Minutes(PDF, 347KB)
Richland County · Richland County · meeting of Apr 13, 2026 · Minutes
Open the original document More from Richland County
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
1
RICHLAND COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION 1
April 13, 2026 2
3
[Members Present: Christopher Yonke, Beverly Frierson, Terrence Taylor, Bryan Grady, 4
Sena Loyd, Chris Siercks, Charles Durant; Absent: Frederick Johnson, II (in at 6:13pm), 5
Mark Duffy (in at 6:45)] 6
7
Called to order: 6:04 pm 8
9
CHAIRMAN YONKE: I’d like to call to order the April 13 th, 2026 Richland County 10
Planning Commission meeting. Staff, please confirm the following: in accordance with the 11
Freedom of Information Act a copy of the Agenda was sent to the news media, persons 12
requesting notificatio n, and posted on the bulletin board locat ed in the county 13
administrative building. Is that correct? 14
MR. DELAGE: That is correct, Mr. Chair. 15
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Thanks, Staff. Can you go ahead and take attend ance for 16
today’s meeting? 17
MR. DELAGE: Grady? 18
MR. GRADY: Here. 19
MR. DELAGE: Siercks? 20
MR. SIERCKS: Here. 21
MR. DELAGE: Taylor? 22
MR. TAYLOR: Here. 23
MR. DELAGE: Durant? 24
MR. DURANT: Here. 25
MR. DELAGE: Loyd? 26
MS. LOYD: Present. 27
2
MR. DELAGE: Duffy? Johnson? Frierson? 1
MS. FRIERSON: Here. 2
MR. DELAGE: Yonke? 3
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Here. 4
MR. DELAGE: Alright, we have a quorum. 5
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Thank you, Staff. Ladies and gentlemen, welcome to t h e 6
April 13 th, 2026 Richland County Planning Comm ission meeting. As Planning 7
Commissioners we are concerned re sidents of Richland County who volunteer our time 8
to thoroughly review and make recommendations to County Council . Our 9
recommendations are to approve or deny Zoning Map Amendment requests. Per Title VI, 10
Chapter 29 of the SC Code of Laws Planning Commission may also prepare and revise 11
plans and programs for the development or redevelopment of unincorporated portions of 12
the County. The County’s Comprehensive Plan update over the last year or so is a good 13
example of this. Once again, we are a recommending body to Coun ty Council and they 14
will conduct their own public hearings and take official votes to approve or deny Map 15
Amendments and Text Amendments on a future date to be published by the County. 16
Council typically holds Zoning Pub lic hearings on the fourth Tu esday of the month. So 17
please check the County’s webs ite for updated agendas, dates an d times. Please take 18
note of the following guidelines for today’s meeting. Please tu rn off or silence any 19
cellphones. Audience members may quietly come and go as needed. A p p l i c a n t s a r e 20
allowed up to two minutes to ma ke comments/statements. Citizens signed up to speak 21
are also allowed two minutes each. Redundant comments should be minimized. Please 22
only address remarks to the Commission and do not expect the Co mmission to respond 23
3
to questions from the speaker in a back and forth style; that i s not the purpose of this 1
meeting. Please no audience/speaker exchanges. No audience demonstrations or other 2
disruptions to the meeting are permitted nor are comments from anyone other than the 3
speaker at the podium. Please remember the meeting is being rec orded. Please speak 4
into the microphone and give your name and address. Abusive language is inappropriate 5
and will not be tolerated. Please don’t voice displeasure or fr ustration at a 6
recommendation while the Planning Commission is still conductin g business. And if you 7
have any questions or concerns you may contact the Richland Cou nty Planning Staff 8
down here below. Staff, this takes us to number 3 on our Agenda, Additions or Deletions. 9
Are there any changes to the Agenda tonight? 10
MR. DELAGE: There are none, Mr. Chairman. 11
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Thank you, Staff. Number 4 on the Agenda is the Approval 12
of the Minutes. The Staff provided the Commission with Minutes from our February 19th, 13
2026 meeting. The Chair would like to make a motion to approve these Minutes as long 14
as I don’t hear any concerns from the Commission. Alright, Chai r makes a motion to 15
approve the Minutes from February 19, 2026. Do we have a second? 16
MR. DURANT: Second. 17
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Second from Commissioner Durant. Staff, can you please 18
take a vote? 19
MR. DELAGE: Grady? 20
MR. GRADY: Aye. 21
MR. DELAGE: Siercks? 22
MR. SIERCKS: Aye. 23
4
MR. DELAGE: Taylor? 1
MR. TAYLOR: Aye. 2
MR. DELAGE: Durant? 3
MR. DURANT: Aye. 4
MR. DELAGE: Loyd? 5
MS. LOYD: Aye. 6
MR. DELAGE: Duffy? Oh, sorry. Frierson? 7
MS. FRIERSON: Aye. 8
MR. DELAGE: Yonke? 9
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Aye. 10
MR. DELAGE: Alright, motion passes. 11
[Approved: Grady, Siercks, Ta ylor, Durant, Loyd, Frierson, Yonke; Absent: Johnson, 12
Duffy] 13
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Thanks again, Staff. Okay, look at the notes. I don’t have 14
any Road Names. Alright, the next part of the Agenda would be t he Consent Agenda. I 15
have a whole description about t hat one but we’re not gonna nee d to use the Consent 16
Agenda today, we’re gonna go ahead and look at every property t hat’s on the Agenda. 17
So that means we can move right along to 5.a., Map Amendments, Case No. 1, 25-046. 18
I’m gonna flip it to Staff for some information. 19
CASE NO. 25-046 MA: 20
MR. SMITH: Okay, so the case you have before you today, Case No. 25-046 MA, 21
the Applicant is Katherine Lloy d, the location is 9450 Wilson B oulevard and Wilson 22
Boulevard, 1.07 acres. The exist ing zoning for each parcel is R T and HM, that’s 23
5
Residential Transition and Home stead. The proposed zoning is Ru ral Crossroads. The 1
proposed zoning request is comp liant with the land use and char acter and intent of the 2
neighborhood low density designat ion. The Comprehensive Plan in dicates that 3
commercial development should be directed to designated neighborhood activity centers 4
and may be also considered along main road corridors and with contextually appropriate 5
distances from primary arterial i ntersections. Although the sub ject property is 6
appropriately situated near a prima ry arterial roadway, Killian Road, and along a main 7
road corridor, Wilson Boulevard, it is not located within a designated neighborhood activity 8
center. Notwithstanding the existing zoning classifications and established development 9
pattern within the subject proper ty’s sphere of influence indic ate that the area could 10
accommodate and support the requested zoning designation. However, the RC district is 11
intended to support the rural areas of the county. This district is designed to be located at 12
major intersections so as to prevent the spreading of commercia l uses along the major 13
road corridors or into surroundi ng countryside. The location o f the property map 14
amendment is not rural in character and abuts existing commercial zoning, therefore it is 15
not aligned with the intent of the RC zoning district. In addit ion, the requested Rural 16
Crossroads zoning would allow uses that are more intensive than those supported by the 17
objectives and guidelines for this designation, potentially introducing activities that are not 18
compatible with the existing dev elopment pattern. And just want ed to highlight to the 19
Commission as well, when we look at these cases we’re not looki ng, we need to be 20
looking at what, not what fits today but what we want this area to look like in the future; 21
just a side note. 22
6
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Thank you, Staff. Commission, do we have any qu estions 1
for Staff? Okay seeing no questions, Ms. Frierson? 2
MS. FRIERSON: We have first the Applicant, Katherine Lloyd. 3
CHAIRMAN YONKE: As we get start ed, both podiums are usually ope n with our 4
microphones. And remember to st ate your name and address and yo u’ll have two 5
minutes. 6
TESTIMONY OF KATHERINE LLOYD: 7
MS. LLOYD: [Inaudible] Okay, there we go. Also with me tonight is Greg Minton 8
with the Spinx Company who will be here as well to answer any q uestions you all may 9
have. My address is 463 Whispering Oak Circle in Chapin, South Carolina. Thank you for 10
your time and consideration this evening. We are proposing to r ezone approximately 11
1.072 acres to RC which will be par t of an overall 3.9 acre dev elopment. Our request is 12
about consistency and appropriate use. The remaining 2.8 acres already carries RC 13
zoning and we believe this application simply aligns with the remaining parcels to create 14
a cohesive, well-planned development. The Rural Crossroads zoni ng district is intended 15
to provide small scale commercial uses such as convenience stor es and gas stations at 16
key intersections to serve the surrounding community. This is exactly what we intend to 17
do without driving large amounts of new traffic as we consider, as we are considered a 18
pass by use and not a destination. The traffic study has been completed and we will abide 19
by all SCDOT requirements to ensur e customer safety if the rezo ning is approved. On 20
March 18th, we presented our project to the community at a town hall meet ing hosted by 21
Councilwoman Cooper. We provided an overview of our company, the benefits we bring 22
to the community and answered questions from the residents. We felt like the meeting 23
7
was positive and we appreciate the opportunity from Staff and Councilwoman Cooper to 1
do so. We believe this request aligns with the intent of concentrating commercial activity 2
at intersections supporting existing development patterns and it provides practical service 3
to a growing area while avoiding broader impacts to the surrounding community. We feel 4
that the rezoning request will not be detrimental to the surrou nding area and it still 5
supports the intent of the Comprehensive Plan established by Ri chland County. We are 6
very proud to serve the communities that we operate in and we appreciate those listening 7
in to our request tonight. Thank you all again and we are happy to answer any questions. 8
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Thank you very much. 9
MS. LLOYD: Yeah. 10
MS. FRIERSON: Next we have Greg Minton, followed by Hunter Whitfield. 11
TESTIMONY OF GREG MINTON: 12
MR. MINTON: Good evening. My name is Greg Minton, 309 Ellington Creek Lane 13
in Greer, South Carolina. I think Ms. Lloyd presented all the f acts behind our proposal 14
tonight. We appreciate the opport unity to present it to you. I’ m here to answer any 15
questions should they come up from the Planning Commission tonight. Again, I just want 16
to reiterate that we feel that this is still, won’t be detrimen tal to the surrounding area, will 17
enhance and provide services to the community, and it does fit into the intent of the 18
Comprehensive Plan that was set by Richland County. And we just appreciate your 19
consideration tonight in reviewing this rezoning application for us. Thank you. 20
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Thank you. 21
TESTIMONY OF HUNTER WHITFIELD: 22
8
MR. WHITFIELD: Good evening, Hunter Whitfield with Siemen Whiteside. We are 1
the civil engineer on the project and again I think all the facts have been stated but we’re 2
here to answer any technical questions, engineering-related questions that may come up. 3
And yeah, thank y’all for letting us be here tonight. 4
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Thank you. 5
MS. FRIERSON: And the last two people who have signed up, Keith Lomaz and 6
Tammy Fulmer. 7
MR. LOMAZ: We’re right here but we don’t have anything to add. 8
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Okay. Okay, thank you for coming out tonight. Commission, 9
this is now on the floor for discussion or any questions. My comment as Chair and I may 10
have overlooked this, is that it’ s compliant with the Comprehen sive Plan and the public 11
that came out to speak, they all did sign up, they signed up under the “for” column. So no 12
one said anything to change the mind, so if you have any other questions I wouldn’t mind 13
leaning towards the Comp Plan. Commissioner Loyd? 14
MS. LOYD: I just have a comment. My last name is Loyd. I have n o relation. I will 15
be voting on this item. Just as a disclosure. 16
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Thank you for clar ifying. Comments from those o n my left 17
over here? 18
MR. DURANT: Just a question, Mr. Chair. 19
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Yes, Commissioner Durant? 20
MR. DURANT: Staff, the properties to the immediate north and east of the property 21
at issue here, were those the subject of any recent map amendment requests? 22
9
MR. DELAGE: So Commissioner Duran t, they were recent as in the last couple 1
years but they are a fairly recent rezoning request to Rural Commercial that the Planning 2
Commission and ultimately Council voted to approve. 3
MR. DURANT: Thank you. 4
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Thank you, Commissioner Durant. Any other comments from 5
the Commission? As Chair I rarely like to make the motion but I ’ll do it. Commissioner 6
Loyd, go ahead. 7
MS. LOYD: If I can – I move to approve to – I – 8
CHAIRMAN YONKE: You make a motion for approval? 9
MS. LOYD: I make a motion for approval for RC Project 25-046 MA. 10
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Thank you, Commissioner Loyd. Do we have a second? 11
MR. DURANT: Second. 12
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Got a second from Commissioner Durant. Thank you. Staff, 13
with a motion and a second can you please take a vote? 14
MR. DELAGE: Alright, so motion for approval. Grady? 15
MR. GRADY: Aye. 16
MR. DELAGE: Siercks? 17
MR. SIERCKS: Aye. 18
MR. DELAGE: Taylor? 19
MR. TAYLOR: Aye. 20
MR. DELAGE: Durant? 21
MR. DURANT: Aye. 22
MR. DELAGE: Loyd? 23
10
MS. LOYD: Aye. 1
MR. DELAGE: Frierson? 2
MS. FRIERSON: Aye. 3
MR. DELAGE: Yonke? 4
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Aye. 5
MR. DELAGE: Motion passes. 6
[Approved: Grady, Siercks, Taylor, Durant, Loyd, Frierson, Yonke; Absent: Johnson, 7
Duffy] 8
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Thank you, C ommission. Thank you, Staff. Than ks for 9
coming out. This will get moved as a recommendation of approva l to County Council, 10
and when is their next meeting, Staff? 11
MR. DELAGE: It is April 28th at 7:00pm. 12
CHAIRMAN YONKE: In these chambers. 13
MR. DELAGE: That’s correct. 14
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Alright. Come back to hear more then. Thank yo u. We’ll 15
move on along to our next map amendment, Case, number 2., Case 26-005 MA. Move it 16
to Staff. 17
CASE NO. 26-005 MA: 18
MR. SMITH: The case before you, C ase No. 26-005 MA. I apologize to the 19
Applicant in advance I’m probably going to butcher this name, Asad Asalim, Incorporated. 20
The location is NX5010 and 5010 Ridgewood Avenue. It’s 0.33 acr es. Current zoning is 21
Residential Zone 4 and requested zoning is General Commercial. The Comprehensive 22
Plan compliance is non-compliant. The proposed rezoning is not compliant with the 23
11
objectives of the mixed residential high density designation in the Comprehensive Plan. 1
While there are existing commercial parcels and uses in the immediate area those parcels 2
have frontage along Monticello Road. To the extent possible com mercial and office 3
development should be located in activity centers and mixed use corridors. The proposed 4
rezoning is not located in an activity center or in a mixed use corridor. Additionally the 5
proposed rezoning could be viewed as an encroachment into the established residential 6
are and thus is not consistent wit h the intentions of the Compr ehensive Plan objectives 7
for commercial in the urban area. 8
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Thank you, Staff. Commission, any questions for Staff? 9
MR. DURANT: Yes, Mr. Chair, question for Staff. 10
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Alright Commissioner Durant, go ahead. 11
MR. DURANT: Staff, do you know what the zoning is in the City of Columbia part 12
that surrounds the property, parcel at issue? 13
MR. DELAGE: So the parcels to the south are zoned one of the residential zoning 14
districts within the city. 15
MR. DURANT: Thank you. 16
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Thank you, Commissioner Durant. Thank you, Sta ff. Any 17
questions? Alright seeing none, Commissioner Frierson? 18
MS. FRIERSON: We have Omar Shaheed. 19
TESTIMONY OF OMAR SHAHEED: 20
MR. SHAHEED: Good evening. My nam e is Omar Shaheed. I’m at 511 9 21
Monticello Road, Columbia, South Carolina. We purchased this piece of property, which 22
is about .33 acres. It was heavil y blighted and that area where we are is right next to 23
12
property that we own. Heavily blighted, snakes, people throwing garbage in the area. We 1
purchased it and we wanted to use it for anything, well not for any businesses or anything 2
but possibly for, if we need it f or parking or something of tha t nature. We’re not trying to 3
make a concrete, we just wanna make it so that it won’t grow up and it has some, I can’t 4
think of what they call it, reeves or reeds or something like t hat just grows up and it just 5
grows up very heavily. Snakes have been seen in the area. And we wanted to clean it 6
off and make it so if we use it for anything it would just be additional parking, but we don’t 7
plan to put a business there or anything of that nature. And we purchased it, if we leave 8
it like it is it’s just gonna k eep growing up and people just g onna keep dumping trash in 9
the neighborhood. And we have been in that neighborhood for, ever since 1980, and we 10
have been very much received. We talked to our Councilman Livin gston about this and 11
he’s familiar with the location and us. And we’ve done nothing in that area but tried to 12
improve. It’s a heavily blighted area and it was heavily blight ed before we got there in 13
1980. I think it was called a club and someone had been killed I think, two people had 14
been killed and they closed the club down. So we went in there as a religious institution 15
and we have been in that area ever since. So we purchased that strictly, if we use it for 16
anything it’ll just be for parking. 17
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Thank you, sir. Thank you for coming out. Anyo ne else 18
signed up? 19
MS. FRIERSON: No one else is signed up. 20
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Alright. Commission, any questions for Staff on this now? I 21
have one about the City of Columbia zoning straight east of the property. That wouldn’t 22
be residential, correct? That shows as a store. 23
13
MR. DELAGE: So according to the Assessor’s data is the RSF3, but we can always 1
pull up the City’s GIS and verify. 2
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Any other thought s from the Commission as we wa it for 3
Staff? Quiet tonight. Ridgeway a ddress looks like. According to the Google map or the 4
Richland map it looks like there’s a store operating there, right sir? 5
MR. SHAHEED: Yes. 6
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Yeah, okay. 7
MR. SMITH: Just for the Commission’s information, the reason for the rezoning is 8
because the parcel is under the amount of acreage that you woul d be able to request 9
anything but because he is adjacent to General Commercial that’ s the reason why 10
General Commercial was his only option. 11
CHAIRMAN YONKE: As to what other type of zoning? 12
MR. SMITH: As to any other zonings that would allow the use that he was looking 13
for. 14
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Thank you. 15
MR. DELAGE: So it looks like, Mr. Chair, what they had on the A ssessor’s Office 16
as RSF3 is what is also listed on the City of Columbia’s GIS as well. 17
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Is that a non-conforming use? 18
MR. DELAGE: I would leave the designation to the jurisdiction that has authority, 19
however, from my experience yes, if it’s a use that is not perm itted in the base zoning 20
district it would be a non-conforming. 21
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Thank you, Staff. Up for discussion for the Commission. 22
MR. DURANT: Mr. Chair, just a question. 23
14
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Yes, Commissioner Durant. 1
MR. DURANT: The Applicant indicated that they’re applying for t his rezoning in 2
order to be able to clean up the property. Can’t that be done regardless of what zoning it 3
is? 4
MR. DELAGE: Commissioner Durant, yes they could technically cle an up the 5
property that would not require a rezoning. I believe that the, as the Applicant said though 6
that the reason why they’re needi ng or they’re trying to potent ially in the future do some 7
additional parking. As it is residentially zoned now and not the same site as the place of 8
worship it would need a differe nt zoning designation than it cu rrently has for them to be 9
able to utilize it for parking. 10
MR. DURANT: Understand. 11
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Thank you, Commissioner Durant. What are the thoughts on 12
this one, or motions? As I’ve said before in other meetings mot ions only go one of two 13
ways. So we could throw some thoughts on that, although County Council is happier to 14
hear our thoughts behind the moti ons that we’re making, especia lly if anyone’s gonna 15
dissent. Commissioner Grady, thank you. 16
MR. GRADY: Yes, Mr. Chair. I have a motion. I would like to mov e that this item, 17
which is Case 26-005 MA, be forwarded to County Council with a recommendation of 18
approval. The reason being that the General Commercial use is i n line with the adjacent 19
property as well as the general character of the roadway corridor. 20
[Johnson in at 6:30pm] 21
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Thank you, Commissioner Grady. Do we have a second? 22
MR. DURANT: Second. 23
15
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Okay, we have a second from Commissioner Durant. With a 1
motion on the floor with a second, Staff can you please take a vote? 2
MR. DELAGE: Alright, motion is for approval. Grady? 3
MR. GRADY: Aye. 4
MR. DELAGE: Siercks? 5
MR. SIERCKS: No. 6
MR. DELAGE: Taylor? 7
MR. TAYLOR: Aye. 8
MR. DELAGE: Durant? 9
MR. DURANT: Aye. 10
MR. DELAGE: Loyd? 11
MS. LOYD: I’m going to say aye to this but I’m gonna give a lit tle bit of an 12
explanation as well. I think that it is disappointing that it i s so limiting that this is the only 13
option when there are probably better options for that neighbor hood, just because 14
General Commercial is what is adjacent to allow the rezoning. 15
MR. DELAGE: Johnson? 16
MR. JOHNSON: Abstain. 17
MR. DELAGE: Frierson? 18
MS. FRIERSON: Aye. 19
MR. DELAGE: Yonke? 20
CHAIRMAN YONKE: I agree with Loyd, aye. 21
MR. DELAGE: Alright, motion passes. 22
16
[Approved: Grady, Taylor, Durant, Loyd, Frierson, Yonke; Opposed: Siercks; Abstained: 1
Johnson; Absent: Duffy] 2
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Commissioner Sie rcks, I hate to put you on th e spot but 3
County Council gets value for those who disagree. 4
MR. SIERCKS: I think while I certainly can see the rationale for voting for approval, 5
I think what stuck with me and what sticks with me in a lot of these types of cases where 6
there doesn’t appear to be, you know, great options and the applicant is kinda stuck with 7
applying under, in this case a General Commercial because there’s no other zonings that 8
fit the needs, it’s worth remembering that this isn’t a rezonin g request for this specific 9
intended use but all intended uses, and how we should look at t hese cases in a long-10
term, not what is intended in the near term but what could also be placed there under the 11
proposed zoning amendment. 12
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Thank you, Commissioner Siercks. And I was kind of on the 13
fence for some of those reasons, too. So that goes as a recomme ndation of approval. It 14
will go to County Council at their next meeting which I should’ve wrote down, tell me again 15
Staff when is it? 16
MR. DELAGE: Yes, sir, Mr. Chair, it’s April 28th, 7:00pm in Council chambers. 17
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Right here. W e’ll go ahead and move on to our n ext case, 18
Case 26-006, flip it right back to Staff. And we welcome Commissioner Johnson 19
CASE NO. 26-006 MA: 20
MR. SMITH: The case you have before you, 26-006MA, the Applican t is Jeremy 21
Haladay. The location is 2101 Kennerly Road and it’s 3.138 acres. The existing zoning is 22
Homestead, HM. The proposed rezoning is RC which is the Rural C rossroads district. 23
17
The Comprehensive Plan compliance is non-compliant. The propose d rezoning is not 1
compliant with the objectives of the neighborhood medium densit y designation in the 2
Comprehensive Plan. Per the Plan nonresidential development within the neighborhood 3
medium density designation may be considered for location along main road corridors 4
and within contextually appropriate distance from an intersection of a primary arterial. The 5
proposed request is not located along a neighborhood corridor w ithin an appropriate 6
distance from an intersection of a primary arterial. Additional ly, the Plan states that the 7
commercial uses should be locat ed within neighborhood activity centers and that 8
commercial land uses should not result in strip commercial deve lopment or fragmented 9
leapfrog development patterns along corridors. The proposed request does not fall within 10
a neighborhood center. A rezoning such as this could be viewed as a leapfrog 11
development. 12
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Thank you, Staff. Commissioners, any questions for Staff? 13
MR. TAYLOR: Question. 14
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Yes, Commissioner Taylor? 15
MR. TAYLOR: Could you repeat the acreage, please? 16
MR. SMITH: The acreage is – sure, the acreage is 3.38 acres. 17
MR. TAYLOR: Okay, I thought you said 1.138. 18
MR. SMITH: I may have. 19
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Any other questions? Alright seeing, hearing no ne, 20
Commissioner Frierson? 21
MS. FRIERSON: We have Phillip Bradley and then Jesse Groat. 22
TESTIMONY OF PHILLIP BRADLEY: 23
18
MR. BRADLEY: Good evening Chairman and Members of the Commissio n. My 1
name is Phillip Bradley. I reside at 518 Lockshire Road, Columb ia 29212. I serve as the 2
lead pastor for Decided church and I’m here regarding the request to rezone the Decided 3
Church property from HM to Rural Commercial. I want to begin by saying we are not 4
coming here with a desire to disrupt the community. I’ve been a part of the community 5
since 1989 so I have a vested interest in this, in the communit y. But we’re here to ask 6
that it be rezoned in such a way that aligns with both the Coun ty’s vision and the 7
surrounding area. This property has functioned as a place of ga thering, ministry and 8
community engagement. What we are requesting does not introduce something entirely 9
foreign to the area but allows for continued and appropriate use of property in a way that 10
is consistent with similar uses already present in this part of the county. From my 11
understanding the commercial rura l designation is specifically intended to allow for low 12
intensity, community-oriented uses that serve the surrounding a rea without introducing 13
the kind of density or impact a ssociated with more intensive co mmercial zoning. This 14
request does not increase resid ential density, it does not intr oduce heavy commercial 15
traffic, and it does not change the fundamental character of th e area. Instead it provides 16
flexibility for the property to be used in ways that serve the community, whether that be 17
continued ministry use or other l ow impact appropriate uses that align with the County’s 18
long-term planning goals. We al so recognize that zoning decisio ns are not just about a 19
single property but about the b roader health of the community. Our intent it to work with 20
that goal. This rezoning would he lp ensure that the property re mains viable, usable and 21
beneficial rather than restricting it in a way that could limit contributing to the area in the 22
19
future. We are grateful for your time and consideration and we respectfully ask for your 1
approval of this request. Thank you. 2
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Thank you so much for coming out. 3
TESTIMONY OF JESSE GROAT: 4
MR. GROAT: Good evening. My name’s Jesse Groat. I reside at 695 Bluff Point, 5
Columbia, South Carolina 29212. I’m the real estate agent that has the property listed for 6
sale. So over the last several months as we’ve been trying to sell it we’ve had many small 7
businesses, also nonprofits, approach us about this facility. Just so y’all know it’s a 5,000 8
square foot metal structure with parking on the front and back of the property, so the 9
building appears to be what looks like a commercial building, there’s office space in it and 10
everything. So we just hope that the council would consider the rezoning of this property 11
just due to all the potential buyers and clients that keep approaching us for this property. 12
So thank you. 13
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Thank you. 14
MS. FRIERSON: Next we have D ean S., I’m sorry I cannot make out your last 15
name, of 518 Cockspur Road, and then Kim Murphy. 16
TESTIMONY OF DEAN SMEDLEY: 17
MR. SMEDLEY: Good evening, my name is Dean Smedley. I reside at 518 18
Cockspur Road, Irmo, South Carolina 29063. And I don’t have much more to add to what 19
was already shared. I think you’ ve heard our heart of what we d esire to do. We desire, 20
actually I’m a part of the church, I work that at Decided, and we really just wanna make 21
sure that this property is used for the good of the community. That’s really what we wanna 22
do. I think you’ve heard the heart, our heart in that, our desire for that. And by making this 23
20
change it’ll allow us to open up to other opportunities for people that really desire to use 1
it for the same purposes, so thank you again for your time. 2
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Thank you. 3
MS. FRIERSON: After Kim Murphy, Clark Thomas. 4
TESTIMONY OF KIM MURPHY: 5
MS. MURPHY: Hi, Kim Murphy here. I’m kinda switching around ju st a little bit. 6
There were three items listed on the Agenda, number 6. Land Dev elopment Code 7
Updates listed as action. 8
CHAIRMAN YONKE: And what’s your address? 9
MS. MURPHY: Okay, 154 Old Laurel Lane. 10
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Thank you. 11
MS. MURPHY: Chapin. Number 7. Comprehensive Plan action and number 10.b., 12
Development Review Team Report. There were no sign up sheets to speak but I’m 13
wondering if you’re gonna allow the public to speak like you di d with the Land 14
Development Code. 15
CHAIRMAN YONKE: We don’t do the back and forth style, but – 16
MS. MURPHY: Pardon me? 17
CHAIRMAN YONKE: The purpose of this meeting isn’t to have a ba ck and forth, 18
Ms. Murphy. So you have the two minutes uninterrupted and then we’ll discuss that as 19
we get to it. 20
MS. MURPHY: Okay, thank you very much. 21
CHIARMAN YONKE: Of course. 22
MS. MURPHY: Thank you. 23
21
CHAIRMAN YONKE: I know you walked through all the Land Developm ent Code 1
stuff with us for many years so I appreciate that. 2
MR. MURPHY: Yes, and I appreciate your work, too. I guess this area is the 3
boundary between rural and suburban and rural, pretty rural. It ’s a good distance from 4
areas that are developed as commercial and if you turn on your zoning layers and zoom 5
out you can see where commercial is. If you were rezoning this to commercial you know 6
anything that’s listed as commerc ial can be constructed there. I don’t wanna say that 7
faithful people are not, are going to do what they say they’re gonna do or they’re not, but 8
it’s the general commercial that is the issue. It would be considered leapfrogging and I’m 9
hopeful that you will deny it because it is such a good distanc e away. HM does allow for 10
commercial development. So they c ould do some commercial. And I ’m not sure if that 11
limits them but it’s the GC that is the issue. Thank you. 12
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Thank you, Ms. Murphy. I was gonna ask if you could put the 13
zoning layer on. 14
MR. DELAGE: Can I be recognized? 15
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Huh? 16
MR. DELAGE: Real quick? 17
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Yes, Staff go ahead. 18
MR. DELAGE: The Applicant is applying for Rural Crossroads, so I just wanna 19
make sure everybody’s clear what you’re voting on, Rural Crossroads. 20
CHAIRMAN YONKE: HM to RC, yes. Thank you. I was curious to see maybe split 21
screen zoning on, and then also street view. Thanks, Staff, and we have one more person 22
signed up to speak. 23
22
[Duffy in at 6:45pm] 1
MS. FRIERSON: Clark Thomas. 2
TESTIMONY OF CLARK THOMAS: 3
MR. THOMAS: Hi, my name’s Clar k Thomas. I’m at 2165 Kennerly R oad. 4
Appreciate the opportunity to speak. I’m here today to respectf ully oppose the proposed 5
rezoning from Homestead to Rural Commercial. I’m the adjacent l andowner where my 6
family has lived for over 65 years. This 3.4 acres under consid eration for rezoning was 7
owned by my family before being sold to the Richland Lodge in 1 998. They sold the 8
property to a church in 2013. The property is up for sale again which I assume is the 9
reason for the rezoning so they can allow for more potential bu yers. Richland County 10
denied the rezoning request in 2013. I’ve got the information o n that if you need it. 11
Homestead zoning exists to protect low density residential living, preserve rural character 12
and allow families to enjoy qui et open space without the impact s of commercial activity. 13
Changing this designation is not a small adjustment, it’s a fun damental shift in how the 14
land can be used. The property is directly across the street fr om an elementary school 15
and the zoning change would allow for multiple types of retail business including liquor 16
stores. This change would increase change and delivery vehicles which raises concern 17
about safety, congestion and the overall quality for the curren t, of life for the current 18
residents. There’s also the issue of precedent. If this rezonin g is approved it opens the 19
door for similar requests nearby. Over time that leads to gradu al commercial 20
encroachment into what is supposed to remain a rural residential area. Property owners 21
in homestead areas have made the investments with the expectation that the surrounding 22
land would remain consistent wit h that zoning. Introducing comm ercial uses can 23
23
negatively affect property values and undermine that expectatio n. Finally, Richland 1
County has already, already has designated areas that are bette r suited for commercial 2
development; places with the infr astructure, traffic capacity a nd planning framework to 3
support it. Moving commercial zoning into homestead areas is no t necessary and is not 4
consistent for long-term planning. For these reasons I respectfully ask that you deny the 5
rezoning request. Thank you for your time. 6
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Thank you for your time, for coming out. 7
MS. FRIERSON: Mr. Thomas was the last person who signed up to speak. 8
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Thanks, Ms. Frierson. Okay Commission, this is on the floor 9
for discussion. Not everybody at once now. Questions as well. G reetings Commissioner 10
Duffy. 11
MR. DUFFY: Greetings. 12
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Thank you. Mixing things up. 13
MR. JOHNSON: Mr. Chairman. 14
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Yes, Commissioner Johnson. 15
MR. JOHNSON: I don’t have a lotta discussion topics on this, I mean, I’m, in my 16
mind I have a conclusion [inaudible] recommendation [inaudible – mic cutting out] 17
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Do you wanna elaborate some of your thoughts before it’s a 18
conclusion? 19
MR. JOHNSON: I think that, looking at the zoning map that notwi thstanding the 20
language that Staff has used there’s only in the [inaudible] challenge for me to support. 21
24
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Thank you, Commissioner Johnson. I see it as well, you have 1
to zoom the map out even more and I still don’t see any commercial in the area. Staff, are 2
you seeing any commercial that we’re missing? 3
MR. DELAGE: No, sir, Mr. Chair, there’s just a PDD just at this scale, we just 4
wanted to double check. 5
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Okay, thank you. Okay, any thoughts, questions, 6
comments? Commissioner Taylor. 7
MR. TAYLOR: So again just for cla rification because you’re saying you don’t see 8
any commercial, it is Rural Crossroads that we’re looking at, c orrect, which would be 9
considered a commercial designation, is that accurate or no? 10
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Staff, would you like to explain? 11
MR. DELAGE: That is correct, yes. 12
MR. DUFFY: Mr. Chair? 13
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Yes, Commissioner Duffy. 14
MR. DUFFY: Question for Staff. If this rezoning was to go throu gh would it not 15
significantly increase the burden on traffic in the area, cause now it’s a church but if it was 16
to be a liquor store, a gas store? I’m familiar with the locati on and know where it is at a 17
major kind of intersection of different roads so would not, you know, there not be some 18
safety concerns if it was a, you know, an active commercial space that was used for liquor 19
store, garage, whatever it may be, and does it not set a bad pr ecedent if there’s no RC 20
around? 21
MR. DELAGE: So I think I can address portions of the question. Not having an 22
exact end use it’d be difficult to say that, you know, particularly there would be a change 23
25
in traffic. Obviously places of worship, depending on how they function, there’s a number 1
that you can assign to them based off the trip generation manua l and so you could 2
potentially identify a use that would have more traffic than what’s existing. However, there 3
is, from what we could see from t he street view, a curb cut, yo u know, if there is a 4
significant change of use or any proposal where they would need more entrances SCDOT 5
is the road maintenance authority so they would need to get an encroachment permit 6
from them and at that point they w ould look at the driveway sep arations and any other 7
requirements. But they would be the authority that would basically be issuing any safety 8
improvements. 9
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Thank you, Staff. Commissioner Duffy, does that answer? 10
MR. DUFFY: Yes, I think so. And just to reaffirm that there’s n o other immediate 11
examples of RC on any sites around it, is that correct? 12
MR. DELAGE: That is correct. 13
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Commissioner Johnson had something? 14
MR. JOHNSON: Yes, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. In the interest of fairness I 15
know we have another Agenda item further down [inaudible] but I wanna raise the same 16
question I raised last month is, we’re making this decision bas ed on the existing 17
Comprehensive Plan, correct? 18
MR. SMITH: Yes, that is correct. 19
MR. JOHNSON: And assuming that the new plan is to be adopted, is successfully 20
adopted, does that change Staff’s recommendation [inaudible]? 21
MR. SMITH: Without having an adopted plan it’s had to say. On a draft front of me 22
looking at it today the proposed rezoning would be compliant in the new code or in the 23
26
new map. And one more thing to point out on this is Kennerly Road is the dividing line on 1
the future land use map that separates the rural designation fr om the medium density 2
designation. In the new mapping I believe this area changes fro m that designation to 3
something else, so yes that area does change in a way. But agai n, this designation of 4
Rural Crossroads is a district t hat provides rural lands with c ommercial uses. So just 5
taking into context what the description of the zoning district is, that’s something you may 6
wanna take into consideration. 7
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Commissioner Johnson, does that? 8
MR. JOHNSON: He addressed my question. And again I said in fair ness I raised 9
the same issue before and [inaudible]. But we’re [inaudible] co nsidering this under the 10
current Comprehensive Plan in terms of what we have before us. 11
CHAIRMAN YONKE: You could look at it for the general character of the area and 12
changes in the neighborhood as time’s going on, right? As we we re doing the research 13
for the new Comprehensive Plan, l et’s look at the maps again, h ow, what’s changing in 14
this area? Is it still light residential and rural? 15
MR. SMITH: The extension of the residential element will be ext ended further to 16
the riverfront. So where the Ken nerly Road divider currently is now that side of the road 17
in the current plan is rural where in the new plan that will become a suburban residential. 18
MR. JOHNSON: [Inaudible] suburban residential? 19
MR. SMITH: That is correct. 20
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Does anyone on t he Commission have comments, 21
discussion? Commissioner Grady’s doing some research. 22
27
MR. GRADY: I am, Mr. Chair. I was just following up on the ques tion of how the 1
draft Comprehensive Plan, if appr oved, would alter this. There appears to be a purple 2
speck, light purple speck on the site of the property in question so I was hoping Staff could 3
clarify what that designation is? 4
MR. SMITH: Without the current map or my GIS in front of me it would be hard for 5
me to answer that question at this time. 6
CHAIRMAN YONKE: And for the public to get better understanding of the picture 7
we’re trying to paint, cause we are tied to a 2015 Comprehensiv e Plan, although the 8
County’s been doing some great work over the past year for the 2025 Comprehensive 9
Plan, and now we are in 2026. So it is relevant to look at what this, how this new plan is 10
shaping up. Commissioner Johnson. 11
MR. JOHNSON: Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Staff, if I could get you just to repeat 12
what the new Comprehensive Plan [inaudible] as currently drafted, or as the current draft, 13
what is that zoning [inaudible]? 14
MR. SMITH: The, in the draft fo rm of the new Comprehensive Plan the land use 15
recommendation for that area would be suburban residential. 16
CHAIRMAN YONKE: [Inaudible] Commissioner Johnson? 17
MR. JOHNSON: Well I was waiting to see if my colleague Commissi oner Grady 18
had a position, but I mean, otherwise I would enter my [inaudible]. In the matter of 26-006 19
MA, I’d enter a motion to [inaudi ble] recommendation for 2101 K ennerly Road to 20
[inaudible] with a recommendation for disapproval. 21
MR. DUFFY: Second. 22
28
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Alright, hold on. We have a motion on the floor f o r 1
disapproval. Do I have a second? 2
MR. DUFFY: I second it. 3
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Second, got a second from Commissioner Duffy. A lright, 4
thank you. With a motion and a second, we’re gonna go ahead an d have Staff take a 5
vote, disapproval. 6
MR. DURANT: Mr. Chair? 7
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Yes, Commissioner Durant. 8
MR. DURANT: For disapproving a motion do we need a basis for it? 9
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Not if it goes with the County’s recommendation , right, for 10
the Comprehensive Plan’s recommendation. 11
MR. DELAGE: Correct, however, if you do want to add one, yes you can. 12
MR. JOHNSON: I’m happy to. I mean, I think that it is important – 13
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Go ahead, Commissioner Johnson. 14
MR. JOHNSON: - just in fairness so that both the public and the Applicant 15
understands, that under the current land use plan that the prop osal is inconsistent with 16
what is [inaudible]. In taking to account if the draft Comprehe nsive Plan were adopted 17
today I don’t think it, speaking from my vantage point, that it would change the outcome. 18
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Okay, that’s gonna be the reasoning. Now Commis sioner 19
Duffy, you still second that? 20
MR. DUFFY: Yes. 21
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Okay. So we got a motion and a second. Staff needs to take 22
a vote. 23
29
MR. DELAGE: Alright. Grady? 1
MR. GRADY: Aye. 2
MR. DELAGE: Siercks? 3
MR. SIERCKS: Aye. 4
MR. DELAGE: Taylor? 5
MR. TAYLOR: Aye. 6
MR. DELAGE: Durant? 7
MR. DURANT: Aye. 8
MR. DELAGE: Loyd? 9
MS. LOYD: Aye. 10
MR. DELAGE: Duffy? 11
MR. DUFFY: Aye. 12
MR. DELAGE: Johnson? 13
MR. JOHNSON: Aye. 14
MR. DELAGE: Frierson? 15
MS. FRIERSON: Aye. 16
MR. DELAGE: Yonke? 17
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Aye. 18
MR. DELAGE: Alright, motion for disapproval passes. 19
[Approved: Grady, Siercks, Taylor, Durant, Loyd, Frierson, Yonke, Johnson, Duffy] 20
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Alright, thank y ou Staff. Alright Commissioner Johnson 21
would like to make some comments. 22
30
MR. JOHNSON: First of all I want to thank Staff for being prepared to answer and 1
address that question. Secondly I just think I raise it again b ecause I think last month it 2
would’ve been a different outcome . I think that if we had looke d at what the draft was 3
[inaudible]. 4
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Thank you, Commi ssioner Johnson. Thank you, 5
Commission. Alright, that was a recommendation of disapproval. It’s gonna go to County 6
Council for April 28 th, 7:00pm. We’re gonna go ahead and keep moving on for tonight. 7
Next case, 26-007. I had to say it. Gotta make fun on a Planning Commission, come on. 8
MR. TAYLOR: Quick question. 9
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Yes, Commissioner Taylor? 10
MR. TAYLOR: Looking at some of these proposals or, and looking at Staff’s 11
recommendation I have a question as far as when we’re looking at these projects and the 12
zoning classifications, you know, a one or two jump is usually understandable or 13
justifiable, [inaudible] you gotta jump, like seven or eight different zoning classes to get to 14
the desired zoning. My question is, can you explain just a little bit, like special exceptions 15
versus special requirements, does that, is that taken into account whenever the applicant 16
comes forward or are you looking for just a natural fit into whatever the zoning class is or 17
the one that’s being requested? 18
MR. DELAGE: So as far as, depending on where they are in the pr ocess, so 19
typically for a rezoning we’re just looking at, you know, basic ally most intense use that’s 20
allowed by right or potentially b y special requirement. Your sp ecial requirements are 21
generally additional development standards that are placed on a property. For example, 22
they may have a requirement for your driveway not to be closer than 30’ to another 23
31
residential zoning or use. It could be for, in some cases like with places of worship, 1
depending on the acreage and the in tensity of the uses that’ll be on the property, if you 2
have a very large parcel you have to be located basically on a road, you can’t use an 3
easement to basically service it. So they’re basically, it’s an administrative function to 4
ensure that there are additional standards placed on those uses to kinda make them fit 5
into areas where they may not otherwise fit based on, you know, some kind of constraint. 6
The special exception is befor e the Board of Zoning Appeals so the idea behind that is, 7
again you have an additional level of review. Generally for those special exceptions they’ll 8
identify, other than the basics, w e want to make sure there’s n ot gonna be any kind of 9
effect on pedestrian safety, traffic, noise, smoke, odor glare. In other cases you may again 10
have some additional development requirements as part of that, but then the Board can 11
also place additional conditions on approval. So that’s kinda t he main difference. But 12
typically when we do have our pre-application meetings if they have an identified use that 13
they want, we will talk about that and make sure that they are given all options of the 14
zoning districts that will permit that either by right or by sp ecial requirement or special 15
exception. But then, of course, after that because it is a rezoning we don’t really talk about 16
uses it’s just whatever’s allowed in the district. 17
MR. TAYLOR: Yeah, and that’s kinda the catch-22 because we’re n ot looking at 18
the uses typically but that’s what we hear when they come to the podium. And that’s why 19
I was asking the question, so thank you. 20
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Thank you, Commissioner Taylor. Good topic. Alright Staff, 21
we’ll move on to this next Map Amendment. 22
CASE NO. 26-007 MA: 23
32
MR. SMITH: Alright. Case No. 26-007 MA. Location 1284 Kelly Mill Road and S/S 1
Kelly Mill Road. The acreage is 7.5 acres. Existing zoning is H M, Homestead. The 2
proposed zoning is MU2, Mixed Use Corridor. The Comprehensive P lan compliance is 3
non-compliant. The proposed rezoni ng is not compliant with the objectives of the 4
neighborhood medium density designation in the Comprehensive Plan. Per the plan non-5
residential development within the neighborhood medium density designation may be 6
considered for the location along main road corridors and within contextually appropriate 7
distances from the intersection of a primary arterial. The proposed request is not located 8
along a main road corridor or within an appropriate distance fr om the intersection of a 9
primary arterial. Additionally, the plan states that commercial uses should be located 10
within a neighborhood activity c enter and that such uses should n o t r e s u l t i n s t r i p 11
commercial development or fragm ented leapfrog development patte rns along corridors. 12
The proposed request is not sit uated within a designated neighb orhood center, 13
neighborhood activity center, I apologize, and is noncontiguous to existing commercial 14
development. Because it effectively bypasses adjacent undevelop ed land the request 15
could not be reasonably characterized as promoting leapfrog development patterns which 16
is inconsistent with the intent of the Plan. 17
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Thank you, Staff. Commission, any questions? Okay, seeing 18
none. Commissioner Frierson, who’s signed up to speak? 19
MS. FRIERSON: We have Mr. Elias Diss and then Levetta Williams. 20
[Loyd out at 7:00pm] 21
TESTIMONY OF ELIAS DIB: 22
MR. DIB: Good afternoon, or good evening. I’m James Bond because 007. 23
33
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Nice. 1
MR. DIB: My name’s Elias Dib. I’m at 240 Brookspring Road, Colu mbia. I bought 2
the property about 20 years ago. T his is the time right now bec ause this area is 3
expanding, it’s growing. That is in Blythewood where houses are being built north, south, 4
east and west, you can subdivisions everywhere. I’m planning to develop it as an anchor 5
grocery store. Reason for that is to serve the community, if th ey want milk, eggs, they 6
don’t have to drive 10 miles or four miles or whatever it is. I t’s very close by. If you want 7
medicine, if you want something else it’s very close by. The need for that in the proximity 8
area is so tremendous. You might find one person or two persons who might object to the 9
progress in Blythewood, but you should not stop the progress, w e should not stop the 10
move forward. It might be sent imental for them, might be been t here for a long time, 11
maybe because their parents, but progress needs to be continued for, as best for the 12
community as a whole; not just for 1% but to the 99% who wanna achieve a better life 13
and do not have to go through, to down to Blythewood several mi les down the road with 14
the traffic to get their eggs or milk. I would like for you guy s to approve it. I would like for 15
you guys to say aye, all of you. And let’s hope for the best. Thank you for your time. 16
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Thank you, sir. 17
MR. DIB: I’m here to answer any questions for you. 18
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Thank you. 19
MS. FRIERSON: Levetta Williams. 20
TESTIMONY OF LEVETTA WILLIAMS: 21
MS. WILLIAMS: Good evening, honorable Chairman and your disting uished 22
members. My name is Levetta Lyl es Williams and I reside at 5410 Hardscrabble Road, 23
34
Blythewood, South Carolina 29016. Home is where the heart is an d quite literally this is 1
my home. I was born in my grandparent’s home at what is now 5425 Hardscrabble Road, 2
just yards from the property being discussed this evening. Long before it was named such 3
and long before it was paved, just an unpaved red dirt road, the home of my grandfather 4
and my grandmother, Nick and Jani e Young, land was farmed by th em and their 11 5
children. I’m very proud to say that my grandparents were pillars of the community of what 6
is now a vibrant community. Just a little up the road where Har dscrabble intersects with 7
Rimer Pond Road my grandfather gav e the lumber from their home to construct the 8
Roundtop Baptist Church, and you all are familiar with Roundtop B a p t i s t C h u r c h , 9
Roundtop Church Road and Roundtop Elementary School. Started from my grandfather. 10
I’m saying all this to say that family roots run deep. Having names change diminishes and 11
takes away from all the families who have worked had, sacrificed much life and limb. It’s 12
shameful and disrespectful. It erases our community’s history and our heritage. This is all 13
in the name of progress. I am not against progress, change or advancement, but we must 14
be more thoughtful and more plan-ful as we do so, not to take a way from what attracted 15
people to Blythewood in the first place. This affects me personally because my property 16
is adjoined to the parcel of land being considered tonight. My first cousin is here with me, 17
Zelma Ruff Gibbs, another of Nick and Janie’s grandchildren. 18
CHAIRMAN YONKE: If you could please give me your final thought, I’ve give you 19
an extra 30 seconds. 20
MS. WILLIAMS: Yes. 21
CHAIRMAN YONKE: To be fair to everybody. 22
MS. WILLIAMS: Is here – 23
35
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Thank you. 1
MS. WILLIAMS: - with me tonight because her name, her home is located on Ruff 2
Road, which is named after her parents. Respectfully I am making my appeal here tonight 3
that there be no name changes and no rezoning from residential. Thank you so much for 4
your consideration and if I can answer any questions I’ll be certainly happy to. 5
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Thank you so much. 6
MS. WILLIAMS: Thank you so much. 7
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Okay. Anyone else signed up? 8
MS. FRIERSON: No, she was the last person to sign up. 9
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Thank you. Okay Commission, this is now on the floor for 10
discussion or questions. 11
MR. JOHNSON: [Inaudible] 12
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Okay Commissioner Johnson, can you ask that in your 13
microphone? 14
MR. JOHNSON: Staff, is it appropr iate just to give contextual r eference to the 15
properties that [inaudible]? 16
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Commissioner Frierson? 17
MS. FRIERSON: Yes, under Discu ssion on page 34, I think there’s a m i s t a k e . 18
Under public services in that second sentence it says Lake Caro lina Elementary School 19
54 miles east of the subject parcel. That’s probably supposed to be 5.4 but I know it’s not 20
54 miles. Just wanted to bring that – see right here? 21
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Yes. No punctuat ion there. Good eye, Ms. Friers on, 22
Commissioner Frierson. Okay Commission, let’s have a discussion. 23
36
MR. JOHNSON: Before we go to discussion may I ask a quick question? 1
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Commissioner Johnson. 2
MR. JOHNSON: The location map has a pink color that’s not refer enced on the 3
zoning map. 4
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Council map districts. This one’s on the edge of a few County 5
Council districts. I can answer that. 6
MR. JOHNSON: Thank you. 7
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Thanks. Okay. One, two, three, discuss. Staff, could you put 8
the zoning layer on? I know what that color is but I wanna ask it out loud, to the southeast, 9
what is that, what does that mean? Does that mean it’s a PDD? All of that, that residential 10
there. 11
MR. DELAGE: Yes, it is part of Lake Carolina. 12
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Thank you. Can we discuss, heartburn for me, pr imary 13
arterial and roads? With the expansion of Hardscrabble Road over the last two decades, 14
it seems like that’s how long it took, right? 15
MR. SMITH: Sure, why not. So the bigger difference is where the se primary 16
arterials versus secondary or collectors is gonna be up to SCDOT classification systems 17
and it’s gonna be the amount of traffic that is accumulating and how they classify it. I will 18
say that the Hardscrabble construction ended at that intersection so at one time it was a 19
two-lane, it became a five-lane, but at the intersection it goes from five lanes to two lanes 20
at the intersection going north. As far as primary and secondary, I believe that Tommy’s 21
gonna bring up, Mr. DeLage is gonna bring up the road classification system. 22
37
CHAIRMAN YONKE: In our Report, as you’re pulling that up, page 35, almost 1
25,000 cars a day. 2
MR. DELAGE: Yes, so it appears t hat the, at the intersection Ha rdscrabble goes 3
from that urban minor arterial to, it looks like the green which is the urban major collector. 4
CHAIRMAN YONKE: But the residents in this area that are there now see this as 5
more of a busier intersection? Staff what’s the use just southeast of the intersection? Yes. 6
MR. SMITH: That would non-conforming residential use with multiple structures on 7
it. 8
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Staff, spin around the street view a little bit. This is just from 9
October. That looks pretty resi dential. Thanks, Staff. What are your thoughts, 10
Commission? Commissioner Grady? 11
MR. GRADY: Yes. Thank you for bringing up the primary arterial question because 12
I was going to. This has been something that I’ve brought up on a number of different 13
occasions because it does seem that SCDOT does not necessarily take into account 14
upgrades or traffic flow changes when making these designations. You know, when I think 15
about where there should, you know, where we should permit comm ercial development 16
in a primarily residential area this strikes me as the sort of site that would apply; whereas 17
the intersection of two roads that are crucial for traffic flow in the area, there’s already 18
substantial residential developm ent in the area. There’s both s ort of the sting for rural 19
development, then you also see t here’s also more traditional sm all lot suburban 20
subdivision type development as well. So while I, you know, appreciate the, the precision 21
with which Staff makes their recommendation and notes that it is not a primary arterial as 22
38
designated by SCDOT, I would, and I will let discussion proceed, but I would be inclined 1
to think that this would be [inaudible]. 2
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Thank you, Commissioner Grady. Commissioner Johnson. 3
MR. JOHNSON: To Commissioner Gr ady’s point when you read the de finition of 4
the zoning district on the botto m of 33, [inaudible] right spot and location for that mixed 5
use [inaudible]. For the same reasons Commissioner Grady outlined that tends to be my 6
initial gut [inaudible] if there was a spot for a mixed use dev elopment that intersection is 7
what makes sense. [Inaudible] – 8
MS. MURPHY: Microphone, please? You’re breaking up. Sorry. 9
MR. JOHNSON: To start from the beginning I was saying that the zoning district 10
summary for M2, MU2 it’s in my mind corner in this intersection which is the essence of 11
what Commission Grady was saying. And I was just saying that I’ m, I arrive to the same 12
point. I was going to [inaudible] residents make a compelling c ase in terms of the desire 13
to retain the current fabric and feel. But if this were an inli ne site I might be inclined to 14
oppose it but being on a corner and being on the corner of those two main roads, it’s hard 15
to not justify [inaudible] supporting that change. 16
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Thank you, Commissioner Johnson. Commissioner Sierks? 17
MR. SIERCKS: Yes, Mr. Chair, if I could ask the Staff to zoom out a little bit on the 18
map. 19
CHAIRMAN YONKE: When we look at the 2015 Comp Plan we use the 20
neighborhood activity center terminology, right Staff? 21
MR. SMITH: That is correct. 22
39
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Okay. If we were back in our time machine to 20 14 and we 1
were coming up with the terminol ogy, what would define that or what’s the birth of one? 2
We’ve got two busy roads here, r esidents around the outside, li k e t h e d i f f e r e n t 3
subdivisions. 4
MR. SMITH: A multitude of factors come into range. Normally whe n we look at 5
these neighborhood centers a lotta things are taken into consid eration between traffic, 6
economics, housing, you know, t he want or the need from the com munity, from the 7
government, from you know, consti tuents. We take all those fact ors into consideration 8
when we identify these activity c enters. And not saying that wh en we do the 9
Comprehensive Plan update in fiv e years from our new one we mig ht see some areas 10
that we view now not as activity centers that we may see as activity centers in five years. 11
CHAIRMAN YONKE: You said the want and need, I see on the map as 12
Commissioner Siercks asked to zoom it out, there’s a want to be there. There’s a lot of 13
residences here. 14
MR. DELAGE: Mr. Chair. 15
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Yes, Staff. 16
MR. DELAGE: So just to provide some additional information, this section of Lake 17
Carolina has that, that’s almost green with my hand, allows for commercial uses as part 18
of the PDD. I believe up here to north is multi-family as well. So just throwing that out 19
there as information if it may help with your discussion. 20
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Is there a natur al boundary in the 2015 Comp Pl an that 21
shows Kelly Mill Road as a barrier? No, it’s in the middle of the same color yellow. Okay. 22
Okay Commission, further discussion or a motion? 23
40
MR. DURANT: Mr. Chair? 1
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Commissioner Durant? 2
MR. DURANT: Just a, one question of Mr., my colleague Commissio ner Johnson 3
brought up the last couple of tim es was would there be any diff erence here if we were 4
under the Comprehensive Plan in the Staff’s view? 5
MR. SMITH: Again from a face value this area from, the difference between what 6
we’re proposing today in our current Comp Plan to what we’re proposing in the new Comp 7
Plan, currently in the 2015 Plan it’s recommended I believe med ium density. In the new 8
Plan this area is actually less dense and lower density, and the dividing line is Rimer Pond 9
Road going north. Rimer Pond Road going north which is the subject perpendicular road 10
that, or Kelly Mill is Rimer Pond. Rimer Pond turns into Kelly Mill at that intersection. So 11
the dividing line is the Kelly Mill/Rimer Pond Road. 12
MR. JOHNSON: Divides between what and what? 13
MR. SMITH: Divides suburban from low density. 14
MR. SIERCKS: Mr. Chair? 15
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Commissioner Siercks. 16
MR. SIERCKS: Looking at this request, I think what stands out i s what has stood 17
out in a couple of the proposed z oning requests tonight which i s to me this just seems 18
like a, a leapfrog development pattern. And with regard to, while I can certainly understand 19
the, the questions surrounding what the Comp Plan might be once it’s, or the updated 20
Land Development Code might be once it’s finished, we can talk about hypotheticals and 21
what could be and what might be; that’s a discussion for when a nd if the Land 22
Development Code is implemented as it’s currently been drafted. That could change. 23
41
What we have before us is a r equest within the guidelines or at least how we should be 1
looking at this is, does it fit within the guidelines of the La nd Development Code and the 2
Comprehensive Plan as it’s c urrently written? If that changes w ith future land 3
development codes or future comp plans then the applicants are free to reapply at that 4
time if it meets with those changes. But to me where I come dow n on this one is it’s not 5
currently within a neighborhood a ctivity center and it seems li ke the, some of the 6
discussion is trying to make it work when it currently does not. 7
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Thank you, Commi ssioner Siercks. More comments? 8
Commissioner Frierson? 9
MS. FRIERSON: Yes, I agree with my colleague. I’m familiar with that area, too, 10
and reading the conclusion that Staff provided I think those points are quite on point and 11
I think that we must work with the provisions that we have curr ently. And as I said I’m 12
familiar with that area and it definitely would be a leapfrog zoning change if we did not go 13
along with what Staff recommended in this instance. 14
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Thank you, Commissioner Frierson. Any further thoughts on 15
this side of the table? On that side? Okay, who’s brave to make a motion? 16
MS. FRIERSON: I will. 17
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Okay, Commissioner Frierson. 18
MS. FRIERSON: Mr. Chairperson, I move that we send Map Amendmen t 26-007 19
to County Council with a recommendation of non-compliance and we don’t have to state 20
a reason because it goes along with Staff, but if we had to it would be because it is not 21
consistent with the Comprehensive Plan, it’s not located along a main road corridor or nor 22
42
is it at an intersection of primary arterial, nor is it designa ted as a neighborhood activity 1
center, so. 2
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Thank you, Commissioner Frierson. Do we have a second 3
for disapproval, non-compliant? 4
MR. SIERCKS: Second. 5
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Second from Commissioner Siercks. Okay Staff, w ith a 6
motion and a second go ahead and take a vote, please. 7
MR. DELAGE: Grady? 8
MR. GRADY: No. 9
MR. DELAGE: Siercks? 10
MR. SIERCKS: Aye. 11
MR. DELAGE: Taylor? 12
MR. TAYLOR: Aye. 13
MR. DELAGE: Durant? 14
MR. DURANT: Aye. 15
MR. DELAGE: Duffy? 16
MR. DUFFY: Aye. 17
MR. DELAGE: Johnson? 18
MR. JOHNSON: No. 19
MR. DELAGE: Frierson? 20
MS. FRIERSON: Aye. 21
MR. DELAGE: Yonke? 22
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Aye. 23
43
MR. DELAGE: Alright, motion passes. 1
[Approved to deny: Siercks, Taylor, Durant, Duffy, Frierson, Yonke; Opposed: Grady, 2
Johnson; Absent: Loyd] 3
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Thank you. I appreciate the discussion. I don’t come in here 4
with my decision already made so hearing from you helps me, tha nks. This goes as 5
disapproval. Staff, would County Council like to hear from dissenting votes on this? That’s 6
been valuable we’ve been told. 7
MR. DELAGE: If y’all would like to have some additional discuss ion on the 8
dissenting votes then that is always helpful. 9
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Those that voted no, Commissioner Johnson, go ahead? 10
MR. JOHNSON: This is a tough case. Again, as I said the locatio n tends to fit the 11
[inaudible] zoning location and as Staff pointed out, while it’ s under a PUD there is 12
provision for commercial down the street. And so one of the key [inaudible] some of our 13
Commission Members were leaning on is the definition of what that road is [inaudible] the 14
actual growth, what’s happening in that corridor presents that challenge of, and it’s the 15
perfect example of the challenge and the balance between rural versus undeveloped. It 16
is, it may not be fully developed but [inaudible] certainly enough [inaudible]. 17
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Thank you, Co mmissioner Johnson. Was it Commiss ioner 18
Grady? 19
MR. GRADY: Yeah, Mr. Chair. So I think articulated my rationale during the 20
discussion to a great extent, but I think what it fundamentally comes down to is it’s a road 21
with 25,000 daily traffic, Hardscrabble Road, in this stretch a s reported by our briefing 22
packet. So given that, while it may not fit the SCDOT definitio n of a primary arterial it’s 23
44
clearly the primary road in the immediate vicinity. There’s sub stantial residential 1
development and not allowing, you know, small scale commercial activity would 2
essentially require people in the area to drive long distances to other portions of the 3
county which would amplify traffic congestion, which I know is certainly a concern in this 4
area. So I would say that it, it seems that this would be the most appropriate site for such 5
a development, even if it does not necessarily fit the exact letter of what is stated. 6
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Thank you, Commi ssioner Grady. And I’ll explain that my 7
vote was swayed by some more information from the Staff with th at PDD down the road 8
that there is some potential for mixed use already assigned to the area that hasn’t been 9
developed yet. So thank you. This will go to County Council on April 28th at 7:00pm. We 10
can move along to our last case. Which is Case 26-008. 11
CASE NO. 26-008 MA: 12
MR. SMITH: The case you have before you is 26-008 MA. The Applicant is Julius 13
Murray, Jr. The location is 1879 Chain Gang Road. It’s 9.68 acres. The existing zoning is 14
HM, Homestead. The proposed zoning is residential transition. C omprehensive Plan 15
compliance is non-compliant. The proposed rezoning is not compliant with the goals and 16
objectives of the Comprehensive Plan. The proposed rezoning of the subject parcel to 17
residential transition is not cons istent with the desired devel opment of the rural large lot 18
future land use designation. Residential development should occ ur on very large 19
individual owned lots or as family subdivisions. However, approval of the requested Map 20
Amendment would be in character with the current zoning, land u ses and development 21
pattern within the area. 22
45
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Alright, thanks Staff. Commission, any question s for Staff? 1
Okay not seeing any, Commissioner Frierson? 2
MS. FRIERSON: First we have the Applicant, Julius Murray. 3
TESTIMONY OF JULIUS MURRAY: 4
MR. MURRAY: Good evening Commissioners. I’m Julius Murray, Jr. I reside at 5
1069 Old Bluff Road, Hopkins, South Carolina. And I come before you today to ask you 6
please rezone this property. This property was sold to these pe ople before 2019. I’ve 7
owned it probably since 1985. My father took care of everything and if you pay attention 8
there’s actually a mobile home on one, on tract B that’s been t here for maybe 15 years. 9
And what has happened is the property was sold for taxes so when I redeemed it or when 10
I bought it back the land that was already cut off was included back into the new map. So 11
I can’t get these people a deed for their property based on the new regs of 2023. And all 12
I’m asking is to rezone so I can issue them a deed. And that’s it. 13
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Okay, thanks for coming out. 14
MR. MURRAY: Thank you. 15
MS. FRIERSON: We have Marya Johnson and then Richard Johnson. 16
AUDIENCE MEMBER: [Inaudible] 17
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Thank you. 18
TESTIMONY OF RICHARD JOHNSON: 19
MR. JOHNSON: My name’s Richard Johnson. I reside at 330 House R oad. I’m 20
also commissioned with the South Carolina Rural Water Association and I’m also licensed 21
with the Wastewater Development also with Richland County. And I’m just here just 22
because I look at the property, one of the properties and I’m just here to state that I check 23
46
the well cause I’m licensed for the well and I’m also licensed with the septic tank and as 1
of right now it is in working order Thank you very much for your time. 2
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Thank you, sir. 3
MS. FRIERSON: Excuse me, Mr. Johnson, you said 330 House Road. What city? 4
MR. JOHNSON: Eastover, South Carolina. 5
MS. FRIERSON: Thank you. 6
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Anyone else signed up to speak. 7
MS. FRIERSON: No, Mr. Johnson is the last person. 8
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Thank you. Okay Commission, this is on the floo r for 9
discussion. For the RT. Staff, could you put the zoning layer on? Thanks. Commissioner 10
Grady. 11
MR. GRADY: So I think this was one of the odd sorts of things that came out of the 12
Land Development Code update where we essentially separated the rural designation 13
into multiple components based on the size of the lot. So essentially it seems like this got 14
labeled as a homestead, whereas surrounding properties were labeled as RT. Certainly I 15
know it said it was a large lot rural future land use. I certainly think an acre is a fairly large 16
lot in my person opinion. So I would certainly be inclined to go along with the Applicant’s 17
request. 18
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Thank you, Commissioner Grady. Any other though ts, 19
comments on this one? 20
MR. DURANT: Question, Mr. Chair. 21
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Commissioner Durant. 22
47
MR. DURANT: For Staff. The surrounding parcels are on the west/east [inaudible] 1
Are they the result of any recent zoning amendments? 2
MR. DELAGE: There has been no re cent map amendment applications but, 3
however as part of that March 1st, 2024 what would’ve been rural was broken up into the 4
RT, AG and HM. So as you can kinda see the adjacent parcel based on acreage went to 5
the RT district. Since this was a larger tract it ended up goin g to the HM zoning 6
designation. 7
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Thank you, Commissioner Durant. Thanks, Staff. Hearing 8
much discussion, does anyone have a motion? 9
MR. GRADY: Mr. Chair? 10
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Commissioner Grady. 11
MR. GRADY: I would like to make a motion. I will move that we advance Case 26-12
008 MA to County Council with a recommendation of approval, the rationale being that 13
an RT zoning designation is in keeping with the surrounding lan d uses adjacent to the 14
subject property. 15
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Thank you, Commissioner Grady. Do we have a second? 16
MR. TAYLOR: Second. 17
MR. DURANT: Second. 18
CHAIRMAN YONKE: I’m gonna give it to Taylor. Alright, second Taylor. Okay with 19
a motion and a second, Staff please take a vote. 20
MR. DELAGE: Alright, motion is for approval, Grady. 21
MR. GRADY: Aye. 22
MR. DELAGE: Siercks? 23
48
MR. SIERCKS: Aye. 1
MR. DELAGE: Taylor? 2
MR. TAYLOR: Aye. 3
MR. DELAGE: Durant? 4
MR. DURANT: Aye. 5
MR. DELAGE: Loyd? Oh, sorry. Duffy? 6
MR. DUFFY: Aye. 7
MR. DELAGE: Johnson? 8
MR. JOHNSON: Aye. 9
MR. DELAGE: Frierson? 10
MS. FRIERSON: Aye. 11
MR. DELAGE: Yonke? 12
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Aye. 13
MR. DELAGE: Motion passes. 14
[Approved: Grady, Siercks, Taylor, Durant, Du ffy, Johnson, Frierson, Yonke; Absent: 15
Loyd] 16
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Thank you, Commission. Thank you, Staff. 17
Recommendation of approval goes to the April 28th, 7:00pm County Council meeting. So 18
that’s the end of the Map Amendments. Takes us to 6., Land Development Code Updates. 19
I’m gonna flip that over to Staff. Mr. Price, hiding in the corner. 20
MR. TAYLOR: Mr. Chair? 21
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Yes. 22
MR. TAYLOR: Before we move, can I ask one quick question? 23
49
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Yes. Commissioner Taylor. 1
MR. TAYLOR: It’s kinda in line with some of the concerns we had recently with 2
these Map Amendments and these RC projects. How often does the SCDOT update their 3
road classifications? 4
MR. DELAGE: That’s a good question. I would assume that it would be as, if there’s 5
any change in capacity. I do not know if there’s a regular, like interval scheduled update. 6
I will say that Staff has noticed that there has been changes to some of the classifications 7
within the last year on the website, whereas it used to just kinda be minor, major, arterial, 8
local, interstate. They’ve kind of broken those down into urban and suburban 9
designations. But for the most part the longstanding designations that we reference in our 10
Code, that has been around since, at least in that format since I started doing some zoning 11
and transportation planning in 2012. But, so it stuck around for a while before they kinda 12
changed and it looks like they’re breaking them up further. But as far as ADTs, which is 13
your average daily traffic, those are generally, those traffic counts are updated yearly. 14
MR. TAYLOR: Thank you. 15
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Thank you, Commissioner Taylor. Thank you, Staf f. Go 16
ahead, Staff, number 6 on the Agenda tonight. 17
MR. PRICE: Okay. Guess who’s back. So what we have before you, it does state 18
that this is an action item and we put that there, again, so if there’s any decision made by 19
Planning Commission we’ll be following the legal guidelines for any items on the Agenda, 20
for any changes. If you notice, if you take note on page 52, 51 kind of explains where we 21
are and then I believe it was at the February 19 th Planning Commission meeting when it 22
was brought before you, Council’s motion for Staff to, or the Planning Commission to do 23
50
a review of the MU2 zoning designation, it was decided that we should look at a number 1
of the other non-residential districts, kind of to do a compari son of those districts, I think 2
it’d be, it kind of made sense. For one it made it easier so we could see exactly what we 3
were gonna be doing going forward. What was provided to you tod ay in your package 4
were the general descriptions for each of those non-residential districts which were the 5
INS, institutional, the rural crossroads, RC, the MU1, the MU2, the MU3 and the GC 6
zoning designations. Those were provided to you along with kind of a matrix of each of 7
the uses that are allowed in each one of these districts. We tried to kind of color code that 8
so it would be a little easier for you as you kind of flip the pages to go along with it. We 9
can take, we can go into further discussion on this at this time and talk about, you know, 10
go through each one of these zoning districts. However, kind of from a discussion with 11
the other Staff, I think it may be recommended that we go forwa rd with the approval of 12
the Comprehensive Plan first. Once we have those designations i n place, cause I think 13
y’all kinda went back and forth a little bit looking at what th e Comprehensive Plan calls 14
for, not just our current Comprehensive Plan but the potential future Comprehensive Plan. 15
But let’s give approval to that and once that’s gone forward we ’ll know what those 16
designations call for and it may be more appropriate to then look at the general description 17
for our current zoning designations. And this also may require some, an eventual work 18
session or two with the Planning Commission to further discuss these. But again, that 19
was just a, kind of a recommendation and we’ll be ready to purs ue according to the 20
decision of the Planning Commission. 21
51
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Thanks, Staff. Thanks, Mr. Price. Commission, what are your 1
thoughts on this? I have a question for Staff. This being an action item, do we have time 2
for public input or is there a signup sheet for it? 3
MR. PRICE: I’m sorry, we should’ve actually provided a sign up sheet because it 4
is an action item at this time. 5
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Can I ask by show of hands, anyone in the crowd wanted to 6
speak on this? We’ll give you two minutes. Just give me a show of hands, Ms. Murphy. 7
Thank you. 8
MS. MURPHY: I don’t need to speak on it if this is being postponed but if – 9
CHAIRMAN YONKE: We don’t know that yet. Okay, Ms. Murphy come o n down 10
and take your two minutes. State your name and address, come on. 11
TESTIMONY OF KIM MURPHY: 12
MS. MURPHY: Kim Murphy, 154 Old Laurel Lane, Chapin, South Caro lina. I did 13
see a list of the zoning classifications but there were no reco mmendations from Staff on 14
what the proposed changes might be. And I know you kinda take their lead and run with 15
it, so if this was going to be a vote tonight I was hoping that you would postpone it until 16
we could hear what the recommendations were going to be. Now it looks like it’s going to 17
be postponed pending your vote. 18
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Thank you. 19
MS. MURPHY: Thank you. 20
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Anyone else wanted to speak since we missed a s ignup 21
sheet, I’ll allow it. Not on this one? Okay. Thank you. Alright back to Commission. Do we 22
52
wanna give Staff more time to work on this, do we wanna have back and forth with Staff? 1
How do we wanna proceed? 2
MR. PRICE: I’m sorry – and again, I think it’d be a little easier to work on this if we 3
know exactly what it is we’re kinda comparing this to, so again with the adoption or with 4
your recommendation of the Comprehensive Plan going forward to Council, we’ll be able 5
to look more at those designations and compare it to our curren t general description of 6
our current zoning designations als o, and the uses to try to co me forward with a couple 7
of ideas for you. But I think in this particular case it will b e great to have this as kind of a 8
collaborate effort between the Planning Commission and Staff. 9
MR. DUFFY: I’ve got a question for Mr. Price. 10
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Commissioner Duffy. 11
MR. DUFFY: If we, as per your recommendation, if we were to vote on this motion 12
would that not impede our abilit y then to make any additional c hanges to the 13
Comprehensive Plan once we, just say the group was to vote in f avor tonight, I’m just 14
curious, if you could just clarify that point. 15
MR. PRICE: I’m sorry, could you repeat – 16
MR. DUFFY: If this motion is voted on tonight and folks are for it, thereafter can 17
additional changes be made to the Comp Plan or kind of are we washed our hands of it? 18
MR. PRICE: Well this is a little separate from the Comprehensive Plan. 19
MR. DUFFY: Okay. 20
MR. PRICE: This is separate. This is actually within the current Land Development 21
Code. 22
MR. DUFFY: LDC. Okay, perfect. 23
53
MR. PRICE: And again, you know, these are things that we’re taking up, and I think 1
you kind of, you, I hate to talk about a particular case but I think you saw that on a couple 2
of your cases today, just how som e of these designations are de scribed where they’re 3
recommended to be located. And I think the idea is to try to tailor this to fit more with what 4
our current Comprehensive Plan, those designations call for. 5
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Okay. 6
MR. DURANT: Mr. Chair? 7
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Commissioner Durant? 8
MR. DURANT: I’m just a little confused. I may be slow but what exactly are we 9
being asked to do today? 10
CHAIRMAN YONKE: I think we’re being asked to defer this. 11
MR. PRICE: Yes, sir. 12
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Okay. So that we can focus on the Comprehensive Plan. 13
MR. PRICE: That is correct. Thank you, Mr. Chair. 14
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Okay, the Chair ma kes a motion for deferral. Do I have a 15
second? 16
MR. JOHNSON: Second. 17
CHAIRMAN YONKE: I got a second from Commissioner Johnson. Okay Staff, with 18
a motion and a second can you ta ke a vote on number 6., Land De velopment Code 19
Updates? 20
MR. DELAGE: Alright, motion is to defer. Is that to the next available meeting or? 21
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Can I go ahead and say till June? Or skip May? 22
MR. DELAGE: So motion is to – 23
54
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Do I need a second on that? Motion is to defer until our June 1
meeting. 2
MR. JOHNSON: I’ll accept the amendment. 3
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Okay, second from Commissioner Johnson. Thank y ou. 4
Procedures, guys. Thank you. 5
MR. DELAGE: Okay, Grady? 6
MR. GRADY: Aye. 7
MR. DELAGE: Siercks? 8
MR. SIERCKS: Aye. 9
MR. DELAGE: Oh, I’m sorry. Taylor? 10
MR. TAYLOR: Aye. 11
MR. DELAGE: Durant? 12
MR. DURANT: Aye. 13
MR. DELAGE: Loyd? Sorry. Duffy? 14
MR. DUFFY: Aye. 15
MR. DELAGE: Johnson? 16
MR. JOHNSON: Aye. 17
MR. DELAGE: Frierson? 18
MS. FRIERSON: Aye. 19
MR. DELAGE: Yonke? 20
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Aye. 21
MR. DELAGE: Alright, motion passes for deferral till June. 22
55
[Approved: Grady, Siercks, Taylor, Durant, Du ffy, Johnson, Frierson, Yonke; Absent: 1
Loyd] 2
CHAIRMAN YONKE: I would not discount the thought of, like a wor k session for 3
this one. But yes, let’s focus on the Comprehensive Plan right now. 4
MR. PRICE: Yes. 5
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Thank you, Staff. So that puts us at number tonight which is 6
the Comprehensive Plan, which is an action item. So I would als o like to give the public 7
some time to speak on this but we’ll have Staff introduce it fi rst. By show of hands from 8
the public since we didn’t have a signup sheet are there people here that wanted to talk? 9
Okay, Ms. Murphy, gotcha. Typically we’ll have Staff present to us so we can all get the 10
information and then we’ll take public input. 11
MS. SMITH: Hello again. Okay, so last time we were here we went over a bunch 12
of different changes. The ones in highlight yellow are the ones that we pushed through. 13
The ones that are crossed out are the ones that either we did n ot need to initiate or we 14
did not get further guidance and they will have to be tabled for a later date. The bigger of 15
the two was the changing of the f uture land use map from a parc el-based to a broad 16
stroke, broad paint stroke based map. And then the expansion up on the Staff Report or 17
the future land use designations f or more details. So this is w hat the map looked like 18
before we changed it from a parcel-based. This is the parcel-ba sed as it stood, and this 19
is what the broad paint brush looks like now. 20
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Flip it back and forth a couple times. 21
MR. SMITH: Yeah, and we’ll get to more in-depth on these as well. 22
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Okay. 23
56
MR. SMITH: One of the first – we’re gonna do these in order – so the first one was 1
the Cedar Creek area that we had identified, making some adjustments to the low density 2
and the countryside elements. This is what we had proposed, wha t the current was and 3
what the proposal was. This is how it actually came out. You ca n see what the current 4
was and what it got changed to. As you can see individual parce ls were not singled out 5
and the white borders around the designations that actually hel p with some of the 6
ambiguity, some of the gray areas that we might come into contact with when we do these 7
map amendments. This allows us a little bit of flexibility to see how that area is developing, 8
is it going towards the countryside or is it going towards what ever it may be next to? 9
Again, this is, the second poi nt that we had, the parcel-based to broad paint. The pros 10
and cons that we identified. I don’t know if you guys want me t o go back through these? 11
Basically it just gives us, it’s better at capturing the rural versus growth structures as far 12
as the character area framework, flexibility across large areas , clear guidance when 13
rezoning to capital projects. Those are some of the reasons tha t we identified. So this is 14
the far out scale that you can see how they changed in that res pect of the hard lines of 15
the parcel-based map to the broad paint. But if y’all would lik e to ask questions at this 16
point with this section y’all can cause I know, I’m pretty sure Yonke had some questions. 17
CHAIRMAN YONKE: I just wanted to look at the map publicly in detail. 18
MR. SMITH: Okay. Yep, and we can come back to that when we go through it all. 19
So this was a small detail t hat needed to be changed, the Hards crabble, Farrow Road 20
[inaudible] corridor. So we had proposed getting rid of the Har dscrabble portion of it and 21
make it – sorry that should’ve been the other way around, I apologize. So it changed from 22
US 21 - is that right? Yep, it changed from Hardscrabble Road, Farrow Road innovation 23
57
center to US 21 Farrow Road. So we got rid of the Hardscrabble which is a, just a 1
oversight that we just had to identify the area appropriately. Next big item was the place 2
type details. In the 2015 plan we have a lotta guidance that we use not only in our Staff 3
Reports but as we look at these areas and what their intended purposes are. In the 2025 4
plan the guidance that we got in the original draft was sparse, it was singled out to single 5
paragraphs. So we felt that we needed to expand upon those desi gnations. This is what 6
it looks like, one of the pages looks like now where we get mor e guidance, policy 7
guidance, typical uses, you know, transportation, street types, connectivity, things of that 8
nature. So all of those different designations now have this expansion of land use types. 9
The other thing that was point out to us was the donut hole designations or the donut hole 10
future land use items. And those are something that we’re continuing to identify and look 11
into cause we know that there’s still some things that we’ve seen tonight was an oversight 12
that we’ll take care of our side when we get back with our consultants. So this was taken 13
care of and you can see how the map changed from there to there. I can show you what 14
it looked like, what it looks like now. We had gotten rid of th e direct alignment table. We 15
felt like this was a little t oo hard lined and didn’t give us t he flexibility that we needed, 16
especially in areas that do develop in a way that we need them to or we wanted areas to 17
have some contextual flexibility if we saw that, you know, an R C might fit somewhere 18
where it normally wouldn’t becau se of the current development p atterns. And so again 19
these are the changes that were made and I’ll take any questions at this time. 20
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Let’s line him up with a bunch of questions. He’s been sitting 21
there all night, he’s been excited about this part. 22
MR. SMITH: So excited. 23
58
CHAIRMAN YONKE: I would like us all to be able to surround this new Comp Plan 1
and say yes that, you know, we like it, so if we don’t feel that way, what’s holding us back? 2
Is there any more work we need to ask Staff to do? 3
MR. GRADY: Mr. Chair? 4
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Yes, Commissioner Grady? 5
MR. GRADY: So I definitely still have some concerns and I articulated this to some 6
degree in February. And while ther e was a public meeting the pu blic was not there so I 7
will restate some of my concerns here. So when I look at the, t he text of the plan there’s 8
a lot of discussion about environm entally sustainable developme nt, about facilitating 9
development that is compatible with non-car ways of getting around that is, you know, a 10
particular emphasis on mixed use development, a particular emphasis on a more, I guess 11
you could say for development going [inaudible]. And the conce rn that I have is that all 12
of that is said in the text but w hen it comes down to what are the changes in the future 13
land use map from the 2015 editi on to this version that is in f ront of us to consider, it 14
seems like the main change is that it would essentially facilitate more of the kinds of land 15
use that we have heard so many concerns about in this chamber s ince I’ve been the 16
Commission since 2020; and that is people are upset about their rural areas being 17
consumed by, by sprawl style development for lack of a better term. They’re upset about 18
traffic congestion. And they’re upset about sort of this, this general sense of sameness I 19
guess you could say. And I feel like this proposed future land use map essentially doubles 20
down on the strategy that we’ve seen in the past 10 years. And I think that facilitating a 21
more of the same when we’ve already seen from the public that t here is substantial 22
concern about the pattern of dev elopment that this county has p ursued in recent years, 23
59
and you know, and our role as, as people who have an expertise in, in community 1
planning, I think that there’s an obligation for us to think ab out some of these broader 2
trends. You know, one thing I would note is that when you look at development in Richland 3
County, in South Carolina as a whole, we have built an extremely high number of single-4
family homes per capita. We have met the demand in large measure for people who want 5
to live in a single-family home. Richland County, however, has a lot of renters, it has a lot 6
of people who, whether they’re a ffiliated with the University o r Fort Jackson or their 7
institutional facilities, we hav e not created development in a manner that fully 8
accommodates the growth that we’ve seen in that population as well. So I think I definitely 9
have concerns about sort of the c ontinued premise of single-family development and of 10
the, sort of the thesis that thi s bakes in that we’ve seen the northeast part of the county 11
which has more or less developed to largely single-family devel opment and there have 12
been obviously lots of fights that we’ve seen on that front. I feel like this essentially takes 13
the north central part of the county and says, well we’re gonna have more of that. And 14
that concerns me. So that’s sor ta where my heads at of, of this mismatch between the 15
map and the priorities that were articulated in the text of the plan and, you know, knowing 16
how we evaluate zoning map amendment requests, you know, we’re looking at the future 17
land use map, that is often the primary mechanism and I feel li ke if there’s a conflict 18
between the map and the text, in the future our successors on the Planning Commission 19
will, will gravitate toward the map and that I think would be a decision for the worst. So 20
that’s in broad strokes my concern with the document as it’s been prepared. 21
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Thank you, Commissi oner Grady. Good points. Sta ff, 22
thoughts? 23
60
MS. WILLIAMS: Yes, Thank you. I’m Synithia Williams, Director o f Community 1
Planning and Development. One thing I’d like to point out with the maps, so in phase 2 of 2
public comment is when we went out to the public with different land use scenarios and 3
we asked the public to kinda give us their feedback on how they wanted to see the county 4
grow over the next 10 to 15 year s. Scenario A was just growing as is, keeping what we 5
had in the 2015 Comprehensive Plan . Scenario B was looking at m ore compact 6
development, encouraging more growth towards the municipal boun daries. Towards 7
those city centers and where we a lready had infrastructure. And Scenario B [sic] was a 8
more conservation type approach where we conserve a lot more land area and sensitive 9
space. And so based off the surveys and the feedback from that phase 2 of public 10
comment, this is the map that c ame out, that we heard from the public. And it’s kinda a 11
mixture of Scenario B and C where you have, you do see the residential because we are 12
growing, we know more people are coming. But that residential g rowth and that mixed 13
use growth and commercial growth is concentrated where we curre ntly have 14
infrastructure, closer to the city centers, municipal boundaries, so that we’re not sprawling 15
out. If you look at the outer edges of the county on this map y ou see there’s still a lot of 16
that agricultural, open space, c ountryside. And we even took ci tizen feedback to add 17
additional countryside area based off that citizen feedback. As far as the text, the map is 18
just visualization, it’s a guiding document of how we wanna see growth but the text also 19
is guiding Council policy decisions outside of just the Land De velopment Code. And our 20
County Council had a work session on this during that strategic session to see what some 21
of the recommendations are in the text and to get their feedbac k. And County Council is 22
very willing to make sure that t he Comprehensive Plan aligns wi th their strategic goals, 23
61
and looking at implementation of other areas of the Comprehensive Plan, not just making 1
it we’re only looking at the Comp Plan when a zoning request comes through; what other 2
policy decisions do we need to take into consideration, what ot her ordinances does the 3
county need to put into place, making sure the different departments are working together. 4
We’re in Planning and Development but we don’t control penny ta x and transportation. 5
So how can we make sure that what the penny tax and the Transpo rtation does is in 6
alliance with the recommendations in the Comprehensive Plan? An d currently we have 7
Council support to make sure that we get the rest of the depart ments to also look at the 8
Comprehensive Plan and make sure their plans are in alignment. S o w h i l e I d o 9
understand the concerns County Council is realizing that this i s not just a document for 10
when we have rezone requests, that we have to look at it holist ically across all county 11
departments. 12
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Thank you. 13
MR. DUFFY: Can I ask a question just off of – 14
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Commissioner Duffy. 15
MR. DUFFY: - just on what Commissioner Grady said and mentioned there. He 16
made some important points on the feedback we’ve had from publi c and, you know, 17
doubling down on some of the mistakes of the past. And I’m just curious, and you know, 18
we’ve had a lot public input, has there been developer input an d builder input into the 19
Comprehensive Plan, and how much have their weighed in on the process? 20
MS. WILLIAMS: Yes. So we had seven stakeholder meetings and one of those 21
stakeholders did include realtors and developers as well. So just to touch on the different 22
public, we had an advisory committee that was created by County Council, the met four 23
62
times on all the different rec ommendations before each public p hase went out for the 1
public input. Seven stakeholders, 18 public meetings, multiple town halls by County 2
Council Members, along with the surveys and the project website where we got feedback 3
from the public, along with the separate workshops we had with Planning Commission 4
and County Council. So we did try to reach out to as many different stakeholders and as 5
many different parts of the co mmunity. We were around the count y over the past year 6
trying to get as much feedback and in all three phases of this Comp Plan update. 7
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Yes, thank you Staff for that front, like learning from the LDC 8
just getting out there with the public. Any other comments? I do wanna open it up to public 9
input. Ms. Murphy. Was there any one else? Wanted to sign up to speak? Okay Ms. 10
Murphy, gotcha. You have your two minutes. 11
TESTIMONY OF KIM MURPHY: 12
MS. MURPHY: Thank you. Kim Mu rphy, 154 Old Laurel Lane, Chapi n, South 13
Carolina. And Mr. Grady, thank you so much for your comments. A ll that was in the 14
Agenda was a resolution to approve the packet, or approve the map. There was no map 15
in there. We don’t know what you were going to approve. It does say action. And I’m 16
wondering if you might be able to tell me when this meeting was, there was a presentation 17
that Mr. Smith had up on the screen. If I can get a copy of that, that would be helpful. And 18
I’m sorry I missed the February meeting. Our recommendations don’t, aren’t on the plan. 19
Mr. Smith sent us the map on the 8th and I had an opportunity just to review the map, not 20
the text of it. What would be very helpful is to see the current map and the proposed map 21
side by side so we can see the changes more readily. But again our recommendations 22
don’t seem to be included, which is to preserve more of the agriculture area and especially 23
63
around the creeks and other waterways and not just have a setback but provide areas to, 1
that would limit development ar ound there. And it would be help ful showing, I think 2
information that was sent out in the email on the 8th was not a redline document, it would 3
be helpful to see the redline doc ument as well if that’s availa ble. And I’m sure I’ll have 4
some other comments once I can see more information but I sure do appreciate your hard 5
work on this, thank you. 6
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Thank you. Come on down. I’m making my own sig nup 7
sheet to give to Staff. State your name slowly and address so I can write it. 8
TESTIMONY OF KATHY YOUNG: 9
MS. YOUNG: Okay. Kathy – 10
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Thank you. 11
MS. YOUNG: Young. 12
CHAIRMAN YONKE: An easy one, I like it. 13
MS. YOUNG: Easy. 1629 Cedar Creek Road, Blythewood, South Carolina. Okay. 14
I wanna thank all of you and especially the Planning Staff for all of the work that has gone 15
in to this plan. It’s a pretty amazing iterative process that we have a lot of people from 16
our community take place, or take part in every single step of it. And we always felt like 17
we were heard and that somethi ng was done based on what we said . Was it always 18
exactly what we wanted? Not quit e, but it was, we heard and the re was something that 19
was done. The way I view this is this is the first step in a pr ocess that will take the next 20
10 years before we do this process again. It’s up to you guys a nd really up to County 21
Council to do the sorts of things that Commissioner Grady is talking about, which is taking 22
this bare bones and continuing to iterate it and change it as i s needed over time. Again, 23
64
this is really a thanks to all of you for what you’ve done for the county and I happen to 1
think that it’s going in a really good direction, so I appreciate it. Thank you. 2
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Thank you so much. Anyone else wanna speak on t his? 3
Okay. Then I’ll close the public input part for this. Okay. Sta ff, do you have some 4
information about the Comprehensive Plan where the public can go get more information 5
online? 6
MR. SMITH: I do. 7
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Alright. 8
MR. SMITH: So we have been working, as Staff we have been working with our IT 9
and public engagement. We just launched our Engage Richland platform on Friday. We’re 10
just now putting this out today to the public. It’s a way for the public to get engaged with 11
the Comp Plan, not just today, not just this year, but for futu re endeavors, future 12
participation. You can view the site at engagerichlandcountysc.gov, that’ll take you where 13
you can view the project, the doc uments associated with it. If you would like to leave 14
comments and participate you’ll have to register with an email of course, but you can view 15
it without putting your email in. It is, right now it is very b are bones, mostly because we 16
have not adopted anything yet so I didn’t want to put too much out there but there is the 17
draft map that you’ve seen tonight, the updated draft for the Comprehensive Plan and the 18
appendix associated with the plan, those are the documents that are associated with it 19
right now. 20
MS. WILLIAMS: And Mr. Chair, if I can jump in. This is the coun ty’s attempt to 21
move the information from the previous Re-imagine Richland webs ite that we had that 22
was hosted by our consultant, and on that website we did have all of the different iterations 23
65
of the draft, all the informati on shown during the public comme nt sessions, the changes 1
from the map by the time it came to Planning Commission, we out lined that, and that 2
information was also emailed out to people who attended those different public meetings 3
that we had, and the stakeholders as well so they would know that it’s on the website and 4
they could go and look at it and give us feedback. So even thou gh we have the 5
engagerichland, I don’t want you to think it just started today ; we’re just moving it from 6
our consultant hosted site to a county hosted site. 7
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Good information. Any other questions, comments? 8
MR. DURANT: Mr. Chair, just one question for Commission Grady. 9
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Commissioner Durant. 10
MR. DURANT: Do I have the right impression that you think that there’s too much 11
single-family development going on in the county? 12
MR. GRADY: So I would say that I am not necessarily suggesting that there is too 13
much single-family development, but what I am suggesting is that what I take into account, 14
honestly my expertise from my previous day job as a housing res earcher, and I think 15
about the goals that are articul ated, specifically on pages 50 and 51 of the draft 16
Comprehensive Plan that I have, when I look at these, this lang uage which I think is, is 17
exactly on point and very thoughtful, you know, when it says he re, you know, there’s, 18
there’s focusing investment in ke y locations, embracing diverse housing options and 19
reducing pressure on rural and undeveloped lands, the main tension I see is that the map 20
does not seem to reflect that s ort of language. It seems that i t is, you know, I’m looking 21
particularly at the S4 area on the draft map, which is essentially as I said the north central 22
portion of the county, which is more or less with very few exceptions covered with a single 23
66
use residential land use. Now it is in many case mixed densities so there is the potential 1
for townhomes and other types of construction, but it fundament ally continues the land 2
use pattern which is the more you have people on residential pr operties without nearby 3
amenities that they can access in a way that does not involve g oing out on a main road 4
and driving several miles to those retail or amenity parcels, y ou know, I think that we’re 5
not really giving this the attention that it deserves. The ambition articulated in those goals 6
does not appear to match what comes out in the map, which overw helmingly is a 7
continuation of the same sort of land use patterns that we’ve s een in recent years. And 8
so when I think about, you know, in there’s equitable access an d connectivity, 9
transportation networks that reduce barriers, promote inclusivi ty and support a dynamic 10
interconnected economy, you know, if you basically say, you hav e to have a car to live 11
here that’s essentially the government putting a tax on you. That is a situation where we 12
are saying you can only live here if you have enough money to b uy a car and gasoline 13
and insurance and the other expenses that are a function of it. So I feel like there’s a need 14
to not only increase the volume of multi-family development but also to rethink the general 15
land use pattern, because if we want to do the things that are articulated in this draft plan 16
there really does have to be a, a different way of thinking abo ut how we organize our 17
development patterns and I’m just not seeing that level of thou ght put into it. And I think 18
that’s not necessarily a, that’s not an indictment on anybody w ho was involved in this 19
plan, neither county staff or oth ers, I’m just seeing a disconn ect here that I feel like 20
certainly needs to be underlines. And so I think that part of it is just the need for a larger 21
amount of multi-family, a larger amount of walkable communities , a larger amount of 22
those sorts of things, and certainly that’s not everybody. Some people want a big house 23
67
on a big lot and Godspeed. I just think we need to serve all of the different types of 1
population that we have in our county which is obviously a very diverse wide gamut. 2
MR. DURANT: Thank you. 3
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Thank you. We need this kind of discussion for every map 4
amendment, this is great. I love it. Cause we are again, I stated this in the beginning, we 5
are volunteers with our time. I enjoy being up here. Staff, go ahead. 6
MS. WILLIAMS: Mr. Chair, and to that point, that’s a very good point, 7
Commissioner Grady. I’d like to also point out S4 is one of those, so we have the priority 8
investment areas which are all the P circles on there, and thos e are areas identified by 9
the Comprehensive Plan where we may have to do separate studies, plans, to figure out 10
how can we redevelop those areas, r evitalize those areas, encourage development. S4 11
is one of the secondary growth a reas. It’s one of the areas whe re we know growth is 12
coming but we need to kind of rethink what that growth looks li ke as it comes to those 13
areas. And so that S4 is one, if you can scroll down to the legend, you see with S4 it talks 14
about this is an area that we need to target for walkable neighborhoods and centers. So 15
this may be changes to the county’s subdivision regulations, maybe other changes to the 16
county’s Land Development Code so that we can see that encouraged. So I understand 17
what you’re saying, the map may not show it specifically but by identifying this area as a 18
secondary growth area we wanna rethink how that area grows so it doesn’t grow just like 19
all of the other subdivisions in the county. That’s gonna be unfortunately how you look at 20
it a little bit of work for the Planning Commission as we prese nt ideas to you all of what 21
we may need to do to change subdivision regulations, and again back to County Council, 22
68
what other policy or decisions they may need to take into consi deration to kinda change 1
how this area grows going forward. 2
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Staff, what do you need from us tonight on this? 3
MS. WILLIAMS: So you have, one option is to, you know, we went through the 4
changes that you all approved back in February, we presented so me ideas, updates to 5
the map. At that February meeting the Commission asked us to go back and make those 6
actual changes to the document so you can see them, which we’ve done. So you have 7
that in front of you now. If y ou feel like you need, wanna look at it, take some more time 8
to review it and then take it up for a vote at your May meeting you have that option. If you 9
feel comfortable tonight you also have the option to recommend the Comprehensive Plan 10
to County Council. But I do point out whether you do that today or you postpone it to May, 11
you have to do it by adopting that resolution. It requires by s tate code that you have to 12
adopt a resolution recommending the Comprehensive Plan to County Council. 13
CHAIRMAN YONKE: And that’s page 58 of our – 14
MS. WILLIAMS: Correct, yes, sir. 15
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Thank you. Commissioner Johnson, did you have 16
something? No? Okay. I would like to make sure we have public input on the Agenda for 17
next month if we decide to defer. And then this would give us and the public more time to 18
engage, engagerichlandcountysc.gov. And then we’ll be able to l ook at the first draft. Is 19
that on there as well? So you can compare the old map? 20
MR. SMITH: No, the first draft is located on our main web page at the 21
Comprehensive Plan, or Comprehensive Planning on the Richland County website. This 22
69
website was developed specifical ly for the separation of the tw o so you can still access 1
the 2015 from our main website, but they’re not gonna be handled the same. 2
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Commissioner Johnson? 3
MR. JOHNSON: Mr. Chairman, question. Well let me make a stateme nt, then a 4
question. I am always a proponent and wanna make sure that we maximize participation. 5
From a consensus standpoint is the majority of the Commission still at unreadiness? 6
CHAIRMAN YONKE: That’s a good question. Can we go around? 7
MR. DURANT: Unreadiness about what? 8
MR. JOHNSON: To move forward with the resolution in our packet. 9
MR. DURANT: Well I thought we were gonna give the public a chan ce to take a 10
look at that resolution and have [inaudible]. 11
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Thank you, Commissioner Durant. Commissioner Duffy? 12
MR. DUFFY: Yeah, can I ask just a question of the Staff for cla rification? If we 13
delay or postpone this decision until next, until May, does the county incur, you know, 14
additional charges from consultants? Just to be good stewards of the taxpayer’s money, 15
or is it a flat fee, are you getting, you know, the longer we d elay taking action are we 16
getting, is the county getting billed thousands of dollars extra per month is my question? 17
MS. WILLIAMS: So we have extende d the contract. If we go past J uly 1, that’s 18
when the contract ends, that’s when we could possibly see addit ional monetary 19
associated with it. If the Commission pushes it to May and make s a recommendation in 20
May, there is still the opport unity for County Council to adopt their ordinance, which is 21
three readings and another public hearing when they do that process and hopefully get it 22
adopted before July 1. 23
70
CHAIRMAN YONKE: I’m gonna borrow Commissioner Johnson’s word, 1
unreadiness. So just from the Commission if we could go around, do we have hesitation 2
or unreadiness. Commissioner Grady spoke, you do have some unre adiness, is there 3
some more changes you would like to see? Are there I mean? 4
MR. GRADY: Mr. Chair, I would say, I would say yes. I would say that I, like I said 5
I think I’m in a position where I, I believe in the good intent ions of everyone involved. I 6
just, I, I see situation where e ssentially inertia gets in the way of implementing the 7
recommendations as articulated. And I, you know, when I look at the map and I see that 8
so much of the county is designated as exclusively a residential area, which necessitates, 9
without radical changes in infrastructure, necessitates long di stance travel by car and, 10
you know, essentially does not m eaningfully implement the recom mendations as 11
articulated, I would say that I h ave, I have concerns and just as we are articulate our 12
dissent in a map amendment case on the Record, I’m more than happy to provide County 13
Council or Staff or anyone else w ho is interested with a more c ogent, less rambling 14
version of what I’ve articulated here. But year, I would say that I, there are some missing 15
pieces here. 16
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Ms. Frierson, looks like you wanted to say something? Thank 17
you, Commissioner Grady. 18
MS. FRIERSON: I too am unready mainly based on the wording of t hat third 19
section of the resolution. You know, it says, you know, we’ve l ooked at the 20
Comprehensive Plan including the text, maps, tables, figures an d the public comment, 21
and we’ve done some of that but i n my opinion we have not done all of that yet. And 22
therefore I’d be uncomfortable with moving forward at this time. 23
71
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Thank you, Commissioner Frierson. Commissioner Taylor? 1
I think I’m hitting everybody. Get ready. 2
MR. TAYLOR: This is a massive amount of information to process and we’ve been 3
processing it for quite a while. I understand the concerns but after a while it gets kinda 4
blurry as to, like even the back and forth on tonight, I understand Commissioner Grady’s 5
concerns and what he articulated, but Ms. Williams’ response almost seems to say, and 6
I know it wasn’t a back and forth or necessarily a rebuttal, bu t that the interpretation of 7
that particular section could’ ve been a little bit off, right, or could lead itself to more 8
interpretation. Personally I’m more apt to, you know, adopt it and push it forward. Pretty 9
soon you can get into that paralysis of analysis and again just having been here to long, 10
some of it you just gotta move with it and, kinda like we’re doing with everything else, you 11
know, we make these corrections along the way, and certainly I don’t think anyone’s intent 12
is to go forward with an incomplete document or a document that does not accomplish 13
the goals that are set forth. But inevitably not everyone’s gon na be pleased with what, 14
with the outcomes, you know, every i can’t be dotted and every t can’t be crossed, it’s 15
just, it’s too massive. I mean, you can try but like I said I’d be more apt – I’m not, I have 16
no problem with public input, you know, at our next meeting, bu t I’m not as apt to hold 17
back and not push it forward to County Council. 18
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Thank you, Comm issioner Taylor. And a quick que stion for 19
Staff as I continue to go down, can you remind me how many publ ic meetings you did 20
have? Cause that is different – I still play the tape of the LDC in my head and how little – 21
we did try – we had to come later on and have the public input here, but you got out in 22
front of this. 23
72
MS. WILLIAMS: That is correct. I, I don’t have the number of to wn hall meetings, 1
it depends on Council Members, but w e had four advisory committ ee meetings, seven 2
stakeholder meetings, 18 public meetings that we held specifically just on the Comp Plan, 3
the town hall meetings we were invited to, the surveys, the pro ject website, and then as 4
– I didn’t include, as you heard from one of the citizens tonig ht, sometimes we went 5
straight to neighborhood groups if they called us to come out and talk to them as well. 6
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Well, we had news coverage for this. 7
MS. WILLIAMS: There was news co verage throughout the process la st year and 8
if you were excited about watchi ng County Council meetings ther e were updates to 9
County Council on the process during the Administrator’s Report several times last year 10
as well. 11
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Alright Commissioner Johnson? I’m going down this way? 12
MR. JOHNSON: Mr. Chairman, I m ean, like Commissioner Taylor I’m ready to 13
move it forward I just want to [inaudible] the pulse of my colleagues. But having said that 14
[inaudible] step with Grady in terms of [inaudible] but the distinction between the projected 15
numbers of growth versus where we ’ve made provision for it. Tha t’s not gonna change 16
[inaudible]. So for that reason I think we need to move forward so that we can continue 17
to [inaudible]. 18
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Thank you, Commissioner Johnson. Commissioner Siercks? 19
MR. SIERCKS: I think generally I’d be ready to move forward. I have a couple 20
questions and more points of clarifications that I think if answered would probably get me 21
even closer to being ready to move forward, the first of which is more of a point of 22
clarification both for myself and the public to the extent that it’s needed. Because it was 23
73
at some point referenced that, you know, on this map, and I may be, I may have misheard 1
or misunderstood, but I believe I heard that, you know, somethi ng to the effect of large 2
swaths of the county are being zoned under this map as resident ial, but if I’m 3
understanding this map as I’m cu rrently seeing it, it’s not nec essarily what’s zoned but 4
there are, the colors denote more of what we would typically se e on the future land use 5
and priority investment areas that this isn’t zoning, this is, you know, akin to, not all of 6
them, but activity center or, y ou know, municipality as it’s la id out on the maps. Is that, 7
am I correct in that? 8
MS. WILLIAMS: Yes, sir, that is correct. 9
MR. SIERCKS: Alright. The second question that I had, and this gets more to the 10
– I forget, the name that it was given, I think bubble or the, the flexible zoning areas. How 11
does that I guess match with what we’re seeing on the map when i t c o m e s t o 12
municipalities? Because the, you know, municipal boundaries are not flexible, and does 13
that, does the map, I mean, cause it looks like what’s on the map as denoted is, you know, 14
city or town limits are considered more with these flexible guidelines. How does that work 15
with the flexible spaces as they’re currently shown? 16
MS. WILLIAMS: So kind of to go ba ck to your previous question, the first map 17
because it was parcel-based it c ould look more like a zoning ma p because it was those 18
hard lines based off of the parce ls. So by going with the more flexible bubble map it 19
doesn’t give you those parcels but what happens here is that wi th the municipal 20
boundaries it still colors in the areas that are part of the municipal boundaries, it just gives 21
us the flexibility where we abut a municipality. So for instanc e as part of this update we 22
did look at other comprehensive plans, what growth patterns the y were trying to 23
74
encourage in their area to try to match our growth pattern to w hat their comp plans say, 1
but by having this more flexible kind of bubble map it gives us that flexibility as, if the 2
municipality boundaries change in the future or if their comp p lans get updated and they 3
change, it gives us a little bit more flexibility to look at that. So it still recognizes that these 4
are municipal boundaries, they don’t change, but because it’s not gonna be that hard line 5
parcel-based it just gives us a l ittle more flexibility from wh at, where we border those 6
municipalities. Does that answer the question? 7
MR. SIERCKS: Yes, ma’am. Thank you. 8
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Thank you, Commissioner Siercks. Commissioner Durant? 9
MR. DURANT: Well I’m sensitive to the idea of kicking the can down the road in 10
pursuit of perfection, but I guess I would have a question for Staff. Are you at a point 11
where you’re ready, you can say comfortably that it’s time to p ush this plan to County 12
Council? Recognizing that it’s the Planning Commission that’s m aking the 13
recommendation, but obviously we’re standing on your shoulders. 14
MS. WILLIAMS: [Inaudible] Jenson would like to answer that question. 15
MR. JENSON: So Mr. Chair, may I be recognized? 16
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Yes. 17
MR. JENSON: Thank you, sir. First of all I wanna say thank you. This is, you have 18
a list of duties and functions that are substantial, and taking this on it just adds to that. So 19
I say thank you. This is the, I forgot, lost count, sixth or se venth comprehensive plan 20
revision that I have shepherded in my career, either as a staff member or as an executive 21
leader for it. And their always difficult, it doesn’t matter. And at the end of the day I hear 22
the exact same comments that I’ve heard here that some folks are, you know, Bruce Lee 23
75
is [inaudible] quoted as saying, perfection is the enemy of goo d or the enemy of done. 1
That’s actually a much older saying but it’s true that at some point you have to kinda just 2
say, we did our best and we’re ready to move on. And I’m not here to tell you that that is 3
tonight or it is not. But what I am here to ask is, if it is n ot tonight please give us very 4
direct, succinct, clear instructions what you need to get to that point so that we can come 5
back in a month and we can bring you, deliver all the information that you require so that 6
we can move forward in a month. So that is all I wanted to shar e. Mr. Price asked if I’d 7
share one other comment which is simply that please remember th at this is not zoning, 8
everything in here is a recomm endation. The rubber hits the roa d when the Planning 9
Commission and the City [sic] Council consider a zoning request. And yes, this absolutely 10
obviously influences those decisions, that’s its purpose. Its p urpose is to say, you know 11
what, when this comes up in the future this is how we intend to act. But it doesn’t mean 12
thou shalt act because there are other factors; there’s timing. We look at the map up there 13
and we see a whole bunch of yellow and we say, tomorrow it’s al l gonna become that, 14
and the answer is, no it’s not because there are always other factors that we have to take 15
into account when we rezone something. So that’s all I wanted to share, thank you. 16
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Thank you. Commissioner Duffy, go ahead. 17
MR. DUFFY: Yeah, I mean, you know, this is some helpful guidance from the, from 18
Staff and the rest of the Commissioners. You know, obviously I’m mindful of there’s been 19
four advisory meetings, and lik e 18 public meetings and a lotta surveys and news 20
coverage around this. I suppose if we were not to move forward on it tonight just based 21
upon the points that were made there, what changes specifically would we wanna 22
request? Like I think we need to be not abstract and be kinda, oh yeah we’d like this or 23
76
that, we need to be like, we need this added on page, you know, what’s the specific ask 1
of the Staff at this point? So i n principle, you know, I’m not opposed to moving forward 2
with it tonight but I just wanna make sure that if there’s dissent or folks on the Commission 3
feel it’s not quite there, like what specifically do we want turned around or improved in the 4
next month, and if we don’t vote tonight can we do it in May an d just, you know, as 5
Commissioner Taylor was saying, just kind of – we’ve been doing this for a while so, and 6
we’ve got a lotta public input so if we can just make a decisio n that would be great. But 7
yes, but more to the group what, what is missing specifically, not in abstract terms, in line 8
by line items if there’s any other major edits from other Commissioners? 9
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Thank you, Commissioner Duffy. Yes, let’s ask that question. 10
Is there anything specifically we can ask the Staff for? 11
MR. GRADY: That is directed at me. 12
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Commissioner Grady and Commissioner Frierson. I want 13
everyone to feel confident about this. 14
MR. GRADY: Yeah. So, so based on what I’ve heard it sounds as though a 15
majority of the Commission is, is in favor of moving forward. And, and it is not my goal to 16
just throwing a spanner in the works for the sake of throwing a spanner in the works. To 17
answer Commissioner Duffy’s question, I think that, I think tha t the, the way to reconcile 18
that concerns that I have would be to, in this future land use map, have a – well first off 19
have a larger share of areas that are mixed use development, be cause if we’re talking 20
about having a, if we’re talking about those broad policy objectives that are articulated in 21
the Comprehensive Plan I think that there is a need to codify n ot just in aspiration but in 22
a physical plan, that we are want ing to do something different, that we are wanting to 23
77
develop in a way that is more sort of pre-World War II in its s patial dimensions and, and 1
reflects these desires to facilitate equitable transportation access that takes into account 2
the desire to have people be in closer proximity to amenities to reduce traffic congestion, 3
to reduce pressure on currently undeveloped or sparsely developed areas on the, further 4
out in the county. So I would say that I would want to see a gr eater number of, of, a 5
greater amount of land that is designated as an activity center or one sort or another and 6
less land that is designated sole ly for, for residential use. A nd I realize that as, as Ms. 7
Williams and others articulated, this is not saying that literally every single building in that 8
area has to be residential, but you know, when you look at it on a map it says residential 9
the default assumption is that that is the, the primary land us e that is there. So, so 10
speaking for myself in terms of this question of how do you rec oncile the text with the 11
map, those are, are broadly s peaking the sorts of changes that I would be interested in, 12
in articulating. As I said if the majority of the Commission wa nts to move forward then 13
we’ll move forward. 14
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Thank you, Commissioner Grady. To piggyback off that, we 15
had our case earlier, that was Ke lly Mill and, is it Hardscrabb le – can we zoom into that 16
part of the map? Cause that was t alking mixed use. In that area , gotcha. Commissioner 17
Grady, you talking about being pr oactive in looking into other areas that could be mixed 18
use, like that one for instance? Or others? 19
MR. GRADY: You know, I hesitate to draw a direct connection bet ween the 20
Comprehensive Plan and the case t hat we reviewed, but certainly that was an example 21
of an area where, you know, as I was looking at the map I was looking at the subdivisions 22
around it, I was looking at the parcel in question, and I could see where if you added some 23
78
sidewalks and some other infrastructure it could materialize into the sort of area that the, 1
the Comprehensive Plan indicates that there is an interest in d eveloping more of. But I 2
think as we heard there was sort of concern, you know, is this leapfrog development as 3
well. I think at some point if you’re going to develop in a con scientious way sometimes 4
you do have to build something beyond the edge of the, the curr ent developed area to 5
ensure that it materializes into the sort of community that ref lects the values that are 6
articulated by this plan and by extension our elected officials and the public. 7
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Thank you, Commissioner Grady. Commissioner Frierson? 8
MS. FRIERSON: Are we supposed to consider the Land Development Code and 9
the Comprehensive Plan as two separate entities? 10
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Tonight on our Agenda? 11
MS. FRIERSON: No, this is what I mean. You know, like tonight w hen we got to 12
Item 6., Mr. Price, you know, started the presentation and we a greed to defer it till June. 13
And now we’re looking at whether or not we’re going to move for ward with a resolution 14
for adoption or moving forward with the Comprehensive Plan. Wha t I’m trying to figure 15
out, are we supposed to be considering the Land Development Cod e as part of the 16
Comprehensive Plan? 17
CHAIRMAN YONKE: We just said we ’re gonna look at those separate ly. We 18
wanted to work on the Comprehensive Plan and get that finalized for Council and then go 19
back – Mr. Price had reasoning. Staff, can you elaborate? Yes? 20
MS. FRIERSON: See, this is what I mean. When we finish it is th e Land 21
Development Code a part of the Comprehensive Plan? 22
CHAIRMAN YONKE: I believe they work hand in hand as they have always. 23
79
MS. FRIERSON: Okay. Well see that’s what I mean by it’s not that I’m opposed to, 1
you know, saying let’s move on down the road, but how can we in good conscience do 2
that when we really haven’t done all the work that we’re suppos ed to be doing with the 3
things that we said we’re doing? If we’re gonna defer part of i t till June, how can we say 4
now in, what’s this, April that let’s just go on down the road and say we’ve adopted this 5
as where we wanna go? We haven’t even heard it all yet. You see what I mean? 6
CHAIRMAN YONKE: I understand it a s the difference, one of the c hanges they 7
made here for the map that it’s now they’re looking at it parcel-based or broad paint brush 8
based. If we’re gonna look at this parcel-based then I absolutely agree with you. Looking 9
at number 6 on the Agenda, the Land Development Code, understanding our commercial 10
zones better, getting that lined up, that’s spot on. But since the map we just, we moved it 11
to more of the bubble based giving us more flexibility, or givi ng future Planning 12
Commissions the flexibility to look at it, it makes me a little bit more ready to move forward 13
as well. 14
MS. WILLIAMS: Mr. Chair? 15
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Yeah, go ahead Staff. 16
MS. WILLIAMS: Can I also touch on that, too? So the Comprehensi ve Plan is a 17
non-regulatory guidance document. So it is just a guide, it is a visualization of how we 18
want the county to grow. So ther e’s no regulatory ties to what is in this. The way the 19
Comprehensive Plan is impleme nted is through regulation, and pa rt of that is the Land 20
Development Code. So typically you see an entity will update th eir comp plan and then 21
they’ll revise their land development code based off of what we ’ve put into the 22
comprehensive plan. So that’s one of the reasons why before we update zoning 23
80
classifications, how do we want the county to grow? Do we agree with this guidance 1
document of what a mixed use activity center should look like, of what a suburban 2
residential area should look like? If we agree on that in the g uidance document then we 3
do that through regulation by updat ing those zoning designation s in the Land 4
Development Code. So that is the reason why Deputy Director Pri c e m a d e t h e 5
recommendation of, before we start making zoning changes let’s make sure our guiding 6
document is what we all agree upon. And so if you look at, so f or instance if we wanna 7
add additional mixed use activity centers to the map, one of th e things that we talked 8
about in February was giving more definition of what a mixed us e activity center should 9
look like, not just for now but when we go to a five year updat e or we see, you know, 10
another thing happens in the co unty and it changes and we reali ze this corridor should 11
be a mixed use activity center, we may have to update the futur e land use map. But this 12
is kind of like that additional policy guidance of where do mixed use activity centers belong 13
in the county and what should we take into consideration if a rezoning request potentially 14
comes up in an area that may or may not be a mixed use activity center; does it also meet 15
these additional policy guidance, the typical uses and building s we would wanna see, 16
what transportation network is around there. So that’s the othe r reason why back in 17
February we talked about, we need more details on what these land uses would look like 18
and how we would determine if an area of the map, if the land use needs to change going 19
forward. Does that help, Commissioner Frierson? 20
MS. FRIERSON: I understand. It seem s like the big, big picture is the 21
Comprehensive Plan and then we c an go back and refine it by fin e tuning the Land 22
Development. 23
81
MS. WILLIAMS: That’s exactly right, yes, ma’am. 1
MS. FRIERSON: But see for me my problem is the wording, it’s saying that we’ve 2
looked at all of this already and we really haven’t. And I unde rstand people say at some 3
point you have to move forward, but it just doesn’t make sense to me when we’re saying 4
we’re going to look at it in more detail, this land development part, which is gonna be a 5
portion of it, I think that we really should do that first. That’s just how I look at it. 6
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Thank you, Commissioner Frierson. Any more thoughts? 7
MR. DUFFY: Yeah, just to add. My understanding, and please corr ect me if I’m 8
wrong, Chair, is that Councilman Branham was very involved in the rewriting of the LDC 9
a few years ago or can you just maybe tell us that or you all d id make, you revised the 10
Land Development Code in the last number of years, is that not correct? 11
CHAIRMAN YONKE: As a Planning Co mmission we did with the help o f Mr. 12
Jenson. We had it approved. We were working on a lot of this d uring covid and we had 13
to take it – what was the analogy you always said, take it off the shelf or put it on the shelf, 14
something like that. And then we did, we, we reworked everythin g. And I’ll let him 15
elaborate, go ahead. 16
MR. JENSON: It’ll take me longer to get to the podium than it w ill to share this. 17
Very simply, it took us seven years to adopt the last Land Deve lopment Code revision. 18
We started immediately following adoption of the Comprehensive Plan update in 2015 or 19
‘14. It just took that long. So t he reality is, yeah we’re gonn a have to start updating the 20
Land Development Code again in thr ee months after Council adopt s this Comp Plan. It 21
just, that’s just, that’s how it works. 22
82
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Thank you. Okay, so Commission unless we’re gon na ask 1
for anything specific from Staff I think it’d be fair for us to make a motion and vote. Is that 2
concerning to anybody? Okay. I’m gonna do it. The Chair makes a motion to approve the 3
resolution, page 58 of our packet. Before I finish that, Commis sioner Frierson, is there 4
any terminology we would like to strike out? 5
MS. FRIERSON: No, it’s just that I don’t think we’re being true to what we’re saying 6
that we’ve looked at, you know, the maps and so forth cause we haven’t finished, that’s 7
all. So. It won’t be a unanimous vote but, you know, I’m bold enough to stick to my guns. 8
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Commissioner Frier son, I agree with you. As of February 9
when Staff came to us and said, we had a couple areas of the map we needed to update, 10
I was like, no I don’t wanna send an unfinished document to County Council. We needed 11
to continue to look at this until we [inaudible] about it. I feel like we asked to see specific 12
changes, you made those changes. I understand, as far as I unde rstand them I agree 13
with them. I, that’s why I’m ready to go ahead, I’m gonna finis h it. The Chair makes a 14
motion to approve the resolution on page 58 of our packet as it ’s written. Do I have a 15
second? 16
MR. DURANT: Second. 17
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Got a second from Commissioner Durant. Alright, this is for 18
the Comprehensive Plan, resolut ion on page 58. We have a motion for approval, 19
acceptance, and a second. So Staff, go ahead and take a vote. 20
MR. DELAGE: Grady? 21
MR. GRADY: No. 22
MR. DELAGE: Siercks? 23
83
MS. SIERCKS: Aye. 1
MR. DELAGE: Taylor? 2
MR. TAYLOR: Aye. 3
MR. DELAGE: Durant? 4
MR. DURANT: Aye. 5
MR. DELAGE: Duffy? 6
MR. DUFFY: Aye. 7
MR. DELAGE: Johnson? 8
MR. JOHNSON: Aye. 9
MR. DELAGE: Frierson? 10
MS. FRIERSON: Nay. 11
MR. DELAGE: Yonke? 12
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Aye. 13
MR. DELAGE: Motion passes. 14
[Approved: Siercks, Taylor, Duffy, Durant, Johnson, Yonke; Opposed: Grady, Frierson; 15
Absent: Loyd] 16
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Okay, we just accepted the resolution of the Comprehensive 17
Plan and moved it over to County Council for their next meeting . And Staff, could you 18
explain their schedule? 19
MS. WILLIAMS: Yes, because the wa y Council’s scheduling has wor ked out this 20
won’t appear until their meeting in May, I have to look at the calendar, cause they meet 21
tomorrow and obviously it won’t be on tomorrow’s agenda, and then they meet the week 22
after for their compressed schedule. So their first meeting of May is when first reading will 23
84
happen. And then we’ll work with them to have, their clerk will schedule the three readings 1
and a public hearing related to that. I don’t have it right in front of me but a schedule of 2
proposed timeline will be presented to them tomorrow based off o f t h e P l a n n i n g 3
Commission approved the Comprehensive Plan going forward in May. 4
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Okay, we got a couple here, Commissioner Johnso n, you 5
had your hand up? You’re gonna defer? 6
MR. JOHNSON: I’ll defer. 7
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Okay. Commissioner Durant? 8
MR. DURANT: We need to sign this, correct? 9
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Staff, is that true? 10
MS. WILLIAMS: Yes, in order for me to submit it for the May Agenda. 11
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Okay. 12
MS. WILLIAMS: And we can get it – 13
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Do you have a nice clean one for me tonight to sign? 14
MS. WILLIAMS: - we can get one together for you tonight to sign. 15
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Okay. Alright, thank you. 16
MR. DUFFY: Chair? 17
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Yes, Commissioner Duffy. 18
MR. DUFFY: I was just gonna add I think this gives the Council, who are obviously 19
elected, more time to make this, you know, to work through this process before the 20
contract needs to be extended or additional monies of taxpayer funds need to be used 21
past July 1. So I think from that standpoint as well it makes, from the economic standpoint 22
it’s prudent that we’re moving forward based upon information presented to us tonight. 23
85
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Yes, Commissioner Duffy. And Commissioner Johns on, 1
right? 2
MR. DUFFY: Yes, sir. 3
MR. JOHNSON: Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Staff, I don’t throw a rock [inaudible] a 4
question, as we go through our meetings and you have the planning maps pulled up and 5
we’re looking [inaudible] properties on those maps, it’s difficult for me sometimes looking 6
for a specific property or parcel to see exactly where it falls . And I know y’all highlight 7
where it is. When we looked at those maps [inaudible] the same issue, so my question is, 8
once this is finally adopted [inaudible] will this be searchabl e? Can we, can those 9
[inaudible] the planning maps and those bubble maps be implemen ted in a way, I know 10
we have some GIS folks here as well, but that we can actually s earch [inaudible] 11
specificity by address or parcel number to see exactly where we [inaudible]? 12
MR. SMITH: Yeah, so that was part of the process as we were go ing to add a 13
layer to our GIS that would put an overlay of the Comprehensive Plan map. 14
MR. JOHNSON: Thank you. 15
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Thank you. I’ve been wanting that for years. The old FLUM 16
map, thank you, of the GIS [inaudible]. 17
MR. JOHNSON: If I was in a community meeting I’d say that’d be a good place for 18
a hand clap. 19
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Any other comm ents on this side? Could you, Sta ff, take 20
some of the notes from this mee ting and make sure County Counci l gets the approval 21
and the dissenting and kind of where we’re at? 22
86
MS. WILLIAMS: Yes, I’ll be updating the Council briefing document and you won’t 1
approve the Minutes before they have that first meeting but I will summarize based off of 2
the discussion tonight what was discussed here and put it in an update for County Council 3
for their first reading. And then they should be able to have y our meetings by the time 4
they get to their second reading, or meeting Minutes that are a pproved by the second 5
meeting. 6
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Okay. Big thank you, Commission and Staff on this one. Can 7
we go ahead and move on to number 8 on our Agenda. Gonna do that. That’s Chairman’s 8
Report. And I just did it, thank you because you’re awesome. Appreciate your time tonight 9
and every month that we get toget her. So moving on we can go on to number 9., that’s 10
Planning Director’s Report. 11
MS. WILLIAMS: You have in your packet the results of the March 24th Zoning 12
Public Hearing, that’s for your information. And then also you have for your information 13
as well the Development Review Team Report. It’s something that w a s p r e v i o u s l y i n 14
Planning Commission packets but now we just decided we would li ke to also give you 15
that information on where we are as far as new development in the county. The goal is to 16
try to get this report to you for information either quarterly or twice a year. But that way 17
you can see where different things are in development because y ou do hear a lot about 18
the development happening in the county and this is just to give you some information on 19
what’s been, where things are in the process. 20
CHAIRMAN YONKE: What are our roles with this list? Is there anything we can do 21
if we see anything concerning? 22
87
MS. WILLIAMS: Well, these projec ts do not require approval by P lanning 1
Commission or County Council, it’s just again for your information of what developments 2
are coming in. 3
CHAIRMAN YONKE: The public heard that, Planning Commission cann ot do 4
anything about these subdivisions, they’ve already been approved. Okay. Gotcha. Is that 5
for the Planning Director’s Report? 6
MS. WILLIAMS: That concludes my report, sorry. Thank you. 7
CHAIRMAN YONKE: Okay, and then we can go to number 10 which is 8
Adjournment and I see Ms. Murphy out there already raising her hand for adjournment, 9
that’s usually how we do it. We’ll talk after the meeting. 10
MS. MURPHY: [Inaudible] 11
CHAIRMAN YONKE: That’s the Development Review Team Report that we were 12
just discussing. Yes. That’s what Ms. Williams just showed us. 13
MS. MURPHY: [Inaudible] 14
CHAIRMAN YONKE: No, that’s not on there as an action and we’re not gonna do 15
the back and forth style, we’re gonna stick to procedural Ms. Murphy, please. Thank you. 16
Alright 10., Adjournment. I’m gonna do this by way of hands. Alright. 17
[Approved: Taylor, Grady, Frierson, Yonke, Johnson, Siercks, Duffy, Durant; Absent: 18
Loyd] 19
MR. DELAGE: It is unanimous. 20
CHAIRMAN YONKE: That’s a unanimous. Thank you so much, we are adjourned. 21
22
[Meeting adjourned at 9:00pm] 23
Source: Richland County website. First collected Oct 15, 2026.