RecordWell Data

_10052026-2275

Town of Mount Pleasant · Charleston County · meeting of Oct 5, 2026 · Minutes

Open the original document More from Town of Mount Pleasant

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

TOWN OF MOUNT PLEASANT, SC POLICE, JUDICIAL & LEGAL COMMITTEE Monday, October 5, 2026 10:15 a.m. Municipal Complex, Council Chambers 100 Ann Edwards Lane, Mount Pleasant, SC 29464 MINUTE S List en to recording here 1. Call to Order Mayor Will Haynie called the Police, Judicial & Legal Committee meeting to order at 10:30 AM. Council Members Mike Tinkey, Howard Chapman and Alex Crosby were all present. Mayor Haynie took a moment to personally thank those who had reached out to him following the recent passing of his mother, who had resided in Mount Pleasant during the last two years of her life. 2. Approval of Minutes from the August 31, 2026 Meeting A m otion to approve the minutes from the August 31, 2026, meeting was made by Mr. Chapman and seconded by Ms. Crosby. The motion carried unanimously. 3. Public Comment Sandra Connell, 2106 Sewee Indian Court, Dunes West, expressed app reciation for the animal protection changes under consideration by the committee and requested the addition of pet registration and microchipping requirements. She cited confirmed rabies cases in Charleston County, overcrowding in local shelters, and the problem of owners surrendering ani mals to strangers or abandoning them. She proposed an annual registration and microchipping program for dogs and cats, including breeding animals, with fees of twenty dollars for altered animals and one hundred dollars for unaltered animals, noting that such fees could fund the program. She referenced a five-page proposal with a five-year projection that she submitted for the committee's review. draft Police, Judicial and Legal Committee October 5, 2026 2 Lisa Schnipke, 185 Mossy Oak Way, representing the Bell Hall Plantation HOA, spoke regarding disruptions caused by T-Mobile's utility installation throughout t he neighborhood, which impacted all 1,079 homes. She expressed concern about inadequate permit filing, failure to follow tree protection guidelines, and lack of notification to HOAs prior to the project's start. She requested that the town consider requiring contractors to notify HOAs in advance of large-scale utility projects and provide oversight during installation, noting that IQ Fiber was anticipated to follow. John Iacofano, 388 Overseer Place, thanked the committee for placing the Flock c amera discussion on the agenda, and emphasized the importance of public education regarding how the technology is used in law enforcement, r ather than as a tool to track law-abiding citizens. He also offered his condolences to Mayor Haynie. Doug Case, 3583 Goodwater Street, expressed interest in the Flock camera system and posed several questions for the record, including a request for a full accounting of camera expenditures over the past three years, a formal data retention and privacy policy modeled on standards similar to HIPAA, the identification of a third-party independent auditor, and defined penalties for policy violations. He noted that he comes from the surveillance industry and raised broader concerns about the potential for misuse of such systems. Emily Cisneros, 1385 Classic Court, stated her opposition to the town's use of Flock cameras. While expressing support for law enforcement and acknowledging t he effectiveness of certain tools in fighting crime, she argued that public safety does not require the routine surveillance of law- abiding citizens. She referenced Florida Governor Ron DeSantis's recent action restricting automated license plate readers on state highways due to privacy concerns. She contended that these cameras collect information on ordinary citizens first and investigate later, which she viewed as inconsistent with the presumption of innocence. She asked the town not to expand the Flock system and to reconsider its use altogether, asserting that the burden of justification should rest with the government. 4. Police Matters 4a. Discussion of the Use of Flock Cameras in Mount Pleasant draft Police, Judicial and Legal Committee October 5, 2026 3 Chief Mark Arnold opened the discussion by acknowledging the significance and complexity of the issue, noting that strong opinions exist on both sides and cautioning against broad generalizations. He grounded his remarks in the department's mission statement, which emphasizes partnership with citizens, protection of life and property, and enforcement of law consistent with democratic values. Chief Arnold introduced the concept of routine activities theory of crime — the idea that crime occurs when a motivated offender, a suitable target, and a lack of guardianship converge. He framed surveillance cameras, including Automatic License Plate Readers (ALPRs), as a form of guardianship, drawing parallels to post-9/11 airport security enhancements. He acknowledged the tension between providing adequate guardianship and avoiding an invasive police state, and expressed confidence that the United States Supreme Court will ultimately be called upon to define that balance. Chief Arnold provided a historical overview of ALPR technology, noting that it originated in the United Kingdom in 1981 and was first used in the United States in 1998 at the border. Mount Pleasant first adopted ALPR technology in 2012 through a SLED agreement, using NDI cameras on the Ravenel Bridge. The transition to Flock Safety cameras took place in May– June 2020 under Project Seahawk, using a subscription-based model that avoids the issues of aging hardware. He addressed common concerns and misconceptions. He confirmed that the system does not use facial recognition — it reads license plates only, not the identity of occupants. He noted that the annual contract cost is seventy thousand dollars, representing 0.0025 percent of the department's annual operating budget. He stated that in the most recent thirty-day period, the system captured approximately 2,670 images and officers conducted 219 targeted searches. Year to date, approximately 40 arrests have resulted from ALPR alerts, spanning offenses related to stolen vehicles, protection orders, registered sex offenders, and gang or suspected terrorist activity. Chief Arnold discussed the department's steps to prevent misuse. Data retention has been reduced to seven days. Officers are no longer permitted to set personal alerts on a license plate without supervisor approval, directly addressing the type of misconduct seen in other jurisdictions — particularly, officers using such systems to track personal acquaintances or draft Police, Judicial and Legal Committee October 5, 2026 4 romantic interests. He stated that no evidence of misuse has been found within the Mount Pleasant Police Department. Regarding data sharing, Chief Arnold directed attention to the department's public transparency portal, accessible through the town's website, which lists all agencies granted permission to search Mount Pleasant's camera data. He confirmed that ICE and federal immigration enforcement are not on that list. He noted that task force officers assigned to the DEA and FBI white collar crime task forces may access the system in the course of specific investigations. He emphasized that per the department's contract with Flock, data is not sold to third parties, and that commitment is reflected in the contract language. Chief Arnold was asked by Councilmember Ms. Crosby about the risk of the camera network growing over time. He confirmed he has no intention of significantly expanding the current network of twenty-two cameras, noting that tracking his own vehicle over a week yielded only four photographs — a volume he argued is insufficient to constitute a meaningful pattern of life. He contrasted this with the far greater surveillance potential of a mobile phone's geolocation data. Following Chief Arnold's remarks, David Pagliarini, Legal Counsel, provided the legal framework surrounding ALPR use. He confirmed that no court has ruled ALPRs unconstitutional in and of themselves. The United States Supreme Court has held that drivers have no reasonable expectation of privacy regarding license plates displayed in public. The critical legal question, Mr. Pagliarini noted, is whether the aggregation of many still images could be considered continuous tracking — analogous to the GPS tracking found unconstitutional in United States v. Jones or the cell phone data collection addressed in Carpenter v. United States. Mr. Pagliarini referenced the case of Schmidt v. City of Norfolk, decided in the Fourth Circuit, in which a federal judge ruled that the plaintiffs could not demonstrate that a 176-camera ALPR network was capable of tracking the whole of a person's movements. That case is scheduled for argument before the circuit court on December 8th, with potential Supreme Court review thereafter. Mr. Pagliarini also addressed the recent Oklahoma case referenced by Chief Arnold, in which a federal judge suppressed drug evidence because law enforcement tracked a vehicle solely on the basis of its out-of-state license plate, without any investigative basis. Mr. Pagliarini clarified that draft Police, Judicial and Legal Committee October 5, 2026 5 even if that ruling is upheld, it would not render ALPRs unconstitutional categorically — it would simply require a proper legal basis before conducting a prolonged, targeted search of a specific vehicle's movements. Mr. Pagliarini concluded that it is highly unlikely an appellate court would adopt an all-or-nothing position on ALPR use, and that the focus should remain on appropriate policies and procedures governing the technology's use. Following the presentations, committee members engaged in substantive discussion. One member expressed support for law enforcement having investigative tools but voiced concern about the surveillance of law-abiding citizens and the risk of "mission creep" — the gradual expansion of the camera network without policy guardrails. The member questioned who would prevent a future administration from expanding the network to the point where it does create a mosaic of citizen movements. Mayor Haynie raised concerns about cybersecurity vulnerabilities, noting that sophisticated hackers could potentially batch-query license plate data across multiple jurisdictions simultaneously, and that municipalities may lack the technical sophistication to detect or prevent such intrusions. Mayor Haynie proposed that the committee convene a follow-up meeting the following month to address three specific areas: (1) the feasibility of an ordinance — rather than merely a policy — requiring council notification before any expansion of the camera network; (2) an analysis of alternative vendors and their respective cybersecurity standards, so that the discussion is not solely focused on Flock Safety; and (3) a review of the department's existing access and search policies to ensure elected officials have a reliable mechanism for oversight and accountability across future administrations. He also requested a discussion of how the town complies with public records law — including FOIA requests — given that camera data is purged after seven days. Chief Arnold and David Pagliarini, Legal Counsel, agreed to prepare for those discussions at the November meeting. 4b. Discussion of Anticipated Security Needs for the Upcoming 2026 Statewide General Election Chief Arnold reported that the Mount Pleasant Police Department coordinates with the Election Commission in advance of all elections to discuss readiness. He noted that by law, police officers are not permitted to draft Police, Judicial and Legal Committee October 5, 2026 6 be stationed at polling locations; they may only appear temporarily to cast their own votes. Any law enforcement presence at a polling site requires a request from the polling manager. For major elections, Charleston County activates its Emergency Operations Center, through which representatives from multiple agencies coordinate with the Election Commission to monitor activities across all locations. Councilmember Mr. Chapman, reported on a recent mayors' meeting convened to discuss election security. Two notable points were raised: first, that federal military or federal law enforcement officers in uniform are not permitted at polling places, and local jurisdictions have been advised to remove them if they appear; second, that drones used in the vicinity of polling locations may be intercepted or disabled upon request from precinct officials to local law enforcement agencies. 5. Judicial Matters 5a. No Agenda Items There were no judicial matters for discussion. 6. Legal Matters 6a. Continued Discussion Regarding the Resolution in Support of Senate Bill S.0246 to Amend Section 46-9-110 of the South Carolina Code of Laws to Provide That a Unit of Local Government May Adopt an Ordinance Restricting the Use of Certain Pesticides Mr. Eric DeMoura, Town Administrator, no ted that a representative from the pesticide association had been invited to present to the committee but was not in attendance. Mayor Haynie proposed deferring this item to the November meeting, and no objection was raised. The item was deferred to the November meeting. 6b. Review and Discussion of the Town of Mount Pleasant Animal Cruelty Ordinance David Pagliarini, Legal Counsel provided an update on the status of the revised animal cruelty ordinance. The ordinance first came before the committee the prior month, and staff has since solicited input from multiple stakeholders, including citizens who submitted useful resources and the draft Police, Judicial and Legal Committee October 5, 2026 7 Mount Pleasant Police Department and animal control officers, whose feedback was recently received. Brent Leary, Legal Counsel highlighted key substantive changes in the draft ordinance, including: the establishment of minimum standards of care for animals; new licensing and registration requirements for pet breeders (Section 90.4) and animal rescue organizations (Section 90.5); the addition of provisions addressing animal hoarding, which was not addressed in the prior ordinance; requirements pertaining to animal welfare during extreme weather conditions; and updated impoundment and redemption procedures. Staff noted that the microchipping proposal raised during public comment is a growing trend nationally and one that the town will need to evaluate carefully against available enforcement resources. Any registration system would require the establishment of a registry and coordination with animal control for site visits and audits. Mayor Haynie confirmed that the tag reference in Section 90.5 refers to the standard rabies vaccination tag issued by licensed veterinarians, not a separate municipal identification tag. Councilmember, Mr. Chapman, reiterated the request made at the prior month's meeting that the local veterinary association be given an opportunity to review the draft and offer input before the ordinance is finalized. Staff confirmed that the goal is to have a near-final draft ready for the following month, at which time it would be presented to full council for deliberation. 6c. Proposed Amendments to Section 130.03 of the Town of Mount Pleasant Code of Ordinances Related to Boat Landings, Town Docks and Boat Charters Brent Leary, legal counsel presented proposed amendments to Section 130.03, which arose from the prior month's discussion regarding illegal boat charter operations, particularly on Shem Creek. Counsel noted that state law generally prohibits local governments from regulating watercraft directly, with limited exceptions such as the recently granted authority to address abandoned watercraft. As a result, the town's primary enforcement mechanism is through its business license authority. draft Police, Judicial and Legal Committee October 5, 2026 8 The proposed amendments would require any boat charter operating within the town — including those picking up or dropping off passengers at town docks — to hold a valid Mount Pleasant business license and to carry a copy of that license aboard the vessel at all times. Additionally, as a condition of licensure, charters would be required to provide a certificate of liability insurance, consistent with requirements already imposed on other businesses such as tow companies and vendors. Charter operators would also be required to execute a hold harmless agreement protecting the town from liability arising from the charter's use of town facilities. Mr. Leary noted that enforcement of Coast Guard credentials and vessel inspection requirements remains the responsibility of state and federal authorities. The town's enforcement authority is directed solely at the business operations of the charter, not the watercraft itself. Mayor Haynie observed that there are reportedly dozens of boats advertising charter services on Shem Creek with very few holding a valid business license, and that these amendments would help bring those operators into compliance. He confirmed that captain licensing and vessel inspection standards for vessels carrying twelve or more passengers remain subject to state and federal jurisdiction. A motion to recommend to full council that the proposed amendments to Section 130.03 of the Town of Mount Pleasant Code of Ordinances related to boat landings, town docks, and boat charters move forward was made by council member Mr. Chapman and council member Mr. Tinkey seconded the motion. The motion carried unanimously. 7. Adjourn With no further business before the committee, Mayor Haynie declared the meeting adjourned at 11:49 AM. Respectfully Submitted by: October 6, 2026 Nancy Hanf draft

Source: Town of Mount Pleasant website. First collected Oct 13, 2026.