the
management staff has the awesome responsibility of operating and maintaining your
utility. They are also entrusted with responsibility of planning the future of your utility.
He showed a slide that he felt was appropriate . He stated it summarizes what we do.
We develop ideas, we discuss them, we plan them, and we develop a strategy to
implement them. This is done for one purpose - "to meet the future goals and
obligations of DPU and ensure that it remains as one of the most respected utilities in
South Carolina. That is what this proposed budget does - it allows DPU to continue to
provide quality utility service to its customers and continues to lay the foundation for the
future .
Manager Miller continued with the meeting stating he was pleased to present a
proposed budget for the City of Orangeburg 's Department of Public Utilities for Fiscal
Year 2013-2014 . This proposed budget has an income of $97,403 ,873, with expenses
of $85,883,153 for a net profit before the transfer of $11,520,720 . He stated this
represents a return on equity for the citizens of City of Orangeburg of 4.4%. He
continued stating that this proposed budget reflects changes in the cost of purchased
power per our electric supply contract with South Carolina Electric & Gas Company
(SCE&G). We are about to complete our second year under this contract. It does not,
however, (and we mention this every year) anticipate the unpredictable costs of fuel
that is used for electric generation.
He continued to explain the proposed budget also forecasts the costs of natural gas to
remain relatively stable at levels that have been below recent history. The Department
expects the cost to remain relatively low through 2014.
He stated the costs of providing water and wastewater services has and will continue to
increase . The cost of many of our commodities, government regulations , and labor are
expected to rise and add to the cost of doing business.
He stated the Department anticipates the costs will be offset by small increases in sales
in the Electric and Gas Divisions, as well as slight increases in the Water and
Wastewater Divisions.
He continued to explain how the budget numbers reflect the predicted changes in each
Division:
Electric Division - In the Electric Division, we are predicting sales to increase slightly
over last year's sales even though overall electric sales are still well below pre
recession levels. Due to increased SCE&G fuel and capacity cost, the cost of
purchased electric power reflected in the Department's electric rates increased
approximately 3% in July of 2013. He explained the power supply costs that we incur
from our suppliers are directly passed through to DPU customers, so the net effect to
our bottom line is zero. This has a significant impact on the price to our customers.
Manager Miller reminded Council that the contract with SCE&G allows fuel costs to be
more levelized . This removes the cost spikes that results from fuel cost fluctuat ions.
Thi~~E8(}lst levelization has helped all of our customers which has proven to be a
good thing . Manager Miller stated, at this time, he did not recommend a change in any
of the electric rates.
Gas Division - In the Gas Division, we are are also predicting that sales will increase
slightly primarily due to the addition of customers in the "West Distribution System" a
project that you approved in Fiscal Year 2013. The Gas Division is anticipating that the
market cost of natural gas will be stable due to the continued production of shale gas.
All our gas requirements are purchased on the open market. The price of natural gas
remains relatively low to the cost of other energy options and we are continuing to look
for opportunities to expand our natural gas customer base through marketing efforts.
The combination of the "West Distribution System" project and the recently approved
increase in industrial base rates should result in an increase in net revenues for the
Gas Division in Fiscal Year 2014. Manager Miller stated, at this time, he did not
recommend a change in any of the Gas Division rates.
Water Division- In the Water Division, sales and revenues declined approximately 5%
in each of the Fiscal Years 2012 and 2013 in all categories , but primarily in the
residential and small commercial sector. The Water Division is predicting that sales will
stabilize at existing levels in Fiscal Year 2014. As we have reported many times, the
cost of operating and maintaining our water system continues to rise. The rapidly
increasing cost are primarily due to increases in chemical costs, depreciation costs and
increased distribution flushing due to regulatory requirements . We are in the process of
conducting a study on our water rates, but this study will not be finalized until after
October 1, 2013. Manager Miller stated, at this times, he did not recommend a change
in the Water Division rates.
Wastewater Division - In the Wastewater Division, which parallels the declines in the
Water Division, sales and revenues are also down, but we are predicting that sales and
revenues will stabilize in Fiscal Year 2014. As in water operations , the cost of
wastewater operations continues to increase. These costs will increase significantly as
the existing 35-year old Wastewater Treatment Plant is upgraded over the next couple
of years. Manager Miller informed Council that the Department is in the process of
conducting a study of our wastewater rates, just as we are in our water rates, but this
study will be finalized until after October 1, 2013. Manager Miller stated , at this time , he
did not recommend a change in the Wastewater Division rates.
********************************************************
Manager Miller reported the proposed spending on capital projects in Fiscal Year
2013-2014 is $12,050,000, which is a substantial increase in capital spending from last
year.
He said that in a few minutes, he was going to ask the Directors to present the
proposed projects in their respective divisions and give you more details.
Manager Miller reported there is one (1) carry-over capital project for the Administrative
Division , two (2) carry-over capital projects for the Electric Division, one (carry-over
capital project for the Wastewater Division and one (1) new proposed project for the
Water Division. There are no proposed capital projects for the Natural Gas Division for
the next fiscal year.
He stated, this is a sound and responsible budget proposal and does not require any
immediate rate increases or at least not at this time. The proposed budget does allow
for a 2% cost of living increase for our employees and allows for an increase in the
transfer to the City by $71,500 . It will also allow us to continue with the previously
approved capital projects that will be presented to you in a few minutes and to add one
(1) new proposed project.
Manager Miller stated there are three (3) obligations that the Department always strives
to meet:
1. Providing our customers with the safest and best service at the lowest possible
rates.
2. Providing a reasonable return on investments for the City of Orangeburg .
3. Continuing to maintain and invest in our utility infrastructure to meet the challenges
of the future .
He stated we are confident that we can continue to meet these obligations with this
proposed budget.
Manager Miller expressed that this concluded his portion of the budget presentation.
******************************************************** 2281
Manager Miller stated since there are not any proposed projects in the Gas Division, he
was going to ask Dave Durgin to come up first and give an update on the Gas Division.
That way, this will keep all of the ongoing and proposed project budget presentations
together .
Administrative Division ........................ . Michael G. Sells, Director
Electric Division ........................ .......... John B. Bagwell, Director
Gas Division ...................................... Dave Durgin, Director
Water Division ................. ................... D. Eric Odom, Director
Wastewater Division . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Richard M. Labrador, Director
GAS DIVISION PROJECT UPDATE
Gas Division Director Dave Durgin stated the Gas Division did not have any new
projects for the upcoming fiscal year. He proceeded by giving a brief update on one
continuing project recently approved- "West Distribution System".
The contractor has completed their work and within the approved budget. Four poultry
farms, two grain drying facilities and two residential customers have been connected
and they seem very pleased with the new gas service. We have approximately 15 more
service orders that we will turn on when the customers are ready. We will soon have a
marketing effort to increase the awareness of natural gas in the area before this winter.
The "West Distribution System" was designated by Council as a Special Project to have
a payback period of 10 years. Although it is still early, it appears to be on schedule and
that we may be able to finish the payback quicker than expected.
Mayor Miller: Are the 15 service orders residential?
Dave Durgin: Yes, we have connected all the commercial orders except for one and
we are currently pursuing them.
Mayor Miller: Are we getting many inquiries?
Davie Durgin: Yes Sir. We seem to get one or two a week. We hope to get more
after we go forward with our marketing effort. The one thing that we have heard from
customers out there is that they did not realize that gas was now available to them.
Mayor Miller: You have the main line, so obviously the people on the main trunk can
get on very quickly. Will you vary off that to serve other residents?
Dave Durgin : Yes Sir. We currently have several summer job projects that will be
starting shortly and those are to address several of the customers who have signed up.
ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION PROJECT UPDATE
Administrative Division Director Michael G. Sells stated the Administrative Division has
one previously approved project which is the replacement of the Administrative
Division's software.
The purpose of this five (5) year project is to replace and improve the Administrative
Division's software for enhanced customer service, accounting, work order
management and Human Resources. The enhancements must meet current and
future needs for a least the next fifteen (1 5) years.
This past year, we identified 8,000 requirements needed in our software . We produced
a RFP that was sent to approximately 25-30 vendors. Sixteen (1 6) responded and they
were evaluated. Four (4) were selected to demo their product. Each demo lasted
approximately 40 hours. We brought in as many as 40 employees to help in the
evaluation. T hrough that, we selected Cayenta as the software vendor of choice.
Cayenta has been in business over 20 years and they have over 115 employees and
over 80 custome rs. They are part of the Harris Corporation, which is a major software
producer that has 2,100 employees and actually has seven (7) different utility software
companies. They were the o nly vendor that came close to meeting our 8,000
requirements. In addition, their product was overwhelmingly voted by the staff as the
best solution for DPU. We are currently working out the best and final offer. We expect
to sign a contract in September and the project to begin November 1st.
Mayor Pro Tern Haire: You said Cayenta came closest to meeting your needs. How
much more is needed to completely meet the needs that you have? Will that trigger in
the future additional things that we might have to do as far as software?
Mi~28(B;: No Sir. What we have to do out of the 8,000, there might have been a
couple hundred and we had to sit down and evaluate them and see how important they
were to us and a lot of times we asked them to do things the way we do things. So we
had to look at them and say can we change, can we do it like all the rest of the utilities.
If not, we would have to pay for a modification . We actually sat down with them and
went through all the problems that did not meet our original requirements and we
looked at their proposals . They said this is what it will cost and actually their cost for
modifications were around $750,000 and we axed out all but $50,000 . We said we
could work around that. We just changed our parameters We can figure out other
ways to do things .
Mayor Miller: What were some of the things you wanted, but you compromised on, but
decided that it was not worth the money?
Mike Sells: We spend a half a day reconciling our bills with Blue Cross, making sure
that what is on our Human Resources records matches our bill. There are some
companies that when Blue Cross sends in the bill it matches up with the payroll and
reconciles itself. Theirs didn't. But when we saw the price, we said we can do it
ourselves. We have been doing it for 100 years, we can just keep on doing it. Nothing
critical. That alone knocked off $650,000 .
Mayor Pro Tern Haire: This system software is predicted to last how long? And we
will not have to go back in between the expectancy of that life of that software.
Mike Sells: I am predicting 15 years. I will not be here, but you can call me up and let
me know . Every so often, maybe every 7 or 9 years they have major upgrades where it
changes dramatically . This would not be a full blown change, it would be a major
upgrading. Our current software has lasted 20 years and I see no reason why this staff
cannot continue using this, unless there is some major change in utilities that I cannot
anticipate .
Mayor Miller: What were some of the major differences between the four (4) you
narrowed it down to?
Mike Sells: One was Oracle and it their cost and it was actually too complicated for us.
It was not even considered because the cost was too high (doubled) and it did not
deliver as much as Cayenta did. Cogsdale was a little simpler, but they met the least of
the 8,000 requirements and there was going to have to be a lot of modifications . They
had not handled as many complicated utilities as ours, they were just missing a lot of
parts. The third one had a very good customer service application, but that is all that
they did, so they had to marry themselves with a finance software and a work
management software. We looked at that and they were not that much cheaper . The
integration was very difficult and we were afraid cne might go out of style while the
other was still in place.
Councilrnernber Keitt: Mike are you saying that the Administrative group that you
have did an excellent job and got right in there and did what they needed to do to save
us some money?
Mike Sells: Yes they did. We had a core team of 10 people that evaluated (they had
to read the 16 proposals and evaluate . We had to vote on how to implement and how
their screens looked and how things performed . Then we had the demonstrations . We
had people from the Administrat ive, Electric, all the Divisions send representatives to
look at the softwa re, they got to vote and Cayenta won every vote- they were the best.
Mayor Miller : How many utilities - I know that we are kind of unique because we have
all four services plus, everybody has Admini strative. How many systems similar to what
we have has this company dealt with?
Mike Sells: They have dealt with 80 customers, some have just have CIS, some have
just work management and some have just finance, but I think that it was about 30 who
had all, it is what you call ERP solutions - that is what we are getting - ERP means you
are getting it all, but out of all the 80, I am going to take a stab, maybe 10 or 20 with
four utilities. We just visited one last week that had two utilities and we asked them if
having more than one utility complicate the software, they said they had no problems
with it. Once they had everything lined up for one, it lined up for all.
Councilmember Barnwell: Mike, once this system becomes operational , how many
meters I assume electric and gas will be read - I guess by riding by?
Mike Sells: That is actually going to be on John's project. He has the AMI. This is
just the software in the office for billing and doi'lg all our basic work.
Mayor Miller: Once you pull the trigger, what is the phase in to get fully operational ?
Mike Sells: We will first be putting in financials , HR, payroll and work mmJent.
This will be a twelve (12) month progress and we will have to meet 3,000 or 4,000
requirements of ours and then we test and test and retest- we actually have to dedicate
about 10 people - pull them out of our ranks to help test this product to make sure it
works. After a year we will go live and run it for about three months and after that we
start all over again with our Customer Service Program. We run the same
configurations for 18 months - testing and testing and making sure (we want to really
make sure you get your bill right) then we will go live and run it for about three months.
After that and then for the next year after that you shake out any little things that you left
behind, sometimes there are little small details that you don't want to slow the whole
progress down.
Mayor Miller: So you will be running a dual system? You will be running the old
system and the new system?
Mike Sells: For the next three years we will be on the old system while the people
testing will be on the new system. We will go live with half of it in a year and a half and
the other half will go live in three and half years from now.
Mike Sells Continued his Presentation:
The budget for this project is approximately $11 .6 million. We expect to spend
$300,000 by the end of this fiscal year for a total budget remaining of $11.3 million. We
expect to spend $3.5 million on this project for the next fiscal year.
Mayor Miller: Is this going to come in under the budgeted figure?
Mike Sells: I do expect and we are pushing very hard and everything looks good for it
to come significantly under budget. I have not signed a contract yet.
Mayor Miller: I understand. I think when you first proposed this to us the figure you
gave us you thought that it was probably higher than what it was going to cost in the
end.
Mike Sells: I expect to save a couple of million. That is what we are shooting for,
unless we have missed something. I have not seen the whole contract yet and have
not signed, but it is looking a lot better than we expected.
Mayor Miller: Mike it sounds to me that you have done a tremendous amount of work.
He wanted to commend the Department for the work that you and the people that are
under you have spent on it, because I know it has involved a lot of time and effort and a
lot of hours, so I know that you are excited about it and we will be excited about it and
hopefully it will move us into the next era we need to be.
ELECTRIC DIVISION PROJECT UPDATE
Electric Division Director John B. Bagwell stated his presentation by addressing
Councilmember Barnwell's earlier question . "How many meters the AMI can read"?
John Bagwell: Mr. Barnwell we will put up seven towers that are capable of reading
20,000 meters at each tower which gives us a total of 140,000 meters that we could
read with the system. Currently we have approximately 60,000 meters, so with could
double the s ize of the meters that Orangeburg has and it will still would perform very
well for us.
Councilmember Barnwell : Is that electric, gas and water?
John Bagwell : Yes Sir. Approximately 60,000 meters today , and we could read up to
140,00 meters with this system. We could add more towers and read more meters, but
our current design, that is what we have.
Mayor Pro Tem Haire: Has any of this been started?
John Bagwell: Yes Sir. Please bare with me and I will give you some more
information on this.
The Electric Division has no new projects for this upcoming fiscal year, but currently we
do have two (2) projects that are continuing from last year and were previously
approved . Project #1 is the Advanced M etering Infrastructure (AMI). Over the last
twelve months the Department has been very busy keeping the AMI project on budget
and on schedule. The Department has installed servers and software for both the AMI
and MOM systems. The AMI consisted of installing five (5) computer servers and
seven (7) communication towers . The MOM (Meter Data Manager's Software consisted
of one server and some software currently. We have completed the data
synchronization between the two (2) systems as well as our Customer information
System which is currently ORCOM . This data synchronization allows for the flow of
infor~i84>etween the systems to keep all systems with concise and consistant data .
We have been working very hard installing electric, gas and water meters during this
year. Before the end of June of this year we will have installed over 1,800 meters and
end points in 3 metering routes . The communication of the system to the meters is
very good. We have exceeding 99% in registered reads per day. We have intergraded
our geographical information system and our outage management systems to supply
information between each of the systems (AMI and MOM). We have tested the electric
connection and disconnection and have used the system to re-check meter readings
that our meter readers have already read. Billing on the system should be completed by
the end of this calendar year. A slide was shown outlining where the towers are
located : We have installed two (2) towers at Substation #20 and one (1) at the Hillcrest
Water Tank. Next year's time line beginning in October 2013, the plan is to purchase
and install additional electric and gas meters sufficient enough to complete the entire
gas system and half of the electric system. Near the end of this coming fiscal year
which is 2013. We will be billing approximately 22,000 accounts of DPU's 60,000
accounts and start preparing for the upcoming integration with the pre-pay and the new
ERP system . Overall the AMI project is definitAiy meeting our expectations.
The total project cost was this Advanced Metering Infrastructure is $14,279,000. To
date we have spent $1,955 ,000 this fiscal year. The estimated 2013-2014 cost is
$2,925,000. Does anyone have any questions?
Councilmember Barnwell: Will this require all new meters - electric and gas
John Bagwell: Yes Sir. It will be brand new electric meters, gas meters will be
retrofitted . It is only a communicational module that has to go on the gas meters .
There will be certain gas meters that has to be changed but it will only be because of
the age of the meter.
**********************
Electric Division Director John B. Bagwell presented Project #2 - Peak Shaving I
Wastewater Plant Generator . This is an ongoing previously approved project.
Director Bagwell stated this project is about two (2) months behind schedule. This is
primarily due to the relocation of the generator set. After reviewing with my staff and
consulting engineers, it was concluded that the Wastewater Treatment Plant site
installation did not allow DPU to peak-shave without additional cost for distribution
system integration at Substation #20 which would make the project go over the initial
budget set for this project. By moving the ge.1eration set to Substation #20, the tie to
our distribution grid became electrically easier and kept us on budget. The new location
will also allow for expandability of additional units in the future and back-up power to the
Wastewater Treatment Facility as originally designed . The purchase order for the
generator set and the generator step-up transformer has been issued . Expected
delivery for both is November this calendar year. The construction documents are
currently out for bid and will be back in late August. Distribution network tie material is
also on order and scheduled to be shipped by the end of September . We have been
busy on this project, but we are just a little behind . Although the generator set is behind
schedule, the Department is comfortable with the completion date of February 2014.
This date will still allow the Department to claim the 2 mega-watts for the summer peak
in 2014 as originally planned. When this project is complete the Department will have
26 mega-watts of peak-shaving capacity installed . Deferring to our customers over $2.5
million a year in electricity cost. The total project cost for this generator set was
$2,125,000. The total project expenditures to date are $200,000 . The total project cost
rema ining is $1 ,925,000 which is expected to be spent this coming fiscal year.
Councilmember Barnwell: Is this within budget?
John Bagwell: Yes Sir.
Mayor Miller: Is most of that going to be for tt .at generator?
John Bagwell : The generator cost is $1,400,000 . That is the engine and the
generator .
Mayor Miller: John, what is the size of it?
John Bagwell: The physical size? The engine is approximately 25 feet long. We then
add another 20 feet for the generator set and beyond there will be a control room added
to it which will be about another 30 feet. Appro ximately 130 feet long - it will be shipped
in two (2) sections .
WASTEWATER DIVISION PROJECT UPDATE
The Wastewater Division proposes no new projects for the upcoming fisc2~S~ but
does have one continuation the Wastewater Treatment Plant Upgrade. This project will
increase the capability of the existing 35-year old Wastewater Treatment Plant to treat
an influent bio-chemical oxygen demand of 300 milligrams per liter (mg/1) while
replacing the aging system components that exceeded their useful lives. As you recall
the major new components include a grit removing system, fine bubble duration basin ,
clarifier, and sludge holding tanks. The project is on schedule and we have received
the necessary construction permits and State approval for reduced interest "Green
Funding" and will be soliciting bids this fall. The total project cost is approximately
$20.3 million of which $500,000 has already been spent. We anticipate spending $4-
million during this upcoming fiscal year.
WATER DIVISION PROJECT UPDATE
Water Division Director Eric Odom stated that the Water Division has one new project
for your consideration for the upcoming fiscal year- Rehabilitation of the 197 4 Clearwell
' The purpose of this project is two-fold .
1. First is to replace the existing ageing roofing system
2. And second is to rehabilitate and repair the internal structure as well as the
internal piping components .
The existing clearwell was constructed and placed into operation approximately 39
years ago. The current roofing system is a precast concrete panel system that sits on
top of reinforced concrete beams. Over time these concrete slabs began to shift due to
thermal expansion and contraction . In order to solve this problem the concrete panels
were eventually anchored to the concrete support beams below. Wh ile this fixed the
issue of the roof panels shifting, the internal structure beneath the panels began to
degrade.
In May of 2011 , a structural assessment of the clearwell was conducted that revealed
the condition of both the roofing system and internal beams as only in fair condition with
several areas showing significant structural degrading. The report stated that many of
the precast concrete roof panels are deteriorating and on the interior, several panels
have major concrete chips leaving the rebar exposed .
The situation is further complicated by the fact that many of the piping components,
valves, ladders etc. are severely deteriorated and at the end of their useful life.
The overall master plan for the elimination of existing problems is to replace the existing
precast concrete panel system with a new light weight, low profile aluminum roofing
system. Prior to the installation of the new aluminum system, the internal structure will
be rehabilitated by coating all exposed rebar and repairing the concrete structure that
will ultimately support the new aluminum roofing system. We also intend to rehabilitate
and repair the internal piping components, valves, and ladders during this process as
well.
The total estimated cost for this project is $2,875,000. Of this we anticipate spending
$200,000 in the upcoming fiscal year, primarily for engineering and plan preparation .
This Completed the Presentation of Proposed Projects
Manager Miller stated to Mayor and Council that this concluded the Departments
proposed capital projects and budget presentations and asked that they please
consider the First Reading of the proposed DPU budget as presented for Fiscal Year
2013-2014. He asked again if there were any questions.
*******************************************************
Mayor Miller presided over the First Reading of Ordinance No. 2013-9 to Adopt a
Budget for the Operation of the Department of Public Utilities for the City of
Orangeburg , State of South Carolina for Fiscal Year October 1, 2013 through
September 30, 2014.
A motion was made by Councilmemb er K eitt, seconded by Mayor Pro Tem Haire, to
accept the First Reading of an Ordinance to Adopt the 2013-2014 Annual Budget for
the Department of Public Utilities for the City of Orangeburg. The motion was approved
unanimously.
Councilmember Keitt: Tommy, I would like to commend you and your staff for the
work that you are doing- continue to do it for us- I we appreciate all that you are doing.
Manager Miller: Thank you.
Ma~6ber: What we have going on is very good and these projects should move us
into a new era and we look forward to seeing DPU continue to be the leader that it is.
Again, Mike, I want to commend ya'll, because that is not a money making thing, like
selling electricity, gas, water or wastewater, but it is an essential part of making a
business run and if they don't watch those p's and g's these other components will not
work.
He asked for a motion to adjourn if there was no further business.
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Keitt to
adjourn. The motion was unanimous.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
Respectfully submitted,
MOv. ~
Becky A.~stin
Secretary to Manager
Department of Public Utilities
RESOLUTION
RESOLUTION OF CITY COUNCIL TO SET SUBURBAN FIRE PROTECTION RATES AS
AUTHORIZED UNDER SECTION 18-4.2 OF THE CODE OF ORDINANCES OF THE
CITY OF ORANGEBURG SOUTH CAROLINA
WHEREAS, the City of Orangeburg, South Carolina provides fire protection and other related
services to the suburban areas outside the city; and
WHEREAS, a large Majority of the emergency calls are in the suburban areas; and
WHEREAS , the City incurs substantial costs in providing this service; and
WHEREAS, the City strives to maintain and improve its level of Public Safety services.
NOW THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, that the Orangebur9CitY. zuncil sets the rate for fire
protection for annual suburban fire contract protection, effective' -1 , 2013, as follows:
SUBURBAN FIRE PROTECTION RATES
1. 1st house less than 900 square feet
All other miscellaneous structures on same lot
2. 1st house 900 square feet to 1499 square feet
All other miscellaneous structures on same lot
3. 1st house 1500 square feet to 2099 square feet
All other miscellaneous structures on same lot
4. 1st house 2100 square feet to 2699 square feet
All other miscellaneous structures on same lot
5. 1st house 2700 square feet to 3299 square feet
All other miscellaneous structures on same lot
6. 1st house 3300 square feet to 3899 square feet
All other miscellaneous structures on same lot
7. 1st house 3900 square feet and larger
All other miscellaneous structures on same lot
21. Single Wide Trailer or Mobile Home
22. Double Wide Trailer or Mobile Home
23. Mobile Home Park, Each Single Wide Trailer or Mobile Home
Mobile Home Park, Each Double Wide Trailer or Mobile Home
31. Apartments, Duplexes, Townhouses or Condominiums less than 900
Square feet
All other apartments
32. Apartments , Duplexes , Townhouses or Condominiums greater than 900
Square feet
All other apartment s
35. Hotels, Motels or Rooming Houses
36. Recycling Centers greater than two acres
41 . Vacant Lot or parcel not exceeding 5 acres
42. Vacant parcels larger than 5 acres
45. Business under 1500 Square Feet (Sq feet must be verified)
46. Business 1501 - 10,000 Square Feet (Sq feet must be verified)
47. Business 10,001-30,000 Square Feet (Sq feet must be verified)
48. Business 30,001 - 50,000 Square Feet (Sq feet must be verified)
49. Business 50,001 - 100,000 Square Feet (Sq feet must be verified)
53. Mall, Shopping Complex or Strip Malls (each unit), Sq. Feet must be verified
Under 1500 Square feet (each unit)
1500 Square feet or Larger (each unit)
54. Storage Warehouse- up to 3000 square feet (Sq ft must be verified)
61. Industrial, Manufacturing , Institutions under 100,000 Square Feet
62. Industrial, Manufacturing, Institutions or Businesses over 100,000 sq. feet
$ 94.50
$ 65.00
$140.00
$110.00
$150.00
$118.00
$159.00
$129.00
$169.00
$140.00
$178.50
$150.00
$189.00
$159.00
$100.00
$142.00
$100.00
$142.00
$100.00
$69.00
$140.00
$110.00
$525.00
$1,575.0J
$ 84.00
$128.00
$157.50
$315.00
$420.00
$630.00
$840.00
$157.50
$367.50
$173.00
$1,706.(X)
$2,567.00
63.
71.
74.
81.
82.
Hospitals
Gasoline Service Stations and/or Convenience Stores
Gasoline , Propane or other Fuel Bulk Plant
Dumpster Sites (per site), or Manned Convenience Stations (per site)
All Vehicle Fires
$8.54200
$420.00
$630.00
$157.50
$550.00
No contracts : When the Department of Public Safety responds to a residential call without a valid
contract, the minimum service charge will be $1,645.00 plus the price of the contract.
All institutions, commercial, manufacturing, or business calls will be billed for actual
costs with a minimum charge of $1 ,645.00 plus the cost of the fire contract . Fire
reports will not be issued until the service charg~aid in~
DONE AND RATIFIED BY Council duly assembled this /7 of r , 2013 .
~~4'.~
~
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
September 3, 2013 2289
Orangeburg City Council held its regularly scheduled meeting on Tuesday, September 3, 2013,
at 7:00P.M., in Council Chambers with Mayor Miller presiding.
PRESENT:
Paul A. Miller, Mayor
Charles B. Barnwell, Jr.
Bernard Haire
Charles W. Jernigan
L. Zimmerman Keitt
Sandra P. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
Mayor Miller recognized students from Orangeburg Wilkinson High School.
A motion was made by Councilmember Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to
approve the August 13, 2013, Special City Council Minutes as distributed. This was a 5-0-2 vote
as Councilmembers J emigan and Knotts abstained, as they were not present at the meeting.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to
approve the August 20, 2013, City Council Minutes. This motion was unanimously approved.
Councilmember Barnwell asked to address Council. He stated, "Last Friday, I was headed to the
Methodist Oaks. On Broughton Street, the train was across the tracks at the CSX crossing. The
train kept going back and forth and for twenty-five (25) minutes blocking traffic. I have looked
into the State Statute and a train cannot block the intersection for more than twelve (12)
minutes."
Councilmember Barnwell made a motion, seconded by Councilmember Stroman, to authorize
the City Administrator to write CSX and state that they are in violation of the State Statute and
they will be fined if this continues. This motion was unanimously approved.
Dr. Eugene Atkinson presented a slide show to City Council on the history of Orangeburg.
City Administrator Yow informed Council, "There will be no changes in the Ordinance
amending the Budget for the City for FY beginning October 1, 2012, and ending September 30,
2013, and we anticipate finishing the year with a balance of revenues over expenditures of
$117,748."
A motion was made by Councilmember Stroman, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, to approve
the Third Reading of an Ordinance amending the Budget for the City of Orangeburg, SC, for FY
beginning October 1, 2012, and ending September 30, 2013. This motion was unanimously
approved.
City Administrator Yow informed Council, "There will be no changes in the Budget Ordinance
to raise revenue and to adopt FY 2013-14 Budget for the City. It is a balanced budget with
General Fund revenues and expenditures totaling $17,479,750. For the record, there is not a tax
increase proposed in this Budget."
A motion was made by Councilmember Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to
approve the Third Reading of an Ordinance to raise revenue and adopt a Budget for the City of
Orangeburg, SC, for FY beginning October 1, 2013, and ending September 30, 2014. This
motion was unanimously approved.
Ms. Kristina Thomas, Director of Community of Character, accepted the September Character
Trait Proclamation, "Courage".
Page~290
Assistant City Administrator John Singh addressed Council in regards to the First Reading of an
Ordinance to amend the Zoning Ordinance ofthe City of Orangeburg, SC Chapter XXIV , Table
!-Schedule of permitted and conditional uses, Sector 71, to permit an indoor shooting range.
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, to
approve the First Reading of an Ordinance to amend the Zoning Ordinance of the City of
Orangeburg , SC, Chapter XXIV, Table !-Schedule of permitted and conditional uses, Sector 71,
to permit an indoor shooting range . This motion was unanimously approved .
Councilmember Barnwell stated, "I have visited shooting ranges in Columbia and they are
outstanding and safe, I recommend we pass this."
City Administrator Yow stated, "Prior to the next meeting for Second Reading of the Ordinance,
proposed special conditions or exceptions will be brought back to City Council.
Mayor Pro Tern Haire made a motion to accept that the City would bring back these conditions
and exceptions at the next meeting . This motion was seconded by Councilmember Keitt. This
motion was unanimously approved
Tommy Miller , DPU Director addressed Council in regards to the Third Reading of the Budget
for the Department of Public Utilities for FY beginning October 1, 2013, through September 30,
2014. He stated, "This Budget shows the income of $97,403,873 with expenses of $85,883,153
with a net profit of $11,520,720 before transfers. This shows a 4.4% return on equity. This
Budget does not require any rate increases at this time."
A motion was made by Councilmember Keitt , seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to
approve the third Reading of an Ordinance to adopt a Budget for the Department of Public
Utilities for the City of Orangeburg , SC, for FY beginning October 1, 2013, and ending
September 30, 2014. This was a 6-1, vote as Mayor Pro Tern Haire opposed .
A motion was made by Councilmember Stroman, seconded by Councilmember Keitt, to enter
into an Executive Session for (1) Economic Development-- location and expansion of industries
and (2) Contractual Matter -- Spec Building, Orangeburg County/City Industrial Park . This
motion was unanimously approved.
There being no further business , the meeting was adjourned.
\pfb
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
September 17, 2013
Orangeburg City Council held a Public Hearing on Tuesday, September 17, 2013, at 7:00
P.M., in Council Chambers with Mayor Miller presiding.
The purpose of the Public Hearing was to receive comments on an Ordinance to amend
the Zoning Ordinance of the City of Orangeburg, SC, Chapter XXIV, Article V. Table 1,
Sector 71, Arts, Entertainment and Recreation and Article X, Section 24-10.7,
Development Standards for conditional uses listed by Table 1, to permit indoor shooting
ranges as conditional uses.
Assistant City Administrator Singh addressed Council in regards to the Proposed change
to Zoning Ordinance and stated that the Ordinance has some fine tuning to be done prior
to Third Reading. Mayor Miller then asked for comments.
Mr. Abe Salama, 1495 Hillsboro Road, addressed Council. “I am retired from SC State
University and I understand and support wholeheartedly the activity and I feel that it
would be a deterrent for people breaking into the businesses in the downtown area. The
location is ideal and if classes were held during the day or night, this would be a
deterrent for burglars on Russell Street.”
Mayor Pro Tem Haire asked, “What type of firearms would be permitted in the facility?”
Attorney Ladson Beach responded, “It is designed for pistol shooting, there will be no
automatic weapons or rifles allowed. This is set up in the criteria.”
Mayor Pro Tem Haire asked, “In Section 2.02.5 in regards to no supervision for single
users, what does that mean?”
Attorney Beach responded, “If a law enforcement officer came in, he would not need any
supervision. A range control officer or safety officer would be present at all times
otherwise; our number one focus is safety.”
Mayor ProTem Haire asked, “In Section 2.03.1.7 concerning alcoholic beverages, is that
allowed?”
Attorney Beach responded, “There would be no alcoholic beverages allowed.”
City Administrator Yow asked Attorney Beach, “Since there is no alcoholic beverages
allowed, would you be open to have that added to the Ordinance? I think that would go
under the fine tuning that Assistant City Administrator Singh mentioned by adding it to
the body of the Ordinance.”
Attorney Beach agreed that anything that would add to the safety of the customers would
be welcomed.
Mayor Pro Tem Haire asked, “In Section 2.03.5.1, it states member or membership, is
this open to the public or is it just for members?”
Attorney Beach responded, “This is in regards to a 700 page manual, it would be a public
range for use of the public or groups, there is no membership requirement.”
Mayor Miller asked, “How many bays would it have?”
Page 2
Attorney Beach responded, “This is undetermined at this time, it could be up to ten, it
would depend on the length and the market.”
Mayor Miller asked, “What is the length of the lanes and what is to keep someone from
shooting in the next lane?”
Attorney Beach responded, “Each lane is seventy-five (75) feet at the most and each lane
is numbered along with the target. Each lane is surrounded by a barrier that is ten gauge
steel which is under the normal criteria as stated in the manual. It will prevent stray
shooting, but of course someone could shoot at another target. This will be monitored by
the range.”
Councilmember Jernigan asked, “Do you anticipate this being used for archery?”
Attorney Beach replied, “You could use it for archery, it would be more than adequate,
but it is made for firearms and it would be too robust for archery; but it could be used for
archery.”
Mr. David Farr, 256 Wiles Street, addressed Council, “How much insulation is in the
building? I live close by and I am worried about the noise.”
Attorney Beach replied, “It will be steel reinforced and it is self-contained and air tight,
you will be only able to hear very little sound, if any.”
Hearing no other comments, the Public Hearing was closed.
PRESENT:
Mayor Paul A. Miller
Bernard Haire
Charles B. Barnwell, Jr.
Charles W. Jernigan
Sandra P. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
ABSENT:
L. Zimmerman Keitt
A motion was made by Councilmember Knotts, seconded by Mayor Pro Tem Haire, to
approve the September 3, 2013, City Council Minutes as distributed. This motion was
unanimously approved.
Mr. Jerry Keitt, who was to be presented a Retiree Resolution, was unable to attend due
to illness. Mr. Buster Smith, Parks & Recreation Director, made comments concerning
Mr. Keitt.
Mr. Kevin Gantt of the SC Department of Transportation addressed Council in regards to
the Russell Street and John C. Calhoun (US 33 & 301) intersection project and the
Municipal agreement for the project.
He stated, “This project is something we have been working on for a few years. The
project was identified by the Lower Savannah Council of Governments for safety
reasons. They have funded it at an estimate for this project of $1,000,000 which includes
the design, survey, engineering and construction. We estimate that the preliminary
engineering to be $150,000, right of way fees are estimated at $350,000 and
$500,000 for construction.
Page 3
Our schedule is to complete the construction by the Fall of 2014. We have completed the
environmental paperwork. The Federal Highway Administration has approved the
categorical exclusion or class of the document. We have also conducted a public
information meeting on February 23, 2012. We had a robust turnout. We were able to do
that and review the comments and incorporate it into the design. Subsequent to that
meeting, we did a few small revisions to the design. Right now, we are ready to go to
Right-of- Way Division, which is purchasing any property for the project and we are
looking at twelve (12) months for that and looking for construction by next fall.
Our purpose for this intersection of improvement at US 33 and US 301, is basically
going through the parking lot of Maurice’s Barbeque. The scope of the project is to
improve the safety of the intersection. When it was identified, we had high incidents of
rear end accidents at the intersection. We will reconfigure that and create a stop position.
By doing that, the drivers would have to stop on Russell Street approaching on US
Highway 301. Right now, because of the geometry, people drive up, expect to merge and
they can’t and everyone behind them slams on the breaks and this creates unsafe
conditions. Left turn lanes would be added to Highway 301. I noticed that once you turn
onto Russell Street, the storage lane is not very deep, so when you have high volumes of
traffic in the morning, it backs up into the middle lane. So adding a turn lane on 301
won’t push back into traffic.”
A map was shown of the location and a map of the proposed improvements. Mr. Gantt
stated, “As you can see the traffic will turn at a 90 degree angle and stop and we think
this is much safer. By creating a stop condition, you are coming and look out to
oncoming traffic at a shorter angle. Now, at the existing condition, you have to pull up
and look back over your shoulder. The LSCOG has several intersection improvement
projects very similar to this all over the five or six county area. A lot of these older
intersections come in at an awkward angle. What we are learning through the accident
rates is, if you pull into a 90 degree angle and stop in either direction, it allows the driver
to make a decision on whether to go or not and reduces the rear end accidents.
The next map is a little closer view of the proposed improvements. In the public
information meeting, we found a monument and we wanted to avoid mitigation to the
environment. If you notice on the map, a blue line is on the picture from the edge of the
restaurant, we basically avoided the impact so that the monument wouldn’t have to be
relocated. We tweaked the drainage. These are the changes since we presented it to
Council last.
The municipal agreement is standard policy for the Department of Transportation. Any
project if we are in the City Limits of a jurisdiction, we have to come out with a
municipal agreement so we are within the limits and for you to be aware of what we are
doing so there is no conflict later on. There are certain legal items that we like to point
out in these agreements. I will go through some of the highlights of this agreement. First
of all, we are asking for consent for this project and to construct this project within your
jurisdiction. The agreement gives us the right to waive certain ordinances that you would
have for a contractor doing work, this would allow contractors that are approved by the
State to come in and bid and give us a better price for the job. Some municipalities
require a local business license and we would ask for those ordinances to be waived. We
would also request the utility relocation within the right-of-way; we would ask the City’s
cooperation to get those moved within a timely manner. Another point is that there is a
portion in the agreement that the City would take over the maintenance for the abandoned
section of the right-of-ways. With this particular project, the SDOT would not abandon
any right-of-way that we are going to have in the project. In the area hatched in pink, we
are going to mill up those areas and later when the bridges are replaced, we will widen
Page 4
that to an acceleration lane. That project has been identified, but there is no funding, so it
could be 10 to 15 years out. When that happens, the right-of-way will be in our
inventory. It would not make sense to sell it and buy it back. So, that would not
necessarily apply to this project.”
Mr. Gantt asked for questions.
Mayor Pro Tem Haire asked, “The amount is $1,000,000, so basically the entities you
would have to deal with is the City of Orangeburg and Bessinger’s, so would you be
paying the City for any property that would be used?”
Mr. Gantt replied, “The $1,000,000 is a budgeted amount that the LSCOG has identified.
The City would be just like anyone else that we would have to pay fair market value.”
Mayor Pro Tem Haire asked, “Would the money be available if DPU had to relocate
utilities, would DPU get paid?”
Mr. Gantt replied, “That is determined by prior rights, if the utility company is occupying
that space before the Department built the road there, then it would be deemed that they
would have prior rights and it would be at no cost for the utility company. Most of these
are within the state’s right-of-ways, so it would be at the cost of the owner. We would be
able to determine that once we move into the right of way phase. We send the plans to
our District Office, they locate the utilities and they send a set of plans to each utility
owner so that they can see where any conflicts are, so we work together to do that.”
Mayor Miller asked DPU Manager Miller, “What utilities would be affected by the Right
of Way Change?”
DPU Director Miller responded, “Having not seen the detailed plans, I cannot answer
accurately. But, looking at these plans, it looks like there are two gas mains on the Edisto
Garden’s side and one sewer main on 301 and there appears to be a water tap at
Bessinger’s. Without detailed drawings, I really cannot answer accurately.”
Mr. Gantt stated he would send DPU Director Miller those drawings.
Mayor Miller asked, “Have you thought about this before spending one million dollars on
this project. Has any thought been given to abandoning that stretch of road and letting
the traffic go out to Highway 301 by the Chamber by the stoplight to see if that would
interfere with traffic?”
Mr. Gantt replied, “Our traffic study was performed and we looked at that option and the
intersection at 301 by the Chamber and the way it comes in, that entire intersection would
have to be realigned. So, that was not a viable option and if we did that, it would be
considerably more than this proposal.”
Mayor Miller asked, “Who did your traffic study?”
Mr. Gantt replied, “Our traffic office performs those studies, I can provide those to you if
you would like to have them for consideration before the municipal agreement is signed.”
Mayor Miller stated, “If you blocked off from the Chamber down Highway 301 and
allowed no traffic on that small stretch, what kind of problem would it cause from a
traffic standpoint.”
Mr. Gantt stated, “I have been down here in the evenings and what you find is that the
traffic splits when it gets to that point. What would happen is that everyone would have
to make a left turn and move the traffic across the bridge and also there is other traffic
Page 5
going across or to the left. What we would have to do is to reconfigure the entire
intersection and allow turn lanes. Those improvements would be more costly and it may
cause the left turn to fail at the gardens because you are turning everyone left.”
Mayor Miller asked, “I believe you said we would be responsible for the maintenance, I
know you wanted to reserve some of the property for future use, what about the balance
of the abandoned property?”
Mr. Gantt replied, “The only piece that I see that would come into our inventory is a
stretch near the gardens. There may be another piece near the Maurice’s property that we
would deem as an uneconomic remainder and until the appraiser would look at his
property and see if that is not qualified to be used, then we will make an offer on that at
fair market value.”
Mayor Miller stated, “I think that portion is mainly parking now, but I don’t know about
the fall on that side of the building.”
Mr. Gantt said, “The building would be a take and the balance of the property would be a
discussion with Mr. Bessinger. We wouldn’t need the entire piece, but if it isn’t a benefit
to him, we have to offer him for the balance.”
Mayor Miller asked, “You are asking us to endorse the Resolution, what if we don’t
endorse it?”
Mr. Gantt replied, “The balance of the funding would go back to Lower Savannah for
another project. Their projects are already ranked so the money would just move to the
next one on the list which would probably be in another area.”
Mayor Miller asked, “If we table this until we get a better idea of the costs, is that going
to slow the project down?”
Mr. Gantt stated, “The projects that I manage, it is really not a requirement to get a
municipal agreement until we move into construction. I feel that it is better to come out
and speak to the municipality and get consent before we start purchasing right-of-way. It
would really be a train wreck if we started purchasing right-of-way and we didn’t see eye
to eye. In the properties that I manage, I like to come out and if we have conflict, we
haven’t spent money on right-of-way.”
Councilmember Barnwell asked, “Would there be a traffic control device there?”
Mr. Gantt replied, “The traffic study did not warrant that during the construction project.
What we did, is that once we pull the intersection into 90 degrees, it meets the geometric
qualifications to put a light there. If it meets the warrants in the future, a light could be
constructed there. Our engineer could put in signal poles there.”
Councilmember Barnwell stated, “I am concerned about someone running the stop sign.”
Mr. Gantt replied, “I would love for some money to fall out the sky and we could do the
bridge and the intersection, but everyone’s money is running thin these days. We would
like to see the ultimate. But for now, at the rate of the accidents, this would create a safer
condition.”
Councilmember Jernigan asked, “Coming south off of 301, where will the traffic go and
coming North also?”
Page 6
Mr. Gantt explained the improvements to the lanes of traffic and explained in detail on
the map, the bridge, lanes of traffic and the movement.
Councilmember Jernigan asked, “There is not going to be a traffic light here at this
intersection?”
Mr. Gantt responded, “Not at this time, but if it is warranted in the future, all that would
have to be done is install the stoplight poles.”
Mayor Miller asked, “Where are the accidents happening and how many have we had?”
Mr. Gantt replied, “They are happening at the end of Russell Street. I have sent the
information to City Administrator Yow and I did not bring copies tonight. The accidents
were very consistent rear end accidents. People cannot accelerate looking over their
shoulder and then they have to stop and people behind are not stopping and rear ending.”
Mayor Miller stated, “That is why I thought it would be a good idea to have people stop
at a stoplight and then turn left or go straight just as an experiment.”
Mr. Gantt stated, “The only thing about that is if we turn right here, the intersection does
not line up. You not only have to account for those cars, but also the cars going through
there already. That would have to be brought up to standards.”
Mayor Miller asked Chief Davis about the accidents at the intersection.
Chief Davis replied, “I do not have that information with me, but I do know there is a
frequency of accidents.”
Mr. Gantt stated, “We have gone back to when we identified the project and it was over
four or five years and the numbers are consistent.”
Councilmember Jernigan stated, “Until we have some figures and know what it is going
to cost the City, I am not ready to approve this. It looks like from the design, it is just
going to make a bad situation worse and that is my personal opinion. With no stop light
there, when those cars stop, they are going to have to make a left hand turn. That is not
helping the situation at all. It is a trade off.”
Mr. Gantt responded, “Our purpose was to stop the rear end accidents. We fulfilled the
purpose and need with this design. To let it sit there and do nothing, we feel like from
our study that this is our best fix to the project.”
Mayor Miller asked if we could table this until we received more information.
Councilmember Jernigan made a motion to table this item until we received more
information. This motion was seconded by Councilmember Barnwell and unanimously
approved.
Councilmember Stroman asked, “Why can’t we try the barricades for thirty days?”
Mr. Gantt responded, “We are afraid to put extra traffic on that intersection because we
know what would happen.”
Councilmember Stroman asked, “Try it for a week and take that money and fix other
roads in the City.”
Page 7
Mr. Gantt stated, “There are no professional engineers that would reroute the traffic in the
other direction.”
Mayor Miller thanked Mr. Gantt for answering the questions and will bring this item
back to a future meeting.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tem Haire, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell,
to approve the Second Reading of an Ordinance to amend the Zoning Ordinance of the
City of Orangeburg SC, Chapter XXIV, Article V. Table 1, Sector 71, Arts,
Entertainment and Recreation and Article X. Section 24-10.7, Development Standards for
conditional uses listed by Table 1, to permit indoor shooting ranges as conditional uses.
This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tem Haire, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to
approve a Resolution for City Council to set Suburban Fire Protection Rates as
authorized under Section 18-4.2 of the Code of Ordinances of the City of Orangeburg.
The 5% increase was covered in the Fiscal Year 2013-14 Budget presentation and Public
Hearing. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Knotts,
to approve the First Reading of an Ordinance to adopt Nationally Recognized Codes and
Standards pursuant to South Carolina Code Section 6-9-10 and Section 6-9-60 and to
repeal Sections 13-5.2, 13-5.3 and 13-5.4 of the Code of Ordinances of the City of
Orangeburg. This motion was unanimously approved.
There were no utility matters brought before Council.
Mayor Miller stated, “First of all I would like to thank City staff for all their cooperation
you have given me in the past eighteen years as a Councilmember and Mayor. I want to
thank the Department of Public Utilities for all the cooperation that was given to me by
that Department.
I just want to say that over the past eighteeen years, Council has done many projects that
we should be proud of. They are too numerous to name. I am proud of the streetscape
that we have done at this point, which actually got started at the renovation of the
downtown lot on the corner of Middleton and Russell Streets. It was a vacant lot where
the Dime Store burned down, we were able to get about twenty entities to help with the
revitalization of that lot, now known as the DORA Park. What has been interesting to me
is that there has been no destruction of that property, it is respected. That was kind of the
beginning of the streetscape. I was actually a part of the birth of DORA coming from the
Chamber of Commerce Board.
We have built the Veteran’s Park near the Chamber of Commerce which has been a long
needed facility for our veteran’s who had served in the armed forces and paid the
ultimate sacrifice. This building that we are in, which was once a fire station and the
courtyard outside is now beautiful. I am proud of what Public Safety has accomplished.
The moving of Public Safety Headquarters downtown was a vision of my predecessor
Martin Cheatham and this Council carried forth on it. Public Safety worked diligently to
decrease the ISO rating from a 5 to a 3 which saves citizens a tremendous amount of
money on their insurance premiums and saves lives and property. We are only one of
2,000 in the US that can boast of an ISO of 3. The accreditation of Public Safety is hard
but reaccreditation is even harder and we have done that three times. We have had
success with economic development and I point out the cooperation between the City and
County with the development of the City/County Industrial Park and today, there has
been over 1,000 new jobs created in that Industrial Park. The City was recognized by the
Municipal Association of South Carolina for the cooperation between the City and
County on that project. It is still in play and the Park has grown. That started with one
Page 8
80,000 square foot building between the City and County for a million dollars and our
first tenant was Allied Air and today there are over five hundred people there and have
over a million square feet. Some things that are on the horizon that you have agreed to is
the City Gym and we are waiting until we get the last penny in when we build it on
Broughton Street backing up to Mirmow Field. The plans are ready to go out for bid as
soon as we get the penny in then we will be able to get that constructed. I have been
working on something with Cox Industries for a long period of time and I think it is ready
to come back to Council for approval. I talked to Cox CEO Mike Johnson and he stated I
can divulge that information and we shall have a corporate headquarters downtown on
Russell Street. One of the latest things that should be happening soon is adding a parking
lot for our disabled veterans to visit the Memorial and that should be completed this fall.
I want to say, let’s continue to make it a great day in Orangeburg and I wish the Mayor
Elect and the citizens of Orangeburg good luck. Thank you for letting me serve as your
Mayor.”
Councilmember Jernigan asked for a moment of personal privilege. He stated, “It’s been
a long sixteen years since I started on Council and the whole time you have been one of
the best ambassadors to Orangeburg that we have had. You not only have been an
ambassador to Orangeburg, but to the entire state. Being President of the Municipal
Association put Orangeburg in the forefront that normally would not have been. All of
the projects that you have mentioned under your leadership are projects that have
furthered Orangeburg. It has been a pleasure working with you over these sixteen years,
you and I have not always agreed on everything, but you and I have been friends for over
forty years and friends may not always agree on everything. It has been a pleasure
working with you and I will also say that I will pledge my support to the Mayor Elect and
will work with him as I have worked with you for the betterment of Orangeburg and the
citizens of Orangeburg and I wish you nothing but the best in the future. I won’t be
surprised if we don’t’ hear from you down the road. God Bless you in your endeavors.”
A motion was made by Councilmember Stroman, seconded by Councilmember Jernigan,
to adjourn. This motion was unanimously approved.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
Respectfully submitted,
Carrie W. Johnson
City Clerk
/pfb
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
October 1, 2013
The Oaths of Office for Orangeburg City Council and Mayor were administered in stJ.~s?r9
Auditorium on Tuesday, October 1, 2013, at 7:00P.M., due to a large crowd attending. Mayor
Pro Tern Haire called the meeting to order. An invocation was given by Reverend Haynes T.
Gainey Jr., and the National Anthem was sung by Ms. Kristen Jamison . The Oaths of office were
administered by Judge Pandora Jones Glover to, Councilmember Charles B. Barnwell, Jr.,
Councilmember L. Zimmerman Keitt, Councilmember Richard F. Stroman and Mayor Michael
C. Butler.
The regularly scheduled meeting was immediately following in the Council Chamber Building
(next door) with Mayor Butler presiding. An invocation was given by Roger Brant, City Service
Department Director.
PRES ENT:
Michael C. Butler, Mayor
Charles B. Barnwell, Jr.
Bernard Haire
Charles W. Jernigan
L. Zimmerman Keitt
Sandra P. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
Councilmember Barnwell nominated Councilmember Charles Jernigan to serve as Mayor Pro
Tern. Councilmember Haire made a motion that the nominations be closed and Councilmember
Jernigan be elected to serve as Mayor Pro Tern. This motion was seconded by Councilmember
Keitt and unanimously approved .
A motion was made by Councilmember Stroman, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to
approve the September 17, 2013, City Council Minutes. This was a 5-0-2 vote as Mayor Butler
(newly elected Mayor) and Councilmember Keitt abstained as they were not present at the last
meeting.
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Jernigan, to
approve the Third Reading of an Ordinance to amend the Zoning Ordinance of the City of
Orangeburg, SC, Chapter XXIV, Article V, Table 1, Sector 71 , Arts, Entertainment and
Recreation, and Article X, Section 24-10 .7, Development Standards for conditional uses listed by
Table 1, to permit indoor shooting ranges as conditional uses. This motion was unanimously
approved.
Councilmember Barnwell asked if there were any changes. Assistant City Administrator Singh
replied none other than what was asked for previously.
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Councilmember Keitt, to approve
the Second Reading of an Ordinanc e to adopt Nationally Recognize d Codes and Standards
pursuant to South Carolina Code Section 6-9-10 and Section 6-9-60 and to repeal Sections 13-
5.2, 13-5.3 and 13-5.4 of the Code of Ordinances of the City of Orangeburg. This motion was
unanimously approved.
There were no utility matters brought before Council; however , Department of Public Utilities
Manager Tommy Miller presented Councilmember Bernard Haire with a twenty-five (25) year
servtce pm.
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Councilmember Keitt, to adjourn.
This motion was unanimous ly approved.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
RESOLUTION
A RESOLUTION FOR THE CITY OF ORANGEBURG, DEPARTMENT OF
PUBLIC UTILITIES TO ENTER INTO CONTRACT WITH N. HARRIS
COMPUTER CORPORATION IN THE AMOUNT $5,993,537.00 FOR THE
PURCHASE AND IMPLEMENTATION OF UTILITY SOFTWARE.
WHEREAS , the Department of Public Utilities of the City of Orangeburg , South Carolina.
received a final proposal on August 19, 2013 for the purchase of utility
software; and
WHEREAS , the low responsive, responsible proposal for this work was submitted by N.
Harris Computer Corporation in the amount of $5,993,537.00;
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED , by the Council of the City of Orangeburg duly
assembled and by authority of the same, that 0. Thomas Miller, Jr., Manager of the
Department of Public Utilities is hereby authorized to accept after all contract documents have
been approved by the City Attorney the low responsive , responsible proposal of N. Harris
Computer Corporation in the amount of$5 .993.537.00; and
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED , that 0. Thomas Miller, Jr., Manager of the Department of
Public Utilities. is authorized and he is hereby directed to execute the contract documents in
said amount and as approved by legal counsel with N. Harris Computer Corporation on behalf
of the Department of Public Utilities of the City of Orangeburg.
RESOLVED BY City Council duly assembled this ~ day of October, 2013.
ATTEST :
1J f~ j~
'c iYYC LERK
RESOLUTION
A RESOLUTION SUPPORTING RESIDENTIAL AND MULTI-UNIT HOUSING
FOR THE CITY OF ORANGEBURG .
WHEREAS , the City of Orangeburg adopted its most recent Comprehensive Plan which
included the required Housing Element on May 16, 2006, and
WHEREAS , a goal of said Element was to increase the supply of affordable housing and
assisted housing, and
WHEREAS , in achieving said goal the Element recommended that such housing be located
on "scattered sites" as opposed to "project settings", that such be designed for compatibility
for the purpose of blending with proposed surroundings and that such housing be
geographically dispersed to provide for "locational preference", and
WHEREAS , said Element recommended that the City continue participation in various
federal and state housing assistance programs as a means of increasing the supply of
affordable housing, and
WHEREAS , by City Ordinance No. 2008-17 dated December 16, 2008 the below described
property was annexed into the corporate limits of the City of Orangeburg and zoned as A-2,
Multi-Unit , Residential, along with other properties zoned A-1, Single-Unit Residential and
0-1, Office Institutional - Residential, and
WHEREAS, said annexation and zoning were in furtherance of the Housing Element of the
above mentioned Comprehensive Plan.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED , by the Council of the City of Orangeburg duly
assembled that the annexation of the below described property, the zoning of said property as
A-2, Multi-Unit, Residential and the development of said property with federal and/or state
housing assistance is in furtherance of the goal of the Housing Element of the Comprehensive
Plan of the City of Orangeburg.
DESCRIPTION OF PROPERTY:
All that certain piece, parcel or tract of land with buildings and other improvements thereon,
situate, lying and being in Orange Township, Consolidated School District 5, County of
Orangeburg, State of South Carolina, containing 7.27 acres and being set forth and shown on a
Topographic Survey thereof prepared for Steve Patel by Edisto Engineers and Surveyors, Inc.,
dated December 18, 2007 and recorded in the Office of the Register of Deeds for the County
of Orangeburg, State of South Carolina in Cabinet D95 at page 2 and having the following
boundaries and measurements: North by property of Julia S. Wannamaker 226.98 feet;
Northeast by property of Barbara K. Moorer 806.07 feet; East by property of American Tower
Systems 185.4 feet, 12 feet and 228.50 feet; South by property of Glenfield Limited
Partnership 483.60 feet and 172.94 feet; and West by property of Glenfield Limited
Partnership 288.28 feet, the right of way of Columbia Road (US Route 21) and measuring
thereon a total distance o£399.32 feet and property of Julia S. Wannamaker 89 feet.
Being the same property conveyed to Julia S. Wannamaker by Deed of Distribution of the
Estate of Dewitt H. Wannamaker, Sr., dated February 25, 2000 and recorded in said Office of
the Register of Deeds in Deed Book 799 at page 78.
TMS No.: 0174-09-03-012
RESOLVED BY City Coun cil duly assembled this 5th day of November , 20 13.
1Jj~ d~·~
~~
/ilfi~
~'L23. ~~
.··zA(~~ ~
L.l\(EMBERS O[c()UN
C\Documcnts and SenmgsVames F Walsh MAIN\Desktop\Beth's Documents\City ofO'burg\Rcsolullons\City Housmg Element doc
City Council Minutes
October 15, 2013
2301
Orangeburg City Council held its regularly scheduled meeting on Tuesday, October 15, 2013, at
7:00P.M ., with Mayor Butler presiding. An invocation was given by Mayor Pro Tern Jernigan.
PRESENT:
Michael C. Butler, Mayor
Charles B. Barnwell, Jr.
Bernard Haire
Charles W. Jernigan
L. Zimmerman Keitt
Sandra P. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
Mayor Butler gave recognition to several ladies in the audience from Orangeburg County
Leadership and thanked them for attending .
A motion was made by Councilmember Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Stroman, to approve
the October 1, 2013, City Council Minutes as distributed . This motion was unanimously
approved.
Mayor Butler asked Thomas Washington, DPU Retiree, and his family along with DPU Manager
Tommy Miller to come forward. Mr. Washington was presented with a Retiree Resolution and a
gold watch for his twenty-seven years, ten months and twenty-three days of service to the
Department of Public Utilities. DPU Manger Miller thanked Mr. Washington for his many years
of service.
Mayor Bulter asked for Ms. Norma Murdaugh and Ms. Evelyn Hubbard to come forward to
speak in reference to Goff A venue Parking.
Ms. Murdaugh addressed Council stating , "I am a third generation owner of property on Goff
Avenue in Orangeburg SC. Having said that, I am deeply upset with the decision to limit the
parking spaces in front of my home without any consideration to the person or persons residing
on that street. There was not a Public Hearing on this matter. It is as though we do not exist.
The decision was made and we are supposed to just adjust to the situation, like it or not. Well,
we are not going to roll over and play dead and pretend that we like what has happened to our
street because we don't. Things are to be done in order, which was not the case in this matter.
This is not how business is carried out in the City of Orangeburg . If changes are being made a
Public Hearing should be held and all persons involved should state their opinion. Not so in this
matter. I am here to say that I would like to have the parking restored on Goff A venue down to
Clark Street so that I don't have to park in my back yard. Thank you."
Ms. Evelyn Hubbard stated, "I ditto Norma 's concerns. She has been a Goff Avenue resident for
30+ years and at present we have no parking spaces, maybe one or two, and those are being
taken by the Univers ity 's faculty and students. Now we have no space for our guest or visitors.
I would like to get some explanation as to why because yellow lines were painted in the space all
the way down to Claflin campus. I think we should have gotten some sort of explanation as to
why this happened."
PageZ302
Mayor Bulter thanked the ladies for their concern and stated that the City wanted to be good
neighbors.
Mayor Pro Tern Jernigan asked if anyone had heard anything about it. He also asked if anyone
on Council knew about it.
Councilmember Haire stated, "I heard about it when Ms. Murdaugh called to complain about
the spaces and painting ofthe curbs. This is not the first time this sort of thing has happened. At
least three to four years ago there were speed bumps put in the middle of Goff Avenue and it did
not come through Council. We knew nothing about it until the speed bumps were placed on
Goff A venue and this is another example of when the public is not informed about what is
happening. I had a meeting with one of the representatives of the University and the University
informed me that because of safety reasons an easement was acquired and the City was asked to
paint the curbings. At present there are students that park on Oak Street between US 601 and
College Street so where is the concern as it relates to safety for these students . These students
have to cross US 601. There are students that park on Oak Street that have to cross Boulevard
and US 601 and there is no kind of concern expressed for these students that I can see. In talking
with an official, I was told they were in contact with Ms. Murdaugh and she was informed she
could use the parking lot across the street near her housing. It does not only affect the residents,
South Carolina State University has the 1890 building that it is affected. You have the ROTC
building that is being affected. You also have South Carolina State University Police Department
that is affected by this. No one can park from 601 down to Clark Street. This has put a burden
on the residents and no one seems to care. The analogy that was given to me by the
representative of the University is that these spaces do not belong to the residents. If we, for
safety reasons, eliminate all the parking spaces on Russell Street from Middleton to Broughton
Streets because people have to cross the street for safety reasons, then we will have traffic go
back down from Middleton Street to Elliott Street and this will impact those businesses on
Russell Street from Middleton to Elliott Streets. The same analogy that is used for this can also
be used to eliminate parking downtown for safety reasons if that be the case. I am just disturbed
that we are not being informed or not made aware of what is going on and it seems as if we don 't
matter as Ms. Hubbard and others have stated. I do not think that is the way it should be. If the
institution wants to do something then I propose that one side of Goff A venue be yellow lined.
If you can't get the whole loaf why not half a loaf. I have not gotten any response but think it
was negative to that position. So we are asking for the community to be considered when
decisions are being made, don't just ram it down someone's throat and then inform them later as
to what is going on. That is not the proper way to handle it. If the institution wants to fix the
situation then let the ones that have been affected by the elimination of those spaces park in that
parking lot without any fee, ifthe goal is not to raise any additional monies. This is a suggestion.
I hope that we as Council would send a strong message that the City needs to be considered, be a
part of these decisions and the residents need to be a part of the decisions and we will not tolerate
not being involved in the future. I think the Mayor mentioned that there will be a meeting to
resolve this. I hope that we can resolve this and I hope that individuals don't plan to gloss over
this because it is impacting more than just one entity, it is impacting the commu nity."
Mayor Pro Tern Jernigan asked a question of City Administrator Yow . ''I'm kind of confused,
are we not suppose to be involved in a decision like this, we are left out of the loop?"
Page3
City Attorney Walsh stated that the municipality controls all parking on streets anZJJ}l.ys
within the City. The authority to govern parking is in the hands of City Council."
Mayor Pro Tern Jernigan asked if they should have consulted us for our consideration and
consent before they talked with the Department of Transportation."
City Attorney Walsh stated, "By statue we have the authority."
Mayor Pro Tern Jernigan stated, I don't think that they consulted us and that Councilmember
Haire has a good point. We need to make sure this is not left undone or swept under the rug.
Mayor Bulter stated, "We are asking all parties impacted by this be brought to the table and
informed as to a resolution for the situation."
Mayor Pro Tern Jernigan stated, "Once these parties have met then it needs to come back to
Council.
Councilmember Barnwell asked, "Who got the encroachment and who painted the lines."
City Administrator Yow stated, "The City painted the lines because we were asked to by the
University. The City thought the encroachment gave the University the authority to paint off the
spaces."
Councilmember Barnwell stated he didn't think they needed a meeting, but just put the spaces
back like they were."
City Administrator Yow stated that if the City Attorney advises Council that we can paint back
the spaces, we will with Council's direction."
Mayor Pro Tern Jernigan stated, "I agreed with Councilmember Haire and they needed to let the
University know that is not the way things are handled in Orangeburg. Council is here to
represent the citizens of Orangeburg and if they are left out of the loop that doesn't happen."
Councilmember Barnwell made a motion to paint over and put the parking spaces back on Goff
A venue as they were and Councilmember Haire seconded the motion. This was a 4-2-1 vote, as
Councilmember Knotts recused, Mayor Butler and Councilmember Keitt abstained.
Assistant City Administrator Singh presented the Third Reading of an Ordinance to adopt
Nationally Recognized Codes and Standards pursuant to SC Code Section 6-9-10 and Section 6-
9-60 and to repeal Sections 13-5.2, 13-5.3 and 13-5.4 of the Code of Ordinances ofthe City of
Orangeburg, SC. He stated, "This is to bring our codes up to the standard codes as stated by the
State of South Carolina.
Councilmember Knotts asked if there were any changes from last reading and Assistant City
Administrator Singh, replied no.
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to
approve the Third Reading of an Ordinance to adopt Nationally Recognized Codes and
Standards pursuant to SC Code Section 6-9-10 and Section 6-9-60 and to repeal Sections 13-5.2,
Page4
13-20043 -5.4 of the Code of Ordinances of the City of Orangeburg , SC. This motion was
unanimously approved.
Ms. Dede Cook, Executive Director of the Chamber of Commerce, accepted the Character Trait
Proclamation for October 2013, "Fairness".
Chief Wendell Davis presented information on a DUI Special Enforcement Grant. He stated,
"The City has had this grant for a number of years. This is a contin uation of the grant from last
year. We have purchased equipment with the previous grant and this grant is primarily used for
salaries and fringes . There will be slight equipment for presentation that will be purchased. This
is a 100% grant with no match .
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Councilmember Stroman, to approve
authorization for City Administrator Yow to accept the SC Department of Public Safety DUI
Special Enforcement Grant in the amount of $61,526 with no local match. This motion was
unanimously approved.
Chief Davis presented information on the 151 Judicial Circuit Law Enforcement Grant. He
stated, "This grant that supports the 1st Judicial Circuit, and is made up of Orangeburg,
Dorchester and Calhoun counties . We are the host agency for the circuit which means we
coordinate efforts for highway safety by awarding many small grants from the $28,000. We get
$7,000 of the $28,000 for equipment and highway safety. It is a 100% grant with no match."
Councilmember Barnwell asked what is the purpose of the grant?
Chief Davis stated, "Orangeburg County has been identified as one of the counties with the
highest alcohol related accidents . The grants purpose is two-fold, to try to deter DUI driving, to
increase highway safety and to increase seatbelt usage. The State separates the grants it has
between the sixteen different circuits in the state. Because of participation in this grant we are
eligible for other things. For example, at the latest meeting we won an additional radar unit
which will be used to promote safety. If you meet all the paramet ers and go to the yearly
meeting, we are eligible to secure additiona l vehicles. So there is an incentive program attached
to this grant"
Councilmember Knotts asked, "Is there any type of educational advertising that went along with
this grant."
Chief Davis stated, "There was a huge component of it and they try to have news releases ."
Mayor Pro Tern Jernigan asked, "What type of equipment was purchased from these grants."
Chief Davis stated, "The black DUI vehicles, along with the equipment inside, were purchased
from the grant and countl ess other equipment. "
A motion as made by Councilmember Stroman, seconded by Councilm ember Keitt, to authorize
City Administrator Yow to accept the SC Departm ent of Public Safety 1st
Judicial Circuit Law Enforcement Network Grant in the amount of $28,000 . This motion was
unanimously approved.
Page 5
There were no matters pertaining to the Department of Public Utilities. 2305
A motion was made by Councilmember Stroman, seconded by Councilmember Keitt, to enter
into an Executive Session for contractual matters, (1) Sale and purchase of real property at 1099
Russell Street by Cox Industries, (2) Blue Cross Blue Shield, Near Site Clinic Administration
and (3) Department of Public Utilities, Computer Software from N. Harris Computer
Corporation. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Jernigan, for
Council to return back into Open Session. This motion was unanimously approved.
Council returned to Open Session.
DPU Manager Miller stated, "Two years ago DPU started investigating new software. This is
the software that literally runs the entire Department as far as billing, accounting, assets and
customer service. The current software is over nineteen years old and we all know how
computers and software changes over the years. This new software will allow us to do more
things than we can do now. After many months we have narrowed the choice down toN. Harris
Computer Corporation in the amount of $5,993 ,537. This company has software that is used all
over the United States and all over North America.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Jernigan, seconded by Councilmember Keitt, to approve
a Resolution for the City of Orangeburg, Department of Public Utilities to enter into a contract
with N. Harris Computer Corporation in the amount of $5,993,537 for the purchase and
implementation of utility software. This motion was tmanimously approved.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
Respectfully submitted,
tl~ ~~-~
Duane Tarrant
Assistant City Clerk
/pfb
2306 CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
November 5, 2013
Orangeburg City Council held its regularly scheduled meeting on Tuesday, November 5,
2013, at 7:00P.M., with Mayor Butler presiding. An invocation was given by Dr. Hill
from Claflin University
PRESENT:
Michael C. Butler, Mayor
Charles B. Barnwell, Jr.
Bernard Haire
Charles W. Jernigan
L. Zimmerman Keitt
Sandra P. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
A motion was made by Councilmember Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Stroman, to
approve the October 15, 2013, City Council Minutes as distributed. This motion was
unanimously approved.
Mr. Jerry Hannah of 591 Summers Avenue addressed Council. He stated, "Thank you
for allowing me the opportunity to speak to you tonight on District #3. This District runs
from Green Street and the Sunnyside section all the way up to Ellis Avenue turns and
goes down Chestnut and Columbia Road. Orangeburg is on the Right Track. The
Department of Public Utilities is one of the best in the state. You tum the website on and
it's there. Fire and Police give great protection. The City is clean and the tax rate is one
of the best you can get. The citizens in District #3 have issues just like everyone else. If
you look in all directions in District #3, you have grocery stores, oriental restaurants,
pharmacies and the old mall is booming. There are so many dentist offices in that area, it
is a blessing. If you take a ride on the City Transit and look, there are homeless people in
this District. Some may say they are not sleeping in the streets. Some can be homeless
within four walls, some rent and some own. I have been asked, where do you present
yourself? You come before City Council. I asked them who are some of the police
officers or firemen and they cannot name any. No one stops to talk or look. Many of
them can name those on the Sheriffs Office. Wi-Fi is here. District #3 is part of this
community, we are on the right track, but sometimes we can't stay on the same track."
City Administrator Yow addressed Council and introduced Mr. Bill Owen, Orangeburg
Green Affordable Housing Development, and stated that he was here before Council for
an endorsement of a project for a 56 unit housing on property at 2574 Columbia Road.
Council did endorse that project. That was last year's Federal Tax Credit grant
application and it was not approved by State Housing and Finance and Council's
endorsement does not carry over to this year. He is here to present it to Council again.
Mr. Owen stated, "We did submit our application in March this year. Across the state,
there were sixty-five applications. It is a competitive business that we are in, the
notifications came out in August and there were eighteen approved across the state. Our
application had a perfect score. Unfortunate ly, it lost out on the fifth tie breaker
concerning a desire of development in a revitalization area. We did not have that and we
did not get the award. This is a new year. We have to do a new market study,
environmenta l study and new drawings and engineering work. We believe in
Orangeburg and our market study stated last year that there is a significan t need for
affordable housing that target up to 60% of the County median income. According to the
estimate, it would take about six to nine months to completely lease the development. It
is a fifty- six unit development which is eight (8) one bedroom units, thirty two (32) two
bedroom units with two bath units and sixteen (16) three bedroom units with two bath
units. It is a garden style development with a separate building for onsite managem ent
and a community center. The development is comprised of 75% brick and hardiplank.
Page 2
This development would be adjacent to Glenfield Apartments. There are washers,l:ti:t 11?
dryers available as well as hook-ups in the units. Currently, we have sixty (60) tax cre'dir
investments in North and South Carolina. We own all of our units and have been in
business since 1979. Every year, the application is tweaked some. One of the things that
the application needs is services near the development. Today, I have been out to the
malls, Historical Society and the South Carolina State University Museum and
Planetarium. We will incorporate all of this in our application. I am asking you for two
things. I am asking for a Resolution to support this area, it is not development specific.
Since this area was annexed and what the Resolution indicates is that this area will
support the housing need part of the consolidated plan for mixed use residential for single
and multi-family. The second is a letter of endorsement of support, specifically for the
development as you, the officials, supporting our application . That will help us in tie
breaker #4 instead of #8 last year."
Mayor Butler asked, "How will this affect Glenfield apartments?"
Mr. Owen replied , "We would be adjacent to them. They target a different tenant. Our
tenants can earn up to 60% of the median income and Glenfield Apartments is federally
subsidized. Their tenants are a different population . One of things we have to do is
perform a new market study by a third party. This study looks at all the existing tax
credit developments in the City and looks at market rate development and subsidized
apartments. If the study was not as good as I said it was, we would not funded. They
will not permit a new development to come in at the expense to the existing development.
We just did one that is only seven to eight months old. This application will be submitted
in March, so we will do one again in February."
Councilmember Barnwell asked, "Is Mr. Marion Moore a partner in this?"
Mr. Owen replied, "He is just my real estate contact in this venture. He is representing us
with the property owners. He is not a partner. He was the contact last time also. When I
was looking for areas to consider , I went online and contacted him as to what I was
looking for."
Mayor Pro Tern Jernigan asked Mr. Owen to show the audience the Development and
other developments in the state. Mr. Owen showed the audience displays of the proposed
properties and others they own.
Councilmember Haire made a motion to approve the Resolution and send a letter of
endorsement for the Development at 2574 Columbia Road, seconded by Councilmember
Barnwell. This motion was unanimously approved.
Ms. Katrina Thomas, Executive Director ofthe Community of Character, accepted the
November 2013, Proclamation, "Compassion".
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to
approve the Resolution supporting Residential and Multi-Unit Housing for the City of
Orangeburg and to send a letter of Endorsement. This motion as unanimously approved .
Councilmember Haire made a motion, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to
approve the First Reading of an Ordinance amending Section 5-29, Titled "Weapons and
Firearms" of the Code of Ordinances for the City of Orangeburg. This motion was
unanimousl y approved.
City Administrator Yow stated, "The Ordinance is for the exchange of properties on
comer of Broughton and Windsor Streets and Russell Street and $75,000 for the First
Citizens Bank building. The Department of Public Utilities and the City purchased the
building in September of 2009 and it did have a tenant in the building who completed
their lease and found another property after their lease was up. DPU used it for storage,
Page3
but have addressed that need in another manner. We have been talking with Cox
JptJ:llsa~bout the trade of properties. We would be receiving property near the City
~ing· rot known as the Mural Building on Russell Street and we would also receive
2.87 acres next to this bank building across from DPU, also plus $75,000 in cash
consideration. The community will be getting both properties up to code by removing
those buildings on that property. We will be receiving two improved properties plus the
cash. We would also be receiving a long standing corporation 's headquarter s into our
downtown. When we make the exchange, Cox will be moving their headquarters into
this bank building. We will not be closing on these properties until the other two
properties are brought within code. We have been working on this about a year and we
appreciate your patience."
Councilmember Stroman asked, "Wasn't something in the agreement that we would get
first refusal if they decided to sell it?"
City Administrator Yow responded, "That is the plans."
City Attorney Walsh stated, "That is not in the Ordinance, it has not been finalized."
Mayor Pro Tern Jernigan asked, "When will they take occupancy?"
City Administrator Yow replied, "It would be after the first of the year. All the buildings
would have to be removed from the other two properties . I believe they are getting a
contractor to remove those buildings in November and December."
Councilmember Barnwell asked, "What about asbestos?"
City Administrator Yow replied, "That is a concern under their contractor doing the
work. The City will receive the property code compliant."
A motion was made by Councilmember Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell ,
to approve the First Reading of an Ordinance to exchange the First Citizens Bank
Building for properties located on Broughton and Windsor Streets and the amount of
$75,000. This motion was unanimously approved.
There were no utility matters brought before Council.
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Keitt, to
enter into an Executive Session for a legal and contractual matter concerning the
Department of Public Utilities Software Implementation Contract- Whitlock Consulting,
LLC. This motion was unanimously approved.
Council went into Executive Session.
A motion was made by Councilmember Knotts, seconded by Councilmember Haire, to
return to Open Session. This motion was unanimously approved.
Council returned to Open Session.
Mayor Butler stated that Council would not be taking any action on Item 10, Department
of Public Utilities Software Implementation Contract - Whitlock Consulting, LLC.
A motion as made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Councilmember Keitt, to
adjourn. This motion was unanimously approved.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned .
RESOLUTION
A RESOLUTION FOR THE CITY OF ORANGEBURG, DEPARTMENT OF
PUBLIC UTILITIES TO ENTER INTO CONTRACT WITH WHITLOCK
CONSULTING GROUP IN THE AMOUNT OF NOT TO EXCEED $1,332,800.00 FOR
ASSISTANCE WITH IMPLEMENTATION OF UTILITY SOFTWARE.
WHEREAS, the Department of Public Utilities of the City of Orangeburg, South Carolina ,
received a final proposal on September 6, 2013 for implementation assistance service; and
WHEREAS , the low responsive , responsible proposal for this work was submitted by
Whitlock Consulting Group in the amount of $1 ,332,800 .00;
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, by Council of the City of Orangeburg duly
assembled and by authority of the same, that 0. Thomas Miller , Jr., Manager of the
Department of Public Utilities is hereby authorized to accept after all contract document s have
been approved by the City Attorney the low responsive, responsib le proposal of Whitlock
Consulting Group in an amount not exceeding $1,332,800.00; and
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that 0 . Thoma s Miller, Jr., Manager of the Department of
Public Utilities, is authorized and he is hereby directed to execute the contract documents in
said amount and as approved by legal counsel with Whitlock Consulting Group on behalf of
the Departm ent ofPub lic Utilities ofthe City ofOrange~j·
RESOLVED BY City Council duly assembled this 3 day of December, 2013 .
l'l!l.i~ ('. 134d'~ -, ,- . -
MAYOR - ' '"" , _
~\ '--""-""'--~ ~ 'J IY'I\v......_,
i .;7
c----~ ~ = r-Q- ~ /
------- ~,--- . . 0 ~..-./:;!?'
·, di. ,, rfu,£t '-flt;t;l {j)
'--
MEMB ERS OF COUNCIL
RESOLUTION
WHEREAS , the City of Orangeburg , South Carolina desires to increase economic
competitiveness and stimulate private investment by revitalizing the
downtown area of the City of Orangeburg ; and,
WHEREAS, the City of Orangeburg, South Carolina is applying for a Community
Development Block Grant for streetscape improvements in the
downtown area of the City of Orangeburg ; and,
WHEREAS, the City of Orangeburg , South Carolina must supply matching funds for
a Community Development Block Grant application.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, that the Mayor and City Council of the City
of Orangeburg, South Carolina , in Council duly assembled, hereby has committed
$309,667 in matching funds .
PASSED BY the City Council of the City of Orangeburg, South Carolina, on this 3rd
day of December, 2013.
!!A;~Lc. £u!K
Mayor
' ~' ~~b~?££ "'---\:D ~'--'~'v~t.___
V~-~ 63, :&~
~ ~erCouncil
)
City Council Minutes
November 19, 2013
2309
Orangeburg City Council held its regularly scheduled meeting on Tuesday, November
19, 2013, at 7:00P.M., in the Council Chambers Building with Mayor Butler presiding.
An invocation was given by Reverend Hayes Gainey of Edisto Fork United Methodist
Church.
PRESENT:
Michael C. Butler, Mayor
Charles B. Barnwell, Jr.
Bernard Haire
Charles W. Jernigan
L. Zimmerman Keitt
Sandra P. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
A motion was made by Councilmember Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Haire, to
approve the November 5, 2013, City Council Minutes as distributed. This motion was
unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Haire, to
approve the Second Reading of an Ordinance amending Section 5-29, titled "Weapons
and Firearms" of the Code of Ordinances for the City of Orang eburg, SC. This motion
was unanimously approved.
City Administrator Yow stated, "The Ordinance is for the exchange of properties on the
comer of Broughton and Windsor Streets and Russell Street and $75,000 for the first
Citizens Bank Building. We would be receiving property near the City parking lot
known as the Mural Building on Russell Street and we would also receive 2.87 acres next
to this bank building across from DPU, also plus $75,000 in case consideration. The
community will be getting both properties up to code by removing those buildings on that
property.
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Councilmember Keitt, to
approve the Second Reading of an Ordinance to exchange the First Citizens Bank
Building for properties located on Broughton and Windsor Streets and the amount of
$75,000. This motion was unanimously approved.
City Administrator Yow addressed Council in regards to a Municipal Agreement from
the South Carolina Department of Transportation (SCDOT) for the reconstruction of the
intersection of John C. Calhoun Drive and Russell Street. He stated, "Mr. Kevin Gantt
appeared before Council in September and the minutes are in the packet for you to
review. At that time, Council asked many questions and received his report. Council did
not take action on his request for a Municipal Agreement to be entered into by the City.
Council asked for this to be brought back to Council and a s~mple Agreement is in your
packet, the drawing of the proposed project and the minutes , as well as proposed costs
from Department ofPublic Utili ties (DPU) in the amount of$35,600 from Mr. Tommy
Miller. Also, included is an accident history on the intersection. Mr. Gantt has called to
see if Council has come to a conclusion on the matter one way or the other."
Mayor Pro Tern J emigan asked, "Have they considered any of our recommendations?"
Page 2
2310
City Administrator Yow replied , "I have not received any proposed amendments to the
property. I know one of the things was a traffic signal and rerouting straight out to
Highway US 301 and turning right. Basically, they asked me to bring it before Council
as it was presented last time."
Councilmember Haire stated, "I think in his presentation he addressed the problem with
the rerouting on Highway US 301, that it would bottleneck."
City Administrator Yow replied , "I think it was all addressed in the minutes , it may not
be enough to satisfy CounciL"
Councilmember Barnwell stated, "In my opinion, I think we are taking a less dangerous
situation now and turning it into a worse situation. It is being proposed as a "T"
intersection and where you will now have a nightmare ."
Mayor Butler stated, "I believe we should go back and do a study for a traffic light
there."
Councilmember Barnwell replied, "I thought he said one was not proposed."
City Administrator Yow replied , "He did say that at this time there was not one proposed.
What you are saying is to ask if it has been reconsidered ."
Councilmember Keitt stated, "They gave us a number of accidents there. My thought is
to try something new and maybe it would eliminate some of the accidents we are having
there. We certainly are in favor of eliminating accidents rather than continuing to have
them. You never know how it is going to be until we try."
Mayor Pro Tern Jernigan asked, ''If we rejected this, what happens? "
City Administrator Yow replied, "I think they could still do the project, but I doubt that
they would. That is speculation on my part. What you are doing is rejecting the
Municipal Agreement."
Mayor Butler asked if we could request a study to be done.
Councilmember Haire stated , "I think we are constantly kicking this ball down the street.
I think we need to make a decision because he has been here at least two times and has
talked about the need for this and the Highway Department has done the study. I think to
delay this project may in essence cause this money to be shifted somewhere else. The
Highway Department has come up with this proposal where their judgment is the best for
this intersection and we need to stop kicking the ball around."
Councilmember Keitt stated, "I would just like to say that I have read in the minutes that
if we do not agree with this proposal that the money would move on to the next project
and we do not want them to do that."
Mayor Butler replied, "My question was how this will affect us in the future?"
City Administrator Yow replied, "I couldn't begin to answer that."
Councilmember Haire made a motion that the City move on with the Municipal
Agreement with SCDOT. This motion was seconded by Councilmember Keitt. The vote
was Councilmembers Haire, Knotts, Keitt and Mayor Pro Tern Jernigan, in favor.
Councilmembers Stroman, Barnwell and Mayor Butler opposed. The motion did not
pass.
Page 3
2311
City Administrator Yow asked Council to consider rescheduling the December 3, 2013,
City Council meeting due to the "Messiah" being performed at the Stevenson Auditorium
on the same date at 7:00P.M. Last year, we rescheduled the meeting at a different time.
If Council did reschedule this, we would ask that you reschedule the meeting for 12:00
Noon or 1:00 P.M. , because we would still have a conflict with people coming in and
setting up."
Councilmember Barnwell asked, "I think we have to consider the final medical numbers
in regards to Affordable Care and I don't know if we will have much time."
City Administrator Yow stated, "We do and that is one of the reasons I thought we would
reschedule at 12:00 or 1:00 because it may be a two hour meeting. I know a lot of times
when we have a mid-day meeting it is relatively short. It may necessitate a special
meeting also."
Councilmember Barnwell stated, "I will have to check my calendar , but I think I may
have a medica l procedure that day."
City Administrator Yow stated, "It doesn't have to be on a Tuesday, the special meetin g."
Mayor Pro Tern Jernigan asked, "Why are we rescheduling again?"
City Administrator Yow stated, "Due to an event in Stevenson for the "Messiah" , but we
don't have to if Counci l wishes not to."
Mayor Butler stated, "They have asked to use this building as a reception hall."
Councilmember Keitt replied , "We did last year."
City Administrator Yow stated, "We haven 't confirmed that and not if we have the
meeting at the normal time."
Mayor Pro Tern Jernigan asked, "I thought that we had agreed that this building would
not be used for reception s and parties ?"
City Administrator Yow stated, "This room here only, but we have not confirmed if they
could use it."
Mayor Pro Tern Jernigan asked, "Are we going to charge them if they do use it?"
City Administrator Yow stated, "No."
Mayor Pro Tern Jernigan asked, "Why?"
Councilmember Barnwell asked, "Why, we would be setting an example that anyone that
has a concert they could use Council Chambers."
Councilmember Haire stated, "This is something that DORA is sponsoring and I think we
need to support DORA in the best way we can."
City Administrator Yow stated, "We have been a partner with DORA in presenting this
to the community. We don ' t even charge for the auditorium for that night because we are
one of the co-sponsors."
Page4
tJY!~utler stated, "DORA is sponsoring the "Messiah".
Councilmember Keitt made a motion to reschedule the December 3, 2013, City Council
Meeting to 12:00 Noon, seconded by Councilmember Haire. Councilmembers Haire and
Keitt and Mayor Butler voted for the rescheduling and Councilmembers Barnwell ,
Stroman and Mayor Tern Jernigan voted against the motion. Councilmember Knotts
abstained. The vote was 3-3-0.
City Administrator Yow stated, "There is no need to call me, I cannot change the
meeting, it is Council's decision ."
Councilmember Haire asked City Attorney Walsh if a Councilmember would need to
recuse themselves from the vote.
City Attorney Walsh replied, "No, since there is not a financial interest."
Councilmember Haire asked that we reconsider the motion previously on rescheduling
the Council Meeting. This was seconded by Councilmember Keitt. This was a 4-3vote,
as Councilmembers Stroman and, Barnwell and Mayor Pro Tern Jernigan opposed.
A motion was made by Councilmember Keitt to reschedule the December 3, 2013, City
Council meeting at 12:00 Noon instead of7:00 P.M., seconded by Councilmember Haire.
This was a 4-3 vote as Councilmembers Stroman and Barnwell and Mayor Pro Tern
Jernigan opposed .
Councilmember Barnwell asked, "What time will it be?"
City Administrator Yow replied, "12:00 Noon."
Councilmember Barnwell stated, "I have a medical procedure that day."
City Administrator Yow stated, "In your packet, there are several positions whose terms
are expiring. Listed by those individuals is the District that they were nominated from.
Individuals don't make appointments and nominations are provided by Council. Please
take note if you have persons who were nominated from your District whose term is
about to expire. If there is not a District by the name, it means they were nominated and
appointed At Large. Ifthere are Districts and one At Large, those are usually nominated
by the Mayor. If you go to the Construction Board of Adjustments and Appeals, all of
those are nominated At Large. I will point out to you that some of these Boards and
Commissions must have backgrounds in certain fields. Most of these require the
individuals to reside in the City. The Aviation Commission is an exception to that rule;
they must reside in Orangeburg County. One that we do not have on the list that we will
have for you at the December 3rd meeting, is the Accommodations Tax Committee . The
state law is very specific in the background they must be from such as hospitality ,
lodging or tourism. I would propose nominations at the December 17'h meeting."
Councilmember Haire stated, "Construction Board of Adjustments and Appeals that is
another Board that may not have to reside in the City."
City Administrator Yow replied , "I will have to check the code, but you may be right."
City Administrator Yow stated, "If you could have nomination s by December 1 0
1
h for the
City Council meeting on December 17'h ; however, you can make other nominations at
the meeting."
PageS 2313
First Reading of an Ordinance amending the existing Ordinance for flood damage
prevention and to replace with definitions, policies and standards in conformity to the
National Flood Insurance Program was postponed.
There were no Dep mtment of Public Utilities matters brought before Council.
A motion was made by Councilmemb er Stroman, seconded by Councilmember Haire, to
enter into an Executive Session for contractual and legal matters concerning acceptance
of land for road construction and cost-sharing of construction contract costs - off North
Road and Department of Public Utilities Software Implementation Contract.
Council will not return to Open Session.
pfb
A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING A COST PARTICIPATION AGREEMENT WITH
FORT MOTTE, LLC FOR THE CONSTRUCTION AND PAVING OF A ROADWAY
TO AND FROM THE LANDS OF THE CITY OF ORANGEBURG AND FORT
MOTTE,LLC
WHEREAS, the City of Orangeburg owns property designated generally as Tract A
containing 131.74 acres, more or less, on a Concept Plan of Magnolia Village attached hereto
as Exhibit "A'', and
WHEREAS, Fort Motte, LLC owns lands generally set forth as Tract B containing 57.26
acres, more or less, on said Concept Plan, and
WHEREAS, the parties recognize that the construction of a roadway to and from their
properties from U.S. Route 178 is beneficial to both parties and necessary for the development
ofboth Tracts A and B, and
WHEREAS, the parties have agreed to share in the cost of the design, paving and
construction of said roadway.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, by the City Council duly assembled that John
H. Yow, City Administrator is hereby authorized to enter into a Cost Sharing Participation
Agreement with Fort Motte, LLC, a South Carolina limited liability company, for the purpose
of design, paving and construction of a roadway sixty-six (66') feet wide, more or less, to and
from the properties of the City of Orangeburg and across the properties of Fort Motte, LLC to
U.S. Highway 178 and being highlighted in yellow on Exhibit "A" attached hereto. Costs and
expenses of design, paving and construction shall be shared equally between Fort Motte. LLC
and the City of Orangeburg.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that John H. Yow, City Administrator is hereby authorized
to sign any and all other documents necessary to complete the construction of said roadway in
compliance with this Resolution. YA
RESOLVED BY City Council duly assembled this jJ.::_ day of December, 2013.
\~v~ ~ :i\~'~'\'-
' c~ /'::) Pi~ dA
~;../~
C:\Documents and SetlingsVames F. Walsh.MAIN\Dcsktop\Bcth's Documents\City ofO'burg \Resolutions\Cit y Housing Element doc
City Council Minutes
December 3, 2013
Orangeburg City Council held its regularly scheduled meeting on Tuesday, December 3,
2013, at 12:00 Noon , in the Council Chambers Building with Mayor Butler presiding.
An invocation was given by Reverend Harry McCutcheon of Trinity United Methodist
Church.
PRESENT:
Michael C. Butler, Mayor
Charles B. Barnwell, Jr.
Bernard Haire
Charles W. Jernigan
L. Zimmerman Keitt
Sandra P. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
A motion was made by Councilmember Keitt, seconded by Counci lmember Stroman, to
approve the November 19, 2013, City Council Minutes as distributed . This motion was
unanimously approved .
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Councilmember Bamwell , to
approve the Third Reading of an Ordinance amending Section 5-29, titled "Weapons and
Firearms" of the Code of Ordinances for the City of Orangeburg, SC. This motion was
unanimously approved.
City Administrator Yow stated, "This Ordinance is for the exchange of properties
between Cox Industries and the City. We would receive propertie s located at
(Broughton and Russell and Windsor that runs to Amelia Street and another property
located on Russell Street) and 75,000 for the First Citizens Bank Building. We would be
receiving property near the City parking lot known as the Mural Building on Russell
Street and we would also receive 2.87 acres next to the bank building across from DPU,
plus $75,000 in cash consideration. The community will be getting both properties
brought to code by the current owner removing the buildings on subject properties.
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell , seconded by Councilmember Keitt, to
approve the Third Reading of an Ordinance to exchange the First Citizens Bank Building
for properties (Broughton and Russell and Windsor that runs to Amelia Street and
another property located on Russell Street) and the amount of $75,000. This motion was
unanimously approved.
Assistant City Administrator Singh addressed Council concerning an Ordinance for flood
damage prevention and to replace with definitions , policies and standards in conformit y
to the national Flood Insurance Program . He stated, "There may be a few additional
changes to this Ordinance, which could be some updating of Federal and State
regulations per City Attorney Walsh."
A motion was made by Councilmember Knotts, seconded by Councilmember Keitt, to
approve the First Reading of an Ordinance amending the existi ng Ordinance for flood
damage prevention and to replace with definitions , policies and standards in conformity
to the National Flood Insurance Program. This motion was unanimously approved.
Page 2
Mrs. Katrina Thomas, Executive Director of the Community of Character, accepted the
December 2013, Character Trait Proclamation, "Virtue".
A motion was made by Counci1member Haire, seconded by Councilmember Keitt, to
approve staff recommendations to the Accommodations Tax Advisory Committee to fill
unexpired terms. Ms. Dede Cook was appointed to represent the hospitality sector and
Mr. John L. Simmons representing the lodging sector. This motion was unanimously
approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Councilmember Keitt, to
approve a Resolution committing to matching funds up to $309,776 for a Community
Block Grant application in the amount of $500,000 for Streetscape project from Lowman
Street to Boulevard Street. This motion was unanimously approved.
Assistant City Administrator John Singh stated, "This Streetscape will tie in to the other
streetscapes that have been completed."
There were no utility matters brought before Council.
A motion was made by Councilmember Stroman, seconded by Councilmember Keitt, to
enter into an Executive Session for a legal and contractual Matter concerning the
Department of Public Utilities software implementation contract with Whitlock
Consulting, LLC. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Keitt, to
return to Open Session. This motion was unanimously approved.
Council returned to Open Session.
DPU Manager Tommy Miller stated, "DPU went through the process, with your
approval, to begin looking for a software company and also to contract with a company
with implementation oversight. Bids were received and we are requesting City Council
to approve the Department of Public Utilities to enter into a contract with Whitlock
Consulting Group, LLC, in the amount of $1,332,800 for assistance with implementation
of utility software .
Councilmember Haire stated, "I am troubled about the process and I will be voting
against the project."
A motion was made by Councilmember Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Stroman, to
approve a Resolution for the Department of Public Utilities to enter into a contract with
Whitlock Consulting Group, LLC, in the amount of $1 ,332,800 for assistance with
implementation of utility software. This was a 6-1 vote, as Councilmember Haire
opposed.
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to
adjourn. This motion was unanimously approved.
There being no other business, the meeting was adjourned.
,23/(p
City Council Minutes
December 17, 2013
Orangeburg City Council held its regularly scheduled meeting on Tuesday, December 17,
2013, at 7:00P.M., in the Council Chambers Building with Mayor Butler presiding. An
invocation was given by Mr. Roger Brant, Director of City Service Department.
PRESENT:
Michael C. Butler, Mayor
Charles B. Barnwell, Jr.
Bernard Haire
Charles W. Jernigan
L. Zimmerman Keitt
Sandra P. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
A motion was made by Councilmember Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Stroman, to
approve the Decemher 3, 2013, City Council Minutes as distributed. This motion was
unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Couacilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Knotts,
to approve the Second Reading of an Ordinance amending the existing Ordinance for
flood damage prevention and to replace with definitions, policies and standards in
conformity to the National Flood Insurance Program. This motion was unanimously
approved.
City Administrator Yow addressed Council. He stated, "An approval was needed for a
contract with L-J Inc., for a parking lot at the Veterans Memorial in the amount of
$119,960. As Council knows, after the park was constructed, Council set as a goal to
construct a parking area on that same side of the street so that elderly Veterans didn't
have to cross the street. The drawing of the entire site is in your packet as well as the
existing Memorial. It is not a large parking area. When we built the Veterans Memorial,
we realized that the site required a lot of dirt excavation and bringing in more dirt and
compact it. We will have the contractor time that in a manner to get the dry dirt in there.
You have a bid tabulation sheet in your packet which ranges from $119,960 to $163,940.
We have done reference checks on the contractor and we are pleased with the information
received and this same contractor has done one job at the Airport for us in the past."
Councilmember Barnwell asked, "Why can't we save this money for some other project
and have them utilize the Chamber parking lot?"
City Administrator Yow stated, "They do utilize it now, but that would be a question you
would need to ask Council. Council issued a directive to move forward with this."
Councilmember Haire stated, "Lives are more important, you could have a Veteran cross
the street and get hit."
City Administrator Yow stated, "The only thing I can say is the money was raised and
appropriated and it was the understanding the money would be used for the parking lot.
We have more than enough to cover this in the 1% Fund and the Hospitality Tax Fund."
C6 ~~. V~Ct llll.~111ber Keitt stated, "We have to look out for the elderly and we need to move
-hr w.acJ.wth this."
Page 2
'\f\ u.:~ ... ~ '·'-··
Mayor ~ :Butlch stated, "How many handicapped parking spaces will there be." 2317
Mr. West Summers, architect for this project stated, "Two (2) handicapped with fifteen
(15) total spaces."
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Council Keitt, to approve
awarding a contract to L-J Inc., in the amount of $119,960 for construction of a parking
area for the Veterans Memorial Park. This was a 6-1 vote as Councilmember Barnwell
opposed.
Cjty Administrator Yow addressed Council. He stated, "As you know the city owns
p~o~.~fty 9,ffthe North Road for a Recreational Complex. In your packet, is a Resolution
in· ~egards 1 to splitting the cost of a road to our property off of the North Road. Fort
Motte, LLC, and the City would split the cost of construction of the road and we would
have permanent use of the road for the recreation area. A diagram is in your packet. We
are talking about the City property behind Wal-Mart and Orangeburg Preparatory High
School. Adjacent to the property is property owned by the YMCA. We discussed having
another means of having an ingress and egress to that property. This would be an
additional road that would cross Fort Motte, LLC, property to our property. In the
agreement, we would have that the City would have a right-of-wa y for the construction of
this road. Fort Motte, LLC, and the City would split the cost of the engineering and
construction of the road. We would have permanent use of the road. One of the items I
will point out, is that we have applied for Transportation Tax Fund monies and have been
approved and this would go toward this and the remaining balance would be split. The
engineer's estimate was around $400,000, but this is not final due to the design. They are
also willing to give up extra width at the entrance for turning lanes as well as a circle for
delivery trucks which may add some cost to the road."
Mayor Pro Tern Jernigan asked, "Who is Fort Motte, LLC?"
City Administrator Yow stated, "The two partners are Johnny Evans and Marion Moore.
It will be a commercial development."
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Councilmember Keitt, to
approve a Resolution authorizing a cost participation agreement with Fort Motte, LLC,
for the construction and paving of a roadway to and from the lands of the City of
Orangeburg and Fort Motte, LLC. This motion was unanimousl y approved.
Mr. Fred Broughton, Chairman of the Accommodations Tax Committee , presented the
Committee's recommendation to Council.
A motion was made by Councilmember Stroman, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell,
to approve the City Accommodations Tax Committee recommendations . This motion
was unanimously approved. The following funding was approved.
Chamber of Commerce (Lead Agency)
Orangeburg Festival of Roses
Downtown Orangeburg Revitalization Association
Orangeburg County Fine Arts Center
City Parks and Recreation Department
TOTAL
$5,600
$4,000
$2,500
$1,000
$3,300
$ 16,400
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Jernigan,
to approve the following individuals to the -Board of Zoning Appeals. This is a four ( 4)
year term ending January , 2018. This motion was unanimously approved.
Lucky Buck
L. Hugh Smith
Willie Brown
~8
A motion was made by Councilmember Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Haire, to
approve the following individuals to the Construction Board of Adjustments and Appeals.
This is a four (4) year term ending January, 2018. This motion was unanimously
approved.
G. W. Berry
Louis Boone
A motion was made by Councilmember Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Haire, to
approve the following individuals to the Aviation Commission. This is a four (4) year
term ending January, 2014. This motion was unanimously approved. This Commission
does not require the individual to live within the City limits.
Reese Earley
Kevin Bell
Samuel Glover
Mayor Pro Tern Jemigan stated, "We took a member off of the Aviation Commission
and put on a new one. Do we have information on him?"
Mayor Butler stated, "He is a retired Army pilot."
A motion was made by Councilmember Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Knotts, to
approve the following individuals to the Planning Commission. This is a four (4) year
term ending, January 2014. This motion was unanimously approved .
Guy Best
Bill Sandifer
Bill BatTett
Jesse Eargle
Don Tribble
There were no utility matters brought before Council.
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Councilmember Stroman, to
enter into an Executive Session for a contractual matter conceming Blue Cross Blue
Shield Health Services for TPA, and Healthstat, Inc., Near-Site Medical Clinic
Administration. This motion was unanimously approved.
Council returned to Open Session.
A motion as made by Councilmember Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Haire, to
authorize the City Administrator to enter into an agreement for Blue Cross Blue Shield
for TPA (self insured). This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Councilmember Knotts, to
adjoum. This motion was unanimously approved.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjoumed.
Source: City of Orangeburg website. First collected Oct 13, 2026.