RecordWell Data

BAR-L Public Comment

City of Charleston · Berkeley County · meeting of Aug 31, 2026 · Agendas

Open the original document More from City of Charleston

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

CITY OF CHARLESTON BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW – LARGE PUBLIC COMMENT AUGUST 31, 2026 A meeting of the Board of Architectural Review – Large (BAR -L) will be held on Monday, August 31, 2026 at 4:30 p.m. in the Public Meeting Room, First Floor, 2 George Street. The following written comments will be provided to the board members 24 hours in advance of the meeting. The comments will also be acknowledged into the record and summarized. The public is encouraged to attend the meeting in person to speak in order for comments to be fully heard. Application information is available at www.charleston-sc.gov/bar. Please check the website on the meeting date to view any withdrawn or deferred agenda items. For additional information, please contact: Department of Planning & Preservation | 843-724-3781 B. APPLICATIONS 1. 106 Coming Street BAR2026-002703 | TMS #4601603017 | Radcliffeborough | Council District 4 New Construction | Height Districts 4, 8 | Old City District Requesting Conceptual Approval of a student housing building. Owner: College of Charleston Applicant: College of Charleston 32 Comments Submitted: • Omar Muhammad, Summerville, SC Submitted to Innovate Site on Aug. 24. 2026 2:43 PM Good Afternoon, Chair and Members of the Board. My name is Omar Muhammad, and I appreciate the opportunity to return before you regarding 106 Coming Street. At the first conceptual review, the community asked this Board to consider a fundamental question: Is the architecture being organized around the historic significance of this place, or is the history being organized around the building? That question remains before us today. Since the first meeting, the applicant has provided additional information concerning the historic municipal burying ground, including excerpts from the January 29, 2026 letter from the State Historic Preservation Office. I believe it is important that the Board understand precisely what SHPO determined and what it did not determine. The presentation highlights SHPO's conclusion that the burying ground does not retain the integrity necessary for eligibility under National Register Criterion A. It also highlights SHPO's discussion of the possibility that previous development may have affected archaeological integrity under Criterion D. But those excerpts do not tell the complete story. SHPO did not determine that this site has no historical significance. In fact, SHPO stated exactly the opposite: "The importance of the burying ground's history is well Board of Architectural Review – Large Public Comment | April 8, 2026 Page 2 established by the documentary record." SHPO further stated that there is "excellent and extensive evidence" that this property was used as a cemetery from the 1790s through 1807. Regarding archaeological significance under Criterion D, SHPO did not determine that archaeological integrity has been lost. SHPO said there is not currently sufficient information to make that determination. That distinction is critical. Undetermined archaeological integrity is not the same thing as an absence of historical significance and physical disturbance is not the same thing as historical erasure. The National Register's technical standards for archaeological integrity should not be confused with the broader historical and cultural significance of this place. SHPO itself recognizes that distinction and this Board has already recognized it. In its previous consideration of this property, the City acknowledged the socio-cultural significance associated with the YWCA and required that significance to receive a highly visible physical manifestation in the new development. SHPO has also determined that the YWCA at 106 Coming Street is individually eligible for the National Register under Criteria A and B for Social History, Black Ethnic Heritage, Civil Rights, and Women's History. So, there should be no question before this Board about whether this place possesses historical and cultural significance. It does. The question is what the architecture does in response to that significance and that brings me back to the concerns raised at the first meeting. The revised proposal uses the language of celebration, commemoration, and contemplation. I appreciate those intentions. But commemoration is not simply a matter of programming. It is also a matter of space. The building footprint still dominates this historically significant property. The architecture continues to establish the boundaries within which commemoration must occur, rather than the historic landscape establishing the boundaries within which development should occur. That is the fundamental problem with this conceptual plan. A site associated with Charleston's early municipal burying ground, the Black YWCA, Black women's leadership, Civil Rights, education, community gathering, and generations of Black life should not be treated as an ordinary development parcel with commemorative features added to it. This is a Black cultural landscape, and a cultural landscape requires sufficient physical space to remain legible as a place. It needs space for remembrance, space for reflection, space for education, space for ceremony, space for community gathering, and space that allows future generations to understand that something profoundly important happened here. If the buildings consume the overwhelming majority of the property and memorialization is compressed into pathways, galleries, and spaces between building masses, then the project may commemorate history, but it does not allow that history to organize the site. That distinction matters. At the first meeting, community members stated that architecture communicates values through hierarchy. I believe that remains true. When we look at this plan, we should ask: What has been given the greatest amount of land, What has been given the greatest visual prominence, and What has been required to fit around everything else? Those choices tell us what the project considers primary. The applicant's own historical research, this Board's previous findings, and now SHPO's letter all establish that this property carries extraordinary historical and cultural meaning. The appropriate design response should therefore be more than interpretation of that history. The land allocation itself should express that history. That means reducing or reorganizing the building footprint and providing a larger, coherent, publicly accessible commemorative landscape, not simply distributing commemorative elements throughout a Board of Architectural Review – Large Public Comment | April 8, 2026 Page 3 predominantly residential development. And there is another reason for caution. SHPO has expressly stated that it does not yet have sufficient archaeological information to determine whether the burying ground retains integrity under Criterion D. That determination remains unresolved. It is difficult to understand why the City should establish the permanent conceptual footprint of the buildings before the archaeological investigation necessary to understand the site. The archaeology should inform the site plan. The site plan should not predetermine the archaeology. I therefore respectfully ask this Board not to treat SHPO's letter as a determination that this property lacks historical significance. It is not. I also ask the Board to require the design team to reconsider the scale and organization of the building footprint and dedicate substantially more of this historic landscape to meaningful, visible, and publicly accessible commemoration and memorialization. And where archaeological questions remain unresolved, I ask that the City's conceptual approval not get ahead of the preservation and archaeological review necessary to answer those questions. At the first meeting, members of the community stated that Black landscapes matter because memory needs space. The additional information we now have only strengthens that principle. Historical significance does not disappear because a landscape has been disturbed. Memory does not disappear because buildings were constructed over it -- and the people buried here, the women who organized here, and the generations of Charleston residents whose lives are connected to this place should not have their history measured only by what physically survived the development that came afterward. This Board now has an opportunity to require something better: A project where commemoration is not accommodated by the architecture, but where the architecture is shaped by the responsibility to commemorate. If buildings shape spaces, then at 106 Coming Street, this historic landscape should shape the buildings not the other way around. I ask the board to defer until additional archaeological data is provided. The applicant's project work plans do not meet this threshold. Thank you for your time and consideration. • Paula Brady, 12 George St., A4 Submitted to Innovate Site on Aug. 24, 2026 5:51 PM BAR - residents ask to first know what lies beneath the surface of 106 Coming St., Before you build the CofC structure. First, respectfully determine the bodies and artifacts that lie below Before the building is approved and done over a likely ancestry site. • Larry Musetti, 98 Logan St. Submitted to Innovate Site on Aug. 25, 2026 9:21 AM How can CofC not comply with a BAR recent ruling and yet asks for BAR approval again. Something is very much amiss in Charleston when citizens keep voicing their concerns about CofC plans for 106 Coming and nothing stops the college from getting what they want. BAR has ruled to defer conceptual approval of the CofC proposed development at 106 Coming Street until archaeological investigation is completed. 106 Coming has extraordinary historical significance as one of Charleston’s oldest public burial grounds and its connection to the former YWCA of Greater Charleston. This alone warranted that BAR obtain a more complete understanding of the location and subsurface cultural resources before approval of building design Board of Architectural Review – Large Public Comment | April 8, 2026 Page 4 was considered. With little additional information provided by CofC, the project somehow was scheduled to return to the BAR-L agenda on AUGUST 31. CofC and their paid consultants appear to be asserting that the required archaeological planning and review processes have been sufficiently addressed, and that they should now be allowed to move the project forward for BAR consideration. I disagree! The fact remains that CofC knows the history of the site, but CofC has done not enough to know what lies beneath the surface today. • WiBi Ashley, 99 Sans Souci Street Apt. B Submitted to Innovate Site on Aug. 26, 2026 1:32 PM I strongly oppose moving forward with this project before we fully understand and respect what is beneath this ground. This is not simply a piece of land waiting to be developed. This is a historic burial ground where enslaved Africans and people of African descent, free people of color, poor white citizens, orphans, strangers, and others were laid to rest. These were people. They had lives, families, stories, and histories that are part of Charleston. Before any further consideration or approval of this project, the archaeological investigation must be completed and the findings made available to the public. We cannot continue to build over history and then try to remember it afterward. As someone who works in the museum space and in preserving and interpreting history, I believe we have a responsibility to listen to what the land is telling us and to honor those who came before us. I urge BAR-L to defer approval of this project until the archaeological work is complete and the public has the opportunity to understand the full significance of this burial ground. Let the ground speak first… • Laura Isenstein, 4 Beaufain St. Submitted to Innovate Site on Aug. 26, 2026 1:40 PM I urge the BAR-L to defer conceptual approval again until archaeological investigations have been completed and their findings are available to the public. Decisions about the future of this site should be based on a complete public record of the historic burial ground and its significance. • Elizabeth Cahill, Ladson St. Submitted to Innovate Site on Aug. 26, 2026 1:44 PM It is ironic that an out-of-town developer of a for-profit project, namely the Four Seasons Hotel, is demonstrating the kind of care for and stewardship of historic resources that we would expect from our College of Charleston. The recent discoveries underneath the Four Seasons site are significant in contributing to our understanding of Charleston's history; without that knowledge we remain unable to honor often-forgotten elements of the past. It is essential that before moving forward, the site at 106 Coming Street be fully investigated and understood. This was the BAR-L's request at the last meeting, and the request has not been honored. Instead, the College has submitted already existing plans for future archaeological investigation and commemoration, which sounds rather vague. With hundreds of pages of ground-penetrating radar results still under review and with NO archaeological investigations underway, the BAR-L still lacks the information necessary to undertake a fully-informed review of the proposal. Any decisions Board of Architectural Review – Large Public Comment | April 8, 2026 Page 5 about the future of 106 Coming Street should be premised on a complete public record of the historic burial ground and its significance. • Belk Daughtridge, 51 Church St. Submitted to Innovate Site on Aug. 26, 2026 2:17PM I believe that some research should be done, but at the end of the day, it’s a Pottersfield and it’s already had construction on it. I believe that the college should utilize the space for dormitories.. Far better to have freshman close to campus as opposed to busing around the city. It land to the quality of life of the environment. • Brandy Culp, 59 America St. Submitted to Innovate Site on Aug. 26, 2026 2:26 PM It is absolutely imperative that the BAR defer conceptual approval again until archaeological investigations have been completed and their findings are available to the public. Decisions about the future of this site should be based on a complete public record of the historic burial ground and its significance. Recent discoveries across the Charleston peninsula underscore that when the historical record points to significant archaeological resources, they are often still present. Before making decisions about a project of this scale at a documented burial ground, it is essential that the site be fully investigated and understood. • Peter Brainard Jr., 58 Warren St. Submitted to Innovate Site on Aug. 26, 2026 3:01 PM I live only about 150 yards away from this proposed project, and understand that once approved will cause a lot of noise and traffic for several years before it is complete. However, this dorm will both take some students out of the historic house rentals in Radcliffeborough and Harleston Village, and put those students under a bit more control by the college. Also, these added dorm rooms will permit lower income in-state SC students the opportunity to stay on campus and not pay exorbitant rents for 12 months a year compared to dorm rental at a lower cost for only 10 months. We have lived full time in Radcliffeborough for over 8 years. Please approve this. • Maggie Woodruff, 969 Portabella Lane Submitted to Innovate Site on Aug. 26, 2026 3:24 PM Please defer conceptual approval again until archaeological investigations have been completed and their findings are available to the public. • Millicent Brown, 1965 Camp Road Submitted to Innovate Site on Aug. 26, 2026 3:34 PM Necessary site information that was not available at the BAR-L's last meeting concerning this unpopular and controversial project is STILL not available. NO degree of design adjustments should override the unanimous wishes of the Council to receive substantive information about the site prior to granting approval. Moreover, BAR-L's guidelines and regulations acknowledge that a site's historic significance IS a part of the criteria for conceptual design approval. The College of Charleston appears to be determined to meet a schedule for funding purposes that ignores the determination of the Council Board of Architectural Review – Large Public Comment | April 8, 2026 Page 6 which is insulting to its members and the community they represent. The site is too important to allow bad planning on the College's part (insufficient housing to accommodate the school's growth) to force premature decision making by the city's officials. • Steven Creedman, 8 George St. Submitted to Innovate Site on Aug. 26, 2026 5:04 PM C of C needs to pause it’s efforts to have the Board approve plans for it’s new mega-dorm until all archeological investigations of the property have concluded and the Board (and the public) have seen the report. My opinion of the submitted architectural rendering of the proposed dorm? Excessively large, out of scale for the surrounding neighborhood! • Judy Klimt Houston, 503 E Lakeview Avenue Submitted to Innovate Site on Aug. 26, 2026 8:10 PM To the Members of the Board of Architectural Review: I am writing on behalf of the Descendant Community of Milwaukee County Grounds Cemeteries, Inc., a descendant-led nonprofit organization advocating for the preservation and dignified treatment of historic burial grounds in Milwaukee, Wisconsin. Our community has experienced firsthand the lasting consequences when development decisions affecting historic cemeteries are made before the location and extent of burials are adequately understood. Once construction and design decisions move forward, opportunities for avoidance, preservation, and meaningful commemoration can be permanently lost. We respectfully urge the Board to defer conceptual approval of the proposed development at 106 Coming Street until sufficient investigation has been completed to establish a more complete understanding of the historic burial ground and the potential effects of the proposed development. The presence of a burial ground should inform the design—not be addressed after the design has advanced. Deferral at this stage is not opposition to development. It is a reasonable preservation measure that allows informed decisions to be made before they become difficult or impossible to reverse. Thank you for recognizing the significance of this sacred space and for ensuring that preservation and respect for those buried there remain central to the decision-making process. Judy -- Judy Klimt Houston, President & Founder Descendant Community of Milwaukee County Grounds Cemeteries, Inc. jhouston@descendantcommunity.org (262)364-6432 Website: https://descendantcommunity.org/ • Allison Sterrett-Krause, 854 Locksley Drive Submitted to Innovate Site on Aug. 26, 2026 8:23 PM The proposal under consideration has not been materially altered since its previous consideration by this board. No additional archaeological evidence has been revealed that would justify the architectural plan and its phasing. The plan has not been substantially revised to account for historical considerations (such as the anticipated extent of the cemetery). The so-called commemoration space is still an alley coupled with a student lounge: hardly a fitting memorial or quiet place for contemplation. The plans should not be approved as presented. The college should be required to delay resubmission until the plans have been materially altered to 1) account for information gathered from permitted archaeological analysis; 2) adjust massing of buildings to the northeastern corner of the site in the first phase, to begin construction on less Board of Architectural Review – Large Public Comment | April 8, 2026 Page 7 sensitive parts of the site; 3) incorporate a garden or public park — not an alley or interior space — for commemoration of the previous inhabitants (living and dead) of the site. • Pat DeMarco, 1430 Brian Rd. Submitted to Innovate Site on Aug. 26, 2026 10:39 PM Conceptual approval should not be deferred, and should instead approve it without delay. This is a worthy project that will help alleviate the current rental housing crunch in the peninsula around C of C's campus, which has become a critical issue for both students and longtime renters in the neighborhood. We must work to keep the peninsula affordable for everyone, not just the wealthy. • Thomas Orth, 515 Robert Daniel Drive, Apt. 2309 Submitted to Innovate Site on Aug. 26, 2026 10:47 PM First, I urge BAR members to defer approval on Monday August 31 of the new proposed College of Charleston dormitory at 106 Coming Street. It is extremely unlikely that C of C in a few short weeks with Liollio Architecture Firm has developed a new design for recognizing the historic Black YWCA (that drew National Attention) from 1964-2010). We ALL remember the last BAR meeting when the College and Liollio proposed to save bricks from the YWCA building for a wall. How insulting to the famous Black women who organized and operated a nationally known and respected YWCA that benefited literally thousands of Black Charleston women and their children from 1964 til approximately 2014. Respectfully, please turn down any request from the College and Liollio Architecture Firm to proceed at this time. • Kathleen Turner, 2919 Rutherford Way Submitted to Innovate Site on Aug. 27, 2026 1:26 PM As a 9th generation Charlestonian, I’m asking BAR-L to defer conceptual approval of the College of Charleston’s proposed dorm at 106 Coming Street. This site is an 18th-century municipal burial ground, and the information needed to evaluate the project simply isn’t available yet. The College has provided plans for future archaeological work, but not the actual findings the Board requested. Ground-penetrating radar results remain unreleased, and no archaeological investigations have occurred. These studies could meaningfully change the design, feasibility, and treatment of the burial ground. Until they are completed and made public, the Board cannot make a fully informed decision. A deferral is the only responsible path to ensure this historic site is understood—and respected—before any approval is granted. Thank you, Kathleen Turner • Tracy Scott, 224 E. Holding Avenue, 1291, Wake Forest, NC Submitted to Innovate Site on Aug. 27, 2026 2:59 PM Despite providing no new information and conducting no additional investigations since the July meeting, why is the College of Charleston returning to the BAR? If additional information and investigations have been performed, will CofC share that information? I urge the Board to defer this proposal until it has a more complete understanding of site conditions and the significance of this sacred space. • Connie Hughes, 119 Coming St. Board of Architectural Review – Large Public Comment | April 8, 2026 Page 8 Submitted to Innovate Site on Aug. 27, 2026 4:16 PM While I understand the College of Charleston’s need for more student housing and support the idea of a dorm on this site, I believe the current design for the Coming Street Commons is excessively large and will overshadow the houses on Coming Street. It will even surpass the height of the St. Philip garage and the AT&T building. To blend with the historic neighborhood rather than dominate the neighboring houses, there must be a way to modify the design. Another aspect of the current design that requires modification is the commemoration area facing the abandoned, deteriorating house. The open brick wall is acceptable, but the view between and above would be quite distressing. (See page 28 of the application.) Looking at an eyesore is never pleasant. Perhaps, the College of Charleston should purchase the house, renovate it, and incorporate it into the design. Alternatively, the orientation of the commemoration area should be redesigned to offer a more pleasant view. A possible design change might be to relocate the dorm away from the street and create a small park in front as the commemoration area. Thank you for allowing me to share my concerns. • Sharon Lowe-Lassiter, 14 Lockwood Drive Submitted to Innovate Site on Aug. 27, 2026 6:50 PM Development without consideration or respect of this site and surroundings is socially unethical. Especially when the conceptual rendering is too similar to so many other recently proposed and/or finished condo/housing complexes in and around the Peninsula. Plus, what will be the true, not calculated impact of up to an additional 1,000 residents concentrated in such a compact area on the infrastructure of Downtown? From the beginning, I have felt this project has been strong armed through without proper pre-construction procedures and public disclosures followed. It is truly a shame that historic Charleston is becoming just another downtown at the cost of its beloved charm. • James Newhard, 8506 William Moultrie Drive, North Charleston, SC Submitted to Innovate Site on Aug. 27, 2026 9:17 PM Chair and members of the Board: I am a Registered Professional Archaeologist, Director of the Center for Historical Landscapes at the College of Charleston, and a member of the Community Engagement Council. I speak only for myself, not for the university or the Council. In July, this Board deferred the application because too little was known about the site to determine an appropriate commemorative and interpretive response or how that response should shape the project’s design. The August submission provides neither substantial new information developed after the hearing nor a materially revised design. The July and August submissions retain the same: ●608 beds and 136,483 square feet; ●four-to-seven-story height, massing, and building volumes; ●building footprint and site organization; ●underlying floor-plan geometry, elevations, sections, and roof plan; and ●phasing, with Phase 1 on the southern portion of the burial ground and the northern portion reserved for future housing. The applicant has not shifted development toward the approximately 13,400 square feet outside the mapped cemetery overlap. Phase 1 continues to be concentrated on the southern portion, which lies entirely within the anticipated cemetery boundaries. The northern portion – nearly half of which lies outside those boundaries – remains reserved for an undated future phase. The project therefore places the immediate construction burden Board of Architectural Review – Large Public Comment | April 8, 2026 Page 9 on the most constrained portion of the property while postponing use of less constrained land. The principal outdoor commemorative space remains the same narrow, alley-like passage. No materially different alternative is presented. The proposal’s principal design change converts the former “Grab & Go” into a “Commemorative Public Gallery and Student Learning Facility.” Additional commemorative floor space does not reduce the footprint over the burial ground, revise the phasing, or redesign the development around the cemetery. Appendix A and the work plans do not cure this problem. The Board did not defer pending a National Register determination. The January 29 SHPO letter and the work plans both predate the July hearing. They provide neither new site information nor an architectural response to the Board’s concerns. Whatever its National Register status, this cemetery bears witness to the enslaved, victims of the Middle Passage, and people whom the City treated as unwanted during the first generation of the American republic. Its significance rests on documented historical facts, not upon a federal classification. The submission’s engagement timeline lists the August 6 Community Engagement Council meeting. The meeting record does not support treating that meeting as engagement on this revision. Although project updates were presented, the university did not disclose the revised BAR-L submission, the August 31 return date, or any revised design. No advice was requested and no discussion occurred. The meeting cannot reasonably be cited as consultation or community engagement on this proposal. CEC members learned of the return to BAR-L through a 4:59 p.m. email from the Chief of Staff on August 19. The next day, the Council adopted – without amendment or opposition – a formal finding that the College had placed it in a “reactive rather than advisory position,” presenting information after decisions had been made and opportunities to influence them had closed. The revision was never presented to the CEC, descendant communities, affiliated Tribal Nations, or the broader public. It includes no community-derived interpretive framework. More commemorative floor space cannot substitute for community participation in deciding what commemoration should be. The submission fails under either interpretation of the July deferral. If the Board required substantial new knowledge about the site, it has not been provided. If it expected a substantive architectural response, the architecture has not changed. If too little is known to determine an appropriate commemoration, too little is known to approve a design that assumes nothing further learned will require the building to change. Please defer this application until the applicant presents a materially revised design developed through genuine community engagement and responsive to the Board’s stated concerns. More commemorative floor space, preexisting appendices, and a meeting at which the revised proposal was never disclosed do not constitute an adequate response to the July deferral. • Vanessa Mullins, 8121 Diehl St. Submitted to Innovate Site on Aug. 27, 2026 11:36 PM Recent discoveries across the Charleston peninsula underscore that when the historical record points to significant archaeological resources, they are often still present. Before making decisions about a project of this scale at a documented burial ground, it is essential that the site be fully investigated and understood. The information needs to be available for review by the residents of Charleston and South Carolina. Board of Architectural Review – Large Public Comment | April 8, 2026 Page 10 • Jayne Flynn, 814 Hideaway Bay Lane, Mount Pleasant, SC Submitted to Innovate Site on Aug. 27, 2026 11:48 AM The project must be slowed or stopped. This burial ground holds important history of Charleston and to lose that completely would be a loss to history. Archaeological excavations should take place before a building is placed on this land, if a building must be placed on this land. • Keelin Love, 30 Carolina St. Submitted to Innovate Site on Aug. 27, 2026 12:39 PM I encourage the board to defer the ruling on plans for build to go forward until more information has been received. As I understand it no further excavating or investigating through GPR has occurred to gain any more information to process since the July 8th meeting. Please pause and encourage The College to properly investigate the groups before the plans can be approved. • Sam McDorman, 4321 Briarstone Court Submitted to Innovate Site on Aug. 28, 2026 BAR should defer the proposal for dormitories at 106 Coming Street until there is a greater understanding of the significance of the public cemetery at the location; and until more thorough, robust, truthful, and dignified community and descendant outreach and consultation can be done. While the College needs housing, many community members doubt that a dormitory would be appropriate for this space. BAR’s defined purpose is “the preservation and protection of the old historic or architecturally worthy structures and quaint neighborhoods which impart a distinct aspect to the city and which serve as visible reminders of the historical and cultural heritage of the city, the state, and the nation." Does this cemetery not count as a place that imparts a distinct aspect to the city? Does this cemetery not serve as a visible reminder of historical and cultural heritage important to the city, state, and nation? These people may rest underground, but they are still there. They did not choose to remove the historic visual identity of the cemetery by changing the landscape - the city did that by dividing the land to sell as housing lots. 106 Coming Street is the location of the second oldest public cemetery in Charleston. Four to twelve thousand people are buried in this place: Freed and enslaved people of color; poor and sick whites; orphaned and abandoned children; immigrants and travelers; and anyone who had nowhere else to go. Dr. Nick Butler’s research shows that the city took money for the interments, and that people also paid a fee to visit loved ones buried here. The care taker kept a log of those who were buried and some of those who visited. They were placed here with the intention that this would be their final resting place. When a person is buried, they become the earth. The ground under the concrete is those people, and it is sacred. Simply removing the bones will not change the fact that the people buried there have become the land. We will never know all of their names. Given time, research could be done to recover some of them. This cemetery closed because it was full. It was active during a pivotal time of African enslavement and European immigration, making it vitally important to our nation’s history. These are the people who built America’s economy, the hands that built the city, and the voices that filled the streets with life. They are the ancestors of Charleston, with living descendant communities who still Board of Architectural Review – Large Public Comment | April 8, 2026 Page 11 honor and love them. They deserve our respect and consideration. Perhaps the best use of this land would be to restore dignity to the thousands buried there, and to ensure we protect and respect them as Charleston continues to grow. BAR should defer their decision until a more robust understanding of the historical context is available for the public cemetery at 106 Coming Street. • Jodi A. Barnes, 918 Duke St., Georgetown, SC Submitted to Innovate Site on Aug. 28, 2026 8:57 AM I am a professional archaeologist and a member of the Council of South Carolina Professional Archaeologists (COSCAPA), and I ask the BAR to defer the decision on the College of Charleston’s plans to build a student dorm on the location of one of the city’s oldest public cemeteries. Aside from the fact that it is unethical to remove potentially thousands of burials for construction of a dorm, the BAR has clear standards for preservation that include the protection and preservation of archaeological resources. BAR’s general guidelines (pg. 14) state that “Archeological resources will be protected and preserved in place. If such resources must be disturbed, mitigation measures will be undertaken.” The cemetery at 106 Coming Street is an archaeological site and additional significant archaeological resources likely exist within the project’s footprint. The SC SHPO has not reviewed the latest GPR report and there are numerous examples of cemeteries being uncovered after inconclusive GPR results. Since the College has not defined the extent of the archaeological site or provided an appropriate mitigation plan, a decision about building plans should not be considered. In historic preservation, mitigation means taking steps to avoid, reduce, or offset the damage or destruction to archaeological sites. In addition to the BAR standards, a thorough consideration of alternatives is a core ethical principle for disinterring burial sites adopted by the Advisory Council on Historic Preservation (see Principal 2, Policy Statement on Burial Sites, Human Remains, and Funerary Objects, March 1, 2023). Members of the Community Engagement Council have noted this fact at several of their monthly meetings. The College administration has failed to provide the public and affiliated communities with a transparent and full accounting of alternative sites, indicating that there are no possibilities for avoidance. If the College of Charleston cannot avoid the impacts to this significant archaeological site, a mitigation plan is required. The College’s plan to remove graves is not a mitigation plan. It is a plan for the destruction of one of the city’s oldest public cemeteries. A mitigation plan should include steps to make this proposed project less severe, painful, and damaging to the archaeological resource, the historic fabric of Charleston, and most importantly the affiliated communities. The college is clearly trying to rush BAR-L approval, but a decision should only be made AFTER the asphalt has been removed and visible features assessed. It is only then that a proper mitigation plan for the destruction of this archaeological resource can be fully understood. Deferring your decision until more information is available is the only responsible action that meets the preservation standards set by the BAR. • Harlan Green, 32 Chapel St. Submitted to Innovate Site on Aug. 28, 2026 9:29 AM I plead with the BAR to again defer any approval or advancement regarding a dormitory on a sacred site. Members wisely ruled at the last meeting that much more information was needed about the scope of the burials, the possible Board of Architectural Review – Large Public Comment | April 8, 2026 Page 12 positioning of the graves and such similar as yet provided information to help determine the massing and situating of the building. None of this information has been provided; and the slight emending of some of the details, the removal of the tone-deaf proposal to separate a celebratory space and a reflective space by "a grab and go" shop is some improvement, reflecting the continuing need to gather more information before any decision as to format and design and concept of the street level appearance and thus upper floors can be made, much less approved. I would be there in person to show my support of a deferral, but, unfortunately, will be out of town. • Kendy Altizer, 564 Martin Rd., Hiawassee, GA Submitted to Innovate Site on Aug. 28, 2026 11:01 AM I echo and support the comments submitted via letter by COSCAPA. This project requires further review and thoughtful consideration. • Walter Brown, 114 Fennick Dr., Moncks Corner, SC Submitted to Innovate Site on Aug. 28, 2026 11:09 AM Charleston’s Board of Architectural Review (BAR) should not be tricked to accept and approve conceptual designs for 106 Coming Street College of Charleston (COC) new residential dorm because, “we want this thing done”, as suggested at the July 8, 2026, regular BAR-L meeting. BAR-L at the July 8, 2026, meeting got it right when it unanimously voted on the motion, “deferral pending to receive further information on the site that may influence height, scale, mass of the building and commemorative element”, by James Meadors. Consistent with its vote to defer a vote on the conceptual design to receive further information on the site, BAR-L should not vote on the conceptual design of the proposed building at 106 Coming Street until further information is provided. That further information can partly come from additional archaeological investigations. It is important that BAR-L adheres to its responsibility under Charleston BAR Ordinance Sec.54-240 and not vote on the conceptual design until further information through archaeological investigation is obtained such that the history, culture and heritage uncovered can influence and be incorporated into the height, scale, mass of the building and commemorative element. This influence cannot occur without additional archaeological investigations. Additionally, it is imperative that the members of BAR-L take a close look at what was presented at the regular BAR-L meeting on July 8 and compare it to what is being presented at this special meeting and decide whether the further information you asked for is being provided. And whether that further information can be provided without further archaeological investigation that leads to a more complete understanding of the history, culture and heritage of the people who occupied the space? As a Community Engagement Council member, I must note that the work plans have been available to the public since March 2026; again, there is nothing new being presented to the BAR. Since this is not new, additional, nor “further information,” BAR-L should not vote on the repackaging of information, a presentation, as if it is new information and that is has been incorporated into the conceptual design of height, scale and mass of the building relating it the history, culture, heritage and environment of this historical site. • Juliette Lovell, 1484 Village Square Board of Architectural Review – Large Public Comment | April 8, 2026 Page 13 Submitted to Innovate Site on Aug. 28, 2026 11:34 AM The College of Charleston has not fulfilled their ethical duty of determining the extent of the historical burial ground at the site of the former YWCA and future dormitory, and without due diligence into identifying and addressing the burial ground, I cannot see how the Board of Architectural Review can approve their housing design. After the BAR voted unanimously to defer the design so that the College could provide more information on site conditions, it is evident that the College has not fulfilled this goal. Thus, the same standards should apply still, and the BAR should not approve a design without this important information. The College's housing project is more than just building a dormitory; it is actively encroaching upon a site of sacred significance to Charleston. The souls of those buried in the "Strangers and Negroes Burial Ground" deserve respect and care, and the College's attempts at rushing this project solidifies their position against an ethical code of conduct. Please give these ancestors respect and defer the proposal until the College does their due diligence. How can they create a commemoration plan without fully understanding those whom they are commemorating? Thank you for your time and consideration. • Emilie Crossan, Summerville, SC Submitted to Innovate Site on Aug. 28, 2026 11:43 AM In addition to the many concerns raised in other public comments, the College’s failure to complete the steps previously required by the BAR before attempting to resubmit should warrant immediate rejection. The College’s actions suggest that its priorities are driven primarily by money and development, with little regard for the CEC or for meaningful community input. In every other instance in which human remains have been found elsewhere on the peninsula, no matter how few or how many, the matter has been handled far better than this situation has been since the project was made public. Ethically, these are thousands of human remains belonging to society's most vulnerable citizens, including enslaved people, dating to the final years leading up to the closure of the Transatlantic Slave Trade. The fact that the burial ground "filled up" around that time should not be viewed as a mere coincidence. Logistically, the College failed to follow the directions set forth by the BAR. I urge the BAR to defer conceptual approval. The College should not be permitted to move forward until it has fully complied with the BAR’s prior instructions and completed all required steps. • Amanda Metze, 321 Sumter St. Submitted to Innovate Site on Aug. 28, 2026 11:59 AM The Board of Architectural Review Policy Statement of Charleston Standards states that: “9. Additions, adjacent or related new construction, and modifications should be undertaken in such a manner that, if removed in the future, the essential form and integrity of the historic property and its context and setting remain unimpaired.” The College of Charleston has not proven that if this building were to be removed in the future, that the integrity of the historic property and its context and setting will remain unimpaired. The historic context and setting of the burial ground will, by contrast, be destroyed by the proposed dormitory. The Secretary of the Interior Standards for Historic Preservation states that: “8. Archeological resources will be protected and preserved in place. If such resources must be disturbed, mitigation measures Board of Architectural Review – Large Public Comment | April 8, 2026 Page 14 will be undertaken.” The College of Charleston’s plan is directly in opposition with the standard that explicitly states the need for archaeological resources to be protected or preserved in place. In addition, The College of Charleston has not presented appropriate mitigation measures, which are also required by the Standards of Preservation.

Source: City of Charleston website. First collected Oct 14, 2026.