RecordWell Data

_09142026-2261

Town of Mount Pleasant · Charleston County · meeting of Sep 14, 2026 · Minutes

Open the original document More from Town of Mount Pleasant

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

TOWN OF MOUNT PLEASANT, SOUTH CAROLINA HISTORIC DISTRICT PRESERVATION COMMISSION SEPTEMBER 14, 2026 MINUTES Staff Report Present: Meghan Gravitt, Chair, Krystine Edwards, Kenny Craft, Eugene Foxworth, Warren Player. Staff: Bryan Hankinson, Lynnette Lynes Ms. Gravitt called the meeting to order at 5:00 pm and reviewed the procedures with the public. 1. Approval of Agenda Ms. Gravitt moved for approval of the agenda. Mr. Player seconded the motion. All in favor. 2. Approval of Minutes--August 10, 2026 Ms. Gravitt moved for approval of the minutes. Mr. Player seconded the motion. All in favor. 3. General Public Comment 4. Correspondence There being no comments, Ms. Gravitt continued with the agenda. All correspondence received was linked to the agenda. 5. Consent Motions Ms. Gravitt moved for consent approval of the following items: ➢ 218 Center St., Survey Card 6049/Non-Historic – TMS 5320900088, Final Review for the replacement of siding on an existing historic primary structure. Mr. Player seconded the motion. All in favor. Historic District Preservation Commission September 14, 2026 Page 2 of 13 6. Business A. 108 Beach St. , No Survey Card/Non -Historic – TMS 5171500131, Preliminary Review for new construction of a primary structure. Mr. Hankinson reviewed staff comments with the Commission. Mr. Will Danielson, Charleston Custom Homes, reviewed the request with the Commission. There being no comments, Ms. Gravitt closed public comment and continued to Commission questions. Mr. Craft asked if the view from the water can be shown for the final submittal. Mr. Danielson answered that this could be done. Mr. Craft asked if the neighbors have been contacted. Mr. Danielson answered that he has not contacted the neighbors at 112 Beach, but 104 Beach did not have any opposition to the request. He stated that the home could be moved forward on the lot , but it is aligned with 104 Beach. He stated that the home was moved forward on the lot to avoid the water line. Mr. Craft asked if it is in an AE10 flood zone. Mr. Danielson answered in the affirmative and stated that a portion is in an X flood zone, so the it slopes up as you approach the water. Mr. Foxworth asked if a raised home was considered. Mr. Danielson answered in the negative and stated it would be built on a crawl space and keeps it more in line with the other homes. Ms. Gravitt suggested that seeing the homes as they present to the water is important. Mr. Craft asked the materials for the garage. Mr. Danielson answered that the lower portion would be stucco . Mr. Kraft asked the material details be called out on the plans with trim details as well. Mr. Foxworth asked if the garage doors could be moved to the side. Mr. Danielson answered that the preference is to keep the garage at the front; moving to the side would mean additional impervious surface. Historic District Preservation Commission September 14, 2026 Page 3 of 13 Ms. Gravitt agreed and suggested moving the garage doors to the side should be considered. Mr. Foxworth asked about the front door. Mr. Danielson answered that it is a French door. Ms. Gravitt suggested that the entrances should be better defined and pronounced. Mr. Craft asked about the porches and if there is a upper floor porch. He suggested that the porches should be better aligned. Mr. Danielson also stated that another challenge is have the garage deep enough for the cars to fit if they are turned on the side of the home. Mr. Craft suggested that the home does not seem to fit the character of the historic district with the wider porches and smaller columns. He suggested this be revisited. Ms. Gravitt asked about the additional roofline. Mr. Craft agreed and suggested that having a more simple roofline should be considered. Mr. Foxworth asked the materials and colors of the roof. Mr. Danielson answered that it would be a metal roof with Confederate Flannel with Aunt Betty China house colors. Mr. Foxworth suggested a standing seam roof. Ms. Gravitt asked if all the setbacks are met. Mr. Danielson answered in the affirmative and the impervious percentage is met as well. Mr. Craft suggested that more of the character details of the OV should be studied and incorporated into the design. Ms. Gravitt asked how the house relates to the others on the street should be shown as well. Mr. Craft suggested simplifying the design with less gable and less corners. Historic District Preservation Commission September 14, 2026 Page 4 of 13 Ms. Gravit suggested that the garage elements are less prominent and subordinate to the main structure. Ms. Edwards suggested that having more emphasis on highlighting the main structure and not the garage should be considered. Mr. Player suggested that more details on the plans should be included. Mr. Player asked if the upper porch would have wire in addition to the “x” pattern railing. He stated that more information on the shutters is needed. Mr. Player asked about the ro om over the garage. Mr. Danielson answered that it has not been determined. Mr. Player asked if it would be separate living quarters. Mr. Danielson answered in the negative. Mr. Craft suggested that more detail on the columns is needed. Mr. Player asked about the setbacks. Mr. Danielson answered that all setbacks are noted on the plans. Mr. Player suggested that the location of the home works well with the existing homes. Mr. Danielson asked if all staff comments and Commission comments are addressed, and could the home come back for final. Mr. Hankinson answered that all comments would be provided to the applicant. Mr. Craft suggested that come back for preliminary might be a better option to ensure that the direction meets requirements. Ms. Gravitt moved for approval to re-open public comment. Ms. Edwards seconded the motion. All in favor. Mr. Dan Derbyshire, owner, asked if they could come back with a final submittal. Mr. Hankinson answered that the previous approval has expired and is no longer vested, so they would have to proceed with this plan as a new submittal. There were no additional Commission comments. Historic District Preservation Commission September 14, 2026 Page 5 of 13 B. 728 Pitt St. , Survey Card 5956/Historic – TMS 5320900072, Preliminary Review for the construction of a new garage addition to an existing primary structure. Mr. Hankinson reviewed staff comments with the Commission. Ms. Linda Balzac, architect, reviewed the request with the Commission. There being no comments, Ms. Gravitt closed public comment. Mr. Craft suggested that it is different from the previous submittal. Ms. Gravitt asked about the neighboring property. Ms. Balzac answered that there is a long driveway. Mr. Foxworth asked if there was any comments from the neighbors. Ms. Balzac answered that the neighbor behind them had no objections. Mr. Craft asked about the porte cochere. Ms. Balzac answered that this was to soften the garage. Ms. Gravitt asked where they access the home. Ms. Balzac answered through the front door. Mr. Foxworth asked about the window in the hyphen between the home and the garage. Ms. Balzac answered that the lift is in the garage up to the hallway Ms. Edwards asked the dimensions of the hallway from the garage. Ms. Balzac answered that the hallway and lift are three feet, six inches wide. Mr. Craft suggested that the hallway from the garage is small. Ms. Balzac answered that it was designed to be as small as possible and if desired, could be removed without affecting the historic structure. Mr. Craft suggested that the porte cochere columns should be revisited. Historic District Preservation Commission September 14, 2026 Page 6 of 13 Ms. Gravitt asked if all comments were addressed. Ms. Balzac answered that the rear porch is not historic. She stated that the windows were replaced in 2016, the colors would match existing, the garage doors would be noted as wood, and there is fiber cement siding that replaced all of the exterior siding and this would be matched. Mr. Foxworth asked if the roof color would match existing. Ms. Balzac answered in the affirmative. Mr. Player suggested that the design looks good. Ms. Edwards asked about the space between the garage and the house. Ms. Balzac answered that it is four feet, 8 inches Ms. Gravitt asked the setback from the front porch to the porte cochere. Ms. Balzac answered that porte cochere is 13 feet, 2.5 inches back. Mr. Craft suggested that wider hyphen should be considered. Mr. Hankinson cautioned that the stormwater runoff from the roof of the garage should be managed. Ms. Edwards asked if the home could be moved so it did not encroach into the setback. Ms. Gravitt suggested that home might be moved back so it is farther from the street and to have the garage farther back on the lot to better meet the guidelines. C. 320 Morrison St. ,Survey Card 6159/Non-Historic – TMS 5320100051,Preliminary Review for the demolition of an existing non - historic primary structure and construction of a primary structure. Mr. Hankinson reviewed staff comments with the Commission. Mr. Joel Adrian, architect, reviewed the request with the Commission. Historic District Preservation Commission September 14, 2026 Page 7 of 13 Ms. Heather Evans, 318 Morrison, expressed concern with the encroachment into the setbacks. She expressed concern with the massing of the home and privacy issues. She suggested that the pool would be seen from the right-of-way. She also expressed concern with the encroachment into the setback to accommodate required parking . She asked that the setback encroachments not be approved and the trees preserved. She suggested that the encroachment relief is not needed because of a constrained lot, but the applicant wanting to maximize the building envelope. She noted that the master bedroom porch was removed and replaced with a Juliet balcony, but the bedroom windows would still look directly into her bedroom. She als o expressed concern with the pool located in the side yard and that it is visible from the street. She suggested that the Laurel Oak proposed for removal is being considered because the construction might cause stress and not because the tree is in poor condition or hazardous. She suggested that removal would cause less sha de. She asked that the setback variances be denied, require an updated and corrected tree protection plan, real privacy mitigation, and accurate renderings before approval. Ms. Amanda Pritchett, 314 Morrison, expressed concern with the environmental impact consider the number of historic trees on the property and trees on the property next door being requested for removal. She suggested that written consent for removing the neighboring trees should be secured. She suggested that no protection plan has been considered for preserving the historic trees. She suggested that removal of the trees would exacerbate flooding, lessen the mature tree canopy and lessen the amount of shade. She suggested that a tree protection plan is submitted, written consent from the neighboring homeowner, confirmation that Board of Zoning Appeals approval is required prior to removal of trees and no variances granted that would allow clearing the lot. Mr. Chuck Bennett, 202 Pitt Street, agreed with the previous comments. He suggested that the proposed home is too large for the home. He suggested that the street is narrow and constricts access in the area. He asked that if approved, all construction vehicles and equipment should be parked on the site and not on the street to avoid further congestion and blocking of the street. He expressed concern that if the street is blocked, drivers would need to use Historic District Preservation Commission September 14, 2026 Page 8 of 13 Mr. Chris Baldwin, 318 Morrison St, expressed concern asked that the guidelines be applied to this application and that encroachments not be approved. He suggested that there is already significant flooding in the area and suggested that the proposed plan shows additional impervious surface that would exacerbate flooding. He suggested that the pool does not meet the guidelines as it can be seen from the street and is not located in the rear of the property. He suggested that the guidelines should be adhered to so that the character of the neighborhood is preserved. There being no further comments, Ms. Gravitt closed public comment. Mr. Craft asked if some of the trees proposed for removal could be preserved. Mr. Adrian read a portion of the tree report for the Commission noting the declining condition of the Laurell Oak . He showed pictures of the other Oak trees showing the issues and condition of the trees. He stated that all comments would be addressed. Mr. Craft stated that there are improvements to the design and thanked the architect for simplifying the massing. Mr. Craft asked about the windows on the Whilden side (right elevation) second story and if there could be fewer windows, so it is not as congested. Mr. Adrian answered that the upper windows were configured to align with the lower windows and door. Ms. Edwards asked if the right elevation encroaches into the setbacks. Mr. Adrian answered in the affirmative and stated that this was done to rotate the garage so the doors were not facing the street. Mr. Craft asked if the existing home is closer to Whilden. Mr. Adrian answered in the affirmative. Mr. Craft suggested that this appears more appropriate. Mr. Craft asked about the encroachment into the TPZ of the Laurel Oak and if this could be minimized. Ms. Edwards stated that she would like more trees and less fence and asked if the trees can be preserved. She suggested that more than a hedge or another fence should be considered so there is more tree canopy. Mr. Adrian answered that the fence is required for the pool. He stated that the trees are declining. Historic District Preservation Commission September 14, 2026 Page 9 of 13 Mr. Player suggested that the trees being removed should be mitigated to help replace the lost tree canopy. He suggested that the two trees on the neighbor’s property should remain. He also suggested that more trees could be installed for shade and screening of the pool. Ms. Edwards asked about the Juliet balcony. Mr. Adrian answered that the owner wanted to be able to view the pool and the family when using the pool. Mr. Craft stated that there is no prohibition from having windows or view into the backyard. He suggested that some type of landscaping or trees be planted to better screen the neighboring homes. Ms. Gravitt suggested that the window frame color should be reconsidered as the black is not historically accurate . She suggested that more muted and cream tones are historically correct. Mr. Craft suggested that having the home closer to the street is the best option. Mr. Foxworth asked if the windows are casement windows. Mr. Adrian answered in the affirmative. Mr. Craft suggested considering the bump out porch areas should be more like infill porches with pilasters and columns and would work better with the base. Ms. Gravitt asked if the number of entrances could be reduced to have a more pronounced main entrance. Mr. Adrian answered that the dual entrance is more historically accurate for corner lots. Mr. Player suggested that changing the gate entrances could give a more pronounced main entrance. Mr. Craft suggested that the number of upper windows be restudied, so it is not as crowded. Ms. Gravitt stated that she appreciates the garage turn. She stated that having the house closer to the street gives more privacy for the neighbors. Historic District Preservation Commission September 14, 2026 Page 10 of 13 Mr. Craft reiterated that the proposed home is more appropriate for the historic district. D. 3 Pierates Cruze , Survey Card 6062/Non-Historic – TMS 5320900008, Final Review for the demolition of an existing non -historic primary structure and construction of a primary structure. Mr. Hankinson reviewed staff comments with the Commission. Ms. Liz Stanton, architect, reviewed the request with the Commission. There being no comments, Ms. Gravitt closed public comment. Ms. Gravitt asked if the encroachment could be approved for the storage building. Mr. Hankinson answered in the negative. Mr. Player suggested that the storage building would help screen the view from the neighboring parking lot. Ms. Edwards asked if the only encroachment would be for stairs. Ms. Stanton answered in the affirmative. Mr. Player suggested that it is a sensitive design and the bluestone is a very historical material feature. Ms. Edwards asked if the storage building could be moved. Ms. Stanton answered that if moved to the back, it would block the harbor view. Ms. Gravitt moved to re-open public comment. Mr. Player seconded the motion. All in favor. Mr. Jeff Bird , owner stated they need storage and suggested that the building could be attached to the main structure if desired. Ms. Edwards asked if the storage is attached to the main structure, would it be within the setbacks. Ms. Stanton answered that the storage and cabana would still encroach approximately ten feet into the 25 foot rear setback. Historic District Preservation Commission September 14, 2026 Page 11 of 13 Mr. Craft asked if the storage could be attached only by the foundation but detached from the main structure in every other way could be accomplished. Mr. Hankinson answered in the negative as it would be a setback encroachment for the main structure. He stated that if attached, those changes would have to be reviewed by the Commission as an addition to the existing home. He noted that the addition would affect the BAR, and pervious surface calculations. Ms. Edwards suggested that the if attached, it would be located behind the fireplace and the stairs moved to be closer to the doors. She suggested that it could be a good location Ms. Lynes raised a point of order that i f denied, the prop osed changes would meet the requirement s of a significant change that could then be reviewed without having to wait one year. Mr. Hankinson answe red that it would be a significant change. Ms. Stanton suggested that to move forward with approval of the plans the shed would need to be removed with the storage addition to be brought back as an addition in the future. M r. Hankinson agreed with all other staff comments be ing completed. Ms. S tanton asked if the demolition permit would be included with the approval of the main structure. Mr. Hankinson answered in the affirmative. Mr. Craft asked if Commission could give a conditional approval for the shed that could be approved at staff level. Mr. Hankinson answered that this could be done, but the Commission would not see the revised plans submitted. He stated that another issue would be the change in BAR and impervious surface. He suggested that the cleanest option would be to approve the main structure without the shed so they could continue moving forward with building. Mr. Player asked if the storage building can be approved as presented. Mr. Hankinson answered in the negative and stated that there is a ten foot setback for all accessory structures that cannot be approved by the Commission. Ms. Gravitt closed public comments. Historic District Preservation Commission September 14, 2026 Page 12 of 13 Ms. Gravitt moved for approval of the demolition and conditional approval of the primary structure with removal of the accessory structure from the current plans presented at this meeting. Ms. Edwards seconded the motion. All in favor. E. 218 Center St., Survey Card 6049/Non-Historic – TMS 5320900088, Final Review for the replacement of siding on an existing historic primary structure. This item was approved by consent. 7. Staff Approvals Mr. Hankinson reviewed staff approvals with the Commission as follows: A. 135 Toomer Ln. 1 , No Survey Card/Non -Historic – TMS 5171500064, Approved for the alteration to an existing driveway. B. 103 Hibben St. , Survey Card 6224/Non-Historic – TMS 5171500110, Approved for the alterations to a previously approved roof design. 8. Right of Way Fencing Conditions Mr. Hankinson stated that this was proposed for discussion at the last meeting. Mr. Craft suggested that if historically there was a fence along the frontage, it should remain. Mr. Hankinson noted that currently , fences are a staff level approval, but if changed, it would then require Commission approval for all changes to a frontage fence. Mr. Craft expressed concern that historic fencing would be lost. Mr. Player suggested that if removed, it should not be required to replace. The Commission discussed whether right-of-way fencing should be further reviewed. Mr. Player moved for approval to revise the guidelines for fences to be discussed at the next meeting. Ms. Edwards seconded the motion. All in favor. Historic District Preservation Commission September 14, 2026 Page 13 of 13 9. Discussion of Items for Next Agenda There were no other items for next month’s agenda. There being no further business, the meeting adjourned at 7:44 pm. Submitted by, L. Lynes HDPC09142026

Source: Town of Mount Pleasant website. First collected Oct 13, 2026.