RecordWell Data

BAR-L Agenda (Image Overview)

City of Charleston · Berkeley County · meeting of Sep 9, 2026 · Agendas

Open the original document More from City of Charleston

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

City of Charleston BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW - LARGE September 9, 2026 4:30 PM DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING & PRESERVATION www.charleston -sc.gov/bar A. Minutes Approval of Minutes from the August 12, 2026 Meeting Approval of Minutes from the August 31, 2026 Meeting B. Applications - Agenda Item #1 989 Morrison Drive BAR2026-002845 | TMS #4590101001 East Central | Council District 4 | New Construction Height District 4-12 | Historic Corridor District Requesting Conceptual Approval of a new multi-family building. Agenda Item #1 Agenda Item #1 Applicant’s Presentation Agenda Item #1 STAFF COMMENTS: • The site is complicated in that it must conform to both UP District Zoning and Coastal A Flood Zone Requirements/a.k.a LiMWA (effective January 1, 2023, South Carolina Building Code 1612) which means spaces below Design Flood Elevation (DFE) can only be used for storage, vehicle parking, and building access, which impacts the design of this project. The Applicants have met Zoning and technical requirements for both per City Staff involved in that review. The Applicant has followed the suggestions proposed by the Project 3500 Charrette (March 2026) for activating streets in LiMWA which include elevated stairs, carriage type doors, and planters to provide for a better sidewalk experience. • Applicant has met requirement per UP Zoning for 12-story height (p. 17). Agenda Item #1 STAFF COMMENTS: • On July 8, 2026, the Board made a motion for “Deferral with Board and Staff Comments and restudy with a focus on: the top/crown of the structure; the courtyard facing facades; and a general simplification of architectural direction.” This application meets those conditions as it includes a restudy of the top of the structure, the courtyard facing facades and simplification of the architectural direction. • The structure now has a singular top expression, as requested by both Board and Staff. While the top looks well composed in isolation (p. 14), when seen with the entire composition it appears a little top heavy. Staff believe the proportions of the top are a bit out of scale with the middle and bottom and recommend the detailing receive further study at Preliminary to make a more harmonious scalar relationship with the rest of the building. • The interior courtyard of the building has been simplified in terms of its formal geometric expression as well as the architectural direction. Staff support these changes. Agenda Item #1 STAFF COMMENTS: • The fenestration in the exterior skin has been simplified, and the material palette has been lightened, which has provided a more cohesive architectural direction. Staff support these changes. • In addition, Board and Staff asked for: – Reduction in the number of different types of screening. The Applicant has complied with the use of organic and geometric screening in a systematic approach. Staff support this change. – Revising the drawing set so that renderings and orthographics match. Applicant has complied. – Improved and more legible elevation drawings. Applicant has complied. • Staff are still concerned that the mechanical top is highly visible from the elevated highway and require continued study and architectural mitigation during Preliminary. Agenda Item #1 STAFF CONDITIONS: 1. At Preliminary, continued refinement of the proportions of the top of the building so it is perceived in better alignment with the base and middle of the structure. 2. At Preliminary, continued study of the relative visibility of the mechanicals and their architectural mitigation. 3. Bring physical samples of materials to Preliminary. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Conceptual Approval with Board and Staff Comments and Conditions Agenda Item #2 48 & 52 Line Street BAR2026-002840 | TMS #4590503136, 9 Cannonborough/Elliottborough | Council District 8 | New Construction Height District 8 | Old and Historic District Requesting Revision to Conceptual Approval and Preliminary Approval of two (2) mixed- use buildings. Agenda Item #2 Agenda Item #2 Applicant’s Presentation Agenda Item #2 STAFF COMMENTS: • On July 8, 2026, the Board: – Approved the Site Plan Design with Board and Staff Comments and Final Review By Staff – Deferred Parcel 4 with restudy of scale, mass and general architectural direction to return aspects of previously approved design – Deferred Parcel 5 with specific Board condition that Board is amenable to 9 stories if previous quality of proposal returns. • For the revised Parcel 4 submission, the Applicant has reduced the NW mass back to 4-stories which has returned the verticality and symmetry of the North façade. Staff support the revised height, scale and mass. In addition, the architectural direction has been revised to include elements and details previously approved back into the design. Staff support the architectural direction. • Staff support material palette and details as shown for Parcel 4. Agenda Item #2 STAFF COMMENTS: • For the revised Parcel 5 submission, the Applicant has: – Adjusted the massing to include previous configurations which addresses the blockiness and less refined scale and mass commented on by Board and Staff in July. – Reintroduced more glazing onto the ground floor of the east façade as requested. – Changed the massing on the NE corner of the east elevation to a cast stone base with stucco above as request to comply with BAR Principles related to “material and craftsmanship on the base should be of the highest, most durable quality.” – Revised the parking garage back to the previous design composition and changed the ground floor back to brick per BAR Principles. – Revised the NW of the west elevation to a cast stone base per BAR Principles. – Added an additional 9th floor to improve the scale and mass of the building per Board and Staff recommendation. • Based on these changes, Staff support the HSM, architectural direction, material palette, and details of Parcel 5 as submitted. Agenda Item #2 STAFF CONDITIONS: 1. If physical materials samples are not shown as requested for Preliminary review, then Applicant would need to return to the Board with samples. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Parcel 4: Revised Conceptual Approval with Board and Staff Comments; Preliminary Approval with Board and Staff Comments and Final Review By Board. Parcel 5: Revised Conceptual Approval with Board and Staff Comments; Preliminary Approval with Board and Staff Comments and Final Review By Board. Agenda Item #3 16 Sabin Street BAR2026-002852 | TMS #4601504055 Medical Complex | Council District 6 | New Construction Height District 55/30S, 85/30, 85/200 | Old City District, Medical District Overlay Requesting Conceptual Approval for a new MUSC cancer hospital. Agenda Item #3 Agenda Item #3 Applicant’s Presentation Agenda Item #3 STAFF COMMENTS: • This project falls within the Peninsula Medical University District Overlay Zone. Per Ordinance Sec. 54-229.10, the proposal is compliant with the Zoning heights and setbacks as outlined in the District Overlay Zone (p. 7). Staff support height, scale and mass as proposed. • Staff support the site plan approach which steps the structure back from Ashley Avenue to allow the 19th century historic houses along Calhoun, and the mid-20th century historic Nunnery on Ashley Avenue to have more visibility and space between those structures and the proposal and provide green space for the public. Agenda Item #3 STAFF COMMENTS: • Staff also support having a public amenity space on Calhoun Street to activate the street and understand the need for the front door to be on the North side of the building to facilitate enough arrival space for patients as well as pedestrian bridge connections to parking garages. This arrangement necessitates the accommodation of loading on Ashley Avenue. Staff have encouraged using architectural and landscape screening, so this loading area is not highly visible and not mistaken as the entrance. • Staff support the general architectural direction. The curtain wall is in keeping with other MUSC buildings as precedent. Staff also support the use of brick and metal work at the base to provide a human scale to pedestrians. The presentation of physical samples for the curtain wall will be paramount as Staff support a color and material palette that disappears into the sky given the imposing height of the structure. While the architectural sail on the tower mass is appropriate given other contextual buildings, Staff would like to see a stronger articulation to the top of the Calhoun mass which appears unfinished. Agenda Item #3 STAFF COMMENTS: • No lighting as shown in renders is approved in the Conceptual review. At Preliminary, provide specific lighting details and renders so that Board and Staff may best understand the accurate intentions of the lighting proposal. STAFF CONDITIONS: 1. At Preliminary, bring physical material samples. 2. At Preliminary, continue to study the top detailing of the Calhoun mass of the structure. 3. At Preliminary provide accurate details of lighting proposal. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Conceptual Approval with Board and Staff Comments and Conditions Agenda Item #4 649 Meeting Street BAR2026-002846 | TMS #4631602060 East Central | Council District 4 | Category 1 | c. 1897 Height District 4 | Historic Corridor District, Landmark Overlay Requesting Preliminary Approval of an addition to a Category 1 building Agenda Item #4 Agenda Item #4 Applicant’s Presentation Agenda Item #4 STAFF COMMENTS: • On June 10, 2026, the Board gave “Conceptual Approval with Board and Staff Comments and Conditions and a requirement for ongoing drawings to be clear and in agreement as to how the addition intersects the historic structure.” • Staff and Board Comments and Conditions included: – Requirement for details demonstrating how the new addition will connect to the historic fabric – Understanding how water from the two roofs is being handled between the two structures. • Sheet 31 demonstrates how the Applicant is addressing water collection between the historic and new roof. Sheet 31 also addresses the seam between the historic and the addition with a copper gutter providing the joint between the two. Staff support these details and will want to see the construction details at Final. Agenda Item #4 STAFF COMMENTS: • The Applicant has also had the site surveyed to provide drawings that more accurately depict sloping site conditions, how the building sits on the site, and how that impacts the height of the design. • The Applicant has provided a detailed site plan (p. 14). Staff support the hardscape, decorative iron gates, and other features as shown. • Staff support the materials as annotated in the drawings. • The detailing of the clerestory windows has changed slightly with windows only on the north side. The height of the flat roof has been slightly lowered from Conceptual. Staff support these changes (pp. 24-25). • Staff support classical details as shown and the wall section demonstrating the masonry construction to be employed. Agenda Item #4 STAFF CONDITIONS: 1. If physical samples are not provided at this meeting, then a return to the Board is required. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Preliminary Approval with Final Review By Staff. Agenda Item #5 295 Calhoun Street BAR2026-002844 | TMS #4570202001 Harleston Village | Council District 8 | New Construction Height District 7 | Old City District Requesting Final Approval of an approximately 300-unit apartment building with retail space at the ground level. Agenda Item #5 Agenda Item #5 Applicant’s Presentation Agenda Item #5 STAFF COMMENTS: • The Applicant received Preliminary Approval by the Board on April 8, 2026. • During Preliminary Review, Board and Staff asked for the following as part of comments and conditions: – Draw joints on the elevations. – Provide details of the joints between the brick, the FRP and the precast. – Provide wall sections to make transitions between materials clear. – Study a lighter color for mechanical screening. – Study a different color for the brick. – Study the south inner courtyard elevations so that the repetition have more vertical expression. Agenda Item #5 STAFF COMMENTS: • The Applicant has addressed these issues in the current submittal in the following ways: – Joints appear on many drawings, with A3 (p. 10) providing the key for the details (p. 11) related to the relationship between the brick, FRP, and precast. Staff note that in addition to FRP, GFRC is now also being used throughout in tandem with FRP related to code issues and the percent of FRP allowed due to the combustible nature of the material. Staff have concerns about this substitution and reserve the right to make an informed opinion based on seeing the physical samples side by side in person. Staff appreciate the use of simulated joints to provide detailing moments in addition to the necessary joints. – Wall sections and axonometrics have been provided to articulate the transitions between the various materials. Staff appreciate the clarity of those additional drawings and support transitions as shown. Agenda Item #5 STAFF COMMENTS: – There are now two sets of mechanical screening (G-110, A-201, A-251, A-254) that allow for the longer one to be lower and the higher one to be minimized in volume to screen only the DOAS equipment. Staff are comfortable with the mechanical screening as proposed. – Brick color has been revised. Staff have no comment until seeing physical samples in person. – The vertical orientation of the joints has helped the interior courtyard elevations to have a more vertical expression. • The Applicant has also provided a mockup proposal (p. 15). Staff is comfortable with the mockup panel as shown, but welcome Board discussion if key detail moments are absent. Agenda Item #5 STAFF CONDITIONS: 1. Any modifications to approved drawings required for code or fire department compliance, or contemplated during construction, must be approved by the BAR prior to undertaking the changes. Any modifications/substitutions to the materials or elements approved at the Final BAR Hearing must be specifically noted, reviewed and approved on the Mockup sample panel. 2. Deviations from previously approved submissions, if determined by the BAR Staff during or after completion of construction to be a downgrade of the quality of the project and inconsistent with previous approvals, are not approved, whether noted or not by Staff during our review of “For Permit” drawings. 3. A project will be subject to a Stop Work Order or a hold being placed on it, if any construction covered by the mockup panel has taken place prior to the review and approval of the mockup panel unless agreed upon otherwise. 4. Submit a full and comprehensive signage package separately for review by the Board. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Final Approval with Final Review by Staff in the Permit. Agenda Item #6 81 Gadsden Street BAR2026-002843 | TMS #4570204001 Harleston Village | Council District 8 | New Construction Height District 5 | Old City District Requesting Approval of a Mockup Panel. Agenda Item #6 Agenda Item #6 Applicant’s Presentation Agenda Item #6 STAFF COMMENTS: • Regarding the caulking samples, Staff prefers white be used when it is a white-on-white material joint and the redwood tan colored caulking be used when white elements meet the brick. • Three colors of weep screening are shown. The black weeps are too dark and interfere with the reading of the brick. If they are set back from brick face, staff is neutral on the tan versus the white weeps and defers to the Board. CONDITIONS: 1. The steel beam flange above the window should extend all the way out on the building but currently doesn’t on the mockup. Flashing should also be included at the bottom of the window on the building per details, but is not on the mockup. 2. Add a slight slope to the top of the box framing the window in the brick (as the bottom already has) to shed water since flashing is not proposed or required for this element. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Mockup Approval with Board and Staff Comments and Conditions Agenda Item #7 56 State Street BAR2026-002849 | TMS #4580503108 Downtown | Council District 8 | New Construction Height District 4 | Old and Historic District Requesting Approval of a Mockup Panel. Agenda Item #7 Agenda Item #7 Applicant’s Presentation Agenda Item #7 STAFF COMMENTS: • During the site visit, the weep holes did not contain screens. The Applicant has subsequently provided photos, but Staff reserve the right to confirm the color selection in person if the Board does not condition the choice in their motion. • The underside of the concrete balcony floor does not show the drip edge and was not built all the way flush to the fascia. This must be corrected in the building. • The bottom courses of brick did not strike the mortars. The mortar condition shown in the middle and top sections of the mockup are correct. • The masonry steel lintel (D4) below the brick courses of the parapet should be recessed to match the raked mortar and painted same color as mortar so as it disappear visually. • While appropriate in color, in various places the sealant shown in the brick has poor craftsmanship. Agenda Item #7 STAFF COMMENTS: • It is noted that the public continues to interface/climb atop the mockup which has caused craft challenges (e.g. the slant shown in the paneling below the window). The applicant should photograph correct conditions to have on hand during construction. • Staff look forward to seeing the tree image in the brick fully built; it is a nice detail to the project. Agenda Item #7 STAFF CONDITIONS: 1. Acorn heads are required on the exposed fasteners for the underside of the aluminum canopy (which will be highly visible to pedestrians). 2. Sealant in brick should be recessed back to the raked joint and not at the face of the brick; care should be taken in its craft. 3. The relationship between the concrete balcony floors and the metal fascia must be constructed as drawn and not as shown in the mockup STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Mockup Approval with Board and Staff Comments and Conditions Agenda Item #8 141 Meeting Street BAR2026-002842 | TMS #4570804220 Downtown | Council District 8 | Category 1 | c. 1876-1878 Height District 4 | Old and Historic District Requesting Approval for new fenestration and two in-kind replacement lanterns. Agenda Item #8 Agenda Item #8 Applicant’s Presentation Agenda Item #8 STAFF COMMENTS: • On October 8, 2025, the Board approved revisions to two existing windows on the north façade to match the fenestration of the original façade. • The Applicant requests the addition of two (2) windows above the previously approved windows. Based on the interior photograph provided by the Applicant, the dimensions of the proposed windows appear to correspond with previous openings in the façade. The proposed windows will also match the previously approved windows in material and design. Staff are comfortable with the proposed fenestration changes. • Although the locations and general outlines of the proposed gas lantern are shown, details have not been provided. Therefore, Staff cannot recommend approval of the proposed gas lanterns until additional information regarding the details and specifications are provided. Agenda Item #8 STAFF CONDITIONS: 1. The two new windows must be installed in-kind to match the windows directly below them. 2. If the Applicant returns for review of the gas lanterns, details shall be provided. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Approval of the fenestration changes with Board and Staff Conditions; Deferral of the gas lanterns for additional information. Agenda Item #9 150 & 152 Market Street BAR2026-002789,90 | TMS #4570801064, 84 Harleston Village | Council District 8 | Not Rated | c. 1939, 1947 Height Districts 3, 4 | Old and Historic District Request Approval of after-the-fact signage. Agenda Item #9 Agenda Item #9 Applicant’s Presentation Agenda Item #9 STAFF COMMENTS: • The following Zoning Ordinances and BAR Policies apply to this application: Zoning Ordinance: – Art. 1, Part 3, Sec. 54-120. Definitions. Off-Premise Sign: “A sign identifying, advertising, or directing the public to a business or commercial activity located on property other than where the sign is located.” – Art. 4, Part 1, Sec. 54-403(b). Calculation of sign area: “Sign area shall be calculated as the entire area within a rectangle enclosing the extreme limits of the sign face, including any frame or border. The area of a sign composed of individual letters, numerals or other devices shall equal the area of the smallest rectangle or square encompassing said letters or devices.” – Article 4, Part 2, Section 54- 404(c). Prohibited Signs: “Off-Premise Signage” BAR Policy Statement on Signage: – 10(a)(i). Facade: “One (1) per business/tenant.” – 10(c)(ii). Window/Door Signs: “…shall not exceed twenty percent (20%) of any glass area of a single window/door.” – 11(a)(viii). Unpermitted Signage Types: “Off-Premise” Agenda Item #9 STAFF COMMENTS: • All signage presented is after-the-fact, meaning there is no prior BAR or permit approval. • 150 Market Street: – Any signage that references any Beemok-operated business is not allowed per policy, as these businesses are located at other addresses. The window sign area was not calculated per policy. – The door sign with the Beemok logo and directional information was also not measured and calculated per policy. – Dimensions for the applicable windows and doors were not provided, which does not allow Staff to verify if their associated signage meets the 20% maximum coverage requirement. – The right-angle sign meets all regulatory requirements and is approvable. Agenda Item #9 STAFF COMMENTS: • 152 Market Street: – Any signage that references any Beemok-operated business is not allowed per policy, as these businesses are located at other addresses. Additionally, one façade sign is allowed per business. The Applicant has put up seven. However, the façade sign that states “Beemok Hospitality” meets all regulatory requirements and is approvable. – The door sign with the Beemok logo and directional information was also not measured and calculated per policy. – Dimensions for the applicable windows and doors were not provided, which does not allow Staff to verify if their associated signage meets the 20% maximum coverage requirement. Agenda Item #9 STAFF COMMENTS: • Staff does not oppose the overall design aesthetic of the sign package. • When applying for an after-the-fact sign permit, ensure that the application is complete and that any renderings are labeled to match the correlating sign numbers listed on the sign application. STAFF CONDITIONS: 1. Remove the Beemok-operated businesses located at other addresses as this is not allowed per policy. 2. Revised sign package should follow all submittal and policy instructions. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Denial of the sign package as submitted.

Source: City of Charleston website. First collected Oct 14, 2026.