Minutes
City of Orangeburg · Orangeburg County · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Orangeburg
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
JANUARY 1,2008
CITY COUNCIL
MEETING
CANCELED
DUE TO
HOLIDAY
NEW YEAR'S
DAY
184~
City Council Minutes
January 15,2008
Orangeburg City Council held its regularly scheduled meeting on Tuesday, January 15, 2008, at 7:00
P.M., in Council Chambers with Mayor Miller presiding.
PRESENT:
Paul A. Miller, Mayor
Charles B. Barnwell
Bernard Haire
Charles W. Jernigan
Sandra P. Knotts
Trelvis A. Miller
Joyce W. Rheney
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Miller, to enter into
an Executive Session. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Rheney, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, for Council to
return to Open Session. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Jernigan, to approve
the December 18, 2007, City Council Minutes as distributed. This was a 6-0-1 vote as
Councilmember Miller abstained as he was not present at the last meeting.
Ms. Avis Butler addressed Council. She stated, "I am president and co-owner of Mandarin Land
Development Company. My partner is also here, who is a builder in South Carolina. During the last
year and a half we have diligently worked with City staff with a planned development for an upscale
subdivision on Longwood Drive. I must say that the cooperation we received from the City
Administrator's Office, Department of Public Utilities and the Public Works Department was
basically second to none. They were responsive, prompt and we really enjoyed that process. What
we finally ended up with was a forty (40) unit single-family detached housing development on a
twenty (20) acre site located on Longwood Drive. What we are requiring, with respect to covenants
and restrictions, are brick homes with a minimum of2000 square feet, irrigation systems, landscaped
yards and common areas and a beautiful site border. We carefully chose that development based on
the existing character of the neighborhood and the housing there. Because we are planning an 8 to 10
million dollar investment for this development for housing ranging from $200,000 to $270,000, we
are very concerned of the zoning of the A-2 property adjacent to our property. If you take a look at
your map, we are #12; our property surrounds the property in question. As you can see all the
property surrounding mine is single-family. What we are saying, ifthere is a zoning of A-2 next to
our property, then we really believe that this would render our project unfeasible as A-I. We found
out that in the last twenty-nine years, the only property that has been built in the immediate vicinity
that is not single family are the two elderly assisted living facilities owned by Longwood Plantation.
We respectfully request that you reconsider the A-2 zoning of the property next door. We are excited
about coming into the City; we would like to have developments that are compatible."
Mr. Freddie Ford addressed Council. He stated, "I anl one of the owners of Longwood Plantation and
ofFord's Tire on Russell Street. My primary job at Longwood is to protect the safety and welfare of
our residents. We have an assisted living home there with thirty-four (34) beds and adjacent to that
we have Magnolia Place, which is a sixteen (16) bed Alzheimer's Unit, which is next door to the
property that is in question tonight. We are not here tonight to fight annexation of this property;
coming into the City is not a bad thing. Multi-family housing on Longwood Drive is a bad idea. At
Longwood, we fight everyday for their quality of life issues for our people who are residents that
cannot take care of themselves. We fight tooth and nail to make sure that they have a good quality of
life while they are there. Mr. Rai has started this development right next door to us on Prakash Court.
Up to this point, he has repeatedly shown that he cannot follow rules, which includes a trespass order,
DHEC Cease and Desist, unlawful burning on June 26,2007, and several stop work orders from
18 -15
Page 2
Orangeburg County. He built his first building on the DPU right-of-way in which you made him cut
down. He didn't observe the set-back regulations from Orangeburg County; he is only 6-8 foot off of
my property and the latest being a litter violation from Orangeburg County on January 2, 2008. I
want you to understand that some folks do exactly what they say and others do whatever they can to
get by. You can see the pictures of construction debris and people changing oil on Shadowlawn. The
property he intends to build next to me is identical. In most places, this type of property in an area it
is now, would be considered a nuisance property. It is like this, if you were having a wedding for
your daughter, she walks up the aisle and someone hands you a piece of paper and the man she is
marrying is not what he appears to be and the reception is paid for and everyone is there, what do you
do? You have a choice; we will handle it afterwards or let's stop the show. Let's revisit it and make
sure it is what it is. Please take this into consideration. Thanks for all the support. We can disagree
without being disagreeable. I don't have anything against Mr. Rai other than this project is in a bad
place."
Mayor Miller replied, "We would love for you to come into the City."
Mr. Ford replied, "A lot of decisions are economic. When we have residents there that get $2,000.00
a month and that pays for their stay and their pills. I want one of you to come out there and tell them
we are going up and you are going to have to pay another $100 a month and they will respond, where
am I going to get it? At some point in the future, anyone of us could be in there and someone will
have to stand up and fight for our rights. Ifit was about money, we'd have a McDonald's, it is about
caring for people and that is our life and I appreciate you listening to me."
Mr. Clarence Higginbotham addressed Council. "I have a unique situation in that 1 live next door to
the individual that owns this property by the nursing home for about five years. 1wish to protest the
multi-family building he proposes to build on Longwood Drive. He has other such properties in the
area that are absolute slums with abandoned automobiles, air conditioning units not being used on the
ground and trash in general. This former resident is about as trashy. When he removed stairs from
the rear of his former house that he still owns and added a back porch, the discarded lumber was piled
at the back of his property line and it stayed there for at least two years. My request to remove it from
the area adjacent to my property was ignored with a promise to move it, which took two years to
complete. It attracted rodents, snakes and pests. There are about three or four pallets that came with
the building materials to build that porch and as of dark today, the pallets are still there. The new
buildings on Longwood under multi-family will reduce the value of all properties on Longwood and
Riley Streets. Ifit were zoned single-family, it would be a considerable improvement to the area."
Ms. Diane Weeks addressed Council. "1 became aware of a multi-family housing where there were
going to be forty-eight(48) apartments being ninety-six (96) cars, since most people have two in that
area. I live on Riley Street and 1 live in the City. 1 elected you as my City Council people to protect
my interest. Little did 1know that 1needed to read every little sign that is posted on a pole to alert me
to a Public Hearing. I have become aware of that and I now will pay more attention to every sign so 1
can then become a part of protecting my interest. I watched the first building go up, as 1go down
that street several times a day, and 1was amazed as to how it was built. It is not quality construction.
It will not improve my home value or the people in that area. I ask you to reconsider this as there is
one building there and twelve (12) more in the works. I ask you to consider what are you doing? 1
am a person who votes in every election possible, I can remember who can look out for my best
interests and 1 ask you to consider that for myself and the other residents in that area."
Assistant City Administrator Bronson overviewed the Third Reading ofthe Ordinance to annex the
within described property through the 75% petition method.
Councilmember Miller commented, "1 was not at the last meeting for my voice to be heard due to my
daughter having pneumonia and this particular item did the City no good. Unfortunately, I couldn't
send my vote through email, text or through another Councilmember. 1 am against this property
coming into the City as A-2. My position has not changed. 1 feel your heart bum and ifI was in
direct eyesight of this property, I would be strongly against it. 1would like to express this to you as it
relates to this."
184G
Page 3
Councilmember Barnwell made a motion to separate the parcels and vote on parcel #'sl-10 and #12
and vote separately on parcel #11 as A- 1 Residential. This motion was seconded by Councilmember
Miller.
A brief discussion was held on how to clarify the zoning on one parcel.
Councilmember Barnwell amended his motion to pass the Ordinance as written and amended parcel
#11 as a A-I Residential, Tax Map # 0174-09-06-020, 102-109 Prakash Court owned by Jai Rai. This
motion was seconded by Councilmember Miller.
Mayor Pro Tern Haire stated, "1 am troubled by what 1have lately learned as to some finagling that
has gone on as it relates to the plot we're talking about bringing in as A-I in the City. Because of the
finagling, I'll change my vote and support the amendment that has been made and 1will no longer
vote or support the idea of parcel #11 as A-2."
Council's vote was unanimous to amend the Ordinance.
A motion was made by Councilmember Miller, seconded by Councilmember Jernigan, to approve
the Third Reading of the Ordinance to annex the property through the 75% petition method to include
the amendment of parcel #11 as A-I, Tax Map #0174-09-06-020,102-109 Prakash Court for
annexation. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Jernigan, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to approve
the Third Reading of an Ordinance to amend the Municipal District Map dated November 6, 2001, for
the purpose of adding newly annexed City property to Council District #2. This motion was
unanimously approved.
Mr. Don Tribble, Community of Character Director at the Orangeburg County Chamber of
Commerce, accepted the Character Trait Proclamation for January 2008, "Good Manners".
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, seconded by Councilmember Jernigan, to approve a
Resolution to amend the Fac;:adeGrants Policy and Procedures. This motion was unanimously
approved.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to approve a
Resolution to grant the City Administrator Yow the authority to approve and execute the right-of-way
and easement to the South Carolina Public Service Authority. This motion was unanimously
approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Rheney, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to approve a
Resolution to approve a change order with AOS Specialty Contractors for the construction of the
parking area and courtyard at City Hall. This motion was unanimously approved.
City Administrator Yow explained the Ordinance amending Section 2-2.20 of the Code of Ordinances
for the City of Orangeburg for the purpose of establishing an alternate procedure for the appointment
or election of Board and Commission Members.
Councilmember Jernigan asked if everyone would try to do their best and get someone from their
district as it is in their best interest to do.
A motion was made by Councilmember Knotts, seconded by Councilmember Rheney, to approve the
First Reading of Ordinance amending Section 2-2.20 of the Code of Ordinances for the City of
Orangeburg for the purpose of establishing an alternate procedure for the appointment or election of
Board and Commission Members. This was a 6-0-1 vote as Mayor Pro Tern Haire abstained.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, seconded by Councilmember Rheney, to reappoint
John (BoBo) Smith- District #2, Carroll Joye-District #1, and Lamar Tisdale-District #4, to the
Aviation Commission. This is a four year term. This motion as unanimously approved.
A RESOLUTION TO AMEND THE PROCEDURES AND GUIDELINES
MANUAL FOR THE FA(ADE PROGRAM
WHEREAS, The City of Orangeburg was awarded a $500,000 by the United
States Department of Housing and Urban Development thru the
South Carolina Department of Commerce, Division of Grants
Administration; and,
WHEREAS, The City Council formally adopted the Procedures and Guidelines
Manual and appointed a Fayade Oversight Committee to
administer and implement the Fayade Program according to the
Procedures and Guidelines; and,
WHEREAS, The Fayade Oversight Committee appointed by City Council has
voted to amend the Procedures and Guidelines Manual to better
meet the needs of the City of Orangeburg and the Fayade Grant
recipients; and,
WHEREAS, The first change approved by the Fayade Oversight Committee and
recommended for approval to City Council is to allow for change
orders if the grant recipient has not received the maximum an10unt
allowed by the program; and,
WHEREAS, The second change approved by the Fayade Oversight Committee
and recommended for approval to City Council is to remove the
30% revolving loan portion of the Fayade Grant Program; and,
WHEREAS, The South Carolina Department of Commerce, Division of Grants
and Administration has approved of the aforementioned changes.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the Mayor and City Council of the City
of Orangeburg, South Carolina, in Council duly assembled, do amend the Procedures and
Guidelines Manual for the City of Orangeburg's Community Development Fayade
Program as proscribed in this resolution.
PASSED BY the City Council of the City of Orangeburg, State of South Carolina, this
15th day of January 2008.
k~~,---- __ v
Attest: CC1~ ~. ~.-J
rd" rlprJ...
RESOLUTION
A RESOLUTION TO AUTHORIZE RIGHT-OF-WAY AND EASEMENT TO
THE SOUTH CAROLINA PUBLIC SERVICE AUTHORITY (SANTEE COOPER)
WHEREAS, The Orangeburg Municipal Airport is owned and operated by the City of Orangeburg
and is located two miles south of downtown Orangeburg off of the Highway 21 by
pass at 1811 Airport Road; and,
WHEREAS, The South Carolina Publ ic Service Authority (also known as Santee Cooper) desires to
acquire an additional 55 foot right-of-way and easement (9.335 acres) to its current
100 foot right-of-way and easement for a total of 155 feet of right-of-way and
easement to construct a new 230 KV Transmission line parallel to their existing
transmission line on the western side of the Orangeburg Municipal Airport property;
and,
WHEREAS, The Federal Aviation Administration, Atlanta Airports District Office has reviewed
and approved the conveyance of aforementioned additional right-of-way and easement
with the following conditions (1) the $27,928.15 compensation paid to the City be
placed in an interest bearing account and utilized for payment of an FAA approved use
on eligible projects at the Orangeburg Municipal Airport, and (2) The City of
Orangeburg update the Orangeburg Municipal Airport's Airport Layout Plan (ALP)
Airport Property Map drawing (Exhibit A) with the aforementioned right-of-way and
easement inform3tion~ and,
WHEREAS, The new transmission line does not interfere with current or future airport operations;
and,
WHEREAS, The South Carolina Public Service Authority will pay the City of Orangeburg a sum of
$27,928.15, equal to the fair market value and timber value of the 9.335 acre right-of
way and easement at the Orangeburg Municipal Airport; and,
WHEREAS, it is in the best interest of the City of Orangeburg, the Orangeburg Municipal Airport,
the South Carolina Public Service Authority that the specified right-of-way and
easements be granted for the specified dollar amount.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the Mayor and City Council of the City of Orangeburg, South
Carolina, in Council duly assembled, that the City Administrator has authority to approve the conveyance of
9.335 acres in right-of-way and easement to the South Carolina Public Service Commission for the amount of
$27,928.15.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the City administrator is authorized to sign and execute all documents
relating thereto.
~~
~~
AM,,~~Ji,j~\~..J
City Clerk
PASSED BY the City Council of the City of Orangeburg, State of South Carolina, this 15'1. day of January
2008.
RESOLUTION TO APPROVE CHANGE ORDER TO JUNE 4, 2007 CONTRACT WITH
AOS SPECIALTY CONTRACTORS FOR CONSTRUCTION OF PARKING AREA AND
COURTYARD
WHEREAS, City Council has prioritized a new parking area and landscaped court yard {
project for early 2008; and, /'a
/
/
/
WHEREAS, AOS Specialty, Inc., was the low responsible bidder and is the contractor on the
CUtTent ongoing streetscape project; and,
WHEREAS, the City of Orangeburg is satisfied with their perfonnance and high level of expertise;
and,
WHEREAS, the type of work to be perfonned on the parking areas and court yard consists
primarily of the same type work and units as the streetscape project; and
WHEREAS, the AOS Specialty Contractors Inc., has agreed to honor the same unit prices to the
parking/court yard project as were bid on the Streetscape Project; and,
WHEREAS, the City's consultant architects and engineer, the Land Plan Group have reviewed
the said unit prices and have determined them to be under their estimated project
costs; and,
WHEREAS, City Staff recommends moving forward with the Parking/Court Yard Project with
AOS Specialty Contractor Inc., and issuing a Change Order to June 4, 2007 Contract
in the amount of$225,000
NOW, THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED, that the Mayor and Members of City Council, duly
assembled direct City Administrator John H. Yow to execute Change Order with AOS Specialty
Contractors, Inc. in the anlount of$225,000 for the construction of a parking area and court yard.
PASSED BY the City Council of the City of Orangeburg, State of South Carolina, this 15th day of
January 2008.
~~
(J:~ if? }?fjf?~""
AC
ES
1' ~ )a~kLo <}t. '1<X/y--'
City Clerk
,..~1(ORANG~~
~ L>?U '%
* " *
<J> "" ~0" Vl"Jf Cp..fjl.O
~
RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE EXECUTION OF A RIGHT-OF-WAY AND
EASEMENT AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE CITY OF ORANGEBURG AND
SOUTH CAROLINA PUBLIC SERVICE AUTHORITY (SANTEE COOPER)
WHEREAS, The South Carolina Public Service Authority (Santee Cooper) owns an
electric transmission line right-of-way and easement 100 feet in width across property owned
by the City of Orangeburg, Department of Public Utilities located at the Wastewater Plant at
369 Gulbrandsen Road (TMS# 171-00-01-010), and;
WHEREAS, The South Carolina Public Service Authority (Santee Cooper) and the City of
Orangeburg Department of Public Utilities have agreed to relocation of the said 100 foot
easement to the southernmost property line of the said property, and;
WHEREAS, The South Carolina Public Service Authority (Santee Cooper) wishes to
acquire an additional electric transmission line right-of-way and easement 50 feet in width to
run contiguous with the relocated right-of-way across said property owned by the City of
Orangeburg, Department of Public Utilities, and;
WHEREAS, The South Carolina Public Service Authority (Santee Cooper) proposes to pay
the City of Orangeburg $32,025.61 for the additional Right-of-Way and Easement, and;
WHEREAS, by the Mayor and Members of Council of the City of Orangeburg, in Council
assembled, and by authority of the same, that this Right-of-Way and Easement Agreement be
accepted, and;
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED, by Orangeburg City Council, duly assembled,
that Fred H. Boatwright, Manager of the Department of Public Utilities is hereby authorized
to execute the attached Right-of-Way and Easement Agreement for the purpose of granting
to the South Carolina Public Service Authority a right-of-way and easement as described
therein.
DONE AND RATIFIED by Council duly assembled this IS-tfay of January, 2008.
k4.~
MAYOR
~~~CITYCLE~ --
I8n
Page 4
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tem Haire, seconded by Councilmember Knotts, to approve the
reappointment of Desiree Chavis-District #4, and Johnny Byrd-District #6, to the Board of Zoning
Appeals. This is a four year term. This motion was unanimously approved. There are still two
vacancies on the Board.
A motion was made by Councilmember Rheney, seconded by Councilmember Miller, to approve the
reappointment of Deborah Stribling-District #2, William R. Evans, Jr.-District #4 and John H.
Wolfe-District #6, to the Planning Commission. This is a four year tenn. This motion was
unanimously approved. There is still one vacancy for District-#5.
Conceming the Department of Public Utilities, a Resolution to grant the right-of-way and easement to
the South Carolina Public Service Authority was presented. A motion was made by Councilmember
Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Miller, to amend, the right-of-way and easement
agreement.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, seconded by Councilmember Bamwell, to approve the
Resolution, as amended, granting DPU Manager Boatwright the authority to approve and execute
the right-of-way and easement agreement to the South Carolina Public Service Authority. This
motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Miller, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to adjourn.
This motion was unanimously approved.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
Respectfully submitted,
~rvtJWrv.~
Carrie W. Johnson ~
City Clerk
/pfb
1848 City Council Minutes
February 5, 2008
Orangeburg City Council held its regularly scheduled meeting on Tuesday, February 5, 2008, at 7:00
P.M. in Council Chambers with Mayor Miller presiding.
PRESENT:
Paul A. Miller, Mayor
Bernard Haire
Charles W. Jernigan
Sandra P. Knotts
Trelvis A. Miller
Joyce W. Rheney
ABSENT:
Charles B. Barnwell
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, seconded by Councilmember Knotts, to approve the
January 15, 2008, City Council Minutes as distributed. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Rheney, seconded by Councilmember Miller, to approve the
Second Reading of an Ordinance amending section 2-2.20 of the Code of Ordinances for the City of
Orangeburg for the purpose of establishing an alternate procedure for the appointment or election of
Board and Commission Members. This motion was unanimously approved
City Administrator Yow overviewed the Zoning Ordinance and proposed amendments. (See Attached
Zoning Ordinance Revisions)
Councilmember Miller asked if the digital signs that are out there now, if they were grandfathered in?
City Administrator Yow responded, "Yes."
There was a discussion on the cutting of trees by permit. Councilmember Jernigan asked, "If an
individual wants to cut a tree in their yard and it is a hardwood, they can't cut it?"
City Administrator Yow responded, "They have not been able to cut any in the past greater than 24
inches and it will now be 18 inches"
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "Will they be subject to fines without a permit?"
City Administrator Yow responded, "Yes."
Councilmember Knotts asked, "If I have a tree in my yard and it is causing damage to my roof, I can't
cut it?"
City Administrator Yow and Building Official Nelson stated, "No, you would be allowed to cut it."
Mayor Pro Tern Haire asked, "What is the rationale for this?"
City Administrator Yow responded, "For preserving and protecting the trees and forests and for
beautification of the City."
Councilmember Knotts stated, "I can see it for new development but not for individuals."
18.19
Page 2
City Administrator Yow stated, "If you don't do it after a development, you regulate what can be
done prior to development but after the development, they can cut everything down. We get a lot of
calls when people cut trees without permits. Now, that is Council's call to leave this in or take it out."
Building Official Nelson stated, "What you have in your Ordinance right now states that you cannot
cut a tree over 24 inches in diameter, what we are doing here is backing it up a little bit to 18 inches."
City Administrator Yow passed out an article on digital billboards for review that Council may want
to address.
A motion was made by Councilmember Jernigan, seconded by Councilmember Rheney, to approve
the Second Reading of an Ordinance to anlend Chapter 24, Zoning Ordinance, of the Code of
Ordinances to the City of Orangeburg, South Carolina. This was a 5-0-1 vote as Mayor Pro Tern
Haire abstained.
Ms. Faye Menefee accepted the Character Trait Proclamation for February 2008, "Cooperation".
A motion was made by Councilmember Rheney, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, to approve a
Resolution to declare February 2008, as "Cities Means Business Month". This motion was
unanimously approved.
Chief Wendell Davis overviewed for Council a report concerning the reduction of crime in the City
over the last ten years. He stated that Orangeburg County, as a whole, was rated number one in
violent crime in 1998 in state and today the County is 38
th
. He further stated that the City of
Orangeburg's crime rate has decreased 44% over the last ten years. He stated that there were several
factors contributing to this decrease such as, increased emphasis on street enforcement, coordinating
patrol and investigations, a zero tolerance policy for simple assaults that tend to escalate, the
establishment of a crime analysis office, the employment of a forensic chemist, focusing on DNA,
gang awareness, and other city departments focusing on urban blight and providing equipment. He
also stated that Council helps control urban blight, for example, by demolishing the old apartments on
Riverside which helped deter crinJe for that area.
There were no utility matters brought before Council.
Mayor Prop Tern Haire asked for a moment and stated, "To say I'm hot enough to spit bullets is an
understatement. Yesterday evening, once again, Norfolk Southern decided that they are going to do
their own thing in Orangeburg. After 1 got off of work, I headed home. 1 normally go across the
Peasley Street crossing to Boulevard. I was not able to do this; however, I went down to Zan Street. I
went home and got my camera and walked back up to the comer of Boulevard and Oak Street. There
were a number of train cars blocking that intersection. After I made several pictures of the blockage
and the train and cars, I walked down to where the engine was and there was a young man sitting
inside there and I asked him how long he was going to block the intersection. He replied that it would
be a while and I then asked as to why it was necessary to blOCk the intersection. He replied that based
on regulations we can only work twelve hours and we have met them. I then asked as to why they
didn't move the train, unbuckle some of the cars and move it down. He replied that it was too long.
On yesterday, the train was blocking the intersection one hour and forty-five minutes. I observed
individuals who would nonnally go across Peasley Street, going down in order to go to Claflin and
South Carolina State. Norfolk Southern does not wish to be inconvenienced, but it does not mind
inconveniencing the citizens here in Orangeburg. I find this to be down right disturbing to me. We
have attempted, as a Council, to try to get the speed lowered of the train coming through Orangeburg
to no avail. I have been in contact with individuals from Graniteville who informed me that once the
accident occurred there that Norfolk Southern reduced the speed to 25-30 mph coming through there.
Does that mean there has to be an accident before the speed is reduced here? We have a too
populated area for the speed of the trains coming through this area. Some of us have had the privilege
of seeing some information that would scare any fair minded person to lower the speed coming
through Orangeburg. In the City Code of Ordinances, for the City of Orangeburg, it mentions about
blocking streets and crossings and time limits. According to our Ordinances, they are allowed only 5
minutes to block a
18~OPage 3
crossing. On last night, I know for a fact, that it was over an hour and forty-five minutes. We have
an Ordinance on the books that governs truck routes and public safety officers stop trucks that violate
these Ordinances. Last night, I observed two different patrol cars from Public Safety passing the
blockage. No one stopped or made any inquiry as to what was going on, they just drove by. 1 am
here tonight to ask that this Ordinance be enforced and that the Public Safety Officers issue necessary
citations when needed. I would hope that the Ordinances that govern speed on the city streets are
enforced and that this be enforced. I stayed up there until some relief crew came through. It is plain
to see that Norfolk Southern can calculate where their crew will be in twelve hours and I would think
they would have the common sense that they don't need to wait until the train stops in Orangeburg for
them to then send a relief crew. I am really hot and I am disgusted and I need to know why we are
not enforcing this Ordinance as it relates to blocking the street crossings?"
Chief Davis responded, "As of yesterday, I don't know why this happened. We put a procedure in
place to address it by logging it into the computer into the CAD system. What I will do, I will look at
that tonight and see if we can't write them a citation from that incident."
Mayor Pro Tern Haire stated, "I have pictures of the cars, drivers, and train and also have witnesses."
Mayor Miller replied "This has been brought to our attention many times and I think a ticket has been
written before."
City Administrator Yow stated, "We wrote the citation to Norfolk Southern and they asked us not to
write the citation to the engineer."
Mayor Miller replied, "Maybe we need to write Norfolk Southern and change the Ordinance to
increase the fine to a point that it gets their attention."
City Attorney Walsh replied, "That is the maximum fine that can be imposed according to state law."
City Administrator Yow addressed Council. "We would like to request that City Council hold a
special meeting next Wednesday, Febmary 13,2008, at 12:00 Noon."
Mayor Miller made a motion to have a Special City Council Meeting on Wednesday, February 13,
2008, at 12:00 Noon. This motion was seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Haire and unanimously
approved.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, seconded by Councilmember Rheney, to adjourn. This
motion was unanimously approved.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
c;;r~i:~
Carrie W. Johnson
City Clerk
Iplb
Table I
Table II
Table III
24-5.1
24-6.1
24-6.4
24-7.3
24-8.4
24-8.6
24-9.1
24-9.2
24-9.3
24-9.4
Changesin ZoningOrdinance
>
Replace Table I Classifications from old SIC to NAICS, Section 24-5.1, Page 7, this is
classification that is commonly used in Municipal Zoning Ordinances, Page 7
Bed and Breakfast no longer allowed as a Special exception in A-1, table 1, Page 16
Pg 19-20 Increase maximum height to 50 Ft, from 35 ft.
Digital signs not allowed within 300 feet of nearest residential dwelling, 24-8, Table
III, Table IV, page 52
Classification from old SIC to NArCS
Eliminated Type A and Type B, PDD's. Now simply have one Type PDD, Section
2~-6.1, Page 22
As council indicated their desire, all PDD's must be approved by Council. Also,
added incremental (conceptual) stage where developer would submit to Council for
initial approval; if approved Developer would proceed to develop detailed plan, Page
23e
Establishment of Design Overlay District- Check special purpose District Page 5, No 3
and Page 34, Section 24-6.4. On Zoning Map this District is from US 60I to Riverside
along Russell and from Amelia to John C. Calhoun.
Added Special Exception for Off-Street Parking, Section 24-7.3, Page 43
More flexibility in parking in Downtown by increasing of Central business District on
Zoning Map and added special exception for off-street parking, Section 24-7.3, Page
43
Added language to Common Signage Plan. Section 24-8.4, page 45
Added Table listing Temporary Signs-47 for clarification purposes. Changes from
sixty (60) to thirty ( 30) days. Prior intervals were all six (6) months; also added
political signs which were previously classified as posters. Section 24-8.6
Increased size and density of buffer areas, Section 24-9.1,24-9.2,3,4
Page 54-60
.,
24-9.5
24-10.7
24-11.3
24-11.9
Tree Protection- Under After Development- Change made to protected size to 18
inches from 24 inches. Requires replacement tree. Section 24-9.5, c3, page 63-64
notes: (1) Gives Zoning Administrator more discretion to cut trees if they are replaced.
(2) City does not regulate pine tree after development.
Eliminate use of Shipping Storage Containers; One year amortization period. Page 18.
Also regulate Portable Storage facilities, Section 24-10.7, Page 81
Added Section on Camp and Resort Vehicle Parks, section 24-10.74 (v), Page 85
Regulate open storage of vehicles at repair shop, Section 24-10.7 (w)
Address Buildable Area for clarity
1'{on-conformities- Rewritten to grandfather existing structure or building for repairs
(not expansion or enlargement)
Articles XIII-Definitions
-
A Resolution to declare February 2008 as "Cities Mean: Business" month
WHEREAS, cities and towns are the economic engines that make the State of South Carolina
more competitive in the global marketplace, and;
WHEREAS, the partnership between the City of Orangeburg and local business leaders is
critical to the new knowledge economy and future of regional workforce
development, and;
WHEREAS, the City of Orangeburg offers a positive quality of life that attracts business,
industry and new jobs to the region through the services that it provides; such as
electric, water, wastewater, and gas utilities, fire protection, police protection,
sanitation services, recreational facilities and recreational programs, land use and
zoning protections, municipal airport, economic development activities and,
responsive local governance, and;
WHEREAS, the City of Orangeburg, and many other cities and towns across the state, bring
value to the State of South Carolina as an important building block in supporting
economic competitiveness and prosperity, and;
WHEREAS, the City of Orangeburg, and many other cities and towns across the state,
constitute the core of economic growth and prosperity for the State of South
Carolina, and work in partnership with business and industry to provide the
necessary infrastructure to assist in their growth and support their
competitiveness, and;
WHEREAS, the success of our state's economic development efforts is dependent on the
strength of the City of Orangeburg, and many other cities and towns across the
state, to provide the quality services and amenities taxpayers and businesses
demand, and;
WHEREAS, the City of Orangeburg supports state legislation that encourages economic
growth within the global economy, and;
WHEREAS, businesses repeatedly point to quality of life as one of the determining factors in
making a decision where to locate, for which the City of Orangeburg and many
other cities and towns across the state are the primary source of the valuable
elements that create a positive quality of life supporting tourism, public safety,
recreation, the arts and cultural actives, and;
WHEREAS, the City of Orangeburg supports state legislative efforts to provide residents and
businesses with cost-effective and efficient programs and services that support a
positive quality of life, and;
WHEREAS, the City of Orangeburg fully supports local decision making for land use and
development regulations and flexible uses of local hospitality and
accommodations taxes that local municipal leadership must have in order to have
the ability to provide resources in a manner that best supports its local needs,
and;
WHEREAS, the City of Orangeburg maintains that local municipal leadership must have the
ability to provide resources in a manner that best supports its local and regional
needs, and;
WHEREAS, research indicates residents want local control over the laws and regulations that
affect the growth and development of their hometowns, and;
WHEREAS, the City of Orangeburg supports local fiscal accountability and management of
resources that are critical to the support of a well-run City such as the ability to
make local decisions on financial priorities and the need for flexible resources to
meet the demands of the City's residents, and;
WHEREAS, the City of Orangeburg supports locally-directed fiscal accountability for municipal
governments and an open and accountable government, and;
WHEREAS, the positive growth of the City of Orangeburg is often hampered by out-dated laws
that prevent orderly and cost-effective growth patterns, and;
WHEREAS, cities that are able to grow to their natural boundaries find it easier to attract a
higher quality workforce, more industry and business, and;
WHEREAS, updated annexation laws can make it easier for cities to attract economic
development by showing realistic evidence of local population numbers and
growth patterns, and;
WHEREAS, the City of Orangeburg fully supports annexation reform of the state's outdated
laws, and;
WHEREAS, the City of Orangeburg fully supports a balanced tax policy that doesn't unfairly
burden any sector of taxpayer, but at the same time, ensures flexibility to
resources so that government can provide services at the level expected by
taxpayers, and;
WHEREAS, the City of Orangeburg offers a comfortable sense of "community" which is a vital
to local citizen, providing them with pride, contentment and well being, and;
WHEREAS, "Cites Mean Business" month celebrates that the City of Orangeburg and many
other cities and towns across South Carolina are committed to a strong and
positive relationship with local business leaders.
NOW, THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED by the Mayor and City Council of the City of
Orangeburg, in Council duly assembled, do declare February 2008 as,
"Cities Mean Business Month"
~
in the City of Orangeburg.
PASSED BY the City Council of the City of Orangeburg, State of South Carolina, this 5th day of
February 2008.
Attesttwoill rrv. ~
City Clerk
1851
Special
City Council Minutes
February 13, 2008
Orangeburg City Council held a Special meeting on February 13, 2008, at 12:00 Noon in Council
Chambers with Mayor Miller presiding.
PRESENT:
Paul A. Miller, Mayor
Charles B. Barnwell, Jr.
Bernard Haire
Charles W. Jernigan
Sandra P. Knotts
Joyce W. Rheney
ABSENT:
Trelvis A. Miller
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Rheney, to enter into
an Executive Session for a legal matter concerning the General Terms and Conditions of the
Department of Public Utilities. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Jernigan, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to return to
Open Session. This motion as unanimously approved.
Council returned to Open Session.
City Attorney Walsh addressed Council. He explained the Ordinance for amending the General
Ternls and Conditions of the Department of Public Utilities. The Ordinance addresses water and
wastewater taps concerning property under consideration of arulexation. He further stated that if the
property is not zoned by the County as single-family that there can be no water or wastewater taps
done from the date ofthe petition until the third reading ofthe Ordinance for annexation. If there is a
substantial hardship, the property owner can come before Council to request permission for a water
and wastewater tap. He also stated that in the Ordinance, it addresses any new construction in the
City, before a water or wastewater connection is made, that a copy of the City building permit be
required by the Department of Public Utilities to show that they are in compliance with the City
regulations and Zoning Ordinance.
City Attorney Walsh explained the Resolution for Council that a moratorium be placed on the
granting of water taps and wastewater taps in newly almexed areas of the City of Orangeburg. He
explained that this would only affect the newly annexed properties from the last Council Meeting off
of Columbia Road, Longwood and Churchill Streets.
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Jernigan, to approve
the First Reading of an Ordinance amending the General Terms and Conditions of the Department of
Public Utilities of the City of Orangeburg, SC, as adopted by Council on November 6, 2002. This
motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Rheney, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to approve a
Resolution placing a moratorium on the granting of water taps and wastewater taps in newly annexed
areas of the City of Orangeburg. This motion was unanimously approved.
City Administrator Yow addressed Council on the closing of Formosa Street. He stated, "Habitat for
Humanity has approached the City on the closing of this alley off of Riggs Street. They own the lot
that this alley cuts through. They plan on building on this lot and it has been verified with the
Department of Public Utilities that there are no utilities on this site. He further stated that it could not
be determined when this alley was added to the City map as a street."
1852
Page 2
A motion as made by Councilmember Jernigan, seconded by Mayor Pro tern Haire, to approve a
Resolution to close and abandon FornlOsa Street. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, seconded by Councilmember Jernigan, to adjourn.
This motion was unanimously approved.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
Respectfully submitted,
0Mw~.
Carrie W. Johnson
City Clerk
/pfb
/
/
RESOLUTION PLACING A MORATORIUM ON THE GRANTING OF WATER TAPS AND
WASTEWATER TAPS IN NEWLY ANNEXED AREAS OF THE CITY OF ORANGEBURG
WHEREAS, the City of Orangeburg is now requiring that property owners located in the
unincorporated areas of Orangeburg County agree to annexation as a condition for provision of
water and wastewater utilities from its Department of Public Utilities, and;
WHEREAS, property owners have and are attempting to circumvent the intent of this
requirement by attempting to obtain vested rights from the County of Orangeburg prior to
annexation, and;
WHEREAS, the City of Orangeburg finds that it is in its best interest to initiate a policy to
prevent said circumvention in order to provide orderly land development and to assure
compliance with its zoning ordinances, and;
WHEREAS, the City of Orangeburg has by ordinance on first reading adopted a procedure
to eliminate said circumvention by amending the General Terms and Conditions of its
Department of Public Utilities; and
WHEREAS, it is necessary that the status quo be maintained during the enactment of said
ordinance.
NOW THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY CITY COUNCIL DULY ASSEMBLED:
That until the above described ordinance which received first reading on February 1~
2008 amending the General Terms and Conditions of its Department of Public Utilities is adopted
on third reading, no water taps or wastewater taps shall be granted to property owners in any
area annexed into the corporate limits of the City of Orangeburg subsequent to January 1, 2008.
DONE ANq~fU\T1FIED BY THE CITY OF ORANGEBURG, STATE OF SOUTH
CAROLINA THIS_/6"1_1DAY OF FEBRUARY, 2008.
~?/fe~ 65: 1L~avM'~. .-C/
;?lj("~- / //
lVIayor _ ,
~~
lVIem6ers6fCCluncii
ATTEST: ~a»d?t~rrJ
1C:\MyFiles\City\RESOLUT10N\Reso[ution.City Grantmg of Water Taps,wpd
RESOLUTION TO CLOSE AND ABANDON FORMOSA STREET PURSUANT TO SOUTH
CAROLINA CODE § 5-27-150
WHEREAS, Formosa Street is a ten (10) foot, more or less, wide street shown on the
municipal maps of the City of Orangeburg running between Riggs Street and Maple Street, and;
WHEREAS, all abutting property owners have access to their properties without the
necessity of Formosa Street, and;
WHEREAS, the owner of Lot 3 on a plat recorded in the Office of the Register of Deeds
for the County of Orangeburg, State of South Carolina in Plat Book C321 at page 5, wishes to
construct a dwelling on said lot and the closing and abandonment of Formosa Street is necessary
for said purpose.
NOW THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY CITY COUNCIL DULY ASSEMBLED, that
pursuant to South Carolina Code § 5-27-150 City Council does hereby declare that Formosa
Street is hereby closed and abandoned after finding that said street is no longer needed for
public use or convenience and that its closing and abandonment would be in the interest of the
City and the interests of the general public and citizens of the City.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that John H. Yow, City Administrator is hereby authoriz€-i
to consent to the closing and abandonment of Formosa Street in accordance with South Carolina
Code § 57-9-10.
DONE AND ~ATlFIED BY THE CITY OF ORANGEBURG, STATE OF SOUTH
CAROLINA THIS ~DAY OF FEBRUARY, 2008.
~~
MemoersofCouncii
"
ATTEST CD»><lC;;;&wrL-
City Cler
1C \MyFiles\Clty\RESOLUT10N\ResoluUon.Cily.CloseandabandonFormosaSt.wpd
1853
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
February 19,2008
Orangeburg City Council held its regularly scheduled meeting on Tuesday, February 19, 2008, at 7:00
P.M., in Council Chambers with Mayor Miller presiding.
PRESENT:
Paul A. Miller, Mayor
Charles B. Barnwell
Bernard Haire
Charles W. Jernigan
Sandra P. Knotts
Trelvis A. Miller
ABSENT:
Joyce W. Rheney
A motion was made by Councilmember Jernigan, seconded by Mayor Pro Tem Haire, to approve the
February 19,2008, City Council Minutes as distributed. This was a 5-0-1 vote with Councilmember
Barnwell abstaining as he was not present at the last meeting.
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Jernigan, to approve
the February 13,2008, Special City Council Minutes. This was a 5-0-1 vote with Councilmember
Miller abstaining as he was not present at the last meeting.
Public Safety Director Wendell Davis and Mayor Miller presented Henry Bowman a Retiree
Resolution and a gold watch for his twenty-eight years and eleven months of service to the City of
Orangeburg Department of Public Safety.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to approve the
Third Reading of an Ordinance amending Section 2-2.20 of the Code of Ordinances for the City of
Orangeburg for the purpose of establishing an alternate procedure for the appointment or election of
Board and Commission Members. This motion was unanimously approved.
City Administrator Yow overviewed the Ordinance to arnend Chapter 24, the Zoning Ordinance for
the City.
Councilmember Barnwell asked, "On page 27, the last paragraph, why is that in there?"
City Attorney Walsh replied, "That language is from state statute."
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tem Haire, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to approve the
Third Reading of an Ordinance to amend Chapter 24, the Zoning Ordinance of the City. This motion
was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Knotts, seconded by Mayor Pro Tem Haire, to approve the
reappointment of Mr. Robert Nance to the Aviation Commission for a four year term ending January,
2012. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Jernigan, seconded by Council member Miller, to appoint Mr.
Tom Salley to serve on the Board of Zoning Appeals for a four year term ending January, 2012. This
motion was unanimously approved.
t')s4
Page 2
Concerning the Department of Public Utilities, City Attorney Walsh overviewed amendments to the
General Terms and Conditions of the Department of Public Utilities. The amendments require the
following:
(I.) No water taps shall be made to property under consideration for annexation by the City which is
located in the unincorporated areas of Orangeburg County and not zoned "RS-Residential, single
Family" as defined in the County of Orangeburg Zoning Ordinance during the period beginning at
the date of the corresponding Annexation Petition and ending upon final adoption of the
Annexation Ordinance or upon said Ordinance not receiving an affirmative, majority vote for
adoption on second or third reading. This prohibition may be waved by majority vote of City
Council upon a finding that same would impose a substantial hardship on a property owner.
(2.) No water taps shall be made for the purpose of providing water to premises located in the City of
Orangeburg for new construction unless the Department receives a valid City building permit.
(3.) No wastewater taps shall be made to property under consideration for annexation by the City
which is located in the unincorporated areas of Orangeburg County and not zoned "RS
Residential, Single Family" as defined in the County of Orangeburg Zoning Ordinance during the
period beginning at the date of the corresponding Annexation Petition and ending upon final
adoption of the annexation Ordinance or upon said Ordinance not receiving an affirmative,
majority vote for adoption on second or third reading. This prohibition may be waved by majority
vote of City Council upon a finding that same would impose a substantial hardship on a property
owner.
(4.) No wastewater taps shall be made for the purpose of providing wastewater to premises located in
the City of Orangeburg for new construction unless the Department receives a valid City building
permit.
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Jernigan, to approve
the Second Reading of an Ordinance amending the General Terms and Conditions of the Department
of Public Utilities of the City of Orangeburg, SC, as adopted by Council on November 6, 2002. This
motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to adjourn.
This motion was unanimously approved.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
Respectfully submitted,
~~,
Carrie W. Johnson
City Clerk
CWJ/pfb
WHEREAS,
WHEREAS,
WHEREAS,
RESOLUTION
Henry Bowman faithfully served the City of Orangeburg's
Department of Public Safety for twenty-eight years and eleven
months with a retirement date of January 2, 2008; and
he, through his long and faithful service, contributed greatly to the
successful operation of the City of Orangeburg's Department of
Public Safety; and,
the City Council, in recognition ofthe fine contribution rendered the
City of Orangeburg, wants to inscribe on the records its
appreciation.
~~
MAYOR
-
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the Mayor and Members of Council,
in Council assembled, do officially recognize the faithful service rendered to the City of
Orangeburg in the capacities in which he served the City and we take pride in commending him for
a job well done.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that a copy of this Resolution, in appreciation for his
devotion of duty to the City of Orangeburg, be placed in the Minute Book of the City and a copy
furnished to Mr. Bowman in recognition of his services.
PASSED BY the City Council of the City of Orangeburg, State of South Carolina, this
nineteenth day of February, 2008.
A~T~~~.
CITY 0'--" ~
1855
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
March 4, 2008
Orangeburg City Council held a Public Hearing on Tuesday, March 4,2008, at 7:00 P.M., in Council
Chambers with Mayor Miller presiding. The purpose of the Public Hearing was as follows:
#1 Rezoning of property: To consider an application for a Zoning Change from D-I Industrial
District to B-1 General Business District property belonging to Orangeburg County Fair Association,
for property located at 350 Whaley Street, NKJA Orangeburg County Fair Grounds, TMP# 0173-19
17-001 and 350 Magnolia Street, NKIA Orangeburg County Fair Grounds, TMP# 0172-07-01-001.
#2 Annexation of property: To consider an application for annexation into the City of Orangeburg
property belonging to Chandra Singh located at 1650 John Wesley Road TMP#01740130940995 and
property belonging to Chandra Singh and Jai Singh, 1656-1658 and 1660 John Wesley Road (NKJA
102, 104,106,108,112, 116 Manisha Court), TMP#0174-13-04-006.
Hearing no public comments, the Public Hearing was closed.
Council then held the regularly scheduled City Council meeting with Mayor Miller presiding.
PRESENT:
Paul A. Miller, Mayor
Charles B. Barnwell, Jr.
Bernard Haire
Charles W. Jernigan
Sandra P. Knotts
Trelvis A. Miller
Joyce W. Rheney
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, to approve the
February 19, 2008, City Council Minutes as distributed. This was a 6-0-1 vote as Councilmember
Rheney abstained as she was absent from the last meeting.
Dr. Johnson from Edisto High School accepted the Proclamation Trait for the month of March 2008,
"Citizenship".
Assistant City Administrator Bronson overviewed the Ordinance to amend Section 24-4.1, District
Boundaries and Maps of the Code of Ordinances for the City and the Zoning Map ofthe City (350
Whaley Street) and to amend Section 24-4.1, District Boundaries and Maps of the Code of
Ordinances for the City and the Zoning Map of the City (350 Magnolia Street).
Concerning the rezoning of the fairgrounds, Mayor Pro Tern Haire asked, "You stated that this only
affects the portion of the City that is in the city limits, what part isn't and why isn't the other part
being considered?"
Assistant City Administrator Bronson explained which portions of the fairgrounds were out ofthe
city limits. He further stated, "The Fair Association has a Board and some are interested in annexing
that portion and some are not. This request was for rezoning and not annexation. The Planning
Commission has also approved this request from D-l to B-1."
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Rheney, to approve
the First Reading of an Ordinance to amend Section 24-4.1, District Boundaries and Maps of the
Code of Ordinance of the City of Orangeburg and the Zoning Map of the City of Orangeburg, South
Carolina (350 Whaley Street). This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Council member Knotts, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, to approve the
First Reading of an Ordinance to amend section 24-4.1, District Boundaries and Maps of the Code of
Ordinances of the City of Orangeburg and the Zoning Map of the City of Orangeburg, South Carolina
(350 Magnolia Street). This motion was unanimously approved.
1856
Page 2
Assistant City Administrator Bronson addressed Council in reference to this item. He stated,
"Continuing on in the area we just annexed with the 75% petition method that you just approved in
January, the property owner at that time did not want to come into the City and decided now that he
wanted to do ahead and bring his property in the City." Mr. Bronson explained the area to be
annexed on the map for Council and the streets, homes and apartments involved. He further
explained about the apartments there and what was planned for development.
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "Are the apartments pretty much full?"
Assistant City Administrator Bronson explained, "Mr. Singh gave numbers that there were residents
in all units."
Assistant City Administrator Bronson stated, "The Planning Commission has approved this
annexation and recommended the zoning designation as A-2."
Mayor Pro Tern Haire stated, "Before we go into this type of hodge podge annexation, I pulled out
my annexation plan from 1996 from Vismor & Associates and this gives an orderly suggestion as it
relates to annexation. I would like to know why we aren't pursuing a plan we have. To me it seems
that there is a consensus to do annexation and I do not see this plan being implemented in any kind of
systematic way."
City Administrator Yow responded, "When that was adopted, of course, a lot of changes have
happened since then. We have spoken to a lot of groups and circulated petitions and they weren't
successful in getting a consensus in the larger areas. Even though that plan suggests bringing in those
larger areas, you still have to meet state law with the 75% petition. That is why we have been doing it
in this matter and we try to get as large an area as we can. In the last annexation, we had a larger area
but we couldn't get enough signatures. We are happy as always to work with any of the areas that
want to come in. I don't know if that study fully took into account state law and the situation with our
utilities and other factors."
Mayor Pro Tern Haire replied, "I would like to see annexation done in a more orderly fashion."
City Administrator Yow stated, "I think that is why Council took the position on the utility covenants.
As the covenants are signed and we go into an area to annex, you will have covenants that you can
execute for annexation. Those covenants are going to take some time in large areas to get enough
numbers to do it."
Mayor Pro Tern Haire asked, "Is one person enough staff to go out in these areas for annexation."
City Administrator Yow responded, "That is something that we have discussed at great length to talk
to you about in the Council Planning Session. Right now, the Department of Public Utilities is
making sure we are getting the covenants, but we really do not have the staff to monitor all the
covenants, and digitize them on the maps. Kevin and other persons at DPU work on them part-time.
To answer your question, we do need more assistance."
A motion was made by Councilmember Jernigan, seconded by Councilmember Miller, to approve the
First Reading of an Ordinance to annex property at 1650 John Wesley Drive, TMP#0174-13-04-005,
into the city limits of the City of Orangeburg, South Carolina. This motion was unanimously
approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Knotts, seconded by Councilmember Miller, to approve the
First Reading of an Ordinance to annex property at 1656, 1658 and 1660 John Wesley Drive (AJKI A:
102,104,106,108,112,116 Manisha Court), TMP#0174-13-04-006 into the city limits ofthe City of
Orangeburg, South Carolina. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Jernigan, to approve
the First Reading of an Ordinance to amend the Municipal District Map dated November 6, 2001, for
the purpose of adding newly annexed City property to Municipal Council District #2. This motion
was unanimously approved.
1857
Page 3
Fiscal Year 2008-09 City of Orangeburg Budget Calendar was presented for information only at this
time.
A motion was made by Councilmember Miller, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to appoint
Mr. Bill Barrett to the City's Planning Commission for District #5. This is a four year term expiring
January, 2012. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, seconded by Councilmember Rheney, to approve the
reappointment of the following individuals to the City's Accommodations Tax Advisory Committee.
This is a four year term expiring March 2012.
Rachelle Jamerson Holmes-At-Iarge sector
David Coleman-Hospitality sector
Buster Smith-Hospitality sector
Fred Broughton-At-Iarge sector
City Administrator Yow overviewed the First Reading of an Ordinance repealing in its entirety
Chapter 9, Section 3 of the Code of Ordinances and repealing Chapter 5, Section 21 of said Code in
its entirety and replacing said Chapter 5, Section 21 with a new Chapter 5, Section 21 for the purpose
of establishing a uniform permit requirement for parades and public assemblies.
He stated, "We have brought this back to you as we have discussed this in the past and we have
continued to work on this. I am going to go over some highlights and I will be happy to answer any
questions that 1can for you. The first thing that is changed in this Ordinance is that a permit is not
required for a spontaneous event, which is one factor making the Ordinance legal and constitutional.
The second thing is that it exempts speech content. We would not grant or withhold a permit based
on the speech content or purpose of an assembly. Also, a permit is also required of an assembly of
25 people or more. A small group would not require a permit. The Ordinance takes an approach,
When a permit that is required for assemblies or groups from a public safety perspective; where we
Have reviewed requests, i.e. parades, and know the routes that they are taking and where these
assemblies are taking place. For example, a 10K run in the Gardens, we will review that route and
make sure it is a safe route. There are a few other things that have been added that I want to review
with you. On page 3, Item 17, when a public assembly is to be held in a residential zoned district,
the application must be signed by at least five (5) property owners within a radius of 500 feet of its
location. The reason for that is because we have had some groups come before Council, as you may
recall, and some people were saying that some assemblies held in their neighborhood was not
organized or attended by people in the neighborhood. This is a requirement. If you tum to the next
page, item C states, no permit shall be granted that allows for sound amplification equipment in any
residential zoned district. Again, that addressed some concerns of some residents that were brought
before Council."
Mayor Miller asked, "Ifthere are five property owners signed for the permit and it is within 500 feet
of the central location, they can't have any music that has amplification in a residential zone?"
City Administrator Yow replied, "Yes, for a public assembly in a residential zone, and that is new."
City Administrator Yow stated, "Another change is on page 3, at the beginning of Section 5-21.5 for
fees. We have added a sentence there where no permit fees shall be required for parades and public
assemblies sponsored by accredited institutions of higher learning. That was also something we
discussed."
City Attorney Walsh stated, "I know that there has been some discussion on the sound equipment in a
residential area for different flillctions."
Councilmember Miller asked, "What if someone wants to have a family reunion, they cannot have
any amplified music?"
City Administrator Yow replied, "Our Noise Ordinance would apply to that, we are talking about
using public property in a parade or public assembly."
1&58-
Page 4
City Attorney Walsh stated, "This applies to private and public property."
City Administrator Yow stated, "Unless I interpret the Ordinance wrong, if they have twenty people
at their house for a family reunion, they wouldn't need a permit anyway."
Councilmember Barnwell asked, "If someone wanted to have a wedding reception at your home, you
couldn't do it with a bandT'
City Attorney Walsh stated, "That is one of those things we need to address to permit some things like
that. This thing has been sitting around and we wanted to bring it to Council to get things back on
track."
Mayor Pro Tem Haire asked, "We had a group that was here before Council and I thought it was that
we were trying to get both sides together to try to come to a happy medium. We are coming up on
another summer and we haven't had a meeting."
City Administrator Yow responded, "I don't know if they have had a meeting or not. Tknow one
group came and then another group."
Mayor Pro TemHaire asked, "I thought the position was that we were going to get the two sides
together and see what kind of agreement we could get with the two sides. I am a product of the
sixties, wherein demonstrations were held here in Orangeburg for various reasons. Tthink that #7 A,
a $100 non-refundable fee to cover administrative costs, do we really have that much activity to
stifle people's right to assemble?"
City Administrator Yow stated, "We are not trying to stifle that in any means. That is why we have
that in here so we don't stifle it."
Mayor Pro Tem Haire stated, "What Tam talking about is when you put a fee out there, that causes
some problems for some people. I don't believe that there is anything in the constitution where
people have the right to peacefully assemble and to put a cost on that peaceful assembly is wrong."
City Administrator Yow replied, "That is only if they are using City property or services that it be
required."
City Attorney Walsh stated, "No, it is a fee for any assembly or parade."
City Administrator Yow stated, "Some events cost us money and some don't. We have to put up
barricades, provide extra police services, roll out containers and pick up litter. Whatever the case may
be."
Mayor Pro tem Haire asked, "Do we have that many cases where we have to provide that?"
City Administrator Yow stated, "Yes, we do, a conservative number would be 12. The thing is that is
Council's call. When we come to the Budget and we have extra overtime costs and we have other
extra costs, in some cases, we are absorbing their costs to have their event or parade."
Mayor Pro Tem Haire stated, "] would like to see us study this and pass over this tonight."
City Administrator Yow replied, "I don't have a problem with studying this, but we need to pass the
First Reading of the Ordinance and ] would rather take that out to pass the Ordinance."
City Attorney Walsh stated, "The other thing is that City Council set those costs by Resolution."
Mayor Pro Tem Haire stated, "] have gone through this particular document and there are some
challenges to this. This document was drawn up based on information received from other cities?"
1859
Page 5
City Administrator Yow responded, "Mr. Walsh has done a lot of research on this and one thing we
don't want to lose sight of is that this Ordinance is drawn to be legal and constitutional and
enforceable where we have concerns that our existing Ordinance may not be. This Ordinance is not
to stifle parades and assemblies as you all know we have them all the time. This is actually to set
forth parameters to govern that."
City Attorney Walsh stated, "This is the Ordinance that is recommended by the National Association
of City Attorneys."
Councilmember Barnwell stated, "I would rather see us delete that than not pass it."
City Administrator Yow stated, "We do need to adopt a new Ordinance. I do want to bring up one
thing from Mayor Pro Tern Haire, and I don't think he intended it this way. When I brought
up the part about the sound amplification, that was not put in there about the one party that the
groups came to us about. We get a lot of calls in residential neighborhoods on parties."
Mayor Miller asked, "Where you have the part in there about five hundred feet of property owners, if
someone wanted to have a wedding reception in their yard, they would have to get five neighbors to
agree to it. Ifhe couldn't get it, he couldn't hold it there."
City Administrator Yow responded, "That was put in there because of some of the concems Council
expressed that night where several ladies came where they said this was a party for the neighborhood
and they were in the neighborhood and they didn't have anything to do with it."
Councilmember Rheney stated, "I have a good example of sound, I have a neighbor and they have
Sunday School groups where they have parties 4th of July, Labor Day and things like that and they
swim and I never see them, Ijust hear them. It is not one of those things I would call the City about."
City Administrator Yow stated, "I am open to any and all amendments as to Council's prerogative.
I need to stress to you, we need to get an updated Ordinance and we have discussed this a couple of
times."
Mayor Miller asked, "Can we table this tonight and let individuals that have concerns with various
things in here get with you and have it brought back."
City Administrator Yow responded, "I think we can accomplish the same thing. I think we can list
for the record what the concerns are and get with me on any others and bring it back on Second
Reading. When you get your minutes from this meeting, closely examine them for the concerns you
raised and if any concems are left out ofthose minutes, let us know and we will get them in there."
Councilmember Bamwell asked, "Why do we say 25 people, suppose you have three individuals who
want to assemble?"
City Attomey Walsh responded, "That is the number that the court decisions have come up with as a
limit to require a permit.
Councilmember Barnwell asked, "Suppose you have an individual on the street?"
City Administrator Yow replied, "That would not apply. This actually gives more rights to picket,
protest or have parades. I think I mentioned that Attorney Walsh has done some research in this area
for you so these were not chosen randomly."
Councilmember Miller asked, "In previous years, South Carolina State Homecoming and maybe
Claflin, you have people leaving the City because of big gatherings. Is this going to require
institutions to have permits?"
City Administrator Yow replied, "Parades will have to have permits as always. The impromptu
gatherings, we are not going to be able to permit those. If someone was going to have a gathering of
1800
Page 6
one hundred people and block a street or use a parking lot or even on private property, they are going
to have to have a pennit for this. We have had cases where churches may have a homecoming
celebration for a 100 year anniversary and we have blocked streets for that ifit is not on a major
thoroughfare. "
Councilmember Rheney stated, "1 think "A" addresses that where no pennit fees are required for
institutions of higher learning. I can also understand where you have barriers or cleanup, that there
should also be a fee."
City Administrator Yow stated, "Communities have struggled with this, we have found all across the
board some communities charge their exact cost to the entity that they absorb the cost for."
Councilmember Miller stated, "This is something we addressed in the planning meeting and this was
something we wanted to implement as a fee for the cleanup."
Councilmember Jernigan stated, "I go along with the fees and 1don't think we should make any
exceptions. I think that we try to make these Ordinances as reasonably fair to all parties concerned,
whether it be the people that are gathering or who have to put up with the people gathering. 1do not
have a problem with the way the Ordinance is written. 1do think we should either take the fee out or
make it for everybody."
City Administrator Yow stated, "We will bring a Resolution to you that will set forth the fee schedule.
That was put in there at the prior meeting. 1 think Mayor Pro Tern Haire stated before that he did not
want a fee in there for the colleges and no one spoke against that. Council didn't vote on it and 1
think it was a silent issue and I think my recollection is correct on that."
City Attorney Walsh stated, "I think that is how the sound amplification got in there."
City Administrator Yow stated, "Sometimes when Council doesn't vote and they have a discussion,
we try to take it as a general consensus."
Councilmember Jernigan stated, "Sometimes you have to think about things before you make a
decision on them."
Councilmember Barnwell stated, "On the same lines, 1 would rather see the fee taken out or no
exceptions because the City is picking up trash and putting out barricades. Ijust don't know if we
should take the responsibility for paying for that."
City Administrator Yow responded, "Let's go ahead and proceed with First Reading and itemize
those items that you have raised. Let me see if! can obtain from our Department Heads estimated
costs so at least you can be making some decisions on monetary values. There are some other events
in the community, just like an event at the fairgrounds. It is good for the community and it may bring
commerce to the community that we get business licenses from and bring commerce to the City, but
we may have to do litter pick up in the area. It is not the fairgrounds doing the litter pick up, it is the
people in the area. That is outside their fence along Boulevard. Those events where we do litter pick
up is hard to put a value on. That is just one example."
Councilmember Barnwell stated, "On page 6, I would like to add item # 1as a suggestion. It shall be
unlawful for any person or organization to carry any sign, poster, plaque or notice that is indecent or
profane which would be out of character."
City Attorney Walsh replied, "You are dealing with the constitution."
City Administrator Yow stated, "We will do some research on this, that is one of the things that this is
referring to. Pennits granted on speech content. There has been a lot of case law on that. In
Myrtle Beach, they went through a lot with T-shirts. 1am going to refer that to Attorney Walsh."
1851
Page 7
A motion as made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Rheney, to approve
the First Reading of an Ordinance repealing in its entirety Chapter 9, Section 3 of the Code of
Ordinances of the City and repealing Chapter 5, Section 21 of said Code in its entirety and replacing
said Chapter 5, Section 21-F with a new Chapter 5, Section 21 for the purpose of establishing a
uniform permit requirement for parades and public assemblies. This was a 5-1-1 vote as Mayor Pro
Tern Haire opposed and Councilmember Knotts abstained.
A motion as made by Council member Barnwell, seconded by Mayor Pro Tem Haire, to approve the
Third Reading of an Ordinance amending the General Terms and conditions of the Department of
Public Utilities of the City of Orangeburg as adopted by Council on November 6,2002. This motion
was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Council member Miller, to adjourn.
This motion was unanimously approved.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
Respectfully submitted,
~tlr-m
Carrie W. JOhllSlln
City Clerk
/pfb
1852
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
March 18,2008
Orangeburg City Council held its regular scheduled meeting on Tuesday, March 18,
2008, at 7:00 P.M., in Council Chambers with Mayor Miller presiding.
PRESENT:
Paul A. Miller, Mayor
Charles B. Barnwell, Jr.
Bernard Haire
Charles W. Jernigan
Sandra P. Knotts
Trelvis A. Miller
Joyce W. Rheney
A motion was made by Councilmember Jernigan, seconded by Councilmember Miller, to
approve the March 4, 2008, City Council Minutes. This was a 6-0 vote as
Councilmember Rheney was not present at the time of voting.
Mr. Michael Williams from Cross Hill, South Carolina, accompanied by his wife, Betty,
presented Mayor & Council with the new rose, "Edisto" named for both the Edisto River
and the Edisto Memorial Gardens. Mr. Williams is a rose hybridizer and he donated
twenty-five (25) Edisto roses to the City to be planted in the Gardens.
A motion made by Councilmember Rheney, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to
approve the Second Reading of an Ordinance to amend Section 24-4.1, District
Boundaries and Maps of the Code of Ordinances of the City of Orangeburg and the
Zoning Map of the City of Orangeburg, South Carolina (350 Whaley Street) This motion
was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Miller, seconded by Councilmember Jernigan, to
approve the Second Reading of an Ordinance to amend section 24-4.1, District
Boundaries and Maps of the Code of Ordinances of the City of Orangeburg and the
Zoning Map of the City of Orangeburg, South Carolina (350 Magnolia Street). This
motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Rheney, seconded by Councilmember Miller, to
approve the Second Reading of Ordinance to armex property at 1650 John Wesley Drive,
TMP# 0174-13-04-005, into the city limits of the City of Orangeburg, South Carolina.
This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Jernigan, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell,
to approve the Second Reading of an Ordinance to annex property at 1656, 1658 &1660
John Wesley Drive, (a1kJa: 102, 104, 106, 108, 112, 116 ManishaCourt), TMP#0174-13
04-006 into the City limits of the City of Orangeburg, South Carolina. This motion was
unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Jernigan,
to approve the Second Reading of an Ordinance to amend the Municipal District Map
dated November 6, 2001, for the purpose of adding newly annexed City property to
Municipal Council District Two (2). This motion was unanimously approved.
City Administrator Yow addressed Council in regards to the amendments that were done
to the Ordinance repealing in its entirety Chapter 9, Section 3 of the Code of Ordinances
and repealing Chapter 5, Section 21 of said Code in its entirety and replacing said
Chapter 5, Section 21 with a new Chapter 5, Section 21 for the purpose of establishing a
uniform pennit requirement for parades and public assemblies. He stated, "We have
made a few amendments in order to clarify things based on questions from Council. The
first amendment is under Section 5-21.1, definitions (I), we have inserted on the second
line "on public property or contiguous public and private property" language to clarify
what a public assembly means. I think there were some questions from various people on
wedding receptions. If you tum to (page 3, #17), we have inserted, "if a public assembly
Page 2
is to be held on public property in a residential zoned district", the application must be
signed by at least five property owners within a radius of 500 feet of its location. On
page 4,21.5 (12 c), no permit shall be granted that allows for sound amplification
equipment on public property in any residential zoned district. We have inserted language
basically around public property. The rest of the Ordinance remains in tact. I know we
have had discussions on the fees. As the memo states, it is Council's prerogative. We
have looked at a list of events, like parades, that we give assistance. It looks as if we
provide assistance to at least 20 to 30 events a year. When we look at these, they are
closely related to our mission, but we spend overtime and costs. It won't put us in any
dire straights if you remove the section on the fees. If an Organization requests
equipment or special services from us, we will charge for that or we just won't give them
those services, like bleachers. We are just talking about permit application fees."
Councilmember Jernigan addressed Council, "I understand it as a fee for administrative
only for filing the application or an application fee. If we are going to charge a fee, it
should be equal across the board. I don't have any problem with taking this fee out all
together."
Councilmember Jernigan made a motion to take the application fee of$IOO.OOout of the
Ordinance and not have an application fee. This motion was seconded by Councilmember
Barnwell. This was a 6-1, as Councilmember Rheney opposed.
Mayor Pro Tern Haire stated, "I requested some other information from other locations
and I thought it would have been in by now, but it isn't. When you have these kinds of
prohibition against amplification of music on property, Ijust want to know the rationale
behind it. According to this, I can have a party in my yard, but if a group is meeting at a
playground, they can't have it."
City Administrator Yow stated, "I think one of the rational is when the people came in
complaining about the sound amplification at some of our parks at recent public
assemblies. The other thing is that on your private property, there mayor may not be
other people there. At a playground, ifthere is sound amplification, other people at that
playground are subject to the sound amplification whether or not they want to be."
Mayor Pro Tern Haire responded, "All of that has been done to make this palatable.
However, there is something that just troubles me about this Ordinance. We have had
Public Hearings as it relates to Ordinances in the past and I have gotten a number of calls
as it relates to this Ordinance. Should we not table this tonight and have a Public
Hearing? I doubt anyone would come but just give them that opportunity to do so. ram
getting calls and is there a real need to have a second reading tonight? Is there
something that necessitates that we go along with this particular Ordinance?"
City Administrator Yow responded, "It is not essential, but r would like to have it. What
are some of those other concerns? Maybe we can help address it."
Mayor Prop Tern Haire stated, "People have called about the sound that I addressed and
the memo you wrote stated you didn't get any kind of feedback from anyone."
City Administrator Yow stated, "We got feedback from the Council meeting and I had a
little bit of feedback since the meeting, but not very much."
Mayor Pro Tern Haire stated, "I appreciate what has been done, but I move that we table
this and have a Public Hearing and give the citizens the opportunity to speak even ifno
one shows up." This motion was seconded by Mayor Miller.
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "Can we go ahead and pass Second Reading and still
have a Public Hearing between Second and Third Reading?"
City Administrator Yow stated, "Our next meeting is April ISland that is fourteen days
away, so we don't have time to advertise a Public Hearing."
,gb3
{Rb4
Page 3
City Attorney Walsh stated, "That is not required by statute."
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "If we could have the Public Hearing at the next Council
meeting and then have Third Reading then or at the next meeting."
Mayor Pro Tern Haire stated, "We could have the Public Hearing, vote on any changes
and vote on the Ordinance that night as Third Reading."
Mayor Miller stated, "We could certainly do that."
City Administrator Yow stated, ''I'd like to hear any concerns if we are missing
something."
Mayor Pro Tern Haire replied, "I have gotten some calls and I bet you a dime to a dollar,
no one shows up."
Mayor Miller stated, "Would you consider withdrawing your motion and go with Second
Reading if we hold a Public Hearing before Third Reading."
Mayor Pro Tern Haire stated, "If we go on Second Reading tonight, I would not be able
to vote on it. I withdraw my previous motion and make a motion that we have a Public
Hearing before Third Reading." This motion was seconded by Councilmember Jernigan
and unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Rheney, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell,
to approve the Second Reading of an Ordinance repealing in its entirety Chapter 9,
Section 3 of the Code of Ordinances ofthe City of Orangeburg and repealing Chapter 5,
Section 21 of said Code in its entirely and replacing said Chapter 5, Section 21 with a
New Chapter 5, Section 21 for the purpose of establishing a uniform permit requirement
for parades and public assemblies. This was a 6-1 vote as Mayor Pro Tern Haire opposed.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, seconded by Councilmember Jernigan, to
approve the renovation of the City Landing located in the Edisto Memorial Gardens and
authorizing City Administrator Yow to sign contract with Sweatman Dock Builders in the
amount of$11O,500. This motion was unanimously approved.
There were no utility matters brought before Council.
A motion was made by Councilmember Rheney, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, to
enter into an Executive Session for a legal matter to discuss mortgage on city real
property and improvements on Chamber Building.
Council returned to Open Session
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to
approve a Resolution authorizing the extension of the mortgage maturity date of two
and sixty-nine hundredths (2.69) acres, with buildings and other improvements thereon,
to South Carolina Bank and Trust in the principal sum of five hundred thousand
($500,000). This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Miller, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell,
to adjourn. This motion was unanimously approved.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
RESOLUTION.
A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE EXTENSION OF THE MATURITY DATE OF
THE MORTGAGE OF TWO AND SIXTY·NINE HUNDREDTHS (2.69) ACRES, WITH
BUILDINGS AND OTHER IMPROVEMENTS THEREON, TO SOUTH CAROLINA
BANK AND TRUST IN THE PRINCIPAL SUM OF FIVE HUNDRED THOUSAND
($500,000.00) DOLLARS AND RECORDED IN THE OFFICE OF THE REGISTER OF
DEEDS FOR THE COUNTY OF ORANGEBURG, STATE OF SOUTH CAROLINA IN
MORTGAGE BOOK 1551 AT PAGE 293
WHEREAS, the City of Orangeburg by Ordinance 2005-1 authorized the above
described mortgage, and;
WHEREAS, the Orangeburg County Chamber of Commerce has requested of
South Carolina Bank and Trust an extension of the maturity date of said mortgage and
the City of Orangeburg has agreed thereto.
NOW THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED BY CITY COUNCIL DULY
ASSEMBLED, that the City of Orangeburg does hereby consent to the extension of the
maturity date to September 1, 2008 of that certain mortgage of The City of Orangeburg
to South Carolina Bank and Trust in the maximum obligation limit of Five Hundred
Thousand ($500,000.00) dollars dated February 11, 2005 and recorded in the Office of
the Register of Deeds for the County of Orangeburg, State of South Carolina in
Mortgage Book 1551 at page 293.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that John H. Yow, City Administrator is hereby
directed and authorized to execute a Commercial Loan Modification Agreement for the
above purpose.
DONE AND RATIFIED BY THE CITY OF ORANGEBURG, STATE OF SOUTH
CAROLINA THIS Jf-iJIDAY OF MARCH, 2008.
~~~P
s of Council
ATTEST:~~ 01·
City Clerk
C:\MyFiles\City\RESOLUTION\ResoluUon.Mortgage.Chamber of Commerce.wpd
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
Aprill, 2008
Orangeburg City Council held a Public Hearing on Tuesday, April 1,2008, at 7:00 P.M.,
in Council Chambers with Mayor Miller presiding. The purpose ofthe Public Hearing
was as follows:
Repealing in its entirety Chapter 9, Section 3 of the Code of Ordinances of the City of
Orangeburg and repealing Chapter 5, Section 21 of said Code in its entirety and replacing
said Chapter 5, Section 21 with a New Chapter 5, Section 21 for the purpose of
establishing a unifonn pennit requirement for parades and public assemblies.
Mr. Abe Salama of 1495 Hillsboro Road addressed Council. He stated, "I am a retired
professor from South Carolina State University. I would like to say that last week when
Mayor Pro Tern Haire projected that you would have a Hearing and that no one would
probably speak up, so I'm here to speak. You voted to have a Public Hearing and I
would like to give you this handout as infonnation. I am sharing with you a poem from
"Dear Abby" from today's paper for April Fools. In the outline, you have the purpose of
the unified requirement is to create a policy that provides for public safety and the
welfare ofthe citizens by ensuring constitutional rights. I am sure everyone in this room
would agree with that purpose. My presentation is with cooperation and citizenship. I
read the old Ordinance and the new Ordinance and I would like to ask about the speed of
approval for this. Is this a need for a Public Hearing? You had the first reading so fast.
Someone mentioned you needed to research that. The second reading started with
changes based on the administrative research and I am glad you made those changes.
Then you stated, you must have second reading on that night even though Mayor Pro
Tern Haire requested a Public Hearing, but someone said you must have second reading
that night. To me, this was speedy, unless you are meeting a deadline. This is a very
important Ordinance that will affect a lot of people here. A motion was presented before
that there be a Public Hearing only if second reading would take place that night. That
was my impression. A Public Hearing is a Public Hearing and I am glad you did not
schedule a third reading tonight. The public is saying, why do you have a Public Hearing
if you are having a third reading tonight? As far as a Public Hearing, I would like for
City Council to follow tradition with County Council to allow for public comment at the
beginning of the meeting and therefore you do not need a public hearing whether it is an
agenda item or not."
Mayor Miller responded, "You can call on Friday before the meeting on Tuesday to be on
City Council's agenda. Let's stick to the item in question for the Public Hearing."
Mr. Salama stated, "City Administrator Yow stated that some language was added after
some Sunnyside residents complained concerning the Father's Day picnic. Are we
abating the Ordinance as a result of one incident? Do we have more incidents like that
since that time? Mr. Yow was then quoted in the newspaper that the proposed Ordinance
was drawn up to be both legal and enforceable, while the current Ordinance is not.
Is the current Ordinance not legal or enforceable?"
City Attorney Walsh replied, "The current Ordinance is unconstitutional."
Mayor Miller stated, "As far as a Public Hearing goes, we do not necessarily have to have
a Public Hearing. We did that on Mayor ProTem Haire's request and that is why we
agreed to have it. Under ordinary circumstances, we wouldn't be having a Public
Hearing on this and we go through three readings."
Mr. Salama replied, "I would like to commend you that last time you made good changes.
You came up with speech content being exempt, what a public assembly is and you took
away private property and made a distinction between public and private property. I
appreciate the work ofthis clarification and I appreciate that you took away the $ I00 fee
for the pennit. I still have three or four concerns that go under interpretation and
enforcement. On spontaneous and planned events, who is to distinguish between that?
18S5
18S~ Page 2
Let me give you an example of that. When I taught at State, I have a class, more than
twenty-five (25) students and I say to them, let's go meet at the Gardens. I will have my
class at the Gardens. This has happened many times. Does that require a pennit?"
Mayor Miller stated, "I believe that would be spontaneous."
City Attorney Yow stated, "There are exceptions and these are noted in the Ordinance,
that would fall under the section of exceptions, students going to and from classes and
paliicipating in educational activities provided that such contact is done with immediate
and direct supervision with the proper school."
Mr. Salama stated, "I will give you another example. At an Orangeburg-Wilkinson High
School Graduation, I have a party at my house and more than twenty-five (25) people are
there and we have so many people that we carry the activity to the park, I wouldn't need
a pennit. But, if! had planned it ahead of time and planned it for the park, I would need
a pennit?"
Mayor Miller replied, "Right."
Mr. Salama stated, "As to the nature of the event, would that make a difference?"
City Administrator Yow stated, "That is stated here where it states speech content does
not matter."
Mr. Salama stated, "You are still requiring the approval of five neighbors within 500 feet,
what is the magic number?"
Mayor Miller stated, "That pertains to having an event that is not on your personal
property. If you are going to hold it in a public place, you are going to have to get five
residents in order to have the event."
Mr. Salama responded, "I am asking you to try to consider this requirement because
anyone may want to call because of the event, maybe the sixth person down the street."
Mayor Miller replied, "We have a Noise Ordinance in Orangeburg and you cannot go out
and disturb your neighbors because if you do even in your backyard and it is creating a
nuisance, someone is going to come by and ask you to tone it down."
Mr. Salama responded, "That is why I gave you the article today about the noise because
we already have the Ordinance whether public or private property or driving my car.
The number is twenty-five (25), I would suggest you make that fifty (50) or above or
higher than twenty-five (25). If you are having a reception that many people is easy to
have."
Mayor Miller replied, "That doesn't pertain to your house."
City Attorney Yow stated, "The number twenty-five (25) was explained to Council
during first reading. The number was not arbitrarily chosen. That number came from
case law established by courts in this type of public assemblies. That was explained the
first night."
Mr. Salama responded, "If! have twenty-four (24), I don't have to have a pernlit?"
City Administrator Yow replied, "That is correct."
Mr. Salama asked, "Is there any flexibility as far as twenty-five (25)? Is there any
enforcement when the police come and they count and there are twenty-five people (25)
there and they state that you are in violation, you pay $500 or go in prison for thirty
years. In any event, I still have real concern about interpretation and enforcement.
Page 3
I would like for the law enforcement to give some input on how this new Ordinance can
be interpreted and enforced"
Mr. Richard Union of 278 Pinehill Road addressed Council. He stated, "This Ordinance
pertains to public places, what are you going to do next month when you have a City
Council meeting? Does City Council have to get a pennit?"
Mayor Miller replied, "No sir."
Mr. Union asked, "What about the Festival of Roses, do they have to get a pernlit?"
Mayor Miller replied, "No sir, I think that it is addressed in the Ordinance, isn't it?"
City Administrator Yow replied, "A government agency is acting within the scope of its
functions."
Mr. Union replied, "On the weekends, the Gardens are full of people having a family
reunion, there are tourists coming here to have reunions. What are we going to do about
those; these things are planned and not spontaneous."
City Administrator Yow replied, "If you look up the defmition of public assembly, that
doesn't interfere with the regular or nonnal flow of pedestrian or vehicular traffic."
Mr. Union asked, "I wouldn't have to get five people to sign off on it?"
City Administrator Yow replied, "No."
Mr. Union asked, "What is the difference from having a gathering at the Gardens or at
Sunnyside, if you have over twenty five (25) people?"
City Administrator Yow replied, "The difference is having it in an area surrounded by
residential houses."
Mr. Union replied, "By Riverbank, there are houses."
City Administrator Yow replied, "That is not a residential zone, the Gardens are not
zoned residential."
Mr. Union asked, "If! am sitting across the street, in my residential home, across from
the Gardens, I have no recourse if! call the Police?"
Mayor Miller replied, "Yes, you can call them if they bother you."
Mr. Union asked, "The assembly is alright if the noise is not a problem; I am asking this
specifically, because if we have a Noise Ordinance already in place, why can't we
enforce that instead of imposing more restrictions on the citizens of the City."
City Administrator Yow replied, "I will read this one section to you. Activity that
interferes with the nonnal flow of pedestrian or vehicular traffic or interferes in any space
open to the general public. That is in the Ordinance."
Mr. Union replied, "That is fine, I understand that. I just wanted to come up and voice
my concerns. I appreciate you letting me take the time to do it. As a citizen of this City,
I am strongly against this Ordinance. Thank you."
Mayor Miller asked if anyone else would like to speak at the Public Hearing. Hearing no
comments, the Public Hearing was closed and Council entered into the regular scheduled
meeting.
18S7
1868
Page 4
PRESENT:
Paul A. Miller, Mayor
Charles B. Barnwell, Jr.
Bernard Haire
Charles W. Jernigan
Sandra P. Knotts
Trelvis A. Miller
Joyce W. Rheney
Visiting students from Claflin University were recognized as well as visiting students
from Project Positeen.
A motion was made by Councilmember Rheney, seconded by Councilmember Miller, to
approve the March 18, 2008, City Council Minutes as distributed. This motion was
unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, seconded by Councilmember Knotts, to
approve the Third Reading of an Ordinance to amend Section 24-4.1, District Boundaries
and Maps of the Code of Ordinances of the City of Orangeburg and the Zoning Map of
the City of Orangeburg, SC, (350 Whaley Street) from D-l to B-1 General Business. This
motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Miller, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, to
approve the Third Reading of an Ordinance to amend Section 24-4.1, District Boundaries
and Maps of the Code of Ordinances of the City of Orangeburg and the Zoning Map of
the City of Orangeburg, South Carolina (350 Magnolia Street) from D-l to B-1 General
Business. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Knotts, seconded by Councilmember Jernigan to
approve the Third Reading ofan Ordinance to annex property at 1650 John Wesley
Drive, TMP#0174-13-04-005 into the City limits of the City of Orangeburg to A-2
Multi-Family. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Jernigan
to approve the Third reading of an Ordinance to annex property at 1656, 1658 and 1660
John Wesley Drive, (alk/a: 102,204,206,108,112,116 Manisha Court), TMP#0174-13
04-006 into the City limits of the City of Orangeburg, South Carolina to A-2 Multi
Family. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to
approve the Fiscal Year 2008-09 Budget Calendar. This motion was unanimously
approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Jernigan, seconded by Councilmember Rheney,
to approve the Third Reading of an Ordinance to amend the Municipal District Map dated
November 6,2001, for the purpose of adding newly annexed City property to Municipal
Council District Two (2). This motion was unanimously approved.
Mayor Miller presented Ms. Sonya Gass with the April, 2008, Character Trait
Proclamation, "Patriotism".
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, to
approve a Resolution recognizing April, 2008, as Fair Housing Month in the City of
Orangeburg. This motion was unanimously approved.
PageS
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, seconded by Councilmember Rheney, to
approve a Resolution for the Department of Public Utilities to accept the low responsible
bid by Utility Service Company of Perry, Georgia, in the amount of $281,000.00 for the
repainting of three (3) elevated water tanks (Saddle Club Road Tank/St. Matthews Road
Tank/Cameron Tank). Councilmember Barnwell asked if they had ever done work for
the City previously and DPU Manager said they had not as they had never submitted a
bid before. This motion as unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Miller, seconded by Mayor Pro Tem Haire, to
adjourn.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
Respectfully submitted,
{~~}/ &1f(A~~
Carrie W. Jo,
City Clerk
/pfb
1859
r870:
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
April 15, 2008
Orangeburg City Council held its regular scheduled meeting on Tuesday, April 15,2008, at 7:00
P.M., in Council Chambers with Mayor Pro Tern Haire presiding.
PRESENT:
Charles B. Barnwell, Jr.
Bernard Haire
Charles W. Jernigan
Sandra P. Knotts
Trelvis A. Miller
Joyce W. Rheney
ABSENT:
Paul A. Miller, Mayor
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Council member Miller, to
approve the April I, 2008, City Council Minutes as distributed. This motion was unanimously
approved.
Mr. Bo Fender, Senior Patrol Leader of Troop 45, addressed Council. He gave highlights ofthe
history of the Troop and fOffilerEagle Scouts of the Troop. A report was given to Council along
with pictures of the projects the Troop had accomplished throughout the community and the
City. He also highlighted what the requirements are for an Eagle Scout and merit badges.
Mr. Jeffrey McMorrow of Horger Street addressed Council. He stated, "I reside in the City of
Orangeburg at 850 Horger Street with my friend and mortgagor and I have a South Carolina
driver's license and I am registered to vote in Ward 8. While writing this speech, I received this
agenda in the mail and "Patriotism" is the Character Trait for April, 2008. Patriotism can be
simply defined as having love for one's country. However, many have created great injustices in
the name of king and country throughout history. The true meaning of patriotism by Lawrence
W. Reed writes the following. He describes patriotism as the root and ideas that in tum gave
birth to a country, but it is the ideas that I think of as being patriotic. I am a patriotic American
because I revere the ideas that motivated the founders that compelled them in many instances to
put their lives, fortunes and sacred honor on the line."
Mayor Pro Tem Haire informed Mr. McMorrow that, "Council has been provided some letters
that you have submitted to both City Administrator Yow and Chief Davis and I don't mean to cut
your speech short, but if you would, we would like to hear what it is that you want Council to
hear as it relates to the complaint."
Mr. McMorrow replied, "Certainly, I will cut out that extraneous matter altogether. I am a
peaceful man but a fighter, though and I feel compelled. My rights are important to me and I
seek to protect them. The following City Ordinances enumerate my rights. Disturbing the peace
in Section 12-2.9 of the City Ordinance states, all animals shall be kept and maintained in such a
marmer as to not to disturb the peace, health, safety and general welfare of a person in the City.
No person shall keep in the city limits an animal that habitually or repeatedly barks or howls to
the extent that it is a public nuisance."
"As you have been made aware, for two years, I and Ms. Crucilla, have been bothered by our
neighbor's dogs at 880 Horger Street. Each and every morning, the dogs will bark too loud and
too often. Chief Davis did a fine job discussing the problem with those neighbors and us and I
praise his effort in trying to restore order. I fear however, our difference with all our neighbors
persists and the dogs are as disturbing as ever and there has been little or no effort being made to
silence them by their owner. I believe that maybe the problem is that our neighbors have too
many dogs. I know that at 880 Horger Street there are at least seven dogs and at 860 Horger,
they have at least four. I say at least because there are some puppies there. I grew up in Sand
Hill, California. That city limited each household to no more than three dogs. I have owned
dogs, two at a time and I understand them well. Dog Trainers and I believe that three or less are
1871
Page 2
a manageable number. Above that, dogs will excite each other into a wild pack behavior, which
could lead to violations of the Nuisance Ordinance. Through mediation with our neighbors, it
was suggested that we try to close our windows, but this encroaches on our freedom and clearly
demonstrates a flexible stance my neighbors have adopted. They complain about the cost of bark
training or collars, then why do they have so many dogs? Neighbors at 860 Horger have recently
acquired four dogs that they keep staked out in the yard day and night. I am no fool; I believe
that this is a part of a concerted effort with the neighbors at 880 Horger to drive us out of the
community. Since we have moved here in December, 2005, they and their family members who
live across the street, have never welcomed us into their neighborhood. They often shout and
hang out, outside in their vehicles and act as if they have more rights than us. It seems they are
quite hostile and have made it clear that we should go back where we came from. I am not
accustomed to take threats of bodily harm and taking steps to tum my quality oflife. Moving is
something we think about every day. Ifwe were to put this property up for sale, I would want
this property to not be negatively affected by neighbors' dogs barking especially in this very
difficult housing market. We also have a general right to live peacefully and not to
accommodate nuisance animals. I believe it is time that this Council adopts an Ordinance
limiting the number of dogs per household and I also think that the laws, already on the books,
should be enforced without putting victims in fear of their safety. This is the true spirit of
patriotism, Thanks for your time."
Councilmember Miller asked, "You feel as though a remedy may be to limit the number of dogs
per household, what if a dog has puppies and most litters are about six to eight, how would we
rectify a situation like that?"
Mr. McMorrow replied, "We were concerned when we moved there that they may be breeders.
It is kind of an odd situation, they are staked out and he brings them in and out. I thought maybe
he hires his dogs out for hunts or something. I am sure he has to have permits for that. The dogs
lead him down the street in the yard. Ijust think he has too many dogs to handle. Ijust wish he
would tell them to calm down. That is what my City did where I used to live; I don't know what
else it would be for?"
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "Has he made any effort to try to come to some kind of
agreement with you or is he sorry for his dogs barking? Is there any communication between the
two of you?"
Mr. McMorrow replied, "The first time I called Public Safety, they asked if! addressed the
neighbors about their dogs? Like I told the Chief, it is almost like he hears a choir of angels
singing when they are barking. Given that appearance, I didn't think it would come to much.
When I did speak to him, he said they were his babies and the talk we had was far from
peaceful. He wasn't concerned about my comfort level and wasn't interested in trying to
mediate things, in fact, he was quite threatening. In fact, we kind of let it go when last year in
2007 when he got a new dog and that dog is louder than the others combined. To make a long
story short, Gene Nelson stopped by to inspect our roof and he noticed the barking of the dogs.
He went over to talk with them and a day later that owner came over and threatened me again.
The meeting we had with Chief Davis, I don't feel there were any concerns about our feelings.
We tried to reach an agreement oftrying to work around it by closing the windows. They
suggested we call the neighbors before we try to call DPS. They are unreasonable."
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "Has anybody else in the neighborhood complained about these
dogs barking, or is everybody on his side?"
Mr. McMorrow replied, "We have businesses that only work during the day and they have
soundproof facilities, but there are some neighbors that do not like it and they are glad we are
here tonight. The salon down the street doesn't like the noise. The neighbors don't have a
fenced yard even though they told Chief Davis they do. Dr. Salley's staff knows what a pain
they are to listen to and there are other people down the street and on Berry Street that hear them
also. I think a lot of people take it in stride because it is not their home. This is our home, we sit
outside and like to barbeque, we have our breakfast out there and it is really quite
overwhelming."
1872
Page 3
Councilmember Rheney asked, "They are not fenced in?"
Mr. McMorrow replied, "No, they are not. Most of them are tied on and only a limited space
and smaJl kennels."
Councilmember Rheney asked, "Have you ever seen them out?"
Mr. McMorrow replied, "I have seen a dog in my yard on occasion. There are two houses in a
row that have dogs. One of these just recently got dogs. These neighbors are very close and it is
if they are living on each other's land. He told Chief Davis, he loved this man and he is great
and we have come in and pushed our way around. It is difficult. There is a man across the street
who recently got two dogs that don't bother us. The noise is something that is very bothersome."
Councilmember Jernigan asked Chief Davis, "Your people have been out to see this situation,
have any citations been issued?"
Chief Davis replied, "We have enough to cite the owners of the dogs. We have documentation
to classify the dogs as a nuisance. In our discussions, Mr. McMorrow's preference was to have
mediation. We were prepared to issue a citation at the next complaint. It was at his urging to
have mediation. We did that on Thursday. As a result, the agreement was that some concessions
would be made that the owners of the dogs would keep them quiet by whatever means and that
we would try that for two weeks and if the situation was not resolved within a two-week period
that we would have to resort to a citation and have it resolved in Municipal Court. At that point,
Mr. McMorrow was in agreement with this. Ifwe need to change the agreement, we would have
to get everyone together again. We have enough at this point to issue a Nuisance Ordinance.
There was an effort to try to create some synergy in the neighborhood so we would not have a
situation where we have one group against another."
Councilmember MiJler asked, "What is your recommendation?"
Chief Davis replied, "To adhere to the agreement that we have. We have not had a wholesale
problem with the number of dogs. I can't document where we have had a problem concerning
the number of dogs. I have not researched the Ordinance that he talks about. That is certainly
something you may want to consider."
Councilmember BamweJl asked, "Have the neighbors threatened you?"
Mr. McMorrow replied, "Yes, he said verbatim, I wiJl drag you out of your house, you need to
let this go, I told you what would happen. He mentioned in 2006, that he was a hit man from
Philadelphia and he could have me taken out anywhere in the City. At that time, I apologized to
him and his wife and the neighbors. The last time when Gene Nelson went to visit him, he came
down the street and said remember what I told you, I wiJl drag you out of your house. He is
smaller than me, I know the laws. He was close enough that I would have been in my rights to
attack him rather than be attacked. It was more like layoff and he told me the dogs are on his
property and they are going to bark and you can't do anything about it. That is not the way I
read the law. Rather than limiting the number of dogs, maybe they need to control the ones they
have. I have footage today; there is never an attempt to quiet them. They are just staked out and
fed and that is it. The dogs are out day and night. Night is another issue."
Councilmember BarnweJl asked, "Have you noticed any results since the meeting?"
Mr. McMorrow replied, "That is the disturbing part. I wrote a letter to Mr. Yow about that, I
don't reaJly see that. There would be a two week moratorium and I would first calJ the
neighbors. I don't even have their numbers. Today, I tried shouting and when I heard an effort
made, I said thank you. I don't see an effort made. As I wrote, these people complain about the
cost of training or coJlars, they have a lot of dogs they are feeding every day. There is one
expense or the other. I look forward to my mornings and I know it will be the same thing."
Councilmember Jernigan stated, "It is hard to keep a dog from barking, but we can't continuaJly
let this be a problem in the City. This is the second time in six to eight months that I have had a
18f)~
Page 4
complaint in my district on barking dogs. The other party that had the complaint took his case to
court and 1don't know the results from that. I know that happened and that is two cases in just
my district."
Councilmember Jernigan recommended that an Ordinance be researched that would limit the
number of dogs in a household. "1 don't know if there is a number, 1think that is part of the
research." City Administrator Yow stated this could be presented at the Budget Planning
Session for discussion. This was agreed to by Council.
Mr. McMorrow replied, "I would like to preserve the community of character as much as
possible. 1realize that this is just one option that 1have. 1could have had this man arrested for
threatening me, 1could have the dogs cited or taken away. There are many options open. 1
would like to stay retired and have a quiet neighborhood."
Councilmember Rheney asked, "Do you have any odors?"
Mr. McMorrow replied, "The newest dogs have odors. The animal control officer also had
concerns and there are really no dog houses."
City Administrator Yow overviewed the Parade and Public Assemblies Uniform Permit
Ordinance, (Chapter 5, Section 21) for Council and highlighted that there were no changes since
last reading and noted a Public Hearing was held on the matter during the last meeting.
A motion was made by Councilmember Rheney, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to
approve the Third Reading of an Ordinance repealing in its entirety Chapter 9, Section 3 of the
Code of Ordinances of the City of Orangeburg and repealing Chapter 5, Section 21 of said Code
in its entirety and replacing said Chapter 5, Section 21 with a New Chapter 5, Section 21 for the
purpose of establishing a uniform permit requirement for parades and public assemblies. This
was a 5-1 vote as Councilmember Knotts opposed.
A motion was made by Councilmember Knotts, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to
approve a request from Orangeburg County to waive the building pern1it fee for renovations to
the County Courthouse. City Council was provided the total renovation costs and dollar amount
of the permit fee. This motion was unanimously approved.
There were no utility matters brought before Council.
A motion was made by Councilmember Miller, seconded by Councilmember Jernigan, to
adjourn. This motion was unanimously approved.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
Respectfully submitted,
~.jitVWVI tJ
Came W. Johrison
City Clerk
/pfb
/i~
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
May 6, 2008
Orangeburg City Council held its regular scheduled meeting on Tuesday, May 6, 2008, at
7:00 p.m., in Council Chambers with Mayor Miller presiding.
PRESENT:
Paul A. Miller, Mayor
Charles B. Barnwell, Jr.
Bernard Haire
Charles W. Jernigan
Sandra P. Knotts
Trelvis A. Miller
Joyce W. Rheney
The Men's and Women's Tennis Tearns from South Carolina State University were
introduced and recognized for their successful season and were wished well in their
upcoming tournament.
Mr. Fred Boatwright, DPU Manager, was recognized as receiving the W.T. Linton
Award for environmental protection from the South Carolina Department of Health and
Environmental Control.
A motion was made by Councilmember Jernigan, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell,
to approve the April 15,2008, City Council Minutes as distributed. This was a 6-0-1
vote as Mayor Miller abstained as he was not present at the last meeting.
Detective Cindy Smoak was recognized as being presented the Service Above Self
Award from the Rotary Club Morning.
Mayor Miller, DPU Manager Fred Boatwright and Electrical Division Manager Jolm
Bagwell presented a Retiree Resolution and a gold watch honoring Jerry E. Hughes for
his thirty-eight years and two days of service to the Department of Public Utilities of the
City of Orangeburg.
Mr. John Cruise addressed Council. He stated, "My name is John Cruise and I live at
2264 Riley Street and have been there since 1972. Tonight, I want to talk to you about
barking dogs, howling dogs and it is hard for me to sleep. I like to sleep and sometimes
in the afternoon. I would like to talk to you about Dog #1, #2, #3 and #4. Dog #1 is a
house dog that lives in the house and then gets put out in the afternoon. Saturday it was
I I:30 a.m. until 2:30 p.m., today it was 4:00 in the afternoon and sometimes in the
mornings they are put out. Small house dogs should be in the house not in the pen. Dog
#2 is a large dog in a lOx 12 pen. He barks when he sees a deer, coon or whenever he
wants to like he does at 2 o'clock in the morning and at 6 o'clock in the morning. All of
these dogs are within 400 feet of my bedroom. If the deer don't show up and the other
dogs don't bark, he is okay. Dog #3 chases bikes and eats all the cat food in the
neighborhood. I found a neighbor all the way over on Woodland that said he couldn't
feed his cats anymore because the dog eats the cat food. He runs loose about 10% of the
time. He was barking at 3 o'clock in the morning. Dogs #4, #5 and #6 live on Hydrick
and one of them runs loose, a black dog. When you call Animal Control, what do they
do, they don't bark, they don't run loose. That is why I am here. I should add that dogs
that are taken care of don't bark, properly cared for dogs don't bark. We have an
Ordinance that covers everyone of these things that are mentioned. I have it here and I
have read it well. Animal Control knows this and they know where they are. Help me
enforce the Ordinance that we have so that I can get some rest."
Mayor Miller asked, "When these dogs bark in the morning and at night, have you called
Public Safety?"
Mr. Cruise responded, "Numerous times over the past year and a half."
Page 2
Mayor Miller asked, "What do they say?"
Mr. Cruise responded, "We don't hear them bark. We talk to the people and nothing
happens."
Mayor Miller stated, "We are going to try to see what we can do to help you sleep at
night because there is nothing worse than a barking dog."
Mr. Cruise stated, "I would like to add that I read Mr. McMorrow's account who
appeared at the last meeting and I said I have an ally. I went over to his house last week
and spent about an hour there. It was like we had five dogs in the living room. I said Jeff,
I would go absolutely ape. When I left, two dogs ran up the street."
Mr. Miller asked Chief Davis, "What is the protocol on this?"
Chief Davis responded, "Certainly, when we get the call, we are going to go out and
investigate it. In this case, Captain Turner sent out a memo to our Patrol Division because
we were aware of this situation. We were in conversation with Mr. Cruise. Ultimately,
we did take this to court. We made at lease one citation that I am aware of. We go out
and try to identify the source, work with the neighbors and get some kind of resolution.
One citation was dismissed in court. With my conversation with Judge Houser, there
were several witnesses who did not see the complaint of the dogs barking as a significant
problem to them, so it was dismissed by the court."
Mayor Miller asked, "If a citizen calls in at two o'clock in the morning and Public Safety
goes out there, what happens?"
Chief Davis replied, "We would make an attempt to get the dog quieted and if the dog
cannot be quieted and we get several calls, we then issue a citation."
Mayor Miller asked, "Do you ever pick the dogs up and take them in?"
Chief Davis said, "That would be an extreme circumstance."
Councilmember Jernigan stated, "It apparently is an extreme problem right now in
Orangeburg. I had a phone call right before Council tonight from an individual who
couldn't be here. They were in support of what Mr. Cruise has said and what Jeffhas
said. They have had problems with it also and they live in my neighborhood. I
personally haven't had a problem with it, but that is not to say no one else has. I am sure
it is a problem because there are too many people complaining about it and I think we
need to address it. At the last meeting, I think we agreed to bring it up at the Planning
Session and discuss it from a standpoint of the possibilities of putting some more teeth in
these Ordinances or seeing what we can do to help get this situation resolved. The
Planning Session is coming up in June, so it is just a month away. We will do everything
we can between now and then, but that will be when we have a chance and can put our
heads together and say look, let's do something about this."
Councilmember Rheney asked, "Mr. Cruise, are some ofthese dogs running loose?"
Mr. Cruise responded, "We have a leash law and we have had some dogs killed lately and
I am sure everyone has read the article by Austin Cunningham who lost his dog and I
cried with him. We have had some cats killed also and it has to be dogs that are running
loose that did it. If these are inside dogs and they are outside and someone calls for help
and these dogs go inside, when the officers get there, they are not going to see or hear
anything."
Mr. Cruise responded, "When we go to court, none of the officers that were there were in
court. The ones that were there did not hear them bark, so I lost."
1875
1876
Page 3
Mayor Miller replied, "We are going to try to see if we can do a better job, not only for
you, but for others that are being affected by barking dogs."
Mr. Cruise stated, "I did a little research and most people don't' want to get involved in
what I am doing. The people are out there; they will can you, but won't get involved. I
don't want any conflict with my neighbors and neither do they."
Councilmember Barnwell asked, "Did you say that some of the officers that were
involved heard them bark and they did not show up for court?"
Mr. Cruise stated, "The notice was rather sudden and they didn't have time and I didn't
have a chance to call them either. I didn't know that they had to appear. No offense to
them. Just help us."
Chief Wendell Davis accepted the May 2008 Character Trait Proclamation "Courage".
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, seconded by Councilmember Rheney, to
approve a Resolution establishing the City of Orangeburg as a Community of Character.
This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tem Haire, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to
approve a SC Department of Transportation Youth Corps Grant. This motion was
unanimously approved.
Assistant City Administrator Bronson addressed Council and overviewed the history of
waivers for water and wastewater taps and the area on the map in question of2574
Columbia Road where Mr. Sudhir Patel has planned to construct a gas station!
convenience store. He stated that Mr. Patel and his partner, Mr. Gopal Kondapaneni are
requesting a waiver and Mr. Kondapaneni is here representing the partnership.
Mr. Kondapaneni addressed Council, "I live at 4115 Riverbank Drive and I have been
there about twenty years. My partner and I are looking to build a convenience store on
this property about a year ago. This property near the apartments seemed to be a good
location for a convenience store. There are almost three hundred apartments there and
there are no convenience stores within a two to three mile radius. This is a planned
convenience store and gas station at 2574 Columbia Road past the Glenfield Apartments.
This building has a modem design, hands on management and security lighting. My
partner lives one-half mile from this location. Actually, property on Columbia Road is
like St. Matthews Road, seven or eight years ago. The same time Horizon opened up a
gas station there and it is extremely busy. This would be a good tax base for the City of
Orangeburg."
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "Have you communicated with the residents up there in
Spring Valley and the surrounding areas about this to see if they would like to have a
convenience store there?"
Mr. Kondapaneni responded, "We have contacted the people in the townhouses near
there on one side (four or five residents) and the realtor at Wilder Realty."
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "What were their feelings?"
Mr. Kondapaneni responded, "Mixed feelings."
He further stated, "We own two lots near Spring Valley and we are willing to put houses
there instead of townhouses on those lots."
Councilmember Miner asked, "Can you qualify a convenience store?"
Mr. Kondapaneni responded, "It is a gas station and a convenience store."
Page 4
Councilmember Barnwell stated, "When I ran for City Council in 2001, my platform then
was that I was totally against destroying neighborhoods and residential communities. All
I see here, I wouldn't want this across from my house. I am not in favor of any of this,
other than single family separate dwellings. I think this would destroy this neighborhood
and what you would do to those neighbors is unfair. They put their life savings into it
and you are going to destroy it and I am totally against it."
Councilmember Jernigan stated, "I have had several phone calls from residents in that
area. Those must be the ones that yOll said are on the other side of the mix because none
of them are in favor of putting this over there. One of their main concerns is the fact that
convenience stores seem to be a high crime target and they are just not really interested in
having something like that in the neighborhood."
Councilmember Barnwell stated, "I have also. Furthermore, the old BP station had to be
closed because the crime was so bad right up the street."
Mr. Kondapaneni responded, "At that time, the City was not growing so much. There is
a lot going on now, look at St. Matthews Road now compared to many years ago. There
are apartments on Baugh Street. At first, we didn't have any security lights there and
now we do."
Mayor Pro Tern Haire asked, "You stated that this would enhance the tax base of the
City. Is it not the desire of the owner to withdraw his signature from the original
annexation petition? The letter here from Mr. Patel is withdrawing his petition from
annexation. The area you are talking about is Tax Map #0174-09-03-012 where the
convenience store would be located. According to this letter, he is withdrawing his
petition for annexation. So, I don't see how that is going to enhance the tax base of the
City."
Mr. Kondapaneni responded, "If! have water and sewer that is an automatic tax base, if
we have a convenience store that is generating the income."
Councilmember Barnwell responded, "Water and sewer is not a tax, it is a service."
City Administrator Yow stated, "I think what Mr. Kondapaneni is trying to say is that he
would be required to sign a covenant for annexation for water and sewer."
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "Are you saying that you would come in the City if you
got your water and sewer?"
Mr. Kondapaneni responded, "Yes, I would like to come."
Councilmember Barnwell asked, "Why did he request his name be removed from the
petition?"
Mr. Kondapaneni responded, "We bought that property based on the convenience store,
otherwise, I don't know what we'd do with it."
Mayor Miller stated, "Build more houses."
Mr. Kondapaneni responded, "The market is not there at this point and we have land on
the other side also."
Mayor Miller asked if anyone else had any questions for Mr. Kondapaneni.
Mayor Miller asked, "Your request of us is to waive our general terms and conditions and
the only way we could waive that is if it presents a hardship and I don't know what the
hardship would be for us to waive that. Can you give me some reason that this would
propose a hardship for you?"
187'7
1870
PageS
Mr. Kondapaneni responded, "Based on the plans and the purchase ofthe property with
the intention of making it commercial and there is a need for that with so many
apartments nearby. There is a need for a gas station."
Councilmember Barnwell made a motion to deny the request from Mr. Sudhir Patel for a
water and wastewater tap at 2574 Columbia Road, seconded by Councilmember Rheney.
This motion was unanimously approved.
Mayor Pro Tem Haire asked Assistant City Administrator Bronson, "I read in the packet,
that there was a community meeting held on May 1,2008, at 7:00 P.M., at the Church of
God on Columbia Road, every property owner in the proposed annexation area was
invited to attend. How did those invitations go out?"
Assistant City Administrator Bronson replied, "Via letter from me, I did not send it
certified, it was sent regular mail about a little over a week in advance."
Mayor Pro tem Haire asked, "In other words, this is in addition to what we annexed prior,
right?"
Assistant City Administrator Bronson replied, "Yes, the area that I am talking about in
the statement you just read is only the area you see on the map right now. The area is the
green and the red area. This is an actual map that DPU is currently using; the green
indicates that the County has that parcel zoned as single family residential, our equivalent
to that in the County. That means that these parcels could get a wastewater tap without
having to have a waiver from you. The parcels in red are zoned something other than
single family residential. According to the general terms and conditions, they are zoned
different than single family residential. In order for any of these parcels in red to get a
water or wastewater tap while this annexation is pending, they have to come before you
and request a waiver. I apologize that I have given you a confusing map."
Mayor Pro Tem Haire responded, "Not so much a confusing map as it is where we are
still not getting the big picture as I see it if we are moving aggressively on annexation
across the board."
There were no utility matters brought before Council.
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Miller,
to adjourn.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
~;Jit~~
Carrie W. Johnson ~. ~
City Clerk ~ -.
/pfb
WHEREAS,
WHEREAS,
WHEREAS,
WHEREAS,
RESOLUTION
the City of Orangeburg desires that all its citizens be afforded the
opportunity to attain a decent, safe, and sound Jiving environment; and,
the City of Orangeburg rejects discrimination on the basis of race,
religion, color, sex, national origin, disability and/or familial status in the
sale, rental or provision of other housing services; and,
the State of South Carolina enacted the South Carolina Fair Housing Law
in 1989; and,
April is recognized nationally as Fair Housing Month.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, that the Mayor and Council, in Council
assembled, do officially recognize April as Fair Housing Month in the City of Orangeburg.
Passed By the City Council of the City of Orangeburg, State of South Carolina, this Ist day of
April 2008.
ATTEST &1dt,~
~~~ORAUNG~.s>
~ D?U ~
<1'0 QI ~v Vl"Jt c.~o
~/
RESOLUTION
A RESOLUTION FOR THE CITY OF ORANGEBURG, DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC
UTILITIES TO ACCEPT THE LOW RE1;PONSIBLE BID BY UTILITY SERVICE
COMPANY OF PERRY, GEORGIA IN THE AMOUNT OF $281,000.00 FOR THE
REPAINTING OF THREE (3) ELEVATED WATER TANKS (SADDLE CLUB ROAD
TANK I ST. MATTHEWS ROAD TANK I CAVIERON TANK)
WHEREAS, the Department of Public Utilitie~: of the City of Orangeburg, South Carolina,
received bids on March 12, 2008 for the repaintinl~ of three (3) elevated water tanks (Saddle Club
Road Tank I St. Matthews Road Tank / Cameron Tank); and
WHEREAS, the low responsible bid for this work was submitted by Utility Service Company of
Perry, Georgia in the amount of$281,000.00; and
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, by the Mayor and Members of Council of the City
of Orangeburg, in Council assembled, and by authority of the same, that the low responsible bid
shown above be accepted; and
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that Fred H. Be,atwright, Manager of the Department of Public
Utilities, be authorized and he is hereby directed to execute the contract documents on behalf of
the Department of Public Utilities of the City of Orangeburg.
RESOLVED BY City Council duly assembled this J§! day of April, 2008.
..........
~1?~'
MAYOR
~.~TYCLERK
A Resolution
To establish the City of Orangeburg as a COMMUNITY OF CHARACTER
WHEREAS, the people of the City of Orangeburg recognize the importance of
honorable character qualities based upon the moral standards held by our Founding Fathers on
which they established our nation and legal system; and,
WHEREAS, we recognize the validity of the statement by Alexis de Tocqueville that
"America is great because she is good. When America ceases to be good, she will cease to be
great"; and,
WJ;:IEREAS, we desire to build upon our heritage and continue to make Orangeburg a
place where families are strong, homes and streets are safe, education is effective, business is
productive and neighbors care about one another; and,
WHEREAS, we recognize that individuals are responsible for their actions and that
daily decisions should be based upon objective moral standards which are the basis of
universally-recognized character qualities, including obedience, honesty, truthfulness, diligence,
generosity, kindness, loyalty and courage; and,
WHEREAS, there is a need for more positive role models among our young people and
tei insure the continued safe atmosphere where character is exemplified, taught and strengthened
and where learning is encouraged; and,
WHEREAS, encouraging employees by recognizing positive character qualities has
resulted in an increase in workplace morale, employee safety and corporate profits; and,
WHEREAS, the emphasis of positive character in every sector of society can only
occur as individuals commit themselves to exemplifying character in their personal lives and
inspiring others to do the same.
NOW,THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the Mayor and City Council of the City
of Orangeburg, South Carolina, in Council duly assembled, pledges our commitment to character
and to doing all in our power to become known as a Community of Character by promoting
character in our schools, businesses, homes, churches, town government media and community
groups and we urge the leaders of each of these groups to do likewise.
rs
:-..,.
&'uW~&t;rfb/L; ,
Adopted by the City of Orangeburg Council this 6th day of May, 2008.
~#,~
~~~ORANG~~
t; i:>?U '%
* ,..",. *
<JI \;" ~O~ Vl"Jt C,,?<O
~
RESOLUTION
WHEREAS, Jerry E. Hughes, faithfully served the Department of Public
Utilities of the City of Orangeburg for thirty-eight years and
two days with a retirement date of April 30, 2008; and
WHEREAS, he, through his long and faithful service contributed greatly to
the successful operation of the Department of Public Utilities;
and
WHEREAS, the City Council, in recognition of the fine contribution
rendered the City of Orangeburg, wants to inscribe on the
records its appreciation.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the Mayor and Members of
Council, in Council assembled, do officially recognize the faithful service
rendered to the Department of Public Utilities in the capacities in which he
served the Department and we take pride in conunending him for a job well done.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that a copy of this Resolution, in appreciation
for his devotion of duty to the Department of Public Utilities, be placed in the
Minute Book of the City and a copy furnished to Mr. Hughes in recognition of his
services.
PASSED BY the City Council of the City of Orangeburg, State of South
Carolina, this 6th day of May, 2008.
L~.~ ,
C~':0-(;:;~'71/DV~
C;;;:tf.~__
City Clerk
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
May 20, 2008
Orangeburg City Council held its regular scheduled meeting on Tuesday, May 20, 2008,
at 7:00 P.M., in Council Chambers with Mayor Miller presiding.
PRESENT:
Paul A. Miller, Mayor
Charles B. Barnwell, Jr.
Bernard Haire
Charles W. Jernigan
Sandra P. Knotts
Trelvis A. Miller
ABSENT:
Joyce W. Rheney
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Mayor Pro Tem Haire, to
approve the May 6, 2008, City Council Minutes as distributed. This motion was
unanimously approved.
Chief Davis presented, as information, to Council an announcement about the upcoming
Memorial Service to be held at 10:00 A. M. on Wednesday, May 21st and also the annual
Department of Public Safety inspection to be held Thursday, May 29th at 6 p.m.
City Administrator Yow advised Council of scheduling conflicts in the approved budget
calendar concerning the all day planning session previously scheduled for June 21. He
proposed the dates of June 23rd, 24th and possibly 25th from 5:30 P.M. until 8:30 P.M.
He also noted that the first council meeting in July would be cancelled. A motion was
made by M ayor Pro Tem Haire, seconded by C ouncilmember Knotts, to approve the
amended budget calendar for Fiscal Year 2008 -09. This motion was unanimously
approved.
City Administrator Yow addressed Council as to the State adopting the 2006 Building
Codes as of July 1, 2008. He noted that the City is currently operating under the 2003
building codes adopted by the State. He noted that this would be his recommendation to
adopt these new codes and asked Council for questions.
Councilmember Barnwell asked, “In Section B under Section 108.4, does that mean
$500.00 and 30 days?”
City Attorney Walsh stated, “It should be “or” but you would have to check the code to
be absolutely sure. They are saying insert $500 and insert 30 days and it is probably an
“or” in between them.”
City Administrator Yow stated, “If I could point out Section C, the maintenance code, the
bottom four items are about weedy lots. What we have inserted here are growing seasons
and I think we just need to insert January through December and enforce the Ordinance
all year long. That would be just one suggestion that I would do and Council agreed to
that change.”
Council agreed to that change.
Mayor Pro Tem Haire asked if there were any other changes. City Administrator Yow
stated, “There were no other changes, but he wanted to review it once more with the
Building Official.”
Page 2
Mayor Miller asked the Building Official if he could check the Code for the “And” and
“Or” in the sections.
Building Official Gene Nelson checked the Code and referred it to City Attorney Walsh.
City Attorney Walsh stated, “It said “or” for both such fines. The insertion is “or.”
City Administrator Yow stated, “We are just inserting in the blanks, what this is saying is
that we have inserted $500 in one blank and 30 days in another.”
Councilmember Barnwell asked, “By adopting this we are adopting Or.”
City Administrator Yow replied, “Yes.”
A motion was made by Councilmember Jernigan, seconded by Councilmember Miller, to
approve the First Reading of an Ordinance to adopt nationally recognized Codes and
Standards pursuant to South Carolina Code Section 6-9-10 and Section 6-9-60. This
motion was unanimously approved.
There were no utility matters brought before Council.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tem Haire, seconded by Councilmember Jernigan, to
enter into an Executive Session for discussion of a contractual matter concerning the
Department of Public Utilities Electric Division. This motion as unanimously approved.
Council returned to Open Session.
DPU Manager Boatwright addressed Council. He stated “On April 30th of 2008, the
Department of Public Utilities contract with SCE&G for electricity will expire and as you
know; we have been working on a new electric supply agreement for well over a year.
In early 2006, we requested proposals from our present supplier, SCE&G. We got one
in March 2007. Also, in March 2007, we requested proposals from Progress Energy, The
Southern Company and Duke Energy. We received proposals from SCE&G, two times,
and Duke Energy.
The proposal we received from SCE&G included an approximate 30% increase in our
electric supply costs over our present rate. We rejected the initial proposal and when
SCE&G submitted a second proposal in June 2007, which had the same increases but
spread over a 10-year rather than a 5-year period and that proposal was rejected in
August. After that rejection, DPU received notice from SCE&G that the present contract
would be terminated effective April 30, 2009. In the meantime, Duke submitted
preliminary numbers, which were significantly more attractive than those from SCE&G,
and we began negotiating seriously with Duke. So after a year of negotiating, extensive
legal review by our Washington Attorney, Spiegel & McDiarmid (Jim Horwood) and
analysis and critique by our consultants Black & Veatch (Larry Loos), we have arrived at
a deal, which I think is a very good deal for the City of Orangeburg and the rate payers of
DPU. The deal includes pricing and terms which are similar to those we presently enjoy,
extremely attractive rates, credit for our own generation (different structure, but same
overall monetary credit), reasonable accommodation for future load growth and most
importantly treatment as “native load” (system average price allocation for generation).
This is a ten-year contract, which if approved, will allow for stable supply costs,
including a reasonable handle on fuel costs and a variety of generation sources. This new
contract will not require any adjustments to any of our residential rates at this time. As
you know, the purchase cost of power is a direct pass through to our customers and we
anticipate the costs in 2009 to be approximately the same as they are now. The really
good news is that they will not go up by 30%. Our cost of delivering the power to our
customers does continue to increase, but I do not anticipate any changes in our residential
rates at this time. We will, however, make some contractual adjustments to some of our
industrial rates to reflect provisions of the new purchase agreement.
Page 3
This is an extremely important step for the Department of Public Utilities, the City of
Orangeburg and the citizens we serve. This contract represents a change in electric
supplier for DPU for the first time since 1919. While DPU’s relationship with SCE&G
has been very good for its customers, the best interest of the citizens of Orangeburg will
be better served by this new agreement with Duke Energy. We are excited at the
prospects of this partnership. Duke Energy is a much respected name in the energy
generation business and provides us with the ability to maintain the mandate of City
Council to provide the lowest possible costs to the customers of DPU. I would like to go
on record as stating that SCE&G has been a significant partner in the success of the
Department of Public Utilities and we are happy to be maintaining a working relationship
with SCE&G. They will provide the transmission of our purchased power through one of
their many interconnection points with Duke Energy to Orangeburg. Mr. Mayor and
Members of Council, I urge you to accept this Resolution authorizing me, as Manager of
the Department of Public Utilities, to sign the new contract with Duke Energy,
Carolinas.”
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tem Haire, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to
approve a Resolution authorizing the Manger of the Department of Public Utilities of the
City of Orangeburg to execute an Agreement for the purpose of purchasing electric
capacity and energy. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Mayor Pro Tem Haire, to
adjourn.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
Respectfully submitted,
Carrie W. Johnson
City Clerk
/pfb
,;..~~ORANG~~
ti D?U '%
* '" *(j> \;l/ ~
0(/ ;;.
1"1( CA-r.O
~
RESOLUTION
A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE MANAGER OF THE DEPARTMENT OF
PUBLIC UTILITIES OF THE CITY OF ORANGEBURG TO EXECUTE AN
AGREEMENT DATED MAY 1,2009 BETWEEN THE DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC
UTILITIES, THE CITY OF ORANGEBURG AND DUKE ENERGY CAROLINAS, LLC
FOR THE PURPOSE OF FURNISHING ELECTRIC CAPACITY ENERGY
BE IT RESOLVED By the Mayor and Members of Council of the City of Orangeburg, South
Carolina, in Council assembled, and by authority of the same;
That the Department of Public Utilities, the City of Orangeburg and Duke Energy Carolinas, LLC
enter into an agreement for furnishing electric capacity and energy between Duke Energy
Carolinas, LLC and the City of Orangeburg effective May 1, 2009 and ending December 3\,
20\8;
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, by the Mayor and Members of Council of the City
of Orangeburg, in Council assembled, and by authority of the same, that the agreement be
accepted; and
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that Fred H. Boatwright, Manager of the Department of Public
Utilities, be authorized and he is hereby directed to execute the contract documents on behalf of
the Department of Public Utilities and the City of Orangeburg. ~
RESOLVED BY City Council duly assembled this ;20 day of May, 2008.
44·~
MAYOR
~k GiS>· ~a:vU/J~
dNll~9La~~ <
MEMBERS OF COUNCIL
([dM'j{,~
City Council Minutes
June 3, 2008
Orangeburg City Council held a Public Hearing on Tuesday, June 3,2008, at 7:00 P.M.,
in Council Chambers with Mayor Miller presiding.
The purpose of the Public Hearing was to consider a zoning Change from A-I Single
Family Residential District to A-2 Multi-Unit Residential District, property belonging to
Courtsey Management for property located on Churchill Road, Tax Map # 0174-09-06
013.
Assistant City Administrator Bronson addressed Council. He stated, "This is a Public
Hearing as required by Ordinance. The property is located on Churchill Road, there is
not an address there because it is undeveloped. In your packets, you have a map that is
color coded to identify the parcel."
Councilmember Jernigan asked, 'The area that is cleared out, is that the only section or is
it the whole section down Aster Court?"
Assistant City Administrator Bronson replied, "The property actually goes from the area
you see cleared out adjacent to the townhomes where the cemetery is, all the way over
down the back of Aster Court. That is the parcel that is in play. The owner has only
cleared a portion ofthat property. Most of it is considered wet."
Councilmember Jernigan stated, "I know that some of the people here tonight are from
that area and I know since this is in my district, I have talked to several of them. I think
they are in concurrence of what the Planning Commission has determined."
Assistant City Administrator Bronson stated, "Just for the record, the Planning
Commission denied the rezoning request."
Councilmember Barnwell asked, "Does it go all the way over to Aster Court?"
Assistant City Administrator Bronson stated, "If you look at the map, the hatch mark
indicates the property. It backs up to the homes on Aster Court. It is about seven (7)
acres."
Councilmember Rheney asked about the wall behind the homes on Aster Court.
Larry Hancock of 112 Aster Court addressed Council. He asked, "If this is voted in,
what are the plans for this particular property ifthis is approved? Has the building plans
been finalized?"
Assistant City Administrator Bronson replied, "I can answer it to a limited extent, the
applicant is not here. So far, what has been discussed is the property is currently zoned
as A-I Residential. The request is for it to be zoned A-2 Multi-Family Residential. The
intent for that is for it to be developed for some type of multi-unit use. According to the
preliminary site plans that the applicant brought to the Planning Commission Meeting, it
shows two triplex units. There would be three rental units in each building."
Councilmember Barnwell asked, "Are they one story or two story?"
Assistant City Administrator Bronson replied, "At the Planning Commission meeting, the
applicant stated they would be one story."
Councilmember Barnwell stated, "I thought he said two-story?"
l&fJq
'1&0- I
Page 2
Assistant City Administrator Bronson replied, "At the Planning Commission meeting
there was some confusion."
Mayor Miller stated, "I am not sure because someone said 600 square feet, some say 700
square feet, I am not sure what they are trying to build."
Mr. Hancock stated, "If they are applying for this, are they not suppose to give you plans
for what they are going to build on the property?"
City Administrator Yow stated, " They are not required to submit to Council the actual
building plan prior to a rezoning request. They are not getting permission to build, they
are asking for a rezoning request. This means that they are requesting to build multi
family housing that would have to meet the Zoning Ordinance with the request. It is not
uncommon for the Planning Commission or City Council to ask what you are planning to
build. When I read these minutes, I am a little confused because it seems at one point
they say one-story and at another point they say two-story. As a technical issue, they are
requesting a re-zoning request that does not require building plans That would come later
if the re-zoning was approved."
Councilemmber Barnwell stated, "In trying to be consistent with single family residences
inside the City, and to me this is deviating and wrecking neighborhoods, I concur with
the Planning Commission in denying it."
Melicue Metts of Aster Court addressed Council. He stated, "All of the homes in there
and around there are single unit homes and I would like for it to be kept consistent."
Hearing no further comments, the Public Hearing was closed.
Council entered into the regular scheduled meeting.
PRESENT:
Paul A. Miller, Mayor
Charles B. Barnwell, Jr.
Bernard Haire
Charles W. Jernigan
Sandra P. Knotts
Joyce W. Rheney
ABSENT:
Trelvis A. Miller
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Jernigan,
to approve the May 20, 2008, City Council Minutes as distributed. This was a 5-0-1
vote as Councilmember Rheney abstained as not present at the meeting.
Mayor Miller presented a Retiree Resolution to David C. Pinckney for his thirty-five
years and five days of service to the City of Orangeburg's Hillcrest Golf Course. Jake
Fogle, Hillcrest Manager, presented him with a gold watch.
Mr. Marty Murdaugh and Tripp Wingard addressed Council in regards to the audit for
FY 2006-07. They reported that the City and DPU were in good financial shape and did
not report any discrepancies. They commented that the staff was very helpful and
knowledgeable. Mr. Miller stated for DPU, capital assets were up 2.6%, cash and
investments were up 13%, total assets were up 4.5%, net assets were up 4.8%, gross
revenues were up 1.2% and up 2.2% from the previous year, operating expenses were
down 4.7%. He further stated for the City, fund balance increased $77,000, cash flow
from Pro Shop and Hillcrest was $2,200 and cash flow from Airport was ($9,500).
Page 3
Concerning the Ordinance to adopt recognized Codes and Standards, City Administrator
Yow stated, "There was one thing I pointed out that I needed to look at. Under
parentheses C, if you go down to the 4th section in 10 inches in height. I thought it
referred to weedy lots and growing season. I was incorrect, that actually refers to heating
and cooling and window screening that we do require. So, we left those dates in tact. I
think we had a couple of other questions on the $500 or 30 days and I think we cleared
that up."
A motion was made by Councilmember Jernigan, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell,
to approve the Second Reading of an Ordinance to adopt nationally recognized Codes
and Standards pursuant to South Carolina Code Section 6-9-10 and Section 6-9-60. This
motion was unanimously approved.
Mr. Don Tribble, Director of Community of Character, accepted the June, 2008 Character
Trait Proclamation, "Fairness".
Assistant City Administrator Bronson addressed Council. He stated, "This is a revised
Resolution from the Planning Commission. The original Resolution had some typos in it,
so this is the revised one signed by the Chairman. You have already held a Public
Hearing. Courtesy Management of Orangeburg has requested a rezoning for property
located on Churchill Road, tax map #0174-09-06-013. The property is currently zoned
A-I Single-Family- Residential and the applicant is currently requesting A-2 Multi-Unit
Residential. All necessary and property documents have been filed and posted according
to South Carolina and Orangeburg laws. On May 22, 2008, a Public Hearing was held
with the Planning Commission regarding this rezoning request. No member of the public
spoke for or against this request. The only people in attendance were the applicant, the
members of the Planning Commission and staff. Ultimately, the Planning Commission
voted 6-0 to deny the request and if you will refer to the Resolution that I gave you, it
essentially says the same thing."
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Counci1member Rheney,
to accept the Planning Commission recommendations to deny and not pass the Ordinance
to rezone property as requested by Courtesy Management..
There were no matters brought before Council for the Department of Public Utilities.
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Knotts,
to enter into an Executive Session for a legal matter concerning the Terms and Conditions
of the Department of Public Utilities regarding water and wastewater taps. This motion
was unanimously approved.
Meeting Adjourned.
18S1
Respectfully submitted,
~!!o&~'UUJ
City Clerk
(pfb
1582 Special City Council Minutes
June 5, 2008
Orangeburg City Council held a Special meeting on Tuesday, June 5, 2008, at 5:30 P.M., in the
City Council Charnber Building with Mayor Miller residing.
PRESENT:
Paul A. Miller, Mayor
Charles B. Barnwell, Jr.
Bernard Haire
Charles W. Jernigan
Sandra P. Knotts
Joyce W. Rheney
ABSENT:
Trelvis A. Miller
Mayor Pro Tern Haire made a motion, seconded by Councilmember Jernigan, to enter into an
Executive Session for a legal matter concerning the General Terms and Conditions of the
Department of Public Utilities regarding water and wastewater taps. This motion was
unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Jernigan, to
return to Open Session. This motion was unanimously approved.
City Attorney Walsh overviewed the Ordinance amending the General Terms and Conditions of
the Department of Public Utilities as adopted by Council on November 6,2002.
A motion was made by Councilmember Rheney, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, to approve
the First Reading of an Ordinance amending the General Terms and Conditions of the
Department of Public Utilities of the City of Orangeburg, SC, as adopted by Council on
November 6, 2002. This motion was unanimously approved.
City Attorney Walsh overviewed the Resolution placing a moratorium on the granting of water
taps and wastewater taps in proposed annexed areas of the City of Orangeburg.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, seconded by Councilmember Knotts, to approve a
Resolution placing a moratorium on the granting of water taps and wastewater taps in proposed
annexed areas of the City. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Rheney, to
adjourn.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
Respectfully submitted,
Qct0L~(}D~~
Carrie W. Johiison
City Clerk
/pfb
RESOLUTION
WHEREAS, David C. Pinckney faithfully served the City of Orangeburg's
Hillcrest Golf Course for thirty-five years and five days with a
retirement date of May 23,2008; and,
WHEREAS, he, through his long and faithful service, contributed greatly to the
successful operation of the City of Orangeburg's Hillcrest Golf
Course; and,
WHEREAS, the City Council, in recognition ofthe fine contribution rendered the
City of Orangeburg, wants to inscribe on the records its
appreciation.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the Mayor and Members of Council,
in Council assembled, do officially recognize the faithful service rendered to the City of
Orangeburg in the capacities in which he served the City and we take pride in commending him for
a job well done.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that a copy of this Resolution, in appreciation for his
devotion of duty to the City of Orangeburg, be placed in the Minute Book of the City and a copy
furnished to Mr. Pinckney in recognition of his services.
~4.~
PASSED BY the City Council of the City of Orangeburg, State of South Carolina, this third
day ofJune, 2008.
\
MAYOR
~
TTEST: ~n ,..\~(J{ (j!>LfLfLMfY\-.J
CITY CLERK
RESOLUTION PLACING A MORATORIUM ON THE GRANTING OF WATER TAPS AND
WASTEWATER TAPS IN PROPOSED ANNEXED AREAS OF THE CITY OF
ORANGEBURG
WHEREAS, the City of Orangeburg is now requiring that property owners located in the
unincorporated areas of Orangeburg County agree to annexation as a condition for provision of
water and wastewater utilities from its Department of Public Utilities, and;
WHEREAS, property owners may attempt to circumvent the intent of this requirement by
attempting to obtain vested rights from the County of Orangeburg prior to annexation, and;
WHEREAS, the City of Orangeburg has by ordinance on first reading amended its
procedure to eliminate said circumvention by amending the General Terms and Conditions of its
Department of Public Utilities; and
WHEREAS, it is necessary that the status quo be maintained pending the enactment of
said ordinance.
NOW THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY CITY COUNCIL DULY ASSEMBLED:
That until the above described ordinance amending the General Terms and Conditions
of its Department of Public Utilities which received first reading on June 5, 2008 is adopted on
third reading, no water taps or wastewater taps shall be granted to property owners in any area
under consideration for annexation during the time said Ordinance is under consideration for
enactment.
DONE ANlLliATIFIED BY THE CITY OF ORANGEBURG, STATE OF SOUTH
CAROLINA THIS ~DAY OF JUNE, 2008.
,f' ~, / ,/'.>'
(_._)~/ . , .....~---..._->
~ C;;/'&~{g - /'
(--:tiP ~ 7
L..'
Members ofCouncil
ATTEST ~, rf£Pvrw,,-J
I Y erk
1C:\MyFiles\Cily\Resolution\Resolution.City.Granting of Water Taps.G.DS.wpd
1893
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
June 17, 2008
Orangeburg City Council held its regularly scheduled meeting on June 17, 2008, in the City
Council Chamber Building with Mayor Miller presiding.
PRESENT:
Paul A. Miller, Mayor
Charles B. Barnwell, Jr.
Bernard Haire
Charles W. Jernigan
Sandra P. Knotls
Trelvis A. Miller
Joyce W. Rheney
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, seconded by Councilmember Knotts, to approve
the June 3, 2008, City Council Minutes as distributed. This was a 6-0-1 vote as Councilmember
Miller abstained, as he was absent at the June 3'd meeting.
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Jernigan, to
approve the June 5, 2008, Special City Council Minutes. This was a 6-0-1 vote as
Councilmember Miller abstained, as he was absent at the June 5th meeting.
Mayor Miller, along with Councilmember Rheney, presented Mrs. Margaret Shecut Williams
with the Edisto Award. This award recognizes citizens based on service, leadership, dedication,
commitment and continuity. Mayor Miller highlighted Mrs. Williams' accomplislunents and
some contributions. He stated, "She organized the Junior Charity League, now the Junior
Service League approximately sixty-two years ago and last year they made $54,000.00. She also
organized the Arts Center on the Edisto River and is very active in Friendship Force. She is also
known for the Cherry Tree Project. She raised $25,000.00 for the Yoshino Cherry Trees that are
in the Edisto Gardens and throughout the City in memory of her husband, Marshall and daughter,
Mary Ashley."
Mrs. Willianls thanked Council, as well as family members and friends, including SC State
Senator John Matthews, who came out in support of her. She stated, "I will keep doing for
Orangeburg as long as 1 live. She paid tribute to her family and friends and her mother who took
her to church and encouraged her education. I always remember to give back."
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Rheney, to
approve the Third Reading of an Ordinance to adopt nationally recognized Codes and Standards
pursuant to South Carolina Code Section 6-9-10 and Section 6-9-60. This motion was
unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, seconded by Councilmember Miller, to approve a
Resolution adopting a City Safety Program. This was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Jernigan, seconded by Councilmember Rheney, to
authorize City Administrator Yow to accept a tentative allocation (grant) from the FAA for an
Airport Improvement Program in the amount of $988,202.00. This motion was unanimously
approved.
City Attorney Walsh overviewed the Ordinance amending the General Terms and Conditions of
the Department of Public Utilities of the City of Orangeburg as adopted by Council on
November 6, 2002.
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Jernigan, to
approve the Second Reading of an Ordinance amending the General Terms and Conditions of the
Department of the Public Utilities of the City of Orangeburg, SC, as adopted by Council on
November 6 , 2002. This motion was unanimously approved.
1884
Page 2
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, seconded by Councilmember Miller, to adjourn.
This motion was unanimously approved.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
Respectfully submitted,
City Clerk
/pfb
Resolution
Adopting City Safety Program
WHEREAS, the City of Orangeburg, South Carolina, realizes that it has the responsibility of
providing a safe work environment for its employees and that each employee
must pursue the highest standards in hislher assigned activities and that all
municipal employees must recognize that their own health and well-being as well
as that of their co-workers and the protection of our human resources, are as
important as the activity and job being performed; and
WHEREAS, the City has established and maintains a Loss Control Management Program and
expects its employees to respond to loss control efforts and to perform their
assigned job in accordance with all applicable safety rules and regulations; and,
WHEREAS, the City has established a Central Safety Committee, chaired by the City
Administrator or hislher designee, Department Heads, Insurance Clerk and
one employee, (appointed at-large by the Safety Committee, for a one year term)
shall be members of the Committee; and,
WHEREAS, the Safety Committee shall continuously strive to improve the loss control efforts
and operational efficiency of the City by adopting and updating safety rules and
policies, safety audits, accident inspections and reviews, counseling employees,
indentifying loss trends; and if necessary, recommending disciplinary action for
employees disobeying safety rules and/or working in an unsafe manner; and,
WHEREAS, each Municipal Department Head and supervisor will be responsible for the safety
of employees and protection of human resources in hislher department as well as
the necessary repair and maintenance of facilities and equipment in his/ her area
of responsibility; and,
WHEREAS, each municipal employee will be responsible for hislher own personal safety and
for the protection of assigned equipment or facilities; and,
WHEREAS, the City of Orangeburg, South Carolina, is committed to doing all in its authority
and responsibility to ensure its Loss Control Management Program is a success
and expects the City Administrator, Department Heads and municipal employees
to assist in this endeavor by contributing effort and expertise.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, by t!le Mayor and Members of City Council this
seventeenth day of June 2008, in Orangeburg, South Carolina.
~tJ:8MN
City C k
1835
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
SPECIAL MEETING
June 30, 2008
Orangeburg City Council held a special meeting on Monday, June 30, 2008, at 12:00 Noon with
Mayor Pro Tern Haire presiding.
PRESENT:
Be11lardHaire, Mayor Pr Tem
Charles B. Ba11lwell
Charles W. Je11ligan
Sandra P. Knotts
Joyce W. Rheney
ABSENT:
Paul A. Miller, Mayor
Trelvis A. Miller
Public Works Director Bowden presented information to Council on entering into a contract with
Plowden Construction Company for the construction of an apron/ramp expansion at the
Orangeburg Municipal Airport in the amount of $893,548.00.
A motion was made by Councilmember Jernigan, seconded by Councilmember Rheney, to
approve the authorization to enter into a contract with Plowden Construction Company for the
construction of an apron/ramp expansion at the Orangeburg Municipal Airport in the amount of
$893,548.00. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Rheney, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to
adjourn.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
Respectfully submitted,
Carrie W. Johnson
City Clerk
CWJ/pfb
1836
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
July 15, 2008
Orangeburg City Council held its regularly scheduled meeting on July 15, 2008, at 7:00 P.M., in
the City Council Chamber Building with Mayor Miller presiding.
PRESENT:
Paul A. Miller, Mayor
Bernard Haire
Charles W. Jernigan
Trelvis A. Miller
Joyce W. Rheney
ABSENT:
Charles Barnwell
Sandra P. Knotts
A motion was made by Councilmember Jernigan, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, to approve
the June 17, 2008, City Council Minutes as distributed. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, seconded by Councilmember Jernigan, to approve
the June 30, 2008, Special City Council Minutes. This was a 3-0-2 vote as Mayor Miller and
Councilmember Miller abstained as they were not present at the meeting.
Mr. Gregg Robinson, Executive Director of the Orangeburg County Development Commission
updated Council on the activity of the Commission for the prior fiscal year and gave Council an
update ofthe Jafza activity in Orangeburg County. He highlighted that there will be a September
trade mission to China and a November economic summit. He stated, "Jafza investors will
unveil their plans and the impact expected on Orangeburg during the fall summit."
A motion was made by DPU Manager Fred Boatwright, seconded by Councilmember Haire, to
approve the Third Reading of an Ordinance amending the General Terms and Conditions of the
Department of Public Utilities of the City of Orangeburg, SC, as adopted by Council on
November 6, 2002. This motion as unanimously approved.
Mr. Don Tribble, Director of the Community of Character Program, accepted the Community of
Character Trait Proclamation for the month of July 2008, "Kindness".
City Administrator John Yow presented a Resolution authorizing an Agreement and Release of
Easement at the Orangeburg Municipal Airport for Ecka Granules. A motion was made by
Mayor Pro Tern Haire, seconded by Councilmember Jernigan, to approve the Resolution
authorizing an Agreement and Release of Easement at the Orangeburg Municipal Airport for
Ecka Granules. This motion was unanimously approved.
City Administrator Yow presented to Council the City Grievance Committee's appointments to
the Committee that have expired and that the individual's have agreed to serve another three (3)
year term, if meets Council's approval.
A motion was made by Councilmember Rheney, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, to approve
the reappointment of the following individuals to the City Grievance Committee for another
three (3) year term. Duane Tarrant-Finance, Clatus Griddle-Hillcrest, Loretta Davis
DPS(Alternate), Tripp Miller-Finance(Alternate).
There were no matters brought before Council concerning the Department of Public Utilities.
'nocrrJ
Mayor Pro Tern Haire gave Council and Staff information involving credit card fraud at gas
pumps.
i\ec~[~~sub
~rrie W. Johns
STATE OF SOUTH CAROLINA
CITY OF ORANGEBURG
)
)
)
RESOLUTION NO. ~~_
RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING AN AGREEMENT AND RELEASE
WHEREAS, the County of Orangeburg, South Carolina (the "County") has executed and
filed in the R.M.C. Office of Orangeburg County, South Carolina, in Deed Book 502 at Page
567, an Aerial Easement applicable to, among others, the Orangeburg Industrial Park (the
"Easement"); and
WHEREAS, the City of Orangeburg, South Carolina (the "City") owns and operates an
airport in the County (the "Airport") and the County granted the Easement to the City in
connection with the construction of the Airport by the City; and
WHEREAS, the Airport is located adjacent to the Orangeburg Industrial Park; and
WHEREAS, Ecka Granules of America, LLC ("EGA") is located in the Park on the
property described on Exhibit A (the "EGA Property") and plans to expand its manufacturing
facility by constructing and operating additional facilities (the "Project") at the Park on the real
estate described on Exhibit B attached hereto (the "Adjacent Property"), if certain conditions can
be met by the City; and
WHEREAS, the Easement is, as a result of the final location of the runway of the Airport,
no longer necessary as written and the City is authorized to approve any waiver of the Easement
to EGA so it can proceed with the Project; and
WHEREAS, EGA, as a condition of proceeding with development of its Project, requires
that the City waive the Easement with respect to the EGA Property and the Adjacent Property
(collectively, the "Property"); and
WHEREAS, the Project will not violate the currently applicable Federal Aviation
Administration ("FAA") height restrictions as determined by the City based upon the information
provided by EGA.
NOW, THEREFORE, be it resolved by the City of Orangeburg, South Carolina, as
follows:
I. Pursuant to the authority granted in the Easement, the City hereby releases the
Property from the height restrictions contained in the Easement, provided, however, that the
maximum height of any structure, tree or other object on the Property shall not exceed 100 feet or
296 feet above mean sea level AMSL, whichever is lowest. This release shall run with the
Property and be to the benefit of any successor in interest in the Property.
2. The Agreement and Release in substantially the form attached hereto is hereby
approved and John H. Yow, City Administrator is hereby authorized to execute and deliver the
Agreement and Release and any other agreements and documents as may be required or
appropriate in order to carry out, give effect to, and consummate the transactions and matters
contemplated by this Resolution and the Agreement and Release.
3. All orders, resolutions, and parts thereof, in conflict herewith are, to the extent of
the conflict, hereby repealed or modified.
DONE AND RATIFIED BY THE CITY OF ORANGEBURG, STATE OF SOUTH
CAROLINA THIS a~AY OF July, 2008.
Members of Council
ATTESTe-~~
City Clerk
C:\MyFiles\City\Resolulion\Eckogrand, wad.wpd
1837
MINUTES
City Council Budget Workshop
July 22, 2008
Orangeburg City Council held a Budget Workshop Meeting on Monday, July 22, 2008 at 5:30
P.M., in the City Council Building.
PRESENT:
Paul A. Miller, Mayor
Charles B. Barnwell
Bernard Haire
Charles W. Jernigan
Sandra P. Knotts
Joyce W. Rheney
John H. Yow, City Administrator
Kevin Bronson, Assistant City Administrator
Carrie W. Johnson, City Clerk
ABSENT:
Trelvis A. Miller
City Administrator Yow overviewed for Council the Fiscal Year projections for FY 2007-08. He
stated that we would be using fund balance monies this fiscal year. It was budgeted at $380,000
and year end projections are $241,156.00. He went over the decline in some revenues, i.e.,
investment interest, having to refund taxes due to a reduced state assessment of a manufacturer
which impacts the current and future budgets and that June, 2008 was the worst medical claims
month the City has had. He stated that the City had to make a payment to SC Local Government
Assurance Group for $235,000.00 in July to cover claim costs. We also exhausted a starting
reserve balance in medical insurance of approximately $250,000 in the last plan year. He went
over the revenues and expenditures projections to conclude this budgeting year.
Mayor Miller stated with all the projects and advancements the City has made in the past year
that if we had to spend some of the fund balance that was fine.
Mayor Pro Tern Haire asked where the City's fund balance was being invested. City
Administrator Yow stated it is invested in the State Investment Pool. It is safe and flexible in
that we can deposit, withdraw or transfer large amounts as necessary.
City Administrator Yow overviewed proposed highlights of the FY 2008-09 Budget as follows.
Total General Fund Budget -- Administrator Recommendations
$16,832,543 Revenues
$17,027,543 Expenses
-$195,000 Difference Proposed DPU Transfer
18 gIl>age 2
HIGHLIGHTS OF REVENUES
Industry Tax Reassessment-$60,000 less annually causing millage to be flat
Interest Income <$165,000
Business Licenses-Slight Growth
Proposed 5% Increase in Fire Contracts -- $40,000
Proposed$l.OO Increase Residential Solid Waste--$52,000 ($9 to $10 per month)
Proposed $1.10 Increase Per Ton Commercial
Proposed 3 Mills Increase Property Tax--$IOO,OOO
Proposed $5.00 Non-Resident Fee (to $35.00)--$4,000
$600,000 Cash Reserve-(last year $380,000)
$1.00 per round Cart Fee Increase-$22,000
Building Permit Penalties--$5,000
Hangar Rentals--$25,000 increase
Accommodations/Hospitality Tax Flat
Proposed DPU Transfer
HIGHLIGHTS OF EXPENDITURES
No new positions-eliminated one at Hillcrest
2% COLA-$150,000
15% Increase in Medical Insurance-$260,000-(City pays all of employee costs and portion of
dependents and retirees, changes to medical plan; no changes to dental)
2% Merit for some employees--$40,000
Associated Payroll Costs $60,000-- Worker's Comp., state retirement, Federal, Social Security
Normal Capital Items
10% decrease in office supplies, computer supplies and upgrades
County increased Solid Waste Fee-$1.50 per ton.
Moved several items to Hospitality and Accommodations Fund
Have held or reduced several line items from previous years
Did not address GASB 45
MAJOR EQUIPMENT-5 Year Lease Purchase
Fire Truck $350,000
Fork Lift $ 58,000
Garbage Truck $183,000
Leaf Vacuum $36,250
Total cost $627,250
OTHER-3 Year Lease Purchase
Assorted vehicles, trucks, cars, mowers, tractors--$409,084
Total Capital Equipment to be financed --$1,036,334
Note: County Reassessment Year (Explain impact of possible millage rollback.)
MEDICAL DENTAL INSURANCE PROPOSED CHANGES
Change deductible from $350 to $500
Reduce Generic Co-Pay from $12.00 to $7.00; others would remain $30.00 for preferred
and $60.00 non-preferred
Eliminate 100 day prescription but add mail-order feature with 90 day supply for 2 co-pays
1839
Page 3
City Administrator Yow went into detail on our medical insurance and what changes we would
see in FY 2008-09. The proposed rate increase was 15%, the rate for generic prescriptions
would be decreased to $7.00 and the deductible would be increased from $350.00 to $500.00.
There was a brief discussion on the Solid Waste Ordinance and the Veteran's Monument.
Everyone was in basic agreement of the Budget. However, Council decided to increase the cost
of-living raise to 3% to help cover the health insurance increases that will be passed on to
employees and families. Also, it was decided to adjust the DPU recommended transfer to
$300,000. Lastly, it was decided to implement a 14% increase in health insurance contributions
vs. 15%.
There being no further business, the meting was adjourned.
Respectfully submitted,
~~PlWLhD
City Clerk
CWJ/pfb
13~O
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
August 5, 2008
Orangeburg City Council held its regularly scheduled meeting on August 5, 2008, at 7:00
P.M., in the City Council Chamber Building with Mayor Miller presiding.
PRESENT:
Paul A. Miller, Mayor
Charles B. Barnwell
Bernard Haire
Charles W. Jernigan
Sandra P. Knotts
Trelvis A. Miller
Joyce W. Rheney
A motion was made by Councilmember Rheney, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, to
approve the July 15, 2008, City Council Minutes as distributed. This was a 5-0-2 vote as
Councilmembers Barnwell and Knotts abstained.
A motion was made by Councilmember Jernigan, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, to
approve the July 22,2008, Budget Workshop Minutes as distributed. This was a 6-0-1
vote as Councilmember Miller abstained.
Mr. Warren Harley, Governmental Affairs Liaison presented Mayor & Council officially
with the Municipal Achievement Award for the Regional Forensic Lab for population of
cities from 10,000 to 20,000 people. He stated, "It was certainly a creative and
innovative project and that is what the achievement award is all about. Cities on the
cutting edge of enhancing the quality of life of the people you serve." He presented
Mayor and Council with a plaque and the award.
Mr. Don Tribble and Reverend Nate McMillan accepted the Character Trait Proclamation
for August 2008, "Self-Respect".
City Administrator Yow presented the Ordinance amending the City Budget for FY
2007-08. He overviewed the revenue and expense projections for Mayor and Council.
He thanked staff for their assistance and experience. He stated, "The General Fund total
is $16,439,721 and we are projecting using $241,000 of the cash reserve. We budgeted
$380,000, but we are projecting to use less than that. As you know from our audit, we
are in good shape. When you look at the Airport, we do show grant monies in the Airport
numbers for revenues and expenses. We began showing grant monies as fund revenues
when we built Runway 17/35. The Pro Shop had a gross profit of$70,843 and it is
transferred to the Golf Course Fund to help offset the cost in operating the golf course.
The number I will bring your attention to is the net difference in the golf course. We are
projecting a loss of $22,499 after depreciation, which means if those numbers hold true
the General Fund will have to supplement the golf course. The Two-Percent (2%) Fund
is in good shape and we do a lot of capital projects and it continues to grow. We always
budget a fund balance but try not to spend it. I would like to say that there are reasons
why we are having to budget fund balance. We have had some big expenditures this
year. First of all, June of this year was the worst month we have had in medical claims
and I don't have to tell you about the gas increases, which will be continually reflected in
next year's budget. There is nothing we can do to control the fuel prices, but we have
taken measures to make sure all our Departments are being responsible."
Page 2
Mayor Miller thanked the City Administrator Yow and his staff for their work.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to
approve the First Reading of an Ordinance amending the Budget for the City of
Orangeburg, SC, for the Fiscal Year beginning October I, 2007 and ending September
30, 2008. This motion was unanimously approved.
City Administrator Yow overviewed Council on the budget for next Fiscal Year, 2008
09. He stated "The General Fund total is $17,132,543 and, of course, this is a balanced
budget. I know you have adopted the minutes that pertained to those items. For the
record, I would like to highlight those items. There are a couple of things that have hit us
hard on the expense side, those being fuel, insurance increases, and workers'
compensation. There were some issues that affected our revenues. There was a state tax
industrial property reassessment that affected our tax revenues, which resulted in the City
realizing $60,000 less in property tax revenue. It made our millage flat. Interest income
is decreasing due to decreased interest rates and in years past this has been one of our
major revenues, which overall decreased about $170,000, which is about 5 mills in taxes.
An area with slight growth is business licenses. Some of the things discussed at the
budget workshops were 5% increase in fire contracts to assist with manpower and fuel
costs, a $1.00 increase in residential solid waste from $9.00 per month to $10.00 per
month. The County has notified us that the tipping fee for us will increase by $1.50 per
ton and that increase will be added to our budget. There is a proposed three(3) mil
property tax increase, which will mean about $100,000 where oou millage will go from
85 mils to 88 mils. We are looking to budget $600,000 in cash reserve to balance the
budget. We have budgeted $550,000 in the past and I do anticipate that we will have to
use some of that. I don't think we are not going to be able to budget that much and not
use some of it. Some of the Enterprise Fund increases are $1.00 per round increase in
cart rentals to help offset a new fleet of golf carts and to service the debt on the new fleet,
which is about $22,000 per year. The hangar rentals at the Airport, due to the new
hangars recently built, should project about $25,000 increase in income. There is no
business license increase at this time. Council discussed this but decided at this time,
there would be no increase. The DPU Transfer will be increased by $300,000.00.
There are no new positions in the budget. There has been one position cut at Hillcrest.
There is a 3% cost-of-living for employees. We did discuss 2%, but due to the health
insurance increase that is being passed on to our employees, Council decided to increase
the cost-of- living to 3%. The big number is the increase in medical insurance, which is
14% and is solely based on the amount of claims. The City pays all of the employee cost
and a portion of dependents and retirees. There is a 2% merit increase built in for some
employees and a I % merit for others. The normal capital items in the budget are a fire
truck, which is about $350,000, a commercial garbage truck, forklift, vehicles, leaf
vacuum, trucks, mowers and tractors. We have to replace some of those every year as
well as dumpsters and roll out containers. We went into some of the line items such as
office supplies and computer supplies and cut them bylO%.
One of the things we did not address in this year's budget is Governmental Accounting
Standards Board (GASB-45). We follow all the other standards. Governmental
agencies are going to have to fund post employment benefits. We pay on an annual basis
now and we will have to start pre-funding for employee's retirement. I have spoken with
other entities around the state that have addressed this. I have told Council that we have
to reevaluate our health insurance plan, but there is nothing in the budget this year for
GASB- 45.
It is a County reassessment year. We are using $34,000 for a mil and once the County
completes the reassessment and we get new numbers for millage, we will come back to
you to possibly roll back the millage."
1891
189:2
Page 3
Mayor Miller thanked Council for bringing in the budget to not cut services that we have
been providing.
Councilmember Barnwell stated, "Everyone hates to see a tax increase especially with
the economy. We went up the amount allowed by the State. We could have done like the
County and the school districts and tacked on additional millage on debt but we opted not
to go that route. I don't' think it is appropriate and I think the State Legislature is going
to close that gap."
City Administrator Yow replied, "I won't comment on what other entities are doing. If
we don't raise taxes by the state formula we could get behind and find ourselves in a
deficit situation."
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Rheney,
to approve the First Reading of an Ordinance to raise revenue and adopt a Budget for the
City of Orangeburg, SC, for the fiscal Year beginning October 1, 2008 and ending
September 30, 2009. This was a 6-1 vote as Councilmember Miller opposed.
There were no utility matters brought before Council.
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Rheney,
to enter into an Executive Session for a legal matter concerning discussion of the Zoning
Ordinance, discussion on the purchase of real property on Russell Street and personnel
matters concerning the City Administrator, DPU Manager, City Attorney and City Judge
positions.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
Respectfully submitted,
~~IL
City Clerk
CWJ/pfb
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
SPECIAL SESSION - AUGUST 12, 2008 1833
Orangeburg City Council held a Special Session Meeting on Tuesday, August 12, 2008,
at 5:30 P.M. in the Assembly Room of the Department of Public Utilities, 1016 Russell
Street with Mayor Paul A. Miller presiding. Michael G. Sells gave an invocation.
PRESENT: Paul A. Miller, Mayor
Bernard Haire, Mayor Pro Tem
Charles B. Barnwell
Charles W. Jernigan
Joyce W. Rheney
ABSENT: Sandra P. Knotts
Trelvis A. Miller, Sr.
Mayor Miller opened the meeting by thanking everyone for attending the Special
Session of City Council. A special welcome and introduction was extended to Cheryl
Washington, DPU's new Human Resources Supervisor and Connie Cauthen, DPU's
new Insurance Clerk.
The meeting was then turned over to Fred H. Boatwright, Manager of the Department of
Public Utilities.
Summary of Budget Presentation &
Proposed Electric & Water Rate Changes
Fred Boatwright to Mayor and Council
Manager Boatwright thanked Mayor and Council for sharing their time and energy and
stated the purpose of the Special Session Meeting was to present to them for their
consideration the proposed 2008-2009 budget including the adoption of new electric
and water rates. He expressed he was happy to have the opportunity to present the
overall proposed budget for the City of Orangeburg, Department of Public Utilities.
Electric Division - The Electric Division anticipates an approximate 7% increase in
sales mainly due to increases in fuel costs (natural gas and coal costs have escalated
significantly). Fuel costs incurred from our supplier are a direct pass through to the
Department's customers, therefore, the net effect is zero. We anticipate only a 1%
growth in Kwh sales. Also presented to Council were three new additional options for
decorative outside lighting.
Gas Division - The Gas Division is anticipating a negative growth in natural gas sales
primarily because of skyrocketing prices and because of losing some of its previously
resale customers to "transportation only customers". The Department is also
anticipating the cost of natural gas will continue to be even more volatile. All gas
requirements are now purchased off the open market. The Department has achieved
substantial saving for our customers by diligent purchase and load control measures.
The Gas Division recently launched an aggressive Natural Gas Marketing Program and
the Department is already seeing positive results.
Water Division - The cost of operating and maintaining DPU's water system continues
to rise. The Water Division is experiencing only moderate growth (1 %) and anticipates
this trend to continue. The rapidly increasing costs are primarily due to increases in fuel
and metal costs, depreciation costs and significant and costly regulatory changes.
Wastewater Division - The Wastewater Division is experiencing modest growth. It is
continuing to act as the County's contractor for certain one-percent (1 %) sales tax water
and wastewater projects which are adjacent to our existing distribution and collection
systems. Our agreement with the County is that we will act as their contractor, having
full control over engineering and design of the projects, that we will pay for the
engineering and construction observation and that the County will reimburse us for all
construction costs. As the projects are completed, the installed infrastructures become
assets of the City of Orangeburg owned and operated by DPU. The Department feels
this is a very good deal for both the County and the City and represents how it is
possible for both of us to work together for the benefit of the citizens we all serve. No
rate changes are anticipated in the Wastewater Division this coming fiscal year.
Proposed Electric and Water Changes
189 ~roposed Electric Rate Changes - The Electric Division's current electric supply
contract with SCE&G expires at the end of April 2009. DPU has in place a new
purchase agreement with Duke Energy. Included in this budget ordinance is a request
for changes in industrial electric rates. These changes, which will affect industrial
customer only, are being made to reflect changes with the Department's new electric
purchase contract. The new proposed rates will not go into effect until January 1, 2009,
but the DPU is contractually obligated to give its NMST customers advance notice of
rate changes. No other electric rates will change at this time.
Proposed Water Rate Changes - A review of the statistics in the Water Division
clearly indicates that the "net profit" of DPU's water business has been in a steady
decline for a number of years and has reached the point that the Department needs to
again raise the rates to all its water customers. The Department is proposing a 10%
across the board water rate increase for customers inside the city and an increase for
customers outside the city to make the outside rates exactly twice the inside rates.
There are several reasons why the Department needs to increase water rates:
• The earnings in the Water Division have fallen to a level which requires that we
raise the rates in order to meet our obligations
• Debt service on the loan for the water plant expansion is approximately $390,000
per year. This a new expense which along will put the Water Division operating
in red if we don't increase the rates.
• The depreciation on the Water Plant amounts to about $250,000 per year
• The cost of producing and delivering the service continues to increase at a rate
that we cannot offset by growth alone. Much of this is mandated by increased
regulations from the State and Federal governments.
Manager Boatwright stated the 5.5% increase in 2006 helped, but as predicted did not
produce enough revenue to offset the costs, but was a necessary first step. The idea is
to implement several small steps rather than one large one to propose water rate
increases. The proposed 10% increase will raise the average inside the city residential
customer's bill by 96-cents per month (based on 6,000 gallon consumption).
Manager Boatwright informed Council that even with the rate increase, the water rates
offered by the City of Orangeburg to its customers will still remain the lowest in the
State (inside the City rates). Council was provided a survey showing DPU Water Rates
are the cheapest in the State).
In addition, the Department is proposing the fire protection rates be restructured to
insure compliance with the new state law which was passed at the end of the last
legislative session regarding fire sprinkler systems.
********************************
Manager Boatwright stated spending on capital projects in Fiscal year 2008-2009 would
be very minimal compared to previous years. There is one (1) new capital project
anticipated for the Administrative, Gas Water and Wastewater Divisions and there is
one (1) carry-over capital project for the Electric Division from the previous year.
The meeting was then turned over to the Director of each Division to give a brief
summary of each Division's projects.
Administrative Division Michael G. Sells, Director
Electric Division John B. Bagwell, Director - Absent
Fred H. Boatwright, Manager
Gas Division O. Thomas Miller, Director
Water Division D. Eric Odom, Director
Wastewater Division........................... Richard M. Labrador, Director
1895
ADMINISTRATION DIVISION PROJECT
Project #1 - Administrative Improvements - Security / Communication
Total Project Cost: $ 260,000
Expenditures to Date: $ 0
Estimated 2008-2009 Cost: $ 260,000
The purpose of this three (3) part project is to improve the Department's existing
telephone system for enhanced customer service and redundant protection, to upgrade
the Department's surveillance systems for increased security, and to automate
communication between the office and field workers for a reduction of the dispatching
load,
ELECTRIC DIVISION PROJECTS
Project #1 - Diesel Peak Shaving Power Plant - Modifications
Total Project Cost: $1,150,000
Expenditures to Date: $ 5,000
Estimated 2008-2009 Cost: $1,145,000
Continuation of an approved/ongoing project. The purpose of this project is to replace
and update the antiquated generator panel and engine control panels of the two (2)
"Enterprise" diesel engines at the Diesel Peak Shaving Power Plant, each with a 7,0
megawatt "Ideal" generator. These units went into operation in 1987 and have served
the Department well. The current control system is of pneumatic design and parts are
no longer available, because the manufacturer has gone out of business, The plant is
to replace the entire control system with an electronic PLC based system.
Councilmember Jernigan asked if the generator can be started from the SCADA Room.
Manager Boatwright replied: Yes, the dispatcher can start the large generator from the
SCADA Room, but we also dispatch an operator to physically go to the generator site
and monitor it while in operation.
GAS DIVISION PROJECTS
Project #1 - Natural Gas Service - Big Buck Boulevard
Total Project Cost: $ 610,000
Expenditures to Date: $ 0
Estimated 2008-2009 Cost: $ 610,000
The purpose of this project is to provide natural gas service to the Big Buck Boulevard
area by installing 15,200 feet of 6-inch high-pressure natural gas main on Big Buck
Boulevard to the intersection of One Oak Lane, Presently, there is no natural gas
service in the back portion of the Orangeburg County/City Industrial Park. Gas service
ends at the intersection of Millennium Drive and Global Drive, Completion of this
project will provide gas service to the back portion of the Industrial Park, provide gas
service to the proposed indusial site across Big Buck Boulevard and provide gas
service down Big Buck Boulevard to a large poultry facility, This type of poultry
operation requires large volumes of gas to keep the chickens warm, Presently, this
facility uses propane, Construction of this pipeline will allow DPU to serve this
customer.
Councilmember Haire asked if we can anticipate natural gas prices coming down
similar to the price of oil.
Gas Director Miller replied: The natural gas market has been mirroring the oil market.
Last month DPU paid $13.50 per dekatherm and this month we are seeing gas trade at
$8,50 per dekatherm.
WATER DIVISION PROJECTS
Project #1 - 12-lnch Water Main Extension Along Highway 400
Total Project Cost: $1,678,750
Expenditures to Date: $ 0
Estimated 2008-2009 Cost: $1,678,750
Continuation of an approved/ongoing project. The purpose of this project is four-fold.
The four primary objectives of this project are to provide additional finished water
storage without constructing another finished water reservoir in the Edisto Memorial
Gardens, improve overall water quality, meet projected demand during summer peak
water usage and provide for water availability during emergency situations.
Councilmember Rheney said she passed by Hillcrest on the St. Matthews Road and
noticed work going on at the Hillcrest Water Tank, were we painting the tank?
10SViJater Division Director Odom replied: Yes, this was a project in last year's budget.
The tank will be painted white like the other tanks and will have "Hillcrest" painted on it
in green and the rose repainted.
Mayor Pro Tem Haire asked why are we keeping the old PVC line in service and what
will be the return and when will the project pay for itself.
Water Division Director Odom replied: The existing lO-inch PVC water main that is
close to reaching its design life will serve as a back-up to new 12-inch water main while
at the same time providing much needed additional finished water capacity to the
Bolentown Tank.
Councilmember Haire asked if a cost analysis had been performed to determine the
pay back on the proposed new 12-inch line.
Manager Boatwright answered: "No, but that in order to provide continuing service for
the growth in the area including the two wholesale customers that this upgrade must be
accomplished as soon as possible."
WASTEWATER DIVISION PROJECTS
Project #1 - 14-inch Force Main - Riverside Pump Station
Project Cost: $1.171.000
Expenditures to Date: $ 0
Estimated 2008-2009 Cost: $1.171.000
The purpose of this project is to provide expanded sewer service to several new and
proposed developments in the Riverside drainage basin. There is significant potential
for growth of the wastewater system in the Riverside drainage basin with several recent
and possible areas targeted for annexation and the new proposed recreation complex.
Councilmember Haire asked if the reason we are putting this project on the fast track is
because of the City's push for annexation.
Wastewater Director Labrador replied: the existing pump station is at its maximum
capacity. This line will upgrade the present pumping capacity from 600 gallons per
minute to 1,000 gallons per minute.
Fred Boatwright added this upgrade is because of growth and annexation. This pump
station serves a large area from St. Matthews Road to the River.
Councilmember Haire commented that he hoped that similar accommodations would be
made for proposed annexations in other areas adjacent to the City and that he hoped
that costs for proposed annexation would be considered by Council before decisions
were made.
Manager Boatwright commented that DPU has in the last two budget requests added
wastewater capacity by constructing gravity sewers in the Whitford Stage Creek area
which will provide for service in potential areas which might be considered for
annexation in those areas in conjunction with County "penny projects".
This Completed the Presentation of Proposed Projects and Rate Changes
Mayor Miller thanked Manager Boatwright and his staff for the informative presentation
and stated he and all the members of Council appreciate the good work that comes out
of DPU.
Mayor Miller presided over the First Reading of the Ordinance to Adopt a Budget for the
Operation of the Department of Public Utilities for Fiscal Year October 1, 2008 through
September 30, 2009 Including the Adoption of New Rates for the Department of Public
Utilities for the City of Orangeburg Effective on the Dates Indicated on the Rate
Schedule Pertaining to Electricity and Water.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tem Haire, seconded by Councilmember Jernigan,
to accept the First Reading of an Ordinance to Adopt the 2008-2009 Annual Budget for
the Department of Public Utilities Including the Adoption of New Rates for the
Department of Public Utilities for the City of Orangeburg Effective on the Dates
1897
Councilmember Barnwell asked if Council needed to discuss the new sprinkler law
passed by the Legislature this past session.
Indicated on the Rate Schedule Pertaining to Electricity and Water. This motion was
unanimously approved.
Manager Boatwright answered that since he had initially talked to Mr. Barnwell about
the new law he had learned that the tax exemption portion was optional for Cities, and
that DPU was preparing to implement the cost accounting measures required relating to
fire tap fees and charges. (Council was provided a copy of Legislative Bill 4470).
A motion was made by Councilmember Rheney, seconded by Mayor Pro Tem Haire, to
adjourn.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
Respectfully submitted,
6£cd<---!Q...,. ~
Becky A. ALstin
Secretary to Manager
Department of Public Utilities
1898
City Council Minutes
August 19, 2008
Orangeburg City Council held two Public Hearings on Tuesday, August 19,2008, at 7:00
P.M., in Council Chambers with Mayor Miller presiding. The purpose of the Public
Hearing were as follows:
(I) To raise revenue and adopt a Budget for the City of Orangeburg, SC, for Fiscal Year
beginning October 1, 2008 and ending September 30, 2009
(2) To adopt a Budget for the operation of the Department of Public Utilities for Fiscal
Year beginning October 1, 2008 and ending September 30,2009, including the
adoption of proposed electric and water rates for the Department of Public Utilities
effective October 1, 2008
On Public Hearing #1, City Administrator Yow addressed Council. He advised Council
that this was a balanced budget of the General Fund of$17,132,543 and that there was an
increase in millage from 85 to 88 mils. He officially entered into the minutes the Budget
Highlights for the Fiscal Year 2008-09.
Total General Fund Budget
HIGHLIGHTS OF REVENUES
$17,132,543 Revenues
$17,132,543 Expenses
Property Tax Reassessments-$60,000 less annually
Interest Income <$165,000
Business Licenses-Slight Growth
Proposed 5% Increase in Fire Contracts -- $40,000
Proposed$1.00 Increase Residential Solid Waste--$52,000 ($9 to $10 per month)
Proposed $1.50 Increase Per Ton Commercial Solid Waste
Proposed 3 Mils Increase Property Tax--$100,000-85 to 88 mils
Proposed $5.00 Non-Resident Fee (to $35.00)--$4,000
$600,000 Cash Reserve-(last year $380,000)
$1.00 per rowld Cart Fee Increase-$22,000
Building Pennit Penalties--$5,000
Hangar Rentals--$25,000 Increase
AccommodationslHospitality Tax Flat
DPU Transfer increase of $300,000
No Business License Rate Increase
HIGHLIGHTS OF EXPENDITURES
No new positions-cut one at Hillcrest
3% COLA-$225,000
14% Increase in Medical Insurance-$243,000-(City pays all of employee costs and
portion of dependents and retirees, changes to medical plan; no changes to dental)
2% Merit for some employees--$40,000-$50,000
Associated Payroll Costs $60,000--Worker's Comp., state retirement, Federal, Social
Security
Nonnal Capital Items (detailed next page)
10% decrease in office supplies, computer supplies and upgrades
Page 2
County increased Solid Waste Fee--$1.50 per ton
Moved several items to Hospitality Accommodations Fund
Have held or reduced several line items from previous years
Not addressed GASB 45
MAJOR EQUIPMENT-5 Year Lease Purchase
Fire Truck $350,000
Fork Lift $ 58,000
Garbage Truck $183,000
Leaf Vacuum $36,250
Total cost $627,250
OTHER-3 Year Lease Purchase
Assorted vehicles, trucks, mowers, tractors--$409,084
Total Capital Equipment to be financed --$1,036,334
*Note: County Reassessment Year--$34,000 per mil currently
MEDICAL DENTAL INSURANCE PROPOSED CHANGES
Change deductible from $350 to $500-Has been at $350 deductible for seven (7) years
Reduce RX generic co-pay from $12.00 to $7.00; other co-pay would remain $30.00 for
preferred and $60.00 non-preferred. Eliminate 100 day prescription but add mail-order
feature with 90 day supply for 2 co-pays
Hearing no comments, Public Hearing #1 was closed.
On Public Hearing #2, DPU Manager Boatwright addressed Council concerning the
Budget for FY 2008-09 for DPU. He stated, "The total amount of revenues projected for
next fiscal year is $102,485,721. This includes a rate increase for water of 10% inside
the City and double the increase outside the City. There are also changes in the electric
rates and industrial rates, but no changes in the residential rates. I would like to offer the
minutes as an official record from our Budget Hearings."
Hearing no comments on Public Hearing #2, the Public Hearing was closed.
Council entered into the regularly scheduled meeting.
PRESENT:
Mayor Paul A. Miller
Charles B. Barnwell
Bernard Haire
Charles W. Jernigan
Trelvis A. Miller
Joyce W. Rheney
ABSENT:
Sandra P. Knotts
Mayor Miller and DPU Manager Boatwright recognized Pat Thomas, Human Resources
Director at DPU upon her leaving DPU after fourteen (14) years of service.
A motion was made by Councilmember Jernigan, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell,
to approve the August 5, 2008, City Council Minutes as distributed. This motion was
unanimously approved.
18G9
!Cl I) ()
Page 3
A motion was made by Councilmember Rheney, seconded by Councilmember Jernigan,
to approve the August 12, 2008, Special City Council Minutes as distributed. This was a
5-0-1 vote as Councilmember Miller abstained.
Mayor Miller presented Miss Eden Graves, Orangeburg Idol 2008 with a Proclamation
proclaiming August 19,2008, as "Eden Graves Day" in the City of Orangeburg.
Department of Public Safety Director Davis, Mr. Don Tribble, Community of Character
Director and Dr. Martha Jean Adams-Heggins gave Council a presentation on Project
20/20 and the Gang Intervention Project. They overviewed the goals and objectives and
the organizational structure and the involvement concerning deterring gangs in the
greater Orangeburg area.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, seconded by Councilmember Jernigan, to
approve the Second Reading of an Ordinance to raise revenue and adopt a Budget for the
City of Orangeburg, SC, for fiscal year beginning October 1, 2008 and ending September
30,2009. This was a 5-1 vote as Councilmember Miller opposed.
A motion was made by Councilmember Rheney, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, to
adopt a Budget for the operation of the Department of Public Utilities for Fiscal Year
beginning October 1, 2008 and ending September 30, 2009, including the adoption of
proposed electric and water rates for the Department of Public Utilities effective October
1,2008. This was a 5-1 vote as Councilmember Miller opposed.
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Rheney,
to reappoint Lee Harter and Randy Shuler for another three year term on the Hillcrest
Commission. Their terms will expire July 2011. This motion was unanimously
approved.
Parks and Recreation Director Smith addressed Council on the grant request through
P.A.R.D. for $15,000.00 for renovation of Summers Memorial Park on Summers
Avenue. He stated, "This would include renovations to bridges, refurbishing of the trails,
adding benches and trash cans and hoping to place some exercise equipment along the
trails. The City's match is 20% or $3,750.00." He requested approval of the grant for
City Administrator Yow to sign and accept.
Mayor Pro Term Haire asked, "What is the maximum amount for this grant?"
Parks and Recreation Director Smith stated, "It varies by County. Each Legislative
Delegation has their own guidelines and approved amounts. At one time, the cap was
$3,500.00 from our local Delegation."
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, to
approve the P.A.R.D. Grant for $15,000.00 for renovation of Summers Memorial Park on
Summers Avenue with the City match of 20%, which is $3,750.00. This motion was
unanimously approved.
In reference to Item #9 on the Agenda, City Administrator Yow addressed Council in
regards to the location of the Veteran's Monument. He stated, "Money was allocated in
the I% Capital Project Tax Fund approved by referendum. We have discussed numerous
locations in and around downtown and in the Edisto Memorial Gardens. We have looked
at several sites, some of them City owned and others the City did not own. The site I
decided to discuss with you tonight, to get approval, so we can move forward on this is
on Riverside between US Highway 301 and Russell Street across the street from the
Chamber of Commerce. If you come out the driveway of the Chamber of Commerce, it
is the grass lot across from them with hardwoods and a bank behind it that the City
currently owns. We have done a limited study on this site, but need further studies such
as soil borings and drainage studies and other things. This is a real nice site and we
would like to move forward with consultant work for final determination on this site."
Page 4
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, seconded by Councilmember Miller, to
move forward with the consultant work and design work for final determination on this
site for the Veterans' Monument. This motion was nnanimously approved.
Mayor Miller stated, "A lot of work has gone into this. I think those in the audience will
be pleased with this location. Thanks for your patience."
Councilmember Barnwell stated, "This is a monument for all wars."
Other than the DPU Budget Ordinance approved for Second Reading earlier in the
minutes, there were no other Department of Public Utilities matters brought before
Council.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
Respectfully submitted,
l~~hlct1.~~
Carrie W. Johnson
City Clerk
1901
CWJ/pfb
19CJ2
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
September 2, 2008
Orangeburg City Council held its regularly scheduled meeting in the City Council
Building on Tuesday, September 2, 2008, at 7:00 P.M., with Mayor Miller presiding.
PRESENT:
Paul A. Miller, Mayor
Charles W. Barnwell
Bernard Haire
Charles W. Jernigan
Trelvis A. Miller
Joyce W. Rheney
ABSENT:
Sandra P. Knotts
A motion was made by Councilmember Rheney, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell,
to approve the August 19, 2008, City Council Minutes as distributed. This motion was
unanimously approved.
Mr. Jeffrey McMorrow addressed Council. He stated that since his last visit to Council,
he suggested the number of dogs in a household should be limited to three (3). He stated,
"1 have reviewed the City Ordinance and do believe that such as Ordinance exists." He
cited many articles in the City Code of Ordinances that relates to animals or harboring
animals in the city limits. He stated, "My neighbor admitted under oath that he had nine
(9) dogs, where he is permitted to have only three (3). I have discussed this with the City
Administrator, Building Official and the Director of Public Works, but they advised Mr.
Nelson, Building Official, to stand down." He read from the Police Ordinances as well
in accordance to disorderly or boisterous conduct. He stated that one of his neighbors
breeds dogs and is in violation of the A-2 residential district restrictions. He stated, "1
have been told no arrests will be made. It is sad we have to put up with this each day. It
seems no one hears them but us. We have tried to resolve our issues with our neighbors.
I know some of you have watched the video of these dogs." Ms. Crucilla Biaggia
addressed Council, "The Animal Control Officer knows this is a nuisance house, but does
nothing and we feel like nothing has been done."
A motion was made by Councilmember Rheney, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, to
approve the Third Reading of an Ordinance amending the Budget for the City of
Orangeburg, SC, for the Fiscal Year beginning October I, 2007 and ending September
30, 2008. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, to
approve the Third Reading of an Ordinance to raise revenue and adopt a Budget for the
City of Orangeburg, SC, for the Fiscal Year beginning October I, 2008 and ending
September 30, 2009. This was a 5-I vote as Councilmember Miller opposed.
Mayor Miller presented to Don Tribble, Executive Director of the Community of
Character, the Character Trait Proclamation for the month of September 2008,
"Compassion".
Page 2
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to
approve the Third Reading of an Ordinance to adopt a Budget for the operation of the
Department of Public Utilities for the Fiscal Year beginning October I, 2008 and ending
September 30, 2009, including the adoption of proposed electric and water rates for the
Department of Public Utilities effective October I, 2008. This was a 5-1 vote as
Councilmember Miller opposed.
Mayor Pro Tern Haire asked for information as it relates to the hurricane and preparation.
City Administrator Yow and DPU Manager, Boatwright updated Council on the City's
and DPU's preparations for potentially approaching storm, Hanna.
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, to
approve entering into an Executive Session for a contractual matter concerning the
Chamber of Commerce and a proposed location of student housing business and
convention center. This motion as unanimously approved.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
Respectfully submitted,
(!tJrJul1l~
Carrie W. Johnson ~
City Clerk -- .......
CW/pfb
1933
1904
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
September 16, 2008
Orangeburg City Council held its regularly scheduled meeting in the City Council Building on
Tuesday, September 16, 2008, at 7:00 P.M., with Mayor Miller presiding.
Present:
Paul A. Miller, Mayor
Charles W. Barnwell
Bernard Haire
Charles W. Jernigan
Sandra P. Knotts
Trelvis A. Miller
Joyce W. Rheney
A motion was made by Councilmember Rheney, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to
approve the September 2, 2008, City Council Minutes as distributed. This was a 5-0-1 vote with
Councilmember Knotts abstaining as she was not present at the last meeting.
Mayor Miller stated that Buster Smith, Parks and Recreation Department Director, asked him to
announce that on Thursday, September 18
th
at 2:00 P.M., in the Rose Garden, The South
Carolina Garden Club and the City are going to have a program on the Noisette Rose..·. Members
of the family and descendents of the family will be there. The Garden Club of South Carolina is
having a convention in Orangeburg on Thursday.
Mayor Miller stated the week, September 15-20, 2008. is Industry Appreciation Week and read a
Proclamation proclaiming Industry Appreciation week. He instructed City Administrator Yow to
deliver the Proclamation to the Economic Development Office.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tem Haire, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to
approve a Resolution authorizing the extension of the maturity date of the mortgage of two and
sixty-nine hundredths (2.69) acres with a building and other improvements thereon, to South
Carolina Bank and Trust in the principal sum of five hundred thousand ($500,000) dollars and
recorded in the Office of the Register of Deeds for the County of Orangeburg, State of South
Carolina in mortgage book 1551 at page 293. City Administrator Yow stated it was a
partnership with the Chamber, the City,DPU and Orangeburg County when built. The City is
the real property owner and the extension is for six (6) months. This motion was unanimously
approved.
City Administrator Yow discussed the grant for "Criminal Domestic Violence Investigator" in
the amount of $44,750 and the City's share is $14,917. Councilmember Barnwell asked, "Is the
grant amount of $44,750 just for salary." City Administrator Yow stated that it was for salary,
benefits, travel, training and supplies. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Miller, seconded by Barnwell, to appoint Ms. Betty
Strong of Maxcy Street to the Board of Zoning and Appeals, for District #5, to fill an unexpired
tenn, which expires January 2010. This motion was unanimously approved.
City Administrator Yow stated that two new Boards will be created under the new Zoning
Ordinance in the near future.
City Administrator Yow gave an update on the report from SCDOT concerning Chestnut and
Columbia Road intersection. Councilmember Rheney stated that she hoped they would look at
the real speed limit at this intersection. City Administrator Yow stated that there had been fifty
six (56) accidents from September 2007 through August 2008. SCDOT has added an additional
traffic signal in each direction and improved the left turning signal and realigned the traffic
signal and the signal timing on Chestnut has been adjusted as well." Councilmember Barnwell
asked, "Have the changes increased or decreased the speed there." City Administrator Yow
stated, "I hope we don't see more people trying to beat the red signal since the timing has been
changed." Councilmember Barnwell discllssed his concerns having three private drives within
19:35
Page 2
fifty-yards of the stop light, referring to KFC and Shoney's. City Administrator Yow stated it
was within the jurisdiction ofSCDOT to detetmine the allowance of drive ways and DPS will be
monitoring the speed.
Mayor Miller asked Chief Wendell Davis, Community of Character Chairman of the Board, to
give an update on what the Board has been doing. Chief Davis stated, We have been to
Abbeville to introduce the program to them and they seemed to be interested in starting one."
Mayor Miller stated that the Community of Character does make a difference.
There were no utility matters brought before Council.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tem Haire, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to
adjourn. This was unanimously approved.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjoumed.
Z;:Y'::lJ
Duane Tarrant
Assistant City Clerk
(pfb
....
19()6
City Council Minutes
October 7, 2008
Orangeburg City Council held a Public Hearing on Tuesday, October 7, 2008, at 7:00
P.M., in Council Chambers with Mayor Miller presiding. The purpose of the Public
Hearing was for consideration of a petition for annexation of property through the
seventy-five (75%) petition method.
Students from a reporting class at Claflin University were recognized.
Mayor Miller opened the Public Hearing for comments.
Assistant City Administrator Kevin Bronson addressed Council. He stated, "I am going
to provide a power point presentation and maps so everyone will know what properties
we are talking about. This annexation has been assembled under the 75% petition
method under Section 5-3-150(1) of the SC Code of Laws and states that if75% of the
property owners own 75% of the assessed value, then we can annex the entire section.
The 75% thresholds have been met as 79% of the property owners have signed the
petition comprising 85.8% of the assessed value. The total assessed value is $197,768
and there are forty-three (43) property owners on record. Each property owner that has
signed the petition has requested specific zoning. If a property owner does not sign the
petition, then the property will be annexed as Single-Famil~, A-I. The Planning
Commission conducted a Public Hearing on September 29' and they recommended to
Council that this annexation be granted and all parcels be zoned Single- Family A-I.
This is the north part of town along the Columbia Road corridor."
He further outlined the revenues and expenditures for the annexation. The revenue
reductions would total $15,729. The revenue increases would total $38,004 and
estimated infrastructure costs would be $80,908, which is for street lights, fire hydrants
and sewers.
Assistant City Administrator Bronson stated, "This property consists of 61.12 acres, four
(4) parcels comprise 13.94 acres that are tax exempt and there are nine (9) vacant parcels
totaling 20.54 acres. There are about 115 people living in 33 residential units, Multi
Family units or nursing facility."
Maps were discussed in detail as to zoning and parcels indicated.
Mayor Pro Tern Haire asked about the gravity sewers and their cost?
Department of Public Utilities Director Boatwright stated, "It would be up to the owner
to tie into the sewer lines and apply for the tap per their request."
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "How many citizens are in this area?"
Assistant City Administrator Bronson replied, "About 115 citizens."
Mr. Harry Fleming of 1650 SparklebelTy Hill addressed Council. He stated, "1 would
like the opportunity to address you in regards to the resident side of this annexation.
When we bought this property some years ago we understood that this community would
remain single fanlily dwellings. This was changed covertly without notifying residents.
People were never asked about apartments or gas stations as it relates to the surrounding
properties. Reactions to Apartments: The front page of the Times and Democrat from
February 18, 2008, shows a problem with trash caused by apartments on Baugh Street.
The trashed pond is down stream from the apartments and many of us are down from the
Page 2
proposed apartments. It was reported at a prior City Council meeting that there was a gas
station and convenience store at the intersection of Route 21 and Wingate Street. This is
down from the proposed property site. This was closed due to frequent robberies. Now
an effort is being made to move this sort of thing in my neighborhood with criminals and
hoodlums and perhaps camp on my front lawn to study the station and perhaps properties.
Traffic Problems: It was reported at an earlier Council meeting that three private
driveways are already facing traffic problems. Route 21 and Chestnut Street is already
one of the most dangerous intersections in Orangeburg with fifty-two (52) accidents in a
period of one year. Increased population density with apartments and increased traffic
with a gas station will only complicate existing properties. Value of Property: I have
been told of apartments being built close to my property would decrease the value of my
property by tens of thousands of dollars. This has been given to me by someone in the
real estate business. We have heard the pain of the developer's side of his investment.
No one has addressed the homeowners suffering and the home is probably the largest
single investment someone will make in their lifetime. This is being caused by a poor
business decision on part of the developer. That happens, but no one has offered to
compensate us for our potential losses. Impact on Orangeburg: An editorial in the
August 28th Times and Democrat stated, "Orangeburg, A Patchwork of Neglect". The
author, William Adair is an Engineer and was raised in Orangeburg, but returns to visit
family. He cites problems with high density housing. Possible Solutions: I have
submitted two samples of solutions to the City to consider and evaluate being an old town
concept with brick sidewalks and gas lights. This could be an added attraction to the rose
gardens and this could be used as an alternative to the downgrading of the City. The
developer could divert his effort to other commercial sites such as in front of
Orangeburg-Calhoun Technical College where there are three properties for sale. The
other possibility would be to build houses of equal or greater value in the area in
question. The land could be sold to someone else at cost, since a profit has already been
made by the selling of the timber. Trees could be planted for harvest at a later date. A
friend of mine asked me about the area in question when she noticed the trees had been
removed and I explained the situation. She observed that there are several roads radiating
from Orangeburg like the spokes of a wheel, but one of those roads was different. One
had pleasant homes and communities on either side of the road, churches and an
occasional pond and woods. Now all of this is being threatened by the encroachment of
commercialism. I respectfully request that the Mayor and City Council reject any request
or approval to build any apartments, gas stations or laundry mats on the area detailed on
page 8 of the Times and Democrat dated September 24th of this year as there are other
solutions to this problem."
Councilmember Barnwell asked, "Are you referring to duplexes or apartments?"
Mr. Fleming replied, "That is a fine question and I am not an authority on that matter. My
understanding of what is being planned could reasonably be called apartments."
Jim Meggs, attorney representing Steve & Hema Patel and Courtesy Management
addressed Council. He stated, "They own the properties that are subject to some
disconcert. The properties owned by clients are not appropriately zoned A-I Single
Family Residential. We would like the opportunity to work with City Staff, Council and
neighbors to develop a plan to truly define a tasteful development for a multi-family
variety. We can meet and compromise the idea of a convenience store that had caused
some concern among the neighborhood is not cast in stone by any stretch. We would be
happy to entertain a neighborhood meeting that would entertain any other kinds of
facilitory needs to bring value to the community. Not all of you are familiar with the
Patels and their partners; you know them to be quality developers who have done a lot for
the Orangeburg community. Again, it is our contention that A-I is not appropriate for
this territory, or for all the parcels, it is not appropriate due to nature ofthe existing uses
that are going to be overlayed with A-I zoning of non-conformities. We believe we can
find a way to yield value for all concerns in the City and neighborhood and for my clients
and we ask for an opportunity for a result."
19Q7
19G8
Page 3
Councilmember Jernigan asked Mr. Meggs to identity the properties in question. He
identified parcels #26, #4, #6 and #7 from the map.
Mrs. Hema Patel addressed Council. She stated, "1 want to make one admission. We
made one huge mistake and that was not talking to the neighbors then to let them know
what we were planning had everyone's interest in mind. Steve and 1have lived in that
neighborhood for quite some time since 1989. We drive down Longwood every day to
our home and we certainly don't want to have anything constructed that will increase
crime or decrease the value of our property. We don't want our neighbors to be forced
into annexation because this is the choice they have; either get annexed with the City or
maybe they don't want to be annexed, but they do because they don't want apartments or
a convenience store. 1want to make it clear of what kind of development we want to do.
We want the same things that everyone in this room wants which is peace of mind at
home. We are going to be in that house for a long time. Our goal is to build homes that
have character and are LEED certified. We want to be the first multi-development in
South Carolina to have LEED certification. We want to build everything green since that
is where everything is going and that is LEED certified. Our development is going to
have gates and the houses on the side will have tremendous curb appeal. Weare not
going to build cheap houses because that is not the kind of people we are. We are going
to build something that is tasteful and something that is going to bring value to
everyone's property and something to bring a buzz to Orangeburg. Our site selection was
based on a requirement for certification, as a pre-requisite. It has to be within walking
distance to stores and other conveniences. Whatever our goals are for the townhouses are
the same for the convenience store. The interior and exterior of the design is the selling
point, so we are not going to put something up there that we are not going to get a return
on the investment. The units are going to be outstanding. We will do what we need to in
order to protect our assets and the assets of the community."
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "How many units are going to be put on the property on
Columbia Road?"
Mrs. Patel replied after discussing with her partners, "Eighteen.(18)."
Mayor Miller asked, "You will have twenty-two (22) on parcel #7?"
Mrs. Patel replied, "Yes."
Mayor Miller asked, "What is the acreage on parcel #4, #6, and #7?"
Mr. Meggs replied to Council, "Parcel #4 is 1.31 acres, parcel #6 is 1.16 acres, and parcel
#7 is 2.06 acres, totaling about 4.5 acres combined."
Councilmember Barnwell asked, "You are putting forty (40) units on 7.5 acres, selling
the ones on Columbia Road and renting the ones on Longwood."
Mrs. Patel replied, "Yes."
Councilmember Miller asked, "What is the rationale behind renting some of the units and
selling the others?"
Mrs. Patel replied, "The Columbia Road property backs up to a neighborhood and we
wanted to be sensitive to those neighbors, so if we sold those there, then there wouldn't
be a change of occupants."
Mayor Miller stated, "On parcels #4 and #6 on 2.4 acres, it looks to me that .13 acres
would be for one house. What are the lot sizes or what is going to be the footage of those
townhouses?"
Page 4
Mrs. Patel replied, "One-thousand (1000) square feet for the townhouses and two
bedrooms. We don't have the lot sizes because everything is not concrete."
Mayor Miller stated, "I am just trying to envision in my mind the townhouse commlmity
and what kinds of houses on the size lots, the square footage and how much you are
plaIming on selling those for?"
Mrs. Patel replied, "One-hundred and ten thousand, ($110,000), aIld the rent ranges from
$550.00 to $800.00, depending on the number of bedrooms."
Mr. Mike Horger addressed Council. He stated, My wife and I own parcels #34 and #36.
1am here to speak in favor of the annexation, but I am against the blanket A-I zoning.
What I want to point out is, units 31 through 37 are all in a block west of Harris Street,
where a number of duplexes are and have been for a number of years. There is currently
a Multi-Family use there. Lot #36 currently does not have a duplex on it. I did put a
sewage tap there to construct a duplex. On that block, I provided Assistant City
Administrator Bronson some materials last week with restrictive covenants on that block,
which is for lots #30-#37. That property in 1977, by restricted covenant, provided for a
one two-family residence for not less than 1800 square feet of floor space exclusive of
porches, terraces and basements. There is currently this use on that block and even parcel
#37 previously owned by Harold Carter. When tiley constructed on that, they went
across a lot line. There is currently a house on one lot and an apartment behind it that
crosses a lot line, which is a multi-family use on that parcel. Lot #36 currently does not
have a building on it. That is the lot my wife and I own which currently has a sewage tap
on it where we have made provisions to build a duplex. I point this out because I think
our legislature this year passed a statute, Section 6-29, 1145 that requires a local planning
agency to consider the uses of the property and restricted covenants on that property. I
think by that State Law, the Planning Commission and Council should consider and are
required that the A-I zoning of that property would be contrary and would conflict with
the restricted covenants on that property. My request would be for the A-2 zoning for
that property be considered."
Councilmember Miller asked City Attorney Walsh, "Can you translate in laymen's
terms?"
City Attorney Walsh replied, "For non-conforming uses, you can't make any additions to
the property and if it is over 50% destroyed by fire, you can't rebuild."
Councilmember Barnwell asked, "You plan on building a duplex on your lot?"
Mr. Horger replied, "I did intend, 1 ran a sewer tap to lot #36."
Councilmember Knotts asked, "On Lot #36, there is no construction at this time?"
Mr. Horger replied, "There is no building there, 1 have a sewer tap and water tap there.
My plan is the same use as the other lots in that block being consistent with tile restricted
covenants that have been in effect for over thirty years, to build a two-family residence to
comply with those restricted covenants."
Councilmember Knotts asked City Attorney Walsh, "If we would allow everything in this
area as A-I, except for those lots as A-2 and you would do another duplex, wouldn't that
set some kind of precedent?"
City Attorney Walsh replied, "Not if we can distinguish the characteristics of the property
that are not similar to other properties."
Councilmember Knotts stated, "Being that everything else around #30-#37, all of those
are already being used as A-2, they are in an A-2 district?"
19Q<t
/'f/O
Page 5
Mr. Abe Salama addressed Council, "I have read about all of this in the newspaper.
Multi-family would be contradictory to the neighborhood and single family use should be
maintained. I would like to see the City increase their size. Mr. Patel should reconsider
selling single housing to be a good neighbor."
Ms. Avis Butler addressed Council. "I am here to speak in favor of the annexation. We
put our project together, we were alerted by the County that since the City has run sewer
down Longwood, we would be subject to annexation at some time. We planned for that
during our development. I must tell you that since we have been annexed, it has worked
wonderful. Our site is under construction. I come to ask you to continue to set forth
keeping the neighborhood intact with single family uses for new construction."
Hearing no comments, the public hearing was closed.
Council entered into the regularly scheduled meeting.
PRESENT:
Paul A. Miller, Mayor
Charles B. Barnwell
Bernard Haire
Charles W. Jernigan
Sandra P. Knotts
Trelvis A. Miller
Joyce W. Rheney
A motion was made by Councilmember Rheney, seconded by Councilmember Jernigan,
to approve the September 16, 2008, City Council Minutes as distributed. This motion
was unanimously approved.
Mr. Don Tribble, Executive Director of the Community of Character, accepted the
October 2008 Character Trait Proclamation, "Diligence".
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Miller,
to approve a Resolution for Mr. Howard Duvall, who retired as Executive Director from
the Municipal Association of South Carolina.
Assistant City Administrator Bronson stated, "This is the Ordinance that we went through
earlier and that the Planning Commission recommended to you. The Planning
Commission has made the recommendation to you for A-I. City Council does have the
authority to zone parcels within here as you see fit. Per the Orangeburg Ordinance, 24
4.4, if there is a piece of property that the owner did not sign, it will be zoned as A-I
Single-Family. I have given you estimates of what the revenue and expense estimates
should be and the infrastructure costs. There are no additional personnel needs to handle
this annexation. The area will be proposed to come into Council District #2. There are
no other additional expenses anticipated at this time for that area. The residential
population is estimated to be 115."
Mayor Pro Tern Haire asked Mr. Bronson, "The parcels located in before #26 and #27,
identify that for me."
Assistant City Administrator Bronson replied, "Glenfield Apartments."
Mayor ProTem Haire asked "Did you consider them in this annexation?"
Assistant City Administrator Bronson replied, "Yes, I have been in contact with the
owners at Glenfield Apartments, they currently are managed by a large company in New
Jersey. They currently have an almexation petition in their possession. They were much
later down the road in bringing them along with the annexation than with the rest of the
group. I do anticipate that we will have a 100% petition signed in the near future. They
have made a verbal commitment. It was considered to be a part of the annexation.
Page 6
The assessed value is very high on the apartments, but since I did not have a verbal
commitment at the time that this annexation was ready, Glenfield was left out of this part
of the annexation."
Mayor Pro Tem Haire asked, "Some time ago you stated that you contacted some persons
in the Eastem part of Orangeburg as it relates to annexation. I believe those individuals
were located in the Belleville area. Could you explain to me the rationale going that far
down where you have other properties contiguous to the Orangeburg area, has there been
any kind of effort to talk to those individuals like going down the lower part of Russell
Street area close to Bethea's Funeral Home."
Assistant City Administrator Bronson replied, "No, not on my part."
Mayor Pro Tem Haire stated, "There has been no effort made to bring in Clarendon
Apartments on Russell Street."
Assistant City Administrator Bronson replied, "As Council passed modifying DPU's
general terms and conditions, if anyone is granted a new water or wastewater tap, an
annexation covenant is required. Periodically, DPU gives me a map to identify parcels
with such covenants. We monitor the maps as to where covenants are being signed and
as annexation is done, we try to head where water and sewer are in place. Spring Valley
has had water for quite some time and sewer for over a year."
Mayor Pro Tem Haire asked, "Are you saying that Clarendon Apartments don't have
water and sewer?"
Assistant City Administrator Bronson replied, "It does and as the covenants stack up that
is where I tend to go from an annexation approach."
Mayor Pro Tem Haire replied, "If we take that approach then the eastern side of
Orangeburg is never going to get annexed."
Assistant City Administrator Bronson replied, "There are quite a few covenants in the
Belleville Road area getting sewer in that area."
Mayor Pro Tern Haire responded, "You are not getting my point, you can never get to
that area where covenants are being issued if we carmot get those contiguous parcels. I
think I have said this once before, I have lived here all my life, born and raised in the
area of Maxcy Street and the city limits hasn't moved in my lifetime in that area in the
eastern direction. I feel tonight, I cannot sit and continue to see that pattem continue and
for that reason I cannot go through with the annexation until we decide we are going to
put some emphasis in other directions pertaining to the city limit boundaries. I have gone
along with other annexations in hopes that there will be some sort of fairness to other
areas. I will not be able to vote for this."
Mayor Miller read the Ordinance by title.
Councilmember Jemigan asked to amend the Ordinance and take in other areas as their
current use.
A motion was made by Councilmember Jernigan to amend the Ordinance to reflect
Parcel #1,1687 Longwood be zoned as A-2, Parcel #9, 2855 Columbia Road be zoned at
Office- Institutional, Parcel #29, 2875 Columbia Road be zoned as Office-Institutional,
Parcel #32, 2821 Harris Street be zoned as A2, Lot #34, 1751 Lee Way be zoned as A-2,
Lot #35 and Lot #36, 1758 Longwood as A-2. All the other parcels would be zoned as
A-I. This motion was seconded by Councilmember Barnwell. This was a 4-3 vote as
Councilmembers Miller and Knotts and Mayor Pro Tem Haire opposed.
1911
1912
Page 7
Assistant City Administrator Bronson overviewed the Ordinance to amend the Municipal
District Map. Mayor Pro Tern Haire asked City Attorney Walsh, "Assigning this to a
district before it becomes atmexed, is that proper?"
City Administrator Walsh stated, "The Justice Department has approved this method."
This was a 4-3 vote as Councilmembers Miller, Knotts and Mayor Pro Tern Haire
opposed.
Councilmember Jernigan stated, "I hear what you are saying on the other side of town as
far as atmexation. I also realize atmexation is a means for the City to grow and prosper.
Annexation takes a lot of time from oUI staffto do it the right way. Ifwe are patient
enough and rely on our staff to do the right thing, I think we will see the City grow in all
directions all the way around, not just in one direction. We have done more atmexations
this year than we have in the last ten years. I think that this is something that we are
getting started on and we really need to be more patient with our staff and help them in
getting these annexations done and investigate who wants to come into the city and take
them in."
Mayor Pro Tern Haire replied, "I hear, but if you would understand having lived here as
long as I have lived here, when there isn't any movement in the other direction,
something is wrong. We had a study done some time ago. I heard John's explanation
some time ago that there is an orderly process in which we do the annexations in certain
areas. I feel we need to move the ball around. I've lived here over fifty years and I have
not seen the city limits move."
Councilmember Barnwell stated, "I would just like to ask that the City Administrator atld
staff try to move atmexation to the east of Orangeburg."
City Administrator Yow replied, "We would be happy to and we would also be happy to
get any assistance in facilitating some meetings with some people, we'd appreciate it."
Mayor Miller stated, "As many of you know, this has been a pet project of mine in
growing the City and I want to thank Mr. Bronson for his efforts. I know it takes a lot to
get all of this together. It is a lot more complicated than just saying we want to annex an
area, it takes a lot more work. I understand what Mr. Haire is saying. I have spoken to
numerous civic clubs and churches urging them to come into the City. This piece we are
bringing in tonight fits in with the other pieces we have at1llexed,tightening up a hole. I
hope anyone that would like to come into the City, we would like to have them inside the
City of Orangeburg and have a voice in government. I commend those in Spring Valley
wanting to come into the City, we are glad to have you."
A motion was made by Councilmember Rheney, seconded by Councilmember Jernigan,
to approve a Resolution to accept the low responsible bid by Randy Pigate Construction
Company, Inc., of Longs, SC, in the amount of$571,5595.00 for the Riverside pump
station upgrade and force main. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Mayor Miller, seconded by Councilmember Jernigan, to enter
into an Executive Session for a legal matter concerning annexation/zoning/Spring Valley,
Columbia Road.
Mayor Miller made a motion, seconded by Council member Jernigan, to adjourn.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
Q
Respectf~lI~ysubmitted,
,aJt\;Q .
arrie W. Joh n
City Clerk
RESOLUTION
A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE EXTENSION OF THE MATURITY DATE OF
THE MORTGAGE OF TWO AND SIXTY-NINE HUNDREDTHS (2.69) ACRES, WITH
BUILDINGS AND OTHER IMPROVEMENTS THEREON, TO SOUTH CAROLINA
BANK AND TRUST IN THE PRINCIPAL SUM OF FIVE HUNDRED THOUSAND
($500,000.00) DOLLARS AND RECORDED IN THE OFFICE OF THE REGISTER OF
DEEDS FOR THE COUNTY OF ORANGEBURG, STATE OF SOUTH CAROLINA IN
MORTGAGE BOOK 1551 AT PAGE 293
WHEREAS, the City of Orangeburg by Ordinance 2005-1 authorized the above
described mortgage, and;
WHEREAS, the Orangeburg County Chamber of Commerce has requested of
South Carolina Bank and Trust an extension of the maturity date of said mortgage and
the City of Orangeburg has agreed thereto.
NOW THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED BY CITY COUNCIL DULY
ASSEMBLED, that the City of Orangeburg does hereby consent to the extension of the
maturity date of that certain mortgage of The City of Orangeburg to South Carolina
Bank and Trust in the maximum obligation limit of Five Hundred Thousand
($500,000.00) dollars dated February 11, 2005 and recorded in the Office of the
Register of Deeds for the County of Orangeburg, State of South Carolina in Mortgage
Book 1551 at page 293 to March 1,2009.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that John H. Yow, City Administrator is hereby
directed and authorized to execute a Commercial Loan Modification Agreement for the
above purpose.
DONE AND RAlFIED BY THE CITY OF ORANGEBURG, STATE OF SOUTH
CAROLINA THIS jj!!DAY OF SEPTEMBER, 2008.
/.
ATTEST'~
Il£','stCity Clerk
C:\MyFiles\City\Resolution\Resolution.Mortgage.Chamber of Commerce.wpd
RESOLUTION
WHEREAS, on October 1, 2008, Howard Duvall did retire as the executive
director of the Municipal Association of South Carolina after thirty-four (34) years of
service to the state's 270 cities and towns; and,
WHEREAS, from his tenure as Director of Intergovernmental Relations to
Executive Director, Howard has consistently provided technical assistance and helpful
information to local elected officials and employees of cities and towns; and,
WHEREAS, Howard Duvall has served as the tireless voice of cities and towns
at the State House on important legislative issues related to Home Rule; and,
WHEREAS, Howard Duvall has led the way to communicate the value of cities
and towns to the state's competitiveness; and,
WHEREAS, officials and employees in the City of Orangeburg appreciate the
dedication, passion and service that Howard Duvall has provided for our hometown on
important issues related to our residents and their quality of life; and,
WHEREAS,
retirement from
endeavors.
the City of Orangeburg congratulates Howard Duvall on his
the Municipal Association and wishes him success in his future
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by Orangeburg City Council on this day,
October 7, 2008, that our grateful appreciation be extended to Howard E. Duvall, Jr., for
his dedication and service to our hometown and all of the hometowns in South Carolina
and for his tireless efforts for over twenty-two years, of his thirty-four years of service,
to the Municipal Association of South Carolina on behalf of cities and towns across the
state.
~~-,
Members of Council
~~~~4!:3
c;JIuW
I.
~~~ORANq~-&!
Ii D?U '%
* 0 *tfI ~
0(/ V
l"1t CA'?-O
~
RESOLUTION
A RESOLUTION FOR THE CITY OF ORANGEBURG, DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC
UTILITIES TO ACCEPT THE LOW RESPONSIBLE BID BY RANDY PIGA TE
CONSTRUCTION CO., INC. OF LONGS, SOUTH CAROLINA IN THE AMOUNT OF
$571,595.00 FOR THE RIVERSIDE PUMP STATION UPGRADE AND FORCE MAIN
WHEREAS, the Department of Public Utilities of the City of Orangeburg, South Carolina,
received bids on September 17, 2008 for the Riverside Pump Station Upgrade and Force Main;
and
WHEREAS, the low responsible bid for this work was submitted by Randy Pigate Construction
Co., Inc. of Longs, South Carolina in the amount 0£$571,595.00; and
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, by the Mayor and Members of Council of the City
of Orangeburg, in Council assembled, and by authority of the same, that the low responsible bid
shown above be accepted; and
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that Fred H. Boatwright, Manager of the Department of Public
Utilities, be authorized and he is hereby directed to execute the contract documents on behalf of
the Department of Public Utilities of the City of Orangeburg.
1~RESOLVED BY City Council duly assembled this day of October, 2008.
~~
MAYOR
./
~(..-'--7Z2~
,/
~-
tfiJJw~CITY CLERK.
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
October 21, 2008
Orangeburg City Council held its regularly scheduled meeting on Tuesday, October 21,
2008, at 7:00 P.M., in Council Chambers with Mayor Miller presiding.
PRESENT:
Paul A. Miller, Mayor
Charles B. Barnwell
Bernard Haire
Charles W. Jernigan
Sandra P. Knotts
Trelvis A. Miller
Joyce W. Rheney
A motion was made by Councilmember Jemigan, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell,
to approve the October 7, 2008, City Council Minutes as distributed. This motion was
unanimously approved.
Assistant City Administrator Bronson addressed Council in regards to the Ordinance to
annex described property under the seventy-five percent (75%) petition method. He
stated, "The only changes in the Ordinance are the ones that Council recommended at last
meeting. Those changes would be closely reflective on this map, #38 will be shaded
yellow and #29 will be gray."
Councilmember Barnwell stated, "On #26 and #27, someone is clearing a lot."
Councilmember Miller asked, "Is #26 and #27 coming in as A-I?"
Assistant City Administrator Bronson replied, "Right."
Councilmember Miller stated, "1 think when this Council decided to change the rezoning
on some ofthe parcels on #9, #29, #34, #35 and #32. I believe we didn't take under
consideration that #26 & #27 are by apartments and that should at least be zoned A-2. I
don't know who owns #28, but #27, that whole strip is apartments or some type of multi
family usage. That too, should be zoned A-2. I think this Council really needs to look at
that. I know there has been some talk about clearing of#26."
Assistant City Administrator Bronson stated, "Parcel #26 has had some clearing and #27
is a single-family home."
Councilmember Miller stated, "Right beside that one is a lot of apartments, correct?"
Councilmember Barnwell replied, "No, there is a wooded gap in between and then there
are other apartments."
Assistant City Administrator Bronson stated, "Where you see Casa Court, that is where
there are apartments in the County."
Councilmember Miller responded, " I understand that is in the County, the way we are
annexing, that may be next in line. Regardless, I believe that #26 is running contiguous
with Glenfield Apartments and that should be A-2. Even, if it zoned A-2, they cannot
build commercial property."
Assistant City Administrator Bronson replied, "There is one caveat to that, on #26 and
#27, #6, #4, #21, and #2 are owned by the Patel's or Courtesy Management and they did
not sign the annexation petition. By the Orangeburg City Code, if someone does not sign
the annexation petition, Council is obligated to annex them in as A-I, single-family
residential."
/9/3
ICf/L.}
Page 2
Councilmember Miller asked, "That is not our discretion?"
Assistant City Administrator Bronson replied, "According to the Code, you shall zone it
as A-I."
City Attorney Walsh stated, "You shall zone it as A-I, the property owner can come back
after the annexation to the PlalUlingCommission."
Councilmember Miller asked, "What is the time, can they do that after third reading, the
next day to the Planning Commission and ask to be zoned A-2, could they withdraw their
request to be withdrawn?"
City Attorney Walsh replied, "If they actually signed it originally and withdraw their
signatures, I would have to address the issue if they can withdraw the withdrawal."
Assistant City Administrator Bronson replied, "The petition can be signed for six months
and the petition was initiated March 18, 2008, which would mean the petition ended
September 18, 2008, which would be the last day a signature could be added to the
petition under the 75% method under state law."
City Attorney Walsh stated, "They signed it earlier, but I haven't addressed the issue."
Councilmember Miller asked, "Can we address that issue before next Council Meeting?"
City Attorney Walsh replied, "Yes."
Councilmember Rheney asked, "Why is #26 being cleared?"
Assistant City Administrator Bronson replied, "I have not spoken with the property
owners. I noticed Sunday it was being cleared and I have received many phone calls
from people in the neighborhood asking why it was being cleared."
Councilmember Miller stated, "If there would be some type of agreement in the
community. I know there has been some deep heartbum because no one wanted a
convenience store on #26. I know that anyone who is in business or who has bought real
estate, they want their property to remain valuable. I know one of my colleagues will
say, we should not move the goal line if the person reaches the goal. If someone is
getting potato chips instead of a steak dinner, I think that there should be a compromise
made in the community."
Councilmember Barnwell asked, "You mean put a business there?"
Councilmember Miller stated, "No, not a business in A-2, you couldn't put a business
there. If Glenfield is A-2 or will be A-2, I believe #26 should be A-2 and properties up
the road are a bunch of apartments. I believe that we need to look at that and see if they
would build apartments there and enhance the community. I offer a suggestion to the
Patel's for #7 to look at possibly building townhouses and sell them instead of renting it
whereas to give value to the property and people take ownership in that property. People
would then have a vested interest in the community. Saying that, this could be the
platform of what could come next. So people could see what they are doing to enhance
the community. I think we need to, in all fairness, to offer the Patel's a seat at the table
in a means of negotiation."
Councilmember Barnwell stated, "I'd like to say this, that individuals that built in Spring
Valley, especially Parcel #7, if you have 18 or 26 apartments there, that is going to
destroy the neighborhood and I'd be opposed to it."
Page 3 '.,-':
Councilmember Miller responded, "I definitely agree with you. I think when they gave
the rendering, they were under the gun. I don't think that they thought about what they
are doing and I am not their liaison. I would pretty much say that they were under the
gun. Once again, I will say, I think they want to do something to enhance the
community to facilitate their ideas into the community."
Councilmember Barnwell replied, "If they are going to facilitate it like the property now
inside the City, it should be single-family to conform to what is in Spring Valley now.
What if you lived out there and someone threw up a bunch of apartments there?"
Councilmember Miller responded, "It is not apartments, they are townhouses. What
about properties #32, #31, #30, #33, #35, and #37? Have you even went out there and
looked?"
Councilmember Barnwell stated, "Yes, in fact I was just out there today."
Councilmember Miller stated, "They are investing a ton of money in parcel #1."
Councilmember Barnwell replied, "I agree, but they are building single-family houses."
Councilmember Miller stated, "We are still zoning that A-2."
Councilmernber Barnwell replied, "No, that is A-I."
Councilmember Miller stated, "Parcels #32, #33, #34, #35 and #36 is A-2."
Councilmember Barnwell replied, "As I understand it, that was one ofMr. Horger's
properties and he was going to build a duplex."
Councilmember Miller responded, "What is the difference between a duplex and an
apartment?"
Councilmember Barnwell replied, "In my opinion, a big difference."
Councilmember Miller asked, "What is it?"
Councilmember Barnwell stated, "It's not a condominium type home"
Councilmember Miller asked, "Is he going to rent it?"
Councilmember Barnwell replied, "I have no idea what he plans to do?"
Councilmember Miller asked, "You don't have any idea what he intends to do?"
Councilmember Barnwell stated, "No, I don't."
Councilmember Miller asked, "What if he decides to build a duplex?"
Councilmember Barnwell replied, "I am totally against apartments or condominiums."
Councilmember Miller asks, "What ifhe decides to build a condominium in #34, #35, or
#36, can you stop that?"
Councilmember Barnwell replied, "No, I can't stop that."
Councilmember Miller stated, "He is also zoned A-2."
Councilmember Barnwell stated, " I think Mr. Horger is a man of his word and he said he
was going to build apartments."
1'1 IS"
jqlf;
Page 4
Councilmember Miller stated, "Are you trying to say that the people of#26 and #27 are
not men of their word? We are attorney's here. Let's be frank, let's be candid. We are
telling these people that we are going to be able to dictate to them what they can and
cannot build. Tum around and tell #34, #35 and #36 that whatever you tell us you are
going to build, we believe you as long as there is this pie in the sky."
Councilmember Barnwell stated, "I said, I believe Mr. Horger is a man of his word."
Councilmember Miller stated, "Why wouldn't the Patel's be a man oftheir word, we
need to get to know them, they are in that community."
Councilmember Barnwell stated, "I am not in favor for anything other than what I said."
Councilmember Miller stated, "Then ya'll all need to zone everything AI."
Mayor Miller asked, "Zone what?"
Councilmember Miller responded, "Parcels #34, #35, #36, #28, #37, #31, #30, #32, #31,
#27, and #26, it all needs to be zoned A-I."
Mayor Miller asked, "Mr. Bronson, the properties that are adjacent to the Family Life
Center on Harris Street, are those duplexes?"
Assistant City Administrator Bronson replied, "Those are all duplexes."
Mayor Miller stated, "In essence, those would be grandfathered in because they are all
duplexes, correct?"
Assistant City Administrator Bronson replied, "Yes."
Mayor Miller stated, "The proposal or motion that Councilmember Jernigan made was to
bring those in as A-2 and to bring in the Family Life Center and the church as Office
Institutional and to change from A-I to A-2, the Longwood Nursing Home, which is what
it is anyway."
Assistant City Administrator Bronson replied, "Yes."
Mayor Miller stated, "Versus raw land, that was not even on the petition, which is what
Councilmember Miller is referring to anyway."
Assistant City Administrator Bronson stated, "I think so."
Mayor Miller stated, "I am not trying to trip anyone up. I am trying to get a sense of
what is going on in my mind. I believe that #4, #6, #7 and possibly #28 and #27 did not
sign the petition to come into the City, is that correct?"
Assistant City Administrator Bronson stated, "Parcel #27 is a single-family residence and
they did sign to come in as A-I. Parcel #28 is vacant property and the property owner
did sign to come in as A-2. Parcels #4, #6 and #7 are owned by Mr. Patel and Courtesy
Management that he initially signed for and withdrew from the petition."
Mayor Miller stated, "Each of the properties that Councilmember Jernigan made in his
motion was recommended by the Planning Commission to be changed to get them to
conform to what they are anyway, correct?"
Assistant City Administrator Bronson replied, "Yes, based on the signatures on the
petition."
Page 5
Mayor Miller stated, "The Nursing Home asked to come in as A-2, which is the proper
designation as it should have been and the church asked to come in as Office
Institutional and the people that owned the duplexes asked to come in as A-2."
Assistant City Administrator Bronson stated, "Those who owned the duplexes that signed
the petition."
Councilmember Miller asked, "Did #28 go A-2 or A-I?"
Assistant City Administrator Bronson stated, "Parcel #28 asked to come in as A-2 on the
petition; Mr. Jernigan did not include them in his motion so they will be staying as A
l,which is what is in your Ordinance right now."
Councilmember Miller stated, "The Mayor posed a great question, what is on #34, #35,
and #36, are there homes there?"
Assistant City Administrator Bronson replied, "On #34 and #35 there are duplexes and
#36 is vacant."
Councilmember Miller stated, "So, it is raw land?"
Assistant City Administrator Bronson, "There is no building on it, I can't say if there are
any trees on it or not. That area from #30 and #37, in between Harris and Dibble Streets,
has restricted covenants that allow for single-family residences or duplexes. [fyou are
familiar with the properties that are out there from the front, they do not look like
duplexes they look like single-family residences."
Councilmember Miller stated, "I am not disputing that, bottom line; if they knock those
structures down tomorrow, they can build high-rises."
Councilmember Barnwell stated, "Not according to the restricted covenants."
Assistant City Administrator Bronson stated, "They can build duplexes, I am not
schooled in covenant restrictions."
Councilmember Miller stated, "They can build duplexes, I have got five attorneys up here
now."
Mayor Miller replied, "Where are the attorneys?"
Councilmember Miller stated, "Everyone is answering my question that I am directing to
Kevin."
Assistant City Administrator Bronson replied, "Which properties?"
Councilmember Miller responded, "Parcels #34, #35, and #36."
Assistant City Administrator Bronson stated, "As Council voted the first time, they can
build duplexes."
Councilmember Miller stated, "Once again, we cannot control what is being built on #34,
#35 and #36 regardless, we know that Attorney Horger, is a man of his word, as Buddy
says and I know he is a fine gentleman. However, we need to open up the
communications with the owners of#28, #7 and #26 and #27 if possible to A-2."
Assistant City Administrator Bronson replied, "Just for clarification #27 requested A-I."
Councilmember Miller stated, "I am just saying, [just threw that out there. I thought the
attorney was going to look since they did sign the petition."
JC11'7
JCj/q
Page 6
City Attorney Walsh replied, "Yes, I would have to go back through the files."
Mayor Miller stated, "The fact of the matter is that #4, #6, #7 and #26 did not sign the
petition, they withdrew."
Assistant City Administrator Bronson replied, "Yes, along with a few other properties."
Councilmember Miller stated, "If the attorney comes back and said that they can and
forfeit, can that be placed back on the petition to be zoned A-2? We would need to
consider that."
Councilmember Rheney asked, "It would still have to go back to the Planning
Commission, right?"
Assistant City Administrator Bronson stated, "The final zoning is Council's prerogative,
the Planning Commission just made a recommendation."
Councilmember Jernigan stated, "Would this have to go back to them if we passed this
Ordinance? Ifwe annexed them in as A-I and they wanted to change the zoning, they
would have to go back to the Planning Commission?"
Assistant City Administrator Bronson replied, "Any property owner who wishes to have
their zoning changed, they can initiate that back through the Planning Commission."
Councilmember Jernigan stated, "They do have an appeal process in taking it back to the
Planning Commission with their plans and letting them know what they want to build
and letting the Planning Commission decide."
City Administrator Yow stated, "One thing we need to clarify is that plans aren't
necessary approved along with the zoning."
Councilmember Jernigan stated, "I think it just proves what they intend to do and adds
credibility."
Councilmember Miller stated, "I think we are stepping on thin ice with that. [know the
Patel's and they have built several hotels on Highway 601, can you name one of them
that look like crap? He stated that it brings credibility to what they intend to build, those
are his words. [fwe are going to get over this, let's get over this hump."
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Jernigan
to approve the Second Reading of an Ordinance to annex the within described property
under the seventy-five percent (75%) petition method. This was a 4-3 vote as Mayor Pro
Tern Haire, Councilmembers Knotts and Miller opposed.
A motion was made by Councilmember Jernigan, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell,
to approve the Second Reading of an Ordinance to amend the Municipal District Map
dated November 6, 2001, for the purpose of adding newly annexed City property to
Municipal Council District #2. This was a 4-3 vote as Mayor Pro Tem Haire,
CounciImembers Miller and Knotts opposed.
A motion was made by Councilmember Rheney, seconded by Councilmember Jernigan,
to approve authorization for the City Administrator to accept Community Highway
Safety Program Grant "Traffic Records Enhancement" in the amount of $30,800 with a
local match of $7,700. This motion was unanimously approved.
Page 7
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to
approve authorization for the City Administrator to accept a Methamphetamine Initiative
Grant in the amount of $280,590 with no local match required. This motion was
unanimously approved.
There were no utility matters brought before Council.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, seconded by Councilmember Jernigan, to
adjourn.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
Respectfully submitted,
~J~~
City Clerk
CWJ/pfb
1919
1920
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
NOVEMBER 4, 2008
Orangeburg City Council held its regularly scheduled meeting on Tuesday, November 4,
2008, at 7:00 P.M., in Council Chambers with Mayor Miller presiding.
PRESENT:
Paul A. Miller, Mayor
Charles B. Barnwell
Bernard Haire
Charles w. Jernigan
Sandra P. Knotts
Trelvis A. Miller
Joyce W. Rheney
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Jernigan,
to enter into an Executive Session for a legal matter concerning the annexation/zoning!
Spring Valley/Columbia Road. This motion was unanimously approved.
Council returned to Open Session.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, seconded by Councilmember Knotts, to
approve the October 21, 2008, City Council Minutes as distributed. This motion was
unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Council member Jernigan,
to postpone agenda Items #3 and #4 based on legal information received regarding these
matters. This motion was unanimously approved.
Chief Wendell Davis accepted the Character Trait Proclamation for November 2008,
"Generosity".
Mr. Mike Sells, Administration Director for the Department of Public Utilities, addressed
Council in regards to the Safety Resolution as recommended by SC Municipal Insurance
Trust.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to
approve a Resolution adopting the Department of Public Utilities Safety Program. This
motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tem Haire, seconded by Councihnember Barnwell, to
adjourn. This motion was unanimously approved.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
Respectfully submitted,
~.
Carrie W. Johns
City Clerk
CWJ/pfb
,>.~~ORANG~<s>
~ D?U '%,
* 0 *(Jl ~
°v VI"ft cP,,?>o
~
RESOLUTION ADOPTING
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC UTILITIES SAFETY PROGRAM
WHEREAS, the Department of Public Utilities, City of Orangeburg, South Carolina, realizes that it has
the responsibility of providing a safe work environment for its employees and that each employee must
pursue the highest standards in his/her assigned activities and that all Department employees must
recognize that their own health aud well-being as well as that of their co-workers and the protection of
our human resources, are as important as the activity and job being performed; and
WHEREAS, the Department of Public Utilities has established and maintains a Loss Control
Management Program and expects its employees to respond to loss control efforts and to perform their
assigned job in accordance with all applicable safety rules and regulations; and,
WHEREAS, the Department of Public Utilities has established a Safety Committee, chaired by the
Manager or his/her designee; and whose members include Division Directors, the Maintenance Facility
Supervisor, one additional representative from each Division including the Maintenance Facility,
(appointed by each Director); and, a representative from Human Resources,
WHEREAS, the Safety Committee shall continuously strive to improve the loss control efforts and
operational efficiency of the Department of Public Utilities by adopting and updating safety rules and
policies, safety audits, accident investigations and reviews, identifying loss trends, potential losses and
safety training needs; and,•
WHEREAS, each Division Director and Supervisor will be responsible for the safety of its employees
and protection of human resources in his/her division as well as the necessary safety and maintenance of
facilities and equipment in his/her area of responsibility; and,
WHEREAS, each Department employee will be responsible for his/her own personal safety, and for the
protection of assigned equipment or facilities; and,
WHEREAS, the Department of Public Utilities, Orangeburg, South Carolina is committed to doing all
in its authority and responsibility to ensure its Loss Control Management Program is a success and
expects the Manager, Division Directors and Department employees to assist in this endeavor by
contributing effort and expeltise.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, by the Mayor and members of City Council this twenty
first day of October 2008, in Orangeburg, South Carolina that the Department of Public Utilities will
endeavor to provide a work environment free of recognized hazards through the establishment and
implementation of loss control policies and procedures, and their subsequent amendments and additions,
designed to provide protection to City employees, public and private property, and members of the
public.
k~~
PASSED BY the City Council of the City of Orangeburg, State of South Carolina, this 4'h day of
November, 2008.
MAYOR
.J~_ '
({mn ~CI~£fJt~)
CITY COUNCIL MINUES
NOVEMBER 18, 2008
Orangeburg City Council held its regularly scheduled m eeting on Tuesday, November
18, 2008, at 5:30 P.M., in Council Chambers with Mayor Miller presiding.
PRESENT:
Paul A. Miller, Mayor
Charles B. Barnwell
Bernard Haire
Charles W. Jernigan
Sandra P. Knotts
Joyce W. Rheney
ABSENT:
Trelvis A. Miller
A motion was made by Councilmember Jernigan, seconded by Mayor Pro Tem Haire, to
approve the November 4, 2008 City Council minutes as distributed. This motion was
unanimously approved.
Mr. Buster Smith, Director of Parks & Recreation, addressed Council. He stated that
the City has been marketing the Children’s Garden’s Christmas drive through and
Kid’s Walk with rack cards and also previewed to Council a thirty second commercial
that will be airing on television stations in Columbia and Charleston between now and
Christmas. He thanked several City Departments and the Department of Public Utilities
for their assistance in this project.
Assistant City Administrator Bronson addressed Council in regards to an upcoming lease
purchase or master lease agreement. He stated, “Th is is to do a lease purchase for some
of our capital items that were put in the budget for this year. We put this out in the middle
of October, which was a chaotic time in the financial market. We are very pleased with
the bids . First Citizens Bank came in with the lowest interest rate. While other
municipalities were only receiving one bid under an average interest rate of 4%, we did
well with our local bank. The finance rate from First Citizens is for $409,084 at 2.65 %
for three years and $627,250 for 3.01% for five years.”
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Rheney,
to approve a Resolution authorizing the execution and delivery of a Master Lease
Agreement. This motion was unanimously approved.
Mayor Miller made a motion to table item #4, on the agenda, relating to the closing of
Gibson Street within the city limits based on discussions and questions. This motion was
seconded by Mayor Pro Tem Haire and unanimously approved.
There were no utility matters brought before Council.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tem Haire, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell, to
adjourn. This motion was unanimously approved.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
Respectfully submitted,
Carrie W. Johnson
City Clerk
CWJ/pfb
A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE EXECUTION AND DELIVERY OF A MASTER
LEASE AGREEMENT, EQUIPMENT SCHEDULE, AND ESCROW AGREEMENT,
AND RELATED INSTRUMENTS, AND DETERMINING OTHER MATTERS IN
CONNECTION THEREWITH.
BE IT RESOLVED by the governing body of the City of Orangeburg (the "Lessee"), at a duly called
meeting of the governing body held on the 18th of November 2008, the following resolution was
introduced and adopted:
RESOLVED, whereas the governing body of Lessee has determined that a true and very real need exists
for the acquisition of Various Equipment as described in the Request for Proposal (the "Equipment"), the
Lessee desires to finance the Equipment, in the amount of$ 409,084.00 at 2.65% APR for three (3) years,
and $ 627,250.00 at 3.01% for five (5) years, by entering into an Equipment Lease Purchase Agreement
with First Citizens as Lessor and the City of Orangeburg as Lessee (the "Agreement") according to the
terms set forth in the Bid Proposal from First Citizens, presented at the board meeting; and the Equipment
will be used by the Lessee for the following purpose: To provide new and cost efficient equipment for
the operation of City government.
RESOLVED, whereas the governing body of Lessee has taken the necessary steps including any legal
bidding requirements, under applicable law to arrange for the acquisition of such equipment.
RESOLVED, whereas the governing body hereby directs its legal counsel to review the Agreement and
negotiate appropriate modifications to said Agreement so as to assure compliance with state law and local
statutory law, prior to execution of the Agreement by those persons so authorized by the governing body
for such purpose.
BE IT RESOLVED, by the governing body of the lessee that:
The terms of said Agreement are in the best interests of Lessee for the acquisition of such Equipment and
the governing body of Lessee designates and confirms the following person(s) to execute and deliver, and
to witness (or attest), respectively, the Agreement and any related documents necessary to the
consummation ofthe translations contemplated by the Agreement.
Name and Title of Person(s) to Execute Agreement:
John H. Yow, City Administrator
RESOLVED, the Lessee covenants that it will perform all acts within its power which are or may be
necessary to insure that the interest portion of the Rental Payments coming due under the Agreement will
at all times remain exempt from federal income taxation under the laws and regulations of the United
States of America as presently enacted and construed or as hereafter amended. The Lessee hereby
certifies that it has not issued or effected the issuance of, and reasonably anticipates that it shall not issue
or effect the issuance of more that ten million dollars (10,000,000.00) of tax-exempt obligations during
the calendar year, and hereby designates the Agreement as a "qualified tax exempt obligation", as defined
by Section 265 (b)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986, as amended.
The undersigned further certifies that the above resolution has not been repealed or amended and remains
in full force and effect and further certifies that the above and foregoing Agreement is the same as
presented at said meeting ofthe governing body of Lessee.
Passed by the City Council of the City of Orangeburg, South Carolina this
18
th
of November 2008.
~
k.~
Paul A. Miller, MayorI __
(~~~~
1922
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
DECEMBER 2, 2008
Orangeburg City Council held a Public Hearing on Tuesday, December 2, 2008 , at 7:00
P.M, in Council Chambers with Mayor Miller presiding. The purpose of the Public
Hearing was for consideration of an Ordinance to amend Section 24-11.10 and 24-11.11
in article VII of the Code of Ordinances for the City of Orangeburg, SC by renumbering
same.
Assistant City Administrator Kevin Bronson addressed Council. He stated, "When we
modify the Zoning Ordinance, we are required to take it to the Planning Commission and
hold a Public Hearing. Once it comes to you, we hold another Public Hearing and it
requires three affirnlative readings on your part. Back in the early part of this year, the
Planning Commission asked for staff to come back with language on residential parking
restrictions. I worked with the City Administrator, City Attorney and the Zoning
Administrator and we took some language to the Planning Commission that dealt with
parking restrictions in residential areas. Ultimately, at the September Planning
Commission Meeting, they decided they would table that language. They thought it was
too restrictive. As part of that process, the City Attorney found out that we have had at
least two items that have been in our Zoning Ordinance at least since 2000, maybe even
longer that were in section 24-11 which is entitled "general provisions" which should be
in Article VII, Application and Development Standards for off street parking and loading
areas. This is just a matter of two articles not put in the best place they could be put.
The City Attorney went through the language and the only thing that was changed was a
few words in 24-7.4, as you see in front of you, where it states that such vehicle and any
boat that used to read equipment. We took out equipment and entered vehicle and any
boat just to be ultra clear. We also changed where it states a period of thirty-six (36)
hours it used to be twenty-four (24) hours. Some people say that was not long enough so
we put in thirty-six (36) hours. The rest of the language in the zoning Ordinance is the
same and it has been on the books for quite some time. I know some people think this is
something new, it is not. It is enforced through complaint compliance. From time to
lime, the Zoning Administrator gets complaints on RV's blocking driveways and such
and this is what he uses to go out and ask them to move the RV. This is not something
we have a bearing problem with. What we are asking tonight is that we renumber this to
put it in the appropriate section."
City Attorney Walsh stated, "There is one other change, in Section 24-7.5A, we added
streets because in PDD's, we have streets that do not front on a public street."
Mr. George Green of 1677 Columbia Road addressed Council. He stated, "I have owned
an RV for 10 to 15 years and when I bought on Columbia Road with one acre of land, 1
had no knowledge of this Ordinance. I think that some of this language in here should
have some circumstances on how much property you own, how close an RV is to the
street or whether it is blocking traffic. None of those apply to me. It seems you should
be doing things for people to save money, not spend money. The RV which costs almost
as much as my house to store it, is not acceptable. I am opposed to this Ordinance.
Where I live, there are businesses there. Right across the street is Nunnie Smith and he
has cars and boats out there all the time. My Motor Home sits at least 40 feet from the
road."
Mayor Miller stated, "You may already meet the set-backs."
Councilmember Jernigan asked, "Has anyone complained to you about your RV in your
yard?"
Mr. Green responded, "No, I have not, in fact someone from Wells Drive told me lo be
here tonight."
Mr. Rolly Williamson of Seminole Avenue addressed Council. He stated, "Sometimes
we have to take our local paper with a grain of salt. Sometimes the truth eventually
Page 2
comes out one way or another. This Ordinance we are discussing really doesn't affect
me. [have a motor home, which is enclosed in a metal building and I do not have a boat
over 17 feel. There are quite a few in the city limits in Orangeburg. I was just wondering
if ten years ago there wasn't much need for this, ifit wasn't enforced. There is no need
to have it, if we aren't enforcing it. The property taxes, like they are now, like Mr. Green
probably pays pretty good city taxes just to have a motor home. These people with 50,
60, or 100 thousand dollar boats sitting in the yard get a knock on the door from the City
saying that the boat has got to go. Where is it going? We have no storage facilities
around here. That might be a good business to get into. What are the ramifications on
something like this? Can we afford to do away with those property taxes on these boats
and RV's? ] am going to tell you, just ride around Orangeburg with that idea in mind,
look in the yards and look how many you see there. Do we really want to get into this
type of Ordinance? Unless it is dilapidated, an eyesore or a problem, what are you going
to tell someone, that thier $50,000 boat or RV in their yard has got to go, you live in
Orangeburg. Does anyone want to respond?"
Mayor Miller responded, "The Ordinance has been intact for a number of years and it has
been enforced a handful of times. What Mr. Bronson said is that it is a tool that we can
use in nuisance situations. That doesn't mean that everyone who has an RV will get a
visit in the morning because they are not getting a visit now. Unless it is a nuisance in
the neighborhood that is causing someone a problem, otherwise they are not going out."
City Administrator Yow stated, "]n cases] can remember, some situations are when the
RV is parked and blocking the driveway or next to a property line or where people were
living in them."
Mr. Williamson stated, "That is understandable, if you are blocking the view. The way]
read the Ordinance is that you can't do that, it's got to go."
City Administrator Yow stated, "No, ifit meets the setbacks where it is not blocking the
view, you can have one."
Mayor Miller stated, "It doesn't say you can't have one. It probably won't affect Mr.
Green and won't affect many people. It hasn't been an issue. We are only talking about
changing some numbers. It has been an Ordinance and if we change it, we have to go
with a Public Hearing and three readings. I am not saying that I don't have some
concerns about it myself. Ifit isn't broke, we don't fix it."
Councilmember Barnwell asked, "Mr. Yow what is the setbacks?"
City Administrator Yow stated, "I am looking for that now. All we have ever enforced
is, if it is up against the property line or blocking the view if someone pulls out on the
street. ] don't know if we ever have gone out and pulled a tape measure to see if
someone is 7 or 9 feet from the line."
Jennifer and Stuart Haig addressed Council. Mrs. Haig stated, "It seems there is a
discretionary enforcement. We have an 18 foot camper that we try to use frequently.
Currently, it is being kept at our in-laws. With the thirty-six (36) hour mle, that seems
impractical for people who work full time who may pick it up on a Saturday to use the
next weekend. If someone calls on Wednesday that we have had it there for three days, it
kinds of concerns us. I have researched storage areas and there are none. If we had to
store it, it would place a burden financially on the citizens who are already paying City
taxes on the property. Ifwe pay taxes, why can't we have it on our property? We can't
put it in our backyard. We have a carport and we have trees on the other side. Anyway,
you look at it, I am not very sure any of us were aware of this Ordinance. We have
worked so hard for this and we are hearing we may not be able to keep it on our property.
When is it going to be enforced? When we can't have it here? If a neighbor down the
street doesn't want it there and calls when our next door neighbor doesn't mind, how is
that going to affect us having it there?"
,qJ..3
Iqd-.Lf
Page 3
Diane Weeks of Riley Street addressed Council. "We have a 35 foot camper and a large
hedge. Now, I am wondering is that a set back? Is it back far enough from the road? I
don't have a fence around my back yard. That concerns me, who is going to make
decisions on the setbacks. I pay taxes on my property and am a law abiding citizen and
this law has been on the books for ten years and now someone comes up with something
that now they want to put it with something else. I feel for this young couple. Camping
is my sanity trips and if I have to pay $50 a month to store my camper and go to Santee
and get it and bring it back and forth, it's not worth it."
City Admininistrator Yow stated, "This does not apply to back yards."
Ms. Weeks replied, "lfI pull it out to get it ready and it's out there, that means I have to
make sure it is not out there longer than 36 hours."
Mayor Miller relied, "If you aren't blocking the view and not causing a problem, there
isn't an issue."
Ms. Weeks replied, "As long as someone likes me they won't call, but if! make them
mad, they may call. If I have an eyesore, then yes, the City has a responsibility to make
my property look better. I pay monthly mortgage payments and city and county taxes.
We elect officials and they need to see that this is one of those stupid rules, think about
it."
David McCall of 331 Brookside addressed Council. "I think everyone else has said
everything that needs to be said. I have an $85,000 motor home which is my second one
for about twenty years. It is beside my house. Is the setback the footage from the
street?"
City Administrator Yow replied, "The way I read it, it is three feet from the side, unless
it is blocking the view near a property line."
Mayor Miller stated, "Then, you are fine."
Mayor Pro Tem Haire stated concerns about tabling the issue based on the concerns from
the citizens.
Hearing no further comments, the Public Hearing was closed.
Council entered into the regularly scheduled meeting.
PRESENT:
Paul A. Miller, Mayor
Charles W. Barnwell
Bernard Haire
Charles W. Jernigan
Sandra P. Knotts
Joyce W. Rheney
ABSENT:
Tl'elvis A. Miller
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Knotts,
to approve he November 18, 2008 City Council Minutes as distributed. This motion was
unanimously approved.
Mayor Miller presented a Proclamation to Julian and Evelyn Stroman for beginning a
tradition of creating an expansive and beautiful Christmas display at their residence on
Old Riley Street which attracts thousands of visitors from the greater Oranegburg area
and out of town visitor as well.
Page 4
DPS Director Wendell Davis accepted the Character Trait Proclamation for the month of
December 2008, "Punctuality".
Mayor Pro Tern Haire made a motion to table agenda item #4, First Reading of an
Ordinance to amend Section 24-11.10 and 24-11.11 in Article VII of the Code of
Ordinances for the City of Orangeburg, SC by renumbering same, seconded by
Councilmember Barnwell. This motion was unanimously approved. City staff was ask
to go back based on the comments and concerns expressed, and redo this Ordinance to
make it more palatable.
Buster Smith, P&R Director, presented to Council the recommendations from the City
Accommodations Tax Advisory Committee. They are as follows:
-Orangeburg County Chamber of Commerce be designated as the lead agency
for the City
-Orangeburg County Fine Arts Center-$2,500-Billboards and ads promoting
Showcase Orangeburg
-City of Orangeburg Parks and Recreation Department-$1,800-TV homepage ad
and rack cards for the Children's Garden Christmas
-Orangeburg County Chamber ofCommerce-$6,350-Vistor Guide, FAM Tours,
visitor's packets and public relations and tourism
-Orangeburg Festival of Roses-$5,000-Promotion of the festival through TV
commercials and other media
A motion was made by Councilmember Rheney, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, to
approve the recommendations of the City Accommodations Tax Advisory Committee.
This motion was unanimously approved.
City Administrator Yow addressed Council. "As Council knows, in the most recent
budget cycle for FY 08-09, we projected the tax millage rate at 88 mills based on the
estimated value of a mill of $34,974. As Council knows, the County has conducted
property reassessment. The new value of a mill is $36,448. In accordance to State Law,
we would calculate the rollback millage as shown in your package. We would
recommend adjusting it from 88 mills to 84 mills which takes in the growth factor and
CPI, meaning 84.6 mills. We have not previously rounded the millage or set paltial
millage but that is Council's prerogative. I would recommend, ifit meets your approval,
to roll back the millage to 84 mills."
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, seconded by Councilmember Barnwell,
to approve adjusting the City's millage from 88 mills to 84 mills. This motion was
unanimously approved.
There were no utility matters brought before Council.
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, to
approve entering into an Executive Session for a legal matter concerning
annexation/zoning/Spring Valley/Columbia Road. This motion was unanimously
approved.
A motion was made by Barnwell, seconded by Jernigan, to adjourn. This motion as
unanimously approved.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.
1925
Cordially yours,
tGJDuJ.·m~)ylO"--
Carrie W. JO~;;' v
City Clerk!
19~6
City Council Minutes
December 16, 2008
Orangeburg City Council held its regularly scheduled meeting on Tuesday, December 16,
2008, at 7:00 P.M., in Council Chambers Building with Mayor Miller presiding.
PRESENT:
Paul A. Miller, Mayor
Charles B. Barnwell
Bernard Haire
Charles W. Jernigan
Sandra P. Knotts
Joyce W. Rbeney
ABSENT:
Trelvis A. Miller
A motion was made by Councilmember Barnwell, seconded by Councilmember Rheney,
to enter into an Executive Session for a legal matter concerning annexation/zoning/Spring
Valley, Columbia Road/Longwood Street and Agreements pertaining to same. This
motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tem Haire, seconded by Councilrnember Barnwell,
for Council to return to Open Session. This motion was unanimously approved.
A motion was Mayor Pro Tern Haire, seconded by Councilmember Jernigan, to approve
the December 2,2008, City Council Minutes as distributed. This motion was
unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Mayor Miller, seconded by Mayor Pro Tem Haire, to cancel the
January 6, 2009, City Council Meeting. This motion was unanimously approved.
City Administrator Yow addressed Council in regards to an Agreement with Courtesy
Management and Patel and Rao Apartments. He stated, "The discussion ofthe
Agreement first originated with Courtesy Management's asssertion of vested rights in the
proposed annexation on their properties. The asssertion of vested rights are based on the
County's site approval, building permits and clearing pennits. City Council, after a
thorough and legal review, determined it would be in the best interest of the proposed
annexation area to enter into a discussion on compromised uses of the parcels in question.
The Agreement we are presenting to Council tonight is between Courtesy Management
and Patel and Rao Apartments and the City. There are four parcels of land in question.
One is on Columbia Road, which is currently under construction as a convenience store
site. Two other parcels are at the entrance of Spring Valley and the other one is at the
comer of Columbia Road and Longwood. The Agreement before you proposes that
these parcels would be annexed in the City. The site currently under construction as a
convenience store would be annexed in as A-2. The construction would then cease. The
two sites at the entrance of Spring Valley would be annexed as A-I, which is as currently
proposed on the annexation petition and Ordinance. The site on Columbia Road and
Longwood would be annexed as A-2. That would require an Agreement between the
City and Courtesy Management allowing them to rescind their withdrawal of signatures
on the petition and resign the petition. In this Agreement, it would also cover that the
development of this site would be coordinated in compliance with the City Zoning
Ordinance. Any site development, or permits needed would be approved by the City.
Also, Courtesy Management reserves the right, if their development plan does not meet
the approval of the City, to proceed with their plan. as they have now. If that happens,
we will have to address that at that time."
Page 2
December 16, 2008
A motion was made by Councilmember Rheney, seconded by Councilmember Jernigan,
to approve the authorization for the City Administrator to execute an Agreement
concerning development of property of Courtesy Management, Inc., and Patel and Rao
Apartments, LLC on Columbia Road and Longwood Street. This motion was
unanimously approved.
Councilmember Jemigan stated, "I would like to thank the City staff and the Patel's for
their hard work and I hope that this Agreement will be beneficial to everyone and that
this will be something that will continue in the future"
1927
Mr. Jim Meggs, Atlomey, addressed Council, "I would like to thank Mayor, Council City
Staff and the community for this result. On behalf of the Patel's, they are looking
forward to doing something of quality nature for the City."
Assistant City Administrator Bronson addressed Council in regard to the 75% petition
method. He stated, "The Ordinance is amended to include the parcels 0174-09-02-003
and 0174-09-03-012 as A-2."
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tem Haire, seconded by Councilmember Jemigan, to
approve the Third Reading of an Ordinance to annex the within described property under
the seventy-five (75%) petition method. This motion as unanimously approved.
A motion was made by Councilmember Bamwell, seconded by Councilmember, to
approve the Third Reading of an Ordinance to anlend the MlUlicipal District Map dated
November 6, 200 I, for the purpose of adding newly annexed City property to Municipal
Council District Two (2). This motion was unanimously approved.
Mayor Miller welcomed the newly alUlexed area into the City.
There were no utility matters brought before Council.
A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Haire, seconded by Councilrnember Rheney, to
adjou111.
There being no fUl1her business, the meeting was adjoumed.
d
Respectfu,llYsUb~,
aJ1u(J~
arrie W. John3-on
City Clerk
CWJ/pfb
c;J
Source: City of Orangeburg website. First collected Oct 13, 2026.