Minutes
City of Sumter · Sumter County · meeting of Oct 13, 2021 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Sumter
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS
Minutes of the Meeting
October 13, 2021
ATTENDANCE
A regular meeting of the Zoning Board of Appeals was
held on Wednesday, October 13 , 202 1, in the Fourth
Floor City Chambers of the Sumter Opera House, 21 N.
Main Street. Five board members – Mr. Leslie
Alessandro, Mr. Jason Reddick , Mr. Sam Lowery, Ms.
Cleo Klopfleisch, Mr. Warren Curtis and Mr. Steven
Schumpert were present. Mr. Louis Tisdale and Mr. L.C.
Fredrick were absent.
Planning staff in attendance: Ms. Helen Roodman, Mr.
Kyle Kelly and Ms. Kellie Chapman.
The meeting was called to order at 3 :00 p.m. by Mr.
Leslie Alessandro, Chairman.
MINUTES
Mr. Steven Schumpert made a motion to approve t he
minutes of the September 8, 202 1, meeting as written.
The motion was seconded by Mr. Sam Lowery and
carried a unanimous vote.
NEW BUSINESS
BOA-21-21, 15 Thomas Dr. (City) was presented by Mr.
Kyle Kelly . The Board reviewed this request for a
variance from the maximum total square footage allowed
for residential accessory structures as outlined in Article
4, Exhibit 4-1: Maximum Square Footage of Residential
Accessory Structures Based on Gross Acreage of the
City of Sumter Zoning & Development Standards
Ordinance in order to construct a +/ - 384 sq. ft. addition
to an existing detached garage / storage building. The
property is located at 315 Thomas Dr
., is zoned
Residential-9 (R -9) and is represented by Tax Map #
204-05-01-042.
Mr. Kelly stated the applicant is requesting a +/- 220 sq.
ft. variance to the maximum total square footage allowed
for residential accessory structures to permit the
construction of a +/ - 384 sq. ft addition to an existing
garage building located in the rear of the property.
Mr. Kelly added the amount of accessory structure
square footage permitted on a parcel is based on the size
2
of the property. For a parcel 0.53-acres in size, the City
of Sumter Zoning and Deve lopment Standards
Ordinance allows for a total of 1100 sq. ft. of accessory
structure square footage, which can be divided among
up two (2) separate buildings. There are currently two
detached accessory structures on the property with a
combined floor area of 936 sq. ft.
The property currently contains a single- family
residential dwelling, a 20’ X 18’ ft (360 sq. ft.) covered
carport, and a 24’ X 24’ (576 sq. ft.) garage.
Both existing accessory structures are located in the
property’s rear yard.
Mr. Charles Lloyd was present to speak on behalf of the
request.
After a brief discussion, Ms. Cleo Klopfleisch made a
motion to approve this request subject to the following
findings of fact and conclusions:
1. Most lots in the Bon Air Terrance subdivision
average 0.35-acres and are rectangular in shape.
The lot at 15 Thomas Dr. is slightly larger at 0.53-
acres, and is square, owing to the addition of a
former portion of road right-of-way combined with
the parcel at 15 Thomas Dr.
2. The shape and size of the lot at 15 Thomas Dr.
does not general apply to other property in the
vicinity. However, under the City of Sumter
Zoning and Development Standard Ordinance, all
properties are required to abide by the accessory
structure size limitation based on gross acreage
of the lot.
3. Under the current Ordinance, the applicant could
expand his existing accessory structure by 164 sq.
ft. without requiring a variance. The ordinance
prevents the applicant from exceeding this limit to
construct the proposed 384 sq. ft. addition.
4. The proposed structure will be located in the rear
yard, where it will not be easily visible from the
public right-of-way and will not be clearly visible
from residential dwellings to the rear.
The motion was seconded by Mr. Jason Reddick and
carried a unanimous vote.
3
BOA-21-22, 4400 Broad St. (County) was presented by
Mr. Kyle Kelly. The Board reviewed this request for a
variance from the sign requirements outlined in Article 8,
Exhibit 19: Maximum Total Sign Area by Use, Number,
Dimensions, and Location of Individual Signs and Article
8, Exhibit 20: Permitted Signs by Type and Zoning
Classification of the Sumter County Zoning &
Development Standards Ordinance in order to install a
free standing mobile home park identification sign that is
+/- 15 ft. in height and has an area of +/ - 50 sq. ft. The
proposed sign type, area, and height do not conform to
sign requirements for the applicable zoning district. The
property is located at 4400 Broad St., is zoned General
Residential (GR), and is represented by T MS# 155-00-
02-002.
Mr. Kelly stated the applicant is seeking variance
approval from applicable Sumter County sign
requirements in order to place a free- standing mobile
home park identification sign that is 15 ft. tall and 50 sq.
ft. in area on the subject property.
Mr. Kelly added the property is located on the southside
of Broad St. (US Hwy 378) just west of Copley Dr. The
property is the
location of “American Mobile Home
Plaza”, an older non -conforming mobile home park
located new Shaw AFB.
Mr. Kelly mentioned the applicant is proposing to place a
free-standing mobile home park identification sign on the
northwest side of the property.
The sign will meet
applicable setback requirements. However, per sign
requirements pertaining to the General Residential (GR)
zoning district, only residential development signs 40 sq.
ft. in size and 5 ft. in height are permitted.
Mr. Kelly added these types of signs are typically
monument signs often taking the form of a wall on each
side of the entrance to the development. Standard free-
standing pole signs are not permitted in the GR zoning
district.
Ms. Debbie Ashby was present to seek clarification on
the variance request as an adjoining property owner. She
did not express any objection once understanding the
proposed sign location.
After a brief discussion, Mr. Warren Curtis made a motion
to approve this request subject to the following findings
of fact and conclusions:
4
1. The property at 4400 Broad St. is +/- 16.83 acres
in size and does not have direct frontage on a
public road. The property is accessed from Broad
St. via two existing private shared commercial
drives. A formal easement exists over one of the
drives per the plat of record (PB98 PG1188) for
the property. The mobile home park cannot be
easily viewed from Broad St. due to the existing
commercial building that are located in front of it.
2. These conditions do not generally apply to ot her
property in the vicinity. The property is landlocked
and has an active mobile home park use. The
property is accessed via shared commercial
drives with no readily identifiable entrance
identification for the mobile home park use.
3. As written, the Ordinance prevents the applicant
from constructing the sign as proposed. A
residential identification sign compliant with
Ordinance requirements would have limited
visibility and functionality given that the access to
the mobile home park is located on Broad St., a 4-
lane divided major arterial road with high traffic
volumes.
4. The applicant is proposing a free-standing mobile
home park identification sign that is 15 ft. in height
with an area of 50 sq. ft. the sign will be located
more than 300 ft. away fr om Broad St. right -of-
way, as proposed by the applicant. All land to the
north of the subject property, with direct frontage
on Broad St., is zoned General Commercial and
allows significantly larger signs than the one being
proposed. The proposed sign’s
location will not
have a significant negative impact on the visual
aesthetics along this section of Broad St.
Additionally, appropriate identification of the
mobile home park may improve road safety by
decreasing the amount of sudden braking and
turning b y parties wishing to enter the
development but are unfamiliar with its exact
location.
The authorization of the variance will not be of
substantial detriment to adjacent property or the
public good, and authorization of the variance will
not harm the character of the district.
5
Subject to the following condition:
• The variance approval under BOA -21-22
only applies to the specific sign being
proposed. Any additional signage must
meet the requirements of the Sumter
County Zoning & Development Standards
Ordinance or received additional variance
approval by the Sumter City-County Board
of Zoning Appeals.
The motion was seconded by Mr. Sam Lowery and
carried a unanimous vote.
BOA-21-23, 1145 Union Camp Blvd. (County) was
presented by Mr. Kyle Kelly. The Bo ard reviewed this
request variance from the sign requirements outlined in
Article 8, Section 8.i.7.i: Directional Signs of the Sumter
County Zoning & Development Standards Ordinance in
order to replace existing directional signs on the site with
new directional signs that are larger than the existing
signs to be replaced and also have a sign area larger
than the than 2sq. ft., the maximum area allowed for
directional signs. The property is located at 1145 Union
Camp Blvd., is zoned Heavy Industrial (HI), and is
represented by TMS# 208-00-03-044.
Mr. Kelly mentioned the applicant is seeking a variance
from the sign requirements outlined in the Sumter County
Zoning and Development Standards Ordinance in order
to replace existing directional signage for the industrial
complex on the site. The applicant wishes to install new
signs that are both larger than the existing
nonconforming signs and larger than the 2 sq. ft.
maximum area allowed for directional signs.
Mr. Kelly stated the property is currently used by
International Paper/Sylvamo as a distri bution facility,
containing +/- 286,000 sq. ft. of warehouse space.
Mr. David Byrd was present to speak on behalf of the
request.
After a brief discussion, Mr. Steven Schumpert made a
motion to approve this request
subject to the following
findings of fact and conclusions:
6
1. The subject property is one of the developed
heavy industrial tracts located at the rear of the
Live Oak Industrial Park south of the City of
Sumter. The property is a corner lot which
includes several different entrances for shipping,
receiving, visitors, and employees on both Lynette
Dr. and Union Camp Blvd.
2. The property is located in an industrial park which
many adjacent lots also have large road frontages
and multiple entrances for various tasks related to
the business. However,
outside of the County’s
two active multi -tenant large industrial parks,
these conditions are not commonly found.
3. Application of the Ordinance as written would
restrict Sylvamo/International Paper from placing
the size of directional signs that best fulfi ll the
need for providing adequate visibility and
instructions to tractor -trailer drivers bringing
materials to the site, as well as minimize the
potential for trucks and cars to navigate the site in
a way counter to the business operations of the
site, which creates safety concerns.
4. Because the property is in an established
industrial park is located in the area of the park
furthest from the industrial park’s entrances, there
is no known detriment identified at this time
authorizing a variance for the req uested signage.
The proposed signage would not harm the
character of the district.
The motion was seconded by Mr. Warren Curtis and
carried a unanimous vote.
BOA-21-25, 2480 Florence Hwy. (County) was
presented by Mr. Kyle Kelly. The Board reviewed this
request for a variance from the rear yard setback
requirements outlined in Article 3, Section 3.n.5.b: AC
District Minimum Yard and Building Setback
Requirements of the Sumter County Zoning &
Development Standards Ordinance in order to create a
new lot that that will result in an existing non- residential
agricultural building being located +/ - 39.4 ft. from the
rear property line, +/ - 10.6 ft. less than required rear
property line setback. The prope rty is located at 2480
Florence Hwy., is zoned Agricultural Conservation (AC),
and is represented by TMS# 284-00-02-022.
7
Mr. Kelly added the applicant is seeking a variance from
rear setback requirements in order to subdivide a 1.69-
acre parcel from a larger agricultural tract located at 2480
Florence Hwy.
Mr. Kelly stated the applicant wishes to create a 1.6-acre
parcel in accordance with the last will and testament of
Harry Lawrence Kirven. This proposed lot includes a 576
sq. ft agricultural accessory structure that does not meet
the required 50 ft. rear setback requirement.
Ms. Carol Kirven was present to speak on behalf of the
request.
After a brief discussion, Mr. Warren Curtis made a motion
to approve this request subject to the following findings
of fact and conclusions:
1. The subject property consists of a large
agricultural tract which lies between the Sumter
County Landfill and Florence Hwy. The property
contains several agricultural accessory structures,
and no residential structures. The ability of the
property owner to create a new parcel compliant
with the County’s Zoning and Development
Standards Ordinance is constrained by the
spacing of the existing agricultural accessory
structures.
The Last Will and Testament of Harry Lawrence
Kirven, dated March 20, 2020, wills Mr. Kirven’s
farmland and swamp property to his son, with the
exception of a planned 300 x 300 ft. parcel fronting
on US Hwy 76, which was willed to his wife.
2. The combination of the parcel’s boundaries,
spacing of agricultural accessory structures, and
stipulations outlined in Mr. Kirven’s will are not
generally applicable to other property in t he
vicinity.
3. Application of the Ordinance as written would
restrict Ms. Kirven’s ability to establish the 1.69-
acre parcel that is referenced in Mr. Kirven’s will.
Without variance approval, the only alternative
action available to Ms. Kirven would be to
demolish the existing agricultural accessory
structure. This building is used to store farm
equipment that Ms. Kirven’s owns.
8
4. The authorization of this request will not be of
substantial detriment to adjacent property or
public good. Additionally, the authorization of this
request will not harm the character of the district.
While the proposed lot creation would result in a
+/- 11 ft. encroachment into the standard rear
setback area in the AC district, the existing pattern
of development, specifically the series of
agricultural structures and fields, would not be
diminished or harmed by establishment of the new
parcel as proposed.
No new accessory or principal structures are
proposed at this time. However, if and when a
single-family residence is constructed on the
property, the existing structure would meet the
setback requirements for the zoning district.
The motion was seconded by Mr. Sam Lowery and
carried a unanimous vote.
BOA-21-26, 180 E. Foxworth Mill Rd. (County) was
presented by Mr. Kyle Kelly. The Board reviewed this
request for a variance accessory structure requirements
outlined in Article 4, Section 4.g.2.b.2: Separation
Criteria and Article 4, Section 4.g.2.b.3: Number of the
Sumter County Zoning & Development Standards
Ordinance in order to construct a +/ - 1,200 sq. ft.
detached garage closer than 10 ft. to the principal
residential structure on the property and to establish a
third accessory structure on the property greater than
120 sq. ft. in size. The property is located at 180 E.
Foxworth Mill Rd., is zoned Agricultural Conservation
(AC), and is represented by TMS# 244-00-02-005.
Mr. Kelly stated the applicant is seeking variance
approval from residential accessory structure separation
requirements to place a new detached garage structure
+/- 3 ft. (including eave overhangs) from t he principal
dwelling on the property.
Mr. Kelly mentioned the property is currently improved
with one principal dwelling unit, an agricultural building,
and an enclosed dog kennel. The principal dwelling unit
includes both the main house area and an exi sting side
loaded two car garage structure that is connected to the
main house area via breezeway. Due to this connection,
the garage area is considered to be part of the primary
9
dwelling unit. A 32 x 32 ft. concrete pad is situated
directly west of the existing garage area.
Mr. Kelly added the applicant is requesting variance
approval to permit the installation of a new detached
garage/equipment storage building to be located directly
south of the concrete pad. This detached garage will be
front loaded and accessed directly from the concrete
pad. To maximize use of the existing concrete pad, the
placement of new accessory structure is +/- 3 ft. from the
existing garage.
Mr. Robert Beatson Jr. and Ms. Christian Beatson were
present to speak on behalf of the request.
Mr. Sam Lowery recused himself from the request.
After a brief discussion, Mr. Steven Schumpert made a
motion to approve this request subject to the following
findings of fact and conclusions:
1. The property at 180 E. Foxworth Mill Rd. is 22.18
acres in size. The property is used for both
residential and agricultural purposes. The
property has existing parking located to the west
of the main area of the house. Parking is
accommodated via an existing side loaded garage
attached to the main area of the house via
breezeway and an existing concrete pad. The
existing +/- 1,200 sf. agricultural building, used to
store motorized farm equipment, is located
approximately 53 ft. from the west side of the
existing garage area. The agricultu ral building,
the existing garage area, the concrete pad, and
the new detached garage/equipment storage
building are located directly south of a drainage
ditch that runs diagonally across the property.
These are extraordinary and exceptional
conditions since moving the new detached garage
further to the west will block access and
maneuverability for motorized farm equipment
stored in the agricultural building due to the
location of the drainage ditch and moving the
building any further south will conflict with the
location of an existing underground water valve.
2. The specific extraordinary and exceptional
conditions stated are generally unique to this
property.
10
3. As written, the accessory structure separati on
criteria prohibit the applicant from placing the
detached garage in the proposed location. While
the property is of sufficient size to accommodate
a new accessory building in accordance with the
requirement for 10 ft. of separation between a
residential accessory structure and the principal
dwelling unit. Doing so would require altering
existing improvements or located the detached
garage in a less functional location on the
property.
4. The request is related to the required separation
criteria between
an accessory structure and a
principal dwelling unit on a property +/ - 22.18
acres in size. The property’s principal dwelling
unit is located over 600 ft. from the front property
line on E. Foxworth Mill Rd. Additionally, the
location of the new accessor y structure is
adequately screened from adjacent property.
Provided that it is documented that the structure
meets residential building codes at its existing
location, then the authorization of the request will
not be of substantial detriment to adjacent
property or the public good, nor will it
harm the
character of the district.
Subject to the following condition:
• A report submitted by a qualified
professional documenting that the
foundation of the structure meets
applicable Building Codes shall be
submitted to the Sumter City -County
Building Department within 120 days of the
date of the Board of Zoning Appeals Order
on Case # BOA-21-26.
The motion was seconded by Mr. Cleo Klopfleisch and
carried a unanimous vote.
OTHER BUSINESS
NONE
There being no further business, Mr. Steven Schumpert
made a motion to adjourn the meeting at 4:16 p.m. The
motion was seconded by Mr. Sam Lowery and carried a
unanimous vote.
11
The next regularly scheduled meeting is scheduled for
November 10, 2021.
Respectfully submitted,
Kellie K. Chapman
Kellie K. Chapman, Board Secretary
Source: City of Sumter website. First collected Oct 15, 2026.