RecordWell Data

_07292026-1485

Town of Surfside Beach · Horry County · meeting of Jul 29, 2026 · Minutes

Open the original document More from Town of Surfside Beach

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

TOWN OF SURFSIDE BEACH 829 Pine Drive Surfside Beach, SC 29575 (843) 913-6111 (843) 238-5432 TOWN COUNCIL WORKSHOP MEETING July 29 , 202 6 , 4 :00 P .M. 1. CALL TO ORDER : Mayor K ro u se ca lle d th e m e e tin g to o rd e r a t 4 :0 0 P M . P re se n t: C o u n cilm e m b e rs S ta m e y, W a lls, F a llo n , K o h lm a n n , La w h o rn , a n d H ia tt. A lso p re se n t: T o w n C le rk M e d in a , S to rm w a te r C o m m itte e m e m b e rs a n d P la n n in g C o m m issio n m e m b e rs. 2. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE Mayor Krouse led the Pledge of Allegiance. 3. PUBLIC COMMENT A. Ken Podroza: I'm a member of the stormwater committee. This draft proposal that we're discussing tonight is much improved over versions we've seen in the past. I appreciate that. The comments today, this time around, will highlight some of the major concerns I have regarding this regulation. I'll be emailing the comments. Overall, when you look at the proposal and intent of this regulation, as it's written, it is to protect and replenish trees. Therefore, when I look at the elements, I always ask : does this regulation do that ? If I look at Table 17 -71 -3, it indicates that the post -regulation only requires a minimum number of trees or diameter by lot size. And if we do that — only do “or ”— then what we're going to do is have a significant reduction of the number of trees and tree canopy in our community. So, I recommend using the word “and ” and modifying the minimum number of trees required, the minimum total diameter, and the total number of lot sizes. So, I would recommend that we have a total number of lot sizes of only four, which really then only changes bar one or two areas to square -foot areas for the minimum number of trees. I would change that to eight being the minimum number of trees within the lots for today. We have 10 in your proposal, and for a minimum cumulative diameter, I would say 66 inches, as opposed to the current proposed regulation of 80. So, these two changes for this particular area really only impact the R -1 zone. So, with regard to replacement trees, it's in the definition of a few other places. Replacement trees must be purchased at a two -inch minimum DBH , as stated in another section center. But when you go to a nursery and want to actually buy a tree, you don't buy the DBH — you buy a caliper. The caliper is measured at 2 to 18 inches as opposed to 4½ feet, and so that's definitely a very different kind of tree. And so, my recommendation is for the caliper and then change the requirements. Replacement trees and qualifying trees — so within those sections we can talk about palm trees. So, I would recommend counting only two palmetto trees or palm trees as the maximum number of trees in any lot size, with a total diameter of 12 inches used to meet the requirements. Otherwise, our community is going to be filled with only palm trees, and canopy will be lost — a significant reduction in water absorption, which will then have more potential flooding. When we look at qualifying trees, replacement trees, protected trees, landmark trees, lots of different kinds of trees, it's a little hard to follow in this particular proposed regulation. I would propose clarifying that, maybe in a chart, to make it really clear. Regarding removing trees within ten feet of an existing building footprint, or driveway, or a pool, I wouldn't recommend having required visual damage to a building, driveway, or some other area like that before it can be removed. And another recommendation is to consult an arborist for options, because you don't always have to remove trees. You can easily do some root control cutting. You can maintain the tree and not have to cut the tree up. As far as mitigation options — tree replacement mitigation — in that particular area in the ordinance, it says to satisfy the minimum when the replacement is not feasible or preferred by the homeowner, the property owner has the option of mitigation instead of payment. So what this says is if you're willing to pay as a homeowner, you can put every tree down and just pay money. So our community will have no trees in their lots. I think it has to get changed. I think you have to get rid of the word “preferred ” and add words like “not feasible, ” with mitigation the only option, as determined by an arborist. There are a lot of different trees you can plant. And with regard to emergencies, if it's an imminent or emergency event, I would recommend changing that to adding damaged trees — a damaged tree — so that it has to be damaged , going to take down , and you have to have pictures to show that because this is in times we're not going to get the approval things coming out. I just think it's really important to do that. Last thing is protective fencing. You're asking to go on the drip line of a tree. That's not practical or feasible. I would recommend five feet away from the tree trunk. That would circle the tree . That's at least practical. B. Yvette Hellyer , We live in a wonderful town. We count our blessings by the people, resources, and the beauty that surrounds us, from the beach, the theater, the climate, the environment. The beach attracts many visitors. The number one attraction is our magnificent trees. It ’s what attracts people. It draws them here. It makes them want to move here. And we are only two square miles. They transform us in a way that there ’s no other part of the Grand Strand that does this. It ’s our civic duty and job as residents to take care of them. I agree with my colleague and president right here. The draft that we reviewed today has made a lot of improvements. We see a lot of great things have been added from the previous January and June drafts. I ’m also, like him, going to provide you with the total comments I have in writing following this meeting. My main concern overall for this ordinance is that the regulations that have been set up for different trees we deal with — invasive, nuisance, landmark, qualifying, protected, and replacement — are being set up to essentially create a dynamic shifting of Surfside Beach ’s polyculture urban forest toward that of a monoculture, a single type or tree species, that makes this environment different. Surfside Beach has an ecosystem that supports an urban forest that includes a variety of oaks, pines, and many other greens, especially the cypress tree. It ’s this diversity that should be protected with these regulations by including both hardwood and softwood trees. It ’s this diversity that gives our trees their unique appearance, benefits, and appeal. By eventually creating a monocultural urban forest, we stand to lose many of these trees and the look of our town. We have to create stewardship that safeguards them as our precious natural resources. I only want to touch upon a few of the texts within the body of the document. Under invasive and nuisance species, those are two different types of trees by definition. In the chart, common bamboo is not a tree, so it really shouldn ’t be moved. It ’s part of the grass family. Privet is listed. Privet is a shrub. There is a privet that grows to a tree form that should be substituted for tree privet and blossom privet. Landmark trees are listed but are defined to include oaks. Should be — I ’m sorry — should be defined to include oaks and evergreens. Oaks are the hardwood. Evergreens are everything else — conifers first. Firs, pines, everything else that this place has. Limiting landmark tree species to just two types of oaks and one cypress would reduce our biodiversity and lessen our ecosystem in greater numbers. The list should also include the native longleaf pine. That is the pine that South Carolina researchers are trying to replace. It has a very vital, highly diversified keystone role in the ecosystem that resists extreme weather, such as drought, prevents catastrophic fires, and supports the endangered wildlife in the state. Qualifying trees are out of order. They need to come after the Ps — this is a minor point. They ’re only including non -invasive trees. This is also an important consideration because we have to include — not take that back — it should not include. It should also not include top trees. Dogwoods. Great, great murals. Your palms next. My question about palms: calling palms trees is not a good idea. Palms are not trees. They are related to grasses. They don ’t make true wood. Their trunks do not grow growth rings. By allowing palms to fall to become qualifying trees, we lower the canopy volume and the cooling effects that real trees provide. Palms do not sprout from seed; they have to be purchased from a nursery. They should be considered ornamental, and if we have to have any regulations regarding palms, it should be in the landscape section of the regulations. Protected trees you list only as non -invasive hardwoods — what about the softwoods? Thank you. C. Dixie Button , I'm Dixie Button. I live at 411 Fifth Avenue North. I had a couple of little questions that, as a homeowner, were a little bit confusing to me. Let's talk about the number of trees versus the total DBH. When I read this, it looks to me like you could have one huge tree and you'd be good because you'd meet the DBH requirement. Or you could have a hundred little saplings, and if you added it all up, you could like see it. So anyway, I just thought I'd point that out. And then another thing, and this is just a personal observation, the enforcement on the business license revocation of a tree company that removes unauthorized freedom or whatever. The first time they do that, you're automatically getting rid of their — removing their business license and reporting them to all these licensing agencies and all this sort of thing. I thought it was a little bit harsh, but that's a personal opinion. Maybe that's what we need. I don't know, but I would suggest maybe giving them a warning. Sometimes it's just a natural mistake. Maybe they didn't know the ordinance had passed yet. I don't know. But as I said, that was just the first thing. And then the thing about weekend police enforcement — somebody's got to do it. Like, so you have to fix the problem. Works 24/7. But just because they don't have a permit showing, I mean, I don't know if we do permits electronically or not, but lots of places do. So I mean, then maybe they should print it out and put it on something — their permit on their tree or whatever, the post they have out there. I mean, the wind blew it off or something like that, and the homeowner's not home for the police to question them, so they put a stop -work order on it. So the officers don't always have up -to -date information, so I would suggest making it a temporary stop -work order rather than, you know, however it's worded there. But on stop -work orders, the ordinance establishes fixed stop -work periods ranging from 30 to 120 days. I'm asking to reconsider this a little bit, because some violations probably could be corrected within a day. But their stop -work is for 30 days, even though they corrected it within that first day. So I would think that maybe change the wording that the stop -work order would remain in effect until the violation has been corrected or something like that, or compliance has been demonstrated. And then mitigation — the payment formula — and this is just, I guess because of my background, you talk about, let's see here, written up this, for example: a 10 -inch DBH tree, the payment is $10, or for a 20 -inch DBH tree, the payment is $20. I think you mean per inch of DBH. Otherwise, I mean, $10 — I got $10 in my purse right now — I'm going to do no kind of thing. So I mean, that's just, that's just a little something or another. You need, you know, a better multiplier, I suppose. And then on the five-year survival — we require them to do replacement trees. But I think the ordinance should spell out more clearly about when inspection intervals will take place, who will do it, what's the responsibility for documenting survival, what constitutes proof of survival, the time you're going to give them to replace a dead tree, and who determines whether that tree has really died or not. Well, I have another minute and 34 seconds, but I don't have anything else to say, so I'll stop. All right, thank you very much. D. Bill Kinken , I'm Bill Kinken, 1312 North Dogwood. I only have two things I want to talk about. Palm trees, they're not a tree. They don't do any of the things that we say that a tree should do. They don't even provide much in the way of shade. So I know there are lots where we take, allow people to take a lot, split it in half ; they're too small, you can't put anything there but pine trees or rosebushes. There's no room for anything else. So in the smaller lot, I guess it's okay, but to allow a palm tree in a 10,000 -square -foot lot to be a tree, it just to me is wrong. And the last thing — oh, first thing I want to thank y'all for doing this. I'm sorry, I skipped right over. I worked on this thing six years ago. It's a nightmare, and I really appreciate all the hard work you put into it. This is much better than what we have. But I don't want to just be critical because I'm really happy with what's, for the most part. And then the last criticism is the $10,000 fine for clear -cutting. It ought to be a hundred thousand. You take, you buy a three hundred or four hundred thousand dollar lot, you put a four hundred, for a million -dollar house on it, what's ten thousand dollars? They weren't even bad — just goes to the mortgage , and it's another two dollars you pay every month. No, that needs to be higher. If we're going to stop clear -cutting, we have to stop clear -cutting. The way you do it is with money. I mean, and maybe pulling permits and not allowing them to build. There's a lot of different ways to do it, but money is one thing. But $10,000 is a drop in the bucket in this town. Thank you. E. Scott Von Busek , 214 South Dogwood Drive. I did not know that this would be in this format, so I did not prepare something the way this is done, but maybe it's a better way. Good to see you all. Some of you are my friends. Some of you are also my friends. So it's good to see you all. I have, I've been a — well, for one, I'm on the Planning Commission, and I did work with Bill Kinken six years ago on the other ordinance, and I was the only negative one on that one. I was the one “no ” vote, and this one ’s even more — hate using the word “draconian ”— but it's a little more strict. I've been a vocal opponent of this ordinance primarily because I believe several of these provisions are unnecessarily restrictive and, in my opinion, excessive. My biggest concern is the reduction of what homeowners can do on their own properties without government permission or a permit. We've gone from allowing the removal of trees that are six or eight inches breast height or so ; now, with this new ordinance, it's down to three inches. During our Planning Commission discussion , I asked whether there was room for reasonable compromise for somebody who's a little bit more conservative, you know, a little bit more freedom -loving, higher than three inches, and the response was maybe three and a half inches. And that told me there was very little willingness to find middle ground. The vote for this ordinance was not unanimous. It was five to zero. There were seven members of the commission. I happened to have had to leave early. It wasn ’t because I was disgusted by the meeting, but now that I look back, that would have been a good reason to leave. Some people ask, what is the harm of getting a permit? What's wrong with going to the government and asking? You know, you probably get approved — maybe. To me, that's not the issue. The issue is whether a permit is granted is that government permission is now required for something that property owners have traditionally been free to do on their own land. I've always believed that government should protect the community by respecting individual rights, personal freedoms, and private property. You should be careful not to create regulations that solve one problem by unnecessarily limiting those freedoms. People often joke about Surfside Beach — you know, you need a permit to be able to blow your nose. Have you heard that one before? I have several times. And it used to be an exaggeration, but lately it's starting to get a little bit closer to reality. I sound like a broken record because on the Planning Commission I keep kind of saying this kind of thing, but this is just another slow and consistent erosion of individual rights and freedoms of residents in this community. I am trusting that the Council will examine this ordinance and be a little more flexible about how to make it more fair and reasonable for our residents. Whenever I'm working with the Planning Commission and listening to you all, I wonder, okay, as a matrix, how does this ordinance or anything that we do promote life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness for our residents? How does this ordinance, this new tree ordinance, do that? And I think it's slowly eroding that away. Now, as a final little note — and I wrote this down before I got here because I thought, hey, I have five minutes, not just two minutes — so I have another minute. I love and worship our Creator. That's one of my foundational beliefs, and that's why I want to treat others with respect and hope they treat me with respect. I love but don't worship His creation, and there's a big difference with that. I love His creation. I think we need to be good stewards of His creation, but we don't have to worship or hug His creation to prove that we love it. And being reasonable and fair, I'm hoping that you as Council — who are elected and hopefully want to remain elected — will consider the residents of this beach. And as an aside, 24 seconds, I love palms. I love crepe myrtles. I think they are trees. They look like trees. They act like trees. They drink water like trees. They're beachy feeling. They're beautiful. And they give it a really good feeling. And after all, the crepe myrtles is how Myrtle Beach got its name out of it. Thank you all, and God bless you. 4. WORKSHOP ITEM S : A. ORDINANCE 26-1007- AN ORDINANCE TO REPEAL CHAPTER 17, "ZONING," ARTICLE VII, "LANDSCAPING AND TREE PROTECTION," SECTIONS 17-700 THROUGH 17-750, AND REPLACE IT WITH NEW ARTICLE VII ESTABLISHING STANDARDS FOR TREE PRESERVATION AND LANDSCAPING IN SECTIONS 17-700 THROUGH 17-752  Ordinance reorganized to improve clarity and reduce length (current 18 pages → proposed 10 pages).  Added comprehensive definitions and structured terms consistently.  Tree minimums revised to be based on lot size , not zoning district.  Minimums apply only in limited removal cases (primarily construction or when removal drops property below minimums).  Replacement tree rules are designed to reduce burden on homeowners while preserving long -term canopy.  Extensive debate occurred on palms, pines, and softwood species.  Landscaping requirements apply only when zoning permits are required , and over 800 sq ft of land disturbance occurs. Definitions:  Need adjustments so “protected tree ” appropriately covers hardwood and certain softwood species.  Ordinance must resolve inconsistencies (e.g., bald cypress classified as softwood but listed as landmark).  Consider adding more native species to landmark/protected lists. Clear -cutting:  Definition may need revision to prevent loopholes (e.g., leaving one sapling to avoid classification). Permits:  Council recommended requiring tree removal companies to be identified for all permits.  Homeowners performing their own removal should sign hold harmless agreements.  Clarification is needed so relocating small, newly planted trees does not require permits. Invasive Species:  Desire for no -fee permits for removing invasives.  Reorganization may be needed so homeowners do not assume all bamboo removal requires permits. Emergency Situations:  Consider extending the 96 -hour reporting window.  Concern about misuse after storms (removing healthy trees under the guise of storm damage).  Options requested for handling emergency exemptions. Pine Trees:  Strong opinions both for and against counting pines toward minimums.  Suggestions included counting only longleaf pine or reducing minimum DBH thresholds. Tree Mitigation Fund:  Fund confirmed to exist; council suggested allowing public tree giveaways (e.g., during Arbor Day). 5 . PUBLIC COMMENT A. Ken P odraza, I won't talk very long, obviously, but first off I want to say my comments from before were rapid -fire because I have only so much time. There was no intent to insult anybody here. I've worked on this for three years for Chapter 18; you've worked on it for a year. You know it's hard. It's tough stuff. You guys have been hearing it, and you can hear it from today — all this stuff is tough. There's a lot of technical information here that we've got to get down to in order to figure out what the right thing is for our community and what our community wants to do. Okay, so just a few other items. Again, this DBH, four and a half feet versus our current two feet. If we're going to have a lot more replacement trees that are small trees, the four -and -a -half -foot DBH of three inches for countable trees, I think, or larger for different ones, it's going to take five to ten years to get it. So, we just have to be aware that DBH was always designed for mature trees and not younger trees. We've talked about the mitigation payments and the dollars — there wasn ’t any — so dollar value per square root of DBH, I think, is a solution. We have an exemption section. We also have, in the clear -cutting, exceptions. So, it really is kind of odd between having an exemption and clear -cutting , which actually has exemptions. So, they probably could be combined and clarified. That's kind of my last two comments. For the regulation, hierarchy is nice. Understand what's most important. If the number of trees — and I'm going to say diameter — because I think that's most important to keep our canopy, it's like what we have today. We apply that. It's going to be important. And from that, everything else falls. It's pretty clear for people to understand. Right now, it's a little hard to understand. I think as we work through this, you kind of get there, but it's kind of hard just to get it from regulation. And finally, two things. One is, again, that Chapter 18 proposed regulation that's there has a lot of good information in it. Some of the discussion points we had today, some of the answers are in there. I know you guys have looked at it — lots of details. I'm not trying to push it; it's just a good reference area for all of you to use to make any decisions. And finally, thanks. I appreciate all the effort from you all and everyone else here. It's always a little disappointing not to see more members, residents, of Surfside talking, but I guess you guys are used to that in some ways. Thank you. B. Scott Von Busek, First , thank you. I'm encouraged by this meeting. I just wrote a few comments, and I'll be a lot quicker than the five minutes. One thing I mentioned during our Planning Commission meetings is precedent. You know, other areas and other towns in this region don't have district tree holdings, and I think we're working on it, which is really good. But in your spare time, if you have any, look at what other towns are doing and compare it to what we're trying to do. It's pretty dramatically different. I had my numbers from my other meeting, but I don't have them here. Still, I do understand where Tree City goes, and we want to keep that status. As far as the future forestation canopy, this was mentioned in our meetings. It was mentioned, quote -unquote, “all trees from three inches to eight inches would be cut down if we allowed it. ” That's just not true. I mean, are all trees from three inches to eight inches cut down? Of course not. What I was arguing is that individuals who are interested would have the freedom to be able to do that if they want to redesign their yard. They may have an orange tree there and say, “Okay, I want to have this over here. ” I ’d have to go get a permit for that orange tree, and I just think people will be stuck. They'll have to go through the whole permit process, which I guess is the point. Carolyn had mentioned the purpose is to bring everything into a permit process, and I understand that. I will say I don't believe residents should have to keep getting permits. The section that matters most to me, and I think you covered it, is that I have a great amount of respect for this council. I want to encourage the Planning Commission that , as we're proposing things and writing things up, to think of what can be passed in council. Sean Fallon, you mentioned that. You said, “At this juncture, I don't know that this would pass. ” As we're working through it, don't think of what we want — think of what could pass and what the residents want. And I think there's … well, I can go on and on and on. Thank you. 6 . ADJOURNMENT Councilmember Stamey made a motion to adjourn at 7:05 PM. Councilmember Walls second. All voted in favor. Motion carried. Surfside Beach Town Council _____________________ Robert Krouse, Mayor ________________________________ ________________________________ John Hiatt, Town Council Chris Stamey, Town Council ________________________________ ________________________________ Rick Lawhorn, Town Council Skip Walls, Mayor Pro Tem _________________________________ _________________________________ Harry Kohlmann, Town Council Shawn Fallon, Town Council Attest: __________________________________ Sheri L Medina, Town Clerk Clerk's Note: This document constitutes a summary of the minutes of the meeting that were digitally recorded and is not intended to be a complete transcript. Appointments to hear recordings may be made with the town clerk; a free copy of the audio will be given to you, provided you bring a new, unopened flash drive. In accordance with FOIA §30-4- 80(A) and (E), the meeting notice and the agenda were distributed to local media and interested parties via the Town's email subscription list.

Source: Town of Surfside Beach website. First collected Oct 15, 2026.