_05142026-536
City of North Myrtle Beach · Horry County · meeting of May 14, 2026 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of North Myrtle Beach
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
1
CITY OF NORTH MYRTLE BEACH, SOUTH CAROLINA
NORTH MYRTLE BEACH CITY HALL
BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS MEETING
Thursday, May 14, 2026
5:00 PM
MINUTES
William McGonigal, Chairman City Staff:
Cynthia Lover, Vice-Chairwoman Ben Caldwell, Zoning Administrator
Mendel Bell Elton Farmer, Zoning Technician
Norfleet Jones Chris Noury, City Attorney
Joe Reaves Amber Elmadolar, Plan Reviewer
Andy Thomas
Wyman Wise
1. CALL TO ORDER & ROLL CALL: Chairman McGonigal called the meeting to order at 5:00 PM. Ms.
Elmadolar called roll.
2. APPROVAL OF MEETING MINUTES: Chairman McGonigal called for a motion to approve the
minutes of the March 12, 2026, meeting. The motion was made by Mr. Bell and seconded by Mr.
Jones. The motion to approve passed 7-0. Chairman McGonigal called for a motion to approve the
minutes of the April 9, 2026, meeting. The motion was made by Mr. Wise and seconded by Mr.
Thomas. Chairman McGonigal abstained due to being absent at the previous meeting. The motion to
approve passed 6-0.
3. COMMUNICATION: Mr. Caldwell reported the only communication from the City concerned
nominations for the positions of Chai r and Vice Chai r. Mr. Bell motioned to nominate William
McGonigal as Chairman and Cynthia Lover as Vice -Chairwoman and was seconded by Mr. Reeves.
The motion passed 7-0.
4. SWEAR IN THOSE PERSONS TO SPEAK: Ms. Elmadolar swore in persons to speak at the meeting.
5. NEW BUSINESS:
A. BZA-26-07: Application by James Baldwin for a variance to remove trees in excess of 24’’ in
diameter at 1702 Springland Drive. Mr. Bell and Mr. Wise stated they would recuse themselves
for this item. Chairman McGonigal stated they were down to a body of five so Mr. Roy would
need three votes for any approval. Roger Roy, applicant, stated he was willing to go forward.
Mr. Roy stated the original request sought approval to remove three trees totaling 136 inches in
diameter. Revised site plans were prepared to relocate the proposed building and preserve those
trees. The revised request was seeking approval to remove two trees totaling 72 inches in
diameter. Mr. Roy explained the trees were located within the proposed building footprint and
driveway construction area. The existing structures to be replaced were outdated and needed
renovation. Relocating the building closer to the parking lot was identified as the least intrusive
alternative and minimized tree removal compared to rebuilding within the existing footprints or
relocating the structure elsewhere on the property. Mr. Roy noted the Surf Club property
encompassed approximately 168 acres and contained a substantial number of hardwood trees.
The Surf Club maintained an annual tree maintenance program and emphasized its commitment
to preserving trees on the property. Mr. Roy further stated the proposed development would not
2
adversely affect neighboring properties and the request was intended to facilitate facility
improvements rather than financial gain. Mr. Roy concluded that removal of the two trees was
necessary to complete the proposed improvements while minimizing impacts to the site's natural
resources.
Chairman McGonigal stated he had visited the site on multiple occasions with the applicant to
review various design alternatives. He noted his appreciation for the revised plan, which
relocated the building and preserved two large oak trees on the golf course. Chairman McGonigal
asked whether photographs of the trees proposed for removal were available for the Board's
review. Mr. Roy presented photographs of the trees proposed for removal and identified their
locations within the site. Mr. Roy stated one tree was a 40-inch diameter white oak and the other
was a 32-inch diameter live oak. In response to a question from Chairman McGonigal, Mr. Roy
clarified the two trees identified for removal were not located on the golf course. Mr. Roy stated
the trees were located in the area near the road entrance by the backdrop, in the vicinity of the
former starter shed. He further noted the originally discussed three trees were located behind
the starter shed in that same general area. Chairman McGonigal confirmed the two larger oak
trees previously referenced were located on the golf course and described them as “gorgeous,”
noting the visual impact of removing the trees had been a key concern during the review.
Chairman McGonigal expressed appreciation that the applicant was able to revise the plan to
preserve those trees. Mr. Roy confirmed the two trees mentioned were the same two trees
previously discussed by the Board. The applicant stated photographs were taken only of those
two trees located along the drive and clarified the trees located behind the starter shed were not
part of the current request and will remain.
Mr. Roy asked if the Board had the recent drawing submittal. Vice-Chairwoman Lover expressed
confusion regarding the drawing and stated she believed she had an old drawing. Mr. Roy
described the site plan, identifying Springland Drive and the driveway leading into the parking
lot near the backdrop. He stated the two trees proposed for removal were located within the
island along the driveway. He further noted other previously discussed trees were located in
different areas of the site. It was discussed that the drawing in the package was the original
submittal and there had since been a new drawing submitted two weeks prior to the meeting.
Vice-Chairwoman Lover stated, when deciding, it was important to ensure the materials in the
meeting packet match the drawings being presented on the screen, so all parties reviewed and
discussed the same information. She emphasized the need for consistency between the
submitted package and the displayed plans. Mr. Roy confirmed the building footprint had been
shifted forward on the site plan to the area of the first tree shown in green. He acknowledged
this was the proposed location of the building footprint.
Vice-Chairwoman Lover commented, given the density of mature trees throughout the site, it
would be difficult to construct a new building without impacting some trees. She noted the
property contain ed many large, mature trees and stated an inability to identify alternative
suitable locations for the proposed structure. Vice-Chairwoman Lover expressed appreciation for
the revised plan, particularly the decision to preserve three significant trees that were initially
proposed for removal. Mr. Roy stated one of the defining characteristics of the Surf Club was the
large number of oak trees on the property. He emphasized preserving these trees was part of
the site’s culture and natural character and noted tree conservation was an ongoing priority in
the management of the property. Mr. Roy responded to Mr. Thomas’s inquiry regarding the
number of hardwood trees on the property, stating there were more than 10,000 hardwoods
3
within the Surf Club property. Chairman McGonigal stated the applicant had done a good job
revising the site plan and relocating the building to better preserve the two significant trees. He
noted that Board members had all viewed the trees in question, which contributed to the decision
to revisit the original plan and explore alternative layouts. Chairman McGonigal further
commented, shifting the building footprint appeared to be an improvement in placement, even
though some tree removal would still occur.
Mr. Caldwell read the description of the request, the ordinance, and recommended to hear the
variance. Chairman McGonigal asked if there were questions for the City and Mr. Roy. Mr. Roy
stated, if a tree replacement schedule was required, the Surf Club requests a three -year
timeframe to complete it. He explained a third phase of the project was planned, and additional
opportunities for tree planting may be available at that time. He noted when the remaining
building structures were removed in the future phase, additional green space will be created,
which may be suitable for new tree plantings. Chairman McGonigal asked for public comment.
Chairman McGonigal called for a motion. Vice-Chairwoman Lover asked what the Board was
thinking regarding replacement. Chairman McGonigal stated his opinion that, if a tree
replacement requirement was imposed, it should include a defined timeframe for replanting. He
noted, given the scale of the proposed renovation work to the clubhouse, including phased
construction and removal of existing structures, there w ould likely be significant areas where
trees were removed. He suggested a future phase of redevelopment could provide appropriate
opportunities for replanting and restoring green space. Mr. Roy stated the clubhouse renovation
was planned as the next phase of the project and was anticipated to take approximately three
years to initiate. Mr. Roy noted this phase would present a suitable opportunity to incorporate
new tree plantings around the clubhouse area as part of the overall redevelopment. Chairman
McGonigal noted the large number of mature oak trees and suggested future phases of
redevelopment, including the clubhouse work, could provide opportunities to plant additional
trees and asked the City their thoughts on replacement timeline. Mr. Caldwell stated the Board
could put conditions on the approval.
Vice-Chairwoman Lover motioned to approve BZA -26-07 with the requirement they replant 74
inches of white oak trees or pay $22,000 into the tree bank or any combination thereof and that
they have three years to complete the replacement project. The motion w as seconded by Mr.
Jones. The motion to approve passed 5-0.
B. BZA-26-09: Application by Jonathan Reynolds for a variance of the required building setbacks
at 1205 Perrin Drive, TMS#357112040061 in the Resort Residential, R -4 District. Mr. Reynolds
stated he was considering adjustments to the setbacks due to the irregular shape of the lot in
an effort to better accommodate placement of a house on the property. Vice-Chairwoman Lover
requested clarification on the specific variance being requested, noting the standard setbacks
were 15 feet in the front and rear and 5 feet on the sides. She asked the applicant to identify
exactly which setback variances were being sought for the proposal. Mr. Reynolds stated at
present, he was uncertain of the exact variance needed, noting the irregular, triangular shape
of the lot made placement difficult. He suggested a reduced setback on the roadside, potentially
to a five -foot setback , may be necessary to accommodate construction of a house on the
property. Mr. Reynolds stated he was comfortable with the side and rear setbacks and was
primarily seeking additional flexibility to shift the house within the lot to achieve a workable
placement. Vice-Chairwoman Lover stated the applicant needed to be more specific. Mr. Thomas
noted the applicant was a good candidate for a variance, but the Board needed plans to make a
4
ruling. Mr. Reynolds stated he did have a survey. The Board noted they had the survey but
needed clarification on the variance request. The Board requested the applicant prepare a site
plan showing a proposed house on the lot, including a plot plan with setbacks clearly identified
on all sides. The Board explained they needed a specific layout to evaluate the request accurately
and determine exact setback variances for each side of the irregularly shaped lot. The Board and
the applicant discussed postponing the request to next month. Chairman McGonigal asked if they
needed to hear from the City or if they could just postpone the request.
Mr. Thomas motioned to postpone BZA-26-09. The motion was seconded by Mr. Bell. The motion
to postpone passed 7-0.
C. BZA-26-11: Application by Cameron Parker for variance to remove a tree exceeding 24" at
1802 South Ocean Boulevard. Chairman McGonigal recused himself and asked Vice-Chairwoman
Lover to take over. Shep Guyton introduced himself and the landscape architect, Greg
Duckworth, and noted the Board had previously reviewed the p roject and provided feedback.
Mr. Guyton stated the requested variances stemmed from conditions unique to the property and
prior project modifications. Mr. Guyton explained the project design had been influenced by three
primary factors: the removal of a proposed four-story parking structure in response to concerns
from neighboring properties and the City, the dedication of a portion of the property for public
use, and efforts to preserve as many existing trees as possible. Mr. Guyton stated the subject
lot was bounded by roadways on two sides, limiting the developable area. He noted a
discrepancy in the project documents regarding the size of a mature tree located within the
center of a proposed drive aisle, explaining the civil plans identified the tree as 24.5 inches in
diameter while the landscape plans identified it as 33 inches in diameter. Mr. Guyton stated staff
had confirmed the tree measured 33 inches in diameter. To preserve other significant trees
around the perimeter of the site, Mr. Guyton requested approval to remove the tree subject to
the required mitigation measures. Mr. Guyton acknowledged the multiple parcels involved in the
project made the request difficult to follow and noted the site plan would be displayed to clearly
identify the specific lot under consideration. He stated the tree was located within the center of
the proposed drive aisle. Mr. Guyton requested approval to remove the tree, subject to the
required mitigation schedule, explaining that removal of the single tree would allow preservation
of the remaining trees located along the perimeter of the lot and would result in greater overall
tree retention on the site.
Vice-Chairwoman Lover noted the project had become confusing due to the number of parcels
involved and referenced the lot designated as 1802 South Ocean Boulevard. She asked whether
the subject lot was the parcel that currently contains the construction office building, described
as the white house on the property. Mr. Guyton stated that was on the rear and was one of the
third-row lots. Vice-Chairwoman Lover stated she remained confused about the location of the
subject property, noting she had recently visited the site and observed the white building
currently being used as a construction office which displayed the address 1802 on the front of
the building. She stated concern, based on her review, the tree proposed for removal did not
appear to be located on the lot identified as 1802 South Ocean Boulevard. Vice-Chairwoman
Lover noted the variance application specifically referenced that parcel and questioned whether
the tree in question was actually within its boundaries. She stated she needed to confirm the
correct addresses, tax map numbers, and tree locations, noting confusion after a site visit and
uncertainty about whether the tree proposed for removal was actually within the boundaries of
1802 South Ocean Boulevard.
Mr. Guyton placed the proposed plan on the projector and explained the lots in question were
the ocean front lot, two second-row parcels, and two third-row parcels, all while Mr. Duckworth
pointed to the parcels on the projector. Vice-Chairwoman Lover asked if they were only here for
5
the variance at 1802 South Ocean Boulevard. Mr. Guyton clarified the project involved a series
of variance applications, which had previously been combined but were separated for clarity. He
stated the specific variance under discussion pertained only to the removal of a 33-inch tree. Mr.
Caldwell stated it may be helpful for clarity to note the white building on the site would be
removed as part of the future parking lot construction. Vice-Chairwoman Lover requested
clarification on how far the 1802 South Ocean Boulevard parcel extended, specifically whether
the adjacent sand lot with trees was included within the property boundaries. Mr. Caldwell stated
the property consisted of four lots in a row, with the first lot containing the white building and
the remaining three being vacant. Mr. Guyton confirmed all four lots were considered part of
1802 South Ocean Boulevard and noted the plan showed the former lot lines prior to
consolidation. Mr. Guyton stated the trees shown at the top of the page were the ones being
referenced and emphasized that every effort had been made to preserve them. Vice-Chairwoman
Lover asked about the smaller live oak trees on the site that were not classified as protected and
requested clarification on the applicant’s plan for those trees.
Greg Duckworth, landscape architect for the project, stated the lot contains a significant number
of trees with high aesthetic value due to their windswept, sculptural character. He noted while
some of the trees were smaller and not technically protected, they contribute to the overall
character of the site as a cohesive group. He explained the design approach aimed to preserve
these trees collectively, emphasizing their value lies in their overall arrangement and mat ure
natural form rather than individual size classifications. Mr. Duckworth stated the project had
been designed with a one-way circulation pattern and a staggered, sawtooth parking layout to
maximize preservation of existing trees and green space. He noted areas shown in gray on the
plan represented canopy protection zones and wo uld utilize a permeable, dust -free aggregate
surface to support root health by allowing water and oxygen to reach the soil. He explained the
intent of the design was to improve long -term tree survival by avoiding full asphalt coverage
around tree trunks and instead maintaining more natural conditions where possible. While
acknowledging that some tree removal was unavoidable, he stated the proposal would preserve
the majority of significant sculptural trees on the site. He further stated the variance request was
limited to the removal of one tree that exceeds the size threshold requiring Board approval, and
its removal would allow for the preservation of the remaining trees within the parking layout.
Mr. Duckworth stated the tree in question was located within a proposed drive aisle and this
constraint led to its removal from the final design layout. He explained the project would use a
gravel binder system designed for use around trees, which creates a dust-free, highly permeable
surface that allows water and oxygen to reach tree roots while supporting both pedestrian and
vehicle use. He described the product as ADA-compliant and suitable for preserving tree health
by reducing soil compaction compared to traditional asphalt. Mr. Duckworth added the material
had been recently discussed with a manufacturer’s representative and would be used in the
aggregate surface areas shown on the plan.
Mr. Bell asked whether parking stalls had been removed from the plan in order to preserve the
trees and requested clarification on how many parking spaces would be lost as a result of the
revised layout. Mr. Duckworth stated the original civil engineering plan included 72 parking stalls
and the revised design resulted in the loss of one stall. He explained the prior layout was a two-
way drive aisle that was overly constrained and maximized asphalt coverage, and it did not
adequately accommodate landscaping or code considerations. He stated the revised one -way
circulation plan was developed to improve functionality, meet requirements, and better integrate
tree preservation and site design. Mr. Duckworth explained the tree in the request was the one
with the dark circle and “X” through it. He stated the plan was coded to meet Board of Zoning
6
Appeals criteria and two additional trees shown with lighter symbols were protected trees that
did not require BZA review. Mr. Duckworth noted the current exhibit was not a final landscape
plan, but rather a parking and tree protection layout intended for review purposes. He further
stated additional trees would be incorporated along Ocean Boulevard, within interior areas, and
in landscape buffers during final design and staff approval. Mr. Duckworth emphasized the
current focus of the request was the preservation of existing trees on the site and additional
landscaping would be provided in future design phases. Vice-Chairwoman Lover stated concern
whether approval of the variance for removal of the 33-inch tree would result in preservation of
all remaining trees shown on the plan and asked whether that outcome was reflected in the
proposed design.
Mr. Duckworth stated trees marked with circles were those to be preserved, while trees marked
with an “X” were identified for removal where necessary to accommodate parking and drive aisle
improvements. He explained the design represented a balancing effort to maintain as many
existing trees as possible while still achieving required parking and circulation. He noted some
smaller trees fall within proposed drive aisles or parking areas, contributing to unavoidable
removals. He further stated additional landscaping, and replacement plantings would be
developed in later design phases once approvals were secured. Mr. Duckworth confirmed that
circled trees represented those intended to be saved. Mr. Bell noted the plan appeared to
preserve approximately 34 trees . Mr. Duckworth explained the dashed lines represented tree
protection areas rather than full canopy limits. He further stated, aside from the trees specifically
marked for preservation, the remaining trees identified with an “X” could be removed, and
confirmed their understanding that, under the plan, the site could otherwise be largely cleared
except for the one protected tree. Mr. Duckworth stated in their view, the project represented a
good-faith effort to create a high -quality design and would likely result in one of the more
attractive oceanfront commercial parking lots if approved. Vice-Chairwoman Lover stated
conditions could be placed on any approved variance and expressed support for conditioning
approval of the 33-inch tree removal on preservation of the remaining trees shown on the plan.
She emphasized concern about ensuring remaining trees would not be removed later without
additional approval and indicated intent to require preservation of all other trees as depicted.
Mr. Duckworth stated agreement with the proposed conditions to preserve the remaining trees
shown on the plan, noting the developer had already taken extensive measures to protect them.
He emphasized no intent to remove additional preserved trees after approval and supported
including the preservation requirement as a formal condition of approval.
Mr. Guyton requested clarification of the proposed condition, stating the preservation
requirement should apply only to the trees shown as protected or proposed for retention on the
plan, not all remaining trees on the site. Vice-Chairwoman Lover stated an example condition for
approval, indicating the variance could be granted provided removal would be limited to trees
marked with hard “X” symbols on the plan. She estimated approximately 28 trees were identified
for removal. Mr. Duckworth stated many trees marked with “X” were smaller trees, with some
that appeared dead but still included on the survey and Vice-Chairwoman Lover added several
cedar trees also appeared to be in poor condition.
Mr. Caldwell read the description of the request, the ordinance, and recommended to hear the
variance. Vice-Chairwoman Lover asked what tree replacement would be required under City
ordinances for two non-protected trees proposed for removal, and Mr. Caldwell responded the
required replacement amount would be 16 inches. Vice-Chairwoman Lover asked whether
7
replacement trees would be required for any additional trees marked for removal. Mr. Caldwell
responded trees measuring 16 inches in diameter or greater would require replacement at 50%
of their diameter and noted no landscape plan had been submitted at that time. Vice-
Chairwoman Lover invited comments from the audience and asked whether any individuals
wishing to speak had been sworn in. She instructed those wishing to provide testimony to come
forward, be sworn in, and state their name for the record.
Ms. Elmadolar swore in a member of the public planning to speak and asked them to sign in if
they did not. A gentleman in the back of the room asked a question pertaining to the number of
parking spaces for the project. Vice-Chairwoman Lover clarified the 71–72 parking spaces shown
on the subject lot represented only a portion of the overall parking plan and the full project
would provide 219 parking spaces, with approximately 71– 72 spaces located on the lot under
consideration. The speaker asked whether current staging areas would be converted into parking
and whether the parking would be ground level rather than a multi-story garage.
Jimmy Michael, 1800 and 1804 Perrin Drive, stated he had lived across from the site since the
mid-1970s and had observed the trees for decades. He expressed opposition to the proposed
tree removals, stating many trees exceed 8 inches in diameter and were marked for removal on
the plan. He estimated approximately 18 trees on the subject sheet and stated the total removal
across all four lots could approach 30 trees. He further stated concerns regarding compliance
with the oceanfront overlay zoning requirements. He stated this project would remove closer to
30 trees for all four parking lots . He asserted parking is not permitted on the third and fourth
rows within the overlay district and stated the ordinance requires parking to be located within
300 feet of the principal site. He further stated, in his opinion, portions of the proposed parking
lot exceed that 300-foot distance. Mr. Michael stated opposition to the proposed tree removal,
noting long-term familiarity with the site and concern the trees provide protection and separation
from the roadway. He stated removal would significantly alter neighborhood character and
expressed concern about increased visibility and density impacts if the trees were removed. Mr.
Michael further stated the project should maintain neighborhood characteristics and minimize
development intensity. He also referenced neighborhood opposition and indicated some
residents would prefer a parking garage over expanded surface parking.
The Board discussed tree protection requirements and noted only trees over 24 inches in
diameter were protected under City ordinance. The Board considered how the variance request
for the 33-inch tree fit within the overall site plan and tree removal strategy, including potential
implications for removal of additional unprotected trees on the property. Mr. Michael stated no
hardship existed for the applicant, he noted a permit had already been issued for a parking
garage. He further expressed belief that the proposal was financially motivated rather than based
on necessity. Vice-Chairwoman Lover stated the only item before the Board was the 33-inch tree
variance and expressed concern that denial of the variance could allow the applicant to remove
remaining trees on the lot without additional restrictions. She further stated City code only
protected trees over 24 inches in diameter and noted the intent of the proposal was to preserve
more trees overall by allowing removal of a single tree. Mr. Michael noted he was cutting down
16 other trees. Mr. Thomas noted the owner and applicant can do that. Mr. Bell stated City
ordinance allows removal of trees under 16 inches in diameter, provided replacement equals 50
percent of the removed diameter or payment was made into the City Tree Fund.
8
Vice-Chairwoman Lover stated the current tree ordinance left limited protection for smaller trees
and noted concern that larger specimen trees often become the focus of variance requests while
smaller trees may be removed without restriction. She referenced common development
scenarios where tree placement conflicts with proposed building layouts and explained the legal
limitations on denying development rights. She stated the intent of the discussion was to balance
approval of the 33-inch tree removal with conditions intended to preserve the remaining trees
on the site. Mr. Thomas stated trees marked with circles would be preserved, primarily those
along the perimeter. Vice-Chairwoman Lover noted preservation of those trees would maintain
a visual buffer in front of nearby homes and contrasted the proposal with a potential alternative
of a multi-story parking structure. Mr. Michael stated zoning on the subject area was R-4 and
noted a separate area previously rezoned to RC for a parking garage project. He referenced prior
City correspondence regarding the rezoning process and stated the original plan included retail
uses at ground level, which the speaker believed had changed after permits were obtained. Vice-
Chairwoman Lover stated the original plan may have required a parking garage due to limited
land acquisition, and suggested later acquisition of adjacent parcels allowed a revised surface
parking design. She further noted general community opposition to parking garages near
residential areas and referenced similar structures in nearby communities. Mr. Michaels
expressed concern about pedestrian safety and traffic impacts, stating the proposed parking
areas would increase vehicle movement along 18th Avenue, a primary access route to the beach,
and create conflicts between vehicles and pedestrians. Vice-Chairwoman Lover asked the City
whether public beach access with golf cart parking required a direct roadway or pedestrian path
alignment across Ocean Boulevard to allow safe crossing to the beach. Vice-Chairwoman Lover
asked whether a direct roadway or pedestrian connection was required across Ocean Boulevard
for the proposed beach access. She noted uncertainty regarding how low-speed vehicle parking
spaces would function along the roadway and asked how the parking arrangement would comply
with City requirements . Mr. Caldwell stated preliminary drawings had been reviewed but
indicated revised drawings may still be forthcoming. He confirmed the site plan had not yet been
approved.
Vice-Chairwoman Lover stated confusion regarding applicable rules and emphasized focus on
the specific lot and the single tree under consideration for the variance request. Mr. Thomas
noted the discussion pertained specifically to the variance request for the identified lot and tree
and emphasized the matter under consideration. Vice-Chairwoman Lover stated agreement with
Mr. Thomas, noting the Board was considering a single zoning request for one lot and expressing
intent to preserve as many trees as possible on the site. Mr. Michaels stated the proposal should
be evaluated in its entirety rather than only the individual request, noting potential issues across
the broader project concept that should be considered before any vote. Vice-Chairwoman Lover
acknowledged the concerns raised but stated the Board must review each request individually
and he explained decisions must be made one variance at a time. Mr. Bell noted there were
several separate parcels with different PIN numbers, and because of that, they don’t have the
ability to vote on them as whole. Mr. Bell stated the Board’s goal was to preserve as many trees
on the property as possible and explained the decision centered on whether to approve removal
of the 33 -inch tree or require it to remain while the remaining trees could be removed. Vice-
Chairwoman Lover noted concerns raised by the public were part of the record but emphasized
the Board’s task was limited to reviewing the single lot and tree variance, with intent to preserve
as many trees as possible on the site.
9
Vice-Chairwoman Lover asked if the speaker ha d been sworn in. Ms. Puffer stated she did not
have to be sworn in since she was not giving testimony. Ms. Puffer asked whether Chairman
Billy McGonigal was associated with the project, she expressed concern about a potential conflict
of interest and request ed clarification regarding his role in the matter under review. Vice-
Chairwoman Lover stated she did believe the Chairman had a financial investment in the project.
Ms. Puffer asked for clarification if Billy McGonigal, the Chairperson of the BZA, was involved in
the project and stated they were at the peril of his project. She noted he was a person who
serves on this committee and again stated she was asking for clarification. She stated she wanted
to make sure for the record; “everybody knows that the Chairperson of the BZA was putting us
in this situation where the community members were asking for help and consideration” . She
asked if the Board was going to figure out a way to help. Vice-Chairwoman Lover stated the
Chairman had recused himself. The Board, Mr. Noury and Ms. Puffer had a discussion regarding
the issues and the Chairman. Vice-Chairwoman Lover advised Ms. Puffer to be sworn in to testify.
Ms. Puffer swore herself in by stating “I swear to tell the whole truth and nothing but the truth.
So, help me God.” Ms. Puffer stated the comments were a question rather than testimony and
asserted a right to speak as a taxpaying citizen. She asked whether the Chairperson was Billy
McGonigal. It was confirmed that he was.
Ms. Puffer asked Mr. Noury if he wanted to step outside to continue the conversation. Vice-
Chairwoman Lover noted Ms. Puffer asked her question and the Board clarified the Chairman
had an interest in the property, which is why he recused himself. Mr. Wise asked Ms. Puffer if
she had any interest in the area. Ms. Puffer stated she lived in North Myrtle Beach, and the
project was going to affect the City as a whole. She stated the question asked was chastising.
Mr. Wise clarified he was unsure if Ms. Puffer lived in the area. Ms. Puffer stated she had watched
and listened to the citizens come and ask for help, while the Board pandered to the citizens. Mr.
Bell stated the Board was not pandering and Ms. Puffer made an assertion without factual basis
and noted clarification had been provided in response. Mr. Bell further stated the Chairperson of
the BZA was identified during the discussion.
Vice-Chairwoman Lover called for a motion. Mr. Bell stated he wanted to ask Mr. Guyton a few
questions to clarify the hardship. Mr. Bell asked the applicant to clarify project hardships and
design intent, noting traffic on both sides of the property as a safety concern and referenced prior
testimony. He stated the plan included a one -way circulation pattern to maximize usable space
while preserving trees identified for retention. He further noted the use of permeable surfaces to
support tree health and oxygenation of remaining trees. Mr. Guyton confirmed the one-way traffic
design, affirmed efforts to preserve trees and use permeable materials, and stated no trees would
be removed except those marked with an “X” on the plan. Mr. Bell stated the intent was to verify
and place the discussion on the record, noting a desire to ensure all parties were aligned on the
stated conditions and understanding of the plan. Mr. Guyton stated the project included 169
rooms, which resulted in a requirement for 170 standard parking spaces. The applicant explained
the proposed 219 parking spaces exceeded the requirement, and noted the additional spaces
were not required under dimensional standards applicable to the project. Mr. Guyton stated he
would address any questions from the Board, not the audience. Mr. Bell asked whether any
restaurant used on the property would be accommodated by the additional parking spaces. Mr.
Guyton confirmed the available parking would cover additional patrons associated with restaurant
activity. Vice-Chairwoman Lover stated trees shown as preserved along Perrin Drive would
function as a visual buffer for nearby residences. She suggested adding a condition to the variance
requiring additional landscaping along Perrin Drive to enhance screening and reduce direct
10
visibility of vehicles from adjacent homes. Mr. Duckworth stated acceptance of the proposed
stipulation while noting the City’s landscape ordinance would already require installation of plant
material along Perrin Drive. He explained the design would include additional landscaping beneath
the preserved trees to create an enhanced buffer between the roadway and the parking areas.
Mr. Duckworth confirmed they would be required by the landscaping ordinance to add additional
shrubbery and green space along Perrin Drive. He noted the existing trees would create a natural
framework for sweeping planting bed lines along Perrin Drive. He explained the understory
landscaping would include a mix of evergreen and shade -tolerant plantings, along with lower -
growing ground covers, creating an attractive visual edge between the parking area and the
roadway.
Vice-Chairwoman Lover asked whether the subject lot was located within the coastal overlay
zone, she referenced comments made by Mr. Michael. Mr. Caldwell stated he believed the coastal
overlay zone only covers the oceanfront lots and he did not have the map in front of him to
confirm. Vice-Chairwoman Lover asked whether landscaping requirements differed within the
coastal overlay zone. Staff responded State requirements app lied regarding planting relative to
coastal zone boundaries, but no planting was required across those lines. Vice-Chairwoman Lover
also asked whether fencing regulations applied to the site. Mr. Caldwell confirmed fencing was
regulated within the zone and noted no existing fences were present on the property. Vice-
Chairwoman Lover stated an intent to explore buffer options between the neighboring residential
area and the proposed project. She asked Mr. Michaels whether a privacy fence along the
perimeter of Perrin Drive would help address concerns and confirmed the speaker’s address. She
stated efforts were being made to address concerns and suggested a fence could be required as
a condition of approving removal of the protected tree, along with limiting additional tree removal.
She asked whether adding a fence in combination with a landscaping buffer would help alleviate
concerns. Mr. Bell noted the location of trees may interfere with the fencing but was doable. The
Board discussed options to make the fence work around the trees.
Ms. Elmadolar swore in a member of the public to speak in front of the Board. A project
representative stated the proposed fence location would be behind the yellow house on the site
and referenced prior discussions with nearby residents. The representative noted concerns had
been raised through written correspondence submitted to the Board. The representative stated
efforts had been made to preserve trees and minimize impacts while adjusting the design to
accommodate constraints on the property. The representative expressed intent to be a good
neighbor and noted the project team had worked to balance development needs with tree
preservation. The representative added that while a fence may reduce openness of the design,
it could be considered and discussed further if required. Mr. Duckworth stated a fence between
Perrin Drive and the parking lot would be acceptable as a Board requirement but expressed
preference for a vegetated buffer instead of a hard fence. He stated a dense evergreen screen
would be more aesthetically pleasing and referenced a nearby development where evergreen
landscaping was used in place of fencing, he noted it provided a more attractive streetscape for
adjacent neighborhoods. Mr. Bell noted there was a neighborhood located on 8
th Avenue North
behind Chick-fil-A that was a good example of a highly vegetated buffer that screened the
neighborhood.
Vice-Chairwoman Lover called for a motion. Mr. Bell motioned to approve BZA -26-11 because
the applicant ha d demonstrated unnecessary hardship . Specifically, there were extraordinary
expectational conditions pertaining to this particular piece of property which was that it does
11
have two road features that had been four lots have been combined into a parking lot and the
applicant was trying to save as many tress on the property as possible which also helped with
the drainage and other issues. These conditions do not generally apply to other properties in the
vicinity. Because of these conditions, application of the ordinance to the particular piece of
property would effectively prohibit or restrict the utilization of the property. The authorization of
the variance would not be a substantial detriment to adjacent properties or to the public good
and to the care of the district would not be harmed by the granting of the variance. The additional
comments to this variance would be the applicant to only remove the trees that have been
marked X on the plot that ha d been shown and presented to the Board today. The applicant
would be required to add a landscape buffer at the back of the property on Perrin Drive to create
a buffer and to dampen the noise for the residents. The applicant could pay the fee that’s
associated with the removal of the tree or the replacement schedule of the 33-inch tree through
the buffer on the back of property with other protective species of trees. That would be in
addition to what the applicant was already required to replace for what is already being removed.
The motion was seconded by Mr. Thomas. The motion to approve with conditions passed 6 -0.
Mr. Duckworth clarified that while additional buffer trees had been discussed for the rear of the
property, it would be beneficial to also allow placement of some of those trees along the front.
The applicant explained that concentrating too many plantings in the rear could negatively affect
the health of existing tree canopies and noted the intent to distribute landscaping more evenly
across the site.
D. BZA-26-12: Application by Cameron Parker for a variance to provide more compact parking
spaces than allowed by ordinance and to reduce the perimeter landscape buffer and to reduce
the minimum required interior landscaping at 1716 South Ocean Boulevard zoned Resort
Commercial, R-4 District. Mr. Guyton stated after further review of the requested variances (26-
12, 26-13, and 26-14), he believed those applications would be withdrawn. Mr. Guyton noted
this had not yet been confirmed with staff and requested the three items be continued to the
next meeting in order to coordinate with staff and formally submit the appropriate withdrawal
documentation. Vice-Chairwoman Lover asked for clarification regarding the term “withdrawal,”
noting that withdrawal would mean the applications would be removed and the applicant would
need to reapply from the beginning. Mr. Guyton clarified the variances would likely not be
needed. He requested a continuance to the next meeting to coordinate with staff and confirm
whether a compliant plan could be achieved without any variances. He stated if confirmed, the
variances would be withdrawn prior to the next meeting.
Vice-Chairwoman Lover called for a motion. Mr. Bell motioned to postpone BZA -26-12. The
motion was seconded by Mr. Reaves. The motion to postpone passed 6-0.
E. BZA-26-13: Application by Cameron Parker for variance to provide more compact parking
spaces than allowed by ordinance and to reduce the minimum required interior landscaping at
1716 Perrin Drive in the Resort Residential, R-4 District. The applicant requested a continuance
to the next meeting.
Vice-Chairwoman Lover called for a motion. Mr. Bell motioned to postpone BZA -26-13. The
motion was seconded by Mr. Reaves. The motion to postpone passed 6 -0, per discussion with
item BZA-26-12.
F. BZA-26-14: Application by Cameron Parker for variance to provide more compact parking
spaces than allowed by ordinance at 1706 Perrin Drive zoned Resort Residential, R -4 District.
The applicant requested a continuance to the next meeting.
12
Vice-Chairwoman Lover called for a motion. Mr. Bell motioned to postpone BZA -26-14. The
motion was seconded by Mr. Reaves. The motion to postpone passed 6 -0, per discussion with
item BZA-26-12.
G. BZA-26-17: Application by Kenny Hyatt for a variance to remove three trees in excess of 24’’
in diameter at 1001 Hyatt Pond Road. Mr. Thomas stated after speaking with the City Attorney
he would recuse himself for his item. Mr. Hyatt stated the request included removal of two trees
located within the building footprint, one of which had been documented as dead by an arborist.
He noted another dead tree near the roadway had been identified as a potential hazard.
Regarding a tree located at the edge of the property, Mr. Hyatt stated the project arborist
expressed concern that foundation excavation would likely damage the root system and result
in the tree’s decline. He further noted adjacent construction activity had already affected one
side of the tree. He acknowledged the Board could determine whether that tree should remain
or be removed. Chairman McGonigal asked for clarification regarding the trees under discussion
and requested identification of which specific tree had been determined to be dead. Mr. Hyatt
pointed to the tree on the projector and noted it was the one on the inside. Vice-Chairwoman
Lover asked the applicant to provide pictures to get a better image of the trees. Mr. Hyatt
identified the tree as one located almost directly on the build line and stated its major root
system extend ed into the proposed buildable area. In response to questions from Vice -
Chairwoman Lover regarding the tree’s size and species, the applicant stated the tree measured
26 inches in diameter and identified it as a red oak. Mr. Bell pointed out the tree was labeled as
a live oak on the plans . Chairman McGonigal asked for clarification on the location of the tree
they were discussing. Mr. Hyatt stated concern the tree would likely be impacted by nearby
construction, explaining that although it may not sit directly on the eve of the house, the arborist
believed it could be severely affected by building activity and potentially die as a result, becoming
an issue between both properties.
Mr. Bell pointed out the plan indicated the tree was 32 inches. Mr. Hyatt stated the measurement
of the tree was taken by Harry and noted uncertainty about how prior measurements were made.
Vice-Chairwoman Lover asked about two trees located near the entrance to Surf States, noting
they appeared beside a neighboring house along a fence line and were not clearly shown on the
submitted map. She requested clarification on those trees’ status and location. Mr. Hyatt and
Vice-Chairwoman Lover discussed the location of the trees in question. Mr. Hyatt pointed out the
trees that were alive and dead on the plan. Vice-Chairwoman Lover stated the two trees her and
Mr. Hyatt were discussing were healthy trees. My. Hyatt stated he had a letter from an arborist.
Mr. Caldwell confirmed he had a letter from the arborist. Mr. Bell asked the City if the Board
would be deciding on the trees. Mr. Caldwell stated there were two trees in that area which were
recommended for removal due to concerns that they were hazardous and pose a safety risk.
Vice-Chairwoman Lover and Mr. Hyatt discussed the location and picture Mr. Hyatt provided. Mr.
Wise noted 26 was the number of the tree and wanted to make sure they were discussing the
same tree. Mr. Hyatt stated that was the size of the tree. Vice-Chairwoman Lover discussed the
health and size of the trees with Mr. Hyatt for better understanding of the request. Vice-
Chairwoman Lover asked whether M&M Tree Service was serving as the arborist and also
questioned whether he would be the contractor responsible for removing the trees. Mr. Hyatt
responded he was not going with the arborist for the tree removal.
Mr. Caldwell read the description of the request, the ordinance, and recommended to hear the
variance. Chairman McGoniogal referenced the tree located between the two properties and
noted concern that construction would likely encroach into the canopy and root system, then
13
asked Mr. Caldwell for his perspective on the situation. Mr. Caldwell stated the lot was an unusual
shape compared to nearby properties and narrows toward the rear, with only a 5- foot side
setback required. He noted although tree protection zones exist, construction activity within that
area could still negatively impact the tree. He also added the 26-inch tree would correspond to
an approximate 13-foot protection radius. Mr. Bell asked whether the property was zoned R-2
and referenced lot size requirements. Mr. Caldwell clarified the minimum lot size was 5,000
square feet, noting the zoning standards applicable to the site. Chairman McGonigal noted two
trees within the building footprint would be removed and asked for discussion regarding the
remaining two trees and their potential preservation or removal. Mr. Bell noted the arborist letter
addressed certain trees and referenced prior discussion regarding the 32-inch and 26-inch trees,
totaling 58 inches of tree coverage. He stated the irregular lot shape constrained buildable space,
which pushed the proposed structure closer to setback limits and limiting usable development
area. Vice-Chairwoman Lover stated the Board would likely need to approve a variance for
removal of the 32 -inch tree, noting its location conflicts directly with the proposed building
footprint. Mr. Bell stated the 26-inch tree was likely to be negatively impacted by construction
and expressed preference for establishing a replacement plan rather than retaining the tree and
risking its loss. Vice -Chairwoman Lover noted concern about fitting replacement planting
requirements on the lot given the overall amount of tree diameter involved. Mr. Bell stated the
32-inch tree was centrally located within the lot and suggested considering a reduced
replacement requirement, potentially around 50% (approximately 24–30 inches), due to the lot’s
irregular shape and limited buildable area. Vice-Chairwoman Lover stated support for a reduced
replacement requirement, with a condition that the additional tree located at the corner of the
property remain in place. Mr. Bell asked whether the applicant was agreeable to preserving the
tree located near the utility easement. Mr. Hyatt confirmed agreement to leave that tree in place.
The Board clarified the status and location of trees within and adjacent to the proposed building
footprint. It was noted the 32- inch tree was located within the footprint and identified for
removal, while the 26-inch tree was outside the footprint but may be impacted by construction.
Mr. Bell stated a third tree near the edge of the footprint ha d been assessed as dead or
unsalvageable due to prior damage. Vice-Chairwoman Lover and Mr. Hyatt looked over pictures
of trees to clarify the locations. Chairman McGonigal asked for public comment.
Mr. Bell motioned to approve BZA -26-17 because the applicant had demonstrated an
unnecessary hardship. Specifically, there were extraordinary and exceptional conditions that
pertained to this particular piece of property which was an irregular shaped lot which limited the
ability to place a house on the lot. These conditions do not generally apply to the other properties
in the vicinity because of the conditions, the application of the ordinance to the particular piece
of property would effectively prohibit or unreasonably restrict the utilization of the property. The
authorization of the variance would not be a substantial detriment to adjacent properties or the
to the public good and the character of the district would not be harmed by the granting of the
variance. Mr. Bell requested that Mr. Hyatt be required to replace the removed trees totaling
approximately 58 inches with either 30 inches of replacement plantings on-site or payment into
the City tree fund at $300 per-inch. Mr. Bell explained to Mr. Hyatt the proposed condition would
require 30 inches of replacement planting, noting the 32- inch tree removal was effectively not
being assessed as a replacement requirement due to its location within the building footprint.
Mr. Bell stated the remaining replacement requirement would account for the 26-inch tree, with
a small additional amount added to reach the 30-inch total. The Board explained the replacement
requirement would follow City standards, which allowed either installation of replacement trees
using approved species, payment into the Tree Bank, or a combination of both. Vice-Chairwoman
Lover noted the estimated value for 30 inches of replacement was approximately $9,000. She
discussed possible combinations of on- site planting and tree fund contributions, with
confirmation that additional trees could be planted along the property edge toward Surfside. The
motion was seconded by Mr. Wise. The motion to approve passed 6-0.
14
H. BZA-26-18: Application by James Baldwin for variance to encroach into the required front
building setback with a projecting roof overhang at 1104 Highway 17 South. Chairman McGonigal
asked if anyone was present for the item. Mr. Caldwell stated he had no communication with the
applicant. Chairman McGonigal advised the Board to postpone BZA-26-18.
Chairman McGonigal called for a motion to postpone. Mr. Thomas motioned to postpone BZA-
26-18. The motion was seconded by Mr. Bell. The motion to postpone passed 7-0.
An unidentified member of the public stated they reside at 1707 Holly Drive and expressed concern about
the proposed parking lot and zoning changes. The speaker asked for clarification on whether any
variances or approvals for additional portions of the br oader project had been waived or postponed,
referencing prior discussion of multiple lots. Mr. Bell stated the matter had been postponed and noted
the applicant indicated they were likely to withdraw from the related application.
Vice-Chairwoman Lover raised an item of old business regarding a tree at Beverly Homes, stating the
Board had previously denied permission for its removal. The member reported the tree was later removed
and requested the item be added back to the agenda for consideration of a potential penalty, noting the
tree was no longer present on the site.
Chairman McGonigal called for a motion to adjourn. The motion to adjourn was made by Mr. Bell and
seconded by Mr. Thomas. The motion passed 7-0. The meeting adjourned at 6:35 PM.
Respectfully submitted,
Amber Elmadolar
Plan Reviewer
NOTE: BE ADVISED THAT THESE MINUTES REPRESENT A SUMMARY OF THE BOARD OF ZONING
APPEALS MEETING AND ARE NOT INTENDED TO REPRESENT A FULL TRANSCRIPT OF THE MEETING.
Source: City of North Myrtle Beach website. First collected Oct 13, 2026.