PC Draft Minutes 1.20.2026
Town of McClellanville · Charleston County · meeting of Jan 20, 2026 · Minutes
Open the original document More from Town of McClellanville
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
Minutes
McClellanville Planning Commission
Quarterly Meeting
January 20, 2026 – 6:00 PM
The McClellanville Planning Commission convened as scheduled for its quarterly
meeting, public notice being provided in accordance with the Freedom of Information
Act. Commissioner Ginny Prevost chaired the meeting. Present from the Planning
Commission were Scott Youngblood, Adam Freeze, Dan Fifis and Oliver Thames; Town
staff present included Kathryn Basha and Michelle McClellan. Planner Eddie Bernard
was present virtually.
Commissioner Prevost called the public hearing to order and that the Commission
review and approve the following minutes:
• October 2, 2025, minutes – Motion to approve made by Oliver Thames, was
seconded by Adam Freeze.
• October 23, 2025, minutes – Motion to approve made by Scott Youngman, was
seconded by Dan Fifis.
• November 3, 2025, minutes – Motion to approve made by Dan Fifis, was
seconded by Oliver Thames.
The Commission discussed the need for election of officers for the upcoming year. After
a brief discussion about some of the upcoming issues to be addressed; including but not
limited to the 5-year review of the adopted Comprehensive Plan, Ginny Prevost and Dan
Fifis were nominated to continue as Chair and Vice Chair, respectively. A motion by
Adam Freeze, seconded by Scott Youngman, was approved unanimously.
The Commission turned its attention to the draft amendments of Article VI: Tree
Conservation. At this time, the meeting was joined by the Town’s consultants from
Kimley Horn Associates who were present to answer any questions as the Commission
reviewed the draft. Provisions discussed for clarification included:
− Clarifying whether an exempt tree can be removed without a permit and removing a
possible conflict with Section 6.5(B). It was agreed that bush hogging, mulching etc.
listed in Section 6.5(B) should be listed as exempt activities at the beginning of the
ordinance.
− Identifying conflicts in the ordinance regarding removal of trees less than eight
inches in diameter (DBH) without a permit. Consensus reached that property
owners should be able to remove exempt trees under eight inches DBH without a
Page 2
January 20, 2026
Planning Commission Quarterly meeting
permit, except for protected trees. - Agreed to keep the eight-inch threshold for
requiring a permit, and to clarify definitions and exemptions in the ordinance.
− Discussing a procedural issue with when arborist reports for removal of hazardous
trees must be submitted: consensus that reports should be submitted before tree
removal, not after.
− Reviewing definitions in Section 6.3. It was agreed to strike redundant or confusing
language, especially regarding 'historic trees' since historic tree designation is
distinct from classification of grand trees which is based on tree size.
− Discussion was held whether grand pines should be exempt. Commission was
reminded that these were removed from protection when the Tree Conservation
section was amended in 2021.
− Staff was asked to look at consolidating and clarifying graphics related to measuring
tree diameter at breast height, branch collars, critical root zones, and multi-trunk
trees.
− It was noted that the definitions of branch collar and tree topping needed work.
− Commission discussed the proposed Table 6.4-1 and requiring the number of trees
retained based on a range of lot sizes. It was discussed that the requirement for 1
acre may not be sufficient when the same requirement applied to a 3-acre lot if the
Town wants to conserve the density and canopy of trees in the village.
Recommendation was to keep the 20 significant trees/acre not including exempt
species of trees. The consultants were asked to provide a graphic to show where
trees can be removed on a site.
− Requesting that staff prepare a more detailed, separate flow chart on how to obtain
a tree removal approval.
− Clarifying Section 6.5(E) to require Tree Conservation and Replacement Plans to
illustrate trees proposed for conservation and/or removal.
− Clarifying that a permit is required for private persons/entities to remove a public
tree (vs. “Non-town”. It was also discussed that the Town would notify the public 15
days in advance of removing a grand tree on public property since the Tree
Committee would already have reviewed the proposal.
− Recommending that emergency provisions also apply to threats to property, in
addition to public safety. It was also recommended that mitigation be required if
determination that disease of a tree from negligence is determined by a certified
arborist.
Page 3
January 20, 2026
Planning Commission Quarterly meeting
− Listing interference with water, wastewater communications, or electrical systems
as allowable grounds for BZA approval for removal of a protected tree.
Meeting discussion then turned to how the zoning and planning fees are determined
and schedule for updating the ordinance draft to incorporate the recommendation
made during the evening’s meeting.
Adam Freeze made a motion to forward these recommendations to Town Council for
scheduling of a public hearing in February. The motion was seconded by Dan Fifis.
Motion to adjourn the meeting was made by Scott Youngman and seconded by Dan
Fifis.
Respectfully submitted,
Michelle A. McClellan
Town Clerk
Source: Town of McClellanville website. First collected Oct 13, 2026.