RecordWell Data

BZA-SD Public Comment

City of Charleston · Berkeley County · meeting of Sep 2, 2026 · Agendas

Open the original document More from City of Charleston

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

CITY OF CHARLESTON BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS – SITE DESIGN PUBLIC COMMENT SEPTEMBER 2, 2026 A meeting of the BZA-SD will be held on Wednesday, September 2, 2026 at 5:00 p.m. in the Public Meeting Room, First Floor, 2 George Street. The following written comments will be provided to the board members 24 hours in advance of the meeting and also be acknowledged into the record and summarized. The public is encouraged to attend the meeting in person to speak in order for comments to be fully heard. Application information is available at www.charleston-sc.gov/bza-sd. Please check the website on the meeting date to view any withdrawn or deferred agenda items. For additional information, please contact: Department of Planning & Preservation | 843-724-3781 A. Review of Minutes and Deferred Applications from Previously Advertised BZA-SD Agendas 5. River Road Johns Island | Council District 3 | TMS# 312-00-00-087, 124 & 139 | Zoned: GB Request a variance from Sec 54-327 to allow the removal of 20 grand trees. Request a variance from 54-327 to allow the reduction in the impervious construction setback near the bases of 26 grand trees. Request a special exception from Sec 54-327 to allow the removal of 9 grand trees. Owner: River Road Associates & Swygert Company Applicant: Kimley-Horn 186 Comments in Opposition 183 Submitted on Innovate 3 Submitted to Staff (see attached documents) First Name Last Name Address Submitted Comment Date/Time Submitted Jim McBride 2222 Des Arc Rd., Johns Island, SC 29455 The request is for a variance from Sec 54-327 to allow the removal of 20+ grand trees, and a request for a variance from 54-327 to allow the reduction in the impervious construction setback near the bases of 26 grand trees. As I am sure the members of this BZA-SD board knows, the River Rd. / Maybank Hwy intersection located less than 100 yards from this proposed development has a Level of Service Aug 27 2026 6:18PM Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | September 2, 2026 rating of worse than "F", and has had that rating since at least 2019. Even after the upcoming widening of Maybank Hwy between River Rd. and the Paul Gelagotis Bridge is complete (est. 2028), the intersection rating is expected to remain "F" due to the exploding population on Johns Island over the past 20 years. Furthermore, River Road -- between Maybank and Main Rd. -- is an extremely dangerous stretch of road: Most of River Rd. has no shoulders bounded by large stormwater ditches and trees, all of River Rd. consists of narrow two-lane (one lane each direction) road, leaving no room for driver error. Fire safety: Even after Fire Station 23 is complete later this year, Johns Island is deficient by two fire stations based on population and geography, and it will take the City many years to build two more stations. This development is zoned GB and, although GB does allow significant flexibility, the intent of GB in this area is for business development, not for hundreds of homes. Therefore, allowing any allowance even in tree removals to allow for more homes in that area is not in the public's interests. All of the factors I listed above are not the developer's fault, and the motivation behind my recommendation is not in any way retributional towards the developer's legitimate interests. I know that the State of South Carolina does not yet have "Concurrency" laws that would require infrastructure to be in place to support development, and that the condition and capacity of River Rd. and Maybank Hwy -- being State-owned and maintained -- is not in the City's purview of control or influence. But one thing in our influence with regard to this development (and others on River Rd.) is for this Board to be cognizant of the real-world circumstances of the traffic congestion, safety concerns, and the significant budgetary constraints of SCDOT that prevents them from Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | September 2, 2026 improving State roads where our City developments are built. Therefore, where there might be a "grey area" of decision factors for this board to consider of this request, the real- world strain on all of the infrastructure in this area of Johns Island I believe should compel the Board to decide in favor of the constituents who are increasingly impacted negatively due to overwhelmed infrastructure. Gary Worth 2493 Summerland Dr Why do we keep having meeting after meeting and all y’all do is just approve it let them cut all the trees down then maybe you wouldn’t have to have a meeting. I oppose cutting 20 grand trees down until we get away on and off the island safely. Aug 27 2026 11:22PM Sara Weddington 3212 Hartwell Street Why would we allow for grand tree removal for developer gain but not to widen Maybank for ease of traffic flow. Aug 28 2026 2:00PM Zac Viscidi 59 Cypress St The request to remove 30 protected grand trees is another assault on the city's canopy. Time and time again, developers are requesting to alter the land to suit their purpose instead of actively surveying the site and building around the natural environment. As has been the case in many other examples where grand trees are being threatened, there are multiple concerned constituents asking for this process to be altered or halted. However, this board continues to overrule these concerns. The citizens who speak up are not asking that all development stop, but we are asking for developers to be more responsive to these views and create plans that mitigate environmental damage. Please use your power to ensure sensible development in the city. Aug 28 2026 11:02PM Chad Dillon 3137Timberline Dr. Johns Island, SC 29455 Please don’t do construction on the land N. of dollar general across from food lion on Johns island. The traffic is already tough in that area. We have a Harris Teeter 4 miles away already on Maybank Hwy. Aug 28 2026 12:37PM Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | September 2, 2026 Courtney Boyer 1609 Sparkleberry Ln, Johns Island For the love of all that is good (that is left) of this city and of the world, vote NO. If some of the trees are graded F… fine… but my guess is that most of these are NOT. If they are anything above an F, the citizens of Johns island urge, no, beg, you to vote NO. This is an intersection that has been graded F for service. I understand if a land is zoned a certain way, blah blah property rights, blah blah. But we don’t need to approve tree removal. Hold the developer’s feet the fire. We ALL Know this development is a bad idea so can we stop with the *shrug, but what can we do* attitude?! What we (you) can do right now is vote NO on tree removal and encroachment. Force the developer to come up with a different plan. We didn’t force them to buy land with so many trees on it. I’m sure they were told, ‘oh it’ll be no big deal! Just ask for tree removal approval!’ WHY should we give that to them? For buying land and wanting to develop on a graded F intersection? We need help on johns island yall. We need the infrastructure to catch up. Everyone knows it, it’s the ongoing joke of the city. Start pushing back now, where you can. PLEASE. Aug 29 2026 5:19PM Ann Skerkavich 220 WATER LOTUS DR CHARLESTON SC Stop destroying precious trees in the name of progress Aug 29 2026 9:38AM Brittany Gardner 3029 Grand Bay Lane Respectfully, there is no need for these townhomes at said location. This is a dangerous intersection and this development will only add to the accidents and traffic that is already out of control. Additionally, the removal of trees and wildlife is taking away from the beauty of the island and putting us all in danger as we continue to build on top of wetlands. Aug 30 2026 2:39PM Emery McDaniel 646 McCutchen Circle Please DENY the grand tree removal for the building of more townhomes. This area includes wetlands. Trees are important to the environment, controlling, stormwater, and flooding and wildlife. Aug 30 2026 3:19PM Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | September 2, 2026 Stefanie Snead 3111 Timberline Drive, Johns Island, SC 29455 Dear members of the BZA-SD, Please DENY the request coming before you to remove 26 grand trees and to reduce the setbacks for 25 grand trees on Johns Island. This property off of River Road has 12.5 acres of wetlands. This request for the removal and to impact to dozens of grand trees does not meet the criteria for removal which the BZA-SD must look to, specifically: 1. There are NOT extraordinary and exceptional conditions pertaining to the particular piece of property--there are thousands of acres of forested, undeveloped property on Johns Island that include wetlands; and 2) The conditions on this property DO generally apply to other properties in the vicinity--other parcels nearby include mature grand trees; the conditions present on this property DO NOT unreasonably restrict the use of the property--density in units can be adjusted to save more grand trees. Lastly, approval of the variance and special exception requests WILL be of substantial detriment to adjacent properties and to the public good, and also to the character of the district--a coastal sea island--- which will be absolutely harmed by the granting of any variance or special exception to remove over two dozen grand trees and reduce the setbacks to 25 grand trees. I am requesting that your Board DENY these grand tree removal requests and impacts. Sincerely, Stefanie Snead, a resident of Johns Island. Aug 30 2026 6:53PM Debbie McCravy McCravy 6999 Pumpkinseed Dr, Johns Island, SC 29455 Please please do not grant this variance for any protected grand trees. �� ���. I am asking you to grant MY variance and leave the trees YOU said were protected from harm. This destroys our wetlands, wildlife habitat and the very air you and I breathe. Your constituents deserve to be heard and we are passionate about saving our trees. The forest actually heals you! Don't do it. Do the right Aug 30 2026 11:59AM Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | September 2, 2026 thing for our environment and the trees!!! Kim Corbett 2003 Covey Lane Charleston SC 29412 Please deny the applicants request to remove 26 grand oaks which includes various varieties of trees. Please consider our environment and how we protect it vs the $ it temporarily brings in. Developers are destroying our communities. Thank you, Kim Corbett Aug 30 2026 12:41PM Nancey Stalker 6607 Bears bluff road Wadmalaw Island South Carolina 29487 Please vote no for tree removal on Johns island for mungo homes. Aug 30 2026 12:58PM Susan Milliken 762 Fort Sumter Dr, Charleston SC 29412 Dear Members of the BZA-SD, Please vote to DEFER this request for the removal of 29 grand trees of many varieties along with the request for reduced setbacks for 25 grand trees-- all on wooded property on Johns Island. This property includes 12.5 acres of wetlands and is in a FEMA Special Protection Flood Zone. We do not see photos or information about ANY of the grand trees to be removed or impacted in the agenda packet. We do not see the number of so-called "F" rated grand trees to be removed without any BZA-SD oversight. Please give City staff more time to review the trees up for removal and to provide more transparency to the public about these trees which are likely 60-80 years old. If you choose not to defer, please DENY the removal and reduced setback/s request as it does not meet the criteria for approval. Any approval of these variance and special exception requests WILL be of substantial detriment to adjacent properties and to the public good, and also to the character of the district (a coastal sea island) which will be absolutely harmed by the granting of any variance or special exception to remove over two dozen grand trees and reduce the setbacks to 25 grand trees. Thank you for your consideration, Susan Milliken, James Island. Aug 31 2026 3:54PM Heather Nofsinger 2186 Parkway Drive Please stop destroying our islands! DENY this tree removal! Keep John’s Island beautiful! Aug 31 2026 4:16PM Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | September 2, 2026 Cheryl Brennan 1674 Folly Road Charleston, SC 29412 Please DENY and stop destroying our habitat and nature for greed. The less trees and vegetation, the more heat and horrible weather. Please stop building in this extremely overpopulated area!!! Aug 31 2026 4:20PM Kevin Nofsinger 2186 Parkway Dr New Townhomes provide housing for few and are not necessary in this part of Johns Island. No need to build in anticipation with our limited infrastructure . The Grand oaks benefits the entire region and are long established not for what may be Aug 31 2026 4:22PM DeAnn Grayson 863 Century Place 29412 I am opposed to removing the 18 grand oaks for this project. Aug 31 2026 4:26PM Tania Palmer 3755 Maybank Highway Johns Island The reason this place is magical is our trees.They are not like pines,that can grow back in a short time.These represent our history and story.It brings tourists and why the make movies here.We are destroying our future,the beauty of our island and the protection from future storms.I choose the island over greed.Please save our trees! Aug 31 2026 4:27PM LaDon Paige 886 Hunt Club Run Please thoughtfully consider denial of the request to remove these grand trees. Continue to preserve Charleston and its natural habitats by upholding the protections in place for these magnificent trees. The trees do not present unusual circumstances or hardships for the developer. Work around them. Development landscaping requirements can never replace these trees Aug 31 2026 4:50PM Caroline Shaw 2910 Silver Lake Drive Johns Island In the last five years I've watched more and more wildlife being displaced due to unbridled development on Johns Island. Stop cutting all the trees and natural beauty from our island. Listen to your constituents and STOP the development!!!! Charleston is beyond capacity and the more yall allow development the less infrastructure we have to handle our current massive issues on Johns Island. Trees aren't just for looking pretty, they also absorb massive amounts of water Aug 31 2026 4:50PM Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | September 2, 2026 which we need them to do. Stop cutting the trees. Stop allowing development. If they want to move here, find an existing place! I'd highly recommend all the powers that be listen to the people who put you in your position! I'm ready for a clean sweep of everyone who is currently sitting allowing this to happen, let them be done with their back door deals and bribery...... because at this point that's the only explanation why anyone would allow more developments! lauren Stubbs 1696 Emmets Road. I am writing to ask that you find a way around the destruction of 25 mature trees on John’s Island. My father has been a developer for 40 years, building neighborhoods all over northern Virginia as well as the goose Creek/monks corner area, and I know firsthand that it is very possible to change site plans, reroute roads, etc., to leave mature trees where they are. I have seen it done many times. I also know, having lived in many different neighborhoods, that a neighborhood that has mature trees looks much more established and appealing, rather than a neighborhood that has had everything razed and saplings put in their place. I know that new neighborhoods will constantly be built, but it can be done in a way that leans towards sustainability and conservation. Aug 31 2026 4:56PM Robert Corbett 2003 Covey Lane Please do not the applicants request to remove 26 grand oak trees. This negativity impacts the environment around it forever and ALL residents pay the cost for flooding, overbuilding, etc. Say no to cutting down the trees. Thank you, Robert Corbett Aug 31 2026 4:57PM Jeff Denison 4962 Amberwood Ln. N Charleston River Road townhouses please do not allow the removal of grand trees, we need our tree canopy and we do not need more houses. Just keep making the flooding worse if we do Aug 31 2026 4:57PM Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | September 2, 2026 Jenna Locke 1148 Wellington Please strongly consider voting against this. We are losing everything that makes this place so special. There are so many birds of prey and unique owls that make their homes in those trees, we are pushing those types of animals away. The trees and green areas are crucial to help mitigate flooding in the islands. Please stop letting developers pave all over and lose what brought us all here to begin with. Thank you Aug 31 2026 5:07PM Rachel Hawes 2126 Edisto Ave Allowing developers to remove 25 grand trees from Johns Island sets a very dangerous precedent that other developers will try to follow. These trees are the reason people want to live on Johns Island. They absorb necessary flood waters and can not be adequately mitigated with another project. Please consider denying the developers request to remove the 25 grand trees. Aug 31 2026 5:35PM Tara Reddy 3980 River Road To the City of Charleston BZA-SD: I am writing concerning a developer’s request to remove 26 grand trees and reduce the setbacks beside another 25 grand trees on a property near River Road. First, this request is premature as we have not seen any site plan for a Mungo townhouses complex come before the TRC or Planning Commission at the City of Charleston. Secondly, Please DENY the request to remove 26 grand trees and reduce the setbacks for 25 grand trees for the following reasons. (A) Any approval of the variance and special exception requests WILL be of substantial detriment to adjacent properties and to the public good, and also to the character of the district (Johns Island, SC) which will be harmed by the granting of any variance or special exception to remove over two dozen grand trees and reduce the setbacks to 25 grand trees. (B) There are NOT extraordinary and exceptional conditions pertaining to this property. Other nearby properties are forested and undeveloped; also conditions on this property do apply to other properties nearby. (C)The presence of Aug 31 2026 5:46PM Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | September 2, 2026 grand trees does not unreasonably restrict the use of the this property. Furthermore (D) The number of units or density of the complex can be adjusted to save grand trees and other protected trees, (E) This property contains 12.5. acres of wetlands and lies in a special protection flood zone per FEMA. Any development whatsoever on this low-lying parcel and any tree removals should be DEFERRED and handled delicately and thoughtfully. We do not even see photos of the grand trees at issue in the BZA-SD packet. The required criteria for your Board to be able to approve the grand trees removal and reduced setbacks is NOT MET IN THIS CASE. Please DENY and ask the developer to work more diligently to save grand and protected trees on this site. Thank you Manda Seel Ravenel SC Slowly our home is being destroyed by developers and things that used to be protected are not anymore…and I can’t for the life of me figure out what happened except greed…it may not matter to those making money off these deals but it matters to those of us who are born and raised and care…stop taking down every dern tree and filling the water outlets. those who we elect that are not doing their best to protect our home, vote them out and make them known… Aug 31 2026 6:14PM Liz Munn 3631 Morse Avenue, Johns Island SC 29455 I request this variance be deferred or denied. There is no listing of the trees, grades, and photos in The packet. This is one of the last forested properties remaining in the area with low areas, wetlands, flooding risks and amazing grand trees. To lose this would cause great harm to the surrounding areas by increasing flood risk, erosion and loss of wildlife. The project has not been through all the other board reviews needed to begin work. The building sizes and heights are not shown. A huge complex would not fit in with the architecture of the area. The developer surely knew of all these trees prior to making an investment. Aug 31 2026 6:31PM Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | September 2, 2026 This is a self imposed grievance which disqualifies as a reason for variance. Grand trees are either protected or not. They would be better served to sell to a conservancy and preserve this fragile ecosystem. Deny the removal of these trees, the encroachment and increase I. Non-pervious surfaces. Daniel Ruedi 1609 Sparkleberry LN This application DOES NOT meet the BZA's criteria for grand tree/s removal! Please, we can at least do this. We all KNOW this development is a bad idea but if we get no choice we can at least deny the things they DO NOT qualify for. Aug 31 2026 6:39PM Randi J Grimball rd Please do not allow them to cut down the grand trees these trees are apart of the island just like a resident. Please save the trees! Aug 31 2026 7:25PM Holly Place 60 Fenwick Hall Allee.John’s Island Please do not allow the removal of the trees- it current doesn’t meet BZA’s criteria! Secondly; we DONT NEED ANY MORE HOUSING- affordable or not. There are two new townhome areas finishing up now. One beginning off Maybank and Fenwick Hall on the new road- Bernice Robinson road- which allows parking on BOTH sides of the road and the fire trucks and emergency vehicles are unable to access. You also have the new and not completed townhouse area Indigo Grove- also odd Bernice Robinson. We do not need housing that cannot me or comply to regulations. Aug 31 2026 7:28PM Donna Chesborough 2024 Coker Ave CHS SC 29412 There's too much development in the Charleston area and you already know that. Do not cut more trees down on Johns Island. Trees make this city beautiful and able to function well, environmentally. Aug 31 2026 7:31PM Dee Smithy legare st NO CUTTING OAKS!!!!! Aug 31 2026 7:31PM Laura Maston 3230 Johnstowne Street Johns Island, SC 29455 I am writing to express my heartfelt opposition to the unnecessary removal of many established and essential trees including Grand Oaks for this project. Johns Island has already succumbed to so much habitat destruction that we must stop and put Aug 31 2026 7:35PM Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | September 2, 2026 an end to these beautiful and cornerstone species being destroyed in the name of greed. Proposed projects must be thought out and consider the natural beauty of the island - purchasing real estate is not a blanket green light to turn our island into a faceless parking lot. Please seriously consider this plea to deny this request. Sincerely, Laura Maston, DVM and the owls, the chickadees, the raccoons, the squirrels, the woodpeckers, the hawks, the moss, the blue jays, the moths, and the citizens of Johns Island Christopher Swenson 3213 Charlie Jones Blvd, Johns Island I am firmly against this proposed removal. Please vote to keep Johns Island, Johns Island. This removal is unncessary and unfair to those of us whom live here already, in the name of a developer and those who dont live here. Thanks for your time. Aug 31 2026 7:36PM Kristie Smith 2018 Lanneau Lane Please do not approve the removal of 26 grand trees for this development. It is extremely confusing why there are even stipulations to keep trees in developing areas if the zoning board continues to approve their removal with what seems to be little resistance. The beauty of Johns Island counts on preserving live oaks and the area in question has already seen enough clear cutting (across the street on Fenwick Hall developers were allowed to decimate the landscape). Please require the builder to modify their plan to encroach upon and remove zero trees. There is no reason they can't spend a little more money to preserve the integrity of the island. Everyone who lives here now begs the zoning board to adhere to the requirements put in place to protect the trees. Aug 31 2026 7:40PM Anne Hagood 433 Greenbriar Lane Leave the grand trees alone! When will we learn, or better yet, when will council learn? The ordinance is in place so people cannot clear cut all of these trees – support the ordinance, support the residence, and leave the trees alone. Aug 31 2026 7:42PM Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | September 2, 2026 Lee Tami 2030 Wildts battery blvd Apt 914 johns island sc 29455 Don't cut down the trees. We are full and can't have more building on the island. Aug 31 2026 7:44PM Lisa Bradley 6448 Pepper Grass Trl. Ravenel, SC 29470 Please do not grant approval to remove the 20 Grand Oaks along River Road. Grand Oaks are irreplaceable treasures that make our Lowcountry great. Developers are destroying our landscape for their profit. They don’t care about our land. We need more people to speak up and protect our natural historic trees, before so many variances have been given out that all of these magnificent trees are gone for good. Laws were passed to protect these trees for a reason, and those who are entrusted to enforce these laws have a fiduciary duty to do so. So I respectfully request you deny this petition to remove the 20 Grand trees along River Road. Thank you. Aug 31 2026 7:46PM Justin Meckes 1010 River Haven Circle Apt R Charleston Sc 29412 Save the trees or you will be voted out. Johns island needs to stop any and all development immediately or we will all suffer Aug 31 2026 7:48PM Clare Brady 3752 Maybank Highway Johns Island needs to be protected from overdevelopment! No one wants to move into a clear cut neighborhood. They would much rather have a beautiful backyard with trees older than all of us. We CANNOT undo the damage from removing historical trees. Planting a sapling doesn't replace what those trees are doing right now. Aug 31 2026 7:52PM Lorre Burt 2568 Hatch Dr. Johns Island Please stop cutting down our beautiful trees. Especially, but not only our gorgeous and ancient Live Oaks, which are hundreds of years old. The developers are ruining one of the most beautiful natural landscapes on the planet, and it MUST STOP before it is all gone, to be replaced by cheap townhomes for someone's profit. The deer, hawks, squirrels, and other wildlife will have nowhere to go. Please stop this now. Aug 31 2026 7:56PM Corinne Mistretta 875 Portabella Ln, Charleston SC 29412 Please stop this project and DO NOT cut the grand Oaks and other trees. This is a terrible tragedy for our James Island/Johns Island home. Aug 31 2026 8:03PM Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | September 2, 2026 Melissa Franklin 307 Woodland Shores Rd Please do not approve the removal of the Grand trees. They are vital, irreplaceable pillars of our town’s infrastructure, environment, and character. Removing so many mature trees at once will have severe and immediate consequences for our community, including: Increased Flooding and Erosion,Loss of Canopy and Heat Increase, Destruction of Wildlife Habitat, Erosion of Community Character. Aug 31 2026 8:04PM Jason Aultman 2923 Sarnoff St. John’s Island, SC Traffic is already bad enough. Developers are ruining this island one high density project at a time. Please delay or put a stop to this until the infrastructure can support it. Aug 31 2026 8:04PM Donna Martin 2725 McFadden Way, Johns Island I have lived on Johns Island for just four years and it is disheartening to see grand trees being removed because of development. These are not easily replaced and these trees are what make this island so beautiful. Isnt there some way for the building plans to be reconfigured to avoid removing grand trees? I object to the tree removal. Aug 31 2026 8:06PM Donna Reinbeck- Grant 2730 Battle Trail Dr Johns Island Dear Members of the BZA-SD, I respectfully urge you to DENY the application for the removal of grand trees associated with the River Road Townhomes (Mungo Homes) project on Johns Island, Agenda Item #5. These grand trees are not simply obstacles on a development plan. They are part of the living character and natural heritage of Johns Island. They have stood on this land for generations, providing shade, beauty, wildlife habitat, stormwater benefits, and a sense of place that cannot be replaced by planting new, smaller trees after construction. Please deny this application for grand-tree removals and require a design that protects these irreplaceable trees. Johns Island is changing rapidly, and with that growth comes an important responsibility: to protect the natural features that make this community special. Aug 31 2026 8:12PM Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | September 2, 2026 Ryan Thompson 132 Botany Bay Blvd. As someone who has lived in Charleston since 2007 and my extended family living here for more than 50 years, I ask that you DENY this application for grand tree/s removals. Charleston has already changed so much and is quickly losing the character and charm that we’re known for. It’s crucial to preserve what separates Charleston from other bigger cities. We aren’t Miami and NYC, which is a good thing. Aug 31 2026 8:13PM Deborah L Brown 185 Sea Cotton Circle I know progress is important. James Island is already way over developed. It loses its charm more and more everyday. Traffic is overwhelming. Why are you destroying this beautiful and historical Island. PLEASE STOP. KEEP THE TREES Aug 31 2026 8:16PM Ash Dent 8433 BinYa Ave Johns Island, SC 29455 These Oak trees are not only stunning, but some are older than The United States itself. They provide protection against storms and cultivate a beautiful and thriving ecosystem. There is so much poured concrete already in this country, let’s preserve what makes Johns Island beautiful and unique. Green is a much better color than gray. Aug 31 2026 8:18PM Edmund Sullivan 598 Windermere Blvd We citizens are so tired of the destruction of the beautiful trees that do so much to make Charleston such a beautiful place. If this town doesn't have natural beauty, what do we have? Pretty old houses downtown and a bunch of anonymous condos everywhere else. Please preserve the trees. Don't turn Charleston into an ugly dystopia. Aug 31 2026 8:23PM Emily Box 5162 Forest Oaks Drive Mature grand oaks are incredibly important to our environment. Their massive root systems help absorb stormwater, reduce runoff and erosion, and help stabilize the soil. Their canopies provide significant shade and help reduce surrounding temperatures, something that becomes increasingly important as more land is cleared and replaced with roofs, roads, driveways, and parking lots that absorb and radiate heat. Aug 31 2026 8:27PM Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | September 2, 2026 They also provide an entire habitat for birds, insects, squirrels, and countless other species. Mature trees capture carbon, filter pollutants from the air, and intercept rainfall before it ever reaches our already stressed drainage systems. Removing established trees while simultaneously adding acres of impervious surfaces is a combination that can contribute to increased runoff and flooding, something the Lowcountry certainly does not need more of. And while developers may plant new trees to “replace” them, a newly planted sapling cannot replace the environmental function of a grand oak that has been growing for 100 years or more. That ecosystem cannot simply be recreated overnight. I understand that growth is inevitable, but responsible growth should mean designing developments around irreplaceable natural resources whenever possible, not removing them simply because it is easier or more profitable. Mary Herriott 1512 maple grove drive Johns island Please please reconsider the removal of these beautiful grand oak trees. If you MUST build this development please find a way to include these beautiful and necessary trees into your design. Too many oaks have been destroyed even though they are safe and protected. This is an unnecessary development and you can surely find a way without this awful act. Please reconsider and do not allow this to happen. We have lost too many already. Aug 31 2026 8:29PM deena Frooman 1667 Lonnie Taylor Lane Dear City of Charleston BZA-SD members: Please DENY the applicant's request to remove 26 grand trees including Live oaks, Laurel oaks, Black Gums, Red Oaks, Magnolias, a Hickory, a Tulip Poplar and Water Oaks. I remember when the little sign after Stono river and on the left just entering John's Island there was a sign, "Welcome to Rural John's Island" We need trees especially the old trees which mark the character and aesthetic of a place. Why KILL Aug 31 2026 8:38PM Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | September 2, 2026 completely? Why not require building around the precious ecosystem? Enough killing of trees and ruining the the character of the district— a coastal Lowcountry sea island. Over development is destroying the natural habitats. As well, over development is not helping the traffic patterns. PLEASE! let's stop building and destroying nature. Instead, let's build up in areas and create better urban planning. Thank you, concerned citizen Sara Frooman 1661 Lonnie Taylor Lane With great concern for the mass killing of nature and with concern for the never ending destruction of of nature and seemingly never ending killing of what the essence of Lowcountry aesthetic is afforded by beautiful and OLD trees, I write an appeal to deny the slaughter of the Mungo homes development which calls for 26 trees to be killed. Builders should be required to build around nature not KILL it! We should rearrange our thinking to appreciate the oxygen provided to humans by trees! We have become a weird society which has a disdain of trees to the point of matter of factly killing and slaughtering what is, essentially, life. Further, the constant clear cutting of Lowcountry land and gutting of trees is derelict in regards to aesthetics. Nature is being replaced by shallow "plastic" man- made fabricated homogenized houses. Back to the 26 trees. Let them live. Require roads and building plans to work harmoniously with nature. Stop with an all out cutting and destruction and re-evaluate how urban sprawl is designed. DENY, please, the slaughter of any more trees. Aug 31 2026 8:48PM Meredith Harman 1084 Oakcrest Drive We cannot continue to remove these grand trees in order for us to have more room to drive. They have been here longer than our country has been here. They deserve the respect and treatment that they have earned by standing all this time surfer as a carbon sink, giving us oxygen, giving us shade and beauty in history. They Aug 31 2026 8:56PM Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | September 2, 2026 must be preserved and kept for the posterity of our children and our grandchildren to see the beautiful legacy that they bring to Charleston. And if you research recent scientific understandings, trees, communicate with each other care for each other, sustain each other, warn each other of threats, and live a vibrant community and family life that we are not able to perceive. They are living sentient beings, who deserve our respect and reverence. They are not simply ops tools in the way of our driving efficiency. People who live and drive in Charleston are completely accustomed to seeing and making way for these grand citizens. Getting rid of them are cutting them down is a cowardly and useless and completely backward way of doing things in this area. The trees were here before we were. We make way for them. Not the other way around. Payton Messner 238 Stefan Dr, Apt C Hello, I strongly oppose any request that would allow the removal of approximately 20 grand oak trees and the destruction or filling of wetlands for the proposed River Road development on Johns Island. Johns Island is one of the last places in our region where residents can still experience the natural beauty and environmental character that make Charleston unique. Grand oak trees are not simply landscape features. They are irreplaceable community assets that provide wildlife habitat, stormwater absorption, shade, carbon storage, and the historic beauty that defines Johns Island. Once these mature trees are cut down, they cannot be replaced within our lifetimes. The wetlands on this property are equally important. Wetlands serve as natural flood protection systems, filtering pollutants, storing stormwater, and reducing the impacts of increasingly frequent heavy rain events. As Charleston continues to face flooding challenges, protecting wetlands Aug 31 2026 9:03PM Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | September 2, 2026 should be a priority, not an obstacle to be waived for development. Approving the destruction of these natural resources would set a troubling precedent and further contribute to the loss of Johns Island's rural character. Residents have repeatedly expressed concern about overdevelopment, traffic congestion, flooding, and environmental degradation. Allowing the removal of grand trees and encroachment into wetlands moves the community in the wrong direction. Growth should not come at the expense of the very resources that make Johns Island special. I urge the City of Charleston to deny any request that would permit the removal of these grand oaks or the disturbance of protected wetlands and instead require a development plan that preserves these vital natural features. Please protect Johns Island's trees, wetlands, wildlife, and quality of life for current and future generations. Respectfully, Payton Messner Danielle Carter 558 River Rd, Johns Island, SC 29455 I am asking the BZA-SD to DENY this application for grand tree/s removals. River Road is a beautiful road that I call home. Please help protect the beautiful grand trees that make up this historic area. Aug 31 2026 9:03PM Mary-Jane Melanson 3227 Joe Wright Rd Johns island Please stop destroying the habitat on this island. The trees give us oxygen, shade, protection from the weather conditions and filter our air. They provide homes for our wildlife. We have to many homes and no infrastructure to support the current residents. Save the trees, save the wildlife, save the island. Please stop the destruction Aug 31 2026 9:03PM Gwen Corinth 1436 Battle Ground Rd, Charleston SC 28412 Please choose to support the environment, not the greed of government officials for tax money and developers who live elsewhere and don’t care about our local quality of life. Grand trees support life: the wildlife that uses them for sustenance and shelter. They absorb carbon and create oxygen to keep air clean and Aug 31 2026 9:04PM Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | September 2, 2026 healthy for all living things. They absorb rain water to mitigate flooding, which is so vital in the Lowcountry. There must be a moratorium to stop building until we can gather the information to decide when enough is enough!! Sharon Johnson 2039 Parish House Circle, Johns Island, SC 29455 Please DENY the application for removal of 26 grand trees. Johns Island is one of the few remaining places in the metro Charleston area with any remaining semblance of rural, southern charm. The grand trees are an important part of what makes Johns Island so special. While I applaud the developers efforts which include some preserved areas that would protect other valued trees, removal of these 26 grands is just not reasonable. We need to stand together to save the beauty, charm, and history of Johns Island. Please deny the tree removal request of Mungo Homes - protect these 26 lowcountry treasures before it is too late! Aug 31 2026 9:05PM Karen Nuttall Pelican Perch , Johns Island I need to speak up about the 26 grand trees being cut down on River Road for yet another development our infrastructure simply cannot support. These trees aren’t just scenery, they’re part of what makes Johns Island Johns Island. They protect our drainage, our wildlife, our shade, and the character of this community. Before removing irreplaceable grand trees, the City should be able to show that the roads, drainage, and emergency access can actually handle the added strain. Right now, they can’t. River Road is already overburdened, and we all know how unsafe and congested it becomes with even small increases in traffic. Once these trees are gone, they’re gone forever. Development should be responsible, not destructive. I’m asking our neighbors and leaders to pause this removal and reassess whether this project is truly in the best interest of the island. Johns Island deserves thoughtful planning, not Aug 31 2026 9:07PM Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | September 2, 2026 shortcuts that cost us the natural assets we can never get back. Pamela Ferguson 2032 Paw Paw Place, Charleston, SC Whomever bought the property knew the trees were there before purchase. Variances should not be given because the owner wants to make more money at the expense of the community. The owner of a property has the responsibility to not cause harm to the surrounding environment and neighbors. If he were to start pouring poisons around the property and allowing run off there would be legal intervention. While the removal of trees does not have such immediate and obvious effects, it too causes damage to the surrounding environment and neighbors. Removal of trees has been associated with higher temperatures, increased flooding, increased water pollution, increased air pollution, increased carbon dioxide, increased noise levels, decreased mental health, increased blood pressure, increased stress, decreased social cohesion, increased crime and aggression, increased energy use, loss of biodiversity, decreased soil quality, and lower property values. Charleston has strict rules about not destroying historic properties, but trees are often treated as expendable. A building can be rebuilt if necessary, but mature trees cannot be replaced for decades. Bit by bit tree variances are deteriorating Charleston communities. Aug 31 2026 9:15PM Lisa VanSyckle 3624 woodscape ct The amount of trees being taken and the home being built is out of control. Animals are loving their homes! Aug 31 2026 9:17PM Julia Nobles 1158 Turkey Trot Drive Johns Island To the Board of Zoning Appeal-Site Design: I am writing to ask you to please vote NO to the request to remove 26 grand trees located on wooded property on Johns Island - River Road. This case does not meet the BZA’s criteria required for approval of the request. Most importantly, the character of the district, Johns Island, will be harmed by the granting of any variance or Aug 31 2026 9:19PM Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | September 2, 2026 special exception to remove over two dozen grand trees and reduce the setbacks to another 25 grand trees. Additionally, these grand trees are located in a flood zone on property that is low-lying and includes 12.5 acres of wetlands. These grand trees are critical to the management of stormwater on this property. Any approval of these grand tree removal requests will be of substantial detriment to adjacent properties and to the public good. Please deny the developer’s request to remove these grand trees and request that they redesign their site plan to save more grand trees. Thank you. Susan Lyons Old Oak Walk, Johns Island I respectfully request that the Zoning Board of Appeals deny this application to remove 20 + 9 grand trees—a total of 29 grand trees—and to reduce the required setbacks in a manner that would impact an additional 26 grand trees. Approval of this request would cause significant and irreversible harm to Johns Island. Removing this number of mature, protected trees would reduce the island’s natural ability to absorb stormwater, worsen flooding, diminish storm resilience, and permanently alter the historic and natural character that makes Johns Island unique. Johns Island has already experienced extensive development and the unnecessary destruction of mature and protected trees. Current residents are living with the consequences of that growth, including increased flooding, loss of natural habitat, reduced storm resilience, and the gradual erosion of the rural and historic character that drew many of us to this community in the first place. At what point will the quality of life of current residents be valued as much as a developer’s desire to maximize the development potential and profitability of a property? At what point will we draw a line and establish a reasonable balance between growth and the preservation of the Johns Island Aug 31 2026 9:20PM Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | September 2, 2026 community? Development does not have to come at the expense of everything that makes Johns Island special. If developers choose to build here, they should respect the community in which they are building and recognize that the natural beauty, mature trees, open spaces, and historic character of Johns Island are not obstacles to development—they are part of the community’s identity and value. Many of us choose to live on Johns Island because of its natural and historic beauty. Once these grand trees are removed, they cannot simply be replaced. The loss is permanent, and the cumulative impact of decisions like this will shape the island for generations. I urge the Board to consider not only the immediate development proposal before you, but also the long-term consequences for the residents, environment, storm resilience, and historic character of Johns Island. Please deny this application and protect the grand trees and character of our community. Kathryn Matrangola 106 Rutledge Avenue, A These do not meet the criteria for removal. Please stop these ridiculous requests from continuing but not allowing this one. Aug 31 2026 9:24PM Brittany O’shaughnessy 1976 Jewel Street, Johns Island, SC 29455 I am writing to sincerely request you Deny this project the right to tear these trees and change the nature of Johns Island. Our Island is a very special place in the Lowcountry and if we continue to allow these developers to cut these trees down for profit and building then what will we have to leave our future generations? Please Deny this request and any others to Preserve our home and our trees. God Bless. Aug 31 2026 9:25PM Jenny Welch 1163 East and West Road Charleston SC 29412 Please do not grant the variance or special exception request to remove dozens of grand tree species. There is nothing out of the ordinary on this property as many nearby properties on Johns Island also contain wetlands and numerous grand trees and must instead be preserved and worked into Aug 31 2026 9:27AM Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | September 2, 2026 the plans. With climate change and flooding, we need to quit destroying one of our biggest safety nets — our trees. Please deny the variance and special exception requests to remove 29 grand trees on Johns Island. Corie Hipp PO BOX 12376 Dear City of Charleston BZA - SD members: Please deny the applicant's request to remove 26 grand trees. It would be of substantial detriment to the adjacent properties, to the public good, and to the character of the entire district - SC's largest sea island. Furthermore, River Road is a nationally recognized historic corridor and deserves to be protected at all costs. Johns Island is too precious to destroy, and to build on wetlands is irresponsible... water will ALWAYS find its way back to where it once was. Aug 31 2026 9:27PM Bradley Reedy 2116 Blue Bayou Blvd Johns Island is not just a place to build. It is a living part of Charleston’s history—defined by its grand live oaks, wetlands, open land, waterways, wildlife, farms, families, and the rural character that generations have worked to protect. The proposed River Road townhome development may be described as progress, but progress should not mean clearing away the very things that make Johns Island worth living on and visiting in the first place. This proposal calls for the removal of dozens of grand trees and setback reductions affecting many more. These are not small saplings that can be replaced with landscaping after construction. Grand trees have taken decades—and often far longer— to grow. They provide shade, absorb stormwater, cool the surrounding area, support birds and wildlife, protect soil, improve air quality, and give Johns Island its unmistakable sense of place. A newly planted tree is not an equal replacement for a grand oak, magnolia, hickory, or tulip poplar. It may take generations before it provides the same canopy, habitat, beauty, and environmental protection. This property also includes wetlands and is located in a Stormwater Special Aug 31 2026 9:30PM Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | September 2, 2026 Protection Area. That should make all of us pause. Wetlands and mature tree canopy are not obstacles to be worked around only after a project is designed. They are part of the natural infrastructure that helps manage flooding, filter water, protect wildlife, and preserve the health of the island. When development continues to compress more buildings, roads, utilities, and parking into sensitive land, the consequences do not remain inside the property lines. They affect neighboring communities, roads, drainage, flooding, traffic, and the character of the entire island. Johns Island has already experienced enormous change. Each new development may seem like one individual project, but the cumulative effect is real: more traffic on roads that were never designed for this level of growth, more pressure on drainage systems, less tree canopy, fewer open spaces, and a gradual loss of the rural landscape that makes Johns Island unique. We are not saying Johns Island can never change. We are saying that growth must be responsible, transparent, and respectful of the land and the people who call this island home. If a proposed project requires the removal of so many grand trees— while potentially removing additional trees classified as poor condition without the same public review—then the public deserves complete information and the City should demand a better plan. Before any approval is given, the community deserves clear answers: •How many grand trees, including those classified as “F” condition, will actually be removed? •Who evaluated those trees, and will the full arborist reports be made public? •What alternative site plans were considered to protect more mature trees? •Why can’t the project be reduced, redesigned, or relocated within the property to avoid these losses? •How will the wetlands, stormwater, drainage, and Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | September 2, 2026 neighboring properties be protected? •What will Johns Island lose—not just today, but 10, 20, and 50 years from now? Once these trees are gone, they are gone. Once wetlands are disturbed and a rural landscape is transformed into dense development, there is no easy way to restore what was lost. Johns Island’s history, beauty, and environmental health should not be treated as the cost of doing business. We need leaders and developers willing to protect what makes this island special—not simply build over it. Amanda B River road. Johns island. Please please no more trees being cutting down. This takes a major toll on our wildlife, helping with flooding and keeping our island historical in addition to many other necessary reasons the trees should stay! No more with all the extra homes and removing trees. Please no citing down the trees Aug 31 2026 9:37PM Rebecca Brewington P.O. Box 70, folly beach, SC 29439 I respectfully submit this testimony in opposition to the removal of the mature trees located along River Road, currently under consideration for River Road townhomes. I ask the Council to require preservation of these trees, or at minimum to require a revised site plan, independent arborist review, and a meaningful mitigation standard before any removal permit is granted. 1. Mature Trees Function as Public Infrastructure Established trees are not merely aesthetic amenities — they perform measurable infrastructure functions that the City would otherwise need to fund through capital projects: Stormwater management: A single mature tree can intercept several thousand gallons of rainfall annually, reducing volume and velocity of runoff into municipal drainage systems. Removing mature canopy shifts this burden onto public stormwater infrastructure. Urban heat mitigation: Canopy cover can reduce surface and ambient temperatures by a significant margin in summer months, lowering Aug 31 2026 9:44PM Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | September 2, 2026 cooling costs for surrounding buildings and reducing heat-related public health risk. Air quality: Mature trees filter particulate matter and absorb pollutants at a rate far exceeding young or newly planted trees. A newly planted sapling cannot replicate these functions for decades. The loss is not one tree for one tree — it is the loss of decades of accumulated ecological service. 2. Preservation Adds Economic Value — Including to the Development Research on residential and commercial real estate consistently finds that mature trees and tree-lined frontage increase property values, often in the range of 3–15%, and improve marketability and lease/sale velocity. A development that retains mature trees is not merely an environmental compromise — it is frequently a more valuable and more marketable development. I would ask the Council to request that the applicant demonstrate they have explored site plan alternatives that preserve these trees before approving removal. 3. Time Is the One Resource That Cannot Be Replaced Mitigation plans that propose replacement planting should be evaluated honestly: a newly planted tree requires 30–100 years to provide the ecological, aesthetic, and property-value benefits of the tree being removed. No mitigation fund or replanting ratio can compress that timeline. Any calculation of "adequate mitigation" should account for this irreplaceability rather than treating tree count as a like-for-like substitute. 4. Community Health and Equity Considerations A substantial body of research links urban tree canopy to reduced stress, improved mental health outcomes, and lower rates of asthma and heat- related illness in surrounding neighborhoods. Canopy loss also disproportionately affects lower- income neighborhoods, which already tend to have less tree cover than wealthier areas. I would ask the Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | September 2, 2026 Council to consider whether this removal is consistent with the City's broader equity and public health goals. 5. Precedent for Future Development Decisions This decision will not be evaluated in isolation. Approving removal here, without requiring alternatives or robust mitigation, sets an evidentiary and practical precedent for the next application, and the one after that. Tree preservation ordinances exist precisely so that these decisions are made according to a consistent citywide standard rather than case-by- case exceptions. I ask the Council to apply that standard rigorously here. 6. Requested Actions I respectfully request that the Council take the following steps before authorizing any removal: Require a revised site plan demonstrating that the applicant has evaluated alternatives that preserve the trees in question without a material loss of density or usable square footage. Require independent arborist review, conducted by a City- retained or City-approved arborist (not solely the applicant's consultant), assessing the health, age, and ecological value of the trees proposed for removal. If removal is unavoidable, require canopy-inch-based mitigation — replacement calculated by the diameter/canopy coverage of the removed trees rather than a flat tree- for-tree count — and require that replacement plantings be maintained and monitored for survival over a multi-year period, with penalties for failure. Hold a public comment period specific to the tree removal component of this application, separate from the general development approval, given the distinct public interest at stake. Preserving mature trees is not an obstacle to responsible development — it is compatible with, and often beneficial to, well-designed development. I urge the Council to hold this application to the same Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | September 2, 2026 rigorous standard the City's tree ordinance was designed to ensure, and to reject removal absent a genuine showing that no reasonable preservation alternative exists. Respectfully submitted, Rebecca Brewington Charleston County Kenneth Dix 3478 Old Pond Road Johns Island SC 29455 Please consider saving the grand trees that Mungo Homes wants to destroy. Aug 31 2026 9:46PM kimberly krauk 2021 Telfair Way 29412 STOP the removal of our most precious assets - the Grand Trees!! When they are gone, there is no replacing them. This application doesn’t meet the criteria for removal so PLEASE DENY OUTRIGHT - no deferral. Aug 31 2026 9:47PM Richard Hardymon 2931 Blackfish Road We need to stop developing the land on Johns Island, there is a traffic problem that needs to be addressed before more homes are built on the island. Aug 31 2026 9:57PM Janet Boggs 2958 Sweetleaf Ln Johns Island SC 29455 Please do not allow the removal of grand trees. Aug 31 2026 10:06AM Rachel Spence 3395 Bohicket Estates Drive, Johns Island SC Please preserve our trees. The grand oaks hold the history and soul of our community. It’s important to protect our natural environment, not just for us, but for our children and our children’s children. This may just be a patch of dirt to developers, but preserving the trees protects the integrity of our culture and beauty of the island. Why tear down the beauty of nature that draws so many to this area? Please vote to protect the trees for future generations. Aug 31 2026 10:09PM Kristen Litch James island 29412 Request to Deny the application for grand tree removals. Trees help keep the island in good shape to reduce flooding, and erosion. This over development must stop. Aug 31 2026 10:11PM Connor Crosier 3100 Ashley Town Center Drive Charleston, SC 29414 Please consider planning the developing around these extremely important trees. Grand Oaks play a vital role in the ecosystem and the water cycle. They help with flood mitigation and leaving them preserves the natural environment and keeps the native southern charm. It’s a win Aug 31 2026 10:19PM Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | September 2, 2026 win to keep these beautiful trees. Since so many are already being cut down in this area, at the very least, build around these trees as much as possible to show that you are consciously trying to preserve the natural southern beauty of the Lowcountry. These trees will help soak up excess water from flood events and they act as homes to native species. It’s time we start preserving our natural environment. Rachel May 2265 Blue Bayou Boulevard Johns Island SC 29455 I am a resident of Johns Island and have concerns regarding the removal of several grand oaks for this development. Part of what makes Johns Island unique and beautiful is the presence of our lovely oaks. In addition, removal of these trees for development in an area currently comprised of wetlands is concerned for future flooding risk in our area. I strongly would voice concern against the removal of these trees which are integral to the character of Johns Island, especially in an area so near to many other developments which have already decimated the natural ecosystem. Aug 31 2026 10:42AM Wendy Delaney 232 Haddrell St Mt. Pleasant, SC 29464 Please help us and make the right choice to save our trees. Enough is enough already. We need to work harder to preserve the natural landscape of our surrounding islands and protect our beloved Charleston scenery. The historic oaks were given a tree protection ordinance for a reason. Please do your part and help us protect these trees from development. One less building versus One less tree! Aug 31 2026 10:45PM Tiffany McClay 5048 Coral Reef Dr. NO!!!! Maybank is a complete disaster. There’s no where for more cars or homes to fit on the island. It’s ludicrous that one would even consider doing this! STOP the building! It’s literally UNSAFE to keep doing this! Aug 31 2026 10:50PM Peter Rubino 3009 Tugalo St., Johns Island, SC 29455 I oppose the removal of the 29 grand trees and the setback reduction on 25 further grand trees. This project is going to impact the worse rated Aug 31 2026 10:51PM Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | September 2, 2026 intersection in Charleston County. The BCDCOG rated the intersection of River Road and Maybank Highway as "F-". There is no way for the access to this site is going to work so close to the "F-" intersection with a right and left turns coming out of a 108 units of townhomes. Let's take a beat here and look at alternates to this development as they will be dumping 108 units worth of cars onto the worst intersection in the county. Let's not remove the trees until we have a serious look at the traffic impacts and any stormwater issues this development may have. Tyler Robb Johns Island I respectfully request that the Zoning Board of Appeals deny this application to remove 20 + 9 grand trees—a total of 29 grand trees—and to reduce the required setbacks in a manner that would impact an additional 26 grand trees. Approval of this request would cause significant and potentially irreversible harm to Johns Island. Removing this number of mature, protected trees would reduce the island's natural ability to absorb stormwater, worsen flooding, diminish storm resilience, and permanently alter the historic and natural character that makes Johns Island unique. Johns Island has already experienced extensive development and the unnecessary destruction of mature and protected trees. Current residents are living with the consequences of that growth, including increased flooding, loss of natural habitat, reduced storm resilience, and the gradual erosion of the rural and historic character that drew many of us to this community in the first place. At what point will the quality of life of current residents be valued as much as a developer's desire to maximize the development potential and profitability of a property? At what point will we draw a line and establish a reasonable balance between growth and the preservation of the Johns Island community? Development Aug 31 2026 11:05PM Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | September 2, 2026 does not have to come at the expense of everything that makes Johns Island special. If developers choose to build here, they should respect the community in which they are building and recognize that the natural beauty, mature trees, open spaces, and historic character of Johns Island are not obstacles to development-they are part of the community's identity and value. Many of us choose to live on Johns Island because of its natural and historic beauty. Once these grand trees are removed, they cannot simply be replaced. The loss is permanent, and the cumulative impact of decisions like this will shape the island for generations. I urge the Board to consider not only the immediate development proposal before you, but also the long-term consequences for the residents, environment, storm resilience, and historic character of Johns Island. Please deny this application and protect the grand trees and character of our community. Christina White 3558 Maybank Highway Johns Island SC 29455 I oppose the removal of the 29 grand trees and the setback reduction on 25 further grand trees. This project is going to impact the worse rated intersection in Charleston County. The BCDCOG rated the intersection of River Road and Maybank Highway as "F-". There is no way for the access to this site is going to work so close to the "F-" intersection with a right and left turns coming out of a 108 units of townhomes. Let's look at alternates to this development as they will be dumping 108 units worth of cars considering two per unit 216 cars on that road (one car per unit very unlikey) onto the worst intersection in the county. Let's not remove the trees until we have a serious look at the traffic impacts and any stormwater issues this development may have. Consider the displacement of all the animals from the natural habitat. We need a better solution for this traffic and safety issues that will arise from this location point. The entrance and Aug 31 2026 11:12PM Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | September 2, 2026 exit is going to backup not only River Road and Maybank Highway but overflow into neighborhoods where children and pets will be at risk. This needs to be addresssed. If this is considered at all, you should add the correct amount of trees that match the caliber that should be replaced. If you do consider removal of trees ensure that the tree mitigation happens on Johns Island. Debbie Hodshon 4260 Hugh Bennett Drive You are destroying the island and protection the trees provide. I left Beaufort and moved to Johns island for the beauty similar to Beaufort. No big commercial development. You are allowing this. You have a choice to stop it Aug 31 2026 11:12PM Margaret Connors 1217 updyke dr The compaction of squeezing in units to accommodate around some of these trees is not enough especially in a special storm water area. We NEED these old trees to help with erosion and taking in excess deep water, NOT buildings and lawns in an already extremely congested area. Traffic already surpasses this proposed entrance EVERY SINGLE MORNING. I understand it is zoned already a certain way but again there needs to not be multiple units - were talking a family with 1-2+ vehicles per unit! Aug 31 2026 11:16PM Meredith Thomason Johns River Creek subdivision, River Rd River Rd does not need any additional development, especially in the area of this tract of land. The traffic is this area has become unbearble, especially in the mornings, and current infrastructure cannot handle the additional traffic burden. The island only has two ways on and off the island. This poses a serious public safety issue, especially when we have another major hurricane like Hugo. The local schools also cannot handle the expected growth from currently approved for development, much less any additional development. Our infrastructure cannot support the existing residents, so the infrastructure must be updated before any additional development is Aug 31 2026 11:22PM Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | September 2, 2026 approved. The grand oaks of Johns Island have been a beautiful display of an island that used to value preservation, history, and a rural way of life. That no longer is the case. The oaks also serve as a very real, much needed natural storm barrier. The more trees and land that are cleared, the more flooding, wind and storm damage residents will experience. We are already seeing regular flooding in areas not previously zoned high flood risk, primarily due to our natural barriers being destroyed. It will already take hundreds of years to try repairing the damage we have done to this beautiful land God gave us, so please do not allow any further damage. Once the land is gone, we cannot get it back. Natalie Orndorff 1761 bee balm road Johns island I am writing in opposition to the requested removal of 26 grand trees and the reduction of required setbacks affecting another 25 grand trees for the proposed River Road Townhomes development. This is not simply a request to remove trees to accommodate development. This is a request to remove a significant portion of the island’s mature tree canopy on a property containing approximately 12.5 acres of wetlands and located within a Stormwater Special Protection Area. Those facts should be central to the Board’s consideration. The applicant’s own materials acknowledge that the wetlands constrain the developable area and that this creates conflicts between the proposed infrastructure and existing grand trees. But the presence of wetlands and the resulting limitations on development should not automatically justify removing protected trees. Rather, they demonstrate why the scale, density, and configuration of the proposed development deserve greater scrutiny. Grand trees are not interchangeable landscaping. Decades-old live oaks, magnolias, gums, hickories, and other mature trees provide stormwater Aug 31 2026 12:45PM Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | September 2, 2026 absorption, shade, habitat, erosion control, carbon storage, and significant ecological value. On Johns Island, where development and impervious surfaces continue to increase, every remaining mature tree and wetland system becomes increasingly important. I am particularly concerned about the cumulative impact of decisions like this. We cannot evaluate each development in isolation. Johns Island is experiencing rapid growth, while simultaneously losing wetlands, tree canopy, and natural areas that help protect the community from the consequences of that growth. If we continue treating these natural systems as obstacles to development rather than infrastructure that supports our community, we will eventually reach a point where the damage cannot be reversed. I also believe the Board should have complete information before approving these requests. Specifically, the public should understand how many additional grand trees are proposed for removal under an “F” rating, who conducted those assessments, and whether those trees were independently evaluated. The fact that trees with an F rating may not require the same approval process makes transparency about the total number of trees being lost even more important. I recognize that the applicant proposes preserving substantial areas of the property, including approximately 1,000 protected trees and 75 grand trees. That is meaningful and should be acknowledged. However, preservation elsewhere on the site does not eliminate the ecological value of the 26 grand trees proposed for removal or justify reducing protections for another 25. I respectfully ask the BZA- SD to deny the requested grand tree removals and setback reductions unless the applicant can demonstrate that these impacts are truly Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | September 2, 2026 unavoidable and that the project has been designed to minimize disturbance to wetlands, mature trees, and other natural resources to the greatest extent possible. Johns Island needs responsible growth. We can build housing while still protecting the natural systems that make this community resilient and livable. This project should be held to that standard. Ellen and Ken Festa Turkey Trot Drive - Johns Island I am writing to oppose the approval of this request. Please DENY the applicants request to remove these trees. In addition to the loss of the trees, the environmental impacts to the Wetlands, and the fact that the location is in a Stormwater Special Protection area, the impact to the traffic congestion in the intolerable intersection of River Rd. and Maybank is incredibly NOT Being taken into consideration. The backup in the one lane OFF the Island (which apparently was made one lane due to saving a grand tree make one ask WHY IS THAT NOT A CONSIDERATION HERE - Is it OK to remove 29 trees for a Developer, but not one tree to ease traffic congestion for taxpaying residents of Johns Island??? Boggles the mind - PLEASE DON'T APPROVE THE PROJECT!!!!! Aug 31 2026 12:53PM Emily Rosenthal 2878 Sweetleaf Ln Johns Island Please please deny the request to remove more of the grand oaks on the island. These took centuries to grow and cannot be replaced for generations to come. Sep 1 2026 1:25AM Amy Bradley 1755 Crystal Lake Drive, 29412 Hi guys. It's me again. I'm the one who has to write each time a developer makes a ridiculous tree removal request. Can we stop this constant dance? I'm getting old. I've lived here for 25 years. I donated money to help save Angel Oak. Is there a way you guys can start just telling developers outright that these horrible grand oak tree removal requests are just not happening and think again? If you can do that, I promise to start asking council members to stop their Sep 1 2026 3:36AM Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | September 2, 2026 constant rezoning that starts this entire grand tree removal process to begin with. Please and thank you. Jessica Hofford 2153 Fort Pemberton Dr., Charleston 29412 I respectfully request this Board DENY the applicant’s request. This massive grand tree removal request and reduced setback request must be DENIED because it would be of substantial detriment to adjacent properties, to the public good, and to the character of the district if this application for grand tree removal was approved. Given the historic character of this property, the central location to primary roadways, including evacuation routes, the existing wetlands on the site, and the known floodplain where it is located, approving the application would create substantial harm to thousands of citizens who already live in this district—not including the 100+ new residents who would occupy the new units being proposed for this site. The flooding issues on adjacent properties and public roadways will be inescapable if these large, healthy trees are removed. Trees absorb water, hold soil together, and do more to protect the Lowcountry from flooding than the current storm water retention requirements in Charleston. The developer purchased this property knowing all of the existing site conditions, and should be required to develop the property within those conditions. Please do not allow this applicant to alter the site in such a drastic way as to inflict irreparable harm to the surrounding property owners, the public right of ways, and the historic character of the district. There are better solutions available for developing this site, and I humbly ask that this Board to challenge the applicant to do better. Please, consider the thousands of citizens who will forever be negatively impacted by the removal of these grand trees and the setback variances. Please, DENY this request. Sep 1 2026 6:25AM Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | September 2, 2026 Richard Thompson 2623 Battle Trail Dr I oppose the plan to remove grand trees. The area cannot support these changes. Why have zoning and rules if they are never followed? Sep 1 2026 6:31AM Debbie Epstein 2041 Egret Lane I strongly oppose cutting down the grand trees along River Road. Please consider what the developers are doing to this beautiful island, the people and the wildlife. Sep 1 2026 6:40AM Chelsea Meadows 975 river road Stop cutting down the trees for neighborhoods until the infrastructure can handle the increased house loads and traffic. We’ve been waiting years to cut down 2 trees to widen the merge at maybank leaving the island. How can we so easily cut down trees for neighborhoods. No one wants to move to Johns island or they leave the island because the traffic is so bad. FIX THE ROADS AND TRAFFIC FIRST! The merge is horrible and continues to get worse. Signed a local, born and raised. Sep 1 2026 6:46AM Nina Kaufman 3354 Berryhill Road, Johns Island, SC 29455 This application does NOT meet the BZA's criteria for grand tree removal. It would destroy vital aspects of the Johns Island ecosystem -- and for what? The project is already doomed to be an additional traffic nightmare in the area. The ecology of our area needs and deserves to be preserved. That can't happen with this widespread destruction of grand trees, which are key aspects of our wetlands. This development is a poster child for what the City should not be allowing. These are the type of parcels the City should proactively work with landowners to buy out development rights -- instead of chopping down the trees that make our area unique. Sep 1 2026 6:48AM Anna Messinger 2928 Sugarberry Lane I respectfully urge the BZA-SD to deny the requested variances to remove protected trees and reduce the required impervious construction setbacks for this development. These trees are not only an essential part of our neighborhood’s natural beauty, but they also play a critical role in supporting the local ecosystem— providing habitat for wildlife, improving air quality, mitigating Sep 1 2026 6:50AM Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | September 2, 2026 stormwater runoff, and helping reduce urban heat. Importantly, the request to remove the grand oak trees and reduce the required setbacks does not meet the applicable requirements for the BZA-SD to approve these requests. The Board should uphold the protections established by the existing zoning and tree-preservation requirements rather than grant exceptions that would allow their intent to be circumvented. Additionally, allowing impervious construction substantially closer to the bases of these mature trees significantly increases the likelihood that even trees designated for retention will ultimately be damaged or killed due to root disturbance, soil compaction, and restricted water infiltration. Granting variances of this scale would set a concerning precedent that weakens existing protections and prioritizes short-term development objectives over the long- term environmental health and character of our community. These mature trees cannot be meaningfully replaced once removed, and their loss would permanently change the character and beauty of the neighborhood. Thoughtful development and environmental stewardship are not mutually exclusive. I strongly encourage the BZA-SD to uphold the existing requirements, deny the requested variances, and require a development plan that preserves these protected trees and respects the intent of the community’s zoning and tree- preservation standards. Thank you for your consideration. Eva Meghreblian 3253 timberline dr johns island sc 29455 The island is not equipped for this. Traffic on John’s island is at an all time high. The roads need to be widened before we can take on a property like this on two of the busiest roads on the island. Sep 1 2026 6:52AM Chris Correale 3051 Fosters Glenn Dr, Johns island Adamantly object to the cutting down of grand trees on this project property as I adamantly object to the propose Sep 1 2026 7:07AM Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | September 2, 2026 development on this property. A cluster of town homes that close to the EXTREMELY busy and congested Maybank/ River intersection, not to mention the filling of wetlands is beyond ridiculous. When is enough enough on John’s Island? Lisa Milo 3416 Patton Ave Johns Island NO to cutting down trees and NO to Any More Development. STOP DESTROYING THE ISLAND Sep 1 2026 7:10AM Laura Dell’Aiera 6013 rainbow trout Drive Johns island SC 29455 Please stop removing our trees and building more homes! Current residents can’t get to work, emergency vehicles can’t service local areas, runoff water is destroying existing properties, and the precious few grand oaks we have left are getting picked off left and right. Make a decision that’s good for the existing residents of this area. Sep 1 2026 7:16AM Stephanie Nodine 1575 Tacky Point Rd Wadmalaw Island I oppose the destruction of 26 grand trees to make room for more townhomes on Johns Island. Not only is the loss of the trees a huge detriment to the area, but the island (and particularly this intersection) cannot withstand the additional traffic that new housing developments bring. The infrastructure problems on the island ahould be well known to this committee. It’s time to start putting people and place over profit! Sep 1 2026 7:20AM Hollis Gallagher 3561 Hunters Oak Lane, John’s Island, Sc 29455 I strongly oppose the requested removal of these grand trees and urge the Board to deny these variances and special exceptions. Grand trees are not simply obstacles standing in the way of development. They are an irreplaceable part of the character, beauty, and environmental health of Johns Island. Residents have watched development accelerate at an extraordinary pace, bringing more traffic, more clearing, more impervious surface, and the steady loss of the natural landscape that makes this island such a special place to live. At some point, we have to ask what we are actually preserving for the people who already live here. The proposal to remove 26 grand trees— Sep 1 2026 7:22AM Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | September 2, 2026 and reduce protections around an additional 25—in order to accommodate 106 townhomes is deeply concerning. If a development cannot reasonably be built while respecting the protections already in place for our grand trees, perhaps the development should be redesigned to fit the land rather than the land continually being stripped and altered to fit the development. Johns Island residents are asked again and again to accept the consequences of rapid growth: worsening traffic, loss of wetlands and open space, flooding concerns, and the disappearance of our tree canopy. Meanwhile, the very things that make living here worthwhile are slowly being taken away. These protections exist for a reason. A grand tree takes generations to grow. Once it is cut down, planting a new tree somewhere else does not replace what has been lost—not for the residents living here today, and not for decades to come. Please think beyond the immediate interests of this particular development and consider the cumulative impact these decisions are having on Johns Island. Development should adapt to the character and natural resources of our community—not require us to sacrifice them. I respectfully ask you to deny the requests to remove these grand trees and to require a plan that preserves them. Johns Island has already given up enough in the name of development. Please protect what remains. Sheena Janse 936 Reddick Street The trees are an integral part of the ecosystem, beauty and well being of the area. They provide a habitat for wildlife, shade and stability to the land, and improve or air quality. The trees provide a value which can’t be replaced. Save the trees! Sep 1 2026 7:32AM Rebecca Ruttiger 3231 Cape Rd, Johns Island This is a prime example of developers requesting variances for projects that will directly harm Johns Island. This lot could be built without the requested variances; it’s simply not what they Sep 1 2026 7:33AM Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | September 2, 2026 desire. However, the continued destruction of wetlands, removal of grand trees, and the clearing of vast forests are detrimental to the island. They directly contradict the City’s plans to plant trees and will ultimately result in increased costs for the City and its residents due to the need to address water runoff and traffic congestion. Introducing more market- priced housing is unnecessary. The addition of traffic at an F-level intersection is also unnecessary. The property owner can utilize the property for the zoned purpose of General Business and contribute positively to the island by providing a much smaller, more suitable business that aligns with the land’s characteristics. Claire Aitken 2983 Edenvale Rd This development is a terrible idea. Filling in marshland, removing trees, creating more traffic withOUT improving infrastructure? This is a money grab and Johns Islanders are sick of it. Please deny this request and go build it where there is actually space and infrastructure. Sep 1 2026 7:34AM Nicholas Montefusco- Vega 1529 Fishbone Dr, Johns Island, SC 29455 This is getting ridiculous for the housing you all are considering approving. Putting this right on Main Rd/Maybank? Are you all aware of the amount of traffics this intersection has today by getting on and off the island?? Please do not make the mistake of going through with this. Johns Island does not need more trees cut down or more congestion at highly traffics intersections. Johns Island trees are what making this part of Charleston beautiful. Sep 1 2026 7:36AM Patricia Luck 2701 Pinelog Lane, Johns Island, SC 29455-3252 I request that this development be denied. The proximity to the River Rd./Maybank intersection will cause serious problems. I live 3.5 miles from the light on Maybank at Fenwick Alley, and morning rush hour it has taken me 45 minutes to travel this. There are wetlands on the property that should be protected to mitigate flooding, not filled. Our grand trees need to be Sep 1 2026 7:51AM Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | September 2, 2026 protected, not cut down. The city should buy out the development rights for this land and let it remain as is. Consider it as a contribution to our Green Space program. Carrie Wick 3745 Seabrook Island Road, Johns Island SC 29455 We urge you not to allow the removal of grand trees at this site or to allow the reduction in the impervious construction setback near the bases of 25 grand trees. Approval would run completely counter to the important goal of protecting such trees on Johns Island. Sep 1 2026 7:58AM Melody Kedzierski 3397 Kit Freeman Lane I am a resident of Johns Island. I’m a land and home owner, a tax payer. I have watched this beautiful island be destroyed by greedy developers for many years, but our Grand Oaks have always been protected, until recently. Anyone who loves Johns Island and it’s history understand how important it is to protect every single one of those majestic trees! Those trees are hundreds of years old, they cannot be replaced! They represent the beauty and country life that we love here. If you remove the Grand Oaks, you will destroy the heart of Johns Island SC. The developers will move on, people will leave because our quality of life has been ruined, and we’ll still be waiting for our New Harris Teeter! (Only locals will understand) please think with your hearts instead of their wallets, Gods Earth is depending on you! Sep 1 2026 8:00AM Jacquelyn Barrus 1414 Widows Court Tearing down the trees not only kills our environment and makes many abnormal homeless but also is an extreme safety hazard to the people of John's Aylin. You have overbuilt and overpopulated an island that only has two exits off of it. Two exits that four islands have to share. This is an extreme safety concern especially during hurricane season. When a hurricane occurs there is no possible way to get everyone off the island safely and you are leaving people to have to fend for themselves in their homes. This is also an issue because Sep 1 2026 8:00AM Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | September 2, 2026 with only two exits of four islands you are adding more and more homes and increasing the population making it more and more difficult to be able to get assistance in emergency crisis. The infrastructure has not even been funded enough or have they worked on improving roadways so residence can safely travel on Johns Island. It is obvious you don't live on the island because the intersection that you're wanting to add hundreds of townhomes too, is an intersection that currently backed up and takes long amounts of time just to get onto Maybank to leave the island. There is already a population issue due to our lack of infrastructure and the it is the to allow all of the building that's going on on Johns Island without giving a crap about the inability Ireland provide safe roadways is absurd. We do not want Johns Island to be the next Mount pleasant! If we wanted to live in Mount Pleasant we would've moved there! Quit tearing down our green spaces and building a bunch of crap houses to fill your pockets with money. We are the people that live here and we don't want our green spaces depleted and all of these homes built. You have no right to make our roadways more unsafe by building more and bringing more people here but not giving a crap about the fact we need roadways and infrastructure to support all of the building you are doing. There should be no building on John's island until you can come up with a smart plan to address traffic and emergency situations before you worry about bringing more building to our island. The idiocyof building that many homes right at the intersection of Maybank and River Road is ridiculous. You have already placed two apartment complexes and a home subdivision right at the entrance of the island from James Island. Let's try and use our brain now and not continue to build but instead plan and think about Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | September 2, 2026 the people who already live on the island and their safety!!! a safe roadway off of Johns Island to James Island was not completed due to a tree but you will cut down a forest of them to build townhomes!!! it is hard to believe it takes an education to do city planning because it sure doesn't show in the plans here!! actually the lack of planning!!! NO NO NO to tearing down trees and building more townhomes at the busiest intersection and one of the only two ways off the island!! Rob Kendrick 2348 Rushland Landing Rd. There is already been enough cutting down of grand trees on Johns Island - how does this align with the mayor's promise to plant 10,000 trees. There will be more taken for the second lane off island (desperately needed) and there were many taken for the project on the pitchfork. Also, the egress in and out of this development would add fuel to an already problematic intersection at Maybank and River - which is not ideal for anyone. Sometime just because "you can" doesn't mean you "should". Sep 1 2026 8:01AM Elizabeth Brumbach 1948 High Meadow Street, Johns Island I respectfully request Council to DENY the destruction of 26 grand trees. These are epic symbols of the Lowcountry. They are essential to our ecosystem and once they are gone, we won’t get them back. You hold the beauty, property value, the life of the Lowcountry in your hands. Please do the right thing and save these epic symbols before they are destroyed forever. Thank you. Sep 1 2026 8:02AM Anne McGowan 54 Blue Heron Pond Road Johns Island I’m opposed. This project of 106 attached single-family homes would generate 696 one-way trips per day adversely impacting the already failed intersection at Maybank-River intersection. Sep 1 2026 8:04AM Jennifer Griswell 1027 Kingswood Drive Save the TREES!!!!! Sep 1 2026 8:04AM Dana Dawson 6509 Foxfire Rd, 29487 Stop cutting down trees for apartments! We need better roads and less houses which bring more Sep 1 2026 8:06AM Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | September 2, 2026 traffic to the area. The islands are being destroyed by greed and over construction. People are getting fed up. Enough is enough. It seems the county will not be happy unless every treee is removed and replaced with concrete or a house. Louise Ravenel 1 King Street - but spend lot of time in Rockville This is the worse submitted development I have seen yet and pray it is not approved. Cutting down major trees in wetlands is a not starter to begin with as we flood enough already. The turning right only to get in and out would NEVER work, as people will just slip in and turn left. When a buyer sees this, they will not love there. This development is INSANE and should never happen! Sep 1 2026 8:09AM S H Penny Lane I strongly oppose the proposed 106 townhomes on this property. This isn’t simply a matter of being against new housing, it’s about how and WHERE we are choosing to develop Johns Island. This site has some serious limitations that should not be ignored. It is directly adjacent to the already- congested Maybank/River Road intersection, and adding 106 homes will inevitably increase traffic on River Road and put even more pressure on an intersection that already struggles to handle existing traffic. Even more concerning, approximately half of the property consists of wetlands, and development would require impacts to some of those wetlands to connect the higher areas of the property. Dozens of mature, grand trees would also be lost. We need to be thoughtful about which properties make sense to develop and which properties should be preserved because of their environmental and infrastructure constraints. This feels like exactly the type of property where the City should be exploring alternatives, including purchasing development rights, rather than forcing an unsuitable development into an already overburdened area. Johns Island needs responsible growth—not growth at any cost. 106 townhomes Sep 1 2026 8:11AM Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | September 2, 2026 on this particular site is not responsible planning. Dwight Kelley 2896 Cavalcade Cir Johns Island It's not just the Trees that are being cut down for the Townhome construction that's a concern, but the added traffic which will occur at an Intersection that is already overly congested. Let's improve the Maybank/River Intersection before any more housing projects are approved near it. Please drive through that Intersection during Rush Hours to see what I mean, especially if active accidents have also occurred there. Sep 1 2026 8:20AM Tracey Porcher 1497 Stratton Pl, Mount Pleasant, SC I write to request the denial of the removal of the grand trees and the filling of our wetlands for further developer greed. I urge the BZA to deny this request. Do not let more of our precious lowcountry fall to the greed of the developer bulldozers and clear cutting! I do not need to explain the value of trees to you. I assume you know. Please do the right thing and deny this request 1000 fold! Sep 1 2026 8:23AM Robert Carroll 4313 Raccoon Key Court I was at this intersection at 7AM yesterday. The last thing needed is more traffic from this development. Also it is possible this is the largest request to cut grand trees per acre on Johns Island. Please protect our island and reject this tree request. Sep 1 2026 8:27AM Robin Shipp 1984 Jewel Street Johns island SC Please do not approve this tree removal. Not only does it not fit the removal guidance but we need to be able to get off the Island to work. Traffic is so bad I literally have turned around twice and called out of work. If these townhomes are approved I may as well move because since school is back in session there have been multiple days I can’t get off the island regardless of every route I tried. Adding the lane to Maybank is not going to do anything to help traffic if we are just adding 100 more homes that house atleast 3 people per home. Please stop already. Thank you for your attention to this matter. Sep 1 2026 8:29AM Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | September 2, 2026 Jennifer Jerome 3451 Hobson Drive, Johns Island . SC 29455 I strongly oppose the passing of the removal of and encroachment on the Grand Trees for this development. These grand trees include: Live oaks, Laurel oaks, Black Gums, Red Oak, Magnolia, Hickory, Tulip Poplar and Water Oaks. There must be a better way to develop than destroying these important and beautiful trees. I am asking that the City’s BZA-SD deny this ill advised application for grand trees removal!! From what I have seen this application does not meet the BZA's criteria for grand tree/s removal. Sep 1 2026 8:35AM Nan Palmer 1607 Tuxedo Ct All of these trees are very valuable, Live oaks, Laurel oaks, Black Gums, Red Oak, Magnolia, Hickory, Tulip Poplar and Water Oaks. Please do not allow them to be removed as the environmental health of our island depends on them! We also desire for our island to be attractive and leave an impression on all who visit! Thanks for saving our trees! Sep 1 2026 8:40AM Anne Bavier 3132 privateer Creek Road Seabrook Island The proposal to remove so many grand trees will permanently harm the island and its historical beauty. Environmental harm impacts many generations and is unnecessary to provide for new developments Sep 1 2026 8:43AM Robert Vingi 338 low oak woods road Johns island S.C. The proposed hundred Plus unit townhome project behind the Dollar General must not be approved. It will generate hundreds of daily vehicle trips near an already overwhelmed intersection and residence will only be able to make right hand turns into the development. Please do not approve this project. It will not be fair to the residence who might inhabit it and the community surrounding it. Sep 1 2026 8:51AM Kimberly Panzardi 3210 Great Egret Drive Johns Island I respectfully submit opposition to the removal of the 26 trees. There have been far too many trees taken out for the sake of "development", which this Island cannot handle. To fully understand what the citizens who live here deal with everyday with the overdevelopment, those who seek to continue the developing, should live here to see what we deal with. Enough Sep 1 2026 8:52AM Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | September 2, 2026 is enough. Please hear the citizens of Johns Island and leave the trees. Kimberly Bowers 4163 Chisolm Rd Johns Island I oppose the cutting of 26 grand oaks for this project. I oppose the project completely - additional traffic at an already F rated intersection, continued wetland loss on the island, loss of trees/greenery. I thought this was exactly the negative impacts the city was working to stop. Sep 1 2026 8:52AM Katrina Dempsey 5554 Katy hill rd Wadmalaw 29487 Against the removal of grad trees with out more info. What Arborist checked the trees and wet land area? more development brings stress to an area already stressed with over development. Infrastructure can not handle more development. Needs to be limited in size and developed with keeping more trees and wetlands as they are Sep 1 2026 8:58AM Nicole Pucci 2659 Private Lefler Dr, Johns Island, SC 29455- 8993, USA I strongly oppose the requested variances and special exception for the River Road development (BZA-SD, Agenda Item A-5). Johns Island is already experiencing tremendous development pressure, and our grand trees are an irreplaceable part of the island’s character, ecosystem, and natural resilience. Removing 26 grand trees and allowing construction to encroach within the protected areas of another 25 should not be considered an acceptable consequence of maximizing development on this property. This site is particularly concerning because approximately half of the property consists of wetlands. If the proposed development cannot be constructed at its current intensity without removing protected grand trees, encroaching upon the protected areas of additional grand trees, and filling wetlands for access, then the development should be redesigned to accommodate the natural constraints of the property. Variances should not simply be a mechanism for making a preferred site plan work. The developer should be required to design the project around the existing Sep 1 2026 8:59AM Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | September 2, 2026 grand trees rather than requiring our protected natural resources to accommodate the development. Johns Island is growing rapidly, and decisions like this will determine what kind of island remains for future generations. Mature grand trees cannot meaningfully be replaced once they are removed. I respectfully ask the Board to deny the requested tree variances and special exception and require a development plan that preserves these grand trees and respects the environmental character of Johns Island. Melanie Brown 3108 Grand Bay Please do not approve more townhomes on Johns island at this time. Our road construction cannot tolerate increased traffic. We need better infrastructure, roads, and schools to decrease traffic burden. Adding 105 households to increase road construction does not help us. Sep 1 2026 9:00AM Kate Tucker- Ostergard 2662 Coquina Drive Johns Island 29455 Please note that we are against the removal of all Grand Trees related to this project including a variance to allow the removal of 19 grand trees; a special exception to allow the removal of 7 grand trees and a variance to allow the reduction in the impervious construction setback near the bases of 25 grand trees. Sep 1 2026 9:05AM Katie Carnevale 3033 Sweetleaf lane Johns Island Please do not allow the variance for the destruction of these trees, the requests do not meet the requirements to remove the trees. Millions of dollars were just spent on a project to alleviate flooding right next to that parcel, which includes many acres of wetlands. Sep 1 2026 9:07AM Val Marsh 4315 Hope Plantation Please do not cut down any Grand Oaks! They are irreplaceable. We need trees considerably more than we need more development. Sep 1 2026 9:08AM Robin Hardin 902 Preston Road PLEASE DENY the developer's request to remove 29 grand trees for the proposed River Road Townhomes. There is absolutely no reason to approve such a destructive request and then ask the public to vote to extend the sales tax to "shore up" the Sep 1 2026 9:09AM Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | September 2, 2026 Charleston peninsula! Please stand strong against developers putting lots of money in their pockets while destroying our irreplaceable natural assets and protections. Chad Dillon 3137 Timberline Dr. Please, slow down or stop development on Johns Island. These roads can’t handle it. Sep 1 2026 9:09AM Douglas Sass 6345 Oak grove Plantation Rd. Wadmalaw Island SC 29487 This development is much too close to an already "F" LOS rated intersection to allow for the addition of 600+ new daily car trips. In addition, the plan calls for multiple variences with regard to protected grand trees as well as the filling of low and wetlands to connect smaller portions of high land to enable over development of this tract. I would ask the board to deny this permit on basis of these multiple reasons.. Sep 1 2026 9:12AM Lawrence Fieroh 10 Turtle Bech Ln., Johns Island, SC I am opposed to this development for the following reasons. 1) building more multi family housing on wetlands. We already have many properties that are in ‘low country’. When are we going to wake up? Is ‘filling’ the right solution? Where will the water go? Wetlands were designated ‘wetlands’ for a reason. 2) living on John’s Island, I travel that route multiple times a month. What used to take 25 minutes, now depending on time can take up to an hour and that intersection is a bottleneck. And this will only make it worse. This development is too close to the Maybank-River intersection. Where is the traffic study ‘WITH’ the proposed development increased traffic??b 3) last but not least, “let’s cut down some more trees”. Apparently dozens of grand trees will need to be cut down. Not a good idea and not what the mayor said about preserving the trees. When will we realize that by developing land that incorporates the beauty of the area, it continues to denigrate the area that we love. Wetlands, traffic and trees are things we should be striving to protect or improve, not make worse. I Sep 1 2026 9:15AM Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | September 2, 2026 would like to see some other sites for this development that do not impact the area like this development does. Kristen Riedmayer 1695 Bee Balm Road This is even bigger than increased traffic that Johns Island can't handle, or about the wetlands that if disturbed, will undoubtably cause more flooding, but my gosh, why are we even considering taking down what makes Johns Island so special? These historic grand trees can't just "come back" elsewhere. Please stop this project before it not only destroys the natural habitat of Johns Island, but adds to the ever growing problems caused by greedy developers who don't even live here to experience the beauty of the trees or the chaos due to their overdeveloping. Sep 1 2026 9:17AM Fran D. 552 Double Eagle Trace We have had property on John’s Island for a few decades now. The look of the island has changed and more so in the past several years than all the previous years that we’ve been visiting. It has been baffling to me that there’s not enough houses in general that anymore need to be built anywhere but I guess as population increases so does housing needs. I also find it baffling that it seems that developers in the Charleston area are building as many apartments and townhomes as possible (vs single family homes) to wedge in as many people as possible. There are only the same couple of roads to access these new places causing every traffic nightmares and danger when it comes to coastal evacuations. But the main focus here is the plan to remove more than 2 dozen grand trees. The grand trees on Johns Island have provided a unique charm that is not found anywhere else. Removing them brings the look of Johns Island one step closer to looking like anywhere USA. (Think Mt Pleasant here, for example. With all of the big stores and neighborhoods, it’s the “same” as going to Honolulu or Marlton, NJ or Route 301 in Maryland. It all looks pretty much the same.) Further, besides the aesthetics, grand Sep 1 2026 9:20AM Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | September 2, 2026 mature trees provide irreplaceable environmental and ecological benefits that younger trees need decades of catching up to do. Without running through a long list of benefits here, I would point out that considering the area is susceptible to storms that one of the most beneficial values of the grand trees is that they have survived decades of storms and they help manage storm water runoff. Grand trees retain soil. These are free services. If you are intent on building these townhomes, I would urge the architect to find a way to wedge the new homes amongst the grand trees in a way that protects the trees. I am not only for aesthetic conservation of the area but I also believe environmental and ecological conservation are just as important. Please save the grand trees! Chris Warrix 1405 Black maple way Removal of these trees and building on wetlands should not be allowed. Both help with protecting from flooding. This area is also in one of the busiest area of the island and is already over loaded with traffic and no infrastructure to resolve the issue the way it is now. Sep 1 2026 9:24AM Lisa Hartzog Johns Island Please DENY this application to remove 25 grand trees. This is a shameful abuse of John’s Island. Johns Island is a beautiful and special place. Developers have already done so much damage to this area chasing the almighty dollar. Please do those of us who are blessed to live on and enjoy Johns Island today, as well as the generations to come, a huge favor by putting an end the complete and total disrespect and disregard for this island and its beauty. PLEASE DENY this application. Sep 1 2026 9:28AM Andrea = Easterday 2659 Battle Trail Drive, Johns Island, SC I’m writing to express my opposition to the request to cut down 26 trees on Johns Island. These trees are an important part of the island’s character, environmental health, and natural resilience. Removing them would negatively impact the Sep 1 2026 9:35AM Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | September 2, 2026 community, wildlife habitat, and the long-term sustainability of the area. I urge the Board of Zoning Appeals to deny this request. The project listed as “River Road,” agenda item “A-5,” under meeting name “BZA-SD,” should not move forward as proposed. Thank you for your attention to this matter and for considering the community’s concerns. Joan Klein 1538 Royal Colony Road I've been subjected to the increased traffic near the River and Maybank intersection for nearly ten years. Recently I came across a letter I had penned to the Courier Post warning prospective buyers on Johns Island to visit during the workweek 7-9 a.m. Imagine now choosing to be a part of the daily frustration and incredulous anxiety of sitting in a 20 minute wait just to approach the intersection. My letter was over five years ago and yet construction continues. New buyers may be naive but those of you on the board are incredibly knowledgeable and should be committed to making the right choice for the residents of a once idyllic island. Please don't disappoint us - reject this new development. Thank you. Sep 1 2026 9:39AM Rex Uber 2041 Kemmerlin St., Johns Island, SC 29455 I request that the Board does not grant a request for the removal of 29 grand trees for this project. Removing the trees changes the character of Johns Island and is detrimental to wildlife. It is also not in the best interest of stormwater runoff. The developer should be required to work around the existing trees. Sep 1 2026 9:59AM Preston McClay 5048 Coral Reef Dr, Johns Island SC 29455 I strongly urge the BZA-SD to deny this application and reject the proposed removal of these 26 grand trees. Mature trees are an invaluable part of the character, beauty, and environmental health of Johns Island, and once they are removed, they cannot simply be replaced. Development should be designed around preserving significant existing trees whenever reasonably possible, not removing them simply because Sep 1 2026 10:00AM Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | September 2, 2026 doing so makes a project easier or more convenient to build. If this proposal does not meet the established criteria for removing grand trees, I believe the BZA-SD has a responsibility to uphold those standards and protect these trees. Johns Island is already experiencing tremendous development pressure, and decisions like this set an important precedent for what our community will look like in the future. I respectfully ask the BZA-SD to deny the request to remove the 26 grand trees and require the project to be redesigned to preserve them wherever possible. Thank you for considering the concerns of the community. Amber Thompson (Not submitted for public record) Please do not do any more development until we have safe roadways and a traffic plan. It already takes me 30 minutes just to go less than a mile through that intersection. Sep 1 2026 10:10AM Joyce Newman 1029 Sunnybrook Dr., Johns Island, SC 29455 This entire project is detrimental for many reasons beyond the loss of trees. It is in wetland, it abuts residences which may flood, wetland mitigation does not benefit John’s Island, it will contribute to traffic congestion in an already severely congested area, it will contribute to the rampant development that is destroying the quality of life on John’s Island and it abuts an historic cemetery. Sep 1 2026 10:12AM Alicia Avnayim 335 Stefan Dr Charleston SC 29412 I ask that you deny the request to remove 26 grand trees as it does not meet the criteria required for the Board to approve the removal. There are not extraordinary and exceptional conditions pertaining to this particular piece of property. Also, these conditions do generally apply to other properties in the vicinity. Many are forested and contain dozens of protected/grand trees and wetlands. We need to save these trees for the health of humans and wildlife! Sep 1 2026 10:14AM Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | September 2, 2026 Bobbie Stanley Charleston When are we going to stop cutting down trees and filling wetland for ridiculous amounts of housing and people that the infrastructure can’t even handle as it is now? When will people actually care and stop making poor decisions to line their own pockets? Johns island needs more wetlands and more trees and less people, cars and houses. John’s Island is full. Sep 1 2026 10:16AM Hope Hannon 69 Rivers Point Row, Charleston SC. 29412 Please deny this application for grand tree removals!! Our Animals have suffered enough due to development and we need our trees for our environment. They help control storm waters and flooding, as well as offer habitats for our bees, birds and other wildlife, which are very important to our communities. Sep 1 2026 10:16AM Kelley Shuler-Armsey 1155 East and West Rd Why do we continue to allow money/greed to drive away the beauty and preservation of James Island. Keep building and see what nature takes back as the concrete keeps pouring. Let progress take place in another STATE. Preserve what we have left before it’s too late Sep 1 2026 10:18AM Jill Farrar 3522 Bohicket Estates Drive, Johns Island SC 29455 Dear Members of the BZA-SD: I am writing to ask you to please vote NO to the request to remove 26 grand trees located on wooded property on Johns Island - River Road. This case does not meet the BZA’s criteria required for approval of the request. The character of the district, Johns Island, will be harmed by the granting of any variance or special exception to remove over two dozen grand trees and reduce the setbacks to another 25 grand trees. These grand trees are located in a special protection flood zone. This property includes 12.5 acres of wetlands. These grand trees are critical to the management of stormwater on this property. Any approval of these grand tree removal requests will be of substantial detriment to adjacent properties and to the public good. Please deny the Sep 1 2026 10:23AM Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | September 2, 2026 developer’s request to remove these grand trees. Thank you, Jill Farrar Deborah Strickland 68 Rivers Point Row Charleston SC. 29412 Please deny the request to remove 26 grand trees. Our community needs our trees for our community and tge environment. Enough trees have been cut down on James & Johns Island and it is time for us to stand up for the public and animals of our communities good! There are not extraordinary and exceptional conditions pertaining to this particular piece of property on Johns Island! Sep 1 2026 10:25AM Whit Hathaway 2157 Medway Rd Charleston SC 29412 Please stop the planned removal of 20+ trees on Johns Island. These trees are vital to our wildlife, drainage, shade, and the natural character of Johns Island. Once mature trees are removed, they cannot be replaced. Please protect our tree canopy and natural beauty. Sep 1 2026 10:38AM Lori Johnson 4065 Oxeye Loop Johns Island Please do not cut down more grand trees. The trees are part of John’s Islsnd history. They provide habitat for do many animals. They provide shade. They help with flooding. When they are gone, they are gone and it takes over 200 years to grow a tree that size. We need to stand up and protect these trees. It is imperative for our future. Sep 1 2026 10:48AM Olivia MacDonald 366 Woodland Shores Rd This application from Mungo Homes does not meet the BZA’s criteria for grand tree removal. Please protect these valuable ecosystems. Developments like this do not align with Charleston’s City plan. Sep 1 2026 10:52AM Tanya Mart 7760 Highway 165, Ravenel Please deny the application that would remove the grand trees which does not meet the criteria required for your approval. It is absurd to have this much development without holding builders/ developers accountable to pay for the necessary infrastructure to deal with the population growth. Using outdated traffic studies, not looking at sewage spillage data, not partnering with conservationists both biological and historical. The dollar bill should not be the deciding factor - look at Sound Rivers v. Clayton Sep 1 2026 10:58AM Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | September 2, 2026 Properties Group/ Mungo Homes for a sneak peak at how your decision could affect generations to come. I am tired of this city constantly passing the problems to the next person or saying it is not their issue - it is everyone's issue. Enough is enough and I hope at some point you will remember the ethics and moral principles that should guide you to make fair and HONEST decisions regarding this development. Utilitarianism - look it up and talk to your constituents, make your decision based on that not the $. Stephanie Burgart 1102 Turkey Trot Dr Don’t allow the wetland fill or the cutting down of the grand trees above the original and strictly necessary allotment. This development should be small enough to allow for wetlands and green spaces. Sep 1 2026 11:01AM Noelle Finlay 533 Rutledge Ave, Charleston, SC 29403 Dear BZA-SD, My name is Noelle Finlay and I serve as the Conservation Project Coordinator at the Coastal Conservation League here in Charleston. Due to concerns regarding tree removal, traffic, and wetland fill, I am writing to urge the Board to deny the River-Road development. While we recognize that Charleston is facing unprecedented growth and that additional housing is necessary, the League strongly supports development that is thoughtful, sustainable, and responsive to the environmental challenges our region is facing. With the Lowcountry experiencing increasingly severe flooding, preserving tree canopy and grand trees, in particular, is critical to keeping residents safe, supporting valuable wildlife habitat and minimizing harmful stormwater runoff. Once these mature trees are removed, their ecological and stormwater management functions are gone, and cannot simply be replaced. The City of Charleston City Plan recognizes green infrastructure as having “many of the same benefits as manmade stormwater management tools for a fraction of the cost.” Protecting and expanding our tree Sep 1 2026 11:02AM Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | September 2, 2026 canopy is not only beneficial to our environment, but it's also a cost- effective investment to the safety and resilience of our community. I again encourage the Board to make decisions based on the city’s own recommendations and priorities, rather than approving development that undermines these goals. With flooding issues becoming an ever- growing threat, protecting our natural resources today will ensure a safer and more resilient community for future residents. I respectfully urge the Board to deny this proposal and prioritize responsible growth that protects trees, wetlands, and the natural environment. Thank you for your time and consideration. Noelle Finlay Conservation Project Coordinator Coastal Conservation League Kathy Banfe 1799 Towne Street Johns Island Please please do not cut down these beautiful trees!!!! These large trees are what makes this island beautiful & special. And with all the influx of new people and ridiculous amount of new homes being built, Johns Island is losing its charm! For the love of money, we are destroying Johns Island. Please STOP! Don’t cut them down. Sep 1 2026 11:04AM Yvonne Smith 2949 Waterleaf Rd Please stop the building, destroying of wetlands, trees, resulting in traffic backlog of miles. Deny, deny, deny. Sep 1 2026 11:04AM Jordan Decker 2700 Sunrose Lane I have lived on Johns Island since 2021 and have watched the progressive decline in quality of life on island as we continue to destroy natural beauty in favor of overdevelopment. We continue to beg for you to stop cutting down our live oaks, that are not only aesthetically pleasing but also assist with drainage (something we very much need in a coastal town that experiences frequent flooding and hurricanes). We continue to ask you to stop shoving in more houses, more townhomes, that only add to the worsening traffic situation. This island is already overpopulated with failing Sep 1 2026 11:05AM Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | September 2, 2026 infrastructure that will take decades to improve even slightly. I live close to this proposed development and I can tell you with absolute certainty that this will only further worsen the issues our island is already facing. Please, for once, listen to the people who actually live here, who drive in the rush hour traffic every single day, who are begging for you to choose us over greedy developers who only care about one thing. This townhome project benefits no one who actually lives here. We have TONS of housing. Multiple developments (townhomes, homes, apartments) are already being built by the hundreds. We are GOOD on housing. What we need now are improved roads. The construction alone, just across the street from apartments being built on Betsy Kerrigan, will only serve to further block up an exceedingly high traffic road. Think of an ambulance trying to get through the Maybank/River light during morning/afternoon rush. Or maybe not even an ambulance, maybe someone who is in labor, desperately trying to get downtown to the hospital in their own personal vehicle. Do you want to add another 150 cars to that situation? Do you want a loved one to get the care they need in a timely manner? Or do you want to condemn us all? Maybank/River is one of TWO exits off this island. What if there is a mandatory evacuation with a future hurricane? Please don’t approve this. We don’t need more housing on this island. We need public officials who fight for their constituents. Please vote against this. Please. Beth Matenaer 4065 east Amy lane. Johns island sc 29455 1000% leave the trees alone ! We can do better as humans! Sep 1 2026 11:11AM Jason Aultman 2923 Sarnoff St. Stop building high density housing without proper infrastructure. Greedy builders are destroying this island. Sep 1 2026 11:16AM Alicia Van Sickle 1748 Towne Street As noted by the developer, due to the limited amount of buildable land, what implications will this have for run Sep 1 2026 11:19AM Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | September 2, 2026 off as it ties to the newly completed flood mitigation project through Burberry Woods and The Cottages at Johns Island? Will the removal of the trees exasperate the flooding? Pat Luzadder 4314 Hope Plantation Please do NOT cut down trees. For a wide variety of important reasons (see all comments), vote NO! Sep 1 2026 11:23AM Elliot Treece 5512 Cypress Cottage Ln This development seems like the kind of development we desperately need to prevent. Removing grand trees, adding unsustainable traffic to an area that is already a nightmare, and filling in wetlands which only makes flooding more of an issue. These projects do not help us grow the right way or improve the overall quality of life for the residents of Johns Island. Sep 1 2026 11:23AM Careen Jensen 904 Lansfaire Dr., Charleston, SC 29414 I am writing to oppose the removal of the grand oaks in the proposed River Road Townhomes project. The grand oaks trees are supposed to be protected trees and we see all over the Charleston area new development and the destruction of these trees. The grand tree removal in this project does not meet the requirements of the BZA-SD. Please do not approve this project or any other project without the developer meeting the requirements. Sep 1 2026 11:28AM JERI CISSNA 5099 HUT CREEK ROAD JOHNS ISLAND SC 29455 Please DENY this application for grand trees removal - this removal request does not meet the criteria to be approved Sep 1 2026 11:28AM Lorri Hurley 1450 Fort Johnson Rd Please just stop cutting away everything that made the Lowcountry special. The trees, the peace and serenity of a visit to John’s Island. I remember driving out there 20 years ago when I moved here to visit the old Rosebank Farms and was in awe of the trees, the quiet and unspoiled landscape. Now I drive out there and it’s nothing but traffic congestion, frustrated angry drivers honking their horns and homes that people who live and work in this city can’t afford. The trees are an integral part of our cities identity. Think about what you are Sep 1 2026 11:42AM Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | September 2, 2026 doing now and the impact on the future. Channing Botts 1762 Towne St Good morning, I am writing to please urge you to deny this application for the grand trees removal. It is my understanding there are 26 trees that they are trying to remove, and they are not meeting the criteria to do so. My husband and I are longtime locals and have lived together on John’s Island now for almost 10 years. Our home backs up to this area that you were trying to remove trees from we have beautiful wildlife, birds, animals that depend on these trees for their home, not to mention how much it means to my husband and I to walk out every morning and see the beautiful John’s Island landscape that we grew up, knowing almost 25 years prior. I hope that you understand, and have the good faith to do so, that if the criteria is not being met to remove these trees, you must deny the application. We are a growing community and we love our community, but the removal of trees to build these additional homes seems unfair to the wildlife or the wetlands that it’s surrounds, and your neighbors. I appreciate you taking the time to hear our comments. Sep 1 2026 11:43AM Caroline deGolian 700 Daniel Ellis Drive Dear Chair and members of the Board of Zoning Appeals-Site Design, I strongly urge you to DENY the River Road Townhomes (Mungo Homes) development any variance or special exception to the Zoning Ordinance. The developer wants to cut down 26 grand trees on Johns Island and fill wetlands to build 105 townhomes, which would only decrease the character of the area, exacerbate flooding, and add hundreds of cars to an already overloaded traffic grid. In order to approve a variance in "an individual case of unnecessary hardship", the Board must find that "1. there are extraordinary and exceptional conditions pertaining to the particular piece of property; 2. These conditions do not generally Sep 1 2026 11:44AM Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | September 2, 2026 apply to other property in the vicinity; 3. Because of these conditions, the application of the ordinance to the particular piece of property would effectively prohibit or unreasonably restrict the utilization of the property; and 4. The authorization of the variance will not be of substantial detriment to adjacent property or to the public good, and the character of the district will not be harmed by the granting of the variance." There are NOT extraordinary and exceptional conditions pertaining to the property; and these conditions DO generally apply to other properties in the vicinity, as many properties in the vicinity on Johns Island have dozens of protected trees, grand trees, and wetlands. An authorization of a variance to the Zoning Ordinance WOULD be of substantial detriment to adjacent property AND to the public good. I strongly urge the Board to protect our Lowcountry sea island communities from overdevelopment. Thank you. Rebecca Waechter 2949 Cavalcade Circle, Johns Island, SC 29455 This request for grand tree removal does not meet the criteria for removal and would put added stress on the congested River/Maybank intersection. Sep 1 2026 11:47AM Sam Pagano 1108 Colossians Ct, Johns Island. No more tearing down grand trees on wetlands for townhomes until roads and environmental impact is addressed. It’s madness Sep 1 2026 11:48AM Amanda Townsend 1316 Kruger Avenue, Charleston, SC 29407 Please deny the application from Mungo Homes to remove the grand trees. These trees are a vital part of the lowcountry ecosystem and are located in a Stormwater Special Protection Area (SPA) and therefore should not be removed. This plan also doesn't include any of the trees that are graded "F" that will also be removed, we (citizens) need a full plan of exactly what is being removed prior to issuing any type of approval. Sep 1 2026 11:53AM Amanda Townsend 1316 Kruger Avenue, Charleston, SC 29407 Please deny the application from Mungo Homes to remove the grand trees. These trees are a vital part of Sep 1 2026 11:53AM Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | September 2, 2026 the lowcountry ecosystem and are located in a Stormwater Special Protection Area (SPA) and therefore should not be removed. This plan also doesn't include any of the trees that are graded "F" that will also be removed, we (citizens) need a full plan of exactly what is being removed prior to issuing any type of approval. Jeffery Brown 2862 Sugarberry Lane, Johns Island, SC I am extremely frustrated to hear about this project requesting zoning variance to remove 29 and encroach upon even more grand trees. This concept is asking for zoning variances as is they are just a rubber stamp, has become a complete slap in the face. Why would the owner/developer think this is even a viable request? Please reject this ridiculous request outright. The ZBA has no reason to even consider such a request, and it's not your job to "fix" the fact that they bought land with so many large trees upon it. You have an opportunity to make a statement, that zoning rules are in place for a reason, and cannot and will not be run over roughshod by developers. Sep 1 2026 11:53AM Jennifer Mills 2904 Bohicket Road, Johns Island I realize this meeting is about the grand trees. I hope the Council will deny the requested variance to allow the removal of 19 grand trees, a special exception to allow the removal of 7 grand trees, and a variance to allow the reduction in the impervious construction setback near the bases of 25 grand trees. I also hope Council requires a traffic study and communicates with the public about any conclusions the study has. It seems it would be difficult for a traffic study to conclude that adding this amount of traffic this close to a failed intersection is in the best interest of the City, the County, and its residents. Thank you for thinking through the situation completely and not focusing on just tax revenues. Sep 1 2026 11:53AM Marlo Mytty 1134 Lining Ct Dear NZA, please deny this request to remove grand trees. We have lost far too many trees and too many Sep 1 2026 12:00PM Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | September 2, 2026 exceptions are granted. Make the developer build around them or not at all. That's what ordinances are for. Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | September 2, 2026 I strongly oppose the requested variances and special exception for the River Road project on Johns Island that would allow the removal of 29 grand trees and reduce the required impervious-construction setbacks around another 26 grand trees. Grand trees are protected for a reason. They are an irreplaceable part of the character, ecology, and natural beauty of Johns Island. They provide shade, absorb stormwater, reduce heat, support wildlife, and help preserve the tree canopy that makes River Road and Johns Island so distinctive. A variance should be an exception necessitated by an unusual hardship, not a mechanism for allowing a development plan to remove or compromise dozens of protected trees. If a proposed project cannot reasonably be built while complying with the County’s grand-tree protections, the appropriate response should be to redesign the project, not weaken the protections. This request is especially troubling because it does not involve one or two trees. It involves removing 29 grand trees, 20 by variance and another 9 by special exception, while reducing construction setbacks around 26 more. That is potentially 55 grand trees affected by a single development. River Road is already experiencing enormous development pressure. Once these mature trees are cut, they cannot simply be replaced. A newly planted tree will take generations to provide the ecological, aesthetic, and community benefits of a grand tree. I respectfully ask the Board to deny these requests and require the applicant to redesign the project around the protected trees. Johns Island’s grand-tree ordinance should mean something, particularly when development pressure is at its greatest. Please forward my comments to the BZA-SD. Sincerely, Elizabeth Wenner, Ph.D. 2027 Leadenwah Dr, Wadmalaw Island, SC 29487 843-442-2253 Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | September 2, 2026 Hello, the public input form is not working, can you please forward my comments to the BZA-SD. I am asking the board to deny this application for the grand tree removal. This property and proposed townhomes is in a Stormwater Special Protection Area. Do we know how this removal would affect the surrounding areas? I am a resident of the Cottages at John's Island. With the completion of the Ecological Park (that removed hundreds of trees and severely impacted the natural landscape in this area, destroyed wildlife habitat, and changed what our neighborhood looks like), do we know how this removal could negatively impact the work that was done there? Towne Street has become a cut through for everyone avoiding the huge traffic snarl that is at Maybank and Main and now is a speedway that has become dangerous for our neighborhood. Do we need to add the potential of 210 plus cars to our already very congested area? I love John's Island and would welcome more residents, but not to a protected space in an already overcrowded area with no infrastructure to support it. Thank you, Emily Kearley 1831 Towne Street John’s Island, SC 29455 Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | September 2, 2026 Hey Eric, I hope all is well. It’s Gary Worth. Please let’s stop cutting down all these trees on John’s Island for development. I’m not a tree hugger but sooner or later we have got to rain it in. Thank you. Interior Woodworking 843-345-3299 Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | September 2, 2026 B. New Applications 2. 2241 Ashley Crossing Drive West Ashley | Council District 2 | TMS# 309-00-00-017 | Zoned: GB Request a variance from Sec. 54-347 to allow a reduced landscape buffer. Owner: 3P Real Estate Holdings 1 LLC Applicant: Forsberg Engineering & Surveying, Inc. No comments submitted 3. 15 Radcliffe Street Radcliffeborough | Council District 4 | TMS# 460-16-02-033 & 041 | Zoned: GB Request a variance from Sec. 54-327 to omit the 15 protected trees per acre requirement. Request a variance from Sec. 54-330 to allow a reduction in the minimum impervious construction setback near the bases of two grand trees. Owner: Warren Place A Joint Venture Applicant: Thomas & Hutton No comments submitted 4. Clements Ferry Road Cainhoy | Council District 1 | Unimproved right-of-way south of I-526 | Zoned: N/A Request a variance from Sec 54-831 to omit sidewalks and street trees for a portion of t he road to be improved/paved. Owner: Berkeley County/City of Charleston Applicant: SeamonWhiteside & Associates 1 Comment in Opposition First Name Last Name Address Submitted Comment Date/Time Submitted W. Andrew Gowder, Jr. 1629 Meeting Street, Suite A, Charleston, S.C. 29405 (law firm address) Dear Chair and Members of the Board: I write on behalf of Peter and Lydia Sniderman, adjacent landowners and residents of St. Thomas Island, in opposition to an application for a variance from the applicable right-of- way requirements for the Subject Road. As we understand the application, the applicant seeks relief that would eliminate the otherwise required sidewalks and street trees for a proposed marina and residential project on the nearby Sandusky parcel to be undertaken by Clouter Creek LLC, which has a Memorandum of Agreement with the City and Berkeley County for that purpose. The Board should deny the requested variance. Sep 1 2026 11:32AM Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | September 2, 2026 The application rests on unresolved questions of jurisdiction and property rights, and the present record does not support the written findings required under South Carolina law for a variance. 1. The Board should not grant site-design relief until annexation and jurisdiction over the Subject Road are resolved. The City’s memorandum of agreement with Berkeley County and Clouter Creek makes the City’s jurisdiction over the Subject Road contingent upon annexation, if approved. The agreement further contemplates that, after annexation, roadway, access, and encroachment approvals will be sought from the City only after annexation. The City does not intend to proceed to the third reading of the annexation until Berkeley County resolves the encroachment issue. Accordingly, the right-of-way in question may not yet be within the City. It would be premature for the BZA-SD to grant a permanent departure from City site-design requirements for a road whose annexation, governing jurisdiction, and final regulatory pathway remain incomplete. The Board should require the applicant to establish a present, lawful basis for the requested City approval rather than treating future annexation as a substitute for the prerequisite jurisdictional determination. 2. The ownership and legal scope of the right-of-way are disputed and cannot be assumed away. The current record identifies an unresolved encroachment involving the Shaw property at the road’s narrow point. Questions remain about the actual limits of the right-of-way and whether Berkeley County completed any earlier condemnation on the affected owners. Unless and until a competent authority resolves those questions, the Shaw family’s homes and property interests must be treated as legally existing in place. The Board need not—and should not— Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | September 2, 2026 purport to adjudicate title, easement, or condemnation issues in this variance proceeding. But it likewise cannot presume a broader right-of- way, the relocation of homes, or a future taking in order to find that the project can be served without compliance with the ordinary standards. The unresolved property- right question is not peripheral. It goes directly to the claimed justification for abandoning sidewalks and street trees and to whether the proposed access configuration can lawfully be implemented at all. 3. A speculative future condemnation cannot supply the basis for this variance. The requested variance appears driven by the applicant’s desire to avoid the consequences of a roadway width that does not accommodate the City’s ordinary sidewalk and street-tree requirements. The alternative sometimes suggested—widening the road through the Shaw property— raises serious constitutional concerns that should not be normalized or implicitly assumed in this proceeding. Article I, section 13 of the South Carolina Constitution prohibits condemnation of private property for a private use and provides that property may not be condemned for a purpose or benefit, including economic development, unless the condemnation is for a public use. S.C. Const. art. I, § 13. On the present information, any widening at the Shaw “pinch point” appears to be needed only to facilitate access for Clouter Creek’s private marina and residential development. Whether any governmental entity could establish a genuine public use for a taking under those circumstances is, at minimum, an unresolved legal question. The BZA- SD should not grant the requested relief on an assumption that the Shaw homes can later be removed or that a taking will validate the project’s preferred roadway design. A variance proceeding is not the vehicle to pre- Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | September 2, 2026 commit the City, Berkeley County, or affected residents to that outcome. 4. The applicant has not shown the statutorily required unnecessary hardship. South Carolina law permits a variance only upon written findings that: (a) extraordinary and exceptional conditions pertain to the particular property; (b) those conditions do not generally apply to nearby property; (c) strict application of the ordinance would effectively prohibit or unreasonably restrict use of the property; and (d) the variance will not substantially harm adjacent property or the public good or the character of the district. S.C. Code § 6-29- 800(A)(2). Each finding is required; the statute also expressly provides that a more profitable use is not a valid ground for a variance. The alleged hardship here is not an extraordinary feature that prevents reasonable use of the Sandusky parcel. It arises from Clouter Creek’s elected plan to intensify the site with a marina and residential subdivision that require an access configuration beyond the existing road’s capacity. The owner may access the property for private purposes and may locate a residence on the property without widening the road or dispensing with the usual street improvements. The application therefore seeks an accommodation for a chosen, higher-intensity development program—not relief from an ordinance that prohibits or unreasonably restricts all reasonable use of the land. South Carolina appellate authority confirms that a property owner cannot establish unnecessary hardship through conditions the owner created. Georgetown Cnty. Bldg. Official v. Lewis, 290 S.C. 513, 351 S.E.2d 584 (Ct. App. 1986). And a variance is an exceptional remedy, not permission to accept an avoidable design inconvenience: the Supreme Court has rejected a variance where a proposal could be rearranged to conform to the Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | September 2, 2026 regulation. Hodge v. Pollock, 223 S.C. 342, 75 S.E.2d 752 (1953). The Court of Appeals likewise has recognized that a claimed hardship based on an owner-created condition or a preexisting restriction does not compel variance relief. Black v. Lexington Cnty. Bd. of Zoning Appeals, 396 S.C. 453, 722 S.E.2d 22 (Ct. App. 2012). The applicant has not demonstrated that the existing right- of-way requirement itself deprives the property of reasonable use. At most, the requirement may prevent the applicant from maximizing the private economic return of its preferred marina-and-subdivision development. That is not unnecessary hardship under section 6-29-800. 5. The record cannot support a finding of no substantial detriment to adjacent owners or the public good. First, the overall purpose of this variance request must not be lost. The applicant seeks this relief to improve this private gravel/dirt road, enabling planned large-scale, dense commercial and residential development that is not possible without substantial road improvements. This Board need not assist in that project without a clear view of the long-term implications of these developments for the families and children who live there, who walk along these roads, and who live and play in their homes and yards. The requested variance would dispense with pedestrian and streetscape features ordinarily required to protect safety and community character. It would do so along a road serving island residents and adjacent properties, at a location already affected by an unresolved encroachment and potential impacts on the Shaw family’s homes. These are concrete concerns for adjacent landowners and the public—not merely generalized opposition. Granting relief now would also create a substantial risk of prejudging the still-pending decisions concerning Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | September 2, 2026 annexation, right-of-way boundaries, roadway design, access approvals, and the project’s final TRC review. The Board cannot make the required no- detriment finding on a record that leaves those foundational matters unresolved. Requested Action For these reasons, the Snidermans respectfully request that the BZA-SD deny the variance application. In the alternative, the Board should defer action until the applicant establishes: (1) that the Subject Road has been lawfully annexed and is within the City’s jurisdiction; (2) the lawful boundaries and status of the applicable right-of-way, without assuming displacement of the Shaw family or a future condemnation; (3) the final roadway and access design; and (4) competent evidence supporting each written finding required by S.C. Code § 6-29- 800(A)(2). Thank you for considering these comments and for protecting the integrity of the City’s site-design standards, the rights of adjacent owners, and the public interest. Respectfully submitted, W. Andrew Gowder, Jr. Austen & Gowder, LLC Counsel for Peter and Lydia Sniderman

Source: City of Charleston website. First collected Oct 14, 2026.