RecordWell Data

BZA-Z Public Comment

City of Charleston · Berkeley County · meeting of Sep 15, 2026 · Agendas

Open the original document More from City of Charleston

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

CITY OF CHARLESTON BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS – ZONING PUBLIC COMMENT SEPTEMBER 15, 2026 A meeting of the Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning (BZA-Z) will be held on Tuesday, September 15, 2026, at 5:15 p.m. in the Public Meeting Room, First Floor, 2 George Street . The following comments will be provided to the board members 24 hours in advance of the meeting and also be acknowledged into the record and summarized. The public is encouraged to attend the meeting in person to speak in order for comments to be fully heard. Application information is available at www.charleston-sc.gov/bza-z. Please check the website on the meeting date to view any withdrawn or deferred agenda items. For additional information, please contact: Department of Planning & Preservation | 843-724-3781 A. PUBLIC HEARINGS – NEW BUSINESS 1. 1 Johnson Rd. Crescent| Council District 11 | TMS# 421-10-00-013 Zoned: SR-8 | BZA2026-002452 Request Variance from Sec. 54-301 to build an accessory building with a 9’ east side setback from the side street (35’ required). Owners: M egan & Chase McNair Applicant: Mary Mac Wilson 3 Comments Submitted to Innovate in Opposition 2 Comments Submitted to Staff in Opposition (see attached) First Name Last Name Address Submitted Comment Date/Time Submitted Roger Warren 1 Jamestown road Charleston We live in the Crescent neighborhood on Jamestown road. During contemplated renovations we wanted a setback from the street variance. We were told unequivocally NO! Your office told our builder that the rules of the Crescent supersede city of Charleston rules. We were told not to even try for a variance so we didn't, and scrapped the planned project. We were informed that we had to be 48 feet from the street and those rules would not be amended. That it was set in stone. We were seeking just 4 feet. NOT 25!!!! Sep 10 2026 11:04AM Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning Public Comment | September 15, 2026 Page 2 Now we understand from the neighborhood that 1 Johnson road wants to be 9 feet from the street ( set back). I strenuously object to this variance request and want this entered into the record as I cannot attend the meeting. This changes the complexion of the neighborhood. NO double standards. Thank you. A concerned neighbor. Bobby Warren Jamestown road We live in the Crescent neighborhood on Jamestown road. During contemplated renovations we wanted a setback from the street variance. We were told unequivocally NO! Your office told our builder that the rules of the Crescent supersede city of Charleston rules. We were told not to even try for a variance so we didn't, and scrapped the planned project. We were informed that we had to be 48 feet from the street and those rules would not be amended. That it was set in stone. We were seeking just 4 feet. NOT 25!!!! Now we understand from the neighborhood that 1 Johnson road wants to be 9 feet from the street ( set back). I strenuously object to this variance request and want this entered into the record as I cannot attend the meeting. This changes the complexion of the neighborhood. NO double standards. Thank you. A concerned neighbor. Section 54-301 explicitly dictates that when determining front setbacks in your neighborhood, the city legally relies on a customized master plan: "that certain map of The Crescent prepared by the City of Charleston Department of Planning and Urban Development, printed in August, 2000". [1] (https://www.zoneomics.com/code/charleston -SC/chapter_5)Because the code mandates that the specific footprints detailed on this custom neighborhood map are legally presumed correct, the 48-foot requirement dictates the true buildable line on your street. [1] (https://www.zoneomics.com/code/charleston -SC/chapter_5)This explains why homeowners on your list of streets (like Jamestown, Sayle, or Guerard) cannot simply build to the standard city-wide 30-foot line. Attempting to encroach past that specific 48-foot neighborhood mapped line forces a homeowner straight into the strict BZA hardship variance process— which, as noted, almost always results in a preemptive withdrawal or forced redesign rather than an official voted denial. Sep 10 2026 11:21AM Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning Public Comment | September 15, 2026 Page 3 bobby Robertso n Jamestown road This public comment represents 4 families who reside in the Crescent. We strenuously oppose the request for a variance. There is no " hardship" represented in this application. In fact, 3 of the 4 families this comment represents have had a setback denial in one way shape or form. The SR-8 Rules are very clear. One family requested a 5 foot setback from the street which was instantly denied. The project was scrapped. If you allow 9 feet from the required 35 feet ( or 48 feet). you are changing the complexion of the neighborhood. If allowed, you are opening up all other homeowners and giving them precedent to stand upon. This will forever change the meaning and tenor of the setback rules established for the Crescent long ago. inc We all must adhere, inconvenient or not. Thank you for your time and consideration. Sep 10 2026 11:43AM From: Buzzy C <buzzychailse@gmail.com> Sent: Thursday, September 10, 2026 9:25 AM To: Harp, Ana <harpa@charleston-sc.gov> Subject: 1 Johnson Road request for Variance Good morning, We live in the Crescent neighborhood on Jamestown road. During contemplated renovations we wanted a setback from the street variance. We were told unequivocally NO! Your office told our builder that the rules of the Crescent supersede city of Charleston rules. We were told not to even try for a variance so we didn't and scrapped the planned project. We were informed that we had to be 48 feet from the street and those rules would not be amended. That it was set in stone. Now we understand from the neighborhood that 1 Johnson road wants to be 9 feet from the street ( set back). I strenuously object to this variance request and want this entered into the record as I cannot attend the meeting. This changes to complexion of the neighborhood. NO double standards. Thank you. A concerned neighbor. From: Buzzy C <buzzychailse@gmail.com> Sent: Thursday, September 10, 2026 9:53 AM To: Harp, Ana <harpa@charleston-sc.gov> Subject: 1 Johnson road Crescent Section 54-301 explicitly dictates that when determining front setbacks in your neighborhood, the city legally relies on a customized master plan: "that certain map of The Crescent prepared by the City of Charleston Department of Planning and Urban Development, printed in August, 2000". [1] Because the code mandates that the specific footprints detailed on this custom neighborhood map are legally presumed correct, the 48-foot requirement dictates the true buildable line on your street. [1] This explains why homeowners on your list of streets (like Jamestown, Sayle, or Guerard) cannot simply build to the standard city-wide 30-foot line. Attempting to encroach past that specific 48-foot neighborhood mapped line forces a homeowner straight into the strict BZA hardship variance process—which, as noted, almost always results in a preemptive withdrawal or forced redesign rather than an official voted denial. Please enter this into the record, we cannot show up and oppose a neighbor but this is a clear violation as no " hardship " is evident . Thanks so very much, Concerned neighbors. Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning Public Comment | September 15, 2026 Page 4 3. 132 S. Battery St. Charlestowne| Council District 8 | TMS# 457-11-01-034 Zoned: STR | BZA2026-002457 Request Variance under Sec. 54-301 to build a covered porch with a 17’ rear setback (25’ required). Owner: Anne Keogh Applicant: David Richards, Architect 5 Comments Submitted to Staff in Support (see attached) Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning Public Comment | September 15, 2026 Page 4 5. 1735 Pinckney Park Dr. West Ashley – Dupont Station| Council District 11 | TMS# 350-06-00-032 Zoned: STR | BZA2026-002459 Request Variance from Sec. 54-824 to create two lots of record with street frontages of 62’ (103’ required). Owner/Applicant: Mark Weatherford 6 Comments Submitted to Staff in Support (see attached) Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning Public Comment | September 15, 2026 Page 5 6. 61 Gibbes St. Charlestowne| Council District 8 | TMS# 457-11-01-050 Zoned STR | BZA2026-002462 Request Special Exception under Sec. 54-110.f. to vertically extend a nonconforming 7’ west side setback (12’ required) and a Variance from Sec. 54-301 to build a two- story rear addition with a 24’ rear setback (25’ required). Owner: Elizabeth S. Christian Applicant: Glenn Keyes Architects 1 Comment Submitted to Staff in Opposition (see attached) From: Hubert Wood <hubie@woodgroupllc.com> Sent: Monday, September 14, 2026 10:37 AM To: Swalhah, Christopher <SwalhahC@charleston-sc.gov> Subject: BZA Agenda Item #D-6 (9/15/26 Meeting) Chris: In follow up to our call a short while ago, please see below and attached for our memorandum in opposition. Kindly include this with the public record and confirm receipt via reply email. Thank you for your assistance, HW MEMORANDUM IN OPPOSITION TO: City of Charleston Board of Zoning Appeals FROM: Joseph Hubert Wood, III and Catherine Avery Wood RE: 61 Gibbes Street Special Exception and Variance Requests (Agenda Item #D-6) DATE: September 14, 2026 INTRODUCTION AND BACKGROUND We own, and permanently reside at, 63 Gibbes Street, Charleston, SC, 29401 which is adjacent to the west side of the subject property. The general area is low lying terrain built on fill/reclaimed land. It is flood prone. The distance between the existing houses at 61 and 63 Gibbes is estimated to be 12-16 feet (see second photograph attached hereto). The area between the houses, particularly toward the rear, is extremely low lying, and subject to flooding and standing water due not only to its low lying nature and direct rainfall, but stormwater runoff from both houses’ roofs and guttering systems. The area receives limited direct sunlight and the ground is perpetually saturated, soft and/or damp. Our property has a basement (which is quite obviously the “low point” in the area) requiring an elaborate sump pump system that runs in a regularly frequent pattern to prevent infiltration of ground water. When flooding occurs, the sump pump system runs in a continuous fashion to discharge the excessive water gravitating to the low point from the surrounding area and on occasion, can become overwhelmed leading to flooding of the basement. ARGUMENT As a threshold matter, we dispute the characterization of a “Special Exception..... to vertically extend a nonconforming... west side setback....” and the stated proposal “to enclose the deck on the first and second floors.” The current nonconforming use is a flat wood surface deck (see first photograph attached hereto). It is adjacent to the first floor at 61 Gibbes Street. There is no roof. There are no walls; only a modest wood railing, and lattice siding between the ground and deck surface. There is no guttering or other mechanism that channels/diverts storm water accumulating on the deck. There isn’t a second level to “enclose.” It has minimal to no effect on sunlight and air flow reaching the area between the two houses. We are not aware of the wooden deck’s foundation but feel confident in asserting that it is not sufficient to serve as a foundation for the proposed “vertical extension.” Rather than a “vertical extension of an existing nonconforming use” and “enclosure of the deck,” we submit that the proposed project actually involves the destruction/removal of a nonconforming use to be replaced by a totally different nonconforming use that will presumably require a new/different foundation along with walls/siding and a roof. As such, Section 54-111(f)(1) is not applicable. It is self-evident from a comparison of the existing West Elevation drawing and proposed drawing submitted with the proposal, that the project would result in an unreasonable intensification of the non-conforming use and have a substantial adverse impact on 63 Gibbes based on its size, scale and proximity to our house alone. Several other factors also support that conclusion. The proposed project will further limit/restrict the amount of direct sunlight and air flow between the two houses, exacerbating the inability of the ground to dry and making it even more susceptible to flooding, standing water and the well known problems that accompany such. The proposed project will also result in more stormwater being channeled/diverted into this area exacerbating the flooding, standing water and problems that accompany such. The proposed project will also “wall off” the rear section on the east side of our house (which includes the master bedroom) from any direct morning sunlight, and limit our view to the east to that of the “vertical extension” depicted on the proposed West Elevation drawing. The unreasonable intensification of the nonconforming use and substantial adverse impact of the proposed project on 63 Gibbes Street is clear and unequivocal. Accordingly, the requests fail under Section 54-111(f)(2) and Section 54-924(d). There are no extraordinary circumstances to support the requests. The zoning requirements/setbacks apply with equal force to all properties in the area. The property at 61 Gibbes can continue to be used in the same manner it has been used for decades if the proposal is not approved. Therefore, the requests fail under Section 54-924(a)(b) and (c). CONCLUSION For the foregoing reasons, we respectfully request that the Board deny the relief requested in Agenda Item #D-6. Thank you for the Board’s consideration. Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning Public Comment | September 15, 2026 Page 7 8. DEFFERED|10 Philadelphia Aly. French Quarter| Council District 8 | TMS# 458-09-01-096 Zoned SR-5 | BZA2026-002454 Request Special Exception under Sec. 54-501 to build a detached single-family home on a lot of insufficient size (1,767sf existing, 2,500sf required), a Variance from Sec. 54-301 for the proposed home to be built with a 0’ rear setback (3’ required) a 0’ north side setback (3’ required) a 0’ south side setback (7’ required) a combined front & rear setbacks of 0’ (3’ required), a combined side setbacks of 0’ (10’ required), and a building lot occupancy of 100% (35% maximum, 100% existing) and a Variance from Sec. 54-317 to provide no off-street parking (2 spaces required). Owner: Footlight Players, Inc. Applicant: Samuel Morris, Nelson Mullins Riley and Scarborough LLP 1 Comment Submitted to Innovate in Support First Name Last Name Address Submitted Comment Date/Time Submitted Stephanie Wilson Gentile 54 Queen St. The Board of the French Quarter Neighborhood Association (FQNA) supports this application. We look forward to having the building used as a single family residence, rather than its current use. We do plan on continuing conversations with the applicant and architect if the project moves forward, to address specific neighborhood concerns re: traffic, construction and the like. Thank you for the opportunity to comment on this application. Stephanie Wilson Gentile, President, FQNA Sep 13 2026 2:01PM Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning Public Comment | September 15, 2026 Page 8 10. 1025 Sam Rittenberg Blvd. West Ashley| Council District 9 | TMS# 415-10-00-073 Zoned LB/SR-1| BZA2026-002460 Request Use Variance to allow a personal service use (wedding photography) on the SR-1 portion of the existing split zoned parcel. Owner: 1025 Sam Rittenberg Blvd., LLC Applicant: Ashley River Hall, LLC c/o Ellis Lesemann 5 Comments Submitted to Innovate in Opposition First Name Last Name Address Submitted Comment Date/Time Submitted Corey Frazier 14 Leichester Road, Charleston, SC 1025 Sam Rittenberg Blvd was originally entirely zoned as residential until 1984 when the city allowed for rezoning under restrictive covenants that allowed for indoor office use only under very restrictive guidelines. Against neighboring property owners opinions, City Council has already passed revisions to these restrictive covenants allowing the operator to utilize the commercially zoned portion of the parcel for outdoor wedding venue use. The operator is seeking to further extend the commercial use of the property through this variance which should not be granted. This application seeks to extend commercial operations which myself and our neighbors feel will negatively impact our privacy and neighborhood and ultimately will put to use for more than the implied "photography" use as evidenced by prior patio event areas being poured and removed as they were unpermitted and/or over the SR-1 line and in critical buffer areas. Furthermore, a variance to the SR-1 line should require the critical line buffer imposed on the LB portion of the parcel to be upheld which currently extends to the current LB zoning line. This prohibits construction of any impervious features and requires the protection of vegetation and restricts any land disturbance. As such if a variance were issued, the critical line should extend through entire area encompassed as SR-1 currently. Issuing a variance in use of the SR-1 portion of the lot as LB is a detriment to the intended use of the property, surrounding neighborhood, and creates opportunity for encroachment into the critical line buffer (marsh). The operation of this business and the modifications to the restrictive covenants under the existing zoning and lot lines has Sep 10 2026 12:47PM Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning Public Comment | September 15, 2026 Page 9 been heard and settled by City Council mere weeks ago and it is my opinion that no further expansion or variances should be granted. Cameron Baker 11 Charing Cross Road This property has already been before City Council to amend the restrictive covenants that were placed on the property. The original covenants precluded the proposed use. City Council approved the amendment of the restrictive covenants, however, provided additional stipulations to protect the adjacent residential property owners. This variance request proposes commercial improvements on a small portion of property that remains residentially zoned. The residentially zoned portion of the property is adjacent to neighboring residential properties and is mostly comprised of SCDES critical area which cannot be developed. Only a small portion of the residentially zoned portions of the property is considered upland and available for improvements. Any proposed improvements in this area would be of further detriment to neighboring residential properties. Denying improvements in the residentially zoned portions of the property would not hinder the ability of this property to be developed as a proposed wedding venue. Additionally, any proposed improvements in this area would be immediately adjacent to SCDES critical areas. Proposed construction activities within the immediate vicinity of a SCDES Critical area should be prohibited. At the time of the city council meeting for the proposed amendment to the restrictive covenants, an approved SCDES critical line plat had not been submitted for City review. This item is required for all proposed construction activities. Furthermore, denial of the proposed variance request does not create any unnecessary hardships for the development. a.A majority of the upland portions of the property, currently zoned to allow the development, can accommodate the proposed improvements. The small portion that is zoned residential is not necessary to accommodate the intent of the development. An extraordinary or exception condition by not permitting commercial improvements within a residentially zoned area. b.Development on a majority of the property is currently permitted as is similar with other commercial properties Sep 11 2026 8:43AM Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning Public Comment | September 15, 2026 Page 10 in the vicinity. c.The inability to construct commercial improvements within a residentially zoned portion of the property does not prohibit or unreasonably restrict the utilization of the property. The property already contains parking and a structure that can be utilized for the wedding venue. d.The authorization of the variance WILL be of substantial detriment to adjacent property owners. Denying the variance request would protect the neighboring property owners by maintaining an undeveloped buffer between the proposed venue and residences. Additionally, this buffer will serve to protect adjacent critical areas, wetlands, and shellfish beds. Lexi Frazier Leichester Road Dear Members of the Board of Zoning Appeals, I am writing to oppose the requested Use Variance for 1025 Sam Rittenberg Blvd, submitted by Ashley River Hall, LLC c/o Ellis Lesemann to be heard at the September 15, 2026 BZA-Z meeting. Two months ago, City Council approved amendments to restrictive covenants that had been in place for 40 years, protecting the Parkshore III neighborhood from certain commercial businesses, including event venues in our neighborhood. After the operator was granted major concessions to be allowed to operate, they are now requesting a use variance for the residential split-zoned parcel. Allowing this use variance comes to great detriment of the adjacent residential properties. Please consider section d of the City of Charleston Variance Test: d. the authorization of a variance will not be of substantial detriment to adjacent property or to the public good, and the character of the district will not be harmed by the granting of the variance. The SR-1 parcel is in direct line of sight from our backyard and deck as well as many neighbors’ properties. Allowing 200 person events to operate in that space will absolutely be a detriment and disturbance to the adjacent properties. Not only will we be looking directly at these events taking place and hearing all of the noise that comes with it, but the venue also looks directly into our private property where our young children live and play. There has been discussion of the limitations being placed on the operator in terms of noise and disturbance which has been Sep 11 2026 12:33PM Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning Public Comment | September 15, 2026 Page 11 limited to 9pm. However, a major factor that has been overlooked in discussions is the disturbance neighboring properties will experience in the afternoon and early evening - times when families are typically enjoying their outdoor spaces is also the prime time for outdoor wedding and event activities. Finally, we have been extremely disappointed in the lack of environmental measures being taken with the work at this property. The original 2,000SF of concrete slabs were poured with no permits and no environmental procedures being followed (silt fencing, tree protection, erosion control, etc.) The SR-1 parcel abuts the marsh and there is little confidence that the operator can and will enforce proper use of the space near and on the critical line. Please do not approve the requested use variance. Thank you for your consideration, Lexi Frazier Sharon Glaab 2 Paddington Circle, Charleston, South Carolina 29407-3407 This repurposing of light office space with very limited parking that fronts the marsh and backs up to the back yards of many long term residents for a high volume event space is a huge change from the previous quiet office usage that the property has hosted for many years. The entrance is directly across from a Ped / Bike crossing to access the recreational path to Northbridge Park and increasing traffic for event guests who will be unfamiliar with the roads and likely drinking alcohol is a recipe for disaster. It will be hosting multiple events with 200+ guests and event staff on a frontage road that has an intersection with Sam Rittenberg Blvd that people already can't figure out how to navigate. There is woefully inadequate parking for a venue expecting 200 guests - the parking area would be enough only for event staff at its current configuration. This huge change in traffic will impeded emergency access and egress for the existing residents and businesses. While the item under consideration today appears to be relatively minor, it is part of an incremental "creep" of multiple changes to the intended use of a property that is so close to where families have peacefully lived for over a generation. This tenant of the property has already shown a disregard for proper permitting and use of this sensitive marsh front land and expanding their privileges is the last thing that should be allowed. My family Sep 12 2026 9:37AM Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning Public Comment | September 15, 2026 Page 12 has lived in Parkshore 3 since 2005 and we supported the Boy Scouts and Tumbleston businesses - our children bought supplies at the Boy Scouts store and had their high school portraits taken when it was Tumbleston Photography. We do not oppose a proper business use of this property - just a neighborhood altering change in purpose to a noisy venue that endangers the residents trying to dodge vehicles while walking or biking in the neighborhood. Pamela Luhn 10 Charing Cross Rd. Dear Members of the Board, As a 28 year resident of the Parkshore lll neighborhood, I am asking that the personal service use variance request TMS 415-10-00-073 BZA 2026-002460 in reference to 1025 Sam Rittenberg Boulevard be denied. Allowing the SR-2 parcel of land to remain just that will not affect the use of the event space and will add protection to the natural marsh environment by prohibiting human activity upon it while offering somewhat of a buffer to the neighborhood. Use variances should be difficult to receive as they can change the functional character of the neighborhood. This LB event space is doing just that by adding noise disruptions to humans and marsh animals alike, for example the blue herons who use this natural marsh environment. There does not appear to be any unnecessary economic or practical use hardship to the event operator if this personal service use variance is not approved as the LB portion of the event site offers outdoor space and beautiful background for photos thus not affecting physical layouts and conditions. The personal use variance would place activity and noise disruption physically closer to the surrounding community, devaluing neighborhood property and violating the core intent of the split parcel. The use of this site as an event space already poses disruption and devaluation to an old established neighborhood, The split parcel LB and SR-2 restrictions had been put in to respect the importance of both of them. A concrete patio had been put in only to be removed as it was done basically under the radar. The remedial demolition of this patio has done nothing to inspire confidence in the neighborhood that more personal service use variances may not Sep 13 2026 10:38AM Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning Public Comment | September 15, 2026 Page 13 come up at a later date. When one personal service use variance is granted, in all probability more will follow. Allowing the SR-2 parcel to remain SR-2 establishes a natural barrier between the LB site and the neighborhood. Allowing the SR-2 parcel to remain SR-2 offers protection for the natural marsh environment from human activity, adds a buffer between event activities and the neighborhood while not curtailing event activities. As stated by the mayor at the June 16, 2026 City Council meeting a reasonable restrictive use had been reached for this “unique property”. The landowner and the tenant had reviewed the proposed revisions and consented to them. Their two asks- one of which was permission to use a microphone by an officiant during a ceremony and the second that the city has the right within one year of ratification to re-open and revisit if any problems arise with no sooner than nine months-were agreed upon. This is a unique property. The intent of the split parcel is to allow both business and neighborhood to live together respectfully. Again I ask that this personal service use variance be denied. Thank you, Pamela Luhn Pamela Luhn 10 Charing Cross Rd. In my letter to the Board I mistyped and put SR-2. It should say SR-!. Sep 13 2026 11:17AM

Source: City of Charleston website. First collected Oct 14, 2026.