Minutes
City of Sumter · Sumter County · meeting of Jan 10, 2024 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Sumter
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS
Minutes of the Meeting
January 10, 2024
ATTENDANCE
A regular meeting of the Zoning Board of Appeals was held on
Wednesday, January 10, 2024, in the Fourth Floor City Chambers
of the Sumter Opera House, 21 N. Main Street. Seven board
members – Mr. Leslie Alessandro, Mr. Louis Tisdale, Mr. Todd
Champion, Mr. Claude Wheeler, Mr. Clay Smith , Mr. Steven
Schumpert and Mr. Jason Reddick were present . Mr. Frank
Shuler and Mr. William Bailey were absent.
Planning staff in attendance : Ms. Helen Roodman, Mr. Jeff
Derwort and Ms. Kellie Chapman.
The meeting was called to order at 3:00 p.m. by Mr. Leslie
Alessandro, Chairman.
MINUTES
Mr. Jason Reddick made a motion to approve the minutes of the
December 7, 2022, meeting as written. The motion was
seconded by Mr. Claude Wheeler and carried a unanimous vote.
ELECTION OF
OFFICERS
Mr. Alessandro opened the floor for nomination for Chair and
Vice-Chair.
Mr. Louis Tisdale nominated Mr. Leslie Alessandro for the
position of Chair. The nomination was seconded by Mr. Steven
Schumpert and carried a unanimous vote.
Mr. Louis Tisdale nominated Mr. Frank Shuler for Vice-Chair.
The nomination was seconded by Mr. Clay Smith and carried a
unanimous vote.
NEW BUSINESS
BOA-23-30, Pinewood Rd, Starks Ferry Rd, S. St. Paul’s
Church Rd, & Gwyndale Rd. (County) was presented by Mr.
Jeff Derwort. The Board reviewed a request for Special
Exception approval for the establishment of a utility scale 74.99
MWac photovoltaic solar energy system on property with
frontage along or near Pinewood Rd., Starks Ferry Rd., S. St.
Paul’s Church Rd., and Gwyndale Rd. The total proposed area of
solar array development and support facilities is +/- 650 acres in
size (maximum). The property is located along or near Pinewood
Rd., Starks Ferry Rd., S. St Paul’s Church Rd; and Gwyndale Rd.
The property is zoned Agricultural Conservation (AC) and is
2
represented by TMS# 179 -00-01-002 (Note: This parcel is split by
the right-of-way of the above referenced roads).
Mr. Derwort presented background information to include the
location of the project, the applicable zoning designation,
existing land use conditions, and floodplain/wetland conditions.
Mr. Derwort discussed the major components of the proposed
project and discussed the proposed general development plan for
the project.
Mr. Derwort discussed the applicable general special exception
criteria outlined in Article 1.h.4.c.2 of the Sumter County Zoning &
Development Standards Ordinance:
1. That the special exception complies with all applicable
development standards contained elsewhere in this
Ordinance, including landscaping and bufferyards, off -
street parking, and dimensional requirements.
A full review of the special design criteria outlined in
Article 5.b.c.3 of the Ordinance is provided elsewhere in
this report. Outside of Article 5.b.c.3 items, the project
complies with all Ordinance development standards.
2. That the special exception will be in substantial harmony
with the area in which it is located.
The applicant has submitted site and landscape buffering
plans, as well as numerous documents and studies to
support the position that the project will be in substantial
harmony with the area in which it is located. All such
documents submitted have been provided as exhibits to
this report. Additional studies submitted include a Health
& Safety Assessment an Appraisal Report), a Glare &
Glint Analysis and a technical memorandum responding
to Shaw Air Force Base concerns.
A Species & Habitat Summary has been submitted. This
report indicates that the project area contains potential
habitat for federally listed threatened and endangered
special based on preliminary review and field
reconnaissance. However, these findings are not
expected to impact or limit the development of the
proposed facility. Both further on- site habitat/species
studies and coordination with the US Fish & Wildlife
Service (USFWS) and the South Carolina Department of
Natural Resources (SCDNR) are proposed to determine
the potential for impact to protected species.
3
Shaw Air Force Base was notified of the project and has
raised several concerns including the potential for
conflict with Poinsett ECR operations and pilot safety.
The applicant is countering these concerns and has
provided additional documentation.
Project compatibility with Poinsett ECR and Shaw Air
Force Base operations is a primary consideration in
determining if the project is in substantial harmony with
the area in which it is located.
3. That the special exception will not discourage or negate
the use of surrounding property for uses(s) permitted by
right.
A majority of the identified project boundary is
surrounded by land used for agricultural/silvicultural
purposes or by land otherwise undeveloped. However,
the project area also completely surrounds an established
institutional use and a single -family resi
dential use, is
adjacent to existing residential development in the
southern and western portions of the project area, and is
in close proximity to residential development to the
north, south, and west.
The applicant is proposing a 300 ft. setback from all
property lines and is proposing to install or retain
landscape buffering to screen the project.
A Health & Safety Assessment and an Appraisal Report
for the project has been submitted in addition to all other
applicant submitted documents to support the position
that the project will not discourage or negate the use of
surrounding property uses(s) by right.
Staff is of the opinion that the project has the potential
to satisfy this criterium, however additional detail on
development plans and certain project revisions are
required.
Mr. Derwort discussed the applicable general special exception
criteria outlined in Article 5.b.3.c of the Sumter County Zoning &
Development Standards Ordinance:
1. All ground- mounted photovoltaic solar energy systems
shall be setback 300 ft. from all property lines. This
provision shall be interpreted to apply to all improved
areas associated with the project(s). This provision
excludes any security fencing, however; the 300 ft.
setback shall apply to arrays, storage areas, permanent
4
stormwater management facilities, battery storage,
inverters, and transformers. The poles and aerial lines
necessary to deliver electricity to the power grid may be
located in the setback so long as all necessary buffering is
maintained as required in Article 5.b.3.c.10.
The site plan submitted by the applicant shows all
identified areas for solar arrays in compliance with the
300 ft. setback requirement. However, the plan lacks
detail concerning storage areas, stormwater management
facility locations, battery storage areas, inverter locations,
and transformer areas. As such, staff cannot fully
comment on whether all required aspects of the project
will meet this standard.
2. All access roads and storage areas shall be established on
a 30-foot minimum easement to a public right-of-way.
Access roads and storages areas are not shown on the site
plan submitted by the applicant. As such, staff cannot
comment on whether the proposal meets this standard.
Staff has included this requirement as a recommended
conditional of approval.
3. On-site All ground ground- mounted photovoltaic solar
energy systems shall be enclosed by a perimeter security
fence that is wildlife friendly and of a height that meets
the National Electric Code (NEC) without the use of
barbed wire. Said fencing shall be installed behind
required buffers and shall not be visible from public
rights of way. In addition to the use of wildlife friendly
fencing, solar developments shall be designed to provide
unfenced wildlife passageways of a size, scale, and
number appropriat e for a given development size in
order to allow large mammals such as deer, coyotes, and
bears to traverse the area.
Based on information submitted by the applicant, the
facility will be enclosed by a security fence that is at least
six (6) feet in height and will meet National Electric Code
(NEC) requirements. No other details on the fencing
have been submitted and staf f is unable to determine if
said fencing is proposed to be wildlife friendly. Further,
the identified project area boundaries are expansive on
both the east and west sides of Pinewood Rd. Some space
between identified solar array areas is provided where
wetland areas traverse the property. However, staff is of
the opinion that additional wildlife through passages for
larger mammals need to be provided for and shown on
plans.
5
4. All ground -mounted photovoltaic solar collectors shall
be limited to maximum height of 15 feet above the
ground when oriented at maximum tilt. The provision
shall not include the interconnection poles, substation
equipment, or other devices necessary for t he electricity
to be delivered to the public utility station.
Submitted documents indicate that a maximum height of
25 ft. at full tilt is being proposed. Staff notes that this
was the maximum height prior to final adoption of OA -
23-01. It is staff’s understanding that a maximum height
of 15 ft. at full tilt is gener ally acceptable to solar facility
developers. The 15 ft. maximum height standard is
required and is outlined in the recommended conditions
of approval.
5. On-site electrical interconnections and power lines shall
be installed underground wherever reasonably practical.
Notes on the submitted site plan state that on-site power
lines between solar panels and inverters will be placed
underground or above ground, subject to final design.
No additional information has been provided, and the
site plan does not show proposed li ne locations. More
information is required from the applicant to adequately
review this standard.
6. The applicant has the burden of proving that glare
produced from a primary photovoltaic solar energy
system will not have a significant adverse impact on
aviation interests, motor vehicle traffic, or neighboring
properties. Submission of a glare assessment prepared by
a qualified professional is required.
A glint and glare analysis prepared by Kimley -Horn and
dated November 2023 has been submitted. This analysis
includes separate reports for arrays with anti -reflective
coating and for arrays without anti-reflective coating. The
reports outline in an “hours per year” metric the potential
level for glare and glint from the project for flight
approaches, roadway users, the Shaw Air Base air traffic
control tower, and from identified observation points.
The analysis does not take into account vegetative
buffers, terrain, and man- made objects in order to
provide a more conservative worst -case situation
analysis. The applicant is proposing to install panels with
anti-reflective coating.
7. For all locations within 5 nautical miles of the center
point of the runway for Shaw Airforce Base, Poinsett
6
Electronic Combat Range (ECR) and the Sumter
County Airport:
a. The applicant shall provide documented proof
of having notified the Shaw Airforce
Base/Poinsett ECR Military Base Commander,
or the Commander’s representative and/or the
Sumter County Airport Director of a
Photovoltaic Solar Energy System proposal.
b. The applicant shall allow 21 days for written
comments to be provided from these agencies.
Any written comments received shall be
submitted with the Special Exception use
application.
This r equirement is applicable due to project area’s
location within 5 nautical miles of the center point of
Poinsett ECR.
Documentation shows that the applicant initially notified
Shaw Air Force Base representatives of the project on
July 20, 2023, and met with appropriate representatives
on July 25, 2023 to discuss the project. Shaw Air Force
Base oversees the operations of Poinsett ECR. On
September 6, 2023, the applicant provided responses to
these comments. On September 6, 2023, Shaw Air Force
Base provided comments to the applicant. On October
4, 2023, Shaw Air Force Base provided additional
comments and responses to the applicant.
Based on review comments in the record, Shaw Air Force
Base is not supportive of the project and cites potential
impacts to restricted air space, conflicts with Poinsett
ECR flight activity, concerns about impacts to pilots and
to the solar facility from o perations due to the project
location, and concerns about the potential for air
accidents due to bird strikes.
The applicant has taken the following steps responding
to this position: 1) held a meeting with Shaw Air Force
Base representatives on November 29, 2023 to discuss
concerns, 2) prepared a technical memorandum
responding to stated concerns, and 3) submitted the
project for review under the formal Department of
Defense Aviation and Installation Assurance Siting
Clearinghouse for higher level review.
7
8. It shall be demonstrated that the Photovoltaic Solar
Energy System will not unreasonably interfere with the
view of, or from, significant sites of public interest such
as public parks and historic sites and resources.
SCDAG ArchSite review shows 1 archaeological survey
site within the project site boundary and 1 archaeological
survey site +/ - 160 ft. outside of the project boundary.
The site within the project boundary appears to be within
the setback area.
The project is adjacent to Enon Missionary Baptist
Church. This is an historic site with an official historic
marker, as it is the location of the original Enon Baptist
Church established in 1872.
The site located outside the project boundary
corresponds to the Enon Missionary Baptist Church
property. Site and landscaping plans indicate that existing
vegetation is located on the subject property and the
church property.
9. Landscape Buffering: A minimum 50 ft. wide landscape
buffer containing evergreen vegetation screening is
required to obscure solar energy systems from public
rights of way and residential uses on adjacent parcels.
Buffers shall meet the following minimum criteria:
a. Existing Vegetation: Existing mature trees and
shrubs shall be retained in the required 300 ft.
setback area. Dead trees and shrubs may be
removed in the setback area. Said vegetation shall
be supplemented to ensure a year -round
evergreen vegetative visual screen of at least 6 ft.
in height over 3 growing seasons and not less
than 20 ft. in height at maturity.
b. Additional Plantings: Where existing vegetation
is insufficient for required screening, a planting
plan shall be developed and submitted that
creates a year -round evergreen vegetative visual
screen of at least 6 ft. in height over 3 growing
seasons and not
less than 20 ft. in height at
maturity. The planting plan shall utilize a variety
of evergreen species to avoid the creation of a
monoculture vegetative buffer.
c. Maintenance: All new plantings must include an
irrigation system that shall be maintained until all
plant materials are fully established and thriving;
8
dead or diseased plant materials shall be replaced within
60 days of notification by the County. It shall be the
developer’s responsibility to ensure all buffer plants remain
healthy and thriving. Failure to replace dying, diseased or
plants failing to thr ive constitutes a violation of the
Ordinance and may result in enforcement action in
accordance with Article 1 of the Ordinance.
Submitted site and landscape plans indicate that a 50 ft.
buffer is provided along public rights of way and
residential uses on adjacent parcels. It is noted that
existing vegetation within the entire 300 ft. setback area
must be retained as required. It i
s also noted that
additional plantings are being proposed were required.
Landscape Buffer detailing and general planting
specifications have been provided. Landscape plan notes
indicate that appropriate irrigation will be provided.
10. For primary photovoltaic energy systems developed in
the Agricultural Conservation (AC) and Conservation
(CP) zoning districts – sites shall be designed and
developed using native ground cover/vegetation and
other best practices as outlined in the Technica l
Guidance for the Development of Wildlife & Pollinator
Habitat at Solar Farms (South Carolina Solar Habitat Act
–
March 2021) document or similar best practices
documents.
Based on submitted documentation, the applicant
intends to use native ground cover. The applicant is
proposing other ground management practices aimed at
alleviating concerns about aircraft bird strikes. Such
practices may conflict with best practices outlined in the
above cited technical guidance for wildlife and pollinator
habitats.
11. Satisfactory completion of a Decommissioning Plan, per
Appendix D. The Decommissioning Plan shall be
recorded at the Sumter County Register of Deeds and be
included with any leasing documents/agreements with
the property owner.
A draft decommissioning plan has been submitted with
this request. The plan outlines many of the components
addressed in Appendix D but includes additional
information and commentary. It is a recommended
condition of approval that a decommissioning plan
addressing all items outlined in Appendix D be recorded
at the Sumter County Registers of Deeds prior to land
disturbance permit approval for the project.
9
12. Must comply with the following Decommissioning
Surety requirements:
a. A form of surety equal to 125% of the entire
cost to decommission the primary photovoltaic
solar energy facility, as approved, is required.
Decommissioning costs shall be estimated by an
engineer licensed to practice in the State of
South Carolina and approved by the Sumter
County Administrator and Sumter County
Attorney.
b. The surety is required to cover the costs of
decommissioning the primary photovoltaic solar
energy facility. Decommissioning costs shall
include all work as described in the recorded
Decommissioning Plan.
c. The surety can be in the from of cash, cashier’s
check, certified check, certificate of deposit,
negotiable U.S. Treasury securities, performance
bond, irrevocable letter of credit, or other
instrument readily convertible into cash at face
value. If utilizing a bond to cover the required
surety, the bond shall have a rating of AAA.
d. The surety can be made directly to Sumter
County or be placed in escrow within a financial
institution designated as an official depository of
Sumter County.
e. Following initial submittal of the surety, the cost
calculation shall be reviewed every (5) years and
adjusted accordingly based upon an updated
estimate provided by an engineer licensed to
practice in the State of South Carolina. Update
estimates must be reviewed and approved by the
Sumter County Administrator and Sumter
County Attorney. In the case of cost increase,
the surety instrument used must be updated to
reflect 125% of the entire cost to decommission
the primary photovoltaic energy facility.
f. Failure to comply with any of the requirements
outlined in Article 5.b.3.c.13 shall result in the
immediate termination and revocation of all
prior approvals and permits; further, Sumter
County shall be entitled to make immediate
demand upon, and/or retain any proceeds of
the surety, which shall be used for
decommissioning and/or removal of the
10
primary photovoltaic solar energy facility, even
if such facility is operational.
The applicant has submitted preliminary cost estimates
for decommissioning as part of their decommissioning
plan. Such estimates are considered preliminary at this
time and must be updated as required if the project is
formally approved. All Article 5.b.3.13 items are required
and have been included in the recommended conditions
of approval.
Mr. Derwort stated that Additional information and plan details
are required to determine whether the project will meet all
applicable special exception criteria. Additionally, concerns have
been raised by Shaw Air Force Base concerning the project’s
potential impact to Poinsett ECR.
Mr. Derwort stated that the Zoning Board of Appeals may only
defer a decision on this request if such a deferral is mutually
agreed upon by the applicant and the BOA.
Mr. Derwort stated that staff has developed recommended
conditions of approval for the project that are outlined in Exhibit
1 of the staff report. If the BOA makes the findings necessary to
approve this request, then it is recommended that such approval
be made contingent upon compliance with said approval
conditions.
Mr. Derwort summarized staff’s recommended conditions of
approval.
Mr. Thomas Del afield introduced himself as being from Ithica
Solar, LLC, the applicant for this project.
Mr. Thomas Delafield provided a project overview, a
development status update concerning the Duke
Energy/Progress RFP, information about the project location,
information about proposed development plans for the project,
information about adherence to the Sumter County 2040
Comprehensive Plan, information about specific project site
design features, information about preliminary evaluations on
threatened and endangered species, information about
operations, maintenance, and decommissioning, information
about facility equipment safety, information about overall project
impact, information about community engagement efforts
carried out to date, information about discussions with Shaw
AFB, information about addressing SHAW AFB concerns, and
information about how the project will benefit the community.
Mr. Thomas Delafield responded to questions from the Board.
11
Mr. Allesandro called a 10-minute break.
Ms. Nicole Scott introduced herself as being an attorney from
Maynard Nexen, the legal firm representing the applicant.
Ms. Nicole Scott introduced an exhibit to record concerning
information on other solar facilities on or near military
installations.
Ms. Nicole Scott stated that all studies being relied upon by the
Board need to be included in the project record. Ms. Nicole Scott
stated that this is a quasi -
judicial board whose decisions are
appealable to the Circuit Court.
Mr. Richard Kirkland introduced himself as being from Kirkland
Appraisers and that his firm was hired to conduct a property
impact assessment for the project.
Mr. Richard Kirkland summarized the results of the property
impact assessment conducted for this project and notes the full
assessment has been provided in the packet.
Mr. Tommy Cleveland introduced himself as an independent
consultant representing Ithica Solar, LLC on the project. Mr.
Cleveland spoke on technical matters related to the project and
utility scale solar projects in general.
Mr. Septimus Harvin introduced himself as being the owner of
the property subject to this request. Mr. Harvin provided general
statements concerning his reasons for allowing for this proposal
on the property.
Mr. Delafield stated that the Ithica Solar, LLC presentation is
concluded.
Ms. Ashley Nichols introduced herself as the Community
Planner for Shaw AFB. Ms. Ashley Nichols stated that she is a
representative of Shaw AFB and is designated to speak on behalf
of Shaw AFB on this matter.
Ms. Ashley Nichols provided information about the Shaw AFB
review process, communications with the applicant to date, and
stated that Shaw AFB does not support the project.
Ms. Ashley Nichols responded to questions from the Board.
Mr. Leslie Allesandro opened the public hearing on the request.
Mr. Leslie Allesandro asks if anyone was here to speak in favor
of the request.
12
There being none, Mr. Leslie Alessandro asked if there was
anyone here to speak in opposition of the request.
Ms. Patricia Hobbs -Canne introduced herself and provided
comments in opposition to the request.
Councilman Carlton Washington introduced himself and
provided comments in opposition to the request.
Mr. Jimmy Artis introduced himself and provided comments in
opposition to the request.
Mr. Chris Brooks introduced himself and provided comments in
opposition to the request.
Ms. Lynn Hawkins introduced herself and provided comments
in opposition to the request.
Mr. Roger Holman introduced himself and provided comments
in opposition to the request.
Mr. Michael Coker introduced himself and provided comments
in opposition to the request.
Ms. Rusty Gulledge introduced herself and provided comments
in opposition to the request.
Ms. Rose Infinger introduced herself and provided comments in
opposition to the request.
Chairman Mr. Allesandro invented the applicant to provide
rebuttal statements.
Mr. Delafield provided rebuttal comments to the Board.
Mr. Louis Tisdale made a motion to deny based on the
requirements in the Sumter County Zoning & Development
Standards Ordinance that require Shaw AFB to be consulted with
for solar facilities projects in certain locations within Sumter
County, and based on the information Shaw AFB provided for
the project and the responses to that information, and based
upon concerns on how the project will impact the ongoing
operations of Poinsett Electronic Combat Range (ECR).
The motion was seconded by Mr. Steven Schumpert and carried
by a unanimous vote.
OTHER BUSINESS
NONE
13
There being no further business, Mr. Clay Smith made a motion
to adjourn the meeting at 6:00 p.m. The motion was seconded
by Mr. Mr. Jason Reddick and carried a unanimous vote.
The next regularly scheduled meeting is scheduled for February
14, 2024.
Respectfully submitted,
Kellie K. Chapman
Kellie K. Chapman, Board Secretary
Source: City of Sumter website. First collected Oct 15, 2026.