Minutes
City of Sumter · Sumter County · meeting of Jun 22, 2023 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Sumter
This document is no longer listed on City of Sumter's website. We kept the copy we read.
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
CITY OF SUMTER
DESIGN REVIEW BOARD
Minutes of the Meeting
June 22, 2023
ATTENDANCE
A meeting of the City of Sumter Design Review Board was held
on Thursday, June 22, 2023, in the City Council Chambers located
on the Fourth Floor of the Sumt er Opera House. Four board
members –Ms. Julie Her long, Mr. Randy Abbott , Ms. Heidi
Burkett and Ms. Jean Whitaker were present. Mr. Jerome
Robinson, Ms. Lucy Wilson, and Ms. Hyacinth Kinle y were
absent.
Staff members present were Mr. Kyle Kelly, Mr. Jeff Derwort, Mr.
Quint Klopfleisch and Ms. Kellie Chapman.
The meeting was called to order at 3:03 p.m. by Ms. Julie Herlong.
MINUTES Mr. Randy Abbott made a motion to approve the minutes from
the May 25, 2023, as w ritten. The motion w as seconded by Ms.
Jean Whitaker and carried a unanimous vote.
NEW BUSINESS HP-23-11, 6 S. Sumter St. (City) was presented by Mr. Quint
Klopfleisch. The C ommittee reviewed this request for Design
Review app roval to install a new storefront entrance with
windows and to modif y the existing porte cochere on the rear of the
building.
Mr. Klopfleisch stated that the building on the property is a single
story commercial structure with elements of mid -century modern
design, constructed in 1960.
Mr. Klopfleisch added approval was granted by the Design
Review Board in 2020 via 3 separate submissions: to install a side
emergency door ( HP-20-02) and to install an awning and signage
on the W. Liberty St. frontage of the building ( HP-20-07 and HP-
20-16).
Mr. Leslie Alessandro w as present to speak on behalf of the
request.
After som e discussion, Ms. Jea n Whitaker made a mo tion t o
approve the request to install a new storefront entrance with
windows and to modif y the existing porte cochere on the rear of the
building, in accordance with the materi als, photographs, and
2
construction details submitted and referenced in the Staff Repo rt
and Staff Presentation and based on compliance with D esign
Review Guidelines. The mot ion was seconded by Ms. Heidi
Burkett and carried by a unanimous vote.
HP-23-12, 120 (122) and 128 (126) N. Mai n St. (City) wa s
presented by Mr. K yle Kelly . The C ommittee reviewed thi s
request for Design Review app roval for exterior alterations to
include installation of a raised brick curb and orn amental metal
railing for planters on both building front facades a nd installation
of brick columns, low brick walls, and metal screen fencing to rea
of 120 (122) N. Main St.
Mr. Kelly stated 120 (122) and 128 (126) N. Main St. are
rectangular two-story buildings constructed in the first decade of
the 20 th century. Both buildings have generally served as
professional offices for lawyers and architects over the years.
Mr. Kelly added 128 (126) N. Main St., k nown as the S mith
Robinson Building , and previously as the Lee, Wilson, Erter &
Booth Building, was built circa 1909. Two story rectangular plan
building, with 3 arched openings on the s treet level contai ning
glass doors and windows and spherical awnings (awnings are not
original). The 2nd story features 5 rectangular windows with stone
sills and lintels. The property is identified as site #135 in the 1985
Historic Resources Surv ey that catalogued the structures in the
downtown area, and first appe ared on Sanborn Maps, and it is an
excellent example of rehabilitation of an older structure.
Mr. Kelly mentioned ba sed on the age of the building and
architectural design and features, this building is a contributing
structure to the City-designated Downtown Review District.
Mr. Kelly stated 120 (122) N. Main St., also known as the Lee &
Moise Building, was built circa 1907, and is a t wo-story
Romanesque Revival building, according to the National Re gister
Nomination for the Sumter Downtown Historic District . It
contains 4 rectangular 1
st floor windows, 5 sti lted-arch windows
on the 2nd floor, and recessed entryway. The property is identified
as site #132 in the 1985 Historic Resources Survey that catalogued
the structures in the downtown area, and first appeared on
Sanborn Maps in 1912.
Mr. Kelly added the survey specifically noted that the re is intricate
brickwork at the cornice and parapet, and that the building is a
good example of the Romanesque Revival architectural style and
an excellent example of restoration.
Mr. Kelly mentioned based on the a ge of the building and
3
architectural des ign and features, 120 (12 2) N. Main St. is
considered a contr ibuting structure to the Downtown Sumter
National Register District and contributes to the City -designated
Downtown Design Review District.
Mr. Ben McIver was present to speak on behalf of the request.
After som e discussion, Mr. Randy Ab bott made a mo tion t o
approve for exterior alterations to include installation of a raised
brick curb and orn amental metal railing for planters on both
building front facades and installation of brick columns, low brick
walls, and metal screen fencing to the rear of 120 (122) N. Main
St., in accordance with the materials, photographs, and
construction details submitted and referenced in the Staff Report
and Staff Presentation and based on compliance with D esign
Review Guidelines. The mot ion w as seconded by Ms. Heidi
Burkett and carried by a unanimous vote.
HP-23-13, 116 N. Main St. (City ) wa s presented by Mr . Kyle
Kelly. The Committee reviewed thi s request for Design Review
approval for demolition of the commerc ial building on the
property.
Mr. Kelly mentione d 116 N. Main St. is a currently vacant small
commercial building. The a pplicant intends to demolish the
structure based on loss of structural integrity and to improve the
aesthetic of the area’ s street fro nt in conjunc tion with the façade
enhancements planned for the building s at 120 and 128 N. Main
St. via HP-23-12.
Mr. Kelly stated that the small infill office space was built in 1956
in a narrow gap between two larger, older buildings. The building
has a rectangular 1-story floor plan, with a glass storefront, ston e
bulkhead and metal sheathing of the transom and cornice.
Assessed during 1985 City Historic Resources Survey, but not
included in the 2010 City Historic Resources Survey.
After some discussion, Ms. Heidi Burkett made a motion to defer
action on this request until the Thursday, July 27, 2023, meeting in
order to receive additional information related to the request.
The Board has requested additional information on the following:
• Available details on rehabilitation and reuse options
considered prior to demolition request.
• Design details on proposed post -demolition
development of the property.
The Board will consider the request as part of the agenda for its
4
July Board Meeting, scheduled for 3:00pm on Thursday, July 27 in
the Council Chambe rs on the 4th floor of the Sumter Opera
House. The mot ion was seconded by Mr. Randy Abbott and
carried by a unanimous vote.
OLD BUSINESS
NONE
RECONGINATION
OF BOARD MEMBER
Ms. Julie Herlong recognized Ms. Jean Whitaker for her dedicated
service to the Board.
CERTIFICATES OF
APPROPRIATENESS
NONE
STAFF REPORT
NONE
ADJOURNMENT
With no further business, Ms. Heidi Burkett made a motion to
adjourn the meeting at 3:48 p.m. The motion was seconded by
Ms. Jean Whitaker and carried by a unanimous vote.
Respectfully submitted,
Kellie K. Chapman
Kellie K. Chapman, Board Secretary
Source: City of Sumter website. First collected Oct 15, 2026.