RecordWell Data

DRB Public Comment

City of Charleston · Berkeley County · meeting of Sep 8, 2026 · Agendas

Open the original document More from City of Charleston

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

CITY OF CHARLESTON DESIGN REVIEW BOARD PUBLIC COMMENT SEPTEMBER 8, 2026 A meeting of the Design Review Board (DRB) will be held on Tuesday, September 8 at 4:30 p.m. in the Public Meeting Room, First Floor, 2 George Street . The following written comments will be provided to the board members on the deadline date and also be acknowledged into the record and summarized. The public is encouraged to attend the meeting in person to speak in order for comments to be fully heard. Application information is available at www.charleston-sc.gov/drb. Please check the website on the meeting date to view any withdrawn or deferred agenda items. For additional information, please contact: Department of Planning & Preservation | 843-724-3781 1. 350 Grand Oaks Blvd West Ashley | Council District 10 | TMS # 301 -00-00-052 | DRB2026 -000382 Requesting conceptual approval for a new multi-family development that has 348 apartments and 33 townhomes plus amenities. Owner: Middleburg Communities LLC Applicant: Mark Ward 23 Comments Submitted on Innovate in Opposition 1 Comment Submitted to Staff in Opposition (see attached) First Name Last Name Address Submitted Comment Date/Time Submitted Suzanne Stinson 232 Brambling Lane These comments are about the area next door to the Landing at Grande Oaks, the neighboring community. 1) There needs to be a landscape buffer of at least 50’ but ideally 75’ between the left side of the development (which coincides with the future planned city road). 2) In addition, there should be a pond located in the current area of the planned parking on that left side to ensure that the extreme development does not end up flooding the Landing at Grande Oaks, its adjacent neighbor. The parking area should be moved to the other side of the buildings in order to accommodate the pond, it is simply Aug 28 2026 6:15PM Design Review Board Public Comment | August 3, 2026 Page 2 too much concrete in that location that will cause water run off and flooding. Both of these fixes should help negate the danger of flooding of the neighboring existing community once this monstrosity is built. Careen Jensen 904 Lansfaire Dr., Charleston, SC 29414 This project is still too huge for the proposed property location. These buildings are 4 story in height and do not fit in with the existing development already in place. This kind of development is already happening on Glen McConnell parkway and should not be in this residential neighborhood. It needs to be scaled way back. Aug 29 2026 9:13AM Betty Reed 1569 Ashley Garden Boulevard, Charleston SC 29414 I am pleased to see the primary entrance moved to West Ashley Circle, however I have concerns about the driveway on Grand Oaks Boulevard...a small 2-lane neighborhood street that simply cannot accommodate another 381 to potentially 762 cars (if each unit has two cars); Also, the drawings are not clear on retaining the existing sidewalks along Grand Oaks. I strongly urge City Planners to rethink the future roadway connecting Grand Oaks to Long Savanna Parkway that will create yet another route for more cars to access the already overcrowded Grand Oaks Boulevard. Aug 29 2026 12:47PM Daniel Gracie 260 Gazania Way, Charleston, SC 29414 August 30, 2026 Daniel P. Gracie, DNP, RN-BC Resident, Grand Oaks West Ashley, Charleston, SC City of Charleston Design Review Board Department of Planning, Preservation and Sustainability 2 George Street Charleston, SC 29401 Re: DRB2026- 000361, 350 Grand Oaks Boulevard: Request for Conceptual Approval of 348 Apartments and 33 Townhomes, Public Hearing on September 8, 2026, 4:30 p.m. Dear Members of the Board: I write as a resident of Grand Oaks to oppose conceptual approval of the Middleburg Communities project proposed for 350 Grand Oaks Boulevard. My neighborhood sits directly against this site, and my neighbors and I will live with the consequences of whatever the Board Aug 30 2026 1:47PM Design Review Board Public Comment | August 3, 2026 Page 3 approves here far longer than anyone reviews the drawings. I ask you to deny conceptual approval, or at minimum to continue the hearing until the developer addresses the traffic, density, and design concerns laid out below. This project has already failed this Board once This is not a new proposal. The Board heard this same project, at essentially this same scale, on July 6, 2026, and declined to approve it. Board members found the building heights and architectural style incompatible with the surrounding Grand Oaks area and asked for more “architectural rigor” before the project could move forward (Post and Courier, July 2026). Twenty- six residents submitted public comment opposing it at that hearing. The developer has trimmed the unit count slightly, from 380 apartments and 36 townhomes down to 348 apartments and 33 townhomes, but the footprint, the height, and the fundamental mismatch with this neighborhood remain. A smaller number attached to the same design does not answer the concerns this Board already raised. Traffic on Bees Ferry Road is already at its breaking point Opponents of this project have estimated it would add roughly 400 additional vehicle trips to a stretch of Bees Ferry Road that residents already describe as “brutal” during peak hours (Post and Courier, real estate coverage of the Harris Teeter parcel). That estimate does not stand alone. Within a two-mile radius of this site, the following projects are approved, under construction, or under active review right now: Aventon Bees Ferry: 394 apartments breaking ground at Bees Ferry Road and Savannah Highway. Long Savanna: up to 4,500 planned homes moving through construction along the same corridor. A 100-unit townhome rezoning request near Storybook Farms and the Red Top community, now before Charleston County Council. Bees Ferry Apartment Homes, Harper Place at Bees Ferry, Design Review Board Public Comment | August 3, 2026 Page 4 Bellerose at Bees Ferry, and Proximity Charleston: existing rental communities already drawing daily traffic from the same intersections this project would use. Charleston County Councilman Larry Kobrovsky has publicly said he could not support adding to what he called the “nightmare” traffic on this corridor, and the county’s own planning commission voted to recommend disapproval of one of these nearby projects before Council overrode it on a narrow 5-4 vote. No signalization upgrade, turn-lane expansion, or corridor study has kept pace with this level of approved density. Approving another 381 units here, on top of everything already in the pipeline, asks Bees Ferry Road to absorb traffic it has no capacity for. Bees Ferry Road does not need another apartment complex West Ashley has absorbed an extraordinary share of Charleston’s rental housing growth over the past several years, and Bees Ferry Road has taken the brunt of it. Between the developments listed above and others already leasing along this stretch, the corridor is not under-supplied with apartments. It is saturated. As Dr. Melody Dover, president of the Red Top Improvement Association, put it in opposing a nearby rezoning request, “We don’t need any higher density. It’s changing the whole culture of our community.” That same logic applies here. Adding 348 more apartment units does not fill a gap in the market. It compounds a problem residents up and down this corridor have already told the county and the city they cannot absorb. The design still does not fit the neighborhood it borders Grand Oaks is defined by preserved forest canopy and a modest, low-rise residential scale. This project proposes buildings up to 55 feet tall along that boundary, a scale with no precedent in the adjoining neighborhood. The city’s own Plan West Ashley design guidelines, adopted in 2017, exist precisely to steer projects Design Review Board Public Comment | August 3, 2026 Page 5 like this one toward a form that respects the corridor and neighborhood context around it rather than imposing a standardized, out-of-scale product on whatever site becomes available. This Board already found, in July, that the project failed to meet that standard. Nothing in the resubmission changes the height, the massing, or the relationship of these buildings to the single-family homes next door. A modest reduction in unit count is not the architectural rigor the Board asked for. Stormwater and flooding history in this basin deserve scrutiny This site sits within the Church Creek/Bees Ferry drainage basin, an area with a well- documented flooding history that has drawn community opposition to development here before, including prior objections to Army Corps of Engineers wetland permitting nearby. Twenty-eight acres of new impervious surface and structure, including roughly eight acres of wetlands on this parcel alone, raise legitimate questions about downstream stormwater capacity that this conceptual approval does not appear to answer. Request I respectfully ask the Board to deny conceptual approval of DRB2026-000361 as submitted. If the Board is unwilling to deny it outright, I ask at minimum for a continuance that requires the developer to produce a current traffic impact analysis accounting for the cumulative effect of the other Bees Ferry corridor projects listed above, and to revise the building height and massing so the project genuinely respects the scale of the Grand Oaks neighborhood it borders, not merely a trimmed unit count on the same design this Board already rejected in July. Thank you for your time and for the Board’s careful attention to this corridor. Sincerely, Daniel P. Gracie, DNP, RN-BC Resident, Grand Oaks Sources cited Post and Courier, “West Ashley development fails to get approval,” coverage of the July 6, 2026 Design Review Board hearing on Design Review Board Public Comment | August 3, 2026 Page 6 350 Grand Oaks Boulevard. Post and Courier, “Another 400 apartments, townhomes proposed behind West Ashley grocery store,” real estate coverage of the Middleburg Communities/Harris Teeter parcel proposal. Post and Courier, “Charleston County gives first approval for controversial request for Bees Ferry townhome development.” Live 5 News, “Charleston community push against potential rezoning for Bees Ferry development,” January 2026, including comments from Dr. Melody Dover, Red Top Improvement Association. ABC News 4, groundbreaking coverage of Aventon Bees Ferry, 394 units at Bees Ferry Road and Savannah Highway. Charleston Housing News, “Charleston’s apartment boom isn’t slowing down,” July 2026, on cumulative West Ashley/Bees Ferry multifamily approvals. Michael Laskavy 509 Hainsworth Dr., Charleston, SC 29414 Grand Oaks Blvd. CANNOT support a multi-family development with 348 apartments and 33 townhomes (“plus amenities”). There is already too much traffic, and the non-stop destruction of the remaining trees and habitat has left local wildlife to increasingly wander into the GO and adjoining neighborhoods in search of food, water and shelter. This has caused death to the animals due to the increasing roadkill as they try to cross busy streets, but also damage to property as they dig holes, eat foliage, and otherwise try to survive. In addition to the increased traffic in and out of GO (forcing residents to leave earlier for work), there will be an increase in noise, the potential for land is paved over, an increase in crime from teens whose parents don’t watch them (will there be increased police patrols??), and the general reduction in the quality of life for those who already live there. The developers will take their money and go elsewhere. They don’t have to live with the consequences. Enough is enough. Grand Oaks is built out. Sep 1 2026 3:46PM Design Review Board Public Comment | August 3, 2026 Page 7 Karen Schwarztrauber 344 Grouse Park, Charleston, SC 29414 The street is packed already with drivers. Basically, the only way in and out of a big development. Adding over 300 more homes, is going to add at least 600 more cars (2 for each home) Even widening the street will cause chaos for those of us living here. It’s hard to pull out. Grand Oaks Blvd already gets backed up at the light to Bees Ferry. AND if you take parking away at the shopping centers, there will be less parking for over crowed parking lots already. I hope there will be an exit on to Ashley Circle. Why not? The Circle is undeveloped. More access to future business. Please put in retention ponds to help with drainage once more land is covered with buildings and concrete Sep 1 2026 7:14AM David Scott 511 Carters Grove Road I am strongly against the 350 Grand Oaks Boulevard Development. I do not believe they are making a good faith effort to incorporate the comments/feedback being recommended by this board, or from the nearby communities. In my comments, I will reference the results from last meeting, specifically staff comments 4, 6, and 12: Staff Comment 12: In the prior meeting they were asked to “study the removal of any parking spaces that would open up any more green space. If keeping these parking #s, DRB requires some of your paved areas to be pervious. (at a min. equal to the sq. footage of parking spaces applicant is over what Zoning requires) Another suggestion is to change all the straight in parking along the west property line to parallel parking to increase the width of the buffer along the west property line.” The overall required number of spaces for this development is 572 spaces (1.5 per unit). Their revised proposal has allegedly reduced the number of spaces by six, from 627 spaces to 621 spaces. (Slide 8 for September, Slide 348 for July). These six reduced spaces are listed as “garage” but overall garage footprint and count remains the same. Sep 4 2026 10:04AM Design Review Board Public Comment | August 3, 2026 Page 8 Additionally, nowhere does it show that the excess parking was changed to be pervious, as previously requested. The six garages around the site provide excessive parking. I request the removal of all six garages, totaling 9,714 square feet. This will enhance the aesthetic of the area while also allowing better rainwater management and providing additional nature protection while having zero impact on overall number of housing units developer is able to establish. If developer is unwilling due to greed/other motive, advise removing parking spaces equal in number to that provided by garages. Request board defers application due to poor/inaccurate parking redesign. XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX Staff Comment 4: Slide 9 shows developer added a path through the landscape buffer, likely to tie in with board requested pathways around ponds (Staff comment 4). With the driveway side of these townhomes facing an apartment complex parking lot, I do not believe the future residents would want people meandering through space this close to their homes. This space is their only available outdoor space, where they may be grilling or having their children play. Recommend removing the trail from the townhome area, especially because there is a sidewalk parallelling this added path. The landscape buffer could then be further enhanced to maintain/improve the visual and aesthetic character of this area. Previous July meeting it was noted how small the backyards of the townhomes would be (previous slide 208). Suggest shortening driveways to allow extra yard/setback space. Current driveway parking count is 2 parking spaces per driveway/unit, the additional length provides substantial detriment to overall site design while not improving any features of the site. XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX Additional clarification requested: Request clarification if 25 foot buffer on Design Review Board Public Comment | August 3, 2026 Page 9 Grand Oaks is from the street or from the sidewalk. If from the street, it is a very misleading number since there is a large drainage ditch between the street and sidewalk, cutting that buffer distance approximately in half. XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX Staff comment 6: I don’t see this addressed anywhere in their plans. Tying in to comment 12 would be changing west property line change to parallel parking, which is also not noted on their new designs. XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX For these reasons I strongly encourage the DRB to defer application until an honest, good faith effort is made by the developer to correct their site design to truly support, protect, and improve the visual and aesthetic character of this area. None of these changes will impact the total number of units they are able to profit from, these changes are solely to the excessive parking/external features of the site. Ronnie Freeman 800 Bent Hickory Road, Charleston, SC 29414 This can only bring in more gridlock and safety issues for Grand Oaks, Bees Ferry and Glenn McConnell. Our area’s infrastructure is already over taxed and this will only cause severe frustrations for the current residents in our area. To build this massive complex will only create nightmares for all involved. There is no solutions to the congestion this will bring to our area. I have been a resident of Mt. Royall for 22 years and I hate the Grand Oaks is becoming. Not to mention the wildlife that is being driven out of our area due to the over crowding. Sep 4 2026 10:39AM Nancy Huber 337 Weeping Willow Way When is enough is enough? How can you even remotely think this development is a good idea? Adding this number of apartments and condos to our already crowded area is 9idiculous. It already takes forever to not only get out of Grand Oaks Blvd but getting to Glen Mc is terrible. Also cutting down all our beautiful trees and adding 4 story buildings is nuts. Our entrance is what makes our area gorgeous. Adding this complex will not Sep 4 2026 10:51AM Design Review Board Public Comment | August 3, 2026 Page 10 only add thousand cars but what about the flooding. Please please please do not approve this development. Thank you Stacy A Autumn Chase neighborhood I am opposed to this application as it is currently proposed. The scale and design of this development are not compatible with the surrounding Grand Oaks community. The proposed four story buildings are significantly out of character with the surrounding neighborhood, which consists predominantly of single-family homes that are no more than two stories. A development of this size and height would create a substantial visual and physical impact on the existing community. I am also deeply concerned about the removal of protected oak trees. These mature trees provide important environmental benefits, including helping with stormwater absorption and drainage. Removing them in an already heavily developed and densely populated area raises serious concerns about additional flooding and stormwater impacts on surrounding residents. The existing traffic situation is already extremely difficult, particularly during peak travel times. Adding 300+ additional residential units will only increase congestion and further impact the quality of life for current Grand Oaks residents. While I appreciate that the primary entrance has been moved to W Ashley Circle, I strongly oppose providing an additional entrance or exit onto Grand Oaks Boulevard. If an access point there is deemed necessary for emergency purposes, it should be restricted to true emergencies and physically gated or otherwise secured to prevent routine use. I recognize that this development is moving forward, and I appreciate the opportunity for the community to provide input on its design. However, I urge the Design Review Board to continue requiring meaningful revisions that better respect the scale, character, environmental Sep 4 2026 10:53AM Design Review Board Public Comment | August 3, 2026 Page 11 conditions, traffic constraints, and livability of the existing Grand Oaks community. Lindsey Gill 302 Steele Magnolia Ave Wildlife in this area cannot be further displaced, particularly the birds. The proposed four-story buildings will not enhance the neighborhood, instead they will be an eyesore. The design needs to be reworked, including lessoning the number of proposed units (at the very least). Where is the plan to beef up the infrastructure to support this rapid growth? Schools are overcrowded and traffic only gets worse. Can we still call it Grand Oaks if all the trees are cut down? Sep 4 2026 10:54PM Kaylee Crouch 205 Larissa Drive, Charleston SC 29414 This neighborhood is not going to be able to handle another 348 apartment units in multiple four story buildings and 33 townhomes. This area is already beyond busy. This community enjoys the wild life and trees that you will be taking away by adding more homes for an area that already has had 3 new apartment complexes come up just within the past 2 years. This is not needed & disrupts quality of life for the people that actually live here Sep 4 2026 11:02AM CYNTHIA SMART 301 Steele Magnolia I realize this project will go forward in some form but please take into account how this will affect traffic both inside Grand Oaks and Bees Ferry and Glenn McConnell. Also this will have a very negative effect on wildlife. Tree removal is one of the biggest contributors for global warming. Please reduce the size of the development to minimize these impacts. Sep 4 2026 11:08AM Summer Scott 511 Carters Grove Road This development has a negative impact on the visual and aesthetic character of this area. Grand Oaks is an area known for single family homes with lots of trees, wetlands, ponds, wildlife, and green space. This development is too large. Multiple four story apartment buildings don’t fit in with this area, which again are single family homes and town homes. The view-shed and horizon line of trees is being demolished by these four story apartments. The oversized parking lots and the amount Sep 4 2026 11:27AM Design Review Board Public Comment | August 3, 2026 Page 12 of pavement being used for parking is atrocious. It does not align with the aesthetic of this area. The “trail” that they are creating along the west side is unnecessary considering there is already a sidewalk that is used daily by the community. This cuts into the 25 foot buffer and/or the potential and limited backyard space for the townhomes lining this side. This further damages the land and the community feel by having a path running parallel to the sidewalk. Reducing the buildings from four story to three would be more in line with the overall character with this neighborhood and community. I request they reduce the parking lots, look at removing the garages, and work to keep additional green space and tree canopy available, which is what this area is known for. Jason Johnson 616 Halstead Street NO regular entrance to Grand Oaks Blvd. ONLY an emergency, gated exit. Grand Oaks blvd is already backed up in the mornings more than enough as it is. The traffic at the light backs up to Monster Storage on a regular basis right now. Evening rush hour traffic is just as bad coming in the neighborhood and would be a hazard for left turning, cross lane traffic in that part of GO blvd. The revised plans appear to prioritize a main entrance out to the circle and a rear entrance to the future parkway. We don’t need or want MORE traffic on GO blvd, and especially left turning traffic on Grand Oaks. This is the burden of being the last to build with 20+ year old approval. Sep 4 2026 11:30AM Karen Schwarztrauber 344 Grouse Park, Charleston, SC 29414 This neighborhood needs to be made with adequate parking. All concrete should be in the original plan to try and determine run off. I just moved to The Landing, which will be attached to the new development. There are very few places for guests to pa rk in the Landing. The driveways in the Landing are not adequate for 2 cars unless you park over the sidewalk. Street parking is only allowed on one street. Of course, there is a garage, but many do not use Sep 4 2026 3:00PM Design Review Board Public Comment | August 3, 2026 Page 13 garages for their cars. Some of the residents in The Landing, have poured concrete to make room for a second car, however, doesn't this cause more runoff of rain? Shouldn't that be in the original development? Charles Privett 420 Sycamore Shade St Traffic in that area severely congested and dangerous due to the city not increasing infrastructure with the growth of West Ashley circle. In addition this is putting incredible pressure on area schools which are also not increasing to keep pace with the population surge. Sep 4 2026 5:21PM Meg Adelmann 582 Carters Grove Road Charleston SC As a resident of Autumn Chase/Magnolia Lakes, I have continued concern on the development being proposed at 350 Grand Oaks. Grand Oaks Boulevard cannot handle the additional traffic, along with the shopping center. The roads continue to flood during large thunderstorms and with the green space being knocked down it will only exacerbate the problem. All entry and exits to the development need to be on West Ashley Circle ONLY. Flooding mitigation also needs to be addressed. Sep 4 2026 6:49PM Carol Robert Sherman 212 Brambling Lane Charleston We are so disappointed that there is a plan to take down all of the beautiful trees and to disrupt the wildlife that lives there at the beginning of Grand Oaks Blvd .. Bees Ferry Road and the communities surrounding it are becoming one big parking lot! We are requesting a buffer of trees be left between The Landing Community and this development and that there is no traffic pattern through our community .. We are also requesting a buffer of trees on Grand Oaks Blvd remain so we can enjoy the beauty which drove us to our community …I wish the builder would reconsider moving forward with this project and consider more the people, families and animals that live in the surrounding space.. Traffic, an abundance of accidents , noise, flooding … This is what we have to look forward too!! Extremely disappointed with all of it !! Sep 5 2026 9:06AM Design Review Board Public Comment | August 3, 2026 Page 14 Eric Wilhelm 1706 N Elgin Ct This is another project which is pro- developer and anti-resident and anti- environment. This is an an area that should be left as forest/wetland and not another part of Charleston's urban sprawl. Scientific data shows storms and weather events are becoming more frequent and stronger due to climate change. If past events in the area are any indication, the area around Grand Oaks and Bees Ferry is and will be prone to devastating flooding (refer to Church Creek flooding parts of Shadowmoss). Charleston is, by natural design, prone to flooding due to its geography, and studies show leaving natural wetlands and forests to absorb extra rainfall are highly beneficial. Bees Ferry and Highway 17 have exploded in new houses, townhomes and apartments. All of this development has not included needed infrastructure improvements. Bees Ferry is already due for widening thanks to the explosion of development in the area. With the city against a I526 extension, surrounding roads need to be improved to handle the surplus of traffic on a daily basis. The Long Savanna project seems to finally be put into motion. It would be best, in my opinion, to scrap development in existing areas, and focus on the Long Savanna development whilst keeping the environment in mind. Just because an area can be developed for housing, doesn't necessarily mean it needs to. Sep 7 2026 12:45PM Pamela Ingram 1036 Tyron Circle, Charleston, SC The project STILL has not been scaled back enough. This is a residential neighborhood and 4-story buildings do NOT belong here-maximum height should be 2-stories given the of the existing structures. Has a traffic study been done yet? The entrance onto Grand Oaks Blvd still needs to be removed. This 2-lane residential road cannot safely handle more traffic. Trees-too many existing trees and supporting plant life are still being removed. I don’t see protections for the trees that are being saved. Trees are essential for flooding mitigation in this Sep 8 2026 10:10AM Design Review Board Public Comment | August 3, 2026 Page 15 low-lying area, and trees/plants support our ecosystem and environment. Pamela Wike 793 Bent Hickory Road I am opposed to the development of 348 apartments and 33 townhomes. The submitted plans although revised still need additional revisions to accommodate the adjacent residents that live in Grand Oaks. The height of the townhomes still sits at 55' 11 3/5" and that is still to high. The tree preserve areas, why remove any trees in these areas? Isn't a tree preserve area meant to preserve the natural beauty already there. I do support a pervious trail through the tree preserve areas. Finally, remove the entrance/exit onto Grand Oaks Blvd. Adding an additional 700 vehicles onto this roadway daily will just contribute to an already congested single lane roadway. Infrastructure is not in place for this development. Do the roadways first, especially since Long Savanna is happening now too. Sep 8 2026 11:53AM Nicole Lovecchio 793 Bent Hickory Road The 25' buffer along Grand Oaks Blvd. is not enough. Grand Oaks residents walk, run and bike along this peaceful natural stretch and still want to have that. Also, remove the entrance/exit onto Grand Oaks Blvd. Our little single lane residential roadway can not handle any more vehicles. Put the exit/entrance at the other two locations. Sep 8 2026 11:58AM Position Statement Design Review Board September 8, 2026 2919 Maybank Highway Dear Board Members: The Preservation Society of Charleston (PSC) recognizes the considerable thought and effort that has gone into the proposed site plan through the PUD review process with the goal of creating a community-centered gathering place. While the landscape plan is thoughtfully designed, the proposed architectural approach requires significant refinement to better reflect the distinctive rural character of Johns Island and support the welcoming, human-scaled environment envisioned for the site. As proposed, the building reads more as a contemporary office building than a hospitality destination. Although the material accents add visual interest, the overall design remains generic, austere, and overly institutional in character, particularly when compared the 2024 PUD application materials. PSC respectfully urges the Board to defer the proposal for further study and refinement. Particular attention should be given to strengthening the building’s relationship to its context and enhancing the pedestrian experience, breaking down the boxy massing, and introducing greater warmth and architectural detail. For example, more traditionally proportioned openings with divided-lite windows would help establish a more residential expression that is better aligned with the character of Johns Island and the quality of architecture this site demands. As always, PSC welcomes the opportunity to meet with the applicant in advance of a future submittal. Thank you for considering our position in this matter. Sincerely, Anna-Catherine Alexander Director of Advocacy Initiatives acalexander@preservationsociety.org Design Review Board Public Comment | August 3, 2026 Page 16 2. 2919 Maybank Hwy. John’s Island | Council District 3 | TMS #313 -00-00-198 | DRB2026- 000384 Requesting conceptual approval for a new 4-story hotel with 75 rooms, plus a site plan that includes a future restaurant location. Owner: Jubilee Hotel LLC Applicant: Kelly Hosack/Greenberg Farrow 9 Comments Submitted in Opposition First Name Last Name Address Submitted Comment Date/Time Submitted Elizabeth Settle 2 Greenhill Street, Charleston SC 29401 The design of the proposed project are too modern and not in keeping g with the Johns Island vernacular. Sep 1 2026 1:49PM Pamela Lapp 1905 Edwins Crossing, Johns Island, SC 29455 Please do not approve this design for the hotel! This looks like the same plan that was rejected except for a color change. The design does not fit Johns Island and looks like a budget hotel by the highway. It also makes me concerned for the other buildings being planned as part of that project since the boutique hotel, which I assume is the star of the project, is so nondescript. Sep 1 2026 5:01PM Janice Grandcolas 3314 Hartwell St, Johns Island, SC 29455 I find the hotel plans to be plain and not attractive. I do like the color and placement of the glazed tiles on the hotel, and the pavers, but I don't feel the outcroppings on the hotel front are attractive. They are too modern, and I don't see the purpose. The only thing that rings South Carolina are the proposed plantings. Sep 1 2026 5:15PM Hollis Gallagher 3561 Hunters Oak Lane I do not believe the revised design is any more appropriate for Johns Island. If anything, it now feels even more generic while still looking like a building that belongs in South Beach—or virtually any other rapidly developed commercial area in the country. Johns Island has a distinct character and sense of place, and this design does nothing to reflect it. Changing the colors and façade of a four-story hotel does not suddenly make it compatible with the island. It is still a large, modern, urban-style building that feels completely disconnected from its surroundings. If the developer deferred the original design specifically to address community concerns that it did not belong on Johns Island, I would hope the redesign would meaningfully respond to that feedback—not simply replace one contemporary aesthetic with another. A Sep 1 2026 7:27AM Design Review Board Public Comment | August 3, 2026 Page 17 project of this scale should make a genuine effort to complement the Lowcountry landscape and architectural character of Johns Island through its scale, materials, rooflines, landscaping, and overall design. Johns Island should not slowly become indistinguishable from every other overdeveloped community simply because development is inevitable. Please ask the developer to go back to the drawing board and create something that actually looks and feels like it belongs here. Rebecca Ruttiger 3231 Cape Rd Johns Island The original version of the hotel definitely didn’t suit Johns Island, but the new version isn’t much different either. It lacks any real architectural depth and is essentially just a box. For the first hotel on Maybank, this would set a low bar for future designs. Other high- end developments have already incorporated a certain aesthetic to reflect the coastal nature. This one should also continue that look, incorporating natural features of the islands like live oaks, a coastal vibe, and/or a rural, country, or farm vibe. Sep 1 2026 7:55AM Jennifer Mills 2904 Bohicket Road, Johns Island. Based on the revised design package, I’m not sure how changing the accent color from teal to brown makes this now a Johns Island design. Have they looked at the design of the buildings at Freshfields, the new buildings at the corner of River/Betsy Kerrison, or even the newer building near River/Maybank that has the Jersey Mikes? Or Minero? Their “revised” design looks like very little was changed. Please reconsider how this is supposed to fit in, because in my opinion, this does not. It could be anywhere. Thank you for your time. Sep 1 2026 12:05PM Susan McLaughlin 3061 Baywood Drive, Johns Island, SC 20455 While the new color scheme is more attractive than the old one, I am still opposed to having a hotel on Maybank because of the traffic this project will generate. In the mornings, traffic backs up all along Maybank making the commute to Charleston miserable yet we just keep building more and more businesses along Maybank Highway and River Road. Our two lane roads were not built for this level of traffic. In my opinion, there should be a moratorium on new projects on Johns Island until someone can figure out a way to address infrastructure issues. Sep 1 2026 12:53PM susan chiafullo 1210 Segar St Johns The design application for the Jubilee hotel looks like a space age, big box. The Charleston area is known for its distinct Southern Sep 2 2026 3:45PM Design Review Board Public Comment | August 3, 2026 Page 18 Island, SC 29455* architecture loaded with details and charm. This current design application contains none of that. I'm not saying that the hotel has to be columns and wide porches but surely a nod to the attributes of the "Southern Style" should at least be considered. The current application is totally out of place in the landscape and it will surely be very noticable due to its size. Grace Frederick 1512 Coles Drive John’s Islans SC My comments are regarding the hotel design currently being proposed by New Leaf. While I believe a thoughtfully designed hotel could be a welcome addition to Johns Island, the design currently presented has the potential to become another unfortunate architectural stain on our beautiful and historic island. Given New Leaf’s connection to Johns Island and the Charleston community as a whole, I believe they carry a great responsibility as they help introduce this new commercial and lodging concept to the island. This project will inevitably set a precedent for future commercial development and hospitality design on Johns Island, and that precedent should be one that respects and celebrates the island’s distinctive history, rural character, and Lowcountry architectural identity. The current proposal falls far short of that responsibility. What is being presented feels like a generic motel design that could exist along virtually any highway in the country. It lacks the character, sense of place, architectural detail, and overall cohesiveness that should be expected for such a visible development along one of Johns Island’s major roadways. A project of this importance should contribute positively to the island rather than further strip the qualities that make Johns Island special. I strongly encourage the City and the applicant to require a substantial redesign that is more reflective of the surrounding environment and celebrates the island’s history and character. The hotel name is Jubilee after all! Johns Island deserves better, particularly after the tremendous amount of development and change longtime residents have already been asked to sustain. Sep 8 2026 11:06AM 1 Comment Submitted in Support First Name Last Name Address Submitted Comment Date/Time Submitted Design Review Board Public Comment | August 3, 2026 Page 19 Joel Hamburgh 4680 Bears Bluff Rd Wadmalaw This is exactly what Johns Island needs. There is not nearly enough shops or restaurants on the island to support the population. With the growth this is a necessity and having a green space is thoughtfully done right. Very similar to other towns in this state that is adding shops, restaurants and helping growth by adding a small town feel, which Charleston has lost. Sep 8 2026 11:21AM

Source: City of Charleston website. First collected Oct 14, 2026.