RecordWell Data

_10052026-2274

Town of Mount Pleasant · Charleston County · meeting of Oct 5, 2026 · Minutes

Open the original document More from Town of Mount Pleasant

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

TOWN OF MOUNT PLEASANT, SC ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT COMMITTEE Monday, October 5, 2026 9:45 a.m. Municipal Complex, Council Chambers 100 Ann Edwards Lane, Mount Pleasant, SC 29464 MINUTES Click here to listen to the recording 1. Call to Order Chairwoman Laura Hyatt called the Economic Development Committee meeting to order on Monday, October 5, 2026, at 9:45 a.m. Council Members John Iacofano and Kathryn Whitaker were present. 2. Approval of Minutes from the August 31, 2026 Meeting Motion to approve the minutes from the August 31, 2026 meeting was made by Council Member Iacofano and seconded by Council Member Whitaker. The motion passed unanimously. 3. Public Comment There was no public comment. 4. Presentation Regarding Potential YMCA on Town Owned Faison Road Property Matt Brady, Economic Development Manager, introduced two representatives who had been invited to present a vision for the town- owned Faison Road property. Adam Ferrara's Introduction Adam Ferrara, managing partner of Buist Contractors and Vulcan Property Group and a former member of the Town of Mount Pleasant Planning Commission, opened by thanking Mr. Brady and the committee for the opportunity to speak. He described the town's holding as more than 38 draft Economic Development Committee October 5, 2026 Page 2 of 13 acres of land on Faison Road in Carolina Park and outlined a vision for a new 60,000-square-foot, world-class YMCA with an Olympic-sized pool and seating as an anchor development. He argued that such a facility could open the door to a strategically planned mixed-use development including small mercantile space, medical office, attainable homes, open green space, a community amphitheater, and walking trails. Mr. Ferrara then introduced David Byrd, CEO of the YMCA of Coastal Carolina, as the primary presenter. David Byrd's Presentation David Byrd, who noted he has dedicated nearly 50 years to the YMCA at both national and local levels, presented slides outlining the vision and organizational profile of the YMCA. He began by noting that there are nearly 100 YMCAs under development across the United States, with approximately 50 percent of those developed through partnerships with municipalities, churches, schools, and medical providers. He emphasized that the YMCA's model is built on partnership rather than competition with existing community services. draft Economic Development Committee October 5, 2026 Page 3 of 13 draft Economic Development Committee October 5, 2026 Page 4 of 13 Mr. Byrd described the proposed facility as approximately 80,000 square feet, including an indoor aquatics natatorium, an indoor walking track, gymnasium facilities lined for volleyball, pickleball, and basketball, a commons and lobby area, youth zones, and specialty rooms. He explained that a full-service natatorium would include a 50-meter indoor pool with seating for approximately 1,000 people, capable of hosting competitive events, supporting local school systems' water safety programs, and training first responders and lifeguards. He also envisioned a partnership with a medical office building on the site. Regarding the site plan, Mr. Byrd confirmed he had personally toured the Faison Road property and described it as a perfect, centrally located site. He stated that with Mount Pleasant's population approaching 100,000 people, the community could theoretically support two YMCAs, as the organization generally serves one YMCA per 40,000 residents, though the intent would be to start with one. draft Economic Development Committee October 5, 2026 Page 5 of 13 draft Economic Development Committee October 5, 2026 Page 6 of 13 Mr. Byrd stated that a YMCA of this magnitude would serve approximately 10,000 or more people annually, with a membership base of around 4,500. He noted that a typical family membership runs approximately $85 per draft Economic Development Committee October 5, 2026 Page 7 of 13 month with no financial assistance, and that no one is turned away for an inability to pay. He described the annual operating budget for a facility of this size as falling in the range of $3,000,000 to $5,000,000. He highlighted the YMCA's broader programmatic scope, including infant through senior adult programs, preschool and after-school care, chronic disease management programs in partnership with medical providers (such as Parkinson's, dementia, Alzheimer's, and blood pressure management), and workforce development through first-time employment of teenagers as lifeguards and camp staff. He noted that the YMCA is the largest employer of teenagers in the United States. He also spoke at length about addressing what he described as a loneliness epidemic in America, emphasizing the YMCA's role in building community connection and a sense of belonging, particularly for older adults and newcomers to a community. Mr. Byrd described a "generational center" model being developed in Myrtle Beach — the first of its kind in the state — that would combine infant-through-preschool care operating throughout the day, an active older adult center in the morning hours, and a teen education center in the afternoon, developed in partnership with local school districts. Committee Discussion and Questions Council Member Iacofano thanked the presenters and expressed appreciation for the vision extending beyond the YMCA itself to encompass the broader site. He acknowledged the community demand for recreation and noted the absence of a senior center in that area of town, suggesting the YMCA could help fill that void. He asked about the financial model — specifically, where the capital investment would come from and what the percentage breakdown might look like. Mr. Byrd explained the concept of a "capital stack," noting that 40 to 50 percent of YMCAs in the United States involve municipal partnerships, which can take many forms including donating land, leasing land, or a city building the facility with a leaseback arrangement. He cited the example of the YMCA in Myrtle Beach, where 17 years ago the city donated land at one dollar per year for 100 years, with capital raised locally through foundations and donors. He noted the YMCA does pursue state and federal draft Economic Development Committee October 5, 2026 Page 8 of 13 funding as well. He indicated that in all likelihood, one part of a probable package for Mount Pleasant would involve the town donating the land. Council Member Iacofano followed up on the housing component shown in the site plan, asking whether the 32 homes depicted were intended as workforce housing. Mr. Ferrara deferred, clarifying that the site is understood to potentially be already zoned for 32 attainable homes and that local partners could be engaged to determine highest and best use. He emphasized that the housing element was a placeholder to demonstrate opportunity, and that green space remained an equally valid alternative for that portion of the site. Council Member Iacofano also raised the question of economic development impact, noting that the YMCA, as a nonprofit, would not generate property tax revenue, and that a nonprofit medical partner similarly would not contribute taxes. Mr. Brady responded by suggesting that a payment in lieu of taxes could be negotiated for any nonprofit facilities on the site, calculated based on what the millage would be on a commercial property of equivalent value. He also noted that outparcels in the site plan would likely be sold to private commercial developers who would pay standard property taxes, and that the YMCA would function as an anchor generating retail gravity for those parcels. Council Member Iacofano asked whether the YMCA engages in revenue sharing with municipalities. Mr. Byrd confirmed that this is done and cited a model from Kansas City, Missouri, where the city owned the building, the YMCA managed it, and the two parties split the revenue surplus. Council Member Whitaker asked whether the YMCA was truly the best use for the property. She noted that a new recreation center is already underway, that Charleston County Schools are expanding three- and four- year-old early education programs in Mount Pleasant, and that the high schools may already have pool arrangements in place. She questioned how much of an unmet need the YMCA would actually be filling across those three program areas. Mr. Byrd acknowledged these were fair questions and conceded he could not answer them fully without a gap analysis. He noted, however, that early childhood education often suffers a split between affordability and quality, and that the YMCA aims to provide both. He also argued that a community of Mount Pleasant's size has room draft Economic Development Committee October 5, 2026 Page 9 of 13 for both a recreation center and a YMCA, with each complementing rather than duplicating the other's services. Council Member Whitaker noted that the point about the loneliness epidemic resonated with her, particularly given the large number of newcomers to the community who may not have an existing social network. Mr. Ferrara addressed the pool question directly, sharing that his son swims for a local club team and that his daughter had swum with Wando. He stated that high school athletic directors are currently approaching neighborhoods to borrow lane space, that a swim event at Park West had recently been cancelled due to a pump failure, and that North Charleston has a world-class aquatic center while Mount Pleasant does not. He argued that a quality aquatic facility is a clear community need and that the YMCA represents a willing and capable partner. Chairwoman Hyatt noted that her colleagues had covered the questions she had as well, and expressed that she could see a potential compromise that might satisfy residents interested in green space. She also referenced prior discussions about pool expansion in the town's Capital Improvement Plan and suggested this partnership could provide an opportunity to redirect some of that funding. Mr. Byrd clarified the various types of pool configurations available, explaining that a 50-meter long-course pool, while capable of hosting major competitive events, is very expensive to build and operate. He recommended that any such facility be developed in partnership with school districts, county entities, and swim teams to ensure the pool is fully utilized. He described the typical model of pairing a competition-oriented natatorium with a secondary warmer pool designed for active older adults, arthritis programming, and disability-related programs. 5. Continued Discussion Regarding Town Owned Property on Faison Road Mr. Brady indicated he had prepared slides for this item but suggested skipping to the final slide in the interest of time, as the committee was familiar with the prior history. He outlined three paths forward: doing nothing, continuing community engagement, or issuing a new Request for draft Economic Development Committee October 5, 2026 Page 10 of 13 Proposals (RFP), which he described as the most transparent option, as it would allow any interested party to submit a proposal for the property. draft Economic Development Committee October 5, 2026 Page 11 of 13 draft Economic Development Committee October 5, 2026 Page 12 of 13 Council Member Whitaker stated that her position at the previous month's meeting had been to hold. However, having now heard the YMCA presentation, she said she believed it was the committee's responsibility to issue a new RFP so that other options could be brought forward and draft Economic Development Committee October 5, 2026 Page 13 of 13 evaluated alongside the YMCA proposal. She further stated that if the town is considering donating the land, she wanted to see an affordable housing option included as a response category, arguing that if the land contribution removes the cost barrier, an affordable housing development on the site could become financially viable. She recommended the committee forward a recommendation to full council to issue a new RFP. Council Member Iacofano seconded that recommendation. He added a request that a needs study for the town be included in the process, and noted that he had personally committed to delivering a senior center in that area of town during his remaining term, and that the YMCA could be a strong vehicle for fulfilling that commitment. Chairwoman Hyatt indicated she would have preferred more community engagement before proceeding to an RFP but stated she was comfortable bringing the matter to full council for a vote. She acknowledged that the YMCA presentation raised the possibility of reallocating recreation-related capital funding and that there was much more conversation to be had. Motion to recommend that full council issue a new RFP for the town-owned Faison Road property was made by Council Member Whitaker and seconded by Council Member Iacofano. The motion passed unanimously. 6. Adjourn With there being no further business, Chairwoman Hyatt adjourned the meeting at 10:25 a.m. Respectfully submitted, Lisa Canney Deputy Clerk of Council October 5, 2026 draft

Source: Town of Mount Pleasant website. First collected Oct 13, 2026.