admin report packet posted
City of Westminster · Oconee County · meeting of Aug 22, 2025 · Agenda packets
Open the original document More from City of Westminster
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
City of Westminster| PO Box 399 | Westminster, SC 29693 | 864.647.3200 |www.westminstersc.org
ADMINISTRATOR’S REPORT
Kevin Bronson
Office of the City Administrator
Westminster, South Carolina
August 22, 2025
GENERAL INFORMATION
Downton Streetscape Project
Bids for Phase I of the Westminster Downtown Streetscape Project was published on Friday, August 13.
Bids will be due on September 22, 2025. The solicitation can be found at:
www.westminstersc.org/departments/administration/#bids.
This Week in Rec: An Update from Recreation Director Herb Poole
• The Football Apple Bowl was a huge success. Westminster Recreation hosted Pendleton and
Walhalla at Owens Stadium.
• Soccer, baseball, softball, and volleyball game schedules will be available in the coming two
weeks.
• We thank the City Council and County Council for celebrating our 10u softball state
championship with us.
• Football schedules can be found on the Recreation Facebook Page
• We are implementing card readers for the recreation department. Participants and spectators
will have the ability to make concessions and admission payments with credit/debit cards.
Assistant Recreation Director
In the FY 2026 Budget, City Council authorized the creation of an Assistant Recreation Director position.
The job has been posted on the City and MASC Websites. The job posting can be found at
https://westminstersc.org/careers/.
Recreation Card Readers for Concessions and Admissions Payments
Westminster Recreation has received and installed some of its card readers and will begin limitedly
accepting debit and credit cards while learning and troubleshooting the new payment system. Card
readers will be implemented across facilities for concessions and admissions over the coming weeks.
The Recreation Department will continue to use Stripe (its current platform) for online registration.
Horton Outdoor Recreational Area
AMW General Contractors began preparing the forms for the concession building this week. Next week
the pad for the building is planned to be poured.
Field construction crews continued to work on field components. The outfields have been holding water
due to the amount of rain the last couple of weeks. A team of Mammoth engineers and the Mammoth
City of Westminster| PO Box 399 | Westminster, SC 29693 | 864.647.3200 |www.westminstersc.org
owner visited the site this week and decided to re-engineer the drain system in the outfields so they will
drain better. The rain runoff was not filtering down to the so-called sock drains due to the compaction
of the clay ground. The new system will be a trench filled with rock and then covered by the topsoil.
Crews began work immediately after the decision was made to reengineer, one fileds is nearly complete
with the others to follow this weekend. Next week the irrigation contractor is scheduled to be back on
site to continue with its work. Construction of two of the light poles was completed this week, the
others to follow as filed conditions allow the lighting contractor to work.
Coopers Mill Phase II
HDH Construction has completed the sewer main and service connections. HDH began installing the
main water line.
SCIIP Sewer Improvements Phase I
Tugaloo/McClam has completed Spring St. and are mobbing materials and equipment to begin on
Crooked Street.
SCIIP Sewer Improvements Phase II
LW Incorporated is the contractor for the second phase of the SCIIP improvements. Below is a timeline
and attached is a project map.
The dates and estimated times to complete the project within the 285 days in the contract. This timeline
was the basis for the negotiated bid. It is expected that amendments to this estimate will change as the
project progresses.
• 8/20 - preliminary sawcut work began
• 8/21 - pipe and fittings delivered
• 8/27 - scheduled MH delivery
• 8/27 - begin construction on Line "A"
• Traffic Control Structures received and placed by the first week in September. Work on Line C to
begin once these are in place and Line A is complete.
• LW anticipates completing manhole-to-manhole sections on an approximate three-week cycle,
recognizing that actual durations may vary due to differing line lengths. Based on this projection,
line work is expected to be substantially complete by early to mid-May, with overlays and
punchout activities concluded by the end of the month.
Heirloom Farms
Water services have been moved to the new water main on Seed Farm Road and tap installation has
begun. Sewer is complete.
2025 Municipal Election Information
For the Special Election to fill the unexpired term for the City Council seat recently vacated the Oconee
County Voter Registration and Elections Office provided the following:
- Candidate Filing Opens - Friday, August 29 @ Noon
City of Westminster| PO Box 399 | Westminster, SC 29693 | 864.647.3200 |www.westminstersc.org
- Candidate Filing Closes - Monday, September 8 @ Noon*
(*Please note the office will be closed on Monday, September 1 in observance of Labor Day)
The Special Election will be added to the November 2025 Election.
Westminster Planning Commission
The Westminster Planning Commission met on Monday, August 18, 2025 to discuss the proposed
ordinance to provide exceptions to the blanket ban on the discharge of firearms. After deliberation, the
Commission made several changes to the proposed ordinance and requested that the new language be
presented again to the Planning Commission before they make a recommendation to City Council. The
updated Ordinance will be considered again by the Planning Commission at the September 15 meeting.
OJRSA
The OJRSA Ad Hoc Reconstitution Committee met Thursday, August 14, 2025, at 2:00 pm; the draft
meeting minutes are attached. The meeting may be viewed on YouTube at
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oiOJKM4GP60.
The OJRSA Operations and Planning Committee met on Wednesday, August 20, 2025, at OJRSA. The
draft meeting minutes are attached.
The OJRSA Finance and Administration Committee will meet on Tuesday, August 26, 2025 at 9:00am at
OJRSA.
PMPA
The PMPA Board met on Thursday, August 21, 2025. The agenda is attached.
Duke Energy Carolina and Duke Energy Progress Merger Request
On Thursday, August 14th, Duke Energy asked state and federal regulators to allow it to combine Duke
Energy Carolinas and Duke Energy Progress. Duke would like this to be effective by January
2027. Duke’s justification for the technical merger is better efficiency and lower cost to meet the
growing needs in the Carolinas. They estimate about $1 billion in savings through 2038. The merger
would need permission from the SC Public Service Commission, NC Utilities Commission, and FERC. The
full filing is attached at the end of the Administrator Report, a synopsis is available at the link below.
https://www.publicpower.org/periodical/article/duke-energy-seeks-approvals-combine-its-two-electric-
utilities-carolinas
Electric System Transformer Supply Chain
A recent report by energy research and consultancy firm Wood Mackenzie states that U.S. demand for
transformers has surged sharply since 2019—power transformers by 116% and distribution
transformers by 41%—driven by rising electricity use, clean energy projects, and aging infrastructure.
Supply has not kept pace, creating shortages projected to reach 30% for power transformers and 10%
for distribution transformers in 2025. Imports will make up 80% and 50% of supply (in 2025),
respectively, leading to higher costs, longer lead times, and project delays. Both domestic and imports
will be subject to higher costs due to a combination of tariffs. Most notable is the 50% tariff on
imported copper that went into effect August 1
st. The tariff applies to semi-finished products like pipe
and wire but excludes input materials like ore, cathodes, anodes, and copper scrap. Alongside the tariff
City of Westminster| PO Box 399 | Westminster, SC 29693 | 864.647.3200 |www.westminstersc.org
under the Defense Production Act, the administration is requiring 25% of domestically produced high-
quality copper scrap to be sold within the USA. The $1.8 billion announced domestic OEM expansion
since 2023 will help ease but not meet the expected increasing demand. An analyst with the
consultancy firm believes “The convergence of accelerating electricity demand, aging infrastructure and
supply chain vulnerabilities has created constraints that will persist well into the 2030s”. He believes all
of this will be the new normal without decisive intervention.
https://www.publicpower.org/periodical/article/power-transformers-and-distribution-transformers-
will-face-supply-deficits-30-and-10-2025-report
PLEASE MARK YOUR CALENDARS
August 26, 2025 at 9:00 am OJRSA Finance & Administration Committee at OJRSA
September 1, 2025 City Offices Closed to Observe Labor Day
September 8, 2025 at 4:00 pm OJRSA Board Meeting at OJRSA
September 9, 2025 at 6:00 pm City Council Meeting at the Westminster Fire Department
September 11, 2025 at 9:00am OJRSA Ad Hoc Reconstitution Committee at OJRSA
September 15, 2025 at 6:00 pm Westminster Planning Commission Meeting at City Hall
September 18, 2025 at 8:30 am OJRSA Operations & Planning Committee at OJRSA
September 18, 2025 at 10:00 am PMPA Board Meeting at PMPA
City Council Meeting Schedule:
Special Events Calendar
South Carolina Apple Festival- September 5-6, 2025 on Main Street Westminster
The South Carolina Apple Festival Committee Hosts the Westminster Apple Fes tival on Main Street.
150th Birthday Tea Party- October 4, 2025 at 2:00pm at the Martin House
Join the Lazy Daisy Garden Club for a Tea Party Celebrating Westminster’s 150 th Birthday. Tickets will be $10 per
person. All proceeds will go to support scholarships for West-Oak Highschool Students. Tickets must be reserved by
September 18 and can be purchased at https://www.zeffy.com/en-US/ticketing/westminster-150th-birthday-tea-
party. A flyer is attached.
City of Westminster| PO Box 399 | Westminster, SC 29693 | 864.647.3200 |www.westminstersc.org
South Carolina Bigfoot Festival- October 10-11, 2025 on Main Street Westminster
The South Carolina Bigfoot Festival Committee Hosts the Westminster Bigfoot Festival on Main Street.
Boo on Main!- October 31, 2025 on Main Street Westminster
The City’s annual Boo on Main! Features a festival style trunk or treat for Westminster Children on Halloween
Night.
Westminster Arbor Day Celebration – December 5, 2025 time and place TBD.
Westminster Christmas Parade and Tree Lighting- December 5, 2025 on Main Street and Retreat Street Park
City of Westminster| PO Box 399 | Westminster, SC 29693 | 864.647.3200 |www.westminstersc.org
Job Title: Assistant Recreation Director
Department: Parks & Recreation
Location: City of Westminster, SC
Reports To: Recreation Director
FLSA Status: Non-Exempt / Full-Time
Salary Range: $42,000-$55,000 (depending on qualifications and experience)
Position Summary:
The City of Westminster is seeking a dedicated, proactive, and knowledgeable Assistant
Recreation Director to support the development, implementation, and maintenance of
recreation programs, athletic leagues, special events, and park operations. A key focus of this
role will be the oversight and management of turf maintenance and field conditions at city
recreation facilities to ensure safe, attractive, and playable surfaces for all users.
Essential Duties and Responsibilities:
• Assist in planning, coordinating, and supervising youth and adult recreational programs,
athletics, and events
• Manage the maintenance and scheduling of athletic fields, including but not limited to
turf maintenance, irrigation monitoring, and field preparation for games and practices
• Develop and implement turf management plans, including mowing schedules, aeration,
fertilization, weed control, and pest management.
• Supervise part-time and seasonal staff; assist with staff scheduling training, and
performance monitoring
• Serve as acting Recreation Director in their absence
• Collaborate with local sports leagues and community groups to ensure efficient use of
recreational spaces
• Ensure compliance with safety regulations and departmental standards across all
recreation areas
• Assist in budget preparation and purchasing for recreation supplies, field maintenance
materials, and equipment
• Respond to citizen inquiries and concerns in a professional and timely manner
• Assist with the planning and execution of city-wide special events and sponsorship
activities
• Maintain accurate records of program participation, maintenance logs, and field
conditions
• Operate and maintain various types of field and turf maintenance equipment
City of Westminster| PO Box 399 | Westminster, SC 29693 | 864.647.3200 |www.westminstersc.org
Qualifications:
Education and Experience:
• Associate or Bachelor’s degree in Recreation, Turfgrass Management, Horticulture,
Sports Management or related field preferred
• Minimum of 3 years of experience in parks and recreation, athletic field maintenance, or
turfgrass management
• Supervisory experience is strongly preferred
C
ertifications:
• Certified Parks and Recreation Professional (CPRP) or equivalent preferred
• Pesticide Applicator License (or ability to obtain within 12 months of hire) is a plus
• Valid South Carolina Driver’s License required
Kno
wledge, Skills, and Abilities:
• Strong knowledge of athletic field maintenance techniques and turf management
practices
• Experience operating turf care equipment such as aerators, mowers, sprayers, and line
markers
• Ability to communicate effectively with the public, staff, and contractors
• Excellent organizational and time management skills
• Proficiency with Microsoft Office Suite and recreation management software is a plus
• In addition to normal working hours, the ability to work evenings, weekends, and
holidays as needed
W
orking Conditions:
• Work is performed indoors and outdoors in all weather conditions
• Must be able to lift and carry up to 50 pounds
• Exposure to chemicals used in turf maintenance may occur with appropriate safety
measures in place
E
qual Opportunity Employer Statement:
The City of Westminster is an equal opportunity employer and does not discriminate on the
basis of race, color, religion, sex, and national origin, age, disability, or genetic information in
employment or the provision of services.
Ple
ase email resumes to the Recreation Director, Herb Poole at hpoole@westminstersc.org
PART 1:•About 1-2 Months•Approx. 529’ of 8” Line•Depths range from 6 to 10 feet•New line to replace old line•Some minor impacts to Oak Street•All work within right-of-way and Oak St.PART 2:•About 2-3 Months•Approx. 1013’ of 8” Line•Depths range from 6 to 10.5 feet•New line to replace old line•Significant Impact to Traffic (will coordinate with SDOC, Law Enforcement, and Emergency Services)•All work within right-of-way and Oak St•Will impact HWY 24 to Sandifer Funeral HomeGeneral Notes•All locations and times are approximate. Delays are possible.•Grant funded through SCIIP: $2,094,690•Traffic impacts will be minimized wherever possible•Work to be completed by LW, Inc.
Oconee Joint Regional Sewer Authority
623 Return Church Road
Seneca, South Carolina 29678
Phone (864) 972-3900
www.ojrsa.org
OCONEE JOINT REGIONAL SEWER AUTHORITY
Ad-Hoc Reconstitution Committee and Executive Committee
August 14, 2025
The Ad-Hoc Reconstitution Committee and Executive Committee meeting was held at the Coneross Creek
Wastewater Treatment Plant.
Commissioners/Committee Members that were present:
• Katherine Amidon (Environmental
Planner, Bolton & Menk)
• Chip Bentley (Appalachian Council of
Gov’ts.)
• Amanda Brock (Oconee County)
• Kevin Bronson (City of Westminster) –
Committee Chair
• Chris Eleazer (Oconee Joint Regional
Sewer Authority)
• Lawrence Flynn (Pope Flynn - OJRSA
Attorney) – via Microsoft Teams
• Joel Jones (Consultant, JonesWater)
• Scott Moulder (City of Seneca)
• Celia Myers (City of Walhalla)
Committee Members that were not present:
• Angie Mettlen, (Vice President, Ardurra)
OJRSA appointments and staff present were:
• Lynn Stephens, Secretary/Treasurer to the Board and Office Manager
Others present were:
• Norm Cannada, The Journal • Dick Mangrum, WGOG Radio
A. Call to Order – Mr. Bronson called the meeting to order at 2:05 p.m.
B. Introduce the Members of the Committee – Mr. Bronson asked each committee member to introduce
themselves. Mr. Bronson stated he wants to keep each of these committee meetings down to one-
hour intervals without stifling any conversation or concerns. He asked everyone if there were any
objections to this; there were no objections.
C. Discuss the Five (5) Recommendations of the Ad- Hoc Sewer Feasibility Implementation Committee
(Exhibit A) – Mr. Bronson stated that all but two (2) of the current committee members were on the
Feasibility Implementation Committee, and he expressed his appreciation to the m for their work in
developing the recommendations. Mr. Bronson also noted that number four (#4) of the five (5)
recommendations (dissolving the Ad -Hoc Feasibility Implementation Committee and creating an Ad -
Hoc Reconstitution Committee) has already been completed by the OJRSA board. There were no other
comments about these recommendations.
Oconee Joint Regional Sewer Authority
Page 2 of 6 August 14, 2025 Ad-Hoc Reconstitution Committee Meeting
D. Committee Discussion and Action Items:
1. Discussion and Approval of Support Resolution (Exhibit B) – Mr. Bronson said Mr. Flynn drafted a
simple resolution. He said there is a typo with the date on item G. It was discussed that the date
should be July 15, 2025 and not June 16, 2025 as written.
Mr. Bronson said item B specifically states Seneca, Walhalla, and Westminster and asked if it
should also include Oconee County and the Town of West Union. Mr. Flynn replied that West Union
has the opportunity to join in the event they reach certain service threshold s (which haven’t been
met yet). He stated that for the Oconee County resolution, another finding would be added to state
they are providing a recommendation based on a proposal to expand membership of the OJRSA ,
and he welcomes any comments from Oconee County personnel if they want something else to be
added.
Mr. Bronson asked if Oconee County language is added, shouldn’t that be on everyone’s
resolution in order that the same resolution is used across the entities? Mr. Flynn replied he could
put in a general finding after item G since adding Oconee County is a recommendation. Mr. Bronson
asked if Oconee County was good with that; Ms. Brock replied that Oconee County’s attorney, Mr.
David Root, will probably red line this. Ms. Brock said she already had a copy of this resolution and
asked if this was the original or a new one; Mr. Flynn replied this is the original. Ms. Brock said she
thinks Mr. Root will not red line it.
Mr. Bronson asked if there was any issue if each entity’s resolution varied a little. Mr. Flynn
replied this the resolution should be as standardized as possible, but it is not binding. The resolution
is meant to establish common ground—that everyone is on board with the recommendations from
the report and that no one is starting the process with serious misgivings. Mr. Flynn added that this
is a difficult enough process, but the committee needs to ensure the foundation is strong to make
it successful.
Mr. Bronson asked if Mr. Moulder had any issues. Mr. Moulder replied he didn’t have any issues.
He said there are a lot of questions, but this committee is charged with answering those questions
on what implementation looks like. Mr. Bronson asked if the Appalachian Council of Governments
(ACOG) is leaving it up to the entities; Mr. Bentley said yes. Mr. Moulder asked Mr. Bentley, as the
208 Water Quality Management, doesn’t ACOG have some type of jurisdictional oversight; Mr.
Bentley said they do but it is based on what the regional treatment facility is going to be and making
sure everyone participates in it.
Mr. Eleazer asked if it was in the recommendation that the OJRSA should consider this within the
90-day timeline as well; Mr. Flynn replied that is correct. He added that it is probably a bit of overkill,
but it shows the Rural Infrastructure Authority (RIA) and other governing bodies and the delegation
that everyone is moving in the same direction with the goal being the long-term success of Oconee
County and its municipalities. Mr. Moulder stated that it is beneficial as not all the representatives
on the current OJRSA board are independent from the municipalities, so it gives them the
opportunity to voice their opinions on the resolution.
Mr. Eleazer said he modified the resolution the OJRSA could use as best as he could and sent it
to Mr. Flynn to finalize. He asked if it should go to the Finance and Administration Committee for
consideration before going to the board. Mr. Bronson said it should go directly to the board since
the Executive Committee is here and will approve it. Mr. Moulder and Ms. Myers agreed and said
it could be sent back to the committee it needed.
Mr. Bronson said the timeline states the resolutions should be provided by October 13, 2025. He
said that it is doable for Westminster and asked if it was doable with the other entities. Mr.
Moulder, Ms. Myers, and Ms. Brock all stated that it was doable.
Mr. Flynn asked if he should create a template for each city or was everyone okay adapting it on
their own with their councils. Mr. Bronson replied that he would like Mr. Flynn to add Oconee
County. Mr. Moulder said he would like Mr. Flynn to draft one for everyone.
Oconee Joint Regional Sewer Authority
Page 3 of 6 August 14, 2025 Ad-Hoc Reconstitution Committee Meeting
2. Consider the Timeline as Stated in the Recommendations (Exhibit C) – Mr. Bronson stated again
that the first task is already completed and the resolution is to be done by October 13, 2025.
Ms. Brock said the recommendation by the Ad -Hoc Committee stated no more than two (2)
representatives from the current board, and there are now three (3). She asked if this was changed
by the board. Mr. Bronson said the recommendation was for the chair and vice -chair, but that
would’ve left the City of Walhalla not being represented. The board wanted to be inclusive of the
three (3) cities. Ms. Brock asked if the intent of the Ad -Hoc Committee was not to have that. Mr.
Eleazer replied that the dis cussion was around having an odd number of members on this
committee for voting purposes, but Mr. Flynn pointed out that if a tie-breaking vote was needed,
there are bigger concerns to deal with. Ms. Brock said she agreed with that.
Mr. Moulder said the biggest obstacle and deliverable is in August 2026—determining who will
be on the board and providing the list of recommendations to the d elegation. Mr. Flynn said the
amendments are important as it gives the d elegation the recommendation authority, and the
governor the gubernatorial appointment in lieu of the members. This will remove some of the
politics.
Mr. Jones said there is a lot of leg work and asked Mr. Eleazer and Ms. Amidon if this is still
practical. Ms. Amidon asked if it had been decided at what level that Ardurra and Bolton & Menk
are to be involved. Mr. Bronson replied no and asked if M s. Amidon had a recommendation. Ms.
Amidon said she and Ms. Mettlen are here as third-party consultants supporting this committee by
doing analysis and anything else consultants would do to get the committee to where it needs to
be; however, the consultan ts cannot make the final decisions and choose the direction forward,
because it won’t be received well by the public. Mr. Bronson replied that Ms. Amidon, Ms. Mettlen,
and Mr. Jones were invited onto this committee as non-voting members. Mr. Bronson asked if any
of the other committee members had a recommendation about what the consultants will need to
do in the process; there were no comments.
Mr. Bronson said he read in the minutes that the RIA would be open to helping finance the
financial analysis. Ms. Amidon said that was a maybe; she said she knows by speaking with Ms.
Bonnie Ammons of the RIA that they are looking for action at this end, and the resolution is only
Step 1 of this action. RIA will also want to see some stakeholder commitment before they assist
further as they feel they have already assisted with funding the feasibility study. Ms. Amidon added
that she recommends this group going back to the recommendations that resulted from Weston &
Sampson’s Master Plan, because some of those things could get started during this reconstitution
plan. She said she would be happy to take a pass with this. Mr. Bronson asked Ms. Amidon to do
that first pass, and there could be a discussion about it at the next committee meeting.
Mr. Jones said a lot of money can be spent on the technical resources needed for the valuation
and challenged the member agencies to determine what issues they have (technical or otherwise)
to get through to allow the consolidation of their systems, and there may be a simpler solution to
address this. Mr. Flynn said someone must do a deep dive on what the OJRSA board is taking on,
and although everything won’t be identified, it would be a good start with the system age, line
degradation, and pump station utilization.
Mr. Bronson said this agenda doesn’t state to adopt the timeline, but he asked if anyone was
ready to adopt it. Mr. Bentley said it is fair to adopt but changes can be made.
Mr. Bentley made a motion, seconded by Mr. Eleazer, to adopt the Timeline as presented.
Ms. Brock stated that being Oconee County has so little technical valuations, it would be unfair
for Oconee County to break a tie vote, so she may abstain. Mr. Eleazer said he put the timeline
together based on the Ad -Hoc Feasibility Committee’s reco mmendations, and they were target
dates, so they can be adjusted. Ms. Brock said it is a motion to approve the timeline. Mr. Moulder
asked Mr. Bentley if he wanted to change his motion.
Mr. Bentley amended his motion, seconded by Mr. Eleazer, to adopt the Timeline as presented and
to accept the dates in the timeline are target dates that the committee will try to maintain progress
Oconee Joint Regional Sewer Authority
Page 4 of 6 August 14, 2025 Ad-Hoc Reconstitution Committee Meeting
towards, acknowledging that things may come up and require adjustments on the dates. The motion
carried.
3. Submittal of Quarterly Reports to South Carolina Rural Infrastructure Authority (SC RIA) – Mr.
Bronson said he and Mr. Eleazer spoke about having Ms. Stephens submit the reports to the RIA,
and he asked if Ms. Stephens was asked about doing this. Mr. Eleazer said he did not ask Ms.
Stephens and said when he reported each milestone during the first Ad-Hoc Committee, he would
just email Ms. Ammons and give a bullet point about what was done, and Ms. Ammons was
appreciative of that. Mr. Eleazer also stated t hat Ms. Ammons could receive key points from the
meeting minutes.
Mr. Moulder made a motion, seconded by Mr. Bentley , to assign Sewer Authority staff with the
responsibility of submitting the quarterly reports to the RIA. The motion carried.
4. Discuss Financial Evaluation of Wastewater Systems – Mr. Bronson said he agreed with what Mr.
Jones said earlier in the meeting that a lot of money can be spent on the valuations. Mr. Bronson
asked, the way it is written in the report, if it is a deal breaker for any of the three (3) member cities
and Oconee County, and he also asked if there were additional considerations this committee needs
to have. Mr. Bronson added that this committee isn’t tied to what they say, as they probably have
not discussed it with their individual councils. Mr. Bronson said that although Westminster’s council
has received weekly reports, they haven’t spoken about it in council yet either.
Mr. Moulder said that Seneca is in the same position and hasn’t gotten feedback from its council
on the recommendations. He said when they initially read the report, there were lots of questions
about what the valuation, transfer, and debt would look like. This committee will have the job of
answering these questions through the assessments. Mr. Moulder said Seneca is open to paying to
bring in a team for a valuation of its system instead of having one (1) firm doing all the evaluations.
He added t hat a lot of the financial analysis was performed during the report generation of the
system with rates and customer base and asked if that could be reviewed and modified for condition
analysis.
Mr. Bronson asked if it would be appropriate for each entity to go back and have these
discussions with their individual councils and then bring the questions back to this committee to vet
through. In addition, the councils should be asked if one (1) consultant should do all the valuations.
Mr. Moulder was in favor of doing this.
Ms. Myers said she agreed with the feedback as well but added that the Ad-Hoc Committee was
leaning towards one (1) consultant to do the valuations to keep the same parameters. Mr. Jones
added that everyone should develop the scope through that one (1) consultant. Mr. Moulder was
good with this.
Ms. Brock said the County Council is grateful to the Sewer Authority for having this amount of
activity around change. She added she is good with getting the feedback but added that she may
bring back many questions, and the answers presented may create even more questions. There
was also some conversation about upcoming elections in the Member Cities and how more
questions may be asked by new councilmembers.
Mr. Flynn suggested the question -and-answer part of the next committee meeting be held in
Executive Session which would allow the committee members to speak freely. Mr. Moulder asked
Mr. Flynn if that would follow the rules for holding an Executive Session, and Mr. Flynn felt it would.
Mr. Bronson asked if everyone felt they could have the discussions with their councils and have
the questions to bring back in time for the next meeting. Everyone felt they could. There was some
additional conversation about upcoming city elections that may bring up additional questions from
new council members.
Ms. Amidon said that the valuation scope wouldn’t be the same for everyone, as there are lots
of unknowns. Mr. Eleazer stated that it should be the same scope sheet for each entity and that
maybe the consultants could be utilized to put the analysis of the unknown items out for solicitation.
Oconee Joint Regional Sewer Authority
Page 5 of 6 August 14, 2025 Ad-Hoc Reconstitution Committee Meeting
Ms. Amidon said the committee probably needs to determine what level of items need to be known
for the valuation as it will cost more the more detail that is required.
Mr. Eleazer asked who was paying for this. Mr. Bronson said that is why he asked if the RIA was
paying for it. This will need to be determined.
Ms. Amidon asked what the legal implications are for the OJRSA taking all these systems on if
everyone is in support and is there anything the OJRSA needs to be aware of in terms of risk analysis.
Mr. Flynn said the OJRSA is already accepting the was te from everyone’s system, so the OJRSA is
just taking on the cost of maintaining the collection systems, which is the cost of doing business.
There is not a lot of heartburn on the legal side of the takeover.
5. Discuss Draft Language for State Law Modifications (Exhibit D) – Mr. Bronson said the language
states there will be a new board with a new way of it being created and the assets being owned
collectively by one (1) entity. Mr. Bronson asked if there were any issues in the language Mr. Flynn
drafted.
Mr. Flynn provided some background stating that he had preliminary conversations with the
delegation, Senator Thomas Alexander, and his legislative liaisons. Being the legislature just finished
year one of the two -year legislative cycle, the previous ad -hoc committee didn’t want to waste a
portion of the session. They wanted to get the language to a level where it’s felt it allows the OJRSA
to do all the things being proposed by the recommendations, giving the flexibility of the organization
to be as successful as possible , and to use the political leverage of Senator Alexander to get it
through. Mr. Flynn added that he feels the OJRSA is at the point if everyone is comfortable with it.
Mr. Flynn stated it won’t take anything away from what the OJRSA has but rather will add additional
authorization on appointments, provide some clarifying language around issuance of bonds to make
sure debt is properly approved, and provide the authority with more flexibility.
Mr. Bronson asked if everyone was comfortable making this a part of the presentation to their
councils. Ms. Myers said it was already presented to the Walhalla council, and Mr. Bronson said it
was to Westminster’s council as well. Ms. Brock said, since Oconee County is not a part of the
organization, they are good with it so far and want it to keep going. This isn’t interesting to them
just yet.
Mr. Bronson said he, Mr. Eleazer, and Mr. Flynn, (at a minimum) need to set up a meeting with
the delegation, but he thinks this should be held off until this committee gets some feedback from
the cities’ and county’s councils. Mr. Flynn said that makes good sense but recommended meeting
with Senator Alexander in October to get some direction. The goal is to have the final introduction
version in December, so it is ready to move come January 1, 2026.
Mr. Bronson asked Mr. Eleazer to contact Senator Thomas Alexander, Representative Bill
Whitmore, and Representative Adam Duncan and share this information with them/lay the
groundwork.
6. Establish Ad- Hoc Committee Meeting Schedule – Mr. Bronson stated that the OJRSA board
recommended having the meeting on the same day and time as the previous Ad -Hoc Feasibility
Committee meeting: the second Thursday of each month at 9:00 a.m. All the committee members
agreed.
Mr. Bronson summarized today’s meeting:
• Ms. Amidon will do a preliminary review of the Master Plan and come back with anything the
committee should review.
• The committee members will bring in a list of questions from their council members.
• The committee members will bring in an outline of specs and whether they are technical or
financial.
Oconee Joint Regional Sewer Authority
Page 6 of 6 August 14, 2025 Ad-Hoc Reconstitution Committee Meeting
E. Upcoming Meetings
1. Operations & Planning Committee – Wednesday, August 20, 2025 at 8:30 a.m.
2. Finance & Administration Committee – Tuesday, August 26, 2025 at 9:00 a.m.
3. Board of Commissioners – Monday, September 8, 2025 at 4:00 p.m.
4. Ad-Hoc Reconstitution Committee – Thursday, September 11, 2025 at 9:00 a.m. (Meeting schedule
established earlier in today’s meeting.)
F. Adjourn – The meeting was adjourned at 3:08 p.m.
Approved By: Date Approved:
Kevin Bronson
Committee Chair
Approved By:
Lynn M. Stephens
OJRSA Secretary/Treasurer
Notification of the meeting was distributed on August 7, 2025 to Upstate Today, Anderson Independent-
Mail, Westminster News, Keowee Courier, WGOG Radio, WSNW Radio, City of Seneca Council, City of
Walhalla Council, City of Westminster Council, Oconee County Council, SC DHEC, www.ojrsa.org, and
posted at the OJRSA Administration Building.
Oconee Joint Regional Sewer Authority • 623 Return Church Road • Seneca, South Carolina 29678 • 864.972.3900
Ad Hoc Reconstitution Committee
and Executive Committee
OJRSA Operations & Administration Building
Lamar Bailes Board Room
August 14, 2025 at 2:00 PM
Amended – Meeting time corrected to 2:00 PM
This committee was established by the OJRSA Board of Commissioners on August 4,2025 to consider the reorganization
recommendations as identified in the Ad Hoc Sewer Feasibility Implementation Committee Final Recommendations
report. This committee can neither create policy nor make decisions on behalf of the OJRSA or other wastewater service
providers within the area. The report is available at www.ojrsa.org/info.
OJRSA commission and committee meetings may be attended in person at the address listed above. The OJRSA will
also broadcast meetings live on its YouTube channel at www.youtube.com/@OconeeJRSA (if there is a technical issue
preventing the livestreaming of the meeting, then a recording will be published on the channel as soon as possible). For
those not able to attend in person, then the OJRSA Board or Committee Chair will accept public comments by mail (623
Return Church Rd, Seneca, SC 29678) or at info@ojrsa.org. Comments must comply with the public session instructions
as stated on the meeting agenda and will be received up until one hour prior to the scheduled meeting. If there is not a
public session scheduled for a meeting, then comments shall not be accepted.
Agenda
A. Call to Order – Kevin Bronson, Executive Committee Chair
B. Introduce the Members of the Committee
C. Discuss the five recommendations of the Ad Hoc Sewer Feasibility Implementation Committee
(Exhibit A) – Led by Kevin Bronson, Executive Committee Chair
D. Committee Discussion and Action Items – Led by Kevin Bronson, Executive Committee Chair, unless
otherwise noted
1. Discussion and Approval of Support Resolution (Exhibit B)
2. Consider the timeline as stated in the recommendations (Exhibit C)
3. Submittal of quarterly reports to South Carolina Rural Infrastructure Authority (SC RIA)
4. Discuss financial evaluation of wastewater systems
5. Discuss draft language for state law modifications (Exhibit D)
6. Establish ad hoc committee meeting schedule
E. Upcoming Meetings All meetings to be held in the Lamar Bailes Board Room unless noted otherwise.
1. Operations & Planning Committee – August 20, 2025 at 8:30 AM
2. Finance & Administration Committee – August 26, 2025 at 9:00 AM
3. Board of Commissioners – September 8, 2025 at 4:00 PM
4. Ad Hoc Reconstitution Committee – Meeting schedule to be established as stated in agenda item
D.6
F. Adjourn
ACCEPTED BY THE OJRSA BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS JULY 15, 2025
EXHIBIT A - Reconstitution Committee 08/14/2025
Page 1 of 24
ACCEPTED BY THE OJRSA BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS JULY 15, 2025
EXHIBIT A - Reconstitution Committee 08/14/2025
Page 2 of 24
ACCEPTED BY THE OJRSA BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS JULY 15, 2025
EXHIBIT A - Reconstitution Committee 08/14/2025
Page 3 of 24
ACCEPTED BY THE OJRSA BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS JULY 15, 2025
EXHIBIT A - Reconstitution Committee 08/14/2025
Page 4 of 24
ACCEPTED BY THE OJRSA BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS JULY 15, 2025
EXHIBIT A - Reconstitution Committee 08/14/2025
Page 5 of 24
ACCEPTED BY THE OJRSA BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS JULY 15, 2025
EXHIBIT A - Reconstitution Committee 08/14/2025
Page 6 of 24
ACCEPTED BY THE OJRSA BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS JULY 15, 2025
EXHIBIT A - Reconstitution Committee 08/14/2025
Page 7 of 24
ACCEPTED BY THE OJRSA BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS JULY 15, 2025
EXHIBIT A - Reconstitution Committee 08/14/2025
Page 8 of 24
ACCEPTED BY THE OJRSA BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS JULY 15, 2025
EXHIBIT A - Reconstitution Committee 08/14/2025
Page 9 of 24
ACCEPTED BY THE OJRSA BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS JULY 15, 2025
EXHIBIT A - Reconstitution Committee 08/14/2025
Page 10 of 24
ACCEPTED BY THE OJRSA BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS JULY 15, 2025
EXHIBIT A - Reconstitution Committee 08/14/2025
Page 11 of 24
ACCEPTED BY THE OJRSA BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS JULY 15, 2025
EXHIBIT A - Reconstitution Committee 08/14/2025
Page 12 of 24
ACCEPTED BY THE OJRSA BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS JULY 15, 2025
EXHIBIT A - Reconstitution Committee 08/14/2025
Page 13 of 24
ACCEPTED BY THE OJRSA BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS JULY 15, 2025
EXHIBIT A - Reconstitution Committee 08/14/2025
Page 14 of 24
ACCEPTED BY THE OJRSA BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS JULY 15, 2025
EXHIBIT A - Reconstitution Committee 08/14/2025
Page 15 of 24
ACCEPTED BY THE OJRSA BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS JULY 15, 2025
EXHIBIT A - Reconstitution Committee 08/14/2025
Page 16 of 24
ACCEPTED BY THE OJRSA BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS JULY 15, 2025
EXHIBIT A - Reconstitution Committee 08/14/2025
Page 17 of 24
ACCEPTED BY THE OJRSA BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS JULY 15, 2025
EXHIBIT A - Reconstitution Committee 08/14/2025
Page 18 of 24
ACCEPTED BY THE OJRSA BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS JULY 15, 2025
EXHIBIT A - Reconstitution Committee 08/14/2025
Page 19 of 24
ACCEPTED BY THE OJRSA BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS JULY 15, 2025
EXHIBIT A - Reconstitution Committee 08/14/2025
Page 20 of 24
ACCEPTED BY THE OJRSA BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS JULY 15, 2025
EXHIBIT A - Reconstitution Committee 08/14/2025
Page 21 of 24
ACCEPTED BY THE OJRSA BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS JULY 15, 2025
EXHIBIT A - Reconstitution Committee 08/14/2025
Page 22 of 24
ACCEPTED BY THE OJRSA BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS JULY 15, 2025
EXHIBIT A - Reconstitution Committee 08/14/2025
Page 23 of 24
Meeting minutes not included in this version of the report but are available at
https://ojrsa.org/wp-content/ uploads/Recommendations-2025-6-15-FINAL-includes-all-
meeting-minutes.pdf or www.ojrsa.org/info. These links include access to the full report and
attachments, including meeting minutes, as accepted by the OJRSA Board of Commissioners at
its July 15, 2025 called meeting.
EXHIBIT A - Reconstitution Committee 08/14/2025
Page 24 of 24
A RESOLUTION ACKNOWLEDGING RECEIPT OF, AND EXPRESSING
SUPPORT FOR, THE IMPLEMENTATION OF THE
RECOMMENDATIONS OF THE AD HOC REGIONAL FEASIBILITY
STUDY IMPLEMENTATION COMMITTEE; AND OTHER MATTERS
RELATED THERETO.
NOW THEREFORE, be it resolved by the City Council of the City of Westminster (the
“City Council”), the governing body of the City of Westminster, South Carolina (the “ City”), as
follows:
Section 1 Findings. The City Council make the following findings in connection with
the adoption of this resolution (this “Resolution”):
A. The City is a municipal corporation of the State of South Carolina (the “ State”)
located in Oconee County, South Carolina, and as such possesses all general powers granted by
the Constitution and statutes of the State to such public entities.
B. The City is a member of Oconee Joint Regional Sewer Authority (“ OJRSA”), a
joint authority sewer system organized under Title 6, Chapter 25 of the Code of Laws of South
Carolina 1976, as amended (the “ Act”), created in 2007 by its three member-municipalities: the
City of Seneca, South Carolina (“ Seneca”), the City of Walhalla, South Carolina (“ Walhalla”),
and the City (collectively, the “Members”).
C. OJRSA commissioned the Regional Feasibility Planning Study (“ Planning
Study”), which was completed in August 2024 and formally adopted by the Board of
Commissioners, as the governing body of OJRSA (“Board”) in September 2024.
D. The Planning Study recommended the formation of an Ad Hoc Regional Feasibility
Study Implementation Committee (“ Ad Hoc Committee”) to further evaluate and develop
implementation strategies to restructure OJRSA.
E. The Board established the Ad Hoc Committee in November 2024, who convened
regularly from December 2024 through June 2025 to conduct a comprehensive review of the
Planning Study and develop independent recommendations for implementation.
F. The City’s representative, Mr. Scott Parris, served as a member of the Ad Hoc
Committee throughout its deliberations.
G. On June 16, 2025, the Ad Hoc Committee issued a final report entitled “OJRSA
Reorganization Recommendations” that includes five major recommendations for the
reorganization and reconstitution of OJRSA under the Act (the “Recommendation Report”).
H. The recommendations are intended to address longstanding operational,
governance, regulatory, and financial challenges facing OJRSA and the Members, and to provide
for a coordinated, compliant, and sustainable regional wastewater system to serve the current and
future needs of Oconee County and its municipalities.
Sample resolution from Lawrence Flynn
SAMPLE
EXHIBIT B - Reconstitution Committee 08/14/2025
Page 1 of 2
2
I. The City Council has received and reviewed the Recommendation Report,
including the proposed implementation timeline, and recognizes the importance of working
cooperatively and in good faith with OJRSA, Seneca, Walhalla, Oconee County, and other
stakeholders to advance the implementation of the recommendations therein.
Section 2 Support for Implementation . The City expresses its support for the
recommendations contained in the Recommendation Report and agrees to work in good faith with
OJRSA, the other Members, Oconee County, and other affected entities to evaluate and, where
appropriate, implement the proposed actions, including but not limited to: (i) the consolidation of
Members’ sewer collection systems, including the City’s system, and enforced compliance of all
applicable sewer user regulations; (ii) the development of a reconstituted governance structure for
OJRSA, including the elimination of ex officio, principal-agent or other potentially conflicted
members; (iii) the drafting of new governance documents; (iv) participation in the formation of an
implementation committee to shepherd the reorganization process; and (v) the use of a coordinated
communications plan to support public engagement and transparency. In addition to its
confirmation and support of the major recommendations of the Recommendation Report, the City
further supports and agrees that changes to the Act are needed and necessary to fully formulate the
terms and findings of the Recommendation Report. Finally, the City Council will act in good faith
to assure the City’s compliance with the timeline for implementation of the Recommendation
Report, including the engagement of all necessary consultants and other personnel necessary to
formalize the planned restructuring.
Section 3 Non-Binding Intent . This Resolution expresses the City’s non-binding
intent to proceed in good faith with the evaluation and implementation process, with the
understanding that final approvals of any restructuring or system consolidation actions will remain
subject to the review and approval of City Council based on mutually agreed-upon terms and
conditions.
Section 4 Further Action; Effective Date. The City Administrator is hereby directed
to deliver this Resolution to OJRSA and any State regulatory agencies or entities in order to
evidence the City’s initial approval of the Recommendation Report. This Resolution shall become
effective immediately upon its adoption.
DONE AND ADOPTED, this ____th day of _________ 2025.
CITY OF WESTMINSTER, SOUTH CAROLINA
__________________________________________
Mayor
(SEAL)
ATTEST:
___________________________
City Clerk
SAMPLE
EXHIBIT B - Reconstitution Committee 08/14/2025
Page 2 of 2
Oconee Joint Regional Sewer Authority • 623 Return Church Road • Seneca, South Carolina 29678 • 864.972.3900
“OJRSA Reorganization Recommendations” Exhibit A Timeline
Task Target Schedule
for Completion* Target Date
Current Board will dissolve the current Ad Hoc Committee and establish the
Implementation Committee (“Reconstitution Committee”) for further
implementation oversight.
45 days 8/29/2025
Legislative revisions to the Joint Authority Water and Sewer Systems Act
(“Act”) will be finalized and provided to the Oconee County Delegation.
Consultation shall be made with the Delegation on whether lobbyist support
will be needed.
45 days 8/29/2025
Reconstitution Committee will provide quarterly updates to the SCRIA, the
current Board, and Oconee County on the progress of the implementation of
the initial recommendations.
Quarterly 9/30/2025
Resolutions of support for consolidation/OJRSA reorganization will be
provided to and adopted by each governing body affected by the
recommendation, including: OJRSA, Seneca, Walhalla, Westminster, West
Union, & Oconee County.
90 days 10/13/2025
Consultants shall be engaged and the process of collection system technical
evaluation and financial valuation will be initiated, including the
identification of potential funding for effort and immediate rehabilitation
projects that may be identified or current CIP. Additionally, a rate consultant
will be engaged.
120 days 11/12/2025
Communication plan to be developed under the guidance of the
Reconstitution Committee and provided to all entities involved. 120 days 11/12/2025
List of recommendations for the initial commissioners for the New
Commission will be provided to Delegation.
Within 60 days of
Approved Changes
to Act†
8/1/2026
Complete the technical evaluation and financial valuation of the collection
systems.
15 months after
beginning process 2/27/2027
Unified, equitable rate structure timeline will be provided as part of initial
terms for collection system consolidation.
18 months after
beginning process 5/12/2027
Legal documents to transfer collection system assets to OJRSA to be
executed, as well as all necessary reconstitution documents.
24 months after
beginning process 7/15/2027
If the legislative amendments have not be approved, plans for consolidation
under the amended Act will be abandoned. Thereupon, the OJRSA will
proceed to consolidate the member system and implement the reconstitution
under the existing Act, with such process to be finalized by no later than 36
months. Additionally, all members shall be issued permits in compliance with
the OJRSA Sewer Use Regulation and added as co-permittees under the
NPDES permit, if consolidation for any member does not occur.
25 months after
beginning process 8/16/2027
* As noted in Exhibit A of the “OJRSA Reorganization Recommendations,” the implementation schedule is to begin when the OJRSA Board
of Commissioners accepted the report its July 15, 2025 called meeting.
† Estimated to be July/August 2026.
EXHIBIT C - Reconstitution Committee 08/14/2025
Page 1 of 1
1
TO AMEND CERTAIN PROVISIONS OF TITLE 6, CHAPTER 25 OF THE CODE OF LAWS
OF SOUTH CAROLINA 1976, TO AUTHORIZE CERTAIN CLARYIFYING AMENDMENTS
REGARDING COMMISSIONERS, RECONSTITUTION, BOND APPROVAL AND
DURATION.
Be it enacted by the General Assembly of the State of South Carolina:
SECTION 1. Section 6-25-20 shall be amended to add the following defined terms:
§ 6-25-20. Definitions.
(14) “Legislative Delegation” means all members of the South Carolina Senate and South
Carolina House representing any county where a joint system is located.
(15) “Governor” means the Governor of the State of South Carolina .
SECTION 2. Section 6-25-50 shall be amended and restated as follows:
§ 6-25-50. Agreement as to number of commissioners each member may appoint; Application filed
with Secretary of State; corporate certificate.
(A) The governing bodies of the members of a joint system shall form an agreement specifying
the number of commissioners each member may appoint to a commission created to govern the
joint system pursuant to Section 6-25-60.
(B) Two or more commissioners The proposed members of a joint system shall jointly file an
application with the Secretary of State an application signed by the commissioner or each proposed
member setting forth:
(1) the names of number of proposed members of the joint system, the number of proposed
commissioners, and their respective appointed commissioners the method of appointment pursuant
to Section 6-25-60(B);
(2) (a) the a certified copy of a resolution of each member determining it is in its best interest
to participate in the proposed joint system; and
(b) the resolution appointing the member’s commissioner;
(3) the desire that the joint system be organized as a public body corporate and politic under
this chapter;
(4) the name which is proposed for the joint system; and
(5) the purpose for creation of the joint system.
The Secretary of State shall file the application if after examining it and determining that it
complies with the requirements in this section and that the proposed name of the joint system is
not identical with that of any other corporation of the State or any agency or instrumentality or so
nearly similar as to lead to confusion and uncertainty.
After the application has been filed, the Secretary of State shall issue a corporate certificate that
must be filed with the application, and the joint system then must be constituted a public body
corporate and politic under the name proposed in the application. The corporate certificate shall
set forth the names of all voting member and the name of the joint system. There also must be
stated upon the corporate certificate the purpose for which it has been created, as set forth in the
application. Notice of the issuance of such corporate certificate must be given to all members of
the joint system by the Secretary of State.
In any suit, action, or proceeding involving the validity or enforcement of, or relating to, contract
of a joint system, the joint system in the absence of establishing fraud shall be conclusively
EXHIBIT D - Reconstitution Committee 08/14/2025
Page 1 of 6
2
considered to have been established in accordance with the provisions of this chapter upon proof
of the issuance of the certificate by the Secretary of State. A copy of the certificate, duly certified
by the Secretary of State, is admissible in evidence in any suit, action, or proceeding and is
conclusive proof of the filing and contents.
SECTION 3. Section 6-25-60 shall be amended and restated as follows:
§ 6-25-60. Joint system to be managed and controlled by commission; appointment of
commissioners; oath; records; seal; quorum; vacancies; expenses.
.
(A) The management and control of a joint system is vested in a commission that may consist
of no fewer than five members and no more than eleven members. A commissioner has one vote
and may have additional votes as a majority of the members of the joint system determines.
Notwithstanding the provisions of this subsection requiring the commission managing a joint
system to have no fewer than five members and no more than eleven members, a joint system in
existence on this section's effective date and having fewer than five members or more than eleven
members on this section's effective date may continue to maintain the number of members serving
on the section's effective date and may add additional members as its commissioners determine.
(B) As contemplated by the initial application to the Secretary of State, commissioners serving
on the commission may be appointed under one of the following procedures:
(1) Appointment by member. The governing body of each voting member of a joint system
shall appoint one or more a commissioner s, pursuant to Section 6-25-50(A), to serve as a
commissioner of the joint system. A commissioner has one vote and may have additional votes as
a majority of the members of the joint system determines. A commissioner serves at the pleasure
of the governing body by which he was appointed. A commissioner, before entering upon his
duties, shall take and subscribe to an oath before a person authorized by law to administer oaths to
execute the duties of his office faithfully and impartially, and a record of each oath must be filed
with the governing body of the appointing authority.
Notwithstanding the provisions of this subsection requiring the commission managing a joint
system to have no fewer than five members and no more than eleven members, a joint system in
existence on this section's effective date and having fewer than five members or more than eleven
members on this section's effective date may continue to maintain the number of members serving
on the section's effective date and may add additional members as its commissioners determine.
Further, and notwithstanding the appointment requirements above, in the event there are an even
number of members of a joint system (i.e. 4, 6, 8, 10), the project contract, bylaws or other similar
agreement for the joint system may authorize one additional member of the commission; such
additional commissioner shall be recommended by the legislative delegation from each county
where the joint system is located, and upon receipt of such recommendation, such additional
commissioner shall appointed by the Governor. Any gubernatorial appointment shall be for a term
of four years and shall serve until a duly appointed successor is appointed and qualified. Any
commissioner appointed by the Governor hereunder must reside within a household receiving
utility services from the joint system or a member of the joint system. Any vacancy of such member
must be filled for the remainder of the unexpired term in the same manner as the original
appointment. If a new member of a joint system is added under the provisions hereof such that
there becomes an odd number of members of a joint system, any gubernatorial appointed
commissioner shall be deemed to automatically vacate his position as a commissioner as of the
date of the admission of such new member of a joint system and their respective appointment of a
new commissioner.
EXHIBIT D - Reconstitution Committee 08/14/2025
Page 2 of 6
3
(2) Appointment by Governor. The commissioners may be appointed by the Governor in
accordance with the following procedures:
(a) The Governor, based upon the recommendation of the legislative delegation from
each county that the joint system operates, shall appoint each commissioner. Each
appointed commissioner must reside within a household receiving utility services from
the joint system or a member of the joint system. In making such appointments, there shall
be at least one commissioner appointed by the Governor from the service area of each
member of the joint system.
(b) Excepting the initial appointments as necessary to create a staggered commission
which may be two or four years, respectively, each commissioner must be appointed and
serve for a term of four years and until his successor is appointed and qualified, provided
that the terms of the commissioners must be staggered such that approximately one-half
of the total members appointed by the Governor must be appointed or reappointed every
two years. A vacancy must be filled for the remainder of the unexpired term in the manner
of the original appointment. Respecting the initial commission appointed herein, the
minority portion of the staggered membership, representing those authorities with the
lowest number of customers of the joint system, shall serve for an initial two-year term.
(B) (C) The commissioners of the joint system shall annually, or biennially, if provided in the
bylaws of the joint system, elect, with each commissioner having one vote, one of the
commissioners as chairman, another as vice chairman, and other persons who may, but need not
be commissioners, as treasurer, secretary and, if desired, assistant secretary. The office of treasurer
may be held by the secretary or assistant secretary. The commission may also appoint such
additional officers as it deems necessary. The secretary or assistant secretary of the joint system
shall keep a record of the proceedings of the joint system, and the secretary must be the custodian
of all books, records, documents, and papers filed with the joint system, the minute book or journal
of the joint system, and its official seal.
(C) (D) A majority of the commissioners of the joint system shall constitute a quorum. A
vacancy on the commission of the joint system shall not impair the right of a quorum to exercise
all rights and perform all the duties of a joint system. Any action taken by the joint system under
the provisions of this chapter may be authorized by resolution at any regular or special meeting
held pursuant to notice in accordance with bylaws of the joint system, and each resolution shall
take effect immediately and need not be published or posted. Except as is otherwise provided in
this chapter or in the bylaws of the joint system, a majority of the votes which the commissioners
present are entitled to cast, with a quorum present, shall be necessary and sufficient to take any
action or to pass any resolution. No commissioner of a joint system shall receive any compensation
solely for the performance of duties as a commissioner, but each commissioner may be paid per
diem, mileage, and subsistence expenses, as provided by law for state boards, committees, and
commissions, incurred while engaged in the performance of such duties.
(E) All commissioners shall hold the qualifications of an elector.
(F) Commissioners appointed under subsection (B)(2) above may not be an officer or employee
of a member of a joint system, and no commissioner shall be permitted to serve on an ex officio
basis. Separately, for commissioners appointed under subsection (B)(1) above, the members of the
joint system may include a restriction in the project contract, bylaws or other agreement for the
joint system that no commissioner may be an officer or employee of a member of a joint system,
and no commissioner shall be permitted to serve on an ex officio basis.
(G) Any commissioner appointed hereunder shall be deemed to forfeit his respective position if
such person (1) lacks, at any time during his term of office, any qualifications for the office
prescribed by general law and the Constitution, or (2) is convicted of any crime, other than civil
infractions or misdemeanors for which no imprisonment is imposed.
EXHIBIT D - Reconstitution Committee 08/14/2025
Page 3 of 6
4
SECTION 4. Section 6-25-70 shall be amended and restated as follows:
SECTION 6-25-70. Change in membership of joint system.
(A) After the creation of a joint system, any other authority may become a member of the joint
system upon:
(1) adoption of a resolution or ordinance by the governing body complying with the
requirements of Section 6-25-40 including publication of notice;
(2) submission of an application to the joint system; and
(3) approval of the application by resolution of the governing body of each member of the
joint system except in the case of a joint system organized for the purpose of creating a financing
pool, in which case the application must be approved by resolution of the commission.
(B) A member may withdraw from a joint system by resolution or ordinance of its governing
body. A contractual right acquired or contractual obligation incurred by a member while it was a
member remains in full force and effect after the member's withdrawal.
(C) Notice of a change in membership must be filed in the Office of the Secretary of State. No
change is final until this filing occurs. The filing is not required if a joint system is organized only
for the purpose of creating a financing pool.
(D) If a new member of the joint system is added hereunder, the approval documentation
required under subsection (A)(3) above shall determine whether any new commissioners shall be
added to the commission as necessary to support such new member of the joint system. If a new
commissioner is added, either by the member of the joint system or the Governor, as applicable,
each such commissioner shall be appointed immediately.
SECTION 5. Section 6-25-80 shall be amended and restated as follows:
§ 6-25-80. Dissolution of system.
Whenever the commission of a joint system and the governing body of each of its members shall
by resolution or ordinance determine that the purposes for which the joint system was formed have
been substantially fulfilled and that all bonds issued and all other obligations incurred by the joint
system have been fully paid or satisfied, the commission and members may declare the joint system
to be dissolved. On the effective date of the resolution or ordinance, the title to all funds and other
income and property owned by the joint system at the time of dissolution must be disbursed to the
voting members of the joint system according to its bylaws.
In the discretion of the members of a joint system for the proper and efficient operation of any
joint system, an existing joint system may be reconstituted by following the procedures for the
creation of a new joint system, mutatis mutandis.
SECTION 6. Section 6-25-110 shall be amended and restated as follows:
§ 6-25-110. Authorization to incur debt and issue bonds.
A joint system may incur debt for any of its purposes and may issue bonds pledging to the
payment as to both principal and interest the revenues, or any portion, derived or to be derived
from all or any of its projects and any additions and betterments or extensions or contributions or
advances from its members or other sources of funds available to it. A joint system may not
undertake a project required to be financed, in whole or in part, with the proceeds of bonds without
the approval of the governing bodies of each member which is obligated or to be obligated under
any contract for the payment of amounts to be pledged as security therefore and a favorable vote
of two-thirds of all commissioners. Notwithstanding the foregoing, when a commission is
EXHIBIT D - Reconstitution Committee 08/14/2025
Page 4 of 6
5
appointed under Section 6-25-60(B)(2), no separate approval of the governing bodies of each
member shall be required for the issuance of any bonds, and such bonds shall be authorized and
approved by a simple majority of the commissioners. Any project may be preauthorized,
preapproved or otherwise permitted under the terms of the project contract for the joint system,
and such authority, approval or permission shall constitute all necessary approval of the
respective governing bodies of each member herein. A joint system formed only for the purpose
of creating a financing pool may issue notes in anticipation of the issuance of bonds by its members
to the government.
SECTION 7. Section 6-25-128 shall be amended and restated as follows:
§ 6-25-128. Contracts between authority and joint system; duration.
An authority may contract to buy from the joint system water required for its present or future
requirements, including the capacity and output, or a portion or share of one or more specified
projects. An authority also may contract for the collection or treatment of wastewater, including
present or future capacity, or a portion or share of another project. The creation of a joint system
is an alternative method whereby an authority may obtain the benefits and assume the
responsibilities of ownership in a project, so a contract may provide that the authority forming the
contract is obligated to make a payment required by the contract whether or not a project is
completed, operable, or operating notwithstanding the suspension, interruption, interference,
reduction, or curtailment of the output of a project or the water contracted for, and that the
payments under the contract are not subject to reduction, whether by offset or otherwise, and are
not conditioned upon the performance or nonperformance of the joint system or any other member
of the joint system under the contract or any other instrument. A contract with respect to the sale
or purchase of capacity or output, or a portion or share of them, of a project entered into between
a joint system and its member authorities also may provide that if an authority or authorities default
in the payment of its or their obligations with respect to the purchase of the capacity or output, or
a portion or share of them, in that event the remaining member authorities which are purchasing
capacity and output under the contract are required to accept and pay for and are entitled
proportionately to and may use or otherwise dispose of the capacity or output which was to be
purchased by the defaulting authority.
A contract concerning the sale or purchase of capacity and output from a project may extend for
a period not exceeding fifty years from the date of the contract and may be renewable and extended
upon terms as the parties may agree for not exceeding an additional fifty years; and the execution
and effectiveness is not subject to any authorizations or approvals by the State or any agency,
commission, or instrumentality or political subdivision of them. Additionally, the contract may
further provide that bonds or other indebtedness of the joint system may exceed the term of an
initial or existing contract between or among the joint system and the respective members of the
joint system, and in such event the contract, or at least the payment obligations of each member,
shall be automatically extended to a period commensurate with the term of the bonds or other
indebtedness.
Payments by an authority under a contract for the purchase of capacity and output from a joint
system may be made from the revenues derived from the ownership and operation of the water
system of the authority or from such other sources of funds as may be available, including any
amounts received as payments in lieu of taxes. An authority may not pledge its full faith, credit,
and taxing power to secure its obligations to the joint system or the bonds of the joint system. An
authority is obligated to fix, charge, and collect rents, rates, fees, and charges for water or sewer
services, facilities, and commodities sold, furnished, or supplied through its water or sewer system
sufficient to provide revenues adequate to meet its obligations under any contract and to pay any
EXHIBIT D - Reconstitution Committee 08/14/2025
Page 5 of 6
6
and all other amounts payable from or constituting a charge and lien upon the revenues, including
amounts sufficient to pay the principal of and interest on general obligation bonds, if any,
heretofore or hereafter issued by the authority for purposes related to its water or sewer system.
An authority that is a member of a joint system may furnish the joint system with money derived
from the ownership and operation of its water or sewer system or facilities and provide the joint
system with personnel, equipment, and property, both real and personal, and from any other
sources legally available to it for such purposes. An authority also may provide services to a joint
system.
A member of a joint system may contract for, advance, or contribute funds derived from the
ownership and operation of its water or sewer system or facilities or from another legal source to
a joint system as agreed upon by the joint system and the member, and the joint system shall repay
the advances or contributions from the proceeds of bonds, operating revenue, or other funds of the
joint system, together with interest as agreed upon by the member and the joint system.
SECTION 8. This act takes effect upon approval by the Governor.
EXHIBIT D - Reconstitution Committee 08/14/2025
Page 6 of 6
Oconee Joint Regional Sewer Authority
623 Return Church Road
Seneca, South Carolina 29678
Phone (864) 972-3900
www.ojrsa.org
OCONEE JOINT REGIONAL SEWER AUTHORITY
Operations & Planning Committee
August 20, 2025
The Operations & Planning Committee meeting was held at the Coneross Creek Wastewater Treatment
Plant.
Commissioners that were present:
• Seat 2 (Seneca): Scott Moulder (Committee Chairman)
• Seat 3 (Seneca): Scott McLane
• Seat 9 (Walhalla & Westminster): David Dial
Commissioners that were not present:
• Seat 6 (Walhalla): Vacant Until New Committee Member Appointed
OJRSA appointments and staff present were:
• Lynn Stephens, Secretary/Treasurer to the Board and Office Manager
• Chris Eleazer, Executive Director
Others present were:
• None
A) Call to Order - Mr. Moulder called the meeting to order at 8:30 a.m.
B) Public Session – None. Mr. Moulder took a moment to say he appreciates being on this committee
and serving as chairman on it.
C) Presentation and Discussion Items:
1. Update on Current Projects (Exhibit A) – Mr. Eleazer highlighted the following items on the list:
Item #17 – This is a package that has been advertised for bids and will be for replacement of a lot
of equipment. Mr. Eleazer stated that OJRSA Operations Director, Mr. Kyle Lindsay, is planning on
procuring much of it internally and then someone will come in and install it.
Mr. Dial said there was no amount for this item and asked if the OJRSA had an idea of the cost.
Mr. Eleazer replied the OJRSA has an estimated cost that was used for budgeting purposes;
however, it is not being advertised, because advertising for this projec t went out Wednesday or
Thursday of last week in the newspaper and through the SC Business Opportunities website, and
everyone that will submit bids would use that estimate. The Director added that Mr. Lindsay will
have a mandatory pre-bid meeting where he will show everyone what needs to be done and give
them the opportunity to ask questions.
Item #5 “Indefinite Delivery Contract for Engineering Services” – Mr. Eleazer said the Procurement
Policy allows the OJRSA to solicit for standby/on-call services. It is in legal review right now before
being advertised. The OJRSA is looking at having two (2) engineering firms to do basic engineering
services (design pump stations, force mains, gravity sewer, rehabilitation, plan review, etc.).
Item #7 – The OJRSA received eight (8) submittals for the CMMS software system upgrade which
closed out on August 14, 2025. The review process is starting and will hopefully be done by the
middle of next week and then three (3) demos will be scheduled. This will allow the OJRSA to move
into true asset management and tracking of costs. Mr. Eleazer added that this will be tied to the
Oconee Joint Regional Sewer Authority Page 2 of 3 August 20, 2025 Operations & Planning Committee Meeting
ArcGIS (ESRI system). The Director also stated that once a CMMS system has been selected, the
OJRSA will move forward with finding a new financial system that will integrate with the CMMS.
2. Richland Creek Gravity Sewer Expansion – The Director distributed a handout to the committee
(made a part of these minutes). He said this would qualify to be an impact fee project. There is no
cost estimate for this project, and it could be done as a whole or in phases.
The current trunk sewer line goes up to Sandifer Blvd./Highway 123/Highway 76. The new Target
development will be located to the northeast corner of the map near the golf course. There has
been discussion for years (even before Mr. Eleazer’s time at the OJRSA) to extend the gravity sewer
along Richland Creek and up to Blue Ridge Boulevard to eliminate the Halfway Branch Pump Station.
This will fix numerous problems that the OJRSA and Seneca Light & Water have regarding capacity
issues.
Mr. Eleazer added that Halfway Branch Pump Station wastewater currently flows through the
western part of the city and through the Cross Creek Golf Course (where there have been several
overflows in the past six (6) months). Between conversations with Mr. McLane and the consulting
engineers, this has always been an area that has been identified as needing attention. It would be
beneficial to take the flow from Halfway Branch and move it to the trunk gravity sewer that flows
to the treatment plant from the west (he pointed to the Coneross Creek Trunk Sewer). That would
serve a dual purpose: to allow sewer availability in an area that is in tremendous demand and to
help Seneca Light & Water with its capacity issues at the S NS South Pump Station. Mr. McLane
added that it would open a lot of doors, including bringing their Cliffabee Leas Pump Station flow
down to Sheep Farm Road.
The Director said the Thornwell Property project is titled “Phase I.” There obviously is another
“Phase II” project planned for the future, but there is no capacity remaining in the sewer system for
a “Phase II” without infrastructure improvements on Seneca’s and the OJRSA’s systems. The OJRSA
is going to have to replace the line over the railroad bridge on Highway 123 near Sealed Air to be
able to accommodate flow that way. Mr. Eleazer explained how he didn’t think SCDOT would let
the OJRSA replace the pipe going across the bridge with a bigger pipe.
Mr. McLane explained how Seneca Light & Water’s original plan was to eliminate the SNS South,
Walmart, and Sheep Farm Road pump stations, and then add Cliffabee Leas and eliminate that
pump station.
Mr. Eleazer asked the committee members if they were interested in looking further at this. All
the committee members were interested in looking at it further, and Mr. Moulder added that it
would benefit all three (3) Member Cities.
D) Action Items to Recommend to the Board for Consideration:
• Consider Moving the Date or Time for the Operations & Planning Committee Meetings – Mr.
Moulder explained to the committee members that Wednesday mornings are extremely busy for
him between meeting with the mayor , staff meetings, and a weekly radio show. He requested to
move this meeting from Wednesday to a Thursday or Tuesday.
Mr. Eleazer added that he checked with OJRSA Attorney, Mr. Lawrence Flynn, to see if there were
any legal conflicts with changing the date and time of the committee meeting, and there was
nothing in the bylaws to prevent it.
Mr. Moulder made a motion, seconded by Mr. McLane, to move the Operations and Planning
Committee meetings to the third Thursday of each month at 8:30 a.m. The motion carried.
E) Executive Director’s Discussion and Compliance Matters – The Executive Director reported on the
following:
1. Environmental and Regulatory Compliance – The OJRSA is still awaiting a response from the SC
Department of Environmental Services (SCDES) regarding the OJRSA’s NPDES permit. The OJRSA
submitted a response to them but has not heard back since. Mr. Eleazer added that the new
wastewater treatment with peracetic acid (PAA) is tied to this permit.
Oconee Joint Regional Sewer Authority Page 3 of 3 August 20, 2025 Operations & Planning Committee Meeting
2. Miscellaneous (If Any) – None.
F) Committee Members’ Discussion – None.
G) Upcoming Meetings:
1. Finance & Administrative Committee – Tuesday, August 26, 2025 at 9:00 a.m.
2. Board of Commissioners – Monday, September 8, 2025 at 4:00 p.m.
3. Ad-Hoc Reconstitution Committee – Thursday, September 11, 2025 at 9:00 a.m.
4. Operations & Planning Committee – Thursday, September 18, 2025 at 8:30 a.m.
H) Adjourn – The meeting adjourned at 8:53 a.m.
Notification of the meeting was distributed on August 1st and 8th , 2025 to Upstate Today, Anderson
Independent-Mail, Westminster News , Keowee Courier , WGOG Radio, WSNW Radio, City of Seneca
Council, City of Walhalla Council, City of Westminster Council, Oconee County Council, SC DHEC,
www.ojrsa.org, and posted at the OJRSA Administration Building.
Oconee Joint Regional Sewer Authority • 623 Return Church Road • Seneca, South Carolina 29678 • 864.972.3900
Operations & Planning Committee Meeting
OJRSA Operations & Administration Building
Lamar Bailes Board Room
August 20, 2025 at 8:30 AM
OJRSA commission and committee meetings may be attended in person at the address listed above. The OJRSA will
also broadcast meetings live on its YouTube channel at www.youtube.com/@OconeeJRSA (if there is a technical issue
preventing the livestreaming of the meeting, then a recording will be published on the channel as soon as possible). For
those not able to attend in person, then the OJRSA Board or Committee Chair will accept public comments by mail (623
Return Church Rd, Seneca, SC 29678) or at info@ojrsa.org. Comments must comply with the public session instructions
as stated on the meeting agenda and will be received up until one hour prior to the scheduled meeting. If there is not a
public session scheduled for a meeting, then comments shall not be accepted.
Agenda
A. Call to Order – Scott Moulder, Committee Chair
B. Public Session – Receive comments relating to topics on this agenda. Session is limited to a maximum of 30
minutes with no more than 5 minutes per speaker.
C. Presentation and Discussion Items [May include vote and/or action on matters brought up for discussion]
1. Update on current projects (Exhibit A) – Chris Eleazer, Director
2. Richland Creek gravity sewer expansion – Chris Eleazer, Director
D. Action Items to Recommend to the Board for Consideration
Consider moving the date or time for the Operations & Planning Committee meetings – Scott Moulder,
Committee Chair
E. Executive Director’s Discussion and Compliance Matters – Chris Eleazer, Director
1. Environmental and regulatory compliance matters
2. Miscellaneous (if any)
F. Committee Members’ Discussion – Led by Scott Moulder, Committee Chair
Discussion can be related to matters addressed in this meeting or for future consideration by the Board or
Committee. Voting is not permitted during this session.
G. Upcoming Meetings All meetings to be held in the OJRSA Lamar Bailes Board Room unless noted otherwise.
1. Finance & Administration Committee – August 26, 2025 at 9:00 AM
2. Board of Commissioners – September 8, 2025 at 4:00 PM
3. Ad Hoc Reconstitution Committee – September 11, 2025 at 9:00 AM
4. Operations & Planning Committee – To be considered at meeting
H. Adjourn
FY2026 O&M FUND PROJECTS CONSENT ORDER ENGINEERING AND OPERATIONS AND MAINTENANCE TASKS 8/18/2025 11:57
Row
#
FY 2026 O&M Project (Project # (if applicable); PM)
CANNOT CARRY OVER TO NEXT FISCAL YEAR WITHOUT
BUDGET APPROVAL
Approx %
Complete
Anticipated
Completion
PO/Contract
Amount ($)
Bids/RFQ/etc.
Issue/Advertised
Req/Contract
Signed Started Work Completed
Obligated/ Spent
($)
Budget
Remaining ($)
GL Code (XXXXX = get
from Office Mgr)
Comp. Performing
(and Project Mgr)
1 Consent Order 21-025-W Project: Biannual Compliance
Report (CE)
0% 11/8/2025 0 Internal Project Internal Project N/A 0 0 N/A OJRSA
Chris Eleazer
2 Agency Reconstitution (Sewer Feasibility
Implementation) (Board, Others)
0% TBD N/A See below See below 7/15/2025 0 0 N/A Board of
Commissioners
3 Completion of Development Guide (AM) 5% 12/31/2025 N/A Internal Project Internal Project 9/10/2024 0 0 N/A OJRSA
Chris Eleazer
4 Development Policy Revision (CE) 70% 10/6/2025 N/A Internal Project Internal Project 9/24/2024 0 0 N/A OJRSA
Chris Eleazer
5 Indefinite Delivery Contract for Engineering Services
(CE)
50% 10/6/2025 N/A In legal review
b/f issue 0 0 N/A OJRSA
Chris Eleazer
6 Arc Flash 70E Assessment of WRF, PSs, and Other
Facilities (AM)
0% 10/31/2025 12,650 Prof Svcs 8/12/2025 0 12,650 Admin: Safety
501-02370
Life & Safety
TBD
7 CMMS & Financial Software System Upgrade (CE) 2% 6/30/2026 TBD 7/3/2025 0 0 Admin Services
501-02420 TBD
8 Comprehensive Sewer Management Plan Project #2026-
04 (KL)
0% TBD TBD Proj #2026-04
Prof Svcs 0 0 Con Sys: Prof Svcs
601-02430 TBD
9 Evaluate Perkins PS & Coneross PS Pumps to Determine
Repair vs. Replace (KL, EP)
0% 10/1/2025 TBD IDC Engineer 0 0 Con Sys: Prof Svcs
601-02430 TBD
10 Hydraulic Model/Field Data Collection (CE) 5% 12/31/2025 TBD Prof Svcs 0 0 Con Sys: Prof Svcs
601-02430
GMC
Hannah Ribelin
11 Coneross PS Rotating Assembly for Pumps #4 & #5 (EP) 0% TBD TBD 0 0 Con Sys: R&M COS-PS
601-05030 TBD
12 Martin PS Motor Base Restraint System (#2 of 3) (EP) 0% 12/30/2025 35,753 Sole Source
8/4/2025 35,753 0 Conv Sys R&M: MAS2-PS
601-05100 TBD
13 Martin PS Aeration Motor Install (crane needed) (EP) 0% 11/30/2025 TBD 0 0 Conv Sys: Equip Rent
601-02540 TBD
14 NPDES Permit Renewal, Including PAA Installation and
Operation (JM, KL)
0% 10/31/2025 3,500 NPDES: 4/19/22
PAA: 4/1/22
NPDES: 8/22/22
PAA: 8/1/22
NPDES: 7/1/22
PAA: 8/2/22
NPDES: ___
PAA: ___ 0 3,500 WRF: Prof Svcs
701-02430
Goldie Assoc
Paul Lewis
15 CIP PRIORITY 1A: Portable Generator Connection for
WRF (includes engineering) (JM, KL)
0% 3/31/2026 TBD 0 0 WRF: R&M
701-03000 TBD
16 Headworks Flow Pulse and Flow Channel Sensor Install
(JM)
0% 8/30/2025 TBD 8/4/2025 0 0 WRF: R&M
701-03000 TBD
Project #2026-02 General Water Reclamation Facility
Installation Projects See below (JM, KL)
1% 5/31/2026 TBD 8/13/2025 0 0 WRF: R&M
701-03000 TBD
CIP PRIORITY 1A: Primary Clarifier Sludge Pump
Replacement and Installation
0% TBD See Row 17
Above
See Row 17
Above
See Row 17
Above 0 0 See Row 14 Above See Row 14 Above
CIP PRIORITY 2: Primary Clarifier #2 Scum Pump
Replacement (one in FY26, one in FY27)
0% TBD See Row 17
Above
See Row 17
Above
See Row 17
Above 0 0 See Row 14 Above See Row 14 Above
Aeration 10" Mag Meter Installation 0% TBD See Row 17
Above
See Row 17
Above
See Row 17
Above 0 0 See Row 14 Above See Row 14 Above
CIP PRIORITY 1A: Aeration Gate Replacement 0% TBD See Row 17
Above
See Row 17
Above
See Row 17
Above 0 0 See Row 14 Above See Row 14 Above
CIP PRIORITY 1A: Aeration Motor Repair/
Replacement
0% TBD See Row 17
Above
See Row 17
Above
See Row 17
Above 0 0 See Row 14 Above See Row 14 Above
Biological Reactor Basin Oxic Motor Replacement 0% TBD See Row 17
Above
See Row 17
Above
See Row 17
Above 0 0 See Row 14 Above See Row 14 Above
Secondary Cla rifier Check Valve and Two RAS
Motors Installation
0% TBD See Row 17
Above
See Row 17
Above
See Row 17
Above 0 0 See Row 14 Above See Row 14 Above
Chlorination/PAA System Mixer Motor Replacement 0% TBD See Row 17
Above
See Row 17
Above
See Row 17
Above 0 0 See Row 14 Above See Row 14 Above
Utility Water Pump Replacement 0% TBD See Row 17
Above
See Row 17
Above
See Row 17
Above 0 0 See Row 14 Above See Row 14 Above
18 Pretreatment Program Update (following NPDES permit
issuance) (AM)
0% TBD 24,500 6/4/2025 6/4/2025 0 24,500 Pretreat: 801-02430
501-02440
Goldie Assoc
Sonya Harrison
19 Seneca Creek FM Replacement Constr
Administration/Inspect (#2023-05; CE)
85% SUB: 10/22/25
FIN: 11/21/25 140,000 RFB #2023-05 4/29/2024 2/3/2025 6/5/2025 75,000 65,000 O&M CIP: Con Sys
1401-06071
GMC
Daniel Mosher
TOTAL AWARDED 216,403 TOTAL FUNDS OBLIGATED/ACTUAL TO DATE: 110,753 105,650 TOTAL AWARDED
BUDGET REMAINING
O&M PROJECT MILESTONES
17
Page 1 of 2
EXHIBIT A - O&P Meeting 08/20/2025
Page 1 of 4
FY2026 O&M FUND PROJECTS CONSENT ORDER ENGINEERING AND OPERATIONS AND MAINTENANCE TASKS 8/18/2025 11:57
Row
#
FY 2026 O&M Project (Project # (if applicable); PM)
CANNOT CARRY OVER TO NEXT FISCAL YEAR WITHOUT
BUDGET APPROVAL
1 Consent Order 21-025-W Project: Biannual Compliance
Report (CE)
2 Agency Reconstitution (Sewer Feasibility
Implementation) (Board, Others)
3 Completion of Development Guide (AM)
4 Development Policy Revision (CE)
5 Indefinite Delivery Contract for Engineering Services
(CE)
6 Arc Flash 70E Assessment of WRF, PSs, and Other
Facilities (AM)
7 CMMS & Financial Software System Upgrade (CE)
8 Comprehensive Sewer Management Plan Project #2026-
04 (KL)
9 Evaluate Perkins PS & Coneross PS Pumps to Determine
Repair vs. Replace (KL, EP)
10 Hydraulic Model/Field Data Collection (CE)
11 Coneross PS Rotating Assembly for Pumps #4 & #5 (EP)
12 Martin PS Motor Base Restraint System (#2 of 3) (EP)
13 Martin PS Aeration Motor Install (crane needed) (EP)
14 NPDES Permit Renewal, Including PAA Installation and
Operation (JM, KL)
15 CIP PRIORITY 1A: Portable Generator Connection for
WRF (includes engineering) (JM, KL)
16 Headworks Flow Pulse and Flow Channel Sensor Install
(JM)
Project #2026-02 General Water Reclamation Facility
Installation Projects See below (JM, KL)
CIP PRIORITY 1A: Primary Clarifier Sludge Pump
Replacement and Installation
CIP PRIORITY 2: Primary Clarifier #2 Scum Pump
Replacement (one in FY26, one in FY27)
Aeration 10" Mag Meter Installation
CIP PRIORITY 1A: Aeration Gate Replacement
CIP PRIORITY 1A: Aeration Motor Repair/
Replacement
Biological Reactor Basin Oxic Motor Replacement
Secondary Cla rifier Check Valve and Two RAS
Motors Installation
Chlorination/PAA System Mixer Motor Replacement
Utility Water Pump Replacement
18 Pretreatment Program Update (following NPDES permit
issuance) (AM)
19 Seneca Creek FM Replacement Constr
Administration/Inspect (#2023-05; CE)
17
Notes
DUE TO SCDES EVERY SIX MONTHS. Reports submitted: 11/14/21, 5/9/22, 11/10/22, 5/9/23, 11/9/23, 5/10/24, 11/8/24, 5/9/24. Next report due
11/10/2025.
See "Agency Reconstitution" sheet to track progress.
8/5: A McCullough reviewing approx 15 dates. 8/13: Have received 22 draft documents from AM for consideration.
8/13: Sent to K Wunder for legal review.
8/5: L&S setting up date to visit and will then provide pricing. 8/12: Scheduled to be performed in September.
8/14: Received 8 submittals. Review to begin soo and interviews to be scheduled for up to 3 offerors during week of 9/8.
8/15: Waiting on cost.
Waiting on IDC.
8/12: Met with H Ribelin and developed a plan for data collection. She is to send us a prioritized list of locations where there is at least one key piece of
data missing. We will use GPS to gather information.
This is to be determined by the evaluation of Perkins PS & Coneross PS pumps to determine repair vs. replacement.
7/14: KL has ordered this so it can be built.
7/23: Submitted comments to SCDES for NPDES Permit.
7/14: BREC, Blanchard, and Instel will need to be involved in switchgear study. KL to contact Amy Howard. 8/18: KL still needs to contact A Howard. He
is to reach out to her very soon.
7/14: KL coordinating with Paul Davis. Items have been purchased. 8/5: Received quotes.
8/4: Waiting on B Kelley (atty) to review prior to advertising. KL will need engineering assistance for logistics to replace gates. 8/7: Sent draft RFB to B
Kelley for legal review as required by procurement code. 8/12: Received copy from BK.
Waiting on NPDES Permit issue.
$80,000 carryforward from FY2025. Obligated/Spent column includes costs from FY2025. Reimbursable by Fountain Residential Properties LLC per
agreement. 8/5 Railroad bore scheduled for Sept.
Page 2 of 2
EXHIBIT A - O&P Meeting 08/20/2025
Page 2 of 4
FY2026 RESTRICTED FUND PROJECTS PROJECTS MAY CARRY ACROSS BUDGET YEARS 8/18/2025 11:57
Row
# Restricted Fund Projects (Project Manager)
OJRSA
Project #
Approx %
Complete
Anticipated
Completion
OJRSA
Funding
Amount (S)
Max Funding
by Others (S)
PO/Contract
Amount ($)
Bids/RFQ/etc.
Issue/Advertised
PO/Contract
Signed Started Work Completed
Obligated/ Spent
Curr + Prev Years
($)
Budget
Remaining ($)
GL Code (XXXXX = get
from Office Mgr)
Comp. Performing
(and Project Mgr)
I-85 Corridor Phase II See below (CE) 80% See below N/A N/A N/A See below See below See below See below See below RO&M: CIP
1401-06050 Varies. See Below
Engineering and Inspection Services COUNTY
FUNDED
99% 10/31/2024 0 480,850 480,850 Inherited from
Oconee Co 5/4/2023 5/4/2023 431,818 49,032 RO&M: CIP
1401-06050
Davis & Floyd
John Reynolds
Construction EDA/RIA/COUNTY FUNDED 100% 10/31/2024 0 12,311,447 11,687,329 9/27/2022 3/23/2023 6/1/2023 2/4/2025 11,687,329 (0) RO&M: CIP
1401-06050
Moorhead Construct
Kevin Moorhead
Creek Stabilization & Welcome Center Waterline 5% TBD 0 78,650 78,650 Contract
Amend #3 2/20/2025 0 78,650 RO&M: CIP
1401-06050
Davis & Floyd
John Reynolds
B Exit 4/Oconee Manufacturing Park ("Sewer South
Phase III") PS/Sewer ENGINEERING (CE) CY 2022 99% 11/1/2024 0 0 N/A OCONEE
CO PROJ
N/A OCONEE
CO PROJ
N/A OCONEE
CO PROJ
Sometime in
2022 0 0 TBD Thomas & Hutton
Lee Brackett
Dewatering Equipment Replacement at WRF See
velow (JM, KL) 25% See below N/A N/A N/A See below See below See below See below See below PROJ & CONT
1501-09011 Varies. See Below
Design, Construction Admin, and Inspection
SCIIP MATCH
75% PHASE II
6/30/2026 440,300 0 440,300 9/15/2023 12/19/2023 1/11/2024 283,100 157,200 PROJ & CONT
1501-09011
KCI Technologies
Tom Vollmar
Construction SCIIP GRANT 5% PHASE II
6/30/2026 0 4,201,858 4,023,098 3/22/2024 7/30/2024 7/26/2024 0 4,023,098 PROJ & CONT
1501-09011
Harper GC
Justin Jones
Consent Order Gravity Sewer Rehab Project
(SSES/Inspection: 2023) See below (CE, KL) 15% See below N/A N/A N/A See below See below See below See below See below PROJ & CONT
1501-09009 Varies. See Below
Engineering SCIIP MATCH 75% 9/29/2025 398,000 0 398,000 N/A 9/15/2023 10/3/2023 351,752 46,248 PROJ & CONT
1501-09009
Ardurra
Priya Verravalli
Manhole Resiliency Plan: Project 1c SCIIP
MATCH
3% 9/30/2025 87,500 0 87,500 N/A 4/21/2025 4/21/2025 16,200 71,300 PROJ & CONT
1501-09009
Ardurra
Priya Verravalli
Construction/Rehabilitation SCIIP GRANT 25% SC: 8/25/2025
FC: 9/29/2025 0 4,069,004 4,076,461 8/14/2024 11/20/2024 1/27/2025 152,944 3,923,517 PROJ & CONT
1501-09009
Bio-Nomic Services
Buck Stevenson
E Martin Creek PS Basin Trunk Sewer CCTV Engineer
Review and Flow Study Report (CE) 2025-03 100% 3/31/2025 141,000 0 141,000 Consent Order
Prof Svcs 9/30/2024 141,000 0 PROJ & CONT
1501-09012
Ardurra
Priya Verravalli
F Gravity Sewer: CONSENT ORDER Evaluation of
CCTV/Smoketesting from MH29 to WRF (KL) 2026-05 0% 11/15/2025 31,500 0 31,500 Prof Svcs 8/12/2025 0 31,500 PROJ & CONT
1501-09014
Ardurra
Priya Verravalli
G Consent Order Speeds Creek FM Replacement
Engineering Design & Easements Only (CE) 2025-TBD 0% TBD TBD 0 TBD IDC Engineer 0 0 PROJ & CONT
1501-09015 TBD
1,098,300 8,270,862 9,197,859 TOTAL RESTRICTED FUNDS OBLIGATED/ACTUAL TO DATE: 944,996 8,252,862 TOTAL AWARDED
BUDGET REMAINING
D
A
C
RESTRICTED FUND PROJECT MILESTONES
2019-XX
and
2023-06
2024-08
2024-06
Page 1 of 2
EXHIBIT A - O&P Meeting 08/20/2025
Page 3 of 4
FY2026 RESTRICTED FUND PROJECTS PROJECTS MAY CARRY ACROSS BUDGET YEARS 8/18/2025 11:57
Row
# Restricted Fund Projects (Project Manager)
I-85 Corridor Phase II See below (CE)
Engineering and Inspection Services COUNTY
FUNDED
Construction EDA/RIA/COUNTY FUNDED
Creek Stabilization & Welcome Center Waterline
B Exit 4/Oconee Manufacturing Park ("Sewer South
Phase III") PS/Sewer ENGINEERING (CE)
Dewatering Equipment Replacement at WRF See
velow (JM, KL)
Design, Construction Admin, and Inspection
SCIIP MATCH
Construction SCIIP GRANT
Consent Order Gravity Sewer Rehab Project
(SSES/Inspection: 2023) See below (CE, KL)
Engineering SCIIP MATCH
Manhole Resiliency Plan: Project 1c SCIIP
MATCH
Construction/Rehabilitation SCIIP GRANT
E Martin Creek PS Basin Trunk Sewer CCTV Engineer
Review and Flow Study Report (CE)
F Gravity Sewer: CONSENT ORDER Evaluation of
CCTV/Smoketesting from MH29 to WRF (KL)
G Consent Order Speeds Creek FM Replacement
Engineering Design & Easements Only (CE)
D
A
C
Notes
2/19/2025: G Hart mentioned that he found that A Brock had submitted it and they haven't heard anything from SCDES yet. 3/18: Issued revised
Conditional Acceptance letter to A Brock for her to send to T&H if she agreed with conditions.
5/5: Received draft report to review. 6/2: Provided comments to Priya. 7/24: Received final report. COMPLETE.
Review CCTV for 9,525 LF of 30" and 36" RCP and 29 manhole inspections to develop list of defects for design of sewer rehab. 8/15: Engineer
confirmed receipt of data (delivered a few months ago). They are verifying all information.
CONSENT ORDER ITEM 7/15/2024: As identified in the 20 Year Master Plan, this force main should be replaced with similar sized pipe. 8/5: Waiting on
IDC engineer.
2/10: Roger Sears responded to R Love's email saying water line will need to be handled through encroachment process. 3/5: Signed, submitted
Stormwater Notice of Termination 3/24: Signed/sent EDA Federal Financial Report to ACOG. SCDES NPDES Permit Notice of Termination docs sent to
Columbia. 7/14: Waiting on record drawings and GIS. 7/21: Spoke with J Reynolds about grass not growing on Phase II project along interstate, he
said he'll call contractor because it is a warranty item and we need the grass to stabilize the site. SCDES will hold us accountable for any offsite impact
due to erosion. JR sent Moorhead an email same day. 7/25: Received GIS info from R Love. Forwarded to D Gant for review 7/28. Still need to
locate/GPS service cleanout at SC59/Fairplay Blvd and shoot elevations of manhole rim/grade elevations. 8/4: Locate clamp received. Waiting for GPR
training to be scheduled. 8/6: Moorhead acknowledged by email that additional stabilization is required. Likely to be performed in September.
1/6/2025: Received 90% plans, Jackson Electric visited site to assess. 1/22: Received SCDES construction permit application payment request of $550.
2/4: Board approved contracts. Signed, submitted stormwater permit application. 3/10: Received feedback from SCRIA on contract. KCI will need to
oversee a few items and respond. 3/28: Received final contract as approved by RIA for signature. Barbian asked Harper to sign then forward for OJRSA
signature. 4/17: Signed contract. 7/25: Looking at November mobilization. Looking at substantial completion in mid-July 2026.
PO/Contract Amount includes $700,000 owner contingency 7/21: Cotractor reports they will have 2 crews (starting today). 7/25: All contractor and
subs are onsite and progressing. BNS will be visiting the golf course to review possible additional manholes to rehabilitate. 8/6: Had meeting with Bio-
Nomic president, Buck Stevenson, to discuss getting project back on schedule and addressing other issues. 8/8: Received complaint about R/W issue,
Bio-Nomic investiaged 8/13 and will address. They communicated with property owner. 8/14: Pay App #5 submitted for ACOG review. 8/18:
Complaint addressed. Contractor in communication with property owner.
Page 2 of 2
EXHIBIT A - O&P Meeting 08/20/2025
Page 4 of 4
HANDOUT 1 - O&P Meeting 08/20/2025
Page 1 of 2
HANDOUT 1 - O&P Meeting 08/20/2025
Page 2 of 2
Piedmont Municipal Power Agency
BOARD PACK
for
PMPA Board Meeting
Thursday, August 21, 2025
10:00 AM (EDT)
Held at:
PMPA Office
121 Village Drive, Greer, SC 29651
Generated: 2025-08-15 11:29:00
INDEX
Cover Page
Index
Agenda
Attached Documents:
2.1 a Minutes : PMPA Board Meeting - 19 Jun 2025...................................................................... 6
3.1 a June 2025 Financial Board Mailing.pdf.................................................................................. 11
3.1 b July 2025 Financial Board Mailing.pdf.................................................................................... 18
4.1 a Fitch Rating - July 2025.pdf.................................................................................................... 25
4.2 a 2025_06_LSG Report.pdf...................................................................................................... 33
4.2 b 2025_06_Demand Response Report_.pdf............................................................................. 34
4.2 c 2025_06_Energy Report.pdf.................................................................................................. 35
4.2 d 2025_07_LSG Report.pdf...................................................................................................... 36
4.2 e 2025_07_Demand Response Report.pdf............................................................................... 37
4.2 f 2025_07_Energy Report.pdf.................................................................................................. 38
4.3 a Catawba Report August 14, 2025.pdf.................................................................................... 39
4.4 a 2025 Power Conference Survey Response.pdf..................................................................... 40
5.1 a EEA Presentation.pdf............................................................................................................. 48
6.1 a Catawba Uprate - PMPA August 21 2025.pdf........................................................................ 66
Generated on: 2025-08-15 11:28:58
Powered by BoardPro 1
AGENDA
PMPA BOARD MEETING
Name: Piedmont Municipal Power Agency
Date: Thursday, August 21, 2025
Time: 10:00 AM to 2:00 PM (EDT)
Location: PMPA Office, 121 Village Drive, Greer, SC 29651
https://pmpa.zoom.us/j/82154409700?pwd=a5cserX8xE4gySNhb2eIHudg2V3
OVX.1
Board Members: Blake Stone, Andy Sevic (Chair), Mayor Brian Ramey, David Vehaun, Eric
Goodwin, Mayor Foster Senn, Jason Taylor, Jimmy Bagley, Joe Nichols, John
Young, Keith Wood, Kevin Bronson, Lance Davis, Marc Regier, Mike Richard,
Steve Bratton, Joey Meadors, Mike Clary, David Dorman, Mayor Randy
Randall
Attendees: Angie Hoover, Brandon Audet, Cindy Frierson, Dedra Howell, Dennis
Cameron, Gary Brunault, Joel Ledbetter, JulieAnne London, Kenny Bradley,
Lynn Price, Mike Frazier, Rion Foley, Robby Townsend, Tom Gressette,
Tracy Quinn, Will Blanton
1. Call to Order
1.1 Identify Virtual Attendees
1.2 Declaration of Quorum
1.3 Invocation
2. Approval of Minutes
2.1 Confirm Minutes
Supporting Documents:
2.1.a Minutes : PMPA Board Meeting - 19 Jun 2025
2.2 Vote to Approve Minutes of June 19, 2025 Board Meeting
3. Acceptance of Financial Report
3.1 June and July 2025
Supporting Documents:
3.1.a June 2025 Financial Board Mailing.pdf
3.1.b July 2025 Financial Board Mailing.pdf
3
6
11
18
Agenda : PMPA Board Meeting - Aug 21, 2025
Powered by BoardPro 2
4. Reports
4.1 Finance
Supporting Documents:
4.1.a Fitch Rating - July 2025.pdf
4.2 Engineering
Supporting Documents:
4.2.a 2025_06_LSG Report.pdf
4.2.b 2025_06_Demand Response Report_.pdf
4.2.c 2025_06_Energy Report.pdf
4.2.d 2025_07_LSG Report.pdf
4.2.e 2025_07_Demand Response Report.pdf
4.2.f 2025_07_Energy Report.pdf
4.3 Catawba
Supporting Documents:
4.3.a Catawba Report August 14, 2025.pdf
4.4 Management
Supporting Documents:
4.4.a 2025 Power Conference Survey Response.pdf
5. Items for Discussion
5.1 Energy Emergency Alerts
Supporting Documents:
5.1.a EEA Presentation.pdf
6. Action Item
6.1 Approval of Capital Request for Power Uprate at Catawba Nuclear
For Decision
Supporting Documents:
6.1.a Catawba Uprate - PMPA August 21 2025.pdf
7. Executive Session
7.1 Vote to enter into Executive Session
4
25
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
48
66
Agenda : PMPA Board Meeting - Aug 21, 2025
Powered by BoardPro 3
7.2 Discussion of Matters Pertaining to Contractual Negotiations
7.3 Vote to return to Regular Session
8. Actions to be taken based on discussion in Executive Session
9. Participant Discussion
10. Adjourn
10.1 Adjourn
Next meeting: PMPA Board Meeting - Sep 18, 2025, 10:00 AM
5
Generated on: 2025-08-15 11:28:58
Powered by BoardPro 1
MINUTES (in Review)
PMPA BOARD MEETING
Name: Piedmont Municipal Power Agency
Date: Thursday, June 19, 2025
Time: 10:00 AM to 12:00 PM (EDT)
Location: PMPA Office, 121 Village Drive, Greer, SC 29651
Board Members: Andy Sevic (Chair), Mike Clary, Mayor Randy Randall, Joey Meadors, Eric
Goodwin, David Dorman, Steve Bratton, Mike Richard, Marc Regier, John
Young, Keith Wood, Mayor Foster Senn, Jason Taylor, Jimmy Bagley, David
Vehaun, Joe Nichols, Lance Davis, Kevin Bronson, Mayor Brian Ramey
Attendees: Joel Ledbetter, JulieAnne London, Mike Frazier, Dennis Cameron, Tracy
Quinn, Lynn Price, Will Blanton, Kenny Bradley, Gary Brunault, Rion Foley
Apologies: Blake Stone, Angie Hoover, Brandon Audet, Cindy Frierson, Dedra Howell,
Robby Townsend
Guests: Belton Ziegler, Mark White, Andrea Kelley, and Max White
Notes: Virtual Attendees: Kevin Bronson, Gary Brunault, and Andrea Kelley
1. Call to Order
1.1 Identify Virtual Attendees
1.2 Declaration of Quorum
Chairman Sevic declared that a quorum is present and the Board can conduct business.
1.3 Invocation
Mr. Ledbetter gave the invocation.
2. Administration of Oath of Office to new Board Member
2.1 Oath of Office - Mike Clary, City of Abbeville
Mrs. Quinn, Office Manager/Executive Secretary, who is also a Notary Public, administered the
oath of office to Mike Clary, who has been appointed Alternate Director from Abbeville (copy
attached).
3. Approval of Minutes
3.1 Confirm Minutes
PMPA Board Meeting May 22, 2025, the minutes were confirmed as presented.
Confirm Minutes 2.1 a
6
Minutes : PMPA Board Meeting - Jun 19, 2025
Powered by BoardPro 2
3.2 Vote to Approve Minutes of May 22, 2025 Board
Meeting
Vote to Approve Minutes of May 22, 2025 Board Meeting
10 Supported
0 Opposed
0 Abstained
Decision Date: Jun 19, 2025
Mover: David Dorman
Seconder: Mayor Foster Senn
Outcome: Approved
4. Acceptance of Financial Report
4.1 May 2025
May 2025
10 Supported
0 Opposed
0 Abstained
Decision Date: Jun 19, 2025
Mover: Mayor Randy Randall
Seconder: Keith Wood
Outcome: Approved
5. Reports
5.1 Finance
Ms. London addressed a question that was posed at the May 2025 meeting as to what impact this
year's increase in working capital will have on the proposed rate increased in 2026. Ms. London
explained that part of this year's increase in working capital is due to the delay in expenditures for
the Laurens Transmission line. In addition, all future rate increases were designed to meet the
minimum working capital target in 2028 as set by the Working Capital Policy, and even with this
years working capital increase PMPA is still projected to be at the minimum working capital target
in 2028. This subject will be discussed more thoroughly at the October planning session.
5.2 Engineering
Mr. Frazier reviewed the standard engineering reports for May that were included in the Board
Pack.
Mr. Frazier also reviewed the current status of the Laurens Transmission Line.
5.3 Catawba
Mr. Cameron reviewed the Catawba and McGuire report included in the Board Pack and any
updates since that report.
Confirm Minutes 2.1 a
7
Minutes : PMPA Board Meeting - Jun 19, 2025
Powered by BoardPro 3
5.4 Management
Mr. Ledbetter discussed the Public Power Reception next week in Washington and stated that
representatives from SCAMPS, Santee Cooper, ElectriCities, and PMPA would be attending.
Mr. Ledbetter also requested the Participants consider providing door prizes for the Power
Conference as they have in the past.
Mr. Ledbetter discussed potential topics for the Participant roundtable planned for the Power
Conference and stated he would email the Board the topics and potential presenters.
6. Items for Discussion
6.1 Participant's declaration of excess Catawba
Mr. Ledbetter discussed the resolutions received from Greer and R...
Mr. Ledbetter discussed the resolutions received from Greer and Rock Hill
declaring all of their Catawba allocation as excess beginning January 1,
2029. Section 11 of the Catawba Project Power Sales Agreement and the
Board policy adopted April 2024 address the procedure for the sale of Catawba
excess. The Board policy gives Participants that may be interested in the
excess 90 days to negotiate a purchase. Six Participants are selling excess
capacity from their allocation and can be presumed to not want to purchase
excess, and the remaining 2 Participants declared they are not interested in
additional Catawba capacity. Mr. Ledbetter stated that it was appropriate to
waive the 90 day negotiation period as stated in the Policy.
The resolution from the City of Rock Hill requests “… PMPA to market 100% of
the City’s share of its Catawba Project Output along with the excess declared
by other participants.” Mr. Ledbetter stated that the 47.5 MW excess of other
Participants had already been marketed and a proposal received, and
requested clarification from Rock Hill that they understood a sale of its Catawba
excess would be a separate marketing and sale. Rock Hill affirmed and agreed
that its sale would be a separate sale.
A motion was made by Mr. Dorman, with a second by Mr. Young to waive the
90-day notice which effectively waives any Participants right to purchase the
excess.
Approved unanimously.
10 Supported
0 Opposed
0 Abstained
Decision Date: Jun 19, 2025
Mover: David Dorman
Seconder: John Young
Outcome: Approved
7. Action Item
7.1 Resolution 25-01: Approval of Catawba Project
Power Sales Renewal Agreement
Resolution 25-01: Approval of Catawba Project Power Sales Renewal Agreement
Mayor Senn made a motion, with a second by Mayor Randall, to adopt
Resolution 25-01. Any changes to the Catawba Project Power Sales Renewal
Confirm Minutes 2.1 a
8
Minutes : PMPA Board Meeting - Jun 19, 2025
Powered by BoardPro 4
Agreement must be agreed to by both the General Manager and the
Chairman. The approved Resolution is attached to these minutes.
7 Supported
0 Opposed
3 Abstentions (Greer, Rock Hill, and Union)
Decision Date: Jun 19, 2025
Mover: Mayor Foster Senn
Seconder: Mayor Randy Randall
Outcome: Approved
8. Executive Session
8.1 Vote to enter into Executive Session
Vote to enter into Executive Session
10 Supported
0 Opposed
0 Abstained
Decision Date: Jun 19, 2025
Mover: John Young
Seconder: David Dorman
Outcome: Approved
8.2 Discussion of Personnel Matters
8.3 Vote to return to Regular Session
Vote to return to Regular Session
10 Supported
0 Opposed
0 Abstained
Decision Date: Jun 19, 2025
Mover: Joe Nichols
Seconder: Jimmy Bagley
Outcome: Approved
9. Participant Discussion
10. Miscellaneous
10.1 Annual Engineering Report
The Annual Engineering Report for 2024 was included in the Board Pack as information. A copy
will be emailed to all Board members and alternates.
Confirm Minutes 2.1 a
9
Minutes : PMPA Board Meeting - Jun 19, 2025
Powered by BoardPro 5
11. Adjourn
11.1 Adjourn
Next meeting: PMPA Board Meeting - Aug 21, 2025, 10:00 AM
A motion was made by Mr. Dorman, with a second by Mr. Young, to adjourn the meeting.
Motion passed.
Signature:____________________ Date:_________________________
Confirm Minutes 2.1 a
10
LAST MONTH INCREASE DECREASE THIS MONTH
ASSETS
CURRENT UNRESTRICTED ASSETS:
Cash And Markable Debt Securities (W/C) $74,245 $2,239 $0 $76,484
Revenue Fund Valuation (2) 0 0 (2)
Fuel (2,840) 914 0 (1,925)
Participants Accounts Receivable (W/C) 17,326 2,557 0 19,883
Other Accounts Receivable (W/C) 697 0 149 547
Materials & Supplies 20,070 278 0 20,348
TOTAL CURRENT UNRESTRICTED ASSETS 109,495 5,839 0 115,334
CURRENT RESTRICTED ASSETS:
Debt Service 36,179 7,195 0 43,375
Debt Service Reserve 46,187 0 0 46,187
Reserve and Contingency 3,527 1,404 0 4,931
Decommissioning 142,518 536 0 143,055
Supplemental Power Reserve 1,600 0 0 1,600
Restricted Funds Valuation (597) 1,121 0 524
TOTAL CURRENT RESTRICTED ASSETS 229,414 10,257 0 239,672
TOTAL CURRENT ASSETS 338,909 16,096 0 355,005
CAPITAL ASSETS, NET:
Generation 357,672 0 744 356,928
Transmission 4,053 0 11 4,042
LDMS/SCADA 439 0 12 426
General 495 0 9 486
Nuclear Fuel - In Stock And Progress 26,864 258 0 27,121
Nuclear Fuel - In Reactor 20,188 0 1,172 19,016
Construction In Progress 23,347 558 0 23,904
TOTAL CAPITAL ASSETS, NET 433,057 0 1,133 431,924
OTHER NON CURRENT ASSETS:
Net Costs Recoverable From Future Participants Billings 211,161 0 4,093 207,069
Participant Settlement Receivable 45,400 0 0 45,400
TOTAL NON CURRENT ASSETS 689,618 0 5,226 684,392
TOTAL ASSETS $1,028,528 $10,870 $0 $1,039,398
DEFERRED OUTFLOWS:
Asset Retirement Obligation $36,499 $0 $79 $36,420
Redemption Losses, Net 3,955 0 54 3,900
Losses On Advanced Refunding Of Debt, Net 4,301 0 81 4,219
TOTAL DEFERRED OUTFLOWS $44,754 $0 $214 $44,540
PIEDMONT MUNICIPAL POWER AGENCY
COMPARATIVE STATEMENT OF NET POSITION
AS OF JUNE 30, 2025
(DOLLARS IN THOUSANDS)
June and July 2025 3.1 a
11
LAST MONTH INCREASE DECREASE THIS MONTH
LIABILITIES
CURRENT LIABILITIES:
Accounts Payable - General (WC) $122 $0 $122 $0
Accounts Payable - Duke (WC) 724 484 0 1,208
Accounts Payable - Other (WC) 802 2,276 0 3,077
Accrued Expenses - Payroll (W/C) 0 0 0 0
Accrued Expenses - Vacation (W/C) 88 0 0 88
Accrued Expenses - Sick (W/C) 178 0 0 178
Accrued Expenses - Property Taxes (W/C) 4,220 843 0 5,063
TOTAL CURRENT LIABILITIES 6,134 3,481 0 9,615
CURRENT LIABILITIES PAYABLE FROM RESTRICTED ASSETS:
Accrued Interest Payable 188,859 2,776 0 191,634
TOTAL CURRENT LIABILITIES 194,993 6,256 0 201,249
LONG-TERM LIABILITIES:
Bonds - Including Current Installment 340,015 0 0 340,015
Bonds - Settlement 48,330 0 0 48,330
Bond Discounts (29) 0 0 (28)
Bond Premium 34,349 0 553 33,797
CAB 80,330 0 0 80,330
Asset Retirement Obligation 185,141 495 0 185,636
Participant Interest Payable (W/C) 144 5 0 149
Other Postemployment Benefits 1,724 0 0 1,724
TOTAL LONG-TERM LIABILITIES 690,005 0 52 689,952
TOTAL LIABILITIES $884,997 $6,204 $0 $891,201
DEFERRED INFLOWS:
Postemployment Benefits $216 $0 $0 $216
NET POSITION
Net Investments In Capital Assets ($13,353) $0 $716 ($14,069)
Restricted For Other 1,600 0 0 1,600
Unrestricted 199,822 5,168 0 204,990
TOTAL NET POSITION $188,069 $4,452 $0 $192,521
INFORMATIONAL PURPOSES:
Working Capital $85,989 $1,161 $0 $87,150
PIEDMONT MUNICIPAL POWER AGENCY
COMPARATIVE STATEMENT OF NET POSITION
AS OF JUNE 30, 2025
(DOLLARS IN THOUSANDS)
June and July 2025 3.1 a
12
PIEDMONT MUNICIPAL POWER AGENCY
FINANCIAL SUMMARY
AS OF JUNE 30, 2025
MAJOR DEVIATIONS FROM THE BUDGET WERE:
(In Millions) $ % Comments
Working Capital $0.70 150.2%
Participant Power Sales $0.89 4.5%
Surplus Sales $0.12 34.0% Santee adjustments related to April and May sales
Miscellaneous Income/Expense $0.05 6.8% Lower than budgeted Duke fees
Interest Income ($0.07) -7.4%
Lower than budgeted yields on DCom and R&C funds, partially offset by higher than budgeted yields on
Revenue fund
Catawba Project Costs $0.50 7.7% Lower than budgeted electrical operations and miscellaneous maintenance costs
Supplemental Power Costs ($0.84) -16.7%
Higher than budgeted Santee capacity ($0.2) and energy ($0.2), higher than budgeted transmission costs due
to increased revenue requirements that took effect in June ($0.2), and Duke SEEM adjustments ($0.2)
Catawba Capital Additions $0.78 59.2% Lower than budgeted expenses due to timing of expenses
PMPA Capital Additions $0.19 89.6% Primarily timing of Laurens Transmission line project
Other ($0.91) -13.2% Primarily higher R&C transfer due to timing of Cap Adds
(In Millions) $ % Comments
Working Capital $5.94 1004.6%
Participant Power Sales $1.45 1.3%
Surplus Sales $1.40 37.9% Higher energy sales and pricing received for sales than budgeted
Miscellaneous Income/Expense $0.31 7.6% Lower than budgeted Duke fees
Interest Income ($0.23) -4.7%
Catawba Project Costs $2.88 7.0% Lower than budgeted O&M costs & year-end Duke benefits, insurance, and G&A true-up
Supplemental Power Costs ($1.39) -6.3% Higher purchases in January due to colder temperatures and increased capacity and transmission costs in June.
Catawba Capital Additions $0.02 0.2%
PMPA Capital Additions $1.12 67.7% Primarily timing of Laurens Transmission line project
Other $0.37 0.9%
Favorable >5%
Near Budget +/- 5%
Unfavorable < 5%
YEAR-TO-DATE VARIANCES
JUNE VARIANCES
June and July 2025 3.1 a
13
CURRENT MONTH
ACTUAL BUDGET OVER(UNDER)
YEAR TO DATE
ACTUAL BUDGET OVER(UNDER) %
CATAWBA PROJECT:
CATAWBA POWER SALES
Participant $14,877 $14,632 $245 $87,638 $86,513 $1,125 1.3%
Duke-Exchange Energy 1,015 948 67 5,801 5,823 (22) (0.4%)
Other-Surplus 457 341 116 5,079 3,683 1,396 37.9%
TOTAL 16,349 15,921 428 98,518 96,019 2,499 2.6%
CATAWBA POWER COSTS
Operations & Maintenance 1,637 2,081 (444) 13,132 15,062 (1,930) (12.8%)
Fuel Amort(Fuel Acct Deposit) 1,172 1,191 (19) 7,009 7,187 (178) (2.5%)
Purch Power-Duke-McGuire Cap 20 20 0 121 122 (1) (0.6%)
-McGuire Energy 1,048 1,016 32 5,636 5,740 (104) (1.8%)
Customer Acct and G&A-Duke 790 758 32 4,323 4,550 (227) (5.0%)
Customer Acct and G&A-Agency 348 432 (84) 2,219 2,616 (397) (15.2%)
Property Tax Equivalent 834 834 0 5,011 5,009 2 0.0%
Tax Other-Duke 93 106 (13) 584 633 (49) (7.8%)
TOTAL 5,942 6,438 (496) 38,035 40,919 (2,884) (7.0%)
FUNDS AVAILABLE FROM OPERATIONS 10,406 9,483 923 60,483 55,100 5,383 9.8%
INTEREST INCOME 825 891 (66) 4,550 4,776 (226) (4.7%)
MISCELLANEOUS INCOME(EXPENSE) (630) (676) 46 (3,752) (4,059) 307 (7.6%)
FUNDS AVAILABLE FOR CAPITAL NEEDS 10,601 9,698 903 61,281 55,817 5,464 9.8%
OTHER AVAILABLE FUNDS
Debt Service-Principal 0 0 0 66,565 66,565 0 0.0%
-Interest 0 0 0 10,952 10,946 6 0.1%
Reserve & Contingency - Capital Additions 536 1,315 (779) 11,329 11,351 (22) (0.2%)
Fuel 258 53 205 4,927 8,789 (3,862) (43.9%)
DEPOSITS
Debt Service-Principal 2,255 2,256 (1) 13,532 13,532 0 0.0%
-Interest 4,431 4,431 0 28,122 28,122 0 0.0%
Reserve & Contingency 1,940 1,940 0 11,640 11,640 0 0.0%
Decommissioning 536 567 (31) 3,244 3,346 (102) (3.0%)
Inventory 278 40 238 (404) (31) (373) 1,204.0%
PAYMENTS
Debt Service-Principal 0 0 0 66,565 66,565 0 0.0%
-Interest 0 0 0 10,952 10,946 6 0.1%
Capital Additions 536 1,315 (779) 11,329 11,351 (22) (0.2%)
Fuel 258 53 205 4,927 8,789 (3,862) (43.9%)
TRANSFERS (TO) FROM
Reserve & Contingency 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.0%
DSR Release/Special Transfers 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.0%
Catawba Working Capital 1,161 464 697 5,145 (792) 5,937 (749.6%)
Supplemental Working Capital 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.0%
WORKING CAP INCREASE(DECREASE) $1,161 $464 $697 $5,145 ($792) $5,937 (749.6%)
PIEDMONT MUNICIPAL POWER AGENCY
STATEMENT OF REVENUE & EXPENSE PER THE BOND RESOLUTION
AS Of JUNE 30, 2025
(DOLLARS IN THOUSANDS)
June and July 2025 3.1 a
14
CURRENT MONTH
ACTUAL BUDGET OVER(UNDER)
YEAR TO DATE
ACTUAL BUDGET OVER(UNDER) %
SUPPLEMENTAL:
SUPPLEMENTAL POWER SALES
Participants-Supplemental Power 5,778 5,138 640 23,286 22,961 325 1.4%
-Leased Facilities 26 29 (3) 158 169 (11) (6.4%)
-Other 121 106 15 621 671 (50) (7.5%)
TOTAL 5,925 5,273 652 24,065 23,801 264 1.1%
SUPPLEMENTAL POWER COSTS
Purch Power-Supp Capacity 1,061 878 183 5,302 5,268 34 0.7%
-Supp Energy 2,210 1,863 347 4,080 3,352 728 21.7%
Purch Power-Participants 1,124 1,108 16 6,265 6,436 (171) (2.7%)
Purch Power-Other 269 239 30 1,572 1,239 333 26.8%
Transmission 1,101 802 299 5,324 4,724 600 12.7%
Transmission-Agency 0 5 (5) 24 25 (1) (4.4%)
Leased Facilities-Duke 37 38 (1) 217 226 (9) (4.0%)
Meter-Agency 0 1 (1) 94 106 (12) (11.3%)
Customer Acct and G&A-Duke 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.0%
Customer Acct and G&A-Agency 92 116 (24) 590 703 (113) (16.1%)
Property Tax Equivalent 9 9 0 52 54 (2) (3.6%)
TOTAL 5,902 5,059 843 23,519 22,133 1,386 6.3%
FUNDS AVAILABLE FROM OPERATIONS 23 214 (191) 546 1,668 (1,122) (67.3%)
MISCELLANEOUS INCOME(EXPENSE) 201 199 2 1,200 1,199 1 0.1%
FUNDS AVAILABLE FOR CAPITAL NEEDS 224 413 (189) 1,746 2,867 (1,121) (39.1%)
PAYMENTS
Debt Service-Interest 202 201 1 1,211 1,211 0 0.0%
Capital Additions-Transmission 3 211 (208) 190 1,263 (1,073) (85.0%)
-LDMSS/SCADA 0 0 0 326 341 (15) (4.4%)
-General 19 1 18 19 52 (33) (63.7%)
WORKING CAP INCREASE(DECREASE) $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 0.0%
PIEDMONT MUNICIPAL POWER AGENCY
STATEMENT OF REVENUE & EXPENSE PER THE BOND RESOLUTION
AS Of JUNE 30, 2025
(DOLLARS IN THOUSANDS)
June and July 2025 3.1 a
15
CURRENT MONTH
ACTUAL BUDGET OVER(UNDER) %
YEAR TO DATE
ACTUAL BUDGET OVER(UNDER) %
% ANNUAL
BUDGET
G&A-OFFICE EXPENSE
$131,743 $138,200 ($6,457) (4.7) Payroll $796,245 $844,600 ($48,355) (5.7) 44.3
9,253 9,500 (247) (2.6) Employer's FICA 63,852 68,900 (5,048) (7.3) 55.5
19,465 19,100 365 1.9 Medical/Life Insurance 117,178 115,000 2,178 1.9 50.9
12,770 12,700 70 0.6 401A Plan 82,867 82,500 367 0.4 50.2
178 300 (122) (40.7) Subscriptions 925 700 225 32.1 46.3
5,057 400 4,657 1,164.3 Dues & Memberships 300,413 309,100 (8,687) (2.8) 79.3
1,549 2,100 (551) (26.2) Utilities 10,420 12,600 (2,180) (17.3) 41.7
1,457 1,600 (143) (8.9) Telephone 8,129 8,600 (471) (5.5) 47.8
512 2,100 (1,588) (75.6) Office Supplies 2,701 12,600 (9,899) (78.6) 10.8
0 100 (100) (100.0) Postage 559 900 (341) (37.9) 28.0
244 100 144 144.0 Printing 293 600 (307) (51.2) 14.7
902 1,300 (398) (30.6) Board & Staff Expenses 9,231 11,700 (2,469) (21.1) 16.2
0 200 (200) (100.0) Miscellaneous 2,397 1,500 897 59.8 79.9
298 500 (202) (40.4) Equipment Rental 3,623 3,500 123 3.5 51.8
11,744 2,700 9,044 335.0 Maintenance-Building 23,082 80,100 (57,018) (71.2) 22.6
39,082 79,200 (40,118) (50.7) Travel-Conf/Meetings 103,280 198,300 (95,020) (47.9) 34.4
2,189 1,000 1,189 118.9 Travel-Training 5,882 23,400 (17,518) (74.9) 19.6
1,737 2,900 (1,163) (40.1) Travel-Agency 11,698 18,000 (6,302) (35.0) 32.5
(394) 0 (394) 0.0 Worker's Comp Insurance 4,604 5,000 (396) (7.9) 92.1
0 0 0 0.0 Property Insurance 11,361 13,000 (1,639) (12.6) 87.4
85,463 100,000 (14,537) (14.5) Liability Insurance 95,589 111,000 (15,411) (13.9) 86.1
252 100 152 152.0 Bank & Rating Agency Fees 28,598 29,600 (1,002) (3.4) 26.0
0 3,000 (3,000) (100.0) Annual Report 0 3,000 (3,000) (100.0) 0.0
1,918 40,200 (38,282) (95.2) Economic Development 119,840 241,800 (121,960) (50.4) 23.8
9,845 9,400 445 4.7 Telecommunications 55,792 56,400 (608) (1.1) 49.4
0 500 (500) (100.0) Maintenance-Telecom 0 3,000 (3,000) (100.0) 0.0
8,539 13,500 (4,961) (36.7) Computer Hardware/Software 295,642 286,100 9,542 3.3 73.4
343,803 440,700 (96,897) (22.0) TOTAL G&A OFFICE EXPENSE 2,154,201 2,541,500 (387,299) (15.2) 47.2
G&A-OUTSIDE SERVICES
57,924 76,200 (18,276) (24.0) Legal 386,249 457,500 (71,251) (15.6) 42.2
34,265 27,500 6,765 24.6 Engineering 127,183 165,000 (37,817) (22.9) 38.5
0 0 0 0.0 Accounting 70,740 70,000 740 1.1 101.1
0 1,100 (1,100) (100.0) Financial 60,778 65,300 (4,522) (6.9) 24.5
3,995 0 3,995 0.0 Administrative 8,120 5,000 3,120 62.4 162.4
0 2,400 (2,400) (100.0) Technology 1,050 14,400 (13,350) (92.7) 3.6
96,184 107,200 (11,016) (10.3) TOTAL G&A OUTSIDE SERVICES 654,120 777,200 (123,080) (15.8) 41.0
$439,987 $547,900 ($107,913) (19.7) TOTAL OPERATING EXPENSE $2,808,321 $3,318,700 ($510,379) (15.4) 45.6
TRANSMISSION EXPENSE-AGENCY
$0 $5,000 ($5,000) (100.0) Transmission Line Maintenance $23,908 $25,000 ($1,092) (4.4) 47.8
0 1,000 (1,000) (100.0) Energy Efficiency/DSM 94,021 106,000 (11,979) (11.3) 69.1
$0 $6,000 ($6,000) (100.0) TOTAL XMSN EXPENSE $117,929 $131,000 ($13,071) (10.0) 63.4
PIEDMONT MUNICIPAL POWER AGENCY
STATEMENT OF G&A EXPENSE
AS OF JUNE 30, 2025
June and July 2025 3.1 a
16
PIEDMONT MUNICIPAL POWER AGENCY
AS OF JUNE 30, 2025
After this month’s operations, PMPA had $87.2 million in working capital, which was $5.9 million better than the YTD budget.
June and July 2025 3.1 a
17
LAST MONTH INCREASE DECREASE THIS MONTH
ASSETS
CURRENT UNRESTRICTED ASSETS:
Cash And Markable Debt Securities (W/C) $76,484 $1,938 $0 $78,422
Revenue Fund Valuation (2) 0 0 (2)
Fuel (1,925) 953 0 (973)
Participants Accounts Receivable (W/C) 19,883 1,413 0 21,296
Other Accounts Receivable (W/C) 547 0 506 42
Materials & Supplies 20,348 156 0 20,504
TOTAL CURRENT UNRESTRICTED ASSETS 115,334 3,955 0 119,289
CURRENT RESTRICTED ASSETS:
Debt Service 43,375 0 2,106 41,269
Debt Service Reserve 46,187 0 0 46,187
Reserve and Contingency 4,931 896 0 5,827
Decommissioning 143,055 590 0 143,645
Supplemental Power Reserve 1,600 0 0 1,600
Restricted Funds Valuation 524 0 0 524
TOTAL CURRENT RESTRICTED ASSETS 239,672 0 619 239,052
TOTAL CURRENT ASSETS 355,005 3,335 0 358,341
CAPITAL ASSETS, NET:
Generation 356,928 0 744 356,184
Transmission 4,042 0 11 4,030
LDMS/SCADA 426 0 12 414
General 486 0 9 477
Nuclear Fuel - In Stock And Progress 27,121 259 0 27,380
Nuclear Fuel - In Reactor 19,016 0 1,211 17,804
Construction In Progress 23,904 1,044 0 24,948
TOTAL CAPITAL ASSETS, NET 431,924 0 685 431,239
OTHER NON CURRENT ASSETS:
Net Costs Recoverable From Future Participants Billings 207,069 0 4,058 203,011
Participant Settlement Receivable 45,400 0 0 45,400
TOTAL NON CURRENT ASSETS 684,392 0 4,743 679,650
TOTAL ASSETS $1,039,398 $0 $1,407 $1,037,990
DEFERRED OUTFLOWS:
Asset Retirement Obligation $36,420 $0 $79 $36,342
Redemption Losses, Net 3,900 0 54 3,846
Losses On Advanced Refunding Of Debt, Net 4,219 0 81 4,138
TOTAL DEFERRED OUTFLOWS $44,540 $0 $214 $44,326
PIEDMONT MUNICIPAL POWER AGENCY
COMPARATIVE STATEMENT OF NET POSITION
AS OF JULY 31, 2025
(DOLLARS IN THOUSANDS)
June and July 2025 3.1 b
18
LAST MONTH INCREASE DECREASE THIS MONTH
LIABILITIES
CURRENT LIABILITIES:
Accounts Payable - General (WC) $0 $0 $0 $0
Accounts Payable - Duke (WC) 1,208 0 85 1,123
Accounts Payable - Other (WC) 3,077 1,601 0 4,679
Accrued Expenses - Payroll (W/C) 0 0 0 0
Accrued Expenses - Vacation (W/C) 88 0 0 88
Accrued Expenses - Sick (W/C) 178 0 0 178
Accrued Expenses - Property Taxes (W/C) 5,063 844 0 5,907
TOTAL CURRENT LIABILITIES 9,615 2,360 0 11,975
CURRENT LIABILITIES PAYABLE FROM RESTRICTED ASSETS:
Accrued Interest Payable 191,634 0 6,491 185,144
TOTAL CURRENT LIABILITIES 201,249 0 4,130 197,119
LONG-TERM LIABILITIES:
Bonds - Including Current Installment 340,015 0 0 340,015
Bonds - Settlement 48,330 0 0 48,330
Bond Discounts (28) 0 0 (28)
Bond Premium 33,797 0 553 33,244
CAB 80,330 0 0 80,330
Asset Retirement Obligation 185,636 495 0 186,130
Participant Interest Payable (W/C) 149 7 0 156
Other Postemployment Benefits 1,724 0 0 1,724
TOTAL LONG-TERM LIABILITIES 689,952 0 51 689,901
TOTAL LIABILITIES $891,201 $0 $4,181 $887,020
DEFERRED INFLOWS:
Postemployment Benefits $216 $0 $0 $216
NET POSITION
Net Investments In Capital Assets ($14,069) $0 $268 ($14,337)
Restricted For Other 1,600 0 0 1,600
Unrestricted 204,990 2,828 0 207,818
TOTAL NET POSITION $192,521 $2,560 $0 $195,080
INFORMATIONAL PURPOSES:
Working Capital $87,150 $479 $0 $87,629
PIEDMONT MUNICIPAL POWER AGENCY
COMPARATIVE STATEMENT OF NET POSITION
AS OF JULY 31, 2025
(DOLLARS IN THOUSANDS)
June and July 2025 3.1 b
19
PIEDMONT MUNICIPAL POWER AGENCY
FINANCIAL SUMMARY
AS OF JULY 31, 2025
MAJOR DEVIATIONS FROM THE BUDGET WERE:
(In Millions) $ % Comments
Working Capital $0.45 1451.6%
Participant Power Sales $1.21 5.8% Primarily driven by higher than normal temperatures this month
Surplus Sales ($0.05) ‐31.0% Lower quantity sold than budgeted, driven by higher than normal temperatures this month
Miscellaneous Income/Expense $0.13 19.1% Lower than budgeted Duke fees
Interest Income $0.06 7.1% Primarily higher than budgeted yields in the Revenue fund
Catawba Project Costs $0.39 5.9% Lower than budgeted electrical operations and miscellaneous maintenance costs
Supplemental Power Costs ($1.46) ‐24.4%
Higher than budgeted Santee capacity ($0.1) and energy ($1.1), higher than budgeted transmission costs
due to increased revenue requirements that took effect in June ($0.2), and Duke SEEM adjustments ($0.1)
Catawba Capital Additions $0.27 20.5% Lower than budgeted expenses due to timing of expenses
PMPA Capital Additions $0.21 100.0% Primarily timing of Laurens Transmission line project
Other ($0.32) ‐4.5%
(In Millions) $ % Comments
Working Capital $6.39 839.0%
Participant Power Sales $2.66 2.0%
Surplus Sales $1.35 35.1% Higher energy sales and pricing received for sales than budgeted
Miscellaneous Income/Expense $0.44 9.2% Lower than budgeted Duke fees
Interest Income ($0.17) ‐2.9%
Catawba Project Costs $3.27 6.9% Lower than budgeted O&M costs & year‐end Duke benefits, insurance, and G&A true‐up
Supplemental Power Costs ($2.84) ‐10.1%
Higher purchases in January and July due to temperatures and increased capacity and transmission costs
in June and July
Catawba Capital Additions $0.29 2.3%
PMPA Capital Additions $1.33 71.3% Primarily timing of Laurens Transmission line project
Other $0.05 0.1%
Favorable >5%
Near Budget +/‐ 5%
Unfavorable < 5%
YEAR‐TO‐DATE VARIANCES
JULY VARIANCES
June and July 2025 3.1 b
20
CURRENT MONTH
ACTUAL BUDGET OVER(UNDER)
YEAR TO DATE
ACTUAL BUDGET OVER(UNDER) %
CATAWBA PROJECT:
CATAWBA POWER SALES
Participant $14,844 $14,859 ($15) $102,482 $101,372 $1,110 1.1%
Duke-Exchange Energy 1,043 988 55 6,845 6,811 34 0.5%
Other-Surplus 107 155 (48) 5,186 3,838 1,348 35.1%
TOTAL 15,993 16,002 (9) 114,512 112,021 2,491 2.2%
CATAWBA POWER COSTS
Operations & Maintenance 1,740 2,081 (341) 14,873 17,143 (2,270) (13.2%)
Fuel Amort(Fuel Acct Deposit) 1,211 1,231 (20) 8,220 8,418 (198) (2.4%)
Purch Power-Duke-McGuire Cap 21 21 0 142 143 (1) (0.6%)
-McGuire Energy 1,068 1,001 67 6,704 6,741 (37) (0.6%)
Customer Acct and G&A-Duke 770 758 12 5,093 5,308 (215) (4.1%)
Customer Acct and G&A-Agency 470 561 (91) 2,689 3,177 (488) (15.4%)
Property Tax Equivalent 835 835 0 5,846 5,844 2 0.0%
Tax Other-Duke 91 105 (14) 675 738 (63) (8.5%)
TOTAL 6,206 6,593 (387) 44,241 47,512 (3,271) (6.9%)
FUNDS AVAILABLE FROM OPERATIONS 9,787 9,409 378 70,270 64,509 5,761 8.9%
INTEREST INCOME 920 859 61 5,469 5,635 (166) (2.9%)
MISCELLANEOUS INCOME(EXPENSE) (548) (677) 129 (4,300) (4,736) 436 (9.2%)
FUNDS AVAILABLE FOR CAPITAL NEEDS 10,159 9,591 568 71,440 65,408 6,032 9.2%
OTHER AVAILABLE FUNDS
Debt Service-Principal 0 0 0 66,565 66,565 0 0.0%
-Interest 9,301 9,308 (7) 20,254 20,254 0 0.0%
Reserve & Contingency - Capital Additions 1,044 1,314 (270) 12,373 12,665 (292) (2.3%)
Fuel 259 581 (322) 5,186 9,370 (4,184) (44.7%)
DEPOSITS
Debt Service-Principal 2,255 2,255 0 15,788 15,787 1 0.0%
-Interest 4,738 4,738 0 32,861 32,860 1 0.0%
Reserve & Contingency 1,940 1,940 0 13,581 13,580 1 0.0%
Decommissioning 590 587 3 3,835 3,933 (98) (2.5%)
Inventory 156 40 116 (248) 9 (257) (2,856.2%)
PAYMENTS
Debt Service-Principal 0 0 0 66,565 66,565 0 0.0%
-Interest 9,301 9,308 (7) 20,254 20,254 0 0.0%
Capital Additions 1,044 1,314 (270) 12,373 12,665 (292) (2.3%)
Fuel 259 581 (322) 5,186 9,370 (4,184) (44.7%)
TRANSFERS (TO) FROM
Reserve & Contingency 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.0%
DSR Release/Special Transfers 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.0%
Catawba Working Capital 479 31 448 5,624 (761) 6,385 (839.0%)
Supplemental Working Capital 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.0%
WORKING CAP INCREASE(DECREASE) $479 $31 $448 $5,624 ($761) $6,385 (839.0%)
PIEDMONT MUNICIPAL POWER AGENCY
STATEMENT OF REVENUE & EXPENSE PER THE BOND RESOLUTION
AS Of JULY 31, 2025
(DOLLARS IN THOUSANDS)
June and July 2025 3.1 b
21
CURRENT MONTH
ACTUAL BUDGET OVER(UNDER)
YEAR TO DATE
ACTUAL BUDGET OVER(UNDER) %
SUPPLEMENTAL:
SUPPLEMENTAL POWER SALES
Participants-Supplemental Power 7,280 6,052 1,228 30,566 29,013 1,553 5.4%
-Leased Facilities 26 28 (2) 185 197 (12) (6.3%)
-Other 121 103 18 741 774 (33) (4.2%)
TOTAL 7,427 6,183 1,244 31,492 29,984 1,508 5.0%
SUPPLEMENTAL POWER COSTS
Purch Power-Supp Capacity 1,008 924 84 6,310 6,192 118 1.9%
-Supp Energy 3,572 2,561 1,011 7,651 5,913 1,738 29.4%
Purch Power-Participants 1,181 1,143 38 7,446 7,579 (133) (1.7%)
Purch Power-Other 383 344 39 1,955 1,583 372 23.5%
Transmission 1,110 795 315 6,434 5,519 915 16.6%
Transmission-Agency 0 4 (4) 24 29 (5) (17.6%)
Leased Facilities-Duke 37 38 (1) 254 264 (10) (3.9%)
Meter-Agency 0 1 (1) 94 107 (13) (12.1%)
Customer Acct and G&A-Duke 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.0%
Customer Acct and G&A-Agency 125 151 (26) 715 854 (139) (16.3%)
Property Tax Equivalent 9 9 0 61 63 (2) (3.6%)
TOTAL 7,425 5,970 1,455 30,944 28,103 2,841 10.1%
FUNDS AVAILABLE FROM OPERATIONS 2 213 (211) 548 1,881 (1,333) (70.9%)
MISCELLANEOUS INCOME(EXPENSE) 200 200 0 1,400 1,399 1 0.0%
FUNDS AVAILABLE FOR CAPITAL NEEDS 202 413 (211) 1,948 3,280 (1,332) (40.6%)
PAYMENTS
Debt Service-Interest 202 202 0 1,412 1,413 (1) 0.0%
Capital Additions-Transmission 0 210 (210) 190 1,473 (1,283) (87.1%)
-LDMSS/SCADA 0 0 0 326 341 (15) (4.4%)
-General 0 1 (1) 19 53 (34) (64.4%)
WORKING CAP INCREASE(DECREASE) $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 0.0%
PIEDMONT MUNICIPAL POWER AGENCY
STATEMENT OF REVENUE & EXPENSE PER THE BOND RESOLUTION
AS Of JULY 31, 2025
(DOLLARS IN THOUSANDS)
June and July 2025 3.1 b
22
CURRENT MONTH
ACTUAL BUDGET OVER(UNDER) %
YEAR TO DATE
ACTUAL BUDGET OVER(UNDER) %
% ANNUAL
BUDGET
G&A-OFFICE EXPENSE
$135,866 $138,200 ($2,334) (1.7) Payroll $932,111 $982,800 ($50,689) (5.2) 51.8
8,352 8,100 252 3.1 Employer's FICA 72,204 77,000 (4,796) (6.2) 62.8
19,470 19,200 270 1.4 Medical/Life Insurance 136,648 134,200 2,448 1.8 59.4
12,846 12,700 146 1.1 401A Plan 95,713 95,200 513 0.5 58.0
41 100 (59) (59.0) Subscriptions 966 800 166 20.8 48.3
355 1,100 (745) (67.7) Dues & Memberships 300,768 310,200 (9,432) (3.0) 79.4
1,719 2,100 (381) (18.1) Utilities 12,139 14,700 (2,561) (17.4) 48.6
1,396 1,400 (4) (0.3) Telephone 9,525 10,000 (475) (4.8) 56.0
180 2,100 (1,920) (91.4) Office Supplies 2,882 14,700 (11,818) (80.4) 11.5
0 200 (200) (100.0) Postage 559 1,100 (541) (49.2) 28.0
0 100 (100) (100.0) Printing 293 700 (407) (58.1) 14.7
198 1,300 (1,102) (84.8) Board & Staff Expenses 9,429 13,000 (3,571) (27.5) 16.5
0 300 (300) (100.0) Miscellaneous 2,397 1,800 597 33.2 79.9
588 600 (12) (2.0) Equipment Rental 4,210 4,100 110 2.7 60.1
4,405 2,700 1,705 63.1 Maintenance-Building 27,487 82,800 (55,313) (66.8) 26.9
17,604 12,200 5,404 44.3 Travel-Conf/Meetings 120,884 210,500 (89,616) (42.6) 40.3
75 1,100 (1,025) (93.2) Travel-Training 5,957 24,500 (18,543) (75.7) 19.9
5,001 3,000 2,001 66.7 Travel-Agency 16,699 21,000 (4,301) (20.5) 46.4
0 0 0 0.0 Worker's Comp Insurance 4,604 5,000 (396) (7.9) 92.1
0 0 0 0.0 Property Insurance 11,361 13,000 (1,639) (12.6) 87.4
0 0 0 0.0 Liability Insurance 95,589 111,000 (15,411) (13.9) 86.1
65,433 80,100 (14,667) (18.3) Bank & Rating Agency Fees 94,031 109,700 (15,669) (14.3) 85.5
1,973 0 1,973 0.0 Annual Report 1,973 3,000 (1,027) (34.2) 65.8
163,256 226,800 (63,544) (28.0) Economic Development 283,096 468,600 (185,504) (39.6) 56.3
9,654 9,400 254 2.7 Telecommunications 65,446 65,800 (354) (0.5) 57.9
0 500 (500) (100.0) Maintenance-Telecom 0 3,500 (3,500) (100.0) 0.0
20,952 22,200 (1,248) (5.6) Computer Hardware/Software 316,594 308,300 8,294 2.7 78.6
469,364 545,500 (76,136) (14.0) TOTAL G&A OFFICE EXPENSE 2,623,565 3,087,000 (463,435) (15.0) 57.5
G&A-OUTSIDE SERVICES
62,378 76,300 (13,922) (18.2) Legal 448,627 533,800 (85,173) (16.0) 49.0
6,103 27,500 (21,397) (77.8) Engineering 133,286 192,500 (59,214) (30.8) 40.4
0 0 0 0.0 Accounting 70,740 70,000 740 1.1 101.1
56,979 59,800 (2,821) (4.7) Financial 117,757 125,100 (7,343) (5.9) 47.5
0 0 0 0.0 Administrative 8,120 5,000 3,120 62.4 162.4
83 2,500 (2,417) (96.7) Technology 1,133 16,900 (15,767) (93.3) 3.9
125,543 166,100 (40,557) (24.4) TOTAL G&A OUTSIDE SERVICES 779,663 943,300 (163,637) (17.3) 48.8
$594,907 $711,600 ($116,693) (16.4) TOTAL OPERATING EXPENSE $3,403,228 $4,030,300 ($627,072) (15.6) 55.3
TRANSMISSION EXPENSE-AGENCY
$0 $4,000 ($4,000) (100.0) Transmission Line Maintenance $23,908 $29,000 ($5,092) (17.6) 47.8
0 1,000 (1,000) (100.0) Energy Efficiency/DSM 94,021 107,000 (12,979) (12.1) 69.1
$0 $5,000 ($5,000) (100.0) TOTAL XMSN EXPENSE $117,929 $136,000 ($18,071) (13.3) 63.4
PIEDMONT MUNICIPAL POWER AGENCY
STATEMENT OF G&A EXPENSE
AS OF JULY 31, 2025
June and July 2025 3.1 b
23
PIEDMONT MUNICIPAL POWER AGENCY
AS OF JULY 31, 2025
After this month’s operations, PMPA had $87.6 million in working capital, which was $6.4 million better than the YTD budget.
June and July 2025 3.1 b
24
22 JUL 2025
Fitch Affirms Piedmont Muni Power Agency, SC's
Electric Refunding Revs at 'A-'; Outlook Stable
Fitch Ratings - Austin - 22 Jul 2025: Fitch Ratings has affirmed the 'A-' ratings on the following Piedmont
Municipal Power Agency, SC's (PMPA) revenue bonds:
--Approximately $535.24 million electric revenue bonds.
The Outlook is revised to Stable from Negative.
The 'A-' rating reflects Fitch's evaluation of PMPA's eight largest of its 10 total participants, its take-or-
pay contractual obligations related to the electric revenue bonds, and Fitch's assessment of PMPA's
strong operating risk profile. PMPA's long-term Catawba project power supply agreements (PSAs) with
its participants provide for a limited 25% step-up on the participant obligations in case of member
default.
Fitch's rating factors a purchaser credit quality (PCQ) assessment of 'bbb', reflecting the midrange
credit quality of several of the weaker project participants. Given the contractual framework, the PCQ is
assessed at a level commensurate with the weakest members whose payment risk is not mitigated by
the 25% step-up provision. The rating also reflects PMPA's operating risk assessment of 'a', which takes
into consideration the solid performance of the Catawba facility and the relatively low cost of power,
notwithstanding the nuclear concentration risk. These strengths provide a modest enhancement to the
project's rating, allowing it to attain a rating of 'A-' despite only midrange purchaser credit quality.
PMPA's financial profile is less of a consideration in the final determination of the PMPA rating given
the contractual payment framework under the PSAs.
The Stable Outlook reflects a general trend of strengthening economic and financial metrics among
many of the participants. Broad service area improvement is reflected in stronger customer growth
and improved employment metrics. The participants' strong to very strong financial metrics are
reflected in mostly positive trends in liquidity and net margin and modest overall debt levels.
SECURITY
The bonds are secured by the net revenues of PMPA, including payments received from each of its 10
participants pursuant to their Catawba project PSAs. Fitch expects payments from the supplemental
PSAs to terminate after 2029. However, the Catawba project PSAs will remain in effect and require each
participant to pay for their share of Catawba project costs, which includes debt service on the PMPA
bonds. The termination of the supplemental PSAs in 2029 consequently does not affect Fitch's rating of
the PMPA bonds.
Finance 4.1 a
25
KEY RATING DRIVERS
Revenue Defensibility - 'bbb'
Strong Take-or-Pay Contracts with 25% Step-up;
Revenue defensibility is midrange. Fitch's assessment of the purchaser credit quality (PCQ) at 'bbb'
uses both Fitch's Portfolio Stress Model (PSM) and Fitch's evaluation of the credit quality of the eight
largest participants, representing approximately 95% of the Catawba project entitlement share. The
Catawba project PSAs are unconditional, take-or-pay obligations and include a step-up provision
requiring each participant to purchase only up to 125% of its entitlement share if any participant
defaults.
Fitch's PCQ assessment and the final rating are capped by the credit quality of the City of Rock Hill, SC
electric system (Rock Hill), PMPA's largest project participant with a 28% entitlement share, since
invoking the 125% contract step-up provisions following a Rock Hill default would not be sufficient to
cover PMPA's obligations. However, Fitch's PCQ assessment and the final rating are currently
constrained by the credit characteristics of other weaker members reviewed by Fitch.
The bonds mature in 2035, coinciding with the current PSAs for all 10 participants. The PMPA Board
recently approved contract extensions for seven of the 10 Catawba participants through 2085. The
project's Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) license currently extends through 2043, well past the
maturity of the bonds and the PSAs.
Operating Risk - 'a'
Low Cost and Reliable Power Supply; Nuclear Concentration
PMPA's strong operating risk assessment is driven by the project's strong operating history and low
operating cost burden, which averaged approximately 5.7 cents/kWh during the past five years. The
project's high-capacity factor and stable, low cost energy provide significant headroom for the
assessment and are factored into the overall rating.
Concentration exists in PMPA's power supply, with nuclear generation accounting for approximately
90% of energy supply, net of the load served by Southeastern Power Administration (SEPA). Exposure
to PMPA's owned interest in Catawba unit No. 2 is mitigated by reliability exchange agreements with
Duke Energy Carolinas, LLC (DEC) and the co-owners of three other units DEC operates.
The Catawba project PSAs obligate the participants to pay debt service on the project bonds regardless
of whether the project is operating or even operable.
Financial Profile - 'aa'
Very Strong Financial Profile
PMPA has historically maintained a very strong financial profile. Fitch expects PMPA's leverage to
Finance 4.1 a
26
decline further as the agency's debt continues to amortize. PMPA completed fiscal 2024 with a leverage
ratio of 3.3x, which is essentially unchanged from the prior year but much lower than 2022 levels, and
227 days of cash on hand. This level of liquidity coupled with coverage of full obligations of 1.5x is
neutral to the assessment.
However, the agency's very strong financial profile is less of a consideration in Fitch's determination of
PMPA's rating given project costs are largely balanced and passed through to the purchasing utilities
through the PSAs.
RATING SENSITIVITIES
Factors that Could, Individually or Collectively, Lead to Negative Rating Action/
Downgrade
--A weakening in the credit quality of PMPA participants.
--Poor operating performance at the Catawba and McGuire nuclear generating units resulting in higher
than anticipated power costs to the participants.
Factors that Could, Individually or Collectively, Lead to Positive Rating Action/Upgrade
-- Improvement in participant credit quality could lead to positive rating action.
PROFILE
PMPA is a public agency organized under the laws of the state of South Carolina. Ten South Carolina
cities (participants) entered into long-term Catawba project PSAs and supplemental PSAs with PMPA.
Under the Catawba project PSAs, each participant pays for its percentage share of the project
operating and debt service expenses of PMPA on a take-or-pay basis, payable regardless of whether
the Catawba project is operating or not. Payments from participants are considered an operating
expense of their electric systems, satisfied ahead of any direct debt service of their electric systems.
PMPA's Catawba project consists of a 25% undivided ownership in the Catawba nuclear unit No. 2,
entitling PMPA to approximately 277MW, which is operated by DEC. The risk of an extended outage of
any one unit is shared among the four units through various reliability exchanges with the Catawba
(units No. 1 and No. 2) and McGuire nuclear projects (units No. 1 and No. 2), providing some protection
for the participants against single-unit outage at No. 2. The largest eight PMPA participants include the
cites of Rock Hill (28.0%), Easley (13.2%), Newberry (10.5%), Gaffney (10.1%), Union (10.0%), Greer
(9.3%), Clinton (7.8%), and Laurens (6.5%), all in South Carolina.
In addition to the Catawba project PSAs, PMPA and the participants signed supplemental PSAs that
require PMPA to provide the participants with all-requirements bulk power supply, net of any SEPA
allocations and any energy derived from each participant's generating capacity. PMPA supplies
participant supplemental power supplies through an agreement with the South Carolina Public Service
Authority (Santee Cooper; A-/Stable). At YE 2019, all 10 PMPA participants provided the required
10-year notice to terminate the supplemental PSAs, and in return, PMPA gave notice to terminate the
Finance 4.1 a
27
corresponding agreement with Santee Cooper. The final termination will occur in 2029, but Fitch does
not expect it to affect the rating, which continues to be supported by the Catawba project PSAs.
Sources of Information
In addition to the sources of information identified in Fitch's applicable criteria specified below, this
action was informed by data from DIVER by Solve.
REFERENCES FOR SUBSTANTIALLY MATERIAL SOURCE CITED AS KEY DRIVER OF RATING
The principal sources of information used in the analysis are described in the Applicable Criteria.
ESG Considerations
The highest level of ESG credit relevance is a score of '3', unless otherwise disclosed in this section. A
score of '3' means ESG issues are credit-neutral or have only a minimal credit impact on the entity,
either due to their nature or the way in which they are being managed by the entity. Fitch's ESG
Relevance Scores are not inputs in the rating process; they are an observation on the relevance and
materiality of ESG factors in the rating decision. For more information on Fitch's ESG Relevance Scores,
visit https://www.fitchratings.com/topics/esg/products#esg-relevance-scores.
Fitch Ratings Analysts
Rebecca Meyer, CFA, CPA, CISA
Director
Primary Rating Analyst
+1 512 215 3733
Fitch Ratings, Inc. 2600 Via Fortuna, Suite 330 Austin, TX 78746
Patrick Goggins
Director
Secondary Rating Analyst
+1 646 582 4695
Andrew DeStefano
Senior Director
Committee Chairperson
+1 212 908 0284
Media Contacts
Cristina Bermudez
New York
+1 212 612 7892
cristina.bermudez@thefitchgroup.com
Finance 4.1 a
28
Rating Actions
ENTITY/DEBT RATING RECOVERY PRIOR
Piedmont
Municipal
Power
Agency (SC)
• Piedmont
Municipal
Power
Agency
(SC)
/Electric
System
Revenues/
1 LT
LT A- Affirmed A-
RATINGS KEY OUTLOOK WATCH
POSITIVE
NEGATIVE
EVOLVING
STABLE
Applicable Criteria
Public Policy Revenue-Supported Entities Rating Criteria (pub.12 Jan 2024) (including rating
assumption sensitivity)
U.S. Public Power Rating Criteria (pub.24 Feb 2025) (including rating assumption
sensitivity)
Applicable Models
Numbers in parentheses accompanying applicable model(s) contain hyperlinks to criteria providing
description of model(s).
Portfolio Stress Model, v1.11.1 (1)
Finance 4.1 a
29
Additional Disclosures
Solicitation Status
Endorsement Status
Piedmont Municipal Power Agency (SC) EU Endorsed, UK Endorsed
DISCLAIMER & DISCLOSURES
All Fitch Ratings (Fitch) credit ratings are subject to certain limitations and disclaimers. Please read
these limitations and disclaimers by following this link: https://www.fitchratings.com/
understandingcreditratings. In addition, the following https://www.fitchratings.com/rating-definitions-
document details Fitch's rating definitions for each rating scale and rating categories, including
definitions relating to default. ESMA and the FCA are required to publish historical default rates in a
central repository in accordance with Articles 11(2) of Regulation (EC) No 1060/2009 of the European
Parliament and of the Council of 16 September 2009 and The Credit Rating Agencies (Amendment etc.)
(EU Exit) Regulations 2019 respectively.
Published ratings, criteria, and methodologies are available from this site at all times. Fitch's code of
conduct, confidentiality, conflicts of interest, affiliate firewall, compliance, and other relevant policies
and procedures are also available from the Code of Conduct section of this site. Directors and
shareholders' relevant interests are available at https://www.fitchratings.com/site/regulatory. Fitch
may have provided another permissible or ancillary service to the rated entity or its related third
parties. Details of permissible or ancillary service(s) for which the lead analyst is based in an ESMA- or
FCA-registered Fitch Ratings company (or branch of such a company) can be found on the entity
summary page for this issuer on the Fitch Ratings website.
In issuing and maintaining its ratings and in making other reports (including forecast information), Fitch
relies on factual information it receives from issuers and underwriters and from other sources Fitch
believes to be credible. Fitch conducts a reasonable investigation of the factual information relied upon
by it in accordance with its ratings methodology, and obtains reasonable verification of that
information from independent sources, to the extent such sources are available for a given security or
in a given jurisdiction. The manner of Fitch's factual investigation and the scope of the third-party
verification it obtains will vary depending on the nature of the rated security and its issuer, the
requirements and practices in the jurisdiction in which the rated security is offered and sold and/or the
issuer is located, the availability and nature of relevant public information, access to the management
of the issuer and its advisers, the availability of pre-existing third-party verifications such as audit
reports, agreed-upon procedures letters, appraisals, actuarial reports, engineering reports, legal
Finance 4.1 a
30
opinions and other reports provided by third parties, the availability of independent and competent
third- party verification sources with respect to the particular security or in the particular jurisdiction of
the issuer, and a variety of other factors. Users of Fitch's ratings and reports should understand that
neither an enhanced factual investigation nor any third-party verification can ensure that all of the
information Fitch relies on in connection with a rating or a report will be accurate and complete.
Ultimately, the issuer and its advisers are responsible for the accuracy of the information they provide
to Fitch and to the market in offering documents and other reports. In issuing its ratings and its
reports, Fitch must rely on the work of experts, including independent auditors with respect to
financial statements and attorneys with respect to legal and tax matters. Further, ratings and forecasts
of financial and other information are inherently forward-looking and embody assumptions and
predictions about future events that by their nature cannot be verified as facts. As a result, despite any
verification of current facts, ratings and forecasts can be affected by future events or conditions that
were not anticipated at the time a rating or forecast was issued or affirmed. Fitch Ratings makes
routine, commonly-accepted adjustments to reported financial data in accordance with the relevant
criteria and/or industry standards to provide financial metric consistency for entities in the same sector
or asset class.
The complete span of best- and worst-case scenario credit ratings for all rating categories ranges from
'AAA' to 'D'. Fitch also provides information on best-case rating upgrade scenarios and worst-case
rating downgrade scenarios (defined as the 99th percentile of rating transitions, measured in each
direction) for international credit ratings, based on historical performance. A simple average across
asset classes presents best-case upgrades of 4 notches and worst-case downgrades of 8 notches at the
99th percentile. For more details on sector-specific best- and worst-case scenario credit ratings, please
see Best- and Worst-Case Measures under the Rating Performance page on Fitch’s website.
The information in this report is provided “as is” without any representation or warranty of any kind,
and Fitch does not represent or warrant that the report or any of its contents will meet any of the
requirements of a recipient of the report. A Fitch rating is an opinion as to the creditworthiness of a
security. This opinion and reports made by Fitch are based on established criteria and methodologies
that Fitch is continuously evaluating and updating. Therefore, ratings and reports are the collective
work product of Fitch and no individual, or group of individuals, is solely responsible for a rating or a
report. The rating does not address the risk of loss due to risks other than credit risk, unless such risk
is specifically mentioned. Fitch is not engaged in the offer or sale of any security. All Fitch reports have
shared authorship. Individuals identified in a Fitch report were involved in, but are not solely
responsible for, the opinions stated therein. The individuals are named for contact purposes only. A
report providing a Fitch rating is neither a prospectus nor a substitute for the information assembled,
verified and presented to investors by the issuer and its agents in connection with the sale of the
securities. Ratings may be changed or withdrawn at any time for any reason in the sole discretion of
Fitch. Fitch does not provide investment advice of any sort. Ratings are not a recommendation to buy,
sell, or hold any security. Ratings do not comment on the adequacy of market price, the suitability of
any security for a particular investor, or the tax-exempt nature or taxability of payments made in
respect to any security. Fitch receives fees from issuers, insurers, guarantors, other obligors, and
underwriters for rating securities. Such fees generally vary from US$1,000 to US$750,000 (or the
Finance 4.1 a
31
applicable currency equivalent) per issue. In certain cases, Fitch will rate all or a number of issues
issued by a particular issuer, or insured or guaranteed by a particular insurer or guarantor, for a single
annual fee. Such fees are expected to vary from US$10,000 to US$1,500,000 (or the applicable currency
equivalent). The assignment, publication, or dissemination of a rating by Fitch shall not constitute a
consent by Fitch to use its name as an expert in connection with any registration statement filed under
the United States securities laws, the Financial Services and Markets Act of 2000 of the United
Kingdom, or the securities laws of any particular jurisdiction. Due to the relative efficiency of electronic
publishing and distribution, Fitch research may be available to electronic subscribers up to three days
earlier than to print subscribers.
For Australia, New Zealand, Taiwan and South Korea only: Fitch Australia Pty Ltd holds an Australian
financial services license (AFS license no. 337123) which authorizes it to provide credit ratings to
wholesale clients only. Credit ratings information published by Fitch is not intended to be used by
persons who are retail clients within the meaning of the Corporations Act 2001.Fitch Ratings, Inc. is
registered with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission as a Nationally Recognized Statistical
Rating Organization (the “NRSRO”). While certain of the NRSRO's credit rating subsidiaries are listed on
Item 3 of Form NRSRO and as such are authorized to issue credit ratings on behalf of the NRSRO (see
https://www.fitchratings.com/site/regulatory), other credit rating subsidiaries are not listed on Form
NRSRO (the “non-NRSROs”) and therefore credit ratings issued by those subsidiaries are not issued on
behalf of the NRSRO. However, non-NRSRO personnel may participate in determining credit ratings
issued by or on behalf of the NRSRO.
dv01, a Fitch Solutions company, and an affiliate of Fitch Ratings, may from time to time serve as loan
data agent on certain structured finance transactions rated by Fitch Ratings.
Copyright © 2025 by Fitch Ratings, Inc., Fitch Ratings Ltd. and its subsidiaries. 33 Whitehall Street, NY,
NY 10004. Telephone: 1-800-753-4824, (212) 908-0500. Reproduction or retransmission in whole or in
part is prohibited except by permission. All rights reserved.
Endorsement policy
Fitch’s international credit ratings produced outside the EU or the UK, as the case may be, are
endorsed for use by regulated entities within the EU or the UK, respectively, for regulatory purposes,
pursuant to the terms of the EU CRA Regulation or the UK Credit Rating Agencies (Amendment etc.) (EU
Exit) Regulations 2019, as the case may be. Fitch’s approach to endorsement in the EU and the UK can
be found on Fitch’s Regulatory Affairs page on Fitch’s website. The endorsement status of international
credit ratings is provided within the entity summary page for each rated entity and in the transaction
detail pages for structured finance transactions on the Fitch website. These disclosures are updated on
a daily basis.
Finance 4.1 a
32
2025_06_LSG Report.docx
To: Board of Directors and Alternates
From: Mike Frazier
Date: July 16, 2025
Santee Cooper called upon PMPA to run the Load-Side Generators on three days
in June due to system conditions.
Load-Side Generation Operation during the month of June:
7 Jun. – 12:15 p.m. to 3:00 p.m. – 2.75 hrs.
24 Jun. – 3:00 p.m. to 9:00 p.m. – 6.00 hrs.
25 Jun. – 3:45 p.m. to 9:00 p.m. – 5.25 hrs.
__________________
TOTAL – 14.00 Hrs.
TOTAL YTD – 22.00 Hrs.
Load-side generation is called for during times of energy deficiency, adverse
system conditions, or high economic energy prices.
Current Load-Side Generators are owned by the City of Clinton, Easley Combined
Utilities, Gaffney Board of Public Works, Greer Commission of Public Works, and
the City of Rock Hill.
PMPA Load-Side Generation Report
Engineering 4.2 a
33
2025_06_Demand Response Report_.docx
To: Board of Directors and Alternates
From: Mike Frazier
Date: July 16, 2025
23 Jun – 1:30 PM to 6:00 PM - 4.50 hrs 25 Jun – 1:30 PM to 6:00 PM - 4.50 hrs
24 Jun – 1:00 PM to 6:00 PM - 5.00 hrs
______________________
TOTAL 14.00 hours
PMPA Monthly Peak1: 555.8 MW @ Hour Ending 5:00 p.m. on Jun 25th
Does NOT coincide with the Duke Energy Transmission Peak on
Jun 25th @ Hour Ending 4:00 p.m.
Monthly Maximum GSP Airport Temperature – 99° F on Jun 25th 2
PMPA Total Participant Load 3: 595.9 MW @ Hour Ending 5:00 p.m. on Jun 25th
PMPA Ratchet Quantity: 507.9 MW – based on Jul. 15, 2024 @ HE 5:00 p.m.
All loads are reflected at the transmission level, which includes 1.96% losses as of June 1, 2025.
1 PMPA Monthly Peak – Used by Santee Cooper to determine PMPA’s capacity charge. This peak
includes the load served by nine Participants (does not include Union) and generation (added back to
the load) produced by the load-side generators. It also does not include Greer CPW’s load served from
the leased Laurens EMC delivery points.
2 This June was almost a repeat of last June with one caveat, more heat. Temperatures at GSP didn’t
break 100 degrees Fahrenheit, but several days came close to it. The last ten days in June had high
temperatures all in the nineties. Even with temperatures remaining in the double-digits, PMPA set its
highest demand ever on June 25.
3 PMPA Total Participant Load – includes load served by all ten Participants including the Greer CPW’s
load served from leased Laurens EMC delivery points and generation produced by the load-side
generators.
PMPA
Demand Response System
Report
Month CDD % of Normal
Jun 2025 401 117
Normal 343
Jun 2024 390 114
Engineering 4.2 b
34
ENERGY REPORT *
Piedmont Municipal Power Agency
JUNE, 2025
The Energy Authority (Surplus Energy Sold and Gross Revenue)
2,742 57,561 $ 20.99 $ / MWh
28,315 865,341 $ - YTD 30.56 $ / MWh - YTD
Duke Energy (Surplus Energy Sold and Gross Revenue)
6,939 186,955 $ 26.94 $ / MWh
79,180 2,521,207 $-YTD 31.84 $ / MWh - YTD
Santee Cooper (Surplus Energy Sold and Gross Revenue)
4,270 108,586 $ 25.43 $ / MWh
59,463 1,786,115 $-YTD 30.04 $ / MWh - YTD
Total Surplus Sales Revenue 353,102 $
5,172,663 $ - YTD 166,958 MWh-YTD
Generation Imbalance Charge ………………………………… (66,663) $
199,066 $ - YTD
($27,575)
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Energy Imbalance Charge …………………………………… (111) $
93,194 $ - YTD
$2,992
Supplemental Energy Purchased ………………………………...………………..……
Santee Cooper TEA Backstand &
Total
39,476 5 39,481 MWh
65,944 7,974 73,918 MWh - YTD
2,069,065 92 2,069,156 $
3,563,057 421,786 3,984,843 $ - YTD
52.41 18.34 52.41 $ / MWh
54.03 52.90 53.91 $ / MWh - YTD
* All MWh are measured at the bus bar (generation level)
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
& Includes energy and transmission costs
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MWh - YTD
MWh
MWh
MWh-YTD
MWh
MWh-YTD
($10,771) ($28,318)
($3,103) $0
Deviation Band 1 - +/- 1.5% Deviation Band 2 - Between +/-1.5% & 7.5% Deviation Band 3 - Greater than +/- 7.5%
Deviation Band 1 - +/- 1.5% Deviation Band 2 - Between +/-1.5% & 7.5% Deviation Band 3 - Greater than +/- 7.5%
Engineering 4.2 c
35
2025_07_LSG Report.docx
To: Board of Directors and Alternates
From: Mike Frazier
Date: August 13, 2025
Santee Cooper called upon PMPA to run the Load-Side Generators on two days in
July due to system conditions.
Load-Side Generation Operation during the month of June:
12 Jul. – 3:00 p.m. to 6:00 p.m. – 3.00 hrs.
21 Jul. – 3:15 p.m. to 8:00 p.m. – 4.75 hrs.
__________________
TOTAL – 7.75 Hrs.
TOTAL YTD – 29.75 Hrs.
Load-side generation is called for during times of energy deficiency, adverse
system conditions, or high economic energy prices.
Current Load-Side Generators are owned by the City of Clinton, Easley Combined
Utilities, Gaffney Board of Public Works, Greer Commission of Public Works, and
the City of Rock Hill.
PMPA Load-Side Generation Report
Engineering 4.2 d
36
2025_07_Demand Response Report.docx
To: Board of Directors and Alternates
From: Mike Frazier
Date: August 13, 2025
7 Jul – 3:00 PM to 6:00 PM - 3.00 hrs 27 Jul – 3:00 PM to 7:00 PM - 4.00 hrs
8 Jul – 2:00 PM to 6:00 PM - 4.00 hrs 28 Jul – 12:00 PM to 6:00 PM - 6.00 hrs
9 Jul – 3:00 PM to 6:00 PM - 3.00 hrs 29 Jul – 3:00 PM to 4:30 PM - 1.50 hrs
21 Jul – 2:30 PM to 6:00 PM - 3.50 hrs
_______________________
TOTAL 25.00 hours
PMPA Monthly Peak1: 544.9 MW @ Hour Ending 4:00 p.m. on Jul 28th
Does NOT coincide with the Duke Energy Transmission Peak on
Jul 8th @ Hour Ending 5:00 p.m.
Monthly Maximum GSP Airport Temperature – 100° F on Jul 26th, 27th
PMPA Total Participant Load
3: 584.4 MW @ Hour Ending 4:00 p.m. on Jul 28th
PMPA Ratchet Quantity: 527.9 MW – based on Jun. 25, 2025 @ HE 5:00 p.m.
All loads are reflected at the transmission level, which includes 1.96% losses as of June 1, 2025.
1 PMPA Monthly Peak – Used by Santee Cooper to determine PMPA’s capacity charge. This peak
includes the load served by nine Participants (does not include Union) and generation (added back to
the load) produced by the load-side generators. It also does not include Greer CPW’s load served from
the leased Laurens EMC delivery points.
2 Every day in July had temperatures reaching ninety degrees F or above. For two consecutive days,
temperatures hit one-hundred degrees F. Fortunately, those days were over a weekend when PMPA
loads are lower than on weekdays. For the month, temperatures averaged far above normal. Even with
the extra heat in July, PMPA did not reach a new all-time peak, which was set last month.
3 PMPA Total Participant Load – includes load served by all ten Participants including the Greer CPW’s
load served from leased Laurens EMC delivery points and generation produced by the load-side
generators.
PMPA
Demand Response System
Report
Month CDD % of Normal
Jul 2025 570 125
Normal 457
Jul 2024 518 113
Engineering 4.2 e
37
ENERGY REPORT *
Piedmont Municipal Power Agency
JULY, 2025
The Energy Authority (Surplus Energy Sold and Gross Revenue)
37 1,100 $ 29.73 $ / MWh
28,352 866,441 $ - YTD 30.56 $ / MWh - YTD
Duke Energy (Surplus Energy Sold and Gross Revenue)
2,207 74,510 $ 33.76 $ / MWh
81,387 2,595,717 $-YTD 31.89 $ / MWh - YTD
Santee Cooper (Surplus Energy Sold and Gross Revenue)
2,074 48,081 $ 23.18 $ / MWh
61,537 1,834,196 $-YTD 29.81 $ / MWh - YTD
Total Surplus Sales Revenue 123,691 $
5,296,354 $ - YTD 171,276 MWh-YTD
Generation Imbalance Charge ………………………………… (1,752) $
269,305 $ - YTD
($487)
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Energy Imbalance Charge …………………………………… (10,102) $
83,093 $ - YTD
$45
Supplemental Energy Purchased ………………………………...………………..……
Santee Cooper TEA Backstand &
Total
65,293 0 65,293 MWh
131,237 7,974 139,211 MWh - YTD
3,509,712 0 3,509,712 $
7,074,681 421,786 7,496,467 $ - YTD
53.75 --- 53.75 $ / MWh
53.91 52.90 53.85 $ / MWh - YTD
* All MWh are measured at the bus bar (generation level)
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
& Includes energy and transmission costs
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MWh - YTD
MWh
MWh
MWh-YTD
MWh
MWh-YTD
($1,265) $0
($10,147) $0
Deviation Band 1 - +/- 1.5% Deviation Band 2 - Between +/-1.5% & 7.5% Deviation Band 3 - Greater than +/- 7.5%
Deviation Band 1 - +/- 1.5% Deviation Band 2 - Between +/-1.5% & 7.5% Deviation Band 3 - Greater than +/- 7.5%
Engineering 4.2 f
38
Catawba 4.3 a
39
2025 Power Conference
Survey Results
16%
4%
28%
52%
Hotel Check-in - 2025
1 = Very Dissatisfied 2 3 = Neutral 4 5 = Very Satisfied
4% 4%
14%
36%
43%
Hotel Check-in - 2024
1 = Very Dissatisfied 2 3 = Neutral 4 5 = Very Satisfied
4%
38%
58%
Hotel Rooms - 2025
1 = Very Dissatisfied 2 3 = Neutral 4 5 = Very Satisfied
4% 4%
11%
54%
29%
Hotel Room - 2024
1 = Very Dissatisfied 2 3 = Neutral 4 5 = Very Satisfied
12%
36%
52%
Meeting Room - 2025
1 = Very Dissatisfied 2 3 = Neutral 4 5 = Very Satisfied
7%
4%
32%
32%
25%
Meeting Room - 2024
1 = Very Dissatisfied 2 3 = Neutral 4 5 = Very Satisfied
Management 4.4 a
40
16%
48%
36%
Meals - 2025
1 = Very Dissatisfied 2 3 = Neutral 4 5 = Very Satisfied
14%
39%
46%
Meals - 2024
1 = Very Dissatisfied 2 3 = Neutral 4 5 = Very Satisfied
4% 4%
29%
63%
Overall Service - 2025
1 = Very Dissatisfied 2 3 = Neutral 4 5 = Very Satisfied
4%
14%
46%
36%
Overall Service - 2024
1 = Very Dissatisfied 2 3 = Neutral 4 5 = Very Satisfied
40%
60%
Conference Schedule - 2025
1 = Very Dissatisfied 2 3 = Neutral 4 5 = Very Satisfied
43%
57%
Conference Schedule - 2024
1 = Very Dissatisfied 2 3 = Neutral 4 5 = Very Satisfied
Management 4.4 a
41
0%0%
48%
52%
Quality of Speakers - 2025
1 = Very Dissatisfied 2 3 = Neutral 4 5 = Very Satisfied
8%
28%
64%
Quality of Speakers - 2024
1 = Very Dissatisfied 2 3 = Neutral 4 5 = Very Satisfied
4%
20%
76%
Overall Conference - 2025
1 = Very Dissatisfied 2 3 = Neutral 4 5 = Very Satisfied
7%
32%
61%
Overall Conference - 2024
1 = Very Dissatisfied 2 3 = Neutral 4 5 = Very Satisfied
38%
62%
Online Registration - 2025
1 = Very Dissatisfied 2 3 = Neutral 4 5 = Very Satisfied
38%
63%
Online Registration - 2024
1 = Very Dissatisfied 2 3 = Neutral 4 5 = Very Satisfied
Management 4.4 a
42
46%
54%
Conference Information Website -
2025
1 = Very Dissatisfied 2 3 = Neutral 4 5 = Very Satisfied
50%50%
Conference Information Website -
2024
1 = Very Dissatisfied 2 3 = Neutral 4 5 = Very Satisfied
5%
33%
62%
Mobile App - 2025
1 = Very Dissatisfied 2 3 = Neutral 4 5 = Very Satisfied
5%
25%
70%
Mobile App - 2024
1 = Very Dissatisfied 2 3 = Neutral 4 5 = Very Satisfied
Management 4.4 a
43
4%
24%
72%
Joel Ledbetter - 2025
1 = Very Dissatisfied 2 3 = Neutral 4 5 = Very Satisfied
17%
50%
33%
Rep. Neal Collins - 2025
1 = Very Dissatisfied 2 3 = Neutral 4 5 = Very Satisfied
4% 4%
32%
60%
Jack Jacobson - 2025
1 = Very Dissatisfied 2 3 = Neutral 4 5 = Very Satisfied
4% 8%
48%
40%
Katherine Elrod - 2025
1 = Very Dissatisfied 2 3 = Neutral 4 5 = Very Satisfied
8%
4%
13%
33%
42%
Sunny Wescott - 2025
1 = Very Dissatisfied 2 3 = Neutral 4 5 = Very Satisfied
13%
67%
21%
Nicole Cervi - 2025
1 = Very Dissatisfied 2 3 = Neutral 4 5 = Very Satisfied
Management 4.4 a
44
4%
21%
54%
21%
Joe Witkowski - 2025
1 = Very Dissatisfied 2 3 = Neutral 4 5 = Very Satisfied
17%
83%
Participant Roundtable Discussion -
2025
1 = Very Dissatisfied 2 3 = Neutral 4 5 = Very Satisfied
4%
26%
70%
Dennis Cameron - 2025
1 = Very Dissatisfied 2 3 = Neutral 4 5 = Very Satisfied
4% 4%
24%
68%
Joel Ledbetter - 2025 (Day 2)
1 = Very Dissatisfied 2 3 = Neutral 4 5 = Very Satisfied
Management 4.4 a
45
Something as simple as no Kleenex, no conditioner
Had to change rooms due to the first room being dirty. Elevators continue to be an issue. Room was never
cleaned during the entire trip. Had to go in search of towels etc. every day. Lobby area was hot & humid for the
whole trip. Pool closes way to early for beach resort during the summer.
I love the hotel primarily due to the all suits rooms, views at ever turn on the hotel etc. I know there are newer but
don’t lose the things that work somewhere else.
Check in seems to always have some issues...
Great hotel. Never leave this spot
Needs more/bigger elevators
Need more handicap parking
Waited over an hour for our room to be ready. They also did not even consider a request for a room on the north
side of the hotel. Food has been OK, not great.
Cold in the meeting room.
This year was as good as any
Mrs. Sunny knocked a home run. She was amazing! All the other speakers were good, and informative.
A couple of speakers had decent content but overall was not the strongest line-up.
Good job to PMPA for planning and the conference itself.
Good info across the conference.
Great job! I enjoyed it!
The audio was better than in past years but I still had some trouble hearing the people speaking. I sat in the second
row near the middle. This could be caused by the room so I am not sure if the audio can be improved.
Could have done without the meteorologist.
Every session was very informative
Sunny was fantastic and information that people really need to hear. For the most part all of the speakers were able
to communicate their point and how it relates to member cities effectively.
Good variety.
Please never invite that Sunny Westcott woman again.
Good info on all sessions on Saturday. Joel’s topic today should have been the after lunch topic for Friday so more
participants could have heard the details.
AI presentation was hard to follow and understand
Good experience
Good job PMPA
Great!
Hotel Comments
Conference Comments
Speaker Comments
Registration & Mobile App Comments
Management 4.4 a
46
Not really
Perhaps someone who speaks on working together and team works and being on the same team.
I thought this was a good mix of topics and information. Encourage you to continue along the same lines.
Like more local and state topics
I would have liked to have heard from Abbeville about the hydroplant and how Helene impacted it.
The temp in the room was a bit chilly each day.
I think it is good as it is.
A brief financial review by our Finance Director. Just some highlights coming from that person.
Nothing to suggest.
I know the audio and visual guys do a great job. There was a little echo in the room this year that I never noticed
in the past.
Vet the speakers just a little more. Make sure they understand what 50 minutes actually is…
Great speakers, but a diverse group of speakers would be awesome.
Greatly appreciate the PMPA staff and their work to make this happen.
Really well done. Thank you!
Joel is an amazing resource and was very helpful to our group. Perhaps some panel type q&a time with just him
for whatever others are dealing with. He took time out of his personal time to help us with a time sensitive issue.
Other comments/suggestions
Are there any topics you wish had been included that were not covered?
Overall, the Conference could be improved by:
Management 4.4 a
47
PMPA
Board of Directors Meeting
EEA Alerts
August 21, 2025
Energy Emergency Alerts 5.1 a
48
Duke Energy – Energy Alerts
Why have an energy alert system?
Winter Storm Elliott
2022 – Christmas Eve
7° F Low recorded at GSP
High only reached 28 ° F
LSG ran 6:00 am – 11:00 am
Energy Emergency Alerts 5.1 a
49
Duke Energy – Energy Alerts
What is the Duke Energy Alert System?
A way “… to improve communications about energy
and capacity constraints for its [Duke Energy] network
and wholesale customers. The communications, known
as Energy Emergency Alerts, are based on the
escalation order and notifications used by Reliability
Coordinators, Balancing Authorities and Transmission
Operators.”
Energy Emergency Alerts 5.1 a
50
Duke Energy – Energy Alerts
Warning – Issue a Capacity / Energy Warning
“Issued the day prior to [or day of] a potential event
for situational awareness and requires no action.
Unless other escalated messages are issued, the only
additional message would be to terminate the
warning.”
Energy Emergency Alerts 5.1 a
51
Duke Energy – Energy Alerts
Warning – Issue a Capacity / Energy Warning
Issued June 20, 2025 @ 2:10 PM [Friday]
“Duke Energy Carolinas is declaring a warning condition for impending high loads
from 13:00 - 22:00 daily beginning Monday, 06/23/2025 through Thursday,
06/26/2025.
There is a higher probability of further escalation, but we are not requesting any
actions by Load Serving Entities at this time.
Please monitor communication channels for further messages in the event
conditions change and call your Wholesale Account Manager with any questions.
Description: Week of June 26, 2025”
Energy Emergency Alerts 5.1 a
52
Duke Energy – Energy Alerts
Energy Emergency Alert 1 [EEA1]
“Issued at or immediately prior to an event and will require
some responsive actions. A separate EEA message will include
a specific end time. Other escalated messages may follow.”
Duke is requesting Load Serving Entities to implement
Demand Response programs and Distributed Energy
Resources assistance.
Energy Emergency Alerts 5.1 a
53
Duke Energy – Energy Alerts
Energy Emergency Alert 1 [EEA1]
Issued June 23, 2025 @ 11:06 AM [Monday]
“Duke Energy Carolinas has entered an EEA1 (all available generation
resources in use) condition. We are requesting Load Serving Entities to
implement Demand Response programs and Distributed Energy
Resources assistance. We will send further notifications, including
termination of this EEA when conditions warrant. Please monitor
communication channels for further messages in the event conditions change
and call your Wholesale Account Manager with any questions.
Description: DEC BA declares EEA Level 1 at 1100.”
Energy Emergency Alerts 5.1 a
54
Duke Energy – Energy Alerts
Energy Emergency Alert 2 [EEA2]
“Issued at or immediately prior to an event and will require some
responsive actions. A separate EEA message will include a specific end
time. Escalated or de-escalated messages may follow.”
Duke is directing all Load Serving Entities to implement all available
Demand Response programs, and Distributed Energy Resource
assistance, to curtail all non-firm energy sales, to curtail all non-
essential loads and run all behind the delivery point meter generation.
Energy Emergency Alerts 5.1 a
55
Duke Energy – Energy Alerts
Energy Emergency Alert 2 [EEA2]
Issued June 23, 2025 @ 7:07 PM [Monday]
“Duke Energy Carolinas has entered an EEA2 (load management procedures in
effect) condition. Load serving entities are directed to implement all available
Demand Response programs, and Distributed Energy Resource assistance, to
curtail all non-firm energy sales, to curtail all non-essential loads and run all
behind the delivery point meter generation. We will send further notifications,
including termination of this EEA, when conditions warrant. Please monitor
communication channels for further messages in the event conditions change and
call your Wholesale Account Manager with any questions.
Description: Notification callout created by Nathan D. Smock for Notifications CW
on Mon 06/23/2025 19:05:34 ET”
Energy Emergency Alerts 5.1 a
56
Duke Energy – Energy Alerts
Run Load-side Generation (if not already)?
Run Standby Generation?
Who pays for that?
Should it be a socialized cost?
Energy Emergency Alerts 5.1 a
57
Duke Energy – Energy Alerts
As Duke Energy Carolinas is the
Transmission Provider and the Reliability
Coordinator for VACAR South (the
Carolinas), Load Serving Entities are
Required to follow its Directives.
Energy Emergency Alerts 5.1 a
58
Duke Energy – Energy Alerts
Energy Emergency Alert 3 [EEA3]
“Issued at or immediately prior to an event and will require
some responsive actions. A separate EEA termination
message will include a specific end time. A de-escalated
message may follow.”
This has not happened since Duke started the alert system.
Energy Emergency Alerts 5.1 a
59
Duke Energy – Energy Alerts
Energy Emergency Alert 3 [EEA3]
“Duke Energy has entered an EEA3 (firm load interruption is imminent
or in progress) condition [i.e. Rolling Blackouts]. If not previously
directed, Load Serving Entities are directed to implement all available
Demand Response programs, Distributed Energy Resources Assistance,
to curtail all non-firm energy sales, and to implement a voltage
reduction, where possible. Additionally, Load Serving Entities are
directed to implement firm load shed equal to (%) of total as soon as
possible. Further notifications, including termination of this EEA, will
be sent when conditions warrant.”
Rolling Blackouts
implement firm load shed
Energy Emergency Alerts 5.1 a
60
Duke Energy – Energy Alerts
Is Your Utility Ready To Drop 5% of its Load?
10% ?
15% ?
20% ?
What is your load shedding plan?
Energy Emergency Alerts 5.1 a
61
Duke Energy – Energy Alerts
Energy Emergency Alert 1 [EEA1]
Issued June 23, 2025 @ 7:50 PM [Monday]
“Duke Energy Carolinas has entered an EEA1 (all available generation
resources in use) condition. We are requesting Load Serving Entities to
implement Demand Response programs and Distributed Energy Resources
assistance. We will send further notifications, including termination of this
EEA when conditions warrant. Please monitor communication channels for
further messages in the event conditions change and call your Wholesale
Account Manager with any questions.
Description: Notification callout created by Nathan D. Smock for Notifications
CW on Mon 06/23/2025 19:49:18 ET
Energy Emergency Alerts 5.1 a
62
Duke Energy – Energy Alerts
Energy Emergency Alert 0 [EEA0] - Termination
“Will be issued prior to termination of the EEA event,
allowing the end of previously requested/directed actions.
Other escalated or de-escalated messages may follow if the
event warning continues.”
Energy Emergency Alerts 5.1 a
63
Duke Energy – Energy Alerts
Energy Emergency Alert 0 [EEA0] - Termination
Issued June 23, 2025 @ 9:34 PM [Monday]
“Duke Energy Carolinas has entered an EEA Level 0 condition as of 22:00 on
06/23/2025. This message terminates all previously declared EEA conditions for
Duke Energy Carolinas. Load Serving Entities are free to cease all previously
requested/directed actions (demand response, Distributed Energy Resource
assistance, curtailment of sales and/or non-essential loads, voltage reductions, and
firm load shed) and return to normal operations. Please monitor communication
channels for further messages in the event conditions change and call your
Wholesale Account Manager with any questions. The Capacity/Energy Warning
continues to remain in effect for Duke Energy Carolinas through 22:00 on
06/26/2025…”
Energy Emergency Alerts 5.1 a
64
Duke Energy – Energy Alerts
Staff suggests PMPA establish a policy for
notification and the reduction of load in the
event of declared energy emergencies.
This can be developed by the Supplemental
Power Supply/Transmission Committee and
brought to the full PMPA Board for approval.
Energy Emergency Alerts 5.1 a
65
Catawba Nuclear Station
Power Uprate
Dennis Cameron
August 21, 2025
Approval of Capital Request for Powe... 6.1 a
66
Catawba Power Uprate
• More than 170 power uprates have been performed
across the US commercial nuclear sector dating back to
1977
– Measurement uncertainty recapture (MUR) power uprates – increased the licensed power
by less than 2 percent by implementing improved techniques for calculating reactor power
– Stretch power uprates – typically between 2 and 7 percent, involves changes to
instrumentation but not major plant modifications
– Extended power uprates – have been approved for increases as high as 20 percent,
usually require significant modifications to major pieces of equipment
– Catawba Unit 1, McGuire Unit 1, and McGuire Unit 2 previously implemented the MUR
uprates earlier prior to 2015
2
Approval of Capital Request for Powe... 6.1 a
67
Capital Power Uprate - continued
• Evaluation studies have determined the feasibility and cost
effectiveness to implement additional power uprates for
McGuire Unit 1, McGuire Unit 2, and Catawba Unit 1
• Duke has decided, with management approval, to move
forward with the power uprates at both McGuire Units
• Increase Output of 75 MWs per unit or 150 MWs for the
McGuire station
• Implementation will be Fall 2029 for McGuire Unit 1 and Fall
2030 for McGuire Unit 2
3
Approval of Capital Request for Powe... 6.1 a
68
Catawba Power Uprate - continued
• Evaluation studies also show the feasibility of uprating
Catawba Unit 1 by 75 MWs
• Catawba Unit 2 cannot be uprated due to the thermal margin
limitations associated with the Steam Generators
• Proposed implementation of Catawba Unit 1 uprate would be
in Spring 2031
• With the proposed uprates for McGuire Unit 1, McGuire Unit
2, and Catawba Unit 1; PMPA would gain additional 13.785
MWs
4
Approval of Capital Request for Powe... 6.1 a
69
Catawba Power Uprate - continued
• Cost Estimate for Catawba Unit 1 Uprate
– $416 million incudes $33 million of contingency and $175 million of
equipment that is to be replaced due to end of service life
– Uprate costs $241 million
• Cost Estimate – PMPA’s Share
– $30.13 million or $2,185 per kw with contingency
– $26 million or $1,886 per kw excluding contingency
5
Approval of Capital Request for Powe... 6.1 a
70
Uprate vs Supplemental Power Costs
(Combined Cycle)
• Uprate of 13.785 MWs
– Capital investment of $2,185/kw
– No increase in O&M
– Incremental fuel costs for additional energy
– Combined Cycle $2,140/kw
– Fixed O&M $1.75/kw-month
– Variable O&M $2/MWh
– Gas price $4-$5/mmbtu
Approval of Capital Request for Powe... 6.1 a
71
Uprate vs Supplemental Power Costs
(Combined Cycle) - continued
• 2031 Uprate will result in a NPV savings of $23 million for the
current license period
• For the period 2031 to 2063 will result in a NPV savings of $45
million
Approval of Capital Request for Powe... 6.1 a
72
Duke Notification
• Duke notified PMPA on June 3, 2025
• Request for approval to move forward with the License
Amendment Application (LAR) process
• The estimate for this process is $77.6 million
– PMPA’s share is $9.7 million
• PMPA has until August 31, 2025 to decide if it wants to
participate in the Uprate project
Approval of Capital Request for Powe... 6.1 a
73
Catawba Power Uprate - continued
• Next Steps
– Approve and keep the MWs for PMPA’s use
– Management Recommendation - Approve the Power Uprate Project
and move forward with finalizing a Capital Additions Agreement with
Duke
– If Board decides not to approve the Power Uprate Project, then
reach an agreement with Duke to pay for PMPA’s share of the
project and rights to the additional output
9
Approval of Capital Request for Powe... 6.1 a
74
1
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA BEFORE THE
FEDERAL ENERGY REGULATORY COMMISSION
Duke Energy Corporation )
Duke Energy Carolinas, LLC ) Docket No. EC25-___-000
Duke Energy Progress, LLC )
APPLICATION UNDER SECTION 203 OF THE FEDERAL POWER ACT FOR
APPROVAL OF INTERNAL CORPORATE REORGANIZATION
Duke Energy Corporation (“Duke Energy”), together with its wholly-owned public utility
operating company, Duke Energy Carolinas, LLC (“DEC”), and its indirectly wholly-owned
public utility operating company, Duke Energy Progress, LLC (“DEP,” together with DEC, “the
Companies,” and collectively, with Duke Energy, “the Applicants”), hereby submit this
application for authorization of a proposed internal corporate reorganization (the “Internal
Reorganization”) pursuant to sections 203(a)(1) and 203(a)(2) of the Federal Power Act (“FPA”)1
and Part 33 of the regulations of the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (“FERC” or
“Commission”),2 in which DEP will merge with and into DEC, with DEC as the surviving entity.
As a result, a single utility will serve all of the existing wholesale and retail customers in the legacy
DEC and DEP service territories.
As described in detail in this application, the Internal Reorganization is consistent with the
public interest and meets the statutory requirements of FPA section 203. Specifically, the Internal
Reorganization should be approved because it is consistent with the public interest under criteria
1 16 U.S.C. §§ 824b(a)(1)-(2) (2018). Duke Energy is the parent holding company and is not itself a public utility.
Duke Energy joins this application solely out of an abundance of caution to the extent that the Commission deems
the Internal Reorganization requires approval under FPA section 203(a)(2) for Duke Energy or any intermediate
holding companies in the Duke Energy system that play a role in facilitating the merger of DEP and DEC.
2 18 C.F.R. Part 33 (2025).
2
outlined by the Commission in its regulations, in the Merger Policy Statement 3 and the
Supplemental Merger Policy Statement,4 and in Order No. 669.5 Applicants therefore respectfully
request that the Commission grant the authorizations requested herein and grant limited waivers
of certain Part 33 filing requirements.6
Contemporaneously with filing this application with FERC, the Companies are also filing
applications seeking approval of the Internal Reorganization with the North Carolina Utilities
Commission (“NCUC”), which oversees the Companies’ North Carolina retail jurisdiction, and
the Public Service Commission of South Carolina (“PSCSC”), which oversees the Companies’
South Carolina retail jurisdiction. 7 The Applicants are requesting regulatory approval from all
3 Inquiry Concerning the Commission’s Merger Pol’y Under the Fed. Power Act: Pol’y Statement, Order No. 592,
FERC Stats. & Regs. ¶ 31,044 (1996), 61 Fed. Reg. 68,595 (1996) ) (“Merger Policy Statement”), reconsideration
denied, Order No. 592-A, 79 FERC ¶ 61,321 (1997).
4 FPA Section 203 Supplemental Pol’y Statement, 120 FERC ¶ 61,060 (2007) (“Supplemental Merger Policy
Statement”), order on clarification and consideration., 122 FERC ¶ 61,157 (2008).
5 See Transactions Subject to FPA Section 203, Order No. 669, 113 FERC ¶ 61,315 (2005), order on reh’g, Order
No. 669-A, 115 FERC ¶ 61,097, order on reh’g, Order No. 669-B, 116 FERC ¶ 61,076 (2006).
6 On May 30, 2025, DEC, DEP, and Duke Energy Indiana, LLC (“DEI”) jointly filed a petition for declaratory
order requesting that the Commission make certain findings so that DEC, DEP, and DEI may each establish a
wholly-owned procurement company (“ProCo”) subsidiary (“DEC ProCo,” “DEP ProCo,” and “DEI ProCo,”
respectively) to achieve customer rate savings through increased tax efficiencies. Petition for Declaratory Order,
Blanket Authorizations, and Waivers, Docket No. EL25-89-000 (filed May 30, 2025) (“Petition”). In the Petition,
DEC, DEP, and DEI requested that the Commission find, inter alia, that DEC ProCo, DEP ProCo, and DEI ProCo
are not public utilities under FPA section 201, 16 U.S.C. § 824. That same day, DEC and DEP submitted proposed
changes to the Duke Energy Joint Open Access Transmission Tariff (“Joint OATT”) to account for the
establishment of DEC ProCo and DEP ProCo. Revisions to Joint OATT, Docket No. ER25-2385-000 (filed May
30, 2025). As of today, the Petition and proposed Joint OATT revisions remain pending. Should the Commission
make the determinations requested in the Petition and accept the Joint OATT changes, Applicants anticipate that
DEC ProCo and DEP ProCo will be fully operational when the Internal Reorganization is consummated and will
be consolidated into a single ProCo that day. Commission approval of the ProCo consolidation is not required
because DEC ProCo and DEP ProCo are not public utilities under FPA section 201. Applicants nonetheless
include this update out of an abundance of caution and confirm that they will submit proposed revisions to the
Joint OATT under FPA section 205 to reflect the consolidation of DEC ProCo and DEP ProCo into a single
ProCo.
7 In addition to the instant application, the Internal Reorganization also requires approval by the NCUC and PSCSC.
Neither the Internal Reorganization nor the relief sought in this application will foreclose, preempt, or otherwise
limit the authority of the NCUC and PSCSC to review the applications pending before them and take any action
on them consistent with state law and jurisdiction. The Companies are also serving copies of the instant
application on the NCUC, the Public Staff–NCUC, PSCSC, and the South Carolina Office of Regulatory Staff.
3
three jurisdictions in order to consummate the Internal Reorganization on January 1, 2027 (“Legal
Day 1”).8
I. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
The purpose of the Internal Reorganization is to consolidate DEC and DEP into a single
electric utility—(that single utility will be DEC, as the survivor of the merger, but referred to herein
as “Carolinas 1U” to avoid confusion with DEC as it currently exists)—serving existing wholesale
and retail customers in the legacy DEC and DEP service territories in North Carolina and South
Carolina. The Internal Reorganization will allow Carolinas 1U to unlock substantial savings to
customers on a system basis through planning, execution, and operational efficiencies.
Specifically, the Internal Reorganization will allow Carolinas 1U to: plan investments in necessary
generation and transmission resources more efficiently; execute those plans more efficiently by
siting and building those resources more cost-effectively; and operate those resources more
efficiently as a fully integrated system.
The single utility’s ability to plan, execute, and operate resources more efficiently will
result in substantial cost savings, benefiting customers by reducing the overall costs to serve. The
vast majority of the quantifiable customer savings identified by the Applicants come from these
planning, execution, and operational efficiencies. The remainder of the benefits is derived from
corporate administrative savings. After factoring in the cost to achieve these savings, the
Applicants project that the Internal Reorganization will save customers more than $1 billion over
the course of twelve years.
8 If the Internal Reorganization is approved, Applicants will make a series of implementation filings pursuant to
FPA section 205.
4
As further described below and in the testimony supporting this application, the Internal
Reorganization is consistent with the public interest. As is the case with most internal
reorganizations, there will be no adverse impact on rates, competition, or regulation, and there will
be no inappropriate cross-subsidization. However, a natural consequence of combining two
utilities with different cost structures (one higher and one lower) is a reallocation of the costs of
the legacy systems among the different jurisdictions served by the utilities. That is in fact what
will happen in this case—the Internal Reorganization will result in a reallocation of costs from the
wholesale to retail jurisdictions, with South Carolina retail being most significantly affected, and,
to a lesser extent, North Carolina retail and existing DEC wholesale power supply customers.
Specifically, the Companies’ wholesale jurisdiction represents a larger share of the DEP
system (the higher-cost system) than the DEC system, while the South Carolina retail jurisdiction
currently represents a larger share of the DEC system (the lower-cost system). The Internal
Reorganization will result in legacy system costs being reallocated from existing DEP wholesale
power supply customers to the retail jurisdictions and existing DEC wholesale power supply
customers. The Internal Reorganization will result in a similar rate adjustment effect between the
Joint OATT transmission customers of the legacy Companies, as DEP’s Joint OATT rates are
generally higher than DEC’s Joint OATT rates, and a combined formula rate will thus result in a
lower rate for legacy DEP Joint OATT customers and a higher rate for legacy DEC Joint OATT
customers.
To address these short-term impacts, the Companies are proposing and seek Commission
approval of a rate mitigation plan (the “1U Rate Mitigation Plan”). The 1U Rate Mitigation Plan
acts as a bridge to address these cost reallocation challenges between the jurisdictions and among
the wholesale customer classes. The 1U Rate Mitigation Plan consists of two components: (1) the
5
“Share the Benefits Plan;” and (2) the “OATT Mitigation Plan.” The Share the Benefits Plan
involves legacy DEP wholesale power supply customers deferring their merger savings for a
period of five years to provide revenue to fund credits to the Companies’ South Carolina retail
customers and existing DEC wholesale power supply customers to offset cost reallocations
resulting from the Internal Reorganization. The OATT Mitigation Plan, in turn, involves three
rate mitigation measures to address transmission cost reallocations resulting from the Internal
Reorganization.
The 1U Rate Mitigation Plan is uniquely tailored to address the particular short-term
impacts that result from the Internal Reorganization, which is driven by the potential to achieve
long-run customer savings. The Commission has long held that the existence of a rate increase as
a result of a particular transaction does not necessarily mean that there is an “adverse impact” on
rates under section 203 of the FPA. 9 The type of cost equalization effects observed here are not
uncommon when two vertically-integrated utilities merge, and the Commission has accepted
effective mitigation proposals to address the near-term impacts. 10 The broad-based agreement
amongst most of the Companies’ legacy wholesale power supply customers is evidence that the
1U Rate Mitigation Plan is consistent with the public interest.
9 See, e.g., Entergy Servs., LLC , 168 FERC ¶ 61,207 at P 49 (2019) (“Based on Applicants’ representations, we
find that, while the Proposed Transaction will increase rates, in the unique circumstances of this case, such an
increase is not adverse.”), order on reh’g and clarification, 171 FERC ¶ 61,038 (2020); ITC Holdings Corp., 143
FERC ¶ 61,256 at P 119 (2013) (“[W]e find, based on the evidence in the record, that Applicants have
demonstrated that the Proposed Transaction will not have an adverse effect on rates. Although rates will increase
for some customers as a result of this transaction, Applicants have shown that the Proposed Transaction will result
in offsetting benefits.”), order dismissing reh’g and clarification, 151 FERC ¶ 61,266 (2015).
10 See, e.g. , NextEra Energy, Inc. , 173 FERC ¶ 61,029 at P 27 (2020) (approving internal reorganization that
proposed mitigation measures to address potential rate impacts on the grounds that the commitments were
“sufficient to mitigate any potential adverse effect on rates resulting from the [transaction]”).
6
For all of these reasons, Applicants respectfully request that the Commission act on this
application at the earliest possible date within the Commission’s 180-day review period and
approve the proposed Internal Reorganization as consistent with the public interest.
II. BACKGROUND
A. Description of Applicants
1. Duke Energy Corporation
Duke Energy is a Fortune 150 energy holding company headquartered in Charlotte, North
Carolina.11 Through its franchised utility affiliates—DEC, DEP, Duke Energy Florida, LLC
(“DEF”), DEI, Duke Energy Kentucky, Inc., and Duke Energy Ohio, Inc.—Duke Energy serves
approximately 8.6 million retail and wholesale customers in North Carolina, South Carolina,
Florida, Indiana, Ohio, and Kentucky. Duke Energy collectively owns more than 55,100
megawatts (“MW”) of energy capacity, and its natural gas utilities serve 1.7 million customers in
North Carolina, South Carolina, Tennessee, Kentucky, and Ohio. Additionally, Piedmont Natural
Gas Company, Inc. (“Piedmont”), a wholly-owned direct subsidiary of Duke Energy, is engaged
in the business of transporting, distributing, and selling natural gas in the states of North Carolina,
South Carolina, and Tennessee.12
2. Duke Energy Carolinas, LLC
DEC is a wholly-owned direct subsidiary of Duke Energy. DEC is a vertically integrated
public utility providing generation, transmission, and distribution services to approximately 2.9
11 To the best of Duke Energy’s knowledge, only one entity holds ten percent or more of Duke Energy’s outstanding
common stock, and is therefore considered an affiliate, pursuant to its authority to hold up to twenty percent of
the voting securities of any public utility. See Quarterly Report of the Vanguard Group, Inc., Docket No. EC19-
57-002 (filed Aug. 6, 2024) (noting a 10.85 percent ownership in Duke Energy).
12 On July 29, 2025, Duke Energy announced the sale of Piedmont’s Tennessee assets to Spire Inc. After the sale—
which is expected to close in the first quarter of 2026—Piedmont will transport, distribute, and sell natural gas
only in North Carolina and South Carolina.
7
million retail customers over an approximately 24,000 square mile service area in Central and
Western North Carolina and Western South Carolina. DEC’s service area includes sixty-two
counties—forty-four in North Carolina and eighteen in South Carolina.
DEC provides transmission service under a formula rate in the Joint OATT. 13 DEC
provides wholesale power supply service to several load-serving entities in the Carolinas pursuant
to long-term contracts on file with the Commission.
In addition to being regulated by FERC, DEC is also regulated by the NCUC and the
PSCSC.
DEC is registered with the North American Electric Reliability Corporation (“NERC”) as
a Balancing Authority (“BA”) for the DUK Balancing Authority Area (“BAA”).
3. Duke Energy Progress, LLC
DEP is a wholly-owned direct subsidiary of Progress Energy, Inc. (“Progress”), which, in
turn, is a wholly-owned subsidiary of Duke Energy. DEP is a vertically integrated public utility
providing generation, transmission, and distribution services to approximately 1.6 million retail
customers over an approximately 28,000 square mile service area covering a substantial portion of
the coastal plain of North Carolina extending from the Piedmont to the Atlantic coast, the lower
Piedmont section of North Carolina, an area in Western North Carolina in and around the city of
Asheville, and an area in the Northeastern portion of South Carolina.
DEP provides transmission service under a formula rate in the Joint OATT. DEP provides
wholesale power supply service to several load-serving entities in the Carolinas pursuant to long-
term contracts on file with the Commission.
13 The Joint OATT governs the provision of transmission service across the facilities owned by DEC, DEP, and
DEF. See Duke Energy Carolinas, LLC – Tariffs, Rate Schedules and Service Agreements, Tariff Volume No.
4, Open Access Transmission Tariff (18.0.0).
8
In addition to being regulated by FERC, DEC is also regulated by the NCUC and the
PSCSC.
DEP is registered with NERC as a BA for the CPLW and CPLE BAAs.
4. The Current BAA/Service Territory Configuration
As shown in the territory map below, DEC’s current service territory covers the western
parts of the Carolinas, including portions of the Blue Ridge Mountains and foothills, and the
heavily populated Piedmont region east of the mountains. In contrast, DEP’s current service
territory mostly covers the eastern parts of the Carolinas toward the coast, with a relatively small
pocket of territory in Western North Carolina along the Tennessee border and around Asheville.
Accordingly, DEC’s service territory is, in general, hillier and more wooded, whereas
DEP’s service territory, apart from the Western North Carolina region, is generally more coastal
and flat, with fewer wooded areas and less cloud cover.
9
Additionally, the graphic below depicts the Companies’ three current BAAs: DUK, CPLE,
and CPLW. The Companies are working with NERC and the SERC Reliability Corporation to
consolidate the BAAs contemporaneously with the Internal Reorganization.
B. The 2012 Duke/Progress Holding Company Merger
In 2011, Duke Energy and Progress, together with their public utility subsidiaries—DEC
(a subsidiary of Duke Energy) and Carolina Power & Light Company d/b/a Progress Energy
Carolinas, Inc. (“CPL”) (then a subsidiary of Progress)—requested Commission authorization for
a merger pursuant to which Progress would become a wholly-owned subsidiary of Duke Energy
(“Duke/Progress Merger”).14 Although Duke Energy and Progress (through their public utility
subsidiaries) each owned a large amount of generation capacity, the DEC and CPL BAAs in North
Carolina and South Carolina were the only markets in which the supply capabilities of DEC and
14 Application for Authorization of Disposition of Jurisdictional Assets and Merger under Sections 203(a)(1) and
203(a)(2) of the Federal Power Act, Docket No. EC11-60-000 (filed Apr. 4, 2011) (“Duke/Progress Merger
Application”).
10
CPL overlapped. Specifically, DEC served wholesale and retail customers in the DUK BAA
(including areas in both North Carolina and South Carolina), and CPL served wholesale and retail
customers in the CPLE and CPLW BAAs (also including areas in both North Carolina and South
Carolina).15 Thus, for purposes of demonstrating that the Duke/Progress Merger was consistent
with the public interest, the analysis of potential horizontal market power concerns focused on
three BAAs: DUK, CPLE, and CPLW.16
The Commission initially concluded that the proposed Duke/Progress Merger resulted in
certain screen failures that raised concerns regarding adverse effects on competition in the DUK
and CPLE BAAs. 17 Therefore, the Commission made approval of the Duke/Progress Merger
conditional on the adoption of certain market mitigation measures. 18 In 2012, the Commission
accepted Duke Energy and Progress’ compliance filing 19 that proposed: (1) “Permanent
Mitigation” in the form of transmission upgrades; (2) “Interim Mitigation” in the form of firm
sales of capacity and energy until the new transmission projects constituting the proposed
Permanent Mitigation were placed in service; and (3) certain “Stub Mitigation” in the form of a
limited set-aside of transmission capacity on the internal interface path from the DEC BAA to the
15 In the Duke/Progress Merger proceeding, the CPL BAAs were referred to as Progress Energy Carolinas-East, or
PEC-East, and Progress Energy Carolinas-West, or PEC-West. To avoid confusion, in this application, we refer
to the BAAs as they are now referenced, including when discussing the Duke/Progress Merger proceeding (i.e.,
when the parties were using the references PEC-East and PEC-West).
16 Duke/Progress Merger Application at 18.
17 Duke Energy Corp. , 136 FERC ¶ 61,245 at PP 1, 117 (2011) (“September 2011 Merger Order”), reh’g denied,
149 FERC ¶ 61,078 (2014) (“October 14 Rehearing Order”).
18 Id.
19 Revised Compliance Filing, Docket No. EC11-60-004 (filed Mar. 26, 2012) (“2012 Compliance Filing”).
11
CPLE BAA, for the summer off-peak season/load period, to be monitored by Potomac Economics
Ltd. (“Potomac Economics”).20
In 2014, the Commission permitted Duke Energy and Progress to supplement their 2012
Compliance Filing, and denied rehearing of, inter alia, the September 2011 Merger Order and the
June 2012 Merger Order.21 As a result of the October 2014 Rehearing Order, the Stub Mitigation
ultimately accepted by the Commission consisted of: (1) DEC establishing a transmission set-aside
of 129 MW of firm transmission capacity on the internal interface between the DEC BAA to the
CPLE BAA in the summer off-peak season/load period; (2) DEC operating certain Phase Shifters
(“PARs”) to eliminate overloads and increase available transmission capability (“ATC”) into the
CPLE BAA; and (3) independent monitoring of the transmission set-aside requirement and the
PARs operation by Potomac Economics, with annual reporting in the Duke/Progress Merger
docket.22
Since 2014, Potomac Economics has filed annual reports in Docket No. EC11-60 to address
the Companies’ compliance with the Stub Mitigation commitments. Each year, one report
addresses the set-aside requirement,23 and a separate report addresses operation of the PARs within
20 Duke Energy Corp ., 139 FERC ¶ 61,194 (2012) (“June 2012 Merger Order”) (accepting the 2012 Compliance
Filing). To date, all of the Permanent Mitigation and the Interim Mitigation has been completed. As confirmed
by the annual Potomac Economics reports filed in the Duke/Progress Merger docket (Docket No. EC11-60-000),
DEC has continued to meet the Stub Mitigation commitments since the Duke/Progress Merger.
21 October 2014 Rehearing Order, 149 FERC ¶ 61,078.
22 Id. at PP 76-77, 79.
23 As Potomac Economics has explained, the Companies’ protocols for implementing the 129 MW set-aside have
evolved over the years. For the summers of 2014 through 2016, the Companies committed to making no short-
term firm reservations during summer off-peak hours. Seasonal Independent Monitoring Report on “Stub
Mitigation” Transmission Set-Aside for Duke Energy Corp. and Progress Energy, Inc., Docket No. EC11-60-004,
at 3-4 (filed Sept. 30, 2024) (“2024 Set-Aside Report”). Beginning in 2017, the Companies implemented an
automated solution that allows the Companies to reserve short-term firm ATC on the DUK to CPLE interface
provided that 129 MW of ATC remains set-aside for non-affiliates. Id. at 3. For long-term firm transmission
requests, when the Companies or an affiliate make a service request on the DUK to CPLE interface, “the ATC
will be reduced by 129 MW before assessing the request,” although “the 129 MW may be lower if new third-
party firm requests on the interface are in queue or confirmed.” Id. at 4.
12
CPLE.24 In these annual reports, Potomac Economics has consistently concluded that the
Companies complied with the Stub Mitigation obligations.
III. PURPOSE AND DRIVERS OF THE INTERNAL REORGANIZATION
Since the Duke/Progress Merger, the Companies have taken significant steps to achieve
operational efficiencies under separate operating companies, including aligning customer service
systems, corporate support functions, and regulatory processes where possible. Through these
efforts, the Companies have achieved over $1 billion in customer savings. In particular, through
operation of the Joint Dispatch Agreement (“JDA”)—approved by the Commission in connection
with the Duke/Progress Merger25—the Companies have achieved hundreds of millions of dollars
in customer savings by jointly dispatching generation resources that remain independently owned
by either DEC or DEP and sharing in the resulting production cost savings.
Despite these benefits, DEC and DEP fundamentally remain two separate operating
utilities, and existing regulatory constraints prohibit DEC and DEP from functioning as one utility.
For example, the JDA does not permit the Companies to jointly plan to meet their combined
capacity needs, requiring each utility to separately ensure that it has adequate resources to
24 In accordance with the October 2014 Rehearing Order, Potomac Economics (1) monitors “the Company’s ATC
process to ensure the ATC values reflect the fact that the PARs should be operated to increase ATC on the DEC-
to-DEP-East transmission path” and (2) “report[s] on statistics relating to the operation of the PARs as specified
by the Commission in its [October] 2014 order.” Seasonal Independent Monitoring Report on “Stub Mitigation”
PAR Operations for Duke Energy Corp. and Progress Energy, Inc., Docket No. EC11-60-004, at 4 (filed Oct. 8,
2024) (“2024 PAR Report”). In terms of meeting Stub Mitigation requirements, Potomac Economics has
explained that “the most important aspect of the PARs being in service is that their availability increases the ATC,
as opposed to actual operating benefits,” meaning that “ensuring that potential operation of the PARs in the
operating horizon is reflected in ATC values is the most important issue for the PAR monitoring.” Id. at 6
(emphasis in original). Over the years, every PARs report from Potomac Economics has concluded that there
were “[no] instances in the operating horizon that require[d] operation of the PARs,” “there were no curtailments
of firm schedules on the DEC-to-DEP-East path,” and the “operation of the PARs did not raise concerns” for the
relevant reporting period. Id. at 9.
25 See Duke Energy Corp., 139 FERC ¶ 61,193 (2012), reh’g denied, 151 FERC ¶ 61,242 (2015), vacated in part
sub nom. Orangeburg S.C. v. FERC, 862 F.3d 1071 (D.C. Cir. 2017). Pursuant to the JDA, DEC and DEP jointly
dispatch their generation fleets to operate their systems more economically for the benefit of their customers.
13
independently meet anticipated demand—even where sharing resources would produce better
outcomes for customers. Additionally, as explained above, the Companies are responsible for
three separate BAAs—DUK, CPLW, and CPLE—and, as a result, must maintain their own real-
time load and generation balance and independently satisfy NERC Reliability Standards.
The merger of DEC and DEP into Carolinas 1U overcomes these limitations by enabling
full integration of resource planning and operations across a single, combined utility. The
efficiencies gained through this integration will deliver customer savings over and above those
already achieved under the existing framework. Specifically, the Internal Reorganization will
achieve lower overall costs for customers by allowing Carolinas 1U to:
Plan investments in necessary generation and transmission resources more
efficiently;
Execute those plans more efficiently by siting and building those resources
more cost-effectively; and
Operate those resources more efficiently as a fully integrated system.
Although the amount of actual savings will depend on events as they unfold over time, the
system savings are estimated to be in the billions—anywhere from $1.6 billion to approximately
$3.2 billion.26 As such, the benefits of the Internal Reorganization will far exceed the costs of the
Internal Reorganization under any reasonably foreseeable resource planning scenario. These
quantifiable benefits flow almost entirely from the planning, execution, and operational
26 See Attachment 1, Prepared Direct Testimony of Nelson Peeler, Jr. at 3, 17. As discussed above, it is well
established under the Commission’s FPA section 203 jurisprudence that merging parties are not required to
demonstrate affirmative customer benefits. See UtiliCorp United Inc., 38 FERC ¶ 61,291, at 61,957 n.5 (1987)
(“Section 203(a) does not require a showing of a ‘positive benefit’ to the public in order for a merger to be found
to be in the public interest. Only an absence of a negative detriment is required.”) (internal quotations omitted).
Nonetheless, the magnitude of potential customer savings is important context for understanding the significant
beneficial impacts of the Internal Reorganization.
14
efficiencies Carolinas 1U can achieve by removing the constraints that currently do not allow DEC
and DEP to fully integrate their system planning and operations, all as described in witness Nelson
Peeler, Jr.’s testimony.
With respect to planning efficiencies, having a single reserve margin to plan towards (the
Carolinas 1U scenario) versus having to separately plan to meet separate reserve margins (the
current scenario) will allow the single, combined utility to defer construction and delay in-service
dates of generation and transmission resources that otherwise would have been needed earlier if
the Companies were required to operate as separate utilities. Specifically, because DEC’s and
DEP’s respective system peaks are not perfectly correlated, planning to a combined system peak
results in load diversity and a lower overall peak relative to simply adding the system peaks of
legacy DEC and legacy DEP together. These diversity benefits will allow Carolinas 1U to defer
certain capital investments that otherwise would have to be built by DEC and/or DEP, operating
alone, to meet the increased planning reserve margin independently.
Carolinas 1U will also be able to execute its resource planning more efficiently. For
example, building utility-scale solar generation requires expanses of flat, open land and is better
suited to DEP’s current service territory, whereas pumped storage hydro resources are more suited
to DEC’s service territory due to its mountainous terrain. As such, by eliminating geographic
barriers that otherwise would exist without the Internal Reorganization, Carolinas 1U will be able
to capitalize on the geographic diversity of the legacy DEC and legacy DEP service territories in
making resource plans. In addition, existing natural gas pipelines run through Western North
Carolina in DEC’s current service territory, making it more cost effective to site and develop
natural gas generation resources in that territory. Without the Internal Reorganization, the cost of
siting additional natural gas plants in DEP’s service territory would generally be higher because
15
of the need to build additional pipeline infrastructure to support any future additional plants.
Further, Carolinas 1U will be a financially stronger utility than either DEC or DEP alone, and that
financial strength will significantly enhance the single utility’s ability to finance large generation
and transmission investments needed to support and reliably serve growing demand. Enhanced
financial strength will also better position Carolinas 1U to manage unexpected events, such as
severe weather or fuel price volatility, without compromising service or financial stability. Lastly,
a single, combined utility creates a broader customer base over which these investments can be
spread, helping to moderate customer rate impacts over time.
The Internal Reorganization will also allow Carolinas 1U to operate more efficiently.
Specifically, the Internal Reorganization will consolidate the three existing DEC and DEP BAAs
(DUK, CPLE, and CPLW) into a single BAA, thereby allowing Carolinas 1U to jointly commit
resources. Under the JDA, DEC and DEP may not commit their generation resources to assist
with each other’s operational needs—they may only dispatch resources that are already operating.
The ability to engage in joint unit commitment means that, post-Internal Reorganization, Carolinas
1U will only need to meet a single operating reserve requirement versus the situation today, where
DEC and DEP must meet separate operating reserve requirements. From these operational
efficiencies, customers will realize savings through reduced fuel usage, reduced unit cycling,
reduced reliability purchases, and reduced solar curtailment.
In sum, the entire purpose of the Internal Reorganization is to allow the full integration of
DEC and DEP into a single operating utility and for customers to reap the full measure of the
benefits of that integration. Notably, the efficiencies to be achieved through the Internal
Reorganization come at a significant juncture in the industry. As the industry works toward
meeting transitional challenges in the coming years—including projected increases in load, the
16
integration of new generation technology and storage facilities, and the need to ensure grid
reliability—the Internal Reorganization will position the Companies to better serve the region’s
growing economy by more effectively managing energy needs across the Carolinas.
IV. DESCRIPTION OF THE INTERNAL REORGANIZATION
The Internal Reorganization is structured as an internal corporate reorganization, as both
DEC and DEP are subsidiaries of Duke Energy. Pursuant to an Agreement and Plan of Merger
(“Merger Agreement”),27 the Internal Reorganization will be accomplished in two steps: (1) Duke
Energy will contribute DEC to Progress; and (2) DEP will merge into DEC. At the Internal
Reorganization’s closing, DEC will survive the merger, and DEP will cease to exist as an entity.
These steps are shown in the pre- and post-closing organizational charts included herein as Exhibit
C. Subject to timely receipt of all required approvals, DEC and DEP anticipate closing the Internal
Reorganization on January 1, 2027. Applicants will inform the Commission of the actual closing
date in a notice of consummation to be filed in the instant docket.
V. THE INTERNAL REORGANIZATION IS CONSISTENT WITH THE PUBLIC
INTEREST
Section 203 of the FPA provides that the Commission shall authorize a proposed
transaction if it determines that the transaction “will be consistent with the public interest, and will
not result in inappropriate cross-subsidization of a non-utility associate company or the pledge or
encumbrance of utility assets for the benefit of an associate company.”28 In determining whether
a proposed transaction is consistent with the public interest, the Commission considers three
27 A form of the Merger Agreement, which will be substantively the same as the final version that will be executed
to consummate the Internal Reorganization, is attached hereto as Exhibit I.
28 16 U.S.C. § 824a(a)(4).
17
factors: (1) the effect on rates; (2) the effect on competition; and (3) the effect on regulation. 29
Applicants need not show that a transaction positively benefits the public interest, but rather simply
that it is “consistent with the public interest,” i.e., that the transaction does not harm the public
interest.30
As demonstrated below, the Internal Reorganization satisfies all of these standards and
therefore should be approved.
A. The Internal Reorganization Will Not Have an Adverse Effect on Rates
The Internal Reorganization will not have an adverse impact on Commission-jurisdictional
rates. The Companies currently operate separate retail service territories, have their own wholesale
power supply contracts, and have separate formula rate templates and zonal revenue requirements
under the Joint OATT. 31 The Companies’ Joint OATT rates are generally based on historical
(rather than projected) costs and are subject to update on June 1 of each year.
After the Internal Reorganization, Carolinas 1U will operate under a single set of books
and a single FERC Form 1. For purposes of Commission-jurisdictional transmission rates,
Carolinas 1U will also have a single OATT formula rate template and revenue requirement. With
respect to Commission-jurisdictional wholesale power supply rates, Carolinas 1U will serve
wholesale power supply customers under contract with the Companies today.
29 See Revised Filing Requirements Under Part 33 of the Comm’n’s Reguls., Order No. 642, FERC Stats. & Regs.
¶ 31,111 at 31,872-73 (2000), order on reh’g, Order No. 642-A, 94 FERC ¶ 61,289 (2001).
30 See, e.g., Tex.-N.M. Power Co., 105 FERC ¶ 61,028 at PP 23, 23 n.14 (2003) (“Tex.-N.M. Power”) (citing Pac.
Power & Light Co. v. FPC, 111 F.2d 1014, 1016-17 (9th Cir. 1940)).
31 Rates for transmission service provided by DEC under the Joint OATT are determined pursuant to the formula
rate contained in Schedule 10-B, Exhibit B of the Joint OATT, with DEC’s annual transmission revenue
requirement derived each year by inputting DEC’s FERC Form 1 information. Rates for transmission service
provided by DEP under the Joint OATT are determined pursuant to the formula rate contained in Attachment H.1
of the Joint OATT. DEP’s formula rate uses a historical test year methodology whereby DEP’s rates change each
June 1 based on the immediately preceding year’s cost of service, calculated using end-of-year balances from
FERC Form No. 1.
18
As previewed above, merging DEC and DEP will create a single utility that calculates rates
for wholesale power supply service and transmission service. The numerator of these rates will
be based on the combined cost of service of the newly merged utility (i.e., it will include the costs
of legacy DEC and legacy DEP). Similarly, the denominator of these rates will be the combined
demand of the customers of both legacy DEC and DEP. As is necessarily the case when two such
rate structures are combined, the resulting merged rate will reflect some degree of equalization (or
averaging) such that the merged rate is comparatively lower for customers of the higher-cost legacy
system (here, DEP) and comparatively higher for customers of the lower-cost legacy system (here,
DEC). As explained in the testimonies of witnesses Jennifer Ellis and Blain Atkins, this
“Equalization Effect” applies to both wholesale power supply rates and transmission service rates.
In addition to the Equalization Effect within the context of the Companies’ FERC-
jurisdictional rates, the Internal Reorganization will result in a cost reallocation amongst the
Companies’ retail jurisdictions. The cost reallocation impacting the retail jurisdictions is purely a
result of the same Equalization Effect in the context of merged retail cost of service calculations.
However, notwithstanding the cost reallocations resulting from the Internal
Reorganization, the business case and long-run customer benefit justification for consolidating
DEP into DEC and operating as a combined utility are very strong, and, as explained below, the
Companies have fashioned a creative solution to address the short-term impacts of the Internal
Reorganization.
1. Summary of Customer Engagement on the 1U Rate Mitigation Plan
The Companies have been engaged in extensive customer outreach regarding the Internal
Reorganization for well over a year and have developed the 1U Rate Mitigation Plan to mitigate
short-term impacts of the Internal Reorganization. Because the 1U Rate Mitigation Plan does not
follow a specific blueprint, the Companies worked closely with their current transmission and
19
wholesale power supply customers to communicate the value and impact of the Internal
Reorganization and to craft the 1U Rate Mitigation Plan. The Companies held roughly a dozen
formal meetings with their entire OATT customer class to develop the OATT Mitigation Plan.
Additionally, the Companies held countless one-on-one meetings with their current wholesale
power supply customers to explain the Share the Benefits Plan. The 1U Rate Mitigation Plan is
the result of extensive customer feedback and input from these outreach efforts.
2. Overview of the 1U Rate Mitigation Plan
The Internal Reorganization is designed to achieve customer benefits over the long term
through reduced system cost of service largely resulting from the planning, execution, and
operational efficiencies explained above and described in greater detail in the testimony of witness
Peeler. However, an additional natural consequence of the Internal Reorganization is a
reallocation of costs among the three jurisdictions.
As indicated above, these cost reallocation impacts are a function of differences in the
system costs of legacy DEC and DEP and the varying jurisdictional shares of each system. Today,
DEP’s cost of service per MW-hour is higher than DEC’s. Additionally, the wholesale jurisdiction
currently represents a larger share of the DEP system (the higher-cost system) than the DEC
system, and the South Carolina retail jurisdiction currently represents a larger share of the DEC
system (the lower-cost system). Post-Internal Reorganization, under the single cost of service
study reflecting Carolinas 1U, there will necessarily be changes in the outcomes at the
jurisdictional level resulting from the cost of service allocation of the combined system. This
result flows naturally from the fact that, as noted above: (1) the costs of the Companies’ existing
systems are not identical; and (2) the current jurisdictional allocations of the Companies’ existing
systems are not identical.
20
The impacts of this cost reallocation effect on the Companies’ current wholesale power
supply customers are described in witness Ellis’ testimony, and the impacts to the Companies’
current Joint OATT customers are described in witness Atkins’ testimony. In short, all else being
equal, as formula rates are re-calculated for a merged company, DEP’s existing wholesale power
supply customers would see lower rates right away, and DEC’s existing wholesale power supply
customers would see higher rates, as the unified rate design allocates costs differently than today.
Further, additional costs would be allocated to the Companies’ South Carolina retail jurisdiction
as compared to today. This occurs because the Companies’ South Carolina retail jurisdiction will
be receiving a larger allocation of the higher-cost system (DEP) than was the case before the
Internal Reorganization.
To mitigate cost reallocation impacts in the near term, the Companies are proposing the
1U Rate Mitigation Plan—a five-year mitigation plan designed to address the impact of cost
reallocation in the short term. The 1U Rate Mitigation Plan consists of two components: the “Share
the Benefits Plan” and the “OATT Mitigation Plan.” The Share the Benefits Plan, as the name
implies, shares the benefits of the Internal Reorganization among the jurisdictions in the near term.
Thus, this targeted plan overcomes cost reallocation challenges in the near term for both the
Companies’ South Carolina retail jurisdiction and DEC’s existing wholesale power supply
customers and acts as a temporary bridge to facilitate full regulatory approval of the Internal
Reorganization. Similarly, the OATT Mitigation Plan mitigates concerns regarding potential
transmission rate increases following the Internal Reorganization by providing two separate credits
to legacy DEC Joint OATT customers for five years and implementing a “lower of” methodology
for calculating ancillary services rates.
21
On balance, the 1U Rate Mitigation Plan is a carefully constructed and negotiated solution
that balances the interests of all affected jurisdictions and wholesale customer classes and positions
all existing customers of DEC and DEP to benefit in the long run from the Internal Reorganization.
It is also consistent with the Commission’s history of approving transitional rate protections.32
a. Share the Benefits Plan
At a high level, as explained by witness Ellis, the Share the Benefits Plan smooths the
transition to Carolinas 1U by mitigating the cost reallocation impacts described above in the short
term. On Legal Day One—the day the Internal Reorganization is effectuated (and DEC and DEP
become one utility)—Carolinas 1U will have one set of books, and, ultimately, a single FERC
Form 1, and each wholesale power supply customer of legacy DEC and legacy DEP will take
service under formula rate templates that are populated with a single set of cost impacts.
Consequently, without an intervening mitigation plan, the impacts described above will occur.
The primary objectives of the Share the Benefits Plan are to address the impacts to the
Companies’ South Carolina retail jurisdiction, as it is allocated a greater proportional responsibility
for system costs, and to protect DEC’s existing wholesale power supply customers from an
immediate rate increase related to cost sharing of the DEP system (the higher-cost system).
To mitigate the near-term impacts of the cost reallocation associated with the Internal
Reorganization, the Companies are proposing that existing DEP wholesale power supply
customers temporarily defer some of the immediate cost reallocation benefits they would
otherwise receive and that they pay a fixed monthly “adder” for a five-year period. In essence, the
Share the Benefits Plan asks existing DEP wholesale power supply customers to continue paying
32 NextEra Energy, Inc. , 173 FERC ¶ 61,029 at PP 21, 27 (2020) (finding proposed five-year mitigation plan
“sufficient to mitigate any potential adverse effect on rates resulting from the Proposed Transaction”).
22
charges based on today’s allocation, rather than paying charges based on a one utility scenario, for
a five-year transitional period. This transitional “adder” maintains the costs existing DEP
wholesale power supply customers would otherwise have paid based on the legacy DEP system
absent the Internal Reorganization. In addition to this contribution, the Companies’ North Carolina
retail customers would contribute approximately $25 million per year to the Companies’ South
Carolina retail customers over a six-year period.
i. Deferred Benefits for DEP’s Existing Wholesale Power
Supply Customers
With respect to DEP’s current wholesale power supply customers, this delay in benefits
will be effectuated through amendments to DEP’s existing wholesale power supply customers’
contracts to secure from those customers a $55 million per year contribution to fund the Share the
Benefits Plan for five years (2027–2031), beginning on Legal Day 1. Witness Ellis explains in
detail how the Companies calculated the total amount of potential savings to be deferred by DEP’s
legacy wholesale power supply customers by analyzing what the current DEP wholesale power
supply customers would have paid under a one utility scenario, versus their actual payments as
stand-alone legacy DEP customers, over a three-year lookback period. This analysis established
the amount that the Companies could work from in developing a mitigation plan to address the
near term impacts of the Internal Reorganization on (1) existing DEC wholesale power supply
customers that would otherwise see immediate upward pressure on their rates, and (2) the cost
reallocation to the Companies’ South Carolina retail jurisdiction during the period in which it
would otherwise be negatively impacted.
From this analysis, the Companies derived specific amounts that each existing DEP
wholesale power supply customer would be asked to contribute to the Share the Benefits Plan to
offset the impact of cost reallocations that would otherwise impact DEC’s existing wholesale
23
power supply customers and the Companies’ South Carolina retail jurisdiction. Witness Ellis’
testimony contains the customer-by-customer detail on what specific amount is requested from
each legacy DEP wholesale power supply customer. Importantly, these amounts will be fixed for
the five-year transitional period; they are not formulaic amounts, nor are they subject to any sort
of true-up (up or down) during the five-year period. Establishing fixed values was critical to giving
DEP’s existing customers certainty about the extent of their contributions.
ii. Allocation of Deferred Benefit Amounts
As witness Ellis explains, the Companies calculated an annual amount for the five-year
transition period that would mitigate the rate impacts of the Internal Reorganization for each legacy
DEC wholesale power supply customer and worked with each existing DEC wholesale power
supply customer to evaluate their historical cost shift impacts, as well as their forecasted impacts
to derive a per-customer annual bill credit. The specific amounts being allocated to each existing
DEC wholesale power supply customer are stated in witness Ellis’ testimony. Like the savings
deferred by DEP’s current wholesale power supply customers, the credits to DEC’s current
wholesale power supply customers are fixed for the five-year transition period.
Each dollar of deferred savings contributed by DEP’s current wholesale power supply
customers that is not being used to fund a credit to DEC’s current wholesale power supply
customers will be used as a credit to the Companies’ South Carolina retail customers. Specifically,
due to the natural lag in retail rate cases, the contributions from the current DEP wholesale
jurisdiction and current North Carolina retail jurisdiction will be deferred to a regulatory liability
to begin flowing back to South Carolina retail customers of Carolinas 1U in the first South Carolina
retail rate case after the Internal Reorganization.
24
The Share the Benefits Plan, while perhaps unorthodox, is necessary to achieve long-term
customer benefits and is consistent with the Commission’s long-held policy that utilities work
collaboratively with their customers to address transaction-related rate issues. The Companies
determined early on in their consideration of the Internal Reorganization that, in order to obtain
state regulatory approvals, the Companies would need to develop such a rate mitigation plan. The
Companies also worked closely with DEP’s current wholesale power supply customers to explain
that the Internal Reorganization could not be achieved without these customers agreeing to some
form of deferred benefits. The Share the Benefits Plan is a delicate balancing of these various
objectives and smooths the way for the long-run efficiencies that will accrue to all customers as a
result of the Internal Reorganization.
Therefore, the Companies urge the Commission to find that the Share the Benefits Plan is
consistent with the public interest and to expressly approve the Internal Reorganization on that
basis.
b. OATT Mitigation Plan
The Companies developed a separate plan for addressing the short term impacts of the
Internal Reorganization on transmission rates under the Companies’ Joint OATT. As noted above,
although DEC and DEP operate under a Joint OATT (along with DEF), they maintain separate
revenue requirements and transmission rates for the DEC and DEP pricing zones. After the
Internal Reorganization, Carolinas 1U will operate a single BAA and calculate a single
transmission revenue requirement and set of transmission rates. Additionally, Carolinas 1U’s
OATT rates will continue to be updated on June 1 of each year. However, because Legal Day 1
is anticipated to be January 1, 2027, due to the timing of the Companies’ Joint OATT rates,
Carolinas 1U will not have a full year of FERC Form 1 data until after its first full year of merged
operations—i.e., the FERC Form 1 compiled in early 2028 based on the 2027 calendar year.
25
Accordingly, the Companies’ plan to move to a single-system rate under the OATT for each
relevant period, as reflected in Table 1 below:
Table 1
To be clear, the OATT Mitigation Plan is independent of the Share the Benefits Plan
described above. The rate mitigation steps described in this section address potential cost shift
impacts solely within the Companies’ Joint OATT customer class—i.e., between the legacy Joint
OATT customers of DEC and DEP.
The OATT Mitigation Plan is explained in detail in witness Atkins’ testimony, but, to
summarize here, the OATT Mitigation Plan consists of three parts: the “Equalization Adjustment,”
the “Divisor Adjustment,” and the “Ancillary Services Adjustment.” At a high level, the OATT
Mitigation Plan provides legacy DEC Joint OATT transmission customers with a credit over a
26
five-year period and adopts the lower rate between DEC and DEP when setting ancillary services
rates.
i. Transmission Service Rates
As result of this Internal Reorganization, two primary drivers will impact transmission rates
for legacy DEC Joint OATT customers.
First, as noted above, there is an Equalization Effect from the simple act of combining the
legacy DEC and DEP Joint OATT rates. The Joint OATT rates for legacy DEC are generally
lower than the Joint OATT rates for legacy DEP. As a result, merely merging DEC and DEP’s
current Joint OATT rates would lead to a near-term increase in the rates paid by legacy DEC
transmission customers.
Second, there is a “Divisor Effect”—in other words, a drop in the load divisor—as a result
of combining the legacy DUK, CPLW, and CPLE BAAs into one BAA and thereby eliminating
point-to-point reservations between the three BAAs. As a result of maintaining separate BAAs,
all current transmission customers, including DEC and DEP, are required to reserve point-to-point
service in order to move power from one DEC/DEP BAA to load in another DEC/DEP
BAA. These point-to-point reservations are in addition to the network service reserved for DEC
and DEP native load and total roughly 34,000 MW-months annually, which is roughly ten percent
of the combined total historical annual loads under the current DEC and DEP formula rates. In
setting transmission rates today, these point-to-point reservations are included in the rate divisor
with all other loads, and their presence increases the denominator, which in turn lowers the
resulting Joint OATT rate for all Joint OATT customers. However, after the Internal
Reorganization, a single BAA will “internalize” what was formerly the CPLE-DUK-CPLW
interfaces and neither Carolinas 1U nor any other transmission customer will need to acquire
point-to-point service to move power across the legacy DEC and DEP systems. As a result, legacy
27
point-to-point reservations will no longer appear in the rate calculation, and, all else being equal,
this lone change will result in a roughly ten percent decrease in the Carolinas 1U OATT rate
denominator, creating upward pressure on the Carolinas 1U OATT rates, as there are fewer MWs
of demand in the denominator over which to spread the revenue requirement.
To mitigate these issues, the Companies are proposing the Equalization Adjustment and
the Divisor Adjustment as part of the OATT Mitigation Plan. The Equalization Adjustment and
the Divisor Adjustment will provide legacy DEC Joint OATT customers with deductions
beginning on Legal Day 1 that will be gradually phased out over a five-year period. Specifically,
as shown in Table 2 below, the Equalization Adjustment will lower legacy DEC Joint OATT
customers’ revenue requirement for 2027-2031 for purposes of calculating rates. The Divisor
Adjustment, in turn, will reinstate a fixed amount of MW into the Carolinas 1U OATT divisor to
offset on a declining basis from 2027-2031. As shown in Table 3 below, the Companies will
reinstate the 36,120 MW originally removed from the rate denominator at 100% on Legal Day 1
and then gradually decrease the MW amount by 20% each year, reaching 0% in year six.
Table 2
Year 133 Year 2 Year 3 Year 4 Year 5
DEC Cost Shift Revenue
Requirement Adj ($000s) (37,139) (29,711) (22,283) (14,856) (7,428)
Table 3
Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Year 4 Year 5
MW Divisor Adjustment 36,120 28,896 21,672 14,448 7,224
As noted above, the Equalization Adjustment and the Divisor Adjustment will phase out
proportionately over a five-year period. Because all Carolinas 1U OATT customers will begin to
33 Year 1 in Tables 2 and 3 represents the 2028 OATT Annual Update.
28
see the benefits of coordinated planning, execution, and operations starting Legal Day 1, it is
equitable to phase out the Equalization Adjustment as the benefits of the Internal Reorganization
phase in.
The Equalization Adjustment and the Divisor Adjustment do not apply to legacy DEP Joint
OATT customers because their rates will go down immediately as a result of the Internal
Reorganization. In other words, because legacy DEP Joint OATT customers are part of a customer
class that is an immediate beneficiary of the Internal Reorganization, further downward mitigation
is not required.
ii. Ancillary Services Rates
The OATT Mitigation Plan also addresses ancillary services rates under the Joint OATT.
Unlike the Companies’ transmission service rates, which update every year, both DEC and DEP
have stated ancillary services rates which have not been updated for many years. Accordingly,
when Carolinas 1U ultimately updates its ancillary services rates, the changes from the existing
rates will likely be driven as much by the updating itself as any merger-related impact. Any
merger-related impact would be driven by averaging the historical rate discrepancies between
legacy DEC and legacy DEP, but in the context of updating inputs, a merger impact would be
practically impossible to isolate without calculating two separate rate cases. Moreover, because
some existing ancillary services rates are higher for legacy DEC customers and others are higher
for legacy DEP customers, it is not clear that the Equalization Effect applies to ancillary services
rates.
Consequently, pursuant to the OATT Mitigation Plan, the Companies are proposing the
Ancillary Services Adjustment. Under the Ancillary Services Adjustment, the Companies will
charge all Carolinas 1U OATT customers the lower of the existing DEC or DEP Joint OATT rate
29
for each ancillary service, as shown in Table 4, for a two-year period (calendar years 2027 and
2028) beginning on Legal Day 1.
Table 4
Lower of DEC-DEP Ancillary Services Rates for Calendar Years 2027 and 2028
Current DEC Rate Current DEP Rate
Lower of
DEC-DEP Rate
Schedule 1 $ 55.00* $ 36.50 $ 36.50
Schedule 3 $ 38.00 $ 47.52 $ 38.00
Schedule 5 $ 81.50 $ 70.09 $ 70.09
Schedule 6 $ 81.50 $ 50.09 $ 50.09
*DEC’s Schedule 1 rate is based on the 2024 annual update
Carolinas 1U will charge the lower of these rates for at least two years and up until such
time as it has operational data as a merged company that could support a FPA section 205 filing
to update the prevailing ancillary services rates across the board. As explained above, because
Carolinas 1U will not have combined FERC Form 1 data until April 2028, Applicants commit that
the earliest effective date that Carolinas 1U would seek to update ancillary services rates would be
January 1, 2029—two years after Legal Day 1. This gives Carolinas 1U OATT customers two
years of ancillary services rates that are either status quo, or lower than the status quo, after Legal
Day 1. And, when Carolinas 1U ultimately files an ancillary services rate case, it will be subject
to the Commission’s full review under FPA section 205 so that the rates resulting from such
proceeding would have been found to be just and reasonable and not unduly discriminatory. For
purposes of finding no adverse impact on Joint OATT rates, this two-year stay-out is more than
sufficient mitigation for a number of reasons.
First, during the two-year moratorium, all Carolinas 1U OATT customers will get an
affirmative benefit under the “lower of” approach because, by definition, they will be paying either
the same ancillary services rate that they pay today, or a lower rate, depending on the specific
ancillary service schedule. Second, when the ancillary services rates are eventually updated,
30
Carolinas 1U customers will get the benefit of a lower operating reserve requirement resulting
from the combined utility, which, all else being equal, will lower rates compared to a two-utility
scenario. Finally, there is no need for the Companies to separately address any Equalization Effect
in ancillary services rates because, as noted above, the rates for these services are not consistently
higher on either the DEC or DEP side, and, when ancillary services rates are finally updated,
Carolinas 1U customers will get the aforementioned benefit of a lower reserve requirement that
would not be possible without the Internal Reorganization.
3. Implementation of 1U Rate Mitigation Plan
As explained above, the 1U Rate Mitigation Plan is the centerpiece of the Companies’ plan
to effectuate the Internal Reorganization and Applicants request that the Commission expressly
approve the Internal Reorganization on that basis.
During the pendency of this proceeding, the Companies will work with each affected
wholesale power supply customer to implement the terms of the Share the Benefits Plan in their
respective wholesale power supply agreements, including the specific Reorganization Amounts
designated for each customer as set forth in witness Ellis’ testimony. Upon the Commission’s
approval of the Internal Reorganization, including the 1U Rate Mitigation Plan, the Companies
will execute amended wholesale power supply agreements with their current wholesale power
supply customers and will file them with the Commission under FPA section 205, to be effective
as of the effective date of the Internal Reorganization.
Similarly, during the pendency of this proceeding, the Companies will be working with their
current Joint OATT customers on a variety of FPA section 205 rate changes that will need to be
made to the Joint OATT to facilitate the Internal Reorganization, including adoption of a single
formula rate template, and the execution of any necessary updated service agreements. Those, too,
31
will be filed with the Commission under FPA section 205 after approval of the Internal
Reorganization.
4. Hold Harmless Commitment
In addition to the aforementioned mitigation measures that the Applicants are proposing to
protect customers from the short-term cost reallocations, Applicants are also willing to make the
traditional commitment to hold transmission and wholesale customers harmless from the
transaction and transition costs associated with the Internal Reorganization in excess of transaction
savings for a five-year period.34 For that five-year period, the Companies will not include merger-
related costs in their transmission revenue requirements or in their wholesale requirements rates,
except to the extent they can demonstrate in a separate FPA section 205 proceeding that merger-
related savings are equal to or in excess of the transaction-related costs included in the proposed
rates. The Commission has approved this type of commitment in its Merger Policy Statement 35
and in subsequent orders, 36 and the scope of this commitment covers the types of costs the
Commission has determined should be subject to hold harmless commitments.37
For all of these reasons, the Internal Reorganization will not have an adverse impact on
rates.
34 See Pol’y Statement on Hold Harmless Commitments, 155 FERC ¶ 61,189 (2016) (“Hold Harmless Policy
Statement”).
35 Merger Policy Statement, FERC Stats. & Regs. ¶ 31,044 at 30,124.
36 See, e.g., Exelon Generation Co., LLC, 176 FERC ¶ 61,121 at P 32 (2021); El Paso Elec. Co., 170 FERC ¶ 61,280
at P 55 (2020), order on reh’g, 172 FERC ¶ 61,082 (2020); NextEra Energy, Inc. , 173 FERC ¶ 61,029 at P 29
(2020) (“NextEra”); Tucson Elec. Power Co. , 169 FERC ¶ 61,204 at P 40 (2020); Dayton Power & Light Co. ,
160 FERC ¶ 61,034 at P 33 (2017); Great Plains Energy Inc., 121 FERC ¶ 61,069 at P 48 & n.63 (2007) (citing
cases), reh’g denied, 122 FERC ¶ 61,177 (2008); Ameren Corp., 108 FERC ¶ 61,094 at P 68 (2004), reh’g denied,
111 FERC ¶ 61,055 (2005).
37 Hold Harmless Policy Statement, 155 FERC ¶ 61,189 at PP 44-45.
32
B. The Internal Reorganization Will Not Have an Adverse Effect on Competition
The Commission’s objective in analyzing the effect of a transaction on competition is to
determine whether the transaction will result in higher prices or reduced output in electricity
markets.38 The Commission’s Merger Policy Statement and Order No. 642 established both
horizontal and vertical competitive analysis screens to allow the Commission to identify proposed
mergers that are unlikely to present competitive concerns.39 As demonstrated below, the Internal
Reorganization raises no concerns about adverse effects on competition.
1. The Internal Reorganization Raises No Horizontal Market Power
Concerns
The Internal Reorganization will not have an adverse impact on horizontal competition.
a. No Change in Control Over Generation
Section 33.3(a)(1) of the Commission’s regulations provides that a horizontal competitive
analysis is only required “if, as a result of the proposed transaction, a single corporate entity obtains
ownership or control over the generating facilities of previously unaffiliated merging entities.”40
The Commission has consistently recognized that intra-affiliate reorganizations typically do not
38 See, e.g., 18 C.F.R. § 2.26; Merger Policy Statement, FERC Stats. & Regs. ¶ 31,044 at 30,116-24; Order No. 642,
FERC Stats. & Regs. ¶ 31,111 at 31,879.
39 Order No. 642, FERC Stats. & Regs. ¶ 31,111 at 31,879, 31,903.
40 18 C.F.R. § 33.3(a)(1).
33
raise horizontal competitive concerns, 41 and applicants seeking authorization for such
reorganizations have not been required to submit a horizontal competitive analysis.42
Here, the Internal Reorganization involves an intra-corporate consolidation of two
affiliated utilities, both of which are wholly owned, direct or indirect, subsidiaries of Duke Energy.
As a result, the amount of generating capacity and/or transmission facilities owned or controlled
by Applicants and their affiliates will not change as a result of the Internal Reorganization. Under
the precedent described above, the proposed Internal Reorganization does not present the type of
horizontal competitive impacts with which the Commission’s FPA section 203 public interest
analysis is concerned.43
For example, in 2013, NV Energy, Inc., together with its public utility operating companies
Sierra Pacific Power Company (“Sierra”) and Nevada Power Company (“Nevada Power”), sought
Commission authorization for an internal reorganization pursuant to which Sierra would merge
into Nevada Power and, post-reorganization, the two separate BAAs operated (respectively) by
Sierra and Nevada Power would become a single BAA. In their application for FERC approval,
the applicants noted that no competitive screen analysis was required under the Commission’s
regulations. Nevertheless, the applicants submitted an “abbreviated” competitive analysis focused
on the effect of combining the BAAs. The Commission declined to make any findings with respect
41 See Ameren Corp ., 131 FERC ¶ 61,240 at P 18 (2010) (finding that an internal reorganization had no adverse
effects on competition); Cinergy Corp., 126 FERC ¶ 61,146 at P 32 (2009) (“Consistent with our precedent, we
find that the Proposed Transaction is an internal corporate reorganization that will have no adverse effect on
competition.”), citing Calpine Power Servs. Co ., 92 FERC ¶ 61,150 at 64,187-88 (2000); PP&L Res., Inc ., 90
FERC ¶ 61,203 at 61,649 (2000); Allegheny Energy Supply Co ., 89 FERC ¶ 62,063 at 64,105 (1999); see also
Order No. 642, FERC Stats. & Regs. ¶ 31,111 at 31,902.
42 See NextEra, 173 FERC ¶ 61,029; NV Energy, Inc ., 145 FERC 61,170 at P 26 (2013) (“NV Energy Order”);
Ameren Energy Generating Co., 106 FERC ¶ 63,011 at P 26 (citing Order No. 642, FERC Stats. & Regs. ¶ 31,111
at 31,902), aff’d in relevant part, Opinion No. 473, 108 FERC ¶ 61,081 at P 64 (2004).
43 Attachment 4, Affidavit of Ms. Julie R. Solomon at 1-2.
34
to the competitive analysis because it was not required to do so under the Commission’s
regulations.44 Instead, the Commission concluded that the “internal reorganization of two utilities
that are already affiliated will not result in any concentration in the generation markets and will
not change the existing competitive incentives.”45
Consistent with the NV Energy Order, the Commission should find that the proposed
Internal Reorganization is an intra-affiliate consolidation that does not raise horizontal competitive
concerns and does not require a horizontal competitive analysis. Nonetheless, the Applicants
include as Attachment 4 an affidavit from Julie R. Solomon of Secretariat LLC explaining the lack
of adverse horizontal impacts of the Internal Reorganization. Ms. Solomon also addresses
generally the pro-competitive impacts that will result from consolidating three BAAs into a single
BAA and the elimination of transmission seams between the three legacy BAAs.
b. Cessation of Stub Mitigation
In Section II.B above, the Companies explained that they are still complying with certain
vestigial commitments from the Duke/Progress Merger. In particular, in the order approving the
Duke/Progress Merger, the Commission ordered certain “Stub Mitigation” in the form of a limited
set-aside of certain transmission capacity on the internal interface from the DEC BAA to the CPLE
BAA, to be monitored by Potomac Economics, as well as requirements related to PARs and ATC
on that path. 46 This Stub Mitigation will necessarily sunset with the combination of the three
legacy BAAs. Specifically, once the interface between the DUK and CPLE BAAs ceases to exist,
there will no longer be a DUK to CPLE path upon which to reserve a set-aside or operate PARs to
44 NV Energy, 145 FERC ¶ 61,170, at P 26.
45 Id.
46 June 2012 Merger Order, 139 FERC ¶ 61,194.
35
increase flows across. Instead, all transmission customers will be able to take network service
throughout the combined BAA, and no Duke Energy affiliates will have a priority over any other
transmission customers.
For most of the summer periods since the Stub Mitigation went into effect, it has been
deemed by Potomac Economics to be “not necessary” because no Duke affiliates were making
short-term or long-term firm transmission reservations over the DUK-to-CPLE path. 47 That was
the case for short-term reservations for 2014, 2015, 2016, 2021, 2022, 2023, and 2024. Potomac
Economics explained that for 2017, 2018, and 2020, there were certain short-term firm
reservations by Duke affiliates, but they were renewals not covered by the Stub Mitigation
commitment. For 2019, there was a single short-term firm reservation on the path, but there was
“over 1000 MW of firm daily capacity” available, which was “more than adequate to meet the set
aside requirement.”48
With respect to long-term firm transmission, the results were similar. For 2014, 2015,
2016, 2017, 2018, and 2019, no Duke affiliates made long-term firm requests for transmission on
the path over the summer period. 49 For 2022, 2023, and 2024, “use of the set aside was not
necessary” because there were “no confirmed or refused request[s]” on the path over the summer.50
For 2020 and 2021, Duke affiliates made certain long-term firm requests on the path, but Potomac
47 See, e.g., 2024 Set-Aside Report at 4.
48 Seasonal Independent Monitoring Report on “Stub Mitigation” Transmission Set-Aside for Duke Energy Corp.
and Progress Energy, Inc., Docket No. EC11-60-004, at 5 (filed Sept. 26, 2019).
49 The 2015 report explains that the IMM agreed to an exception for a certain transaction for summer 2014 that
involved “redirection” of a reservation that would not use more ATC than an existing reservation. Duke Energy
Corp., Seasonal Independent Monitoring Report on “Stub Mitigation” Transmission Set-Aside for Duke Energy
Corp. and Progress Energy, Inc., Docket No. EC11-60-004, at 5-6 (filed Sept. 30, 2015).
50 See, e.g., 2024 Set-Aside Report at 4.
36
Economics confirmed that third-party requests exceeded the 129 MW, so the set-aside was
satisfied.51
Although certain language in the Commission’s order approving the Duke/Progress Merger
suggests that detailed market power analyses could be required to lift the Stub Mitigation, that is
not the form of relief the Companies are seeking here. The Commission’s language in that order
referred to a situation in which the Companies sought to eliminate the Stub Mitigation but
otherwise operate as explained at that time (i.e., separately with the maintenance of an internal
interface). The Internal Reorganization and its consolidation of BAAs simply renders the Stub
Mitigation unnecessary because there will be no intra-BAA boundaries.
2. The Internal Reorganization Raises No Vertical Market Power
Concerns
The Internal Reorganization does not present any vertical market power concerns. The
Commission’s regulations provide that a vertical market power analysis is only required “if, as a
result of the Reorganization, a single corporate entity has ownership or control over one or more
merging entities that provides inputs to electricity products and one or more merging entities that
provides electric generation products . . . .”52 Here, the Internal Reorganization will not result in
Applicants owning or controlling any new entities that provide inputs to electricity products or any
new entities that provide generation products.
Moreover, access to DEC’s and DEP’s respective transmission facilities will be governed
under the Carolinas 1U OATT. Transmission access will thus continue to be available under a
Commission-approved OATT, and the Internal Reorganization will not change the Commission’s
51 See, e.g ., Seasonal Independent Monitoring Report on “Stub Mitigation” Transmission Set-Aside for Duke
Energy Corp. and Progress Energy, Inc., Docket No. EC11-60-004, at 5 (filed Sept. 30, 2020).
52 18 C.F.R. § 33.4(a)(1).
37
authority to review the Carolinas 1U OATT upon consummation of the Internal Reorganization.
The Commission has found that this is sufficient to address vertical market power concerns
resulting from transmission ownership.53
C. The Internal Reorganization Will Have No Adverse Effect on Regulation
The Internal Reorganization will not have an adverse impact on regulation. As the Internal
Reorganization pertains to federal regulation, Carolinas 1U, the surviving entity, will continue to
be a “public utility” as defined in FPA section 201(e)54 and will remain subject to the
Commission’s jurisdiction.
The Internal Reorganization likewise will have no adverse effect on state regulation.
Concurrent with this application, Applicants are filing applications with the NCUC and PSCSC
for approval of the Internal Reorganization. As a result, the NCUC and PSCSC will have an
opportunity to review the Internal Reorganization to ensure it is consistent with North Carolina
and South Carolina law, respectively, and in the interest of North Carolina and South Carolina
retail customers. Further, upon consummation of the Internal Reorganization, Carolinas 1U’s
retail electric operations will continue to be subject to regulation by the NCUC and PSCSC.
Consistent with Commission precedent, the Internal Reorganization will thus have no adverse
effect on state regulation.55
53 See EDF Dev., Inc. , 126 FERC ¶ 61,141 at P 23 (2009); Okla. Gas & Elec. Co. , 124 FERC ¶ 61,239 at P 57
(2008).
54 16 U.S.C. § 824(e).
55 See, e.g., Madison Gas & Elec. Co. , 106 FERC ¶ 61,098 at P 20 (2004); Tex.-N.M. Power Co. , 105 FERC ¶
61,028 at P 22.
38
D. The Internal Reorganization Will Not Result in the Cross-Subsidization, Pledge,
or Encumbrance of Utility Assets
Under section 203(a)(4) of the FPA and Section 2.26(f) of the Commission’s regulations,56
the Commission considers whether a merger will result in a cross-subsidization of a non-utility
associate company by a utility company or in a pledge or encumbrance of utility assets for the
benefit of an associate company, and if so, whether the cross-subsidization, pledge, or
encumbrance will be consistent with the public interest. Here, the Internal Reorganization falls
within one of the Commission’s “safe harbors” identified in the Supplemental Merger Policy
Statement,57 such that detailed explanation and evidentiary support to demonstrate a lack of cross-
subsidization is not required. Specifically, the Commission applies a “safe harbor” to “transactions
that are subject to review by a state commission.”58 As the Commission has explained,
The Commission, in the context of specific mergers or other corporate transactions,
intends to defer to state commissions where the state adopts or has in place ring-
fencing measures to protect customers against inappropriate cross-subsidization or
the encumbrance of utility assets for the benefit of the “unregulated” affiliates.
Therefore, compliance with Exhibit M could be satisfied with a showing that the
Reorganization complies with specific state regulatory protections against
inappropriate cross-subsidization by captive customers.59
The Internal Reorganization thus qualifies for a safe harbor for meeting the FPA section
203 cross-subsidization demonstration. 60 Nonetheless, Applicants submit Exhibit M to further
address cross-subsidization issues.
56 16 U.S.C. § 824b(a)(4); 18 C.F.R. § 2.26(f).
57 Supplemental Merger Policy Statement, 120 FERC ¶ 61,060 at P 18.
58 Id. at P 18.
59 Id.
60 Id. at P 16.
39
VI. INFORMATION REQUIRED BY PART 33 OF THE COMMISSION’S
REGULATIONS
Pursuant to Section 33.2 of the Commission’s regulations,61 Applicants provide the
following information:
A. Exact Name of Applicants and Addresses of Principal Business Offices (18
C.F.R. § 33.2(a))
The exact legal names and addresses of the principal business offices of Applicants are:
Duke Energy Corporation
525 South Tryon Street
Charlotte, North Carolina 28202
Duke Energy Progress, LLC
410 South Wilmington Street
Raleigh, North Carolina 27602
Duke Energy Carolinas, LLC
525 South Tryon Street
Charlotte, North Carolina 28202
B. Names and Addresses of the Persons Authorized to Receive Notices and
Communications in Respect to Applicants (18 C.F.R. § 33.2(b))
The names and addresses of persons authorized to receive notice and communications with
respect to this application are:
Heather Horne
Associate General Counsel
Duke Energy Corporation
1301 Pennsylvania Ave. NW, Suite 200
Washington, DC 20004
(202) 824-8009
heather.horne@duke-energy.com
Christopher R. Jones
TROUTMAN PEPPER LOCKE LLP
401 9th Street, NW, Suite 1000
Washington, DC 20004
(202) 662-2181
chris.jones@troutman.com
61 18 C.F.R. § 33.2. The Commission has previously relaxed the full filing requirements of Part 33 of its regulations
and allowed the filing of only such information as required to satisfy the minimum statutory requirements of FPA
section 203. See, e.g., FirstEnergy Solutions Corp., 170 FERC ¶ 61,096 at P 81 n.111 (2020). This application
provides the Commission with the information necessary to determine that the Proposed Transaction is consistent
with the public interest and will not adversely affect competition, rates, or regulation or raise cross-subsidization
issues.
40
C. Description of the Applicants and the Other Parties to the Internal
Reorganization (18 C.F.R. § 33.2(c))
1. Business Activities of Applicants (Exhibit A) (18 C.F.R. § 33.2(c)(1))
The business activities of Applicants are described in Section II.A of this application.
Therefore, Applicants request a waiver of the requirement to file a separate Exhibit A.62
2. Energy Subsidiaries and Energy Affiliates and Their Business
Activities (Exhibit B) (18 C.F.R. § 33.2(c)(2))
The Applicants’ primary business is described in Section II.A. Applicants’ subsidiaries
and affiliates are not impacted by the Internal Reorganization, as it only applies to DEC and DEP.
Applicants therefore request waiver of the need to provide any additional information in a separate
Exhibit B under Section 33.2(c)(2).63
3. Organizational Charts (Exhibit C) (18 C.F.R. § 33.2(c)(3))
In Exhibit C, Applicants are providing pre- and post-Internal Reorganization corporate
organization charts.
4. Description of All Joint Ventures, Strategic Alliances, Tolling
Arrangements or Other Business Arrangements, Including Transfers
of Operational Control of Transmission Facilities to Commission
Approved Regional Transmission Organizations, Both Current, and
Planned to Occur within a Year from the Date of Filing, to Which the
Applicants or Their Parent Companies, Energy Subsidiaries, and
Energy Affiliates Are Parties, Unless the Applicants Demonstrate That
the Internal Reorganization Does Not Affect any of Their Business
Interests (Exhibit D) (18 C.F.R. § 33.2(c)(4))
Except as set forth in this application, the Internal Reorganization will have no effect on
any current or planned joint ventures, strategic alliances, or other business arrangements of
62 See, e.g., IIF US Holding LP, 173 FERC ¶ 61,232 at P 56 (2020).
63 Id.
41
Applicants or their parent companies, energy subsidiaries, and energy affiliates. Therefore,
Applicants request a waiver of the requirement to file a separate Exhibit D.64
5. Common Officers or Directors (Exhibit E) (18 C.F.R. § 33.2(c)(5))
The Internal Reorganization will not affect the officers and directors of the Companies’
parent company, Duke Energy. As such, Applicants request waiver of the need to provide a list
of common officers and directors. While DEC and DEP may share some common officers and
directors, that is not germane to the Commission’s FPA section 203 analysis.
6. Description of Customers (Exhibit F) (18 C.F.R. § 33.2(c)(6))
Exhibit F includes a list of Applicants’ wholesale power customers and unbundled
transmission services customers.
D. Description of Jurisdictional Facilities Owned, Operated, or Controlled by the
Applicants or Their Parent Companies, Subsidiaries, Affiliates, and Associate
Companies (Exhibit G) (18 C.F.R. § 33.2(d))
See Section II.A, above, for a description of the jurisdictional facilities affected by the
Internal Reorganization. Applicants therefore request waiver of the requirement to provide a
separate listing of jurisdictional facilities owned by Duke Energy affiliates in a separate Exhibit G.
E. Narrative Description of the Reorganization (Exhibit H) (18 C.F.R. § 33.2(e))
1. The Identities of All Parties Involved in the Internal Reorganization (18
C.F.R. § 33.2(e)(1))
A narrative description of the Internal Reorganization is included in Section IV of this
application, including identification of the parties involved in the Internal Reorganization.
64 See, e.g., PNM Res., Inc., 124 FERC ¶ 61,019 at PP 50-54 (2008).
42
2. All Jurisdictional Facilities and Securities Associated with or Affected
by the Internal Reorganization; consideration for the Internal
Reorganization; effect of the Internal Reorganization on jurisdictional
facilities and securities (18 C.F.R. § 33.2(e)(2) – (e)(4))
The jurisdictional facilities and securities associated with or affected by the Internal
Reorganization, the effect of the Internal Reorganization on such facilities and securities, and the
consideration for the Internal Reorganization are described in Section IV of this application and/or
Exhibit I. Accordingly, Applicants respectfully request waiver of the need to submit a separate
Exhibit H.
F. All Contracts Relating to the Internal Reorganization Together with Copies of
All Other Written Instruments Entered into or Proposed to Be Entered into by
the Parties to the Internal Reorganization (Exhibit I) (18 C.F.R. § 33.2(f))
The Internal Reorganization will be effectuated pursuant to the Merger Agreement, a
Contribution Agreement, and Articles of Merger. Forms of those documents, which will be
substantively the same as the final versions that will be executed to consummate the Internal
Reorganization, are attached as Exhibit I.65
G. A Statement Explaining the Facts Relied upon to Demonstrate That the Internal
Reorganization Is Consistent with the Public Interest (Exhibit J) (18 C.F.R. §
33.2(g))
The facts relied upon to demonstrate that the Internal Reorganization is consistent with the
public interest are described in Section V of this application. Accordingly, Applicants request a
waiver of the requirement to file a separate Exhibit J.
65 Pursuant to Order No. 642, the undersigned counsel for Applicants certify that, to the best of their knowledge, the
final agreements will reflect the terms and conditions contained in the forms of agreement attached as Exhibit I
in all material respects. See Order No. 642, FERC Stats. & Regs. ¶ 31,111 at 31,877.
43
H. Map (Exhibit K) (18 C.F.R. § 33.2(h))
Exhibit K includes a map showing the current service territories of DEP and DEC, currently
spanning three separate BAAs. Exhibit K also includes a map showing the combined service
territories of DEP and DEC in a single, post-Internal Reorganization, combined BAA.
I. Other Regulatory Approvals (Exhibit L) (18 C.F.R. § 33.2(i))
As discussed in Section V.C of this application, the Companies are seeking regulatory
approvals for the Internal Reorganization from the NCUC and the PSCSC. In addition to seeking
regulatory approval from the NCUC and PSCSC, the Companies will make a filing with the
Nuclear Regulatory Commission to transfer DEP’s nuclear licenses to DEC, as well as a separate
FERC filing to transfer DEP’s existing hydro licenses to DEC.
J. Cross-Subsidization (Exhibit M) (18 C.F.R. § 33.2(j)(1), (2))
The facts relied upon to demonstrate that the Internal Reorganization will not result in
cross-subsidization of a non-utility associate company or pledge or encumbrance of utility assets
for the benefit of an associate company are provided in Section V.D above and in Exhibit M.
K. Proposed Accounting Entries (18 C.F.R. § 33.5)
Applicants have provided proposed accounting entries in Attachment 5. Applicants will
provide final accounting entries within six months of closing if directed by the Commission, and
those accounting submissions will be company-specific and provide all the accounting entries and
amounts related to the Internal Reorganization along with narrative explanations describing the
basis for the entries.
44
L. Verification (18 C.F.R. § 33.7)
Pursuant to Section 33.7 of the Commission’s regulations, a signed verification by a person
having authority with respect thereto and having knowledge of the matters set forth in this
application is included as Attachment 6.
VII. OTHER MATERIALS
In addition to the information described above and included in Exhibits required by
Commission regulations, Applicants include as attachments the following:
Attachment 1 – Prepared Direct Testimony of Nelson Peeler
Attachment 2 – Prepared Direct Testimony of Jennifer S. Ellis
Attachment 3 – Prepared Direct Testimony of Blain Atkins
Attachment 4 – Affidavit and Supporting Materials of Ms. Julie R. Solomon
Attachment 5 – Accounting Entries
Attachment 6 – Verification
VIII. CONCLUSION
As demonstrated in this application, including the attached Exhibits and Attachments, the
Internal Reorganization is consistent with the public interest under the standards for public interest
findings set forth in the Commission’s Merger Policy Statement and Part 33 of the Commission’s
regulations. Accordingly, Applicants respectfully request that the Commission authorize the
Internal Reorganization under FPA section 203 as consistent with the public interest. Applicants
also respectfully request that the Commission grant waivers of the Commission’s regulations as
described herein or to the extent necessary to grant this application.
[Signatures Follow]
45
Respectfully submitted,
/s/ Heather Horne
Heather Horne
Associate General Counsel
Duke Energy Corporation
1301 Pennsylvania Ave. NW, Suite 200
Washington, DC 20004
(202) 824-8009
heather.horne@duke-energy.com
/s/ Christopher R. Jones
Christopher R. Jones
TROUTMAN PEPPER LOCKE LLP
401 9th Street NW, Suite 1000
Washington, DC 20004
(202) 274-2881
chris.jones@troutman.com
Counsel to Duke Energy Corporation, Duke Energy Progress, LLC, and Duke Energy
Carolinas, LLC
Exhibit C
Pre- and Post-Transaction Corporate Organization Charts
DEC/DEP COMBINATION: SIMPLIFIED SCHEMATIC ILLUSTRATING
TRANSACTION STEPS AND RESULTING CORPORATE STRUCTURE
Exhibit F
Description of Customers
Joint OATT Customers
DEC DEP
Brookfield Renewable Trading and Marketing LP
Carolina Power & Light
Carolina Power Partners, LLC
North Carolina Electric Membership Corporation
South Carolina Public Service Authority - P2P
City of Orangeburg, South Carolina
Blue Ridge Electric Membership Corporation
Central Electric Power Cooperative, Inc.
City of Concord, North Carolina
City of Kings Mountain, North Carolina
City of Seneca, South Carolina
South Carolina Electric & Gas Company
EnergyUnited Electric Membership Corporation
Greenwood Commissioners of Public Works
Haywood Electric Membership Corporation
Lockhart Power Company
Macquarie Energy LLC
North Carolina Municipal Power Agency Number 1
New River Light and Power Company
Piedmont Electric Membership Corporation
Piedmont Municipal Power Agency
Rutherford Electric Membership Corporation
Southern Power Company - Rowan Plant
Town of Dallas, North Carolina
Town of Due West, South Carolina
Town of Forest City, North Carolina
Town of Highlands, North Carolina
United States Department of Energy
Western Carolina University
North Carolina Electric Membership Corporation
City of Camden, South Carolina
French Broad Electric Membership Corporation
Haywood Electric Membership Corporation
North Carolina Eastern Municipal Power Agency
Piedmont Electric Membership Corporation
Public Works Commission of the City of
Fayetteville
Town of Black Creek, North Carolina
Town of Lucama, North Carolina
Town of Sharpsburg, North Carolina
Town of Stantonsburg, North Carolina
Town of Waynesville, North Carolina
Town of Winterville, North Carolina
Uwharrie Mountain Renewable Energy
Craven County Wood Energy
Wholesale Power Supply Customers
DEC DEP
Blue Ridge Electric Membership Corporation
Rutherford Electric Membership Corporation
Haywood Electric Membership Corporation Central
Electric Power Cooperative, Inc.
City of Orangeburg, South Carolina
Lockhart Power Company
Town of Dallas, North Carolina
Town of Due West, South Carolina
Town of Forest City, North Carolina
Town of Highlands, North Carolina
North Carolina Electric Membership Corporation
Piedmont Electric Membership Corporation
Haywood Electric Membership Corporation
Fayetteville Public Works Commission
French Broad Electric Membership Cooperative
North Carolina Eastern Municipal Power Agency
North Carolina Electric Membership Corporation
Piedmont Electric Membership Corporation
Exhibit I
Agreement and Plan of Merger, Contribution Agreement, and Articles of Merger
EXHIBIT FORM
AGREEMENT AND PLAN OF MERGER
THIS AGREEMENT AND PLAN OF MERGER (as amended, restated, supplemented or
modified from time to time, this “Agreement”), is entered into as of [January 1, 2027], by and among
Duke Energy Corporation, a Delaware corporation (“Parent”), Progress Energy, Inc., a North Carolina
corporation (“Progress”), Duke Energy Carolinas, LLC, a North Carolina limited liability company
(“DEC”), and Duke Energy Progress, LLC, a North Carolina limited liability company (“DEP”). Each of
Parent, Progress, DEC and DEP are referred to herein individually as a “Party”, and collectively, as the
“Parties”.
RECITALS
WHEREAS, Progress is a wholly-owned direct subsidiary of Parent;
WHEREAS, DEP is a wholly-owned indirect subsidiary of Parent, with Progress being the sole
member and holder of 100% of the issued and outstanding ownership interests in DEP;
WHEREAS, immediately prior to the execution of this Agreement, DEC was a wholly-owned
direct subsidiary of Parent and Parent was the sole member and holder of 100% of the issued and
outstanding ownership interests in DEC;
WHEREAS, [immediately prior to the execution of this Agreement], Parent and Progress have
entered into a Contribution Agreement, pursuant to which Parent has contributed all of its ownership
interests in DEC to Progress (the “Contribution”);
WHEREAS, after giving effect to the Contribution and at the time of execution of this
Agreement, (a) DEC is a (i) wholly-owned direct subsidiary of Progress and (ii) wholly-owned indirect
subsidiary of Parent, and (b) Progress is the sole member and holder of 100% of the issued and
outstanding ownership interests in DEC;
WHEREAS, prior to the Merger Effective Time (as defined below), the Board of Directors of
each of Parent, Progress, DEC and DEP, as applicable, (i) has declared it advisable and determined that it
is in the best interests of each such Party, as applicable, to pursue, and has authorized and approved, for
valid business purposes, a restructuring of certain of its direct and indirect subsidiaries, including
Progress, DEC and DEP, as applicable (the “Restructuring”), and the transactions contemplated
thereunder, and (ii) has adopted and approved the execution, delivery and performance by each such
Party, as applicable, of the Restructuring and the transactions contemplated thereunder, including this
Agreement, the Contribution Agreement and the consummation of the Merger (as defined below) and the
Contribution;
WHEREAS, prior to the Merger Effective Time, Parent, through DEC and DEP, has provided
applicable notice to or obtained applicable approval of the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, the
North Carolina Utilities Commission, and the Public Service Commission of South Carolina with respect
to the Restructuring and the transactions contemplated thereunder;
WHEREAS, as part of the Restructuring, the Parties hereto desire to enter into this Agreement
pursuant to which DEP will be merged with and into DEC, with DEC surviving such Merger; and
WHEREAS, it is intended that the Merger shall qualify as a “reorganization” within the meaning
of Section 368(a) of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986, as amended (the “Code”), and that this
-2-
Agreement is intended to be and is adopted as a plan of reorganization for the purposes of Sections 354
and 361 of the Code.
NOW, THEREFORE, in consideration of the foregoing and the mutual covenants and agreements
herein contained, the receipt and sufficiency of which hereby are acknowledged, and intending to be
legally bound, the Parties hereto hereby agree as follows:
AGREEMENT
1. Subject to the terms and conditions contained herein, at the Merger Effective Time, DEP
shall be merged with and into DEC (the “Merger”), in accordance with Section 57D-9 of the North
Carolina Limited Liability Company Act (the “Act”), and DEC shall be the surviving entity (hereinafter
sometimes referred to as the “Surviving Entity”) and shall continue to exist as the Surviving Entity under
its present name pursuant to the provisions of the Act. The separate existence of DEP (hereinafter
sometimes referred to as the “Merging Entity”) shall cease upon the effective time of the Merger in
accordance with the provisions of the Act. The Merger shall become effective at such time as the Articles
of Merger are duly filed with the Secretary of State of the State of North Carolina or at such later time as
is specified in the Articles of Merger (the time the Merger becomes effective being hereinafter referred to
as the “Merger Effective Time”).
2. The Articles of Organization of DEC as of the Merger Effective Time will continue to be
the Articles of Organization of the Surviving Entity and will continue in full force and effect until
changed, altered or amended as therein provided and in the manner prescribed by the provisions of the
Act.
3. The Operating Agreement of DEC as of the Merger Effective Time will continue to be
the Operating Agreement of the Surviving Entity and will continue in full force and effect until changed,
altered or amended as therein provided and in the manner prescribed by the provisions of the Act.
4. [The members, directors and/or officers of DEC on the Merger Effective Time shall be
the members, directors and/or officers of the Surviving Entity, respectively, all of whom will hold their
membership, positions and/or offices until the election and qualification of their respective successors or
until their tenure is otherwise terminated in accordance with the Operating Agreement of the Surviving
Entity.]
5. Each ownership interest of DEC as of the Merger Effective Time will continue as the
ownership interests of the Surviving Entity. The ownership interests of the Merging Entity as of the
Merger Effective Time shall, upon the Merger Effective Time, be cancelled and cease to exist and no
payment shall be made with respect thereto.
6. In the event that the Merger has been fully authorized in accordance with the provisions
of the Act, the Merging Entity and the Surviving Entity hereby stipulate that they will cause to be
executed and filed and/or recorded any document or documents prescribed by the laws of the State of
North Carolina, and that they will cause to be performed all necessary acts therein and elsewhere to
effectuate the Merger.
7. Each of Parent and Progress, as the direct or indirect sole member of the Surviving
Entity, shall be authorized to execute and file with the Secretary of State of the State of North Carolina
the Articles of Merger on behalf of the Surviving Entity in conformity with the provisions of the Act.
Each of Parent and Progress, as the direct or indirect sole member of the Surviving Entity and the
Merging Entity, respectively, shall be authorized, empowered, and directed to do any and all acts and
-3-
things, and to make, execute, deliver, file, and/or record any and all instruments, papers, and documents
which will be or become necessary, proper, or convenient to carry out or put into effect any of the
provisions of this Agreement or the Merger.
8. The Parties intend that the Merger shall qualify as a “reorganization” within the meaning
of Section 368(a) of the Code, and that this Agreement is intended to be and is adopted as a plan of
reorganization for the purposes of Sections 354 and 361 of the Code.
9. Notwithstanding the approval and adoption by the Parties of the Restructuring and the
transactions contemplated thereunder, this Agreement may be amended or terminated and the Merger and
the Contribution may be abandoned by Parent at any time prior to the Merger Effective Time.
10. If, at any time after the Restructuring, DEC, as the Surviving Entity, determines, in its
sole discretion, or is advised, that any documents (including any deeds, bills of sale or instruments of
conveyance), assignments, assurances or any other actions or things are necessary or desirable to vest,
perfect or confirm or record or otherwise vest in DEC its right, title and interest in, to or under any of the
rights, properties or assets of DEP acquired or to be acquired by DEC as a result of, or in connect with,
the Merger, then the officers and directors of DEC will be, and hereby are, authorized to execute and
deliver, in the name and on behalf of DEP, all such deeds, bills of sale, instruments of conveyance,
assignments and assurances, and to take and do, in the name and on behalf of, each of such companies or
otherwise, all such other actions and things as may be necessary or desirable to vest, perfect or confirm
any and all right, title or interest in, to and under such rights, properties or assets in DEC or otherwise to
carry out the terms, conditions or intent of the Restructuring and the transactions contemplated
thereunder, including this Agreement and the Contribution Agreement.
11. This Agreement shall be governed by, and construed and enforced in accordance with,
the laws of the State of North Carolina, without regard to the choice of law provisions thereof.
12. This Agreement, and any amendment, restatement, supplement or other modification
hereto or waiver hereunder, may be executed in counterparts, each of which will be deemed an original,
but all of which together will constitute one and the same instrument.
[Remainder of page intentionally left blank; Signature page follows.]
Signature Page to Agreement and Plan of Merger (Duke Energy – 1U Merger)
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the Parties hereto have caused this Agreement to be executed by their
respective officers or authorized signatories thereunto duly authorized, as of the date first set forth above.
PARENT:
Duke Energy Corporation
By: ________________________________
Name:
Title:
PROGRESS:
Progress Energy, Inc.
By: ________________________________
Name:
Title:
DEC:
Duke Energy Carolinas, LLC
By: ________________________________
Name:
Title:
DEP:
Duke Energy Progress, LLC
By: ________________________________
Name:
Title:
EXHIBIT FORM
CONTRIBUTION AGREEMENT
THIS CONTRIBUTION AGREEMENT (this “Agreement”) is made and entered into as of
[January 1, 2027], by and between Duke Energy Corporation, a Delaware corporation (“Duke”), and
Progress Energy, Inc., a North Carolina corporation (“Progress”).
RECITALS
WHEREAS, Progress is a wholly-owned direct subsidiary of Duke;
WHEREAS, Duke is the sole member of and owns 100% of the issued and outstanding
ownership interests (the “DEC Interests”) in Duke Energy Carolinas, LLC, a North Carolina limited
liability company (“DEC”);
WHEREAS, Progress is the sole member of and owns 100% of the issued and outstanding
ownership interests in Duke Energy Progress, LLC, a North Carolina limited liability company (“DEP”);
WHEREAS, prior to the Effective Time (as defined below), the Board of Directors of each of
Duke, Progress, DEC and DEP, as applicable, (i) has declared it advisable and determined that it is in the
best interests of each such party, as applicable, to pursue, and has authorized and approved, for valid
business purposes, a restructuring of certain of its direct and indirect subsidiaries, including Progress,
DEC and DEP, as applicable (the “Restructuring”), and the transactions contemplated thereunder, and (ii)
has adopted and approved the execution, delivery and performance by each such party, as applicable, of
the Restructuring and the transactions contemplated thereunder, including this Agreement, the Merger
Agreement (as defined below) and the consummation of the Contribution (as defined below) and the
Merger (as defined below);
WHEREAS, prior to the Effective Time, Duke, through DEC and DEP, its wholly-owned direct
or indirect subsidiaries, has provided applicable notice to or obtained applicable approval of the Federal
Energy Regulatory Commission, the North Carolina Utilities Commission, and the Public Service
Commission of South Carolina with respect to the Restructuring and the transactions contemplated
thereunder;
WHEREAS, as part of the Restructuring and pursuant to this Agreement, Duke desires to
contribute, assign, transfer and convey to Progress all of Duke’s rights, interests and obligations that may
be allocable in and to the DEC Interests (the “Contribution”), such that, as of the Effective Time, DEC
becomes a wholly-owned direct subsidiary of Progress;
WHEREAS, as part of the Restructuring and pursuant to this Agreement, Progress desires to
accept Duke’s Contribution and acquire and assume all of Duke’s rights, interests and obligations
allocable or attributable in and to the DEC Interests on the terms and conditions set forth herein; and
WHEREAS, Duke and Progress intend that the Contribution as provided herein shall constitute a
transaction subject to the provisions of Section 351 of the United States Internal Revenue Code of 1986,
as amended (the “Code”).
NOW, THEREFORE, in consideration of the foregoing and of the mutual promises and
covenants contained in this Agreement, and intending to be legally bound, the parties hereto hereby agree
as follows:
2
AGREEMENT
1. Effective as of the Effective Time, Duke hereby contributes, assigns, transfers and
conveys to Progress all of Duke’s rights, interests and obligations that may be allocable in and to the DEC
Interests, and Progress hereby accepts Duke’s Contribution and acquires and assumes all of Duke’s rights,
interests and obligations allocable or attributable in and to the DEC Interests.
2. The Contribution, deliveries and other transactions contemplated hereunder shall become
effective as of [January 1, 2027] at [●] Eastern Time (the “Effective Time”).
3. This Agreement shall be governed by, and construed and enforced in accordance with,
the laws of the State of North Carolina, without regard to the choice of law provisions thereof.
4. This Agreement may be executed in counterparts, each of which will be deemed an
original, but all of which together will constitute one and the same instrument.
5. This Agreement shall be binding upon, and shall inure to the benefit of, the parties’
respective heirs, representatives, successors and assigns.
6. Duke and Progress intend that the Contribution as provided herein shall constitute a
transaction subject to the provisions of Section 351 of the Code.
[Signature page follows.]
[Signature Page to 1U Contribution Agreement]
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties hereto have executed this Contribution Agreement as of
the date first set forth above.
Duke Energy Corporation
By: ________________________________
Name:
Title:
Progress Energy, Inc.
By: ________________________________
Name:
Title:
EXHIBIT FORM
State of North Carolina
Department of the Secretary of State
ARTICLES OF MERGER
Pursuant to North Carolina General Statute Sections 55-11-05(a), 55-11-12, 55A-11-09(d), 55A-11-04,
57D-9-42, 59-73.32(a) and 59-1072(a), as applicable, the undersigned entity does hereby submit the
following Articles of Merger as the surviving business entity in a merger between two or more business
entities.
1. The name of the surviving entity is Duke Energy Carolinas , LLC, a limited liability company
organized under the laws of North Carolina.
2. The physical and mailing address of the surviving entity is:
Physical Address:
525 South Tryon Street
Charlotte, North Carolina 28202
Mecklenburg County
Mailing Address:
525 South Tryon Street
Charlotte, North Carolina 28202
Mecklenburg County
3. The name of the merging entity is Duke Energy Progress , LLC, a limited liability company
organized under the laws of North Carolina.
4. The physical and mailing address of the merging entity is:
Physical Address:
411 Fayetteville Street
Raleigh, North Carolina 27601
Wake County
Mailing Address:
525 South Tryon Street
Charlotte, North Carolina 28202
Mecklenburg County
5. The mailing address of the surviving entity prior to the merger shall be the mailing address of the
surviving entity after giving effect to the merger.
6. No amendments to the surviving entity’s Articles of Organization are necessary as a result of the
merger, and as such, the surviving entity’s Articles of Organization, as currently filed with the
Secretary of State of the State of North Carolina, shall be the Articles of Organization of the surviving
entity, upon the effective time of these articles set forth below.
7. A Plan of Merger has been duly approved in the manner required by law by each of the business
entities participating in the merger.
8. These articles will be effective at [●] Eastern Time on [the date these articles are filed by the
Secretary of State] [OR] [January 1, 2027].
This the [1st] day of [January], [2027].
DUKE ENERGY CAROLINAS, LLC
By: ____________________________________
Name:
Title:
Exhibit K
Maps of Current and Post-Internal Reorganization Service Territories
Current Service Territories
DUK
CPLW
CPLE
Operated by DEC BA
Operated by DEP BA
Combined Service Territory Post-Internal Reorganization
DUK
Operated by DEC BA
Exhibit L
Other Regulatory Approvals
Applicants are also requesting authorization of the Internal Reorganization from the North
Carolina Utilities Commission and the Public Service Commission of South Carolina. In addition
to seeking regulatory approval from the NCUC and PSCSC, the Companies will make a filing with
the Nuclear Regulatory Commission to transfer DEP’s nuclear licenses to DEC, as well as a
separate FERC filing to transfer DEP’s existing hydro licenses to DEC.
Exhibit M
Cross-Subsidization
Under section 203(a)(4) of the FPA and Section 2.26(f) of the Commission’s regulations,1
the Commission considers whether a merger will result in a cross-subsidization of a non-utility
associate company by a utility company or in a pledge or encumbrance of utility assets for the
benefit of an associate company, and if so, whether the cross-subsidization, pledge, or
encumbrance will be consistent with the public interest. Here, the Internal Reorganization falls
within one of the Commission’s “safe harbors” identified in the Supplemental Merger Policy
Statement,2 such that detailed explanation and evidentiary support to demonstrate a lack of cross-
subsidization is not required. Specifically, the Commission applies a “safe harbor” to “transactions
that are subject to review by a state commission.”3 As the Commission has explained,
The Commission, in the context of specific mergers or other corporate transactions,
intends to defer to state commissions where the state adopts or has in place ring-
fencing measures to protect customers against inappropriate cross-subsidization or
the encumbrance of utility assets for the benefit of the “unregulated” affiliates.
Therefore, compliance with Exhibit M could be satisfied with a showing that the
Reorganization complies with specific state regulatory protections against
inappropriate cross-subsidization by captive customers.4
The Internal Reorganization will be subject to review and approval of the North Carolina
Utilities Commission and the Public Service Commission of South Carolina and thus qualifies for
1 18 C.F.R. § 2.26(f).
2 Supplemental Merger Policy Statement, 120 FERC ¶ 61,060.
3 Id. at P 18.
4 Id.
this safe harbor for meeting the FPA section 203 cross-subsidization demonstration.5 Nonetheless,
Applicants submit this Exhibit M to further address cross-subsidization issues.
Mergers of two regulated franchised public utilities regulated by this Commission and State
Commissions are not the type of transactions that give rise to cross-subsidy issues. In accordance
with Section 33.2(j)(1)(ii) of the Commission’s regulations, except as described in the body of the
application, Applicant verifies that the Internal Reorganizations will not result in: (1) any transfer
of facilities between a traditional public utility associate company that has captive customers or
that owns or provides transmission service over jurisdictional transmission facilities, and an
associate company; (2) any new issuance of securities by a traditional public utility associate
company that has captive customers or that owns, or provides transmission service over,
jurisdictional transmission facilities, for the benefit of an associate company; (3) any new pledge
or encumbrance of assets of a traditional public utility associate company that has captive
customers or that owns or provides transmission service over jurisdictional transmission facilities,
for the benefit of an associate company; or (4) any new affiliate contract between a non-utility
associate company and a traditional public utility associate company that has captive customers or
that owns or provides transmission service over jurisdictional transmission facilities, other than
non-power goods and services agreements subject to review under FPA sections 205 and 206.
To the extent that DEC and DEP are considered “associate companies” of each other for
Exhibit M purposes, the transfer of facilities and consummation of the Internal Reorganization is
consistent with the public interest for the reasons described in the body of the application. DEP
will merge its jurisdictional facilities with and into DEC but the result will be a single regulated
5 Id. at P 16.
utility subject to the same regulatory oversight for purposes of avoiding any undue cross-
subsidization.
Attachment 1
Prepared Direct Testimony of Nelson Peeler
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
BEFORE THE
FEDERAL ENERGY REGULATORY COMMISSION
Duke Energy Corporation )
Duke Energy Carolinas, LLC ) Docket No. EC25-___-000
Duke Energy Progress, LLC )
PREPARED DIRECT TESTIMONY OF
NELSON PEELER
ON BEHALF OF
DUKE ENERGY CORPORATION,
DUKE ENERGY CAROLINAS, LLC AND
DUKE ENERGY PROGRESS, LLC
August 14, 2025
Exhibit No. EC25-___-000
Page 1 of 18
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
BEFORE THE
FEDERAL ENERGY REGULATORY COMMISSION
Duke Energy Corporation )
Duke Energy Carolinas, LLC ) Docket No. EC25-___-000
Duke Energy Progress, LLC )
PREPARED DIRECT TESTIMONY OF
NELSON PEELER
ON BEHALF OF
DUKE ENERGY CORPORATION,
DUKE ENERGY CAROLINAS, LLC AND
DUKE ENERGY PROGRESS, LLC
I. INTRODUCTION AND PURPOSE 1
Q. Please state your name and business address. 2
A. My name is V . Nelson Peeler, Jr., and my business address is 525 S. Tryon Street, Charlotte, 3
North Carolina, 28202. 4
Q. By whom are you employed and in what capacity? 5
A. I am the Senior Vice President, Grid Strategy, Planning and Integration for Duke Energy 6
Corporation (“Duke Energy”). 7
Q. What are your responsibilities in this role? 8
A. In this role, I lead the organization responsible for long-term grid planning, including 9
transmission and renewables planning and integration, transmission planning and 10
operations strategy, grid solutions development, energy storage development, and strategic 11
projects. These responsibilities include the planning necessary to support the operational 12
integration of Duke Energy Carolinas, LLC (“DEC”) and Duke Energy Progress, LLC 13
(“DEP,” together, with DEC, the “Companies”). 14
Exhibit No. EC25-___-000
Page 2 of 18
Q. Please briefly summarize your educational background and professional experience. 1
A. I graduated from North Carolina State University with a Bachelor of Science degree in 2
Electrical Engineering and earned a Master of Business Administration degree from 3
Queens University. I am a registe
Text truncated. Open the original for the full document.
Source: City of Westminster website. First collected Oct 14, 2026.