_10052026-2278
Town of Mount Pleasant · Charleston County · meeting of Oct 5, 2026 · Minutes
Open the original document More from Town of Mount Pleasant
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
TOWN OF MOUNT PLEASANT, SOUTH CAROLINA
PLANNING COMMITTEE
OCTOBER 5, 2026
MINUTES
Municipal Complex, Council Chambers
PowerPoint Presentation
Present: Laura Hyatt, Chair, Alex Crosby, Mike Tinkey, Kathryn Whitaker.
Staff: Eric DeMoura, Michele Reed, Peter Stone, David Pagliarini
1. Call to order
Ms. Hyatt called the meeting to order at 1:03 pm.
2. Approval of Minutes from the August 31, 2026 meeting
Ms. Crosby moved for approval of the minutes. Ms. Whitaker seconded the
motion. All in favor.
3. Public Comment
Mr. Barrett Brewer, 477 Settlers Rest East , state that he is a board member at
Trident Academy. He spoke regarding the proposed text amendment under item 4A.
He stated that his understanding was that the Town would be reaching out to the
affected property owners, but that has not occurred. He stated that based on the
previous discussions, overriding the Comprehensive Plan was not desired and the
reason for looking at making changes and the appropriate course of action. He
suggested that no changes are needed and asked Town Council to work with property
owners for a solution that would protect property owner’s rights.
Mr. David Yowell, Middle Street Partners, spoke regarding the Oakland PD
amendment request under item 5A. He stated that there has been overwhelming
support from the surrounding residents and asked that the plan be approved. He
suggested that this would be an improvement to the area with the proposed
additional open space , a reduction in traffic impact, and future proposed traffic
improvements. He stated that mixed use with residential above retail was considered
but was not considered a good fit for the area and their overall plan.
draft
Planning Committee
October 5, 2026
Page 2 of 7
Mr. Drew Harris, 1160 Sharpestowne Court, is a member of the Porcher Preserve
HOA Board and spoke regarding item 5A. He stated that much of the neighborhood
is in support of the proposed development, particularly because there would be less
traffic, more open space, and tree preservation and additional landscaping. He stated
that another aspect is that many of the residents are also business owners. He stated
that the property has not been developed, even after plans were approved. He stated
that the residents would like to see development of the property so that it is not used
as a dumping ground, and the property will be properly maintained . He suggested
that it would provide better safety for the surrounding area and provide better
pedestrian and bicycle access for the area. He stated that if developed as a hotel there
would be more traffic and more transient traffic. He suggested it is not as important
for this to be part of the PD as the other property within the PD is already developed
with commercial uses. He suggested that the allowing the proposed residential units
provides mixed use for the PD as a whole and is more desired by the surrounding
residents.
Ms. Anita Crudge, 1177 Sharpestowne Court, spoke regarding item 5A. She stated
that one of the reasons for choosing to live in Porcher Preserve w as because of the
proximity to the existing commercial development. She suggested that th is is a
vibrant commercial development and the proposed residential development would
provide needed housing for the area. She stated that the Highway 41 improvements
are necessary and she is looking forward to those improvements being completed.
4. Deferred from September 8, 2026, Town Council Meeting:
A. Zoning Code Text Amendment, Chapter 156.039. Proposed modification to
certain Residential Districts, establishing density provisions where these
districts are designated on the Comprehensive Plan Future Land Use Map
as Community Facilities
Ms. Reed reviewed this item with the Committee and stated that it was
deferred from Town Council. She reviewed the differences between the
Comprehensive Plan Future Land Use Map and the Zoning Code and Map with
the Committee and that the Comprehensive Plan is used as a guide.
Ms. Hyatt stated that the Planning Commission indicated that other solutions
should be considered. She stated that the goal is to have a public process that
allows the desired goals to be achieved. She suggested that rezoning all the
properties to be consistent with the Comprehensive Plan does not make sense
draft
Planning Committee
October 5, 2026
Page 3 of 7
as it would mean rezonings taking place every time the Comprehensive Plan is
changed. She suggested that this be sent back to the Planning Commission to
discuss it further and consider a recommendation. She suggested that there
should be a public process and review by Town Council.
Mr. Tinkey asked what the Planning Commission would be discussing. Ms.
Hyatt answered that it would be determining what should be done when the
Comprehensive Plan recommendation does not match the existing zoning. Mr.
Tinkey suggested that the property owner rights should be considered as well as
consideration of the future needs. He suggested that some residential uses
might be appropriate; therefore, if rezoned to match the Comprehensive Plan
recommendation might mean that the use would not be allowed. He suggested
that the impacts of entirely losing the schools is a different situation than
allowing a portion of the property to be sold and used as a residential use or
other appropriate use . He stated that the schools, churches, and parks are an
asset for a neighborhood and losing them entirely has significant impacts for the
neighborhood and for those residents that chose that neighborhood because of
those amenities. He expressed concern with not having review of a change in
use for the entire property. He suggested that there should be more community
discussion and the unintended consequences considered for these properties
that have an underlying zoning that conflicts with the Comprehensive Plan. He
agreed that improvements or changes to these properties should be reviewed by
Town Council.
Ms. Whitaker suggested that if the underlying zoning is to be changed to be
consistent with the Comprehensive Plan, it should be considered during the five
year review of the Comprehensive Plan.
Ms. Crosby agreed with Mr. Tinkey and Ms. Hyatt that there should be some
type of review for significant changes . She stated that careful consideration
should be taken to ensure that the property rights of the owner are considered
while ensuring any requests are for the public good.
Ms. Hyatt asked how to best have community discussion. Ms. Reed answered
that sending it back to the Planning Commission could be done to allow more
public input. Ms. Hyatt asked if a motion would be needed to send this back to
the Planning Commission. Ms. Reed answered in the negative. Ms. Hyatt
suggested that if the desire is to change the zoning there should be a public
draft
Planning Committee
October 5, 2026
Page 4 of 7
process. Ms. Reed stated that it can be brought back to the Planning Commission
for additional discussion.
The Committee agreed to send this item to the Planning Commission for
additional discussion.
5. Review of Planning Commission recommendations from the September 23,
2026 meeting
A. R-27-26. Oakland Plantation PD Amendment . Request to amend the
Oakland Plantation PD, Planned Development District Ordinance, to
establish 87 townhouse units on a six-acre parcel.
Mr. Stone reviewed the request with the Committee. He stated that Planning
Commission recommended denial.
Ms. Whitaker moved to recommend to Town Council approval of the request.
Ms. Crosby seconded the motion.
Ms. Whitaker stated that during the Planning Commission discussion it was
noted that one of the reasons for their denial is that this property was
recommended for hotel use. She stated that she reviewed the July 2026 Explore
Charleston report to see the number of hotel rooms and the occupancy rates
within the Town. She s uggested that, based on this report, preserving this
property for a hotel use does not make sense given the recent report and that
the previously approved plans for a hotel did not come to fruition. She stated
that another issue discussed was the impact on the area schools. She stated that
the latest report shows a decrease of enrollment for the area schools and
therefore, there is no concern with overcrowding the area schools.
Mr. Tinkey suggested that the occupancy report shows that the occupancy
rate is high and continues to grow. He suggested that a hotel use could be
accommodated; however, he would prefer a true mixed -use development for
this property. He suggested that a blend of medical uses and residential w ould
be beneficial for this area. He asked how many access points there are for this
property. Mr. Stone answered that there are two main accesses, from Porcher
Bluff and South Morgans Point, with additional internal access. He stated that
additional connectivity would be desired for better traffic flow. Mr. Tinkey asked
if the entire development would be townhome units. Mr. Stone answered in the
draft
Planning Committee
October 5, 2026
Page 5 of 7
affirmative. Mr. Tinkey suggested that some affordable housing should be
included. He expressed concern with the buffers and suggested that they should
be larger. Mr. Stone reviewed the widths of the buffers with the Committee. Mr.
Tinkey suggested that there would be more concentrated traffic impact with the
townhome use rather than dispersed throughout the day for a hotel and/or
commercial use. Mr. Stone agreed that the traffic would be somewhat
concentrated to during the am/pm peak times, but there are other
considerations such as working from home that would be a factor as well. Mr.
Tinkey stated that there was a recent development that was not approved until
they changed to a more traditional mixed use.
Ms. Crosby asked what could be developed on the property if the request
was denied. Mr. Stone answered that any use allowed under area-wide business
zoning. Ms. Crosby asked if there is any affordable housing being considered.
Mr. Stone answered in the negative.
Ms. Hyatt asked for a comparison of what is currently allowed under the PD
and what is being requested. Mr. Stone reviewed this for the Commission noting
that they are asking for 16 units per acre, when nine units per acre is currently
allowed. Ms. Hyatt stated that this area was slated as a commercial hub with
hotel uses because of the lack of hotels in the area. She stated that she is not a
proponent of changing from a commercial use to a residential use and suggested
that the commercial zoning should remain. She suggested there is no benefit to
allowing the residential as proposed as it would mean more impact on services
the Town provides. She asked about the alignment of the roadways. Mr. Stone
answered that the improvements were included in the Highway 41 expansion
with this development tying into Winnowing Way.
Mr. Tinkey asked if a PD amendment would be needed if they had a mixed
use development. Mr. Stone answered in the negative. Mr. Tinkey suggested
that a true mixed use development should be considered with residential above
the commercial uses and include affordable housing.
Ms. Hyatt agreed that a mixed use development with affordable housing
would be desired in this area.
Ms. Whitaker stated that although market rate units, the townhomes are a
more affordable option. She suggested that another consideration is that the
draft
Planning Committee
October 5, 2026
Page 6 of 7
adjacent neighborhood is in favor of the request. She also noted that the
adjacent use in the PD is a medical office use, which does lend to mixed having
mixed uses within the PD.
Ms. Hyatt called for a vote on the motion. Motion failed on a 1 to 3 vote with
Ms. Whitaker in favor; Ms. Crosby, Ms. Hyatt, and Ms. Tinkey opposed.
Mr. Tinkey suggested that a different proposal should be considered.
B. R-28-26. 663 Faulkner Drive Annex and Zone . Request to annex and zone
RR, Rural Residential, and approximately 1.95 -acre parcel located at 663
Faulkner Drive.
Mr. Stone reviewed the request with the Committee. He stated that the
Planning Committee recommended denial.
Ms. Hyatt moved to recommend to Town Council approval of the annexation.
Ms. Whitaker seconded the motion.
Mr. Tinkey asked if zoning is denied, would the property be annexed as RC-2. Mr.
Stone answered in the affirmative.
Ms. Hyatt asked the difference between RR and RC -2. Mr. Stone reviewed
this for the Committee.
Ms. Hyatt called for a vote on the motion. Motion passed on a 3 to1 vote with
Ms. Crosby, Ms. Whitaker, and Ms. Hyatt in favor; Mr. Tinkey opposed.
Ms. Hyatt moved to recommend to Town Council denial of the zoning request.
Ms. Crosby seconded the motion. All in favor.
C. R-29-26. 1268 Porchers Bluff Road Annex and Zone. Request to annex and
zone R-1, Residential District, an approximately 0.84-acre parcel located at
1268 Porchers Bluff Road.
Mr. Stone reviewed the request with the Committee. He stated that the
Planning Committee recommended approval.
draft
Planning Committee
October 5, 2026
Page 7 of 7
Ms. Whitaker moved to recommend to Town Council approval of the
annexation and zoning requests. Mr. Tinkey seconded the motion.
Ms. Hyatt asked if sewer is available. Mr. Stone answered in the negative and
stated the property currently has septic service. Mr. Tinkey asked if the owner
would be required to tie into sewer once available. Mr. Stone answered in the
affirmative.
Ms. Hyatt called for a vote on the motion. All in favor.
6. Update from Planning Commission Discussion on Data Center Land Use and
Zoning
Ms. Reed reviewed the request with the Committee. She stated that the Planning
Commission reviewed this item and staff would be bringing back additional
information to the Planning Commission for consideration and recommendations.
Mr. Tinkey agreed that having some specific definitions and specifications are
needed.
Ms. Hyatt asked if the megawatt threshold is a general standard . Mr. Pagliarini
answered that this is the national standard differentiating between a large data
center and a small data center . Ms. Hyatt asked about the impact of a smaller data
center under one megawatt and how this would be regulated . Mr. Pagliarini
answered that this would be included under the special exception requirements for
approval.
Ms. Crosby agreed that having specific parameters is important to ensure less
impact on surrounding areas.
7. Adjourn
There being no further business, the meeting adjourned at 2:12 pm.
Submitted by,
L. Lynes
PlanComm10052026
draft
Source: Town of Mount Pleasant website. First collected Oct 13, 2026.