RecordWell Data

_08102026-2233

Town of Mount Pleasant · Charleston County · meeting of Aug 10, 2026 · Minutes

Open the original document More from Town of Mount Pleasant

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

TOWN OF MOUNT PLEASANT, SOUTH CAROLINA HISTORIC DISTRICT PRESERVATION COMMISSION AUGUST 10, 2026 MINUTES Staff Report Present: Meghan Gravitt, Chair, Krystine Edwards, Meghan Gravitt, Kenny Craft, Eugene Foxworth, Warren Player. Staff: Bryan Hankinson, Lynnette Lynes Ms. Gravitt called the meeting to order at 5:00 pm. 1. Approval of Agenda Ms. Gravitt moved for approval of the agenda. Mr. Player seconded the motion. All in favor. 2. Approval of Minutes Ms. Gravitt moved for approval of the minutes. Mr. Player seconded the motion. All in favor. 3. General Public Comment 4. Correspondence 5. Consent Motions There being no comments, correspondence, or consent motions. Ms. Gravit continued with the agenda. 6. Business A. 307 Morrison St ., Survey Card 4235/Historic – TMS 5320100047, Final Review for the alteration to a previously approved COA. Mr. Hankinson reviewed staff comments with the Commission. Mr. Bill Buck, owner, reviewed the request with the Commission. He stated that the requested changes were requested and received verbal approval from staff. Historic District Preservation Commission August 10, 2026 Page 2 of 9 Mr. Chuck Bennett, 202 Pitt St, stated that he has no problem with the architectural changes, but asked if there is sufficient parking for the site. There being no further comments, Ms. Gravitt closed public comments. Ms. Gravitt asked when it was previously approved. Mr. Buck answered that it was 201 8-2019. Ms. Gravitt stated that this construction has been in progress for a “long time”. Ms. Gravitt asked if there was siding on the front porch. Mr. Buck answered that the previous plans showed that, but there was a previously verbal approval to not have the siding. He stated that the original home did not have the siding. Ms. Gravitt asked if Mr. Buck has pictures of the historic home. Mr. Buck answered in the negative and stated that there was previously a parapet wall that was not included with the construction. Ms. Gravitt suggested that the new construction should mirror the historic structure. Mr. Buck stated that there were some changes that were approved such as removing the parapet wall and the design of the porch so that there was better air flow. Mr. Hankinson stated he has some pictures of the historic cottage during mid-demolition. Mr. Craft suggested that he is comfortable with the changes. Ms. Gravitt moved for approval to submit historic photos for review. Ms. Edwards seconded the motion. All in favor. Mr. Craft asked what is being requested. Mr. Buck answered that the chimney is to remain the same as was on the original home. Mr. Craft asked if the intention is for the new home to be close to the historic home with the changes of the parapet wall and porch. Mr. Buck answered in the affirmative. Mr. Hankinson clarified that his initial inspection of the site brought these items to his attention. He stated that minutes could not be found. Mr. Buck suggested that the home was built according to what was previously approved. Mr. Craft suggested that the design is nice. Historic District Preservation Commission August 10, 2026 Page 3 of 9 Ms. Gravitt asked about the parking. Mr. Hankinson answered that this would be verified with the final inspection. Ms. Gravitt moved for approval. Mr. Foxworth seconded the motion. All in favor. B. 124 Mary St. A , Survey Card 6253/Historic – TMS 5171500075, Preliminary Review for the construction of a new primary structure. Mr. Hankinson reviewed staff comments with the Commission. Mr. Ryan Smith, architect, reviewed the request with the Commission. He stated that the property has been subdivided and has its own address of 122 Mary Street. Mr. Scott McCormick, 141 Toomer Lane, asked that the encroachment into the setback not be approved. He suggested that while the architecture meets the character of the neighborhood, the encroachment into the front setback is not a minor encroachment and is a major departure from the established building line. He suggested that there should be a major justification for approval of this significant encroachment. He suggested that traffic, parking and safety on this right -of-way is a major concern as there is not sufficient space for two vehicles to pass each other. He stated that over the last eight years, some homeowners have “commandeered” portions of the right-of-way for extension of their front yards, decreasing the width of the right-of-way. He asked that the Commission deny the request. There being no further comments, Ms. Gravitt closed public comments. Mr. Player asked the reason for the varying window types and suggested that it is “too much”. He suggested that the architecture looks like modular sections put together and that the encroachment into the setback should be restudied. He suggested that dimensions should be added to the plans. Ms. Gravitt asked the overall height. Mr. Smith answered that he is not sure, but it is under the maximum 35 feet allowed. Historic District Preservation Commission August 10, 2026 Page 4 of 9 Mr. Craft stated that the location of the home mirror s the same as the house located to the right. Ms. Gravitt asked the reason for the encroachment. Mr. Smith answered that they were trying to keep as much space in the back as possible. He stated that the modular feel was to mirror a historic home with additions added. He stated another reason for pulling the home forward was to avoid the tree protection zones as much as possible. He stated that the neighboring homes are also pulled forward and meeting the setback would be out of character with the surrounding properties. Ms. Gravitt asked how the footings and foundation would avoid the tree protection zones. Mr. Smith answered that the porch has piers and was designed in keeping with the arborist report. He stated that the home was situated to take 124 Mary and the angle of 120 Mary into consideration. Mr. Craft asked what the material is for the dormers on the front. Mr. Smith answered that there is a singular piece of trim at the dormers. He stated that full details would be noted in the final drawings. Mr. Foxworth asked if the shutters are double back. Mr. Smith answered that the larger windows would have double-back shutters. Mr. Player asked if the small window on the northeast elevation is the stairwell. Mr. Smith answered in the affirmative. Mr. Player asked if the entire roof would be a metal roof. Mr. Smith answered in the negative and stated that the front of the home would be a shingled roof. Mr. Hankinson asked the Commission to determine if they are comfortable with the setback encroachment. Mr. Craft suggested that the historic context of the house placement should be taken into consideration and not just the newer “suburban setback”. Ms. Gravitt suggested that it is a significant encroachment and that the home should be located more in keeping with the neighboring homes. She asked that the dimensions from the home to the property line should be noted. Historic District Preservation Commission August 10, 2026 Page 5 of 9 Ms. Edwards suggested that there should be some delineation with a pull off or parking pad. Ms. Edwards asked the percentage of porch. Mr. Hankinson answered that it is 12%. Ms. Edwards suggested that the porch could be reduced. Mr. Craft suggested that it generally has a smaller envelope. Ms. Gravitt suggested that the footings and foundation should be shown around the tree protection zones. Also, the BAR should be identified as well. C. 256 Magwood Ln. , Survey Card 6231/Historic – TMS 5171500032, Final Review for the moving and altering of an existing non -historic accessory structure. Mr. Hankinson reviewed staff comments with the Commission. Mr. Ross Ritchie, architect, reviewed the request with the Commission. There being no comments, Ms. Gravitt closed public comments. Ms. Gravitt asked if the encroachment is allowed. Mr. Hankinson answered that eaves are allowed a 24 inch encroachment. Ms. Gravitt asked about the pool equipment and if it will be screened. Mr. Ritchie answered in the affirmative. Mr. Craft asked about the drawing on the last sheet. Mr. Ritchie answered that it shows a small section of the porch. Mr. Craft asked if rafter tails would be used. Mr. Ritchie answered that it would be as an enclosed eave. Mr. Craft asked that the detail be shown and if this could be modified. Mr. Ritchie answered that the home must be elevated due to building code. He stated that would like to keep the main structure and elevate it. Mr. Craft asked about the original structure with inset columns and if they all could be corrected. Mr. Ritchie answered that this could possibly be done if it does not exceed the building requirements. Mr. Hankinson suggested that more roof details on rafter, pool screening and verification of encroachment in setbacks should be identified. Historic District Preservation Commission August 10, 2026 Page 6 of 9 Mr. Craft suggested that these are positive improvements. Ms. Gravitt moved for approval with the following conditions: ➢ Roof eaves do not encroach into setback further than 24 inches and are labeled on the plans ➢ Clarification of the roof eave details to be approved by staff ➢ All pool equipment is screened from public view Mr. Player seconded the motion. All in favor. D. 320 Morrison St. , Survey Card 6159/Non-Historic – TMS 5320100051, Preliminary Review for the demolition of an existing primary structure and construction of a new primary structure. Mr. Hankinson reviewed staff comments with the Commission. Mr. Joel Adrian, architect, reviewed the request with the Commission. Ms. Heather Evans, 318 Morrison, expressed concern with privacy and the proximity of the house to the neighboring properties. She stated that the two story porches could mean being able to see into their bedrooms. Mr. Chuck Bennett, 202 Pitt Street, expressed concern with cut -through traffic and asked that the construction vehicles be parked on site as opposed onto the street. There being no more comments, Ms. Gravitt closed public comment. Mr. Player noted that there are many golf carts that come down the street as well. Mr. Craft stated he has no objection to the demolition. He suggested that the 3-D models help in showing the massing . He suggested that the gables could be simplified and asked what is driving the second gable on the front elevation. He suggested that the window configuration could be simplified as well. Ms. Edwards agreed with Mr. Craft about the gables and asked the reason for it. Mr. Adrian answered that it was to show a step down in the massing. Historic District Preservation Commission August 10, 2026 Page 7 of 9 Mr. Craft suggested that the extra gable detail was not needed. Ms. Gravitt asked the reason for the positioning of the home. Mr. Adrian answered that they were trying to avoid further encroachment into the tree protection zone for the 36 inch willow oak. He stated that the arborist provided guidance on the amount of encroachment into the tree protection could be done without impacting the tree. Ms. Gravitt asked for details on how the home would affect the canopy of the willow oak. Ms. Gravitt asked if a variance would be required. Mr. Hankinson answered that the tree can be pruned according to ANSI standards, but if it was desired to be removed, it would require approval from the Board of Zoning Appeals (BOZA). Mr. Craft asked if the trees on the neighboring lot could be removed. Mr. Adrian answered that they are diseased and they are working with the neighbor and staff on approval for removal of those trees. Ms. Gravitt asked about the second story porch and the reason for it. Mr. Adrian answered that this is the master bedroom and the owner thought it would be a nice feature. He suggested that it could be re-studied. Mr. Craft suggested flipping the porch to be in the front might be an option. Mr. Player suggested that having the second story porch would be no different than having windows in that same location. Mr. Foxworth asked if a more traditional roof color could be considered. Mr. Adrian answered that this could be re-studied. Mr. Craft asked about exploring other options for materials should be considered. Mr. Adrian answered this could be explored. Ms. Edwards asked about the garage and that this should be studied as well. Mr. Craft asked about the shutters. Ms. Edwards suggested that the shutters need more character or detail. Ms. Gravitt suggested that the shutters should be consistent throughout the house. Historic District Preservation Commission August 10, 2026 Page 8 of 9 Ms. Gravitt suggested that trying to pull the home farther out of the tree protection zone and more toward Whilden Street should be considered. Mr. Adrian answered that this might be difficult. Mr. Craft agreed that the house might be able to shifted. Ms. Gravitt asked that the garage be re-studied to be more in keeping with the historic district. E. 430 Church St. , Survey Card 6192/Historic – TMS 5320100094, Final Review for the in-kind replacement of historic siding. Mr. Hankinson reviewed staff comments with the Commission. Mr. Ross Evans, owner, and Mr. Will Isaac reviewed the request with the Commission. Ms. Gravitt closed public comment. Ms. Edwards asked if the same person is doing the repairs. Mr. Isaac answered in the negative. Ms. Gravitt asked what is needed for color approval. Mr. Hankinson answered that if staff approve, they need to clarify color. Ms. Gravitt moved for approval with the conditions that the materials and color match the historic structure. Ms. Edwards seconded the motion. All in favor. 7. Staff Approvals Mr. Hankinson reviewed staff approvals with the Commission as follows: A. 310 McCormick St., Survey Card 6079/Non-Historic – TMS 5320900087, Approved for the replacement of doors and windows on the historic primary structure. B. 340 Middle St. , Survey Card 6004/Non-Historic – TMS 5321300014, Approved for the roof repair on two existing flat roofed dormers. Historic District Preservation Commission August 10, 2026 Page 9 of 9 C. 303 Hibben St. , Survey Card 6230 /Non-Historic – TMS 5320100100 , Approved for the installation of new hardscapes, fencing, and fence gates. D. 427 Church St. , Survey Card 6204/Non-Historic – TMS 5320100071, Approved for alteration to a previously approved COA. E. 218 Center St. , Survey Card 6049/Non-Historic – TMS 5320900088, Approved for the installation of a new roof. F. 218 Center St. , Survey Card 6049 /Non-Historic – TMS 5320900088 , Approved for the repairs and replacement of windows and siding. G. 417 Pitt St. , No Survey Card/Non-Historic – TMS 5320500015, Approved for the alterations to previously approved siding. Mr. Craft asked about 303 Hibben and if the frontage fence would be replaced. Mr. Hankinson answered that it is non-historic, and the fence is not required to be retained. He stated that the ordinance and guidelines would have to be amended. Mr. Craft suggested that the frontage fences are part of the character of the historic district and suggested that they should remain. 8. Discussion of Items for Next Agenda The Commission agreed to discuss possible changes to the guidelines regarding the front yard fences at their next meeting. There being no further business, the meeting adjourned at 6:44 pm. Submitted by, L. Lynes HDPC08102026

Source: Town of Mount Pleasant website. First collected Oct 13, 2026.