RecordWell Data

_05052026-1446

Town of Surfside Beach · Horry County · meeting of May 5, 2026 · Minutes

Open the original document More from Town of Surfside Beach

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

Page 1 of 6 Town of Surfside Beach Planning, Building & Zoning Department 210 US Hwy. 17 South, Surfside Beach, SC 29575 (843) 913-6341 PLANNING COMMISSION REGULAR MEETING MINUTES DICK M JOHNSON CIVIC CENTER 829 PINE DR, SURFSIDE BEACH SC TUESDAY, MAY 5, 2026, AT 6:00PM 1. CALL TO ORDER – Carolyn Pravlik, Chair called the meeting to order. Attendees: Ms. Dubanoski, Ms. Abrams, Mr. McKeen, Mr. Monson, Ms. Lane-Laveglia, Director Brodeur and Secretary Angie Poston. 2. INVOCATION 3. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE 4. PUBLIC HEARING – None. 5. AGENDA APPROVAL Mr. Monson - Motion to approve the agenda. Ms. Abrams second. All in favor. 6. MINUTES APPROVAL – April 7, 2026 Meeting Minutes: Mr. Monson - Motion to approve April 7, 2026 meeting minutes. Mr. Von Buseck second. Ms. Abrams: Moved to amend the April 7 minutes stating that there's one significant thing that happened at the last meeting. I'd like to have added to the record the following: In response to a question, Director Brodeur stated that the 7brew application for a zoning map amendment was filed the day after the last meeting on March 4th, 2026. There was a lengthy discussion of the time requirements of Section 17-202 of the town ordinance. And then in parentheses, post-meeting note, this information was later corrected when Director Brodeur informed the commission that the application was not deemed filed until April 13, 2026, when the applicant paid the application fee. I think it’s important that some of that get on the record. Mr. Monson - As the original motion maker, I have no objection. All were in favor of amending the minutes of April 7, 2026, meeting minutes, as indicated by Ms. Abrams. 7. PUBLIC COMMENTS ON AGENDA ITEMS (5 Minutes per Speaker): None 8. DIRECTOR’S REPORT – Director Brodeur -- Two Town Attorney Opinions (Section 17-201 Proposed Amendment & Golf Cart Rentals) Mr. Brodeur - Two opinions from Attorney. One being the section 17-201, which is being discussed later on in the agenda under old business. After a considerable search on my part and on the part of the town attorneys, keeping us from keeping Page 2 of 6 17-201 intact the way it is or if we want to amend it, there are towns in the state who after the 1994 act was passed did remove provisions in their codes to allow the director to make minor modifications on. There was also a number of cities who chose not to amend that and still have those in our code. Since we had it in our code before the 1994 passage of the Comprehensive Planning Act, I assumed that the town, at that time, decided to keep it in there, it's legal, whether you want to change it or not or if you want to delete it or not or whatever you want to do with it is up to you, but I wanted you to know that he felt there was no we were in no risk of litigation to keep it. The other one is much more interesting and he hasn't provided me with an opinion on yet, but I want to tell you a little story about this one. As you all know we have number of golf cart rentals and sales purveyors in the town. And this tells me that competition is heating up. There is a golf cart rental company who is placing or I'll call it staging golf carts in…… pre-arranged short-term vacation rentals in our town. So, they're working through a realty management company to ask the owners of those short- term vacation rentals if they would like to have a golf cart staged at that property for the sole intended use of the week or for the day or whatever it is. Another golf cart company is suggesting that that's an illegal use, it's a commercial use in the residential area because there's a commercial transaction going on these private property. So the complaint cites various issues with sections of the code, that I have transmitted to the town attorney for an opinion for it. I have also done some research and assisting the town attorney with that, coming up with some of, I guess, what I would call my own opinions, providing those to the town attorney. But it's certainly an interesting problem. So, I just wanted to bring those to you. I expect I will have an opinion from the town attorney on the second part of this, probably within the next couple of weeks, hopefully before the May 21st hearing. So I can tell you what the outcome was, but if not, I'll bring it to you at the subsequent meeting. Discussion as to mechanisms for limiting the number of similar businesses in Town. 9. BUSINESS ITEMS a. New Business i. Consideration of a motion to direct the Planning Director Direction to Schedule a Public Hearing to Amend Municipal Code Chapter 17, Article VII –Tree Protection and Landscaping. Mr. Monson - Made a motion to approve directing the planning director to schedule a public hearing to amend the municipal code chapter 17, article 7, tree protection of the landscaper. Mr. McKeen seconded. Followed by discussion of the date for such a hearing. Mr. Monson – I would like to revise my original motion to be a motion in favor of directing the planning director to schedule a public hearing to amend municipal code Page 3 of 6 chapter 17 article 7 tree protection and landscaping for the date of Tuesday, June 30th at 5 p.m. Mr. McKeen seconded. All in favor. b. Old Business i. Discussion and possible action on previously tabled proposal to amend Zoning Code Section 17-201(a) (Nonconforming lot) to permit the Director to include "lot coverage" as a permissible reduction in site development standards. Mr. Monson - Made a motion to un-table the discussion of the old business as stated in 9b of the agenda. Mrs. Dubanoski second. Discussion as to the new language suggested by Director Brodeur to include lot coverage in lieu of yards. Ms. Pravlik suggested that we need a legal opinion so that we are moving authority currently held by the Board of Zoning Appeals and shifting it to the Director. Director Brodeur suggested that the Planning Commission vote no on the amendment so that it can be moved to Town Council. Then at the Town Council meeting, an opinion can be obtained from the Town Attorney. He confirmed that the Town Attorney had offered an opinion that Section 17- 201 was a proper provision to have in our code; he has not offered an opinion(s) as to the questions posed by Ms. Pravlik. Director Brodeur stated that he could make a decision on the pending application with the Section 17-201 language as it currently stands. It was later corrected that there is no application, but someone is waiting for the decision. Mr. McKeen made a motion to table the amendment of Section 17-201 until the May 19 meeting. Mr. Monson seconded. All in favor. ii. Reconsideration discussion item: (a) Review Ordinance Language 17-420 – Spaces required for certain uses (i.) Review of certain sections of Chapter 17, Zonin, 17-420 Regarding Parking Requirements for self-storage warehouses and other establishments. Mr. Monson made a motion to open consideration of the topic. Mrs. Dubanoski seconded. Discussion as to prior staff report on changing parking requirements and question of whether the current parking was to limit such facilities. Director Brodeur suggested that he come back to us with specific language. He stated that he has an applicant and this is holding him up. Ms. Pravlik stated that if the parking requirement is to be changed that the Use Table also needs to be amended. Director Brodeur suggested that he come back with an amendment that addressed the parking and added a conditional use that the facilities be located 150 or more feet away from the Highway 17 right of way. Mr. Von Buseck made a motion to direct Director Brodeur to come back to the Commission with on the parking amendment and conditions on self-storage. Mr. Monson seconded. Ms. Pravlik moved to amend to include parking in 17-420, conditional Page 4 of 6 uses in 17-396.42, and a buffer or set back from the right of way. Mr. McKeen seconded. All were in favor. 10. DISCUSSION ITEMS a. Proposed Amendment to Chapter 17, Article VII, Landscaping and Tree Protection Ms. Pravlik explained changes made to the draft since the last discussion of the Tree Ordinance. Discussion of the changes and other issues. [Mr. Von Buseck left the meeting during the discussion] Discussion of further changes to clarify the language. Public hearing on this ordinance is July 21. 11. PUBLIC COMMENTS – General Comments (5 Minutes per Speaker) My name's John Hiatt and I am the liason from the town council. I just thought maybe you guys might consider adding to the penalties that fines of 50% for a first offender unless it can be shown that they knew or should have known that their action was illegal. Thanks. Yvette Hellyer - Once again I’m brought back to flashbacks. 7th Avenue North On protected trees charging 500 and 3 inches. This is a deterrence and very effective when individuals don't follow it because $500 for some people is something they've got to pay and then be done with. That often happens. Ms. Pravlik: I know we're not supposed to do this. Go ahead. But did you say protected trees? Ms. Hellyer -- I think that's what I saw in the writer that you were talking about. It's twenty-five hundred. Well the five hundred to three inches is what I'm covering. That's for non-protected trees. So I'm going to bring this up a little bit later but there is such a thing as an enforcement response policy. Chapters 14 has one. It provides a low, medium, and high range for penalty assessment. So in the ordinance, you always include the highest penalty a person can accrue if they're gonna have a penalty or a fine. You also need for every should or sorry, shall or must provision of the ordinance, you need to put somewhere like in the enforcement section, what is the result, the resolution for that? They may get a notice of violation, they may get a stop work order for the particular, they may get a fine or something along that line. But with shall must provisions in your ordinance you should be having, that's the general rule. When it comes to comments about whether or not three inches is appropriate, again, I strongly recommend that. Just for sharing, we talked a lot with the council when we were working on the tree ordinance and some folk wanted it to be two inches for every tree being requiring a permit. Some as high as 20 depending 15. They didn't like the idea of going after scrawny little trees but you're never going to get an urban forest if you don't protect the scrawny little trees. So, I commend you for going to three inches because we tried but got some resistance from comments that we got. So, We sort of split the baby and went to, I think, six inches or eight inches. Under paragraph F on page 5 of 10, also need to provide steps for how to predict potential damages to foundations, Page 5 of 6 because one of the criticisms we often got from the Code Enforcement Officer is that if it's a perceived potential, it's very hard to ensure that. That just might be an excuse. So, there's got to be some measure of data evidence to collect or information to corroborate that kind of potential so that they have to know that they have to provide it rather than just say it. Council can say under paragraph H that fines are going to be what you want to propose to the council because council does not identify fines. We did ask that question. They have no idea what they went better with is if you come in and you talk about Myrtle Beach and you talk about Georgetown County and you talk about North Myrtle Beach, that gives them a better sense of where fines could potentially go and whatever you propose would be more likely to be more reasonable to them because that is a very hard thing for them to try to gauge and some folk will go to the extreme and others will go to a very low range. So, I don't think that you should think that council is the one that makes that decision. They do make the decision, but they need help with how they go about making that decision. And that really comes from your assessments and what you have found out in reading about. Georgetown County does fine $500 per inch of their trees, not just per tree. So, it is this fine of $500 for each tree that is a good range because it sort of falls right in line with the Grand Strand. What happens if the proposed owner is not here when a storm occurs and they're not able to notify PB&Z in 96 hours? They may be on a ship cruising, they may be sick in the hospital, they may be whatever. So, I think you may need to put some language in there about, I'm not sure exactly how, but notifying them in an appropriate manner, because it's really the notification they need to provide, not actually getting the tree cut down. We may have time to do that a little later. Like an absentee owner? Yeah, or an absentee owner, and they find out because the property manager tells them, and they don't have the authority to make any decisions. Um, penalties for 25 to 36 inches is going to be allowed for trees to be removed easily. Um, again, I already said that if you make it so it's 25 to 30 inches, the idea to go ahead and remove it and pay the penalty is most likely to happen because we've seen that happen a lot. People will pay the money. They will have the trees cut down over the weekend. Please require they post the permit. I really didn't see this when I did my post review. Posting just like they do when they do any kind of construction work. That really helps the neighbors out. It brings a sense that they have been looked at, they have been assessed by PB&Z. And if it happens on the weekend, which the tree company should be legally able to do, As long as they post their sign, it will come in. Then when police comes because of a complaint in my office. The enforcement rules, I think I'd let you know that there is such a thing as an enforcement response policy, which is very useful for PB&Z, because there are always extenuating circumstances that could warrant not having to charge $500. And they may be able to come up with this. Lastly, the previous discussion on paragraph 9, 6, or B, 3, 2. That's why I left this one last. I do want to refresh people's memories. That issue about self-storage and having so many parking spaces required, I think that's that came about because there was where the hotel is going to be that was intended by the owners Page 6 of 6 of the property to put in a huge giant cell storage there and the town people screamed and yelled. Protested, did protest marching, to convince council not to allow prime property in our town to be used for storage facilities. And that was kind of the best idea they could come up with. Kind of right. It was worth it to the town overall that that property stay not built until they got the right person or company to come in, that that did happen. 12. COMMISSION COMMENTS - None 13. EXECUTIVE SESSION, AS APPLICABLE 14. ADJOURMENT: Mr. Monson made the motion to adjourn. Ms. Abrams seconded. All in favor.

Source: Town of Surfside Beach website. First collected Oct 15, 2026.