RecordWell Data

Minutes

City of Orangeburg · Orangeburg County · Minutes

Open the original document More from City of Orangeburg

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

356 Orangeburg January 5, presiding. CITY COUNCIL MINUTES JANUARY 5, 1988 City Council held its regularly scheduled meeting on 1988 in City Hall Chambers at 7:00 P.M. Mayor Pendarvis PRESENT: E. O. Pendarvis, Mayor W. Everette Salley, Mayor Pro Tern Henry F. Frierson Sara H. Alexander Herbert W. Bradley, Jr. A motion was made by Councilmember Bradley, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Salley, unanimously approved the December 15, 1987 City Council Minutes as distributed. Mr. Wes Pickens, Ms. Jeannine Kees, Captain Harold Carter and Mr. Austin Cunningham presented information to Council on Orangeburg County Crimestoppers. Ms. Kees informed council that January 17th through January 23rd, 1988 is the week set aside for a fund rising drive and to provide the public with information and recognition of the Crimestoppers program. Captain Carter of the public Safety Department informed Council that since the program's inception in May 1986, four hundred and two (402) code numbers have been issued and two hundred and twenty-six (226) cases have been solved. He informed Council of the possible monies that may be received back to the local governments once the drug related cases are processed through the courts. He stated that if cases go through the state court the maximum amount that could be received back is 10%. If the Drug Enforcement Administration (DEA) is involved and the cases go through federal court we can get anywhere from 75% to 90% of the monies back. Mr. Cunningham requested $7,500 from the City and $7,500 from the county out of the aforementioned confiscated funds and property. He stated that they would like to receive 50% of all funds that are returned. Chairman, Wes Pickens, made a formal request of Council for $7,500. A motion was made by Mayor Pendarvis, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Salley, unanimously approved to provide this $7,500 out of confiscated funds and property. Attorney James F. Walsh informed Council that on January 19, 1988 Mr. Roy Bates and Mr. Bobby Bowers would like to meet with Council for an executive session at 5:00 P.M. with a Public Hearing following at 7:00 P.M. to discuss the Single Member District Plan. A motion by Mayor Pendarvis, seconded by Councilmember Bradley, unanimously approved this request. Concerning the recent presentation by representatives of the Aetna about employee's hospitalization insurance, Mayor Pro Tern Salley made a motion, seconded by Councilmember Frierson, unanimously approved to accept "Plan E" where the City would pick up the total increase on employees and retirees with the employee picking up one-half of the dependent increase cost this year with the balance of one-half being picked up next year. This would make the employee pay one-half of all dependent cost after next year. This motion also included the initiation of a study for future planning in regards to insurance for employees. A motion was made by Councilmember Frierson, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Salley, unanimously approved to pay the City's portion of the re-roofing at the Law Enforcement Complex with the acceptance of the low bid of $166,668 from Palmetto State Roofing and SM Company in Greenville plus approximately $31,000 in contingency and fees with total estimated cost being $197,668. The City budgeted $48,960 in the FY 87-88 budget for our share. __ ' A motion by Councilmember Frierson, seconded by Councilmember Alexander, unanimously approved to accept the low bid of $9,848.55 from Central Chevrolet in Columbia for the purchase of a 1988 one-half ton pick-up truck for use in the Service Department. I ! d 1-.1 fL UI Cli " " r;-~l (S) ((I r-'--J I ~I IF) u-, r") 0 (0 Co L ..J w r- =, 0... Q; ;'1 l~l c:i " r-< w =, f- "" m , If) r-< , f- U 0 I j i) "j l 1 j (,1 j 0, "1 " II) n., {) 'U " " Cd ~{ c, ,~ ['. .:> rn 1"1 In ~! I) , , 1', r;1 (,1 ,", H ~ ~ "" ,0 r, ! " '" :1 f~f til "j " H t-' " 1--1 H r' .C) (J H " In .. , fl, '" 0 l-I 0 (:. r< .. { n, ~Ll (I [' , ;~ '-I [, H U in !_:\ ',,1 p .,1 " :11\ n , " "I (\, ('J ~ C' , ' f" (,'j 0 '--' ().~ "J 1 __ 1 H d~ P, n. c' (,) :1. ;-:~ 1;1 (fl (i (fJ [j Ul '" ill (; UJ b-l p "j >.0 ?~ I' I'l 11 o TI , , ,>< i" " .-,1 t--> Q ,:'-1 m c). ~~ tl ' I 0 &i S~ E~ ,-, () ~; If' ~~ ,q e-J, q, ',' r.·; 1'1 ~l r; 1 1< I' . ()~ () y~ ., r:J ::::; >, ~, V. ", .:II ' 'J ,; " ?j • 1 0 f;j H :--1 (/1 >lTI E-I l't , {~ ['I jJ I_I ", ,-, nl .,-, I·, ri: I-J u 0 H i) !-) 1', ,n [of (I c,~ ,~) fil r' f.=-',! ,., 1:) 'n u ( , (;I r-:'! H . ) p' u " ~J. ,,1 n, rn ",:~ fI; fd F ,-) 1"1., ( 'I ;j n. Ci rq 111 p ':(', ,". I'J 7 () , ' r r ~ "I ld L"· It, l~' ~~-J ," fd (-I :3 fl ~. ' -, ,1 ". (\1 UJ (, f 'J I' 1;, rr:j '-7- 0 ,." " I ~'i, ,.( \ ' (, n, U} CL ,d "l " 11 , ,,) 0 I) hI () lf~ ~ .:1 ". ,-I W' P C} {)(-~ f,j ? ? c) ,I ~i. ~~1 (('I o. ", 1"\ ~! . " 'u _,I ,,' ", ., (' , oj, ( :- .J ("J (,'} , ,I' C') ", , ) '" '" , '" , , , '" '" .J;- ,j) 1/\ ." ,n r\·~ ._,Ti ".;~ ,0 u ,n O~l ", I '<:II " I If) , '0 1 () C) D I In ,.~ I (0 I ,-, "j I') 1O ",,) \0 0> CJ> U} If> (f) U> ~() -- " i ;.1,'1 1'; i_') In CO f'l "r (I) "1 10 CI It) CJ 10 ," N In ~o '" , ,. (") N ~(} C) v; ~.:-) C) 1<) (0,] '" '.I' I d n ll;. '" m {f, '" </, UI , m <\. '1 , ( ., « • iI u 'I ;n " ~fl II> :;' , • " II) m ." <l) I, 'Il iJJ fh . .. .. >1 '0 , '0 .. . , /) ":i i) ;i\ 0, '(i , (" ' -~I ,: ,'), , ,,) I- II) ,J, ~ :if " n~ ", " 'Il ;-, IJ) lli ;J} ( I '6) ~' :>. '1., ,'Ii " 0 I , ,tl '1' Cd I , (\J (Y) " m m « CITY COUNCIL MINUTES JANUARY 5, 1988 PAGE 2 357 City Administrator Smith presented a memorandum to Council on the FY 87-88 budget projection shortfall. This stated that our projected balance was overstated by $558,802. A motion by Mayor Pendarvis, seconded by Counci1member Alexander, unanimously approved to continue with the budget as is because City Administrator Smith stated we could postpone certain capital items from the current year budget until the next budget year. A motion by Councilmember Frierson, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Salley, unanimously approved the Resolution granting the City Administrator the authority to make line items changes in the budget such that it does not change the total approved budget amount. A motion by Mayor Pro Tern Salley, seconded by Councilmember Alexander, unanimously approved the first reading of an ordinance to amend the 1986-87 budget due to some expenditures which were not approved by the Accomodations Tax Board and for the purchase of a fire truck which was divided between FY 86-87 and FY 87-88 budgets. This would increase expenditures from $5,129,263 to $5,232,824. A motion by Mayor Pendarvis, seconded by Mayor Pro unanimously approved parking privileges behind the Boy's the Rose Festival, April 28th through May 1st, approximately twenty-five (25) camper trailers. Tern Salley, Club during 1988, for A motion by Mayor Pendarvis, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Salley, unanimously approved a Resolution granting easement rights on Highway 49 near the sub station to the South Carolina Department of Highways and Public Transportation. A motion Alexander, rights on and Public by Mayor Pro Tern Salley, seconded by Councilmember unanimously approved the Resolution granting sloping Highway 49 to the South Carolina Department of Highways Transportation. There being no further business, the ~ting was adjourned. Res~,):~u;»" submitted, /r /h~{l ~~on City Clerk /r 358 CITY COUNCIL MINUTES JANUARY 19, 1988 Orangeburg City January 19, 1988 presiding. Council held a Special City Council Meeting on in City Hall Chambers at 5:00 P.M., Mayor Pendarvis PRESENT: E. O. Pendarvis, Mayor W. Everette Salley, Mayor Pro Tern Henry F. Frierson Sara H. Alexander Herbert W. Bradley, Jr. A motion by Mayor Pro Tern Salley, seconded by councilmember Alexander, unanimously approved to enter into an executive session for legal briefing. A Public Hearing began at 7:00 P.M. concerning single member districts. Mr. Bobby Bowers, Director of the South Carolina Depart ment of Statistics and Research discussed the five (2-city, 3-ACLU) proposed plans for re-districting the City in regards to election of City Council Members. He explained that based on the 1980 census, the population of the City of Orangeburg was 14,933 of which 49% are black. If you exclude the colleges, 38% of the citizens are black. If the City is divided into six (6) districts this would put the population in each district at approximately 2,489. Mr. Bernard Haire expressed a desire for Council to make a decision tonight and move forward with the process. No other comments were made concerning this matter. A motion Alexander, Minutes as A motion Frierson, amend the by Councilmember Bradley, unanimously approved the distributed. seconded by councilmember January 5, 1988 City Council by Mayor Pro Tern unanimously approved 1986-87 Budget. Salley, seconded by Councilmember the second reading of an ordinance to A motion by Mayor Pro Tern Salley, seconded by Councilmember Alexander, unanimously approved the revised project application for clearing and site preparation on the new Runway 17/35 to include the Environmental Assessment Report. Public Works Director, Reese Earley, informed Council that this would not increase the budget. A motion by Councilmember Frierson, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Salley, unanimously approved the Resolution to postpone the February 9, 1988 Special Election until a decision is reached concerning the proposed single member districts. A motion by Mayor Pro Tern Salley, seconded by Councilmember Bradley, unanimously approved to accept "Plan 4" of the five plans submitted concerning single member districts. (See Attachment) Department of Public Utilities Manager, Ted Johnson, brought no utility matters before council. Mr. Bernard Haire wanted council to re-open the Cable TV issue of the City going into the Cable TV business because of the proposed increase in the rates. Mayor Pendarvis informed Mr. Haire that we had previously reported the results of the study and found it not feasible. There being no further business, th~meeting was adjourned. ~.P7ctfi:.~ ubmitted, 1%1 f~~ runs on City Clerk / / '-,. -......~~. ~rf------"""------------- J •••• ;i~ .... ··-.. 111,.. .. •· -' ORANGEBURI \' COUNC I L ,~ SIX DISTRICTS - RED TOTAL POPULATION - 14,933; IDEAL DISTRICT - 2,489 If AREA DISTRICT 1 9901 101-136 201-203 9902 BG1 302 304-307 -1.56% Variance DISTRICT 2 9902 BG#2 308 9903 201-247 249 255-259 -0.12% Variance DISTRICT 3 9902 301 303 309-330 BG 11'4 -3.54% Variance TOTAL POP. 1,326 92 890 54 a8 2,450 946 99 1,179 126 136 2,486 46 42 697 1,616 2,401 BLACK POP. 81 4 4 2 7 98 12 o 305 121 50 488 4 o 5 580 589 % BLACK POP. 4.0% 19.6% 24.5% VOTING AGE POPULATION TOTAL BLACK % BLACK 1,045 75 614 39 67 1,840 693 74 923 86 96 1,872 35 29 520 1 ,225 1,809 71 2 o 2 5 80 7 o 202 83 29 321 4 o 3 411 418 4.3% 17.1% 23.1% - : J ... ,,"~ ...... ,."'.if....-fJ, .. .' . 4. ! ". • 1, .... , • '.Y ·If ~-- . t .) - ) \ , II -- l r VOTING AGE POPULATION AREA TOTAL POP. BLACK POP. % BLACK POP. TOTAL BLACK % BLACK DISTRICT 4 9901 137 25 0 15 0 204-220 797 650 538 434 301-311, 312 Part, 314-317 1,742 1,724 1,561 1,542 2,564 2,314 92.6t 2,114 1,976 93.5% +3.01% Variance 1,140 852 74.7% 886 647 73.0% DISTRICT 5 9901 312 Part, 313, 318-332 1,961 1,821 1,756 1,633 401-419 238 122 182 79 421 38 20 27 15 422 0 0 0 0 428 33 25 19 16 432-434 189 167 115 95 9903 101 " 102 108 103 88 84 2,567 2,258 88.0t 2,187 1,1122 87.9% +3.13% Variance 1,255 957 76.3% 918 659 71. 8% DISTRICT 6 9901 420 33 5 23 3 425-427 1 1 1 1 429-431 57 18 42 13 437-438 130 20 102 16 9903 103-142 716 426 506 263 248 6 6 0 0 250-254 140 137 87 85 BG *3 900 832 596 529 BG *4 482 127 373 79 2,465 1,572 63.8t 1,730 989 57.2% -0.96% Vari~nce MAXIMUM VARIANCE: 6.67 (HIGH +3.13; LOW -3.54) ~,. ,-:.;".,: RESOLUTION WHEREAS, the City of Orangeburg is the owner of the below described property and WHEREAS, said property is being used by the Department of Public Utilities, the City of Orangeburg, as a substation. WHEREAS, South Carolina Department of Public Highways and Public Transportation wishes to acquire pennission for sloping tc extend five (5) feet beyond highway right-of-way or forty-five (45) feet fram the centerline of S-49 for the purpose of improving SOuth Carolina Highway 49. WHEREAS, such improvements tc South Carolina Highway 49 will benefit the Department of Public Utilities in maintaining and operating its substation. NOW, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE City council, The City of Orangeburg, South Carolina duly assembled this ~-+h day of .j()Y\()..Oi-V ,1988, that TedM. Johnson, Jr., Manager of the ~ Department of Public Utilities, of the City of orangeburg is hereby authorized to execute a slope permission agreement with the South Carolina Department of Highways and Public Transportation. The property is shown on South Carolina Department of Highways and Public Transporta- tion's Drawing, project Number RS1047 (70) , File Number 38.892 between Stations 36 + 05 and 39 + 61 RT. Done and ratified this s-w, day of ~ h 'd' ru v , 1988. ATTES0.! / 'h'~'//;'7 . -,t? / /4 / . Jd.w /)f.---.J City~'Clerk and Treasurer " Z /~-_/ /" -z.,;-,<,-,/,:-.t!!1!{':>7 w~fi.Au.~ ~~ ~Z~:~ N~.l6ttLdL~L=i. Members of Council' -ri ;';""',' RESOLUTION WHEREAS, the City of Orangeburg is the owner of the below described property and WHEREAS, said property is being used by the Depart:ment of Public Utilities, the City of Orangeburg, as a substation. WHEREAS, South Carolina Depart:ment of Public Highways and Public Transpcrtation wishes to acquire a two . and one-half (2-1/2) foct easement for the purpcse of irrproving South Carolina Highway 49. WHEREAS, such irrprovements to South Carolina Highway 49 will benefit the Depart:ment of Public Utilities in maintaining and operating its substation. NOW, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE City Council, The City of Orangeburg, South Carolina duly assembled this 5-+1" day of _ ~nu0.n . .j , 1988, that Ted M. Johnson, Jr.. Manager of the -' Depart:ment of Public Utilities, of the City of orangeburg is hereby authorized to execute a right-of-way easement to the South Carolina Depart:ment of Highways and Public Transpcrtation. The property is sh= on South Carolina Depart:ment of Highways and Public Transportation's Drawing, Project N\.UlIber RS1047 (70), File N\.UlIber 38.892 between Stations 63 + 86 and 66 + 25 LT. Done and ratified this S~ -,-- day of --"0 V> " f) r- u ,1988. -' ~'--= ~o.. Merobers of Council" , 'i& w~ffi~ CitY Clerk and Treasurer RESOLUTION BE IT RESOLVEV by zhe Mayo~ and Memb~ on Coun~ 0[, zhe C~y at O~angebMg, SOuZh CMauna, .-i.n Coun~ lU-6embled, and znaz by auZha~!f on zhe -6ame: GRANT auZho~zation zo zhe C~ Adm.-i.n.{./.)UaZM on zhe C~y on OnangebMg za change budga amounU on une ~em-6 .-i.n needed -6uch zhaZ zhue changu do noz aU~ zhe zoza,f budga amounZ. PASSEV by Coun~, .-i.n Coun~ lU-6embled at O~angebMg, SOuZh CMauna, zh.<.!.> n.-i.nzh day an JanUM!f, 1988. ATTEST:/ ,f / // / / // ,,',' / 0/°" '/ ,</} //;~" ,,///"'/'(/ / I ,pi /;4/ // /~~. /-'- ..... - CI1Y CLERK ~--:7_ ,// , ' / d / ,/::/ // ----, ,c7 ";;::.:: - ,-.'/ -,1 //x'/?' ,,:::);.;;,~~,"-;:.-%'--:::-/ ..//j t~Zf!5~~s CF COUNCIL C\J (Y) M m m <t: CITY COUNCIL MINUTES February 2, 1988 359 Orangeburg City council held its regularly scheduled City Council Meeting on February 2, 1988 in City Hall Chambers at 7:00 P.M., Mayor Pendarvis presiding. PRESENT: E. o. Pendarvis, Mayor W. Everette Salley, Mayor Pro Tern Henry F. Frierson Sara H. Alexander Herbert W. Bradley, Jr. A motion by Councilmember Bradley, seconded unanimously approved the January 19, 1988 distributed: by Mayor Pro Tern Salley, City Council Minutes as A motion by Mayor Pro Tern Salley, seconded by Mayor Pendarvis, unanimously approved the third reading of an ordinance to amend the 1986-87 Budget. A motion by Mayor Pro Tern Salley, seconded by Councilmember Frierson, unanimously approved the first reading of an ordinance to implement a new election procedure. Attorney Walsh explained to council that changes were made on the map to include newly annexed areas and to swap the district numbers on 1 and 2. This ordinance provides for an election to be held on the second Tuesday in September, 1988 to elect representatives from districts 1, 3 and 5 for a one year term and from districts 2, 4 and 6 for a three year term. Attorney Walsh explained that there would not have to be an election in district 1 if there was only one Councilmember residing in that district prior to that election. (According to the new map there are two coucilmembers residing in this district at present.) A motion by Councilmember Alexander, seconded Bradley, unanimously approved the acceptance of $45,108.84 from Central Chevrolet in Columbia for size four door sedan pursuit patrol cars. by the four Councilmember only bid of (4) 1988 full A motion by Mayor Pro Tern Salley, seconded by Councilmember Alexander, unanimously approved the low bid of $3,470.75 from A.J.S. Associates for the purchase of two (2) scoreboards and cable wires for the Parks and Recreation Department. A motion by Mayor Pendarvis, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Salley, unanimously approved the low bid of $5,795.00 from Porter Brothers for the purchase of one (1) three-wheel tractor for Hillcrest. A motion by Councilmember Frierson, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Salley, unanimouslY approved the low bid to enter into a lease purchase agreement with Club Car for $2,300.00 per month (total agreement $110,400) on forty (40) gas powered golf carts. Attorney Walsh brought Council up to date on litigation concerning W. W. Sutcliffe against the City. He explained that Mr. Sutcliffe had a lot on Dixie Circle and requested a variance instead of re-zoning. The City's position was that this would be an amendment of the Zoning Ordinance and not a request for a variance. Mr. Sutcliffe appealed to the Circuit Court and had a hearing and the Circuit Court denied this appeal. Attorney Walsh submitted a copy of the order and stated that Mr. Sutcliffe would have ten (10) days after receipt of this order to appeal the ruling. 360 CITY COUNCIL MINUTES FEBRUARY 2, 1988 PAGE 2 DPU Manager, Ted Johnson, informed Council that due to a savings on the generating plant ($250,000.00) and a rate reduction from SC Electric and Gas Company ($727,591.00) he was requesting a total rate reduction ($977,591) based on last year's consumption figures. A motion by Mayor Pro Tern Salley, seconded by Councilmember Bradley, unanimously approved a Resolution granting this rate reduction. There being no further business, the ~eeting was adjourned. /r R"tV ''''''itted, ~runson City Clerk • ORANGEBURG CIry COUNCIL 'f ; SIX DISTRIC'i' ~EQ TOTAL POPULATION - 14,933; IDEAL DISTRICT - 2,489 VOTING AGE POPULATION AREA TOTAL POP. BLACK POP. % BLACK POP. TOTAL BLACK % BLACK DISTRICT ::P 9901 101-136 1,326 81 1,045 71 201-203 92 4 75 2 9902 BG1 890 4 614 0 302 54 2 39 2 304-307 88 7 67 5 2,450 98 4.0% 1,840 80 4.3% -1.56% Variance DISTRICT 9902 BGII2 946 12 693 7 308 99 0 74 0 9903 201-247 1,179 305 923 202 249 , 126 121 86 83 255-259 136 50 96 29 2,486 488 19.6% 1,872 321 17.1% -O.IH Variance DISTRICT 3 9902· 301 46 4 35 4 303 42 0 29 0 309-330 697 5 520 3 BG 114 1,616 580 1,225 411 2,401 589 24.5% 1,809 418 23.1% -3.54% Variance /. • AREA DISTRICT 4 9901 137 204-220 301-311, 312 Part, 314-317 +3. on Variance DISTRICT 5 9901 312 Part, 313, 318-332 401-419 421 422 428 432-434 9903 101 " 102 +3.13% Variance DISTRICT 6 9901 420 425-427 429-431 437-438 9903 103-142 248 250-254 SG 13 SG U . . -0.96% cVI!.l.".l.anC/l ,i: ~ ',!'-' :. .. . . .~,': i:~.::·;; ~-;-. :'. y.~:,J;i" .. ({ .. ~; :': MAXIMUM VARIANCE: TOTAL POP. 25 797 1,742 2,564 1,140 1,961 238 38 0 33 189 108 2,567 1, 255 33 1 57 130 716 6 140 900 482 2,465 SLACK POP. o 650 1,7H 2,374 852 1,821 122 20 0 25 167 103 a,258 957 5 1 18 20 426 6 137 832 127. 1,572 ~ '~J';' ~ , . ''-(f_~~ .... ~ ~: . -- % SLACK POP. 92.6% 74.7% 88.0% 76.3% 63.8% ·If VOTING AGE POPULATION TOTAL SLACK % BLACK 15 538 1,561 2,114 886 1,756 182 27 0 19 115 88 2,187 918 23 1 42 102 506 o 87 596 .. ' 373 '1,730 o 434 1,542 1,976 647 1,633 79 15 0 16 95 84 1,Ua 659. 3 1 13 16 263 o 85 529 79,: , 989 . ;,- -........ 93.5% 73.0% 87.9% 71.8% . :.- 57.2% ' .. ";' '1,",:"<" ""':";p-." ' .• "" :'-·' .. ~,~::-i>!;'" "":'-;--';,':' '. ,.. . 6.67 (HIGH +3.13; LOW -3.54\ ;'\":)?.. :.~.: . .':~\, " , l~' .-' 'l;':~~' ::t~ ,:_~, --- '- ,. I' I ~ l RESOLUTION BE IT RESOLVED By the Mayor and Members of Council of the City of Orangeburg, South Carolina, in Council assembled, and by authority of the same: That the rates of the Department of Public Utilities of the City of Orangeburg pertaining to Electricity, as heretofore adopted be, and the same are hereby repealed, and in lieu thereof, the Electric Rates of the Department of Public Utilities of the City of Orangeburg, hereto attached, be and they are hereby, declared effective and in full force on March 1, 1988 billings. PASSED by the City Council, in Council assembled at Orangeburg, South Carolina, this ;;{rv1 day of 'febru,C! '--:1 , 1988. / 71dL &ITy Clerk and Treasurer Signed: p: ((/~~LZ/a~ f ? or e /2J ~-/ldJrh - 1./ /(~) -0/'? , ~ (\j (Y) .rJ m m <:( CITY COUNCIL MINUTES FEBRUARY 16, 1988 361 Orangeburg City Council held its February 16, 1988, in City Hall Pendarvis presiding. regularly scheduled meeting on Chambers at 7:00 P.M., Mayor PRESENT: E. O. Pendarvis, Mayor A motion Alexander, minutes as W. Everette Salley, Mayor Pro Tern Henry F. Frierson Sara H. Alexander Herbert W. Bradley, Jr. by Councilmember Bradley, seconded by Councilmember unanimouslY approved the February 2, 1988 City Council amended. An appearance was made by Mr. Jim Bethune, owner of Bethune Investments and Horne Motors to complain about a situation concerning the fact that he had been billed over twenty (20) months for utilities at a building of which Mr. Joel Webb (Oil Express) was the tenant. The bills amounted to $4,448.95. Mr. Bethune stated that he did not sign a utility agreement or give DPU a check to cut on the utilities and that DPU just took Mr. Webb's word that Horne Motors would pay the bill. Mr. Bethune stated that when he found that he had incorrectly paid this bill for over twenty (20) months and requested a refund from DPU, he was told that because he paid the bill and did not catch the error when it first happened that legally he had lost his presumption that he did not order the utilities. He was told that he would have to sue in order to receive a refund and he said he would. For the record, he brought a copy of the contract that he had with Mr. Webb stating that Mr. Bethune was not responsible for payment of the utilities. Mr. Bethune stated that he also checked his personal bill and noticed that his water consumption was multiplied by ten. He was told that this would correct itself by the next month. The main thing Mr. Bethune wanted to say was that he wanted Council to look at this situation because a lot of people do not know how to protect themselves in situations such as these or have access to legal council as he does. A motion by Mayor Pro Tern Salley, seconded Frierson, unanimously approved the second reading implement the new election procedure as amended. by Councilmember of an ordinance to A motion by Councilmember Frierson, seconded by Councilmember Bradley, unanimously approved the low bid of $8,292.90 for the purchase of a Massey Ferguson 240 tractor from Pioneer Farm Equipment in Orangeburg for the Service Department to be purchased from the cemetery fund. Mr. Joey Taylor, Executive Director of the Orangeburg County Chamber of Commerce, presented a plaque to City Council recognizing the SC Festival of Roses as being one of the top twenty (20) events in the Southeast. This award was presented from the Southeast Tourism Society. This is the second year in a row that the Festival has been chosen and one of the few chosen as top twenty winners back to back. Marion J. Smith, Director of Parks and Recreation Department, presented the 1988 Rose Festival Budget which included estimated revenues of $13,450 and estimated expenditures of $13,175. The Festival of Roses will be held April 29th through May 1st of this year. Mr. Smith also informed council that the Queen of Roses Pageant has been sanctioned as an official preliminary pageant of the Miss SC Pageant. The budget was accepted as information. 362 CITY COUNCIL MINUTES PAGE 2 City Administrator Smith presented a report to Council on the results of the ISO Fire Department inspection. He stated that the City remained class 5 inside the city limits and dropped from class 7 to class 5 outside the city limits as long as an individual is within the fire district, has a paid contract and is within 1000 ft. of a fire hydrant. City Administrator Smith said that this should benefit those people through a reduction in their fire insurance (homeowner's insurance, etc.). City Administrator Smith stated that when he receives a detailed report we can analyze the deficiencies in order to determine if changes would be cost efficient. City Administrator Smith presented the FY 1986-87 final audit prepared by J. W. Hunt and Company. The net result for the City was that we ended with a $314,053 positive variance. DPU Manager,Ted Johnson, brought no utility matters before council. Councilrnember Bradley asked Mr. Johnson what the normal procedures are if a person feels that charges have been improperly accessed. Mr. Johnson said that they do investigate these reports and that approximately 50% of all cut ons/cut offs are handled by phone. He also said that his records state that Mr. Bethune made the call regarding the cut on of utilities and that Mr. Webb never indicated that he impersonated Mr. Bethune. Mr. Johnson stated that it is normal for the landlord to cut on the utilities to clean a building and then discontinue the service before the tenant occupies. In this case the service continued. He also said that normally with the first bill if the person did not order the utilities he would notify DPU and that DPU would discontinue the service and issue a warrant. ~" There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned. ~tfUll'V "ubmitted, ~:?.r.n"on City Clerk /r (\J (Y) 'rl en en <! -' CITY COUNCIL MINUTES MARCH 1, 1988 363 Orangeburg City council held its regularly scheduled meeting on March 1, 1988 in City Hall Chambers at 7:00 P.M., Mayor Pendarvis presiding. A motion Alexander, Minutes as PRESENT: E. o. Pendarvis Mayor w. Everette Salley, Mayor Pro Tern Henry F. Frierson Sara H. Alexander ABSENT: Herbert W. Bradley, Jr. by Councilmember Frierson, seconded by Councilmember unanimously approved the February 16, 1988 City Council distributed. A motion by Councilmember Alexander, seconded by Mayor Pendarvis, unanimouslY approved the third reading of an ordinance to implement the new election procedure. A motion by Mayor Pro Tern salley, seconded by Councilmember Frierson, unanimously approved the low bid of $5,216.73 for baseball and softball uniforms and equipment for the Parks and Recreation Department from The sportsman Shop in Charleston. council unanimously agreed to postpone a request from the Orangeburg county Chamber of Commerce. Mayor Pendarvis nominated Freda Summers to replace Ms. Barbara Zellerino's unexpired term and Mr. W. J. Stoudenmire to replace Mr. Joey Taylor's expired term on the Planning commission. A motion by Councilmember Frierson, seconded by Councilmember Alexander, unanimously agreed to close the nominations. Ms. Summers' term will expire March 3, 1989 and Mr. Stoudenmire's term will expire March 1, 1992. A motion by Mayor Pendarvis, seconded by Councilmember Frierson, unanimously agreed to authorize the Mayor to enter into a lease agreement renewal with E. J. Braxton et al on a walkway in the 100 block of Russell, NE to rear parking lots. Council agreed not to sell the City's used parking meters to the City of Columbia. City Administrator Smith requested an executive session for legal briefing. Department of Public Utilities Manager, Ted Johnson, brought no utility matters before Council. A motion Frierson, executive by Mayor Pro Tern Salley, seconded by Councilmember unanimously approved to adjourn and enter into an session for legal briefing. There being no further was adjourned. /r 364 CITY COUNCIL MINUTES MARCH 15, 1988 Orangeburg City Council held March 15, 1988 in City Hall presiding. its regularly scheduled meeting on Chambers at 7:00 P.M., Mayor Pendarvis PRESENT: E. o. Pendarvis, Mayor A motion Alexander, Minutes as W. Everette Salley, Mayor Pro Tern Sara H. Alexander Herbert W. Bradley, Jr. ABSENT: Henry F. Frierson by Councilmember Bradley, seconded by unanimously approved the March 1, 1988 distributed. Councilmember City Council Mr. A. J. Hutto discussed the request from the Orangeburg county Chamber of Commerce to set the cost of rent per month at $250 for the next ten (10) years along with the request for repairs to the building amounting to approximately $10,000. Mayor Pro Tern Salley said that the City should not settle for the $250 a month for ten (10) years. Mayor Pendarvis suggested that a committee meet with the Chamber officials to discuss the situation. A motion by Mayor Pendarvis, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Salley, unanimously approved the appointment of Mr. Tom Vargo as Chairman of the Grievance Committee with his term expiring 4-1-91. A motion by Mayor Pro Tern Salley, seconded by Councilmember Bradley, unanimously approved the appointment of the following members to the Accommodation's Tax Board. TOURIST Joey Taylor, Chairman Tom Vargo Jackie Davis Leah Holstein NON TOURIST Marion J. Smith Edna Fischer Fred Broughton TERM 3-15-92 3-15-90 3-15-92 3-15-90 TERM 3-15-92 3-15-90 3-15-92 Parks and Recreation Director, Marion J. Smith, presented a report to council about the continuing deterioration of the Old AA Building. He presented three (3) proposals to council for their consideration, with a recommendation that the building be leveled and the area left open. A motion by Councilmember Bradley, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Salley, unanimously approved Mr. Smith's recommendation. Attorney James F. Walsh brought Council up-to-date concerning the Cable TV litigation. He said that a motion was filed to amend the City's original answer and that a counter claim has been filed based on the following: 1. Jones Intercable's recent action of combining basic and expanded basic forcing citizens to receive expanded basic at increased rates--violation of the Sherman Act. 2. Violation of the State's unfair trade act. 3. Failure to comply with pole permit procedures. A motion by Mayor Pendarvis, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Salley, unanimously approved a Resolution to approve the City's answer and counter claim. (Copy of second amended answer and counter claim attached.) C\I (Y) o;:-! co co 0::::( CITY COUNCIL MINUTES MARCH 15, 1988 PAGE 2 365 Department of Public Utilities Manager, Ted Johnson, brought no utility matters before Council. There being no further /r business, th~eting was adjourned. ~'Y "ubmitted. caro~nson City Clerk 366 Orangeburg April 5, presiding. City 1988 CITY COUNCIL MINUTES APRIL 5, 1988 Council held its regularly scheduled meeting on in City Hall Chambers at 7:00 P.M., Mayor Pendarvis PRESENT: E. O. Pendarvis, Mayor A motion by unanimously distributed. W. Everette Salley, Mayor Pro Tern Henry F. Frierson Sara H. Alexander Herbert W. Bradley, Jr. councilmember Bradley, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Salley, approved the March 15, 1988 City Council Minutes as A motion by Mayor Pro Tern Salley, seconded by Mayor Pendarvis, unanimously approved for the Mayor to have the authority to execute a lease with the State Highway Department to improve 1.66 miles of city streets. A motion by Mayor Pro Tern Salley, seconded by Councilmember Bradley, unanimously approved the Aviation Commission's recommendation that the existing lease for the operation of the airport not be renewed and that a new lease, taking into account current conditions, be negotiated with the present operator. Council unanimously agreed to postpone the consideration of six proposed streets in a proposed subdivision at the end of Livingston Terrace until additional information can be received from the corps of engineers concerning an alternate entrance to the subdivision from Riverside Drive. Concern was also expressed concerning a road over a dam that the State will not accept into their system. Mr. Don Smith explained that they were not proposing this street to be accepted. It would be used as an alternate road or private drive, etc. for as long as it remains sound. A motion by Mayor Pendarvis, seconded by Councilmember Frierson, unanimous lay approved whatever fire station repairs were necessary. Council agreed to postpone the Ku Klux Klan parade until an alternate date is scheduled. Department of Public Utilities Manager, Ted Johnson, brought no utility matters before Council. There being no further business, /r Carol A". Brunson City Clerk 'V -~ RES 0 L UTI 0 N WHEREAS, the City of Orangeburg, recognizes the need for a convenient access for its citizens from the 100 block of Russell NE to parking lots behind buildings; and WHEREAS, in an effort to provide said access, the City, for the past twenty years, has leased a walkway located on Russell NE owned by formally Harry S. Zeigler, et ai, now E. J. Braxton and Lyla C. Braxton; and WHEREAS, the City continues to recognize this need and wishes to renew said lease for a twenty year period. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, that E. O. Pendarvis, Mayor of the City of Orangeburg, South Carolina, is hereby authorized and directed to enter into the lease agreement attached hereto with E. J. Braxton and Lyla C. Braxton for this purpose. PASSED by the City Council, in Council assembled, at Orangeburg, South Carolina, this first day of March, 1988. ATT~~ (/ "'CITY CLERK 7 .•. :1 2~ (/ if/!/;' ~~~ MAYOR· . (;' y(-!--~J ., 'u~Cb /EJ CITY rouNCIL -r /1 STATE OF SOUTH CAROLINA, ) ) COUNTY OF ORANGEBURG. ) E. J. Braxton and L yla C. Braxton , and ) ) Lessors, ) City of Orangeburg, ) Lessee. ) ./wl \ Qc'b q; D_\w..~\ LEASE AGREEMENT ~ This Lease Agreement made this / ~ day of March, 1988 between E. J. Braxton and Lyla C. Braxton, hereinafter referred to as Lessors, and City of Orangeburg, hereinafter referred to as Lessee; Witnesseth: That the Lessors do hereby lease unto Lessee the following described property: All that certain piece, parcel or lot of land fronting on the northerly side of Russell N. E. (being No. 159 Russell N. E.), in the City" of Orangeburg, said County and State, being set forth and shown on a sketch thereof made by B. Reese Earley dClted December 7 , 19S7 , attached hereto and made a part of this description by reference and having the following boundaries and measurements: South~ast by Russel! N. E., 7 feet~ 2 :nches; Southwest by other property of E. J. Braxton and Lyla C. Braxton, 198 feet; North\vest by a 20-foot alley, 7 feet, 2 inches, and Northeast by property of Lester I. Finkiestein, 198 feet, together with al! right, title and interest in easements ,appertenant thereto. It is hereby stipulated and agreed that Lessee at its expense is granted the privilege to 'remove all improvements on said real estate so that the same can and will be used exclusively as a walkway. To have and to hold the premises above described for a term of twenty (20) years beginning on the 1st day of March, 1988, and continuing for a period of twenty (20) years from such date at a monthly rental of 'Fifty and 00/1110 ($50.00) Dollars, said rent to be paid in advance on the first day of each and every month during the term of this Lease by Lessee \.!nto Lessors at Orangeburg, S. C., or to their duly authorized agent. This Agreement to bind the Heirs, Admin~trators,ggEx~cutors, "-,~ ....:...! Successors and Assigns of the parties hereto. ::::3 = C'l = c::J <-' :~ " ·0 ~. -0 :::J ,.' ::::3 ,-'<j 0 :..:J. i'0 0 :;:J o· ;:::l -,:..-:r I-" ~,." ;:,~ ,'; r-,,,, ~UI:;;' ~ tuUr'. t..,";')'-_t r,:..~E...~Uv.,;t ;: i; " ,A t~l ;.:' i; " !, " 0" '" ;: . i. '. ~ © UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT DISTRICT OF SOUTH CAROLINA ORANGEBURG DIVISION Jones Intercable, Inc. and Jones Cable Income Fund l-B, Ltd. , ) ) ) ) l l ) Civil Action No. 5-87-2014-6 Plaintiffs, vs. l City of Orangeburg, S.C., ) E. O. Pendarvis, Sara H. ) Alexander, Herbert W. ) Bradley, Jr., Henry F. ) Frierson, W. Everette Salley, l and Ted M. Johnson, Jr., ) Defendants. ) ) _________________________ l SECOND AMENDED ANSWER AND COUNTERCLAH! Defendants, answering the Complaint of the plaintiffs, would respectfully show this Court: For a First Defense 1. All allegations not specifically herein admitted are denied. 2. The allegations of paragraph 1 are admitted on information and belief. 3. The allegations of paragraphs 2, 3, 4 and 5 are admitted. 4. Answering the allegations of paragraph 6, defendants acknowledge that this Court has jurisdiction over the subject matter of this action but deny that jurisdiction under 28 U.S.C. ~ . ~:% §1332 is well fo·unded in that the plaintiffs did not plead· the citizenship of the ~artners of Jones Cable Income Fund 1-8, Ltd.; further answering, defendants deny any violation of plaintiffs' rights or any failure to meet obligations owed to plaintiffs. 5. The allegations of paragraphs 7, 8, 9, and 10 are admitted. 6. Answering the allegations of paragraph II, defendants crave reference to the franchise for the full and true terms and conditions thereof. 7. Answering the allegations of paragraph 12, defendants allege that the City of Orangeburg has, since the turn of the century, owned and operated its own electric distribution system pursuant to Article VIII, Section 16 of the Constitution of the State of South Carolina, both inside and outside of its corporate limits, pursuant to a referendum of its electors • Defendants admit that the city is the only supplier of electricity, water, wastewater service and .natural gas wi thin the ci ty, and that it also supplies those utilities in the county along with numerous other competing utilities including South CaroJina Electric .and Gas Company, Tri-County Electric Cooperative, Aiken Electric Cooperative, Edisto Electric Cooperative, and others. The city has not been assigned any exclusive territory for electric service in the county and serves almost entirely in unassigned territory. DPU, purchases electricity from South Carolina Electric and 'Gas Company at its published sale for resale rate, and also purchases some electricity from the Southeastern Power -2- ". Administration, and distributes' the electricity to its residential, cOTllmercial, and industrial customers, within and without its corporate limits over its electric distribution system. 8. Ans~ering the allegations of paragraph 13, defendants admi t that pIa intiffs' predecessor and the Department of Public Utilities (DPU) for Orangeburg entered into a Pole Attachment Agreement on November 21, 1967, and that the agreement was assigned to plaintiffs on November 25, 1986. The allegations concerning plaintiffs' agreement with Southern Bell are admitted on information and belief. With respect to plaintiffs' allegations concerning the terms of the Pole Attachment Agreement between DPU and Jones, defendants allege that such agreement gives to Jones certain clearly specified and limited rights to ,!~~ use utility poles owned by the City of Orangeburg and defendants crave reference to the agreement for the full and true terms, and conditions thereof. 9. Answering the allegations of paragraph 14, defendants admit that the use of existing utility poles is a common, - . practical and cost efficient means of establishing and operating a cable television system, but deny that such pole use is necessarily the most practical and cost efficient means; defendants deny that Federal or South Carolina legislation recognizes any such "most common, practical and cost efficient means· of establishing a cable system; defendants crave reference to the Federal and South Carolina legislation for the content -3- thereof; and defendants lack sufficient information to form a belief as to the allegations concerning plaintiffs' motivation in purchasing the assets of Orangeburg Cable TV and therefore deny them. 10. Answering the ,allegations of paragraph 15, defendants admit that DPU controls the substantial majority of the utility poles which plaintiffs use and wish to use, but deny that said use is "required." 11. Answering the allegations of paragraph 16, defendants admit that DPU has an agreement with Southern Bell to share poles and avoid duplication and that the effect of this agreement is that in some places where DPU has poles there are no Southern Bell poles and vice versa; the remaining allegations of i?aragraph 16 are denied. 12. The allegations of paragraph 17 are denied. 13. Answering paragraph 18 of the complaint, the defendants admit only that employees of DPU were informed of the basics of a proj?osed expansion such as the one alleg'ed on 'or' about January 12, 1987. 14. Answering the allegations of paragraph 19, defendants admit only that representatives of DPU had discussions in January 1987 concerning. expansion plans contemplated by the plaintiffs; the remaining allegations of paragraph 19 are denied. 15. The allegations of j?aragraphs 20, 21, 22, 23, and 24 of the complaint are denied. -4- 16. Answering the allegations 9f paragraph 25" defendants admit so much thereof as alleges~ that the Pole, Attachment Agreement requires that the plainti~fs meet the requirements of the Nation&l Electrical Safety Code; but the agreement also prescribes other standards, conditions and requirements and reference is-- ,- craved to the Agreement for the specific requirements thereof. The remaining allegations of paragraph 25 of the complaint are denied. 17. Answering the allegations of paragraph 26, defendants crave reference to the Pole Attachment Agreement for the terms and conditions thereof and admit that in those instances where compliance with the terms of the Pole Attachment Agreement requires Jones to move or adjust lines, poles, or equipment and pay the cost thereof, Jones' costs are increased by its compliance with its agreement. paragraph 26 are denied. The remaining allegations of 18. Answering the allegations of paragraph 27(a), defendants admit that the National Electrical Safety Code has since long before the Pole Attachment Agreement was executed, contained an exception to its normal forty inch requirement which permits a minimum separation between a communications cable and a grounded neutral' of thirty inches, but allege that a minority of DPU poles qualify for that exception; defendants further allege that the sound professional engineering practices and standards imposed by DPU on itself, on Southern Bell, and through the Pole Attachment Agreement, on Jones, require a standardized separation -5- ~ oE forty inches between the lines and that the parties have 'accepted and acted upon the uniform forty inch requirement since the inception of the Pole Attachment Agreement. The remaining allegations of paragra!?h 27(a) are denied. 19. Answering the allegations of paragraph 27(b), defendants admit that the sound professional engineering practices and standards imposed by DPU on itself, on Southern Bell, and, through the Pole Attachment Agreement, on Jones, do not permit the ~se of "extension arms' on its poles except in unusual circumstances.' The remaining allegations of paragraph 27(b) are denied. 20. The allegations of !?aragraphs 28, 29, and 30 are denied. 21. The defendants reallege their res:;>onses to the allegations incorporated in paragraph 31. 22. The allegations of paragraphs 32 and 33 are denied. 23. The allegations of paragraph 34 are admitted as they relate to the area served by the city within the city limits and denied as to areas without the city limits. 24. The allegations of paragraph 35 and 36 are denied. 25. Defendants deny the allegations of paragrap!ls 37, 38, 39 and 40. 26. Defendants reallege their responses to the allegations incorporated in paragraph 41. -6- ,_ .. -.,-----, i ~'~ , T ., .,.';'(' . .., ;.~i ' :'f~ iB ~.f~ .;::" ,Ii' ~~~~ t>, j .• , , .~:r; 0' ;;':',' , .. 1'1 ,~, t.:,~: .~~ :~" "-l., :~} .~ .,~ -:;; "., " ~.~ t~ " .~., '~:.I ,~~ ,~. 27., Answe ri ng the' allegations of paragraph 42 the, defendants admit only that certain aspects of plaintiffs' opera tiqn of a cable t'elevis ion sys tern "implicate" interests protected by the First Amendment. 28. The allegations of paragraphs 43, 44 and 45 are denied, and, further answering paragraph 43, Jones apparently does not itself recognize such a constitutional right since Jones has failed and refused, in violation of its franchise, to extend service to prospective viewers who live in certain neighborhoods in the city limits, despite repeated requests from the city 'and the prospective viewers that it do so. 29. Defendants reallege their responses to the allegations incorporated in paragraph 46. 30. Defendants deny the allegations of paragraph 47 and would show that the city has complied in all respects with its obligations under the Pole Attachment Agreement and has also insisted on behalf of its citizens on its rights as bargained for, and agreed to by Jones; defendants crave reference to the Agreement itself for the obligations and rights established ~ thereby. 31. The allegations of paragraphs 48, 49 and 50 are denied. 32. Defendants reallege their responses to the allegations incorporated in paragraph 51. 33. The allegations of paragraphs 52, 53 and 54 are denied. -7- : . 'i'!'): For a Second Defense 34. Count I fails to state a claim upon which relief can be granted as the activities of the defendants were taken ;pursuant to the clearly expressed policy of the State of South Carolina and are ex",l1)pt under the "state action" doctrine from the coverage of federal antitrust laws. For a Third Defense 35. The individual defendants are immune from any liability under Count I,Count II, and Count IV as all of their acts were done in good faith and under the reasonable belief that such acts violated no statutory, constitutional, or other rights of the plai nt Hfs. For a Fourth Defense 36. Count III does not state a claim upon which relief can be granted against the individual defendants, because they were not parties to a contract with the plaintiffs. For a Fifth Defense 37. Defendants Pendarvis, Alexander, Bradley, Frierson and Salley are absolutely immune from any liabili_ty under Count; r, Count II and Count IV as their actions complained of were taken in a legislative capacity. For a Sixth Defense -8- 38. Neither Count I, Count III, nor Count IV states a claim upon which relief can be granted ·as to the individual defendants as no allegations of actions in an individual capacity are alleged but only actions as officials, agents, or employees acting on behalf of the city. For a Seventh Defense 39. Count IV does not state a claim upon which relief can be.granted because the parties and facts alleged are not embraced within the scope. of the statute relied upon and because the parties and the Eacts alleged come within the exemption oE S· C·. Code Ann. 539-5-40 (1977). By l';ay of A First Counterclaim 40. Defendants reallege and incoq'.orate each and every paragraph set Eorth above not inconsistent with the allegations set forth herein. 41. The Defendants assert this counterclaim as representatives oE the citizens of the City of Orangeburg who subsdribe to cable television services, and the individual Defendants also assert this counterclaim in their individual capacities as subscribers or potential subscribers to cable television service in the City of Orangeburg and its outlying area. -9- 'L ., rl ~ ::i ' .. ' -;..- ~'" :', I;:' , ;'; ';; , 42. The City of Oeangebueg and its outlying aeeas constitute a geogeaphic maeket foe the p,eovision of cable television services. 43. The Plaintiffs enjoy dominant maeket powee in the" eelevant geogeaphic market, the City of Oeangebueg and its outlying areas, for the provision of cable television service. 44. Cable television services are provided in multiple tiers, each tier containing one oc more channels. Effective in March, 1988, Plaintiffs will no longec permit subsccibers to purchase the cable service heretofore des igna ted "bas ic cable service" unless they also pucchase the service provided in a secondary tier., containing different channels, at an additional and higher rate. Plaintiffs' pcactice of requicing cable television subscribers in the relevant geogcaphic market to subscribe to additional channels from a secondary tier in order to receive channels traditionally provided in the basic cable service tier constitutes a violation of Section 1 of the Sherman Act, 15 U.S.C. §l as an impermissible tying acrangement. 45. The channels provided in the seco~dary cable t~ec constitute the tied product, while the channels offeced in the previously designated bas ic cable service tiee, constitute the tyi ng product. 46. The channels provided in the two tiers are separate and distinct products, and the Plaintiffs' 'provision of these products cons.titute separate and distinct services. -10- "j .;':' .~ "'" .:-','3 :,: . ~. :*\. , <'; '-: .. ;-'. , .'/' I' ~ .: ~, ;' ~ ".' " . . \-.' ';"1 f;( , .~' , ~ ;~. ;n' ,~~; :;~, :.~ ~ 47. Plaintiffs" scheme to collapse the tiers forces subscribers to purchase unwanted channels which they, would not otherwise have purchased in order to receive channels previously designated as basic cable services, such as area broadcast stations via cable. 48. The forced purchases inherent in this practice have foreclosed a greater than insubstantial amount of commerce. Purchasers of the undesired tied product are deterred from purchasing products and services which compete with the tied product such as pre-recorded video casset te programs, movies displayed in theatres and cinemas, and satellite receivers. 49. Subscribel:"s to the previously designated basic cable television services are injured by Plaintiffs' anticompetitive practices since they are fo'rced to purchase unwanted, cable television channels in order to purchase the desired cable television channels which they previously purchased • 50. The Defendants and adversely affected subscribers are and will continue to be irreparably harmed by Plaintiffs' unlawful tying arrangement and the Defendants h~ve an inadequate remedy at law. By Way Of Second Counterclaim 51. Each and every paragraph set forth above is incorporated and realleged herein. Plaintiffs" provision of cable television access constitutes a "trade" and/or ·commerce" as those terms are defined in S.C. Code Ann. )39-5-10(b)(1976). -11- ~~ 7':. 52. Plaint:iffs' tying' .arrangement advers<:!ly affects tlie public interest and is capable of being, and likely to be repeated in ~he future. 53. Plaintiffs' tying .arrangement constitutes an unfair trade practice·-- and violates §39-5-20 (a) S. C. Code Ann. (1976). 54. The Defendants are and will continue to be irreparably harmed by Plaintiffs' unlawful tying arrangement. By Way Of Third Counterclaim 55. Defendants reallege and incorporate each and every paragraph set forth above. 56·. On November 21, 1967, Plaintiffs' predecessor in interest, .Orangeburg Cable T. V., Inc., 'entered into a Pole Attachments Agreement with the Department of Public Utilities of the City of Orangeburg (DPU). By this Agreement, O~angeburg Cable T.V. was allowed to attach its cable to the utility poles of D.P.U. 57. Upon the purchase by Plaintiffs of Orangeburg Cable T.V., Inc., the Plaintiffs assumed the rights and responsibilities of Orangeburg Cable T.V. under-the Pole Attachments Agreement. 58. The Pole Attachments Agreement in Paragraph 3 requires plaintiff to submit an application and receive a permit 'for each DPU utility pole to which it wishes to attach its cable -12- (:"' l' r, ~t :~- " , '.:', " , " n' :r· ;1" '!} " ~,,;: ;'i;" ;.;.,1 ~: (:\ 'It " ::;; " !<.: -;" ,,~ ,,'\ if! ',j '1:, Or"· !,.:< i:\; ,I: ~" !IL :''/ r':f ,_J. '" ~h I.;~ f:~1 ~'6 ~H] fj;! ~i,~; ',Fr" ,-If;'! ;~,"\' 'b' ,{~: ,1\'. ''f~~ .J., ~,~ " , television cable or equipment. At the time that Orangeburg Cable T.V. began operations, and at all times since, the DPU utiiity poles have been used for the provision of electric service and telephone service and accordingl1 have electric and telephone cables and equipment attached to them. Good engineering practices and safety considerations require that strict spacing requirements be maintained between the various utility and communications cables and equipment on a given pole and between such cables and 'equipment and the ground. 59. In order to 'maintain these spacing requirements and c lea rances, the Pole Attachments Agreement requires the plaintiffs to submit applications for pole attachment permits containing detailed diagrams of each specific pole to which attachment is sought. These diagrams show the location on each pole of all existing utility cables arid equipment and the location of any cables and equipment which plaintiffs propose to attach to the poles. The diagrams also show the distances between all existing pole attachments and between existing at tachments and those proposed by the plaintiffs';'. 60. Prior to making any actual attachments to DPU poles, the Plaintiffs'are required to submit to DPU for approval pole attachment permit applications containing,the pole diagrams described in the preceding paragraph. Employees of DPU review these applications for compliance with the spacing and clearance requirements specified by DPU pursuant to the Pole Attachments, -13- < ~! y: ~. ~, .' j ' . . ;~'I :..~; '. ~; 1:" r;i; I' ~t .~'- " ,i1' ~/ ,"'" ;f;: ~~ ~~~!: ~::,: '~.:, f~ ~:,iiY: ,{:~ f~l)' ',.1 ;~~ ;~, ',' (' .. ;;], ~- Agreement. In reviewing and approving these app lica tions UPU is entitled to and does rely upon the accuracy of information submitted by the plaintiffs and their representatives. 61. Plaintiffs by the terms of the Pole Attachments Agreement ar~'required to attach their cable to DPU poles strictly in compliance with the pole permits previously issued by UPU. Any difference between the permitted attachment and the actual attachment made by plaintiffs' employees constitutes a breach of the agreement unless the discrepancy is noted on the permit, submitted to DPU for approval, and approved. 62. The permitting procedures described above have been in effect since the inception of the Pole Attachments Agreement, a period of approximately twenty years. Uuringthis period, uPU has repeatedly found vio·lations of various provisions of the Pole Attachments Agreement and the UPU permitting procedures. Through the years, UPU has met with varying· degrees of success in requiring plaintiffs and plaintiffs' predecessor to correct violations in pole attachments and in maintaining accurate and complete pole permits on file. 63. In connection with this litigation UPU conducted a sample survey of plaintiffs' pole attachments and pole attachment permits for compliance with the requirements of' the Pole Attachments ~greement and the UPU permitting procedures. results of this survey showed widespread violations by the plaintiffs of the terms of the Pole Attachments Agreement. violations included: a) poles used without applying for permits; -14- The These i'· i i " ~ , - R ~ , • M .. j t ~ ! ~ " ~ ~1 ::, ;t· , ~t t ,-;'" ~f, ~,,:' ~~" !i:' ;<;": ~~: ~; :2. i., ;;;: 'ii-' ~:k' ~,~ ~~ :~<I __ ~'.-' ',W :f~ ,~;,\, J; :,:.~ :;: :1~ ,.,} ... --" ' ~ ::;,~ " ;{:, ~ .. ~-;.: " . • 'f' f'o,. lfi " ;.;; ;1;1 :;; ., iI'.! . :~r.~ 'Ii !~~: • .,';'i 'l!J.,. ..... ' .. tl~ ." 'i,!". f,::'{ '~;:; l!:t1 ·~1 ~i'-~ jlr '.</ B:~ ~~. 1\.' ~A/ b) c) d) e) , . failure to maintain propex road clearances,; failure to maintain proper clearances between plaintiffs' cable and other attachments; failure to set anchors; undocumented discrepancies between actual construction and the permit applications made by plaintiffs and approved by DPU. Each and every violation discovered in this survey is a violation of the Pole Attachments Agreement and the very substantial number of the violations, as well as the history of repeated violations, demonstrate plaintiffs' neglect of their responsibilities under the Pole Attachments Agreement. 64. The survey conducted by DPU covered a small but substantial and representative sample of poles to which plaintiffs' cable system is attached. The survey results showed violations by plaintiffs on an estimated twenty percent (20%) of such poles. It would be far too costly and burdensome for DPU to conduct a survey of all of its poles to determine each and every violation by the plaintiffs. Under the terms of the Pole Attachments Agreement it is plaintiffs' responsibility to see that its pole attachments comply with the Pole Attachments Agreement and the DPU permits • 65. The Defendants are and will continue to be irreparably harmed by Plaintiffs' refusal to abide by their'responsibilities under the Po,le Attachments Agreement, and the Defendants have an inadequate remedy at law. -15;­ I , .- · WHEREFORE, these befendants, having . responded to the Complaint, pray that Plaintiffs' claims be dismissed with prejudice, and for such relief on its Counterclaims as the Court may deem just and proper including, on the FIRST COUNTERCLAIM, (a) a declaratory judgment that the Plaintiffs actions as "specified above are in violation of the Sherman Act, 15 USC §l; (b) a permanent injunction enjoining the Plaintiffs from requiring subscribers who only desire to purchase those channels previously designated as "basic service" to also purchase additional channels as a prerequisite to obtaining the basic service; (c) an award of such actual damages as may be proved at trial, trebled; (d) costs and attorneys fees; and, on the SECOND COUNTERCLAIM, (a) such actual damages as may be proved at trial; and, (b) a permanent injunction requiring the Plaintiffs' to: (1) survey each and every DPU pole to which its cable system is attached; (2) correct each and every violation found by such survey; and, -16- ~ ..... <""p " r;:;2 8{;O¥:),j·.J r-,oc.f.1Uv In the Presence of: /~~?o/£,/ D1zJ~ 6 As to -E. J. Sraxton ~//~/~~ - - v D,4Vc~ As to Lyla C. Braxton i, ~./l /( ;Y/" / ,rJd;451 ~9~PJh,. C;::>;',J -(/0./ iJ. ~- ~fILJ--J As to The City of Orangeburg STATE OF SOUTH CAROLINA } ) COUNTY OF ORANGEBURG. } :;'V :-" ("'~ ,It [":':--2 SUJr,;)j'j ptttlU;J ~ ' f « ;:;;/ / )~ ) ~. J. B xt~ ) "on J ) J ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) } } } ) --' -~; ,,- r<~ ',I:::yla C. Braxton Lessors. CITY OF ORANGEBURG ~ /;' '7/)"V ., ~' By: /' L/' /?#/vG??r/'/JY~~ . Mayor'" Lessee. Personally appeared before me pc:> \/>::::;/ kyl, C:dr/~s , "tho, being duly S'ilrorn, says that he:.- saw the above named r'~',/ /' /'" z;, i - /./ c . ..J,. )"JF?:-~'-irv-Fl ~ . .--.;:-//2:- c:::; :::5/-21 ';(K /,7 sign, sea~ anc, as ;7778/r- / ---- act and deed, deliver the foregoing Lease Agreement, and that h "', P ,'/ L:::''' with D-~· J~c:::.e: ~c:... L- C}"'r"-/ ~ SWORN to me this :E;7' /= day ) - ) of March, 1988. ,"6?ec:::~£;.-c./~ / NOTARY PUBLIC FOR SQMTH CAROLINA ) } ) ) witnessed the execution thereof. (j (jvv~J w ~~ My Commission expires: ~-'I-/9o / / STATE OF SOUTH CAROLINA ) COUNTY OF ORANGEBURG ) /? ,'II - Z7 L Personally appeared before me &C/ / e ./rC ;L-. /'--£i''::;:/ / , who, being duly s1rJOrn, says that .:;5;1; e_ saw the above named DO; )Y&1/,-cj~1-::::::--V)-S sign, sea! and, as //;~,c,;5 act and deed, deliv'er the foregoing Lease Agreement, and that 3.be.. with r::;' I L D /' ·:.--Cr'"C·; /177/7 DJ"-£.I'/,'/ -::xy n witnessed the execution thereof. SWORN to me this ::;;;;-. / c=- day ) - ) of March, 1988. ~-4 '~ , ;~?4=-<-cd&-.x---.-e'-<L J ) ) ) ~~d1fi?~ NOTARY PUBLIC FOR sPUTH CAROLINA My Commission expires: Page #2. , / ;;;;r--h' -'i£/ :? C '" / i'~' Recorded this \ \: day of ~~~ 19~'\ Jn~ ,'"'r At"l51 "':/: SVi:(f iiik 1 U A., ~! "'- RMC ORANGEB1lRG co., s. c. 1 '0 .. i; b .~ '. ''''<~'~':~ ,," '~'.' (3) submit corrected pole permit applications demonstrating that it has corrected all violations. Columbia, South Carolina March __ ' __ , ~988. ROBINSON, .MCFADDEN, ~100RE, POPE, WILLIAMS, TAYLOR & BRAILSFORD, P.A. By: ~A= tr1. eJ~J, / FI£ JesM. Brailsfo~~ ~ By: ~/?#di\:: Frank R. Ellerbe, III P. O. Box 944 Columbia, SC 29202 803-779-8900 . -17- , C\I (Y) M CO CO <:( CITY COUNCIL MINUTES APRIL 19, 1988 367 Orangeburg City April 19, 1988 presiding. Council held its regularly scheduled meeting on in City Hall Chambers at 7:00 P.M., Mayor Pendarvis PRESENT: E. o. Pendarvis, Mayor A motion Alexander, Minutes as w. Everette Salley, Mayor Pro Tern Henry F. Frierson Sara H. Alexander Herbert W. Bradley, Jr. by Councilmember Bradley, seconded unanimously approved the· April 5, distributed. by 1988 Councilmember City Council To clarify a motion that was passed on 4-5-88, a motion by Mayor Pro Tern Salley, seconded by Mayor Pendarvis, unanimously approved for the existing lease for the operation of the airport not to be renewed and that a new lease be negotiated taking into account current conditions. Mayor Pro Tern Salley did not mean in his first motion of 4-5-88 that this new lease has to be negotiated with the present operator. A request was received from the Orangeburg County Chamber of Commerce to initiate a new lease between the City and the Chamber. A motion by Mayor Pro Tern Salley, seconded by Councilmember Alexander, unanimously approved to refer this to Attorney Walsh for lease agreement preparation. Don Smith presented an evaluation to council concerning accesses to the new subdivision at the end of Livingston Terrace. Representing the developers, Attorney Tom Bryant, said that an agreement can be worked out to save harmless the City from liability from a street over a dam that the state will not take into its system. A motion by Mayor Pro Tern Salley, seconded by Councilmember Alexander, unanimously approved to accept the six (6) proposed streets, not to include one over the dam, subject to receipt of the afore mentioned instrument by the City Attorney. City Administrator Smith informed council that Public Safety Director, Eugene A. Brant, had written the Ku Klux Klan for them to choose an alternate date other than 4-30-88 for their demonstration. To date he had not received a response. A motion by Mayor Pro Tern Salley, seconded by councilmember Frierson, unanimously denied this request because it conflicts with the Rose Festival. Public Safety Director Brant states that he could not provide adequate police protection at that time due to the Rose Festival. A request was received from Mr. David Ott of the Public Safety Department requesting consideration in his case that in less than one year he will have thirty (30) years of service to the City and that under the present policy if he was to retire before age sixty (not of age 60) he would lose his health insurance benefits. A motion by Mayor Pendarvis, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Salley, unanimouslY approved for City Administrator Smith and Department of Public Utilities Manager, Ted Johnson to review the current City policy and bring a recommendation to council. A motion by Mayor Pro Tern Salley, seconded by Councilmember Bradley, unanimously approved to send a letter to the state highway engineer concerning improvements to Boulevard NE and St. Matthews Road NE. Hillcrest Golf Course Manager, Tom Vargo, presented a report to council on the greatly improved revenue situation at the golf course. He stated that if conditions continue the deficit will not be as great as budgeted. He said this means we are moving closer to reaching the break-even point if conditions continue to improve. Mayor Pendarvis and Mayor Pro Tern Salley both expressed their feelings that we definitely need to reach that break-even point. 368 CITY COUNCIL MINUTES APRIL 19, 1988 PAGE 2 There was no Department of Public Utilities matters as Manager, Ted Johnson, was not present. There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned. ReS~UllY submitted, ~ lc~Ol A. Brunson City Clerk /r /;- Donald J. Smith & Associates II., Inc. April 14, 1988 Engineering Consultants 120 Bull. SI. P.O. Box 2043 Orangeburg, SC 291 i 6-2043 (803) 533-1083 Members of City Council City of Orangeburg, S.C. 29116 Re: Proposed Streets Dear Members of Council, We have evaluated the possible alternative entrance locations to serve the proposed project as requested and submit the following for Y8ur consideration. Livingston Terrace Livingston Terrace has been used as access for this property for many years and is being currently used by the owners and tenant. This route provides the most direct and unobstructed access to the property and is the mosi economically feasible. Also, this route would not destroy or endanger protected wetland habitat as would other possible accesses. Previous owners have constructed approximately three hundred feet of asphalt roadway that can be utilized at a savings of $6,000. The Livingston Terrace access is the only route that would utilize this existing roadwaY. Abandonment of this road would result in the loss of approximately 0_50 acre of usable land. The proposed project will consist of lots of comparable price range as those of Livingston Terrace. The developers of this project anticipate lots prices to range between $25,OcrO and $6~,000. Records show the appraised value of the lots along Livingston Terrace to be between $21,000 and $45,000. Riverside Drive Access for the proposed development from Riverside Drive would require the filling of approximately 95,000 square feet of protected wetland habitat. Construction of this road would require a permit from the U.S. Army Corp. of Engineers. The decision to issue this permit would be based on an evaluation of the probable impact of the project, including cumulative impacts of the proposed activity, and will include the application of gUidelines promulgated by the Secretary of the Environmental Protection Agency in conjunction with the Secretary of the Army under authority of Section 404(b) of the Clean Water Act. These guidelines state that: a .. "no discharge of dredged or fill material shall be permitted if there is a practicable alternative to the proposed discharge which would have less adverse impact on the aquatic ecosystem, so long as the alternative does not have other significant adverse environmental consequences." The process of applying for this permit would take approximately six to twelve months. This access location would also destroy approximately 11,000 cubic yards of floodplain, increasing the flood depths in other locations of the Caw Caw drainage basin. The cost of constructing this road, if permitted, would be approximately $173,600. Plantation This location of the entrance road would also destroy protected wetland habitat. Approximately 2,550 square feet would be affected. Construction of this road would be approximately $16,400. Loss of land associated with this change in the entrance location would amount to approx'imately $30,000. This location would require traffic to enter the development thru North Ridge Subdivision. Lot prices in North Ridge have an appraised value that range from $7,800 to $12,000,as compared to the anticipated lot prices of $25,000 to $60,000 in the propose~ project. The developers feel that this large difference in prices would be detrimental to their project. Also, this route would be less direct than others, increasing the possibility of traffic problems. The entrance at this location would have a greater slope than is desirable fo~ residential streets. . Riley Entering the project from Riley would increase the street cost by approximately $11,400. This site would be similar in location to that of Livingston Terrace but would not be as direct and require traffic to negotiate three ninety degree turns. This entrance location would be affected by the difference in lot prices as mentioned. in the case of the Plantation entrance. Loss of residential land associate with this --- / change in the entrance location would be approximately $35,000. It it our opinion that the Riverside Drive and Plantation locations are the least desirable route for an entrance, primarily because they would require the destruction of environmentally important, protected wetland habitat and the excessive costs associated with construction. The Riley Drive location would serve no purpose except to re-route traffic from Livingston Terrace thru North Ridge Subdivision, a route that would be more indirect, obstructed and costlier. In summary, we feel that Livingston Terrace is the more direct, logical, economical as well as least environmentally damagiQg location available. Very Sincerely Yours, Donald J. Smith. R.L.S. President \ '" a: <t a.. I­ W ::;; W " C\I (Y) aJ aJ « CITY COUNCIL MINUTES MAY 3, 1988 369 Orangeburg City Council 3, 1988 in City Hall presiding. held its regularly scheduled meeting on May Chambers at 7:00 P.M., Mayor Pendarvis PRESENT: E. O. Pendarvis, Mayor W. Everette Salley, Mayor Pro Tern Henry F. Frierson Sara H. Alexander Herbert W. Bradley, Jr. A Public Hearing was held for rezoning property located on the 400 block of Sellers, SE from A-2 Residential to D-l Industrial and for rezoning property located on the 300 block of Seaboard, NW from A-2 Residential ~ B-1 Business. A motion by Councilmember Frierson, seconded by Councilmember Alexander, un nimously approved the April 19, 1988 City Council Minutes as distributed. A motion by Councilmember Bradley, seconded by councilmember Alexander, unanimously approved the amended Retirement Policy--Hospitalization Insurance Plan. It was noted that this change would be effective immediately upon Council's approval. A copy of which is attached. A motion by Mayor Pro Tern Frierson, unanimously approved rezone the property located on Residential to D-1 Industrial. Salley, seconded by councilmember the first reading of an ordinance to the 400 block of Sellers, SE from A-2 A motion by Councilmember Frierson, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Salley, unanimously approved to rezone the property located on the 300 block of Seaboard, NW from A-2 Residential to B-1 Business. A motion by Mayor Pro Tern Salley, seconded by Councilmember Alexander, unanimously approved for the Uptown Merchant's to have two (2) sidewalk sales on May 6th through 7th and June 10th through the 11th. A motion by Mayor Pro Tern Salley, seconded by Councilmember Bradley, unanimously approved the low bid of $20,480 from Lee's Lawnmowing Service for the cutting and maintaining of weedy lots. A motion by Mayor Pro Tern Salley, seconded by Councilmember Bradley, unanimously approved the purchase of radio beacon equipment ($9,195) for the Orangeburg Municipal Airport from Southern Aviation Company, Beaumont, Texas, noting that the City received a grant in the amount of $6,725 from the South Carolina Aeronautics Commission. A motion by Councilmember Alexander, unanimously approved a Proclamation National Nurses' Day. seconded by Mayor Pendarvis, observing May 6, 1988 as Department of Public Utilities Manager, Ted Johnson, brought no utility matters before Council. There being no further business, the meeting was\ adjourned. L. Hugh Smith ~~~ C~ty Adm~n~strator /r 370 CITY COUNCIL MINUTES MAY 17, 1988 orangeburg 17,1988 presiding. City Council held its regularly scheduled meeting on May in City Hall Chambers at 7:00 P.M. Mayor Pendarvis PRESENT: E.O. Pendarvis, Mayor W. Everette Salley, Mayor Pro Tern Henry F. Frierson Sara H. Alexander ABSENT: Herbert W. Bradley, Jr. A motion by Mayor Pro Tern Frierson, unanimously approved as distributed. Salley, seconded by Councilmember the May 3, 1988 City council Minutes A motion by Councilmember Frierson, seconded by Councilmember Alexander, unanimously approved the second reading of an ordinance to rezone the following: a. A-2 Residential to D-1 Industrial--400 Block of Sellers SE b. A-2 Residential to B-1 Business--300 Block of Seaboard NW A motion by Councilmember Alexander, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Salley, unanimously approved the first reading of an ordinance to lease to the Orangeburg Chamber of Commerce the lot and building known as the "Chamber Building" located on U. S. Highway 301 in the City of Orangeburg, SC. A motion by Mayor Pendarvis, seconded by Councilmember Frierson, unanimously approved the Crime Stoppers request to match up to $5,000 (each from City and County) after Crime Stoppers raises $10,000 from private donations. A motion by Mayor Pendarvis, seconded by Councilmember Frierson, unanimously approved the pawn shop application from Gale R. Stanley. A motion by Councilmember Alexander, seconded by Mayor Pendarvis, unanimously approved the low bid of $16,995.30 from Zimmerman-Evans, Inc., in Greensboro, NC for the purchase of fire fighting equipment for the Public Safety Department. At this time Mayor Pendarvis fire at Lee's Exxon Station several persons for avoiding a point of this letter was that with fire fighting equipment immediately to this situation. read a letter concerning the recent which praised the quick action of very dangerous situation. The main a Public Safety Officer in the area in his vehicle was able to respond A motion by Councilmember Frierson, seconded by Councilmember Alexander, unanimously approved the following Resolutions: 1. A Resolution expressing intentions of the City of Orangeburg to file an application for Rental Rehabili­ tation Program Grant Funds in the approximate amount of $50,000. 2. A Resolution authorizing the State Housing Authority to handle any and all HUB Section 8 Vouchers for Rental Rehabilitation Grant. DPU Manager, Ted Johnson, informed Council that an upcoming increase in natural gas from the supplier will be passed along to customers "penny for penny." This will be reflected in the surcharge refund which will vary from month to month. A motion by Mayor Pro Tern Salley, seconded by Mayor Pendarvis, unanimously approved the Resolution authorizing Mayor Pendarvis to sign all necessary contracts concerning the above matter. --_._-- _. ..-.::, O. PENDARVIS L HUGH SMITH CITY ADMINISTRATOR I MAYOR , lARA H. ALEXANDER lERBERT W. BRADLEY. JA. .<ENRY F. FRIERSON. M.D. w. EVERETTE SALLEY. D.V.M. MEMBERS OF COUNCil TO: FROM: VATE: <llittt .of <IDnmg.ehurg ~Ilutlt ClIllrillinll 29116-0387 OJULngebWLg c.i;.ty COun.ei.f. L. Hugh SmUh, c.i;.ty Admi..ni/.:tJr.JL Ted Johnl.on, MangeJL VPU Ap!t.U 22, 19.88 SUBJECT: c.i;.ty Re:t.iJLemen:t Policy--HoAp.U:a.Uza:t.ion InAWUULee M JLequuzed a;t ;the c.i;.ty Coun.ei.f. Mee.:ti.n.gheld on 4-19-88 we Mve JLeviewed .the policy de.:teJun.i.n.i.g .the el..igibiUtY o~ cLty emp!.oyeu :to JLe:t.i.JLe and :to JLe:ta..in. Aome .uu.WUULee benenm. The CWVLen:t policy ba.&ic!a.Uy i4: 1. The emp!.oyee may JLe:t.i.JLe a.M;VL ha.ving JLea.c.hed .the age on 60 w.U:h a;t Lea.J..t 20 yea.JL6 on AeJLv.i.cL 2. The emp!.oyee may JLe:t.iJLe a;t .the age on 65 w.U:h a;t !.ea.I..t 15 yea.JL6 of. AeJLv.i.cL . One po.&.Ub.te ame.ndmen:t :to'.thi4 policy .tha.t wou.ld JLeeognize emp!.oyeu. who ha.ve AeJLved 30 OJL mOJLe yea.JL6 w.U:h .the c.i;.ty and who wou.ld Uke :to JLe:t.iJLe pJLioJL :to a.ge 60 wou.ld be .the f.oUOI,nmg: IJL The emp!.oyee may JLe:t.iJLe a;t any age a.f..tVL ha.ving AVLved 30 OJL mOJLe yea.JL6 w.U:h .the c.i;.ty. If. a.n employee JLe:t.iJLu w.U:h 30 oJtmOJLe yea.JL6 AeJLvice pJLioJL :to JLea..ehUtg .the age of. 60, he OJL Ahe wou.ld be a.tl.tXIJed :to Jte:tain c.oveJLa.ge on .the c.i;.ty' A hoAp.U:a.Uza:t.ion policy a;t lli OJL heJL OIAIn 1!XpenJ.e. : Upon JLe.a.c.hi.ng age 60 .the c.i;.ty wou.ld .then begin pa.ying.;the Aame .uu.uJu.utc.e plLem.ium4 .tha.t Me .then ~ being pa.id f.OJL o.theJL JLe:t.i.JLed emp!.oyeu. Tlli benef.U /Alou.ld apply only :to ,thoAe employeu who JterIiaiir.ed on .the c.i;.ty policy f.JLOm .the time he OJL Ahe JLe:t£JLed un:.t.i..l JLea.c.hing age 60. • (\j (Y) rl OJ OJ « CITY COUNCIL MINUTES MAY 17, 1988 PAGE 2 371 A motion by Mayor Pro Tern Salley, Alexander, unanimously approved the change in rates for natural gas. seconded by Councilmember Resolution authorizing the There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned. /r 7ft(:l ,ubmitted, (S~l A. Brunson \..:1. ty Clerk 372 CITY COUNCIL MINUTES JUNE 7, 1988 Orangeburg City council 7, 1988 in City Hall presiding. held its regularly scheduled meeting on June Chambers at 7:00 P.M., Mayor Pendarvis PRESENT: E. O. Pendarvis, Mayor W. Everette Salley, Mayor Pro Tern Henry F. Frierson fRra H. Alexander Herbort W. Bradley, Jr. A motion by Councilmember Alexander, seconded by Councilmember Bradley, unanimously approved the May 17,1988 City Council Minutes as distributed. Parks and Recrea~ion Department Director, Marion J. smith, informed Council that the "All America Rose Selections" has presented a certificate for outstanding Rose Garden Maintenance in 1987 to the Edisto Memorial Gardens Rose Gardens. The society commended Marion Davis, City Horticulturist, and all other City employees who contributed to making this honor possible. A motion by Councilmember Alexander, seconded by Councilmember Frierson, unanimously approved the third reading of an ordinance to rezone the following: a. A-2 Residential to D-l Industrial--400 Block of Sellers, SE b. A-2 Residential to B-1 Business--300 Block of Seaboard, NW A motion by Mayor Pro Tern Salley, seconded by Councilmember Alexander, unanimously approved the second reading of an ordinance for the Chamber of Commerce Lease. A motion by unanimously for sale of Mayor Pendarvis, seconded by Councilmember Frierson, agreed to hold a joint auction with the County and City surplus property. A motion by Councilmember Frierson, unanimously approved the request of parade on 6-18-88 with restrictions Safety Director, Eugene Brant. seconded by Mayor the Ku Klux Klan to be placed by Pendarvis, to hold a the Public Department of Public Utilities Manager, Ted Johnson, brought no utility matters before Council. There being no further business, th~eting was adjourned. Re~~~Ul~YASUbmitted' /#Jfo {~runson (g~ty Clerk /r RESOLUTION RENTAL REHABILITATION GRANT APPLICATION WHEREAS, The. Ci:tg on O:umgebuJtg ~ :to 6il.e. an appUeati..on noJt Re.n;ta.f. Re.hab-iLi;ta;U.on PltOgJr.aJ1l GJta.n:t nundo .in :the. appltOtima:te. amount on $50,000, and WHEREAS, :the.oe. nundo aJte. ;to be. u6ed noJt :the. Re.h.a.b-iLi;ta;U.on au.i&ta.nee. noJt tOOl and mode.Jta:te. .ineome. namili.e.o in :the. Ci:tg on OJtangebuJtg, and NOW, THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVEV, :tha:t :the. Ci:tg on O:umgebuJtg au:thoJt.ize.o :the. pltOee.o.6.ing an .{)aid appUeati..on nOlL :the. gJtant nund.o. AVOPTEV, :thi.o 17:th day an May, 1988 a:t O:umgebuJtg, Sou;th CaJtoUna. A;:,/ /,// / j/ I "'/ // 'Y,""/ , " // . ,; / /';;/ / / / / //' /,// ,j ./-:, . / 'V-' cjiY CLERK £~~!.~ t: (7/ ,/ CL_~~[1 '.4)/ '-c // /' /-;>' /~C/ v' (/;\2 ' ~<-/ ' J ~ / ~~ d ~~'- MEMBERS Of COUNCIL RESOLUTION AVMINISTRATION OF HUV SEerION 8 VOUCHERS FOR RENTAL REHABILITATION GRANT WHEREAS, The Ci:ty 06 OlULngebUlLg ,£.M.endh :to 6-(£.e an appUca.:t.Wn nOlL Ren:tal. Re.htzhl..U:ta.tn PlLOglUlm GJLa.n:t 6UYU:1.h .in :the applLOlWna:te amo(lJ'l;(; 06 $50,000, and WHEREAS, :thue 6UYU:1.h .alLe :to be lL6ed nOlL :the Rehab-iLi:to.;Uon tL6.6.u:tanee 60lL low and modVUI:te .income 6a.m.iLi..u .in :the Ci:ty 06 OlULngebUlLg, and NOW, THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVEV, :tha:t :the Ci:ty 06 .OlULngebWLg au:thOJUzu :the S:ta:te HOIL6.ing Au;;t:hoJU;ty :to h.and.ee aYlIj and al£. HUV Sec:tion 8 VouehVLO .in connec:t.i.on w.i;th :the Ci:ty'.6 Ren:tal. Rehab-iLi:to.;Uon GJLa.n:t AppUea:t.Wn, -<'11 6unded.. AVOPTEV, .th.i..6 11:th day 06 1AaJj, 1988 a:t OlULngebUlLg, Sou;;t:h CalLOUna. ~&a£ y- " ;;?~ ~ Z .. ATTEr /~' '. '/ / i//, ~';/ / '§(;; / /YJ-.-­' ··/ll1// / CiTY CLm MAVy.. ' ~~ /...~ r(j":' // I \ / /./.~. /-'. /"'" ";;< F~ . i' ( /-..-/ - /u€-LL ,D ~Z /C / ---. --' • MEMBERS OF COUNCIL RESOLUTION BE IT RESOLVED By the Mayor and Members of Council of the City of Orangeburg, South Carolina, in Council assembled, and by authority of the same: That the rates of the Depart:rnent of Public Utilities of the City of Orangeburg pertaining to Natural Gas, as heretofore adopted be, and the same are hereby repealed, and in lieu thereof, the Natural Gas Rates of the Depart:rnent of Public Utilities of the City of Orangeburg, hereto attached, be and they are hereby, declared effective and in full force on June 15, 1988 billings. PASSED by the City Council, in Council assembled at Orangeburg, South Carolina, this Il,iJ", day of fY'irA u , 1988. =i.( //? /~~?- CiJ;Y/Clerk and Treasurer J Signed: ftJ, ~ ~~~/~~ Members of Council F Depart:ment of Public Utilities - Orangeburg, South Carolina ELECTRIC RATE NO. 1 - RESIDENTIAL SERVICE (Code 2A) APPLICABLE: To a single-family dwelling unit supplied through one meter for domestic use. This schedule is not applicable to a residence which is used for commerciaL professional, or any other enterprise unless the domestic use can be separately metered, in which case this schedule is applicable to the metered domestic portion of energy use only. CHARACTER OF SERVICE: Alternating =rent, 60 hertz. Voltage and phase at the option of the Company. GROSS MONTHLY RATE: (See Article IV-A, Item number 4, "General Terms and Conditions" for discount) Standard Rate First 50 kwhr @ $0.1319 per kwhr Next 200 kwhr @ $0.0719 per kwhr All in excess of 250 kwhr @ $0.0614 per kwhr Min:iJ:num $6.38 per meter per month. Note: "General Terms and Conditions" in effect apply to above. See Article IV-A, Item Number 4, "General Terms and Conditions" for discount on above. CURRENT FUEL CHARGE WILL BE APPLIED TO THIS RATE SCHEDULE. Effective: March 1, 1988 -, Department of Public Utilities - Orangeburg, South Carolina ELECTRIC RATE NO. l-A - RESIDENTIAL SERVICE - ALL ELECTRIC (Code 2B) APPLICABLE: To a single-familY private dwelling unit supplied through one meter for all domestic use, including water heating, space heat­ ing, and air conditioning, where electric service is the only source of energy for the dwelling unit, except energy provided by wood-burn­ ing fireplaces used primarily for aesthetic purposes. This schedule is not applicable to a residence which is used for commercial purposes. If the customer's wiring is so arranged that electric service for domestic and nondomestic purposes can be metered separately, this schedule is applicable to that portion used for domestic purposes only. CHARACTER OF SERVICE: Alternating current, 60 hertz. Voltage and phase at the option of the Company. GROSS MONTHLY RATE: (See Article IV-A, Item number 4, "General Terms and Conditions" for discount) Standard Rates Summer Season First 50 kwhr @ $0. 1319 per kwhr Next 200 kwhr @ $0.0719 per kwhr All in excess of 250 kwhr @ $0.0614 per kwhr Winter Season First Next Next All in excess of Miffilllum 50 kwhr @ $0.1319 per kwhr 200 kwhr @ $0.0719 per kwhr 750 kwhr @ $0.0614 per kwhr 1,000 kwhr @ $0.0506 per kwhr $6.38 per meter per month. The winter season begins with Cycle 7 bills dated November and ends with Cycle 6 bills dated May. The summer season applies for all other bills rendered during the year. Note: "General Tenns and Conditions" in effect apply to above. See Article IV-A, Item Number 4, "General Tenns and Conditions" for discount on above. CURRENT FUEL CHARGE WILL BE APPLIED TO THIS RATE SCHEDULE. Effective: March 1, 1988 1- Department of Public Utilities - Orangeburg, South Carolina ELECI'RIC RA'IE NO. 2 - GENERAL SERVICE (Code 2C) APPLICABLE: To any nondanestic and/or commercial or industrial customer for all power and energy uses at anyone location where service of a single character is taken through one meter at one point of delivery for which no specific schedule is provided. This schedule is not applicable to breakdown, standby, supplementary, resale or shared electric service. All temporary service will be billed under this schedule. This rate will not be available for any new account which has a demand in excess of 300 ¥Ji.I. CHARACTER OF SERVICE: Alternating =rent, 60 hertz. Voltage and phase at the option of the Company. GROSS MONTHLY RATE: (See Article IV-A, Item Ntmiber 4, "General Tenus and Conditions" for discount) Standard Rate First 50 kwhr @ $0. 1299 per kwhr Next 100 kwhr @ $0.1190 per kwhr Next 200 kwhr @ $0.0962 per kwhr Next 2,650 kwhr @ $0.0731 per kwhr All in excess of 3,000 kwhr @ $0.0643 per kwhr Mininu.ml $6.38 per meter per month. Note: "General Tenus and Conditions" in effect apply to above. See Article IV-A, Item Number 4, "General Tenus and Conditions" for discount on above. CURRENT FUEL CHARGE WILL BE APPLIED TO THIS RA'IE SCHEDULE. Effective: March 1, 1988 Depart:rnent of Public Utilities - orangeburg, South Carolina ELECTRIC RATE NO. 2-A - GENERAL SERVICE - ALL ELECTRIC (Code 2D) APPLICABLE: To any nondomestic and/or corrrrnercial or industrial customer who would otherwise receive service under Rate No. 2 for all general power and energy use including lighting, water heating, space heating and air conditioning, where electric service is the only source of energy. This rate will not be available for any account which has a demand in excess of 300 ¥N. CHARACI'ER OF SERVICE: Alternating current, 60 hertz. Voltage and phase at the option of the Campany. GROSS MONTHLY RATE: (See Article IV-A, Item Number 4, "General Tenus and Conditions" for discount) Standard Rates S\.lITIITIer Season First 50 kwhr @ $0.1299 per kwhr Next 100 kwhr @ $0.1190 per kwhr Next 200 kwhr @ $0.0962 per kwhr Next 2,650 kwhr @ $0.0731 per kwhr All in excess of 3,000 kwhr @ $0.0643 per kwhr Winter Season First 50 kwhr @ $0.1299 per kwhr Next 100 kwhr @ $0.1190 per kwhr Next 200 kwhr @ $0.0962 per kwhr Next 650 kwhr @ $0.0731 per kwhr Next 2,000 kwhr @ $0.0687 per kwhr All in excess of 3,000 kwhr @ $0.0556 per kwhr M:inimJm $16.90 per meter per month. The winter season begins with Cycle 7 bills dated November and ends with Cycle 6 bills dated May. The s\.lITIITIer season applies for all other bills rendered during the year. Note: "General Tenus and Conditions" in effect apply to above. See Article IV-A, Item Number 4, "General Tenus and Conditions" for discount on above. CURRENT FUEL CHARGE WILL BE APPLIED TO TlUS RATE SCHEDULE. Effective: March 1, 1988 Department of Public Utilities - Orangeburg, South caroUna ELECTRIC RATE No. 3 - MEDruM GENERAL SERVICE (Code 2E) APPLICABLE: To industrial or ccmnercial customers for general power and energy purposes and having demands of 100 kw or over. This schedule is not applicable to breakdown, standby, supplementary, resale or shared electric service. CHARACTER OF SERVICE: Alternating current, 60 cycle, three phase service. Voltage at the option of the Company. GROSS MONTHLY RATE: (See Article N-A, Item Number 4, "General Te:rms and Conditions" for discount) Demand Charge First All in excess of 100 kw @ $973.00 of billing demand 100 kw @ $9.73 per kw of billing demand The bilUng demand (to the nearest whole KW) shall be the greatest of (1) the max:imum integrated fifteen-minute demand measured during the current month, (2) eighty percent (80%) of the highest demand occurring during the eleven preceding months, or (3) the contract demand, or (4) 100 KW. Energy Charge All kwhr @ $0.03080 per kwhr Mirrilllum The rn:i.nirmJm monthly charge shall be the demand charge as determined above. POWER FACTOR CORRECTION: The customer shall at all times maintain a power factor of not less than 85 percent. The Department reserves the right to conduct tests to determine the power factor of the customer's in­ stallation during periods of max:imum demand or by measurement of the average power factor for the monthly bilUng period. Should the power factor so detennined fall below 85 percent, the demand for bilUng purposes will be determined by multiplying the max:imum kw demand by 85 percent and dividing by the determined power factor. No credit shall be given for power factor greater than 85 percent. Note: "General Terms and Conditions" in effect apply to above. See N-A, Item N\JIlIber 4, "General Te:rms and Conditions" for discount on above. CURRENT FUEL CHARGE WILL BE APPLIED TO THIS RATE SCHEDULE. Effective: March 1, 1988 Department of Public Utilities - Orangeburg, South Carolina ELECI'RIC RATE NO. 4 - IRRIGATION SERVICE (CODE 2F) APPLICATION: To any customer for all power and energy used at any one location where service of a single character is taken through one meter for the operation of electric motor driven pumps and equipnent supply­ ing water for irrigation of farmlands and plant nurseries. The pumping units served hereunder shall be used solely for the purpose of irriga­ tion. CHARACTER OF SERVICE: Alternating current, 60 cycle, three phase service. Voltage at the option of the Corrvany. STANDARD RATE I. SUJV1lVIER - Months of June - September ON-PEAK - Billing Demand - $ 5.78 per kw. of billing demand Energy -------- $ .1333 per kwhr. SHOULDER - Energy ------ $ . 0889 per kwhr. OFF-PEAK - Energy ------ $ .0444 per kwhr. II. WINTER - Months of October - May All Energy -- $ . 0444 per kwhr. MINIMUM CHARGE: The monthly rnirUntum charge shall be $12.00 per month except when the revenue produced by the customer does not sufficiently support the the investment required to serve the load. The Corrvany will dete:rmine in each case the amount and form of payment required to correct the revenue deficiency. ON-PEAK, SHOULDER, AND OFF-PEAK HOURS A. On-Peak Hours: Sum:ner months of June through September The on-peak hours are defined as the hours between 1:00 p.m. - 7:00 p.m. Monday - Friday, excluding holidays * B. Shoulder Hours: Sum:ner months of June through September The shoulder hours are defined as the hours between 11: 00 a.m. - 1: 00 p.m. and 7:00 p.m. - 9:00 p.m. Monday - Friday, excluding holidays * C. Off-Peak Hours: The off-peak hours in any month are defined as all hours not specified above as on-peak or shoulder hours. *Holidays are Independence Day and Labor Day. NOTE: "General Terms and conditions" in effect apply to above. See IV-A, Item Nurriber 4, "General Terms and Conditions" for discount on above. CURRENT FUEL CHARGE WILL BE APPLIED TO THIS RATE SCHEDULE. Effective: March 1, 1988 - Department of Public Utilities - Orangeburg, South Carolina ELECTRIC RATE NO. 7 - LARGE POWER AND INDUSTRIAL (Users having Connected Load of 41 kilowatts and over) (Code 2I) Monthly M:inirmJm Charge of $3.00 per kw of Connected Load. First 50 kwbr @ $0.13611 per kwbr per ll10nth Next 100 kwbr @ $0.11452 per kwbr per ll10nth Next 200 kwbr @ $0.10552 per kwbr per ll10nth Next 4,650 kwbr @ $0.06968 per kwbr per ll10nth All in excess of 5,000 kwbr @ $0.05696 per kwbr per roonth NOTE: TIllS RATE NOT AVAILABLE AFTER OCTOBER 6, 1970. Note: "General Terms and Conditions" in effect apply to above. See Article IV-A, Item Number 4, "General Terms and Conditions" for discount on above. CURRENT FUEL CHARGE WILL BE APPLIED TO THIS RATE SCHEDULE. Effective: March 1, 1988 Department of PUblic Utilities - Orangeburg, South Carolma ELECTRIC RATE NO. 8 - LARGE GENERAL SERVICE (Code 2H) APPLICABLE: To large :industrial or commercial customers for general power and energy purposes and hav:ing demands of 1,000 kw or over. This schedule is not applicable to breakdown, standby, supplementaxy, re­ sale or shared electric service. CHARACTER OF SERVICE: Alternating current, 60 cycle, three phase service. Service will be metered at primary voltage. GROSS MONTHLY RATE: (See Article TIl-A, Item Number 4, "General Tenus and Conditions" for discount) Demand Charge First All :in excess of 1,000 kw @ $9,730.00 of bill:ing demand L 000 kw @ $9.24 per kw of bill:ing demand The bill:ing demand (to the nearest whole FYI) shall be the greatest of: (1) the:maximum :integrated fifteen-minute demand measured dur:ing the current month, (2) eighty percent (80%) of the highest demand occurr:ing dur:ing the eleven preced:ing months, (3) the contract demand, or (4) 1,000 FYI. Energy Charge First 400,000 kwhr @ $0.03080 per kwhr All :in excess of 400,000 kwhr @ $0.02970 per kwhr Minimum The rn:in:iJuum monthly charge shall be the demand charge as determined above. POWER FACTOR CORRECTION: The customer shall at all times mainta:in a power factor of not less than 85 percent. The Department reserves the right to conduct tests to determine the power factor of the customer's :in­ stallation dur:ing periods of :maximum demand or by measurement of the average power factor for the monthly bill:ing period. Should the power factor so determined fall below 85 percent, the demand for bill:ing pur­ poses will be determined by multiply:ing the :maximum kw demand by 85 percent and divid:ing by the determined power factor. No credit shall be given for power factors greater than 85 percent. Note: "General Tenus and Conditions" :in effect apply to above. See Article TIl-A, Item Number 4, "General Tenus and Conditions" for discount on above. CURPENT FUEL CHARGE WILL BE APPLIED TO THIS RATE SOlEDULE. Effective: March 1, 1988 --, Department of Public Utilities - Orangeburg, South carolina ELECTRIC RATE NO. 9 - OVERHEAD PRIVATE LIGHTING (Code 2K, 2L, 2M, 2Q, 2R, 2S) The following is the rate schedule for lights installed for customers on company's standard poles which are a part of company's distriliution system. Size 2K - 7,500 Lumens (Mercury) Open Type Globe 2L - 20,000 Lumens (Mercury) Closed Type Globe 2M - 50,000 Lumens (Mercury) Closed Type Globe 2Q - 9,500 Lumens (BPS) Open Type Globe 2R - 27,500 Lumens (BPS) Closed Type Globe 2S - 50,000 Lumens (BPS) Closed Type Globe Larrp Charges Per Month $ 5.85/each $11. 14/each $17 .46/each $ 5.85/each $11. 14/each $17.46/each Cost Per Month For Each Additional Pole: 30 ft. 35 ft. 40 ft. 45 ft. $1.30 $2.00 $2.50 $3.00 KJAhr • Per Month Watts 70 140 400 40 105 160 175 400 1000 100 250 400 Note: "General TeIllIS and Conditions" in effect apply to above. See Article N-A, Item Number 4, "General Terms and Conditions" for discount on above. CURRENT FUEL CHARGE WILL BE APPLIED TO THIS RATE SCHEDULE. Effective: March 1, 1988 Department of Public Utilities - Orangeburg, South Carolina ELECTRIC RATE NO. 10 - STREET LIGFII'S (Code 2J, 2N, 20, 2P, 2T, 2U, 2V, 7M, 2Y) GROSS MONTHLY RATE: See Article D/-A, Item Number 4, "General Tenus and Conditions" for discount. 2N- 20 - 2P - 2T - 2U - 2V- 2W - The following is the rate schedule for lights installed for street lighting in the City of Orangeburg. A. Unmetered Street Lights Larrp Kwhr. Charges Per Size Per Month Month 7,500 Lumens (Mercury) Open Type Globe $ 6.13/each 70 20,000 Lumens (Mercury) Closed Type Globe $11.70/each 140 50,000 Lumens (Mercury) Closed Type GlObe $29. 67/each 400 9,500 Lumens (HPS) Open Type Globe $ 6.13/each 40 27,500 Lumens (HPS) Closed Type GlObe $11. 70/each 105 36,000 Lumens (HPS) Closed Type Globe $12.2S/each 140 50,000 Lumens (HPS) Closed Type GlObe $13.23/each 160 2Y - 140,000 Lumens (HPS) Closed Type Globe $29. 67/each 400 B. Metered Street Lights 2J - $0.08374 per KWH Watts 175 400 1000 100 250 360 400 1000 Note: "General Terms and Conditions" in effect apply to above. See Article D/-A, Item Number 4, "General Tenus and Conditions" for discount on above. CURRENT FUEL CHARGE WILL BE APPLIED TO THIS RATE SCHEDULE. Effective: March 1, 1988 Department of Public Utilities - orangeburg, South Carolina Exhibit A CONTRACT RATE (Code 2X) CONTRACT RATE: FOR SALE OF ELECI'RIC POWER AND ENERGY TO GREENWOOD MIILS LINER PLANT AVAILABILITY: This rate is available by contract for service to Greenwood Mills Liner Plant (Plant). CHARACTER OF SERVICE: Alternating current, 60 cycle, three phase service metered at primary voltage. GROSS MONTHLY RATE: Demand Charge Energy Charge Facilities Charge Mir.drrnzrrMonthly Facilities Charge $10.80/Kw of billing demand 2.687¢/KWh of energy delivered 0.45¢/KWh of energy delivered $4,500.00 MONTHLY BILLTI'JG DEMAND: The monthly billing demand (calculated to the nearest whole Kw) shall be detennined as the power requirement of the Plant coincident with the Department's monthly rnax:iJnum demand. The Department's monthly :maximum demand shall be as detennined by South Carolina Electric and Gas Corrpany (SCE&G) for the purpose of billing the Department for the purchase of power under PERC Rate Schedule WR or its successor. In the event the Department's Billing Demand from SCE&G is in excess of the Department's monthly rnax:iJnum demand due to the effect of applying a billing ratchet, the billing demand herein applicable to Plant shall be silnilarly detennined. ADJUSTMENT FOR CHANGES IN PURCHASE POWER COST: The above stated demand and energy charges are based on purchased power and energy charges to the Department by SCE&G of $9. 72/Kw (exclusive of high voltage discount) and 2. 418¢/KWh, respectively. To the extent that the actual cost to the Department of power (exclusive of high voltage discount) and energy purchased from SCE&G differs due to change in SCE&G' s Rate WR, or due to application of SCE&G's Wholesale Fuel Cost Adjustment provision or for any other reason, the above Gross Monthly Rate shall be adjusted proportionately. POWER FACTOR CORRECTION: The Plant and Plant generating station shall at all times maintain a power factor of not less than 85 percent lagging. The Department reserves the right to conduct tests to detennine the power factor of the Plant's installation during periods of rnax:iJnum demand or by measurement of the average power factor for the monthly billing period. Should the power factor so detennined fall below 85 percent lagging, the monthly rnax:iJnum demand shall be adjusted by I1U.1ltiplying the rnax:iJnum Kw demand by 85 percent and dividing by the determined power factor. No credit shall be given for power factors greater than 85 percent. TERMS AND CONDITIONS: The Department's "General Terms and Conditions" in effect apply to the above. See Article N-A, Item Number 4, "General Terms and Conditions" for discount on above. The Department's current fuel charge will not be applied to this contract rate schedule. Effective: March 1, 1988 ---.- Department of PUblic Utilities - Orangeburg, South Carolina CONTRACT RATE (Code 2X) CONTRACT RATE: FOR PURCHASE OF ELECTRIC POWER AND ENERGY FROM GREENWOOD MILLS LINER PLANT Exhibit B CHARACTER OF SERVICE: The Plant shall supply power and energy to the Department in a manner which will not degrade the electric service or jeopardize the safety of the Department or electric custaners of the Department. NET MONI'HLY RATE: Demand Charge Energy Charge $9.72/KW of billing demand 2.418¢/Kwh of energy delivered BILLING DEMAND: The billing demand from the Plant (calculated to the nearest whole Kw) shall be determined as the power supplied to the Department by the Plant coincident with the Department's monthly maximum demand as determined by South Carolina Electric & Gas CQllPaIly (SCE&G) for the purpose of billing the Department for the purchase of power under PERC Rate Schedule WR or its successor. In the event the Department's Billing Demand for purchases from SCE&G is in excess of the Department's monthly rnax:i.murn demand from SCE&G due to the effect of applying a billing ratchet or power factor adjustment, the Billing Demand herein applicable to the Plant shall be proportionately determined. ADJUS'IMENT FOR CHANGES IN PURCHASE POWER COST: The above stated demand and energy charges are based on purchased power (exclusive of high voltage discount) and energy charges to the Department by SCE&G of $9.72/Kw and 2.4i8¢/Kwh, respectively. To the extent that the actual cost to the Department of power (exclusive of high voltage discount) and energy purchased from SCE&G differs due to change in SCE&G' s Rate WR, or due to application of SCE&G's Wholesale Fuel Cost Adjustment prOvision or for any other reason, the above monthly rate shall be adjusted proportionately. Effective: March 1, 1988 -'"'- Departnlent of Public Utilities - Orangeburg, South Carolina CONTRACT RATE (code 2X) Exhibit A CONTRACT RA'IE: FOR SALE OF ELECTRIC POWER AND ENERGY TO GREENWOOD MILLS LINER PLANT AVAILABILITY: This rate is available by contract for service to Greenwood Mills Liner Plant (Plant). CHARACTER OF SERVICE: Alternating current, 60 cycle, three phase service metered at primary voltage. GROSS MONTHLY RATE: Demand Charge Energy Charge Facilities Charge Minimum Monthly Facilities Charge $10.80/KW of billing demand 2.298¢/KWh of energy delivered 0.45¢/KWh of energy delivered $4,500.00 MONTHLY BILLING DEMAND: 'TIle I1lOnthly billing demand (calculated to the nearest whole KW) shall be determined as the pcwer requirement of the Plant coincident with the Departnlent' s I1lOnthly rnax:intum demand. 'TIle Department's I1lOnthly rnax:intum demand shall be as determined by South Carolina Electric and Gas Company (SCE&G) for the purpose of billing the Department for the purchase of power under PERC Rate Schedule WR or its successor. In the event the Department's Billing Demand from SCE&G is in excess of the Department's I1lOnthly rnax:intum demand due to the effect of applying a billing ratchet, the billing demand herein applicable to Plant shall be s:iJnilarly determined. ADJUS1MENT FOR CHANGES IN PURCHASE POWER COST: 'TIle above stated demand and energy charges are based on purchased pcwer and energy charges to the Departnlent by SCE&G of $9. 72/KW (exclusive of high voltage discount) and 2.068¢/KWh, respectively. To the extent that the actual cost to the Department of pcwer (exclusive of high voltage discount) and energy purchased from SCE&G differs due to change in SCE&G' s Rate WR, or due to application of SCE&G' s Wholesale Fuel Cost Adjustnlent provision or for any other reason, the above Gross Monthly Rate shall be adjusted proportionately. POWER FACTOR CORRECTION: 'TIle Plant and Plant generating station shall at all t:i1lIes maintain a pcwer factor of not less than 85 percent lagging. 'TIle Department reserves the right to conduct tests to determ:ine the pcwer factor of the Plant's installation during periods of rnax:intum demand or by measurement of the average power factor for the I1lOnthly billing period. Should the power factor so determ:ined fall below 85 percent lagging, the I1lOnthly rnax:intum demand shall be adjusted by multiplying the maxi.rnum KW /' demand by 85 percent and dividing by the determined power factcr. No credit shall be given for power factors greater than 85 percent. TERMS AND CONDITIONS: The Department's "General Terms and Conditions" in effect apply to the above. See Article DJ-A, Item Nurriber 4, "General Terms and Conditions" for discount on above. The Department's current fuel charge will not be applied to tbis contract rate schedule. Effective: March 1, 1988 9-, Department of Public Utilities - Orangeburg, South Carolina CONTRACT RATE (Code 2X) CONTRACT RATE: FOR PURCHASE OF ELECTRIC POWER AND ENERGY FROM GREENWOOD JVlILLS LJNER PLANT Exhibit B CHARACTER OF SERVICE: The Plant shall supply pcwer and energy to the Department m a marmer which will not degrade the electric service or jeopardize the safety of the Department or electric customers of the Department. NET MONI'HLY RATE: Demand Charge Energy Charge $9.72/KW of bill:ing demand 2.068¢/KWh of energy delivered BILLING DEMAND: The bill:ing demand fran the Plant (calculated to the nearest whole KW) shall be determined as the pcwer supplied to the Department by the Plant comcident with the Depart:roent' s IlIOnthly maximum demand as determined by South Carolina Electric & Gas Corrpany (SCE&G) for the purpose of billmg the Department for the purchase of pcwer under PERC Rate Schedule WR or its successor. In the event the Department's Billmg Demand for purchases fran SCE&G is in excess of the Depart:roent' s IlIOnthly roa:x::i.mum demand fran SCE&G due to the effect of applying a bill:ing ratchet or pcwer factor adjust:roent, the Billing Demand herein applicable to the Plant shall be proportionately determined. ADJUSTMENT FOR CHANGES IN PURCHASE POWER COST: The above stated demand and energy charges are based on purchased pcwer (exclusive of high voltage discount) and energy charges to the Depart:roent by SCE&G of $9.72/KW and 2.068¢/KWh, respectively. To the extent that the actual cost to the Depart:roent of pcwer (exclusive of high voltage discount) and energy purchased fran SCE&G differs due to change in SCE&G's Rate WR, or due to application of SCE&G's 'Wholesale Fuel Cost Adjust:roent provision or for any other reason, the above IlIOnthly rate shall be adjusted proportionately. Effective: March 1, 1988 -, Department of Public Utilities - Orangeburg, South Carolina GAS RATE No. 1 - RESIDENTIAL SERVICE (Code 3A) APPLICABLE: To a s:ingle family clwell:ing unit or :individual dwell:ing units :in apartment structures or other multi -family residential structures supplied by :individual gas meters. This schedule is not applicable to a residence which is used for commercial, professional, or any other enterprise unless the danestic use can be separately metered. Service Charge $3.00 per bill per month Commodity Charge: First 20,000 C.F. @ $0.5867 per 100 C.F. per month All :in excess of 20,000 C.F. @ $0.5506 per 100 C.F. per month MINJMJM The monthly rniIilln:um charge shall be the Monthly Service Charge as stated above. Note: "General Tenus and Conditions" :in effect apply to above. See Article N-A, Item Ni.mlber 4, "General Tenus and Conditions" for discount on above. CURRENT SURCHARGE WILL BE APPLIED TO THIS RATE SCHEDUlE. Effective: June 15, 1988 Bill:ing Department of Public Utilities - Orangeburg, South Carolina GAS RATE NO. 2 - GENERAL SERVICE (CODE 3B) APPLICABLE: To any non-domestic and/or commercial or industrial customer havlilg requirements of less than 400,000 CF per month. SERVICE CHARGE: $3.00 per bill per month COMMODITY CHARGE: First 20,000 C.F. @ $0.5867 per 100 C.F. per month Next 80,000 C.F. @ $0.5506 per 100 C.F. per month All in excess of 100,000 C.F. @ $0.5266 per 100 C.F. per month M:irrinn.:rrn The monthly:minimum charge shall be the lXbnthly Service Charge as stated above. Note: "General Terms and Ccnditions" in effect apply to above. See Article D/-A, Item Nlll!1ber 4, "General Terms and Conditions" for discount on above. CURRENT SURCHARGE WILL BE APPLIED TO THIS RATE SCHEDULE. Effective: June 15, 1988 Billing .~ Department of Public Utilities - Orangeburg, South Carolina GAS RATE NO. 3 - LARGE GENERAL SERVICE (CODE 3C) APPLICABLE: To any non-domestic and/or commercial or industrial customer having requirements in excess of 400,000 CF per month. COMMODITY CHARGE: First 40 MCF @ $5.47584 per MCF per month Next 60 MCF @ $5.25761 per MCF per month Next 400 MCF @ $5.09412 per MCF per month Next 1, 500 MCF @ $5.03963 per MCF per month All in excess of 2,000 MCF @ $4.98513 per MCF per month M:irriJnum $17.00 per month Note: "General Tenus and Conditions" in effect apply to above. See Article IV-A, Item NUmber 4, "General Tenus and Conditions" for discount on above. CURRENT SURCHARGE WILL BE APPLIED TO THIS RATE SCHEDULE. Effective: June 15, 1988 Billing '-- Department of Public Utilities - Orangeburg, South Carolina GAS RATE NO. 4 - INI'ERRUPTmLE "A" (CODE 3D) APPLICABLE: To all industrial conSumers Who have adequate stand-by facilities. All MCF at $0.4444 plus cost of gas sold calculated at gross. Excluding peak shaving quantities. Department of Public Utilities retains the right to discontinue interruptible service on a one-hour notice for as long as gas is necessary for fir.m customers. Note: "General Tenus and Conditions" in effect apply to above. See Article N-A, Item Nurriber 4, "General Tenus and Conditions" for discount on above. CURRENT SURCHARGE WILL BE APPLIED TO THIS RATE SCHEDULE. Effective: June 15, 1988 Billing Department of Public Utilities - Orangeburg, South Carolina GAS RATE FIRM - (CODE 3S) APPLICABLE: To Orangeburg Plant Greenwood Mills for process. Demand Commodity M:i.nimurn Demand Charge $2.419 per MCF $4. 68440 per MMSTU Note: "General Tenns and Conditions" :in effect apply to above. See Article N-A, Item Number 4, "General Terms and Conditions" for discount on above. CURRENT SURCHARGE WILL BE APPLIED TO THIS RATE SOlEDULE. Effective: June 15, 1988 Bill:ing RESOLUTION BE IT RESOLVED by the Mayor and Members of COuncil of the City of orangeburg, State of South Carolina, in Council assembled and by authority of the same: 'Ihat the City of Orangeburg enter into an agreement dated June 1, 1988 with the South Carolina Pipeline Corporation, Whereby the South Carolina Pipeline Corporation agrees to sell to the City of Orangeburg up to 10,200 MCF of firm gas per day under Rate DS-1 and interruptible gas under Rate DISS-l. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that his Honor E.O. Pendaxvis, Mayor, be, and he is hereby authorized and directed to sign said agreement on behalf of the City of Orangeburg. PASSED by the City Council in Council assembled at Orangeburg, South Carolina this ~ day of (iiO u , 1988 . ...J ~~ ~~- Members of Council C\l (Y) -rl m m c:::( Orangeburg 20, 1988 presiding. CITY COUNCIL MINUTES JUNE 20, 1988 373 City Council held its regularly scheduled meeting on June in City Hall Chambers at 7:00 P.M., Mayor Pendarvis PRESENT: E. O. Pendarvis, Mayor A motion Alexander, Minutes as W. EVerette Salley, Mayor Pro Tern Henry F. Frierson Sara H. Alexander Herbert W. Bradley, Jr. by Councilmember Bradley, seconded by unanimously approved the June 1 , 1988 distributed. councilmember City Council A motion by Mayor Pro Tern Frierson, unanimously approved the Chamber of Commerce Lease. Salley, seconded by councilmember the third reading of an ordinance for A motion by Mayor Frierson, unanimously presented. Pro Tern Salley, seconded by Councilmember approved the Law Enforcement Complex Budget as A motion by councilmember Frierson, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Salley, unanimously approved the Proclamation declaring July as the "National Recreation and Parks Month." A motion by Councilmember Frierson, Salley, unanimously approved the Accommodation's Tax Advisory Committee. seconded by Mayor Pro Tern recommendations of the City Administrator Smith requested an executive session for legal -briefing. A motion by Mayor Pro Tern Salley, seconded by Mayor Pendarvis, unanimously approved the nomination of Mr. Charles E. Taylor, III as a member of the City of Orangeburg Industrial Development Commission. A request was made by Mr. Arthur J. Lusty, Jr. that the restrooms be made more accessible to the public in the Edisto Gardens on the week-ends. A motion Frierson, for legal by Mayor Pro Tern Salley, seconded by councilmember unanimously approved to enter into an executive session briefing. There being rio further business, the meeting was adjourned. Respectfully submitted, da~ L. HU*'th City Administrator /r 374 CITY COUNCIL MINUTES JULY 5, 1988 Orangeburg City council 5, 1988 in City Hall presiding. held its regularly scheduled meeting on July Chambers at 7:00 P.M., Mayor Pendarvis PRESENT: E. O. Pendarvis, Mayor A motion Alexander, Minutes as W. Everette Salley, Mayor Pro Tern Henry F. Frierson Sara H. Alexander Herbert W. Bradley, Jr. by councilmember Bradley, seconded unanimously approved the June 20, distributed. by 1988 Councilmember City Council A Resolution and gift was presented to each of the following retiring employees of the Department of Public Utilities: John B. Brandenburg Julian Hart James Simpson, Jr. Jeanette King Henry Tant L. Frederick Smoak 40 years 35 years 30 years 30 years 34 years 20 years An appearance was made by Mr. Arthur Lusty representing the Orangeburg Arts Council. He discussed the renovations on the Pink Palace (Old Orangeburg County Jail) and their intentions for the future. He stated that they have spent about $50,000 so far and there is still more to do. They want to completely refurbish the building and find an occupant so that the building will be in use at all times. He discussed the possibility of the upper floor becoming a museum at a later date. Mr. Townsend Sifly stated that a structural survey has been completed with the results that the building is sound. The grounds have been surveyed and the roof repaired and they are beginning the renovations of the interior. The parking area has been completed and they will soon begin the landscaping. Mr. Flynn Bowie also discussed some of their fund raising projects. Councilmember Bradley wants the Arts Council to bring a definitive proposal on what they want the City to do. Councilmember Frierson asked City Administrator Smith if our Accommodation's Tax Funds could be used to assist in these renovations. City Administrator Smith stated that he would investigate this matter. Public Works Director, Reese Earley, introduced Mr. Bill Spearman of the South Carolina Land Resources Commission to update Council on the Dukes Street Drainage Plan. Mr. Spearman informed council that the cu~~ent flood study only takes in one-half of the drainage area that ~).~ Land Resources Commission studied. Because of this Mr. Spearmah requested a time extension on the contract which expired 6-30-88. He was not requesting an increase in the fee but to change the deadline on the contract until 1-31-89. This should give them adequate time to complete the project after they receive the FEMA (Federal Emergency Management Agency) mapping. Council received consideration of the request from Mr. Ed Brant concerning his hospitalization insurance eligibility. Mr. Brant left the employ of the City on 6-30-86 (55 years of age) after nineteen (19) years and nine (9) months of service to the City. Mr. Tom Bryant (friend of Mr. Brant) asked Council to reconsider this request. Council requested more information on this entire matter. City Administrator Smith said that he would compile this information and present it to Council at a later date. A motion by Mayor Pendarvis, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Salley, unanimously approved the first reading of an ordinance to increase the members of the Industrial Development Commission (seven members along with DPU Manager and Executive Director of the Chamber of Commerce as ex-officio non-voting members). RESOLUTION WHEREAS, L. Frederick Srroak became an employee of the Department of Public Utilities of the City of Orangeburg on May 20, 1968, and faithfully served this Department and the City 1.IDtil J1.IDe 28, 1988; and WHEREAS, He, through his long and faithful se:r:vice contr:ib­ uted greatly to the successful operation of the Department of Public Utilities; and WHEREAS, The City C01.IDcil, in recognition of the fine con­ trlbution rendered the City of Orangeburg, wants to inscribe on the records its appreciation; NOW THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED That the Mayor and Members of C01.IDcil, in C01.IDcil assembled, do officially take cognizance of the faithful se:r:vice rendered to the Department of Public Utilities of the City of orangeburg by L. Frederick Srroak in the capacities in which he served the Department for the past twenty years, one month and eight days, and commend him for a job well done. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED That a copy of this resolution, in appreciation of his devotion of duty to the City of Orangeburg, be placed in the minute bock of the City and a copy furnished to Mr. Smoak in recognition of his se:r:vices. PASSED By the City C01.IDcil of the City of orangeburg, State of South Carolina, this fifth day of July, A.D., 1988. A;U ~ City Clerk ~ -£ / -2 /I·'/~/'..~../~<J /'V /C2 . ~. IA; .)L ,/tft! ~l v ,y '/ ~~y.. a e >" /<<...-' ~. t~~ ~uJ_' ~~.C}- , RESOLUTION WHEREAS, Hen:r:y Tant became an employee of the Department of Public Utilities of the City of Orangeburg on AUgust 14, 1953, and faithfully sexved this Department and the City until June 28, 1988; and WHEREAS, uted greatly tc Utilities; and He, through his long and faithful seIVice contrib­ the successful operation of the Department of Public WHEREAS, The City Council, in recognition of the fine con­ tribution rendered the City of Orangeburg, wants to inscribe on the records its appreciation; NOW THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED That the Mayor and Members of Council, in Council asserribled, do officially take cognizance of the faithful seIVice rendered to the Department of Public Utilities of the City of Orangeburg by Hen:r:y Tant in the capacities in which he sexved the Department for the past thirty-four years, ten months and fourteen days, and corn:nend him for a job well done. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED That a copy of this resolution, in appreciation of his devotion of duty to the City of Orangeburg, be placed in the minute book of the City and a copy furnished to Mr. Tant in recognition of his seIVices. PASSED BY the City Council of the City of orangeburg, state of South Carolina, this fifth day of July, A.D., 1988. '" ~.~ Members of Council ~-~, ;f~ v City Clerk rnent 1957, 1988; RESOLUTION WHEREAS, Jan:es Simpson, Jr. became an errployee of the Depart­ of Public Utilities of the City of orangeburg on September 24, and faithfully served this Department and the City until June 7, and WHEREAS, He, through his long and faithful service contrib­ uted greatly to the successful operation of the Department of Public Utilities; and WHEREAS, The City Council, in reccgnition of the fine con­ tribution rendered the City of orangeburg, wants to inscribe on the records its appreciation; NOW THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED That the Mayor and Merribers of Council, in Council asserrbled, do officially take ccgnizance of the faithful service rendered to the Department of Public Utilities of the City of Orangeburg by Jan:es Simpson, Jr. in the capacities in which he served the Department for the past thirty years, eight months and fourteen days, and commend him for a jab well done. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED That a copy of this resolution, in appreciation of his devotion of duty to the City of Orangeburg, be placed in the minute book of the City and a copy furnished to Mr. Simpson in reccgnition of his services. PASSED By the City Council of the City of Orangeburg, State of South Carolina, this fifth day of July, A.D., 1988. /Afl ~ ~ ~::!{;I~/1' ~/?'~~ l ' Ma~ , :1 - ~;,~ ~'-". / y.(~ .::;r:L %c /.<_ ',"" ~;"?<'- 0~ £:J ~ fid.::~~~ RESOLUTION WHEREAS, Julian Hart became an employee of the Department of Public Utilities of the City of Orangeburg on June 22, 1953, and faithfully served this Department and the City until June 28, 1988; and WHEREAS, uted greatly to Utilities; and He, through his long and faithful service contrib­ the successful operation of the Department of Public WHEREAS, 'Ihe City Council, in recognition of the fine con­ tribution rendered the City of orangeburg, wants to inscribe on the records its appreciation; NOW THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED 'Ihat the Mayor and Members of Council, in Council assembled, do officially take cognizance of the faithful service rendered to the Department of Public Utilities of the City of Orangeburg by Julian Hart in the capacities in which he served the Department for the past thirty-five years and six days, and ccrmnend him for a job well done. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED 'Ihat a copy of this resolution, in appreciation of his devotion of duty to the City of orangeburg, be placed in the minute book of the City and a copy furnished to Mr. Hart in recognition of his services. PASSED By the City Council of the City of Orangeburg, State of South Carolina, this fifth day of July, A.D., 1988. Z/I fi / I' L//, ··/4#<tZe~~ l~<~ V ~ 7 ~ ~~~~~C1-~.cr---< A'T'T'l<~ City Clerk RESOLUTION WHEREAS, Jeanette B. King became an employee of the Depart­ ment of Public Utilities of the City of Orangeburg on September 30, 1957, and faithfully served this Department and the City until June 29, 1988; and WHEREAS, uted greatly to Utilities; and She, through her long and faithful service contrib-­ the successful operation of the Department of Public WHEREAS, The City Council, in recognition of the fine con­ tr:ibution rendered the City of Orangeburg, wants to inscribe on the records its appreciation; NOW THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED That the Mayor and Members of Council, in Council assembled, do officially take cognizance of the faithful service rendered to the Department of Public Utilities of the City of Orangeburg by Jeanette B. King in the capacities in which she served the Department for the past thirty years, eight IllOnths and twenty-nine days, and commend her for a jab well done. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED That a copy of this resolution, in appreciation of her devotion of duty to the City of Orangeburg, be placed in the minute book of the City and a copy furnished to Mrs. King in recognition of her services. PASSED BY the City Council of the City of Orangeburg, State of South Carolina, this fifth day of July, A.D., 1988. Iidt V City Clerk /&fi~.~ /~/J.4V~~ >~ f1\1avo. r . jI ,/- fi!' / ....----, /' (/ '-.-/ };'/ / ~ IA /~--;:;:~£7' /i U .;:c,L ,&:.z'v /"" c/c:u.-v _ ~ J~'~ Members of Council ~ - ~ ~ RESOLUTION WHEREAS, Jcihn B. Brandenburg became an employee of the Department of Public Utilities of the City of Orangeburg on May 1, 1948, and faithfully served this Department and the City until June 29, 1988; and WHEREAS, uted greatly to Utilities; and He, through his long and faithful service contrib­ the successful operation of the Department of Public WHEREAS, The City Council. in recognition of the fine con­ tribution rendered the City of Orangeburg, wants to inscribe on the records its appreciation; NOW THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED That the Mayor and Members of Council, in Council assembled, do officially take cognizance of the faithful service rendered to the Department of Public Utilities of the City of Orangeburg by Jcihn B. Brandenburg in the capacities in which he served the Department for the past forty years, one month and twenty-nine days, and canrnend him for a job well done. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED That a copy of this resolution, in appreciation of his devotion of duty to the City of Orangeburg, be placed in the minute book of the City and a copy f1.n:nished to Mr. Brandenburg in recognition of his services. PASSED By the City Council of the City of Orangeburg, State of South Carolina, this fifth day of July, A.D., 1988. ':---? ___ -I' Y c;/~ Ji. pLi2<,a, ,/<. -- ~ ~~ ~~~~~ ~~k L C\I (Y) 'r1 co co <:( CITY COUNCIL MINUTES JULY 5, 1988 PAGE 2 375 City Administrator Smith read a letter of resignation from Councilmember Herbert W. Bradley, Jr., to be effective 9-12-88 if the new election procedures are implemented as planned. City Administrator Smith presented a revised personnel policy to Council for their study. (6) members of South Carolina Mr. Oliver C. appointees to City Administrator Smith informed Council that six the Hillcrest Commission terms have expired 7-1-88. State College has re-appointed Dr. Lewie Roache and Dawson and that the Council needs to consider four (4) represent the City. City Administrator Smith informed Council that Mr. J. C. Kizer's term on the Board of Adjustments will expire 7-20-88 and that they will need to consider another appointee. Concerning the Department of Public Utilities matters, a motion by Mayor Pro Tern Salley, seconded by Mayor Pendarvis, unanimously approved the first reading of an ordinance to amend Chapter 27 defining the authority and duties of the Department of public Utilities Manager. A motion by Mayor Pendarvis, seconded by Councilmember Bradley, unanimously approved to enter into an executive session for discussion of personnel in the Administrative and Executive Departments. There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned. /r :ne=fuJdy submitted, Carol A. Brunson City Clerk 376 CITY COUNCIL MINUTES JULY 19, 1988 Orangeburg City Council held its regularly scheduled meeting on July 19, 1988 at 7:00 P.M. in City Hall Chambers with Mayor Pendarvis presiding. PRESENT: E. o. Pendarvis, Mayor W. Everette salley, Mayor Pro Tern Henry F. Frierson Sara H. Alex~nder Herbert W. Bradley, Jr. A motion by Councilmember Bradley, unanimously approved as distributed. Frierson, seconded by Councilmember the July 5, 1988 City Council Minutes Mr. John Phillips of the Local Government Assurance Group (LGAG) made an appearance before Council to discuss an alternative to our present health insurance plan. City Administrator Smith told Council that they are working on a proposal to submit to Council. Ms. Geraldine Boltin made an appearance before Council requesting a waiver of the penalty on her 1987 taxes on property that she purchased in 1987 from James L. and Jane H. Rainey. Her request was denied, but suggested that she contact her attorney that handled her closing and then meet again with the Finance Director. A motion by Mayor Pro Tern Salley, seconded by Councilmember Frierson, unanimously approved the second reading of the Industrial Development Commission Ordinance for increasing their membership. A motion by Councilmember Bradley, seconded by councilmember Alexander, unanimously approved the Resolution adopting the revised personnel policy for the City of Orangeburg. City Administrator Smith informed Council that we need to appoint four (4) appointees for the Hillcrest Commission and an appointee for the Board of Adjustments to replace Mr. J. C. Kizer. Council wishes to postpone this until a later date. A motion by Mayor Pro Tern Salley, seconded by Councilmember Bradley, unanimously approved the first reading of the FY 1988-89 Budget Ordinance. A motion by Mayor Pendarvis, seconded by councilmember Frierson, unanimously approved to award the audit bid to J. W. Hunt and Company with the bid being $20,000 to expire on September 30, 1991. A motion by Mayor Pro Tern Salley, seconded by Councilmember Alexander, unanimously approved the banking services for the City of Orangeburg to NCNB as the low bidder to expire September 30, 1991. Councilmembers Frierson and Bradley abstained from voting. City Administrator Smith requested that an evaluation be conducted concerning the activities in the Public Safety Department since its inception. He and Public Safety Director Brant want this to find out how this department stands for the first eight (8) months. City Administrator Smith suggested that City Recorder/Judge Ronald Salley and City Attorney James F. Walsh conduct the evaluation. Concerning the Department of Public Utilities, a motion by Mayor Pendarvis, seconded by Councilmember Frierson, unanimously approved the second reading of an ordinance to amend Chapter 27 defining the authority and duties of the Department of public Utilities Manager. A motion by Councilmember Frierson, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Salley, unanimously approved the first reading of the FY 1988-89 Budget for the Department of Public Utililites. ~ ~. --' J RESO~UTION WHEREAS, the City of Orangeburg has a desire that all employees should be informed as to the guidelines concerning employment with the City and, WHEREAS, a Perso~nel Policy Manual has been prepared stating the policies which are ordinarily followed, NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the City Council of the City of Orangeburg hereby adopts the Personnel Policy Manual as its guidelines for the City of Orangeburg. The contents of this document are not intended nor should they be interpreted to establish a contractual relationship of employment with any employee or to provide any property rights in employment; nor to induce reliance thereupon by any employee. All employees shall continue to serve at the will and the pleasure of the City. These guidelines are subject to change at any time and for any reason at the sole discretion of this council. PASSED by the City Council of the City of Orangeburg, South Carolina, this Iq,q, day of ::r"'/Ii , A.D., 1988 • /27 g'~(R~r ...J 9('.u-.u/-»'~ t~~ Jd~w.I3-t~<~ Members of Council , City Clerk C\I (Y) ~ m m <{ CITY COUNCIL MINUTES JULY 19, 1988 PAGE 2 377 council was informed that the Department of Public Utilities needs some additional land around the gardens. The Department of Public Utilities will pay the City to reconstruct a similar park office complex in order to allow for expansion of the Department of Public Utilities Water Treatment Plant. Department of Public Utilities Manager Johnson and City Administrator Smith are researching this. There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned. /r Respect?fUlly submitted, .~!.// //~£ 6:~ 01 A. Brunson City Clerk 378 CITY COUNCIL MINUTES AUGUST 2, 1988 Orangeburg City council held its regularly scheduled meeting on August 2, 1988, at 7:00 P.M. in City Hall Chambers with Mayor Pendarvis presiding. PRESENT: E. o. Pendarvis, Mayor W. Everette Salley, Mayor Pro Tern Sara H. Alexander Herbert W. Bradley, Jr. ABSENT: Henry F. Frierson A motion by Councilmember unanimously approved the distributed. Bradley, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Salley, July 19, 1988 City Council Minutes as A presem::d.'L.l.,n was made by Mr. Malcolm Mann and Mr. Ewart Irick, repres€.nt.ir.;: tile Battle of Eutaw Springs Chapter of the Sons of the Amer::'can Rcv::>Ll.tion, to Department of Public Safety Director, E. A. Brant. He ~as the first recipient of this Law Enforcement Commendation Medal for continuous dedication and outstanding work for those persons engaged in any field of law enforcement. A mo~ion by Mayor Pro Tern Salley, seconded by Alexand~r, unanimously approved the third reading of Development Commission Ordinance for increasing their Councilmember the Industrial membership. A motion by Councilmember Bradley, seconded by Councilmember Alexander, unanimously approved the following four (4) appointees for the Hillcrest Commission with terms expiring 7-1-94. Francis Faulling Vernon Williams Joseph Ashley Jane C. Covington A motion Alexander, appointed 7-20-91. by Mayor Pro Tern Salley, seconded by unanimously approved for Mr. Alfred S. to the Board of Adjustments with his Councilmember Gramling to be term expiring A motion by Mayor Pro Tern Salley, unanimously approved the following Golf Course: seconded by Mayor Pendarvis, increase in rates at Hillcrest GREEN FEES: 18 holes (weekends) 18 holes (week days) 9 holes (weekends) 9 holes (week days) SCSC CART FEES: 18 holes 9 holes MEMBERSHIP: Family Single Senior $ 10.00 $ 8.00 $ 6.00 $ 6.00 $ 6.00 $ 14.00 $ 7.00 $450.00 $350.00 $150.00 RESOLUTION BE IT RESOLVED By the Mayor and Members of Council of the City of Orangeburg, South carol:ina, in Council assembled, and by authority of the same: That the Departrnent of Public Utilities of the City of Orangeburg, hereinafter called the City, enter into an agreement with the Southe:m Railway Corrpany, a Virginia Corporation, hereinafter called the Corrpany, Whereby said corrpany grants unto the said City the right or license to install and maintain for the purpose of a sewer main, an eight (8") inch P.V.C. pipe crossing the right-of-way and under the track or tracks of said Corrpany at or near Orangeburg, South Carol:ina, at a point 3,470.5 feet North, measured along the center line of said track, fram Milepost SC77, as shown on drawing dated March 8, 1988 prepared by the Departrnent of Public Utilities, and Which drawing is on file in the Office of the Departrnent of Public Utilities, of the City of orangeburg and attached and made a part of said agreement. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that his Honor, Mayor E. O. Pendarvis, be, and he hereby is, authorized and directed to sign said agreement on behalf of the City of Orangeburg. PASSED this ;l.. ,-,.01. day of R <..tc\ U <-!- , 1988. J Signed: ~ /1 // ATI'EST' /~ f //b~~ J.J~. 4-o.~~ Members of Counc~ . critYClerk' and Treasurer C\.I (f) m m 0::::( CITY COUNCIL MINUTES AUGUST 2, 1988 379 Concerning the Resolution passed during the July 19, 1988 City Council Meeting revising the Personnel Policy for the City of Orangeburg , a motion made by Councilmember Bradley for an amendment is as follows: 1. Two or more members of an immediate family shall not be employed by the City if such employment will result in one supervising a member of his immediate family, except when permitted by City council upon recommendation of the City Administrator or Depart­ ment of Public Utilities Manager. 2. No member of the immediate family of the Mayor or of a Council member shall be employed by the City in any capacity. The motion was seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Salley and unanimously approved by Council. concerning the Department of Public Utilities, a motion by Mayor Pro Tern Salley, seconded by Mayor Pendarvis, unanimously approved the second reading of the FY 1988-89 Budget for the Department of Public Utilities. A motion by Mayor Pro unanimously approved the Southern Railway. Tern Salley, seconded by Mayor Pendarvis, resolution to enter into an agreement with A motion by Mayor Pro Tern unanimously approved the Chapter 27 defining the Public Utilities Manager. Salley, seconded by Councilmember Bradley, third reading of an Ordinance to amend authority and duties of the Department of There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned. /r " Respettful SUbmitted, I~~L c~~tBrunson 'City Clerk 380 CITY COUNCIL MINUTES AUGUST 16, 1988 Orangeburg City Council held its regularly scheduled meeting on August 16, 1988, at 7:00 P.M., in City Hall Chambers with Mayor Pendarvis presiding. PRESENT: E. o. Pendarvis, Mayor W. Everette Salley, Mayor Pro Tern Henry F. Frierson Sara H. Alexander ABSENT: Herbert W. Bradley, Jr. A motion by Counci1mernber Alexander, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Salley, unanimously approved the August 2, 1988 City council Minutes as corrected. An appearance was made by Mr. John Kemp of 460 Berry Street protesting a penalty and a delinquent tax cost added to his unpaid taxes. He purchased this property in August of 1987, therefore, the tax bill was in the previous owner's name. Council instructed the Finance Director to research this matter. A motion by councilmember Alexander, seconded by councilmernber Frierson, unanimouslY approved the second reading of the FY 1988-89 Budget Ordinance. A motion was made by Councilmember Frierson to approve from Mr. Ed Brant to continue his health insurance. died for lack of a second. the request This motion A motion by Mayor Pendarvis, seconded by councilmernber Alexander, unanimously approved to postpone Mr. Brant's request until the next council meeting. A motion by Mayor Pendarvis, seconded unanimously approved the first reading of of property between the City and County. by Mayor Pro Tern salley, an Ordinance for exchange A motion by Mayor Pro Tern Salley, seconded by Councilmernber Alexander, unanimously approved the third reading of the FY 1988-89 Budget Ordinance for the Department of Public Utilities. City Attorney Walsh requested an executive session for legal briefing. A motion made by Mayor Pendarvis, seconded by Councilmernber Frierson, unanimously approved entering into an executive session for legal briefing. A motion by Mayor Pendarvis, seconded by Councilrnernber Alexander, unanimously approved to designate the week of August 21-27, 1988, as Family Week in South Carolina. There being no further business, the m~ting was adjourned. Ir Respfilctfull~submitted, /ld£ ~arol A. Brunson City Clerk (\j (Y) 'rl co co <:( 381 SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MINUTES August 22, 1988 Orangeburg City council held a special meeting on August 22, 1988, at 6:00 P.M., in the City Hall Conference Room with Mayor Pendarvis presiding for the purpose of conducting a FY 1988-89 Budget Workshop. PRESENT: E. o. Pendarvis, Mayor W. Everette Salley, Mayor Pro Tern Henry F. Frierson Sara H. Alexander L. Hugh Smith, City Administrator Carol A. Brunson, Finance Director Thomas A. Boland, Jr. ABSENT: Herbert W. Bradley, Jr. Discussion was expenditures. concerning proposed revenues and department Council agreed to re-instate the position of Assistant Finance Director and fill that position with the current Accounting Officer. Council had several questions that would be researched and reported on Tuesday, August 23, 1988. /r Respectf~IY submitted, 44t' C~=l~~nson City Clerk 382 SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MINUTES August 23, 1988 Orangeburg City Council held a special meeting on August 23, 1988, at 6:00 P.M., in the City Hall Conference Room with Mayor Pendarvis presiding for the purpose of conducting a FY 1988-89 Budget Workshop. PRESENT: E. o. Pendarvis, Mayor W. Everette Salley, Mayor Pro Tern Henry F. Frierson Sara H. Alexander Herbert W. Bradley, Jr. L. Hugh Smith, City Administrator Carol A. Brunson, City Clerk Tom Vargo Hillcrest Golf Course Manager, Tom Vargo, discussed his operations at the golf course. Council instructed Mr. submit a request to the Accommodation's Tax Advisory Board on the following: Maintenance Building Irrigation System $14,000 $ 9,000 plans for Vargo to for funds Council eliminated $415,050 in capital items and added $56,500 in operating costs. council agreed that $32,000 (of $415,050) in capital items would probably be eligible to be purchased from the Cemetery Fund and instructed the City Administrator to investigate this. Council instructed City Administrator Smith to institute a plan for a smoother operation of the Public Safety Department. Council felt that until all cross training is complete that there should be a Fire Commander as well as a Patrol Commander. These two positions would assist Director Brant until the training program is complete. The commander positions would be forty hours a week positions. City Administrator Smith said that duties, goals and expectations should be assigned to each employee for them to follow so that they can be accurately evaluated. Ir RespectfrU1ly submitted, ;tit ;Ca,rolt--A. Brunson 'e1ty Clerk C\J (Y) -rl ill ill <t SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MINUTES AUGUST 24, 1988 383 Orangeburg City 6:00 P.M., in presiding for Workshop. Council held a special meeting on August 24, 1988 at the City Hall Conference Room with Mayor Pendarvis the purpose of conducting a FY 1988-89 Budget PRESENT: E. o. Pendarvis, Mayor W. Everette Salley, Mayor Pro Tern Henry F. Frierson Sara H. Alexander Herbert W. Bradley, Jr. L. Hugh Smith, City Administrator Carol A. Brunson, City Clerk Council agreed to place Major Robert L. Keith in the position of Fire Commander and Captain David N. Bolen as Patrol Commander. Council agreed that Keith would have the authority to take all necessary steps to achieve a smooth operation in the Fire Division while reporting to Director Brant. Councilmember Frierson suggested that once our bonded indebtness is satisfied that we take those funds and establish a depreciation fund for large capital items just like we have for fire equipment (trucks). Council eliminated the $100,000 Administrator Smith said that if "being down for repairs" then we in two shifts per "pick-up" date. front-loading garbage truck. we run into problems with a would have to run the other City truck truck Council instructed City Administrator Smith to cut 5% in operations ($15,000 of $289,832). A motion by Councilmember Alexander, seconded by Councilmember Bradley, unanimously agreed to give all city employees a 2.5% cost of living raise--the exception being those Public Safety employees that had received salary adjustments when they agreed to cross train. A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Salley and seconded by Councilmember Frierson to increase the transfer from the Department of Public Utilities by approximately $730,000. Mayor Pendarvis opposed this motion. This will be actualized after all budget adjustments are made. A motion by Councilember Alexander, unanimously agreed City Recorder/Judge by $5,000 /r Frierson, seconded by to increase the base plus benefits. Councilmember salary of the /2 I. Respe. C(A/tfUl;7Ubmi tted, !#fi:<~ Ls~gf"A:. Brunson -c~ty Clerk 384 SPECIAL MEEI'ING CITY COUNCIL J.VITNUI'ES SEPTEMBER 2, 1988 Orangeburg City Council held a special meeting on September 2, 1988 at 6:00 P.M. in the Conference Room of the Department of Public Utilities, 195 Russell S.W. with Mayor PendaJ:vis presiding for discussion of capital improvement projects for the fiscal year Octdber 1, 1988 thru September 30, 1989. PRESENT: E.O. Pendarvis, Mayor W. Everette Salley, Mayor Pro Tem Henry F. Frierson Sara H. Alexander Herbert W. Bradley, Jr. Amotion by Mayor Pendarvis, seconded by Mayor Pro Tem Salley, unanimously approved the 1988-1989 capital Improvement projects. There being no further business, the meeting was adjoillTIed. TMJ/ba Respectfully submitted, ;~r~- Ted M. Johnson, Jr. Manager Department of Public Utilities C\I (Y) -rl co co <:( ~ CITY COUNCIL MINUTES SEPTEMBER 6, 1988 385 orangeburg City council held its regularly scheduled meeting on September 6, 1988, at 7:00 P.M., in City Hall Chambers with Mayor Pendarvis presiding. PRESENT: E. o. Pendarvis, Mayor W. Everette Salley, Mayor Pro Tern Henry F. Frierson Sara H. Alexander Herbert W. Bradley, Jr. A Public Hearing was held on the FY 1988-89 Budget. No comments from the public were made. A motion by unanimously amended. Mayor Pro Tern Salley, seconded by Councilmember Bradley, approved the August 16, 1988 City council Minutes as A motion by Councilmember Frierson, seconded Salley, unanimously approved the August 22, Council Minutes. A motion by Councilmember Bradley, seconded Salley, unanimously approved the August 23, Council Minutes. by 1988 Mayor Pro Tern Special City by Mayor Pro Tern 1988 Special City A motion by Coucilmember Bradley, Alexander, unanimously approved the Council Minutes. seconded by Councilmember August 24, 1988 Special City A motion by Councilmember Alexander, seconded by Councilmember Bradley, unanimously approved the september 2, 1988 Special City Council Minutes. Frierson, seconded the request of Mr. penalty. Mr. Kemp A motion by Councilmember Bradley, unanimously denied his 1987 city property tax council meeting. by Councilmember John Kemp to abate did not attend the Mr. Bill Dukes of the Orangeburg Aviation Commission presented a recommendation to Council concerning the airport fixed based and aircraft maintenance operators. The recommendation was to separate the FBO and AMO. The lease would be for three years with a non-renewal clause. The rent would remain the same on FBO but the per gallon cost of gasoline would increase from two cents to three cents. A motion was made by Coucilmember Alexander to accept this recommendation but it did not receive a second. Mr. Clyde Dean (an Orangeburg attorney) spoke on behalf of some of the aircraft owners and pilots at the Orangeburg Municipal Airport. He presented a petition to council with twenty-nine signatures requesting the removal of the current FBO. Mr. John Baxley of Springfield spoke on behalf of Mrs. Pat Rhudy. He believes that she does a good job and has a well runned organization and wants it to remain the same. Mr. Larry Gardner of Holly Hill also stated that he was pleased with the services. Mr. George Daniels of Cordova, whose plane was recently vandalized at the airport, complained about beer drinking of certain employees of Orangeburg Aviation on week-ends. Mr. Hinchie McGee of Orangeburg expressed concern about safety at the airport. Mr. Dukes stated that the Commission tired to maintain an open mind when the recommendation was decided upon. He said that he knew those making the comments are only trying to do the right thing and that is what the Commission is striving to do also. A motion by Mayor Pendarvis, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Salley, unanimously agreed to postpone action on this recommendation. 386 CITY COUNCIL MINUTES SEPTEMBER 6, 1988 PAGE 2 Concerning a request from Mr. Ed Brant to continue his hospitalization insurance, Mayor Pro Tern Salley stated he realized that 40% of council mislead Mr. Brant and apologized for this, but there are other people to be affected and he does not believe that the City can afford to change the policy for one individual without changing it for all. A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Salley, seconded by Mayor Pendarvis to deny Mr. Brant's request. Councilmember Bradley opposed this motion. A motion by councilmember Frierson, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Salley, approved the third reading of the FY 1988-89 Budget Ordinance. Mayor Pendarvis opposed and made a statement explaining his position. ( A copy of which is attached and made a part of these minutes.) A motion by Mayor Pro Tern Salley, seconded by Councilmember Alexander, unanimously approved the Personnel Policy as amended. A motion by Mayor Pro Tern Salley, seconded by Councilmember Frierson, unanimously approved to demolish the house at Hillcrest. A motion by Mayor Pro Tern Salley, seconded by councilmember Bradley, unanimously agreed to the Housing Rehab Contract. This contract will be with Hampton and Associates of Bowman in the amount of $7,000.00 plus some additional fees per work write-ups per house. Mayor Pendarvis expressed some apprehension about the administrative fee. Ms. Hampton explained that she had had much experience in administering this type of program and would work with the Building Official, Allan ott, in order for him to learn how to administer these type of grants in the future. A motion by Councilmember Frierson, seconded by Councilmember Bradley, unanimously authorized for City Administrator Smith to sign the contract. A motion by Mayor Pendarvis, seconded by Councilmember Bradley, unanimously approved for Mr. Harry Mccullohs, Jr., to be re-appointed to the LEC Commission with his term expiring 9-1-92. A motion by Councilmember Alexander, seconded Salley, unanimously approved for Mr. J. L. re-appointed to the Board of Adjustments with 9-17-91. by Mayor Pro Tern Townsend to be his term expiring A motion by Mayor Pro Tern Salley, seconded by Councilmember Bradley, unanimously agreed to enter into a lease purchase agreement with Amick Equipment Company for a new commercial garbage truck. The amount of the contract will be for $88,575. City Administrator Smith said the first payment would be due one year after the signing of the lease purchase agreement. City Administrator Smith read a letter addressed to Mayor Pendarvis from Mr. John Rickenbacker, Chairman of the Trash Watch Committee for Orangeburg County. He was asking for Council to adopt a resolution that would lend support to Adopt A Highway Program. Councilmember Frierson commented on the success of this program in other counties. A motion by Mayor Pendarvis, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Salley, unanimously agreed to support this request. Mayor Pendarvis made a public statement responding to the evaluation report of the Public Safety Department by City Attorney Walsh and City Recorder Salley. (A copy of which is attached and made a part of these minutes.) ~! I have a moment ago voted against the 1988-1989 City of orangeburg Budget and I wish to explain my position. This is not an apology and it is not a pleasant moment for me, but I have given long and serious thought and I would be less than loyal in perfonning my duties to you and would corrpromise my integrity if I just went along. Having said that, let me hasten to say that I realize that the other members of Council are your elected representatives also, and that they have the same responsibilities to you as I do, and they are capable persons 1tJho are entitled to make their individual decisions and I do not claim infallibility for myself. The Projected Budget 1988-1989 1tJhen presented to Council originally called for expenditures of $6,063,072.00 with projected revenues of $4,691,486.00, 1tJhich would have been a deficit of $1,371,586.00, during the budget studies this deficit was reduced to $993,036.00 and in my opinion could have and should have been reduced further. A ten (10) mill tax· increase was proposed and I am in agreement with that and it will raise approximately $200,000.00 and an increase in the transfer of funds from the Department of Public Utilities of $750,000.00 for a total from DPU of $2,401,368. My judgement called for an increase from DPU, but on a much more modest scale. I base my judgement on the fact that I am convinced that we are overstaffed in some departments and tend to be not quite as careful with the expenditures of the citizens resources as we should and could be. I think that it would be good business and good government if the Council would freeze hiring until either Council or a committee could ~ investigate and determine the operations, needs and efficiency of our municipal operation. A further ccrnrnent on DPU is that it is an efficient arm of the City of Orangeburg that is serving not only the City but TIU.lch of the surrounding area, with dependable and excellent service and with rates that are comparable in quality and cost with the best. The fact that the DPU is so successful in serving, expanding, and contributing to the expansion of industry, keeping the rates reasonable and at the same t:ilne operating profitably was not a coincidence and did not, "just happen", but rather is the result of many years of on-going decisions of former Councils to pennit it to grow and expand. If those Councils had decided to use the profits on a year to year basis, I think we would not have any lllOney to use from that source now, nor would we have the excellent industrial situation that we have. One further ccrnrnent, this Council recently approved current and future expenditures by the Department of Public Utilities for necessary expansion and lllOdernization of the electric, wastewater, water and gas systems that would need lllOre lllOney than is presently available. There is at this t:ilne a bonded debt of approximately six (6) million dollars. I have found from personal experience that lllOney can only be spent once. Another, possible negative aspect to this situation is the favorable credit rating available to Orangeburg, both Moody and '- Standard and Poor rate us M, 1Nhich means substantial savings if and when we borrow money. This credit rating is in roy opinion the result of long term excellent management and operation and is the only such rating tbn Revenue Bonds in South Carolina. . · I have carefully examined the evaluation report of the Public Safety Department that was presented to Orangeburg City Council by Hr. Ronald Salley and Mr. James Walsh, Jr. I regret that the report found that the P.S. Dept. has been operating so unsatisfactorily and was so dis­ organized that morale and performance were affected to an impermissible degree. My conclusion is that it is a factual and honest effort to call atten­ tion to the citizens of Orangeburg and to it's employees and officials of the situation, and in my opinion Hr. Walsh and Mr. Salley, were the appropriate appointees for this study, s'ince they both have "knowledge -and connections with the municipal government. Mr. Walsh, being the City Attorney and Mr. Salley, the City Recorder and a former member of Orangeburg City Council. My purpose at this time is not to place the blame for this situation, but I do wish to say that I as a member of Council had and have respon­ sibility. I voted to consolidate the Fire and Police Department into one department to be known as the Public Safety Department. I thought at that time that it was a practical and workable idea, with much potential for the City, in efficiency, performance and economy. I still am of that opinion. After joining in the decision to make the consolidation, I watched the action closely and regularly inquired about the situation and was assured that progress was being made and unexpected complications that arose were being dealt with. After several months, I began to hear of incidents of poor morale behavior and internal strife. I questioned more often and more urgently about the eVidently deteriorating situation. More in­ formation and my observations became progressively convincing to me, incidentally up to this pOint, which I guess to have been about four or five months ago had been voluntary. Then about three months ago, I began to try to ascertain for myself, what .was needed and how to proceed, and let me assure you that this kind of information is not easy to come by, and I, not being a professional in such matters was in somewhat of a dilemma. I proceeded as best I could with my limited talents. My regrets and apology to the citizens of Orangeburg is that I did not make this statement in June. The new plan of reorganization, which was proposed and approved by Mayor's Statement Page Two Council and is to become effective this week is a move in the right direction, in my opinion, but it nor any other plan is going to work unless we have a strong and fair person, who has the authority, the knowledge, the determination to make it work. This person cannot just let it work, they must make it work and will need to have the support of the employees, the citizens and the officials of the City. I pledge my whole hearted support and promise to monitor the progress regularly and often, and if I think it appropriate, I will talk to the citizens again. " September 6, 1988 E. O. Pendarvis Hayor RES 0 L U T rON WHEREAS, The CUy. on OMngebUltg fuu, a de.6hte ;tluvt CLU empioyee.6 .6houid be .{.nnOltmed M ;to ;the gcu.drune.6 c.onc.VtMng empioymen;t wUh ;the CUy and, WHEREAS, a PVt.6onnei PoUc.y Manua.i hM been plLePCUted .6;trnng ;the poUUe.6 wh.-i.c.h CUte otuUncvUty n oUowed, and WHEREAS, ;trw.. PVt.6onnei PoUey WM adop;ted by ;the OMngebUltg CUy Counw on Ju.iy 19, 1988, and WHEREAS, U hM been nound ;tluvt an amendmen;t iJ., needed ;to ;trw.. PVt.6onnei PoUc.y. NOW, TffEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVEV ;tluvt ;the CUy Counw on ;the CUy on OMngebUltg hVteby adopu ;the PVt.6onnei PoUey Manu.a.i, M amended, M ill gcUdrune.6 nOlt ;the CUIj on OMngebUltg. The c.on;tenU on ;trw.. doc.u.men;t CUte no;t .{.n;tended nOlt .6houid ;they be .{.n;tVtpftue4 ;to e.6;tabwh a c.on;(;Jtac.;tua.i fteia.tion.oh.-i.p on empioymen;t wUh aYllJ empioljee Oft ;to pltOv.-i.de anlj pltOpVt;tij !t.-i.ghU . .{.n . empioymen;t; nOlt ;to .{.nduc.e ft~nc.e ;thVteu.pon blj any empioyee. AU empioljee.6 .6hCLU c.onUnue ;to .6Vtve a.;t ;the w.{.U and ;the pieMUlte on ;the CUy. The.6e gcu.drune.6 CUte .6ubjec.;t ;to c.hange a.;t aYllJ time and nOlt aYllJ fteMon a.;t ;the .boie wc./te;t.{.on on ;trw.. Counw. PASSEV by ;the CUIj Counw on ;the CUIj on OMngebUltg, Sou.;th CCUtotina., ;trw.. 6;th dCI.IJ on Sep;tembVt, A.V., 1988. , ~ 4': --4 ~ ~ " MAYOR/, ~.r; ~.£_t5 i~~ 7 / r--/ .J~.~._~ C1 ~-Z//~A4;7~-y~ c:/ c/' c>J.J~N . ~~¥- MEMBERS OF COUNCr L ~ A1TES>~~ _/,~<-~ ", ,/ ciTY CLERK RESOLUTION WFJEREAS, the Department of Public Utilities of the City of Orangeburg, South Carolina, received bids on August 17, 1988 for the construction of New Brookland Sewer, Phase III. WFJEREAS, the low resp:Jnsible bid for this work was submitted by Mccoy Utilities, Inc. of sumter, South Carolina, in the amount of $97,170.00; and NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE Mayor and Members of Council of the City of Orangeburg, in Council assembled, and by authority of the same, that the low resp:Jnsible bid shown above be accepted, subject to approval of the Governor's Office, Division of Economic Development; and BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that Ted M. Johnson, Jr., Manager of the Department of Public Utilities, be authorized and he is hereby directed to execute the contract documents on behalf of the Department of Public Utilities of the City of Orangeburg. PASSED by the City CounciL in Council assernbled, at Orangeburg, South Carolina this 1.0 ..Dr., d'D,y of S "-v-\.,, WI be,. A.D., 1988. , , Signed: ~ i,f,<.v£;'-".L.L{. _ 60'~ ~~9J.- A'ITE~,T:~/ h ~~L CitY' Clerk and TreasUrer-- C\I (Y) >I CD CD c::::( ~ CITY COUNCIL MINUTES SEPTEMBER 6, 1988 PAGE 3 387 Concerning matters regarding the Department of Public Utilities, a motion by Mayor Pro Tem Salley, seconded by Counci1member Alexander, unanimously approved the resolution awarding the low responsible bid to McCoy Utilities, Incorporated of Sumter in the amount of $97,170 for the construction of Phase III of the New Brookland Sewer Project. This resolution authorized Mr. Ted M. Johnson, Jr., to exercise the contract. There being no further business, the~ing was adjourned. submitted, /r a:rol A. Brunson City Clerk 388 CITY COUNCIL MINUTES SEPTEMBER 20, 1988 Orangeburg City Council held its regularly scheduled meeting on September 20, 1988, at 7:00 P.M.; in City Hall Chambers with Mayor Pendarvis presiding. PRESENT: E. o. Pendarvis, Mayor W. Everette Salley, Mayor Pro Tern Henry F. Frierson Sara H. Alexander A motion by Councilmember Alexander, seconded Frierson, unanimously approved the September 6, Minutes as distributed. by Councilmember 1988 City Council Mayor Pendarvis recognized councilmember Alexander as this being her last meeting. He stated that she was a hard working councilmember. Ms. Alexander stated that she served her city to the best of her abilities and appreciated all the support from fellow councilmembers and the citizens of the City of Orangeburg. A motion Frierson, Land Swap by councilmember Alexander, seconded by Councilmember unanimously approved the third reading of the City/County Ordinance. A motion by Councilmember Alexander, seconded by Councilmember Frierson, accepted the recommendation by the Orangeburg Aviation Commission on the airport fixed based and aircraft maintenance operations. Council unanimously accepted the Election Commission Report. (See Attachment) A motion by unanimously Lovell, SE. Mayor Pendarvis, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Salley, approved the prohibiting of parking on the east side of council unanimously approved to defer the executing agreements and right of way easements for the State Department to improve the following city streets. project Highway 1. Oakland NE from Russell NE northerly approximately 350 feet 2. Pine SE from Palmetto SE to Moseley SE 3. Boulevard NE from Russell NE to Sifly NE City Attorney Walsh presented a Resolution pertaining to the litigation with Jones Intercable. He pointed out that no money would be paid but this agreement may include certain wavers of the pole attachment agreement. A motion by Councilmember Alexander, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Salley, unanimouslY approved the first reading of an ordinance to amend Chapter 11 of the City of Orangeburg Code of Ordinances regulating minimum standards for housing in the corporate limits. A motion by Mayor Pro Tern Salley, seconded by Councilmember Alexander, unanimously approved the first reading of an ordinance to amend Section 5-1 of the Code of Ordinances, City of Orangeburg, SC ~­ adopted october 21, 1969, relating to adoption of the standard building code. RESOLUTION WfIEREAS, studies by the Surgeon General of the United States, The National Academy of Sciences, and other health organizations have linked passive exposure to tobacco smoke (second-hand smoke) to a variety of negative health conditions in non-smokers, and WfIEREAS, The Department of Public Utilities for the City of Orangeburg, State of South Carolina seeks to protect non-smokers from passive exposure to tobacco smoke (second-hand smoke) by regulating smoking within its general offices located on Russell EM in the City of Orangeburg, State of South Carolina; NOW, THEREFORE, be it resolved by City Council duly assembled that smoking shall not be permitted within the general offices and building of the Department of Public Utilities for the City of Orangeburg, State of South Carolina, located on Russell EM in said City and State. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the Manager of the Department of Public Utili ties and the Manager's designees shall have the authority to manage and control smoking within said offices and building and shall post or cause to be posted and prominently displayed, and shall maintain, "No Smoking" signs at all entrances to said building. Signs shall be of sufficient nurril:Jer and in sufficient locations to convey the message clearly to all persons wi thin said building. DCNE AND RATIFIED this dO~ day of S~m),.p(· , 1988 . ATTESL d /~~( ! City Clerk '-./ Signed: . 0 , 7 ~ Members of Council RESOLUTION WHEREAS, the City of Orangeburg, the individual members of City Council and the Manager of the Department of Public Utilities are defen- dants in that certain civil action entitled Jones Intercable Inc., et al., Plaintiffs vs. City of Orangeburg, et al., Defendants, Docket No. 5-87-2014-6 of the United States District Court, Orangeburg Division, and WHEREAS, both the Plaintiffs and the Defendants have determined through extensive discovery that settlement of said litigation is in the best interest of all parties, and WHEREAS, settlement negotiations have been ongoing between the respec- tive attorneys for the parties; NOW, THEREFORE, be it resolved by City Council duly assembled that the attorneys of record for the Defendant5are authorized to negotiate a settle- ment with the attorneys for the Plaintiffs which shall not include the payment of any sum of Il10ney Whatsoever by or on behalf of the City of Orangeburg or its officials to Jones Intercable, but which may involve the granting of certain waivers or amendments to the Pole Attachment Agreement for the purpose of minimizing the :inpact of the construction of the Depart- ment of Public Utilities' fiber optics SCADA system on Jones Intercable; provided, the Manager of the Department of Public Utilities is of the opinion that such waivers or amendments will not have a substantial adverse effect on the Department of Public Utilities or its fiber optics SCADA system. DONE AND RATIFIED this C2 O+k day of ~D+€ vY\ h<l.. , 1988. Signed: ./ <X'~ A- ae.....- 4:. $n~~~ < • ~ ntfo Members of Council City Clerk DECLARATION OF RESULT OF CITY ELECTION .' ~ < For City Council Members, Districts 2, 3, 4, 5 and 6 - Held September 13, 1988 We, the duly appointed Commissioners of Election for the City of Orangeburg, having received the report of the Managers of the Election who had charge of the election held in the City of Orangeburg on September 13, 1988, for the purpose of electing council members for Districts 2, 3, 4, 5 and 6, and having had delivered into our charge the ballot boxes with the ballots sealed therein, met at the City Hall on Thursday, September 1G, 1988; no person appeared before your Commissioners with any statement or request in regard to the said election, and the following is the tabulated vote received by the candidates at said election: DISTRICT 2 Sara- H. Alexander Dr. W. Everette Salley .' DISTRICT 3 Thomas A. Boland, Sr. Barney M. Houser Paul A. Miller DISTRICT 4 Eugene Montgomery Bernard Haire DISTRICT 5 Liz Zimmerman Keitt Forrest O. Blunt DISTRICT 6 Rev. Allen W. Parrott 141 votes 161 votes 249 votes 101 votes 76 votes 83 votes 135 votes 80 votes 21 votes 112 votes Having received no contests, your Commissioners therefore TERM EXP1RES 9-91 TERM EXP1RES 9-89 TERM EXP1RES 9-91 TERM EXP1RES 9-89 TERM EXP1RES 9-91 '- ~-,-,- declare that the said Dr. W. Everette Salley, Thomas A. Boland, Sr., Bernard Haire, Liz Zimmerman Keitt and Rev. Allen W. Parrott have been elected as Council Members for the City of Orangeburg. a . Ott, Municipal to Election Commission J).Y, S0QQo'7(~ D. D. Salley, III, ~hairman ~~ Carol H. Riley d ,,/ q/j 0 /'7_, /'~"-'<'::"--K ..--'<- ""' rf/~, Harold I. Robinson Municipal Election Commission for City of Orangeburg, South Carolina s~ m, "" ", 16i~ day of S '?@'±"->n b <? r ,1 9 8 8 lfotary Public, South Carolina l My Commission Expires: t6 /JG/ '13 , , (\j (Y) >i m m <! CITY COUNCIL MINUTES SEPTEMBER 20, 1988 PAGE 2 Pertaining to the Department of Public Utilities matters, a motion by Councilmember Alexander, seconded by Mayor Pendarvis, unanimously approved a Resolution to prohibit smoking in the Department of Public Utilities building. Mayor Pro Tern Salley made include all city buildings. an amendment to the above Resolution to It did not receive a second. There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned. ReS~UllY ?libmitted, ~~n "City Clerk /r 389 390 CITY COUNCIL MINUTES OCTOBER 4, 1988 Orangeburg City Council held its regularly scheduled meeting on October 4, 1988, at 7:00 P.M., in City Hall Chambers with Mayor Pendarvis presiding. PRESENT: E. o. Pendarvis, Mayor Thomas A. Boland, Sr., Mayor Pro Tern Henry F. Frierson Bernard Haire L. Zimmerman Keitt Allen W. Parrott W. Everette Salley Attorney recently Salley) . James F. Walsh administered the oath elected councilmembers (Boland, Haire, of office to the Keitt, Parrott, and A motion by Councilmember Keitt, seconded by Councilmember Parrott, unanimously approved the election of Thomas A. Boland, Sr., as Mayor Pro Tern. A public hearing was held on the rezoning of Edisto Gardens from A-2 Residential to B-1 Business. City Administrator smith explained that the Department of Public Utilities needed to expand their water plant thus displacing the City's Park Office which must move to another location. The size of the land in question is not sufficient to honor the set back requirements of A-2 zoning. No public comments were received. A motion by Councilmember Frierson, unanimously approved the September distributed. Councilmember Haire comments included in the minutes. seconded by Councilmember Keitt, 20, 1988 City Council Minutes as noted that he wanted public An appearance was scheduled for Mrs. P. Gardiner Clark but she did not attend the meeting. A motion by councilmember Salley, seconded by Councilmember Haire, unanimously approved the right of way easement for Oakland NE from Russell NE northerly approximately 350 feet. A motion by Councilmember Salley, Frierson, unanimously approved the right from Palmetto SE to Moseley SE. seconded by Councilmember of way easement for Pine SE A motion was made by Councilmember Salley and seconded by Councilmember Frierson (seconded for the purpose of opening the matter for discussion) to approve executing the State Highway Department project agreement on Boulevard NE from Russell NE to Sifly NE. councilmember Haire stating that he opposed the matter, requested a public hearing. councilmember Parrott stated that more study was needed on the people that it will affect. councilmember Keitt wanted to enforce the request made at the previous meeting by Mr. Eugene Montgomery for a public hearing, therefore, councilmember Keitt, Mayor Pro Tern Boland, Councilmember Haire, Councilmember Parrott, opposed execution of this project agreement thus postponing this matter again. Mayor Pendarvis pointed out that this is a sore point and an area needing attention. Some improvements have been made but there is still some problems. He thinks that council should move forward and have the problem alleviated so that the area can be more attractive. This project amount is approximately $500,000 and he does not want to risk the possibility of not having anything done at all. He stated that we should schedule a public hearing as soon as legally possible. After some discussion about when the hearing should be, Councilmember Salley stated that he felt that it needed to be a separate meeting because of the seating capacity in the Council Chambers. Mr. Eugene Montgomery wants council to consider all the area to the Orangeburg Mall as brought up in a plan some years ago. He's hoping that the highway department will include this in their presentation as it is part of the problem. (\j (Y) OJ OJ c:::{ CITY COUNCIL MINUTES OCTOBER 4, 1988 PAGE 2 A motion by Counci1member Salley, seconded by Counci1member Frierson, unanimously approved the second reading of an ordinance to amend Chapter 11 of the City of Orangeburg Code of Ordinances regulating minimum standards for housing in the corporate limits. A motion by Councilmember Salley, seconded by Councilmember Frierson, unanimously approved the second reading of an ordinance to amend Section 5-1 of the Code of Ordinances, City of Orangeburg, South Carolina, adopted October 21, 1969, relating to adoption of the standard building code. A motion by Councilmember Salley, seconded by Councilmember Parrott, unanimouslY aproved the first reading of an ordinance to rezone the Edisto Gardens from A-2 Residential to B-1 Business. Mayor Pro Tern Boland read a Veteran's Day Proclamation proclaiming Friday, November 11, 1988, as Veteran's Day. He also noted that there would be a ceremony at 11:00 A.M. on this day at the Edisto Gardens. Mayor Pro Tern Boland read the Proclamation proclaiming October 3rd through 9th, 1988, as National Community Health Center Week. A motion by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Councilmember Salley, unanimously approved Councilmember Keitt as a member of the Intergovernmental Affairs Committee replacing former Councilmember Herb Bradley. A motion by Mayor Pendarvis, seconded unanimously aproved to defer action on a Center to retain un-spent funds until the the 7-4-88 fire) to the LEC is known. by Councilmember Haire, request from the Detention amount of the damage (from A motion by Councilmember Frierson, seconded by Mayor Pendarvis, approved the first reading of the Airport Fixed Base Operating Lease Ordinance. councilmember Keitt abstained from voting. A motion by Councilmember Frierson, seconded by Councilmember Salley, unanimously approved the Airport Mechanics Lease Ordinance. Mayor Pro Tern Boland expressed concern over the parking meter situation around the court house. He stated that employees of the court house have now returned to parking in the customer parking spaces. He feels that we need to return to enforcing parking regulations. A motion by Mayor Pro Tern Boland, seconded by Mayor Pendarvis, unanimously approved this. He also expressed concern of some business people wanting to remove the parking meters on Boulevard by the railroad. He suggested a meeting with these business people. Mr. Lamar Dawkins requested that this meeting be part of the public hearing when the railroad corner is discussed. Mayor Pro Tern Boland stated that shop lifting is becoming a problem again in the downtown area. He thinks that a foot beat patrol needs to be performed once or twice a day during business hours. A motion by Mayor Pro Tern Boland, seconded by Mayor Pendarvis, approved this. Councilmember Salley stated that council is now directing the Chief (Public Safety Director Brant) on how to run his department and feels that it is a mistake to do it in this manner. City Administrator Smith presented a report to council on Public Safety. (A copy attached and made a part of these minutes.) Mayor Pro Tern Boland requested Walsh and City Judge Salley Public Safety. the same report presented by Attorney to the previous council concerning 391 392 CITY COUNCIL MINUTES OCTOBER 4, 1988 PAGE 3 Mayor Pro Tern Boland requested a report on employment, dismissal, and grievance procedures of the City. City Administrator Smith pointed out that this was in the Revised Personnel Policy handbook that was recently issued. Mayor Pro Tern Boland asked why did the City and DPU have separate Grievance Committees. City Administrator Smith requested an executive session on behalf of Attorney Walsh for legal advice. DPU Manager, Ted Johnson, was not present, therefore, there were no utility matters brought before council. A motion by Councilmember Salley, seconded by Councilmember Parrott, unanimously approved to enter into an executive session for legal advice. There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned. submitted, City Clerk /r " -E. 0. PENDARVIS L. HUGH SMITH CITY ADMINISTRATOR P. D. DRAWER 387 MAYOR THOMAS A. BOLAND, SR . . _HENRY F. FRIERSON. M. D. ~ .~ -, BERNARD HAIRE L. ZIMMERMAN KEITT ALLEN W. PARROTT W. EVERETTE SALLEY. D.V.M. ([it~ of ®rauB.ehurB ~nutq QIarnlinlt 29116-0387 MEMBERS OF COUNCIL TO: FR.OM: VATE: SUBJECT: Olla.ngebWtg CU;y Coun.eU. L. Hugh SmUh Oc.t:obeJl 4, 1988 PubUc. Saf, dy VepaJU:men:t St:at:u.t, R.epolLt The Public Saf,dy VepaJU:men:t .i..6 ruJI(/ Oll.ganized. wilh. a. PoUc.e V.ivLsi.on. and. a. F.vr.e V-i.v.i..6-i.on. opella.t.i.n.g undeJl ;the a.cfm.in..iA:I:ve l.ea.d.vu.hi.p of, ;the Public Sal, dy V.vr.ec.t:oJl.. Police V-i.vLsi.on. pvu.on.n.el.. aJLe woJtki.n.g :thJtee e.i.ght hoWl. Mu.f,;U peJl d.a.y wki.le ;the F.vr.e V-i.v.i..6-i.on. opvr.a.tu on. a. :t1AIe.n.ty-f,OWl. hoUlLl> on. du;ty and. f,olLty-e..i.ght hoUlLl> oU du;ty .6c.hedul.e. . The ClW.6.6 ;tJza..UWzg of,. pvu.on.n.el.. .i..6 con:ti.nl.Li.ng. N.i.n.e poUc.emen and. noWl. f,.vr.emen have juU: comp£.e;te.d Pha..6e III F.vr.e TJUt.i.n..Uz.g. . An.o;theJl c.ltu..6 .i..6 .&taJLt.Utg on. Oc.t:obeJl lO;th wh-i.c.h w.i.U co¥l.l..i..6t: of, ;ten policemen and. :t1AIo f,.vr.emen. Thue :t1AIe.n.ty-f,-i.ve peop£.e aM ;then .6c.hedul.ed. ;to a;t;ten.d ;the Sou;th Ccvr.o.e..i.na. F.vr.e Ac.a.demq on. Oc.t:obeJl 23JUl ;to be ;tu;ted. f,OlL ceJLt.i.f,-i.c.a.t.i.on. a..6 f,.vr.emen. O;theJl c.ltu..6u aJLe be.i.n.g p£.a.n.n.ed. wh-i.c.h w.i.U. .600n. have aU. of, OWl. Pub.e..i.c Sa.f,dy pvu.on.n.el.. .. j).vr.e c.eJVt.i.j)-i.ed.." F.vr.emen aM on. a. .6c.hedul.e wh-i.c.h ca.U..6 f,olL ;them :to .6u.pp£.emen:t ;the poUc.e pa;tJw£. f,0IL :thi..tc.:tq-:t1AIo hoUlLl> peJl mon:th. They aJLe ga..i.nin.g ex.peJL-i.ence -in. JLou:t.i.n.e pa.tJw£. woJLk bu:t Me ;to lLUpond -i.mmed.i.a.tei..!! ;to IInq j).vr.e .6cene wilh. ;the.vr. equ.i.pmen:t be.i.n.g -in. .th.e piWr.o£. c.aJL. We Me wa.i.1:.i.n.g f,0IL CJr..i.m.in.a.l JIL.6t:-i.c.e Aca.demq d.a:tu ;to become a.va..i..f.a.b£.e .60 ;tha;t ;thue emp£.oqeu can a;t;ten.d and. become "po.e..i.c.e c.eJVt.i.j)-i.ed.." LHS/lL STATE OF SOUTH CAROLINA, COUNTY OF ORANGEBURG. I, Thomas A. Boland, sr., Councilmember of the City of Orangeburg, do solemnly swear that I will equally, fairly and impartially, in the best of my ability and skill, exercise the trust reposed in me and I will use my best endeavors to preserve the peace and carry into effect according to the law for the purposes for which I have been elected. I do further solemnly swear that I will at all times endeavor to secure and maintain for the City an honest and efficient govern­ ment in every particular, with an eye single to the public wel­ fare. I do further solemnly swear that I am duly qualified, according to the constitution of this State, to exercise the duties of the office to which I have been elected and that I will, to the best of my ability, discharge the duties thereof and preserve, protect and defend the Constitution of this State and of the United States, So Help Me God! swornft~~. b ~re me this da~'988 qarol x. Br~nson Notary Publ~c, SC 4th My Commission expires 6-16-93 ( ~~<£JLQx< Thomas A. BOland, Sr. STATE OF SOUTH CAROLINA, COUNTY OF ORANGEBURG. I, Bernard Haire, Councilmember of the City of Orangeburg, do solemnly swear that I will equally, fairly and impartially, in the best of my ability and skill, exercise the trust reposed in me and I will use my best endeavors to preserve the peace and carry into effect according to the law for the purposes for which I have been elected. I do further solemnlY swear that I will at all times endeavor to secure and maintain for the City an honest and efficient govern­ ment in every particular, with an eye single to the public wel­ fare. I do further solemnly swear that I am duly qualified, according to the constitution of this State, to exercise the duties of the office to which I have been elected and that I will, to the best of my ability, discharge the duties thereof and preserve, protect and defend the Constitution of this State and of the United States, So Help Me God! ~/ Sworn to ~fore me this day Of~oCttOOber 198,8, ,//~~ qarol A. Brunson Notary public, SC 4th My Commission expires 6-16-93 ~.~ - STATE OF SOUTH CAROLINA, COUNTY OF ORANGEBURG. I, L. Zimmerman Keitt, Councilmember of the City of Orangeburg, do solemnly swear that I will equally, fairly and impartially, in the best of my ability and skill, exercise the trust reposed in me and I will use my best endeavors to preserve the peace and carry into effect according to the law for the purposes for which I have been elected. I do further solemnly swear that I will at all times endeavor to secure and maintain for the City an honest and efficient govern­ ment in every particular, with an eye single to the public wel­ fare. I do further solemnly swear that I am duly qualified, according to the constitution of this State, to exercise the duties of the office to which I have been elected and that I will, to the best of my ability, discharge the duties thereof and preserve, protect and defend the Constitution of this State and of the United States, So Help Me God! Sworn to ~ore me this ~~;;a Carol A. Brunson Notary Public, SC 4th My Commission expires 6-16-93 ,~,#~ .. ~ erma~#dt1~ ~ = STATE OF SOUTH CAROLINA, COUNTY OF ORANGEBURG. I, Allen W. Parrott, Councilmember of the City of orangeburg, do solemnly swear that I will equally, fairly and impartially, in the best of my ability and skill, exercise the trust reposed in me and I will use my best endeavors to preserve the peace and carry into effect according to the law for the purposes for which I have been elected. I do further solemnly swear that I will at all times endeavor to secure and maintain for the City an honest and efficient govern­ ment in every particular, with an eye single to the public wel­ fare. I do further solemnly swear that I am duly qualified, according to the constitution of this State, to exercise the duties of the office to which I have been elected and that I will, to the best of my ability, discharge the duties thereof and preserve, protect and defend the Constitution of this State and of the United States, So Help Me God! swor~ft~. ,fore me this day ~~/t~er, 1988 /~ Carol A. Brunson Notary Public, SC 4th My Commission expires 6-16-93 ~~Q"~~~ Allen W. Parrott STATE OF SOUTH CAROLINA, COUNTY OF ORANGEBURG. I, W. Everette Salley, Councilmember of the City of Orangeburg, do solemnly swear that I will equally, fairly and impartially, in the best of my ability and skill, exercise the trust reposed in me and I will use my best endeavors to preserve the peace and carry into effect according to the law for the purposes for which I have been elected. I do further solemnly swear that I will at all times endeavor to secure and maintain for the City an honest and efficient govern­ ment in every particular, with an eye single to the public wel­ fare. I do further solemnly swear that I am duly qualified, according to the constitution of this State, to exercise the duties of the office to which I have been elected and that I will, to the best of my ability, discharge the duties thereof and preserve, protect and defend the Constitution of this State and of the United States, So Help Me God! Sworn to before me this 4th day of octOber, 88 /'ijg Carol A. Brunson Notary Public, SC My Commission expires 6-16-93 ~. W. Everette sa~ey J;_~ Form 001 (Rev. 8·1·77) /J"k/ .. "c/ PC' The State of South Carolina Item 28919 TRACT ........ 1 ...................... COUNTY of ... Rm.ng(l);>m;g ............................... . Route No .... S.7.?9)''+' ............... "ik No Right of Way Easement Project No .................................. , ....... ,., ........... . City of Orangeburg Approx. survey staticn. from ... Ot32 ...... to3t4Q .. Rt .• &Lt. KNOW II.I.L MEN BY THESE PRESENTS. That I (or we) Orangeburg .5. C. 29115 ...... , ....................................................................... . ...... ....... , ....... " ......... , ..................................................... . in consideration of the ~um of One DoHar. to me (or u<;:) in hand paid. and ether valuahlc consideration at and before seat· ing: and delivering thcn.~of. by the S01lth C::',rolin3 f)er~r1mcnt of Highways and Public Transportation. receipt of which i~ hereby acknowiedgcrl. have gl':l.nted. bargained. s('!ld. and released. and by these presents do grant. bargain. sell and re­ lease. unto the said South CarcJin:\ !1cl'lIttment of Highways and Public Transportation, h~ successors and assigns a right of way fot" the construction (,f 2 <;;c("~ioll of the State:, Highway fTom ....... $.0I!.Q., ... ~Q\l:t'?.J3 .......................................... . r-..nnw "f Pl!ln: to .... ).').Q;t'.t)))<.$.<>.t. ................................................................. on Route No ... S".2.Qll .......................... State and ~'.'1t1<' I '1 l'l;l"~·. County aforesaid. ~~ shown by plans prepared hy th~ South Carolina Department of Highw"-ys and Public Transportation. on and over an la:'1ds which I (or ... ·c) "\~_y own in whole or in p3n, for the purpose of locating. constructing, improving. and maintaining the above described high\vay with the bridges and causeways thereo;'. and the tight to c('.'nstruc..'t and maintain controlled acce..:s facilities to said highway. Bounded by the 1,,,o, or. .... ~.,!; .•... ~.ta.t.e .. .c.Q.ll"'gt;! ... ,ln .. :th~ .. n.or.th"'.e.<>.i. •... $ .•. C •... Raute .. :3:3 .•. on. .. the ........ . \1, .. " "Illy III(' l;jml O\\"("r~ :\10)1I,~ The ~1't.:hw:1\ . . ~.Q.uthe.a&t .......................................... . . ..................•.......•... _ .......... , ....................•.• and others. Said right of \ .... a)' to have:tl. wi-:1th {)f ...... .lA:O ......... ".fec:t. that is ..... 20 .. " ........... f::··:t '.,n each side of the center line of the highway. The grantor CXPtt!s<;!v tecogni7.t's tr,t: possibility j'hat the property d~s:::riberl herein may be used in the future by cable tekvision companies for the rurr(lse~ provided by Act No. 688 of the Ads. of Joint Resolutions (1976). , 'Spocial Provision s:" .. A .. !tq. X9.9.t . };.~g.lxt:-... 9.:f. .. 1'(~y. .• 9,;'; •. ;';)).9)<))...QJ!.. .. "p.l'" t .. :1:~ (:Qx:d.ed ' .. in.. :pIa.t ...... . 1'.9.9.15 .. 1 ... ~ t .. p.%~ .. n R .. ,,;'; .. ;r;~".Qm~R. .. 11).. Jn~ .. Qf.f. ).Q(l .. pt: .. :the .. R. J.l •. Cl. ••• .f. ax: .. ax:ange burg .. .cD .•..... ............................................................................................................................................. Together v.:it]'l. all and ~inguiar, the rights. members. hereditaments and 3ppunenances thereunto belonging, or in any wise im'iocnt or appcrt:1ining. It is a~r("ed that buildings. fences. signs (If uther obstructions will not be erected by me (or us). m."- heirs. a.ssigns or ~ldministr3t('.s within the limits of the righ[ of way herein conveyed and that such buildings n_n,1 i\;nces a5 arc nQw within the limits of the right "f way !'It:rcin conveyed will be moved from the right of way lmd reo stored in os good condition :\5 l'tei'n!l: moving at the ('xpcn:o;:e of the South C.lroiina Dcp.1rtrnent of Highways and Public Transportntion. TO HAVE AND TO HOl.D. all 3Tld singular. the said right (if "'lay and the righls hereinbefore granted. untC1 the said Snuth Cu· .. ~!ina Department of Highways and Public Transportation. its successnrs and assjgn~ forever ~ iN ·~VrTNF.SS WHEREOF. 1 {er we) have hereunto set my (or ('lur) hand ... and s'.!al... tbis ....... ~ ... ~" ......... day o~,~-i?,6.:4'::":: .. in th,- yoor of uur Lord. One Tholl"nd Nine Hundred and_5.jy">?t,~.$.-:}!:-;:Z'.~ . ~ign~d. scaled ,O!nd delivered. in the presence of: ·;~UJt?.a.il(~·C::t. .. ···t{p1f.~1t·h .......... . ( :-'\1. ,', ,;:y~ / IJ {!. ~4/~' .... :::::~:::'~~'.::::.~!::::::::.:: .. Cit! of ory.,)"ebur g , c.:; -.-,-"~/ . ./../ I. ~ -'~ ..... /. /', .. : 1'7..-7 • -. ,- ~-- '..--1 ;::: ... .1C''':. __ ,. "I/.' &. ., .. L.L .'. ~::I>. r.: C:. ;,.c •• ,a... Co·,: ••.•••••• (L.S.) ~1ayor NOTE: All Right of \V2Y J.grcc1n<'r.!S must hc in writing "I~d <Ire subject to rejection by the South CaroHna Department of Highways and Public Tr3r1spcrtation. =;=.==---=-.;.-=----- . The State of South Carolina COUNTY OF .. ~,~,~"'/,V;.,",£-c:-,'""'~,'2;,,::.: ............ . {/ --_. . L/'" ;' PersonaJIy 3ppeared ............... ~,(~~g,-:-:' ......... L.J, .. A.:t~7/.~~ .................................... . <7./ .c;; V ,/J '. and made oath that ... ~~~ ..... saw the within na.mcd ...... ~.\.O'.( .... / .. ~-.q,;.';'?::C.~.(-5 ........................ . PrinT or lypewritc Name . . ~ - , sign, seal and, 3.s ... ?-;~{;,~.,.,..,-:' .•..• act and deed. deliver the within written easement; aT\dthat ..... ~ .... with ~- 1': " . ....... ~~·;:~·:<·.-8-"'--:': .... ..;?.~ ... ~:f.(;r..1..(.{;.:7~ .......... , ........................................... witnessed the ex:ecution thereof. S b " c· ~/;:C worn to Clore me t';I$ ................ =:·: ...•...•........•......•............. day of .. a~:r.f?,.,fd.?,,":::::::-:-.................. A. D .. 19.&:-.Y ~~ ....---'. __ A _~ J_ _ •••• 4~ 'c.""==-~~ed."'"0~" ,,= ........... o ••• (L.S.) My Commi .... i(lf] expires"".,." ,,-, .. ~//~;. /-:".97-...0." .. NOTary rllhh~' ti,r .')"urli" (';w\ J l' . dt.i . (._-. . .. 4:)}!A~:~-;:~n hc"i{~tj··~··· ,--.- • The State of South Carolina RENUNOATIONOFPOWER COUNTY OF........................................................................ . ....... Notary Public for S. C. I ........................................................................................... , ...................... . do hereby certify unto whom it may concern, that Mrs ............................ , ..................... f •••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••• ' •••••• the y,:ifr: of the within llanv:d ...................................... , ........................................................... did this day appear hefore me, and upon being pr;';are1~' anJ separately examined by me, did declare that she does freely. voluntarily. and · ... ~fhotTt an:'; r:ompulsion. dre~d or fear d nny person or persons whom$oever. renounce. release. an4, forever relinquisn un· !" Ih'~ , .. ;;-r.i" named South Canhna Department of Highways and Public Transportation. its 5uccessors and ;u:sign$. all her ir:trn· ... ' ' ...... : "<.tate, and als('l her ri21,t and claim of Qower of. in arid to. aU and singular. the premises within mentioned and r("lt"ascd Given under my hand and seal. thiS ....... , .......•......... , ................................ day of ............................... · ...•...... Anno Domini. 19 ...••..... . ........................ sij.i~;i~;.<,.·;Jf"wii~::··························· S\\'orn t(} before me this .... , .............•........ day of ..•........•....•......•.................. ~ .............................. A. D.,. 19 .....•.... ................................................................................. (L. S.) I'''J~ C.lmmi .. ~inn {.(PlfO.,. ............. .. .............. . N')lary Puh!k ti,r SOI:th (';.rolina The State of South Carolina MORTGAGE RELEASE COUNTY OF ....................................................................... . KNOW ALL MEN BY THESE PRESENTS. That 1 (or .we) ............................................................................. .. do for ccrtain valuable consider:ltion release frnm the lien and operation of my (or our) mortgage the property conveyed bv the within deed so that the said property shaH be free and unaffected by said mortgag~. . -'~V1tness our hand and seal this .............................. day of ............................................................. 19 ...... , ... . In the presence of: .... • _ ... --t __ . Item 28863 Form 801 (Rev. 4-27-88) THE STATE OF SOUTH CAROLINA COUNTY OF Orangeburg Road/Route No. _-'S'--_1=0-"'0.,,6 ____ _ File No. __________ _ Project No. _________ _ RIGHT OF WAY E~SEMENT APPROXIMATE SURVEY STATION f~-</C'5&~ 0+16 TO 4+34 RT & LT ro ---------------- ---------------_ __________ TO _______________ _ KNOW AlL MEN BY THESE PRESENTS, That I (or we) Ci tv of Orangeburg, Orangeburg, South Carolina 29116 in consideration of the sum of One Ool1ar, to me (or us) in hand paid, and other valuable consideration at and before the sealing and delivering thereof, by the South Carolina Department of Highways and Public Transportation, receipt of which is hereby acknowledged, have granted, bargained, sold and released and by these presents do grant, give, bargain, sell, release and quitclaim, unto the said South Carolina Department of Highways and Public I Transportation, its successors and assigns, an easement or right of way for the construction, improvement, operation and maintenance of a public road as a State Highway from Road S-1005 (Palmetto St) to Road S-1095 (Moseley St.) on Road S-1006 (Pine St.) , State and County aforesaid, as shown by plans prepared by the South Carolina Department of Highways and Public Transportation, upon and across the land which I (or we) may own, in whole or in part, between the survey stations referenced above and as depicted and described on the above referenced plans together with, all and singular, the ri ghts, members. heredi taments, and appurtenances thereunto belong; ng, or in any way inci dent or appertai ning. Said right of way to have a width of 38 si de of the ceriterl i ne of the hi ghway . The grantor descri bed herei n may be used in the future by a pub 1 i c ri ght of way. feet, that is 19 feet on each expressl y recognizes the possibil ity that the property utility or others granted the statutory right to use the SPECIAL PROVISIONS: Also herein granted is a 15 X 15 foot triangular area right of approximate mainline survey station 0+40 at the intersection of Road S-1006 and Road S-1005. TO HAVE AND TO HOLD, all and singular, the said easement or right of way and the rights hereinbefore granted, unto the said South Carolina Department of Highways and Public Transportation, its successors and assigns forever __ for a public road, highway, other public transportation purposes or other public uses as are permitted within and in conjunction with highway rights of way and the grantors hereby dedicate their respective interest in said strip of land to public use for such purposes. It is agreed that buildings, fences, signs or other obstructions will not be erected by me (or us), my (or our) heirs. assigns or administrators within the limits of the right of way herein conveyed and that such buildings and fences as are now within the limits of the right of way herein conveyed ,will be moved from the right of way and restored in as good condition as before moving at the expense of the South Carolina Department of Highways and Public Transportation. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I (or we) have hereunto set my (or our) hand and seal this ~ ~ day of ~~-e...-.;- ,in the year of our Lord, One Thousand Nine Hundred an~~~~~ sealed and delivered in the presence of: CITY OF ORANGEBURG Zd /:/ / ' f. BY: ~ ~ ("':7 ZZ-""%c9/?~;;:; /'::/ (L.S.) MAYOR / _______________________________ (L.S. ) are subject to rejection by the South Carolina SOUTH CAROLINA COUNTY OF ~~ r~A.~ Personally appeareddefore me the undersigned witness and made oath ;;gn, seal and as the grantor's act and deed, deliver the within written 'iitness whose s ;gnature appears above witnessed the executi on thereof. that s/he saw the within named grantor easement; and that s/he with the other Sworn to before me this ~ day of ~,:/---c.d- , A.D .. 19~ ~L ~ // <~~~7«L.S.) dwo"-.-O<. =l<u_'x~ 1 st \iitness si gn here () My Commission Expires: c':::;;f/¥'rra Recorded By: File, _______ _ project~ _____________ _ Tract 1 THE STATE OF SOUTH CAROLINA MORTGAGE RELEASE COUNTY OF __________ _ KNOW ALL MEN BY THESE PRESENTS, That I (or we) ________________ _ do for certain valuable consideration release from the lien and operation of my (or our) mort­ ~age the property conveyed by the within deed so that the said property shall be free and unaffected by said mortgage. Witness our hand and seal this day of , 19, ___ _ In the presence 'of: SPECIAL PROVISIONS CONTINUED: .~ of South Carolina Department Highways and Public Transportation Form 807 (Rev. 1-19-88) MUNICIPAL-STATE HIGHWAY PROJECT AGP~EMENT STATE OF SOUTH CAROLINA ) ) COUNTY OF Orangeburg ) ) FILE NO. 38. ) RESOLUTION ) F. A. PROJECT NO. ) ) ,mmm-~ ROAD NO. S-2011 ) c:Ja/4'".,d hie- WHEREAS, In accordance with Chapter 5, Title 57, Code of Laws of South Carolina, 1976, and amendments thereto, the South Carolina Department of Highways and Public Transportation in cooperation with the Municipality of Orangeburg , proposes to construct, reconstruct, alter, or improve a certain street, or streets, on duly constituted routes in the State Highway System, within the corporate limits of said Municipality, according to plans prepared by the South Carolina Department of Highways and Public Transportation, identified as follows: Project No. Route or Road No. Road S-2011: Along Oakland Street from Route 33 northwesterly for approx. 0.058 of a mile to survey station 3+40. Be it resolved that the Municipality of N01-l THEREFORE, Orangeourg does hereby consent to the construction or improve­ ments ot the atoresaid Municipal street, or streets, in accordance with the aforesaid plans, thereby evidencing compliance by the South Carolina Department of Highways and Public Transportation with the provisions of Section 57-5-820, Code of Laws of South Carolina, 1976; and further the Municipality, having review'ed the plans for said construction, does hereby approve said plans, as heretofore identified, as provided for in Section 57-5-830, of the 1976 Code. It is exprassly agreed that the South Carolina Department of Highways and Public Transportation shall not be held liable for any damages to property or injuries to persons as a consequence of the placing, maintenance, or removal of any utilities by the Municipality, or by others pursuant to permission of the Municipality; further, that the Municipality agrees to indemnify and hold harmless the South Carolina Department of Highways and Public Transportation against any and all claims or actions brought against it arising out of the placing, maintenance, or removal of any utilities by the Municipality, or by others pursuant to permission of the Municipality. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, That the Municipality will legally protect the rights of way as shmm by the plans prepared by the South Carolina Depart­ ment of High"ays and Public Transportation and as established for this street, or streets, from future encroachment along any or all parts of the improvement covered by this agreement, and that all water, sewer and gas pipes. manholes, or fire hydrants and all power, light, telegraph, or telephone poles will be moved, r.elocated or rearranged, or caused to be moved, relocated or rearranged by the Municipality, in accordance with plans prepared by the South Carolina Department of Highways and Public Transportation and/or by respective utility companies showing their present - Page 1 - and proposed location, and made a part hereof, with provJ.sJ.on that pole lines and hydrants be located back of the sidewalk, and all necessary rights of way for drainage ditches or pipes will be secured to conform to the plans for the proposed improvement and that all of the above will be done without any expense or cost to the South Carolina Department of Highways and Public Transportation except for those items which are shown on the construction plans for this project to be adjusted as items in the construction contract or contracts to be awarded by the South Carolina Department of Highways and PubliC. Transportation. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, That the Municipality will furnish the South' ~ Carolina Department of Highways and Public Transportation with evidence satisfactory to the Department that the utilities are operating within the Municipality of franchise or other written permission with provision that-­ all necessary relocations of such utilities to accommodate street improve­ ments will be made at no cost to the South Carolina Department of Highways and Public Transportation; that the presence of the utilities over, along or under the street will in no way interfere with construction, mainte­ nance, and safe operations of the street; and that no additional utility installations within the limits of the street improvement from the date of the execution of this agreement will be permitted without approval of the South Carolina Department of Highways and Public Transportation, and that the relocation activities will be coordinated so as to minimize interfer­ ence with contractor operations. BE . IT FURTHER RESOLVED, That the Municipality hereby signifies its intention to faithfully observe the provisions of Chapter 5, Title 56, Code of Laws of South Carolina, 1976, and all amendments thereto relating to the regulation of traffic on the street, or streets, to be constructed, recon­ structed, altered or improved as hereinabove identified and further agrees to refrain from placing or maintaining any traffic control devices upon any section of said street, or streets, without having first obtained written approval of the South Carolina Department of Highways and Public Transpor­ tation as required. in Section 56-5-930 of the 1976 Code, nor enacting any traffic regulation ordinances inconsistent therewith. IN WITNESS WHEP~OF; This Resolution is hereby adopted and made a part of the Municipal records this 3~0 day of ()~b~~ , 19~ __ and the original of this Resolution will be filed with theouth Carolina Department of Highways and Public Transportation at Columbia. South· Carolina ATr- /' BY ?"L{/':j, <~/I~~~/ r.z-~ - Page 2 - (\J (Y) rI co co « CITY COUNCIL MINUTES OCTOBER 18, 1988 393 Orangeburg City Council held its regularly scheduled meeting on October 18, 1988, at 6:30 P.M.,(in order to begin with a public hearing) in City Hall Chambers with Mayor Pendarvis presiding. The meeting was opened by a prayer from Councilmember Parrott. PRESENT: E. O. Pendarvis, Mayor Thomas A. Boland, Mayor Pro Tern Henry F. Frierson Bernard Haire L. Zimmerman Keitt Allen W. Parrott W. Everette Salley The first item of business was a public hearing concerning improvements at Boulevard NE from Russell NE to Sifly NE. Mr. Tim Ray of the SC Highway Department presented a brief history of the project area. He stated that the project started some twelve to twenty years ago as improvements on Boulevard and Russell to be included in the Russell Street lighting project which would have eliminated a left turn with a traffic light. As the years went by the discussion went on to include the elimination of one of the cross overs (Peasley Street) and improving the other cross over (Sifly Street). Mr. Ray stated that in 1985 when he became involved with the project the estimated cost was $400,000 to $500,000. This included the removal of one crossing, improvement of the other crossing and installing flashing lights and signals for the railroad crossing. After visiting the area Mr. Ray and other engineers noticed a few things that would improve the traffic flow in the area. He stated that with the two-way traffic there was a lot of conflicting traffic which would lead to a high potential for accidents. He also expressed concern about the old granite curbing gutters, poor drainage and areas of potential flooding. He stated that overall the road just did not look that good. He got approval for an increase in the cost of the project to $1,100,000. He stated that now he could not get approval for this. Mr. John Rickenbacker, 1875 North Braircliff Road, (present county council member) wanted to know if a left turn could be made on Russell at East End Motors. Mr. Ray stated yes. Mr. Oscar P. Butler, 515 Woodlawn Drive, (Vice President of Student Affairs at SC State College) wanted to know what is the problem at Highway 601 and College. Ray said conflicting traffic. Mr. Butler also wanted to know if there would be a light at the new entrance to 601 from Boulevard. Ray said no, but there would be a yeild sign. Butler also wanted to know if they had monitored the flow of traffic. Ray said that a light would not increase the efficiency of traffic flow with a light. Mr. Richenbacker stated that he had asked the following question at previous times (when this area in question had been discussed) and still suggests this: Why not delay all lights six or seven seconds in order to stop everyone before moving any traffic. He said that some of his constituents are concerned that people will by-pass their businesses if the proposed changes are made. Ms. Patricia Rose, lights had never Boulevard. 385 Boulevard NE, been established wanted to know why left turn at both sides of 601 and Mr. Allie Blewer,property owner at Sifly and Boulevard, wanted to know how to eliminate the problem without destroying property values with the changes. He was uncertained about the drainage problem and with the destroying of the neighborhood. He thinks that they should widened Boulevard from Bennett Street to Russell Street. He expressed concern about changes already made that have done nothing to improve the area. He thinks that maybe they should allow only passenger cars. 394 CITY COUNCIL MINUTES OCTOBER 18, 1988 PAGE 2 Ms. Louisa Robinson, 415 Boulevard, department needed all the room that out of a one block dead end street. need for as much radius as projected street. wanted to know why the highway they had staked ~o get in and Mr. Ray said ther~ would be no if it was a one block dead end Mr. George Watson, 175 Boulevard, stated that they are just setting up a death trap at that proposed spur. Ray said they are just trying to separate the flow of traffic. Mr. Watson said that he would rather tolerate trucks and all the traffic as it is now as to what they are proposing here. He wanted to know what is the vision. Mr. J. W. Robinson, 1953 Chestnut, was concerned that they were not considering the two churches in the area. Mr. Ray said that they were trying to accommodate the churches and the highway department is trying to do what is best with something that has been there for a long period of time. He recognizes that there are differences of opinion of what is best. The department is trying to make assessment to the best of thier ability and to show to the citizens. I Mr. E. V. Fenton, 656 Boulevard, expressed concern over what provision had been made for pedestrian traffic. Rat said none unless a specific site was already being used. Mr. Rat pointed out that you could not do everything in one project. " Ms. Marian Anderson (Clafin College) wants a light at I the entrance of Clafin onto 601. She expressed concern about an increase flow of traffic. Ray said that he did not know if traffic engineers had looked at this project but it could be looked at. ' Councilmember Haire wanted to know if the traffic light!flow pattern could be changed. Ray said that he felt that eliminating traffic lights is a better answer but timing can take care of some of the problems. Mr. Erick Payne (property owner on Boulevard for approximately 25 years) does not want to see a one-way street and stated that what is needed is drains. Rev. C. W. Joyner, 3879 Live Oak Drive, (Minister at New Mount Zion Church) wanted to know if the main problem initially 'was the left turn situation and Ray stated yes. Rev. Joyner stated that he agreed with Councilman Rickenbacker with concern over the spur entrance on 601 without a light. He felt that this would be establishing "suicide lane". He felt that they should look at left turn lights and safety. Mr. Oscar P. Butler was wanted them to compare by-pass/ Russell Street concerned about pedestrian crossing and the worst accident at this area to the 21 intersection. Mr. Rickenbacker stated that they should try alternatives before spending this large sum of money. He stated that maybe they should build a ramp for students and citizens to cross 601. He hopes that council will listen to the citizens' input. Mayor Pendarvis pointed out that this project is the highway department's recommendation to council. Ms. Elizabeth Rose, 385 Boulevard NE, was concerned about the radius needed in the Oak street area. Mr. Ray pointed out that they would keep an open mind at this point but felt that they did not need this much radius at this area. C\I (Y) -rl m m « CITY COUNCIL MINUTES OCTOBER 18,11988 PAGE 3 . 395 Mr. Isaac Gillispie , Whittaker Parkway SE, wanted to point out that Russell Street is the main artery to the black community. If you couldn't turn left off of Boulevard onto Russell then what better way is there than they have at the present time. Mr. Ray pointed out that they would have the ramp (spur) and the light or the Sif1y Street cros~ing and then go down and turn. Rev. Joynerl wanted to know what was the distance from the spur to the red light. Ray said 450 feet. Joyner was concerned about cars in the right hand lane trying to get into the left hand lane without enough tim~. Ms. Dorothy Hartzog, Executive Director of the Orangeburg Area Resource Center, was concerned about the thirty-four mentally retarded citizens living off Sifly Street. She had no problems with the traffic flow but was concerned about the safety of those walking to work an4 walking around the area. Mayor Pro Tern Boland presented an alternative drawing to Mr. Ray. It consisted of making Peasley one way onto Boulevard and Sifly one way out of! Boulevard. He suggested making the right of way along the railroad a holding line or turn lane and the vacant lot on Sifly used to create a turn lane in the middle with coordination of a traffic light. Then use the money saved by eliminating the slip ramp to pave Boulevard to Bennett Street. Ray point out that many combinations have been studied. Mr. EugeneiMontgomery, 325 Tradwell 5,500 to 61,000 students plus faculty and Claflin College. Ray said that a done. ' NE, was uncertain about the and staff at SC State College pedestrian study had not been Ms. Pat Rose, 385 Boulevard, (works at Claflin College) was concerned ,about the tractor-trailer trucks speeding on 601. She suggested Ithat they use the three feet of right away owned by the city betw~en Oak and Sifly on the railroad side of Boulevard to straightened the curve. Ray pointed out again that only so much can be done at one time. Rev. Robinson, 1953 Chestnut, suggested that they put up "Don't Walk" andi"Walk" lights. This being the end of the public hearing the Mayor ask if this was still the!highway department's recommendation and Ray replied yes. A motion ~y unanimously distributed. councilmember approved the Haire, seconded by Councilmember Keitt, October 4, 1988, City council Minutes as City Administrator Smith pointed out that it was recently announced by the Awards and Citation Committee of the SC Recreation and Park Society that the City of Orangeburg Parks and Recreation Department had been awarded the Outstanding Recreation Agency Award for 1988 in the population category from 10,000 to 25,000. A motion by Councilmember Harie, seconded by Councilmember Keitt, approved not to approve the recommendation of the highway department to improve Boulevard NE from Russell NE to Sifly NE but recommended that the highway department re-surface Boulevard with existing funds and consiider public comments. Mayor Pendarvis, Councilmember Salley, C,buncilmember Frierson opposed. A motion iby Mayor Pro Tern Boland, seconded by Councilmember Parrott, unanimously approved the third reading of an ordinance to amend Chapter 11 of the City of orangeburg Code of Ordinances regulating minimum ~tandards for housing in the corporate limits. 396 CITY COUNCIL MINUTES OCTOBER 18, 1988 PAGE 4 A motion by Counci1member Salley, seconded by Counci1member Keitt, unanimously approved the third reading of an ordinance to amend Section 5-1 of the Code of Ordinances, City of Orangeburg, South Carolina, adopted October 21, 1969, relating to ad6ption of the standard building code. I A motion by Councilmember Haire, seconded by council~ember Salley, unanimously approved the second reading of an ordinance to rezone Edisto Gardens from A-2 Residential to B-1 Business. A motion by Councilmember Salley, seconded by Icouncilmember Haire,unanimously approved the postponing of the second reading of the Airport Fixed Base Operator's Lease Ordinance. I A motion by Councilmember Salley, seconded by Counci]member Keitt, unanimously approved the second reading of the Airpdrt Mechanic's Lease Ordinance. I A motion by councilmember Frierson, seconded by CounciJrnember Haire, unanimous 1y approved for the additional cost ($ 7 , 0819.84) for the re-roofing the Law Enforcement Complex. I A motion by Councilmember Salley, seconded by counci1member Keitt, unanimously approved the acceptance of the state grant offer of a project application for engineering and design servibes for a new runway at the Orangeburg Municipal Airport. I Counci1member Haire suggested that all Board an~ Commission appointments be by districts. City Administrator Sm~th point out that there would be problems with a couple of th6 Broads and Commissions (i.e. Hillcrest and Accomodation Tax Bpard) due to established guidelines. A motion by Mayor Pendarvisi, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Boland, unanimously approved the recommendation of City Administrator Smith to provide a list of th6 Boards and Commissions so that council could study them. II I City Administrator Smith requested that council I consider an executive session for legal advice. Department of Public utilities Manager, Ted Johnson~ brought a request before council that they re-consider re-issuinglgas/plumbers license, which was revoked five years ago to Mr. ~oe Myers. A motion by Mayor Pendarvis, seconded by Mayor Pro 'I Tern Boland, unanimously approved the re-instatement of Mr. Myers' license. I Mayor Pro Tern Boland presented a motion on the personnel policy and a motion on the Department of Public Safety to be in6luded on the agenda for the November 1, 1988, city council meeting. Ii There being no further /r business, the meeting was adjourAed. Respec~l.l,r §llbmitted, ~ / ";/ / / . / . / /' / ":Pvc-- (E~rol~. Brunson City Clerk ,,'/ ... E. O. PENDARVIS MAYOR THOMAS A. BOLAND, SA. HENRY F. FRIERSON, M. D. BERNARD HAIRE L. ZIMMERMAN KEITT ALLEN W. PARROTT W. EVERETTE SALLEY, D.V.M. MEMBERS OF CqUNCU. • " MIL. fleJUnIJ.n, P. SrtydeJt. sta.t:e fI.i.ghway fng.Ute~ C!lit-g 11£ (l!haltgthUtlr '0It1~ Gtuuli'ul 2$11 1 6·0387 Oetob~ 21, 1988 'Ve.paJt.tment: on H.i.ghway~ eutd PubUc. TlUtItl.poJt.t4.tum P.O. Bol(. 191 Columb.i.a, SC 29202 Rf: Y OWL .te.:tt~ dated AuglU>t 1, 1988 Veal!. MIL. SrtydeJt.: VWL.i.ng U:.6 Octob~ 18, 1988 meet.i.ng :th.e. OJtangebWLg CUy. CoU¥U!oU. by a. ma.joJr.U;y . vote., ir.ej ec;Ced :th.e highway de.paJLtme.nt'.4 PMPOl.ed p.ta.n nOJL S-38-25 (Bou.£.e.vllltd Nfl. Hope.f,u.£..ty a.no:th.~ f,e.a.4,w.te. me..thod CIm be. now to Jt.e.Ue.ve. :th.e. h4za.Itd.& .that ;th.i.& p.ea.n. Wa.l. ~. We would like noJt. :th.e. nUJUU that w~e. obUga:t:ed to .t.:h.U pMject to be. expended on a.n a.U~ve. I.o.i.u:Uon to. :th.e. BoUle.vllltd NE pMj~. 1-6 ;th.i.& .u. nat 1,e.a.J..ib.te., :th.e.n pte.a.4e Jt.e1,eJt. to my te.t{eJt. to you. eutd yoWL Jt.e.pi.g on AugUi.t 1. 1988 wh.i.c.h. a.ddJt.e.uu o:th.~ tlr.a.6M.e ne.edI. .Ut OWL Mea.. S.i.ne~e1y • t.~~ Mayoll. /11. cC: Vea.n Campbe.U. .. .., E. O. PENDARVIS MAVOR THOMAS A. BOlAND, SR. HENRY F. FRIERSON, M. O. BERNARD HAIRE L. ZIMMERMAN KEITT ALLEN W. PARROTT W. EVERETTE SALLEY, D.V.M. MEMBERS OF COUNCIL . .... :~ .' .' • , Oetob~ 20, 1988 MIL. Ve.an CampbeU. V.uw.c..t Eng.we.eIL ~II. . SC 'Ve.palr..tme.¥Lt on H.ighway.4 and. Pu.b.Uc. TlUlJl.&poJlt4tion P.o. Box. 1086 .. OJta.¥tgebWLg, Be 29116-1 a ~6 RE: Rd. S-38-2S--Boute.ualtd NE to RuUeU. SE 'VeaJt. MIL. CampbeU.: I.. HUGH s.wtTH CITY ~TRATCR P. O. OMWEII 387 The. OlU1Yl.gebWLg c.u:y CouneU., duJt.i.ng U:.4. ·meeting 06 OetobeIL ls, 19U by 4 maj oJt.Uy uo.te., J!.ej e.c..ted .the. .impJl.Ouemwt p.tanJ. J.u.bm.Uted by .the /U.gWJ4y Vepalr..tmwt c.onc.eJJ.n.i.ng .the aboue pJI.Oj e.c..t.. ..- 1.t WGt4 JLequeJ..ted by Cou.neU. .th.a.t .the. .4uggeJ..tion.4 plte4wted duJt.ing .the PI.I.bU.c. H eaM.ng be. c.on.4.i.deILed and. .th.a.t 4PpJl.Op!t.i.a.te. ac.t.ior)..6 be. .taken 'by yoWL depaJltme.nt. . . Mo.o.t 01. .the4e. c.onunen.t& peJt.tahr.ed to uaJt.iou.4 W~.4 .th.a.t:.the J..ig~Ugh.t.4 c.ouU be. ad] u.4.ted oJ!. mocU.Med to hdp .aUe.u-Ut.te. .th.U pJI.Obtem.··. . Conc.eJt.n.4 WelLe. a.U.o 1!X.pJJ.e.ued about p~ "a&e.ty·and. c/JuW&agi. . . . . ..... . Thank you tiol!. yoWL c.on.4.i.deJt.a.t.i.on .w .th.U ma.tt~ /J.ayoJ!. /I!. \ CC: HeJt.ma.n SyndeIL ~-f-..:?' S:t.a-te H.i.ghway Eng.w<?eIL '. ' . .... (\j (Y) -rl m m c:::( CITY COUNCIL MINUTES NOVEMBER 1, 1988 397 OrangeburgiCity Council held its November 1, 1988, at 7:00 P.M., Pendarvis presiding. regularly scheduled meeting on in City Hall Chambers with Mayor PRESENT: E. O. Pendarvis, Mayor Thomas A. Boland, Sr., Mayor Pro Tern Henry F. Frierson Bernard Haire L. Zimmerman Keitt Allen W. Parrott W. Everette Salley A motion by Councilmember unanimously approved the distributed. Parrott, seconded by Councilmember Keitt, October 18, 1988, City Council Minutes as Mr. Jim Headley, Executive Director of the South Carolina Recreation and Parks 'Association made a presentation to Hillcrest Golf Course and Mr. Tom Vargo for hosting the 1988 Southern District Golf Tournament for the South Carolina Recreation and Parks Association. Mr. Headley also made a presentation to Mayor Pendarvis for the city winning the outstanding Agency Of The Year Award for city population size of 10i,000 to 25,000 for the Edisto Gardens and various programs sponsored by the City of Orangeburg's Parks and Recreation Departmen~. A motion by Councilmember Salley, seconded Frierson, unanimously approved the third reading rezone Edisto Gardens from A-2 Residential to B-1 by Councilmember of an ordinance to Business. A motion, was made Councilmember Keitt Fixed Bas~ operator's by Councilmember Frierson and seconded by to approve the second reading of the Airport Lease Ordinance. Mr. Clyd~ Dean, Attorney,interrupted stating that on September 6, 1988, he came before council representing certain owners of airplanes' at the Orangeburg Municipal Airport and submitted a petition 'at that time objecting to the renewal of the contract to Ms. Pat Rhudy. He also stated on September 15, 1988, he wrote a letter to the City Attorney requesting that this matter go into executive session. He was here to present evidence of possible criminal misconduct at the airport and requesting an executive session. A motion by Councilmember Frierson, seconded by Mayor Pendarvis, unanimously approved to enter into an executive session. This was approved but interrupted by the chairman of the Airport Committee, Mr. W. W. Dukes, who requested that the Airport Commission be present at the executive session because they investigated the situationithoroughly and made the recommendation to council. councilmember Frierson withdrew his motion for an executive session and for the motion to approve the lease agreement for the Fixed Base Operator's Lease Ordinance. councilmember Frierson, seconded by Mayor Pendarvis, unanimously approved ~he postponing of the Fixed Base Operator's Lease Ordinance to the next council meeting. A motion by Councilmember Salley, seconded by Mayor Pendarvis, unanimously approved the third reading of the Airport Mechanic's Lease Ordinance. 398 CITY COUNCIL MINUTES NOVEMBER 1, 1988 PAGE 2 Mr. W. W. Dukes interrupted stating that the Airport Commission recommended that the lease be negotiated with Mr. Barbieri in connection with the other lease (FBO). The two leases were part of one recommendation and thinks that council should delay executing this lease until they decide what they are going to do with the main lease (FBO). If council decides to do something else on the main lease, this arrangement might not be in the best interest of the city. Mayor Pendarvis called for a vote on Councilmembers Frierson, Parrott, Haire, Mayor Pendarvis opposed thus postponing Mechanic's Lease Ordinance. the motion on the floor. Mayor Pro Tem Boland and the third reading of the Concerning the appointment of board and commission members, Mayor Pendarvis made a motion that when a vacancy arises that each member of council should be asked for a nominee and then the entire council vote on it. Councilmember Salley seconded. councilmember Haire does not want to make appointments at large but by the individual districts. councilmember Frierson be appointed to the district where they entire council. feels that the most qualified people should boards and commissions irregardless of the live. This person should be appointed by the Mayor Pendarvis pointed out that these members serve without compensation and a lot of times "take a lot of heat" for taking positions. He also stated that it is not always easy to get people to serve on these boards. Councilmember Haire stated that they would be appointing the most qualified persons from their individual districts and would not appoint anyone who is not qualified. City Administrator Smith presented a report to council. concerning the number of board and commission members. (See Attachment) Mayor Pendarvis called Councilmembers Kiett, opposed. for a vote concerning Parrott, Haire and these appoihtments and Mayor Pro. Tem Boland A motion by Mayor Pro Tem Boland, seconded by councilmember Parrott, directed Attorney Walsh to investigate what the boards and commissions can be set at and see if they can be expanded to where these would be seven members and then allow the new members to be appointed at a random basis so that each councilmember would have an opportunity to put someone on the boards/commissions in the very near future. This would allow each councilmember to appoint someone(does not have to be from own district but from the city at large). Councilmembers Frierson, Salley and Mayor Pendarvis opposed this motion. Mayor Public Haire. Pro Tem Boland read his motion concerning the Department of Safety (See Attachment). This was seconded by Councilmember councilmember Frierson made a statement that he was conyinced that the public safety concept would work at its inception and he is still convinced it will work. He was concerned about the expense that reverting back to the old system would cause the, present FY 1988-89 budget which has been adopted and the milage rate established. He is convinced that the city is heading in the right direction and thinks the public safety concept should be continued. (\j (Y) -rl CD CD <:t CITY COUNCIL MINUTES NOVEMBER 1, 1988 PAGE 3 Counci1member Parrott stated that he hoped we would not rush out of the public safety concept as we rushed in. He wants council to scrutinize the concept more and look at the postive aspects. After studying the situation, if council feels that it is not for the city then he has no problems with abandoning it. Mayor Pro Tern Boland stated that twelve (12) additional people are needed anyway and that the $2,000 (increase by those officers who cross-trained) would not be taken away from anyone. He stated that cross training was needed anyway for large emergencies. Mayor Pendarvis stated that he voted for the public safety concept because he was convinced it was worth a try. Other cities have operated this program successfully. It is also a way to give better service and get the budget down. He stated that he knew mistakes were made by council and those directly in charge. He agreed that it would be as bad to rush out of it as we rushed in. Mayor Pendarvis called for a vote from council on the motion on the floor. councilmembers Frierson, and Salley opposed, thus approving the initiation of a study to investigate the public safety concept. Mayor Pro Tern Boland, Councilmember Frierson and Mayor Pendarvis were appointed by council to serve on the committee to research the public safety concept. 399 Councilmember Frierson expressed concern about being confined to Mayor Pro Tern Boland's recommendations. A motion by Mayor Pendarvis, seconded by Councilmember Frierson, agreed not to be confined to Mayor Pro Tern Boland's recommendations. Mayor Pro Tern Boland opposed. Councilmember Salley was concerned about appointing a fireman at this time without the completed study. Councilmember Keitt agreed that we should wait on the committee's recommendation. Mayor Pro Tern Boland withdrew the section of his motion concerning the immediate appointment of a fireman to command the fire division. A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tern Boland and seconded by Councilmember Haire, to amend the section of the personnel policy concerning the grievance committee. Councilmember Frierson requested that this matter be postponed due to the influx of information received on this matter. (Two letters from Mayor Pro Tern Boland and one from City Attorney Walsh) council agreed. A motion by councilmember Frierson, seconded by Councilmember Parrott, unanimously approved the project agreement for PRT Grants for renovation to Adden Street Tennis Court and Albergotti Tennis Court in the amount of $10,000 and authorized Marion J. smith, Parks and Recreation Director, to sign the agreement. The city's share was approved in the FY 1988-89 budget. DPU Manager, Ted Johnson, stated that the water plant expansion would probably not affect the recreation facilities until around 2010. Director Smith stated that present tennis courts at Albergotti were constructed with BOR monies (Bureau of Outdoor Recreation) and would have to be investigated when the time for expansion arose. The monies presently under consideration carry a five year obligation (10-25-93) due to the small amount of money. A motion by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Boland, unanimously approved the elimination of parking spaces at the St. Paul's Methodist Church drive way and Amelia NE. The elimination of parking spaces on Amelia NE and Middleton NE as well as Russell NE/SE and Broughton NE/NW were postponed until the businesses that would be affected are notified. 40~TY COUNCIL MINUTES NOVEMBER 1, 1988 PAGE 4 Mayor Pendarvis requested citizen's suggestions in writing (must be signed) to be submitted to council concerning the railroad corner (Boulevard and Russell). Mayor Pendarvis stated that he had written to Dean Campbell and Herman Synder (State Highway Engineer) asking them to consider the alternative suggestions presented at the 10-18-88 public hearing. (Letters Attached) As of today, Mayor Pendarvis states that he has received no response. A motion by councilmember Parrott, seconded by councilmember Keitt, agreed to proceed with the receiving of suggestions. DPU Manager, Ted Johnson, presented council with the charge off history (1978-1988). He stated that customer deposits have risen and would like to conduct a study annually of those individuals who, for twenty-four consecutive months, have had a good payment record and refund their deposit. Councilmember Frierson stated that he would like them to continue the study but to see how much of the deposits are forfeited when people leave town (owing a utility bill). If it is an excessive amount then it may be necessary to maintain the deposit system. If it's not a significant amount and not expected to rise then he felt that the deposits should be refunded to those qualifying customers. Councilmember Haire asked Mr. Johnson if a customer received interest on his deposit when refunded. Mr. Johnson's reply was no. Mayor Pendarvis wants people to pass the word and get citizens to write him immediately concerning the railroad corner situation. Mayor Pro Tern Boland reminded the public that November 11, 1988, is Veteran's Day. There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned. submitted, /r E. O. PENDARVIS L HUGH SMITH CJTY ADMINISTRATOR P. O. DRAWER 387 MAYOR THOMAS A. BOLAND. SR. HENRY F. FRIERSON. M. D. BERNARD HAIRE L. ZIMMERMAN KEITI ALLEN W. PARROTI QJ:itll of ®rung.ehurg W. EVERETIE SALLEY. D.V.M. '- MEMBERS OF COUNCIL TO: FROM: SUBJECT: VATE: "cutq QJ:arclina. 29116-0387 OJLMgebWLg Cay Counc..U. L. Hugh SmUh, CLty ~Jr. Method on appo..in.ti.ng Boa.JUl6 and Coinm.i.l..6.i.on.& OetobeJr. 20, 1988 OWL BoaJr.d.6 and Comm.u.wn.& weJr.e eUabU.6hed by .6eveJW.i cUUVLertt; me.thodl.. Tho.6e u;tabU.6hed by. olUUYumc.e 0Jr. by Jiuo.tu:Uon c.an be changed by c.ounc..U. by amencUng .the olUUYumc.e oJr. ;the Jl.uo.f.Ll;t.i.on. . The noUow.i.ng .u. a Ul.Ung· on ;thue Boa.JUl6 and C07II11l.i.&.6.ion.& wah .the numbeJr. on appo.i.n;teu .6hown: , Uec:Uon Comm.u.wn BoMd of, Adjw,;tmen;to (zoning) Avia:ti.on Comm.u..6.i.on P.ea.nn.i.ng C omrn-U..6.i.on IndU.6;tJUa,t Vevelopmen;t Comm. 3 5 6 5 7 + e.x.-of,Mcio (1) . The H.u.tcJtu;t Comm.u.6.i.on Wa.6 .in.6;t:.i..tu.ted by a .t.ea.&e agJr.eemen;t wLth SC sta;te College. The .t.ea.&e agJr.eemen;t .6;i;a;tu .tha;t .the Comm.u.wn mw,;t be c.ompo.6ed On a;t .t.ea.&;t M.x. membeM wLth 2/3 behtg appo.i.n;ted· by .the eU:y and 1/3 behtg appo.i.n;ted by .the c.ollege. We now have a n.i.ne membeJr. c.ollll!\.U.6.ion wLth .6.i.x. appo-i.n;ted by .the eU:y and fuee by ;the c.ollege. The. BoMd on Appeal.6 (bull.cU.ng c.ode) -i..6 adop;ted a.6 a paJr.;(; on .the S;tandaJu:l BuU.cUng Code wh-i.c.h de;taU.o .;the numbeJr. on membw, clu:t.iu and e;i;c.. Th.i.& BoMd c.on.&-i..6.to .on 6-i.ve membeM. The Law Enn OJl.c.emen;t Cen;teJr. Comm.u.wn (LEC) Wa.6 J..nU;.i.a;ted by agJr.eement wLth OJLMgebWLg and Ca.t.ltoun c.ountiu. We· Me a.Ucwed ;two membeM on .th.u c.omm.u..6-i.o n. The Ac.c.omoda;t-i.on.& Tax. BoMd -i..6 u;tabU.6hed by ·.6.ta..te .taw.' 1;t -i..6 a .6even membeJr. boMd. A majolLUy on .th.u .6even mU.6;i; Jr.epJr.uen;t .the Ho.6p.i.:ta.U;ty Irtdu.6;t;Jty. /Jr. c.- I: ~,'; - . ,'" E. O. PENDARVIS MAYOR THOMAS A. BOLAND, SR. HENRY F. FRIERSON, M. D. ~. BERNARD HAIRE I L. ZIMMERMAN KEITT ALLEN W. PARROTT W. EVERETTE SALLEY, D.V.M. (llit~ of ®nmg.ehurg MEMBERS OF COUNCil DATE: TO: FROM: November 1, 1988 City Council ,:l$\nutq ([lIrnlinli 29116-0387 Thomas A. Boland, Sr. L. HUGH SMITH CITY ADMINISTRATOR p, O. DRAWER 387 In order to approach the Department of Public Safety (DPS) problem in a manner that will give all parties a chance to voice their views and in a hope to reconcile their differences and to provide the City of Orangeburg with the Fire and Police protection it deserves, I'move we immediately appoint a committee of three city councilman to study the DPS plan now in existence versus the concept of a separate police and fire department versus some possible combination of these two to determine which is best for Orangeburg. I further move that the most qualified Fireman be placed in charge of the Fire division of DPS immediately. I further move that the DPS director with assistance of the head of the Fire Division and the Police Division prepare two sets of detailed budgets - one for the DPS as was originally proposed, and one that would have these two departments operating separately. This budget would be guided to the salaries being paid prior to the merge. If they determine that a third method might be feasible then they can develop a budget for this method. I further move that they develop a time scedule that would reflect how these two plans would be implemented depending on which one City Council adopts. They should also include what kind of, how, and when training would be conducted, and also a work schedule showing what hours their officers would work. These two plans should show how many officers will be available to work on each shift and what contingencies they will provide in the event of extreme emergencies. In the plan that deals with the separation of these departments, they are to incorporate the continued minimum cross-training of their personnel so that each department could assist the other in emergencies. They should also reflect the use of the firemen in providing foot partrols in the business districts and the enforcement of parking regulations. The City Administrator is to provide any assistance these men need to carry out this project. Particular emphasis should be given to the number of personnel needed under the two plans, especially those needed over the next three-five years, and the approximate cost over the next three-five yers. Emphasis should also be given as to how each plan would respond in the event of a major fire or fires occurring at the same time as a major robbery, murder, hostage, etc. situation occurred. I further request that the City Administrator assist the committee in preparing a short history of the DPS concept and how this concept has been used in other communities (especially those similar to Orangeburg). If other communities have adopted this program and then abandoned it, the committee should try to determine why they did so. In communities that have a similar successful program, they should find out what problems they had and how they were overcome. Particular emphasis should be placed on how these other communities funded their programs. If possible, copies of these other cities' budget should be obtained as they can be of assistance to the director of DPS in carrying out his assigned mission. I further move that the director of DPS provide the committee a status report of their progress within thirty days and a completed report and budgets within sixty days. The committee will review these reports, ensure thie accuracy and completeness, and then present their findings (with recommendation if appropriate) to the City Council within seventy-five days. E. O. PENDARVIS MAYOR THOMAS A. BOLAND. SR. HENRY F. FRIERSON, M. D. BERNARD HAIRE L. ZIMMERMAN KEITT ALLEN W. PARROTT W. EVERETTE SALLEY, D.V.M. MEMBERS OF COUNCIL DATE: TO: FROM: @it~ of (llhanB.ehurB November 1, 1988 City Council ~outq (1larolinll 29116-0387 Thomas A. Boland, Sr. L. HUGH SMITH CITY ADMINISTRATOR P. D, DRAWER 387 I move to amend the Grievance Procedure of the Personnel Policy of the City of Orangeburg as revised September 6, 1988, as follows: ~~. 1. Page 13, The Employee Grievance Committee The section captioned "The Employee Grievance Committee" shall now read as follows: "City Council shall appoint a grievance committee composed of nine (9) employees to serve for a term of three (3) years, except that the members appointed initially shall be appointed so that their terms will be staggered, and approximately one-third (1/3) of the terms shall expire each year. A member shall continue to serve after the expiration of his term until a successor is appointed. Any interim appointment to fill a vacancy for any cause prior to the completion of a member's term shall be for the unexpired term." Initial Term 3 years 3 years 2 years 1 year 3 years 2 years 2 years 1 year 1 year Police Parks & Recreation/Hillcrest Public Works Fire Electric Wastewater/Gas/Garage Water Service/Admin/Executive DPU Administration Only one member from one of these departments can be on the Grievance Committee at any time. Any member may be reappointed for succeeding terms at the discretion of 'the City Council. Members employed in the same Department or Division as the grieving employee and members having formed an opinion on the issues prior to the hearing, shall not participate in that employee's hearings. 2. Page 14, Line 3: This sentence shall be changed to read: "A quorum shall consist of seven (7) members, and no hearings may be held without a quorum .. " (\J (Y) -rl m m 0:::::( CITY COUNCIL MINUTES NOVEMBER 15, 1988 401 Orangeburg City Council held its November 15, 1988, at 7:00 P.M., Pendarvis presiding. regularly scheduled meeting on in City Hall Chambers with Mayor PRESENT: E. O. Pendarvis, Mayor Thomas A. Boland, Sr., Mayor Pro Tern Henry F. Frierson Bernard Haire Allen W. Parrott W. Everette Salley ABSENT: L. Zimmerman Keitt A motion by Councilmember Parrott, unanimously approved Minutes as distributed. Frierson, seconded the November 1, by Councilmember 1988, City Council An appearance was made by Mr. Jesse Eargle, Orangeburg County Extension Director, who presented a motion to council considering "cleansweep Orangeburg County". A motion by Mayor Pendarvis, seconded by Councilmember Salley, Unanimously approved this resolution for "Cleansweep Orangeburg County". This event will be held at the Orangeburg County Fairgrounds on December 3, 1988, from 9:00 A.M. to 3:00 P.M. A motion by Councilmember Frierson, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Boland, postponed the second reading of the Airport Fixed Base Operator's Lease Ordinance and the third reading of the Airport Mechanic's Lease Ordinance. Mr. Tom Bryant, attorney for Pat Rhudy, was disturbed that council refuses to take action on this matter--months since these considerations have been before council. These matters have been put off time and time again. He felt that everyone had had time to appear before the Aviation Commission and be represented by counsel to air their grievances about the lease renewal. Mr. Bryant stated that from his understanding, this is not a matter that can be held in executive session and Mrs. Rhudy does not want this held in executive session. He expressed concern that her name has been "dragged around the bottom of the floor". He stated that he felt that everyone has had the opportunity and that she (Rhudy) and John (Barbieri) are entitled to have council move forward and act on this. Mayor Pendarvis stated that Clyde parties against the lease renewal, he (Mayor) agreed that this matter Dean, attorney for the concerned was ill and in the hospital, but needs to be moved on. Mr. Bryant wanted to know how many chances these people are going to have to attack these people. Is it every time they want to be heard? Mr. Bryant felt council is ignoring the recommendations of the Aviation Commission. A motion by Mayor Pro Tern Boland, unanimously agreed to postpone the Policy/Grievance Procedure. seconded by Mayor Pendarvis, amendment to the Personnel councilmember Haire stated that he had contacted the businesses in the concerned areas and had received opposition from two businessmen concerning the Amelia NE and Middleton NE area and from one businessman concerning the Russell NE/SE and Broughton NE/NW area. The two opposed to the Amelia/Middleton area were concerned about the decrease in spaces available for customer parking. Councilmember Salley wanted to know if Councilmember Haire had considered the driving public. Councilmember Haire said yes. councilmember Haire made a motion to not eliminate the proposed parking spaces, seconded by Coucilmember Parrott. This was unanimously approved by council. 402 CITY COUNCIL MINUTES NOVEMBER 15, 1988 PAGE 2 City Administrator Smith and DPU Manager, Ted Johnson, presented a recommendation to council that the city change hospital insurance from Aetna to SCLGAG (South Carolina Local Government Assurance Group). One of the main reasons cited was that Aetna was going to increase insurance rates by 19%-25%. SCLGAG could provide similar insurance for the same rate as at present. One of the main reasons is because SCLGAG's administration costs are lower. Mr. Mike Sells, Director of Administrative Division at DPU, was on hand to answer questions about the differences between Aetna and SCLGAG. After some discussion from new councilmembers, City Administrator Smith read a resolution to proceed with SCLGAG. A motion by Councilmember Frierson, seconded by Mayor Pendarvis, unanimously approved this resolution with Smith and Johnson having the authority to sign the necessary documents. (copy of insurance discussion attached) Mr. Tom Ford, Executive Director Commission, presented a map with for further clarification of the Councilmember Salley, seconded by approved the sale of the land approval. (NOTE: this motion was land sale not the actual sale.) A motion by Counci1member unanimously approved the certificate. Haire, employee of the Orangeburg Area Development the proposed site of Mosler, Inc., area in question. A motion by Mayor Pro Tern Boland, unanimously in question contingent on FAA made to accept the concept of the seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Boland, Christmas dinner and $25.00 gift Council considered a request from the Prince of Orange Mall for police security. Councilmember Haire asked Public Safety Director Brant about the present security provided. Brant said that the city patrol, answer calls and occasionally walks through. Anytime traffic is heavy they put officers down there. Especially during the holiday season they have to "beef-up" patrol downtown and at the mall. It was the consensus of council to provide security to the Prince of Orange Mall as per the direction of Public Safety Director Brant in accordance with available manpower. Attorney Walsh wanted council to understand that downtown is public and the mall is private property. The city can patrol private parking lots if jurisdiction is given to the city. Mayor Pendarvis stated that we would police to the best of our ability. Mayor Pendarvis asked if any other councilmembers had response to the request for citizen input on Street/Boulevard situation. Mayor Pro Tern Boland had call and Mayor Pendarvis had received three letters. received any the Russell received one DPU Manager, Ted Johnson, brought no utility matters before council. There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned. /r ubmitted, t~i6! -K. Brunson CIty Clerk RESOLUTION TO AUTHORIZE THE MUNICIPALITY OF ORANGEBURG ;to bec.ome a membeA 06 ;the Sou.;th CaJLolina Loc.at GoveAnmen;t A.6.6wr.anc.e G!1.OUp. WHEREAS, ;the CouncU. 06 ;the MuvUupa..U.:ty 06 OMngebwr.g MncLs ;tha.:t );t .u., -i-n ;the b eM -i-n;teAUU 06 ;the muvUupa..U.:ty ;to j o-i-n w);th o;theA muvUup~u, PWL6uan;t ;to A;r;t,[c.R..e VIII, Semon 13 06 ;the COYL6;i;Uu;t-Lon on ;the S;ta.;i;e 06 Sou;(;h CaJLoUna, ;to j o-i-n;tty pJi.ov.we 60ft ;the .6 Ut --i-YL6UMnc.e and fte.ta.:ted b ene6w 60ft ;the muvUup~u and ;thUft emptoyeu; and WffEREAS, ;the Sou.;th CaJLoUna Loc.at GoveAnmen;t A.6.6UMnc.e Gftoup ha.6 been 60Jtmed M ;the mea.YL6 60ft muvUup~u and o;theA toc.at goveAnmen;i;6 ;to pftov-i-de tOft ;the jo-i-n;t adm-i-vU.6~on 06 an -i-YL6UMnc.e and .6u6--i-YL6wr.anc.e pftogJtam and ;the .6ha.Jt-Lng 06 ;the C.O.6u. ;theAe06. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVEV BY ;the OMngebwr.g C);ty CouncU. -i-n c.ouncU. duty M.6 embted: Semon 1. The MuvUupaU;(;y 06 OMngebwr.g heAeby agfteu ;to bec.ome a membeA 06 ;the Sou;(;h CaJLot-Lna Loc.at GoveAnmen;t A.6.6UMnc.e Gftoup, ac.c.oftd-Lng ;to ;the ;tQAm.6 on ;the agfteemen;t :u;tabwh-Lng ;the gftoup, da.:te MaJLc.h 19, 1981, and agfteu ;to ab.we by ;the ;teJtm.6 06 ;tha.:t agfteemen;t, adopting ;the .6ame by fte6 eAenc.e M 6 uUy M -i-6 .6 e:t ou;(; -i-n 6 ill heAun. Semon z. We nwr.:theA ac.k.nowtedge ;tha.;i; ;the Med-Lc.al Bene6);t Plan, .u., a .6u6 -i-YL6UMnc.ed plan and ;tha.:t upon ;teJtm-i-nation 06 paJLtiupation -i-n ;the SCLGAG oft -i-n ;tfU.6 plan, ;tha.:t ;the SC LGAG w-LU no;t be Uabte 6 Oft any ~ atJ;i;eA ;the e66emve da.:te 06 .6uc.h ;teJtm-i-na;t-Lon and ;tha.:t ;the C);ty 06 Oftangebwr.g bec.omu .6ote.ty ftupoYL6-Lbte ;to W emptoyee.o pa.-Ld pft-LOft ;to ;the ennemve da.:te 015 .6uc.h ;teJtm~on and 60ft .6uc.h aggftega.:te to.6.6U on w ac.c.oun;t ;then ou;(;6;tand-Lng 6!1.Om c.UJr.Jten;t and pftev-i-oU.6 yeaJL.6. Semon 3. TfU.6 Ruotu;t-Lon .6hatt bec.ome e66emve. upon appftoval by CouncU., M a.;i;;tu;ted buow and );t .u., agfteed ;tha.:t membeJ1J.>h-Lp. -i-n ;the Sou.;th CaJLoUna Loc.al GoveAnmen;t GftOUP .6hatt be e66emve upon ftec.up;t by ;the BOaJLd 06 TftU.6;teu 06 ;the gftOUp 06 a c.opy 06 ;tfU.6 RUotu;t-Lon, and upon c.ompUanc.e by ;the muvUupa..U.:ty w);th ;the ;tQAm.6 and c.ond-LtioYL6 06 membeJ1J.>h-Lp .6e:t 60Jt;(;h -i-n ;the above-fte6eAenc.ed agfteemen;t. Appftoved;tfU.6 15;th day on NovembeA, 1988. AT77.«;l~ ( ~/~ CY-TY CLERK - d' ~/ I ~ , ,... ~ tJ, . A?~L~L./?~~ ~~ .. \=:;;:;:<t) '" ~~-- .. , ...... ~-\ ~~\, \ h -,'. "";\ \ .. }'-../ \ .. : ~\;" \,,\~" .4~ ': ,...//' ) ~ /h~.....,.,.,/"j .7\.%'&/ U "---,, r /~/'. ~" /- .' IV:: ~.~;/ .. . . -----.. \ / ;/L~if~~~~' ~~~/~~---<-- ?i~.,~Q~L - Most of the report submitted to council was researched by Mike Sells, Director of Administrative Division, DPU. Concerning the administrative costs, Aetna charges a percentage based on the premium, SCLGAG charges so much per employee per month. Boland: 2nd page, item 3--more risk assigned to the city. What do you mean by that? Sells: The only risk assigned would be if we switched carriers. As we leave Aetna, we leave with no risk at all. Because we paid them an extra heavy premium, they have built up a very heavy reserve. If we leave and they owe us money then we don't get it back, if we owe them money then we don't have to pa¥ it. However, if we change to LGAG, then we are totally 100% self-~nsured. Which means if we decide to leave at any time them we pay for all claims incurred. Boland: At this time do we know if we have a positive balance or a negative balance with Aetna. Sells: Right now, it's almost even. We have a big reserve which they will retain. Boland: What does that mean? Sells: In excess of $180,000. smith: They use this to payoff claims and anything left over, we'll get it back. Sells: They are responsible for all claims up to the day we change. It usually takes about three months for run-off claims. It'll take most of this money. They only time you're looking at risk is if you do insurance-hopping. Boland: On next page, the next to the last paragraph--LGAG has pre­ existing condition restrictions, Aetna does not. What does that mean? Sells: That is actually a plus for the city. Boland: That's if someone has something wrong with then at the time they come into the policy, then it's not covered? Sells: That's correct. smith: Unless they switch over from Aetna. If you are with Aetna right now with the City and are picked up by LGAG, then you're covered. If you are a brand new employee who's not been with us before then and you have something wrong with you then that's a pre­ existing condition. Boland: Has LGAG been shown to Aetna for them to give a comparison? smith: Aetna was not shown this particular packet. Aetna sent letter starting off raising our rates 25%. They then sent letter dated November 2, stating that they had looked at the claims and they were not as bad as they thought and they were not going to make any adjustments at this moment. But on February 1, 1989, they would make adjustments. Sells: Aetna was given the rates and they cannot match it. Johnson: would be beginning With Aetna we are re-insured at $50,000, and with LGAG it $30,000 (per employee). A level is established at the of the year. The City would have to pay the first $50,000 v or $30,000 and Aetna would pay the overage. For this we pay insurance­ -we have a ~olicy. If we leave Aetna, then we will not have to pay them any add1tional money because a reserve has been established. With LGAG we do not have to put money in a reserve, nor do we have the benefit of the reserve. In the event we changed from LGAG then we would have to pay the additional claims. It's pretty much a washout. Sells: We do have a reserve, but it's much smaller. smith: $150,000. Which based on calculations, we reach this point the first year and then we won't have to worry about that any more. Frierson: What was the recommendation about the prescription part? smith: getting for the We left that in the policy. Take a prescription filled and either pay $6 generic. card to pharmacy when for a name drug or $3 Boland: Page 14--random sample comparison. 1st 2, why would employee's cost be so much greater in #2 than #1 when benefit would be $60 less. Looks like the employee would be paying more overall with LGAG than with Aetna. Sells: Not exactly. We selected 50 claims. If you look down the column what the employee pays is very similar. Johnson: At certain levels Aetna would be cheaper. You cannot really get two policies. We did not have the option of going out and tailor making policies. We selected two policies that were very similar to Aetna. One may pay more for a procedure and another may pay for another type of procedure. Sells: Normally at the lower level, LGAG will pay better. LGAG has a $100 deductible and Aetna's $250. To counter act this, Aetna has a basic benefit that pays certain dollar amounts for certain claims before deductible. The City paid $800,000 in claims last year and feels that the amount will be the same next year with LGAG with the benefits being to the employees. One employee may benefit more on a. claim an other less, but the affect on the City would be the same. Boland: Is LGAG financially sound? Sells: company. that we would be Can't compare a company as large as Aetna to a much smaller Remember that we are self-insured and we guarantee employees are going to pay the claims. The only thing we could lose administrative costs which are lower to begin with. Boland: Would retired employees be hurt in any way? Johnson: No, I do not think so. They will be covered as all employees. Phillips: Nominal surcharge to carry the retirees. Haire: Is there going to be an increase in costs to employees? Johnson: No, nor to the City. Sells: If we stay with Aetna then least a 19% increase (Johnson: actually a benefit financially. we feel sure that there will be at from somewhere). switching is Haire: Has this particular plan been shared with employees? Sells: No. Johnson: It's a council-management decision. This can be reviewed for years to come. Boland: Have other cities been satisfied? Sells: it. Talked to Rock Hill (the largest) and they highly recommend Boland: If the City left LGAG a year or two later would the City be required for any debts incurred over the life of the policy? smith: If they were not paid during that period. Boland: Is this fair and will give adequate protection to the employees as compared to Aetna? Smith: Yes. It's ~retty much a washout except for the drug card which feels is a beneflt. Sells: Tested on thirty employees (only DPU) and they were for the change. Johnson: We would not have recommended this is there was a problem with the employees. Walsh: If wanted to get cover a certain large claim incur that risk? out of this and the new coverer would not (in excess of $30,000) then the City would Phillips: Technically that's true. contract--that's not unusual. That is a standard excess risk Boland: policy? will LGAG accept any risk for any claims under the Aetna Phillips: No. Collece of ACricultural Sc:ences Cooperative Extension Service ORANGE3URG COUNTY P. O. Drawer 1206 Orangeburg, SC 29116 November 9,1988 RESOLUTION Whereas the philosophy of the Orangeburg County Extension Office is to assist the citizens of Orangeburg in identifying educational needs and to provide practical information and educational programs to meet those needs, and Whereas the Orangeburg County Extension Office has identified a critical need for educational programs relative to storing and disposing of agricultural and household hazardous and other wastes, now therefore Be it Resolved, that the Orangeburg City Council extend its heartfelt support of ·Cleansweep Orangeburg County·, the first agricultural/household hazardous waste collection day and educational program to be implemented in the State of South Carolina. Be it Resolved, that the Orangeburg City Council directs that December 3, 1988 be designated as Cleansweep Orangeburg Day and the Orangeburg City Council directs that this resolution be known publicly to the citizens of Orangeburg. ~GST CFFICE ::;::l;. ..... E::l ~:c~ • C;::l,.l..NGE3U::lG, seu;,.. O,"C\..lNA :~'. \6 • .... 'Et_:.? ... C~.E ~C'!:~:'~-':':!l~ r"E C:..5'''50'' :":~jl'JE~Sl1"Y C:OP€::lA ';':'JE ;:x':"E~.S:C~j SE~VICE CFFE;;:S ITS ;:>s:lCG<=l;.·.lS ,0 "E~P~S CF ALL :.Gi:S ::lEG.;.:::CLS;;;S OF :::':'0:;. ::LC;:I, SEx ;;:E~.G;CN 'jATIC'lAL QI=iIG;N c __ "ANOIO? AND ,5 AN ECU;"L. Cppcl=lTUNITY E'.IP!"CYE;;: CLE'..-1SCN uNI'JE::Islry -:::OP':."IA T·'~'G 'I'll, ... U S CE"'A><;~E'jT OF AG?ICt.a. ::':PE. SOUTH C;';:!CUNA COUNTIES EXT:;~jSICN SERVIC!:. 9 K 'NEaB ;::1::::::,:-::;1=1 C:..E·.'SC~. s:: ISSUED 'N P..lRTHE::l;'NCE CF COCPSl:lATI'JE SXTE~ISIO~j ,'10;;11( IN AG"ICUlrUI=lE AND !-lOME SCCNCMICS. ;'CT5 OF ',..1AV a AND ":UNE:::: "So'': C\.l ('f) >l CO CO <:( fM hea.cUn.g .bee Pa.ge 6 CITY COUNCIL MINUTES DECEMBER 6, 1988 403 A public hearing was held on rezoning A-l Residential to Office-Institutional Apartments --W. w. Sutcliffe. Also, rezoning A-l Residential to A-2 Residential--Henry A. Goodwin. City Administrator Smith read a description of both properties in question and the types of structures that could be located on them. No one spoke in favor of rezoning of W. W. Sutcliffe's property. Ms. Kitty Sligh, 2225 Broughton NW, spoke in opposition of this change. She wants it to remain A-l. She was concerned about the type structures that could be established--apartment complexes, day care facilities, etc. Said that they requested to come into the City because of the benefits that they would receive. She stated that they are numerous and he (Sutcliffe) is one. Mr. Earl Carven, 132 South Circle, stated that in 1972 this same property came into question as pertaining to trailer parks. That is when they decided to come into the City. They came into the City because they wanted the protection of the zoning laws, etc. They've had that protection and they appreciate it. The boundary between residential and commercial is Broughton Street and wants to remain as is. Mr. James Dempsey, 166 South Circle, wants this to remain as is. Thinks it's a wonderful neighborhood and wants it to remain. Mr. Henry A. Goodwin spoke in favor of rezoning his property stating it's a two-story apartment and he wants to put an apartment downstairs. There are other apartments in the area and no one that he's talked to has any problems. No one spoke against this change. A motion by made by Councilmember Salley, seconded by Councilmember Frierson, to accept the recommendation of the planning and zoning commissions concerning the following properties: 1. A-l Residential to Office-Institutional Apartments W. W. Sutcliffe--Recommendation was to deny 2. A-l Residential to A-2 Residential Henry A. Goodwin--Recommendation was to approve Therefore, a motion was made by Councilmember Salley, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Boland, unanimously approved first reading of an ordinance to rezone the property owned by Goodwin. A motion by Mayor Pro Tern Boland, unanimously approved the 11-15-88 include the discussion concerning seconded by City Council the hospital Councilmember Keitt, Minutes as amended to insurance. A motion by Councilmember Frierson, seconded by Mayor Pendarvis, unanimously approved the second reading of the Airport Fixed Base Operator's Lease Ordinance which was recommended by the Aviation Commission. Attorney Walsh said that Ms. Rhudy would personally guarantee this lease even though the agreement would be in the name of a corporation. This was added to Frierson's motion. Councilmember Haire wanted to know where the issue of an executive session stood. Mayor Pendarvis said that there was no motion on the floor for an executive session, but there would still be the option for an executive session at the next meeting. Attorney Ladson Beach said that he had been contacted by several individuals concerning this matter since their attorney was hospitalized. Their attorney and a key individual who wants to address council were not able to be here tonight but want to be heard before the third reading. These individuals want to be sure that they will have a time to air their grievances. 404cITY COUNCIL MINUTES DECEMBER 6, 1988 PAGE 2 A motion was made by Mayor Pendarvis, seconded by Counci1member Parrott to approve the postponement of the third reading of the Airport Mechanic's Lease Ordinance until they (both ordinances) can be considered at the same time. councilmember Salley opposed. Concerning the grievance procedure, Councilmember Salley said that we have a grievance procedure that appears to be working and no one has presented any information to council that there are any problems. He stated that he felt that it was unnecessary to change it. Mayor Pro Tern Boland stated, " ... felt that everybody that worked for the City should be held to the same standards. I've heard that possibly Mr. Johnson holds his people to higher or tougher standard, that's more like a business. I would recommended that we also run the other side of the house in the same manner. That way everything's a business and should be run as a business. Everybody should be held to the same standard and that it would be equal treatment to everyone. That this policy gives all departments a chance to put their say in and if there's something that we don't agree with we always have the last word. And for moral and for equal treatment and for good business that we should hold everybody to the same standard ... " Councilmember Salley said, "I agree that everybody should be held to the same standard but lets get this side up to their standards rather than putting them together and maybe bringing that side down to this standard. Get this side up first then put them together ... " Mayor Pendarvis stated, " ... we have two separate divisions in the City ••• The administrative part which is everything except the Department of Public Utilities is by nature and by intent political. It's not that the people who work for it aren't just as worthy or just as good or just as important, that's not the point." He also stated that the administrative side of the City's is to provide services with funds raised through taxes, etc. He stated that this side is political and that it disastrous to put politics into the business side (DPU). function licenses, would be He also stated that he felt that the people in the administrative part and the DPU portion would feel more comfortable and be more understood by being judged by their peers who know them and their work. Mayor Pendarvis stated that the present grievance procedure is rarely used and that as far as he knows has no problems. Councilmember Parrott called on DPU Manager, Johnson, to elaborate on the differences. Johnson stated that the grievance committee is used as a last resort. He also stated that a large portion of the employees of DPU are professional by nature--6 engineers, 2 chemists, 2 biologists and quite a few other professions. Their (administrative) standards are different maybe because they are political type employees. He said it would be difficult for each division to judge the other. He realizes that DPU is part of the City. He stated, "We are the only municipal in the state of South Carolina with a AA rating ...• I would hate to see something change just for sake of changing not unless there is a reason." Councilmember Keitt stated that if the council is going to move forward that they are going to have to accept new changes. They should want to bring the standards up for all employees regardless of job title. She stated that we all work for the City of Orangeburg. We need to help other areas instead of downgrading anyone. (\j (!) >I m m <:( - CITY COUNCIL MINUTES DECEMBER 6, 1988 PAGE 5 DPU Manager, Ted Johnson, presented three matters: 407 1. Motion by Councilmember Salley, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Boland, unanimously approved a resolution to enter into an agreement with Southern Railway Company to construct and maintain an overhead wire line crossing the right of way at a point five hundred fifteen feet south of mile post SC-77. This authorizes the Mayor to sign the agreement. 2. Informed council that DPU has approximately $1,000,000 set aside in customer deposits. He was proposing that a customer who has 24 consecutive months without being in arrears be refunded his deposit. He stated that the money will serve better in the hands of the people who need it. Approximately 10,175 customers meet the afore mentioned criteria. The 5,800 customers with deposits that meet the criteria would be refunded approximately $296,000. This procedure would be run on a monthly basis to include everyone so that you could actually be in arrears one month and after that have 24 consecutive months without being in arrears and receive their refund. councilmember Keitt requested copies of this information. Councilmember Haire stated that City Administrator smith always sends an agenda and information in packet before the council meeting but yet Johnson just puts the information on their desk right before the meeting. He requested that council be sent DPU's information along with Smith's information. Johnson stated that he had just received this particular information today. It had to come in after the audit. councilmember Keitt asked if they had looked at twelve months as opposed to twenty-four months. Johnson said they did, but the charge-offs would be higher. This would eventually cause a rate increase. Johnson discussed the problem of water being used out of hydrants for uses other than fighting fires. He proposed that DPU install a full fire flow service meter on hydrants. Water used to actually fight a fire will not be billed, other uses will be billed at 300%. A motion by Councilmember Salley, seconded by Councilmember Parrott, unanimously approved the resolution concerning these two matters as changes to the General Terms and Conditions. 3. A motion by Councilmember Salley, seconded by Councilmember Parrott, unanimouslY approved the resolution to delete water rates and insert new rates. This will provide rates to be charged for use water through the detect-o-meter. There is no change in residential, commercial or industrial rates (inside or outside the city). Councilmember Keitt stated that any matters pertaining to DPU be given to council before hand. She stated that she did not enjoy hearing Johnson read something without knowing what he was reading. councilmember Parrott liked the fact that DPU would give deposits back to customers that have been good customers. But, he was concerned about the persons facing cutoffs. This is the time of the year when you hear of persons burning to death and find that they did not have any utilities or way to heat. Wanted to know about a policy helping a person facing cutoff. 40~ITY COUNCIL MINUTES DECEMBER 6, 1988 PAGE 6 Johnson said that there are about 3,500 - 4,000 per month that receive a final notice that they are in arrears. They cut off on some days as many as sixty (60) customers per day because they have not paid. He stated that if you talk to a person they would have a good reason as to why they did not pay the bill. Johnson stated that the CCMO (Cooperative Church Ministry of orangeburg) and the United Way are interested in participating in a program where certain funds could be donated through the billing system and turned over to the United Way. He emphasized that they do not have a firm committment from anyone yet. Mayor Pendarvis stated that he would like to pursue a program that allows people to tack onto the utility bill payment that would help the needy. Johnson said that you have to be careful of mingling funds due to the restrictions imposed when rate hearings are held. They would have to design a computer program that will provide a clear audit trail. A motion by Councilmember Keitt, seconded by councilmember Parrott, approved entering into an executive session for legal briefing. There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned. Re~~'ubmitted' od#..=n,on City Clerk /r O.lUlngebMg Ci.:ty Cou.nm held ill ILegu1aJr.ty 1>cheu.dted mee;Ung on. VecembeJt 6, 1988, cd 7; 00 P. M., -tn Ci.:ty HaLe. Chambvu wi.:th Ma.yoJ!. Pendc(.lw..u pJte1>.«Ung. PRESENT: E. O. Penda.itv..u, Ma.yoJt Thoma.!.> A. Bound, Ma.yOit PM Tem HenJty F. Fn-tVUon BeJtna.Jtd HMite L. UmmeJtma.n Ke..il;t AU. en W. P a.JtJto;t;t W. E v eJte:Ue SaLe.ey (\j (Y) \l en en <I: CITY COUNCIL MINUTES DECEMBER 6, 1988 PAGE 3 405 Councilmember difference in makeup of the Frierson said that he did not believe that there was a the standards or procedures but a difference in the grievance committees. Councilmember Haire stated that he did not see the need for the City to have more than one grievance committee. Mayor Pro Tern Boland stated that he felt that both sides are political. The administrative side has professionals also. He felt that if you put everyone together from the highest to the lowest they they will all work together and will bring about a feeling of teamwork. City Administrator Smith declined to comment. A motion by Mayor Pro Tern Boland, seconded by Councilmember Haire, approved the resolution changing the grievance committee. councilmember Frierson, Councilmember Salley, and Mayor Pendarvis opposed. A motion by Councilmember Haire, seconded by Mayor Pendarvis, unanimously approved the first reading of an ordinance for sale of land located near Orangeburg Municipal Airport and abutting the Orangeburg County Industrial Park. Attorney Walsh pointed out the initial building will be constructed on the county property. Part of the agreement is that Mosler must begin construction on the property within twelve (12) months--not necessarily on the City part. Nothing would prevent Mosler from building on the county property and perhaps selling off a back portion if they wanted. The City would have the option to repurchase the unimproved property if construction is not begun within twelve (12) months and completed within a reasonable length of time. Mayor Pro Tern Boland a small building on decide to sell it. wanted to know what would happen if they build the property and then two years down the line Attorney Walsh said the City would not back. Walsh also pointed out that agreement in line with the county's. have the option to buy he was trying to keep it the councilmember Salley pointed out that due to the location of the City portion that it would not be of use to anyone else. Sherrill Hampton updated council on the rental rehabilitation program. When the city first applied the project included thirty-eight (38) units. The funds to be received at $53,700 with the property owners matching brings the total project to $107,400. The number of units had to be cut. Twenty-eight were looked at and just completed work write ups on those. We still may have to cut some more because some of the units require intensive work to being them up to code. Some of the problems that will have to be corrected are erosion problems, indoor facilities, electrical, plumbing, heating, etc. Ms. Hampton pointed out that these are 1987 funds and that 1988 funds will soon need to be applied for. There should be some administrative funds to help the City bear the cost of the program. It would not be a total start-up since the City would have an on going project. Ms. Hampton stated that she is carefully checking potential contractors to be sure that the turn around time is in line. 40~ITY COUNCIL MINUTES DECEMBER 6, 1988 PAGE 4 Ms. Hampton pointed out does not think that fashion. You need to proficient in what they that handling grants is a full-time job and it can be properly handled in a piece meal be sure that the person handling grants is do. Mayor Pendarvis was concerned that he did not know if the City could secure enough grants to warrant a full-time position. Ms. Hampton pointed out that the City is going to have to stay out there and apply and be innovative in the techniques that we use--put aside some funds. The City may have to look at having a local development corporation, etc. Look at your housing needs. Councilmember approved to homes inside whenever the Haire, seconded by Councilmember Keitt, unanimously a continuing program of seeking funds to revitalize the City. This would include sending letters of intent City receives a RFP requesting such. Ms. Hampton also pointed out that the Governor's Office also has some funds to be used for community development--rental or home owner. For community revitalization $23,500,000 is available. The particular program ($10,000,000) she was addressing could be used for individual home owner as well as rental. The letter of intent is due 1-10-89. She said the state has imposed an average $12,000 rehab cost. The maximum amount that the City could apply for is $350,000. A local match is required of 10% ($35,000). This could be in the way of cash, in-kind or force account. The average rehab cost around the state is $17,000 - $20,000. Ms. Hampton also mentioned the other projects available that were listed in her packet. Councilmember Haire wanted to know if there were funds available to complete the Sunnyside Canal project. City Administrator Smith said that was done by using Community Block Grant monies. The City was told never to come back again to ask for monies for the canal project. Some of that money was used for housing rehabilitation and to complete the Zimmerman Center. That was when the program was handled by the Federal Government. He said we have applied before but the per capita income in the areas where rehabilitation was needed was too high. Smith pointed out that if the application is accepted that we will have to know where we are going to get the $35,000. A motion by Mayor Pro Tern Boland, seconded by Councilmember Parrott, unanimously approved to proceed with what ever is necessary to apply for CDBG. Councilmember Haire had asked the City Attorney for information concerning putting restrictions on the use of bottle rockets. Walsh said we are limited to the extent as to which we can regulate fireworks. He said the most we could do would be to limit the use of fireworks in certain areas. He said that Department of Public Safety Director Brant said that this would not be practical as far as the areas to be used and the manpower to police it. Walsh said that the City cannot be more restrictive than the State. Mayor Pendarvis said that Attorney Walsh would talk to other cities and see what their procedures are concerning regulating fireworks. Attorney Walsh requested an executive session for legal briefing. ,~ RES 0 L UTI 0 N WHEREAS, The CUy on OMngeblUtg ha.6 a de.6bce ;tha;t aU. emp£.oyee.6 .6hou£.d be .-i.nnotuned a.6 ;to ;the gu.-LdeUne.6 c.onc.eAn--Lng emp£.oymen:t wUh ;the CUy a.nd, WflfREAS, A PeJL60nnu Pouc.y MaMa.£. ha.6 been pILepa.ned .6;ta;Ung ;the pOUUe.6 wh-Lc.h a.ne OILdbwl.-U.y n oUowed, a.nd WflEREAS, ;th..i..6. PeJL60nnu Pouc.y Wa.6 adop;ted by ;the OMngeblUtg CUy Counw on Ju.£.y 19, 1988, and WIfEREAS, U ha.6 been nound ;tha;t a.n a.mendmen:t .-L.6 needed ;to ;th..i..6 PeJL60nnu Pouc.y. NOW, TIfEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVEV ;tha;t ;the CUy Counw on ;the CUy on OILangeblUtg heAeby adopu ;the -6oUow.-i.ng a.mendmen:t.6 ;to ;the PeJL60nnu Pouc.y Ma.nua.£.. 1. Pa.ge. 13, The. Emp£.oye.e. G4i.e.vanc.e. Colllln-i;t;te.e. The .6emon c.a.ptioned "The Emp£.oyee G4i.evanc.e Commillee" .6haU. now ILea.d a.6 noUOW.6: "CUy Counw .6haU. appo.-i.n:t a G.tr..-i;evanc.e CommUee c.omp0.6ed 0-6 n--Lne (9) emp£.oyee.6 ;to .6eAve nOlL a ;tenm on ;thILee (3) yea.M, ex.c.ep;t ;tha;t ;the membeJL6 appoh1.:ted J..~ .6haU. be appo.-i.n:ted .60 ;tha;t ;the.Ut .;teAm.6 w.-i.U be .6;taggeAed, and appILOJVima;te£.y one-;thVr.d (1/3) on ;the ;teAm.6 .6ha.U. ex.pbce eac.h yeaJt. A membeA .6haU. c.ontinue ;to .6eAve aMeA ;the ex.pbca.:ti..on on h..i..6 ;tenm un:t-i..t a .6UC.C.e.6.601L .-L.6 appo.-i.n:ted. Any .-i.n:tViA.m appo.-i.n.:tmen:t ;to -6.-i.U a vac.a.nc.y -6 OIL any c.a.u..6 e p4i.OIL ;to ;the c.omp£.eUoYl on a membeA'.6 ;teAm .6haU. be nOlL ;the unex.pbced ;tenm." I n.{;t.{.a.£. T enm 3 YeaM 3 YeaM 2 YeaM 1 Ye.a.n 3 YeaM 2 Yea.M 2 Yea.M 1 YeaJt 1 Yea.n Pouc.e P MM & R ec.ILea.Uo Yl/ H.-i.Uc.lLe.6;t Pubuc. WOILM Fbce E£.ec..:tJt..i.c. Wa.6;tewa;teA/Ga.6/Ga.JLa.ge Wa;teA SeAv.-i.c.e/Adm~;tna.:ti..ve/Ex.ec.u.tive VPU Adm.-i.n.-L.6;tna.tioYl Onl..y OYle membeA nILom one 0-6 ;the.6e depaJt:tmen:t.6 c.a.n be on ;the GIL.-Levanc.e Commillee a;t any time. Any membeA may be ILea.ppoh1.:ted nOlL .6uc.c.eecUng ;tenm.6 a;t ;the wc.lLeUon on ;the CUy Counw. MembeJL6 emp£.oyed .-i.n ;the -6a.me depaJt:tmen:t OIL cUv.-L.6J..on a.6 ;the glL.-Levh1g empLoyee and membeJL6 havJ..ng notuned an opJ..n--LOYl on ;the .-L.6.6ue.6 plL.-LOIL ;to ;the hea.nmg, .6haU. no;t paJttiu.pa;te J..n ;tha;t emp£.oyee.'.6 hea.nJ..ng.6. z. pa.ge. 14, Une. 3: Th..i..6 .6en:tenc.e .6ha.U. be c.hanged ;to ILea.d: "A quOlLum .6ha.U. c.oYl-6.-L.6;t on -6even (7) membeJL6, and ylO hea.nJ..ng.6 may be he£.d wUhou.;t a quOlLum." PASSEV by ;the CUy Counw on ;the CUy 0-6 OMngebMg, Sou.;th Ca.nouna., ;th..i..6 15;th day on NovembeA, A.V., 1988. /~ ATT;Y~£ C[JY CLERI\" MAYOR 'dL~<MQ~ MEMBERS()FCQUNCIL RESOLUTION BE IT RESOLVED By the Mayor and Members of Council of the City of Orangeburg, Scuth Carolina, in Council assembled, this sixth day of December A.D., 1988, and by authority of the same: 'Ihat the rates of the Department of Public Utilities of the City of Orangeburg pertaining to Water, as heretofore adopted, be, and the same are hereby repealed, and in lieu thereof, the Water Rates of the Department of Public Utilities of the City of Orangeburg, hereto attached, be, and they are hereby, declared effective and in full force on January 1. 1989 billings. PASSED by the City Council, in Council assembled at Orangeburg, South Carolina, this sixth day of December, 1988. Signed: Members of Council Depart::rnent of PUblic Utilities - Orangeburg, South carolina WATER RATES No. 1 - RESIDENTIAL AND COMMERCIAL (Inside City Lilni ts) (Code 4A = Residential) (Code 4B = commercial) First 5,000 cu. Ft. @ $0.66 per 100 CU. Ft. per month Next 10,000 CU. Ft. @ $0.62 per 100 CU. Ft. per month Next 15,000 CU. Ft. @ $0.59 per 100 CU. Ft. per month All in excess of 30,000 CU. Ft. @ $0.46 per 100 CU. Ft. per month MINJl'1UMS : For 3/4 inch tap ------------ $ 3.75 per month For 1 inch tap ----------- $ 5.00 per month For 1-1/2 inch tap ----------- $ 7.50 per month For 2 inch tap ------------- $10.00 per month For 3 inch tap ---------- $15.00 per month For 4 inch tap ---------- $20.00 per month For 6 inch tap ----------- $30.00 per month Note: "General Terms and Conditions" and "Rules and Regulations" in effect apply to above. See Paragraph 4, "Rules and Regulations" for discount on above. Effective: January 1, 1989 Billing Department of Public Utilities - Orangeburg, South Carolina WATER RATES No. 2 - INDUSTRIAL (Inside City L:i1l1its) (Code 4C) First 5, 000 CU. Ft. @ $0.66 per 100 CU. Ft. per month Next 10, 000 CU. Ft. @ $0.62 per 100 CU. Ft. per month Next 15, 000 CU. Ft. @ $0.59 per 100 CU. Ft. per month All in excess of 30, 000 CU. Ft. @ $0.46 per 100 CU. Ft. per month JVlINIlVlUMS : For 3/4 inch tap ----------- $ 3.75 per month For 1 inch tap ---------- $ 5. 00 per month For 1-1/2 inch tap $ 7.50 per month For 2 inch tap ------------ $10.00 per month For 3 inch tap ------------ $15.00 per month For 4 inch tap ----------- $20.00 per month For 6 inch tap ---------- $30.00 per month Note: "General Tenus and Conditions" and "Rules and Regulations" in effect apply to above. See Paragraph 4, "Rules and Regulations" for discount on above. Effective: January 1, 1989 Billing Department of Public Utilities - Orangeburg, South Carolina WATER RATES No. 3 - RESIDENTIAL AND COMMERCIAL (OUtside City Limits) (Code 4D = Residential) (Code 4E = Ccmnercial) First 5,000 Cu. Ft. @ $1. 20 per 100 Cu. Ft. per month Next 10,000 Cu. Ft. @ $1. 04 per 100 Cu. Ft. per month Next 15,000 Cu. Ft. @ $0.83 per 100 Cu. Ft. per month All in excess of 30,000 Cu. Ft. @ $0.71 per 100 Cu. Ft. per month MINIMUMS: For 3/4 inch tap ---------- $ 6.85 per month For 1 inch tap ----------- $ 9.00 per month For 1-1/2 inch tap ------------ $13.75 per month For 2 inch tap ---------- $18.25 per month For 3 inch tap ------------ $27.00 per month For 4 inch tap ------------ $36.00 per month For 6 inch tap ------------- $55.00 per month Note: "General Tenns and Conditions" and "Rules and Regulations" in effect apply to above. See Paragraph 4, "Rules and Regulations" for discount on above. Effective: January 1, 1989 Billing Department of Public Utilities - Orangeburg, South Carolina WATER RATES No. 4 - lMlUSTRIAL (OUtside City L.i.m:its) (Code 4F) First 5, 000 cu. Ft. @ $1. 00 per 100 cu. Ft. per month Next 10, 000 CU. Ft. @ $0.85 per 100 cu. Ft. per month Next 15,000 cu. Ft. @ $0.69 per 100 cu. Ft. per month All in excess of 30,000 cu. Ft. @ $0.57 per 100 cu. Ft. per month J'IIJNIMlJlVlS : For 3/4 inch tap -------------- $ 5.75 per month For 1 inch tap ----------- $ 7.50 per month For 1-1/2 inch tap ------------- $11.50 per month For 2 inch tap -------------- $15.00 per month For 3 inch tap ----------- $23.00 per month For 4 inch tap ------------- $30.00 per month For 6 inch tap ----------- $46.00 per month Note: "General Terms and conditions" and "Rules and Regulations" in effect apply to above. See Paragraph 4, "Rules and Regulations" for discount on above. Effective: January 1, 1989 Billing Department of Public Utilities - Orangeburg, South Carolina WATER RATES No. 5 - COMMERCIAL AND rnDUSTRIAL DETECTO CHECK FIRE SERVICE OR FULL FIlJW FIRE SERVICE (Inside City L:irnits) (Code 4G = Commercial) (Code 4H = Industrial) SERVICE CHARGE: For 4 inch tap For 6 inch tap For 8 inch tap For 10 inch tap For 12 inch tap COMMODITY CHARGE: $ 4. 00 per month $ 5. 00 per month $10. 00 per month $20. 00 per month $30. 00 per month First 5,000 Cu. Ft. @ $1.98 per 100 Cu. Ft. per month Next 10, 000 Cu. Ft. @ $1. 86 per 100 Cu. Ft. per month Next 15, 000 Cu. Ft. @ $1. 77 per 100 Cu. Ft. per month All in excess of 30, 000 Cu. Ft. @ $1. 38 per 100 Cu. Ft. per month l\TINIMUM: The monthly minimum charge shall be the monthly service charge as stated above. Note: "General Terms and Conditions" and "Rules and Regulations" in effect apply to above. See Paragraph 4, "Rules and Regulations" for discount on above. Effective: January 1, 1989 Billing Department of Public Utilities - orangeburg, South Carolina ~RATES No. 6 - COMMERCIAL AND TI'IDUSTRIAL DETECTO CHECK FIRE SERVICE OR FULL FIf)W FIRE SERVICE (OUtside City Lllnits) (Code 41 = COlI'IlIercial) (Code 4J = Industrial) SERVICE CHARGE: For 4 inch tap For 6 inch tap For 8 inch tap For 10 inch tap For 12 inch tap COMMODITY CHARGE: $ 8.00 per month $10.00 per month $20.00 per month $40. 00 per month $50.00 per month First 5,000 CU. Ft. @ $3.00 per 100 CU. Ft. per month Next 10,000 CU. Ft. @ $2.64 per 100 CU. Ft. per month Next 15,000 CU. Ft. @ $2.07 per 100 CU. Ft. per month All in excess of 30,000 CU. Ft. @ $1. 71 per 100 CU. Ft. per month MINJMJM: The monthly min:imum charge shall be the monthly service charge as stated above. Note: "General Terms and Conditions" and "Rules and Regulations" in effect apply to above. See Paragraph 4, "Rules and Regulations" for discount on above. Effective: January 1, 1989 Billing ,- Deparbnent of Public Utilities - Orangeburg, South Carolina Vi'\TER RATES No. 7 - COMMERCIAL, COMBINED DOMESTIC AND FULL Flf)W FIRE SERVICE (Inside City Limits) (Code 4K) SERVICE CHARGE: For 4 inch tap ---------------------- $ 4.00 per month For 6 inch tap ----------------- $ 5.00 per month For 8 inch tap ------------------- $10.00 per month For 10 inch tap ------------------ $20.00 per month For 12 inch tap ---------------- $30.00 per month COMMODITY CHARGE: First 5,000 cu. Ft. @ $0.66 per 100 CU. Ft. per month Next 10,000 CU. Ft. @ $0.62 per 100 CU. Ft. per month Next 15,000 CU. Ft. @ $0.59 per 100 CU. Ft. per month All in excess of 30,000 CU. Ft. @ $0.46 per 100 CU. Ft. per month MINIMUMS: For 4 inch tap ----------- $20.00 per month For 6 inch tap ---------- $30.00 per month For 8 inch tap ---------- $40.00 per month For 10 inch tap ---------- $50.00 per month For 12 inch tap --------- $60.00 per month Note: "General Terms and Conditions" and "Rules and Regulations" in effect apply to above. See Paragraph 4, "Rules and Regulations" for discount on above. Effective: January 1, 1989 Billing Depart:ment of Public Utilities - Orangeburg, South Carolina VU\TER RATES No. 8 - COMMERCIAL, COMBIl\lED DOMESTIC AND FULL FTiJW FIRE SERVICE (Outside City Limits) (Code 4L) SERVICE CHARGE: For 4 inch tap For 6 inch tap For 8 inch tap For 10 inch tap For 12 inch tap COMMODITY CHARGE: -------_._---- $ 8.00 per IlIOnth $10.00 per IlIOnth $20.00 per IlIOnth $40.00 per IlIOnth $50.00 per IlIOnth First 5,000 Cu. Ft. @ $1. 20 per 100 Cu. Ft. per IlIOnth Next 10,000 Cu. Ft. @ $1. 04 per 100 Cu. Ft. per IlIOnth Next 15,000 Cu. Ft. @ $0.83 per 100 Cu. Ft. per IlIOnth All in excess of 30,000 Cu. Ft. @ $0.71 per 100 Cu. Ft. per IlIOnth r.mrrMUMS: For 4 inch tap ---------- $36.00 per IlIOnth For 6 inch tap ---------- $55.00 per IlIOnth For 8 inch tap ----------- $65.00 per IlIOnth For 10 inch tap $75.00 per IlIOnth For 12 inch tap --------- $85.00 per IlIOnth Note: "General Tenus and Conditions" and "Rules and Regulations" in effect apply to above. See Paragraph 4, "Rules and Regulations" for discount on above. Effective: January 1, 1989 Billing RESOLUTION BE IT RESOLIIED By the Mayor and Members of Co=il of the City of Orangeburg, in Council assembled, and by authority of same: THAT the "GENERAL TERMS AND CONDITIONS" of the Departrnent of Public Utilities of the City of Orangeburg, South carolina, as heretofore adopted on November 18, 1986, be amended as follows: Paragraph G-3-C of Section III: Amend Paragraph G-3-C of Section III of said "General Tenus and Conditions" by inserting the following: paragraphG-3-C C. Fire Service Taps 1. Existing Fire Service Taps Fire service taps before January 1, 1989 are for fire protection only. The Departrnent will install detector check valves with meter on all fire services made prior to January 1, 1989. This meter will be read each IlIOnth and the customer billed as per the appropriate rate schedule. If this detector meter shows consUIT\Ption for any four IlIOnths in a twelve IlIOnth period, the customer will be required to install at his expense, a full flow fire service meter. 2. New Fire Service Taps All new fire service taps after January 1, 1989 will require the installation of a full flow fire service meter. The custaner will be required to purchase a fire service tap of the size he desires, to meet his fire protection requirements. This tap may be used for both fire protection and danestic service at the discretion of the Departrnent. Water used to actually fight a fire will not be billed. a. All fire service taps connected to an anti-freeze (wet) system or one which has private hydrants will require a State approved double check backflow preventer supplied by the customer at his expense. Those fire services utilizing a standard alarm check (dry) system will not require a backflow device unless under unusual circumstances such a device is deemed necessary by the Departrnent. b. The custaner will be required to grant to the Departrnent an easement adj acent to the property line at which the cormection to the Departrnent' s water system is to be made, for the purpose of the meter installation including a vault to hold the meter and associated equi];X[lent. The meter and vault will be the property of the Departrnent under its sole control. The backflow device, if required, shall be the property of the custaner and the responsibility for its maintenance in accordance with the rules and regulations of the South carolina Depart:rnent of Health and Environmental Control and the Depart:rnent, shall remain with the customer. 3. Monthly Fire Service Availability Charge A ll10nthly fire service availability fee will be charged to each customer provided with fire protection. This charge will be in accordance with the rate schedule. 4. Fire Service Tap Fees Per Tap: The cost of a fire service tap will be calculated by the Depart:rnent for each individual case. The cost will include all materials and labor (including the Ireter and vault) . Paragraph C-2 of Section IV: Amend Paragraph C-2 of Section IV of said "General Te:r:ms and Conditions" by inserting the following: Paragraph C-2 2. Deposits shall be returned when the customer completes twenty-four (24) consecutive payments without an arrears. PASSED by the City Council, in Council assembled, at Orangeburg, South Carolina, this 6th clay of December A. D., 1988 . .c; /J-J p . L. (/r / __ ~~~~-/ / Mayor lXferobers of Council ~' DEPARTIVlENT OF PUBLIC UTILITIES CHARGE-oFF PREDICTIONS FOR FISCAL YEAR 1987-88 WITH NEW POLICY OF APPROVED REFUNDS OF DEPOSITS November 15, 1988 'Ihe Depart:rnent proposes to begin refunding deposits to customers whose credit history is acceptable as per the Depart:rnent' s General Tenus and Conditions. Presently the Depart:rnent requests a standard deposit for each active service. This deposit remains with the Depart:rnent until the service is terminated. In addition the Department requests from all customers new to our system an additional cash deposit of $100.00 (or up to two IllOnths probable for nonresidential customers), a guarantor or an acceptable letter of credit from the customer's former electric supplier. Deposit monies in excess of the basic deposit are refundable after twelve consecutive payments without arrears. In the proposed policy the Department would retain the customer's full deposit until the customer carrpletes twenty-four consecutive payments without arrears. Upon the customer's request or by evaluation of Department records each month the Depart:rnent would refund the customer. However, the customer roay be required to reinstate or increase the deposit when the customer's payment record shows delinquent payment practice. TIle intentions of the statistical analysis below is to provide a reliable prediction to the result of a change in the Department's deposit policy to the Department's yearly recorded bad debts (charge-offs). Data Accumulated 'Ihe following info:rmation was accumulated from the Depart:rnent' s 1987-1988 charge-off records. A. Average charged-off bill B. Average charged-off deposit C. Average charged-off bill less deposit D. Number of customers charged off $194 $ 62 $132 690 TIle following data for this analysis was accumulated by random saIl\Pling of the Department's list of Final Bill CUstomers. E. Total Number of Final Bills in One Year F. Total Number of Final Bills in Test SaIl\Ple G. 'Ihe percent of the saIl\Ple which had a deposit H. 'Ihe percent of the saIl\Ple which would have had a deposit if the new policy were in place. 1. TIle decrease in percentage with deposits due to the 2,800 200 98% 81% ~ new policy. 17% J. The percent of the sa:rqple Which would have been refunded their deposit and left no unpeid bills. 16% K. The percent of the sa:rqple Which would have been refunded their deposit and left unpeid bills. 1% L. Average final bill before deposit of customers who would have refunded their deposit. $ 54 Estimate of Charge-0ffs Under Proposed Policy Max:imum Loss M. 17% (I) x 2800 (E) = 476 Possible Final Bill CUStomers without a Deposit N. 476 (M) x $54 (L) = $25,704 (Note: Technically the only loss the Department would suffer would be the dollar value of the refunded deposit. However, the average bill of these refunded customers is lower than the average deposit. Therefore, the lower amount of the bill , $54, was used instead of the amount of the deposit.) Best Estimate (Note: The study showed that 50% of the customers who had a balance after deposits were applied did not pay the balance due.) o. $25,704 (N) x 50% = $12,852 Min.irmJm Loss P. 1% (K) x 2800 (F) = 28 Possible Final Bill CUStomer leaving unpeid bills Q. 28 (p) x $54 (L) = $1,512 Nuniber of customers Refunded and Dollar Values of Refund A program was run against the Department's history records to aid in detennining the nuniber of customers who would be refunded by the policy change. The program listed 10,175 customers who have peid twenty-four consecutive months without arrears. A sa:rqple of of 200 customers fram the list were tested. One Hundred fourteen or 57% had deposits totalling $ 5,833.24. Therefore we estimate that 5800 customers would be refunded a total amount of $296,786.00. The average deposit refund will be $51.17. 114/200 = 57% 57% x 10,175 customers = 5,800 customers to refund $5,833.24 / 114 customers = Average refund of $51.17 per customer 5,800 customers x $51.17 per customer = Total Refund of $296,786.00 RESOLUTION BE IT RESOLVED By the Mayor and Members of Council of the City of Orangeburg, South Carolina, in Council assembled, and by authority of the same: That the City of Orangeburg enter into an agreement with Southern Railway Company, a Virginia Corporation, whereby Southern Railway grants unto the City of Orangeburg, in so far as its title enables it so to do, a license to construct and maintain an overhead wire line crossing upon the right-of-way on property of the said Car[lany at a point five hundred fifteen (515) feet South of Mile Post SC-77 North of Orangeburg, South Carolina, being that identified and located substantially as sh= on annexed print of Drawing of Department of Public Utilities marked Ex:h:ibit A, dated May 17, 1988. BE IT FURTBER RESOLVED that his Honor, Mayor E. O. Pendarvis, be, and he hereby is, authorized and directed to sign said agreement on behalf of the City of Orangeburg. PASSED this 6th day of December , A.D., 1988. Signed: Members of Council C\J (Y) ~ OJ OJ <t CITY COUNCIL MINUTES DECEMBER 20, 1988 409 orangeburg City Council held its regularly scheduled meeting on December 20, 1988, at 7:00 P.M., in City Hall Chambers with Mayor Pendarvis presiding. An invocation was given by Councilmember Parrott. PRESENT: E. o. Pendarvis, Mayor Thomas A. Boland, Mayor Pro Tern Henry F. Frierson Bernard Haire L .. Zimmerman Keitt Allen W. Parrott W. Everette Salley A motion by Councilmember Keitt, seconded unanimously approved the December 6, 1988 distributed. by Councilmember Haire, City Council Minutes as A motion was made by Councilmember Frierson, seconded by councilmember Haire to approve the recommendation of the Aviation Commission for third reading of the Airport Fixed Base Operator's Lease Ordinance. Attorney Clyde Dean, representing requested an executive session misconduct and malfeasance on the operator, Pat Rhudy. some to part aircraft discuss of the Attorney, Tom Bryant, representing Ms. Rhudy, would prefer to discuss this matter in open follow council's wishes. owners and pilots possible criminal current fixed base said that Ms. Rhudy session, but would A motion by Councilmember Salley, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Boland, approved entering into an executive session for the discusssion of possible criminal misconduct. Councilmember Haire and Councilmember Frierson opposed. The Times and Democrat, represented by Tucker Lyon, protested this executive session. When the meeting was reopened, a motion by councilmember Frierson, seconded by councilmember Keitt, unanimously approved entering into an executive session for legal advice. When the meeting was open again, Mr. George Daniels of Cordova, voiced his opposition to the lease renewal. He complained about beer drinking by employees at the airport on weekends, improperly tied-down planes, lack of grass cutting, beer bottles in the parking area, lack of 24-hour security, employees not being there when they are suppose to be and inconsistency in fees. He felt that the lease had not been properly enforced. Mr. Bill Covington, Orangeburg, complained about the condition he has found his plane in several times, no one being at the airport for advisory information, no one to pump fuel and employees asleep at the desk. Mr. Dean ended with a statement that the Fixed position of public trust. He wanted council Commission's recommendation. Base to Operator reconsider is a the Mr. Bryant stated that Ms. Rhudy has received much support and had people at the meeting for her support. He said that maybe there have been communication problems. Ms. Rhudy needs to listen to the complaints. These customers need to let her know if they have problems. She cannot keep everyone happy, she will keep the majority happy. She has some fences to mend. He also pointed out the Aviation Commission recommended the lease renewal. There were no dissenting votes. 410cITY COUNCIL MINUTES DECEMBER 20, 1988 PAGE 2 Ms. Rhudy said that she has not adjusted the over the airport. They were adjusted when the airport. fees since she took Harold Biggers operated Mr. Wannamaker said that the new lease addresses lease charges by plane size. The charges would be approved by the city. Ms. Rhudy said that she does not remember Mr. Covington ever coming to her with his complaints about his plane condition. The lease was approved with the following amendments: 1- 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. Include personal guarantee from Ms. Rhudy Prohibit the sale of the corporation without the consent of council ~ ~ Employees of the corporation be~p, oved by COUSil upon the recommendation of the commission Ms. Rhudy must be on the premis s 40 hours per wee The three year lease will beg1n 10-01-88 " The lease will be for one year"subject to approval for an additional year after a public h'earing held 90 days :before the expiration of the one year le~e ' A motion by Councilmember Salley, s Boland, unanimously agreed to enter into above mentioned amendments. onded the by Mayor Pro agreememt with Tern the Mr. Dukes said that for nine months the commis\,ioIL/~ired to talk to everyone and they heard more good than bad. The/ complainers have made the airport sound like a sloppy, unsafe operation. The Commission cannot do a~thing if the Commission does not know of any problems. Let them knd~immediately. / Mr. Dukes read excerpts fram a letter of commendation from Jr. John Hamilton, Director of the Sdlith Carolina Aeronautics commission. / Mr. Dukes informed! council tha~they meet, Jwhen necessary--at least once a month. 'They do post n0,tices at /the airport whenever a meeting is going to be held. \" ! A motion by CoUi:lcI1member Haire, s~~0.ndt by councilmember Keitt, unanimous~~ approved the t"hird read7'u of the Airport Mechanic's Lease Ord~~ance. / /' -, '-, , A motion tby Mayor Pendarvis, seconded by Counci1member Salley, unanimously approved the second re~ing of an ordinance for sale of land located near Orangeburg Municipal Airport and abutting the orangeburg\county Industrial Park with the following provision that woUld allov.t\the city the option to buy back the land if it was ever offered for ,sale. Therefore,. the ordinance would be amended to coinci'de with orangeburg Coun,ty plus the FAA restrictions. \ '; A moti6n by \ CouncilmembeI/ Salley, seconded by Councilmember Frierson~ unani~UslY appro~ed the second reading of the ordinance to rezone \one pieC{! of p¢perty for Mr. Henry A. Goodwin from A-l Residential to A-2 ~ential. \ \ \Attorney Walsh stated that the purchase of a house on 901 Ellis NE reference an nas been withdrawn. But to clear this for future ~~:ention h01e would not be permissible in A-lor A-2. co~ncilmembe~ Haire expressed his concern that nothing further had bee~ done a~ far as informing the Highway Department of the citizens' comments on the Boulevard traffic improvements. " ; ~' '- 4-10 CITY COUNCIL MINUTES DECEMBER 20, 1988 PAGE 2 Ms. Rhudy said that she has not adjusted the over the airport. They were adjusted when the airport. fees since she took Harold Biggers operated Mr. Wannamaker said that the new lease addresses lease charges by plane size. The charges would be approved by the city. Ms. Rhudy said that she does not remember Mr. Covington ever coming to her with his complaints about his plane condition. The 1- 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. lease was approved with the following amendments: Include personal guarantee from Ms. Rhudy Prohibit the sale of the corporation without the consent of council Employees of the corporation be approved by council upon the recommendation of the Commission Ms. Rhudy must be on the premises 40 hours per week The three year lease will begin 10-01-88 The lease will be for three years subject to cancellation after a public hearing held 90 days before the expiration of each anniversary. A motion by Councilmember Salley, seconded by Mayor Pro Tern Boland, unanimously agreed to enter into the agreement with the above mentioned amendments. Councilmember Frierson opposed. The original call for third reading was then unanimously approved with the above amendments. Mr. Dukes said that for nine months the Commission tired to talk to everyone and they heard more good than bad. The complainers have made the airport sound like a sloppy, unsafe operation. The Commission cannot do

Text truncated. Open the original for the full document.

Source: City of Orangeburg website. First collected Oct 13, 2026.