RecordWell Data

BAR-S Public Comment

City of Charleston · Berkeley County · meeting of Oct 8, 2026 · Agendas

Open the original document More from City of Charleston

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

CITY OF CHARLESTON BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW – SMALL PUBLIC COMMENT OCTOBER 8, 2026 A meeting of the Board of Architectural Review – Small (BAR-S) will be held on Thursday, October 8, 2026 at 4:30 p.m. in the Public Meeting Room, First Floor, 2 George Street. The following written comments will be provided to the board members 24 hours in advance of the meeting. The comments will also be acknowledged into the record and summarized. The public is encouraged to attend the meeting in person to speak in order for comments to be fully heard. Application information is available at www.charleston-sc.gov/bar. Please check the website on the meeting date to view any withdrawn or deferred agenda items. For additional information, please contact: Department of Planning & Preservation | 843-724-3781 B. APPLICATIONS 5. 33 Elizabeth Street BAR2026-002891 | TMS#459-13-01-037 | Garden District | Council District 4 Not rated | c.1940 | Old and Historic District Requesting approval for demolition of dwelling. Owner: Glen Gardner, Two Four John LLC Applicant: Glen Gardner Landscape Architect LLC 3 Comments Submitted to Innovate in Support First Name Last Name Address Submitted Comment Date/Time Submitted Brian Borry, CPA, LLC 4 1/2 John Street I support Mr. Gardner's demolition request. My property is adjacent to this project. The old shack has been an eyesore for 30-plus years. Mr. Gardner's plans to reunite the adjacent property and expand the gardens will greatly benefit the neighborhood. Oct 6 2026 7:18PM Susan Flaster 42 Chapel St., Charleston, SC 29403 I support Mr. Gardener's plan to demolish the run-down shed structure on this lot. It was never meant to be permanent, and without it, it will be possible to return 33 Elizabeth to its original identity as part of the 4 John St. property Oct 6 2026 10:19PM william goodale 37 chapel st in favor of the proposal Oct 7 2026 9:32AM Board of Architectural Review – Small Public Comment | October 7, 2026 Page 2 8. 0 Atlantic Street BAR2026-002903 | TMS#457-16-04-066 | Charlestowne | Council District 8 Category 4| c.1850 | Old and Historic District Requesting additional height for Architectural Merit and conceptual approval for rooftop appurtenance. Owner: Cody Mcintyre Applicant: Tom Wales 2 Comments Submitted to Staff in Support (see attached) Outlook 0 Atlantic Street, BAR-S FromCharles C Geer <charlescgeer@gmail.com> Date Mon 9/28/2026 10:28 AM To bar <bar@charleston-sc.gov> ATTENTION: This email originated from outside the City of Charleston's systems. Do not click links or open attachments unless you are expecting them from the sender and/or have confirmed the content is safe. Forward any suspicious emails by clicking the Phish Alert Button. TO WHOM IT MAY CONCERN; Our neighbor at 0 Atlantic Street, Codi McIntyre, discussed his project with us. They provided pictures for the proposed plans and we have no objections.  He  has been a good addition to the neighborhood. Thank you for the consideration. Frances and Charles Geer 2 Atlantic Street Outlook Zero Atlantic bar S submission FromAkim Anastopoulo <akim@akimlawfirm.com> Date Wed 9/23/2026 3:14 PM To bar <bar@charleston-sc.gov> ATTENTION: This email originated from outside the City of Charleston's systems. Do not click links or open attachments unless you are expecting them from the sender and/or have confirmed the content is safe. Forward any suspicious emails by clicking the Phish Alert Button. My neighbor at zero Atlantic Cody McIntyre discussed his project with me. He provided me with drawings of the proposed project and I am in support of such project. Please let me know if you have any questions sincerely, Akim Anastopoulo at 31 East Battery St. Sent from my iPhone Board of Architectural Review – Small Public Comment | October 7, 2026 Page 3 32 Comments Submitted to Staff in Opposition (see attached) From: Sam Howell <samhowell@bond-law.com> Sent: Tuesday, September 29, 2026 12:05 PM To: Pinto, Frankie Cc: Lavinia Howell (laviniahowell@comcast.net) Subject: 0 Atlantic St. Proposed Rooftop Addition Dear Ms. Pinto. My wife (Lavinia Grimball Howell, also the property owner) and I write to express our opposition to the 0 Atlantic Street’s BAR-S application for a rooftop addition and roof deck due to its height and visibility from Water street and Atlantic street. The proposed glass walls to surround the deck are completely incongruous with the historic buildings (including our residence) surrounding 0 Atlantic Street, as well as the neighborhood in general. The proposed addition is easily viewed from our property (from both our house as well as our garden). Any noise and/or lights generated from activity in the proposed rooftop addition and deck will be easily heard and seen from our home. Please consider our opposition to this proposal at the applicable BAR and/or BZA meetings and reviews. If you would like additional details regarding our opposition to this proposal, please contact me below. Thank you for your consideration of this request. Lavinia and Sam Howell 3 Water Street Charleston, South Carolina 29401 Telephone: 843.266.3801 ATTENTION: This email originated from outside the City of Charleston's systems. Do not click links or open attachments unless you are expecting them from the sender and/or have confirmed the content is safe. Forward any suspicious emails by clicking the Phish Alert Button. From: ginny bush <ginnybush6@gmail.com> Sent: Monday, September 28, 2026 5:30 PM To: Pinto, Frankie Subject: 0 Atlantic St proposed rooftop addition ATTENTION: This email originated from outside the City of Charleston's systems. Do not click links or open attachments unless you are expecting them from the sender and/or have confirmed the content is safe. Forward any suspicious emails by clicking the Phish Alert Button. I write to express my opposition to the 0 Atlantic Street’s BAR-S application for a rooftop addition and roof deck. The application raises zoning questions that cannot be resolved by the materials submitted by the applicant. In particular, whether the maximum height limit and setback minimums for an SR-3 zoned property would be satisfied. The drawing suggests that the property may be an existing nonconformity although the setback distance is not shown. A vertical addition and intensified use of a nonconforming structure merits consideration by the BZA. I would think that a determination of compliance with zoning should be made before the BAR-S addresses the design. If necessary, an application for a variance or special exception should be made before a BAR-S application. If the Planning Department has properly determined the proposal meets applicable zoning standards (although I found no BZA record), I oppose the rooftop addition and deck due to its height and visibility from at least two rights-of-way (Atlantic St. and Water St.). Moreover, the proposed design appears to include glass walls surrounding the deck, which is incongruous with the historic surrounding properties and the neighborhood character. Based on the renderings, it would appear to be visible from my house, 6 Water St., which is directly opposite 1 Water St. that adjoins the 0 Atlantic property. In addition to my visual concerns, the likelihood of noise and lights from gatherings on a nearby rooftop should be taken into account. I respectfully urge the BAR-S to defer this application until possible zoning issues are resolved and the BAR-S can give. further consideration to the design and magnitude of the additions. Thank you for considering my concerns. Ginny Bush 6 Water St. Charleston SC 29401 (404) 825-2899 Ken and Helen Copeland 1 Water Street Charleston, South Carolina 29401 September 25, 2026 Frankie Pinto BAR-Small Administrator Board of Architectural Review Department of Planning & Preservation City of Charleston 2 George Street, Suite 3100 Charleston, South Carolina 29401 Re: 0 Atlantic Street — Proposed Rooftop Addition and Roof Deck Dear Frankie: We are writing to express our objection to the proposed plans for a rooftop addition and roof deck at 0 Atlantic Street, which we understand will shortly come before the Board of Architectural Review. We are the owners of 1 Water Street, adjoining the subject property. The owner’s architect contacted us to discuss and review the plans, having been advised to do so by other stakeholders. Having now been shown the plans and thoroughly reviewed them ourselves we have significant concerns about their impact on the livability of our home. From what we observed, and from what the architect communicated, the proposal consists of approximately 250 square feet of new enclosed structure adjacent to the current highest point of the building, running from the rear of the building on the Water Street side to the front on the Atlantic Street side. The plans also appear to include approximately 500 square feet of open roof deck surrounded by a wall/coping, occupying the remaining roof. The architect described that coping/wall as glass, consistent with the proposed plans we have observed. A roof deck of this size is large enough to host a large gathering of people, and the overall scale of the proposal is therefore inappropriate. Our eight-year-old son’s bedroom, with its single-pane window, sits at the same level as the proposed deck in close proximity to it. We recently measured these distances by laser: approximately 32 to 33 feet from the deck to our son’s bedroom, and approximately 21 to 22 feet to our primary bedroom suite, which is also on that side of the house. The likelihood of significant noise and disturbance at these distances is not acceptable in this context. Recourse to the noise ordinance would not be adequate remedy in an instance where the roof deck were used in certain ways, and privacy is a serious concern at both locations. We are also uncertain about construction logistics, as no mention was made of them by the architect. Noise on weekends and in the morning, so close to a child’s bedroom, would be problematic, as would any debris or dust. To the extent the existing roof contains problematic materials such as asbestos, we would be even more concerned about the demolition. Were the owner to propose something significantly more modest, we could envision an arrangement that is considerably less impactful and workable for both households. A small deck on the Atlantic Street side, allowing for water and sunset views and perhaps the occasional dinner party of six to ten people, might be acceptable. The proposed scale goes well beyond that. Something more modest, with appropriate sound and privacy mitigation, might work; something that can accommodate large gatherings cannot. More generally, we believe this sets a poor precedent for roof decks downtown. A deck for genuinely personal use that does not impact neighbors is one thing; a deck that can host large parties becomes a potential nuisance, both in this location and in others. We also object to the proposal as designed on visual grounds. The glass coping and wall enclosing the deck will be visible from Water Street, Atlantic Street, and East Battery. A visible roof deck is a poor precedent to set for the East Battery corridor, a visual corridor of unique significance in this city. The proposed enclosed addition will likewise be visible from Atlantic Street, Water Street, and the High Battery. We do not believe any visible rooftop element is appropriate at this location, and we would urge the Board to permit none. We are also not certain how a 4 th story in a 3-story Old City Height District which extends a non-conforming condition is appropriate or even allowable per zoning. The present moment calls for particular vigilance: with three East Battery mansions currently for sale, one of them under contract, whatever is approved here will be tested by others. We respectfully ask that the Board reject this submission in its current form. We very much appreciate your consideration. Sincerely, Ken and Helen Copeland 1 Water Street The Swink Family 10/06/26 27-29 East Battery Charleston, SC 29401 Board of Architectural Review – Small Department of Planning, Preservation & Sustainability City of Charleston 2 George Street, Suite 3100 Charleston, SC 29401 Re: Opposition to Proposed Fourth-Floor Addition at 0 Atlantic Street Dear Members of the Board: I write on behalf of our family in opposition to the proposed fourth-floor addition to the carriage house at 0 Atlantic Street in the Old and Historic District (Charlestowne / South of Broad). The carriage house is attached to our home, and the proposed addition would eliminate our western windows, permanently destroy the important western view we enjoy across Charleston’s rooftops at twilight, and significantly diminish our quality of life by removing a daily source of light, openness, and connection to the historic cityscape that is central to our experience of living here. A four-story addition is incompatible with the height, scale, and mass of this mid-19th- century carriage house and the surrounding streetscape. Carriage houses in Charleston have traditionally remained subordinate structures. Raising this building to four stories would reverse that relationship and disrupt the established two- and three-story character of Atlantic Street. The proposed wood-and-glass construction is not sympathetic to the historic brick and stucco character of the existing structure or the neighborhood. The glass handrail of the rooftop deck is not a historic material and further contributes to a contemporary appearance out of character with the district. In addition, handrails and rooftop decks usually are to be set back from the parapet walls; this proposal does not appear to meet that standard. New rooftop structures are expected to be non-visible from the public right-of-way. This proposal is fully visible from Atlantic Street and is also fully visible from Water Street to the north. NOTE: Sheet 16 of the submitted architectural drawings shows a sight line from Atlantic Street claiming the new structure is not visible from Atlantic Street; that claim is incorrect. The sight-line analysis relies on the front structure’s parapet, which is not relevant to views of the proposed addition on the rear carriage house. Approval would set a troubling precedent for vertical expansion and visible rooftop additions in this tightly scaled section of the historic district. We respectfully urge the Board to deny the proposed fourth-floor addition. Sincerely, The Swink Family Justine Wardrop 2 Zig Zag Alley Charleston, SC 29401 September 28, 2026 Frankie Pinto BAR-Small Administrator Board of Architecture Review City of Charleston 2 George Street, Suite 3100 Charleston, SC 29401 Re: 0 Atlantic Street Proposed Addition and Roof Deck Dear Frankie, I am writing to strongly oppose the proposed plan to add a roof deck and conservatory section to the existing structure at 0 Atlantic Street. I have not been contacted by the owner or the architect and have only heard about this through my neighbors. I have significant concern about this plan since my patio, kitchen and master bedroom are located at the back of my house and are in close proximity to 0 Atlantic. I have been informed that this plan would allow the owner to accommodate large parties on the deck assuming this would be the purpose for such a large outdoor space. The noise and disturbance in addition to the current design would be intrusive and inconsiderate to those of us who live nearby and care about the historic integrity of the neighborhood. From what I understand there is considerable concern about the proposed plan, and I hope the BAR and BZA will require the owner to reconsider the scale, design and purpose of this addition. Thank you for your consideration. Justine “Tina” Wardrop September 21, 2026 Ms. BD Wortham-Galvin City Architect/ Director-Preservation 2 George Street Suite 3100 Charleston, SC 29401 Dear Ms. Wortham-Galvin, It has come to the attention of the Charlestowne Neighborhood Association (CNA) that an application will be filed with the Board of Architectural Review – Small (BAR-S) for a proposed renovation and addition at 0 Atlantic Street, including a rooftop penthouse structure and outdoor roof gathering area. The CNA was informed of the project by the architect and applicant, Young+Wales Architects. The CNA was subsequently contacted by adjacent neighbors on Water Street, who confirmed they met with the applicant to review the proposed work. The neighbors expressed serious concerns about the scope of work and the negative impact the project would have on their property. The CNA advocates for neighbors to resolve disputes before applications are filed with the city, to limit the impact that contentious applications may have on the proceedings of the board. However, when contentious applications are brought to the board, the CNA urges the BAR-S to defer the application to allow for the parties to resolve their differences outside the BAR-S meeting. Given the contentious nature of this application, the CNA urges the BAR-S to defer the application for further study, and for the applicant to address the concerns raised by the adjacent neighbors. Sincerely, ___________________________________ Sebastian von Marschall, President, Charlestowne Neighborhood Assn. Board of Architectural Review – Small Public Comment | October 7, 2026 Page 4 13. 3 Gadsden Street BAR2026-002880 | TMS# 457-03-03-074 | Harleston Village | Council District 8 Not rated | c. 1958 | Old and Historic District Requesting conceptual approval to extend front stoop for new front portico and mineral stain. Owner: Adam Gould Applicant: Kyle Belcher 3 Comments Submitted to Innovate in Support 1Comment Submitted to Staff in Opposition (see attached) First Name Last Name Address Submitted Comment Date/Time Submitted Marty Osborn 122 Beufain St I am the owner of 122 Beufain St Unit A , the home directly across the street from Adam and Barbara Gould at 3 Gadsden Street and am writing in support of their proposed exterior improvements. Because my property directly faces 3 Gadsden, I am very familiar with the appearance of the home from the street. I have reviewed the proposed changes and believe the new front portico will be a substantial improvement to the front elevation and will give the home a more attractive and appropriately defined entrance. Also, without a porch, what do you do with packages? When it rains, we have to go over there if they are not home and get them out of the rain. I also support the proposed white limewash of the existing brick.The brick currently has noticeable variations in color and appearance, and I believe the limewash will help unify those differences and create a more cohesive exterior. Together with the new portico and other proposed improvements, I believe it will significantly enhance the home's appearance from Gadsden Street. I believe the overall renovation will be a positive improvement to 3 Gadsden Street and to this portion of the neighborhood, and I am pleased to support the application. Oct 5 2026 3:04PM Kathy Wille 11 Gadsden St. We live at 11 Gadsden Street, just a few houses from Adam and Barbara Gould’s home at 3 Gadsden Street, and we am writing in support of their proposed exterior improvements. As a nearby neighbor, we am very familiar with the property and have reviewed the proposed changes. We believe the new front portico will be a very attractive improvement to the home and will give the front entrance greater architectural definition while fitting nicely with the character of Gadsden Street. We also support the proposed white limewash of the existing brick. The brick currently has noticeable differences in color and appearance, and we believe the limewash will provide a more consistent and Oct 5 2026 6:14AM Board of Architectural Review – Small Public Comment | October 7, 2026 Page 5 cohesive finish that works well with the proposed portico and other exterior improvements. We appreciate the care Adam and Barbara are putting into the renovation of the property. We believe the finished project will be an attractive addition to our street and a positive improvement to the neighborhood. We am pleased to support their application. Kathy Wille and Casey Meuer David Grubbs 5 Gadsden Street My family and I have lived at 5 Gadsden street for over 26 years, and I am the next-door neighbor of Adam and Barbara Gould at 3 Gadsden Street. My wife and I are writing in strong support of the proposed exterior improvements to 3 Gadsden. I have reviewed the plans for the new front portico and believe it will be a significant improvement to the appearance and architectural character of the house. The proposed design is appropriately scaled and will give the front entrance greater definition while fitting well with the surrounding homes on Gadsden Street. I also support the proposed limewash treatment of the existing brick. I believe the lighter finish, together with the new portico and other exterior improvements, will create a more cohesive appearance and enhance the property and our immediate streetscape. As their next-door neighbor, I believe these improvements will be a very positive addition, and I hope you will give favorable consideration. David and Lizzy Grubbs Oct 5 2026 10:19AM Position Statement Board of Architectural Review – Small October 8, 2026 3 Gadsden Street Dear Board Members, The Preservation Society of Charleston (PSC) maintains our previous position that the Colonial Revival-style door surround is a character-defining feature and should be maintained. Additionally, the PSC is not supportive of the request to paint the existing unfinished brick exterior. Unpainted brick is a highly characteristic material of Colonial Revival-style buildings in Charleston’s early-20th century neighborhoods. Consistent with the Secretary of the Interior’s Standards for Rehabilitation, we urge the Board to require preservation of the building’s historic finish. Thank you for considering our position in this matter. Sincerely, Flannery Antinoro Preservation Specialist

Source: City of Charleston website. First collected Oct 14, 2026.