_08192026-2245
Town of Mount Pleasant · Charleston County · meeting of Aug 19, 2026 · Minutes
Open the original document More from Town of Mount Pleasant
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
TOWN OF MOUNT PLEASANT, SOUTH CAROLINA
PLANNING COMMISSION
AUGUST 19, 2026
MINUTES
PowerPoint Presentation
Present: Brett Bennett, Chair, Pam Ireland, Gary Davis, Michelle Mansour,
Corey Barber, Kevin Berry, Bill Smyth (entered at 5:08 pm),
Daniella Harris (entered at 5:08 pm).
Staff: Michele Reed, David Pagliarini, Brent Leary, Peter Stone,
Lynnette Lynes
Mr. Bennett called the meeting to order at 5:05 pm.
1. Approval of the Agenda
Ms. Ireland moved for approval of the agenda. Mr. Davis seconded the motion.
All in favor.
2. Approval of Minutes
Ms. Mansour moved for approval of the minutes. Ms. Ireland seconded the
motion. All in favor.
3. Planning Commission Recommendations Update
Mr. Stone reviewed Town Council decisions with the Commission.
Mr. Smyth and Ms. Harris entered at this time (5:08 pm).
4. General Correspondence
5. General Public Comment
There being no comments, Mr. Bennett continued with the agenda.
6. Business
A. PUBLIC HEARING , Zoning Code Text Amendment, Chapter 156.039 ,
Proposed modification to certain Residential Districts, establishing density
Planning Commission
August 19, 2026
Page 2 of 9
provisions where these districts are designated on the Comprehensive Plan
Future Land Use Map as Community Facilities. Text Amendment Staff Report
Ms. Reed reviewed the text amendment with the Commission.
Mr. Bennett asked if the process for approval would be the same. Ms. Reed
answered in the affirmative.
Mr. Davis asked what issue is trying to be resolved. Ms. Reed answered that
this is to provide a means for Town Council to weigh in on how the density is
determined.
Ms. Ireland asked how many of the community facility properties are zoned
Areawide Business. Ms. Reed answered that there are only a few. Ms. Ireland
asked how many have been redeveloped since the change. Ms. Reed answered
that she is only aware of one instance. Ms. Ireland asked if Planning Committee or
Town Council recommended it come back to the Planning Commission. Ms. Reed
answered that Town Council recommended the item come back to the
Commission. Ms. Ireland asked if at least one residential unit could be
constructed. Ms. Reed answered in the affirmative and stated that they would be
allowed to build one residential unit for the entire parcel; if more units were
desired, they would need to requ est a C omprehensive Plan amendment. Ms.
Ireland asked if it was discussed allowing one unit per acre. Ms. Reed answered in
the negative and stated that this is the reason for this discussion.
Ms. Barber asked if the caveat would be included in the ordinance. Ms. Reed
answered in the affirmative. Mr. Barber asked if R -3 and R -4 zoning would have
the same requirements. Ms. Reed answered that most are R-1 and R-2. Mr. Barber
asked if it would apply to commercial development. Ms. Reed answered in the
negative. Mr . Barber asked about commercial uses. Ms. Reed answered that the
density for commercial properties through other means such as overlay districts.
Mr. Davis asked the reason for the change. Ms. Reed answered that those
making comments would be able to address this. She suggested that the concern
is that the density would be determined through the Comprehensive Plan.
Mr. Berry suggested that the challenge is finding a balance between property
rights and having a change of use.
Planning Commission
August 19, 2026
Page 3 of 9
Mr. Hacker Burr, Trident Academy, expressed concern with the proposed
changes and that this could negatively affect the school’s financial stability. He
expressed concern about not having sufficient publicity and notice for the
requested changes. He suggested that this would remove the right of
redevelopment from the property owners.
Mr. Erik Kreutner, Assistant Head of Trident Academy, suggested that the Town
has not properly notified the churches and schools of the proposed changes . He
stated that Town Council expressed concern with optics, and that normal
notification of zoning changes means posting a sign, but this was not done. He
stated that staff indicated at the previous Town Council meeting staff indicated that
the property owners would be made aware of any zoning changes. He suggested
that this was not done and suggested that the Town is failing the churches and
schools in this manner.
Mr. Furman Buchanan, Rector at Christ Episcopal Church, provided the history
of Christ Church Parish. He is aware of the requested changes to add density
requirements to the Comprehensive Plan rather than rezoning the property. He
suggested that R-1 zoning is a more appropriate zoning rather than PI zoning. He
stated that they have discussed using some of the church property for residential
homes for their clergy. He suggested that this is a critical need for many churches.
He suggested that they would also like to provide affordable housing for teachers
and other critical workforce. He suggested that preserving the R -1 zoning and
providing reasonable density would enable the church to achieve their goal of
providing affordable housing for their church staff and local housing for public
service employees.
Mr. Gordon Shrek, trustee for Mount Pleasant Presbyterian Church, suggested
that there were a couple of churches not included in the recommendations for
rezoning and asked the reason for this. Mr. Bennett noted that this is a public
comment period and could be addressed through Commission questions.
Mr. Gilly Dyer, attorney for Christ Our King and the Church Diocese, distributed
a copy of their legal concerns for the Commission to review. He stated that the
Diocese has 13 properties that would be affected by this requested change. He
stated that the Diocese relies on these properties for operations. He suggested
that the proposed change would devalue the properties by requiring Town Council
Planning Commission
August 19, 2026
Page 4 of 9
approval to redevelop the property for more than one residential unit through a
planned development or Comprehensive Plan amendment. He suggested that this
“puts the church and school on a different playing field” than other residential
property owners. He suggested that the requested change would give zoning
regulation effect to the Comprehensive Plan that is prohibited by state statute. He
also suggested that there is not an issue that needs to be resolved and therefore,
there should not be a change.
Mr. J.C. Taylor, Board Chair of Trident Academy, reiterated that the concern is
the taking of a right that would have detrimental financial ramifications. He
suggested that the financial impacts would be significant if approved because of
the change to the property rights. He asked that the Commission consider the
consequences to the churches and schools that are a vital part of the community.
There being no further comments, Mr. Bennett closed the public hearing.
Mr. Berry asked if this would apply to all the 82 properties and were there any
exemptions. Ms. Reed answered that St. Andrews PI-1 and Friendship AME Church
are currently zoned PI-1. She stated that some of the properties currently have a
non-residential zoning or are in a planned development, so they would not be
affected by this proposed change . She stated that the request was to look at
changes for the properties zoned R -1 and R -2 that are recommended for
community facility in the Comprehensive Plan.
Mr. Davis asked if this was a legal issue. Mr. Pagliarini answered that executive
session could be considered for legal advice if necessary.
Ms. Ireland suggested that the Commission makes a recommendation and the
legal ramifications would be handled and considered with Town Council. She
stated that this was previously done in the Comprehensive Plan with no issue. She
stated that it was previously recommended to rezone the properties, but this was
abandoned by Town Council. She suggested that community facilities are needed
within the Town and there is a public interest in having these facilities within the
Town and retaining them. She suggested that requiring Town Council approval for
a change is not a definite “no” but gives Town Council the opportunity to weigh in
on whether the requested action is appropriate for the neighborhood and the
Town. She suggested that there should be an exception to allow churches to have
housing for clergy.
Planning Commission
August 19, 2026
Page 5 of 9
Mr. Bennett suggested that some residential develop could be appropriate
such as clergy housing. He agreed that there should be a balance. He stated that
there has been previous debate on this issue to ensure a balance is reached.
Mr. Berry asked if residential zoning allows a church use. Ms. Reed answered
that a church would be a special exception; a school would be allowed by right.
Mr. Berry asked if the focus was on the density and not the use. Ms. Reed
answered in the affirmative. He suggested that in most cases, the underlying
zoning did not change, but they are now being restricted and expressed concern
with that.
Mr. Bennett suggested that some legal advice might be appropriate.
Ms. Mansour moved to convene into executive session for legal advice. Mr.
Smyth seconded the motion. All in favor.
The Commission convened into executive session at 6:00 pm and reconvened at 6:11
pm. No action taken while in executive session.
Ms. Ireland moved for approval with the change to allow one residential unit
per acre as this will allow for the property owners to have some adjustments for
residential units such as a parsonage residence without being a major
redevelopment and makes the Comprehensive Plan the same as prior to 2025. Mr.
Barber seconded the motion.
Mr. Berry suggested that this is changing a use of right and he is opposed to
that request.
Mr. Davis suggested that based on the comments, the motion for one
residential unit per acre seems to be arbitrary. He suggested that the
recommendation should include T own Council consider a different
recommendation.
Mr. Smyth agreed with Mr. Davis and Mr. Berry.
Mr. Davis suggested that Town Council should make the decision on what
changes should be considered based on the comments that have been received.
Planning Commission
August 19, 2026
Page 6 of 9
Mr. Barber suggested that the opinions of the surrounding property owners of
these properties should be considered as well. Mr. Bennett agreed.
Mr. Bennett called for a vote on the motion. Motion failed on a 4 to 4 vote
with Mr. Barber, Ms. Harris, Ms. Mansour and Ms. Ireland in favor; Mr. Smyth, Mr .
Bennett, Mr. Davis, and Mr. Berry opposed.
Mr. Berry moved to deny the request with the recommendation that T own
Council look at keeping the underlying zoning uses . Mr. Bennett seconded the
motion.
Mr. Barber suggested that the motion does not address the request and would not
provide a recommendation to Town Council. He suggested that the issue should
be addressed.
Ms. Mansour suggested that the motion does address the concern and that
something should be done but there might be a better solution that addresses the
property rights as well as defining the density.
Mr. Barber moved to amend the motion to have staff come back with an
alternate solution that takes the expressed concerns into consideration. Mr. Berry
seconded the motion. All in favor.
Mr. Bennett called for a vote on the motion as amended. Motion passed on a
6 to 2 vote with Mr. Smyth, Mr. Bennett, Mr. Barber, Ms, Harris, Mr. Berry, and Ms.
Mansour in favor; Mr. Davis and Ms. Ireland opposed.
B. PUBLIC HEARING, R-22-26, Oyster Park PD, Planned Development, TMS No.
532-11-00-275, Request to amend the Oyster Park PD Height Map. Staff
Report
Mr. Stone reviewed staff comments with the Commission.
Mr. Locky Brown, representative for Duberry, reviewed the request with the
Commission.
Ms. Ireland asked if the footprint is already established. Mr. Brown answered
that the footprint could change. He stated that the design has not been
Planning Commission
August 19, 2026
Page 7 of 9
completed. Ms. Ireland asked if this would change the parking in that area. Mr.
Brown answered in the negative and that additional parking would be added in the
rear.
Mr. Bennett asked what buffer would be gained. Mr. Brown answered that the
building would be moved approximately 48 feet with additional parking. Mr.
Bennett asked if the buffer would be ten feet. Mr. Stone answered in the
affirmative.
Mr. Barber asked if the building would abut the drive aisle. Mr. Brown
answered that sidewalks would be installed. Mr. Barber asked about the tree line.
Mr. Brown answered that there would be street trees and sidewalk. Mr. Stone
noted that it is a Town right-of-way and standards would have to be maintained.
Mr. Barber asked the exact area dimensions being proposed. Mr. Stone answered
that the proposed area is not drawn to scale.
Ms. Ireland asked if the PD stipulates maximum building area. Mr . Stone
answered in the affirmative.
Mr. Davis asked where West Marine was located. Mr. Brown answered that it
was at the edge of the current building.
There being no comments, Mr. Bennett closed the public hearing.
Mr. Davis moved for approval. Ms. Ireland seconded the motion. All in favor.
C. PUBLIC HEARING, R-23-26, 3587 North Highway 17, TMS No. 614-00-00-013,
Request to rezone TH, Townhouse District. Staff Report
Mr. Stone reviewed staff comments with the Commission.
Mr. Davis asked if the request is to increase the number of units, that would
increase the density. Mr. Stone answered that there is a different housing type
and lot size being proposed.
There being no applicant, Mr. Bennett moved to comments. There being no
comments, Mr. Bennett closed the public hearing.
Planning Commission
August 19, 2026
Page 8 of 9
Ms. Ireland moved for denial of the request. Mr. Davis seconded the motion.
Mr. Barber suggested that the request is not appropriate for the area.
Mr. Bennett called for a vote on the motion. All in favor.
D. PUBLIC HEARING , R-24-26, 1129 Joe Bryant , TMS No. 598-00-00-019,
Request to rezone AB-1, Areawide Business District-1. Staff Report
Mr. Stone reviewed staff comments with the Commission.
There being no applicant, Mr. Bennett moved to comments.
There being no comments, Mr. Bennett closed the public hearing.
Ms. Ireland moved for approval of the request. Mr. Smyth seconded the
motion. Motion passed on a 7 to 1 vote with Mr. Smyth, Mr. Bennett, Mr. Barber,
Ms. Harris, Mr. Berry, Ms. Mansour, and Ms. Ireland in favor; Mr. Davis opposed.
E. PUBLIC HEARING , R-25-26, 1182 Russell Drive , TMS No. 532-03-00-026,
Request to rezone NC-2, Neighborhood Commercial District-2. Staff Report
Mr. Stone reviewed staff comments with the Commission.
Mr. Bennett asked if NC-2 is compatible with the surrounding uses. Mr. Stone
answered in the affirmative.
There being no applicant, Mr. Bennett moved to comments. There being no
comments, Mr. Bennett closed public hearing.
Mr. Berry moved for approval. Mr. Smyth seconded the motion. All in favor.
F. PUBLIC HEARING, R-26-26, Jordan Tract PD, Planned Development, TMS
Nos. 514-00-00-001, -487, Request to rezone two parcels on Johnnie Dodds
Boulevard to AB-1, Areawide Business District-1. Staff Report
Mr. Stone reviewed staff comments with the Commission.
Planning Commission
August 19, 2026
Page 9 of 9
Mr. Davis asked about the trees. Mr. Stone showed the map for the
Commission.
Mr. Morris reviewed the request with the Commission.
Mr. Bennett asked if there is a conceptual plan. Mr. Morris answered in the
negative.
Mr. Davis asked if the trees would be clear cut. Mr. Morris answered that a
tree study would be conducted prior to the design being completed.
There being no comments, Mr. Bennett closed the public hearing.
Mr. Barber asked about the PD. Mr. Stone reviewed the Jordan Tract PD with
the Commission.
Mr. Smyth moved for approval. Mr. Berry seconded the motion.
Mr. Davis suggested that the tree study be completed before the request is
approved. Mr. Stone stated that the tree study would be required when reviewed
by the Design Review Board.
Mr. Barber asked if a zoning change was required for other uses within the
planned development. Mr. Stone reviewed the development progression of the
Jordan Tract PD with the Commission.
Mr. Bennett called for a vote on the motion. Motion passed on a 6 to 2 vote
with Mr. Smyth, Mr. Bennett, Ms. Harris, Mr. Berry, Ms. Mansour, and Ms. Ireland
in favor; Mr. Barber and Mr. Davis opposed.
There being no further business, the meeting adjourned at 6:54 pm.
Submitted by,
L. Lynes
PlanComsn08192026
Source: Town of Mount Pleasant website. First collected Oct 13, 2026.