RecordWell Data

_09232026-2266

Town of Mount Pleasant · Charleston County · meeting of Sep 23, 2026 · Minutes

Open the original document More from Town of Mount Pleasant

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

TOWN OF MOUNT PLEASANT, SOUTH CAROLINA PLANNING COMMISSION SEPTEMBER 23, 2026 MINUTES PowerPoint Presentation Present: Brett Bennett, Chair, Corey Barber, Daniela Harris, Pam Ireland, Gary Davis, Bill Smyth, Michelle Mansour, Grant Gilmore. Absent: Kevin Berry. Staff: Michele Reed, Peter Stone, David Pagliarini, Marissa Noble, Lynnette Lynes Mr. Bennett called the meeting to order a t 5:00 pm and introduced Mr. Gilmore as the newest member. 1. Approval of the Agenda Mr. Smyth moved for approval of the agenda. Ms. Ireland seconded the motion. All in favor. 2. Approval of Minutes Mr. Smyth moved for approval of the minutes. Mr. Davis seconded the motion. All in favor. 3. Planning Commission Recommendations Update Mr. Stone reviewed Town Council decisions with the Commission. 4. General Correspondence 5. General Public Comment All correspondence received was linked to the agenda. Mr. Andrew Harris, 1160 Sharpestowne Court, spoke regarding data centers and stated that his company constructs smaller centers. He stated that there is a need for the smaller modular data centers are needed to provide service. He suggested Planning Commission September 23, 2026 Page 2 of 11 that the Commission consider allowing the smaller centers. He suggested that differentiating between the different centers is important. There being no further comments, Mr. Bennett continued with the agenda. 6. Business A. PUBLIC HEARING , R-27-26, Oakland Plantation PD, Planned Development, Request to establish a Townhouse Development within Market at Oakland. Staff Report Mr. Stone reviewed staff comments with the Commission. Mr. Bennett asked about the setbacks for the proposed development. Mr. Stone answered that it depends on if the townhome is front loaded or rear loaded; if rear loaded, the five-foot setback would be applied. Mr. David Yowell, Millstreet Partners, reviewed the request with the Commission through a PP presentation. Mr. Davis asked the reason for the change in use for these parcels. Mr. Yowell answered that they were not involved with the previous applicant. Mr. Barber asked about the configuration of the townhomes. Mr. Yowell answered that they would predominately be three bedroom units. Mr. Gilmore asked additional positive impacts with the development. Mr. Yowell answered that this will provide more of a mixed use feel for the Market at Oakland and help the area be more vibrant. He also suggested that the town homes are a more reasonable price point than a single family home. Ms. Harris asked what the impact would be for schools in the area . Mr. Yowell answered that given the number of town homes proposed, the impact to the local schools would not be significant. Mr. Barber asked about traffic impact and if it has been reviewed by staff. Mr. Stone answered that an impact assessment was not required for this proposal. He stated that the impacts recommended with the previous impact assessment were included in the Highway 41 improvements. Mr. Barber asked Planning Commission September 23, 2026 Page 3 of 11 if staff has reviewed this proposal in terms of traffic. Mr. Stone answered in the affirmative and stated that no additional improvements were needed. Mr. Barber questioned that there was less impact for this use. Mr. Gilmore suggested that it was fewer trips as there are fewer cars in the area. Mr. Bennett agreed. Mr . Yowell suggested that more detail calculations were included in the traffic analysis. Mr. Davis asked when the development construction would commence. Mr. Yowell answered that it depends on the review process but estimates in nine to twelve months. Mr. Gilmore asked about sustainability improvements for the site . Mr. Yowell answered that there is tree preservation, wetland preservation, and 14% green space that is above the required percentage is proposed. Mr. Gilmore asked if other aspects such as permeable paving, solar roofs, etc. would be included. Mr. Yowell answered that these will be considered as the development moves forward. Mr. Gilmore asked about walkability. Mr. Stone answered that pedestrian connections would be included with Mount Pleasant Way and/or Highway 41 improvements, which is a joint SCDOT and Town project. Mr. Gilmore asked about pedestrian access to the commercial uses and suggested there should be careful consideration for inclusion and connection. Mr. Ed Trevisani, 1192 Sharpstowne Court, and President of Porcher Preserve HOA, stated that they are in support of the proposal . He suggested that the proposed 87 town homes would be more compatible than the previously approved commercial plans. He stated that there is a proposed reduction in traffic of approximately 60%, which is an important consideration for Porcher Preserve. He suggested that the information presented would be more compatible and mean fewer peak hour trips and traffic. He stated that the proposed improvements to Porcher Bluff Road and the Highway 41 improvements will provide relief in the area needed. He asked for the proposal be approved. Mr. Andrew Harris, 1160 Sharpestowne Court, stated that he supports the request as well. He stated that the developer is a quality builder with a quality product that has high aesthetics. He suggested that having the residential component would help to support the exiting commercial uses. He state that Planning Commission September 23, 2026 Page 4 of 11 Billy Swails Parkway is in the area and provides pedestrian access to Laing School and provides areas for the students to walk and ride their bikes to Laing School. He suggested that once Mount Pleasant Way is completed it will connect to the commercial areas as well. There being no further comments, Mr. Bennett closed the public hearing. Mr. Barber asked about the impacts to the Town in terms of services provided by the Town. Mr. Stone answered that he is not sure of the contrast between commercial and residential for services such as water and sewer and trash. He stated that the development would need to have private trash collection. Mr . Barber asked about tax revenues. Mr . Stone answered that multi-family is considered a commercial use in terms of tax revenues. Ms. Ireland stated that she appreciates the concerns for traffic. She stated that the Comprehensive Plan recommends changing commercial zoning to residential and that this is essentially being done with this request. She stated that hotel uses were designated certain hubs, including the Market at Oakland. Again, this request would remove that use. She further stated that the townhomes would not be attainable housing and would increase the number of cars and traffic in the area. She expressed concern about the density and that the number of homes would increase the density in the area. She suggested that having a mixed use with commercial uses would allow 4 units per acre on the second floor or higher, with an additional 4 units per acre if attainable housing, but this is not being requested. She suggested that the request should not be approved. Mr. Barber suggested that there are other options for development for this site other than what has been proposed. Mr. Bennett suggested that the residential would make the PD more mixed use. Mr. Barber suggested that mixed use would be different uses within the same building. Ms. Ireland stated that T own Council recently denied a townhome development near commercial off Highway 17 that was like this proposed development. She suggested that the proposed is not mixed use . Mr. Bennett suggested that from a practical standpoint, the proposed development is adjacent to retailers and has walkability to those uses. Planning Commission September 23, 2026 Page 5 of 11 Mr. Bennett moved for approval as presented with the findings that although not attainable housing, it would serve a niche within the housing market that is not well filled at this time. Also, the proposed development would have fewer trips and less traffic. Mr. Smyth seconded the motion. Mr. Barber suggested there is more opportunity for this area that could be more beneficial. He suggested that it should remain open to more commercial development or a more true mixed development. Mr. Gilmore asked if there have been other proposals with small boutique hotels that were recently approved. Mr . Stone answered in the negative. Mr. Bennett stated there were two requests like this one that were not approved. Mr. Gilmore s uggested that the proposal could be more creative and have more positive benefits such as having less traffic. He suggested that more attainable housing should be considered. Ms. Mansour suggested that it does seem dense and agreed with Mr. Barber that the traffic impact would be heavier in the evening and mornings. Ms. Harris suggested that the implication and impact to the schools should be considered. She suggested that the density seems high when considering the school impacts. Mr. Gilmore asked if conditions could be recommended. Mr. Bennett answered in the affirmative and should be done with the motion. Mr. Bennett called for a vote on the motion. Motion failed on a 2 to 6 vote with Mr. Smyth and Mr. Bennett in favor; Mr. Barber, Ms. Harris, Mr. Davis, Mr. Gilmore, Ms. Mansour and Ms. Ireland opposed. Mr. Barber suggested that approval with conditions might not get the desired outcome. Ms. Lynes called for a point of order and asked if a recommendation was needed since the previous motion failed. Mr. Pagliarini answered that while not required, it could be considered. Planning Commission September 23, 2026 Page 6 of 11 Ms. Ireland moved for denial. Mr. Barber seconded the motion. Motion passed on a 6 to2 vote with Mr. Barber, Ms. Harris, Mr. Davis, Mr. Gilmore, Ms. Mansour and Ms. Ireland in favor; Mr. Smyth and Mr. Bennett opposed. B. PUBLIC HEARING, R-28-26, 663 Faulkner Drive, TMS No. 596-15-00-026, Request to zone RR, Rural Residential District. Staff Report Mr. Stone reviewed staff comments with the Commission. There being no applicant, Mr. Bennett moved to public comment. Being no comments, Mr. Bennett closed public comment. Mr. Barber suggested that the R C-2 zoning designated has larger lot requirements and setbacks. He asked if the RC-2 could be recommended. Mr. Stone answered that denial of the request for RR zoning would mean that it could be annexed with RC-2 zoning. Ms. Ireland suggested that the density would protect the property given the acreage of the lot. She suggested that another aspect is that there is not a lot of roadway frontage as it is already a flag lot in the County. Mr. Barber suggested that deviating from the RC -2 zoning would be deviating from the Comprehensive Plan. Mr. Davis asked if there is any concern with it being a flag lot. Mr. Bennett answered that the flag lot exists in the County. Mr. Stone concurred and stated that it was configured in 1999. Mr. Barber moved for denial. Ms. Ireland seconded the motion. Motion passed on a 6 to 2 vote with Mr. Bennett, Mr. Barber, Mr. Davis, Mr. Gilmore, Ms. Mansour and Ms. Ireland in favor; Mr. Smyth and Ms. Harris opposed. C. PUBLIC HEARING, R-29-26, 1268 Porchers Bluff Road, TMS No. 600-00-00- 018, Request to zone R-1, Residential District. Staff Report Mr. Stone reviewed staff comments with the Commission. Planning Commission September 23, 2026 Page 7 of 11 The applicant not present, Mr. Bennett moved to public comment. There being no comments, Mr. Bennett closed the public hearing. Mr. Barber moved for approval. Ms. Harris seconded the motion. Motion passed on a 7 to 1 vote with Mr. Smyth, Mr. Bennett, Mr. Barber, Ms. Harris, Mr. Gilmore, Ms. Mansour and Ms. Ireland in favor; Mr. Davis opposed. D. SKETCH PLAN, SP-11-26, 1748 Halls Pond Road, TMS No. 558-00-00-197, Request to create three lots on 1.25 acres. LDR Waiver also requested to subdivide from an access easement. Staff Report This item was withdrawn by staff. E. SKETCH PLAN, SP-12-26, 1751 Rifle Range Road, TMS No. 5 61-00-00- 102,112, Request to create four lots on 1.8 acres. LDR Waiver also requested to subdivide from an access easement. Staff Report Ms. Noble reviewed staff comments with the Commission. Mr. Bennett asked the elevation of the property. Ms. Noble answered that it is approximately ten feet. Mr. Barber asked about the three properties adjacent to the proposed parcel. Ms. Noble showed the location on the site plan for the Commission. Mr. Barber expressed concern that the lots are not being configured to mirror the adjacent lots. Mr. Barber asked about the retention pond. Ms. Noble answered that the retention will be reviewed accounting for the maximum impervious surface drainage for each lot. Mr. Barber if the dry retention pond would collect from the adjacent lots. Ms. Noble answered that she believes that the adjacent lots flow away from the pond, but she has requested LiDAR topography to verify. Ms. Mansour asked who maintains the private road. Mr. Davis McNair, applicant, stated that the parcel has the right to utilize the right-of-way in conjunction with the three adjacent properties. He stated that the HOA would be responsible for maintenance of the roadway and pond. Planning Commission September 23, 2026 Page 8 of 11 Mr. Davis McNair reviewed the request with the Commission and stated that the configuration would remove two driveways from Rifle Range Road. Mr. Barber asked if the lots would have septic tanks. Mr . McNair answered in the affirmative and state that there is not main septic available in the area. He stated that the lots would have water service from Mount Pleasant Waterworks and a fire hydrant was being required as well. Ms. Ireland asked about LDR waiver and expressed concern with subdivision within a settlement community and if the neighbors have been contacted. Mr. McNair answered in the negative and stated that this is heir’s property. Ms. Ireland expressed concern with the proposed request and that subdivision would affect the character of the settlement community. Mr. McNair suggested that there is precedent with the subdivision and that the property is part of a larger common plan (LCP). Mr. Barber expressed concern with having dry retention ponds and asked if a cistern configuration could be considered. Mr. McNair answered that this is an LCP , and while a different system could be considered, it would most likely still require a pond . Mr. Noble stated that the pond is centralized detention and is recommended by the Town. Mr. Barber asked if the roadway would be paved. Mr. McNair answered that it would be a gravel roadway with stormwater . Mr . Barber asked if having only three lots would mean the pond would not be needed. Mr. McNair answered in the negative. Ms. Noble stated that the roadway would have to handle emergency vehicles and meet fire standards. Mr. Gilmore asked if a cul-de-sac could be changed. Mr. McNair answered that it is existing. Mr. Gilmore asked if the adjacent lots are accessing the roadway. Mr. McNair answered in the affirmative. Mr. Gilmore asked if the cul-de-sac could be removed to preserve more trees. Mr. McNair answered in the negative and stated that the cul -de-sac would be needed for emergency vehicles. He stated that the improvements include centering the existing road access on the right-of-way. Ms. Mansour asked about relocating the trees to another location. Mr. McNair answered that this could be considered. Planning Commission September 23, 2026 Page 9 of 11 Mr. Gilmore asked the location of the loblolly pine. Mr. McNair answered that it is located to the upper left of the pond. Ms. Harris asked why septic. Mr . McNair answered that there is no gravity sewer available in the area. Ms. Noble stated that Mount Pleasant Waterworks is requiring they adhere to their maintenance schedule. Mr. Pagliarini stated that a condition be placed to show that they have legal access and a maintenance agreement. Mr. Eric Bak ey, developer, stated that this is the third configuration reviewed by the Town. He stated that there proposal would eliminate a flag lot. Ms. Ireland expressed concern with removal of trees and impact to the settlement community and that the request does not meet the LDR waiver requirements. Ms. Ireland moved for denial. Mr. Davis seconded the motion. Motion passed on a 7 to 1 vote with Mr. Smyth, Mr. Bennett, Mr. Barber, Mr. Davis, Mr. Gilmore, Ms. Mansour and Ms. Ireland in favor; Ms. Harris opposed. 7. Discussion of Data Center Land Use and Zoning Ms. Reed reviewed the item with the Commission. Ms. Ireland asked about Information technology uses and that a data center could be classified under this category. Ms. Reed answered that they are more classified as data processing and computing infrastructure uses. Mr. Bennett suggested that the definitions need to be carefully considered and any changes implemented to ensure there are specific parameters. Mr. Davis suggested that the Town is moving away from being a residential town. He suggested that this type of use is not needed. Ms. Ireland suggested that there should be some limits regarding size, capacity, employees, etc. She stated that electrical and water usage is a concern as well as Planning Commission September 23, 2026 Page 10 of 11 the amount of noise. She stated that the Town should be mindful on what the impact of the size of center would be not only for the Town but also the surrounding areas and neighborhoods. Mr. Barber suggested that having them allowed with a special exception should be considered. Ms. Ireland agreed with Mr. Barber but expressed concern with making sure the parameters are clearly outlined. Mr. Gilmore asked if any of the parcels would allow a large data center. Ms. Reed answered that she was not sure. Mr. Gilmore suggested that a large data center could not be built in Mount Pleasant. He asked the acceptable size of a data center. Mr. Pagliarini answered that the zoning restrictions should be reviewed to determine if they are sufficient and if necessary, further restrict them. He stated that currently the one megawatt is the nation al standard at this time. He stated that noise, pollution, etc. should be reviewed and those parameters and restrictions put in place to be followed in the future. Mr. Bennett suggested that firms such as S PAWAR (now NAVWAR) , BenefitFocus, Blackbaud, etc., should be used as benchmarks. Mr. Davis asked the zoning of the property on Faison near the airport. Ms. Reed answered that it is zoned PD with AB and ED zoning uses allowed. She stated that another factor is that an impact assessment would be necessary if they meet those thresholds. Ms. Reed stated that the use table would be reviewed to determine if some of the current uses should be broken out. Mr. Bennett suggested that another factor is the proximity of property to the ocean and the possible impacts and additional scrutiny. Ms. Ireland suggested that coordination with the County would be beneficial . She suggested that an overlay district might be another solution particularly for properties currently in the County jurisdiction. Planning Commission September 23, 2026 Page 11 of 11 Mr. Barber suggested that megawatts might not be the only way to restrict them and that a square footage requirement might be needed as well. Mr. Pagliarini stated that the 120 days would start once Town Council has final reading on the moratorium. There being no further business, the meeting adjourned at 7:06 pm. Submitted by, L. Lynes PlanComsn09232026

Source: Town of Mount Pleasant website. First collected Oct 13, 2026.