_08032026-2240
Town of Mount Pleasant · Charleston County · meeting of Aug 3, 2026 · Minutes
Open the original document More from Town of Mount Pleasant
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
TOWN OF MOUNT PLEASANT, SC
POLICE, JUDICIAL & LEGAL COMMITTEE
Monday, August 3, 2026
MI
NUTES
Li
sten to the meeting here.
1. C
all to order
The Chair called the Police, Judicial and Legal Committee meeting to order on Monday, August
3, 2026 at 11:30 a.m.
2. Ap
proval of Minutes from the June 1, 2026 meeting
A motion to approve the minutes from the June 1, 2026 meeting was made by Howard Chapman
and seconded by Mike Tinkey. The motion carried unanimously.
3. P
ublic Comment
Three members of the public addressed the committee, all speaking in support of strengthening
animal welfare protections in Mount Pleasant.
The first speaker, Paul Sperry, expressed gratitude to the committee for its consideration of
animal advocacy efforts and noted that he was looking forward to a forthcoming meeting with
the police chief and other stakeholders. He encouraged the town to become a model municipality
that other counties and municipalities could follow, and he acknowledged that the growth of
Mount Pleasant brings with it an increased need for improved animal welfare ordinances.
The second speaker, Sandra Connell, a resident of Dunes West, shared personal observations
about the growth of animal abuse and referenced a recent case involving a neglected dog named
Howie. She noted that animal abuse has worsened in recent years and expressed hope that
municipalities could act more quickly than the state to prevent cruelty rather than simply respond
to it. She cited a national statistic of approximately 600,000 animals euthanized in shelters in
2025, and she offered to assist the town in any way possible.
The third speaker, Lisa Schipkne, of Mossy Oak Lane expressed support for both the police
department's reaccreditation and the town's initiative to regulate rodenticide use in Mount
Pleasant. She noted that second-generation anticoagulant rodenticides pose deadly risks to
raptors, cats, and dogs, and she encouraged the town to look at best practices from neighboring
municipalities such as Kiawah and Seabrook.
Public comment was closed.
4. Police matters
a. Announcement of the Mount Pleasant Police Department’s
reaccreditation
Police Chief Mark Arnold announced that the Mount Pleasant Police Department has once again
earned reaccreditation from the Commission on Accreditation for Law Enforcement Agencies,
commonly known as CALEA. Chief Arnold described the reaccreditation as a department-wide
achievement reflecting the daily dedication of every member of the department to adhere to
CALEA's rigorous standards of professional excellence, accountability, and transparency.
Chief Arnold gave special recognition to Lieutenant Croy, who stepped in as interim
accreditation manager during a transition period and was instrumental in the most recent
accreditation cycle, including the department's trip to Omaha, Nebraska, for the formal review.
The committee responded with applause.
b. Recognition of Mount Pleasant Police Cadets for earning first
place in the Youth Program
Chief Arnold reported that the Mount Pleasant Police Department's cadet program — formerly
known as the explorers program — competed in the statewide annual competition in Columbia
and earned first place overall. Competing against numerous larger agencies, including Charleston
City and the county sheriff's office, the cadets navigated complex law enforcement scenarios
with distinction.
Chief Arnold highlighted that Deputy Chief Carter has led the explorer program for many years
and has done an outstanding job. He noted that the program serves as both a recruiting tool and a
community relations asset, adding that several current police officers began their careers as
explorers. Committee members expressed strong praise for the achievement.
5. Judicial matters
a. No agenda items
6. Legal matters
a. Discussion to make rodenticide regulation a Town legislative
priority in the next legislative session
The Chair provided context, noting that the town had previously addressed the issue of second-
generation anticoagulant rodenticides (SGARs) and that state law currently preempts local
regulation of these substances.
Town Attorney David Pagliarini confirmed that South Carolina state code specifically controls
local ordinances pertaining to this matter. He reported that Resolution 25072, passed by this
committee and council last year in response to a pending state bill, had seen no action at the state
level, and that the bill remains in committee.
Mr. Pagliarini noted that, as of January 1, 2025, the state did implement a new requirement that
dealers of these rodenticides must hold a specific license, which represented the one meaningful
change that occurred at the state level in the prior year.
Council Member Mike Tinkey provided additional context, stating that the concern has expanded
beyond birds of prey to include cats, dogs, and bobcats, particularly on Kiawah Island. He
described a voluntary program undertaken by Kiawah and Kiawah Resort in partnership with
pest control companies, noting that it has seen encouraging results and that education has been a
key driver of its success. He observed that many residents are entirely unaware of the chain-
reaction impact these rodenticides have on wildlife and the broader ecosystem, and he urged the
town to work with its local legislative delegation to move the bill out of committee.
Council Member Howard Chapman inquired whether the town could engage Clemson
University, which he noted appeared in prior presentation materials as an administrator of related
programs, to provide a presentation to the committee and potentially assist in advancing the
matter through the General Assembly. Mr. Pagliarini confirmed that Clemson University is
actively working on this issue and that the town would make every effort to arrange their
participation.
Council Member Alex Crosby emphasized the importance of public education, noting that
residents should read labels on products they use in their yards and understand the downstream
effects on local wildlife.
The Chair summarized a path forward, directing staff to undertake the following actions:
● Revisit and renew the town's public information campaign on rodenticide risks, citing the
heightened public awareness following recent publicized incidents involving birds of
prey.
● Bring back the prior resolution for review and possible updating for the new legislative
session, with the intent to recommend it to the full council.
● Arrange for representatives from Kiawah Island, the Center for Birds of Prey, and
Clemson University to present at the September committee meeting.
The Chair also indicated his intention to engage State Senator Campsen, whom he described as
one of the most prominent conservationists in the State Senate, regarding Senate Bill 246.
b. Assessment of the Town’s ordinance covering animal cruelty
Mr. Pagliarini provided a high-level overview of the town's current ordinance on animal cruelty,
found in Chapter 90 of the town code. He prefaced his remarks by noting that a meeting had
been scheduled for Wednesday involving the police department and community advocates to
begin the collaborative process of developing amendments.
Mr. Pagliarini described the current ordinance as broadly written and enforceable, but noted that
it is insufficient relative to model ordinances available through organizations such as the Animal
Legal Defense Fund. He identified several areas where the existing code could be strengthened
with more precise definitions, including: cruelty and neglect, tethering standards (hours and
type), extreme weather provisions, confinement area requirements, motor vehicle standards, and
adequate shelter requirements. He indicated that, in his view, the relevant chapter of the code
would likely be substantially rewritten in accordance with national model standards.
On the question of penalties, Mr. Pagliarini clarified that the state restricts municipal maximum
penalties to 30 days and a $500 fine, making enhanced municipal penalties a nonstarter. He
noted, however, that state law provides for significantly stronger penalties — up to 90 days or a
$1,000 fine for neglect, and up to 5 years imprisonment and a $5,000 fine for torture or serious
offenses — and that working with the police department to pursue charges under state law,
where appropriate, could meaningfully improve outcomes.
Council Member Tinkey expressed enthusiasm about engaging with advocates who have already
assembled thoughtful research and proposed practical solutions, such as permitting requirements
for breeders, which Mr. Pagliarini confirmed is an area not currently addressed in the town's
ordinances but one that could be adopted.
Council Member Crosby raised a concern about the treatment of individual animal cruelty
incidents as isolated events rather than part of a pattern of behavior, and emphasized the
importance of documentation — including photographs — to build a comprehensive record. Mr.
Pagliarini acknowledged the concern and confirmed it would be addressed in the Wednesday
meeting with the police department.
The Chair underscored that the committee's goal is not simply to enhance penalties after a
tragedy has occurred, but to give law enforcement the tools necessary to intervene in situations
of systematic neglect or cruelty before they become irreversible.
Paul Sperry, speaking as a community advocate involved in dog welfare efforts, offered
additional perspective on the slow pace of state legislative action, noting that he had been
involved in the Humane Dog Breeding Act earlier in the year and estimated that achieving
meaningful state-level changes would take three to five years even with bipartisan support. He
expressed support for focusing efforts at the local level in the interim and offered to assist in
comparing ordinances across counties and municipalities to identify strengths that Mount
Pleasant could incorporate and model for others.
The Chair confirmed that a draft of proposed amendments to Chapter 90 would be prepared for
review at the September meeting, at which point the committee could advance a recommendation
to the full council.
7. Adjourn
There being no further business, the Chair declared the meeting adjourned at 12:07 p.m.
Source: Town of Mount Pleasant website. First collected Oct 13, 2026.