_06112026-552
City of North Myrtle Beach · Horry County · meeting of Jun 11, 2026 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of North Myrtle Beach
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
1
CITY OF NORTH MYRTLE BEACH, SOUTH CAROLINA
NORTH MYRTLE BEACH CITY HALL
BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS MEETING
Thursday, June 11, 2026
5:00 PM
MINUTES
William McGonigal, Chairman City Staff:
Cynthia Lover, Vice-Chairwoman Ben Caldwell, Zoning Administrator
Mendel Bell Elton Farmer, Zoning Technician
Norfleet Jones Chris Noury, City Attorney
Joe Reaves Amber Elmadolar, Plan Reviewer
Andy Thomas
Wyman Wise
1. CALL TO ORDER & ROLL CALL: Chairman McGonigal called the meeting to order at 5:05 PM. Ms.
Elmadolar called roll.
2. APPROVAL OF MEETING MINUTES: Mr. Elmadolar stated the Minutes for the May 14, 2026 ,
meeting were not available for this meeting. Chairman McGonigal stated they will review next
meeting.
3. COMMUNICATION: Mr. Caldwell stated BZA-26-11, BZA-26-12, and BZA-26-13 were withdrawn by
the applicant. Chairman McGonigal gave the option to postpone an item due to the Board missing a
member.
4. SWEAR IN THOSE PERSONS TO SPEAK: Ms. Elmadolar swore in persons to speak at the meeting.
5. NEW BUSINESS:
A. BZA-26-09: Application by Jonathan Reynolds for a variance of the required building setbacks
at 1205 Perrin Drive, TMS# 35712040061 in the Resort Residential, R -4 District. Mr. Reynolds,
applicant, stated the lot was irregularly shaped and the requested setback adjustment was
intended to accommodate the site's configuration. He stated the proposed setbacks would be
approximately 5.1 feet on all sides. Vice-Chairwoman Lover asked Mr. Reynolds to specify the
variance being requested, she noted it was not clearly identified in the application. Mr. Reynolds
responded he wanted to move the setbacks 5 feet all the way around. Vice -Chairwoman Lover
asked if he wanted a 10 -foot variance on the front and 10 foo t on the rear. Mr. Reynold s
explained he was looking for 10-foot variance on the front, rear and sides of the property.
Vice-Chairwoman Lover asked how a five-bedroom house would fit on the lot and inquired about
the proposed size and number of stories. Mr. Reynolds stated the proposed home would be three
stories and explained the intent was to maximize the buildable area. He stated the plans would
be finalized by the architect and noted the design might be reduced to a four -bedroom home
due to the lot's irregular configuration. Vice-Chairwoman Lover asked whether Mr. Reynolds had
a plan yet. Mr. Reynolds stated he did not have a finalized plan at the time of application, he
explained he was seeking approval of the variance first in order to avoid the expense to prepare
architectural plans. Vice-Chairwoman Lover stated the Board should review the site plan before
2
granting the variance. She further noted that applicants were normally required to submit a plan
and indicated, in this case, a plan had not been provided.
Mr. Thomas stated the Board would grant a variance based on what was submitted. Vice -
Chairwoman Lover asked Mr. Reynolds if he could build a smaller house without the variance.
Mr. Reynolds stated he would need to review the plans but the proposed dwelling was intended
to be approximately 2,500 square feet of heated space and potentially a five -bedroom layout.
Mr. Thomas noted it was a very small and oddly shaped lot, and Vice-Chairwoman Lover agreed.
Chairman McGonigal asked for public comment.
Mr. Caldwell read the description of the request, the ordinance, and recommended to hear the
variance. Chairman McGonigal stated he would like to try a different structure based on a training
held earlier that day and indicated he wanted to run through it with Mr. Caldwell. Chairman
McGonigal asked Mr. Caldwell whether the property had extraordinary or exceptional conditions
pertaining to the shape of the lot. Mr. Caldwell responded it did. Chairman McGonigal asked
whether the setback requirements generally applied to other properties in the vicinity, and Mr.
Caldwell responded they did. Chairman McGonigal asked about the shape of the lot, and Mr.
Caldwell responded the lot was odd and irregular. Chairman McGonigal asked whether
application of the ordinance to the property would effectively prohibit or unreasonably restrict
utilization of the property, and Mr. Caldwell responded it would. Chairman McGonigal asked
whether granting the variance would be a substantial detriment to adjacent properties or the
public good or whether the character of the district would be harmed, and Mr. Caldwell
responded it would not.
Vice-Chairwoman Lover asked Mr. Caldwell when the property was platted. Mr. Caldwell stated
he did not know when the lot was platted but he did know it had been around for quite a while
and there had been prior questions regarding it. Mr. Caldwell referenced a prior situation
involving an adjacent property owner, where a request to construct a swimming pool on the lot
was denied because it was a separate parcel. Mr. Caldwell stated the applicant was advised the
lot could be combined with the adjoining property to allow such use, but the owner declined in
order to retain the ability to sell the lot separately in the future. Mr. Caldwell stated he believed
it was platted before the current zoning because a smaller subdivision of this size would not have
been allowed.
Vice-Chairwoman Lover asked whether a house could be built on the property while still meeting
the required setbacks and whether denial of the variance would unreasonably restrict use of the
property. She continued a house could be built within the required setbacks. Vice-Chairwoman
Lover stated she did not believe a variance was required specifically for a five -bedroom house
and noted any variance granted should be limited to the minimum necessary. Mr. Bell stated he
agreed with Vice-Chairwoman Lover and expressed concern the discussion was hypothetical, and
noted he had an issue with proceeding on that basis. Chairman McGonigal agreed with the Board
and added he wanted to give the applicant defined direction, so he wasn’t creating several sets
of plans. Mr. Thomas stated if Mr. Reynolds chose to proceed, the Board would be granting a
variance based on the plans submitted. He further stated if the architect or engineer determined
the design would not work due to constraints, Mr. Reynolds would need to revise the plans and
return to request another variance.
3
Mr. Reynolds stated after the initial plans were completed, the proposed deck design was revised
to extend across the structure on two levels. He stated the lot was irregular in shape, he noted
width constraints of approximately 18 feet in one area and 12 feet in another, which made it
difficult to configure bedrooms and building layout. He further stated due to the uncertainty of
approval; he did not want to incur the expense of preparing full architectural plans before
knowing what would be granted and indicated he sought clarification on what could be approved
before he proceeded with plan design. Chairman McGonigal stated the property had been
identified as an irregularly shaped lot. He stated the question before the Board was how much
flexibility to allow so the applicant could work with an architect to develop a design that would
comply with the Board’s requirements. Vice-Chairwoman Lover agreed it was a small lot and
referenced the ordinance criteria which required the variance be necessary for reasonable
development of the site and any variance granted be the minimum necessary to accomplish the
intended purpose. She questioned whether reasonable development required a five -bedroom
house and whether the requested variance represented the minimum necessary to allow
reasonable development of the site. Vice-Chairwoman Lover stated the requested 10 -foot
variance would be substantial relative to the required setbacks and suggested a lesser variance
should be considered. Chairman McGonigal noted the applicant mentioned pulling 10 feet off of
the front with the deck. Vice-Chairwoman Lover noted the proposed deck would also require a
variance if it exceeded 12 inches in height. The Board inquired about the existing structures on
the property and asked Mr. Caldwell about the current setbacks applicable to the existing
structure. Mr. Caldwell stated the current setback on the structure was 5 feet and he was unsure
of the setbacks of the adjacent structure.
Mr. Bell stated the existing structure on the subject property had a 5-foot rear setback and noted
the house at 1203 Perrin Drive had the same rear setback. Mr. Bell and Vice-Chairwoman Lover
discussed the setbacks at 1203 Perrin Drive. Vice-Chairwoman Lover stated a variance would
likely be necessary but noted the applicant was requesting a 10-foot variance from both the front
and rear setbacks, which represented approximately two-thirds of the required 15-foot setback.
Chairman McGonigal asked Mr. C aldwell for his opinion on the request. Chairman McGonigal
stated he was not concerned with the design of the house but was concerned with the proposed
footprint and asked what a reasonable solution would be to grant the applicant. He stated Mr.
Reynolds had demonstrated hardship and noted the remaining question before the Board was
the amount of relief to provide. Mr. Bell stated there was likely a 10-foot front easement on the
property and referenced the presence of utility or setback constraints along the front of the lot.
Mr. Caldwell stated the front setback would be increased by an additional 10 feet, resulting in a
total setback of approximately 15 feet, and noted this would move the structure closer to the
center of the lot.
The Board and Mr. Caldwell discussed the property’s front and rear setback conditions, they
noted the lot’s irregular shape, limited buildable area, and the need to consider the minimum
variance necessary to reasonably develop the site while aligning with surrounding development.
Mr. Caldwell stated the full district setbacks would result in a very small, triangular buildable
footprint and described the lot as having exceptional conditions. Vice-Chairwoman Lover asked
what the minimal variance to grant would be. Mr. Bell noted Mr. Reynolds was very limited on
what he could build. Chairman McGonigal stated concern over the proposed building footprint,
he noted the number of bedrooms was not the primary issue and the focus was on whether a
reasonable footprint could be achieved.
4
Mr. Farmer stated if the approved variance did not comply with impervious surface requirements,
the applicant would be required to return for additional approval and noted other regulatory
requirements were equally important. Mr. Caldwell noted on this plan they showed 50%
impervious for the proposed house and driveways were all p ervious materials. Chairman
McGonigal asked City staff for suggestions on a reasonable level of relief, he noted the applicant
had demonstrated hardship and stat ed the Board wished to provide a framework for
development. Chairman McGonigal referenced prior comments regarding impervious surface
requirements and stated the applicant would still be required to comply with those standards in
preparing final plans. Mr. Reynolds stated the driveways could be impervious and that would get
him to 60%. Mr. Caldwell explained the plans showed pervious. Chairman McGonigal asked Mr.
Noury for any comments. Mr. Noury stated he had no comments and he thought the Board was
going through what it needed to go through to come to a decision to grant or deny the variance.
Chairman McGonigal stated he wished to revisit comments made by Mr. Bell and noted there
appeared to be limited usable area in the front of the property. He stated the rear setback may
warrant greater consideration due to proximity to an adjacent property owner and referenced a
5-foot setback had been identified. Vice-Chairwoman Lover stated she was inclined to support a
5-foot rear setback but wanted a greater setback at the front. She further stated concerns about
the proximity of the proposed house to adjacent property and referenced the circumstances of
the lot’s sale. Mr. Caldwell stated the minimum requirement was 15 feet. Mr. Reaves noted the
front and rear setbacks were 15 feet and the sides were 5 feet. Mr. Bell stated he would be
inclined to allow an additional five feet of relief at the front, resulting in a 10-foot front setback.
Mr. Bell stated if the setback was increased back to 15 feet, the applicant would not be able to
build within the required line and agreed that the applicant needed some variance to make
development feasible. Mr. Bell stated a reasonable compromise would be to allow a 5 -foot
variance at the front and a 10-foot variance at the rear. The Board stated a compromise would
be to grant a 10 -foot variance to the rear setback and a 5 -foot variance to the front setback,
resulting in a 10-foot front yard setback, and indicated this would be a reasonable solution for
the property.
Chairman McGonigal called for a motion. He stated the Board had worked through the items
using a revised format and noted it was being reviewed to evaluate the process. Mr. Bell
motioned to approve BZA -26-09 because the applicant ha d demonstrated an unnecessary
hardship as proven by the City and as strictly stated here. The only additional comment would
be the applicant was only allowed a 10-foot setback on the front and a 5-foot setback to the rear
of the property line for the property itself . Mr. Bell clarified Mr. Reynolds would get a 5 -foot
setback variance on the front to bring it to a 10-foot setback and a 10-foot variance on the back
to bring it to a 5 -foot setback. Vice Chairwoman Lover proposed adding a stipulation to the
motion that required compliance with impervious surface requirements and noted this would
prevent the applicant from returning later for additional variances related to impervious surface
limits. The motion was seconded by Mr. Thomas. The motion to approve with conditions passed
7-0. Ms. Elmadolar stated for the record Wyman Wise was present and arrived late, making him
present for the vote.
B. BZA-26-18: Application by James Baldwin for variance to encroach into the required front
building setback with a projecting roof overhang at 1104 Highway 17 South zoned Highway
Commercial, HC District . Shep Guyton, representative for the applicant, stated the request
involved the former Sea Merchants Restaurant building, which predated both zoning and the
consolidation of North Myrtle Beach, and characterized the proposal as a renovation rather than
new construction. He stated the existing front wall would remain unchanged, but prior elements
5
such as a staircase and planter that previously extended into the right-of-way had been removed
when the roadway was widened. He further stated the proposal would increase the building
overhang from 24 inches to 36 inches, which would provide protection for floor -to-ceiling
windows and improve safety and weather protection for patrons entering and exiting the
restaurant.
Mr. Guyton stated he would address the criteria the Board used to evaluate whether a variance
should be granted. Mr. Guyton stated the ordinary, extraordinary, and exceptional conditions
pertaining to the property were related to the building’s age and its construction prior to the
zoning ordinances, and that subsequent widening of Highway 17 had further compacted the site,
particularly impacting vehicular circulation and existing parking improvements. He stated the
conditions were unique to the subject property because the restaurant was located closer to the
right-of-way than adjacent properties due to Highway 17 widening and noted the parking and
circulation requirements were more stringent than those for retail or other uses. In response to
the question of why the zoning regulation proposed for variance would prohibit or unreasonably
restrict utilization of the property, Mr. Guyton stated without the requested relief the restaurant
would be limited to a 24 -inch front overhang, which would unreasonably restrict use of the
building given the site constraints. He stated the additional overhang was needed to protect the
roof and windows, reduce stormwater impacts that could undermine the foundation, and provide
shelter for patrons entering and exiting the restaurant during inclement weather. In response to
the question of how authorization of the variance would be in harmony with the intent of the
zoning ordinance and would not be injurious to adjacent properties, the neighborhood, or the
general public, Mr. Guyton stated the variance impacted only the front setback adjacent to
Highway 17 and did not affect any neighboring properties. He stated the request was limited to
an overhang above pedestrian areas and would not interfere with access or use of the site
improvements. He further noted that overhangs were already permitted to encroach 24 inches,
and the request was for an additional 12 inches. In response to the question of how the variance
represented the minimum necessary for reasonable development of the site, Mr. Guyton stated
the proposed overhang was limited to 38 inches and constituted a relatively small encroachment
when compared to the overall pedestrian corridor it was intended to protect. Mr. Guyton stated
the requested variance would not confer any special privilege denied to other property owners
in the same zoning district, he noted buildings within the City commonly included overhangs and
the requested 12-inch additional encroachment was not excessive or out of character with other
buildings, particularly along the Highway 17 corridor.
Mr. Bell stated the original proposal submitted to the City indicated a request for a 38-inch front
overhang and clarified that the request would effectively result in a 14-inch variance rather than
12 inches. Mr. Guyton clarified they were requesting 14 inches not 12 inches. Vice-Chairwoman
Lover questioned whether the proposed front overhang was intended to provide shelter for
pedestrians or for patrons entering the building and asked whether a walkway would be located
in front of the windows. Mr. Guyton stated under the previous Sea Merchants layout, pedestrian
movement along the front had been obstructed by a planter and stairwell configuration, but
those elements had since been removed. He stated the revised design was developed in
coordination with staff to improve curb appeal along the Highway 17 corridor and included
landscaping and soft pathways to allow pedestrian access in and out of the building frontage.
Vice-Chairwoman Lover asked if there was a sidewalk along the front of the building. She
questioned how the proposed overhang would provide protection for restaurant visitors, she
noted there was no sidewalk at the front and the entrance door was located on the side rather
than the front. James Baldwin, applicant, came to the podium and stated Vice-Chairwoman Lover
was correct, that along the frontage of the building there were only windows. Mr. Baldwin stated
there would be a soft path, likely a pavered or grass pathway, through the landscaping to allow
patrons on the west side of the building to cross and enter the building on the east side. Vice-
6
Chairwoman Lover stated the proposed design would provide safer pedestrian movement by
allowing patrons to walk along the building without being exposed to adjacent traffic and noted
under rainy conditions individuals would be sheltered beneath the overhang. Chairman
McGonigal asked if there were any further questions for the applicant and or the public.
Mr. Caldwell read the description of the request, the ordinance, and recommended to hear the
variance. Chairman McGonigal asked how the Board should address the variance criteria given
the applicant had already addressed the hardship and related requirements, he referenced prior
discussion on evidentiary procedures and ask ed how the City should proceed from staff’s
perspective. Mr. Noury advised the Board could use the same set of questions previously applied
to evaluate the application. Mr. Caldwell asked Chairman McGonigal if he wanted him to say if
he agreed to the conditions presented and noted he was not prepared to come up with his own.
Chairman McGonigal responded he just wanted Mr. Caldwell to answer if the applicant had
addressed the comments. Mr. Caldwell stated that the ordinary, extraordinary, and exceptional
conditions pertaining to the property included the site's smaller size compared to many other
restaurant parcels along Highway 17 and its proximity to the front setback line. He further noted
the widening of Highway 17 had contributed to the site's constraints. Mr. Bell questioned
whether; in order to maintain parking requirements and grandfathered status, the applicant had
been required to keep the existing building footprint and whether removal of the structure had
been restricted. Mr. Caldwell stated he believed they met their parking requirements based on a
site plan that was submitted. Mr. Bell asked Mr. Baldwin if parking requirements were met and
Mr. Baldwin responded they did.
The Board and Mr. Caldwell discussed what had required the existing structure to be maintained,
noting if the building were demolished it would likely trigger new setback requirements. Mr.
Caldwell stated a full rebuild would require approximately 20 -foot setbacks, and noted the
existing structure was already close to that dimension. The Board and City staff clarified if the
property were fully redeveloped, it would be subject to approximately 20- foot front setbacks,
and staff confirmed the existing structure already met that setback. They further clarified the
requested variance did not affect the building footprint itself, but instead applied only to the
projecting roof overhang, which extended into the setback beyond what was permitted. Mr.
Caldwell confirmed the applicant requested approximately a 14-inch variance for the overhang.
Mr. Caldwell stated the conditions were unique to the subject property because of the location
of the existing building in relation to the front setback line and working with these conditions
provide unique challenges that other nearby properties may not have. Vice -Chairwoman Lover
asked Mr. Caldwell where he was reading from . Mr. Caldwell stated he was reading from the
application. Vice-Chairwoman Lover stated Mr. Caldwell was regurgitating what was on the
application.
The Board discussed an earlier training course and noted the Board was supposed to review the
request and not give evidence and stated Mr. Caldwell was the evidentiary. Vice-Chairwoman
Lover stated the Board was supposed to have a report from staff which they did not. The
Chairman stated the Board had already discussed the applicable requirements and noted this
portion of the hearing would serve as the evidentiary review by City staff. Vice-Chairwoman
Lover stated she interpreted the process differently, explaining that she believed City staff should
prepare an independent report and recommendation on whether the variance should be
approved or denied for the Board’s consideration. Mr. Caldwell stated many highway commercial
buildings constructed prior to the adoption of zoning had varying setback conditions, with some
meeting the required front setback and others exceeding it. He stated the subject property was
unique because it had been constructed pr ior to the adoption of the City's zoning regulations.
Mr. Caldwell stated that, given the unique conditions of the existing building and property, strict
application of the zoning ordinance would inhibit aesthetic improvements to the existing
7
structure. Vice-Chairwoman Lover questioned whether aesthetic improvements alone would
prohibit or unreasonably restrict utilization of the property, noting the building could still be used
as a restaurant without the requested variance.
Vice-Chairwoman Lover stated she supported approval of the overhang variance but noted that,
when the evidentiary criteria were applied, many variances could be interpreted similarly. The
Board discussed the property included an irregular lot shape, an older building, and impacts from
the widening of Highway 17 that altered the setback configuration and reduced usable area. Mr.
Farmer noted the original plan did not meet today’s landscape buffer requirements , but the
current project complied with the new 10-foot landscape buffer requirement. Mr. Bell stated they
could require the applicant to install access in front of the building for pedestrians that goes
under the overhang. Mr. Caldwell stated the owners were making substantial improvements to
the quality and aesthetics of the existing building and approval of the variance would contribute
to the overall aesthetics of the Highway 17 corridor. He stated while he agreed with those points
and believed the variance would not be injurious to adjacent properties, the neighborhood, or
the general public, he did not believe aesthetics alone constituted sufficient grounds for granting
the variance, though he considered the lack of adverse impact on surrounding properties to be
a relevant factor. Mr. Caldwell noted the owners had determined the requested overhang was
the minimum needed to achieve the desired aesthetics for the renovated building, and he
acknowledged this may be accurate; however, he stated it was not necessary for reasonable
development of the site.
The Board discussed the minimum variance under consideration was approximately 14 inches
and noted the proposed overhang provided benefits related to pedestrian safety, aesthetics, and
preservation of green space. They further stated adjacent properties, including Cole’s Jewelers,
were built close to the property line, and reiterated the request involved only an overhang rather
than a building expansion. They noted the case had become more difficult in light of recent legal
guidance affecting variance decisions and noted that Highway 17 widening had progressively
reduced usable space on the property while leaving the applicant subject to existing zoning
requirements. Mr. Wise asked if the overhang would have met regulations before the widening
of Highway 17. Mr. Caldwell stated his best answer was “probably”. Mr. Caldwell stated other
landowners may not have the same extraordinary conditions as the subject parcel and noted
extraordinary conditions had been demonstrated for this property. He further stated in a similar
situation on neighboring properties, the same request would likely be denied, and the overhang
would be required to comply with the 24 -inch standard. Mr. Thomas questioned whether
neighboring properties would be in a similar position regarding impacts from the Highway 17
right-of-way acquisition, he noted adjacent properties along the corridor, including nearby
commercial uses, could also be affected by roadway widening. Mr. Caldwell stated the zoning
ordinance allowed a 24-inch encroachment and any encroachment beyond that limit could not
be approved under the ordinance.
Mr. Caldwell asked whether the applicant could address the setback of the original building and
inquired whether there had previously been a staircase or other structure located at the front of
the building. Mr. Baldwin stated there was a staircase on the front and believed it encroached 2
feet into the setback. Mr. Caldwell stated with the renovation of a nonconforming structure, the
City did not require the building to be brought back to current setback lines and clarified the
structure could remain closer to Highway 17 than current setback requirements would otherwise
allow. Mr. Baldwin confirmed that statement was true if the staircase was included. The Board
and applicant confirmed the staircase was found on the exterior of the structure. Mr. Caldwell
stated stairs can encroach up to 3 feet into front setbacks. Mr. Bell noted a landscape buffer
would be maintained that didn’t exist before. Chairman McGonigal stated the removal of the
stairwells and related changes resulted in a 14 -inch overhang that improved the aesthetics of
8
the building. He stated the renovation worked within an existing footprint had been in place for
approximately 50 years and noted additional landscaping improvements complemented the
overall site design.
Mr. Bell motioned to approve BZA-26-18 because the applicant had demonstrated unnecessary
hardships. Specifically, there were extraordinary exceptional conditions pertaining to this
particular piece of property given the fact they did lose some of their frontage due to the
widening of Highway 17 which pushed their setback further back. They also maintained a 10-
foot landscape buffer through the process of rebuilding which didn’t exist before leading to a
more harmonious community. Additionally, the overhang will protect pedestrians walking from
the south side of the property back to the north side . These conditions do apply to other
properties in the vicinity. Because of the conditions , the application of the ordinance to the
particular piece of property would not prohibit or restrict the property but would also not be a
substantial detriment to adjacent properties or to the public good and the character of the district
wouldn’t be harmed by granting the variance. Mr. Bell added the applicant must maintain a
footpath under the overhang for pedestrians’ safe access, if they go through with the overhang.
The motion was seconded by Mr. Jones. The motion to approve passed 7-0.
C. BZA-26-19: Application by Roger Roy for a variance to encroach into the required rear yard at
9419 Long Meadow Way zoned Mid Rise Multifamily, R-2A District. Roger Roy, representative for
the applicant, stated the applicant was seeking a variance to construct a screened porch over an
existing rear patio and grill. He stated during the contractor’s measurements, it was determined
the proposed structure would encroach approximately three feet into the requi red setback. He
further stated the property was unique due to a pond located behind the lot and a public
easement along one side, which limited the number of adjacent properties affected. He stated
the proposed porch would not obstruct neighboring views of the pond and relocating the
structure to meet the setback would create a safety concern by placing it too close to the existing
gas grill and gas line. Mr. Roy presented a picture on his phone of the backyard. Mr. Roy stated
the requested three -foot variance would not encroach into the existing landscape buffer and
would extend only to the rear edge of the existing patio. He stated the three -foot request
represented the minimum variance necessary based on the location o f the existing patio. Mr.
Roy noted the proposed variance would not harm neighboring properties in the area. He further
stated the packet included a letter from the homeowner’s association which indicated support
for the request, provided that it received City approval and the necessary permits were obtained.
Vice-Chairwoman Lover asked how many houses were located on the lake, questioning the
assertion that the property presented a unique circumstance. Mr. Roy responded there were
probably 300 houses. Vice-Chairwoman Lover stated the condition was not unique or
exceptional, noting multiple nearby homes, at least ten visible along the lake, also backed up to
the same pond, and therefore the presence of the pond did not distinguish the subject property
from surrounding parcels. Vice Chairwoman Lover and Mr. Roy discussed whether the presence
of a pond constituted a unique circumstance for the property. Vice Chairwoman Lover stated
that, based on her review of the neighborhood, multiple properties also backed up to the pond
and the condition did not appear unique under the statutory requirement. Mr. Roy responded
there were differing interpretations of the legal standard being applied.
Mr. Roy responded to Mr. Bell that the concrete pad was poured two years prior, and the owners
bought the house with the concrete pad already existing. Mr. Roy and Mr. Bell discussed the
existing patio pad had been constructed at the rear of the property during or shortly after
construction and the applicant intended to enclose it to improve usability due to intense
afternoon sun exposure. They further stated the proposal would enclose the existing patio on all
sides. Vice-Chairwoman Lover questioned the safety rationale for enclosing the grill area, stating
9
that covering the grill could trap smoke and increase the risk of it entering the structure or
creating a fire hazard, and asked how the enclosure would improve safety compared to leaving
the area uncovered. Mr. Roy stated the proposed structure would extend three feet into the
setback and if required to meet the setback line, it would be positioned approximately three feet
from the existing grill. He stated this limited separation would leave a very small space between
the grill and the proposed structure. Vice Chairwoman Lover questioned how close the proposed
structure would be to the back of the grill, she noted the grill appeared to be located near the
edge of the existing patio and a wall or enclosure could place the structure closer than three
feet. Mr. Roy responded the structural support for the screened enclosure would not be placed
behind the grill but stated if adjustments were required the structural corners would still define
the enclosure footprint and noted that the screen system would be part of the overall structure.
Vice-Chairwoman Lover stated the justification being presented felt inconsistent with the
photographs and plat of the property and the safety rationale for enclosing the grill appeared
questionable. She stated a covered grill area did not seem safer than an uncovered one and
questioned whether locating the structure at the edge of the patio was necessary, suggesting
instead that the structure could be set back further by three feet. Mr. Roy stated the applicant
wanted to cover the entire patio. Vice -Chairwoman Lover stated she didn’t see there was a
hardship. She stated the applicant could have enclosed the area within the allowable 17- foot
setback without requiring a variance and noted the applicant had poured the patio and later
chose to extend it into the setback area. Vice-Chairwoman Lover stated the applicant could have
constructed a patio within the allowable 17-foot setback without requiring a variance and noted
the applicant instead chose to extend the patio into the setback area, which created the need
for relief. Mr. Roy stated the proposed patio was a paver surface rather than a concrete pad and
noted that, while it functioned as an impervious surface due to the pavers, it was not a traditional
concrete installation. Mr. Bell stated the site plan indicated the patio was constructed of concrete.
Mr. Roy stated the patio was constructed of pavers. Vice Chairwoman Lover referenced the
application, which stated a roof would be installed over the existing concrete patio. Chairman
McGonigal asked if there were any more questions for the applicant and if there were any
interested parties wanting to speak.
Mr. Caldwell read the description of the request, the ordinance, and recommended to hear the
variance. Mr. Caldwell stated there were no zoning regulations for building a screen porch over
a grill and mentioned the Fire Marshall may have a comment. Mr. Wise questioned whether,
even if the roof were extended, a variance would still be required . Mr. Caldwell stated the roof
overhang was permitted to extend two feet into the required setback, while the structure could
not extend as far as desired under that allowance, it could still be built to an 18-foot rear setback
with the roof overhang included. The Board and Mr. Caldwell discussed whether a variance would
be necessary if the structure were limited to a roof over the patio without enclosure. Mr. Caldwell
stated a variance could potentially be granted for a roofed structure without enclosing the space,
while he also noted that such a roof overhang may already be permissible within existing setback
allowances. Mr. Caldwell clarified the three-foot variance request applied to the screened room
enclosure rather than the roof overhang alone. Mr. Bell stated theoretically, only a one -foot
variance would be required if the project were limited to a roof structure alone, and he noted a
roof could be constructed without enclosing the space. Mr. Roy stated he had not discussed the
matter with Mr. Heard and noted whatever variance the Board decided to grant would need to
be followed by the applicant. He further stated if a variance were not granted, the applicant
would need to revise the proposal and pursue an alternative approach.
Chairman McGonigal asked if anyone was prepared to make a motion. Vice -Chairwoman Lover
stated her motion would be to deny and stated if another member wished to make an alternative
motion, they could propose approval with a one -foot variance or another amount deemed
10
appropriate. Mr. Bell stated he would not make a motion since he made several motions already.
Vice-Chairwoman Lover stated she would make a motion, and the Board can vote no or yes.
Vice-Chairwoman Lover motioned to deny BZA-26-19 as the applicant had not demonstrated a
hardship. The applicant ha d not demonstrated extraordinary and exceptional conditions
pertaining to his particular piece of property. The cited pond as a condition does apply to other
people in the vicinity and the application of the ordinance would not prohibit or unreasonably
restrict the utilization of the property. The granting of the variance could be a detriment to the
adjacent property or the public good due to a possible fire hazard. The motion was seconded by
Mr. Bell. The Board discussed differing opinions regarding whether the presence of a pond
constituted a unique condition. Some members stated similar conditions existed on multiple
nearby properties and therefore did not appear to be exceptional, while others stated water-
adjacent properties could be considered unique within the broader context of the area. The
Board further discussed the applicant could construct a roof without enclosing the structure
without requiring a variance, but noted the applicant was seeking an enclosed screened structure
rather than a roof alone. Mr. Caldwell stated posts could be set at the 20-foot setback line and
the roof overhang could then extend an additional two feet into the required setback toward the
rear. The motion to deny passed 5-2. Chairman McGonigal and Mr. Thomas voted nay.
Chairman McGonigal called for a motion to adjourn. The motion to adjourn was made by Mr. Reaves and
seconded by Mr. Thomas. The motion passed 7-0. The meeting adjourned at 6:11 PM.
Respectfully submitted,
Amber Elmadolar
Plan Reviewer
NOTE: BE ADVISED THAT THESE MINUTES REPRESENT A SUMMARY OF THE BOARD OF ZONING
APPEALS MEETING AND ARE NOT INTENDED TO REPRESENT A FULL TRANSCRIPT OF THE MEETING.
Source: City of North Myrtle Beach website. First collected Oct 13, 2026.