Minutes
City of Orangeburg · Orangeburg County · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Orangeburg
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
0\C ~ ~c
.~
~ L~~ gv•• ~
~
~
'0-- ~ (....)
.~
8
~ ~
0
~ ~
~ (....)
~
.~~
V)
~ ~
~ u ~
~
City Council Minutes
January 20, 2009 1929
Orangeburg City Council held its regularly scheduled .meeting on Tuesday, January 20, 2009, at
7:00 P.M., in Council Chambers Building with Mayor Miller presiding.
PRESENT:
Paul A. Miller, Mayor
Charles B. Barnwell
Bernard Haire
Charles W. Jernigan
Sandra P. Knotts
Trelvis A. Miller
Joyce W. Rheney
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tem Haire, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to approve
the December 16, 2008 minutes as distributed. This was a 6-0-1 vote with Councilmember Miller
abstaining as he was not present at the meeting.
A highlight video was shown on SC State University's Football Team's Season. A Proclamation
was presented to the Team, Head Coach Buddy Pough and Athletic Director Charlene Johnson
honoring their 2008 Bulldog Football Season.
Mr. Harry Fleming addressed Council thanking them on behalf of the residents of Spring Valley.
He thanked them for the opportunity to present their side of things and expressed thanks to Kevin
Bronson who kept us informed whether good or otherwise.
Mr. Don Tribble, Director of Oranegburg Community of Character, accepted the January 2009,
Character Trait Proclamation, "Cheerfulness".
City Administrator Yow overviewed for Council the Resolution for fire contract rate changes. He
stated that this was discussed and approved during the budget process and hearings for the FY
2008-09 budget year. The smallest square foot houses classifications was not affected by any
increase, some categories were increased 5% and others were reclassified and new classes were
added.
A motion made by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, seconded by Council member Knotts, to approve the
Resolution to set suburban fire protection rates as authorized under Section 18-4.2 of the Code of
Ordinances. This motion was unanimously approved.
Public Works Director Durwood Bowden addressed Council in regards to sole source purchasing a
residential garbage truck that is approved in the FY 2008-09 budget. He stated the reasons that sole
sourely made good business sense for the City. The budgeted amount was $183,000.00 and this
truck will be $168,319.00, plus sales tax, from Amick Equipment Company.
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Rheney, to approve
the purchase ofa new residential garbage truck in the amount of$168,319.00, plus tax, from Amick
Equipment Company. This motion was unanimously approved.
The scheduled consideration of the City's Code for abandoned, junk or unlicensed vehicles had
been canceled. City Administrator Yow noted the issue was cleared up after discussing the item
with Mayor Pro Tem Haire who asked that this item be placed on the agenda.
Concerning the Depattment of Public Utilities, DPU Manager Fred Boatwright presented
appointments to the DPU Grievance Committee. Janice Price from the Administrative Division as
alternate, tenn to expire January 2012, Brett Yougue from the Electric Division, term to expire
January 2010, Brittany Gan'ick from the Gas Division, term to expire January 2011, and Michael
Owens from the Water Division, term to expire 2012.
A motion made by Rheney, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern, to approve the appointments to DPU's
Grievance Committee. This motion was unanimously approved.
lq:;O
1>age 2
A motion was made by Councilmcmber Barnwell, seconded by Councilmembcr Miller, to
enter into an Executive Session concerning Economic DevclopmenllBusiness Recruitment This
motion was unanimously approved.
There being no further business. the meeting was adjourned.
RESOLUTION
RESOLUTION OF CITY COUNCIL TO SET SUBURBAN FIRE PROTECTION RATES AS
AUTHORIZED UNDER SECTION 18-4.2 OF THE CODE OF ORDINANCES OF THE
CITY OF ORANGEBURG SOUTH CAROLINA
WHEREAS, the City of Orangeburg, South Carolina provides fire protection and other related
services to the suburban areas outside the city; and
WHEREAS, a large Majority of the emergency calls are in the suburban areas; and
WHEREAS, the City incurs substantial costs in providing this service; and
WHEREAS, the City strives to maintain and improve its level of Public Safety services.
NOW THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, that the Orangeburg City Council sets the rate for fire
protection for annual suburban fire contract protection, effectiv~, 2009, as follows:
SUBURBAN FIRE PROTECTION RATES
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
21.
22.
23.
31.
32.
35.
36.
41.
42.
45.
46.
47.
48.
49.
53.
1st house less than 900 square feet
All other miscellaneous structures on same lot
1st house 900 square feet to 1499 square feet
All other miscellaneous structures on same lot
Ist house 1500 square feet
to 2099 square feet
All other miscellaneous structures on same lot
1st house 2100 square feet to 2699 square feet
All other miscellaneous structures on same lot
1st house 2700 square feet to 3299 square feet
All other miscellaneous structures on same lot
1st house 3300 square feet to 3899 square feet
All other miscellaneous structures on same lot
I st house 3900 square feet and larger
All other miscellaneous structures on same lot
Single Wide Trailer or Mobile Home
Double Wide Trailer or Mobile Home
Mobile Home Park, Each Single Wide Trailer or Mobile Home
Mobile Home Park, Each Double Wide Trailer or Mobile Home
Apartments, Duplexes, Townhouses or Condominiums less than 900
Square feet
All other apartments
Apartments, Duplexes, Townhouses or Condominiums greater than 900
Square feet
All other apartments
Hotels, Motels or Rooming Houses
Recycling Centers greater than two acres
Vacant Lot or parcel not exceeding 5 acres
Vacant parcels larger than 5 acres
Business under 1500 Square Feet (Sq feet must be verified)
Business 1501 - 10,000 Square Feet (Sq feet must be verified)
Business 10,001 - 30,000 Square Feet (Sq feet must be verified)
Business 30,001 - 50,000 Square Feet (Sq feet must be verified)
Business 50,001 - 100,000 Square Feet (Sq feet must be verified)
Mall, Shopping Complex or Strip Malls (each unit), Sq. Feet must be veri fied
Under 1500 Square feet (each unit)
1500 Square feet or Larger (each unit)
$ 90.00
$ 62.00
$133.00
$105.00
$143.00
$112.50
$151.00
$123.00
$161.00
$133.00
$170.00
$143.00
$180.00
$151.00
$ 95.00
$135.00
$ 95.00
$135.00
$95.00
$66.00
$133.00
$105.00
$500.00
$1,500.00
$ 80.00
$122.00
$150.00
$300.00
$400.00
$60000
$800.00
$150.00
$350.00
54.
61.
62.
63.
71.
74.
81.
82.
Storage Warehouse - up to 3000 square feet (Sq ft must be verified)
Industrial, Manufacturing, Institutions under 100,000 Square Feet
Industrial, Manufacturing, Institutions or Businesses over 100,000 sq. feet
Hospitals
Gasoline Service Stations and/or Convenience Stores
Gasoline, Propane or other Fuel Bulk Plant
Dumpster Sites (per site), or Manned Convenience Stations (per site)
All Vehicle Fires
$165.00
$1625.00
$2445.00
$8,135.00
$400.00
$600.00
$150.00
$525.00
No contracts: When the Department
of Public Safety responds to a residential call without a valid
contract, the minimum service charge will be $1,565.00 plus the price ofthe contract.
All institutions, commercial, manufacturing, or business calls will be billed for actual
costs with a minimum charge of$I,565.00 plus the cost of the fire contract. Fire
reports will not be issued until the service charge is paid in full.
'fh
DONE AND RATIFIED BY Council duly assembled this d{) f_~:!....':'.~~~I!--, 2009.
Mayor
City
City Council Minutes
February 3, 2009
Orangeburg City Council held its regularly scheduled meeting on Tuesday, February 3,
2009, at 7:00 P.M., in the Council Chambers Building with Mayor Miller presiding.
PRESENT:
Paul A. Miller, Mayor
Charles B. Barnwell
Bernard Haire
Charles W. Jernigan
Trelvis A. Miller
Joyce W. Rheney
ABSENT:
Sandra P. Knotts
A motion was made by Councilmember Miller, seconded by Councilmember Jernigan, to
approve the January 20, 2008, City Council Minutes as distributed.
Mr. Al Breland of The Greater Edisto American Red Cross addressed Council. He
gave a brief update on where the Chapter is at. He stated, "I am now the Director of the
Red Cross and I bring a lot of management skills to the Red Cross. Currently, our by
laws are out of compliance and we had seventeen board members last fall and we now
have nine. I am going around collecting names and recommendations to get new board
members. I also want to establish a financial plan. I have about ninety days to get it
rolling. I want to tell you what Red Cross is doing for your community. In the last six
months alone, we assisted thirty-seven families, received direct aid for fires, which
equates to $15,000 of aid paid directly. We have taught seventy-five health and safety
courses. We have processed fifty-three emergency communication claims and processed
military aid society loans. We are going to have fundraisers and put together a baby
crawl and a tricycle race. We will have a yard sale at our Chapter House on March 21st.
We would be happy to accept any donations for the yard sale. We will be having a Clara
Barton Campaign with major donors and will be working with the United Way. What I
am trying to tell you is that the Red Cross has been a part of this community. It always
has been and always will be. Everyone has been over enthusiastic of what has been
happening with the Red Cross. Please help me find key community leaders for board
members to represent the three counties of Bamwell, Allendale and Orangeburg
Counties."
Councilmember Jernigan asked about the blood donation program.
Mr. Breland replied, "There are two wings of the Red Cross. Columbia does the Blood
Drive in this area. It will be Thursday at the Mall. I have asked the Chapter how much
we have advertised in the past. I want to make sure the community knows that we are
here and I know that the hospital also does a blood drive."
Mayor Pro Tern Haire asked, "Of the three counties, what is the ratio for the Board?"
Mr. Breland replied, "We don't specifically have a ratio at the moment. With
Orangeburg having the most population it would probably be more representation from
Orangeburg."
Yow updated Council on the status ofthe Veteran's Memorial Park. He stated, "This is
the general location above where this is directly across from the Chamber of Commerce
which is owned by the City of Orangeburg. As we pointed out in an earlier meeting, we
were concerned with the lowness ofthe area. We have had soil borings done. This site
can be used but we will have to bring in more soil. I wanted to point that out in the
drawing in more detail. The total budget for this project is $375,000.00. We have spent
thus far approximately $20,000.00 on design work and architectural work.
1931
1932
Page 2
We have about $350,000 left. As you can see from the drawing, the architect has
removed part of this project from this phase which is parking onsite and the reflection
pool. This does not mean we cannot come back at a later time and put those items in.
Parking would be in the Chamber of Commerce parking lot."
Councilmember Barnwell asked, "On the stone, would that be the branches of service?"
A discussion was held on where the branches of service were and the conflicts would be
placed. There was a discussion on where the conflicts would be listed.
City Administrator Yow stated "All the details have not been finalized yet and Mr. Bill
Salley wanted to address Council on the flags. There is an area out in front in brick and
concrete and I know that there is a possibility of the selling of bricks from the Veteran's
Council."
Councilmember Rheney wanted to know if drainage would be done to include a future
fountain.
City Administrator Yow stated no.
Mayor Miller responded also that the fountain was taken out to save approximately
$60,000 and to save costs.
City Administrator Yow also stated that it did not mean that this could not be revisited at
a later time.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, seconded by Councilmember Rheney, to
direct City Administrator Yow to move forward with this project and direct Mr. West
Summers, Architect to move forward. This motion was unanimously approved.
Mr. Bill Salley of the Orangeburg County Veteran's Council addressed Council. He
stated, "His organization feels strongly that the memorial should have a flag for each
branch of service for a total of nine. Local veteran's associations will pay to replace
those flags as necessary. In addition, we would like a placard to designate each conflict
since the Revolutionary War. I have estimated the cost to be approximately $800-$900
each and twelve placards would cost $10,000.00. I, as commander, would like to be a
part of the design committee for this monument"
Mayor Pro Tern Haire asked, "What about future conflicts?"
Mr. Salley responded, "The memorial should be designed to accommodate additional
conflicts and leave space and add placards."
Mayor Miller responded, "We have an architect for this project and the branches of
service could be displayed in the brick work and we have got to leave all of that to the
architect. We will be recognizing the conflicts and leave room for additional. How we
are going to do that, I don't know at this point. We will be working with Mr. Summers
on this and the design committee, I don't know if we can do that. We have Mr. Summers
to design it to fit in with our pocketbook. I hear what you are saying. I think it is taken
us a long time to get here and we need to move forward. I think we will take this
information under advisement."
Mr. Salley also stated that there is a brick drive to sell bricks and to date they have sold
less than ten.
Mr. Don Tribble, Executive Director of the Community of Character Program, accepted
the Community Character Trait for the month of February 2009, "Patience".
Page 3
Mayor Pro Tern Haire made a motion, seconded by Councilmember Miller, to approve a
Resolution for Cities Mean Business. This motion was unanimously approved.
Assistant City Administrator Bronson addressed Council. "We are presenting to you
recommended changes in the Zoning Ordinance before sending it to the Planning
Commission for review and a Public Hearing. The changes are proposed to give Council
and the Commission greater flexibility in zoning annexed property. We hope to bring
this back to you in March from the Planning Commission."
Mayor Po Tern Haire asked, "When it comes back from the Planning Commission, is it a
done deal?"
Assistant City Administrator Bronson stated, "No, we brought it before you tonight for
you to make sure what you want in the language is there as I present it to the Planning
Commission. They will then make a recommendation to you and it is Council's
prerogative to do with it what you wish."
City Administrator Yow stated, "The reason we brought it back to you was the discussion
over the last annexation and the Planning Commission was not part of that discussion.
Changes in the Zoning Ordinance go before the Planning Commission but Council has
the fmal say."
Mayor Pro Tern Haire asked, "Would A-I be proposed for any annexed properties?"
Assistant City Administrator Bronson replied, "When we do the 75% Petition Ordinance
Method, if someone does not sign the annexation petition, they are automatically zoned
as A-I. This allows you flexibility to zone other than A-I."
A motion as made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Haire,
approving sending the proposed Zoning Ordinance Text Amendment to the Planning
Commission. This motion was unanimously approved.
There were 110 utility matters brought before Council.
A motion as made by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, seconded by Councilmember Miller, to
adjourn. This motion was unanimously approved.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
Respectfully submitted,
~
//'hL-W
arrie W. Jo
City Clerk
Ipfb
1933
1934
City Council Minutes
February 17, 2009
Orangeburg City Council held its regularly scheduled meeting on Tuesday, February 17,
2009, at 7:00 P.M., in Council Chambers with Mayor Miller presiding.
PRESENT:
Paul A. Miller, Mayor
Charles B. Barnwell
Bernard Haire
Charles W. Jernigan
Sandra P. Knotts
Trelvis A. Miller
ABSENT:
Joyce W. Rheney
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Jernigan,
to approve the February 3, 2009,City Council Minutes as distributed. This was a 4-0-1
vote as Councilmember Knotts abstained as she was not present at the meeting and
Councilmember Miller was not yet present.
Mr. Fred Boatwright and Tommy Miller presented Mr. Ray L. Fogle with a Retiree
Resolution and a gold watch for his thirty-three years, four months and six days of
service to the Department of Public Utilities.
Dr. Eugene Gehry addressed Council in regards to the Veteran's Monument being
proposed. He gave Council his credentials as far as his military service. He stated,
"With no disrespect to Mr. Summers, I would rather have no monument than have that.
Let's not get in a hurry to build it and let's build it right, not as a monument to the
Department of Defense. We want to see something for the men and women of this
County who gave their lives for our freedom. I feel that we need to collect money from
those families to have names ofloved ones engraved on the monument for $25.00 each. I
will put money in it right now. I am not criticizing Mr. Summers, but I say let's put in a
wall and move the names from the Lady Fountain and use them on the new memorial. I
think my idea of selling the right to sponsor the name on the monument is the right thing
to do. I'd like to go down to that spot and shed tears there and kneel down and thank
God for the service for those people that died for us."
Mayor Pro Tern Haire stated, "I feel that it would be a disservice to Veterans who died in
action if they did not have families to pay for their names included on the monument. I
think we could leave someone out and that would be a disservice to them."
Chief Wendell Davis, Keith Hewitt Sr. and Keith Hewitt Jr. presented Council with a
Thermal Imaging System that was donated by State Farm through a public/private
partnership. It is an infrared device that is hand-held that can identify hot spots and aid in
search and rescue. The Hewitt's in the past have donated an arson dog and funds toward
a fire house for children.
Orangeburg County Chamber of Commerce President David Coleman and Parks and
Recreation Director Buster Smith presented Council with awards from the SCINC
Festival & Events Association for Best Mass Marketing for billboards, Best Mass Media
Production for television ads and Best Merchandise Award for the Edisto Memorial
Gardens Postage Stamp.
Page 2
Mr. West Summers, architect for the Veteran's Monument addressed Council. He stated,
"We have looked at several sites and the site that has been agreed on can be used and it is
a visible site. The earth (soil) just needs to be stabilized. This monument is dignified and
respective of the Veterans. We tried to incorporate all concerns in this design. We have
scaled down the overall concept due to budget constraints and it has been designed with a
lot of sensitivity. We tried to do something to honor and commemorate all Veterans,
wars and conflicts and include all six branches of service and a POW flag. It resembles
the Washington monument, simple with a wooded background and grassy surrounding.
There is a hill to the back and flags will be incorporated in the design. We hope to have
this project within budget. This is a once in a lifetime experience for me and I was also
in the Navy. I think what we have tried to do is for all Veterans. There is room for
bricks that can be etched and I think some are being sold now."
Mayor Miller stated, "I appreciate all the hard work that has gone into this and I know we
have scaled it down to reduce the costs, in particular a reflecting pool which saved us
about $50,000. I think there are 1000 bricks in the walkway and there is a lot of
opportunity to add names."
Councilmember Barnwell asked, "If we wanted to have the nanles engraved in the
panels, could this be done and what would the costs be?"
Mr. Summers replied, "Yes, the panels could be continued on the side and names could
be engraved and as of the cost, I don't know at this time."
Councilmember Barnwell stated, "I would recommend to you Mr. Gehry, that you
approach Orangeburg County Council for funding. We were promised by a County
Councilman that the County would assist us in this memorial. This has not materialized
and it is a memorial for all Veterans of the County, not just the City."
A motion was made by Mayor ProTem Haire, seconded by Councilmember Miller to
give the City Administrator authority to proceed with design drawings and bid documents
and to put the Veteran's Monument out forbid and bring it back to Council for approval.
This motion was unanimously approved.
City Administrator Yow addressed Council in regards to the closing of Gibson Street for
the expansion of the courthouse by Orangeburg County. There was a discussion on
whether or not St. Paul's United Methodist Church was notified and had approved the
closing of the street.
Councilmember Barnwell stated that he was under the impression that the church was not
in agreement and that the street is being used by the church school. Council agreed to
table this item until a letter from the church approving the closing of the street was
received.
There were no utility matters brought before Council.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, seconded by Councilmember Jernigan, to
adjourn. This motion was unanimously approved.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
1935
1936
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
March 3, 2009
Orangeburg City Council held its regularly scheduled meeting on Tuesday, March 3, 2009, at
7:00 P.M., in Council Chambers with Mayor Miller presiding.
PRESENT:
Paul A. Miller, Mayor
Charles B. Barnwell
Bernard Haire
Charles W. Jernigan
Sandra p. Knotts
Trelvis A. Miller
Joyce W. Rheney
A Public Hearing was held regarding amending Section 24-4.4 of the Zoning Ordinance of the
City of Orangeburg, State of South Carolina.
Assistant City Administrator Bronson overviewed the text amendments to the Zoning Ordinance.
Hearing no public comments, the Public Hearing was closed.
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, to enter
into an Executive Session for a legal matter concerning the Terms and Conditions of the
Department of Public Utilities. This was a 6-0 unanimous vote as Councilmember Miller was
not present at this time.
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Jernigan, for
Council to return to Open Slfssion. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Knotts, seconded by Councilmember Jernigan, to
approve the Febmary 17, 2009, City Council Minutes as distributed. This was a 6-0-1 vote as
Councilmember Rheney abstained as she was not present at the Febmary 17th meeting.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tem Haire, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to
approve a Resolution authorizing the extension of the maturity date of the mortgage of two and
sixty-nine hundredths (2.69) acres with a building and other improvements thereon, to South
Carolina Bank and Tmst in the principal sum of five-hundred thousand ($500,000) dollars and
recorded in the office of the Register of Deeds for the County of Oranegburg, State of South
Carolina, in Mortgage Book #1551 at Page 293. City Administrator Yow was authorized to
execute necessary documents. This motion was unanimously approved.
DPS Director Wendell Davis, who currently serves as Chairman of the Community of Character
Board, accepted the Character Trait Proclamation for March 2009, "Sportsmanship".
A motion as made by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to approve
the First Reading of an Ordinance amending Section 24-4.4 of the Zoning Ordinances of the City
of Oranegburg, South Carolina. This motion was unanimously approved.
City Attorney Walsh addressed Council for amending two areas of the General Terms and
Conditions of the Department of Public Utilities. He stated, "One area of concern is that there is
a parcel that is located partly in the City and part is out; however, they are receiving in City
utility rates, but not paying city taxes. So, in effect they are receiving in city rates without paying
taxes. This is in Section 70 of the Terms and Conditions. Once this is passed, they will payout
of city rates for that entire parcel. The next portion amends language addressing covenants for
outside properties requesting utilities. We now require covenants for water and wastewater; we
have discovered that properties outside the City may be titled to different LLC's or Corporations
yet they may belong to the same owner or owners. This would require that all of the owners of
the properties must sign the covenant and a covenant is required on all properties."
1937
Page 2
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, seconded by Councilmember Miller, to approve
the First Reading of an Ordinance to amend the General Terms and Conditions of the
Department of Public Utilities. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Miller, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, to adjourn.
This motion was unanimously approved.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
Respectfully submitted,
~
Carrie W. Jo
City Clerk
/pfb
1938
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
March 17,2009
Orangeburg City Council held its regularly scheduled meeting on Tuesday, March 17, 2009, at 7:00 P.M.,
in Council chambers with Mayor Miller presiding.
PRESENT:
Paul A. Miller, Mayor
Charles B. Barnwell
Bernard Haire
Charles W. Jernigan
Sandra P. Knotts
Trelvis A. Miller
Joyce W. Rheney
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Rheney, to approve the
March 3, 2009, City Council Minutes as distributed. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Knotts, seconded by Councilmember Jernigan, to approve the
Second Reading of an Ordinance amending Section 24-4.4 of the Zoning Ordinances of the City of
Orangeburg, SC. This motion was unanimously approved.
Mayor Miller read the 20 I0 Census Proclamation.
A motion as made by Mayor Miller, seconded by Councilmember Miller, to reappoint Ms. Tara
Williamson to the City Election Commission. This motion was unanimously approved. This is a six year
term expiring March 2015.
City Attorney Walsh addressed Council. He stated, "This Ordinance in amending the General Terms and
Conditions in two different areas. If a parcel is partially in and partially out of the City, the owner will pay
out of City utility rates for the entire parcel. Also, it will clarify that all adjoining property owners
seeking City water or wastewater services are required to sign an annexation covenant to receive service.
The Ordinance further defines an owner of adjoining property as ownership in any legal entity owning
adjoining property or ownership by immediate family members.
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, to approve the
Second Reading of an Ordinance to amend the General Terms and Conditions of the Department of
Public Utilities. This motion was unanimously approved.
Councilmember Barnwell made a motion to authorize City Administrator Yow to send a Resolution to
AIG for the atrocious stealing of our tax dollars. This motion was seconded by Councilmember Jernigan
and unanimously approved.
Mayor Pro Tern Haire addressed Council in regards to a bipartisan press conference at the Statehouse in
Columbia. He stated, "The House passed their version of the budget and restored $70 million of the $120
million initially proposed. So that left $50 million to be taken away from cities and counties. The Senate
has expressed concern about what the House has done. I make a motion to authorize City Administrator
Yow to prepare a Resolution for the next April 7th session, if it is not too late." This motion was seconded
by Councilmember Barnwell and unanimously approved.
A motion as made by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to adjourn. This
motion as unanimously approved.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
Respectfully submitted,
C~
City Clerk
CWJ/pfb
Resolution
WHEREAS, American International Group, Incorporated (AIG) is an international provider of
insurance and financial services; and,
WHEREAS, the City of Orangeburg, South Carolina, recognizes the importance of fiscal
responsibility and good custodianship of taxpayer funds; and,
WHEREAS, the United States Treasury and Federal Reserve have committed almost $200
billion in various forms of taxpayer assistance to AIG for the company's financial
shortfalls; and,
WHEREAS, the commitment of almost $200 billion in taxpayer assistance represents one of
the largest Federal government rescues of a single private corporation in the
United States history; and,
WHEREAS, AIG irresponsible practices have resulted in substantial losses to the company, its
clients, investors and ultimately taxpayers; and,
WHEREAS, despite the irresponsible actions of AIG executives that threatened the company's
financial stability, while exposing taxpayers to almost $200 billion to cover losses
from excessive risks; these executives will receive hundreds of millions of
taxpayer money in retention payments and bonuses for performance in 2008 and
2009; and,
WHEREAS, the City of Orangeburg, South Carolina, finds these actions committed by
American International Group, Incorporated (AIG) as the utmost representation of
corporate malfeasance and all of these bonuses should be returned immediately.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, by the Mayor and Members of City Council this
seventeenth day of March 2009 in Orangeburg, South Carolina.
( .,(-=- YVVV"V;-,~.<= JvtMV£vU.t'tj!"
TEST:~
'I.~
City CI
Mem bers of Council
A Resolution For The Sound Financial Management of the South Carolina
Local Government Fund
WHEREAS,
WHEREAS,
WHEREAS,
WHEREAS,
WHEREAS,
WHEREAS,
WHEREAS,
WHEREAS,
WHEREAS,
WHEREAS,
WHEREAS,
WHEREAS,
the City of Orangeburg receives money from the State of South Carolina which reimburses the
city for services which the city is required to provide on behalf ofthe State; and,
the Locai Government Fund evolved from a patchwork of taxes due to cities and counties
originaily cailed Aid to Subdivisions. As early as 1925, the state coilected these municipal and
county taxes and returned the proceeds to cities and counties through multiple complex
formulas. in 1991, the process for returning these taxes to local government was simplified
creating what is known today as the Locai Government Fund; and,
the Local Government Fund is calcuiated at 4.5 percent of the previous year's state general fund
revenues divided between counties (83.3%) and cities (16.7 %) distributed based on population;
and,
State law prohibits the Fund from being cut below the ievel of the previous year without separate
and specific iegislation; however the Local Government Fund is subject to mid-year across the
board cuts by the Budget and Control Board only to the previous year's funding level; and,
the S.c. House of Representatives has passed a Bill (H 3581) which would reduce the city's
portion of the Local Government Fund by $73,381 or cause an increase of two (2)mills to pay for
those services that the State currently funds, and if H3581 becomes law, the benchmark is
reduced for future years. Not only is this a dangerous precedent, but this will put pressure back
on the property tax; and,
the impact of the local aid cuts will force immediate and severe service cutbacks in communities
throughout South Carolina and rather than dismissing these cuts as "pennies on the dollar," it is
important to recognize that essential local services will be hurt as a result of the largest and latest
local aid reduction in state history; and,
local aid is used by the city to pay for essential core services: policing the streets, fighting fires,
responding to emergencies, collecting trash, maintaining safe roads, and providing water and
sewer services. When local aid is cut, local services will be cut, and everyone is impacted; and,
there are only two ways that the city can deal with local aid cuts, one is to raise property taxes
even more and the other is to cut essential services that people want, this will be the worst of
both worlds; and,
the State either doesn't understand local finances or they are misrepresenting the meager
amount that cities and towns have available as reserves in order to justify their rush to cut local
aid. While the city does have reserves, it has been spending its reserves to protect local services
and its bond ratings; and,
fund balances, reserves or stabilization accounts are mostly used to pay for prudent cash flow
purposes, unexpected emergencies or unexpected but necessary expenditures. Raiding these
funds would weaken the city's finances and cut other services; and,
due to the millage cap previously imposed on South Carolina cities the city is already restricted
by state laws; and,
the Local Government Fund offsets losses local governments experience from a number of tax
exemptions and revenue raising prohibitions, such as Homestead property tax exemption,
business inventories tax exemption, and a 15 percent cap on millage rate increases. This
proposed cut forces local governments to carry the financial burden of the budget crisis without
giving them an alternative solution to create revenue; and,
1939
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
APRIL 7, 2009
Orangeburg City Council held a Public Hearing on Tuesday, April 7,2009, al 7:00 P.M., in
Council Chambers with Mayor Miller presiding. The purpose of the Public Hearing was to
consider a Zoning and Land Use change from A-2, Multi.Family Residential District to B-1
General Business, property belonging to Pruitt Properties, Inc., localed at 775 Whitman Street
nexllo Oranegburg Nursing Home, TMP# 0173-14-07-012.
City Administrator Yow noted the Public Notice and the Public Hearing by the Planning
Commission and the proper posting orproperty. He also presented the Planning Commission's
recommendation.
Hearing no comments, the Public Hearing was closed.
Council entered into the regularly scheduled meeting.
PRESENT:
Paul A. Millcr, Mayor
Charles B. Barnwell
Bemard Haire
Charles W. Jernigan
Sandra P. Knotts
Joyce W. Rheney
ABSENT:
Trelvis A. Miller
A motion was made by Coullcilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Jernigan, to
approve the March 17,2009 City Council Minutes as distributed. This motion as unanimously
approved.
Mr. Tripp Wingard and Mr. Marty Murdaugh from Murdaugh and Associates addressed Council
in regards 10 Ihe FY 2007-08 Audit for the Cily and Department of Public Utilities. Mr. Wingard
started with the OPU highlights being: Capital assets were up 4.4%, cash and investments were
down 6%, total assets were up 3.7%, net assets were up 5%, gross revenues were up 8.3% and
operating expenses were down 9.3%, this being due to higher electricity costs.
The City highlights were stated as; The General Fund balance sheets were healthy, there is
approximately six months worth of operating expenses in cash and investments. The Fund
balance decreased by 5378,000 and $380,000 was budgeted during Council sessions. Cash flow
from the Pro Shop and Hillcrest was down $4,500 excluding depreciation. There was an
operating loss al the Airport of approximately $69,000 due to budgeted expenses in moving the
T.hangar to make room for Ihe ramp expansion. This was planned and paid through the one
percent funds and the new asset has basically no debt. Airport assets were up $625,000 due to
the new hangars.
Councilmcmber Barnwell asked, "Where was the opinion if there was anything wTOng or
misrepresen tati ons?"
Mr. Wingard replied, "On page I, third paragraph, presented fairly and all material aspects."
Mr. Murdaugh also stated. "We are required to report it this way and also on page 60."
Councilmember Barnwell asked, "Do we have a clean bill of health?"
Mr. Wingard replied, "Yes."
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tem Haire, seconded by Coullcilmember Barnwell, to
approve the City's/Oepartment of Public Utilities FY 2007
4
08 Audit. This motion was
unaninlouslyapproved.
19: 0
A motion was made by CouncjJmembcr Jernigan, seconded by Councihnember Rhcney, to
approve the Third Reading of an Ordinance amending Section 24-4.4 of the Zoning Ordinances
of tile City of Orangeburg, Sc. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion as made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, approving
the ratificationof a Resolution sent to American Intemational Group, Incorporated(AIG)
concerning irresponsible actions with taxpayer's money. This motion was unanimously
approved.
Department of Public Safety Director Davis addressed Council in regards 10 the Department of
Public Safety. He advised Council that lhe Department has been reaccredited by the
Commission on Accreditation for Law Enforcement Agencies. He also notified Council that the
Agency has been awarded the Crime Prevention Unit of the Year Award and that the AFIS
machine is up and ruruling. He stated, "This machine (AFIS) which means Automated
Fingerprint Identification System, allows the Department to detect fingerprints a lot faster than
before. This is a second phase of our forensic lab." He also notified Council of the upcoming
press conference 011 Wednesday.
Mr. Lee Wiles from Miller Communications accepted the Character Trait Proclamation for the
month of April, 2009, "Loyally",
A motion as made by Mayor Pro Tem Haire, seconded by Councilmember Knotts, 10 approve a
Resolution recognizing April, 2009 as Fair Housing Month in the City of Orangeburg. This
mol ion was unanimollsly approved.
The City of Orangeburg Budget Calendar for FY 2009-2010 was received as information and
City Administrator Yow to review and this will be presented for adoption at the next Council
Meeting.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to
approve a Resolution for the Sound Financial Management of the SC Local Government Fund.
This motion was unanimously approved.
City Administrator Yow stated, "Mayor Pro Tern Haire went 10 a press conference in Columbia
and briefed Council on these cuts. Some legislators are willing 10 make large cuts to local
govcmment. No one has suggested cutting the S837.000 the City sends the state in traffic and
criminal fine assessments. I think it is wholly unfair."
Mayor Pro Tcm Haire stated, ''There is a solution."
Mayor Miller stated, "Both Senator HUllO and Senator Matthews were not in favor of the House
Bill; however, lhey felt like jfthe State was going to be cut, the cities and counties would have to
take their lump along wilh everyone else. They arc scripling us on what we can and can't do and
along with lhe millage caps."
A motion was made by Councilmcmber Rheney, seconded by Council member Jernigan, to
approve the First Reading of an Ordinance to amend the Land Use Map of the City
of Orangeburg, SC, for the purpose of changing from "Residential General District"
10 ·'Business/Commercial Dislrict" the property of Pruitt Properties, Inc. This was a 5-0-1 vote
as Mayor Pro Tem Haire abstained. This was property that was discussed in the Public Hearing.
A motion was made by Councilmcmber Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Knous, to
approve the First Reading of an Ordinance to amend Section 24-4.1, District Boundaries and
Maps of the Code of Ordinances of the City of Orangeburg, SC and the Zoning Map of the Citv
of Orangeburg. This was a 5-0-1 vole as Mayor Pro Tern Haire abstained. This was property'
thal was discussed in the Public Hearing.
A motlOn was made by Mayor Pro Tem Haire, seconded by Councilmember Rheney, to approve
the Third Reading of an Ordinance to amend the General TClms and Conditions of lhe
Department of Public Utilities.
CilY AllOnlCY Walsh stated, 'This is doing two things, it is addressing utility rates for property
partially inside and partially outside the City. They will be charged outside the city rates.
Secondly, it clarifies how we define owner in regards to annexation covenants before they can
receive waler and wastewater service. There have been no changes from the first and second
reading."
This Illation was unanimously approved 10 approve the Third Reading of an Ordinance to amend
the General Tenns and Conditions of the Department of Public Utilities.
A motion as made by Councilmemher Rheney, seconded by Mayor Pro Tem Haire, to approve a
Resolution for State Revolving Fund Loan Application for wastewater, water pollution control
revolving fund in the amount 0£S4,557,000. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tem Haire, seconded by Councilmcmber Knotts, 10 approve a
Resolution for State Revolving Fund Loan Application for water, drinking water revolving loan
fund in the amount of$I,845,000. This motion was unanimously approved.
Council member Bamwcll commended Manager Fred Boatwright in negotiating a lower interest
rale.
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilrnember Jernigan, to
adjourn. This motion as unanimously approved.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
1"14-1
~~Ub~l/iit;Jl
Carrie w. JOhnSO UI l'I
Ci'y Clerk
Ipfb
/" / -\
,,
WHEREAS,
WHEREAS,
WHEREAS,
WHEREAS,
RESOLUTION
the City of Orangeburg desires that all its citizens be afforded the
opportunity to attain a decent, safe, and sound living environment; and,
the City of Orangeburg rejects discrimination on the basis of race,
religion, color, sex, national origin, disability and/or familial status in the
sale, rental or provision of other housing services; and,
the State of South Carolina enacted the South Carolina Fair Housing Law
in 1989; and,
April is recognized nationally as Fair Housing Month.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, that the Mayor and Council, in Council
assembled, do officially recognize April as Fair Housing Month in the City of Orangeburg.
Passed By the City Council of the City of Orangeburg, State of South Carolina, this 7th day of
April 2009.
C -=¥-t-vu;~ =-~:v,1:/r--=-'
Members of Council
ATTEST ~QNuj~ ~
City Cl rk
Page 2
WHEREAS,
WHEREAS,
WHEREAS,
In accordance with existing state law the City of Orangeburg dutifully collected and faithfully
submitted to the State $693,416.15 of traffic fine assessments last year while receiving no
compensation for such collection and submission and also submitted $143,365.65 in criminal
fine assessment last year for a total of $836,781.80; and,
the city doesn't have the liberty to amend the state laws and reduce assessments given to the
State; and,
the City of Orangeburg faithfully maintains rights-of-way within its corporate boundaries on State
owned roadways and receives no compensation other than its own sense of pride; and,
NOW, THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED by the Mayor and City Council of the City of Orangeburg, in Councii duly
assembled, do wholeheartedly, willfully and dutifully petition the South Carolina General Assembly to leave the
Local Government Fund in full force and effect.
PASSED BY the City Council of the City of Orangeburg, State of South Carolina, this 7'h day of April 2009.
~~~_J
Mayor
Members of Council
A~1J.~crvJ
City Clerk
RESOLUTION
WHEREAS, the South Carolina Water Quality Revolving Fund Authority (the "State Authority")
provides low-interest loan financing for the construction of publicly owned wastewater treatment
facilities from the Water Pollution Control Revolving Fund (the "Fund") pursuant to the Federal
Clean Water Act and Title 48, Chapter 5, Code of Laws of South Carolina, 1976, as amended; and
WHEREAS, the City of Orangeburg is a legally constituted municipal corporation in the State of
South Carolina and is authorized to incur revenue debt pursuant to Title 6, Chapter 21, Code of
Laws of South Carolina, 1976, as amended; and
WHEREAS, the City of Orangeburg has determined that it is in the best interests of the City to
apply to the State Authority for a loan from the Fund;
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the City Council of the City of Orangeburg, South
Carolina (the "Council"), in a meeting duly assembled:
1. That the Council hereby authorizes Fred H. Boatwright, Manager of the Department of Public
Utilities to complete, and Paul A. Miller, Mayor of the City of Orangeburg, South Carolina to
execute and submit an application to the State Authority for a loan from the Fund in the amount
of approximately $4,557,000 to finance the costs of improving, refurbishing, rehabilitating,
repairing or replacing the City's 24"(inch), 36"(inch), and 42"(inch) wastewater interceptors
and improving, refurbishing, rehabilitating, or repairing the City's Wastewater Treatment Plant.
The Manager of the Department of Public Utilities is authorized to take such actions as may be
necessary or convenient to complete the application process.
2. That the City will grant to the State Authority a pledge of, and lien on, all revenues ofthe City's
Combined Utility System for repayment of the loan.
1i1;ayD B~ tpe City Council ofthe City of Orangeburg, State of South Carolina, this
'J\\J..., ,2009.
PAS
of
3. That the final terms and conditions ofthe loan and the loan documents shall be subject to the
approval ofthis Council.
Mayor
Members of Council
\ n pw • I I • . JV~
1+hday
Mayor
~~~ORANG(C'~
"- l::,
u i:>?U '£
* '" *
<Jl "" ~0t- ,.:;.
7"f( CA~O-.......::.:.;;
RESOLUTION
WHEREAS, the South Carolina Water Quality Revolving Fund Authority (the "State Authority")
provides low-interest loan financing for the construction of public drinking water facilities from the
Drinking Water Revolving Loan Fund (the "Fund") pursuant to the Federal Safe Drinking Water Act
and Title 48, Chapter 5, Code of Laws of South Carolina, 1976, as amended; and
WHEREAS, the City of Orangeburg is a legally constituted municipal corporation in the State of
South Carolina and is authorized to incur revenue debt pursuant to Title 6, Chapter 21, Code of
Laws of South Carolina, 1976, as amended; and
WHEREAS, the City of Orangeburg has determined that it is in the best interests of the City to
apply to the State Authority for a loan from the Fund;
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the City Council of the City of Orangeburg, South
Carolina (the "Council"), in a meeting duly assembled:
I. That the Council hereby authorizes Fred H. Boatwright, Manager of the Department of Public
Utilities to complete, and Paul A. Miller, Mayor of the City of Orangeburg, South Carolina to
execute and submit an application to the State Authority for a loan from the Fund in the amount
of approximately $1,845,000 to finance the costs of improving, refurbishing, rehabilitating,
repairing or replacing a 1O"(inch) water line on South Carolina Highway 400. The Manager of
the Department of Public Utilities is authorized to take such actions as may be necessary or
convenient to complete the application process.
2. That the City will grant to the State Authority a pledge of, and lien on, all revenues ofthe City's
Combined Utility System for repayment of the loan.
3. That the final terms and conditions of the loan and the loan documents shall be subject to the
approval of this Council.
~~-
Members of Council
A~wJQCI~
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
April 21, 2009
Orangeburg City Council held its regularly scheduled on Tuesday, April 21,2009, al 7:00
P.M., in the Council Chamber Building with Mayor Miller presiding.
PRESENT:
Paul A. Miller, Mayor
Charles B. Barnwell
Bernard Haire
Charles W. Jernigan
Sandra P. Knotts
Trelvis A. Miller
Joyce \V. Rheney
A molion was made by Councilmember Jernigan, seconded by Councilmember Rheney,
to approve the April 7, 2009, City Council Meeting Minutes. This was a 6~O vote as
Councilmember Miller was not present at the time oflhe voting, but was present for the
remainder of the meeting.
Mr. Clint Shealy, Professional Engineer with Black and Veatch, awarded the
Department of Public Utilities the winner of the Best Tasting Water Competition.
This award was presented at the SC Environmental Conference and is one of the largest
environmental conferences in the Southeast. Mr. Eric Odom and Mr. Hank Rutland from
the Water Department of the Department of Public Utilities accepted the award.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, seconded by Council member Barnwell, to
approve the City of Orangeburg Budget Calendar [or FY 2009~201O. This motion was
unanimously approved.
City Administrator Yow addressed Council in regards to amending the Land Use Map
and amending the Zoning Map for changes from Residential General District to Business
Commercial and to amend the Zoning Map. He explained these items had a Public
Hearing and the Planning Commission comments. First Reading was held previously.
Mayor Pro Tern Haire stated, "I talked to Dr. Sarah Watson Favor, she is not in favor of
the change being proposed. As Councilmembers a few years ago, there was a similar
situation where businesses were encroached in residential areas such as St. Matthews
Road and Chestnut Street. In talking with her, she is not in favor of that change; she was
going to try to get here tonight. For that reason, I will be voting against this."
City Administrator Yow asked, "Was she opposed to Business, Office-Institutional, or
any re-zoning?"
Mayor ProTem Haire replied, "As we have it, it will change to Business and she is
opposed to that."
City Administrator Yow stated, "The reason I ask is 1hat Council can turn it down and do
no re-zoning or Council can change it to Business-Commercial or Council can change it
to O~I. That might be one of the things that Council may want to consider."
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "\\'hat were her main objectives to this?"
Mayor Pro Tern Haire replied, "She did not want the business in the area; I know the
house is between the nursing home and her house. She doesn'1 want any other business
in that area,"
1943
Page 2
Mayor Miller asked, "We are only talking about onc piece ofpropeny next to the Nursing
Home which is zoned A-2?"
City Administrator Yow stated, "Yes, it's last use was a duplex,"
Councilmember Barnwell asked, "Will Office-Institutional suffice for their use?"'
City Administrator Yow replied, "Yes, they plan to use it as an office for the ursmg
Home so it should suffice."
Mayor Miller asked, "Would 0·1 be suitable with herT'
Mayor Pro Tern HaJre replied, "1 haven't discussed that with her."
A representative with Pruitt Properties, Mr. Brian Bonner addressed Council, "They are
trying to get it zoned as the same designation as the nursing home itself and usc il as a
meeting space for the nursing home and for executive office space."
Mayor Miller asked, "If we were to change it to 0-1, you could make that work within
your plans?"
The representative replied, "Yes, but it would make it much more difficult once we get
into financing down thc road, but it would work with our plan."
A motion to table items #4 and #5 was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by
Mayor Pro Tern Haire. This motion was unanimously approved.
Mr. Buster Smith addressed Council, "An Angel of Hope Project was given to Parks and
Recreation for consideration which is a monument dedicated to children who have lost
their lives by natural causes or accident. There is no current "Angel of Hope" monument
in South Carolina. This would be the first in South Carolina which would be displayed in
the Edisto Memorial Gardens. The proposed location would be close to DPU Centennial
Park on a knoll. Pavers would be installed for names and bricks also. This project was
brought to us by Mr. & Mrs. Tim Adams. A committee would be fomled in order to
solicit funds. Other opportunities for individual recognition would be for trees or
benches. This would be special because it would be the only one in South Carolina."
Mr. Tim Adams addressed Council, "Our daughter died in an automobile accident last
May and lhis would be a great project and the Gardens would be an ideal spot for this if
we could incorporate this as a concept at the Edisto Memorial Gardens."
Mayor Pro Tern Haire asked, "How many names could be added to the granite wall?"
Mr. Smith replied, "We have not gotten all of that information yet, we anticipate at least
twenty (20) on each side and also other bricks can be purchased."
Mayor ProTem Haire slaled, "I think it is a greal idea. My concern is as it relates to those
who have suffered a loss lhat cannot pay to have their loved ones name added, this would
eliminate them. If Council agrees to this, I hope the money will be there for those that do
not have the money."
Mr. Smith and Mr. Adams stated, "There will be means in place and fundraiscrs year
round."
PageJ
Councihnember Jernigan asked, "Once this is built, willlhe City be responsible for
maintenance?"
Mr. Smith replied, "Yes."
Councilmernber Rheney asked, "WiJl money be in place before this is built?"
Mr. Smith replied, "This will be an ongoing project and as funds COl11~ in we will develop
the projecl."
Mr. Adams staled, "My wife and J arc willing to donate the cost of the monument which
is about $15.000."
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "What is the cost to the City?"
Mr. Smith replied, "We will be involved in installation and landscaping to costing about
$3.000."
It was agreed that Buster Smith, P&R Director, would be a member o[the committee.
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Mayor ProTem Haire, to
adopt the concept and location and report back to Council when funds are available and
10 update us on the project.
A motion was made by Councihnember Rheney, seconded by Mayor Pro Tem Haire, 10
approve a Resolution ror Theft Protection Policy for the City and the Department of
Public Utilities. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, 10
enter into an Executive Session for a contractual matter concerning DPU's Electric
Division. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Knotts,
to return to Open Session. This motion was unanimously approved.
DPU Director Boatwright addressed Council, "On May 23,2008, we executed a Power
Purchase Agreement with Duke Energy and on March 30th of this year the North Carolina
Utilities issued an order "adverse to the agreement with respect to the "system average
generation pricing" provisions of the agreement. Duke in turn implemented the clause in
the agreements, Notice of Condition Precedent, which specifies that system average
generation pricing CalUlot be used as the basis for selling their generation services to DPU
and therefore incremenlal pricing would go into effect with commencement of the service
May 1,2009 and remain in effect until December 31, 2010.
In the meantime we received an offer from SCE&G to extend the existing contract until
December 31,2010. The present contract provides for a 3% increase in the purchase
price of electricity for 2009 and 2010. We compared the offers and detennined that it is
in our ratepayers best interest to extend the present contract with SCE&G.
1 am therefore asking that you approve a Resolution tonight authorizing me to notify
SCE&G of our intention to accept their offer to rescind its notice oftenninalion of the
present contract and to extend their service until December 31, 2010. Further, that 1
provide Duke Energy with the City of Orangeburg's fonnal notice that it is terminating
the Agreemenl for Duke to provide and Orangeburg to receive Contingent Service under
the provisions of Section 3.5.\ of the Power Purchase Agreement dated May 23,2008
between Duke Energy Carolinas and lhe City orOrangeburg ("PPA").
Page 4
This arrangement provides the best pricing for our customers and allows us the
opportunity to continue 10 explore all options open to us both legal and contractual for
our long tenll needs. I do not anticipate any immediate changes to our structure,"
A mOlion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, seconded by Councilmemher Barnwell, to
approve the Resolution for approval of Electric Purchase Agreement This motion was
unanimously approved.
A motion as made hy Councilmember Rhelley, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, to
adjourn. This motion was unanimously approved.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjoumed.
r;~~~
Carrie W. JOhnSU
UT
City Clerk
19~5
CWJ/pfb
19.17
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
May 5, 2009
Orangeburg City Council held a Public Hearing on Tuesday, May 5,2009, at 7:00 P.M., in
Council Chambers with Mayor Miller presiding. The purpose of the Public Hearings were:
1. Annexation of property to consider an application for annexation into the City of Orangeburg
property belonging to Kinder Hillcrest, LLC., for property located on St. Matthews Road for
Parcel A at TMP# 0174-14-01-010
2. Annexation of property to consider an application for annexation into the City of Orangeburg
property belonging to South Carolina Healthcare Facilities, LLC., for property at 1748 St.
Matthews Road at TMP# 0174-14-06-007
City Administrator Yow gave Council and the public an overview of the two proposed
annexations and infonned Council that the Planning Commission recommended the annexations
with the requested zoning.
Hearing no comments, the Public Hearing was closed.
Council entered into the regularly scheduled meeting.
PRESENT:
Paul A. Miller, Mayor
Charles B. Barnwell
Bernard Haire
Charles W. Jernigan
Sandra P. Knotts
Joyce W. Rheney
ABSENT:
Trelvis A. Miller
A motion was made by Councilmember Rheney, seconded by Councilmember Knotts, to
approve the April 21, 2009, City Council Minutes as distributed. This motion as unanimously
approved.
Mayor Miller recognized members of Claflin's Men's basketball team and presented the team
with a Proclamation.
City Administrator Yow notified Council that the owners of Pruitt properties asked for additional
time to meet with Council and neighbors to explain their plans.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, seconded by Councilmember Jernigan to table
items #4 and #5 until next Council meeting.
Mr. Brian Bonner and Ms. Theo Reed spoke and advised Council of their intent of the use of the
property next door as office space for the nursing home.
Chief Wendell Davis accepted the Character Trait Proclamation for the month of May 2009,
"Virtue".
City Administrator Yow advised Council of the next two items concerning the annexation. He
stated, "No one spoke at the Public Hearings that was held and all documents and minutes from
the Planning Commission were included for Council's review."
Councilmember Barnwell asked, "Once the City provides sanitation services, would the
dumpsters would be removed? They look atrocious and need to be totally redone."
19 4~age2
City Administrator Yow responded, "The owners have a choice of city service or commercial
service according to our Solid Waste Ordinance. They will probably opt for our services, but
that is not a given. Once they are annexed in the City, we'll apply our codes."
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tem Haire, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to
approve the First Reading of an Ordinance to annex property belonging to Kinder Hillcrest,
LLC., for Parcel A at TMP# 0174-14-0-010 and Parcel Bat TMP# 0174-24-07-027. This
motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilrnember Rheney, to
annex property belonging to South Carolina Healthcare Facilities, LLC., for property at 1748 St.
Matthews Road at TMP# 0174-14-06-007. This motion was unanimously approved.
There were no utility matters brought before Council.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tem Haire, seconded by Councilmember Knotts, to adjourn.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
Respectfully submitted,
(pib
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
June 2, 2009
Orangeburg City Council held its regularly scheduled meeting on Tuesday, June 2, 2009,
at 7:00 P.M., in the Council Chamber Building with Mayor Miller presiding.
PRESENT:
Paul A. Miller
Charles B. Barnwell
Bernard Haire
Charles w. Jernigan
Sandra P. Knotts
Joyce W. Rheney
ABSENT:
Trelvis A. Miller
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell; seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Haire,
to approve the May 19, 2009, City Council Minutes as distributed. This was a 5-0-1 vote
as Counci1member Rheney abstained as she was not present at the meeting.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, seconded by Councilmember Rheney, to
approve the plaza infrastructure work for the Veteran's Memorial Park in the amount of
$86,842.00 to O'Cain Construction Company, Inc. This motion was unanimously
approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Knotts,
to approve the contract for granite work for the Veteran's Memorial Park in the amount
of$148,500.00 to Carolina Granite and Marble Company. This motion was unanimously
approved.
City Administrator Yow briefed Council on the Second Reading of an Ordinance to
amend the Land Use Map of the City of Orangeburg, South Carolina for the purpose of
changing from "Residential General District" to "Business Commercial District" the
property belonging to Pruitt Properties Inc. He stated, "This item has been tabled twice
by Councilor recommendation from the owners. Just for infornlation, if Council decides
to make changes to Office Institutional instead to Business, then a land use change will
not be required."
Councilmember Barnwell made a motion to amend the Ordinance from General Business
or Business Commercial to Office Institutional, seconded by Counciinlember Jernigan.
Mayor ProTem Haire stated, ''I'd like to state my objection to the existing motion and the
substitute motion. I have taken some pictures also. The home on the right in the picture
is the home of Mrs. Sarah Washington Favor. The house in question is to the left. We
are talking about changing it to Office-Institutional. I am very concerned about changing
that neighborhood from what it has already been changed. Once you start, it creates a
domino effect. The office next to Mrs. Favor's house is something I wouldn't want next
to mine. It is going to bring in additional traffic. There is no telling what will end up in
this structure. I have talked to the owner and she is not in favor and we have talked to
representatives of the company and they have not convinced me of anything different
from my viewpoint. We should not allow further encroachment in this neighborhood and
I feel like this would. For that reason, I will be voting no to this and to the substitute
motion."
1953
1954page2
Councilmember Jernigan asked Mr. Brian Bonner from PruittProperties, "What
construction will be done to this house, will it be internal? Will you be adding any rooms
on?"
Mr. Brian Bonner replied, "All the construction will be internal, there will be no
additional parking. The parking will be at the nursing home to the left ofthe home. We
will be making some cosmetic changes cleaning up the outside. Not to my knowledge
will there be any rooms added."
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "The nursing home is immediately to the left of this
home? H
Mr. Bonner replied, "We own right up to the property line of this structure as you can see
in this picture, the parking will be at the nursing home."
City Administrator Yow stated "I am not disputing what he is saying, but I'd like to point
out that once we rezone something there are other changes that are then allowed."
Councilmember Jernigan stated, "I can't see where it is going to be detrimental to the
area at all. Who is to say what it would be 10 or 20 years from now. I would be in favor
of Office-Institutional."
Councilmember Barnwell asked, "What are the improvements going to be to the
outside?"
Mr. Bonner replied, "Just cosmetic and landscaping."
Mayor Miller asked, "The operation would be from 8-5 or 9-5?"
Mr. Bonner stated, "Yes, for the Administrator."
Councilmember Barnwell replied to Councilmember Haire, "I agree with you, but I made
the motion to change it to 0-1 because I would not want to see it go commercial or
business; I do not think this would harm the neighbor next door. I think it would if it
were commercial."
Councilmember Rheney stated, "I think you will have a lot more coming and going with
apartments."
We had a previous motion to change the Ordinance from Business Commercial to Office
Institutional.
A motion was made by Councilmember Jernigan, seconded by Councilmember Rheney,
to cancel the Second Reading of an Ordinance to amend the Land Use Map of the City of
Orangeburg, SC, for the purpose of changing from "Residential General District" to
"Business/Commercial District" the property of Pruitt Properties, Inc. The Second
Reading of an Ordinance to amend Section 24.4.1, District Boundaries and Maps of the
Code of Ordinances of the City of Orangeburg, SC and the Zoning Map of the City of
Orangeburg to change the property of Pruitt Properties Inc. to Office Institutional. This
was a 4-2 vote as Mayor Pro Tern Haire and Councilmember Knotts opposed.
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Jernigan,
to approve the Third Reading of an Ordinance to annex property on St. Matthews Road
belonging to Kinder Hillcrest, LLC for Parcel A at TMP#O174-14-01-010 and Parcel B at
TMP# 0174-24-07-027 as Multi Family Residential. This motion was unanimously
approved.
Page 3
A motion was made by Councilmember Rheney, seconded by Councilmember Jernigan,
to approve the Third Reading of an Ordinance to armex property belonging to South
Carolina Healthcare Facilities, LLC., for property at 1748 St. Matthews Road at
TMP#017414-06-007 ad commercial. This motion as unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Jernigan,
to approve the Second Reading of an Ordinance to amend the Municipal District Map
dated November 6, 2001, for the purpose of adding newly annexed City property to
Municipal Council District Two (2). This motion was unanimously approved.
Chief Wendell Davis accepted the Character Trait Proclamation for the month of June
2009, "Leadership".
A motion was made by Councilmember Jernigan, seconded by Councilmember Rheney,
to approve the First Reading of an Ordinance amending the Personnel Handbook of the
City of Orangeburg, SC., for the purpose of adopting new Federal regulations regarding
the Family Medical Leave Act (FMLA). This motion was unanimously approved.
Councilmember Barnwell made a motion, seconded by Councilmember Jernigan, to enter
into an Executive Session for a legal matter concerning the Department of Public Utilities
Wastewater Division. This motion as unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Knotts,
to return to Open Session. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Knotts, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell,
to approve a Resolution for acceptance oflow bid for Water Main Rehabilitation along
SC Highway 400 from Seaside Utilities, Inc., of Moncks Comer, SC in the amount of
$763,296.20. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Rheney, seconded by Councilmember Jernigan,
to approve a Resolution for acceptance of low bid for improvements to the Wastewater
Treatment Plant from M. B. Kahn Construction Company, Inc., in the amount of
$2,034,003.50. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Jernigan,
to approve a Resolution for acceptance oflow bid for rehabilitation of 42", 36" and 24"
Gravity Sewers from Insituform Technologies, LLC of St. Louis, Missouri, in the amount
of$1,233,672.90. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Jernigan, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell,
to adjourn. This motion was unanimously approved.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
19.)5
19SG City Council Minutes
June 16, 2009
Orangeburg City Council held a Public Hearing on Tuesday, June 16,2009, at 7:00 P.M.,
in Council Chambers with Mayor Miller presiding. The purpose of the Public Hearing
was to annex the within described property (Glenfield Apartments) Tax Map
#0174-13-05-001 into the City of Orangeburg, South Carolina
City Administrator Yow addressed City Council on the proposed annexation outlining the
process to date.
Hearing no comments, the Public Hearing was closed.
Council entered into the regularly scheduled meeting.
PRESENT:
Paul A. Miller, Mayor
Charles B. Barnwell
Bernard Haire
Charles W. Jernigan
Sandra P. Knotts
Joyce W. Rheney
ABSENT:
Trelvis A. Miller
A motion was made by Councilmember Rheney, seconded by Councilmember Jemigan,
to approve the June 2, 2009, City Council Minutes as distributed. This motion was
una1\imouslyapproved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Rheney, seconded by Councilmember Jemigan,
to approve the Third Reading of an Ordinance to amend Section 24-4.1, District
Boundaries and Maps of the Code of Ordinances of the City of Orangeburg, SC, and the
Zoning Map of the City of Orangeburg, Tax Map# 0173-14-07-012 to Office
Institutional. This was a 4-2 vote as Mayor Pro Tern Haire and Councilmember Knotts
opposed.
Mayor Pro Tem Haire asked City Administrator Yow, "How is the nursing home zoned?"
City Administrator Yow replied, "I believe it is commercial, but I'd have to check on it."
A motion was made by Councilmember Jemigan, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell,
to approve the Third Reading of an Ordinance to amend the Municipal District Map dated
November 6, 200 I, for the purpose of adding newly annexed City property to Municipal
Council District Two (2). This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councihnember Knotts, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, to
approve the Second Reading of an Ordinance amending the Personnel Handbook of the
City of Orangeburg, Sc., for the purpose of adopting new federal regulations regarding
the Family Medical Leave Act (FMLA). This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to
approve the appointment of HalTY Holman, Public Works Department employee, to the
City Grievance Committee. This is a three (3) year term expiring June, 2012. This
motion was unanimously approved.
Page 2
Concerning First Reading of an Ordinance to annex the within described property,
Glenfield Apartments, Tax Map # 0174-13-05-001 into the City of Orangeburg, South
Carolina, Councilmember Jernigan asked, "How many people live in the apartments'?"
City Administrator Yow replied, "A complete census has not been done yet, but we
estimate 250 people."
Councilmember Barnwell stated, "I have some concern about all of this annexation that
we have been doing, it is all multi-family and residentia1. Now, these annexations will
get reduced water and wastewater rates and get sanitation. I am concerned we aren't
annexing any commercial properties or businesses. This will cost us more in finances."
City Administrator Yow responded, "We have covered this in Council Work Sessions in
detail and Council has said at this time, they are taking a bigger approach to grow the city
and that we would eventually get commercial properties. One of the reasons, we also
passed the covenant language that anyone wanting water and sewer would have to sign a
covenant meaning that when they become contiguous to the City they will be
automatically annexed. In some cases, you are right; some properties coming into the
city will actually save money and some will not. I have not run the bottom line numbers
on this one. I don't know the number of cars on this one that will be paying property
taxes. We can give you the real property. That is a concern that again, I will reiterate to
Council during Budget Work Sessions."
Mayor ProTem Haire stated, "Isn't it true, in order to get where we want to be, we have
to annex to get there'?"
City Administrator Yow stated, "That is the position and philosophy that Council has
taken up to this point. As we discussed earlier, the real crucial point will come when we
will have to start adding personnel or sanitation trucks or equipment because of the
annexation. We have not had to that yet. Of course, Council tells us to annex and we
will continue to work on annexations."
Councilmember Barnwell asked, "Will this put us closer to our goaj'J"
City Administrator Yow replied, "Any annexation will do that. We are not at that point
yet. "
Mayor Miller stated, "We have been pretty dormant for a long time, we have been on a
roll now. People understand the value of being in the city."
City Administrator Yow stated, " For the record, we have annexed some small
commercial properties on Chestnut Street. Rental properties are not taxed at 4% rate, but
at 6% rate; we hope that after we do some annexations, we will have some numbers
under our belt to do better calculations. As you know when we annex a property it
doesn't go on the tax roll for another year. It will depend on the time of the annexation as
to when we actually start to collect taxes; however, their sanitation and other services
start immediately."
Councilmember Jernigan stated, "This is another reason we need an accurate census."
City Administrator Yow replied, "That is another point. We do get money from the state
on aid to subdivisions based on population. That is one of the things that have been cut
17%. lfwe annex 17% more, we are just breaking even. One thing I will point out on
this one is this company has already paid their fire contract. They wanted to know if they
were going to get a refund. We explained the tax situation and they understood that and
weren't pushing it. We have received some revenue from these apartments."
1957
Page 3
A motion was made by Councilmember Rheney, seconded by Councilmember ]ernigan,
to approve the Third Reading of an Ordinance to allnex property belonging to South
Carolina Healthcare Facilities, LLC., for property at 1748 St. Matthews Road at
TMP#017414-06-007 ad commercial. This motion as unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Jernigan,
to approve the Second Reading of an Ordinance to amend the Municipal District Map
dated November 6,2001, for the purpose of adding newly annexed City property to
Municipal Council District Two (2). This motion was unanimously approved.
Chief Wendell Davis accepted the Character Trait Proclamation for the month of June
2009, "Leadership".
A motion was made by Councilmember Jernigan, seconded by Councilmember Rheney,
to approve the First Reading of an Ordinance amending the Personnel Handbook of the
City of Orangeburg, SC., for the purpose of adopting new Federal regulations regarding
the Family Medical Leave Act (FMLA). This motion was unanimously approved.
Councilmember Barnwell made a motion, seconded by Councilmember Jernigan, to enter
into an Executive Session for a legal matter concerning the Department of Public Utilities
Wastewater Division. This motion as unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Knotts,
to return to Open Session. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Knotts, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell,
to approve a Resolution for acceptance of low bid for Water Main Rehabilitation along
SC Highway 400 from Seaside Utilities, Inc., of Moncks Comer, SC in the amount of
$763,296.20. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Rheney, seconded by Councilmember Jernigan,
to approve a Resolution for acceptance of low bid for improvements to the Wastewater
Treatment Plant from M. B. Kahn Construction Company, Inc., in the amount of
$2,034,003.50. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Jernigan,
to approve a Resolution for acceptance of low bid for rehabilitation of 42", 36" and 24"
Gravity Sewers from Insitufonn Technologies, LLC of St. Louis, Missouri, in the amount
of $1 ,233,672.90. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Jernigan, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell,
to adjoull1. This motion was unanimously approved.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
City Clerk
1955
1959
City Council Minutes
Special Meeting
July 7, 2009
Orangeburg City Council held a Special City Council meeting on Tuesday, July 7, 2009, at 12:00
Noon in the Council Chambers Building with Mayor Miller presiding.
PRESENT:
Paul A. Miller, Mayor
Bernard Haire
Sandra P. Knotts
Joyce W. Rheney
ABSENT:
Charles B. Barnwell
Charles W. Jernigau
Trelvis A. Miller
Meeting was called to order by Mayor Paul A. Miller.
Mr. John Singh, Assistant City Administrator was formally introduced to Council.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tem Haire, seconded by Councilmember Rheney, to approve
the First Reading of a Series Ordinance making provision for the Terms and Conditions of
Combined Public Utility System Revenue Borrowing of the City of Orangeburg, SC, authorized
by a Bond Ordinance of the City of Orangeburg adopted January 20,2004; approving the
financing of system improvements for the City through the borrowing of, not exceeding,
$982,514 plus capitalized interest, if any, from the State Drinking Water Revolving Loan Fund.
This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tem Haire, seconded by Councilmember Knotts, to approve
the First Reading of a Series Ordinance making provision for the Tenns and Conditions of
Combined Public Utility System Revenue Borrowing of the City of Orangeburg, South Carolina,
authorized by a Bond Ordinance of the City of Orangeburg adopted January 20, 2004; approving
the financing of system improvements for the City through the borrowing of, not exceeding,
$4,280,163 plus capitalized interest, ifany, from the State Water Pollution Control Revolving
Fund. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilrnember Rheney, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, to adjourn.
This motion was unanimously approved.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
CWJ/ptb
19CO
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
Ju1r 14, 2009
Orangeburg City Council its regularly scheduled meeting on Tuesday, July 14,2009, at
7:00 P.M., in the Council Chamber Building with Mayor Miller presiding.
PRESENT:
Paul A. Miller, Mayor
Charles \V. Barnwell
Brrnard Haire
Charles \V. Jernigan
Sandra P. Knotts
Joyce \V. Rheney
ABSENT:
Trrl\'is A. Miller
Mayor Miller recogni;:ed members of Boy SeOUl Troop 45.
A motion was made by Councilmcmber Rhcney, seconded by Council member Jemigan,
to approve the June 16,2009, mmutes as distribUled. This motion was unanimously
approved.
A molion as made by Mayor Pro Tent Haire, seconded by Councilmember Rhcney, 10
approve the July 7, 2009, Special City Council minutes as distributed. This was a 4-0-2
\'ote as Councilmembers Barnwell and Jemigan abstained because they were not present
al the meeling.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tem Haire, seconded by Councihnemher Barnwell, to
approve the Third Reading of an Ordinance amending the Personnel Handbook of the
City of Orangeburg SC, for the purpose of adopting new federal regulations regarding the
Family Medical Leave Act (FMLA). This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, seconded by Councihnember Knolts, to
approve the Second Reading of an Ordinance to annex the within described property,
Glenfield Apartments Tax Map #0174-13-05-001 into the Cily of Orangeburg, Soulh
Carolina. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion as made by Coullcilmemher Bamwell, seconded by Mayor Pro Tem Haire, to
approve the Second Reading of an Ordinance 10 amend the Municipal District Map dated
November 6, 2001, for lhe purpose of adding newly annexed eity property to Municipal
Council District Two (2). This motion was unanimously approved.
Mr. Don Tribble accepled the Proclamation Character TraIt forthe month of July 2009,
"lntegrity".
City Administrator Yow presented Council with the bid results from Ihe audit request for
proposals. The requests and reeommendalions were discussed. He stated, "I have
provided a tabu]ntion of the bid sheets and the request for proposals were sent out by the
Depanment of Public Utilities and Mr. Billy Beeks sent these requests oul from DPU. I
also provided to you a copy of an email [rom Mr. Becks recommending that we go with
the second lowest bid from J.W. Hunt. 1. W. Hunt has done the City .md DPU's audit
hefore some years ago. They have extensive utility experience and I'd like to point out
that they are S4,200.00 higher than the low bid, being $128,200.00 versus SI24,000.00.
The Thompson, Price. Scali and Adams is a firm out of North Carolina. 1believe it
makes a lot of sense to award the bid 1o a finn closer than lhat and one that has extensIve
utility auditing experience. 1concur \\1t11 the recommendation 10 award to hid 10 .I.\V.
Hunt ,.
CouncI1member 8anlwell asked, "Hasn't C. r. McGregor done our audit in the past?'·
Clly Administrator Yow replied, "They were not our past auditor, bUllhe onc prcvious to
1hat onc. As yOIl know, the- City every lhrce to five years, bids this out which is
recommended."
Councilmembcr Bamwell asked, "Why is there stlch a difference in the pricmg of
McGregor of the second and third bid"
City Admmistrator Yow replied, "Each finn decides on what their costs will he, so I
really can'1 ans''''cr that for you."
Council member BamwelJ asked, "Since they are a local company. I'd like to sec that the
husmess stay local with C.c. McGregor. Council member Rheney concurred."
Mayor Miller replied, "I wouldn't be inclined to spend another S30,000.00 particularly
since J.W. HUllt has done the audit before."
Councilmemhcr BamwelJ stated, "So has McGregor, I'd just like to keep it locaL"
COllllcilmemher Rheney asked, "Do the Hunt's havc an office in Orangeburg."
City Admllllstrator Yow replied. "No"
Mayor MJl1cr stated, "Mr. Beeks has worked with Hunt and McGregor and J assumc you
picked them because of the price?"'
Mr. Billy Becks frolll tile Depal1mell1of Public Utilities replied, "Yes."
Mayor ProTem Haire made a motion that we accept the recommendation by stan to
award the audit contract to J.W. Hunt. seconded by Council member Rheney. This
motion was unanimously approved.
A Illotion was made by Councilmcmber Barnwell, Seconded by Mayor Pro Tem Haire, to
approve the Second Reading of a Series Ordinance making provision for the Tcnns and
Conditions of Combined Public Utility System Revenue BorrowlI1g of the City
authorized by a Bond Ordinance of the City adopted January 20, 2004; approving the
financing of syslem improvements for the City through borrowing of, not exceeding,
£982,514 plus capitalized interest, if any, from the State Drinking Wmer RevolvlIlg Loan
fund. This mOllon <lS unanimously approved.
A motion as ll1<Jde by Mayor Pro Tem Haire, seconded by CoullciJmembcr Rheney. to
approve the Second Reading of a Series Ordinance making provision for the Temls and
Conditions of a Combined Public Utility System Revcnue Borrowing of the City
authorizcd by a Bond Ordinance of the City adopted January 20, 2004; approving the
financing of system improvements for the City through Ihe borrowing of, not exceeding,
54,280,163 plus capitalized interest, ifany, from the Slate Water Pollution Control
Revolving Fund. This motion was unanimously approved.
Mayor ProTem Haire asked for a moment of personal privilege. He stated, "I would like
to address some problems with SCOOT. Mrs. Hayncs who lives on Russell Slrect, and 1
believe the Public Works Department has been assisting her, lives about a block from
Maxcy Street toward Whittaker Parkway. She has had problems with drainage causing
her yard to be n00ded. Any limc it rains for a numher of days. there will he'll " to y,." of
ram in her yard and lhere :Irc drains on Maxey Street that IS supposed 10 take Ihis rain
water ofrthc street Howcver, 1have noticed that the SCDOT has placed signs on Maxcy
alerting citizens about water on the road. She needs some relief as it relates to Ihis watcr.
A couple of days after it rains, you call ride by and see what I am talking about. f would
likc Council 10 ask SCOOT to give her some relief. The line on Russell Street has
collapsed and they have 1101 solved the prohlem."
19G 1
19S2
Mayor Pro Tem Haire also stated in reference to the SCOOT. "On Russell Street and
Highway 60 I, some time ago there was an agreement, and J believe Mayor Cheatham
was here at that time, about the number of seconds as to the time the traffic ljght should
stay green. The traffic on Highway 601 (Magnolia) is continuously moving and the
traffic on Russell and Boulevard Streets has to wait. Those persons on Russell and
Boulevard Streets are just as important as those on 601. I would like for Council to ask
SCOOT to adju5tlhe cycle as it relates to the time lapsing so people can pass through. I
would hope that Council would agree that we ask City Administrator Yow to have
SCOOT to correct these problems."
A motion was made by Mayor ProTem Haire, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to
ask the City Administralor to meet with SCDOT to make corrections in the drain line on
Maxcy Streel and also \0 reduce lhe amount of wait time on Russell Street to allow
motorists less wait time and to improve traffic flow al the intersection of Russell and
f-lighway"601. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion as made by Councilmember Rheney, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Haire. to
adjourn. This motion was unanimously approved.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
CWJ/plb
~~~ORANG~<SI
t; i:>?U l
* " *
cJl "" ~0(/ V
l"f( C~~O
~
RESOLUTION
A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE MANAGER OF THE DEPARTMENT OF
PUBLIC UTILITIES OF THE CITY OF ORANGEBURG TO EXECUTE AN
AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC UTILITIES OF THE
CITY OF ORANGEBURG AND THE SOUTH CAROLINA ELECTRIC & GAS
COMPANY, INC. FOR THE PURPOSE OF FURNISHING ELECTRIC CAPACITY
AND ENERGY
BE IT RESOLVED By the Mayor and Members of Council of the City of Orangeburg, South
Carolina, in Council assembled, and by authority of the same;
That the Department of Public Utilities, the City of Orangeburg and South Carolina Electric &
Gas Company, Inc. enter into an agreement extending an existing agreement for furnishing
electric capacity and energy between South Carolina Electric & Gas Company, Inc. and the City
of Orangeburg ending December 31, 2012;
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, by the Mayor and Members of Council of the City
of Orangeburg, in Council assembled, and by authority of the same, that the agreement be
accepted; and
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that Fred H. Boatwright, Manager of the Department of Public
Utilities, be authorized and he is hereby directed to execute the contract documents on behalf of
the Department of Public Utilities and the City of Orangeburg.
RESOLVED BY City Council duly assembled this 18th day of August 2009.
~-t',~.~ t
Z" ~ /'~~----
~~~{ft~~W~
.,MAYO/ r-'l-L/
~/\T~
MEMBERS OF COUNCIL
Q
~1)TEST{ /I.
~l{{fJ)i~
ITYCLERK )
1953
MINUTES
City Council Budget Workshop
July 28,2009
Orangeburg City Council held a Budget Workshop Meeting 011 Tuesday, July 28, 2009, at 5:30
P.M. in the City Council Building.
PRESENT:
Paul A. Miller, Mayor
Bernard Haire
Joyce W. Rhellcy
Sandra P. Knotts
Charles B. Barnwell
Charles W. Jcmigan
John H. Yow, City Administrator
John D. Singh, Assistilnt City Administrator
Carrie W. Johnson, Finance Director
Fred Boatwright, DPU Manager
Mike Sells, DPU Administration Manager
Phil Sarata, T&D
ABSENT:
Trclvis A. Miller
City Administrator Yow briefed Council on our medical/dental plan insurance and what we have
spent on insurance in the last len years. He overviewed our relationship with SCLGAG and what
benefits they have provided to us. He then turned the meeting over to Mike Sells from the
Department of Public Utilities.
Mr. Mike Sells, Administration Manager n·om the Department of Public Utilitics, addressed
Council and provided i.l power point presentation on the recommendations from the City and tbe
Department of Public Utilities on health/dental insurance, retiree's coverage. GASB 45 and
future post employment benefits. (See Anached Presentation).
A discussion was held on quotes and insurance agents and guaranteed rates for insurance and
where we started and where we are now with our current carrier.
Rates were discussed on SCLGAG self insured, SCLGAG modified pool and Blue Cross/Bluc
Shield.
Councilmembcrs were asked to think on the presentation and come back with questions the ncxt
night.
City Administrator Yow went over the year end projections for FY 2008-09 for the General
Fund, Airport, Hillcrest and Pro Shop. He stated, "We anticipate using $] 24,480 of cash reserve
to balance the budget. This also included capital cuts, holding scveral posilions open during the
year and CUllingcosts across the board.
Meeting was adjoumed.
Respectfully submitted,
iaX~),~YWlff\.)
Carrie W. JOh~'J:f V
City Clerk
C\VJ/plb
MINUTES
City Council Budgel Workshop
July 29, 2009
Orangeburg Cuy ('ouncil held a Budget Workshop MccllIlg on W('dn~sday. July 29, 2009. at 5:30 !l M .
III the City Council Bulldmg_
PRESENT:
Paul A. MilleT. Mayor
Bernard Haire
Joyce W. RhcDC)'
Sandra P. Knotts
Charles B. Harm\ ell
Charles W. Jernigan
John H. Yow, City Administrator
Johu D. Singh, Assistant City Administrator
Carrie W. Johnson, Finance Director
Phil Sarata. T&O
A8SENT:
TT('h'i~ A. Miller
elly Adnl1lllstrator YO\\ asked COUllclllftherc were any questions on last mght's presentation or any
datil
Projected yenT end summary for FY 2008·09 wa~ mentioned [rom the nigh! before. A $400,000 fund
balance was budgeted. We projected usmg $124,480 fund balance. To accomplish thIs we deferred
many capllnlltcms and left pOSillOllSunfilled. An Exccu1JvCSummary was passed out by the City
Adm1l11strator 10 all In attendance and wenl over all revenue and expendIture hlghllghls and noted that at
present we aJ1lJClpale using S234,479 m cash reserve to balance the FY 2009-10 Budget. Note· ThIS
was later adjusted to 5355,80710 cover cost ofaddmg a fire lru.:k.
The Revenues were htghilghtcd In dctailnotlng Ihal [here was a 3 mill tax mcreasc, a 3.8% mcreasc 111
commerCial sam tallon, an Jncrease III buslllcss bccnsc penal lies and an mcrease III penalties found
work1l1g wuhout a becnsc, as well as a S.50/S1.00 increase in cart fees at HIllcrest Golf Course.
TOTAL GENERAL FUND BUDGET $16,342,088 Revenues
$16,342,088 Expenditures
• Includes Operational and General fund C"pital
Docs nol include 2% Hospitality/Accommodations or County Capital 1%, which arc separate
runds
REVENUE HIGHLIGHTS
3 mill tax increase, SIOO,OOO(NOll': Rollback 4 mills last year to 87 mills for this year)
InlereSl income down $300 - S400,000
No Fire Conlract Fee increase
No Business License rate increase/increase in penalties
Increase in Commercial Solid Waste Fee-County increased Tipping Fee
10 change in Residential Solid Waste Fee
No change in DPU Transfer
5234,479 Cash Reserve Budgeted-later adjusted 105355,807
AccommodalionsIHospitality Tax Flat
Several hangars stilI vacanl; fuel sales down
$1.00 per round increase in cart fee
Reduction in Local Government Fund S75,OOO
Industrial Tax Reassessmel1l S60,OOO reduction
EXPENDITURE HIGHLIGHTS
Continue with residential recycling
Continue with Commercia! Solid Waste colleclJon
No cost of living raises
No merit raises
No furloughs or layoffs
Change Health Insurance Provider
No new positions
CUi seven (7) positions City wide
Counly Increased Solid WaSLe Fee
lJLilitycosLS incr..:ascd
Moved several items to Hospilalily/AccollllllodaLions Fund
Transferred S 190,000 to General Fund from HospitaliLy/Aecommodmions Fund
Very small capital funding- approximately $250,000
No fire trucks/garbage trucks/sweepers
H.we held or reduced most line items for several years
Fuel costs stabilized for now
Have nol addressed GASB 45
Lease purchase for approximately 5225,000
CAPITAL EQUIPMENT
Police Cars
Pick-ups
Lawn Movers
Tractor
Garage Vehicle Lin
Trailer
Copiers
No Fire Truck, Garhage Truck, Sweeper, Dump Trucks, Backhoes
Councilmember Bamwell asked about the Industrial Park and the Chamber Building.
City AdminlstralOr Yow noted that a fire truck is needed and it could possibly be funded by a
granl; however, we would like lo include it in this year's budget. He stated we could add the
money to capital and for other financing and it would increase our cash reserve numbers needed
to balance budget, approximately $125,000.00. If we did not need it, we wouldn't. All of
Council was in agreement with this
It was discussed also thaL there W::IS 110 cost of living lIlerease budgeted in Lhis budget year and
from our records since 1988; there has been a cost of living increase. There wcre no merits
budgeted; howe\'er. we have not implemented any furloughs or layoffs.
An overview oCtile capilal equipmenl thaI is anticipated to be purchased was presented. Allof
Council was in agreemenL with the budget as prcscnted. The 2% Capital/OperaLing Fund was
also discllssed.
MeeLing was adjoumcd.
Respectfully submitted.
(Jt:::W~&JUryJ
City Clerk
1935
CWJ/plb
i9SG
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
Augusl 4, 2009
Orangeburg City Council held its regularly scheduled meeting on Tuesday, August 4,
2009 at 7:00 P.M., ill the Council Chamber Building.
PRESENT:
Paul A. Miller~ Mayor
Bernard Haire
Charles \-V. Jernigan
Joyce \V. Rheney
ABSENT:
Sandra P. Knotts
Trclvis A. Miller
Charles \V. Barnwell
A mOlion was made by Councillllcmber Jernigan, seconded by Councilmember Rhcncy,
to approve the July 14, 2009, City Council Minutes as distributed. This motion was
unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tem Haire, seconded by Councilmember Jemigan, to
approve the Third Reading of an Ordinance to annex the within described property,
Glenfield Apartments Tax Map # OI74-I3~05-001 into the City of Orangeburg, Sc. This
motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, seconded by Councilmember Rheney, to
approve the Third Reading of an Ordinance to amend the Municipal District Map dated
November 6, 2001, [or the purpose of adding newly annexed city propc11y to Municipal
Council District Two (2)
Cily Administrator Yo\\, addressed Council, "As you know this item, the permanent
closure of Gibsoll Street has been on prior agendas, November 18, 2008 and February 17.
2009. There were questions from City Council such as encroachment pcnllits, DOT's
review and some agreement with SI. Paul's Methodist Church to work out a driveway 10
be cut and the driveway to be lI1stallcd by the County. 1have attached the enlire file for
you to review. In keeping with state law the County filed legal papers to close the street
and Atlomey Walsh states we have not consented to this. If the City elects to consent to
thIS it needs to be contingent on an amended utility right-oC-way for DPU. Attorney
Walsb has infOlllled me that we do hav!: a signed utility right-away and it does need to be
amended. DPU Manager Boatwright is aware of this.
Councilmel11ber Jernigan asked, "If the City Attomcy has to do an amendment, should
we wait?"
City Attorney Walsh replied. "r can handle Lhis with the court if Council gIves the
consent. lfwe don't get the right-of-way, we won't consent."
Mayor MilIcI' stated, "It is time for us to move on with this; it has drug on long enough
wiLh the provision that the CJty Administrator's documentation will meet al1 the
necessary requirements."
Mayor Miller made a motion to grant the closure of Gibson Street upon the condition thai
the City gets an acceptable uLility right-of-way on behalf of the Department of Public
Utilities. This motion was seconded by Couneilmember Rheney and unanimously
approved.
Mayor Miller stated, "We could have had this done a year ago jfthe County would have
done what they should have done and this is what Judge Jimmy Williams told them to do,
to file a lawsuit and follow procedures and they did 110t. In Lhe spirit of coopcration
between Ih~ City and the.: County, 1am pleased that we arc moving rorward with this and
that we can move on to morc important things. I have talked with the church and they arc
satisfied with the fifieclI foot (IS') one·way driveway."
Mr. Don Tribble, Director of Community of Character, accepted tilt.: August 2009
Proclamation, ··Supportive".
City Administrator Yow addressed Council in regards to the City's Amended Budget for
FY 2008-09. He Slated, "We 3J11icipateusing $124,480 in fund balancc this year; we
budgeted 5400,000. As you know, we did not purchase all of our capital items that were
budgeted this year; we held positions open and cut costs. We wil1 continue to monitor
Ihe expenses the lastlwo months."
A motion was made by Councilmember Rheney, seconded by Mayor Pro Tem Haire, to
appro\'e the Firsl Reading of an Ordinance amending the Budget for the City of
Orangcburg, SC for fiseal year beginning October 1,2008 and ending September 30,
2009. This motion \Vas unanimously approved.
City Administrator YO\\r addressed Council ill regards 10 the City Budget for FY 2009-10.
He highlighted the revenue and expenditure. He stated, "As Council knows there is a
thorough article in the Times (lnd Democrat today that discusscs most oftllis, but I will
go over it once 1110re. We are proposing a three (3) mill tax increase, which amounts to
almost $100,000.00. As you know last year, we rolled back four 4 mills. We were at 88
last year. With 3 mill increase we will bc at 87 mills. There is no fire contract increase
111 this budgct. Some of tile things that have affected the budget are the decrease in
investment income of almost $400,000.00. There is no business license rate increase, but
there will be an increase in penalties am] we hope not to collect any penalties. There is
an increase in the commercial solid waste fee due to the County increasing the lipping
fee. There is no change in the residential sanitation rates and no change in the DPU
transfer. There has beell a reduction in the Local Govcmmcnt rund from the state,
resulting ill a S75,000.00 revenue cut. There is a proposed rate increase in the Hillcrest
GolrCourse for can fees by S 1.00 for 18 holes. Going Ihrough the expenditure
11lghlights, we discussed whether to continue curbside recycling and commercial
sanitalion. We have left those scrvlces in our budget. There are no cost~of.llving
II1creases or merit increases in Ihis budget; however, there are no layoffs or furloughs.
This has bccn the lirst time in over twenty-two years thaI there is no eost-of- Jiving
budgeted. There arc no new positions proposed and in faci we have eliminated seven
vacant positions in lhis budget. We do anlicipate making substantial changes to our
health insurance plan. This year we have a very small capital funded, about $775,000.00,
which S550,000.OO is a fire truck in which we added in case we need to be prepared to
buy. We have had very small capitallhe last two years. We continuc wilh the
Hospitality & Accommodation Tax Fund being flat but not decreasing that list is in your
budget book. We do anticipate using £355,807 in cash reserve."
COllllcilmelllbcr .1cmigan commented that wc have a good staff that has proven their
merit and risen to the top with \'ery little to work with, , commend you and thank you.
A motion as made by M::lyor Pro Tcm Haire, seconded by Councilmcmbcr Rheney, to
approve the First Reading of an Ordinance to raise revellue and adopt a Budget for the
City of Orangeburg, SC for the fiscal year beginning October 1,2009 and ending
September 30. 2010. This motion was unanimollsly approved.
A motion as made by Couneilmember Jemigan, seconded by Mayor Pro Tem Haire, [0
appoint Joscph Keill and Frances Faulling to a lhree (3) year term 011 the Hillcrest
Commission and Lynette Rhoad and Marion Moore to a two (2) year term on the
Hillcrest Commission. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by COlllleilmember Jemigan. seconded by Mayor Pro rem Haire, to
approve the Third Reading of a Series Ordinance making provision for the Terms and
/947
Conditions of Combllled Public Utility System Rcvcnue BOITowing of the City
,luthonzcd by a Bond Ordinance of the City adopted January 20, 2004; approving the
Jin<lnclllg of system improvcments for thc City through borrowing of, not excecding,
$982,514 plus capitalizcd interest, if ,my, from the Slate Drinking Water Revolving Loan
Fund. This motion was unanimously approved.
A mollon was madc hy Mayor Pro Tem Haire and Coullcilmcmber Rhcney, to approve a
Third Reading of a Series Ordinance making provision for the Tenns and Conditions of
a Combined Public Utility System Revenue Borrowing of the City authorized by a Bond
Ordinallcl.' orthe City adopted January 20,2004; approving the financing of systcm
IInprovclllcnts for the City through the bon'owing of, not exceeding, $4,280,163 plus
capitalized interesl, irany, from the Stale Waler Pollution Control Revolving Fund. This
motion was unanimously approved.
A motion \vas made by Mayor Pro Tem Haire, seconded by Councilmcmhcr Jernigan, to
cnh:r Into an Executivc Session concerning thc Administration Departlllent and the
purchase of rc;:a! propcrly. ThIS motion was unanimously approved.
~=~~i£~,
Carrie W. Johnson
City Clerk
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
SPECIAL SESSION - AUGUST 12, 2008 19~9
Orangeburg City Council held a Special Session Meeting on Tuesday, August 11, 2009,
at 5:30 P.M. in Ihe Assembly Room of the Departmenl of Public Utilities, 1016 Russell
Street with Mayor Paul A. Miller presiding. Michael G. Sells gave an invocation.
PRESENT: Paul A. Miller, Mayor
Bernard Haire, Mayor Pro Tem
Charles B. Barnwell
Charles W Jernigan
Sandra P. Knolts
Joyce W. Rheney
ABSENT: Trelvis A. Miller, Sr.
Mayor Miller opened the meeting by thanking everyone for attending the special called
meeting in August to discuss the Department of Public Utilities budget.
Mayor Miller requested the order of items on the agenda be changed and that Council
consider the Executive Session items first. Mayor asked for a motion to go into
Executive Session to discuss the purchase of real property and a contractual malter
with the Electric Division and then return to open session. A motion was made by
Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Rheney. This motion was
unanimously approved
After Execulive Session Mayor Miller asked for a motion to return to regular session. A
motion was made by Councilmember Rheney, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell
This motion was unanimously approved.
Mayor Miller asked O. Thomas (Tommy) Miller, Director of the Gas Division to come
forward. Mayor Miller stated to Director Miller that he noticed in the newspaper that he
had been named Chairman of the American Public Gas Association. He congratulated
Director Miller. Mayor Miller stated over the years DPU has had numerous Directors
who have taken active rolls in various Divisions and he felt this was a credit to DPU.
Director Miller thanked the Mayor for his kind words and stated he felt Ihe real credit
goes to City Council and Manager Boatwright and thanked them for their support and
for their trust. Manager Boatwright also congratulated Director Miller and added that
this Director Miller is the lirsl South Carolinian to serve as the Chairman of the
American Public Gas Association. A copy of the first article written by Director Miller
was giving to Council. Manager Boatwright also brought to Council's attention an article
written by John B. Bagwell, Director of the Electric Division that was published in the
Transmission Distribution Magazine a few months ago. He informed Council that the
article was about DPU's distribution automation system and reminded them that it was
a capital project presented in last year's budget.
The meeting was then turned over to Fred H. Boatwright, Manager of the Department of
Public Utilities.
Summary of Budget Presentation &
Proposed Electric & Water Rate Changes
Fred Boatwright to Mayor and Council
Manager Boatwright expressed 10 Mayor and Council thai he wished to present to Ihem
a proposed bUdget for the Cily of Orangeburg's Department of Public Utilities for Fiscal
Year 2009-2010. Manager Boatwright said on a personal note this has been the most
difficult budget that he has tried to put logether in his tenure as Manager of Ihe
Departmenl of Public Utilities. He slated the proposed budget reflecls changes in the
cost of purchased power per our purchase agreement and amendments with South
Carolina Electric and Gas Company, anlicipated cosl of natural gas off the market and
the increased costs of providing water and wastewater services.
He stated decreased sales in all four of the Department's utility services is a reality in
this current fiscal year mainly caused by a severe drop in Industrial sales. The
Department anticipales this trend to continue into Fiscal Year 2009-2010. Manager
Boatwright stated the Department's growth is static or negative, and decreased sales
mean decreased revenues. He also stated business is down approximately 17% from
last year. This bUdget reflects anticipated changes as follows:
Electric Division - The Eleclric Division anticipates an approximate 7% decrease in
sales, even though our contractual purchase costs are 3% higher than last year
r
($68-million dollars projected in the upcoming year as compared to $72-million dollars
projected as present fiscal year). These predictions are based on stable fuel costs of
19 -;' ~proximately $32/mega watt hours. The Department cannot predict fuel costs because
fuel costs that we incur from our supplier are a direcl pass through 10 our customers, so
the net effect on our bottom line is zero. He explained Ihat this can and does have a
significant impact on the price our customers have to pay. He stated the good news is
that he does not does n01 anlicipate any changes in our electric rates in this coming
year.
Gas Division The Gas Division is predicting a negative growth of 8.9% in sales based
on the present rates ($15.5 million dollars in 2008-2009 as compared to $14.1 in 2009
2010, but anticipates the income will remain relatively stable because of a rate change
that he is proposing in this bUdget for natural gas. Manager Boatwright recommended a
rate increase a 5.9% for natural gas for the Department's residential customers. He
stated this proposed rate will change the average residential customer's bill (this is
based on 75 therms) by $4.88/month. He stated the last rate change for the Natural
Gas Division was in 2002 and even with the proposed increase, the Department will
remain among the lowest cost providers of this service in the Slate.
Manager Boatwright outlined a summary of proposed natural gas rate changes by
cuslomer class: Residential (5.9% increase) Commercial (7.3% increase) and Firm
Industrial (6.7% increase). This will generate approximately $600,000 over the next
year.
Water Division - The Department is predicting a negative growth in the Water Division
of approximately 11.8% due to loss of sales in all categories, but primarily in the
industrial sector. The cost of operating and maintaining our water system continues to
rise. The rapidly increasing costs are primarily due to increased chemical costs,
depreciation costs and regulatory changes. Manager Boatwright stated he is requesting
a 5% increase in water rates for customers inside the city limits and an increase in the
outside rates to keep them twice the inside rales. This will mean an increase of
$0.57/month for our inside the cily customers and $1.14/month for our oulside city
customers. Even with the proposed rate increases, we wlJl remain among the lowest
providers of this service in the State and well below the State average in both cases
Manager Boatwright stated that he hopes business will pick up and that these trends
are going to reverse, but that he cannot predict this.
Wastewater Division - The Wastewater Division is anticipating an approximate 4%
negative growth compared to the actual of 2007-2008 01 $4.6 million dollars to $4.2
million dollars under the current rates projected for 2009-2010 which are spread across
all customer categories but again primarily in the industrial sector. The cost of
operations continues to increase (anticipated 2% higher than inflation). This is mainly
due to the aging infrastructure at the Wastewater Treatment Plant. He reminded
Council that they already authorized the Department to enler into an SRF Loan to rehab
the 30-year old facility, which hopefully over time will help decrease and off-set some of
these costs He stated that in the recent past Ihe Department was able to off-set
increased cost with customer growth, a trend that lately we are seeing reversed. The
Department actually has fewer wastewater customers and fewer water customers than
we had a year ago at this time. The Department does anticipate a negative customer
growth in the coming year. Included in the budget ordinance for this year is a proposed
5% increase in wastewater rates for inside the City customers and an increase of the
outside the City cuslomers rales to make them and keep them twice the inside rates.
The proposed rate will increase by $0.80/month for our inside the City customer's bill
and $5.20/month to our outside the City customer's bill. He explained the last time the
Departmenl changed rates was in 2006. We did not double the rates for wastewater on
the service charge, but did on the commodity charge. The Department is correcting this,
and this explains why the outside city customers is higher than the inside city
customers.
Mayor Miller asked if this would affect everybody, homeowners, and commercial.
Manager Boatwright replied, yes this will affect everybody, because everybody pays a
service charge.
.,.,"""".""".,.,.,.,.,.,.. .,.,., "...,.,.,.,.,,,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.. ., """.,.,.,.,
Manager Boalwright stated in summary, the proposed budget for the Capital Projects
for Fiscal Year 2009-2010 is going to be 42% less than last year. He staled compared
to the last ten (10) years, that we are proposing subslantially less, because we have
less. The Department's interest income is down from what it was over the past year
and that is because there is less money in the bank and less interest drawing on that
money. The Department anticipates no tap or impact fee changes, or other
administrative fees changes. No cost of living raises or merit raises are proposed. The
Department does not anticipate any layoffs or furloughs and this is a good thing. We
are not going to add any new positions In the coming year and the Departmery. 9 1
anticipates major changes in our health insurance plans, both for our active employee~ 7.
and for our retirees to economize and reduce our GASB liability.
Manager Boatwright stated there is one (1) new capital project each anticipated for the
Electric and Water Divisions and there is one (1) carry over project each for the
Administrative, Natural Gas and Wastewater Divisions (which you have already
approved).
He explained that when you approve bUdgets, these capital expenditures are not
always spent that year. Some of them, such as the current Wastewater Project have
been going on now for three years. We have spent very little money on il, because we
jusl did not have the money available, and that is the same this year. We try to
exercise good jUdgment and spend only when we have the money. He further
explained that he feels this is a sound and responsible budget proposal that does
unfortunately have some rate increases. He expressed no one hales rate increases as
much as he does, but that Council trusts him to run a business for them and that it is his
job to recommend what he feels is best for that business. He stated no cost of living or
merit increases for our employees; Significantsavings from changes in health insurance
coverage and a 42% reduction in proposed capital spending will help to continue to
provide the Department with the resources necessary to continue to meet its obligations
of:
1 Providing our customers with the best possible service at the lowest possible rate
2. Providing a reasonable return on investment for the City of Orangeburg and the
citizens
3. Maintaining and investing in our utility infrastructure to meet the challenges of the
future
The meeting was then turned over to the Director of each Division Lo give a brief
summary of each Division's projects.
Administrative Division..
Electric Division.... , .
Gas Division... . .
Water Division...
Wastewater Division _ .
Michael G Sells, Director
John B Bagwell, Director
.... O. Thomas Miller, Director
D. Eric Odom, Director
Richard M. Labrador, Director
ADMINISTRATION DIVISION PROJECT
Project #1 - Administrative Communications Improvements
Total Project Cost: $ 350,000
Expenditures to Date: S 0
Estimated 2009·2010 Cost: $ 350,000
Administrative Division Director Michael G. Sells presented the continuation of an
approved/ongoing project. He stated the purpose of this project is to improve the
Department's existing network and telephone system for enhanced custom service and
redundant protection. The Department's telephone system is ten years old and while
functional it has two serious deficiencies. First, II lacks the ability to monitor call
availabilily. The improved system will allow key personnel such as the receptionist,
customer service supervisor and secretaries to monilor telephone traffic so they can be
routed properly. Second, the system has no redundant protection. If the Department
were to lose the lelephone system or the main office to a catastrophic event, all
facilities of the Department could be without telephones for weeks. The improved
system will allow all telephone traffic to be routed within hours to Ihe Operation Cenler
on Sprinkle Avenue, which has space, compulers and telephones to continue
connectivity to customers. The cost of this projecl is $350,000. These funds mayor
may not be spent in the upcoming year.
Mayor Pro Tern Haire asked "with this new system how much more automation, and is
there going to be live body and live voice"? Director Sells replied, uno changes in
automation is expected from the customer's point of view, we actually want to have
monitoring to make sure we have enough agents always available, so that they can get
live bodies answering. We are not planning on giving a number of menus where you
choose one and then one again and one again, it will be the same level of automation
that we have now, and we want to make sure there are plenty of people to answer the
phone. At the present time, we are blind, we cannot see how many people are
available to answer calls",
Mayor Miller asked "how many phones do we have". Director Sells answered, "150
phones, it is a very complicated phone system. We have 23 trunks and we Just ordered
1972.23. more to relieve the congestion. T~ere a~,e many days on Monday mornings and
. Friday afternoons that all 23 trunks are tied up .
ELECTRIC DIVISION PROJECTS
Project #1 - Medium Voltage Breaker and Relay Replacement
Total Project Cost: $ 910,000
Expenditures to Date: $ 0
Estimated 2009-2010 Cost: $ 710000
Electric Division Director John B. Bagwell presented one (1) new proposed project He
stated the project is to improve the Electric Division's substation and distribution ptant
by upgrading the existing substations with electronically controlled relays and breakers.
The rationale behind this is that the substations located in and around the City are
extremely old. The equipment in Substations #2, #4, #5, #6, #7, and #9 is vintage late
1950's and early 1960's. The equipment at Substations #1 and #12 was put In service
in the late 1960's. This dates the equipment in each substation to an average of over 50
years old. Changes in operating procedures, new regulations and maintenance costs
have and continue to challenge DPU personnel to keep these older pieces of
equipment in service. With the average age of the equipment over 50 years, parts are
becoming more and more rare and expensive to find. New regulations dealing with
personnel protection has forced the Electric Division to change restoration plans and
marntenance plans. Compliance with regulations on safety tagging such as hot line tag
cannot be achieved using the existing equipment.
The Electric Division plans to replace all relay and breaker equipment in the substations
previously mentioned. The Electric Division will write specifications and bid documents
in house to eliminate outside consultant fees. The Electric Division will also use its
personnel for the removal of the old and installation of the new equipment where
possible. The Department plans to stage the installation over the next 12-months. The
cost associated with this project is $910,000. The estimated cost including material,
equipment and labor for the 2009-2010 fiscal year is approximately $710,000.
Councilmember Joyce Rheney asked "what will be done with the $200,0007" Director
Bagwell replied "sometimes a project wilt take longer than the fiscal year. We feet this
project is going to lake 12-months, and we don't think we will spend all the funds during
this fiscal year. These funds may be carried over to the next fiscal year"
Mayor Miller asked "what witl the Department do with the scrap, will we sell it for
saivage value?" Director Bagwell replied "we could sell the otd items as scrap metal, but
the equipment is 1950's and 1960's and I don't think anyone wants the equipment, so I
think it is all scrap metal. We will check because some of the parts are valuable and it
is possible we will sell the contacts and relays".
GAS DIVISION PROJECTS
Project #1 - Natural Gas Service Big Buck Boulevard
Total Project Cost: $ 610,000
Expenditures to Date: $ 0
Estimated 2009-2010 Cost: $ 610 000
Gas Division Director O. Thomas Miller (Tommy) presented the continuation of an
approved/ongoing project. He stated the project involves constructing 15,200 feet of 6
inch high-pressure gas main on Big Buck Boulevard. The benefits of this project are to
provide gas to the rear of the County/City Industrial Park. It will also provide gas to
another proposed industrial site and also be an immediate benefit that would serve a
very large poultry operation which presently uses propane gas, but is interested in using
natural gas. This customer would be an almost immediate customer on this line. The
cost of the project is $610,000 and the Department mayor may not spend this during
thiS fiscal year.
Mayor Pro Tem Haire asked "what would be the determining factor as to whether or not
this will be spent during this fiscal year7" Director Miller replied "whether we have the
money to spend or not" He further slated that last year the Department did not feel it
could spend the funds and that is why it is here again this year.
1973
WATER DIVISION PROJECTS
Project #1 - Relocation and UDarade Highway 4/400 Booster Pump Station
Total Project Cost: $ 950,000
Expenditures to Date: $ 0
Estimated 2009-2010 Cost: $ 950,000
Water Division Director Eric Odom slated the Water Division has one (1) new project for
Ihe upcomin9 fiscal year; the relocation and uP9rade of the Highway 4/400 Booster
Pump Station, This is the second phase in a two-phase project. The first phase of this
project which was approved last year was the installation of a new 12-inch ductile iron
water main that is being installed along Highway 400, The Department was able to
obtain SRF funding for thai phase of the project, which now allows us to work on the
second-phase in the upcoming fiscal year, The purpose of this projecl is two-fold: one
is to provide additional finished water capacity to Ihe Bolentown pressure zone; two is
to provide improved reliability to all of our customers, both retail and wholesale, served
by the Bolentown pressure zone,
Director Odom went on to explain the ever increasing demands due to growth and
projections contained within the Water Supply Master Plan and more recent the West
Orangeburg Water Study, and the need for additional capacity for the Bolentown
pressure zone. The coverage area of Ihe Bolentown pressure zone is much larger than
the Department's other pressure zones. Currently served by the Bolentown pressure
zone is not only the Town of Cope and Cordova, but also approximately 2,700 services
in this territory and it also serves the Department's two wholesale customers (Town of
Norway and Silver Sprin9s Water District). Additionally, the existing booster pump
station that supplies the water to the Bolentown tank has reached its maximum
pumping capacity and its useful design life.
The situation is further complicated by the fact that the suction line supplying the
Booster Pump Station is also insuffiCient to keep up with the growth and demand in Ihe
area, a situation which critically limits the development of additional capacity through
the pump station and through the delivery systems to the tank,
The overall master plan for the elimination of existing problems in the system and
provisions for continued growth has two major phases: first is increasing the reliability
and capacity of the delivery system to the tank, which is about to begin, and thai is the
12-inch ductile iron water main that is along Highway 400 and the second is adding
additional pumping capacity at the same lime while addressing the inadequacies of the
suction side of the existing pump station,
The plan for the second phase of this project is to relocate the two existing pumps
presently located at the intersection of Highway 4/400, With the relocation of the two
existing pumps and providing for the future addition of a third pump will allow for an
increase in pumping capacity by relocating the pump station to a lower elevation and
prior to the high point of the suction line we are in turn able to correct the suction side
issues of the pump station while increasing its pumping capacity. The total cost of this
project is 5950,000, which we mayor may not spend in the upcoming fiscal year.
WASTEWATER DIVISION PROJECTS
Project #1 - Whitford Stage Creek Pump Station Upgrade
Prolect Cost: $1,125,000
Expenditures to Date: $ 50,852
Estimated 2009-2010 Cost· $1,074,148
Wastewater Division Director Richard M. Labrador presented no new projects for the
upcoming fiscal year and one (1) continuation, the Whitford Stage Creek Pump Station
Upgrade. He explained this project consists of approximately 2-miles of 16-inch force
main and some pump stalion modifications to accommodate the flows associated with
the expansion and growth in the Whitford Stage Creek Pump Station drainage area.
The total project cost is approximately $1,125,000 of which $51,000 has been spent.
The tolal cost remaining is 51,074,000 all of which maybe spent during the upcoming
fiscal year.
Mayor Miller stated "we have been talking about this for a number of years, how much
of this, if any, is tied to the "penny"? Manager Boatwright answered "the growth of the
gravity sewer system in this drainage basin has been significantly increased due to
"penny projects". You must remember that this particular drainage area goes from the
hospital around the Belleville Road and Easlwood Acres and Highway 33. This is a
huge area and as you know there has been significant increase in our gravity sewer
services in the Belleville Road area particularly due to the "penny projects". The
commercial growth that has occurred al Ihe 1-26 1601 interchange is also a significant
amount and all that discharges into this pump station. Mayor Miller stated that it seems
like we have been hearing about this for four or five years. Manager Boatwright replied,
197 4es you have, this is the third year and hopefully we will be able to move on.
Mayor Pro Tem Haire asked Manager Boatwright, ·when you present to us a project
with a projected cost and we for whatever reason do not get this project on the way are
we absorbing large amounts of additional funds due to inflation and the cost of things,
how does that work"? Manager Boatwright replied "sometimes that is the case, recently
construction for this kind of operation has actually declined. As you recall, we have
been getting very good costs on the last couple of jobs that have been brought to you,
but you are right, over the long haul sometimes the costs do go up, but again I have to
make judgment decisions every year based on the cash flow of what I think we can fund
and can't fund and sometimes make critical decisions of what I think is the most
important. Hopefully we are going to get this job done, at least a substantial portion of it
in the coming year. The money we have spent so far has been primarily for
engineering and rights-ol-way".
This Completed the Presentation of Proposed Projects and Rate Changes
Mayor Miller presided over the First Reading of Ordinance No. 2009-15 to Adopt a
Budget for the Operation of the Department of Public Utilities for the City of Orangeburg
for Fiscal Year October 1, 2009 through September 3D, 2010 Including the Adoption of
New Rates for the Department of Public Utilities for the City of Orangeburg Effective on
the Dates Indicated on the Rate Schedule Pertaining to Natural Gas, Water and
Wastewater.
Councilman Barnwell expressed his concern to Manager Boatwright. He stated "I am
concerned, as well as t know you are, with the economy the way it is and I know that we
have got to keep DPU advanced but how is this rate increase on all three utitities going
to affect our customers". Manager Boatwright replied, "any rate increase always effects
our customers, we have tried to keep the rate increases as low as we possibly can and
I am certainly concerned about that too, as all of you are. Again anytime is a bad time
for me for rate increases especially this lime with the economic situations in our
community and throughout the country as they are now, but again my responsibility is to
present to you what I think is appropriate, and the prudent thing to do. II is my opinion
that if we don't have these rate increases, the Wastewater Division will actually be
operating in the red by about $200,000. We will make absolutety nothing In the Water
Division, of which we are not making much now, and in the Natural Gas Division which
is a significant portion of the earnings that the citizens of Orangeburg enjoy from their
utility La be used for various other things. Again it is my recommendation that we do
this Mr. Barnwell. That is the best answer I can give you.
A motion was made by Councilman Jernigan, seconded by Councilmember Rheney,
to accept the First Reading of an Ordinance to Adopt the 2009-2010 Annual Budget for
the Department of Public Utilities for the City of Orangeburg Including the Adoption of
New Rates for the Department of Public Utilities for the City of Orangeburg Effective on
the Dates Indicated on the Rate Schedule Pertaining to Gas, Water and Wastewater.
Mayor Pro Tem Haire stated "he spoke to Mr. Boatwright this morning as it relates to
this particular matter and I was suppose to have gotten back with him with some
information, but because of work at the University, I was unable to get back with him in
time, I am going to support this, but this does not necessarily mean that I continue
based on the information I gel". Manager Boatwrighl replied he understood and he
appreciated Mayor Pro Tem Haire's statement.
The motion was approved unanimously.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tem Haire, seconded by Councilman Barnwell, to
adjourn. The motion was unanimous.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
Respectfully submitted,
:J!le~ <1 CIuot:J
Becky Alfustin
Secretary to Manager
Department of Public Utilities
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
August 18, 2009
Orangeburg City Council held a Public Hearing on Tuesday, August 18,2009, at 7:00
P.M.. in Council Chambers wilh Mayor Miller presiding. The purposes orlhe Public
Hearings were:
1. To raise revenue and adopt a Budget for the City ofOrallcgburg, se, for the Fiscal
year beginning Octoher 1,2009 and ending September 30, 2010.
2. To adopt a Budge! for the operalion orthe Department of Public Utilities for the City
of Orangeburg, se, for the Fiscal Year beginning October 1,2009 and ending
September 30, 20 I0, including the adoption of new rates for the Department of Puhlic
Utilities for the City of Orangeburg effective on the dates indicated on the ralc
schedule pertaining to natural gas, waler and wastewater.
City Administrator Yow addressed Council. He stated, "'fyou will bear with me,l know
we have gone over this in great detail at the first reading, but I did want to go through the
highlights again for the Public Hearing. The General Fund tOlalthis year is $17,013,416
for revenues and expenses, so it is a balanced budget. We are budgeting $355,807 in
cash reserve, for reference we budgeted 5400,000.00 last year in cash reserve and I laId
you in the amended budget, we are anticipating using $125.000 of that The total budget
once you add in the Municipal Airport, Hillcrest Golf Course and the Pro Shop is
S18,323,028. I would like to go through a few highlights that make up this budget. First
of all, therc is a three (3) mill tax increase built in this budget, Ihis equates to about
$12.00 on a SIOO,OOO.OOhouse. As a reminder, we did roll back the millage 4 mills lasl
year and with a three mill increase, wc will only be back to 87. There is no rire contract
increase. There is no business license rate increase. There is an increase in commcrcial
solid waste fee to cover the Counly tipping fee. We have to pass that on to commercial
businesses. There is no change in rates of the residential sanitation fee. There is 110
change in the DPU Transfer. There is a $1.00 per round increase for 18 holes for cart fcc.
Just to mention for the record, Council knows interest rates are down significantly; our
interest income is down S300,OOOto $400,000 per year. The state has cut our local
govemment rund monies by about $75,000.00. I know Mayor Pro Tern Haire lobbied
some this year to maintain our monies. All local governments have been faced with this
across the slale. On the expenditure side, for the first lime in about twenty years, there is
no cost-of- living built in this budget, there are also no merit raises. However, there arc
no furloughs or layoffs anticipated in this budget. There are no new positions cut in this
budget. in fact, there are seven (7) existing vacant positions cul rrom this budget. There
is a very small capital funding. Originally, we started with about $250,000.00. Last year,
we had over I million dollars in capital budgeted. We did add back a fire truck in capital.
We have applied for a grant for this purchase, so we will be on stand by for this. One
thing we have not done is address GASB 45, which is a new accounting standard mosl
local govemmcnts have to adhere to. We have done a thorough review of our health
insurance plan, even since our first reading, we have gotten some new numbers. We
could very well have some significant changes to our health insurance coverage. ThaI's a
brier overview of the budget. I will be happy to answer any questions."
Hearing no comments on Public Hearing #1, to raise revenue and adopt a Budget ror the
City of Orangeburg, SC, for the Fiscal Year beginning October I, 2009 and ending
September 30, 2010, the Public Hearing #1 was closed.
DPU Manager Boatwright addressed Council on DPU budgel highlights. "Projected
income is $97,920.000, projected expenses 587,081,000 and retained earnings
510,839,000. Income down from last year 102.5 to 97.9. Retained earnings down from
last year 15.8 to 10.8. Capital projects totaling 53,694,148 - one new each for electric
and water divisions and one each continuing project ror natural gas, administrative and
wastewater divisions. Rate increases arc as follows: Natural gas-5.9% on residential
customers, $4.88 per month for 75 themls. Water-5% for inside residential customers,
$0.57 per month and double the rate for outside customers. Wastewater·5% for inside
residential customers. SO.80/month and double the rates for outside. Proposed spending
on capital projects in FY 2009-10 is proposed to be 42% less Ihan laSI year. No lap or
1975
1970
Page 2
impact fee or other administrative fee changes in this budget. No cost-of-living raises or
merit raises; however, no layoffs or furloughs. No new positions arc anticipated and
there will be major changes in our health insurance plans to economize and reduce our
GASB liability."
Hearing no public comments on Public Hearing #2, to adopt a Budget for the operation of
[he Department of Public Utilities for lhe City of Orangeburg, SC, for the Fiscal Year
beginning October 1,2009 and ending September 30, 2010, including the adoption of
new rales for the Department of Public Utilities for the City of Orangeburg effective on
the dates indicated on the ratc schedule pertaining to natural gas, water and wastewater,
the Public Hearing was closed.
PRESENT:
Paul A. Miller, Mayor
Charles B. Barnwell
Bernard Haire
Charles \V. Jernigan
Joyce \V. Rheney
ABSENT:
Sandra P. Knolls
Trelvis A. Miller
Council entered into the regularly scheduled meeting,
A motion was made by Mayor Pro rem Haire, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to
approve the July 28,2009 Budget Workshop Minutes as distributed. This motion was
unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Jernigan, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, to
approve the July 29,2009 Budget Workshop Minutes as distributed. This motion was
unanimously approved.
A motion as made by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, seconded by Councilrncmber Jernigan, to
approve the August 4, 2009 City Council Minutes as distributed. This was a 4-0-1 vote
as Council member Barnwell abstained as he was not present at the last meeting.
A motion was made by Councilmembcr Rheney, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, to
approve the August 11, 2009 Special City Council Minutes as distributed. This motion
was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Coullcilmember Rheney, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, to
approve the Second Reading of an Ordinance amending the Budget for the City of
Orangeburg, SC, for the Fiscal year beginning October 1,2008 and ending September 30,
2009. This mol ion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Mayor Pro Tem Haire, \0
approve the Second Reading of an Ordinance to raise revenue and adopt a Budget for the
City of Orangeburg, SC, for the Fiscal year beginning October 1,2009 and ending
September 30, 2010. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Rheney, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell,
to approve the Second Reading of an Ordinance to adopt a Budget for the operation of the
Department of Public Utilities for the City of Orangeburg, SC, for the Fiscal Year
beginning October 1, 2009 and ending September 30, 2010, including the adoption of
new rates for the Department of Public Utilities for the City of Orangeburg effective on
the dates indicated on the rate schedule pertaining to natural gas, water and wastewater.
This Illotion as unanimously approved.
Page 3
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tem Haire, seconded by Councilmember Jernigan, to
approvc a Rcsolution authorizing the Manager of lhe Department of Public Utilitics of
the City of Orangeburg to execute an Agreement between the Department of Public
Utilities of the City of Orangeburg and Soulh Carolina Electric and Gas Company, Inc.,
[or lhe purpose o[ furnishing electric capacity and energy_
Business License Revocation Hearing for Mil's Reception Hall
Mayor Miller stated, "This is a Hearing held by City Council pursuant to Section 7-2.19
of our Business License Ordinance. The question hefore Council is the revocation ora
business license held by Hemlan Dewayne Robinson at 1074 Russell Street doing
business as Mil's Reception Hall issued January 20,2009 with a license number 0[2009
14. Mr. Hennan Dewayne Robinson was issued proper notice by personal service on
July 30, 2009. The noticc consisted ofa letter issued by Carrie W. Johnson, Finance
Director for the City dated June 30, 2009 setting the grounds for the revocation and
setting a hearing date for August 18,2009. The notice was signed by Dcwaync
Robinson. The grounds for the revocation arc set forth in the June, 30, 2009 notice and
are as follows: Vou have breached conditions of the license and you have failed to
comply with the provisions of the Business License Ordinance of the City of Orangeburg.
You have obtained this license through fraud, misrepresentation, false and misleading
statements, evasion and suppression of material facts in your application and you have
engaged in unlawful activity related to your business activities."
Cily Attomey Walsh represented the City and entered into the record the license
applicalion for Mils' Reception Hall signed by Dewayne Robinson. He stated, "Also
attached are his driver's license and the amount paid for the license. The second item is a
letter dated July 6, 2009 selling fmih grounds for revocation for a Hearing to be held on
August 18,2009 and also attached to that is a copy of the Ordinance. Aflidavit of
personal service signed hy Sgt. Lucas along with photographs of the residence and
another affidavit of service signed by LI. Smoak were also entered into the record. A part
of the City Zoning Ordinance with tables and lhe NAICS codes specific to real eslate
businesses were also made a part of the record.
City Attomey Walsh Slated, "I call Carrie Johnson, Finance Director to the stand"
Mrs. .lohnson was sworn in by Councilmember Barnwell.
City Attorney Walsh asked Mrs. Johnson, "What is your full name?"
Mrs. Johnson replied, "Carrie W. Johnson."
City Attorney Walsh asked. "What is your title?"
Mrs. Johnson replied, "Finance Direclor."
City Attorney Walsh asked, "Isn't it one of your dUlies to review and issue business
licenses?"
Mrs. Johnson replied, "Yes."
City Attorney Walsh asked, "Did you have an occasion to issue a license to a Mil's
Reception Hall for Hennan Dewayne RobinsonT
Mrs. Johnson replied, "Yes."
City Attorney Walsh asked, "At what address'?"
Mrs. Johnson replied, "1074 Russell Street."
1977
1978 Page 4
City Attorney Walsh asked, "What was the dale on that license?"
Mrs. JOhl15011 replied, "January 20, 2009."
City Attorney Walsh asked, "What is the number orlhal license?"
Mrs. Johnson replied, "2009-14,"
City Attomey Walsh asked, "What was that license forT'
Mrs. Johnson replied, "For a rental halL"
CiLy Attorney Walsh asked, "Is that at 1074 Russell Street?"
Mrs. Johnson replied, "Correct."
City Attomey Walsh asked, "Could you let members ofCounciJ know the procedures for
issuing a business license,"
Mrs. Johnson replied, "When a person comes in for a business license and in fact the
location is in the City of Orangeburg, the application is completed in full, make a copy of
one or IWO identifications, verify lheir identity and il is then forwarded 10 Zoning for any
inspecuons which could take anywhere from 48 to 72 hours for approval."
Cily AHorney Walsh asked, "What kind of approval?"
Mrs. Johnson replied, "Zoning, fire inspections and any other inspections that needs to be
done,"
City Attomey Walsh asked, "Was this the first application that was submitted?"
Mrs. Johnson replied, 'The first application was for a teen club and that was denied from
the Zoning Administrator,"
City AHorney Walsh replied, "What happened after Ihat?"
Mrs. Johnson replied, "He was allowed to obtain a rental license for renting the
establishment out for receptions or birthday parties."
City Altomcy Walsh asked, "Do you know why the first one was denied?"
Mrs. Johnson replied, "Because of the Zoning,"
City Attorney Walsh asked, "Because of this license being a rental hall, could admission
he charged'?"
Mrs. Johnson replied, "No."
City Attorney Walsh asked, "Did you have any conversations with Mr. Robinson during
tltis procedure?"
Mrs. Johnson replied, "Yes, very briefly and I told him he was not to charge admission
and he was told by other staff as well."
:vIr. Dcwaync Robinson was asked ifhc had any questions for Mrs. Johnson.
Mr. Robinson stated," 0, I don', have any questions, I have never seen her before."
Cily Attorney Waish called Mr. Gene Nelson to the stand. He was sworn in by
Coullcilmember Barnwell.
Page 5
City Altomey Walsh asked Mr. lclson, "Please state your full name and title."
Mr. Nelson replied, "Elden Eugene Nelson II, Building Official and Zoning lnspector."
City Altomcy Walsh asked, "Did you have the occasion to review a license request for a
Mr. Dcwayne Robinson?"
Mr. Nelson replied, "Yes."
City Attomcy Walsh asked, "I believe there was more than one requesl."
Mr. Nelson replied, "Yes, for a teen club and il was denied at 1074 Russell Stree!."
City Attomcy Walsh asked, "What is the zoning for Ihat location'!"
Mr. Nelson replied, "It is B-2."
City Altomey Walsh asked, 'The teen club was denied based upon what?"
Mr. Nelson replied, "On Table 2 of the Zoning Ordinance, which gives the pemlitted
uses, and in B-2 a teen club is prohibited."
City Attorney Walsh asked, "Could you please go through the process of denying the
application."
Mr. Nelson replied, "Once I received the application and delemlined the classification of
the business; then detcnnined ifit was pennissiblc in that location. It was 713990 from
the NAICS ..
City Attomey Walsh asked, 'That was denied, why?"
Mr. Nelson stated, "Under that classification under dance halls, recreational halls without
alcohol, and other amusements that was not allowed in the B-2 zoning"
City Allorney Walsh asked, "Was there another application?"
Mr. Nelson stated, "Yes, for a rental hall."
City Allomcy Walsh asked, "Was it a similar situation in approving this application?"
Mr. Nelson stated, "Yes, and its classification was a 531, which would be for a rental hall
or banquet hall."
City Atlomey Walsh stated, "Would that be a rental hall or a dance hall you could renlto
a third party?"
Mr. Nelson stated, "You could rent it out as a party, but admission could not be charged
because they would not have a business license."
City Attorney Walsh asked, "If that rental hall is rented to a third party, he or she would
have to gct a special pennit for this?"
Mr. elson staled, "If the use fell into the 713, it would not be permilted and they could
110t charge because a license could not be pemlitted for that classification."
City Attorney Walsh asked, "Did you meet with Mr. Robinson and did you tell him he
could not charge admission?"
Mr. Nelson stated, "I have met with him several times and he was told he could not
charge admission and anyone he rented to could not charge admission."
1979
1980 Page 6
City Allomey Walsh asked, "Did he understand that?"
Mr Nelson replied, "I thought he did."
City Allomey Walsh asked Mr. Robinson ifhe had any questions for Mr. Nelson.
Mr. Robinson slated, "When I first mel you, yOll told me I had (0 do dIfferent things \0
the building in order to get it ready for any business."
Mr. Nelson, "The first time I mel you, you wanted to do a teen club."
Me Robinson sUlled,"The first time I met you, J jnquired about a rcnlal hall and you told
me I didn't have a fire wall when you inspected because I was nexl to Mrs. Dickson, do
you remember that?"
Mr. Nelson replied, "Yes, there were some issues with the building codes thai needed 10
be corrected first."
Mr. Robinson stated, "Do you remember that you slated whenever someone rented the
building that lhey had to get a temporary one day evenl license?"
Mr. Nelson replied, "On one occasion, we did grant a one-day license for an evenI when
you first opened because you came 10 me when you had already rented the hall and I (old
you that you could not charge admission."
Mr. Robinson asked, "Isn't a social hall for family reunions, socials and class reunions.
Won't yOlltake up tickets before the event to actually serve?"
Mr. Nelson replied, 'Traditionally, I wouldn't think you would charge admission to a
birthday party or any type oCparty."
Mr. Robinson asked, "You don't remember approving people to gel a lemporary license
forthe events at the hall because they had a contract?"
Mr. Nelson replied, "Yes, only one time, in the very beginning."
Mr. Robinson asked, "This was never announced to me when we started at the begirming;
you told me what I had 10 do to the building in the bcgirming, do you remember that'!"
Mr. Nelson replied, "I explained 10 you even with a banquet hall when you were
approved Ihat people could not charge admission because thai would be anolher business
and that was not allowed."
Mr. Robinson asked, "I noticed you kept saying I applied for a tcen club, where did I sign
for a teen club. the only thing I did was do the renovations you asked for to approve the
inspection."
Mr. Nelson replied, ''That was an earlier application that was denied."
Mr. Robinson replied, "1 never applied for a leen club, I did everythlllg you asked me 10
do. The renovations and I did everything you asked me to do."
Mr. Nelson stated, "The renovations were because you were using the facility as an
assembly and the renovations were necessary due to the building codes."
Mr. Robinson slaled, "I am doing Ihe same thing that Mark's Music did around the
comer."
Mr. Robinson had no other questions for Mr. Nelson.
Page 7
City Attorney Walsh asked Mr. Nelson, "Is this the license application you approved at
1074 Russell Street for a banquet hall?"
Mr. Nelson replied, "Yes it is,"
Cily Allorney Walsh asked, "Did Mr Robinson ill one LlIne apply for a promotionliccnse
[or parties and events?"
Mr. Nelson replied, "Yes, he did."
City Attorney Walsh asked, "Was that license denied?"
Me Nelson stated, "Yes, for the same reason."
Mr. Robinson stated, "The promoter's license carne up when they told me I couldn't hold
any events there. I had to apply for a promoter's license because I could not charge. J
applied for something that you told me 10 apply for. I sent people 10 apply for licenses to
you for events at the mal1."
Me Nelson stated, "The mall is a different zoning classification that IS allowed at the
mall."
Mr. Robinson Slated, "That is in the city."
Mr. Nelson replied, 'There is a different zoning classification that is B~l, you arc in B~2,
which was not allowed."
Mr. Robinson asked, "B~ 1 is there and B-2 is on Russell?"
Mr. Nelson replied, "Yes."
No more questions on either pan.
City Attorney Walsh called Chief Wendell Davis to the stand. He was sworn in by
Councilmcmber BamwelL
City Attomcy Walsh asked, "Please state your name and title."
Mr. Davis replied, "Wendell Davis, Director of Public Safety."
CIty Attomcy Walsh asked, "Are you familiar with the location 1074 Russell Strect?"
Mr. Davis replied, "Very much."
City Attorney Walsh asked, "Did you have an occasion to respond to calls at that
location'?"
Mr. Davis replied, "We had a number ofcaIls at that location responding specifically at
1074 and a number of other calls around 1074 Russell Street."
City Attomcy Walsh asked. "Can you describe those cases?"
Mr. DaVIS replied, "There were several fight calls, crowd control calls, one trespassing
call, and disturbance calls. There was one crowd control call where people were in the
street and across the street where there were a number of oflicers dispatched."
City Attomey Walsh asked, "Were any of those calls or activities unlawful?"
1981
1982 Page 8
Mr. Davis replied, "There were a number of arrests particularly at fights and other
unlawful activity. We found paraphernalia and illegal weapons to close proximity to the
site. We could not definitely place at the site, but within close proximity to the site. We
propose that these weapons were a result of the site."
Cit y Attomey Walsh asked, "Do you have a timeline for lhese activities'?"
Mr. Davis replied, "We do have the times, times range from 10:00 pm until 2:00 am."
City Attorney Walsh asked, "What days of the week?"
Mr. Davis responded, "On the weekend, generally on Saturday nights."
City Attorney Walsh had no other questions and asked Mr. Robinson to ask Mr. Davis
any question he may have had.
Mr. Robinson asked, "Do you remember me calling you for security for the hall to use
public safety?"
Mr. Davis replied, "No, rdidn't get any message or I didn't talk with you. We do not do
security for any business that serves alcohoL That would probably be the premise that
was told to you."
Mr. Robinson replied, "I do not have any alcohol, it is a rental hall. There is no telling
who is going to act up kids or adults. 1just wanted to have security there for protection,
bUll was denied by the city. Do you remember thal?"
Mr. Davis replied, "You never contacted me, you may have called. I don't' remember
talking to you."
Mr. Robinson stated, "One of your officers told me that you do that for the skating rink,
those are kids. So, I had to deal with the Sherrifrs Department, whether it is an adult or
kids, anyone that rents the building. I tell them they have to have the security for any
event 1have to fill out paperwork every week. Is that correct?"
Mr. Davis stated, "it is my understanding that there were Sherifrs deputies at most of the
evelliS that wc responded to. We responded lo calls, one time up to forty-eight officers
were therc."
Mr. Robinson asked, "Thc calls that you received, werc they from 1058?''
Mr. Davis replied, "Some came from 1058, some wcre not, some were from different
sources. At terms of where all ofthcm came from, some were from l058 and some were
noL"
Mr. Robinson asked, "So most of the calls were from 10S8?"
Mr. Davis replied, "Some of lhe calls were from 1058 concerning the activity of 1074.
Any citizen can call."
Mr. Robinson did not have any more questions for Mr. Davis.
City Attorney Walsh called Mr. Dwayne Robinson LO the stand. He was sworn in my
Councilmember Barnwell.
City Attorney Walsh asked, "What is your full name?"
Mr. Robinson stated, "Helman Dwayne Robinson."
Page 9
City Attorney Walsh asked, "You are the individual proprietor for Mil's Reception Hall
and the business license?"
Mr. Robinson slaled, "Yes."
City Attorney Walsh asked, "For your events, you had to have the Shcniffs Department
there'?"
Mr. Robinson stated, "For any event, they had to have the Sherriffs Department there. I
don't' take anything for granted. I fix it where the Sherrifrs Department has 10 be there.
I have to pay the officers $25.00 per hauL"
City Attomcy Walsh asked, "Did you have any events at 1074 Russell Street, yourself?"
Mr. Robinson stated, "I rented the hall to individuals and then they were to go 10 the City
and get a temporary aile day license and after that they would come to me and say the
license was not approved and they had to go see Mr. Gene Nelson and then he would
deny them the license. If they are charging, they could not get a license. Whatever event
the person was having, whether it was a daycare graduation or another event, even kids
having birthday parties. I make it affordable; they can rent my building for $500.00. The
Cinema charges £1,500.00 to $2,000.00. I didn't come here to hurt the city, the only
thing I wanted to do was to rent and help out the kids. Before I even started renting the
building, I fixed it up first. .,
City Attomey Walsh asked, "Did you have any events there yourself?"
Mr. Robinson slated, "I did once they could not get any licenses anymore when they
starting denying individuals licenses for the one day licenses. What they arc doing now,
they would corne through me since 1 have the business license."
City Attorney Walsh asked, "On some occasions, did you rent to a third party, such as
John or Sue to have a party?"
Mr. Robinson replied, "John or Sue would come to me to rent to them."
City AtlOmey Walsh asked, "When you have your parties under your business license,
did you charge admission'?"
Mr. Robinson stated, "Every event that I had was people coming to me to rent the
building. There was admission charged."
City AHorney Walsh asked, "You were told that individuals could not be charged,
wereB't you?"
Mr. Robinson asked, "On what grounds?"
City Attorney Walsh stated, "It doesn't maHer on the grounds."
Mr. Robinson stated, "What am I supposed to tell the people lhat come to me to rent the
hall, they want to make money. When you spend money, don't you want to make
money?"
City Allorney Walsh asked, "I thought they were birthday parties?"
Mr. Robinson replied, "They got to get something for it, whether it is a donation of $5.00
for whatever they do."
Clly Altorncy Walsh asked, "Were there people at that door charging people money for
admission'?"
1933
1934
Page 10
Me Robinson staled, "There was people sitting at the door, correct and they charged."
City Atlorney Walsh asked, "Do you know how much they charge?"
Mr. Robinson replied, "$5.00 or $1.00."
City Attorney Walsh asked, "In order to go in, you had to pay to do 50'1"
Mr. Robinson replied, "Yes, it was a $1.00 or $5.00."
There were no more questions for Mr. Robinson.
City AHorney Walsh recalled Mr. Gene Nelson, Building Official. Councilmember
BamwelJ stated to Mr. Nelson that he was still under oath.
City Attorney Walsh asked, "Any licenses Ihal was issued 10 Me Robinson, under any
circumstances, could you charge for admission?"
Mr. Nelson replied, "We did issue one license at the very beginning when he first opened
up. They was a gray area that staff had to work out. After that, we understood how it
was to be laid out. He can rent the hall to an individual to a party. The misunderstanding
is that thc party should come get a business license to charge admission. We can't do that
because it is in violation of the zoning. I told him that and people didn't need to come get
a business license. They can still rent the hall and have a party, but they cannot charge
admission. "
City Attomey Walsh asked, "So, if they did charge admission, that would be in violation
of the business license that was issued Lo Mr. Robinson?"
Mr. Nelson replied, "We could not issue a business license for that so they would in
violation. "
City Attomey Walsh asked, "Not only would they be in violation of his business license,
they were in violation becausc they had no business license."
Mr. Nelson replied, "Yes, that is correct."
City Attorney Walsh had no other questions or other witnesses.
Mr. Robinson testified, "I want to first start off apologizing to Council, I didn't actually
present myselfhere to hurt the city. I opened up this rental hall not to do wrong. I
wanted to open this rental hall after my mother, who has passed. I named it Mill's
Reception Hall. My mother died of cancer. I did it in her name. I didn't know what had
to be done. 1spent $4,000 ~ $5,000 o[my own money with sheet rock to actually have a
rental hall. I had to bring iL up to city codes; I had to have a bathroom, handicapped. The
building I rent, I don't have a lease, I have a month to month rental. I actually had the
building a year fixing it up and paying rent; my rent is 5700.00 per month. I wasn't
trying to gain anything. Whatever your decision is today, I accept it. I didn't come here
to mislead anybody and to open a business the wrong way. As I stand before you today, I
will be seeing ML Nelson again. I have gone to the mall in order to rent space for kids to
have a place to work when they get of school to do hair. I am an instructor, once they get
out of school; they have no place to work. ram not here today to try to fight. I am glad
to be here so people can see who I am. A lot of kids rent the building. I can't stop kids
from acting up or doing anything wrong. With the Sherriffs Department there, I dealt
with Mr. Larry and their ability. My main thing before you today is our kids, they are the
future. If I can have an event and three hundrcd kids are being dropped off; that is why
the officials were there. 1 am not here to do the City wrong. If I need to go somewhere
Page II
else and do something elsc, thai is fine. Whatever the decision is here today, I am fine
with it. Nobody really knew me. It all started next door with the guy with the sports bar.
He was saying it was causing problems with his crowd. We had some verbal
conversations. At first he was fine because oCthe Shcrrirrs Department Then he said
because the Sherrirfs Department \\'a5 there, it was causing his customers noilo come in.
The next thing you know, there were phone calls [rom next door. J opened up one day a
week. There was a time when people were out in the road. I was on military dUly at the
time. I had security there [or Ihe event. Anyone who rents the building, they had to fill
oul an application. The only business license hall I ever applied for is Mil's Reception
Hall. J have licenses here where people went to Mr. Nelson lo get a temporary event
license. When someone rents a building, I would get a copy. If anyone would go to them
ror 1074, it would be denied. He told me to send people to him and then when he gOI
'here, he would deny them. I havc paperwork whcn I rented Mark's Music and I had to
do the same thing. I would rent The Place to Be and get a one day license. Anytime, I do
anything, I had 10 get a promoter's license. It went as we go. J didn't mean to hurt the
City, thank you."
City Attorney Walsh asked, "You say you have an cvcntliccnse, can 1see it 1"
Mr. Robinson produced one license.
City Anomey Walsh stated, "This is the one lhat we issued olle time ror J&K Delight."
Mr. Robinson stated, "The other people have their licenses, they bring the contract to Mr.
Nelson and lhey get the business license."
City Attorney Walsh asked, "Do you have anything signed by Mr. Nelson other than this
one he said that he issued,?"
Mr. Robinson replied, "All those records the individual has,l ended up with that one
because that person was working that day and I ended up with it. Those people who had
those contracts have their licenses."
City Altomcy Walsh staled," They arc only signed by you."
Mr. Robinson replied, "They get the license rrom the City, they take the contract to Mr.
Nelson to actually get a temporary event license prior to this. Everybody has got their
own license, I only have that one."
City Attorney Walsh stated. "Regardless orwhether they need a license or not. did they
charge admission?"
Mr. Robinson stated. "Yes."'
The Mayor asked iranyone else has any other questions.
City Attomey Walsh recalled Mr. Nelson. Councilmember Barnwell reminded him you
are under oath.
City Anomey Walsh asked. "Did yOll issue any other business licenses other than that
one?"
Mr. Nelson replied, "No, just that one license. That was Ihe one carlyon lhat he first got
his license that he had the hall and he already signed a contract and we lel him have that
one. He charged admission for that one time due to us having to rC$earch that area in the
Ordinance."
Mayor ProTem Haire asked to sec lhe license he had ror the special event.
1935
193G
Page 12
Mayor Pro Tem Haire asked Mr. elson, "You said in your testimony that first of all, the
business license was issued 1120/2009, this particular special event was 5/0812009. That
was about 4-5 months, was that the first event he had?"
Mr. Nelson replied, 'That was Ihe first event he had."
Councilmember Jernigan asked 10 see the license.
Mayor Miller asked "Who is J&K Delight'"
Mr. Robinson Slated, "That was a business where a young lady had cakes that she
showcased and baked cakes and thal was how she promoted her business."
Mayor Miller asked, "That was 10 sell cakes?"
Mr. Robinson Slated. "She had an oldie goldie party where she showcased her cakes and
gave out pens and cards and to sec her business. She did this where people could buy
some of her cakes for olher occasions."
Mayor Miller asked, "Mr. elson is Ihis handwriting here that stales thaI no admission
could be charged ifrcnlcd for a private pany."
Mr. Nelson replied, ·'Yes."
Mayor Miller asked, "Is Mrs. Kennerly the J&K Delight?"
Mr. Robinson replied, "Yes."
Councilmember Jel1ligan asked Mr. Robinson, "On lhis firsl event you had, Ihat was for
J&K Delight to showcase their cakes?"
Mr. Robinson replied, "No, they didn't showcase their cakes, they advertised themselves
so far as to give out pens, memos,jusl a promotion. That was not the first party there.
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "Didn't Mr. Nelson testified that this was lhe first
evenl?"
Mr. Robinson stated, "Thai was not the first event."
Mayor Miller asked, "When was the firsl event?"
Mr. Robinson replied, "When I first got the business license, thaL was not the first event."
Mayor Miller asked, "That was in January?"
Mr. Robinson relied, "That is correct."
Mayor Miler asked, "When you were told that admission could not be charged?"
Mr. Robinson replied, "Thai was around the Slh, May Fest weekend, I had something al
the mall for a fashion show and a talent show. There was a promoter having something
after my event. Prior 10 Ihat, they lold my partner not 10 open up. They sent Iwo sheriffs
deputies there saying J had the wrong business license that I could not open up. So, Lt.
Thompson from Public Safely was senllhere by Wendell saying I could not open up May
Fest weekend. that the City said] had the wrong business license to open up. I did not
open up, I did nol quarrel with Ihem. J abided by the rules. I came in the next day, I
Page 13
spoke to a young lady a Miss ..... what 15 her name, he asked the Finance Director what
her name was and she replied, "Carrie Johnson",
Mr.. Robinson thell replied. "Yes, I spoke to you. you give out the licenses.
Mrs. Johnson replied. "But, you said you never met me?"
Mr. Robinson stated, "This is my second time meeting you. When you came in, I was
sitting there waiting all you and you went 10 the back and asked what is he domg oul
there and you came out and asked i ranyone was helping me. I then explained my
situation and you gave me the application 10 apply for a promoter's license. You sent Lt.
Thompson there to close me down. Youthcn told me it cost $100.00. You then laId me
it had 10 he approved."
Mayor Miller stated, "There arc several things Ihat I am Irying 10 sort through in my mind
and Ihe first one is, were you or wcre you not told that if you rented your hall to a third
party thal the third party could not charge money for people to enter."
Mr. Robinson replied, "In the heginning when I \.,.as told to rent the building. I was told
anyone who rents the building should come and get a one·day special event license which
is $25.00. with I kncw that because I have rented other places and J knew Ihat. As time
wcnt on. they told me they could not charge admission because of the zoning I was in and
they could not get a special events license."
Mayor Miller Slated, "So you were told because of the zone that you were in, lhat would
be illegal."
Mr. Robinson replied, "When the zoning thing came up, he kept talking about the gray
area and he was talking with Mr. Yow. When you have a bunch of kids, they call it a
teen club, it is a reception hall. We can go do the same thing somewhere else; you can
call it a club. I did not apply for a club. I cannot deny the right for people to rent it. It is
a rental hall. 1058 has analyzed me and callcd it a club, that I had drugs. I had the cops
oUlthere. They can't even have cigarettes. They can't leave the building. They can't
even bring in bandannas like a gang. 1 know one time, they went out at aile time, and
everyone was outside that happens at a game."
Mayor Miller stated, "1 have missed something somewhere in these past two hours we
were talking. Didn't you apply for a teen club?"'
Mr. Robinson replied, "That is what they say, I never signed anything for a teen club."
Mayor Miller asked, "You asked about a teen club?"
Mr. Robinson replied, "I only applied for a rental hall and 1 did the building renovations
lhat Gene told me to do."
Mayor Miller replied, "But, you were told not to rent it to a third party to charge
admission."
Mr. Robinson replied, 'They never told me that unlil 4 10 5 months afier we rented the
building. Untillhcy started sending the cops out there. everything was fine. On May
Fest weekend, I lost a lot of money'"
Mayor Pro Tem Haire asked the finance Director, Carrie Johnson, "Mr. Robinson stated
that he came to yOll and you were unaware Ihat there was this prohibition against the May
Fest weekend'"
Mrs. Johnson stated, "If that is the same weekend, he had a license for that. J&K had a
license if that was the same weekend. I don'l knO\v what May Fest weekend would be."
1937
1.958
Page 14
Mayor Pro Tem Haire nsked, "Did someone make an error in nol allowing him to open
up on the weekend?"
Mrs. Johnson replied, "Only if thaI was the same weekend. I do not know when May Fest
was."
Councilmcmber Jernigan stated, ''This license is daled for May 8th."
Councilmember Jernigan asked, '" have a few questions. You say this license was (0
display cakes and things like thai so she could show what she had and possibly to gel
people to hire her to do something."
Mr. Robinson stated, "She didn't have any cakes, she only had cards to promote herself."
Councilmembcr Jemigan replied, "The license says it is for a special evenl birthday
party?"
Mr. Robmson staled, "Exactly, it was her birthday and she was chargmg people for her
birthday. In order for her to get that license, she had to go to Gene to get it."
Mayor Pro Tem Haire asked, "Does anyone know what May Fest was?"
A discussion was held as to whether May Fest was Rose Festival weekend, which was
May ISl weekend
Councilmcmber Jernigan asked Mr. Nelson, "You stated this was the first event.'·
Mr. Nelson replied, '''-hal is the first even I we knew about."
Councilmember Jernigan replied, "Mr. Robinson stated it was not the first event."
Mr. Nelson replied, "'think he was operating under his rental hall license."
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "He could actually renl his establishment as long as they
weren't charging for it'?"
Mr. Nelson replied, "Yes."
Mayor Miller asked, "Does anyone know ifhe charged or not?"
City Attorney Walsh stated, "He admitted that he charged."
City Allomey Walsh entered the J&K license into the record.
City Attomey Walsh summarized the City's position. He stated, "I feel like I am making
closing arguments to ajury. ] do want to say that you should use common sense that
when you have a birthday party or a gradualion party, you invite people to them, you
don't charge admission. III this case, Mr. Robinson admitted that persons he rented lhe
hall to, they were charging. This is a 8-2 business district Lhat pennits a rental hall bu!
ulld~r no circumswllces can you charge admission. This would require a different
business license that is not allowed in this district and Mr. Robinson did not have that.
Under the classifications, a rental hall is permilled, but under no circumstances should
admission be charged. He has admitted thal admission was charged of $5.00."
Mr. Robinson made remarks. "Like I said before, if you have a rental hall, you can do
Illany things. If you have a skating rink, you have public safety and security. You can'l
take anyone for granted that no person is going to do wrong. I paid security and I
Page 15
charged to pay for that. Admission was never told to me until calls started coming from
next door. Nobody knew I was there, everyone was home asleep and lhat is when the
kids \Vere renting lhe building. I tried to do no wrong. I am nol ashamed of nothing that I
did. The only thing rdid was have the cops there for protection al all time. They shOl
someone al Hardee's, you didn't close them down. What I am saying, I never took
anything for granted. J was in the military. I told them when I let them oUI, call your ride
or text your ride and go outside. As I grew, I learned the business."
Councilmember Barnwell asked, "Were you physically there when these events were
taking place?"
Mr. Robinson stated, "I hired security, I have girls and guys security, they can bring in no
combs, objects, bandannas or even cigarettes. Inside, I have security walking around the
whole time. I did not fix this to do no wrong, if anything, I wish everyone would come
down and sec what I was doing. I was hoping the Sheriffs Department would talk to the
kids ahout different events, school and the homeless."
Mayor Miller stated, "Council, we can act on the revocation based on the testimony given
tonight, we can table it until next meeting and suspend any action; I put it before you to
what's your pleasure:'
Mayor Pro Tem Hairc Slated, "While I can appreciate what Mr. Robinson was anempting
to do, he did mention in this testimony that admission was charged which was in
violation. It seemed to be ambiguities by city officials and I would hope that in the future
that these ambiguities would not exist. However, through his own admission there were
violations in fees that were charged, so at this time I would have to support the position
ofrcYocation." This was seconded by Councilmember Rheney.
Councilmember Barnwell asked, "Mr. Robinson, Do you understand what the situation
• f)"
IS.
Mr. Robinson replied, "I undersland fully whatever the case may be. I apologize, this
came about when I first charged. I couldn't pay the cops out ormy pocket, so that wenl
towards that. Nothing was told to me in lhe beginning. I understand now. Whatever the
case may be, I understand."
Councilmember Barnwell stated, "I think this was all a misunderstanding, irwc revoke
this license, could he apply for another one, since he understands now."
City Attorney Walsh replied, "Yes."
Council unanimously approved the revocation of business license at 1074 Russell Street.
Mayor Miller staled, "J appreciate you coming in and your willingness to discuss this
mailer tonight. Sometimes things are bitter, but maybe there is a good lesson to be
learned here. In the future, make sure you arc in the right zoning and do it the right way
and we probably won't ever sec you down here and I wish you luck in your future
endeavors."
City Attomey Walsh stated, "1 will have to prepare a written statement and I will present
it to Mr. Robinson."
Mayor Miller asked City Allorncy Walsh, "Do you have a time table for this?"
City Attorney Walsh stated. "Once it is signed by Council, I will have to get itlo him
within ten days,"
Mayor Miller staled, "We will get yOll an official notice by mail."
1939
1930
Page 16
City Anomcy Walsh asked Mr. Robinson if the City had his correct address and he was
advised thallhe revocation was effective now. Mr. Robinson verified his correct mailing
address was 1221 Jackson Belt Road, Holly Hill, SC 29059.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, seconded by Councilmcmber Barnwell, to
enter into an Executive Session for a legal matter concerning pending litigation, Mabel S.
All vs. City of Orangeburg. This motion was unanimously approved.
Council did not return to Open Session, therefore, the meeting was adjourned.
Respectfully submitted,
~~M!JUY0
City Clerk
CIVJ/pfb
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
September 1, 2009
7:00 P.M.
Orangeburg City Council held a Public Hearing on Tuesday, September 1,2009, at 7:00
P.M. in Council Chambers with Mayor Miller presiding. The purposes of the Public
Hearings were:
I. Annexation into the City of Orangeburg, property belonging to Orangeburg Foods,
Inc., located on John C. Calhoun Drive at TMP# 0173-19-03-003
Hearing no comments on Public Hearing #1, the Public Hearing was closed.
2. Annexation into the City of Orangeburg property belonging to Stephen D. Nash,
Orangeburg Stockyards, located at 805 Whaley Street at TMP# 0173-19-03-008/0173
19-03-009
Hearing no comments on Public Hearing #2, the Public Hearing was closed.
City Administrator Yow noted that the Planning Commission unanimously voted to
annex these properties.
PRESENT:
Paul A. Miller, Mayor
Charles B. Barnwell
Bernard Haire
Charles W. Jernigan
Sandra P. Knotts
Joyce W. Rheney
ABSENT:
Trelvis A. Miller
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tem Haire, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to
approve the August 18,2009, City Council Minutes as distributed. This was a 5-0-1 vote
as Councilmember Knotts abstained as absent from the PRIOR meeting.
A motion was made by Councilmember Rheney, seconded by Mayor Pro Tem Haire, to
approve the Third Reading of an Ordinance amending the Budget for the City of
Orangeburg, SC, for the Fiscal Year beginning October J, 2008 and ending September
30, 2009. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Mayor Pro Tem Haire, to
approve the Third Reading of an Ordinance to raise revenue and adopt a Budget for the
City of Orangeburg, SC, for the Fiscal Year beginning October 1,2009 and ending
September 30, 2010. This motion was unanimously approved.
City Administrator Yow overviewed Council on the proposed site of the City Community
Center/Gymnasium. He advised Council of the proposed building location on Broughton
and Whaley Streets and advised Council that staff had visited many facilities throughout
the state. A power point presentation was presented by Neal, Prince Architects from
Greenville. City Administrator Yow stated "The funds to pay for this facility would
come from the Capital J% Fund (First Round), some additional costs were funded in the
second round of the I% Fund which equaled about $2 million dollars; $500,000 would be
paid from the 2% Fund Balance and the remaining $1.8 million we would borrow from
the public finance market. However, the City will pursue grant funds, if available. The
estimated cost of the building is $4.3 million. I am asking tonight that you endorse this
concept and give direction to start preparing bid documents and re viewing financial
options. It would require us to bring the bids back to Council for construction
approval. "
19!H
1992
Page 2
Councilmember Barnwell stated, "I do not see anything wrong and I am in favor of the
concept, but my concern is the borrowing of two million dollars where we just
increased taxes and this is not the proper time to do this, but I will vote in favor of the
plans."
Mayor Miller stated, "I think from what this gentleman said contractors are hungry and
the chances to get this built for a good price would be better now than later."
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, seconded by Councilmember Knotts, to
approve the staff to start preparing bid documents for the construction of the City
Community Center/Gymnasium.
Councilmember Rheney stated, "This has been on the table a long time and I think we
need to proceed with this or lose the money."
This motion was unanimously approved.
Mr. Don Tribble, Director of Community of Character, accepted the Character Trait
Proclamation, "Trustworthy" for the month of September 2009.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to
approve the First Reading of an Ordinance to annex the within described property as
Orangeburg Foods, Inc., Tax Map #0173-19-03-003 into the City of Orangeburg, Sc.
This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Rheney, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, to
approve the First Reading of an Ordinance to amend the Municipal District Map dated
November 6,2001, for the purpose of adding newly annexed City property, Tax Map
#0173-19-03-003 to Municipal Council District Five (5). This motion was unanimously
approved
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Knotts,
to approve the First Reading of an Ordinance to annex the within described property of
Stephen D. Nash, Orangeburg Stockyards, located at 805 Whaley Street at Tax Map #'s
0173-19-03-008/0173-19-03-009 into the City of Orangeburg, South Carolina. This
motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Jernigan, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, to
approve the First Reading of an Ordinance to amend the Municipal District Map dated
November 6,2001, for the purpose of adding newly annexed City property, Tax Map #'s
0173-19-03-008/0173-19-03-009. This motion was unanimously approved.
City Administrator Yow addressed Council in regards to the possible purchase of
property at 1099 Russell Street. He stated, 'The Mayor was approached by bank
representatives some time ago. He came to Mr. Boatwright and me as to whether or not
we would have any need for this property. The property has been walked through by the
three of us. The property is 7/1 0 of an acre, it is two story brick with a basement and is
10,000 square feet finished and 5,000 square feet partially finished. It has one tenant on
the second floor with a lease of approximately 28 more months, the lease would transfer
to us and the tenant would remain there for that time period. DPU indicated that they do
have need for a portion ofthe building for storage purposes for records and offices for
two employees. We have some storage space needs but not great needs. We have some
desire to incorporate some of the acreage into a planned municipal parking area. As
Council knows, for some time we were going to take a parking lot that is not publicly
owned and we would acquire and take that and this acreage, if we can acquire all of the
easements and develop an entrance from Broughton into the parking area so you can go
out on Windsor or Broughton Street. We have been talking with First Citizens long
before this came about conceming this parking lot. In addition, we may approach some
non-profit organizations in the community about relocating to this building as
Page 3
well. Those would be the uses the City and DPU would have for this property. If it
meets with Council's approval, we recommend that you give me permission to move
forward with this; for us to schedule a closing sometime in the next month and give Mr.
Walsh the authority to work with me on the pertinent documents."
Councilmember Bamwell asked, "Where will the money from the City come from?"
City Administrator Yow replied, "It would come from the 2% Fund unless we see that we
would not cause a deficit in this year's budget, we could pay for it from the general
fund."
Councilmember Barnwell asked, "How much would we benefit from the lease?"
City Administrator Yow replied, "The rental is different amounts for different months, it
averages about $27,000.00 per year and we have 28 more months on the lease."
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tem Haire, seconded by Councilmember Rheney, to
approve a Resolution for the purchase of real property at 1099 Russell Street from First
Citizens Bank and Tmst in the amount of$300,000. This motion was unanimously
approved.
City Administrator Yow stated, "As the City embarked on annexation, we realized that
we were encountering larger tracts of property and we never adopted what was referred to
as subdivision regulations. We then statted seeing developments of larger tracts in the
city and tracts being annexed that were larger. We realized we didn't have anything other
than our Zoning Ordinance to address these larger parcels. As Mr. Walsh and I spoke to
Council about that, we decided to contact Mr. Dan Vismor, our consultant on the
Comprehensive Plan and our Zoning Ordinance to develop a Land Development
Ordinance. We are bringing this to you tonight for first reading. Mr. Vismor could not
be here tonight, but he will be here for the next reading. He will be here to go over
details on this Ordinance. We want to proceed with first reading and the other
Resolution, which is the cessation ofland development and subdivision in the city.
Councilmember Barnwell asked me today about some issues. This does not take the
place of the Zoning Ordinance. That Ordinance still applies. The authority to do the
Land Development Ordinance is granted to cities through state law, at Section 6-29
1110- 6-29-1200. This applies to all large developments not just residential; it applies to
commercial, mixed use, office institutional, and residential. The Planning Commission
has reviewed and recommended this plan. The best summary is written in the document
in the second paragraph in the Ordinance which states the City finds that it is in its best
interest to govem the subdivision of said lands, encourage economically sound and stable
development, assure the timely provision of required streets, utilities and other facilities
and services, to assure adequate provision of safe and convenient access and circulation,
to assure public open spaces and to assure the wise and timely development of said
properties in harmony with the Comprehensive Plan of the City of Orangeburg."
DPU Manager Boatwright concurred with the recommendation of passing this. City
Attorney Walsh stated that this would require an amendment to the General Terms and
Conditions of the Department of Public Utilities.
Mayor Miller asked about plans that have already been approved.
City Administrator Yow replied, "They would still have to comply with the Zoning
Ordinance and they would not be affected by the temporary cessation."
City Administrator Yow stated, "This doesn't come to Council for plat approval. They
go to the Planning Commission, for plats approval. Council approves the Zoning
Ordinance and POD's come to City Councilor someone who doesn't comply with the
1993
19!34
Page 4
Zoning Ordinance. One thing that would come before Council is the financial guarantees
and the contract assurances. If someone does not have all the improvements done, they
could bring some financial guarantees to Council."
A motion as made by Councilmember Jernigan, seconded by Councilmember Rheney,
approving the First Reading of an Ordinance adopting Land Development Regulations
for the City of Orangeburg. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Mayor Pro Tem Haire, to
approve a Resolution providing for the temporary cessation of land development and
subdivision. This motion was unanimously approved.
DPU Manager Boatwright overviewed the Ordinance to adopt a Budget for the operation
of the Department of Public Utilities for the City of Orangeburg, SC, for the Fiscal Year
begilming October 1, 2009 and ending September 30, 2010, including the adoption of
new rates for the Department of Public Utilities for the City of Orangeburg effective on
the dates indicated on the rate schedule pertaining to natural gas, water and wastewater.
There were no changes from second to third reading.
Councilmember Knotts stated, "I have pondered over this issue since its inception about
raising the water, wastewater and natural gas rates. I have had mixed feelings since the
very beginning. I have been approached by many citizens, some seniors, some who have
lost jobs and it is because of that, it is just my conscience and it is just who I am and what
God has purposely put me here for, I support DPU and their effOlts, but at this point in
time, I cannot vote for this."
A motion was made by Councilmember Jernigan, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, to
approve the Third Reading of an Ordinance to adopt a Budget for the operation of the
Department of Public Utilities for the City of Orangeburg, SC, for the Fiscal Year
beginning October I, 2009 and ending September 30, 2010, including the adoption of
new rates for the Department of Public Utilities for the City of Orangeburg effective on
the dates indicated on the rate schedule pertaining to natural gas, water and wastewater.
This was a 5-0-1 vote as Councilmember Knotts opposed.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tem Haire, seconded by Councilmember Bamwell, to
enter into an Executive Session for (1) administration legal matter concerning litigation
regarding Telecommunications Franchise and (2) administration contractual matter
concerning sale of real property. This motion was unanimously approved.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
~;Qr'"~
Carrie W. Joh
City Clerk
/pfb
r---l
RESOLUTION PROVIDING FOR THE TEMPORARY CESSATION OF LAND
DEVELOPMENT AND SUBDIVISION.
WHEREAS, the City of Orangeburg on September 1, 2009 adopted by first reading a Land
Development Ordinance setting forth regulations for land development; and
WHEREAS, the City of Orangeburg finds that during the adoption of said ordinance it is
necessary to cease any land development or subdivision which would be governed by said Land
Development Ordinance pending its final adoption.
NOW THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY CITY COUNCIL DULY ASSEMBLED that for
the period beginning September 1, 2009 until the final adoption of its Land Development
Ordinance, no land development or subdivision which would be governed by said ordinance shall
be conducted within the corporate limits of the City of Orangeburg until said ordinance is adopted
on third reading or said Land Development Ordinance is tabled by a majority vote of Council.
DO~E AND RATIFIED BYTHE CITY OF ORANGEBURG, STATE OF SOUTH CAROLINA THIS
~ DAY OF SEPTEMBER, 2009. z4.
~~
-~~---?'
C~L
/ - 't
ATTEST; \.....\t.",';':'_~ \I V", I v • v ! =
Members of Council
E \MyFiles\City\Resolution\landDevelopment.wpd
RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE EXECUTION OF A CONTRACT FOR SALE AND
PURCHASE OF REAL ESTATE BETWEEN THE CITY OF ORANGEBURG AND FIRST
CITIZENS BANK AND TRUST COMPANY, INC. AND FOR THE PURCHASE OF SAID
PROPERTY DESCRIBED THEREIN.
WHEREAS, First Citizens Bank and Trust Company, Inc. offered the below described
property to the City of Orangeburg for the consideration of $300,000,00; and,
WHEREAS, the City and its departments are in need of additional office and storage
space which wouid necessitate the construction of additional physical plant for said purposes;
and,
WHEREAS, the City has determined that the cost of said construction far exceeds the
within consideration of $300,000.00; and,
WHEREAS, the City has inspected the building located on the below described property
and finds that same is suitable for its needed office and storage space; and,
WHEREAS, the City finds that it is in its best interest and that of its citizens that the City
purchase the below described property from First Citizens Bank and Trust Company, Inc, in lieu
of expending public funds for the construction of additional physical plant.
NOW THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY CITY COUNCIL DULY ASSEMBLED that the
City of Orangeburg enter into a Contract for Sale and Purchase of Reai Estate ("Contract") with
First Citizens Bank and Trust Company, Inc, for the purpose of purchasing the below described
property in accordance with the terms and conditions of said contract for the total consideration
of $300,000,00,
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, upon compliance by each party with the terms and
conditions of the Contract that the City of Orangeburg purchase the below described property
for the consideration of $300,000,00, subject to the terms and conditions of the Contract.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that John H" Yow, City Administrator is hereby authorized
to enter into said Contract on behalf of the City and to sign any and ail other documents to
purchase the below described property in accordance with the terms and conditions of the said
Contract.
Description of property: Ail that certain piece, parcel or lot of land, with improvements, situate,
lying and being on the northwestern side of the intersection of Broughton and Russell Streets,
in the City of Orangeburg, State of South Carolina, being more fully shown and delineated as
,069 Acre/30213 SQ, Ft. on a pial prepared for First Citizens Bank and Trust Company of South
Carolina by Cox and Dinkins, Inc, dated November 1,2000, recorded in Plat Book C202 at Page
1, which is incorporated herein by reference, and having such measurements, boundaries, and
courses as shown thereon; be all measurementsa little more or less.
DONE ANJ~TJFIED BY THE CITY OF ORANGEBURG, STATE OF
CAROLINA THIS DAY OF SEPTEMBER, 2009. L! ,
T~c( ~""""~-
Mayor
ATTEST:~J~"'v 1
Gltyere
SOUTH
CITY COUNCI L MINUTES
September 15 ,2009
Orangeb urg City Counci l held its regularly sch edu led meeting on T uesday , Septemb er
15, 2009, at 7:00 P .M., in Counci l Chambers with M ayor Miller presiding.
PRESENT:
Paul A. Miller, M ayor
Cha rles B. Barnw ell
Bern ard Haire
Cha rles \V. J ern igan
Sa ndra P . Kn ott s
Joy ce \ V. Rhen ey
ABSENT:
T re tvts A. Mill er
A motion was made by Counci lmcmber Je rnigan, seconded by Mayor Pro Te rn Haire, La
approve the Sep temb er 1, 2009 , City Council Minutes as distribut ed. This motion w as
unanimously approved .
Mr. Dan Visrnor ad dressed Council i n regards to the Land De velopmen t Regulations .
He slated, " This Ordinance, unlike t he Zoning Ord inance which regulates the use of land,
regulates the development o f the con version or raw land i nto d eveloped land. It focuse s
on the installation o f infrastruc ture and it e stablishes minimum design a nd con struction
standards on th e infrastruct ures supporting u rban deve lopment. D esign requ irements a re
streets, curb & gutter, shoulde rs, signage , easements, lots, blocks , sidewalks a nd areas
prone to flooding . This basic ally carrie s it a step further as far as development of a flood
plain as well a s utilities and surveys a nd markin g. The d evelopmen t of this Ordi nance i s
relatively simple . We looked a t what the County h ad in place so we would be as
compat ible as possible with the County regulations. The develop ers in Orangebu rg
County like to know if the rules are reasonably the same. It helps them t remendou sly.
The Administration is div ided between the Zoning Adm inistrator a nd the Pl annin g
Commission. All subdi visio ns of property in the City of Orangebur g would have to c ome
before the Zonin g Administrator be fore anything can be done. If it is an exempt
subdiv ision. that w ould be one according to s tate law that divides propert y to minimum
lot size of greater t han five acres or cemetery lots or the reco nfiguration of lots when you
do not produce any additional lots that is referred to as an exe mpt subdivision i n the State
Code and in your Ordinance . What ha s to happen t here is that the developer still ha s to
come hefore the Zon ing Administrator, he then r eviews it, and stamp s it according ly and
then the developer i s then free to have that su bdivision recorded in the court house . Prior
to regulations such a s these. there were no requireme nt that the su bdivi sion created in the
City o f Orange burg had 10 be approved b y anybo dy before they could be recorded in the
court house. This will change all of that.
The second type of subdivisio n that woul d have to be approved b y the Zoning
Administration would be a m inor subdivis ion. It would have the same number oflots and
the same co nditions that prevai l in Oran geburg County. Jf you a re going to d ivide a piece
ofland on an ex isting street and i t is not going to require any add itional wa ter lin es,
sewer lines, or a dditional drainage requirements , you can do that provided that you do not
exceed five lots. Tha tsubdivision can b e approved by the Zoning Admi nistrator without
having to come before the P lanning Comm ission . What we are trying to do is t o allow
"rubbcrstam p" sub divisions to make it e asier for the developer to get it approved without
having to tie up th e P lanning Commi ssion and schedule it with t hem . It wou ld be a don e
deal and i f it is. the Zoning Ad ministrator should be able to proces s that to e xped ite it.
There are two o ther t ypes of subdivis ions that have to be administe red and approved. a
major subdivision would be anything ov er five lots that involves t he ex tensio n of water
and sewer or any other development. First of all the , Zoning Admini strator wo uld have
to meet w ith the developer to ens ure that the propo sed subdivision m eets all the
requirements and channel t he developer to the approp riate city depart ments in an effort to
help the developer in getting h is plan approved. There w ill be development regu lations
in place and the revi ew o f the plan by the Adm inistrative Staff and the Department
19 35
19%
Page 2
Head 's sho uld be in a position to assis t the developer s o wh en he fi nalizes the s ubdivision
plan, it will mee t all the requirements to get it approve d. Then it goes through a
preliminary plat procedure and a final plat procedure . The final de velopm ent is one that
is not included i n the 1994 Comprehensive Plan, which is called a Land Development
Project othe r than a subdivision. This w as put in legis lation since it wa s reali zed you
could b uild o n a fifty acre site if you don' t subdivide it, it is then not subject to
developm ent regulations of you r Ordinance . A large subd ivision , hospita l comple x or
apartment complex that would be situated on a si ngle lot, irrespecti ve o f tile size, w ou ld
he exe mpt of the regulations prior to 199 4. We then defin ed this dev elopment tha t does
not involve th e division ofla nd and then set forth d esign requirements and criteria t hai
the developer has to meet. There are provisions in the Ordin ance as financ ial guarantees.
Develop ers receive a preliminary plat approva l; otherwise, m eeting th e preliminary
require menls. Thi s entitles him to develop a fi nal pla t, one that wi ll be record ed. Once
that final plat is develop ed, he still cannot record it un til the infrastructure t hat is required
is installed . That can c reate a problem for the develo per as w hat he wan ts to do is to ge t
the p roject started and whe n he se lls lots . he can hel p pay fo r the infrastruc ture that is
needed to s upport that developm ent. What we h ave here is a se ction that sets u p financial
guarantees. If a deve loper co mes be fore the P lann ing Comm issio n and the Co uncil and
requests t hat he give you a fi nancial i nstru ment that w ould be a pprov ed by the C ouncil
and City Attorne y, that basi ca lly pled ges and secures the in stallation of those
improveme nts. It puts yo u in a pos ition of negotiation to give him needed relie f in orde r
for him to estab lish t hat sub divisio n, but at the same time assures you the necessary
improve men ts will be made . Your i nvo lvement in this administration i s minim al;
however , if guarantees are invo lved, you will be d irectly involved . The Plannin g
Commission an d the Zoning Adm inistrator would be involved g reat ly. When you adop t
this Ordin ance; you arc s aying it is fine for now unless you ame nd i t a t a future point like
when you amend t he Zoning Ordinance or Zoni ng Map. You ar e saying t o the Planning
Comm ission it is up to yo u to e nforce th ese r egu lations now. If a develope r does n ot
agree wi th the Planning Commission , his recourse is to C ircuit Court . If the Planni ng
Com miss ion denys a plat, then th e develope r is forced to work o ut a co mpro mise or
develop a plat that is acce pted by the Plann ing Com miss ion unless the Plann ing
Commission w ould grant a v ariance . U nlike w ith the zoning p roce ss, whe re the Planning
Commission mak es reco mm endatio ns and you make the chan ges and any recour se of a
hearing is required, it then goes to th e Zo ning Board o f Appeals. Th e Planning
Commissio n basically operates as the re view a nd approval age ncy b ut a lso t he ent ity that
can relax and a pprov e these regula tions accordingly . I served on the R ichland Cou nty
Plann ing Comm ission for ei ght ye ars and the o nly time w e actuall y rev iew ed and
approved plats is when t hey did not me et the strict st andards and requir ements of the
Ord inance. We essentially gave t hat j ob to the admi nistrati ve staff. 1tstates in black and
white what you have to do to get y our plat approv ed and when you do that, you wi ll get it
approved. T he standard proced ure was to acc ept the recom mendation s of the staf f.
Those that were brought to o ur attention were usua l grounds such as hardship o n a
develo per to m eet t he strict rules and regulations . There has to be a provision in place to
provide for relief in the eve nt you have a situation th at ju st doesn ' t fit. T he Pl ann ing
Comm ission acts as an approvi ng authority or relief authority. If he fe els like he needs to
appeal, he can go to Circui t Co urt. In m y recollection, I don't t hink anyt hing has been
sent to court. We a lso have in th is Ordinance a checklist th at is designed to b e used by
the develope r to make s ure he has addressed every thing and t o ex pedite the pr ocess."
Mayor Pro Te m H aire st ated . " I am a li ttle troubled by the fac t that the Zoning
Administrat or has the final say a nd we don't have a ny authority, it is being gi ven a way .
What is the rationale o f going to Ci rcuit Court i nstead of Counci l?"
Mr. Vismor replied , "Tha t is in Sta le Code and that is the wa y it wa s se t up. 1 wasn 't
consulted when they drafted the St ate Code or J would not have sugg ested that as a reli ef
valve and w e jus t cannot g et aro und t hat: '
Page 3
Mayor Pro Tern Haire s tated. " I have o ften said that to o much au tho rity has been taken
away from us by the State an d hop efull y some day so meo ne will cha llenge thi s."
City Admini strator Yow s lated, "As I said last week, I want to make sure t hat you know
that this does n ot t ake the place of the Zoning O rdin ance; all o f these developm ents must
meet the zoning requirements . Th is is just for ce rtain types of large devel opm ents ."
Coun cilm cmb er Barnwel l stated, " I also co ncur w ith Mr . Haire's c once rn with certai n
power s of Coun cil. Docs this apply t o in city or o utside the city?"
City Administrator Yow replied . "Inside th e city."
Coun ciImcmh er Barnwell asked, "If a developer wants to subd ivide prop ert y and bu ild
A-2 M ulti-Famil y hou sing right in the middle ofa reside ntial section, can he do it, even
if it less than five lots?"
Mr . Vismo r repli ed, "No , that is covered by your Zoning Ordi nan ce. Tha t is the u se of
land where he i s going t o use propert y withi n an established sing le family area by a
multi- family use. That is the use o f land . This Ordinance spea ks spec ifically and
exclusively to infra stru cture , it doesn't have anyth ing to do wit h land.
Co uncilmem ber Barn well re plied , " I still have probl ems with it as giving up C oun cil' s
rights ."
Mr. Vismor repli ed, "This Or din ance parallels in a numbe r of ways th e land deve lopment
regu lations in Orangebur g C ounty so it won't be a new ba llgame i f they mov e from the
Count y to the Cit y and vice ve rsa. It was important to k eep t hese as c lose a s possib le."
Mayor Pro Tern Haire aske d, ' Individuals can incur a suit and th e C ity would have to
incur c osts t o fight this s uit?"
Mr. Vis mor rep lied , " Yes, but k eep in mind, that the regula tions are specific so th e
develo per know s what h e has to do to co nvert raw la nd into th e C ity int o develop ed land
in term s of prov iding the n ecessary i nfrastructure and there fore, it is not the Pl ann ing
Commi ssion that is arbitrary in an y regard . The onl y question is the inabilit y of the
develope r to meet t hese r egu lations. Ifhe cannot meet the regu lat ions, then the Planning
Commi ssion will m eet with the dev elop er in order to get some relief a nd it is my
experie nce that they w ill ass ist the d evelopment in order not to stop dev elopment , There
are mor e o ften t o ben d the ru les than ta ke a hard position to enable a devel ope r to take it
to a Circu it Court. Th ere a re minimum standards that yo u have es tablished, if the y ar c
too r igid, then you get back in to the act with an amendm ent to the Ordin ance. If anyt ime
you feel this is not performin g the way yo u intend ed it to perform and it is increas ing the
cost o f development and th ey are bringing this to your a ttention , the n you need to a mend
them just like you wou ld with the Zoning Ordi nance or an y o ther on e you would adopt."
Councilme mbcr Barnwell aske d, "W hy a ll developm ents ca n' t be brou ght before t he
Plannin g Commis sion?"
Mr. Vismor replied , " We tri ed to take the easier ones out and n ot en cumbe r the rev iew
proc ess. If I ow ned a strip of land and it alread y had al l the wa ter and sewer lines and I
wanted t o di vide it into t hr ee or four lots, why wou ld you want me t o hold off on
approv ing that wh en all I would have to do is go before the Zon ing Admin istrato r and he
approves it an d ch eck s the regul atio ns and the y can start build ing . In m os t cases stree ts
arc in p lace , water and sewer i s there . We have felt in those instan ces you should not
burd en the deve loper in go ing through the P lanning Com mission when i t is a rout ine
thing; when yo u wo uld li ke to stream line t he regulations a nd n ot inhi bit t he d evel op er
and save t ime ."
193 7
19G8
Pa ge 4
Councilmembc r Barnwell stated, " H sounds to me that this Land Ordin ance is more in
favor of the de veloper ?"
Mr. Vismor replied, "I wou ldn' t say that because c urrently any developer in the City of
Orangeburg has no regulations unless they go by Department o f Public Utilities. Right
now, they have no re gulations whereas the Co unty does. It is a whole l ot easier than
building in the County now beca use they have regulations and those plats have to go
before their Plannin g Co mmission or staff. I hard ly see it is in favor o f the developer: '
Councilmerubcr Jernigan s tated, " 1concur with Councilmembcr B arnwe ll and Mayor Pro
Tem Haire beca use I feel like we arc out of the loo p and the citizens of Orangeburg have
elected us to be in that loop and when you take us out, it is not fair to them."
Mr. Vismor replied, "C urre ntly, you are not in the loop, because there is no loop."
City Administrator Yow stated, "That is why I stated before, I think there is some
confusion on this. The re is no au thority taken a way from City Counci l, you will still have
the same aut hority. Th is is additional regulation a nd if you d idn 't adopt t his, there won' t
be any r egulations. It is your decision what goes in the Ordinan ce, it is new
requireme nts, it is not putt ing less on them . I don't think. any developer w ould argue that
this is giving them mo re lever age. I think state law doesn' t allow this t o be appealed to
Council; therefore i f we don 't adopt it, they operate under o nly our curre nt Zoning
Ordinanc e now."
Council mcmbe r Jernigan aske d, " In the past, I think a develo per would go b efore the
Planning Commi ssion and t hen it came to us?"
City Administrator Y ow replied, "It still will ."
Councilmembe r Jernig an ask ed, "What is wrong w ith this coming to us after it comes to
the Planni ng Commis sion?"
City Admini strator Yow replied, " State law doesn 't allow it other than the fin ancial
guarantee ."
Mr. Vismor stated, "T hat is correct, it comes to you for an Ordinance change. If you
were going to cha nge the Ordin ance , it would back t o Council. If a develope r wanted
some relief, it wo uldn 't go to you, it would go to the Zoning Boa rd of Appeal s. The
point I was trying to make e arlier , under your Zoning Or diann ce you have a Z oning
Board of Appeals t hat can accep t appeals. Under thi s Ordi nance , there is no Zoning
Board o f Appea ls, the Plann ing Com mission can review and a ppro ve them even though i t
doesn't meet the strict definition s in this Ordinance . They have more authority outside of
and beyond the str ict re gulations . If there is any k ind o f conflict between the
Comm ission and develop er, it go es to cou rt. In my exper ience, if there is any kind of
con flict, the d evelop er know s what he has to do and unless there are e xtenuating
circum stances that he c anno t do it a nd he can convince the Plann ing Commi ssio n of
these, nine times out of ten, th ey will c ompromise . It is not goi ng to court in all
likelihood, it is go ing to b e resolved at the Planning Com mission and administrat ive
level. It is like Fred, he has his regu lations and develop ers he has to wo rk with and if
they can' t meet them an d they fee l if there is a circumstance to provide relief, he may
consider it. "
City Attorney Walsh s tated, "The P larming Commissio n under this Ordinance is ac ting
like the Board of Appea ls, there are no changes."
Cou ucilrnember Jernigan slate d "I understand that, but if I had a piece of property that
met all the zoning reg ulations an d someone wanted to build a ho spit al on this piece and it
met all the regulations, but some citizens around the neighborhoo d doesn't want this
there. What are we going to tell them, we are not in con trol, you have to talk to the
Planning Commission ,"
Pa ge 5
Mr. Vismor replied , "No, th at is zoning."
City Attorney Walsh replied. "There ar e a few times where the Circuit Court and
Supreme Court could overtum what the City does because they have met the
requirements...
Mr. Vismor stated, "11 gets back t o zoning reg ulations and these regu lations. If they
allow something that you don 't think ought to be allowed, then the regulations should be
addressed. That is where you get back involved and redo the regulation s."
Councilmcmbe r Jernigan asked, "What if we put something in there where it has to come
to us for final approval, but at least it gives us some authority now?"
Mr. Vismor replied, "Again, what you ar e talking about i s not an issue that is covered in
these regulations."
City ALtome y Walsh slated, "What you arc talking about comes wi th a good
Comprehensive Plan, which would prevent that and Council has adopted th e
Comprehensive Plan."
Mayor Miller as ked, "If the subjec t property is in an area zoned A- I, the only thing that
the developer co uld put in there is A-I. if it was zoned B ~ I , then all that could be put
there is what is in that t able in the Comprehensive Plan, so that i s the failsafe in passing
this Land Developm ent Re gulations."
Mr. Vismor stated, "Yes, this has nothin g to do with the Zoning Ordinance."
City Attorney Walsh stated, "Currently we have no control over a developer who has a
large tract of land, thi s is to give us m ore c ontrol of a developer o ver a l arge piece of
prop ert y."
Mr. Vismor replied, " I don 't think con trol is the right word, it is that you will ensure that
this property is properly developed and the proper infrastructure will be put in place and
that is all this Ordinance w ill accom plish."
Mayor Miller stated. "As w e annex p roperty, it is annexed A- I, isn't that correc t?"
City Adm inistrato r Yow replied, "It is z oned A- I unl ess Council makes ano ther zoning
recommendation ."
Mayor Miller stated, " If we brought in a tract ofl and and it came in as A- I, unless the
developer c ame before Counci l and asked fo r it to be a shopping center'; otherwise, it
would come in as A- t. That is wher e Council has their say as t o what c an and cannot be
buill on that land."
City Adm inistrator Yow agreed.
City Administrator Yow sugg ested postponin g Second Reading until Cou ncil m embers
have an opportunity to contact h im for f urther review of the Land Development
Ordinance.
Counci lmember Jernigan made a motion t o postpone the Second Reading o f an
Ordinance adopting Land Development regu lations for the City of Orangebu rg until a
later meeting. This motion was seconded by Counc ihnember B arnwell and unanimou sly
appro ved.
/9'1':1
Page 6
A motion was made by Councilrn ember Barnwell , seconded by Ma yor Pro Tern Hai re, to
approve the Second Read ing of an Ordinanc e to approv e the Second Reading of an
Ordina nce to an nex the within describ ed propert y as Orangeburg Foods , Inc., Tax Map
#0173-19-03-003 into the City of Orangebur g, South Carolin a. This motion was
unanimously approved .
A mot ion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Haire , seconded by Co uncilrn emb er Knotts, to
approve the Second Reading of an Ordinan ce to amend the Munic ipal Distric t Map dated
November 6,2001, for the purpose of adding newly annexed City property, Tax Map
#0173 -19-03-003 to Municipal Council District Five (5). This m otion was unanimou sly
approved .
A motion was made by Councilmemb er Rheney , second ed by Mayor Pro Tern H aire, to
approve the Second Reading of an Ordi nance to annex the wi thin described property of
Stephen D. Nash , Orangeburg Stockyards , located at 805 Wha ley Street at Tax Maps
#0173-19-03-008 /0173 -19-03-009 into the City of Orangeburg, South Carolina . This
motion was unanimously approved .
A motion was made by Ma yor Pro Tern Haire, se conded by Coun cihnember Barnwe ll, to
approve a S eco nd Reading of an Ordin ance to amend the Mu nicipal Distr ict Map dated
Novemb er 6, 200 1, for the purpose of adding newl y annexed City prop erty, Tax Maps
#0173-19-03-00 8/0 173-19-03-009 to Municipal Counci l Distric t Five (5). This motion
was unanimously approved .
A motion was made by Co uncilmember Barnwell , seconded by Councilmember Knotts,
to approve the F irst Reading of an Ordinance amend ing the Genera l Terms and
Conditions of the Department of Public Utilities to adop t and imp lement Land
Developmen t Regulatio ns of the City . This motion was unanimous ly approved .
Councilmember Rheney recognize d Mr. Harris Davis for his dedicated service to th e
City's Planning Commi ssion. Mr. Dav is resigned from his position on the Planning
Commissio after appr oximate ly twenty (20) years of service .
A motion wa s made b y Mayor Pro Tern Haire, seconded by Councilme mber Jernigan, to
enler into an Executive Session for a con tractual matter concern ing Orangeburg County
Chamber of Comme rce Bui lding . This motion was unanimously a pprov ed.
A motion was made by Cou ncilmember Jernigan , seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, to
return to Open Session . This motio n as un animousl y approved .
Council returne d to Open Sess ion.
Councilmember Barnwell made a motion authorizing the City Adm inistrator to make a
payment in the amou nt o f $ 120,000 toward the principa l balance on debt o utstanding on
the Orangeburg County Cham ber of Commerce building and to put the matter of
extending the no te on the Octo ber 6, 2009 City Council agenda. This mo tion was
seconded by Councilm embe r Jernigan . This motion was unanimously approved .
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, seconded by Councilmember Jern igan, to
adjourn. This motion was u nanimously appro ved .
There being no furth er business , the meeting was adjourned .
c:i~h; ub m i tt e
Carrie W. Jo
CWJ/pfb
2001
City Council Minutes
October 6, 2009
Orangeburg City Council held its regularly scheduled meeting on Tuesday, October 6,
2009, at 7 :00 P.M., in Council Chambers with Mayor Miller presiding.
PRESENT:
Paul A. Miller, Mayor
Charles B. Barnwell
Charles W. Jernigan
L. Zimmerman Keitt
Sandra P. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
ABSENT:
Bernard Haire
Oaths of Office wer e held for Mayor Paul A. Miller , and Councilmembers Charles B.
Barnwell, L. Zimmerman Keitt, and Richard F . Stroman .
Project Life Positeen recognized a class and students from SC State University were
recognized.
A motion was made by Mayor Miller, s econded by Counc ilmember Jernigan to change
the meeting time at the October 20, 2009 meeting to 6:00 p .m. This motion was
unanimously approved.
A Public Hearing was held on a zoning change request from A-2 Multi-Family
Residential District to 0-1, Office-Institutional Residential District, property belonging
to Charles L. Dibble for property located at the intersection of Middleton Street and
Adden Street at Tax Map #0152-16-06-003.
Assistant City Adm inistra tor John S ingh addressed Council on the re zoning request of
property located at the intersections of Middleton and Adden Streets .
Mayor Miller asked if anyone would like to speak at the Public Hearing .
Mr. Bill Davis , representative of Larry Blumberg and Associates of Dothan , Alabama,
addressed Council representing Mr. Dibble . " I came up a few weeks ago and met with
your planning and zoning . I reviewed the minutes of that meeting and that is what brings
me here today. A couple of items I'd like to clarify from that meeting. First of all, it was
mentioned in that meeting that we were attempt ing to rezone the entire parcel at Adden
and Middleton Streets. That is not entirely true; we are only requesting the rezoning of
1.27 ofthe 2.25 acres . We feel that the property is in the trans ition between residential
and commercial. We are not asking for spot zoning. I have copies of the zoning map and
the parcel located directly to the west separated by Adden Street is currently zoned 0-1.
We are not asking for special circumstances, we are only asking for the 0-1 to be
extended across the street. " Slides were shown of the proposed site, proposed buildings
and the landscape dimensions. "What we are trying to do is to relocate the Social
Security Building. Th ey have outgrown their current building and they have solicited
bids for new construction. This is our proposal to rezone this property for that purpose.
This project will fit in well architecturally . We have done about a dozen ofthese for
Social Security across the Southeast. As you can see , it is a brick facade building that
will blend in very well. It will be an office Monday through Friday, open from 8:00 a.m.
until 5:00 p .m. with low traffic. It is a good fac ility to put in this trans ition area."
2002Page 2
Councilmember Jern igan asked about 0 -1Zoning in the parcel.
Mr. Davis stated, "The Middleton and Adden Street apartments are already zoned."
Councilmernber K eitt aske d, "Do you still own the current bu ilding w here Social
Security is now?"
Mr. Davis replied, " We do not own that building, it is owned b y Mr. Wayne Lorick.
What he is planning to do with the buildin g, I am not certain. S ocial Security is currentl y
soliciting bids to cons truct a new building."
Councilmember Barnwe ll stated, "I hate to see a nother vacant buil ding, [ don't w ant to
see a buildin g back up to a residential neighborhood. How long will they be at that
location?"
Mr. Davis replied , "They signed a fifteen year lease . I wouldn' t pursue this as a
developer, if it wasn' t feasible."
Councilmemb er Jernigan asked about spot zoning.
City Attorne y Walsh answere d this would not be spot zoning.
Mayor Miller asked, "You don 't have a con tract yet, you are just in a bid situation, is that
right?"
Mr. Davis replied. "Yes, you are corr ect."
Mayor Miller stated, " If we were to overturn the Planning Commis sion and you didn 't
get the deal, we would have a piece of property that we rezoned for w hat?"
Mr. Davis replied, "I would like to offer that if Council would consider th is, it would be
contingent on my contract. I can't guarantee th at, we have built almost every Social
Security office in the Southeast in the last five years."
Mayor Miller aske d, "I don't e ven know i f that is possible, it is either voted up or down.
That is one of the things [have a concern with, if we overturn th e Planning Commission.
They have spent a lot of time with zoning matters ove r the years. In thi s economy, there
are a lot of hungry people out there in the bidding process. Ifw e op en it up and you do
not get the contract, then something else, less desirable may go there. It is a shame th at
they built th at building not long ago and can't retrofit it to suit th eir needs and not waste
tax payer's money ."
Mr. Davis stated, "I understand y our position a nd there is no guarantee th at my firm will
get the proj ect, but if Council voted i n favor of the rezoning and someo ne decided to
come in later yo ur City's Planning Commission would still have to ok t he use. No one
will be abl e to come in and put a l iquor store there because yo u have defi ned uses in your
municipal cod e that will prohibit that."
Councilmemb er Jernigan stated, "It just seems to me that when we have a zoning change
it is trying to change residential prop erty to some sort o f business and we have tried over
time to discourage that as much as possible."
Councilmember Stroman asked, "Hav e you looked a t any oth er sites?"
Z003
Page 3
Mr. Davis stated, "GSA g ives us a delineated area and this particul ar site would be the
only one that would quali fy. I don't know if you are familiar wi th that come r, but there
are some areas that n eed some sprucing up and I believe that thi s build ing wo uld be much
more attractive th an what is down there now. I understand your con cern about a
residential area. There ar e acres there now that are zoned for bu siness a nd it is not like
going into a residential area puttin g in a convenience store. It is a transitional a rea and it
is a good fit. The onl y residential area that we are touching is to the east and we have a
buffer zone and landscape zo ne. The property to the north, we intend that to remain A-2
and that is residential off of Broughton . We are not asking for that to be rezoned. T here
is a 58.5 foot buffer to the nearest home. I am in a catch-22, without th e zoning, there
would be no contract."
Hearing uo comments th e Public Hearing was closed.
Ms. Eddie Glenn Bryant addressed Council, as information, pertaining to the Greater
Orangeburg Mayor's Committee on the Employment of People with D isabilities.
Council was provided a ca lendar of events includin g White Cane Day at SC State
University on October 16, 2009.
At the request of City Admini strator Yow for Mayor Pro Tern H aire, in his absence, a
motion was made by Councilm ember Bamwe ll, seconded b y Councilmember Keitt, to
table item #4, Seco nd Reading of an Ordinance adopting Land D evelopment Regulations
for the City of Orangeburg. This motion was unanimou sly approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Bamwell , to
approve the Third Read ing o f an Ordinance to annex the with in described property as
Orangeburg Foods, Inc. , Tax Map #0 173-19-03-003 into th e City of Orangeburg, SC.
This motion was unanimously ap proved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded b y Councilmember J ernigan,
to approve Third Readin g of an Ordinance to amend the Muni cipal District Map da ted
November 6, 200 I, for the purpose of adding newly annexed City property, Tax Map
#0 173-19-03-003 to Muni cipal Cou ncil District Five (5). This m otion was unanimously
approved.
A motion as made by Councilmember J ernigan, seconded by Councilmember K eitt, to
approve the Third Reading o f an Ordinance to annex the w ithin described property of
Stephen D. Nash, Orangeburg S tockyards, l ocated at 805 Wha ley Street at Tax Map #' s
0173-19-03-008/0173-19-03-009 into the City of Orangeburg S C. This motion was
unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember B arnwell, sec onded b y Councilmember Knotts,
to approve th e Third R eading of an Ordinance to amend the Muni cipal District Ma p dated
November 6 ,2001, f or the purpose of adding newly annexed City property, Tax Map
#' s 0173-19-03-008/0173-19-03-009 to Municipal Council Di strict Five (5). T his motion
was unanimously approv ed.
Mr. Don Tribble, Orangeburg C ounty Community of Character Director, ac cepted t he
Proclamation fo r October 2009, "Tru thful" .
Item #10, First Reading of an Ordinance for a zoning change from A-2 Multi-Family
Residential Di strict to 0-1 Office-Institutional Re sidential District property belo nging to
Charles L. Dibble for prop erty located the intersection of Middleton S treet and Adden
Street at Tax Map #0152-16-06 -003 died for lack of a motion.
:J..ooLf
Page 4
A motion was made by Councilmember Stroman , seconded b y Councilmember Jerni gan,
to authorize City Admini strator Yow to accept th e GrantlViolence Against Women Act in
the amount of$ 47,450.00 with a loc al match of $15,817.00 Th is motion was
unanimou sly approved .
A motion was made by Councilmember J ernigan, seco nded b y Councilmember Keitt, t o
pass a Resolution to appl y for $400,000 Community D evelopment B lock Grant for the
purpose of redeveloping Boswell Street Neighborhood . This motion was un animously
approved .
A motion was made by Councilmember J ernigan, seco nded by Councilmembcr Barnw ell,
to pass a Resolut ion authorizing the extension o f the mortga ge to SC Bank a nd Trust on
the Orangeburg Count y Chamber Bu ilding and authori zing payment in th e amount of
$120,000 for principal loan reduction. This motion was unanim ously approved .
A motion was made by Councilmemb er Barnwell, seconded b y Councilmember Knott s,
to table item #14, Second Readin g of an Ordin ance a mending th e Gener al Terms a nd
conditions of the Department of Publi c Utilities to adopt and impl ement Land
Development R egulati ons of the City, since the Second Read ing o f an Ordin ance
adopting L and Development Regulations for the City has been tabled . Th is mo tion w as
unanimously approved .
A motion was made by Councilmember Barn well, se conded b y Councilmember K eitt, to
adjourn. This motion was unanimously approved .
There bei ng no further bu siness, the meeting was adjourned .
Carrie W. Jo'
City Clerk
/pfb
Resolution
Resolution to apply for $400,000 Community Development Block Grant
for the purpose of redeveloping Boswell Street Neighborhood
WHEREAS, the City of Orangeburg, Orangeburg County, South Carolina desires to improve
and to provide safer living conditions for the citizens of the City; and
WHEREAS, the City of Orangeburg, Orangeburg County, South Carolina is applying for a
(CDBG) Community Development Block Grant in the amount of $400,000 for
Neighborhood Revitalization in the Boswell Neighborhood; and,
WHEREAS, the City of Orangeburg, Orangeburg County, South Carolina must supply 10%
matching funds for a Community Development Block Grant; and,
WHEREAS, the City of Orangeburg, Orangeburg County, South Carolina is committing the
required 10% matching funds.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, by the Mayor and Members of City Council this
sixth day of October, 2009, in Orangeburg, South Carolina to apply for CDBG Grant Funds in
the amount of $400,000 for Boswell Street Neighborhood Redevelopment.
~.y:~
Mayor
'-- /.2f:(,l1. «-fA T. '!-'\h-~
Members of Council
r;~u nL
City Cler
RESOLUTION
A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE EXTENSION OF THE MATURITY DATE OF THE
MORTGAGE OF TWO AND SIXTY·NINE HUNDREDTHS (2.69) ACRES, WITH
BUILDINGS AND OTHER IMPROVEMENTS THEREON, TO SOUTH CAROLINA BANK
AND TRUST IN THE PRINCIPAL SUM OF FIVE HUNDRED THOUSAND ($500,000.00)
DOLLARS AND RECORDED IN THE OFFICE OF THE REGISTER OF DEEDS FOR THE
COUNTY OF ORANGEBURG, STATE OF SOUTH CAROLINA IN MORTGAGE BOOK
1551 AT PAGE 293
WHEREAS, the City of Orangeburg by Ordinance 2005-1 authorized the above
described mortgage, and;
WHEREAS, the Orangeburg County Chamber of Commerce has requested South
Carolina Bank and Trust to extend the maturity date of its loan secured by said mortgage,
and;
WHEREAS, South Carolina Bank and Trust has agreed to said extension
conditioned on a reduction of the outstanding principal.
NOW THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED BY CITY COUNCIL DULY ASSEMBLED,
that the City of Orangeburg does hereby consent to the extension of the maturity date of
that certain mortgage of The City of Orangeburg to South Carolina Bank and Trust in the
maximum obligation limit of Five Hundred Thousand ($500,000.00) dollars dated February
11.2005 and recorded in the Office of the Register of Deeds forthe County of Orangeburg.
State of South Carolina in Mortgage Book 1551 at page 293 to October 6, 2010 in
consideration of a principal loan reduction in the amount of $120,000.00 to be paid by the
City.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that John H. Yow, City Administrator is hereby
directed and authorized to execute a Commercial Loan Modification Agreement for the
above purpose and take all other necessary actions authorized by this resolution.
DONE AND RA~P!E\Y THE CITY OF ORANGEBURG, STATE OF SOUTH
CAROLINA THI ' . dAY OF OCTOBER, 2009.
~4".~
9_Chamber of Commerce.wpd
-R
,7 £/.~,~""",
'<\ ,~""',-~..2\.~ ~-
" mbers of Council
Maypr
ATTES~'~ v ",=<_V C' I I v,"
) I
ity Clerk
2005
City Council Minutes
October 20, 2009
Orangeburg City Council held its regularly scheduled meeting on Tuesday, October 6,
2009, at 7:00 P.M., in Council Chambers with Mayor Miller presiding.
PRESENT:
Paul A. Miller, Mayor
Bemard Haire
Charles B. Barnwell
L. Zimmerman Keitt
Sandra P. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
ABSENT:
Charles W. Jemigan
Mayor Miller recognized students from SC State University and Claflin University and a
Boy Scout working on a communications badge.
A motion was made by Councilmember Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Knotts, to
approve the October 6, 2009 minutes as distributed. Mayor Miller, Councilmembers
Keitt, Knotts and Stroman voted for the approval of the minutes and Mayor Pro Tern
Haire abstained and Councilmember Bamwell was not present at the time of the voting.
DPU Manager Fred Boatwright and Director of the Electrical Division John Bagwell
presented David G. Long a Retiree Resolution for his thirty (30) years, six (6) months
and twenty-four (24) days of service to the Department of Public Utilities.
City Administrator Yow addressed Council. He stated, "We have had First Reading on
adopting the Land development Regulations Ordinance a few meetings ago. This
Ordinance is very similar to those used by other govemments including Orangeburg
County. Mr. Dan Vismor came and presented this to Council at First Reading. He has
worked with Orangeburg County on their Land Development Ordinance. We may have
developers in the City and in the County that are developing tracts. It would be
beneficial to have similar Land Development Ordinances. We started looking at this
about a year ago. As we annex large tracts ofland and undeveloped tracts, we needed
something to complement the Comprehensive Plan and the Zoning Ordinance and
conditions. This does not substitute or take the place of the Zoning Ordinance or
Comprehensive Plan. All of the conditions of both of these Ordinances are still in effect.
The Land Development Ordinance goes beyond the Zoning Ordinance into the areas and
events of infrastructure. It ensures the City's standards are met with adequate utilities,
streets, sidewalks, drainage, greens pace and traffic pattems. It even has dimensions and
designs of curbs and gutters. It is necessary for a developer to meet those requirements
that we have set f0l1h before a plat is recorded. The Ordinance helps eliminate any
subjective determination on what is adequate infrastructure. Right now, we do not have
anything to detemline that. This gives us another tool to protect persons who move into a
Development but at the same time it is assisting the Developer with clear guidelines to
meet and follow and if they do that they can reasonably expect their approval of plans by
the City. It is a balancing thing to protect the City and the citizens. I would recommend
we proceed with Second Reading."
Page 2
2006
Mr. Marion Moore from the audience asked ifit was voted on tonight, when it would be
brought back for final reading. City Administrator Yow stated, "In two weeks." City
Administrator Yow would get Mr. Moore a copy of the Ordinance for his review.
Councilmember Barnwell stated, "Initially, I had some apprehensions on this, but after
reading and researching, State Law supersedes us and we have to have this in place
because we have nothing now."
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Keitt, to
approve the Second Reading of an Ordinance adopting a Land Development Regulation
for the City.
MPT Haire stated, "While I have had some concems, I plan to vote in favor of this. Once
again, I'd like to state my dislike to Legislation as it seems we are still being left out of
proceedings and appeal processes. Home Rule was voted on some years ago and it seems
that is being eroded."
Carrie: Was it unanimously and where do you want me to put this since Haire made a
comment before voting.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tem Haire, seconded by Councilmember Knolls, to
approve the Second Reading of an Ordinance amending the General Terms and
Conditions of the Department of Public Utilities to adopt and implement Land
Development Regulations of the City. This motion was unanimously approved.
Mayor Pro Tem Haire made a motion for City Administrator Yow to write a letter to the
Highway Department for their help in solving the drainage problem on Maxcy Street. It
was seconded by Councilmember Barnwell and unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tem Haire, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to
adjourn. This motion was unanimously approved.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
Respectfi
o,
Carrie W. JohnSefn
City Clerk
/ptb
N
_0_
City Council Meeting
November 3, 2009
2007
Orangeburg City Council held its regularly scheduled meeting on Tuesday, November 3, 2009 at
7:00 P.M., in Council Chambers with Mayor Miller presiding.
Present:
Paul A. Miller, Mayor
Charles B. Barnwell
Bernard Haire
Charles W. Jernigan
L. Zimmerman Keitt
Sandra P. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
Mayor Miller mentioned that next Wednesday, November 11, 2009 would be a little more than a regular
Veterans Day. The City will dedicate the Veterans Memorial Park on this day. The dedication will be
held in conjunction with the Veterans Memorial Services. Lt. E.G. Buck Shuler, Orangeburg resident, US
Air Force- Retired, wiii the guest speaker. Information will be in the paper and the street will be
blocked from 301 to Riverside. We will have people movers for people parking in the Gardens and
needing transportation. There will also be a fly over at 11:25 A.M. The monument has been in talks for
10 years and is being paid for by the Penny Capital Sales Tax Program. All the bricks have been sold at
this time. Refreshments will be provided on the front porch of the Chamber and the Jarvis Brothers will
be providing the entertainment. The program will begin at 11:00 A.M.
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Mayor Pro Tem Haire, to approve the
October 20,2009, minutes as distributed. This was a 6-0-1 vote as Councilmember Jernigan was not
present at the last meeting.
Mr. Marion Moore addressed Council. He stated, "I stand before you tonight as a very concerned citizen
of Orangeburg, not as a local realtor and developer. I am here to address the Land Planning Ordinance.
I have done some research since the last meeting and I am asking you to reject or at the very ieast, table
it, until some further study can be done to show its impact on the citizens of this community. Realize I
said citizens, not developers or builders. I will not stand before you and go through ever page of such an
ill formed document. This is the broadest, most oppressive, cumbersome document that I have ever
reviewed in my 35 years in real estate. It is, in my opinion, total counter productive in what we should
be doing in trying to grow our City. Nobody would deny that we do need a program for development;
this is just over the top. I hope that you have had time to study this because it is a very complex
document. I think that it will stifle development in the City and force development in the County. It will
raise the cost of any new housing and business development and guess who's going to pay for that, me
and you. With this new plan it could raise the cost of hard development, the roads and infrastructure
cost of any new development by 15 to 25 percent. By stifling the growth it will reduce the future real
estate tax base in the City. It will also make us less competitive to attract new business in Orangeburg.
This will just be one more brick in the wall for not getting new business. I have not been able to get an
answer as to why this came about with the Planning Commission, but from what I have gathered, it was
due to a developer not doing what he was supposed to do and clearly it cost DPU a sum of money. If
that is the problem, let's address that problem; do not throw the baby out with the bath water. Let's
pass an Ordinance that would protect DPU from this again, not something that is so broad and menacing
as this Plan. It is not like the City is overrun with rampant unsuperVised new development. We have a
great Council, administration, building inspectors than I have ever seen in my 35 years. Even with what
the County has right now, this Plan is more stringent than what the County has. I can't think of one
development done in the City in the recent past that was not done tasteful and pleasing and passed all
the DHEC and City inspections imposed on it. Just let the public know what the major problems are if
we are having them. I am not sure taking the Council out of the circle is the best thing to do. This is
about the future of the City of Orangeburg. We just need to be very careful how we position ourselves
to other cities. I ask that you take a stand tonight and reject this Ordinance or at least table this so that
it can be studied further."
Page 2
MaycJ!~ Haire asked, "Are you familiar with the Point of Sale Bill and what that particular Bill
would do to cities, counties and school boards as it relates, if it is passed."
Mr. Moore stated, "I understand it is going to create more revenue for the City"
Mayor Pro Tem Haire stated, "It was going to create more revenue?"
Mr. Moore said, "I would think by adding more taxes."
Mayor Pro Tem Haire said, "According to the way he understands that legislation, the legislatiDn that
came up In 2006 that gave some relief tD people to help keep them in their homes and in that
legislatiDn, you could only in 5 years raise the mileage by 15%. Under this particular plan with the Point
of Sale, if that house has a value of WOK and the realtor sells it for 12SK, we cannot get that full value of
125K, we can only get llSK as it relates tD value because we can not go over 15%. You, as a realtor,
come to us and ask us for our understanding with this particular legislation that was generated in the
State Legislature that prevents us from doing what we are talking about doing; but on the other hand
you all as realtors, and I am not saying you in particular, are working with it, but you as realtors are tying
our hands as what we can do in Dur local government and you are criticizing that pDrtion of the
legislatiDn that prevents us from dDing something but you are supporting a piece Df legislation that's
preventing us from doing something."
Mr. Moore stated, "I was never for POS, I am not here representing any realtors Dr my company. I want
the City tD grow so that the City will have a iarger tax base. I think if you adopt this Ordinance, I think
you will see less growth."
Mayor Pro Tem Haire stated, "You mean less growth as the City annexing?"
Mr. Moore stated, "I think it will be a tougher fight, I'm not saying you won't get it, but people wili be
less inclined to come into the City with these regulations. That is just my opinion though."
Councilmember Barnwell stated, "As far as excluding CDunciI, it was by state statue and that is what he
was opposed to, but that was something that state legislature has done, but I would love to be able to
help, but there is no choice."
Mr. Moore stated, "There were more chDices,there were several things in the Ordinance that they
could change Dr ami!."
Councilmember Barnwell stated, "I am not a develDper, but were there some specifics that YDU are
strongly opposed to?"
Mr. Moore stated, "Some Df the changes for the rDad building are Dutrageous, the new platting
procedures are unbelievable, the fact that DPU wDuld no longer put the utilities in, that wDuld be left up
to the developer. I have a lot of points, but I think this is just an ill formed document. "
Councilmember Barnwell asked, "If it was gDing to CDSt the resident more money to purchase a house?"
Mr. Moore stated, "I am telling you, for a fact, it will cost you more tD buy a house in the City period,
because the infrastructure CDSt to bring that into the City would be SD great."
Mayor Pro Tem Haire asked, "If it was Dkay fDr the City to bear the cost of that infrastructure but not the
realtor?"
Mr. MaDre stated, I'm not saying that at all, but that it has changed the rules."
MayDr Pro Haire stated, "The same infrastructure that we are talking about DPU Manger Boatwright
has been providing that; SD in other words, now YDU are saying it has shifted tD the developer;
therefDre, it is Dkay for DPU to pay for it, but not the developer. "
Mr. Moore stated, "Yes, but DPU will get paid for it by tap fees and ongDing cost Df the utilities that is
what you all do. But the developer wDuld have to pay that and then that CDSt is passed on to the
consumer."
2oo<i
Page 3
Mayor Miller asked, "What's the difference between the City Land Planning Ordinance and the one the
County has?"
Mr. Moore stated, "That's a great question and it was asked by the vice-chairman of the Planning
Commission and it was never answered. This document is quite more stringent than the County
document in ever which a way. "
City Administrator Yow stated, "I can answer that, and I stated on the phone that I had a list of that as
an example, the street's pavement width, the requirements are the same in the City and the County.
The required right-a-way widths are actually 50 feet for City and 66 feet for the County and only 50 for
the City, so it is actualiy less in the City. The standards that the roads have to be built to are the
Highway Department standards. The one difference Mr. Moore is correct on, is that the City requires
curb and gutters which could provide extra cost."
Mr. Moore stated, "The planning process and the bonding fees are quite different. An area like Laurel
Hill or Edisto Plantation, that we developed, would not be good enough to have in the City. I just think
that this document would provide more than our economic demographics can handle."
City Administrator Yow stated, "In fairness to Mr. Moore, he left one thing out, the main arterial roads
will require sidewalks, butthat is negotiable in this document. "
Mayor Miller stated, "I hear what Mr. Moore is saying but was not hearing what it is specifically; what
you want us to table to discuss. We don't have to pass this tonight, we can table it and come back and
beat it around some more, but going back to the initial questions, what is the difference for what you
have to do in the County versus in the City?"
Mr. Moore stated, "I will be glad to provide a document to you for that."
Mayor Miller stated, "I have read the Land Plan several times and it is very complicated and I'm not
sure if Attorney Walsh could answer what some of the differences were or let Mr. Vismor come back
and tell us what the differences are. I believe we just need some sort of documents in place to control
how the development is going to be in the City."
Mr. Moore stated, "Nobody would disagree with that."
Mayor Miller stated, "One thing he did like in it was that he, Mr. Moore as a developer, had a list of
things that you have to check off, if you will and if you comply then there is no saying no. You comply,
you are good to go. As it stands now, that may not be the case. I don't like it being able to come back to
Council no more than any other Councilmember, but it is State Law, so there is no choice on it."
Mayor Miller stated, "I am willing to look at something further, if there is something to look at."
Mr. Moore stated, "I think it all needs to be looked at, from start to finish."
Mayor Miller stated, "I want to know what the difference is if you are going to do a development in the
County versus doing one in the City."
Councilmember Moore asked that they let him or someone that can work on this before; they make a
decision on it.
Mayor Pro Tem Haire stated, "I think that staff has done an excellent job in explaining it to Council and
that we need to move forward with it. Ithink we have delayed enough on this particular document."
Councilmember Jernigan stated, "He has been against this for a long time now, because there seems to
be after listening to everyone else, different points from different people on this Ordinance as to what is
wrong. Everybody doesn't agree to it and everybody is probably not going to agree to it at any point in
time, but with as many people disagreeing to it, Ithink we need to take a good hard look at it. As far as
leaving Council out, I don't like that idea either and if we don't stand up and take a stand if we don't like
it because the state is saying it, then they are going to continue to do it and Home Rule is going to
continue to erode and we are going to get left out of a lot of things when they come up as it relates to
Ordinances. Based on those things, I make a motion that we table this for further study."
;2D/D
Page 4
Councilmember Keitt seconded Councilmember's Jernigan motion. She stated she wanted to have
more studies on it before they passed it. This was a S-2 vote as Mayor Pro Tem Haire and
Councilmember Knotts opposed.
Councilmembers Barnwell and Keitt stated they wanted to address it at the next council meeting, and
Council Jernigan stated he would like to see Mr. Vismor attend the November 17'h meeting.
City Administrator Yow asked Council what they wanted studied.
Mayor Miller, Councilmembers Keitt and Barnwell stated they wanted to know the differences between
the City and County Ordinance. Councilmember Keitt also stated she wanted to know whether we are
looking out for our constituents, that is important, to see if it is going to be valuable to them.
Mayor Miller stated, "What's the difference was between Mr. Moore, Mr. Berry, and Mr. Hutto, any of
these guys building in the City versus building in the County. This is my number one question. If we are
fairly equal then there is not an argument as to whether to build in the City or build in the County."
City Administrator Yow stated, "They could do that, but he wanted to make one point and that was that
building in a rural area and building in an urban area were not the same and they should not necessarily
be the same. That's why some people choose to live in the County and some choose to live in the City."
Mayor Miller stated, "I will bring it back at the next meeting for third reading provided that we can get
the information and Mr. Vismor to attend.
Council stated that Mr. Moore would be responsible for providing the cost analysis.
Councilmember Jernigan stated, " I think with something this important we need to make sure we are
doing the right thing the right way."
City Administrator Yow stated, "I will be happy to meet with Mr. Moore and Mr. Vismor."
Mr. Moore thanked Council.
City Attorney Walsh asked, "What is the time table for getting documents?"
City Administrator Yow stated, "He could give a list of the differences, but that he would be happy to put
Mr. Moore and Mr. Vismor together, and he would be there with them."
City Administrator Yow stated, "Mr. Moore, anything that the City has already committed to with the
utilities and such, we plan on keeping that commitment." DPU Manager Boatwright agreed with this.
Mr. Moore asked, "Does any other City owned utility provide services to developers?"
DPU Manager Boatwright stated, "There are other cities that provide utilities up to the property line,
which is what the City/DPU are proposing and they do charge impact fees, but they do not come close to
covering the cost. Someone has to pay, either the developer or the utility rate payers."
Mayor Miller presented the Community Character Trait, "Forgiveness" for the month of November
2009 to Ms. Betty Stone.
Mayor Miller stated that he needed a motion to table the Land Ordinance for DPU.
Councilmember Barnwell made motion, seconded by Councilmember Jernigan to table the Land
Ordinance. This was unanimously approved.
Mayor Miller asked for a motion to go into Executive Sessionto discuss a contractual and legal matter
concerning Administration Department and DPU regarding health and dental coverage.
Page 5
2011
Mayor Pro Tem Haire made a motion, seconded by Councilmember Keitt. This was unanimously
approved.
Councilmember Barnwell made a motion, seconded by Councilmember Jernigan, to return to Open
Session. This motion was unanimously approved.
City Administrator Yow asked for a motion to allow the City Administrator to enter into a contract for
health and dental insurance. City Administrator Yow stated, "The City has been with SCLGAG for 18
years and has had a very good relationship with this organization, which is a part of the Municipal
Association of South Carolina. Due to the continued escalation of health insurance cost, not just with
SCLGAG but nationwide, the City started a year ago to research changing our provider. We have a
recommendation from Mr. Boatwright and I that we leave SCLGAG.
Mayor Pro tem Haire made a motion to accept the recommendation coming from the City Administrator
and DPU Manager as it relates to leaving our health care provider, SCLGAG. This motion was seconded
by Councilmember Jernigan. This motion was unanimously approved.
City Administrator Yow asked for direction to award a contract for the medical.
Councilmember Keitt asked for a motion to accept the low bid proposai from Plan Benefit Services in the
amount of$ 2,875,452.24 and authorize City Administrator Yow to enter into the contract. This motion
was seconded by Mayor Pro Tem Haire and was unanimously approved.
City Administrator Yow asked for direction from Council on dental/life/vision coverage.
Councilmember Knotts asked for a motion to approve the motion for dental/life/vision for Grampian
Hills Insurance Agency in the amount of 198,082.80 and authorizing City Administrator Yow to enter into
the contract. This motion was seconded by Councilmember Keitt and was unanimously approved.
Mayor Pro Tem Haire made motion, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to adjourn. This motion was
unanimously approved.
Respectfully submitted,
Duane Tarrant
Assistant City Clerk
DT/pfb
.--
/'/
2012
Medical/Dental Insurance
Workshop
November 3, 2009
Orangeburg City Council held a Medical /Dentallnsurance Workshop Meeting on Tuesday, November 3,
2009 at S:30 P.M., in Council Chambers Executive Board Room.
PRESENT:
Paul A. Miller, Mayor
Charles B. Barnwell
Charles W. Jernigan
l. Zimmerman Keitt
Sandra P. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
John H. Yow, City Administrator
John D. Singh, Assistant City Administrator
Duane Tarrant, Assistant Finance Director
Mike Sells, DPU
Fred Boatwright, DPU Manager
Gary Snyder, Insurance Consultant
ABSENT:
Bernard Haire
Mayor Miller thanked everyone for coming early. He introduced Mike Sells, DPU and Gary Snyder as the
consultant that has been working with the City/DPU.
DPU Manager Boatwright asked to make an opening comment.
Boatwright thanked everyone for coming and taking time to listen to this very important issue.
Boatwright stated that Sells would be going through the whole presentation again, for the sake of the
two (2) new council members. Boatwright stated that Mr. Gary Snyder of Carolina
Benefits Group had worked with us to come up with a plan for two things, first to help protect the
City/DPU for the cost of the health insurance, as well as the GASB liability, and second to protect the
employees and retirees to help keep their cost low and still provide them with the best coverage/plan.
He stated that he was very pleased with where we(City/DPU) were, but that there were couple of
differences from last presentation.
Sells thanked everyone that had helped with the work that had been done on the plan. Sells presented
a power point presentation that would be looking at a comparison of our medical benefits for
employees and retirees now versus what we propose them to be. He stated that there are two key
issues, the medical insurance cost and the GASB 4S liability. Sells stated that this insurance problem has
been growing for years and years and it is a national problem. Our accountants tell us that we need to
set aside $2.8 million annually to fund this GASB 45 liability. Lowering the GASB 45 liability is the key
and the way to do that is to change our health insurance obligations.
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "If we were to set aside this money and it goes on our books, does it
go on our books as an asset or a liability?"
Mr. Sells stated, "It will go on as an asset, but the liability portion is what we promised, the future
benefits for our employees."
Councilmember Barnwell asked, "What do you mean by promise".
Page 2
Mr. Sells stated, "It was the portion of the benefits and medical insurance that the City/DPU would be
paying for the future retirees. The Resolution right now states that when a person retirees b~GiJ,3
certain ages, that the City pays a portion of the benefits.
Yow stated the it (the yearly funded amount) doesn't really go on our books, it goes in an Irrevocable
Trust. Sells stated that the money goes in the trust, but the liability goes on our books and may affect
our future ability to borrow money. Yow stated that the money is an asset but it goes in the Trust and is
dedicated to paying the future benefits for those retirees. Once it goes in the trust, City Councilor the
City will never be able to do anything with it or retrieve it.
Mr. Sells stated that with the new insurance proposals that is what we are trying to prevent from
happening.
Councilmember Barnwell asked, "How many cities in South Carolina have funded this."
City Administrator Yow stated, "Some have partially funded it but none have fully funded it.
Mr. Sells stated that we are trying to get the liability low so that if we had to fund it, we could.
DPU Manager Boatwright stated, "He has not found an attorney yet that could tell him that there was a
law stating that the City had to fund this trust, but you do have to disclose it and that is the key and it
could affect the credit rating of the City."
Mr. Sells stated. "In 1999 our insurance costs were at$ 1.8 million and it has done nothing but go up
and up and in April 2009 we were told to expect a $ 4.1 million renewal figure. South Carolina Local
Government Assurance Group is a part of the Municipal Association of South Carolina and we are in a
self-funded plan. It is a high risk plan and has been very good for us in the 1980's and 1990's, we did
well with it. Within the last few years we have had some bad years."
Councilmember Keitt asked, "It is because of health problems with people that is what has caused the
cost to go up?
Mr. Sells stated, "It is mostly just the high cost of insurance and rate increases.
Councilmember Keitt stated, "I know a lot of people are haVing a lot of health issues."
Mr. Sells stated, "We will have to face a runoff, whether we leave now or in the future. LGAG has told
us we would have a renewal cost of $4.1 million. We told them that it would not work and they went to
Medcost and came back with a new figure of $3.2 million, but with a lesser plan options. We went and
talked with Gary and an actuarial company and Blue Cross/BlueShield came back with a proposed price
of $3 million with our exact same plan. We found that if we split our medical insurance, dental, vision
and life that we could get a better price on them. The plan that BlueCross Blue Shield has proposed is
the same plan we have now. Blue cross Blue Shield also said for the first 2 months, since we would have
the runoff from our current coverage, that they would let us defer half of the monthly premiums for
January and February 2010 to help with cash flow since we have the runoff. Blue Cross Blue Shield also
promised the first year renewal would not be any higher than 11%. We are recommending that we go
to Blue Cross Blue Shield and continue to pay for 100% of the employee's premium. We would be
changing our tier schedule for spouse, dependents and family portion that the city would pay. To help
our GASB 45 liability we will need to cease all retiree benefits for employees hired after 12-31-09. This
will change our GASB 45 liability for future years. What will we offer to retain new employees if we
cease retiree benefits? We are proposing we offer them an HSA - Health SavingsAccount that is where
we offer them money today. If we give it today, it isn't a GASB 45 liability."
Page 3
City Adl0S1r40rYow stated, "We are not promising anything to retirees or future employees. It
means that the Council next year and the next can change what they feel like is appropriate to offer
retirees based on an annual basis. Yow stated that Council would have to repel the old Retiree Medical
Resolutions but the new one would be written so that no one would be able to say that we made a
promise to them for benefits. Promises will only be on an annual basis for that budget year."
Mr. Sells stated, "What they wanted to offer was a $100 benefit for that HSA. If the employee will save
this and does not spend it, once they retire they will have this money to pay for their medical insurance.
Yow stated that there is a tax savings to this, as long as they use it for medicaL"
Mr. Boatwright stated that the employee can add to it. City Administrator Yow stated that there was a
maximum. Mr. Gary Snyder stated this year it was an individual maximum of $3000. Mr. Sells stated
that the way the HSA works is that the younger employee will see this as an appealing option.
The post 6S employees now have a better plan than the active employees. We would replace their
coverage with a $99/month Medicare advantage plan and then give those a $70/month HRA - Health
Reimbursement Account type benefit if they incur costs above $2,000 during a plan year. We would
also eliminate the $22.23 monthly spousal benefit.
City Administrator Yow stated that that means we will no longer be paying anything on the spouse
coverage for post 6S.
The only difference in the active employee plan and the new Medicare Advantage Plan is the maximum
exposure. The maximum exposure for active employee is $2,000 and retiree is $2,845. That is the only
difference. it is not quite as good, but comparable. City Administrator Yow stated, the retiree is
responsible for the first $2,000 just like the employee, but once they reach it, the City will fund the other
$845 out of the $70/month HRA.
Barnwell asked, "What are the copays for the prescriptions on the Medicare advantage."
Mr. Sells stated, "It was $9, $40, and $75 for the new plan."
The pre 65 retirees have always had a low rate. We are proposing to move them to the active rate, to
get the price in line with the plan that they are on. The City would help contribute $100 for the spouse
premium on the pre 65 group due to the amount changing so much to get the rates in line. This would
be only for current retirees in that situation at this time. Future employees that retire in this area will be
told what the true figure will be. City Administrator Yow stated that we would need to notify LGAG and
get the claims ran through. He wanted to let Council know that due to those claims, you won't realize a
$900K savings the first year due to the runoff of claims.
Councilmember Jernigan wanted to know how much LGAG worked to keep us. DPU Manager
Boatwright and City Administrator Yow stated they came down from $ 4.1 million to $3.2 million, but
they also changed the plan some. City Administrator Yow also stated that they went back out to the
larger providers and got deeper discounts.
Councilmember Barnwell asked how much we would save from the half premiums. City Administrator
Yow stated that you don't save, you have to pay your premium, and they just defer the payment until a
later date to help with cash flow in paying the runoff. We may not take the half premium deal and are
not required to. We would analyze the interest rate BC/BS would apply to the deferral.
Councilmember Barnwell stated he was ready to get this done.
Page 4
City Administrator Yow stated we would need to do some education with our employees and retirees.
He also stated that the City would have to redo the Resolution that concerns the retirees an~ 15
"promise" that employees refer too.
Bids will be discussed in Executive Session and then Council will need to decide on which company to go
with and give City Administrator Yow permission to analyze and enter into contracts.
Mr. Sells stated again "That there are a lot of cities that are just not offering any retiree insurance
coverage. City Administrator Yow stated that some cities are even charging a portion for employees and
do not offer any family or dependent coverage.
Mayor Miller thanked Mr. Gary Snyder for coming and all of his hard work.
lC"L
Duane Tarrant
Assistant Finance Clerk
DT/pfb
City CouncilMeeting
November 17,2009
2016
Orangeburg City Council held its regularly scheduled meeting on Tuesday, November 17, 2009 at 7:00
P.M., in Council Chambers with Mayor Miller presiding.
PRESENT:
Paul A. Miller, Mayor
Charles B. Barnwell
Bernard Haire
Charles W. Jernigan
L. Zimmerman Keitt
Sandra P. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
A motion was made by Mayor Miller, seconded by Councilmember Keitt, to hold the next City Council
meeting on December 1, 2009 at 6:00 P.M. instead of 7:00 P.M. This motion was unanimously
approved.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tem Haire, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to approve the
November 3, 2009 City Council Minutes as distributed. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Jernigan, to approve the
November 3,2009 Medical/Dental Insurance Workshop Minutes as distributed. This was a 6-0-1 vote as
Mayor Pro Tem Haire abstained as he was not present at the meeting.
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnweli, seconded by Councilmember Jernigan, to elect
Councilmember Haire to serve as Mayor Pro Tem after the September 2009 election of
Councilmembers. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Jernigan, seconded by Mayor Pro Haire, to approve
authorization for the City Administrator to accept the Highway Safety Grant in the amount of $149,848,
with no local match. This grant provides funding for two full-time officer positions with salary and fringe
benefits to include two vehicles with needed equipment. The goal of this project is to prOVidethe City
with an advanced DUI enforcement team to allow for greater identification and enforcement of DUI
vioiations in the City.
There were no utility matters brought before Council.
A motion was made Councilmember Keitt, seconded by Mayor Pro Tem Haire, to enter into an Executive
Sessionfor a contractual and legal matter concerning dental/vision insurance.
A motion was made by Councilmember Keitt, seconded by Mayor Pro Tem Haire, for Council to return to
Open Session. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Keitt, to rescind the prior
award to Grampian Hills Insurance Company for Dental, Vision and Ufe Insurance and award the
contract to Hlbbits and Nash in the amount of $198,082.80. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Mayor Pro Tem Haire, to adjourn. This
motion was unanimousiy approved.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
Q~~;~it~l' 0 ~ L
CarrieW.Johnson U1)-jUVWv--.....J
City Clerk
/pfb
City Council Meeting
December 15, 2009
2017
Orangeburg City Council held a Public Hearing on Tuesday, December 15, 2009, at 7:00
P. M. in Council Chambers with Mayor Miller presiding. The subject of the Public
Hearing was the Proposed Land Development Regulations.
Ms. Alice Hutto of Broughton Street addressed Council. She stated, "I enjoy living in
Orangeburg and the services I get from the City and DPU. I am in the real estate
business, rdo sell houses. I am concerned about the costs that this Ordinance will have
on the homes in Orangeburg. We lose a lot of clients to Lexington and Columbia
because we can't match their quantity, we do quality. I know you want to see the City of
Orangeburg grow and r do not want to lose customers to those other cities. This will
affect the housing market. I am not a developer and I know you want to see the city grow
and I know you do that through annexation. I do feel this will create a problem for us
down the road and for me, personally, in about 10 years when I want to downsize."
Mayor Miller asked, "I need you to clarify something. Go back to what you said about
losing customers to Lexington and Columbia rather than them living in Orangeburg,
explain that to me."
Ms. Hutto replied, "A lot of times it is the cost of homes. Homes in Lexington are less
expensive than they are in Orangeburg. We lose customers that way."
Mayor Miller stated, "What you are saying is that it is cheaper to buy a home in
Lexington rather than in Orangeburg, what is the specific reason?"
Ms. Hutto replied, "I think they have more people and they can sell more houses. I
represent the realtors in Orangeburg and I feel this will hurt the business and I want the
realtors in Orangeburg to have a competitive market."
Mayor Pro Tem Haire asked, "Have you checked the margin of profit for the sale of
homes in Columbia versus the sale of homes in Orangeburg?"
Ms. Hutto replied, "I have not checked into that, but would be glad to do that."
Mayor Pro Tem Haire asked, "Could it be that the realtors here are charging more?"
Ms. Hutto replied, "Actually, the realtors in Columbia probably have a higher
commission, we don't set rates, they are set within our office."
Councilmember Barnwell stated, "This Land Development Ordinance that we are
attempting to pass isn't even in existence, so you are telling me that people are moving
based on what we have now?"
Ms. Hutto replied, "Exactly, I am concerned if the cost continues to rise, we are going to
lose more homes in Orangeburg."
Mayor Pro Haire asked, "You don't think because of what Columbia offers as it relates to
what citizens are looking for that just isn't here, that is the reason people are moving
there?"
Ms. Hutto replied, "Those are all factors, sometimes they move because of schools and
other di fferent factors which are things we all need to work on and things we can offer.
We have doctors and plant managers who choose to live elsewhere and drive to
Orangeburg. Ifwe can offer competitive housing that would be one draw to the area."
Mayor Miller stated, I have lived here for a long time and I have always been of the
opinion you get more house for your money in Orangeburg than you can in any other
large metropolitan area. I am having a little problem understanding why houses are
2018
Page 2
cheaper in Columbia or Lexington. You say it is, that is fine, but I am having trouble
understanding that."
Ms. Hutto replied, "Actually in 1977, I paid more per square foot here than what mine
sold for. It was thirteen years old, but we had to pay more here. It is supply and
demand."
Mr. Marion Moore, a local developer and owner of Century 2l!Moore Company,
addressed Council, "I think you know the City is near and dear to my heart. I want to
make it clear that there is nothing personal involved in my questioning of this Ordinance.
I was elected to City Council and my mission was to protect and defend DPU. I have
defended DPU many times and assisted the City with many projects. My family has
lived in the City for three generations and no one is more proud than I on what DPU has
done. In all the 36 years, I have been in business; I felt I needed to view my objections to
the Ordinance since this is out of line. This was ill-conceived, ill-designed and Lord
knows, ill-timed.
The Mayor asked me to supply you with a list of things I felt were wrong with the
document as well as cost differential to build in the City versus to build in the County.
There is an actual cost you see in your folder, and while each and everyone of these
objections is valid and each of the $5,700 is an additional cost to the developer to build a
home in the City, is important. That could be more based on whether DPU's Ordinance is
passed ifsewer and water were not available and if I thought that were enough to
convince Council to reject this Ordinance, I'd stop there. But through research, there is
tangible evidence and hard facts of costs and implementation problems and it appears
that Counci I wants to move forward with no further consideration. I would like to see
these items answered. What is the urgency? It took County planners nearly two years to
fOfJ11 an acceptable Ordinance when they started their deal. It took lots of public input.
This Ordinance we have on the table tonight can and will have a long-term effect on our
city. Mr. Berry couldn't be here tonight as you can see in your folder, but I had a
conversation with him and the Mayor. He basically told us that if the proposed guidelines
are in effect, the new development he has planned on Hillsboro will not be going
forward. I was asked time and time again by John and various people, "What is the
problem? John and I have had great substantial discussions on this and I applaud his
eff011s,he has done a great job on this. Where is the problem, what is causing all of this,
why are we looking at doing something? And basically, a lot of it goes back to drainage
problems, it sounds like that, were developed 20, 30, to 40 years ago in the city that were
done before we had the appropriate guidelines to correctly develop property. I feel like
with DHEC, SCDOT and everyone else, these types of issues are clearly addressed and I
ask Council on top of what is now actually working very well.
The other part is the Ordinance, which is only part of the equation. It's being passed in
conjunction with and driven by, I believe, DPU's desire to no longer run sewer and water
into City property. I know there has been at least one problem with DPU being left out to
dry and there's not a soul in this room that wants anything like that to happen. But I can't
believe Mr. Boatwright and Company can't come up with a way to solve that problem
through bonding or whatever it may be. I know they can do that, I'm comfortable they
can handle that. The present policy, which has served our city well for several decades
and particularly well in the last ten years with the development guideline, is suddenly no
longer viable.
As I mentioned earlier, have you taken into consideration the competitive advantage this
will take away from us. Fred's correct; there are very few cities that will do this now, that
will run into your project. But that is a terrific advantage if a client or developer is
looking at it and what they are willing to do, that costs is obviously bringing in the
development, taxable sales, utilities, etc., so I think giving up that competitive advantage
Page 3 2019
is going to hurt us long-tenn into drawing business and attracting new development.
Unless I missed something, there are not a lot of people knocking on our door right now
to develop anything in Orangeburg and not just Orangeburg. I think we need to do
everything we can to keep our rifles loaded so to speak to create new shopping centers
and subdivisions, things that will strengthen our tax base and create jobs. Not speaking of
annexation, I know that's what members of this Council want to do and I think the news
of this Ordinance and the DPU Ordinance, when fully understood by the citizenry, I don't
know how that'll be received or if it'll be received very well. Like it or not, DPU is a
growth engine for Orangeburg and it appears you have taken away advantages the city
can imploy, create development and in tum, making it more difficult for any kind of
development to occur; bottom line, they are the only game in town and we do what DPU
says to do. I've never known DPU to be anything but forthright, never heavy handed in
any way, but these new Ordinances are a long way towards big govemment and utilities
instead of growth and development in my opinion. So rather than go through all of this,
what I will say to you; I believe there are things in place already, maybe they can be
compiled in some other sort of compendium than this huge Development Ordinance.
Let's fix this; there are things that can be done. No one wants to stifle DPU. They have
been well run for a number of years; the City has been well run for a long time. There is
man power on Council and wisdom here instead of putting a cookie cutter approach to
this and lying down on top of everybody. There is a lot of good in it. It is not all bad. I
think it can be done better. Unless I misunderstand the urgency, I would ask you to table
this indefinitely and the DPU Ordinance until these issues can be ironed out and a study
done on the economic impact on the citizens of Orangeburg."
Councilmember Bamwell stated, "I think it is a consensus of Council whether or not we
pass this tonight and DPU is not going to fund the Development as far as pipes, water,
and wastewater. No, other city does that."
Mr. Moore replied, "I understand that, but DPU may be mn better than other utilities. It
gives OPU the opportunity to promote development instead of being set in stone that it is
done."
Mayor Pro Tem Haire asked, "Did you say that DPU is heavy handed?"
Mr. Moore replied, "No, I said DPU has never been heavy handed."
Mayor Miller stated, "You made a statement, I want to challenge as it relates to tap fees,
etc. Our water tap and impact fees are $1,200 and across the state they average from
$1,525.87, so we are 21 % below average for water taps throughout the state. On
wastewater, the average is $1,943.37 and DPU is $1,550.00, which is 20% less than
throughout the state. My point is that it is cheaper for a Y. inch tap for residential
property, unless you want a larger tap. In doing a survey across the state, including
Florence, Charleston, Beaufort, Columbia, Rock Hill and Anderson the developer pays
for the infrastmcture within the Development and the City of Orangeburg has been the
only city who has been paying that. You asked me what the purpose was, the purpose is
to promote the development ofland in the pursuit of public health, safety, economy,
appearance, convenience and the morals and general welfare of the community. Your
associate, who gave me some notes, he felt like a Comprehensive Land Development
Ordinance would be beneficial to the City of Orangeburg and he asked to hold off on the
vote. Ms. Hutto said people were going to Columbia because they could buy a house up
there cheaper, but you are saying the opposite. You are saying if we pass this Land
Ordinance and we don't provide the utilities, that this would drive people away."
Mr. Moore replied, "Obviously the costs are going to go up. As a realtor and a
developer, I think it is a great thing that we can do. I am not going into the financial
2020Page4
applications, just because every other city does it, doesn't make it right or wrong."
Mayor Miller asked, "I think the question is, is it fair for the ratepayers to pay for the
development rather than the developer; rather than all across the state, the developers are
paying for it. You are talking about hard economic times and we are feeling the pinch
too. It is like everyone else. I think everyone is across the state, where people are trying
to minimize the expense."
Mr. Moore replied, "Under the existing guidelines, the City will run sewer and water into
your property for the cost ofX. This is what the City gets in return for the X. I was
using a one inch water tap fee which is $1,400.00, sewer tap is $1,550.00, also the site is
sold water, gas, wastewater and natural gas. The City then taxes the property at 20 to 30
times the value of the undeveloped lot. Just like my mother's house, which has been
there 50-60 years, she has enjoyed the services. It has worked well until now. [fthat is
they way Council wants to do, I understand, but it takes away from my competitiveness.
I never would want to hurt the city or DPU financially."
Mayor Miller stated, "You understand the City doesn't assess property, the County does.
[own property like you own property and [don't like it anymore than you do and we
have to use the figures they give us."
Councilmember Jemigan asked, "On the handout, you have a lot in the City versus a lot
in the County, are you saying it would increase your development cost versus developing
in the County. That cost would have to be passed on to the person buying the house?"
Mr. Moore replied, "Yes."
Councilmember Barnwell asked, "Why?"
Mr. Moore replied, "Who is going to eat it?
Councilmember Barnwell stated, "I think one of the big issues is that it is cutting into the
developers profits."
Mr. Moore stated, "That may be, but obviously hard costs are passed on, infrastructure
costs and [ can't speak to what developers make. [sure haven't made enough to eat
$5,000.00 on a lot, [can tell you that."
Councilmember Barnwell stated, "You got the comparison ofa lot in the County, the
County doesn't have to worry about the infrastructure. There is no cost allocated to the
County."
Mayor Miller asked, "I asked you the last time you were here to tell me what it was that
you objected to and ifthere were some things that were objectionable that we could
possibly revisit those areas. We are not trying to be the bad guys. We are trying to be
beneficial to the developers when they meet the criteria for the development set forth in
here. There is no one here in the City that is going to overturn it. We have had instances
where it meets certain criteria and G. W. Berry was one of them. In all due respects, I
think the Land Development Ordinance can be beneficial to the developers in the long
run. [have looked at your list and Ijust don't know specifically what it is except for the
infrastructure costs. [n the County, the developer has to pay for that."
Mr. Moore replied, "You can cherry pick the list and John and I have talked about that as
late as today."
Page 5
2021
Page 5
Mayor Miller asked, "The catch basins, like stonn water, you don't have to have those?"
Mr. Moore replied, "Yes, you do, an engineer did that for me."
Mayor Miller stated, "1 am not an engineer or a developer and I don't want to second
guess anything."
Mr. Moore stated, "We may stifle the growth and we may not, but it may make it more
difficult in a difficult time already."
Mayor Miller stated, "1 don't know what the rest of Council's ideas are, but anything we
do tonight or whatever is not totally cast in stone and it can be changed. There may be
some things in there that a Developer may come back and it may cause some concerns
and I think John has some recommendations and there may be others. I appreciate you
coming and your concern. I don't' think this Ordinance will cause us to be worse off
than we are alread yare."
Hearing no further comments, the Public Hearing was closed.
Council entered into the regularly scheduled City Council Meeting.
PRESENT:
Paul A. Miller
Charles B. Barnwell
Barnard Haire
Charles W. Jernigan
Sandra p. Knotts
Richard F. Stroman
ABSENT:
L. Zimmerman Keitt
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tem Haire, seconded by Councilmember Knolls, to
approve the November 17, 2009, City Council Minutes as distributed. This motion was
unanimously approved.
City Administrator Yow addressed Council on the Land Development Ordinance. He
stated, "I would like to say that I appreciate everyone's interest in this. I have had many
conversations with Mayor and Council and other persons in regards to this and all of my
conversations have been civil and professional. If City Council elects to go forth with
third reading tonight, there are some recommendations I would like to go over with you.
Mr. G. W. Berry pointed out that the drainage diagram on page 27 was a little
ambiguous and hard to follow. I would suggest we replace it with this new diagram with
the concrete curb and gutter 18 inches in width. The other diagram may have shown
extra widths which could cost the developer more and we have also shown that a valley
gutter which can be used instead of a concrete curb and gutter. I have checked in other
developments and I would recommend that this be changed from the original document.
On page 24, on dead end streets or cul-de-sacs, it refers to them as maximum700 linear
feet; I think we should allow them to be 1000 linear feet. In another section of this
Ordinance it states that blocks can be 1000 linear feet. So if blocks can be, let's make
dead end streets the same size as one full block. This mayor may not come into play
depending on the property.
2022
Page 6
On page 16, the ternl political lines, that should be jurisdictional lines. This is included
in a list of information that the developer has to provide to the City in order to get their
plat approved. That should be jurisdictional lines.
There has been some discussion on sidewalks. Sidewalks are required on the main streets
in the development, not on all streets. It requires sidewalks to be five feet in length. If
Council has no change of heart and wants to leave sidewalks in, I would recommend that
the sidewalks be reduced to four feet in width.
There are some typos and some ambiguous parts to reword but not changing the intent or
effect. The only other point is that on page 24 we prohibit alleys. There have been some
questions raised. We can leave it as it is or we can insert a service alley where both lots
back up to each other. I know some of you may be hearing this for the first time. In
other words, this does not allow for service alleys and it may be an upcoming trend. If
someone was applying for a PDD, under the Zoning Ordinance, not the Land
Development Ordinance, they could have an alley in it and have it approved under the
PDD.
"City Attorney Walsh replied, "I also think you need to check with Zoning if you take
that out to see if the alleys are permitted in residential areas are under the Zoning."
Councilmember Barnwell asked, "What is the purpose~ Why do you need it?"
City Administrator Yow replied, ''To have a service alley in the rear of your lot. The
trend that is being stated to me is an entrance to your garage from the rear. If the City
agreed also, their sanitation carts could be serviced fTom the rear on the alley on both
sides."
"City Attorney Walsh stated, "The best way to do that is to not permit alleys, but to
permit service alleys, if that is what you are trying to do."
City Administrator Yow stated, "There are a couple of definitions that need to be added
such as alleys or service alleys and it also mentions half streets are prohibited and I do
not see a definition of half street included. Those are just administrative things that need
to be addressed. I am not real strong on the alleys but I have heard from several people
that this has been being done in a lot of locations. If you approve and put it in there, it
still doesn't mean that ifit doesn't fit in the overall development that the Planning
Commission still has to approve it. It just means it is not strictly prohibited."
Councilmember Barnwell stated, "Personally, I would be amendable to doing away with
sidewalks. "
City Administrator Yow replied, "If you did that, I would say in residential only, not in
commercial. "
Councilmember Stroman asked, "I think Mr. Berry was asking for sidewalks to be
eliminated, what about vested rights, why can't we give them another year?"
City Administrator Yow stated, "I think it is now two years and an extension for thirty
six (6) months, that is five years. Now, ifit is not a phased development, it is two years
and an additional 12 months."
Councihnember Stroman stated, "That is what I was speaking of, he marked it in the
paper I got today, he was wanting an additional 12 months."
City Administrator Yow stated, "Let's stay on sidewalks and we can get back to that"
Page 7
Mayor Pro Tern Haire asked, "Mr. Barnwell, what were you saying about the
sidewalks?"
Councilmember Barnwell replied, "I have no objection to removing the required
sidewalks in residential areas not commercial areas."
Mayor Pro Tern Haire stated, "Once this becomes operational, they will then ask
someone to put the sidewalks in."
Councilmember Barnwell replied, "We have a lot of areas now where there are no
sidewalks. "
&0&'
Mayor Pro Tern Haire stated, "I think that with the sidewalks it would provide later on
from preventing someone for asking to put in sidewalks. It serves a purpose. 1feel like
they need to be in there."
City Administrator Yow stated, "I hate to put you all at odds, we will have to get
something to include in a motion and also to look at vested rights."
Councilmember Stroman stated, 'That is a Phased Development is 36 months total on
page three? 1 would like to help these developers; they may need an additional 12
months."
City Attorney Walsh stated, "You have to understand vested rights is a state statute so
when you are reading this section and you are talking about a Phased Development Plan,
you have to go back to state statue and the different periods. The language is verbatim
from the section. 1don't know if we would have any authority to increase that."
City Administrator Yow stated, "I guess we need to know if City Council wants to move
forward with this tonight or as someone said, table it. But, if you move forward, 1 would
recommend those changes that 1 went over with you. If you leave sidewalks in, 1 would
make the recommendations to decrease it to four feet."
Mayor Miller stated, "The comment 1 made earlier tonight was that we can always come
back and make changes or tweak it, isn't that correct?"
City Administrator Yow stated, "You do that now with changes to the Comprehensive
Plan and the Zoning Ordinance."
Councilmember Jernigan stated, "Honestly, 1 don't' feel comfortable passing this
Ordinance with this much discussion. 1 feel we need to put it off a little bit and get these
questions ironed out, get these things that John has recommended into it, and then come
back for third reading. 1 am not in favor of passing this Ordinance. Mr. Moore and Ms.
Hutto have come up with some problems with this Ordinance and 1think we need to look
at all of that. There is no need in passing an Ordinance if we are going to have to come
back and make changes to it."
Mayor Pro Tern Haire stated, "I don't' think that we know we are going to have to go
back and change. First of all, there have been conversations between Councilmembers
and developers and there has been no conversation with certain Councilmembers and
developers. It seems as if there is an attempt to delay this. It has been more than ample
time to move on this particular document. It seems when there is not an 1 dotted or a T
crossed, then we have to go back and study. 1 think John and Mr. Boatwright and staff
have put ample time to this document and either vote it up or down and stop delaying it.
Where are all of those people that are supposed to be so concerned? 1 haven't seen them
here. I understand Mr. Moore's position to get this document tabled. We have wasted
~o.,l'
too much time already."
Councilmember Jernigan stated, "I disagree with you, Mr. Haire, I think time is
something we need to put to it to get it .done right. If it takes time to get it done the right
way, I don't have a problem to take the time to get it done. John has come up with a lot of
things to add to this and I don't know what all of them are."
Mayor Pro Tem Haire asked, "We can't incorporate them into the document tonight?"
City Administrator Yow stated, "Some of these changes were based on questions we have
had since the other week. There are things I could have changed for you tomorrow or
definitely by next Council meeting. The drainage diagram I have already given you,
changing the words, changing sidewalk width from five feet to four feet or taking out the
sidewalks altogether. You have to decide what you want to change."
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "You could have a complete document to us by next
meeting to pass a completed document?"
City Administrator Yow stated, "Yes."
Councilmember Jernigan made a motion to table this Ordinance until the next Council
meeting until the changes can be implemented from the City Administrator into the
document and also extend any moratoriums. There was no second, motion died.
Mayor Pro Tem Haire made a motion to adopt the plan with the changes made by the
City Administrator.
City Administrator Yow stated, "Changes were to insert a new drainage diagram and
allow valley gutters, allow dead end streets to be 1,000 linear feet instead of 700 feet, the
wording political on page 16 to be changed to jurisdictional lines and reducing sidewalk
width to 4 feet and other typographical areas. I did not address alleys, so alleys would be
left as they are in now."
Councilmember Knotts made a second to Mayor Pro Tern's motion to adopt the plan with
the changes made by the City Administrator
Councilmember Barnwell stated, "I don't think we can add something, we don't know
the answer to it and we cannot legally extend the time."
Mayor Miller stated, "If state law says one thing, then we don't have the authority to
change it. If Jimmy finds out we have the ability to change it then we can come back and
address Mr. Stroman's concern. That is why I said we may need to tweak some things."
City Administrator Yow stated, 'Those things are up to Council's discretion."
Councilmember Barnwell asked, "What is the rush to pass this thing? Make it right or
don't do it."
The Mayor read the Ordinance and called for the vote, this was a 4-2 vote with
Councilmembers Jernigan and Barnwell opposing.
Mr. Don Tribble, Executive Director of the Community of Character, accepted the
Character Trait Proclamation, "Gratitude".
A motion as made by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, seconded by Councilmember Knotts, to
approve the Third Reading of an Ordinance amending the General Tenns and Conditions
2025
Page 9
of the Department of Public Utilities to adopt and implement a Land Development
Regulation of the City. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion as made by Councilmember Stroman, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell,
to enter into an Executive Session for a personnel matter concerning the Executive
Department. This motion was unanimously approved.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
c~;; ""bm;t<" ~
c"m'W.J~
City Clerk
/pfb
Source: City of Orangeburg website. First collected Oct 13, 2026.