_08312026-2260
Town of Mount Pleasant · Charleston County · meeting of Aug 31, 2026 · Minutes
Open the original document More from Town of Mount Pleasant
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
TOWN OF MOUNT PLEASANT, SC
POLICE, JUDICIAL & LEGAL COMMITTEE
Monday, August 31, 2026
1:00 p.m.
Municipal Complex, Council Chambers
100 Ann Edwards Lane, Mount Pleasant, SC 29464
MI
NUTES
Click here to view the presentation.
Click here to listen to the recording.
1. Call to order
Mayor Will Haynie called the Police, Judicial & Legal Committee meeting
to order on Monday, August 31, 2026, at 1:22 p.m. Before proceeding,
Mayor Haynie requested that all present stand to observe a moment of
silence in honor of Officer Chris DeLong of the Columbia Police
Department, who was killed in the line of duty the preceding Saturday,
and in recognition of Officer David Dymock, who was wounded in the
same incident and had been released from the hospital.
The Chief of Police addressed the committee, noting that members of
the Mount Pleasant Police Department were wearing mourning bands in
solidarity with the Columbia Police Department. The Chief shared that
Officer DeLong is survived by his wife and two small children and asked
for continued prayers for injured officer’s recovery.
2. Approval of Minutes from August 3, 2026
Motion to approve the minutes from August 3, 2026, meeting was made
by Councilmember Chapman and seconded by Councilmember Crosby.
Motion passed unanimously.
3. Public Comments
The Chair opened the floor for public comments, requesting that
speakers provide their name and address and noted a two-and-one-half-
minute time limit.
Sandra Connell, 2106 Sewee Indian Court, Dunes West, thanked the
committee for its work on animal protection ordinances. She encouraged
Police, Judicial & Legal Committee
August 31, 2026
Page 2 of 10
members to view proposed ordinances through the lens of irresponsible
owners and breeders rather than responsible ones, and cited Lawrence
County, South Carolina as a model for bold, enforceable ordinances with
clear consequences. She urged the committee to visit local animal
shelters before voting, noting that accidental litters are flooding shelters
and that the town must make it harder to do the wrong thing.
Lisa Schnipke, 185 Mossy Oak Way, commented on the August 3rd
special Town Council meeting, at which two community members were
given fifteen minutes to present their vision for development at the town-
owned Faison Road property. She expressed the view that such
presentations would be better directed through the appropriate
committee, such as the Economic Development Committee, rather than
a special full Council meeting.
Mark Fieb, 1590 Fiddlers Marsh, representing Palmetto Breeze
Charters, Charleston Water Taxi, and Captain Cocktail Charters, raised
the issue of illegal charter operations using the Mount Pleasant public
dock at Shem Creek. He stated that on any given weekend, an
estimated twenty to thirty illegal charters operate from the dock, that
none carry proper insurance or United States Coast Guard credentials,
and that two recent fatalities in the region—one locally and one near the
Statue of Liberty in New York—were linked to illegal charters. He noted
that legitimate operators carry the Town of Mount Pleasant as a third-
party rider on their insurance policies, and urged the town to police the
dock and verify business licenses and insurance.
Casey Brazil, 970 Cottingham Drive, echoed the comments of Sandra
Connell and offered specific suggested improvements to the proposed
animal cruelty ordinance. These included more precise definitions for
dogs and cats, prohibition of hoarding in addition to its definition,
inclusion of animal mill provisions, a limit on crate duration, a clearer
definition of abandonment, and stronger breeder licensing requirements
including mandatory inspections and license revocation for failed
inspections.
Police, Judicial & Legal Committee
August 31, 2026
Page 3 of 10
Paul Sperry, 238 Yates Avenue, representing the South Carolina
Animal Welfare Alliance, thanked the committee for its ongoing work and
indicated that the Alliance intended to continue collaborating with town
staff to enhance the proposed ordinance.
Perry Rourk, 2004 Brick Kiln Parkway, addressed agenda item 6a
regarding the requirements for calling a special meeting. He expressed
concern that the agenda lacked detail about what might be discussed or
voted upon. He stated that under current rules the mayor may
independently call a special meeting while other council members must
have the support of two additional members. He urged the committee to
ensure that any revisions strengthen the council form of government,
and recommended that the mayor be subject to the same threshold as
other members.
4. Police Matters
a. Employee Years of Service
The Chief of Police recognized Sergeant John Shaver for ten years of
dedicated service to the Mount Pleasant Police Department. The Chief
highlighted Sergeant Shaver’s career in patrol, his roles as field training
officer, patrol corporal, and patrol sergeant, and his service as a Mobile
Field Force team leader and senior Harbor Patrol operator. The Chief
also noted Sergeant Shaver’s coordination with multiple agencies to
safely return a veteran with Alzheimer's disease who had driven from
Florida to Mount Pleasant, as well as his academic achievements,
including a master's degree from Charleston Southern University, and
his support of the Special Olympics, Cops on the Coop, and the Polar
Plunge. Mayor Haynie congratulated Sergeant John Shaver and thanked
him for his service.
b. Review Of Policies And Enforcement Of Boat Use At Town-
Owned Dock At Shem Creek Park
The Chief of Police reported that there is currently very little enforcement
of charter activity at the town-owned dock at Shem Creek Park, as the
department has no advance knowledge of charter schedules and
nothing in existing policy prohibits commercial charter operations from
using the dock for passenger pickup and dropoff.
Police, Judicial & Legal Committee
August 31, 2026
Page 4 of 10
Town Administrator DeMoura indicated that a range of short- and long-
term measures could be pursued, and suggested that staff needed
additional time to develop a formal recommendation. As a short-term
measure, he proposed assigning a business license official to the dock
alongside a police officer on weekends, beginning in September, to
verify that operators possess valid business licenses and to saturate the
area for several weeks as an initial step.
Mayor Haynie noted the complexity of the area, which also includes a
county-operated boat ramp, kayak and paddleboard rentals, and the
shrimp boat operation, and expressed longstanding interest in
establishing a collaborative harbor master arrangement involving the
Department of Natural Resources, Charleston County, and the town,
which would free sworn officers for other duties. Mayor Haynie indicated
he would contact DNR Director Tom Mullican and the Chair of County
Council to explore a joint enforcement arrangement and noted the town
should not bear the full burden of policing the waterway.
Mark Fieb, the public commenter, was invited to return to the podium
and provided additional detail. He stated that illegal charters operating in
the area are most active on Fridays and Saturdays between 10:00 AM
and 4:00 PM, often involving binge drinking excursions on unregistered
vessels, and that legitimate Coast Guard-certified operators visibly
display a credential sticker at the helm. He further noted that the Coast
Guard had recently convened a meeting with legitimate operators due to
the scale of the problem, and that those operators are actively
photographing and reporting illegal charters to a Coast Guard task force,
though the Coast Guard acknowledged its enforcement capacity is
limited.
Councilmember Chapman emphasized that the problem extends beyond
Shem Creek to other locations such as Patriots Point Marina, and that
enforcement efforts must account for operators relocating when one
area is monitored.
The committee reached general consensus to direct staff to proceed
with a near-term business license inspection presence at the dock and
to continue exploring a broader, multi-agency long-term solution.
Police, Judicial & Legal Committee
August 31, 2026
Page 5 of 10
c. Discussion Of The Town Of Mount Pleasant Towing Ordinance
The Chief of Police explained that the proposed amendment to the
towing ordinance is a straightforward change resulting from a rotational
tow company whose lease at its impound lot had expired. Due to the
difficulty towing companies face in finding suitable lots within the current
distance requirement, the Chief recommended amending Section 112.22
to increase the allowable distance for towing company impound lots from
four miles to ten miles from the corporate limits of the town.
Motion to revise the towing ordinance to increase the allowable impound
lot distance from four miles to ten miles from the corporate limits,
adopting the Chief's recommendation, was made by Councilmember
Chapman and seconded Councilmember Tinkey. The motion carried
unanimously.
5. Judicial Matters
There were no agenda items under Judicial Matters.
6a. Review And Possible Action Regarding The Requirements For
Calling A Special Meeting
Corporation Counsel David Pagiarini reviewed the current ordinance
governing special meetings, noting that the mayor may call a special
meeting independently and shall call one when requested by any three
council members.
Mayor Haynie provided historical context, explaining that the three-
member threshold had previously replaced a one-member threshold
after individual council members had used the ability to place items on
the agenda of special meetings in ways the council found disruptive to
the committee-based process of government. Mayor Haynie clarified the
distinction between the council form of government in Mount Pleasant
and the so-called strong mayor form, emphasizing that the primary
differences relate only to administrative functions such as budget
presentation, and hiring and firing of staff—not to the mayor's ability to
call special meetings or manage emergency situations. He reviewed a
record of special meetings called since 2018, noting they were
overwhelmingly tied to BOZA appeals, COVID-related matters, and
standard pre-council appointment meetings.
Mayor Haynie and multiple committee members expressed the view that
the special meeting process had been used in a manner inconsistent
Police, Judicial & Legal Committee
August 31, 2026
Page 6 of 10
with the committee structure of government, and that requiring a majority
of council—five members—to call a special meeting would ensure that
any such meeting had sufficient support to actually result in a vote, while
still preserving the mayor's independent authority to call meetings in
emergency or exigent circumstances. It was discussed that the existing
committee system exists precisely to vet items before bringing them to
the full council, and that the recent special meeting to receive a
development presentation from community members should have been
directed through the Economic Development Committee instead.
Councilmember Crosby expressed some reservation about requiring five
votes and suggested that procedural safeguards, rather than a
numerical threshold alone, might better protect the committee process.
The committee discussed the matter and ultimately agreed to move
forward with the five-member threshold.
Motion to amend Section 30.22 of the town ordinance to require five
council members—rather than three—to request that the mayor call a
special meeting, while preserving the mayor's independent authority to
call such meetings, was made by Councilmember Chapman and
seconded by Councilmember Tinkey. Councilmember Crosby voted no.
The motion carried 3–1.
6b. Continued Discussion Regarding The Resolution In Support Of
Senate Bill S.0246 To Amend Section 46-9-110 Of The South
Carolina Code Of Laws To Provide That A Unit Of Local
Government May Adopt An Ordinance Restricting The Use Of
Certain Pesticide Products
Corporation Counsel David Pagliarini noted that the committee had
previously requested presentations from outside experts and that two
presentations had been prepared, along with a draft resolution for
possible action. Staff noted that the Town Council had passed a
resolution the prior year supporting the companion House bill, which had
not advanced.
Police, Judicial & Legal Committee
August 31, 2026
Page 7 of 10
Presentation by the Avian Conservation Center
Stephen Schabel, CEO of the Avian Conservation Center, introduced
Valerie Sprinkle, principal investigator for a local birds of prey study. Ms.
Sprinkle presented findings from a study conducted between May 2024
and September 2025, during which forty-eight birds of six species were
tested for nine chemicals, including both first-generation anticoagulant
rodenticides (FBRs) and second-generation anticoagulant rodenticides
(SGARs). Key findings included that nearly 90 percent of birds tested
had anticoagulant compounds in their systems, 60 percent exceeded the
established lethal limit, and 48 percent had three or more compounds
present simultaneously. The highest cumulative burdens were found in
the Charleston area, and all five birds from the Mount Pleasant vicinity
had compounds at or above meaningful levels. Ms. Sprinkle noted that
SGARs—the more lethal compounds requiring only a single feeding to
kill—were the predominant compounds detected, and that these can
persist in tissues and the environment for up to three years. She also
noted that the study found no statistically significant difference in
compound profiles before and after the February 2025 federal regulatory
change, likely due to this persistence.
Mayor Haynie thanked the Avian Conservation Center for its work and
expressed the committee's interest in pursuing state-level action. He
acknowledged that while Mount Pleasant is a small municipality, coastal
counties may share the same concern, and he asked that the Center
help identify the most achievable and scientifically supported path
forward, noting that bills may be prefiled in November ahead of the next
legislative session.
Presentation by Clemson University, Department of Pesticide
Regulation (via video)
Ryan O'Neill, Assistant Director of the Department of Pesticide
Regulation at Clemson University, joined via video conference alongside
Deputy Director Dr. Mike William and Field Operations Manager Michael
Russell. Mr. O'Neill noted that Clemson holds statewide primacy from
the EPA for pesticide use regulation and has the authority to regulate
both pesticide use and product registration.
He described a successful voluntary reduction program piloted on
Kiawah Island beginning in 2020, cautioning that results take time given
the persistence of SGARs in the environment. He reported that Clemson
Police, Judicial & Legal Committee
August 31, 2026
Page 8 of 10
implemented a restricted use pesticide status for second-generation
anticoagulants in January 2025, limiting their sale to licensed dealers
and their application to licensed professionals, and that this restriction
has been extended indefinitely. Inspections in the first year found
violations at approximately one-third of retail locations, which was
characterized as a strong first-year result. Mr. O'Neill recommended that
Mount Pleasant consider a pilot program modeled on Kiawah Island,
beginning with the town's own public works operations, maintaining
sustained public education, and engaging directly with the pest control
industry through its state association.
Mayor Haynie confirmed that the Kiawah Island program had involved
approximately 33,000 residents, with roughly 25 percent signing a
voluntary pledge, and noted that Mount Pleasant had already pursued
conversations with pest control operators in the area. He indicated he
had observed that many restaurant operators are unaware of the risks
posed by SGARs and could be receptive to education.
Councilmember Chapman requested that the pest control association be
formally invited to a future committee meeting, as Clemson had been
today, so that their cooperation could be sought proactively rather than
having regulations imposed upon them. Staff confirmed this could be
arranged.
The committee did not take a final vote on the resolution but directed
staff to continue developing the program, engage the pest control
association, and keep the matter on the legislative agenda given the
upcoming prefiling window.
6c. Review And Discussion Of The Town Of Mount Pleasant Animal
Cruelty Ordinance
Corporation Counsel David Pagliarini presented an overview of a
proposed updated animal cruelty ordinance, noting that the drafting
process involves multiple iterations as the town works toward an
enforceable, well-defined ordinance within the bounds of available
staffing and resources. He highlighted three primary areas of
improvement in the current draft: strengthened and more specific
definitions, the addition of breeder regulations with a requirement for an
annual business license, and clarified procedures for search warrants
and seizures to assist law enforcement and improve public
understanding.
Police, Judicial & Legal Committee
August 31, 2026
Page 9 of 10
Mr. Pagliarini noted that a standalone breeder licensing process—
separate from the standard business license—would require additional
staffing and administrative capacity, and recommended that this be
addressed as a subsequent step rather than included in the initial
ordinance.
Councilmember Chapman asked whether local veterinary professionals
could be engaged to assist with developing inspection standards, and
Mr. Pagliarini indicated that while national standards had informed the
current draft, local veterinary input had not yet been incorporated and
would be a valuable addition before the ordinance returns to committee.
Councilmember Crosby suggested that the definition of hoarding be
revised to use the term "minimum care" rather than "humane and
adequate care," as the latter is more ambiguous and could be
interpreted differently by bad actors.
Mayor Haynie confirmed that the ordinance would be brought back to
committee the following month after a period of public comment and
internal review by all council members. He encouraged the group to
forward suggested improvements to staff and to consider involving local
veterinary organizations in the review.
No vote was taken. The matter was continued to the next committee
meeting.
6d. Executive Session - Legal Advice Related To Deierlein Et Al V.
Town Of Mount Pleasant
The Committee moved into executive session to receive legal advice at
2:44 p.m.
Motion to enter executive session to receive legal advice related to
Deierlein et al. v. Town of Mount Pleasant was made by Councilmember
Crosby and seconded by Councilmember Chapman. The motion carried
unanimously.
6e. Post Executive Session
At 3:12 p.m., Mayor Haynie announced that the committee had
reconvened from executive session and that no votes were cast and no
action was taken.
Police, Judicial & Legal Committee
August 31, 2026
Page 10 of 10
6f. Committee May Take Action On Any Item, Including Any
Subsection Of Any Section, Listed On An Executive Session
Agenda Or Discussed In An Executive Session During A Properly
Noticed Meeting
No action was taken.
7. Adjourn
There being no further business, Mayor Haynie declared the meeting
adjourned at 3:13 p.m.
By S. Ohannessian
August 31, 2026
Source: Town of Mount Pleasant website. First collected Oct 13, 2026.