RecordWell Data

BAR-L Meeting (Additional Public Comment)

City of Charleston · Berkeley County · meeting of Aug 31, 2026 · Agendas

Open the original document More from City of Charleston

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

The Council of South Carolina Professional Archaeologists www.coscapa.org August 27, 2026 City of Charleston Board of Architectural Review - Large C/O B.D. Wortham-Galvin, City Architect SUBJECT: Comment on Application 1. 106 Coming Street, August 31, 2026 Dear Members of the Board: As a Registered Professional Archaeologist (RPA) and current president of the Council of South Carolina Professional Archaeologists (COSCAPA), I write today to implore BAR-L to defer action on the College’s proposal to build a student dorm at 106 Coming Street. The BAR has clear standards for preservation that include the protection and preservation of archaeological resources: “Archeological resources will be protected and preserved in place. If such resources must be disturbed, mitigation measures will be undertaken” (BAR General Guidelines, pg. 14, emphasis added). Charleston’s second-oldest public cemetery, which lies underneath the asphalt at 106 Coming Street, is, by definition, an archaeological site. Other significant archaeological resources likely exist beneath the asphalt within the project’s footprint. But many questions about the project and the extent and nature of the archaeology remain unanswered. Must the CofC build a dorm at 106 Coming Street? Although the College insists that developing this site is a must, to date, the administration has failed to provide the public and affiliated communities with a transparent, complete accounting of its consideration of alternative sites. Members of the Community Engagement Council (CEC) have noted this fact at several of their monthly meetings and formally requested more information, especially about the financial basis of its consideration of alternatives. Yet the College has not been forthcoming. In addition to the BAR standards, a thorough consideration of alternatives is also a core ethical principle governing whether burial sites should be disturbed under the Advisory Council on Historic Preservation’s Policy Statement on Burial Sites, Human Remains, and Funerary Objects (see Principle 2, March 1, 2023). These principles are written into the conditions of the project’s Coastal Zone Consistency determination. For this project, these are requirements to be followed, not advisory guidance. Although the Board’s immediate task is to review the architectural design, the appropriateness of the design cannot be separated from the College’s choice, despite community objections, to place it on a documented burial ground with local, national, and international significance. Are appropriate mitigation measures proposed? Archaeological data recovery can mitigate information loss when a site is to be destroyed, but excavation itself is destructive. Once soil layers, features, artifacts, and burials are removed from their original relationships, the archaeological resource cannot be restored. The tradeoff can be acceptable for the remains of a house or other building when avoidance is impossible. It takes on a fundamentally different ethical character when the resource is a known burial ground, avoidance has not been shown to be impossible, and descendant and affiliated communities have not supported disturbance. Careful excavation may document what is destroyed. It cannot make disinterment without community support respectful or ethically acceptable. What is the College giving back to the descendant and affiliated communities to mitigate the harm done to them by removing graves without their assent? A commemorative gallery and a sign in a narrow passage that says nothing about why individuals were removed, how that removal occurred, or that the removal occurred without community support is neither just nor restorative, and it is certainly not mitigative. Choices of appropriate interpretive and memorial products should always be developed in consultation with descendant and affiliated communities. However, by failing to consult with these communities on the fundamental question of development, the College has undermined their own efforts to consult on products. It is also worth noting that in April, COSCAPA took a public position against the 106 Coming Street project primarily because the College of Charleston was refusing to meaningfully consult with affiliated communities on the most important question to them: should this burial ground be developed for a student dorm (see Smith and Barnes, P&C, April 10, 2026). That continues to be the case. The College is clearly trying to rush BAR-L approval. Were it not, the College would have waited at least until the latest GPR report had been reviewed by the SC SHPO and shared with the CEC and the public. But even that report will not provide a complete archaeological assessment. The condition and extent of exposed archaeological features can be evaluated only AFTER the asphalt has been removed. That uncertainty is reason enough to defer. What is found could require a materially different design or demonstrate more fully why building here at all is inappropriate. The only responsible action the BAR-L can take today is to defer the decision until more information is available and the currently available information, along with what is learned from the exposure of features, has been reviewed by SC SHPO, the CEC, consulting Tribal Nations, and the public. Respectfully submitted, Karen Y. Smith, Ph.D., RPA # 32973293 President

Source: City of Charleston website. First collected Oct 14, 2026.