RecordWell Data

BAR-S Public Comment

City of Charleston · Berkeley County · meeting of Sep 10, 2026 · Agendas

Open the original document More from City of Charleston

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

CITY OF CHARLESTON BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW – SMALL PUBLIC COMMENT SEPTEMBER 10, 2026 A meeting of the Board of Architectural Review – Small (BAR -S) will be held on Thursday, September 10, 2026, at 4:30 p.m. in the Public Meeting Room, First Floor, 2 George Street. The following written comments will be provided to the board members 24 hours in advance of the meeting. The comments will also be acknowledged into the record and summarized. The public is encouraged to attend the meeting in person to speak in order for comments to be fully heard. Application information is available at www.charleston-sc.gov/bar. Please check the website on the meeting date to view any withdrawn or deferred agenda items. For additional information, please contact: Department of Planning & Preservation | 843-724-3781 B. APPLICATIONS 1. 2 S Enston Avenue BAR2026-002812 | TMS#463-12-01-143 | North Central | Council District 4 Not rated | c.1940 | Historic Materials Demolition District Requesting approval for demolition of remaining building. Owner: Johnson Charles Willard Applicant: Carolin Weiss 1 Comment Submitted to Innovate in Support First Name Last Name Address Submitted Comment Date/Time Submitted Zac Viscidi 59 Cypress St I am writing in favor of this demolition request. The home in question is beyond dilapidated, and is in great need of rehabilitation. There does not seem to be a way to do this through renovation, and allowing for a demolition, and a full rebuild will allow that corner to be revitalized and reinvigorated. Sep 8 2026 7:36PM 3. 2 Hester Street BAR2026-002800 | TMS#463-11-03-090 | Wagener Terrace | Council District 6 Category 4 (Group 2) | c.1940 | Historic Materials Demolition District Requesting approval for partial demolition of exterior elements visible from the public right- of-way. Owner: HOMEBUYERS SC LLC Applicant: Amber Aument LLC Board of Architectural Review – Small Public Comment | September 10, 2026 Page 2 1 Comment Submitted to Innovate in Opposition First Name Last Name Address Submitted Comment Date/Time Submitted Seth Gainey 103C Winyah Alley Dear Members of the BAR, I am writing in response to the application for 2 Hester Street. My wife and I own the property immediately east and south of 2 Hester Street. We live one building down the street. Over the past five years, we have worked to rehabilitate the wetlands immediately adjacent to 2 Hester, with the help and cooperation of the former owners, the M.A.R.S.H. Project, Charleston Parks Conservancy, and other neighborhood groups. I'm proud of the progress that has been made and look forward to engaging with the new owners so that this work can continue. I respectfully ask the BAR to defer this application until it can be heard by the Wagner Terrace Neighborhood Association, which mets every 3rd Monday. The WTNA often reviews and writes letters of approval for these projects. This request is not an objection to thoughtful redevelopment of the property. I admire Amber Aument’s work and appreciate her previous projects. I'm excited to see her vision for 2 Hester Street. Sep 9 2026 10:06AM 5. 380 Ashley Avenue BAR2026-002832 | TMS#460-03-01-006 | Hampton Park Terrace | Council District 6 Not rated | c.1940 | Historic Materials Demolition District Requesting approval for partial demolition of exterior elements visible from the public right- of-way. Owner: Jason Rosenberg Applicant: Brian Crouch Architect, LLC 1 Comment Submitted to Innovate in Support 3 Comments Submitted to Staff in Support (see attached) First Name Last Name Address Submitted Comment Date/Time Submitted Kevin Eberle 367 President St., Charleston, SC 29403 As the president of the National Register Hampton Park Terrace neighborhood association, I am glad to say that the proposal for 380 Ashley Ave. is the sort of work we encourage. The historic house has seen some unsympathic work over the decades, and it will be great to see the house restored. The house was built as a single-family house, and the side-by-side entries were a much later alteration when Sep 3 2026 1:02PM Board of Architectural Review – Small Public Comment | September 10, 2026 Page 3 it used converted into a duplex. Reversing that change should be applauded. Likewise, the awnings are old but not particularly character-defining. Besides, replacing the fake shutters with operable ones will far outweigh the loss of the metal awnings as the historical climate-regulating devices return. I have spoken with the new owners about the front porch. The house would have certainly had a wooden porch when it was built. Metal porch swaps happened a lot in the area during the mid-20th century. The one on 380 Ashley has some hallmarks of a one-off design (and not an off-the-shelf model), but no attribution has been found to the maker. Returning to the original could be justified, but so could keeping the 60-year old metal. The choice to keep the decorative panels from the railings while returning the columns to wood is an interesting middle ground that preserves some of both eras and, most importantly, makes the owners happy. The applicaiton arose between neighborhood meetings, so we have not officially taken a vote on it. However, no one with whom I have spoken about it has had anything negative to say at all. We appreciate the owners' interest in the house's history, and we look forward to seeing the work proceed. Brian Crouch <brian@briancroucharchitect.com> 380 Ashley Ave. Kevin R. Eberle <keberle@charlestonlaw.edu> Mon, Aug 31, 2026 at 5:00 PM To: "brian@BrianCrouchArchitect.com" <brian@briancroucharchitect.com> Brian – Thanks for the call today about the project at 380 Ashley Ave. When our neighborhood was built, many of the houses were—like 380 Ashley Ave.—a bit on the small side by modern standards. More problematic is that they often lacked more than a single, tiny bathroom for an entire house. There are several examples of historic houses expanded over time with additions to the rear that respect the original and make the house useable for a modern family. I am happy to see in the plans that the addition will be a bit narrower than the old house to give a visual break between the old and new. The layout seems a lot better while still clearly signaling a historic house. As the president of the neighborhood association, I am often asked to weigh in on projects like this one that come up between our every-other-month official meetings. From years of past experience, I can’t imagine that anyone would be opposed to your design even if we had a live meeting of the neighborhood tonight. Kevin Rebecca <rebeccafharris@gmail.com> 380 Ashley Proposal Lauren Rule Maxwell <laurenarule@gmail.com> Fri, Aug 14, 2026 at 11:40 AM To: Rebecca <rebeccafharris@gmail.com> Hi, Rebecca, I (along with my husband, Jason) support your redesign and am happy the house will be renovated. Good luck with the permitting process, and welcome to the neighborhood! All the best, Lauren (383 Ashley Avenue) Sent from my iPhone On Aug 14, 2026, at 11:11 AM, Rebecca <rebeccafharris@gmail.com> wrote: [Quoted text hidden] <Screenshot 2026-08-14 at 11.08.03 AM.png> <Screenshot 2026-08-14 at 11.08.16 AM.png> 8/20/26, 12:43 PM Gmail - 380 Ashley Proposal https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/?ik=9f2f47355d&view=pt&search=all&permmsgid=msg-f:1873513835392281007&simpl=msg-f:1873513835392281007 1/1 Board of Architectural Review – Small Public Comment | September 10, 2026 Page 4 11. 175 ½ Wentworth Street BAR2026-002799 | TMS#4570303063 | Harleston Village | Council District 8 Not rated | c.1858 | Old and Historic District Requesting conceptual approval for new accessory structure. Owner: Cozy Development Applicant: Cozy Development 3 Comments Submitted to Innovate in Opposition First Name Last Name Address Submitted Comment Date/Time Submitted David & Scottie Hoffman 9 Pitt Street, Charleston, SC 29401 We find several problems with this application submitted to the BAR-S. First, this looks like an ADU. If so, there are zoning issues to be addressed. On the real estate listing, it states that there already is a BAR approval for a swimming pool and an accessory dwelling unit. Also, the design is very awkward. With a small footprint, this ADU looks too vertical and narrow. We feel the Board should get clarification as to whether this proposal is for an ADU as advertised. If so, it should be referred to the Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA) for a variance based on lot size. If the Board does review this ADU for height, scale, and mass, the application should be denied. The design is too vertical, making it out of proportion - height versus width. Sep 9 2026 9:17AM Wiley Becker 44 Rutledge Avenue Harleston Village Association Charleston, South Carolina Re: Board of Architectural Review - Small September 10, 2026 Meeting 175 ½ Wentworth Street (Agenda Item 11) Dear Chair and Members of the Board, On behalf of Harleston Village neighbors, we respectfully oppose conceptual approval for the request at 175 ½ Wentworth Street. The application proposes a new accessory structure at the rear of a historic property in the Old and Historic District. Based on the submitted materials, we have concerns regarding the architecture, scale, massing, and proportions of the proposed structure. While we understand an accessory structure may be allowed under the applicable zoning, the proposal as drawn is not clearly subordinate to the principal historic structure and should be denied or deferred unless revised. 1) Scale, massing, and subordination The proposed structure is very narrow relative to its height, which makes the Sep 9 2026 11:34AM Board of Architectural Review – Small Public Comment | September 10, 2026 Page 5 massing feel out of proportion for the site. The elevated finished floor and exposed foundation also make the structure appear taller and less subordinate to the primary residence. The proposed finished floor appears to be approximately 1’ higher than the main house, further contributing to this issue. At a minimum, the siding should be extended down over the CMU foundation to make the structure appear lower to the ground. The recessed panel/foundation treatment also appears too large in comparison with the primary residence. 2) FEMA and plan clarification The plans appear to call out the ground floor as conditioned space, which we understand would not be allowed under FEMA requirements. We ask that this be clarified before any approval moves forward. 3) Neighborhood context and precedent We are concerned about continued pressure to maximize development on historic residential lots in Harleston Village. This type of rear-yard infill can create additional density, scale, and massing impacts that are not appropriate for the Old and Historic District. Approval here could set a poor precedent for similar requests elsewhere in the neighborhood. 4) Requested action Respectfully deny conceptual approval as submitted. In the alternative, defer the request and require the applicant to revise the plans to reduce the scale and mass of the proposed accessory structure, make it clearly subordinate to the principal historic structure, better address the exposed foundation, and clarify the ground-floor FEMA issue. Thank you for your consideration. Respectfully submitted, Harleston Village Association James Ewing 75 Ashley Ave I am a neighbor to 175 1/2 Wentworth, and the proposed structure would be very visible from my backyard. I write in opposition based on height, scale, and massing. The proponent, who has claimed that this ADU is already "BAR-Approved" in their sales literature, is simply trying to add square footage (49.99% of the lot, of 50% permitted) for the sale. While these criteria are not within the BAR purview, the inverted eyesore that this ADU would be is. With a floor a foot higher than the main building, and a full height ceiling and roofline above that of the main building annex, this proposed building Sep 9 2026 11:57AM Board of Architectural Review – Small Public Comment | September 10, 2026 Page 6 does not appear subordinate to the main house. In addition, the siding on the upper story gives it a very clumsy, upside-down profile. It is also odd that the ground floor is proposed as 'conditioned' space, given that FEMA rules would not permit this. We have seen a number of these dwellings proposed recently (and a disproportionate from this proponent, who again is already marketing this property for sale, and is thus not planning to use the ADU in any way other than for sale value), and I also voice my concern alongside the HVA that approving a large number of these would set a poor precedent for the neighborhood. I request denial as submitted, with the potential to come back with a structure that is more subordinate to the main building and suitable to the property and its neighbors. 14. 2 Ashton Street BAR2026-002822 | TMS#460-11-01-118 | Cannonborough/Elliotborough | Council District 6 | Not rated | c.1940 | Old City District Requesting conceptual approval for infill of front and rear porches as well as rebuilding of stairs. Owner: Spencer Gibson Applicant: Rhythm Architecture 1 Comment Submitted to Staff in Support (see attached) From:John McCollummccollumjohnd@gmail.com Subject:Renovation letter Date:July 5, 2026 at 9:30 PM To:Spencer Gibsonspencerlgibson@gmail.com To Whom It May Concern, I have reviewed the proposed renovations for the home at 2 Ashton Street and support the project. I believe the design is well thought out, fits the character of the neighborhood, and will be a positive improvement to the property. I have no concerns with the proposed changes and support the owner’s application for approval. Sincerely, John McCollum 4 Ashton St, Charleston, SC 29403 (913) 306-1599 mccollumjohnd@gmail.com

Source: City of Charleston website. First collected Oct 14, 2026.