RecordWell Data

Amended Mediation Settlement Agreement - 148 Smith Street (City Council Agenda Item - 9.8.26)

City of Charleston · Berkeley County · meeting of Sep 8, 2026 · Agendas

Open the original document More from City of Charleston

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

1 STATE OF SOUTH CAROLINA ) IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS COUNTY OF CHARLESTON ) FOR THE NINTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT ) Ashley Hall Foundation, ) CASE NO. 2025-CP-10-05487 ) Appellant, ) ) v. ) ) City of Charleston and ) City of Charleston Board of Architectural ) Review-Small, ) ) Respondents. ) ____________________________________) Ashley Hall Foundation (“ Appellant ” ) and Respondents City of Charleston and City of Charleston Board of Architectural Review – Small (the “ BAR-S ” ) mediated the above-referenced appeal on January 29, 2026, in accordance with S.C. Code § 6-29-915 requiring pre-litigation mediation if requested by the property owner. During the course of the mediation, and following the recommendations of the Community Development Committee of Council, the parties reached a settlement conditioned on approval by City Council and the Court of Common Pleas. Below is the background of this appeal, the mediation, and a statement of the settlement terms. 1. The controversy concerns the BAR-S ’s decision on August 28, 2025, denying Appellant ’s request to demolish a structure located at 148 Smith Street, Charleston, South Carolina (TMS No. 460-16-01-053) (the “ Property ” ). 2. The Property was once the location of Dash Hall, an historic dance hall during the Jim Crow era. 3. The 1902 Sanborn map depicts Dash Hall as a two-story building with a double porch. In 1950, Dash Hall was demolished, and a one-story concrete apartment building was constructed in its stead, as shown in the 1951 Sanborn map. The currently existing one- MEDIATION SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT (148 Smith Street) 2 1 The structure essentially abuts two property lines, using land that district setback regulations require to be open unoccupied space, as measured by the requisite 3- and 9-foot setbacks, making it a nonconforming use, as defined by Sec. 54-120: “ Nonconforming Use. A use of building or land that does not conform with the regulations of the district in which it is situated. ” The record reflects that the structure has not been used for more than three (3) years. While a nonconforming use at the time the zoning ordinance was adopted may be continued, after more than three (3) years of a lack of use, a nonconforming use cannot be re-established pursuant to Sec. 54-110, as further supported by S.C. Code Ann. § 6-29-730, South Carolina jurisprudence, and local government treatises . 2 See fn. 1, supra. story wood-frame structure first appears on the 1955 Sanborn map. Russell A. Rosen, P.E., presented to the Community Development Committee that he observed the currently existing structure to be a late nineteenth - to early twentieth -century, single-story building that was relocated to the Property from elsewhere. The interior of the structure shows the addition of a nonoriginal mezzanine. In addition, structural analysis reveals that the majority of piers and foundation are compromised, as are the joists and roof. 4. The structure was heavily deteriorated at the time it was acquired by Appellant and given its configuration, 1 no uses of the structure were viable. Appellant ’s purchase of the Property was to provide additional campus parking. 5. The parties appreciate the deep importance of the history of Dash Hall. Furthermore, Appellant, as an educational institution, finds it important to acknowledge the cultural and historic significance and a story that needs to be told. 6. In its deliberations at the meeting on August 28, 2025, the BAR-S emphasized the cultural significance of Dash Hall, applied that to the currently existing structure, and indicated that it could be restored for reuse. 2 The Board voted unanimously to deny the demolition request. 7. Appellant filed the instant appeal and requested pre-litigation mediation pursuant to S.C. Code Ann. §§ 6-29-900 & -915 on September 26, 2025. 3 3 Appellant may make application for a demolition permit, and the permit shall be promptly issued upon a complete application, subject to the caveat th at demolition may not commence until as provided in subparagraph 8.a.vi . 8. As a result of the pre-litigation mediation discussions that included the City architect and staff as well as input from the Community Development Committee , the parties have reached the following settlement: a. Based on the above facts and subject to the following conditions, the BAR-S and City grant Appellant approval to demolish the structure at the Property. i. Prior to Appellant commencing the demolition of the structure, 3 Appellant shall make the structure available to any interested governmental or nonprofit organization (an “ Interested Party ” ) that wishes to relocate the structure from the Property to another site. ii. The BAR-S and City approve the removal and relocation of the structure from the Property by an Interested Party, whether or not the receiving site is within the boundaries of the City of Charleston. iii. Appellant shall make the structure available to an Interested Party for a professional examination in good faith efforts to meet the requirements of subsection 8(a)(iv) below. iv. To qualify, an Interested Party must deliver to Appellant, with a copy to the City architect, no later than October 31, 2026: (A) a written relocation plan identifying the receiving site, the licensed contractor who will perform the relocation, and the proposed removal date; (B) evidence of funding sufficient to complete the relocation; (C) adequate insurance ; and (D) a written acknowledgment that the Interested Party accepts the structure in 4 its present condition, “ as is, where is, ” with all faults, assumes all risk of damage to or collapse of the structure during removal and transport, and releases and agrees to indemnify and hold harmless Appellant and the City from any claim, loss, or damage arising from the relocation. If more than one Interested Party timely qualifies, Appellant shall select among them in its sole discretion. v. The selected Interested Party shall remove the structure from the Property, at its sole cost and risk, no later than November 30, 2026. vi. Pending removal, Appellant has no obligation to maintain, secure, stabilize, repair, or insure the structure and is not liable for any deterioration, damage, or collapse of the structure occurring prior to removal. vii. If no Interested Party timely qualifies under subparagraph (iii), or if the structure or any portion of it remains on the Property after November 30, 2026, Appellant may demolish the structure and remove any remaining foundation, debris, and materials without further notice, hearing, or approval by the BAR-S or City, other than a demolition permit . b. Appellant is desirous of commemorating the history of Dash Hall, and will do so in such form as it and the City architect deem appropriate, with the following features: i. Incorporation of the history of Dash Hall in its 11 th -grade American Studies class; ii. Presentations to Ashley Hall students by the City architect, which shall serve as a collaborative effort with students to participate in the creation of 5 an historical plaque, marker, or monument, the plan for which shall be presented to the City of Charleston ’s History Commission for approval; iii. Any other measures that Appellant and the City architect elect to pursue in this regard. c. Appellant shall place the plaque, marker, or monument at a publicly accessible location on or along Smith Street no later than December 31, 2028. 9. This settlement is to end lengthy litigation over the appeal with an uncertain outcome. 10. In agreeing to this settlement, no party is admitting the validity of the position or arguments of the other party. The settlement is to resolve contested claims and terminate the parties ’ expenditure of time, money, and resources on this disputed legal proceeding. 11. Following execution of this Agreement and approval thereof by City Council, Appellant shall cause to be filed with the Charleston County Clerk of Court ’s office a consent order approving mediation settlement pursuant to S.C. Code Ann. §§ 6-29-900 & -915 in such form as agreed to by counsel for the parties and a dismissal of the appeal with prejudice. Time is of the essence for each and every provision of this Agreement. (SIGNATURE PAGES FOLLOW) 6 ___________________________________________ Ashley Hall Foundation APPELLANT ___________________________________________ Brian A. Hellman ( SC Bar 72399) Jason S. Smith (SC Bar 80700) HELLMAN & YATES, PA 105 Broad Street, Third Floor Charleston, South Carolina 29401 Telephone: (843) 266-9099 bh@hellmanyates.com js@hellmanyates.com ATTORNEYS FOR APPELLANT 7 ___________________________________________ William S. Cogswell, Jr. Mayor for the City of Charleston and BAR-S ___________________________________________ Magalie A. Creech, Assistant Corp. Counsel 50 Broad Street Charleston, SC 29401 creechm@charleston-sc.gov Telephone: (843) 724-3730 ATTORNEY FOR RESPONDENTS September ___, 2026 Charleston, South Carolina

Source: City of Charleston website. First collected Oct 14, 2026.