Minutes
City of Sumter · Sumter County · meeting of Apr 22, 2021 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Sumter
This document is no longer listed on City of Sumter's website. We kept the copy we read.
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
HISTORIC PRESERVATION
DESIGN REVIEW
Minutes of the Meeting
April 22, 2021
ATTENDANCE
A regular meeting of the Historic Preservation Design
Review Committee was held on Thursday, April 22, 2021,
in the Council Chambers located on the Fourth Floor of the
Sumter Opera House. Seven board members –Ms. Julie
Herlong; M s. Heidi Burkett ; Ms. Jean Whitaker ; Mr. Bill
Buxton; Ms. Vivian Sharp; Mr. Jerome Ro binson; and Ms.
Lucy Wilson were present.
Staff members present were Mr. Kyle Kell y, Mr. Jeff
Derwort and Ms. Kellie Chapman.
The meeting was called to order at 4:30 p.m. by Ms. Julie
Herlong.
MINUTES
Mr. Bill Buxton made a motion to approve the minutes of
the March 25, 2021 meeting as written. The motion was
seconded by Mr. Jerome Robinson and c arried by a
unanimous vote.
NEW BUSINESS
HP-21-09, 80 Calhoun Pl. (City ) was presented by M r.
Kyle Kelly . The Committee reviewed thi s request for
Historic Preservation Design Review appr oval for
construction of an 1,840 SF single family home with
attached two-car garage and roof mounted solar panels.
Mr. Kelly stated the applicant is requesting approval for an
additional/alternate architectural design plan for one of
four (4) single-family detached residential structures to be
located at 80 Calhoun Place ( corner of Calhoun Pl. and
W. Ca lhoun St. ) This property originally rec eived HP
Design Review approval in 2008 (HP -08-13) with four (4)
unique but complementary designs identified for the four
(4) lots to be developed. The request was later amended
and appro ved for an alternat
e design for the parcel
located at 10 Calho un Pl. The development is a
residential inf ill project within the Hampton Park H istoric
District.
2
Mr. Kelly added that under a planned development project
approved in 1991, the property form erly known as 315 W.
Calhoun St. was to be developed for 8 single- family
detached units, each on its own parcel. 2 of the original 8
parcels, located at the rear of the site, were developed
prior to the adoption of the current design guidelines.
Since ap proval of the 1991 development plan, new
guidelines were adopted that emphasize design
standards more comp atible with existing character of
Hampton Park. The third residence constructed in the
development obtained design review approval in 2008,
based on an alternate design to those approved in 1991
that was more in keeping with the architectural character
and context of the District.
Mr. Kelly mentioned the proposed architectural detail of
the house is con centrated in the front elevation,
particularly on the porch. However, due to the or ientation
of the structure, the eastern elevation of the structure will
be highly visible. The Design Guidelines in this instance
suggest the need for additional archi tectural detail in
elements along the side of the str ucture to create visual
interest. The applicant is propos ing to achieve this result
by incorporating a bay window on the east elevation, and
has incor porated additional elements on the front
elevation, including porch balusters, as well as vertical
and horizontal siding.
Mr. Kelly added that the applicant is pro posing to install
+/- 27 solar panels on the rear portion of the western roof
face.
Mr. Larry Bau m, Ms. Helen Baum, and Mr. Tom Swan
were present and spoke against the request.
Mr. Dennis Kern (applicant) was present to speak o n
behalf of the request.
After some discussion, Mr. Bill Buxton made a motion to
defer this request to the next meeting and to ask staff to
provide additional information to the Committee regarding
solar panels , the p lanned development ordinance, and
proposed garage placement. The mot ion was seconded
by Ms. Vivian Sharp and carried by a unanimous vote.
3
HP-21-10, Downtown Mural Sites (Mu ltiple Locations)
was presented by M r. Kyle Kelly . The Committ ee
reviewed thi s request for Historic Preservation Design
Review app roval for installation of large- scale murals
painted directly on exterior building walls.
Mr. Kelly stated 16, 26, 30, and 36 W. Liber ty St., 34 S .
Main St., and 9 N. Main St., are downtown commercial
properties with large unadorned walls in the Downtown
Design R eview District which are being eva luated for
installation of large format murals through the Sumter
Mural Pro ject sponsored by the City of Sumter and the
Sumter County Cultural Center.
Mr. Kelly mentioned the applicant is proposing to install full
wall artistic murals on e xterior walls in the alley between
16 and 36 W. Liberty St., on the south -facing wall of 34 S.
Main St., and on the south-facing second-story wall of 9 N.
Main St.
Mr. Kelly also noted that due to an administrative error,
two additional proposed mural locations were advertised
incorrectly. 17 and 25 S. Main St. are not proposed for
mural placement at this time. The correct site for the final
intended mural locations (37 and 43 S. Mai n St., also
known as M osaic Alley) will be bro ught for Board review
and consideration as a revision to this request at a future
meeting.
Mr. Kelly ad ded that the Sumter Mural Project will be
funded by a variety of sources, including priv ate donations
and grants, and will also include sites outside the
Downtown Design Review District. The project is awaiting
decision regarding grant funding.
Mr. Kelly stated that a committee comprised of
representatives from the applicable pro perty owners,
Sumter County C ultural Center, and City of Sumter will
review th e artist s’ proposed design and make final
decision regarding the content and style of each mural.
Ms. Leigh Newman, and Ms. Mel anie Colclough
(applicant’s representatives) were present to speak
regarding the request.
Mr. Scott Hor ton was present to spe ak regarding the
request.
4
After some discussion, Mr. Bill B uxton made a motion to
approve this re quest in accor dance with the mat erials,
submitted and based on compliance with Design Review
Guidelines with th e condition that two Board members
(Julie Herlong and Luc y Wilson) be included on the Mural
Design De cision Committee. The mot ion was seconded
by Mr. Jerome Robinson and carried by a unanimous vote.
OLD BUSINESS
NONE
OTHER BUSINESS
Mr. Kyle Kelly informed the members there was one
Certificates of Appropriateness issued by staff for exterior
paint during the period of March 25, 2021 – April 22, 2021.
ADJOURNMENT
With no further business, Mr. Bill Buxton made a motion to
adjourn the meeting at 5:45 p.m. The motion was
seconded by Ms. Lucy Wilson and carried by a unanimous
vote.
Respectfully submitted,
Kellie K. Chapman
Kellie K. Chapman, Board Secretary
Source: City of Sumter website. First collected Oct 15, 2026.