RecordWell Data

Surfside Beach Town Council Workshop

Town of Surfside Beach · Horry County · meeting of Apr 16, 2026 · Agendas

Open the original document More from Town of Surfside Beach

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

TOWN OF SURFSIDE BEACH 829 Pine Drive Surfside Beach, SC 29575 � (843) 913-6111 � (843) 238-5432 TOWN COUNCIL WORKSHOP MEETING April 16, 2026, 2:00 P.M. Please join my meeting from your computer, tablet or smartphone. https://meet.goto.com/777709101 You can also dial in using your phone. Access Code: 777-709-101 United States (Toll Free): 1 877 309 2073 United States:+ 1 (571) 317-3129 1. CALL TO ORDER: 2. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE 3. PUBLIC COMMENT (5 minutes per speaker) 4. WORKSHOP ITEMS: Sec. 3-52. Birds and waterfowl-Findings and determinations 5. ADJOURNMENT - March 30, 2026 Decision Paper Written by: William Mickle, Chief of Police 1. SUBJECT: Review and consideration of proposed modifications to the Town of Surfside Beach wildlife feeding ordinance, including potential transition from a civil enforcement model to a progressive penalty structure incorporating criminal penalties. 2. PURPOSE: To provide Town Council with relevant information regarding the current wildlife feeding ordinance, proposed modifications, and comparable ordinances from other jurisdictions, in order to support informed legislative decision-making. This briefing is intended to address legal considerations, enforcement implications, and best practices, while maintaining the Police Department's neutral role as the enforcing authority. 3. FACTS: A. Current Ordinance Framework The Town's existing wildlife feeding ordinance: • Prohibits the feeding of wildlife under specified conditions • Contains defined exceptions for lawful activities • Is enforced through a civil penalty _structure • Does not include custodial penalties • Allows for each violation to be treated as a separate offense B. Proposed Ordinance Modifications The proposed revisions introduce: • Expanded definitions of prohibited conduct, including indirect feeding • A progressive penalty structure for repeat violations • Consideration of criminal enforcement mechanisms, including potential incarceration C. Legal Considerations Under South Carolina law, municipalities may enforce ordinances through criminal penalties, subject to statutory limits: • Maximum penalty of $500 fine and/or 30 days imprisonment • Prosecution through municipal court • Requirement for due process and proof beyond a reasonable doubt Sentencing Authority: • Sentencing is determined solely by the municipal judge • The judge may impose: o A fine o A term of imprisonment (within statutory limits) o Community service, where appropriate, either in lieu of or in addition to other penalties Any ordinance provision should preserve judicial discretion and avoid mandatory sentencing requirements. D. Comparison to Other Jurisdictions Included two very differently crafted ordinances for reference: • Isle of Palms o Straightforward prohibition o Limited complexity • Horry County o Broader nuisance-based framework o Reliance on general penalty provisions E. Enforcement Considerations From an operational standpoint, the following factors should be considered: • Clarity of language to ensure consistent interpretation • Consistency in application across cases • Increased evidentiary requirements for criminal enforcement F. Use of Government-Supported Findings To strengthen the ordinance's legal defensibility and public understanding, consideration should be given to: • Including or maintaining references to recognized governmental authorities, such as: o U.S. Department of the Interior o South Carolina Department of Natural Resources o Centers for Disease Control and Prevention • Supporting statements regarding: o Harm to wildlife o Risk of human injury o Disease transmission o Property damage with data from appropriate government agencies It is advisable to avoid reliance on private or non-governmental sources unless such materials have been used in establishing law or regulation. 4. RECOMMENDATION: No specific policy recommendation is provided, as the adoption and structure of the ordinance is a legislative function of Town Council. However, the Police Department recommends that prior to adoption: • The proposed ordinance be reviewed by the Town Attorney and/or Prosecutor • Legal counsel confirm: o Compliance with South Carolina law o Constitutionality of any criminal provisions o. Clarity and enforceability of progressive penalty language The Police Department remains committed to enforcing any ordinance adopted by Council and emphasizes the importance of ensuring the final ordinance is: • Clear • Legally sound • Operationally enforceable ISLE OF PALMS Sec. 6-2-8. Definitions. As used in this chapter, the following terms shall have the meanings indicated: Wildlife. Animals that have not been domesticated or tamed and are usually living in a natural environment, including both game and nongame species such as deer, coyotes, opossums, raccoons, skunks and waterfowl. Waterfowl. Any bird that frequents the water; am aquatic fowl, including but not limited to ducks, geese, swans, heron and egrets. Feeding. The act of providing food, whether intentionally or unintentionally, to wildlife. Feral Cats. Cats that are domesticated but have reverted to a wild state and live independently of human care. Bird Feeders. Devices specifically designed for the purpose of providing food to birds. (Ord. No. 2024-06, § 1, 9-24-2024) Sec. 6-2-9. Feeding wildlife. (a) No person shall purposely feed or make food available for consumption by wildlife on private or public property within the City. (b) No person shall recklessly feed or make food available for consumption by wildlife on private or public property within the City. (c) Each property owner or person having control of the property shall have the duty to remove any materials or devices placed on the owner's property in violation of this section. (d) Nothing in this section shall apply to any agent of the City, County, State of South Carolina or Federal Agency lawfully engaged in a wildlife management program. (Ord. No. 2024-06, § 1, 9-24-2024) Sec. 6-2-10. Exemptions. (a) The feeding of feral cats is exempt from the provisions of this ordinance, provided that the feeding is conducted in a responsible manner that minimizes the attraction of other wildlife. (b) Bird feeders are also exempt from the provisions of this ordinance, provided that the feeders are maintained in a clean and sanitary manner and any spilled or excess seed is promptly cleaned to avoid attracting wildlife. (Ord. No. 2024-06, § 1, 9-24-2024} Created: 2026-01-86 12:53:84 [EST) (Supp. No. 27) Page 1 of 1 HORRY COUNTY Sec. 1-8. General penalty; continuing violations. (a} Code or ordinance violation declared to be unlawful, or an offense, or a misdemeanor; abatement. Wherever in this Code or in any ordinance of the county any act is declared to be unlawful, or an offense, or misdemeanor, or whenever in such Code or ordinance the doing of any act is required, and the failure to do any act is declared to be unlawful, or an offense, or misdemeanor, and where no specific penalty is provided therefor, the violation of any such provision of this Code or any such ordinance shall be subject to a fine not exceeding five hundred dollars ($500.00) or by imprisonment not exceeding thirty (30} days, or both. In lieu of fine or imprisonment, under the appropriate circumstances, a violator may be given up to thirty (30) days of public service. Each day any violation of any such provision of this Code or of any such ordinance shall continue shall constitute a separate offense, except as otherwise may be provided. In addition to the penalty hereinabove provided, any condition caused or permitted to exist in violation of any such provisions of this Code or of any such ordinance may be abated by the county by restraining order, injunction, or other means provided by law, and the county may take the appropriate action to recover the costs of the action taken to abate. (b) Code or ordinance violation declared to be an infraction or a public nuisance; abatement. Whenever in this Code or in any ordinance of the county any act is declared to be an infraction or public nuisance, or whenever in such Code or ordinance the doing of any act is required, and the failure to do any act is declared to be an infraction or public nuisance, and where no specific penalty is provided therefor, the violation of any such provision of this Code or any such ordinance shall be subject to a fine not exceeding two hundred dollars ($200.00). In lieu of fine, under the appropriate circumstances, a violator may be given up to thirty (30} hours of public service. Each day any violation of any such provision of this Code or of any such ordinance shall continue shall constitute a separate offense, except as otherwise may be provided. In addition to the penalty hereinabove provided, any condition caused or permitted to exist in violation of any such provisions of this Code or of any such ordinance may be abated by the county by restraining order, injunction, or other means provided by law, and the county may take the appropriate action to recover the costs of the action taken to abate . . (c) Warnings, citations and notices. Any person who violates any provision of this Code or any ordinance of the county may be issued a warning or notice that the person is in violation of the Code or ordinance, or notification that certain action is necessary to comply with the Code or ordinance, in lieu of or in addition to, any penalties provi�ed for a violation of the Code or ordinance. Any warning or notice shall state the bond/fine set for the violation, if any, and the date and time at which the violator is to appear before the magistrate's court, if applicable. The procedures governing the issuance, form and content of warnings and notices shall be prescribed by the county administrator or his designee, or otherwise as set forth in this Code. (Ord. No. 60-09, § 1, 9-1-09) Cross reference(s}-Courts, Ch. 7; offenses and miscellaneous provisions, Ch.13; sheriff, Ch.17. State law reference(s}-Authority to provide penalties for ordinance violations not in excess of jurisdiction of magistrates' courts, S.C. Code 1976 § 4-9-30(14); jurisdiction of magistrates' courts, S.C. Code 1976 § 22-3- 550. Sec. 4-32. Definitions. [The following words, terms and phrases, when used in this chapter, shall have the meanings ascribed to them in this section, except where the context clearly indicates a different meaning:] Created: 2025-89-08 U:52:14 [EST] (Supp. No. 86) Page 1 of 2 Domestic waterfowl: Non-native ducks, gees and swans not retained in agricultural operations. Feed or feeding: The act of or the furnishing of food or other substance that is essential for growth or maintenance of waterfowl. Migratory waterfowl: Ducks, geese and swans native to North America. (Ord. No. 69-07, 5-15-07) Sec. 4-33. Prohibition of feeding. (a) No person shall feed, cause to be fed or provide food for domestic or migratory waterfowl in residential areas of Horry County. (b) No person shall create or foster any condition, or allow any condition to exist or continue, which results in a congregation or congestion of domestic or migratory waterfowl in residential areas of Horry County. (Ord. No. 69-07, 5-15-07) Sec. 4-34. Exceptions. Facilities dedicated to wildlife management that are located on a minimum of five (5) acres are exempt from this chapter. (Ord. No. 69-07, 5-15-07; Ord. No. 17-19, § 1, 3-19-19) Sec. 4-35. Enforcement. The Horry County Police Department is authorized and directed to enforce this chapter. (Ord. No. 69-07, 5-15-07) Sec. 4-36. Violations and penalties. Any person convicted of violating any provision of this chapter shall be subject to punishment as provided in section 1-8 of this Code. Created: 2825·89·88 11:52:19 [EST) (Supp. No. 86) Page2 of2 ORDINANCE 2024 06 AN ORDINANCE TO AMEND TITLE 6 HEALTH AND SANITATION, CHAPTER 2 ANIMALS, ARTICLE A GENERAL PROVISIONS TO INCLUDE PROHIBITIONS AGAINST FEEDING WILDLIFE WHEREAS, the City of Isle of Pa]ms has a significant and growing wildlife population within City Limits; and WHEREAS, the intentional feeding of wildlife can lead to various ecological and public health issues, including increased human-wildlife conflicts, the spread of disease, and encourages concentration and growth of animals in urbanized areas, which poses a hazard to humans, pets and plant life; and WHEREAS, the improper and intentional feeding of wildlife disrupts animal's natural habitats as well as their feeding and foraging habits, as they become dependent upon human provided food sources; and WHEREAS, the Isle of Palms City Council finds that regulating the feeding of wildJife is imperative to the health, safety and welfare of the animals and to the City of Isle of Palms and its residents; and WHEREAS, Isle of Palms City Council has the authority to enact new sections of its Code of Ordinances when deemed to be in the best interest of the citizens of the City, and now desires to do so as displayed below. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED by the Mayor and Councilmembers of the City of Isle of Palms, in Council assembled, that Section 6-2-8 and 6-2-9 be included under Title 6, Chapter 4, Article A of the City of Isle of Palms Code of Ordinances as follows: SECTION I. That Section 6-2-8 "Definitions" and Section 6-2-9 "Feeding Wildlife" be included to state as follows: Section 6-2-8 Definitions As used in this Ordinance, the following tenns shall have the meanings indicated: Wildlife · Animals that have not been domesticated or tamed and are usually living in a natural environment, including both game and nongame species such as deer, coyotes, opossums, raccoons, skunks and waterfowl. Wate,fowl Any bird that frequents the water; am aquatic fowl, including but not limited to ducks, geese, swans, heron and egrets. Feeding- The act of providing food, whether intentionaJly or unintentionaJly, to wildlife. Feral Cats - Cats that are domesticated but have reverted to a wiJd state and live independently of human care. Bird Feeders- Devices specifically designed for the pwpose of providing food to birds. 6-2-9 Feeding Wildlife (a) No person shall purposely feed or make food available for consumption by wildlife on private or public property within the City. (b) No person shall recklessly feed or make food available for consumption by wildlife on private or public property within the City. ( c) Each property owner or person having control of the property shalJ have the duty to remove any materials or devices placed on the owner's property in violation of this section. (d) Nothing in this section shall apply to any agent of the City, County, State of South Carolina or Federal Agency lawfully engaged in a wildlife management program. 6-2-10 Exemptions a) The feeding of feral cats is exempt from the provisions of this ordinance, provided that the feeding is conducted in a responsible manner that minimizes the attraction of other wildlife. b) Bird feeders are also exempt from the provisions of this ordinance, provided that the feeders are maintained in a clean and sanitary manner and any spilled or excess seed is promptly cleaned to avoid attracting wildlife. SECTION 2. That should any part of this Ordinance be held invalid by a Court of competent jurisdiction, the remaining parts shall be severable therefrom and shall continue to be in full force and effect. SECTION 3. That all ordinances or parts of ordinances conflicting with the provisions of this Ordinance are hereby repealed insofar as the same affect this Ordinance. SECTION 4. That this Ordinance take effect and be in full force immediately. PASSED AND APPROVED BY THE CITY ��f����;!:,.HE CITY OF ISLE OF PALMS, ON THE ]t4--__ DAY OF�• , 2024 . ... PH Phillip Pcf'nds, ,. Sec. 3-52. Birds and water fowl-Findings and determinations. The town council (the "council") hereby finds and determines: (a) The feeaiRg ef 1c1RcoRfiAea-Wilalife iR aRy p1c1blic Jnlf-k--Or OR aR'r other prepert·r owRea or eperated-&V the towR is prehlbitea, seas to protect p1c1blle healtR, safety ano-weifaFe, (bl lhat tile R\JmaA llaRa feeaing of water fowl within tRe to»,n limits is res1c1ltiAg IA a p1c1blic n1Jisanee by the aepesit effeeal matter, garbage, aellris, aAa filth en s1c1rr01c1naing properties, and aestrnetian of lawns anel ornamental shrnlls, in aelelitiaA to ea1c1sing otRer pralllems for prapert� O'l•Aers whese properties are laeateel Relit to or Rea, people who ehaese ta feeel water fowl OR a regular basis, as well il5-tA€FeaSingly aggressiye llirel behaYior. (el lhe feeeliAg of auel1s aAa geese eAeou,ages waterfowl to 1'talt their Aormal migrations aAa establish a resieleAEV in !Re town. lRe grawiAg populatieAs of waterfowl res1Jlt in large amauAts of waterfowl areppings tRat poteRtially ean spreael aisease. Other problems ea1Jseel b�• elrappings are exeess PUtfien.t5-m.the-t<lwA's lakes that IA twrn CilR caus;e algae llleams, a am age ta lawRs aRel the soiling of public areas ar01rna the tewR's lal,es. (a) TRat acce,aing to the PlatioRal Marine Fisheries Ser,,iee it is 1Jnhealthy far tRe biras, ana unRelpful to feed wile dueks, geese, er sea biras with faaas ether tlian faaels essential ta tRe proper aevelepment of ya1Jng biras, anel huRtiRg fer food increases wilel lliras SUF\'i\·al, while hana feeeling aeereases ��kkllls,. (e) lRat the U.S. 9epartmellt-Gf Interior FisReries and Wildlife Ser>,iees ana U.S. Department of ngriwlt1Jre ,•,nimal ana PlaAt Inspection Ser¥iee (APHIS) ha¥e aeterminea that tRese fowl re111Jire ','BUAg grass ana vegetation for fee a ana results in tRe aestr1Jeti0A of lawns in residential areas, parlEs, community ga,eens, businesses ana earporate areas resulting iA eeyelepment of ave,graliAg an grasses, ornamental plants, ans aceumulatieA of elropping5; feathers; attaelis OR hw'Rans; fouling of reservoirs, beames, dacl,s, lawns, and Ele&truetian of craps aAG-€Effifliets witR Ruma� (fl lhat the foremast methea recammeAeed by /\PHI£ fer aiseauragen1ent ehhe settlement of large numbers of water fowl is the discaRtinuanee af feeding iA order ta allew the fowl ta re·,ert llaek ta the nati;ral fa eels s01Jrees. (g) It Is ttle Intention a/this paragraph ta allaN residerits-t�eiaA Geese anli ether Auisanee water fe•n•I witRin tRe town limits iA aecerelance with local, state aAd feaeral law. (A) lllat it Is tRe intent aft1'lis article ta minimize tAe attractlen a/these biFds ey restricting their feeeiAg ana ether acts that encaurnge the migrateP( waterfowl ta Ralt tReir migFatians anel to reside iA tile tawA. It is Rat t1'te-inteflt;en of this cRapter ta halt the feediAg of small ROA migratory eird-ey-€it+reR5 tllrough the use of eira feeliers on pFIYate �rape,ty, A. That the attracting of migratory waterfowl by feeding them creates a public nuisance through causing such birds to lose their natural tendency to migrate and, instead. to congregate within the town's limits. Such congregation results in the deposits of unhealthy fecal matter on. and the causing of other damage to public and private property, including lawns, parks, playing fields, roadways, and waterways. Additi_Qnally, such co� re ation oft n results in im eding the safe and normal flow of vehicular traffic. The Council further notes that feeding the w;1terfowl non-natural foods ma.v result in their development of irreversible and often non-survivable wing deformity referred to as "angel wing" B. That the feeding of seagulls can cause them to congregate in large numbers around people possessing and eating food on the town's beach. At times. seagulls, sometimes in large numbers, may attack � especially small children. in an attempt to obtain the food, thfil' have been possessing. This can result in terrjfyjng their victims. Crnhd: 2825-e8·14 09:54:21 (EST] (Supp. No. 36) Page 1 of 3 (Ord. No. 09-0668, 5-26-09; Ord. No. 14-0775, 4-21-14) • Sec. 3-53. - Prohibited activity. A. Subject to any exceptions contained in state and federal law, it shall be unlawful to take, trap, hunt, shoot, or attempt to shoot, in any manner whatsoever any bird or wild fowl, or to rob bird nests or wild fowl nests in the town. In the event that sparrows, blackbirds, pigeons, crows or similar birds or water fowl are found congregating in numbers in a particular locality within the town limits, as to constitute a public nuisance or menace to the public health or to private or public property, then in that event or any of them, the congregated birds or wild fowl may be discouraged, destroyed or removed by the town administrator, acting through the town police department or another agency or department of the town, county or state government in a manner consistent with state and federal laws concerning the protection of birds . .(Q}Water f.owl: It shall be unlawful to engage in the feeding of wild water f.owl, duEks, geese, seagulls and/or pigeons 'A<ithin the Eity limits, which feeding results in the fl€.posit of refuse, debris, feEal matter, or other offensive substanEe, in any plaEe in the town, including but not limited to lal�es and stormwater holding ponds to the prejudiEe or annoyanEe of any person, unless otheAA1ise permitted by law; or whiEh feeeing results in aggressi1•1e bird behavior towards humans or other animals, or which results in endangering humans or other animals in any manner deemed advisable by and under the super¥ision and rnntrol of the police department of the town. No person may purposefully furnish food to wild waterfowl (including ducks. geese and swansl. seagulls and pigeons within the town limits. unless otherwise permitted by law or in the lawful furtherance of their control. © No person shall create or foster any condition. or allow any condition to exist or continue. which results in a congregation of such birds within the town's limits. (Ord. No. 09-0668, 5-26-09; Ord. No. 14-0775, 4-21-14) • Sec. 3-54. - Penalties. A. A person who violates the provisions of this article shall be guilty of a civil infraction. punishable by a fine of not more than two hundred dollars ($200.00). Each subsequent infraction shall escalate the initial fine by $1 oo to a maximum fine of $500. B. Violations shall be issued on a uniform ordinance summons. C. Violators shall only be cited by police officers or authorized code enforcement officials. (Supp. No. 36j Page 2 of 3 Created; 2925-98-14 09:54:21 (EST] D. Violators shall appear and be subject to the jurisdiction of the town's municipal court. E. Violators shall have a right to a jury trial upon proper request. F. Violators shall be subject to set-off debt process and failure to pay or appear may result in a non-resident violator compact (NRVC) notice for South Carolina licensed drivers. G. Violators shall not be subject to incarceration. H. Violation of this article is hereby declared to be a public nuisance, which may be abated by the town by restraining order, preliminary and permanent injunction, or other means provided for by law, and the town may take action to recover the costs of the nuisance abatement. I. Each day of a continuing violation of this article shall be considered a separate and distinct offense and may result in cumulative infraction fines. (Supp. No. 36) Page 3 of 3 Created; 2825-08-14 89:54:21 [EST] •--·--· Formatted: Level 4, Indent: Left: 0.5", Space Befo � e: 3.75 pt. After. 9.75 pt, Line spacing: At least 21 pt, Font Alignment: Center, Pattern: Clear (White)

Source: Town of Surfside Beach website. First collected Oct 15, 2026.